Rotman Management

The Democratization of Judgment

HARDLY A DAY GOES BY WITHOUT the announcement of a promising new frontier for Artificial Intelligence (AI). From fintech to edtech, what was once fantastically improbable is becoming a commercial reality. At the same time, corporate investments in Big Data and the dividends they yield in terms of consumer insights are trumpeted on a daily basis.

Oddly, we don’t hear much about the demand created by this rising ‘supply’: In a world of Big Data and AI, the demand for sound and distributed judgment is increasing. ‘Qualitative judgment’ — the ability to make a decision based on a personal interpretation of the context and available facts — has never been more important. In this article I will exlain why judgment has become so important, and how to go about enabling it throughout your organization.

The Rising Demand for Judgment

A basic decision process can be deconstructed into four logical steps: collect and organize available data; analyze it for patterns and insights; predict the best possible courses of action; and use judgment to make a final decision. This last step is more important than ever, and there are three main reasons for this.

1. Qualitative judgment is the last preserve of humanity in making decisions.

There is no question that Big Data and AI offer important advances in the realm of management. Already, they are helping organizations analyze their markets and consumers more effectively and

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from Rotman Management

Rotman Management13 min read
ESG RISK: What’s on Your Radar?
IN THE CURRENT ENVIRONMENT, ESG risks pose one of the greatest threats to public companies’ abilities to deliver predictable results. A recent Bank of America study calculated that 24 ESG incidents in the period 2014–2019 cost U.S. public companies o
Rotman Management4 min read
Sustainability Tools: The Regenerative Compass
We are well into what climate experts are calling ‘the decisive decade’ for sustainability and Net Zero commitments. And yet, significant action and momentum are missing in most organizations. Even in companies that have made bold commitments for 203
Rotman Management8 min read
Management: Philosophy in Action
LOOKING BACK OVER MY CAREER, I sometimes I think of a roller-coaster as an analogy for the relative arbitrariness of a career: there are ups and downs, not necessarily related to personal effort or work. Today’s success does not guarantee tomorrow’s

Related Books & Audiobooks