Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
*5
VUHFLQGH NRQWURO NRUXPD YH J|UQWOHPH JLEL oRN JHQL ELU NXOODQP DODQQD
*QP]GH UHWLOPL ELUoRN DOJOD\FGDQ V|] HGLOHELOLU 0LNUR HOHNWURQLN WHNQRORMLVLQGHNL LQDQOPD] K]O JHOLPHOHU EX NRQXGD KHU JQ \HQL ELU EXOX \D GD \HQL ELU X\JXODPD WLSL JHOLWLULOPHVLQH RODQDN VDODPDNWDGU
GLHUOHUL UH]LVWLI PDQ\HWLN RSWLN YH GLHU HOHPDQODUQ ELUOLNWH NXOODQOPDVQGDQ ROXXU $OJOD\FODU ELOLQHQ WHPHO ELOLPVHO SUHQVLSOHUH J|UH oDOU %X HOHPDQODUQ WHPHO ELOJLVLQL JHUHNWLULU DQODOPDV JHQHOGH IL]LN HOHNWULNHOHNWURQLN NLP\D EL\RORML YE JLEL DODQODUQ
%D] DOJOD\FODU ELU IRWRGL\RW JLEL ROGXNoD EDVLW RODELOLUNHQ NDUPDN \DSGDNL
WDQPODQU $OJOD\F LVH oHLWOL HQHUML ELoLPOHULQL HOHNWULNVHO HQHUML\H G|QWUHQ FLKD]ODUGU $QFDN \OQGD ,6$ ,QVWUXPHQW 6RFLHW\ RI $PHULFD EX LNL WHULPL H DQODPO RODUDN NDEXO HWPL YH NXOODQODELOLU HOHNWULNVHO PLNWDUD G|QWUHQ ELU DUDo RODUDN WDQPODPWU |OoOHQ IL]LNVHO |]HOOLN PLNWDU YH NRXOODUQ
7H]LPGH DOJOD\F WUOHULQL NVDFD DQODWUNHQ YXUJX GDKD oRN EDVQo DOJOD\FODU YH EDVQoOD \DNQGDQ LOLQWLOL RODUDN \NVHNOLN|OoHU $OWLPHWHU NRQXVX RODFDNWU
$/*,/$<,&,/$5
$OJOD\FODUQ 6QIODQGUOPDV $OJOD\FODU ELUELULQGHQ IDUNO ELUoRN VQID D\UPDN PPNQGU gOoOHQ E\NOH J|UH oN E\NOQH J|UH EHVOHPH LKWL\DFQD J|UH YE $DGD EX VQIODUGDQ ED]ODUQD GHLQLOHFHNWLU
*LUL %\NONOHULQH *|UH $OJOD\FODUOD |OoOHQ E\NONOHU JUXED D\UODELOLU %XQODU D 0HNDQLN 8]XQOXN $ODQ 0LNWDU .WOHVHO $N .XYYHW 7RUN 0RPHQW %DVQo +] YPH 3R]LV\RQ 6HV 'DOJDER\X YH <RXQOXX E 7HUPDO 6FDNON YH V DN F (OHNWULNVHO 9ROWDM $NP 'LUHQo (QGNWDQV .DSDVLWDQV 'LHOHNWULN .DWVD\V 3RODUL]DV\RQ (OHNWULN $ODQ YH )UHNDQV G 0DQ\HWLN H ,PD
$ODQ <RXQOXX $N <RXQOXJX 0DQ\HWLN 0RPHQW *HoLUJHQOLN <RXQOXN 'DOJDER\X 3RODUL]DV\RQ )D] <DQVWPD *|QGHUPH I .LP\DVDO <RXQODPD oHULN 2NVLGDV\RQ5HGDNVL\RQ 5HDNVL\RQ +] 3K 0LNWDU
dN %\NOHULQH *|UH gWH \DQGDQ DQDORJ oNODUD DOWHUQDWLI RODQ GLMLWDO oNODU LVH ELOJLVD\DUODUOD GRUXGDQ %XQODUGDQ VHUL LOHWLLP SURWRNROOHULQH DDGD NVDFD GHLQLOPLWLU D 56&
%X SURWRNRO EDODQJoWD WHOHIRQ YHUL LOHWLLPL LoLQ WDVDUODQPWU 'DKD VRQUD VWDQGDUW ELU LOHWLLP SURWRNROX KDOLQH JHOPLWLU E 56$
+DWODUGD EX PHVDIH VHEHEL\OH RODELOHFHN ]D\IODPD P9 VHYL\HVLQH NDGDU D]DOVD GD VLVWHP LOHWLLPH GHYDP HGHU 'LIHUDQVL\HO DUD ELULP VD\HVLQGH VLQ\DOGHNL ]D\IODPD LKPDO HGLOHELOLU G]H\H oHNLOLU YH ROGXNoD \NVHN ELU YHUL K]\OD KDEHUOHPH VDODQDELOLU F 56
6WDQGDUW $ SURWRNROX JHQLOHWLOHUHN ROXWXUXOPX ELU SURWRNROGU %X SURWRNRO VDODQDELOLU 56 SURWRNRO NDEORGDNL LOHWLLP SUREOHPOHULQL RUWDGDQ NDOGUPDNWDGU
LOH ELUOLNWH oDODELOHQ DGHW DOF YHULFLQLQ WHN ELU NDEOR\OD YHUL LOHWLLPL
%HVOHPH LKWL\DFQD *|UH $OJOD\FODU EHVOHPH LKWL\DFQD J|UH VQID D\UODELOLU %XQODU 3DVLI $OJOD\FODU +LoELU HNLOGH GDUGDQ KDULFL HQHUML DOPDGDQ EHVOHPH JHULOLPLQH LKWL\Do GX\PDGDQ IL]LNVHO \D GD NLP\DVDO GHHUOHUL ELU EDND E\NOH oHYLULUOHU %X DOJOD\F WLSLQH |UQHN RODUDN 7HUPRFRXSOH 7& \D GD DQDKWDU J|VWHULOHELOLU
$NWLI $OJOD\FODU dDOPDODU LoLQ KDULFL ELU HQHUML EHVOHQPHVLQH LKWL\Do GX\DUODU %X DOJOD\FODU WLSLN RODUDN ]D\I VLQ\DOOHUL |OoPHN LoLQ NXOODQOUODU $NWLI DOJOD\FODUGD GLNNDW HGLOPHVL JHUHNHQ QRNWD JLUL YH oNODUGU %X WLS DOJOD\FODU GLMLWDO \D GD DQDORJ IRUPDWWD DNPGU
3R]LV\RQ 6HYL\H YH <HU GHLLP $OJOD\FODU )L]LNVHO FLVLPOHULQ SR]LV\RQ YH \HU GHLLPOHULQLQ |OoP oRX X\JXODPDODUGD oRN NRQWURO URERWLN VLVWHPOHU JYHQOLN VLVWHPOHUL YE 3R]LV\RQXQ DQODP VHoLOHQ ELU UHIHUDQVD J|UH FLVPLQ NRRUGLQDWODUQQ GRUXVDO YH\D DoVDO EHOLUOHQPHVLGLU %X DQODPGD ELU oRN \|QWHP NXOODQODUDN EX E\NONOHU |OoOHELOLU %XQODU D 3RWDQVL\RPHWULN $OJOD\FODU E <HUoHNLPL $OJOD\FODU F 8OWUDVRQLN $OJOD\FODU G .DSDVLWLI $OJOD\FODU H (QGNWLI $OJOD\FODU J 2SWLN $OJOD\FODU I 0DQ\HWLN $OJOD\FODU
|QHPOLGLU gUQHLQ JHUL EHVOHPH NRQWURO LOHPL SHUIRUPDQV |OoP XODPGD WUDILN
+] YH YPH $OJOD\FODU +] ELU FLVPLQ GLQDPLN NDUDNWHULVWLLGLU oQN 1HZWRQXQ LNLQFL NDQXQXQD J|UH K] ELU NXYYHWLQ X\JXODQPDVQ JHUHNWLULU $VOQGD \HU GHLLPL K] YH LYPH ELUELUOHUL\OH LOLNLOLGLU +] \HU GHLLPLQLQ ELULQFL WUHYL YH LYPH LVH LNLQFL WUHYLGLU NL DQD EDON DOWQGD LIDGH HGLOHELOLUOHU
D YPH gOoHUOHU
PLNWDUODUQGDQ ELULGLU .XYYHWLQ |OoP FLVLPOHULQ WDUWOPDV \DSD\ SURWH]OHULQ WDVDUODQPDV YE LoLQ PDNLQD YH LQDDW PKHQGLVOLLQGH JHUHNPHNWHGLU %DVQo |OoOG ]DPDQ NXYYHWLQ |OoOPHVL JHUHNLU .DWODU HOH DOQGQGD NXYYHW |OoOU
YH DNNDQODU VY YH\D JD]ODU HOH DOQGQGD LVH EDVQo |OoOU GHQLOHELOLU +DUHNHW ELU QRNWD\D X\JXODQGQGD NXYYHW GLNNDWH DOQU YH NXYYHW JHQL ELU DODQD \D\OG ]DPDQ LVH EDVQo |OoOU
.XYYHW DOJOD\FODU QLWHOLN YH QLFHOLN PLNWDU EDNPQGDQ LNL VQID D\UODELOLU %LU
QLFHOLN DOJOD\FV JHUoHNWH NXYYHWL |OoHU YH GHHULQL HOHNWULN VLQ\DOL HNOLQGH J|VWHULU %X DOJOD\FODUD |UQHN RODUDN VWUHQJHoOHU YH \N KFUHOHUL YHULOHELOLU .XYYHW DOJOD\FODUQ |\OH VQIODQGUDELOLUL] D 6WUHQJHoOHU
E 'RNXQPD $OJOD\FODU
)L]LLQ WHPHOOHULQGHQ ELULVL NWOH ROXS NRUXQDQ ELU PLNWDUGU <RNWDQ YDU HGLOHPH] YH\D \RN HGLOHPH] .WOHQLQ ND\QDNODU YH\D \XWDNODUQQ \RNOXXQGD VQUODUQD EDNOPDNV]Q PLNWDU VDELW NDOU %XQXQOD EHUDEHU VQUODU LoLQGH NWOHQLQ JLULL YH\D DUDOQGD KHU LNL ELULP |OoOGQGH VLVWHPH JLUHQ NWOH VLVWHPL WHUN HGHQ NWOH\H HLWWLU
oN YDUVD NWOHQLQ JLUL YH oNODUQQ WRSODPQQ VIU ROPDV JHUHNLU $\Q ]DPDQ
.DUDUO ELU DNWD YHULOHQ ELU QRNWDGDNL K] ]DPDQD J|UH VDELWWLU +DUHNHWOL ELU GDOP ]DPDQGDQ EDPV]GU %LU K] YHNW|U KHU ] QRNWDVQGD DN KDWWQD
RUWDPGD KHU QRNWD ER\XQFD JHoHQ ELU DN KDWW oL]LOHELOLU .DUDUO DNWD DN KDWWQQ WDQMDQWWU $NQ ELU GHPHWLQL oHYUHOH\HQ DNQ VQUODU DN WS RODUDN DGODQGUOU %|\OH ELU WSQ VQU DN KDWODUQGDQ ROXWXXQGDQ KLoELU DNNDQ JD] ELU DN WSQQ VQUQ JHoHPH] YH WS EHOOL ELoLPH VDKLS ERUX JLEL GDYUDQU $NNDQ RUWDP
DODQQGDNL D\Q ERUXQXQ GLHU XFXQGDQ oNDU %LU DN WSQQ LoLQGHNL KDUHNHWOL PDO]HPHQLQ K] JHQHOGH WS ER\XQFD IDUNO JHQOLNWH RODFDNWU $N DOJOD\FODU DDGDNL JLEL VUDODQDELOLU
$ JLUL NHVLW DODQQD VDKLS E|\OH ELU ERUXQXQ ELU XFXQGDQ JLUHU YH $ oN NHVLW
D ,VO OHWLP $OJOD\FODU E 8OWUDVRQLN $OJOD\ODU F (OHNWURPDQ\HWLN $OJOD\FODU G 0LNURDN $OJOD\FODU H +DILI 5]JDU $OJOD\FODU $NXVWLN $OJOD\FODU
7HPHOGH PLNURIRQ JHQL ELU VSHNWUDO DUDON ]HULQGH VHV GDOJDODUQQ G|QP LoLQ DGDSWH HGLOPL ELU EDVQo G|QWUFVGU 0LNURIRQODU GX\DUOONODU \|QH EDO NDUDNWHULVWLNOHUL IUHNDQV EDQW JHQLOLNOHUL GLQDPLN DUDONODU E\NONOHUL YE LOH IDUNOON J|VWHULU $\Q ]DPDQGD WDVDUPODU GD VHV GDOJDODUQQ DOJODQDFD RUWDPD EDO RODUDN WDPDPHQ IDUNOON J|VWHULU .DWODUGDNL WLWUHLPOHULQ YH KDYD GDOJDODUQQ DOJODQPDV GXUXPXQGD DOJOD\F PLNURIRQ RODUDN DGODQGUOUNHQ VYODUGDNL DOJOD\F\D KLGURIRQ DG YHULOLU %DVQo DOJOD\FV LOH DNXVWLN DOJOD\F DUDVQGDNL IDUN DNXVWLN DOJOD\FQQ VDELW YH\D oRN \DYD GHLHQ EDVQoODU |OoPH JHUHL GX\PDPDVGU dDOPD IUHNDQV DUDO QDGLUHQ ELUNDo +]GHQ EDODU YH VW oDOPD IUHNDQV DUDO LVH ROGXNoD \NVHNWLU XOWUDVRQLN X\JXODPDODU LoLQ ELUNDo 0+]H NDGDU oNDELOLU
$NXVWLN GDOJDODU PHNDQLN EDVQo GDOJDODU ROGXXQGDQ KHUKDQJL ELU PLNURIRQ YH\D YH GL\DIUDPQ VDSPDODUQ HOHNWULN VLQ\DOLQH G|QWUHQ ELU \HU GHLLP
KLGURIRQ EDVQo DOJOD\FVQGDNL D\Q WHPHO \DS\D VDKLSWLU +DUHNHWOL ELU GL\DIUDP DOJOD\FVQGDQ ROXPDNWDGU <DQL EWQ PLNURIRQODU YH\D KLGURIRQODU EX LNL WHPHO ELOHHQLQ WDVDUP LOH IDUNOON J|VWHULUOHU $NXVWLN DOJOD\FODU LoLQ PLNURIRQ RODUDN DDGDNL \|QWHP VD\ODELOLU %XQODU D .RQGHQVHU 0LNURIRQODU E )LEHU 2SWLN 0LNURIRQODU G (OHNWUHW 0LNURIRQODU H 5H]LVWLI 0LNURIRQODU 1HP $OJOD\FODU
F 3LH]RHOHNWULN 0LNURIRQODU
<NVHN HPSHGDQVO HOHNWURQLN GHYUHOHU HOHNWURVWDWLN GX\DUO ELOHHQOHU \NVHN ELU IDNW|UGU
JHULOLPOL D\JWODU KDVVDV PHNDQL]PDODU YE ED] D\JWODUQ oDOPDV LoLQ QHP |QHPOL
1HP K\JURPHWUH DGQGDNL D\JWODU LOH |OoOHELOLU ON K\JURPHWUH 6LU -RKQ /HVOLH WDUDIQGDQ NHIHGLOPLWLU 1HP LoHULLQLQ |OoOPHVL LoLQ ELU K\JURPHWUH PRGOH HGLOHELOPHOLGLU 1HP DOJOD\F LoLQ DDGDNL \|QWHP VD\ODELOLU %XQODU D .DSDVLWLI 1HP $OJOD\FODU E OHWNHQOLN $OJOD\FODU F ,VO OHWNHQOLN DOJOD\FODU G 2SWLN 1HP $OJOD\FODU H 2VLODV\RQOX 1HP DOJOD\FODU LoLQGHNL DOJOD\F VX\D VHoLFL ROPDO YH GDKLOL |]HOOLNOHUL VX NRQVDQWUDV\RQX LOH
(OHNWULNVHO G|QP LoLQ DOJODPDQQ IDUNO PHWRWODU NXOODQOU %XQODU UH]LVWLI VO HOHNWULN \DULOHWNHQ RSWLN YH SLH]RHOHNWULN DOJOD\FODUGU 6FDNOQ DOQPDV YH\D |OoOPHVL WHPHOGH FLVPLQ VO HQHUMLVLQLQ NoN ELU NVPQQ DOJOD\F\D LOHWLPLQL JHUHNWLULU DOJOD\FQQ IRQNVL\RQX EX HQHUML\L HOHNWULNVHO VLQ\DOH G|QWUPHNWLU 7HPDVO ELU DOJOD\F FLVPLQ ]HULQH YH\D LoLQH \HUOHWLULOGLLQGH FLVLP YH SURE DUDVQGDNL DUD \]H\ ER\XQFD V LOHWLPL \HU DOU 3URE VQU YH\D VRXU |UQHLQ FLVLP LOH V GHLLPL \DSDU 1H NDGDU NoN ROXUVD ROVXQ ELU SURE |OoPH DODQQ ER]XFX \|QGH HWNLOH\HFHNWLU
7HPDVO ELU VFDNON |OoP NRQWDN \]H\L YH SUREXQ Lo NVP DUDVQGD VO JUDG\DQ
ROPDG VUHFH WDP RODUDN NDEXO HGLOPHNWHGLU %X LOHP EHOOL ELU ]DPDQ DOU oQN
SURE \HUOHWLULOGLNWHQ VRQUD |]HOOLNOH WHPDV \]H\L NXUX LVH FLVLP YH DOJOD\F WDKPLQL PHWRGX NXOODQOGQGD ELU VFDNON GHQJHVL JHUHNPHPHNWHGLU
$/*,/$<,&, 6(d0
%LU WDVDUPF YH\D PKHQGLV EHOOL ELU GHLNHQLQ J|]OHQPHVL JHUHNWLLQH NDUDU
YHUGLLQGH ELU LNLOHP LOH \] \]H JHOLU EX L LoLQ HQ L\L DOJOD\F QHGLU" dDODQ KHU DOJOD\F EDVLW ELU NDYUDPD GD\DQU %LU DOJOD\FQQ IL]LNVHO |]HOOLL KDULFL ELU HOHNWULN VLQ\DOL LOH GHLWLULOPHOLGLU 2OGXNoD VN RODUDN D\Q X\DUF ROGXNoD IDUNO X\JXODPD LoLQ HQ L\L DOJOD\FQQ VHoLPL ELU PKHQGLVOLN WHUFLK SUREOHPLGLU 6HoLP EDOGU (Q L\L VHoLP VDGHFH EWQ GHLNHQOHU GLNNDWH DOQGNWDQ VRQUD \DSODELOLU %X EDNPGDQ ;L |OoPHN LoLQ X DOJOD\FQQ NXOODQOPDV JHUHNLU" 6RUXVX GRUX ELU VSHNWUXP DUWODUQ LoHUPHOLGLU
IL]LNVHO ROD\ODU YH GROD\V\OD IDUNO DOJOD\FODU LOH |OoOHELOLU %X \]GHQ |]HO ELU NULWHUL PHYFXGL\HW PDOL\HW Jo WNHWLPL oHYUHVHO DUWODU YE JLEL oRN IDNW|UH
VRUX ROPD\DFDNWU 8\JXQ ELU VRUX VHoLPL ELU YH\D LNL WHUFLKH LQGLUPHN LoLQ JHQL ELU
%X NDGDU oRN DOJOD\F oHLGL YDUNHQ \DSODFDN X\JXODPD LoLQ X\JXQ DOJOD\FQQ \DQQGD RUWDP HWNLOHUL YH LOHYVHOOLN JLEL ELUNDo |QHPOL IDNW|UH GH EDOGU $OJOD\F VHoLPL LOH LOJLOL ELOJLOHU DDGD VXQXOPXWXU gOoP .RXOODU
gOoPQ WHPHO DPDF QHGLU" gOoOHQ E\NON QHGLU" gOoP DUDO QHGLU" gOoPQ GRUXOXN VHYL\HVL QH RODFDNWU" gOoOHQ E\NOQ GLQDPLN NDUDNWHULVWLL E\NON ELU DNNDQ LVH IL]LNVHO YH NLP\DVDO |]HOOLNOHUL QHGLU" $OJOD\F QHUH\H YH QDVO PRQWH HGLOHFHNWLU" $OJOD\FQQ PDUX] NDODFD oHYUHVHO HWNLOHU QHOHUGLU" QHGLU" gOoP VUDVQGD |OoP DUDOQQ DOPDV QH |OoGH RODFDNWU" gOoOHQ
9HUL 7RSODPD 6LVWHPL .RXOODU 9HUL WRSODPD VLVWHPL DQDORJ PX \RNVD GLMLWDO PL" 9HUL WRSODPD VLVWHPLQLQ VLQ\DO
NRXOODPD oRXOODWUPD DQDORJGLMLWDO oHYLUPH |]HOOLL 7UDQVIHU |QFHVL WDPSRQ GRUXOXN IUHNDQV FHYDE |]HOOLNOHUL QHOHUGLU" %XOXQDELOLUOLN .RXOODU
EHOOHN EXIIHULQJ |]HOOLNOHUL YHUL ND\G YH LOHPH |]HOOLNOHUL YHUL WRSODPD VLVWHPLQLQ
7P LVWHNOHUL \HULQH JHWLUHQ DOJOD\F SL\DVDGDQ EXOXQDELOL\RU PX" $NVL WDNWLUGH WDVDUP \DSPDN P JHUHNHFHN" %X LL VWOHQHELOHFHN UHWLFLOHU NLPOHUGLU" $OJOD\F ]DPDQQGD WHVOLP HGLOHELOHFHN PL" 0DOL\HW )DNW|UOHUL
YDURODQ ELU DOJOD\F\D NoN GHLLNOLNOHU \DSPDN \HWHUOL RODFDN P" <HQL ELU
gQHULOHQ DOJOD\FQQ PDOL\HWL J|VWHUHFHL IRQNVL\RQ LOH RUDQWO P" 6HoLOHQ DOJOD\FQQ VHEHS RODFD WHVW SHUL\RGLN NDOLEUDV\RQ NXUXOXP JLEL HNVWUD PDVUDIODU QHOHUGLU" 9HUL WRSODPD VLVWHPLQGH \DSOPDV JHUHNHFHN RODQ G]HQOHPHOHU QHOHUGLU"
KWL\DFP] RODQ DOJOD\F GRUX RODUDN VHoHELOPHN LoLQ \XNDUGD GHLQLOHQ EWQ NULWHUOHUH KDNLP ROPDN JHUHNPHNWHGLU $NVL WDNWLUGH JHUHN PDOL\HW DoVQGDQ JHUHN ]DUDUD XUD\DELOLUL] |OoP VRQXoODUQQ GRUXOXX DoVQGDQ JHUHNVH \DSWP] LWH JYHQ DoVQGDQ
%$6,1d $/*,/$<,&,/$5,
%DVQo .DYUDP %DVQo NDYUDP |QFHOLNOH *DOLOHRQXQ NVD ELU VUH LoLQ |UHQFLVL RODQ (YDQJHOLVWD GROGXUXOPX WDEDNODUOD \DSW GHQH\OHUL VUHVLQFH DWPRVIHULQ \HU ]HULQGH ELU EDVQo
7RUULFHOOLQLQ LON oDOPDODUQD GD\DQPDNWDGU 7RUULFHOOL GH FLYD LOH PH\GDQD JHWLUGLLQL DQODG GH GLHU E\N IL]LNoL %ODLVH 3DVFDO 3HULHULQ FLYD VWXQXQD HWNLOH\HQ EDVQFQ \NVHOWL\H EDO ROGXXQX J|]OHPOHGL 'HQH\GH
\DUGP\OD 3X\ GH 'RPH GDQQ WHSHVLQGH YH DDVQGD ELU GHQH\ JHUoHNOHWLUGL YH NXOODQG YDNXP LoLQGHNL FLYDO D\JWD EDURPHWUH DGQ YHUGL GD 5REHUW %R\OH
VDELW VFDNONWD YHULOHQ ELU KDYD NWOHVL LoLQ EDVQo YH KDFLP |OoOHULQLQ oDUSP VDELWWLU LOLNLVLQL LIDGH HWPLWLU 'DQLHO %HUQRXOOL %R\OHQLQ NDQXQXQXQ DQDOLWLN RODUDN oNDUODELOHFHL QRNWDGD JD] EDVQFQQ HWNL WHRULVLQL JHOLWLUGL
%HUQRXOOL D\Q ]DPDQGD &KDUOHV*D\ /XVVDF NDQXQXQGDQ |QFH VDELW ELU KDFLPGH GHWD\O WDQPODU LoLQ WHPHO IL]LN NLWDSODUQGDQ ELULQLQ LQFHOHQPHVL \HWHUOL RODFDNWU ELOJLOHU YHULOHFHNWLU
JD]Q VWODUDN EDVQFQQ DUWWQ LIDGH HWPLWLU *D] YH DNNDQODU GLQDPLLQLQ $DGD EDVQo DOJOD\FODUQQ WDVDUP YH NXOODQOPDV LoLQ JHUHNOL ED] WHPHO
*HQHO DQODPGD PDGGH NDW YH DNNDQODU RODUDN LNL\H D\UODELOLU $NNDQ NHOLPHVL DUDVQGDNL D\UP WDPDPHQ EHOLUOL GHLOGLU %DVQFQ GHLPHVL\OH ELU VYQQ JD]D YH JD]Q VY\D GHLWLULOPHVL PPNQGU %LU DNNDQD \]H\LQH QRUPDOGHQ EDND GLHU \|QOHUGHQ EDVQo X\JXODQPDV PPNQ GHLOGLU GHUHFHQLQ GQGD ELU DoGD DNNDQ VDGHFH ND\DFDN YH\D DNDFDNWU %X \]GHQ DNNDQD X\JXODQDQ KHU NXYYHW WDQMDQW RODUDN HWNLU YH VQUODUQD HWNL\HQ EDVQo \]H\LQH QRUPDOGLU 'XUJXQ ELU NXYYHWL LOH WDQPODQDELOLU DNNDQQ EDVQF ELU VQU \]H\LQLQ ELULP DODQ $ ]HULQH GLN RODUDN HWNL\HQ )
G) G$
%DVQo WHPHO RODUDN ELU PHNDQLN NDYUDP ROXS NWOH X]XQOXN YH ]DPDQ |OoOHUL LOH WDQPODQDELOLU %DVQo VQUODU LoLQGHNL SR]LV\RQX LOH PXWODND GHLPHNOH EHUDEHU GHLLP \|QGHQ WDPDPHQ EDPV] ROGXX ELOLQHQ ELU JHUoHNWLU <NVHOWL LOH EDVQoWDNL
GS ZGK
%XUDGD Z RUWDPQ |]JO DUO YH K GLNH\ \NVHNOLNWLU %DVQo VQUOD\F oHYUHQLQ ELoLPLQGHQ HWNLOHQPH] %XQGDQ GROD\ oRN NoN WLSWH EDVQo DOJOD\FODUQQ WDVDUP ELoLP YH ER\XW GLNNDWH DOQPDGDQ \DSODELOLU D\HW EDVQo DNNDQ YH\D JD]Q EXOXQGXX oHYUHQLQ \]H\OHULQGHQ ELULQH X\JXODQUVD EDVQo GHHULQGHQ KLo ELU H\ ND\EHWPHGHQ EWQ \]H\H LOHWLOLU HQHUMLVLQLQ ELU |OoV VD\ODELOLU
S
U &
157
%XUDGD .( NLQHWLN HQHUML 9 KDFLP & PROHNOHU K]ODUQ NDUHVLQLQ RUWDODPD GHHUL VFDNONWU
U \RXQOXN 1 ELULP KDFLP EDQD PROHNO VD\V 5 |]JO JD] VDELWL YH 7 PXWODN HLWOLLQH J|UH VNDELOHQ DNNDQODUQ JD]ODUQ EDVQo YH \RXQOXX GRUXVDO LOLNLOLGLU %DVQoWDNL DUW \RXQOXXQ RUDQWO DUW LOH VRQXoODQDFDNWU gUQHLQ DWP EDVQoWD YH &GHNL KDYDQQ \RXQOXX NJP LNHQ D\Q VFDNONWD YH
DWP EDVQoWD \RXQOXX NJP ROXS NH] GDKD E\NWU %XQXQ WHUVLQH VYODUQ \RXQOXX GHLLN VFDNON YH EDVQo DUDOQGD oRN D] GHLLU gUQHLQ & YH DWPGH VX\XQ \RXQOXX NJP & YH DWPGH VX\XQ \RXQOXX NJP
*D] EDVQFQQ RUWDP EDVQFQQ ]HULQGH YH\D DOWQGD ROPDV\OD DU EDVQo YH\D
YDNXP KDNNQGD NRQXXOPX ROXU %DVQo RUWDP EDVQFQD J|UH |OoOGQGH LVH DEVROXW RODUDN DGODQGUOU %LU RUWDPQ EDVQF GXUJXQ DNNDQD J|UH VWDWLN YH\D KDUHNHWOL ELU DNNDQQ NLQHWLN HQHUMLVLQH J|UH GLQDPLN RODELOLU %DVQo %LULPOHUL %DVQFQ 6, ELULPL SDVFDOGU 3D
EDO UHODWLI RODUDN DGODQGUOU EDVQoWDNL YDNXPD J|UH |OoOGQGH LVH PXWODN
\]H\ ]HULQH GHQJHOL RODUDN GDOP ELU QHZWRQOXN NXYYHWH HLWWLU %D]HQ WHNQLN VLVWHPOHUGH DWP \L J|VWHUPHN LoLQ DWPRVIHU NXOODQOU %LU DWPRVIHU QRUPDO \HU oHNLPL LYPHVLQGH GH PHWUH \NVHNOLLQGHNL VX VWXQXQXQ ELU VDQWLPHWUH G|QWUOHELOLU 3D
NDUHVLQH HWNL\HQ EDVQoWU 3D DDGDNL LOLNLOHU NXOODQODUDN GLHU ELULPOHUH OELQ DWP
FP +J
KDWUODPDN NXOODQO RODELOLU (QGVWULGH EDVQFQ GLHU ELU ELULPL VN RODUDN NXOODQOU 1RUPDO DWPRVIHU EDVQFQGD YH QRUPDO \HU oHNLPLQGH & GH PP YH WRUU RODUDN DGODQGUOPWU 'Q\D DWPRVIHULQLQ LGHDO EDVQF WRUU YH IL]LNVHO DWPRVIHU RODUDN DGODQGUOU DWP WRUU 3D FLYD\D HWNL\HQ EDVQo RODUDN WDQPODQU %X ELULPH 7RUULFHOOLGHQ VRQUD LVLP YHULOPL
86QLQ NXOODQG ELULPOHU EDVQF LQo NDUH EDQD ELU SRXQG RODUDN WDQPODU OEVVT YH\D SVL 6, ELULPLQH DDGDNL JLEL G|QWUOU SVL 3D
DWP
%LU EDVQo DOJOD\FVQQ oDOPD SUHQVLEL GX\DUO ELU HOHPDQD HWNL\HQ EDVQFQ DNDELQGH ELU HOHNWULN VLQ\DOLQH G|QPQH GD\DQU +HPHQ KHPHQ EWQ GXUXPODUGD EDVQo EHOLUOL \]H\ DODQQD VDKLS ELU HOHPDQGD \HU GHLLPL LOH
VRQXoODQU %XQXQ VRQXFX RODUDN EDVQo |OoP \HU GHLLPL VRQXFX PH\GDQD JHOHQ \HU GHLLPL YH\D NXYYHWLQ |OoOPHVLQH LQGLUJHQHELOLU %DVQo $OJOD\FODU YH '|QWUFOHUL &YD %DVQo $OJOD\FV %DVLWOLL LOH EHUDEHU YHULPOL ELU DOJOD\F HNLO GH J|UOG JLEL ELOHLN NDSODU FLYDQQ \NVHNOLL\OH RUDQWO RODUDN WHOLQ GLUHQFL NVD GHYUH ROXU 'LUHQoOHU ELU SUHQVLELQH GD\DQU 8 ELoLPOL LOHWNHQ ELU WHO FLYD LoLQH GDOGUOU KHU VWXQGDNL :KHDWVWRQH N|SUVQH EDODQPWU YH WSWHNL EDVQo VIU ROGXX VUHFH GHQJHGH
NDOU 7SQ NROODUQGDQ ELULQH EDVQo X\JXODQGQGD N|SUQQ GHQJHVL ER]XODUDN GLHU NROXQ GLUHQFL GDKD D]GU dN JHULOLPL FLYD LOH |QWOHQPH\HQ GRNXQPD\DQ NROODUGDNL LOHWNHQ WHOOHULQ '5 GLUHQo IDUNODU LOH RUDQWOGU
9RXW 9 '5 5 9E'S
ELU oN VLQ\DOL YHULU 6RO WSWHNL \NVHN EDVQo LOH EX NROXQ GLUHQFL GDKD \NVHN YH
$OJOD\F GRUXGDQ WRUU ELULPLQGH NDOLEUH HGLOHELOLU %DVLW ROPDV\OD EHUDEHU DOJOD\FQQ HWNLOHQHELOHFHL KDVVDV VHYL\HOHUH JHUHNOLOLL GDUEH YH VDUVQW\D GX\DUOO YH JD]Q FLYD EXKDUODU LOH NLUOHWLOPHVL JLEL ED] VDNQFDODU YDUGU
HNLO *D] %DVQFQQ gOoOPHVL oLQ &LYD 'ROGXUXOPX 8 %LoLPOL %RUX
.|UN =DU QFH /HYKD 9H 3ODNDODU %DVQo DOJOD\FODUQGDNL DOJODPD HOHPDQ PHNDQLN ELU D\JW ROXS JHUJLQOLN DOWQGD ENOPO YH KHOLVRLGDO NYUPO YH HVQHN FDWHQDU\ GL\DIUDPODU NDSVOOHU N|UNOHU Io WSOHUL YH EDVQo DOWQGD ELoLPL GHLHQ GLHU NRPSRQHQWOHUGLU \DSVDO GHLLNOLNOHUH XUDU 7DULKVHO RODUDN E|\OH D\JWODU EXUGRQ WSOHUL & ELoLPOL
HNLO GHNL N|UN EDVQF GRUXVDO ELU GHLLPH G|QWUS X\JXQ ELU DOJOD\F LOH |OoOPHVL DPDF\OD \DSOPWU %|\OHFH N|UN EDVQFQ HOHNWULN VLQ\DOLQH G|QWUOPHVLQGH ELULQFL DGP \HULQH JHWLULU 2OGXNoD JHQL ELU \]H\ DODQ YH EX
\]GHQ GN EDVQoODUGD E\N \HU GHLLPL LOH NDUDNWHUL]H HGLOLU 'LNLVL] PHWDOLN N|UNOHULQ ULMLWOLL VWLIIQHVV PDO]HPHQLQ <RXQJ PRGO LOH RUDQWO YH G oDS YH NDEDFD oQF NXYYHWL LOH DUWDU N|UN E|OPOHULQLQ VD\V LOH WHUV RUDQWOGU 6HUWOLN D\Q ]DPDQGD GXYDU NDOQOQQ
%DVQFQ GRUXVDO ELU VDSPD\D G|QPQQ SRSOHU ELU |UQHL ELU VYV] DQHURLG EDURPHWUHGHNL GL\DIUDPGU HNLO 6DSPD J|VWHUHQ ELU HOHPDQ EDVQo RGDFQQ HQ D]QGDQ ELU GXYDU J|UHYLQGH YH VDSPD\ HOHNWULN VLQ\DOOHULQH G|QWUHQ ELU oRX PLNURPDNLQD WHNQRORMLVL LOH UHWLOPL VLOLNRQ ]DUODUGDQ \DSOPDNWDGU JHUJLQOLN DOJOD\FVQD VWUHQJH\o EDODQPWU LPGLOHUGH EDVQo DOJOD\FODUQQ
%LU ]DU 1P RODUDN |OoOHQ 6 UDG\DO X]DWF JHUJLQOLL WHQVLRQ DOWQGD LQFH ELU
GL\DIUDPGU HNLO %NF NXYYHWOHUH NDU J|VWHULOHQ VHUWOLN ]DUQ NDOQOQQ oDS LOH NDUODWUOGQGD oRN NoN ROGXXQGDQ HQ D]QGDQ NDW GDKD NoN LKPDO HGLOHELOLU =DUQ ELU WDUDIQD EDVQo X\JXODQGQGD VDEXQ N|S JLEL NUHVHO
ELU HNLO DOU 'N S EDVQo IDUNODUQGD ]P PHUNH] VDSPDV YH VP 1P JHUJLQOLL EDVQFQ NVPL GRUXVDO IRQNVL\RQODUGU
HNLO %LU %DVQo '|QWUFVQQ dHOLN .|UNOHUL HNLO %DVQFQ 'RUXVDO 6DSPDVQQ '|QP oLQ 0HWDO .YUPO 'L\DIUDP
]PD[
V PD[
U S 6
6 J
%XUDGD U ]DU \DUoDS YH J NDOQOGU 6WUHVV JHQHOGH ]DU DODQ ]HULQGH HLW GDOPWU =DUQ HQ GN GRDO IUHNDQV
IR SU 6 UJ
HLWOLLQGHQ KHVDSODQU %XUDGD U ]DU PDO]HPHVLQLQ \RXQOXXGXU D\HW ]DUQ NDOQO LKPDO HGLOHPH\HFHN NDGDU NoN GHLOVH UJ RUDQ YH\D GDKD D]VD ]DU LQFH SODND RODUDN DGODQGUOU HNLO D\HW OHYKD ELU oHLW VNWUF KDONDODU DUDVQGD VNWUOUVD LQFH SODND YH VNWUF KDONDODU DUDVQGDNL SODND YH GHVWHN SDUoDODUQQ WHN SDUoD PDO]HPHGHQ \DSOG \HNSDUH \DSGU VUWQPHGHQ GROD\ HWNLOL ELU KLVWHUH]LV PH\GDQD JHWLULU 'DKD L\L ELU G]HQOHPH LVH
% =DU
%XUDGD ( <RXQJ PRGO 1P YH Y LVH 3RLVVRQ RUDQGU dHYUH ER\XQFD PDNVLPXP JHUJLQOLN GH EDVQFQ GRUXVDO ELU IRQNVL\RQXGXU
V PD[ U S J
<XNDUGDNL HLWOLH J|UH ELU EDVQo DOJOD\FV ]DU NDOQOQQ YH LQFH SODNDQQ IL]LNVHO HWNL LOH HOHNWULNVHO VLQ\DOLQH G|QWUOHFHLGLU %XQXQ LoLQ ED] VHoHQHNOHU DOJOD\FODU YH RSWRHOHNWURQLN DOJOD\FODU
VDSPDVQQ D]DOWOPDV LOH WDVDUPODQDELOLU %XQGDQ VRQUDNL VRUX VDSPDQQ KDQJL YDUGU 3LH]RUH]LVWLI DOJOD\FODU NDSDVLWLI DOJOD\FODU GHLNHQ UHONWDQVO
3LH]R5H]LVWLI $OJOD\FODU %LU EDVQo DOJOD\FV \DSPDN LoLQ LNL WHPHO ELOHHQ JHUHNLU %XQODU $ ELOLQHQ DODQD VDKLS SODND ]DU YH X\JXODQDQ ) NXYYHWLQH WHSNL YHUHQ ELU GHGHNW|UGU %X LNL
ELOHHQ VLOLNRQGDQ \DSODELOLU %LU VLOLNRQ GL\DIUDP EDVQo DOJOD\FV HODVWLN PDO]HPH RODUDN LQFH VLOLNRQ GL\DIUDP YH GL\DIUDPQ LoLQH GDWODUDN \HUOHWLULOPL NDWN PDO]HPHOHULQGHQ \DSOP JH\o GLUHQoOHULQGHQ ROXXU %XUDGD VLOLNRQXQ VWQ HODVWLN NDUDNWHULVWLNOHULQL XQXWPDPDN JHUHNLU QHUHGH\VH NXYYHWOL VDELW EDVQoODU DOWQGD ELOH NDOF ER\ X]DPDV YH KLVWHUH]LV PH\GDQD JHWLUPH] 6LOLNRQXQ JH\o IDNW|U LQFH PHWDO LOHWNHQOHUGHQ GDKD oRN E\NWU 6WUHQJH\o GLUHQoOHULQLQ ELU
:KHDWVWRQH N|SUVQH EDODQPDV LVH ELU JHOHQHN KDOLQH JHOPLWLU %|\OH ELU ELoLPH JHWLUPHN LoLQ VLQ\DO G]HOWLFL GHYUH\H JHUHN YDUGU 6LOLNRQXQ VFDNON GX\DUOOQQ oRN ROPDVQGDQ GROD\ VLQ\DO G]HOWLFL GHYUH\H VFDNON NRPSDQ]DV\RQ GHYUHVLQLQ HNOHQPHVL D\UFD JHUHNPHNWHGLU SLH]RUH]LVWLI
'5 5
HWNL
VRQXFX
'5
NDGDU
GLUHQo
GHLLPL
PH\GDQD
JHOLU
VLOLNRQ NULVWDOL ]HULQGHNL GLUHQoOHULQ NRQXPXQD EDOGU %XQXQ VRQXFX RODUDN HNLO GL\DIUDP \]H\ NRQXPXQGD G]HQOHQLU .DWVD\ODU
S
O
GH J|UOG JLEL SWLSL \D\OP GLUHQo ! \|QQGH YH Q WLSL VLOLNRQ NDUH WLSL
S
S
X\JXODQDQ EDVQoOD RUDQWOGU 'LUHQoOHU GL\DIUDP ]HULQGH ER\XQD YH HQLQH ]W \|QOHUGH GHLLU
'5 5 '5 5
S V O\
V
O[
E
HNLO %LU 6LOLNRQ 'L\DIUDPGD 3LH]R5H]LVW|UOHULQ 3R]LV\RQX
9oN
(S V O\ V O[
6RQXo RODUDN EDVQo GX\DUOO DS YH GHYUHQLQ VFDNON GX\DUOO E7 NVPL WUHYOHU DOQDUDN EXOXQDELOLU
D w9 ( wS
RXW
S w V V wS
O\ O[
E7
wD S D S w7
wS S w7
6LOLNRQ EDVQo DOJOD\FV LOHPLQGH NXOODQODELOHFHN UHWLPLQ GHLLN PHWRWODU YDUGU %LU PHWRWWD \]H\ NRQXPX LOH EDODQJo PDO]HPHVL QWLSL VLOLNRQ \DSGU
LPSODQWDV\RQX LOH IDEULNDV\RQX \DSOU 3LH]RUH]LVW|UOHUGHQ ELUL 5 SDUDOHO YH oHYUHVHO ELOHHQOHU VFDNON NRPSDQ]DV\RQX LoLQ NXOODQOU YH SLH]RUH]LVW|UOHULQ \DSOPD VUHFLQGHNL D\Q LOHPGH \DS ]HULQH \HUOHWLULOLU %XQODU GL\DIUDPQ NDOQ NDSDN DODQQD \HUOHWLULOGLLQGHQ GL\DIUDPD X\JXODQDQ EDVQFD NDU GX\DUV]GUODU GLHUL 5 GL\DIUDP NRQXPXQD GLNH\GLU 'LUHQoOHU YH SQMRQNVL\RQODU JLEL GLHU
FP
\]H\
NDWN
NRQVDQWUDV\RQOX
SLH]RUH]LVW|UOHULQ
ERURQ
L\RQ
*HUJLQOLN DOJODPD\D GLHU ELU \DNODP HNLO GD J|UOHQ 0RWRUROD 03; EDVQo DOJOD\FVQGD NXOODQOPWU 6WUHQJH\o RODUDN J|UHY \DSDQ SLH]RUH]LVWLI HOHPDQQ GLUHQoOHULQ YH QROX XoODUQGDQ ER\ODPDVQD JHoHU YH GL\DIUDP JHUGLUHQ EDVQo LQFH ELU VLOLNRQ GL\DIUDP ]HULQH L\RQ LPSODQWDV\RQX \DSOU 8\DUWP DNP DNPQ DNQD GHUHFH Do LOH X\JXODQU *HUJLQOLN GLUHQoWH ELU HOHNWULN DODQ
PH\GDQD JHWLULU YH YH QROX XoODUGDQ EX JHULOLP DOJODQU 7HN HOHPDQO HQLQH NXOODQODUDN :KHDWVWRQH N|SUV WDVDUP LoLQ JHUHNHQ ELUELULQH \DNQ GHHUGH G|UW ]DPDQGD NDOLEUDV\RQ YH VFDNON NRPSDQ]DV\RQX LoLQ JHUHNOL HN GHYUHOHU GH EDVLWOHWLULU %XQXQOD ELUOLNWH WHN HOHPDQO VWUHQJH\o HOHNWULNVHO RODUDN N|SU
JHULOLP VWUHQJH\oL +DOO HWNLOL PHNDQLN DQDORJ D\JW RODUDN J|UOHELOLU %LU HOHPDQ DGHW JHUJLQOLN YH VFDNOD GX\DUO GLUHQoOHULQ NXOODQOPDV HOLPLQH HGLOLU $\Q
GHYUHVLQH EHQ]HU %DODQV RIIVHW ELOLQHQ N|SUGH ROGXX JLEL HOHQPL GLUHQoOHUH EDO ROPD\S HQLQH JHULOLP XoODUQQ QH NDGDU L\L D\DUODQGQD \DQL D\Q GRUXOWX\D JHWLULOGLLQH EDOGU %X D\DUODPD NRQWURO NROD\O EDNPQGDQ IRWROLWRJUDILN
LOHPGH \DSOU 7DVDUPFQQ LLQL NROD\ODWUPDN LoLQ oLSLQ LoLQH VFDNON NRPSDQ]DV\RQX YH NDOLEUDV\RQ HOHPDQODU\OD ELUOLNWH VLQ\DO LOHPH DUDELULP HOHPDQODU GD HNOHQPLWLU
HNLO 0RWRUROD 03; %DVQo $OJOD\FVQQ .RPSDQ]H (GLOPHPL 7HPHO 3LH]R5H]LVWLI (OHPDQ
$ODQ PP E\NOQGH LQFH ELU VLOLNRQ GL\DIUDP ND]PD o|]HOWLOHUL LOH HNLOOHQGLULOLU |UQHLQ K\GUD]LQH VX\X 1 + + 2 DQLVRWURSLN ND]\F %LU 6L2
WDEDND RODUDN J|UHY \DSDU .D]PD ]DPDQ DNPDNWD RODQ o|]HOWLGH & GH PPGDNLNDGU 'L\DIUDPQ VRQ NDOQO PP FLYDUQGD VDODQU
$ hUHWLP $GPODU
'L\DIUDP UHWLPLQLQ GLHU ELU PHWRGX VLOLNRQ I]\RQ \DSWUPD\D 6)% GD\DQU DUD NDWPDQODU NXOODQOPDNV]Q WHN NULVWDO VLOLNRQ \DSUDNoNODU PNHPPHOH \DNQ DUD YH\D KD\YDQODU ]HULQGHNL |OoPOHUGH NOFDO ERUX FDWKHWHU G|QWUFOHULQGH \]H\OHU RODUDN JYHQLOLU HNLOGH \DSWUODELOLU %X WHNQLN WS DODQQGD FDQO ELWNL NXOODQODQ oRN NoN DOJOD\FODUQ \DSPQD L]LQ YHULU 7RSODP oLS DODQ QRUPDO
VLOLNRQ EDVQo DOJOD\FODUQQ DODQQGDQ NDW GDKD NoN RODELOLU $OJOD\F LNL
NVPGDQ ROXXU DOW YH VW \DSUDNoODU HNLO D $OW VQUOD\F \DSUDNoD J|YGH |QFHOLNOH DQLVRWURSLN ND]PD LOH GL\DIUDPQ LVWHQLOHQ |OoOHULQGH ELU NDUH GHOLN DoOU $OW \DSUDNoQ NDOQO \DNODN PP YH GL\DIUDPQ \DQ |OoOHUL PPGLU NDYLWH PH\GDQD JHWLULOLU %XQGDQ VRQUDNL DGP QWLSL HSL WDEDND LOH SWLSL \DSGDQ
E|\OHFH DQLVRWURSLN ND]PD LOH \DNODN PP GHULQOLLQGH SLUDPLW ELoLPOL ELU
ROXDQ \DSUDNoQ ]HULQH VLOLNRQ \DSWUPD LOHPL 6)% \DSPDNWU (SL WDEDNDVQQ NDOQO GL\DIUDPQ LVWHQLOHQ HQ VRQ NDOQOQD NDUON JHOLU 6RQUD \DSUDNoQ ]HULQGHNL ID]ODON WDPDPHQ ND]PD LOHPL LOH NDOGUOU YH E|\OHFH DOJOD\FQQ GL\DIUDP ELoLPLQL DODQ WHN NULVWDO WDEDND VLOLNRQ ]HULQGH NHQGLOLLQGHQ \DSN EUDNOP ROXU %XQGDQ VRQUD GLUHQoOHULQ L\RQ LPSODQWDV\RQX \DSOU NRQWDN DGPGD VQUOD\F \DSUDNoN \HUOHWLULOLU YH D\JWQ LVWHQLOHQ NDOQOQGD DOW \]H\L JHoLOHUL ND]QU YH ELULNWLUPH YH ND]PD WHNQLL LOH LVWHQLOHQ SDWHUQH JHWLULOLU 6RQ SDUODWOU PP FLYDUQGD 6)% oLSOHULQLQ ER\XWODU NRQYDQVL\RQHO oLS ER\XWODUQQ \DUV FLYDUQGD ROPDVQD UDPHQ EDVQo GX\DUOONODU LVH D\QGU 6)% YH GLHU oLSOHULQ NDUODWUOPDV HNLO EGH J|VWHULOPLWLU $\Q GL\DIUDP ER\XWODU YH oLSLQ G ER\XWODUQD J|UH 6)% D\JW GDKD NoNWU
%DVQo DOJOD\FODU HNVHUL\HWOH PXWODN IDUN YH JH\o EDVQF |OoPOHUL LoLQ o WHPHO NRQILJUDV\RQGD \DSOUODU 0XWODN EDVQo EDURPHWULN EDVQo JLEL ELU YDNXP RGDFQQ UHIHUDQVQD J|UH |OoOU 2GDFN GDUGD RODELOHFHL JLEL DOJOD\FQQ LoLQGH GH RODELOLU HNLO D %LU IDUN EDVQF IDUN EDVQo DN PHWUHVLQGH ROGXX JLEL GL\DIUDPQ ]W \|QOHULQGHQ D\Q ]DPDQGD EDVQo X\JXODQDUDN |OoOU %XQD |UQHN RODUDN DWPRVIHULN EDVQFD J|UH \DSODQ NDQ EDVQF |OoP YHULOHELOLU +HU o D\QGU gUQHLQ ELU IDUN YH\D JH\o DOJOD\FV \DSPDN LoLQ ELU VLOLNRQ SDUoD
G]HQOHPHQLQ SDNHWOHPHOHUL IDUNOON J|VWHULUNHQ GL\DIUDP YH VWUHQJH\o WDVDUPODU RGDFQ LoLQH \HUOHWLULOLU HNLO E 3DUoD KHU LNL \DQQGD LNL DoN JLULH VDKLSWLU GROGXUXOXU MHO EDVQo VLQ\DOLQLQ VLOLNRQ GL\DIUDPD JHoPHVLQH L]LQ YHULUNHQ SDUoD D\JWODUQQ LoLQH PRQWH HGLOHELOLU HNLO 6FDN VXOX oHNLo DQGUF DNNDQODU
6DUVQWO RUWDPODUGDQ DOJOD\F\ NRUXPDN LoLQ NXWXFXXQ Lo NVP VLOLNRQ MHO LOH \]H\LQL YH LOHWNHQ EDODQW\ L]ROH HGHU %LU IDUN DOJOD\FV GHLLN EDODQW oNO YH \N KFUHOHUL JLEL ED] X\JXODPDODU IL]LNVHO L]RODV\RQX YH oLSL WD\DQ SDNHW LOH KLGUROLN NXSODM ]RUXQOX NODU %X HN GL\DIUDP YH N|UNOHUOH \DSODELOLU +HU GXUXPGD GROGXUXODELOLU KDYD EROXXQD VLVWHPLQ IUHNDQV WHSNLVLQLQ D]DOPDPDV LoLQ VLOLNRQ \D
% 'LIHUDQVL\HO
%WQ VLOLNRQ WDEDQO DOJOD\FODU VFDNON EDPOO LOH NDUDNWHUL]H HGLOLUOHU YH GRUX EDVQo DOJODQOPDV LoLQ NRPSDQ]H HGLOPHVL JHUHNLU .|SU GHYUHOHULQLQ
'X\DUOOQ VFDNON NDWVD\V E7 HLWOLL LOH WDQPODQU YH JHQHOOLNOH QHJDWLIWLU VFDNON NRPSDQ]DV\RQ PHWRWODU 17& WHUPLVW|UOHU LOH ND\QDD VHUL EDO VDELW
GLUHQoOHU LOH VFDNON NRQWUROO JHULOLP ND\QD LOH YH ELU DNP ND\QD LOH \DSODELOLU DGD J|UOG JLEL RODELOLU
dRX X\JXODPDODUGD EDVLW IDNDW YHULPOL VFDNON NRPSDQ]DV\RQX DOJOD\F\D VHUL YH\D SDUDOHO VFDNON NDUDUO GLUHQo EDODQDUDN \DSODELOLU 'LUHQFLQ X\JXQ ELU GHHULQLQ VHoLPL LOH DOJOD\FQQ oN LVWHQLOHQ oDOPD DUDOQD D\DUODQDELOLU HNLO E *HQL DUDONWD GDKD L\L VFDNON G]HOWLPL ]RUXQOX LVH VFDNON GHGHNW|UOHULQLQ EXOXQGXX GDKD NDUPDN NRPSDQ]DV\RQ GHYUHOHULQLQ NXOODQOPDV JHUHNHELOLU %XQD
VFDNON DOJOD\FV LOH |OoOG ELU \D]OP VRIWZDUH NRPSDQ]DV\RQXGXU %DVQo VD\VDO RODUDN \DSODFD LOHPH GHYUHVLQH J|QGHULOLU YH VFDNON DOJOD\FVQGDQ JHOHQ YHULOHU VD\VDO QPHULN ELU NRPSDQ]DV\RQXQ
.DSDVLWLI $OJOD\FODU 6LOLNRQ GL\DIUDP ELU NDSDVLWLI DOJOD\FGD EDVQoWDQ HOHNWULH G|QWUPH LOHPLQGH NXOODQODELOLU %XUDGD GL\DIUDPQ \HU GHLLPL UHIHUDQV SODNDVQD DUND SODND J|UH NDSDVLWDQVWD PRGODV\RQ PH\GDQD JHWLULU %X G|QP |]HOOLNOH GN EDVQoO DOJOD\FODU LoLQ HWNLOLGLU $OJOD\FQQ WDPDPQQ IDEULNDV\RQX WHN SDUoD VLOLNRQ NWOHGHQ \DSODELOLU E|\OHOLNOH oDOPD NDUDUOO PDNVLPXPD oNDUWODELOLU 'L\DIUDPQ WDP DUDON ]HULQGH DOJOD\FODUQ oNQQ GRUXGDQ VD\VDO IRUPD G|QWUOPHVLQL NROD\ KDOH JHWLULU NDSDVLWDQV UHWHFHN HNLOGH WDVDUPODQPDV EX
%LU SLH]RUH]LVWLI GL\DIUDPQ NHQDUODUQGD PDNVLPXP JHUJLQOLN RODFDN HNLOGH WDVDUPODQPDV JHUHNLUNHQ NDSDVLWLI GL\DIUDP RUWD NVPQGDNL \HU GHLLPLQGHQ \DUDUODQU %X GL\DIUDPODU GL\DIUDPQ KHU LNL NHQDUQD \DNQ \HUOHWLULOHQ PHNDQLN GXUGXUXFXODU LOH DU EDVQoODUD NDU NRUXQDELOLUOHU |UQHLQ ELU IDUN EDVQo
DOJOD\FV 0DDOHVHI SLH]RUH]LVWLI GL\DIUDPODUGD D\Q NRUXPD PHWRGX oDOPD \HU GHLLPLQLQ NoN ROPDVQGDQ GROD\ WDPDPHQ HWNLOL ROPDPDNWDGU 6RQXo RODUDN SLH]RUH]LVWLI DOJOD\FODUQ WLSLN GHOLQPH EDVQoODU WDP VNDOD DUDOQQ \DNODN NDW ROXUNHQ NDSDVLWLI DOJOD\FODU DU EDVQo GXUGXUXFXODU YH\D VQUOD\FODU LOH WDP VNDOD DQPD EDVQFQQ ELQ NDWQD NDGDU GD\DQDELOLUOHU %X |]HOOLNOH oRN \NVHN EDVQo SDOVOHULQLQ ROXDELOHFHL GN EDVQo X\JXODPDODUQGD |QHPOLGLU
%LU EDVQo DOJOD\FVQQ WDVDUP \DSOUNHQ L\L ELU GRUXVDOON LoLQ GL\DIUDPQ G]JQOQQ NRUXQPDV |QHPOLGLU *HOHQHNVHO RODUDN EX DOJOD\FODU VDGHFH NDOQONODUQGDQ oRN GDKD D] \HU GHLLPOHUL LoLQ GRUXVDOGUODU 'RUXVDO DUDO
DUWUPDQQ ELU \ROX PLNURPDNLQD WHNQRORMLVL LOH GL\DIUDP ]HULQGH NYUPO YH GDOJDO \ROODU \DSPDNWU (N RODUDN NDSDVLW|UQ SDUDOHO SODND DNVL\RQXQX VUGUPHVL LoLQ \]H\L NDEDUWPDO \DSOU .YUPODUQ YH NDEDUWPDQQ NRPELQDV\RQX WDP VNDODGD VLOLNRQ DUDVQD VDQGYLo JLEL \HUOHWLULOPLWLU hVWWHNL VLOLNRQ SDUoD PHNDQLN DU EDVQo GXUGXUXFX RODUDN J|UHY \DSDU $DGDNL VLOLNRQ SDUoD LVH &026 GHYUHVLQL YH NDSDVLW|UQ DUND SODNDVQ ]HULQGH WDU YH D\Q ]DPDQGD GLHU \|QGH DU EDVQo GXUGXUXFX RODUDN J|UHY \DSDU $OJOD\FQQ WDPDP HNLO DGD J|UOPHNWHGLU OLN ELU GRUXVDOV]OD QHGHQ ROPDNWDGU 'L\DIUDP GLHU LNL SDUoD
'] GL\DIUDPODUQ JHQHO RODUDN D\Q |Oo YH NDOQONWDNL NYUPO GL\DIUDPODUD J|UH GDKD GX\DUO ROGXX GQOPHNWHGLU %XQXQOD EHUDEHU G]OHP LoLQGHNL JHUGLULFL VWUHVOHULQ YDUOQGD NYUPODU JHUJLQOLLQ ELU NVPQ EUDNPD J|UHYL \DSDUODU YH E|\OHFH GDKD L\L GX\DUOON YH GRUXVDOON YHULUOHU HNLO E
$ %LU .DSDVLWLI 'L\DIUDP 9H $UDELULP% 3ODNDGDNL *HUGLULFL 6WUHV $OWQGD $\Q %R\XWODUGDNL .YUPO 9H (OHNWURQLN 'HYUHVL HNLO '] 'L\DIUDPODUQ 0HUNH] 6DSPDV
'HLNHQ 5HONWDQVO %DVQo $OJOD\FODU 'N EDVQoODUQ |OoPQGH LQFH ELU SODND YH\D GL\DIUDPQ VDSPDV oRN NoN RODELOLU *HUoHNWH GL\DIUDPD HNOHQPL YH\D LoLQH \HUOHWLULOPL VWUHQJH\oOHULQ NXOODQP GN oN VLQ\DOLQGHQ GROD\ SUDWLN ROPD\DELOLU %X SUREOHPH X\JXQ ELU
FHYDS PDO]HPHGHNL GDKLOL JHUJLQOLN \HULQH GL\DIUDPQ VDSPDVQQ ELU UHIHUDQV WDEDQD J|UH UHODWLI SR]LV\RQX LOH |OoOG ELU NDSDVLWLI DOJOD\F RODELOLU %|\OH DOJOD\FODUD GDKD |QFH GHLQLOPLWL g]HOOLNOH oRN GN EDVQoODU LoLQ NXOODQO GLHU ELU o|]P PDQ\HWLN DOJOD\FGU 'HLNHQ UHONWDQVO EDVQo 953 DOJOD\FVQGD ELU IDUN WUDQVIRUPRWRUXQXQ PDQ\HWLN GLUHQFLQL PRGOH HGHQ PDQ\HWLN \DNODP GHGHNW|UOHULQH oRN \DNQGU HNLO D PDQ\HWLN DN PRGODV\RQXQXQ DUNDVQGDNL WHPHO ILNUL J|VWHUPHNWHGLU ( WLSL QYH YH VDUJ GRQDQPQQ UHWWLL JHoLUJHQOLL KDYDGDQ HQ D]QGDQ ELQ NDW GDKD E\NWU YH PDQ\HWLN GLUHQFL KDYDQQ JHoLUJHQOLH VDKLS GL\DIUDP NXOODQOU $OJOD\FQQ oDOPD SUHQVLEL PDQ\HWLN
PDQ\HWLN DN QYHGHQ KDYD \ROX\OD GL\DIUDPD JHoHU ( QYHOL PDQ\HWLN PDO]HPHQLQ GLUHQFLQGHQ GNWU +DYDQQ PDQ\HWLN GLUHQFL QYHQLQ PDQ\HWLN GLUHQFLQGHQ oRN GDKD E\N ROGXXQGDQ KDYD DUDO QYH VDUJ GRQDQPQQ LQGNWDQVQ DUDO DUWDUDN YH D]DODUDN LQGNWDQVQ PRGODV\RQXQD QHGHQ RODFDNWU EHOLUOHPHNWHGLU 'L\DIUDP VDSPD J|VWHUGLLQGH VDSPD \|QQH EDO RODUDN KDYD
% (GHHU 'HYUH
D $OJOD\F 7DNP
%LU EDVQo DOJOD\FV UHWPHN LoLQ PDQ\HWLN RODUDN JHoLUJHQ ELU GL\DIUDP WUDQVIRUPRWRUXQ NDEXN NVPQQ DUDVQD VDQGYLo HNOLQGH NRQXOXU HNLO +HU NDEXN NVPGD ELU (QYHVDUJ GRQDQP YDUGU 6DUJODU oRN \NVHN EDVQoODU
DOWQGD ELOH PDNVLPXP NDUDUOOQ VUGUOPHVL LoLQ VHUW ELU PDGGH LoLQH NRQXOPXWXU 'L\DIUDPQ KHU LNL \DQQD LQFH EDVQo NDYLWHOHUL ELoLPL YHULOPLWLU 'L\DIUDPQ NDOQO WDP VNDOD oDOPD DUDOQ EHOLUOHPHNOH EHUDEHU oRX GXUXPODU DOWQGD WRSODP VDSPDQQ PP\L DPDPDV EX D\JW GN EDVQoODU LoLQ oRN
GX\DUO \DSPDNWDGU 'DKD GD |WHVL LQFH EDVQo NDYLWHOHULQGHQ GROD\ DU EDVQo GXUXPODU DOWQGD ]DU DU EDVQoWDQ NRUXQPX ROXU %|\OHFH 953 DOJOD\FODU GRDO RODUDN JYHQLOLU D\JWODU ROPDNWDGU %LU $& DNPOD X\DUWOG ]DPDQ KHU QYHGH YH GL\DIUDP \ROX\OD KDYD DUDOQGD ELU PDQ\HWLN DN UHWLOLU %|\OHFH DOJOD\FODU LNL LQGNWDQV LoHUPHNWH YH KHU ELU LQGNWDQV N|SUQQ ELU NROXQX ROXWXUGXX GHLNHQ EDVQF X\JXODQG ]DPDQ ELU NHQDUQGD D]DOPD YH GLHU WDUDIQGD DUWPD LOH UHONWDQVO N|SUQQ \DUV JLEL GQOHELOLU HNLO E 'L\DIUDPD ELU IDUN GL\DIUDP VDSPD J|VWHULU YH X\JXODQDQ IDUN EDVQF LOH RUDQWO RODUDN KDYD DUDO VNDOD EDVQF oRN NoN ROPDQQ \DQQGD oN VLQ\DOL oRN E\N RODFDN YH JUOWOHUGHQ UDKDWONOD oNDUWODELOHFHNWLU
953 DOJOD\FVQQ oN PRGODV\RQOX HOHPDQODU RODUDN HGHHU LQGNWLI UHDNWDQVODU [ UHONWDQVOD RUDQWOGU %LU VDUJQQ LQGNWDQV VDUJ VLSLU VD\V YH VDUJ JHRPHWULVL LOH EHOLUOHQLU $ODQ DNV LoLQH PDQ\HWLN JHoLUJHQOLH VDKLS ELU PDO]HPH NRQXOGXX LQGNWDQVQ GHLWLULU 'HYUHQLQ LQGNWDQV YH DNDELQGH UHDNWDQV PDQ\HWLN UHONWDQVOD WHUV RUDQWOGU \DQL [
NXOODQDQ LQGNWLI
]DPDQ PDQ\HWLN DODQ oHNHUHN GN GLUHQoOL ELU \RO PH\GDQD JHWLULU YH VDUJQQ |]
N G EXUDGD N ELU VDELW YH G KDYD DUDOQQ
E\NOGU .|SU $& LOH X\DUWOG ]DPDQ N|SU XoODUQGDNL oN JHULOLPL X\JXODQDQ EDVQo LOH JHQOLN PRGODV\RQXQD XUDU %X JHQOLN N|SUQQ GHQJHVL]OLL WHSNL UHWPHN LoLQ GHPRGOH HGLOHELOLU YH GHQJHVL]OLLQ \|Q LOH GHLHQ oN VLQ\DOLQLQ ID] LOH RUDQWOGU $& VLQ\DOL '&
2SWR(OHNWURQLN $OJOD\FODU 'N VHYL\HOL EDVQoODUQ |OoPQGH YH\D WHUVLQH JHQL ELU GLQDPLN DUDONWD NDOQ ]DUODUQ NXOODQOPDV ]RUXQOX ROGXXQGD \HWHUOL o|]QUON YH GRUXOXX VDODPDN LoLQ GL\DIUDPQ GHLLPL oRN NoN RODELOLU %XQODUQ \DQQGD SLH]RUH]LVWLI ROGXXQGDQ HN ELU VFDNON NRPSDQ]DV\RQXQD JHUHN GX\DUODU %LU RSWLN RNXPD
DOJOD\FODUQ oRX YH ED] NDSDVLWLI DOJOD\FODUQ VFDNOD GX\DUOONODU oRN VLVWHPL GLHU WHNQRORMLOHULQ ]HULQGH DYDQWDMD VDKLS RODELOLU \DQL EDVLW ELU NXWXODPD LOHPL NoN VFDNON HWNLOHUL \NVHN o|]QUON YH GRUXOXN g]HOOLNOH XPXW YHULFL RODQODU Q NDUP LQWHUIHUHQFH IHQRPHQL LOH oDODQ RSWRHOHNWURQLN DOJOD\FODUGU %|\OH ELU DOJOD\FQQ EDVLWOHWLULOPL ELU GHYUHVL HNLO GH J|UOPHNWHGLU .DUPQ LQWHUIHUHQFH DQODP D\Q IUHNDQVWD IDNDW IDUNO ID]GD LNL GDOJDQQ ELUOHLPLQLQ GDOJD JHQOLLQLQ GHLPHVLQH QHGHQ ROPDVGU
HNLO .DUP QWHUIHUHQFH )HQRPHQL OH dDODQ %LU 2SWR(OHNWURQLN %DVQo $OJOD\FVQQ .HVLW *|UQ
$OJOD\FQQ WHPHO SDUoDODU XQODUGU VLOLNRQ ]HULQGH ND]PD LOH ROXWXUXOPX ]DU LOH NHQGLOLLQGHQ UHWHQ RSWLN EDVQo oLSL N \D\DQ GL\RW /(' YH GHGHNW|U oLSL %DVQo oLSL EXQGDQ |QFH EDKVHGLOHQ NDSDVLWLI EDVQo DOJOD\FVQD EHQ]HPHNWH IDNDW
LQWHUIHURPHWUH ELoLPOL RSWLN NDYLWH NXOODQOPWU 6LOLNRQ oLS ]HULQH DUND NVP
ND]QP WHN NULVWDO GL\DIUDP LQFH PHWDOLN WDEDND LOH NDSODQP YH DUND NVPQGDNL PHWDOLN NDWPDQQ ]HUL FDP SODND LOH NDSODQPWU &DP VLOLNRQ oLSWHQ Z X]DNOQGD KDUHNHWOL D\QD YH FDP ]HULQH \DU HIIDI G] SDUDOHO GXUDQ VDELWOHQPL D\QD LOH
LNL EROXN YHULFL LOH D\UOPWU NL PHWDOLN WDEDND ]DU ]HULQGH EDVQFD GX\DUO GHLNHQ EROXNOX ELU )3 LQWHUIHURPHWUH ROXWXUPDNWDGU 'HGHNW|U oLSL o DGHW SQ RSWLN )3 ILOWUHOHUL LOH NDSODQPWU )LOWUHOHU ELULQFL \]H\ VLOLNRQ D\QDODU RODUDN
MRQNVL\RQOX IRWR GL\RW LoHULU %XQODUGDQ LNLVL D] PLNWDUGD IDUNO NDOQONWD HQWHJUH ELoLPOHQGLULOPL 6L2 WDEDND LOH NDSODQP YH \]H\OHUL LQFH PHWDO D\QD LOH $O NDSODQPWU $OJOD\FQQ oDOPD SUHQVLEL )3 NDYLWHVLQLQ JHQLOLLQH EDO RODUDN J|QGHULOHQ YH \DQV\DQ GDOJD ER\ODUQQ PRGODV\RQXQXQ |OoPQH GD\DQU .DYLWHGHQ \DQVPD YH LOHWLP KHPHQ KHPHQ Z SHUL\RGXQD HLW Q GDOJD ROGXXQGDQ \DQV\DQ N GDOJD ER\X PRGODV\RQOXGXU ER\XQXQ WHUVLQLQ O SHUL\RGLN IRQNVL\RQXGXU Z X\JXODQDQ EDVQFQ ELU IRQNVL\RQX
'HGHNW|U oLSL GHPRGODW|U RODUDN oDOU YH X\JXODQDQ EDVQF WHPVLO HGHQ HOHNWULN
VLQ\DOOHUL UHWLU %X LNL )3 ILOWUHVL DUDVQGDNL \NVHNOLN IDUN LOH PH\GDQD JHOHQ ELU
JHUoHN NDYLWH LOH EDVQo DOJOD\FVQQ DOJODPD NDYLWHVLQLQ RSWLN ELU NDUODWUPDVQ \HULQH JHWLULU D\HW KHU LNL NDYLWH D\Q LVH GHGHNW|U PDNVLPXP IRWR DNP UHWLU YH EDVQo GHLWLL ]DPDQ IRWR DNP N ND\QDQQ RUWDODPD GDOJD ER\XQXQ \DUV LOH UHIHUDQV GL\RWX RODUDN J|UHY \DSDU YH GHGHNW|UH XODDQ N LGGHWLQL J|]OHU WDQPODQDQ ELU SHUL\RW LOH NRVLQV PRGODV\RQXQD XUDU )3 ILOWUHVL] IRWR GL\RW 'HGHNW|UQ oN VLQ\DOL ELOJLQLQ RUDQWO LOHQPHVL LoLQ NXOODQOU 'RDO RODUDN
DOJOD\FQQ oN GRUXVDO ROPDGQGDQ ELU PLNURLOHPFL LOH GRUXVDOODWUPD LOHPL JHQHOGH ]RUXQOXGXU %HQ]HU RSWLN EDVQo DOJOD\FODU ILEHURSWLNOHUOH X]DNWDQ DOJODPD LoLQ |]HOOLNOH NXOODQO KDOH JHOPHNWHGLU WDVDUODQDELOLU %|\OHFH UDG\R IUHNDQV NDUPQQ FLGGL SUREOHP RODELOHFHL \HUOHUGH
0DO]HPH VRUXQODUQQ WHPHO QHGHQL \NVHNOLN DUWWNoD RUWDP EDVQF D]DOPDVGU %XQXQ QHGHQL ]HULPL]GHNL KDYD WDEDNDVQQ \NVHNOLN DUWWNoD D]DOPDVGU 'HQL] GLELQGHQ VDWKD \NVHOLUNHQ EDVQo QDVO D]DO\RUVD \DDGP] DWPRVIHU LoLQGH \NVHOGLLPL]GH GH EDVQo D]DOU $QFDN EX D]DOPD GHQL]GHNL JLEL EDVLW GRUXVDO ELU EDQW\D LIDGH HGLOHPH] 'HQL] VX\X LoLQ KHU PHWUH GHULQOLNWH EDVQo DWPRVIHU DUWPDVQD NDUQ KDYD LoLQ \NVHNOLN EDVQo EDQWV 3 H[S > [K [ 7 @ 0HWUH FLQVLQGHQ \NVHNOLN 7 .HOYLQ
gUQHN PHWUH \NVHNOLNWHNL .DoNDU %\N 'HQL] *|O N\VQGDNL RUWDP EDVQFQ EX IRUPOOH RODUDN EXODELOLUL] %X IRUPOQ NXOODQOPDV \HULQH LUWLIDEDVQo oHYULP WDEORVX NXOODQDUDN GD RUWDP EDVQFQ KHVDSOD\DELOLUL] %X WLS WDEORODUQ HQ JYHQLOLUOHULQGHQ ELUL 'Q\D 6LYLO +DYDFON 7HNLODW
QQ ,&$2 LUWLID EDVQoWDQ IDUNO oNDELOLU %XQXQ QHGHQL GQ\DQQ NXWXSODUGD EDVN \DSV YH HWNLVL GH J|]|QQGH EXOXQGXUXOPXWXU EDVQo JUDILLGLU +HU LNL \|QWHPOH GH EXOXQDQ EDVQo EDURPHWUH LOH |OoOHQ PHWHRURORMLN DUWODUGU %6$& WDEORODUQGDNL LUWLIDEDVQo JUDILLQGH KDYD DUWODUQQ g]HWOH LUWLIDGD RUWDP EDVQF IDUNO PHWRWOD EXOXQXU UWLIDEDVQo JUDILLQGHQ RNX\DUDN UWLIDEDVQo IRUPO X\JXOD\DUDN %DURPHWUH NXOODQDUDN
6HQV|U %DODQWV <NVHNOLLQ EDVQoOD ELUOLNWH GHLWLLQL GDKD |QFHNL DQODWPODUPGD GD EHOLUWPLWLP <NVHNOLN gOoHU GHQL] VHYL\HVLQGHQ \XNDU oNOGNoD YH\D KHUKDQJL ELU EL]H GRUX RODUDN J|VWHUPHVL JHUHNPHNWHGLU \NVHNOLNWHQ DD LQLOGLNoH EX EDVQo IDUNQ GROD\V\OD \NVHNOLN IDUNQ DOJOD\S
%HQLP EXUDGD X\JXODPDVQ \DSWP GHYUH \DQL <NVHNOLN gOoHU V|] NRQXVX \NVHNOLN IDUNQ GLUHN DOJOD\S J|VWHUHFHN HNLOGH WDVDUODQPDPWU %XQXQ \HULQH %DVQo LOH GLUHQFL GHLHQ GHYUH ELU oRN \|QWHPOH \DSODELOPHNWHGLU %DVoOD GLUHQFL EDVQoOD GLUHQFL GHLHQ ELU VLVWHPGHQ \DUDUODQDUDN EX LOHPL JHUoHNOHWLUPHNWHGLU GHLHQ GHYUHGHQ JHOHQ JHULOLP ELOJLVL ,&/ HQWHJUHPL]H JLWWLNWHQ VRQUD VHJPHQW GLVSOH\GH EDVQo RODUDN RNXQXU %X EDVQo GD GHQNOHP GH \HULQH NRQXODUDN \NVHNOLH oHYULOLU
HNLO GH J|UOHQ VHQV|U EDODQW HPDV VHPEROLN ROXS VDGHFH ELU :LQVWRQ N|SUVQGHQ N|SUVQGHNL GHLNHQ 5 GLUHQFL ]HULQGH GHQ JHULOLP ELOJLVL JLWPHNWHGLU ROXPDNWDGU %X VD\HGH <NVHNOLN gOoHULPL]H :LQVWRQ
%XUDGD X\JXODPDVQ \DSWP <NVHNOLN gOoHU EDVQoWDQ \DUDUODQDUDN \NVHNOLL |OoW LoLQ HNLO GHNL GHYUH <NVHNOLN gOoHUH VDGHFH LKWL\DF RODQ JHULOLP ELOJLVLQL J|QGHUPHNWHGLU
HNLO GHNL :LQVWRQ N|SUV NXUXODUDN 5 EDVQo GLUHQFL JHULOLPH G|QWUOG YH LOH ROXWXUXODQ YROWPHWUH GHYUHVLQH J|QGHULOGL
<h.6(./.
'HQL] 6HYL\HVL
IHHW
7255
+*
6,&$./,. &
3UDWLN 'HYUH %DVQo VHQV|UOHULQLQ JHQHO \DSV EDVQo LOH GLUHQFL GHLHQ ELU PDGGHGHQ LEDUHWWLU %X GLUHQFL |OoPHN LoLQ :LQVWRQ N|SUVQGHQ \DUDUODQDELOLUL] %|\OHFH EX GLUHQFL YROWPHWUH NXOODQPDP] JHUHNOLGLU %X \]GHQ LoLQGH ELU $' oHYLULFL YH VHJPHQW GLVSOD\ VUF EXOXQGXUDQ HQWHJUHVL NXOODQOPWU 'HYUHQLQ %ORN HPDV HNLO GH <NVHNOLN gOoHULQ HQWHJUHVLQLQ Lo \DSV YH HQWHJUHVLQLQ HQWHJUHVLQGH GLVSOH\ RWRPDWLN RODUDN VUOU JHULOLPH oHYLUPL ROXUX] dHYLUGLLPL] EX JHULOLPL |OoPHN LoLQGH KDVVDV ELU
'HYUHQLQ dDOPDV gOoOHFHN YROWDM YH QROX XoODUD 5 YH 5 GLUHQoOHUL ]HULQGHQ X\JXODQU YH VRQ RODUDN & NDSDVLWHVL ]HULQGHQ HQWHJUHVLQLQ YH LQFL SLQOHULQH X\JXODQU %X SLQOHU HNLO GHQ GH J|UOG ]HUH HQWHJUHQLQ JLUL SLQOHULGLU 5 GLUHQFL YH
& NDSDVLWHVL GDKLOL VDDW IUHNDQVQ EHOLUOHPHN LoLQ NXOODQOU YH EX VDDW GDUEHVL +] FLYDUQGDGU %X VDDW GDUEHVL LOH VDQL\HGH LNL YH\D o |UQHNOHPH \DSOU HQWHJUHVLQLQ YH QF SLQOHUL DUDVQGDNL & NRQGDQVDW|U GDKLOL UHIHUDQV YROWDMQQ QHGHQ ROGXX KDWDODU NRPSDQ]H HGHU YH GLVSOD\OHUL VDELW ELU GHHUGH WXWDU
VDODU 5 LOH 3 SRWDQVL\RPHWUHVL ELUOLNWH JLULLQ KDQJL GHHULQGH oNQ VIU RODUDN J|VWHULOPHVLQLQ NDOLEUH HGHU 5 GLUHQFL GLVSOH\OHUH JLGHQ DNP NRQWURO HGHU DQRWOX GLVSOH\L VUHFHN HNLOGH WDVDUODQPWU %X GLVSOH\OHUGHQ LONL LDUHW GHHULQL YH HQWHJUHVL LOH P9 LOH P9 DUDV '& JHULOLPOHU |OoOHELOLU <HGL 6HJPHQW 'LVSOH\ <HGL DGHW OHGLQ HNLO GH J|VWHULOGLL JLEL GL]LOPHVL LOH HOGH HGLOHQ HOHNWURQLN GHYUH HOHPDQODUQD \HGL SDUoDO J|VWHUJH YH\D NVDFD GLVSOH\ GHQLU %X J|VWHUJHOHU J|VWHUHELOLUL]'LVSOH\OHU RUWDN DQRW YH RUWDN NDWRW ROPDN ]HUH LNL oHLWWLUOHU \DUGP LOH UDNDPODUQ YH\D $ E F G ( ) KDUIOHULQL %|\OHOLNOH GLVSOH\OHULQ SDUODNO GHLWLULPL ROXU HQWHJUHVL WDQH RUWDN UDNDPQ J|VWHUPHN LoLQ YH GLHUOHUL LVH GLHU UDNDPODU J|VWHUPHN LoLQGLU
I H
D J G
E F
9 $& JHULOLP G|QWUPH RUDQ RODQ WUDQVIRUPDW|U LOH 9 $& JHULOLPH UHJODW|U RODQ /0 HQWHJUHVL LOH WDP GRUXOXNOX ELU '& JHULOLP HOGH HGLOGL
G|QWUOG %X JHULOLP WDP GDOJD GRUXOWPDo LOH GRUXOWXOGX 9 SR]LWLI JHULOLP
$QDORJ'LMLWDO '|QWUFOHU $'& $QDORJ GLMLWDO oHYLULFLOHU FRQYHUWHU PRQROLWLN HQWHJUH GHYUHOHU ,& \NVHN
D\Q DQODPGD NXOODQOPDNWD ROGXXQGDQ DUDGDNL IDUN L\L DQODOPDOGU $\ ]DPDQGD oHYLULFLOHU ELOLQHQ VWDQGDUW HOHPDQODU YH |]HO HQWHJUH GHYUHOHU RODUDN EHOLUOL GLMLWDO YHUL LOHPH D\JWODUQD X\JXQ HNLOGH HGHHU GLMLWDO ELoLPH G|QWUU $'& ND\EROPDPDV o|]QUON G|QP K] NDUDUOON YH IL\DW LoHULU )L\DW HVDV RODQODUGU (Q SRSOHU $'& oHYLULFLOHU K] YH GRUXOXN DUDVQGD GRDO ELU X\JXODPDODU LoLQ EXOXQDELOLUOHU $'& oHYLULFLOHU DQDORJ YHUL\L QDGLUHQ JHULOLP oHYLULFLOHULQ DQDKWDU NDUDNWHULVWLNOHUL PXWODN YH EDO GRUXOXN GRUXVDOON NRGODUQ SUREOHP ROGXXQGD D\U ELOHHQOHU YH\D PRQROLWLN ,& YHUVL\RQODU HQ YHULPOL X\XPDGDQ GROD\ DUGN \DNODP WHNQLLQH GD\DQU %XQXQOD EHUDEHU GLHU SRSOHU NXOODQOU
$QDORJ VD\VDO YH VD\VDO DQDORJ G|QWUPH DQDORJ LDUHW GQ\DV LOH VD\VDO LDUHW GQ\DV DUDVQGDNL LOLNL\L VDODPDNWDGU )L]LNVHO ROD\ODU RODQ VHV KDUHNHW J|UQW VFDNON EDVQo YE JLEL ELUoRN LDUHWLQ DQDORJ DNP JHULOLP YH\D KHU LNL GHHUL ELUGHQ |OoOHELOPHNWHGLU gOoOHQ EX GHHUOHULQ NXOODQODFDNODU GXUXPD J|UH VD\VDO VLVWHPOHULQ DQOD\DELOHFHL VD\VDO LDUHWOHUH G|QWUOPHVL JHUHNPHNWHGLU %X %DVQo GHLLPL GROD\O RODUDN DQDORJ RODUDN GHLHQ ELU
\]GHQ DQDORJ VD\VDO G|QWUFOHU ROGXNoD |QHPOLGLU %L]LP 'HYUHPL]GH GH G|QWUOPHNWHGLU %X DQDORJ JHULOLPLQ EL]LP LoLQ DQODPO ELU KDO DOPDV LoLQ VD\VDO RODUDN LOHQPHVL JHUHNPHNWHGLU JHULOLPH
$QDORJ VD\VDO G|QWUFOHU DQDORJ ELU LDUHWL VD\VDO ELU LDUHWH G|QWUPHNWHGLU EORN \DSV HNLO GH J|VWHULOPLWLU
6D\VDO DQDORJ G|QWUF LVH EXQXQ WDP WHUVLQL \DSPDNWDGU *HQHO ELU $'&QLQ
NXDQWDOD\F\D X\JXODQU 'DKD VRQUD GD NRGOD\F\D X\JXODQGNWDQ VRQUD oNQGDQ VD\VDO ELOJL DOQP ROXU %X DUDGD JHoHQ ]DPDQ VUHVL G|QWUPH ]DPDQ RODUDN LVLPOHQGLULOLU
'|QWUPH NXDQWDOD\FQQ \DUGP LOH ROPDNWDGU .XDQWDOD\F JHOHQ DQDORJ LDUHWL SDUoDODUD E|OPHNWHGLU 7LSLN RODUDN QLFHPOH\LFLGH DGHW EDVDPDN YDUGU 1
1
VD\VDO oNWDNL ELW VD\VQ J|VWHUPHNWHGLU .XDQWDOD\FGD NXOODQODFDN RODQ ]DPDQ LoHULVLQGH |UQHNOHQHQ DQDORJ LDUHW VD\VDO LDUHWH G|QWUOU
EDVDPDN VD\V |UQHNOHQHQ DQDORJ LDUHW LOH X\JXQ ROPDOGU 'ROD\V\OD G|QWUPH
*HQHO RODUDN oRN oHLWOL WUOHUGH $'& GHYUHOHUL \DGD $'& oLSOHUL PHYFXWWXU %XQXQ
QHGHQL GH KHUIDUNO X\JXODPD LoLQ IDUNO ELU $'& QLQ JHUHNOL RODELOHFHLGLU gUQHLQ \]GHQ $'&OHU oHLWOL HNLOOHUGH VQIODQGUODELOPHNWHGLU
ELU X\JXODPD LoLQ o|]QUON |QHPOL LNHQ ELU EDNDV LoLQ VH K] |QHPOL RODELOLU %X
'HYUHGH NXOODQGP HQWWHJUHVL NHQGL LoHULVLQGH oRN K]O ROPD\DQ VDQL\HGH |UQHN DQFDN \NVHN o|]QUONO ELU $'& E|OP LoHULU 9) dHYLULFLOHU *HULOLP IUHNDQV oHYLULFLOHUL 9) \NVHN o|]QUONWH G|QP VDOD\DELOLU YH X]XQ G|QHP LQWHJUDV\RQ PRGODV\RQX JHULOLP L]RODV\RQX YH LVWHH EDO IUHNDQV E|OP YH oDUSP JLEL ED] '$ LOH ELUOLNWH GLMLWDOGHQ IUHNDQVD oHYULP IUHNDQV
|]HOOLNOHUL LOH DOJOD\FODU LoLQ NXOODQOQ DUWUDELOLU dHYLULFL DNP YH\D JHULOLP
HNOLQGH DOJOD\FGDQ DQDORJ oN NDEXO HGHU %D] GXUXPODUGD DOJOD\F ELU $' YH\D IUHNDQV JLUL GHHULQLQ RUWDODPD GHHUL LOH RUDQWOGU oHYLULFLQLQ ELU SDUoDV RODELOLU 9HULOHQ ELU JLUL GHHUL LoLQ VDQL\H EDQD SDOV VD\V
%LU 9) oHYLULFL NXOODQODUDN HQ EDVLW YH HQ HNRQRPLN ELU $' oHYLULFL \DSODELOLU
VNDOD IUHNDQV YH LVWHQLOHQ o|]QUON LOH LOLNLOLGLU *HQHOGH 9) oHYLULFLOHUL DUGN \DNODP D\JWODUQD N\DVOD ROGXNoD \DYD ROPDNOD EHUDEHU oRX DOJOD\F LVWHQLOHQ |UQHNOHPH RUDQ LOH VDDW VLQ\DOLQGH ELU VD\F LOH NXSODMODQU X\JXODPDODU LoLQ ROGXNoD X\JXQ ROPDNWDGU 9) oHYLULFL ELU $' RODUDN oDOUNHQ
$QDORJ JHULOLPLQ GLMLWDO VLQ\DOH G|QP LoLQ JHUHNHQ ]DPDQ 9) oHYLULFLQLQ WDP
'RUXGDQ 6D\VDOODWUPD +HPHQ KHPHQ EWQ DOJOD\FODU GN VHYL\HOL VLQ\DO UHWLUOHU %X VLQ\DOOHULQ YHUL LOHPH D\JWODUQD X\JXQ VHYL\H\H JHWLULOPHVL LoLQ JHQHOGH \NVHOWLFLOHU NXOODQOU 0DDOHVHI \NVHOWLFLOHU YH EDODQW NDEORODU YH LOHWNHQ WHOOHU HN KDWDODU PH\GDQD JHWLUHELOLU D\JWQ PDOL\HWLQL DUWUDELOLU YH NDUPDNO DUWUDELOLU $OJOD\F WDEDQO HQ D]QGDQ ED] oHYLULFLOHU LoLQ \HQLGHQ J|]GHQ JHoLULOPHVLQH QHGHQ ROPDNWDGU g]HO RODUDN oRX HQGVWUL\HO DOJOD\F EHVOHPHOL VLVWHPOHU GLMLWDO YHUL LOHWLPL YH LOHPH D\JW NXOODQPDNWDGU %X HLOLPOHULQ \|Q ]RU ELU LOHP RODQ DOJOD\F oNQQ DOJOD\F GHYUHQLQ HQWHJUDV\RQX GXUXPXQGD GRUXGXU
.ODVLN $' G|QP WHNQLNOHUL \NVHN VHYL\HOL JLUL GHHU DUDONODU ]HULQGH
GXUPDNWDGU %X HQ NoN ELW DGP E\NOQQ RODELOGLLQFH E\N ROPDV RIIVHWLQ YH JUOW KDWDVQQ D]DOWOPDVQD L]LQ YHULU %XQGDQ GROD\ PLQLPXP HQ NoN ELW VLQ\DOL GDLPD HQ D]QGDQ P9 RODUDN VHoLOLU %X \]GHQ oRX DOJOD\FODUQ GRUXGDQ EDODQPDV |UQHLQ 57' VFDNON G|QWUFOHUL YH\D
SLH]RHOHNWULN VWUHQJH\oOHULQ GRUXGDQ EDODQPDV JHUoHNoL ROPDPDNWDGU %|\OH oHYLULFL P9 FLYDUQGD HQ NoN ELWH VDKLS RODFDN GHPHNWLU
G|QWUFOHULQ WDP VNDOD oN ELUNDo PLOLYROW LOH VQUODQU \DQL ELWOLN ELU $'
'|QWUF VLQ\DOOHULQLQ GRUXGDQ VD\VDOODWUOPDV '& NDWQ HOLPLQH HGHU YH GRUXOXX VD\VDOODWUPDQQ DUNDVQGDNL DQD ILNLU ELU DOJOD\FQQ ELU $' oHYLULFL YH\D ELU HPSHGDQVIUHNDQV oHYLULFLVL JLEL VLQ\DO oHYLULFLQLQ LoLQH GDKLO HGLOPHVLGLU %WQ E|\OH oHYLULFLOHU PRGODV\RQ LOHPL \DSWNODUQGDQ GROD\ GRUXVDO ROPD\DQ HOHPDQODUGU %XQGDQ GROD\ EXQODU HNVHUL\HWOH HLN NDUODWUFV RODQ ELU oHLW GRUXVDO ROPD\DQ GHYUH\H VDKLSWLU (LN VHYL\HVLQLQ ND\GUOPDV oN VLQ\DOLQL PRGOH HGHU NL EX LVWHQLOHQ ELU HWNLGLU D]DOWPDNV]Q GDKD L\L ELU SHUIRUPDQV YHUHELOLU 'RUXGDQ
6218d
%DVQo \HULQH \NVHNOLL J|VWHUPHN ]HUH G]HQOHQPL HQWHJUH DGLOPL DOHWH <NVHNOLN gOoHU GHQLOLU <NVHNOLN gOoHUOHU %DURPHWUHOHULQ ELU oHLGLGLU <NVHOGLNoH EDVQFQ D]DOPDV NXUDOQD GD\DQDUDN \NVHNOLNOHULQ |OoOPHVL DPDF LOH GL]D\Q HGLOLUOHU
<NVHNOLN gOoHUOHU JQP]GH ELUoRN DODQGD NXOODQOPDNWDGUODU g]HOOLNOH VDYD VDQD\LVLQGH YH GDFONOD LOJLOL EWQ VSRUODUGD JHQL ELU NXOODQPD \HOSD]H]L YDUGU
\NVHNOLN |OoOU %DVQFQ GD ELUoRN \|QWHPH J|UH |OoOHELOGLLQL %|OP GH D\UQWO ELU HNLOGH DQODWPD\D oDOWP gOoOHQ EDVQoWDQ KDUHNHWOH \NVHNOLN GHHULQL EXOPDN GD WHPHOGH \|QWHPOH \DSODELOPHNWHGLU %XQODU D UWLID%DVQo JUDILLQGHQ RNX\DUDN F %DURPHWUH .XOODQDUDN E UWLID%DVQo )RUPO 8\JXOD\DUDN 'HQNOHP %X \|QWHPGHQ KHUKDQJL ELULQL NXOODQPDN oHYUH NRXOODU LOH ELUOLNWH WHPHOGH NXOODQFQQ LVWHLQH YH LKWL\DFQD NDOPWU 8\JXODPDVQ JHUoHNOHWLUGLLP EX WH]LPGH QRUPDO DUWODUGD EDVQF DOJOD\S EXQX
GLUHNW RODUDN ,&/ WPOHLN HQWHJUHVLQH JHULOLP ELOJLVL RODUDN J|QGHUPHVL
JHUHNHQ VHQV|U \HULQH SRW LOH GLUHQFL GHLHQ GROD\V\OD JHULOLPL GHLHQ VHPEROLN ELU VHQV|U WDVDUODQPWU HNLO GH J|UOHQ GHYUH \DUGP LOH EX VD\HGH SRW LOH R\QD\DUDN VDQNL EDVQoOD GLUHQFL GHLHQ ELU VLVWHP :LQVWRQ .|SUV YDUP JLEL
\DSOPWU %X VHPEROLN VHQV|U HNLO :LQVWRQ .|SUV ,&/ WPOHLN HQWHJUHVLQH GHLNHQ GLUHQo ]HULQGH GHQ JHULOLPL J|QGHUHUHN HQWHJUHPL]LQ oNQGD EXOXQDQ \HGL VHJPHQW GLVSOH\GH KHUKDQJL ELU EDVQo GHHULQL J|VWHUPHVLQL VDODPDNWDGU 6HPEROLN VHQV|UP] \DQL :LQVWRQ .|SUP] 9OXN ELU 'F
JHULOLPOH EHVOHQPHNWHGLU 'LVSOH\GH HQ GRUX GHHUL J|UHELOPHPL] LoLQ LVH GHYUHPL]LQ GHQL] VHYL\HVLQGH NDOLEUH HGLOPHVL JHUHNPHNWHGLU
5()(5$16 .$<1$./$5
ZZZHJHFRQWUROVFRP ZZZHOLPNRFRP 'Ro 'U 2VPDQ *h5'$/ $/*$/$<,&,/$5 9( 'g1h7h5h&h/(5 $QNDUD
3URI 'U +DOLW 3$67$&, (/(.75. 9( (/(.7521. g/d0(/(5 VWDQEXO
g=*(d0
\OQGD .0$5$Q 3$=$5&,. LOoHVLQGH GRGX ON YH 2UWD |UHQLPLQL .0DUDQ 3D]DUFN LOoHVLQGH WDPDPODG 2UWD gUHQLP KD\DWQGDQ VRQUD QRUPDO |UHQLPLQH LNL \OON ELU DUD YHUGLNWHQ VRQUD 0HUVLQ hQLYHUVLWHVL 0HUVLQ 0HVOHN <NVHN 2NXOX (OHNWULN 3URJUDPQD \D]OG \OQGD 0HUVLQ hQLYHUVLWHVL (OHNWULN 3URJUDPQ .RFDHOL hQLYHUVLWHVL 0KHQGLVOLN )DNOWHVL (OHNWULN 0KHQGLVOLLQL ND]DQGNWDQ VRQUD WHUN HWWL +DOHQ .RFDHOL hQLYHUVLWHVL 0KHQGLVOLN )DNOWHVL (OHNWULN 0KHQGLVOLL %|OP ELWLUPH GXUXPXQGD RODQ |UHQFLVLGLU
(./(5
(N $
(N % 'HYUHQLQ 5HVLPOHUL
'HYUHQLQ *|UQ
.RPSOH o *|UQ
6HPEROLN 6HQV|U