MotorTrend

DIVINE DRIVES

THE JURY

Ed Loh, Editor-in-Chief

Mark Rechtin, Executive Editor

Jonny Lieberman, Senior Features Editor

Chris Walton, Road Test Editor

Christian Seabaugh, Features Editor

Alisa Priddle, Detroit Editor

Scott Evans, Associate Editor

Erick Ayapana, Associate Road Test Editor

Miguel Cortina, Associate Editor

Derek Powell, Guest Judge

Randy Pobst, Professional

Racer

Patron saint of literary cool Joan Didion—who stalked the steamy, smoggy canyons of Los Angeles in a Daytona Yellow 1969 Corvette Stingray—once said, “Rationality, reasonableness bewilder me.”

If only Didion were along for this year’s Best Driver’s Car competition.

There is nothing rational or reasonable about holding the keys to $1.9 million worth of the world’s dreamiest sports cars, exotics, grand tourers, and supercars.

It’s one thing to parse the packaging of family-friendly compact SUVs. That’s our day job. Best Driver’s Car is about the way a car makes you feel. It’s about the bees in your belly as you clip an apex, the giggles induced by the slingshot launch of barely restrained acceleration, and the sense of satisfaction that comes from the melding of man and machine. Where’s the cupholder for my latte in the McLaren? Can you fit anyone in that back seat of a 911? How much does that Ferrari 488 really cost? Don’t know. Don’t care.

Our Highway Patrol–assisted closure of California State Route 198 and subsequent invasion of Mazda Raceway Laguna Seca are the highlights of this event. But the Best Driver’s Car format actually began two weeks prior at Auto Club Speedway, when our testing trio of Kim Reynolds, Chris Walton, and Erick Ayapana took their first crack at our contenders with our battery of standardized instrumented testing.

To earn the title of Best Driver’s Car, a vehicle must deliver a balance of usable performance, intuitive handling, and driver-friendly design. The winner should be a vehicle with a multidimensional personality, a car that will delight and reward the enthusiast driver on any road at any time, regardless of weather and traffic conditions.

We had quite the field this year, with representation from Italy, Germany, Japan, England, and the V-8 thunder of American freedom. But as the test team crunched the test results, there was no clear leader. A storm was brewing.

THE CONTENDERS: ALFA ROMEO GIULIA QUADRIFOGLIO • ASTON MARTIN DB11 • CHEVROLET CAMARO ZL1 1LE CHEVROLET CORVETTE GRAND SPORT Z07 • FERRARI 488 GTB • LEXUS LC 500 • MAZDA MX-5 MIATA RF CLUB MCLAREN 570GT • MERCEDES-AMG GT R • NISSAN GT-R NISMO • PORSCHE 718 CAYMAN S • PORSCHE 911 TURBO S

READY FOR TAKEOFF For our support crew, the staging area is the best spot to watch the 198 action. Where else are you going to watch a 911 Turbo, GT-R NISMO, McLaren, and Ferrari launch at full throttle?

Highway 198 is a magical place, a two-lane roadway filled with tight switchbacks, sweeping curves, and panoramic views.

FATHER OF GODZILLA Hiroshi Tamura (right) is the chief engineer behind the current R35-generation Nissan GT-R. He graced us (and surprised Nissan HQ) with his presence over Best Driver’s Car week.

DRIVER’S DOZEN We brought these beasts to a closed highway. Guess what happened next.

Highway 198 Revisited

A four-hour drive along I-5’s trackless wastes

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from MotorTrend

MotorTrend3 min read
2023 Ford F-Series Super Duty
PROS Strong engines • Hugely capable haulers • Functional interior layout CONS Looks and feels old • Mediocre unladen ride quality • Loose steering The heavy-duty truck world moves more slowly than other pickup classes, and progress comes in spurts.
MotorTrend3 min readIndustries
MotorTrend’s 75th Anniversary: The Icon
Your choice as the most iconic car of the past 75 years? Of course it’s the Corvette; there really isn’t any other car that comes close. For 71 of the 75 years MotorTrend has been informing and entertaining the world about all things automotive, the
MotorTrend4 min read
Uaw President Shawn Fain Is The 2024 Motortrend Person Of the Year
Shawn Fain is the fiery auto worker driven to become a United Auto Workers leader. He was elected as the group’s president by a small margin in March 2023—the first UAW president directly selected by the membership—promising an end to past regimes’ c

Related Books & Audiobooks