EQNIKH TAMOTHTA

H EQNOTIKH BAIH M E EBNIKHZ TAMOMTAI

Kat tov avrioro~xov h6yov (discours)xou uto0srsi TO i6lo arojm. ' E m q voplpocppoobvq o q v s0v6rq.r~ sivat 6uvar6v va ~pqoylonouq0~i crspyahsiaAv p6001 6noq rou 016ino6oq pnopsi va oplorodv wq supioq a x o 6 s ~ ~ i q K&)) orqv uqpeoia axhrspov U T O ~ I K ~fi V ouhkoyt~hv oupcpsp6vrov, KU6paparl~6q acpqyfiosy xou avacpipovra~ os ysyov6ra rou xapeh06vroq ahhd pioq ax6 U V T U ~ W V ~ A~ i r ~xou K ~i ~ ~ ouv avay~g va ~~vqroxo~fioouv p~{uxqp~rodv odyxpovouq o~oxodq fi Kal pshhovr1~06qoroxouq, r6rs pxoT O U q y6X&<0 ~ 6 U6 KOU ~ T ' T~ ~P~KT~V ' I E P O K E ~ ~ ~ VV Oa U R P O W ~ ~ ~ O O U V 81~65 p0dp&V a xodps xCi& 70 6 0 ~ P 0~ ~ ~ O K 070 E T ER~KEVTPO ~~ ~ ~ ax0 6 75 0Uq A ~ ~ O V &~l8lh{&q orqv xdhq yla q v K U T ~ X ~ rqq W gouoiaq. ~~ CE aurfi rqv ndhq, Gqpocpthsiq Kal xavraxob xap6vrsq av~iorotxouqpd0ouq rqq vsorspl~fiq q s0v6rqra a v a 6 a ~ v d ~ ros a l xp-flo~po ~pyabi0.~ xspt66ou: sou E ~ V ~ K ~ ~ T L K O pd00u. I[) Ksvrpt~fi 0Eov oE aut6v ~arahapDdvc1 Avdpsoa os auriq r y 6lap&~p1~6 avri0srsq ax6\yaq Bpio~ovral ot xpoq 16ia noq r a i0vq U ~ ~ P X O Uax6 V apvqpovsdrov ~pdvov Kal xoq 01 oxaosyyiaaq xou Givouv nsp1oo6tepq kpcpaoq gza I~TOPIK& Kal oupBoh1~61raur6rqraq. Aurfi q V l l p 0 0 ~ ~ 1 K f i 60i rou E ~ V ~ K I O EXOUV ~ O ~ K~WKO va V m acpuxvioouv an6 rov pa~paiovo 7t0hl~loplKd ~ClpaK'ypZo~lKd ~0~0'ClKflq hfi0apy6 rouq yla va ~arahaBouv rq 0Coq xou rouq a v f i ~ pioa s ~ os fvav Exoup u100ozfios~ s6h. H s 0 v o r ~ ~op66a fi sivat iva si6oq x o h ~ r ~ o p l ~ f i q K6~p0 axorshodp~voax6 EBvq. H snlppofi rou EOvouq, oxoq 0a Godps, EV ~olv6qraq xou ~ { a i p e ro ~ p610 rov pd0wv ~arayoyfiq Kal r y lo~opl~iq pipsi ~ ~ K E I T os ~ aurfi I rqv ux6oxsq yla oorqpia xou spnspd~sl q s0vl~vfipsq Kal ~a0iorarat avayvopiolpq Baosl piaq fi nsp~oo6rspovxohlrlKI~TZK acpfiqoq. ~~ 'Opoq q 66vapfirou ouxva auSaverat avuxoMyiora an6 op1~hv Giacpophv 6xm5 q 0pqo~&ia, r a 60lpa, q y h h o a fi 01 Osopoi. np6rq covravfi xapouoia rov napaGoosov, nou svooparhvouv pvfipsq, odpKElTUl yla K O I V ~ T ~ T ROU E ~ &iv~ bll d h cclozop~~iq)): 6x1 C ~ ~ V EOX E ~ T) S 10TO~~ Doha, p d 0 o ~ Kal a{i&q ax6 xohd xpoysvEorspsq EROXE~q q I;ofiq E V ~ S oup ~ ~pvfipq f i Exs1 ouo1cb6q m p a d a yta rq ouvi~sldTOW ahha K a t &7t&l8fi y~s~plpkvou nhq0uopo6, K O ~ V ~ T T ~ Tfi US nsploxfi~. ExopEvoq, ~ a r apxaq ' axordobv K a l 01 i6~sq npol6vra ouy~e~plpkvov loropu~hv Guvdpov K a l xpE7ta va ~~psuvfiooups au~iq a~plbciy r y apo-vswrspt~iq s ~ v o r l ~Tauiq ouvsxhq sival s~rs0s~pivsq orqv toropt~fl ahhayfi Kat 071-1cp0opa. r6rqrsq Kal xapaG6aaq.' CE aur6 ro q w i o 0a f i ~ a v ~pfiapo va Gla~pivoup~ r1q E ~ V O Z ~KaK ~ ~ H ivvola q q <(.&0v6rqraq)) ixsl xpooeh~dowrqv xpooo~fi xohhhv r a zqyopi~q ax6 ry ~ 0 v o n ~ ~ iq o l v d ~ q01 z ~nphrsq ~. siva~ av0phx1vot nhqrshsuraia ~p6vla.Optopivot uxoorqpi(ouv xoq Gla0irsl pla ccapxiyovq)) 0uopoi ot oxoisq 0swpobvra~ -rouXii~lorov ax6 Eva pipoq rov ~ { W T E P I K ~ V xodrqra. nos URUPXE~(TTq ( ~ d ~650 q , ax6 TO XP~VO. XWq 7tp6K~l~al yla xaparqpqrhv- wq (s~oploricxohtrtop~~iq K a l loropl~iqouvopa6hostq. Eva ax6 ra <<6&60pivaw rqq av0phn~vqq 6nap{qq (q axoyq aurfi a x i ~ r q o s 'Opwq or i6to1 01 nhq0uopoi xou opi<oupx ps aur6 rov 7 ~ 6 x 0 ntOav6v va ~dxola uxoorfip~{qnp6ocpa.s~ ax6 rqv ~ o ~ v o v Dlohoyia, t~fi q oxoia 0swpsi pqv i ~ o u v nhfipoq avaxruypkvq auroouvsiGqop xu@ p6vo p a aoacpfi airqv EvraSq orqv s0v6zqm o~ x p o i ~ r a q rov 6la6l~aolhv ysvsn~fiq sxlo0qoq 6 n anorshodv pla {s~oplorfi ouhhoyu~6rqra.' E m ol Todp~ot rqq hoyfiq Kat 'tqq xpooappoor~~fiq ~KUV~~~TU Cro < ) . dhho d ~ p o apio~ovra~ Avaroliaq xplv TO 1900 ayvoorioav os pydho Ba0p6 a ~ 6 p K a a t rqv dnapEKE~VO 710U ~ ~ E O P O ~T V q V ivra{q 0s pla E ~ V O T ~ 0pa6a K ~ ~ W q <(OUYKUP~UK~~M, (q plaq (sxwptarfiq (croup~t~fiq)) rauz6rqraq -6laQ0p~~lKfiS an6 rqv KU6qha6fi 621 ~ i v a(firqpa t o r a q ~a, v r t h f i ~ ~ Kal o v ouvalo0qpa~ov, ra oxoia piap~q 0~6ljUtvlKfi fl TqV U X E P K E ~ ~ E V Tl~haplK$ ) Kat, xbpav rodrou, 0 ~ ~ avay~aon~ sivat d cpeuyahia Kal wrafihqra Kal bacpopoxotodv~at avdho0soporioav au6pa nlo o q p a v r ~ ~ i rq y roxl~iq rouq raur67qrsq, ot oxoisq sonci<ov~av mq ouyyfvsla, 70 ~ o p fi d ~ q xsploxfl v TOW. TO i810 pxopodya p~ rq ~ U ~ K E K P L ~ ~ardoraoq ~VT) TOU U A O K E I ~ ~ V O U xoq . 6x05 ahhd<s~ q aropt~fi ~araoraoq, irol psraaahhsrat K a t q ouhhoy~~fi radrtoq fi, roup EV a ~06p& AWG imus yla T O W C ~ O ~ ~KUTO~KO& K O U ~ T6lV K O ~ ~ & ~ZOV OV hdxlo~ov, xoq o&6laQop&~lK6~ K E P ~ ~ ~ OKUl U CK ~ Z O ax6 6lacpopsn~bq oUVKapna0iov xplv ro 1850, nap6 TO ysyovk 6n G1E0erav K O L V ~ GI&~EKTO I Kal W K Epxopsi ~ va prafihq0si TO ~ 1 6 1 Bapoq ~ 6 TWV xohhaxhhv raurorfirov
Kplrl~fi xapouoiaoq TOU ooqplohoyl~o6 ~ E ~ I E X O ~ ~TOU V OE U~ rie (1960) Kal Breuilly (1982).
V I K ~ ~~ J T~ KedouO ~

Tla pla X E P U J ( I ~ T & ~ E O K T & T @ ~ xapowta~fl a~rhv TOV avtay0~1or1~6v WOQEYy(o&wv, j3)c. ro SOKQLIO TOU Paul Brass oto Taylor and Yapp (1979) Kal A. D .Smith (1986a, KEV. 1).

EONIKH TAMOTHTA

H EONOTlKH BMH T H t EQNIKHI TAYTOTHTM

nthosy s i v a ~ 01 acpqyjosy yla rov 'Opwo rou Pirhi ri rov rouhtihpo TGho Kal rov r~bohsp*, 01 onoisq 6xouv svoopa~oesi orqv ((loropt~fl ouvsi6qoq)) wags EhBsr06. AEVE ~ V U L povo or1 yi)Po anC, rov nupiva rs~pqplopivwv loropl~hv YEYOVOTOV avanrdooovra~p~ suwohia supsiaq ano60xilq Gpapan~65 acpqyj o s y yla TO napQOov ~(unqpsrhvraqa j y ~ p o v o y j pshhovrl~o6q owono65 snlnhiov, 01 ~ l 6 e o nou ~ avacp6povra1 orqv nohtrlwi ~ U ~ K ~ ~ T T rqv ~CTT~, anshsu0Gpoq, TOV ~wnarplopoKat Tqv E K ~ O Y TOU ~ ha06 X ~ ~ O ~ ~ O K O wq IO~V acperqpia r o u ~ ouy~swptpGvatoropuwa ysyovora, r a onoia orq ouvixs~a smvsppqvs6ouv Kal ~navsnsS~pya~ovra~. 0 npooqhunopoq rou BhaGipqpou rou KtbB0~or0 X p t ~ ~ t a ~(988 t o pp.X.) ~ ( ll i6puoq Tq5 Phpqq (753 K.X.) ROPE^ va 0~opodvrat loropl~a ysyovora ahha q oqpaoia rouq Gy~slrat orq 06~6s4 r o w PE Z O U ~epdhouq q q iGpuoqq. Aurq awptphq q oBv6~oqsival nou rouq np006i6~lK O ~ V O V ~Xpqolporqra K~ q y i q rqq nohlzt~~jq ouvmiq.8 IIap6pota, q C T ~ V ~ p& E O pla ~ ~ U Y K E K ~ L ~ EE ~C V( ( ~P ~ K~ +K T U O Kat ~ p&ou~ K E K ~ ~ ~ cono8soiaq V E < 6 ~ sn ~ i o1q ~ p ~ e l ~KaI f i U ~ O K E I ~ E V ~xpola. K T ~ Auro nou 6 ~ oqpaoia ~ 1 yla rqv E ~ V O T I K raljr~oq ~~ sivat n~p~oo6rspo 01 6sopoi ps rq yq Kalot ouvelppoi nou 6 q p l o ~ p y ~ Ki a l hlyorspo TO ysyovoq rqq napapoviq os a u r j j q ~ a r o x rqS. j l l p o ~ ~ l ryla a l TO pbpoq oro onoio a v i ~ o u ps. Zuxva avnnpoowne6s~pua ~ p yq, j rq yq TOV narGpov, TOV V O ~ O ~ E rhv, rwv Baothfov, rov oocphv, rov nolqrhv Kal rwv lspbov pug. 6ha aura eival nou rqv K ~ e l o r 0 6 xarpiba ~ pa<. A v j ~ o u p s os a u r j 6ao avjwet K a l aurfi os &PUG. Enlnhiov, r a 1&pa~ b v r p a rqq xa~pibaq anorshodv noho Gh{qq yla r a pihq rqq sevor~wfiq KOIV~T~~ Kat T U r~a sy~ap6tC;)vo~v a~@a Kal ES anooraosoq, a ~ b p a Kat av Bpseodv os pta pa~poxpovq~(opia.Cuvsnhq q ethnie pnopsi va E'/IISIL;)~E~ yla nohlj ~ a ~ pawpta p o an6 r a narpta &66cp?l rqq xapq orqv fvraoq rou voorou Ka1 rqv nvsupan~fi rqq npoo6~oqoe aura. Aur6 awpqhq U R ~ P TO ~ EX E ~ P W ~ G V O oplopivov K O I V O T ~ T W Vrqq &aonopaq, dnoq 01 Ebpaiol Ka1 01 Appiv~o~? Mdvo orav ozpacpo6ps ora 7tolKiha orotxoia q q K O I V ~ ~ ~0~~ h ~ 0 6 p nou aq Gtacpoponotodv r o u ~ ahqOuopo& psraS6 rouq 0a ouvavrjooups ~ a n o ~ nIo a ~ V T ~ K E ~ ~ E Vyvopiopara. IKU H yhhoaa, q Qpqo~sia, r a G0tpa j t o xphpa rou 6bppa~0 O~ UVT~~W 8&op&i~al < 6 n KEP~Y~U(POUV CLVTIKE~~EV~ ((710hl~l0plKa KU
ZXETIKU ps ~q popai~qnspinroaq, oh. Tudor (1972, KE(P. 3)- yla rouq E ~ ~ E T I K O ~ ) ~ p68ouc, oh. Steinberg (1976). H 0llpaoia Trlc A P o O ~ E ( J ~ QTV ~ < yo E{&TU<ETU~ QTO Armstrong (1982, KEQ. 2).

opoqpa)) j cc&t6onoto%61a(popbq)) nou un6pxouv av&{aprqra an6 rq BOG h q q rov azopov, yta r a onoia pak~ora pnopd va cpcliverat 6.r~ hs~roupyo6v nsptoplon~b Qordoo, aur6 nou GXEL p q a h d t ~ p q pap6qra yla rqv E ~ V O Z ~ K ~ ra6zlcq ~ E V sival rooo q a v e s ~ r 1 ~ 6 r q( r aq avs~uprqrq xapouoia yvoplopdrov 6noq ro xphpa fi q Bpqo~siaahka q q p a o i a nou 70% npoo6iSst Bvaq p s y d h ~ apt0p6q ar6pov (4 opyavwoeov), 6 n w K ~ T ~ ~ E ~ qK aucaV ~ E ~ v6psvq n o h t n ~ fPapljrqra i nou a d ~ r q o a v q ykhooa KaL TO ~ p h p a TOUS 660 r~hsuzaiouqalhvsq. T a xohlzlopuca yvopioya~aK ~ t ~ h f l j ' o va ~v 0sopq006v COG ~ V T ~ K E I ~ E -TOU~UX~UTOV V~K~ ~ O acp0pb V TOV .1rpoo610pt0~6 T o V E~VOU~ h opiwtc v p6vo 6rav npol~torodv p G~acpoponouqnwfi a{ia!O 'Oha aura uno6qhojvouv noq q &evon~rj ~01vd.rtl.ra K U ~ Eahho napa npoauhv~asival nap6 rouq xspi rou avn0brou lquptoporjq K a l rq pqropl~il rwv EOV~K~OTIKQV 18~0hoythvK a l TOU E ~ V I K ~ ~ ~h6you. I K O ~ 01auSops~hoey rqq U~OKEI~EVIK~JS oqpaoiaq nou b ~ ~ na 0 i v a a d ra xpoavacp~p06vrayvopiopara yla ra @kq p a q wolv6rqraq &nqp&a<ouv avdhoya rq ouvo~fi Kat rqv aurorruvsidqaq rou ohparoq rwv p k h v ~ q q '000 . mplm6r~pa yvopiopara ouv6ua<ovrat Kal 000 nsploo6r~pobvrova Kat spcpavfi ~a0ioravra1, 7600 s v ~ o ~ b sq ra aio0qoq ~ rqq E ~ V O T ~ raur6rqraq K ~ ~ Ka1, pari ps auriv, q q &0vori~i\S ~01~6rqraq. Avriorpocpa, drav aura ra yvqiopara apBh6vovrat K a l d,ao0evodv, &nqps&<&ral avdo~o~ q~ y&v1~6r&pq a a i o e q q rqq ~ 0 v o n d q rauz6qraq K a l mq EK r06rou T) i61a q ethnie ~azah-ilystorq Gtahuoq fi rqv acpopoiooq!' IIhq oxqpari<s~at 6po5 pa ~ B v o n ~~otv6rqra; fl Mxopodw, va Ghooups povo ~ E P I K B60Klpaorl~Eq ~ anavrfioa~. 'Onou a u r j q G ~ a S ~ ~ a bxw oia ~uraypacpd o r y 1orop1~bqnqykq, 6tacpaivefal q napouoia optop6vwv ora8&phvpovrbhov or0 o ~ q p a r ~ o p s0vorfirov. o E ~ K & [ E Ipnop06p~ ~ ~ K u , va &a~pivoup& 660 ~I)pla &i8q o~~)putlopoi): rq ouvbvoq Kal rq Gtaipaoq. An6 rq pia nh~updr~ v r o n q o u p napa6siypara c ~ ~ q p a n o p o ~0vorfirov d ax6 rqv Evooq avs~6prqrov povaSov, pta 61a6l~aoia nou pnopsi va uxoSlatpe0si
'O Bk. axsruca Gellner (1973) ( J X E T I K ~ ps rq aupPok1~fi xpfioq aurhv rwv yvoplapbrov w; ctop~o0~rt~hv pqxav~ophv)) yla 7q 81b~p1aq TWV EOVO~IKOV op68ov, pk. Barth (1969, Waayoyfi). " 1 s aurb 0a brrp&x& va npoa8tooups no5 01 E~VOTIKBG napa86osy Kalol8&paTo(p6Xa~fq rovq ~ a e h c Kat 01 nollnopl~oirpoxot b~cppacrqc(yhhoaa, b01pa, r s ~ v o ~ p o n i ~ q K.)IR.) pnopsi va aa~Tjaouv lqupfi, 81ap~fi Kat &apopcpw?l~fi sn~ppo?i yla p & ~ d kYooc VIK& 1~~)1680uq ~ X E T I K UPh. Armstrong (1982, passim).

1 . -

EQNIKH TAYTOTHTA

H EQNOTIKH

BAEH T H I EBNIKHI TAYTOTHTAI

AvziorPocp% o& ~ h h &ns~lnrciwel~ < q anoru~ia zq< e p q o ~ ~ i a va q HEr a P ~ u 0 ~ 1 ofl z~ 0iap.srl~looKhtl~orlK65 0uvrqpqnop6q zqc, pnop~i V a (JTP&Wouv rrlv ~ 0 v o n ~auro-avavhoq fi O& 63Lh&< obob<. A U Touv&bq ~ p7 0 'Ehhv~ GzlS ~ P X ~ S 1 9 0 ~ alhva. H &hhqvop0660{q&KKhqolaonKfl uP ~ P X ~TVS U Kovoravnvoinrohqq anopa~puv6rav610 KUI n~ploo67~po an6 rrl Woaia zdrSrl Kal za h a i ~ 6 opapaza ahha KUI an6 rou< ~ 6 0 0 ~ Ka~ ~ ~ E PKhflPo~, O U an' 6x011n~oih0av optopkvot an6 rou< qyBzoq z q ~ Ensvaozaoll< ozo Mopla. ' E m , 01 ~6001 ZOV Ehhfiv~v nporJ&cp~yav 0~ ivav agav6p.sva K O ~ P ~ K ~ , I Airlo ~ E y1a O ~va O~mnjlouv ~ ~ K ~ TOUS ozhow

noalrlo~~~ 6a dv~ra CTO~uprjtspo~ ~ 6 zqq i o ~ouh~odpa<, q &~vos~~( &n~bi@(J"l ~ E V P ~ O P EVU ~ .I.PUVE~an6 zqv anop6voq ahhdr an6 7 0 &nth&~ ~ 7 1k ~v 6~ 1 o Kal ~ 6 E ~ E ~ ~ C LX EO V ~EI ~ T ~ O ~ &nacp&. ~ K ~ < Tla cjrhhq pm wpk av~hfloou Eva ~ ~napa6~lypa an6 rqv ~ B p a i ~lo~opia. fi TO &p&opa ~hhrlvlorl~o6 nohlzlopo6, an6 za xp6vta rou Ah6cav6pou Kar &cp&gq<, voK ~ ~ G E< @ ~ a v f El R ~ C P PE ~ T ~T S~ ~ &hk~)vt~& S K U ~ rqc ~ D p a i . ~OK&fi~ WI~C q oxoia -nap6 n q 6papazr~B~ ~O~ITLK& ~Gn t n z h r o( ) ~ < ~~~ pnhoi)~~o& Kal ~ v i o ~ ok6~hqpo uo~ TO q-~iiopa TOU E B ~ U ~ K nohlrtopoi) O ~ ~ a zqq l &$paimi< rau.l.6r()za<" YndP~ouvnolha aK6pa napa6~iypatanou cpav~phvouv rou< nohu@l0~ou< ~ P ~ ~ O UTOUS S OXO~OU<E{OTEP~K~ nohl'tiopl~~ &p&Oio ~ a r aat E X ~ C Pavavfooav ~G zrlv aio~qoq zqq EOVOTLK~~< zaur6~qraq piow zq< E K ~ ~ E K T ~oK t~ ~~ ~S~ o n o i opto$vov qoq~ ~OL~TI~~ ~ Z IO L~ ~X KKE Q ~R ~ V O~ IE< V. ~upkw yvoor6q XE~IIKZ(;)(TE~S E~VU q~ Ianwvia, q Pooia ~ aq lAiyunroc zou 190u a~hva.
3. Aaiinj ou~W.ro~rf. Z1.0 K O ~ V O V ~ n~6i0, K~ pnopoljp~va 6la~pivoup rp6xouc E ~ V O ~ K auro-avavbwcrrl~ ~ ~ S p&oaan6 za ~ ~ v f i p arov r a 6tacp6pov ~ o t vCJv1~hvozP6.)~at.wv Kal T ~ ~ E O VAvdp~oa . TOUS, or~v6r~p wv&&p&va a w TO Ofpa pa< ~ i v ara l ha'i~a ~lvrjpa~ nou a ~~cppa(ouv TO a i r q ~rqq ( ~ 61~6~ puvqq tq< o u p ~ r o x r orqv i ~ n o h ~ z ~ o p tfi~nohlri~fi fi ~ p a p ~ iTO a . psyaho ~o~vwv~~o-~prloK&u'~lK6 ha'i~6 Kivqpa zou pa<6a~topo6 orq oaoavdl~fi n~poia sou 50u athva avavEooe rov ooDap6 flappfvo 101-6 rqq n~polKfi< <@Poao~p1Kfl< ~ o l v 6 ~ q t akozo c , Kal av raur6~povau n f o ~ za a ~fj&p&hta ~

Gpaaq TO ~araorahz1~6, a h M Enioq~ava<ooyovrlrl~6 an6 E ~ V O T ~ K a~ m )~ q~Kivqpa , TOU X00p6r\ A' TOV 60 a~hva, 70 onoio ouv66~rar PE T ~ ~w61V ~07CoiqoIlr0V u r 0 1 ~ ~ ROU io~ anorkh~oav TU Dam BWou Barnz w ~xrorpocpq orqv ~ p a v i ~ pu0ohoyia t i mi h ~ p ~ ~ i a a w l pta xiov*, ~ e v l ~avaykvvqoq fi orq hoyots~via,zqv &0rporuzia,rrlv na16sia K a l rl< .c&x.~v&~.SPl Ta Miua K L V ~ W T zou ~ ~ ~ 6 a i o p oan6 6 , .rr\ ~ w a i ~ 11~~i060 t i 6% ro ~aa6mp6, ora onoia avacpap0fluap.s q6q, ~ x i o rBofl&loav l~ zrlv avavkoorl zqq &qpi>6ouq~ &Bpa'i~qq ethnie ~pnv6ovzaqE V ~ O W ~ ~ Iha'i~q ~ T I oupproxf~ Kal l&panooroh~~6 (tjho. TO i6lo tq6&tual yla za h a ' i ~ 6 ~ l v f i ~ a ~ 10a hap, p~.ra@jrev onoiov o u y ~ a ~ a h t yro ~~ islo a l TO ~ ~ P U T ITOO K ~ Kivq~a Kaehq Kal r a Gt&cpopa oouvrn~6 ~ a olu n ~ xoupl~av1~d a ~ a ~l~ o o l a v l ~ a ~~vfipaza nou ~ ~ 6 q h h v o v rp6xp1 a l z y pgpsg pa<, 6 n w h . ~ o . $axa$1op6~, 0 wa~vnopk* ~ a qr o u r t ~ f~navbozam l ozo Ip6v.SPZ
4. 0 pci~~g % ~BvorzmfqEK;~OY&. An6 noXU< U ~ ~ W E 01 K ~~6001 , 7011XE-

ploblou h o d ~azkxouv KEVTPI~ 0 6 p~ r a t 6 TOV &agdp@v~p6nov autoa v a v & m ~ a ~nopEvo< l E X ~ $ ~ ~Z G~ TS E )S ~VOT~K K~O~~SV ~ T T ) ~ Kaz' ~ < . UPX&Cnaparqpo6p n y do&<ethnies oz~po6vralT E T O ~ ~ ~V ceov (fl 6 ~ Kav zopehvouv va r0uq ~vozahkSouvOTO o6~0h0 7 0 z ~h 0 u o ~ o 6 ) r&ivouvva anoppocpqeofiv an6 61kq ~olvir.cqzs< 6zav x&oouv TVV av&Sap.rrloiaTOUS. ~ u cpuolK& ~ 6 ~ i v aEva l ~ n q ~ i p q fiaoropivo pa ozqv anouoia P W T ~ P y ~ l~ aV ~ i, ou~40q do&<~ 0 v 6 r q r y G~a06zouv~P~OKEUTIKO~Y ~ 6 0 n&pi 0 ~ E~ ~VOT~K~S ~ ~ h o y fijta0Ezouv lq ~nioqq KU~ E ( E ~ & K E U ~' ~ ~V I~ ES E ZOu Y ~ U V ~ ~ OQU V ~ E ~ e ~ Kat q TK ffp00~TtK&~ .row p~ q v ~ n ~ r u ~ ~i aa mv l E X ~ P P Oa ~~ ~~hv zov p60wv - at o u v f l 0 ~ an6 rkrol~q' C & ~ E~ YP O ~ P X O V 01 TC ~~ L O V ~ ~ ~ K ~ S ypanr&q pap~upiq nou 8xoups o ~ 6ta0~ofl q PUS. n a v z o ~ av E ~ E ~ & ~ O ~ P E 5 ~ qr vh q 6oov ~Ovozfi~wv 6k0~zav p&vE(E~~~KEu@vE< 6x1 6 ~ 0 Kal ~ 6 0 0 & & o n M E K A O (QE ~ ~ avzi0sq ~ p ro ~ 6 0 0 ( ( E K ~ E K T O ~ ) ) fjaolua), 0a 6lamorhooup oacph n y ~ i x a v (J"llravn~&JIEL~JWEVES nleav6rq7&<~ n l b i o m& ~ , tq axo~ahtinrouv 01 xsptnrho&~< nl< Aosupia<, W< (Potvi~q< at T ~ (Plhlorai~v. V

" BI Tcherikover (1970) K a l Hengel (1980).

" ExE'TIK~ pk. Frazee (1969) K a l Kitromilides (1979).

mn bynv A ~ I 1~1k . 513!0n0>310d~~3n ~ X I L I Z D I A ~ ~~ Dn ~A n ID (?. 5CLod1n13 kl01 -hpd~un ~ n ~ q g i o ho@ndA un ~ m nlr l q ~ d 01 ~J ~ I 1 f)n7110n~ 10 1nn nj3znd 3 1 a2 53~do~ndno~nn 5plA(rl1~03T( Inn 53)nXdn512 gun 5flyou 31) nxo~yyfl
' ~ D ~ \ u ~ A ~Xi1 ox DI~L?~XIU Ah0 ~ I)03fl 0 1 ~ ~ 3 %01 ~ 0 911l.~.X)Tln3hll01 ~ 0 ~ 1DX
500%S!~om~pkdo 51n oa1n19

grlgn(l oz

3 r l

nkoyp~n ?3yyp$ld3u 511 nou nodg!nun

y d 3 1 '532C129hy3p gun

5h2 k d g r l oylpharl Inn h3ygu 53ylpk3rl 5 1 5 132uqynn nou 5 b h ~ o u 0 n ~ m ~ 1 o x

pbbh~93d319~n1go>31g od3%9o~ld3u !311nua 5qq1.16~~) 0~31i9~l~h o~ylocj3gn1g h3&3 OOQZ m a , '513q~u1d3u53~1d31130 oh~rl 311(10gd3hn~~)

an3 ~no>pnrlhXo '531~hynx3 IDW

30

mdcA IOA

- f l m ~ n k d o532h~g~1on 53yyou
O I L 0 DA

5 0 d p 1nn

bodd1u3 b n 1 1 h n r l L L OA ~ O D ~ ~ X

~nmgdS)~Dn 10~mhnd 1 0 inn 5 j 3 h ~ d A 1 0 '5j3d3110 'A@I3@An9 AC)lX!39

ah a l l 'lo-pno 10 Ian io>gozon~ lo ' l o g ~ n y d lo ~ "l~n~yizon 10x 'loykky 10 ' l c q ~ lo j '10~13tld3~ 10 ~OAOYOU 10 5muo s?ruqJa 5gn~numdn3 53dohqlg Inn qyyn ' X q 10 '~o)?odv lo 4 0 q d Inn 53nhyylya, ~o>ogggdo 10 ' l o l ~ y i d v 10 'ndpXrfv5ouo~glv 10 1 ~ ~ 1 5mug 3 3 0 n y 5noyyy 30 mn arlnooyoz~o DA nl~odourlS~Aoyn3 5I.u

ha2 53~(L(]q00311a1g 5m tozh~ydaua 'arlydsr,osar(r(pdkk3 gn'19n~orl os PAX +ID 5732~0, '532075)~ Inn ~ ~ I A X ~ L 30 A ~10~3tjm~nMo Q lpnXnr, 'logmhnd 10 1nx IDA!^ 513099ndnu 51%~(1010uon1gmn 1nn ~(1010uokd3~

51ohndk

lo '513431 1 0

noggrl

no1 D L X ) ? ~ Q ~ ~~~x ~ ~O z~ ~A Xo ) ~)o)~ nkoy?~n Az)

-3ADll3 'lnz~(iolhQn no%!01nD 5 3 ~ h 9 ~ 1 ~ ~ 0U ~ I ~ ~ L O ~ 5123 A - Of531~3k ~ U 5 3 ~ -3t10Xd3~3 hl.0 b ~ d g f u 3 ~ 9 0 5130ggndn11 ~ 0 ~ 1 0

.53n&~m 530211,~~) OBQZ 3 0 nofl (iorlopdd3 no%5lmmd1u3

5 l u nofdhz~nrl

5 3 2 0 0 ~ g d 2OlOlt

3y~ -5nzh2g~1oa 5h2 53111

gni~nri~q3~0 ADA? un D A X 1 1 1 3

(I02 P19131X 732 5)ZD DAQ 1 X ) A 1 35~173h0Il OlnV .5~12b9~03 5 1 1 5 hNXg1113 hfl0 -30gduodnnrl bz ail 5q1u3~m 1nx ~ ~ O ~ A D kn110~03 A X ) A [ L ~ . n1A grl01~nXhrl ~noX3dnugony rto~qotd?u 13tig~ag no1 ?fion~Anelon X U O A5h2 ~ ~ nd@nndnX (IOX

~ 1T k) L X ) T ( O ~ Y X ) X ?Xleh Ill ' 5 h ~ l l ( t ~ ~1 U

-1h3?i13~011~1 K I ~ D Y I ~ ~ O I LQOZ X ~ A~ D1 0 ~ g f l O-5bmgdohlyD~ g3~ ~ @ I T ~ O U ~ O1X)N U -n3n~hdg-o~g3 5nyou 30 laln2Aovn nou '((5bhodi~lu3)) 5h2

lpyyn 5ho1rlg~dh~3rl5~n1~a3nohdg rnnrllu\ln 5n~~q1~1noun 513op~adau 5 5 3 x 1 2 bhlgun h ~ n i

'513~&.)10~3u 1nn 5313~l;mno 53d3~glnynu 5 1 1 0 ~ ~ O ~ L D ALL U 1300y1 L ~

-9>1~nh~i3~nu3 11 11323yj3ho 33ng '(102~ o f l ~ n ~ ~ no2 ngn~ n g fn1 i ~9ozol~no

-3k 53nlXognlg lo lpn1zn3y1u3 A ~ O ~ L An?ouo X, ~112 gun '5ndgo1ynon 511x12 X)XIy32 j320d1kfi~ 53!2~) Inn X)!uOL -Oh03 5 1 1 1 hn~gn~nnndnu hd31!731g1 '53mdb 'n1ghok3A n~3rloldo gun I D X yyyn 5h~X32old3 1nn 531kdn013y32 ' ~ f l l '5313d1~)~ ~3 '53~9~1 gun 3 Llh3fl(l0~320~~) Ir~ogpdnu .5nzhzg~lon 5h2 n~3rlgX31d3u yn1rl~121you DL Inn n j u o d ~ o o h ~~~no);doenx , 53!0u0 1 0 lox '53~grllnouodohn19 (p~h0oln b ~pdgnrln) 1nn mleg 'hyyp A ~ L D lp1~3k n!?l hz gun A ~ O A ~nou ~ Y ~m30g~ndnu 1nn 5l)ttlo~odhyn 5n1rl bhdorl h1 A ~ O A a ) ~ 53)nxn3y31 u 1 0 -~md~~?lndnu ~~n1rl9111~0u IDX A ( ~ ) X I A O A I O J ~m~ldnlp~g
-a3 olo!nyu D A mi ~

nou

5h~ndhn3 5bn1t10121you5bn1rlo1n 5h~3rl9yyn$n~3715q1n

~ 0 0111 1 ~ nrlgnn 9 hnoyyg(lodu 5 1 3 0 02

-do19 57)lrl Inn

-h1ghg3 5112

n l h ~ g n 1 ~ nA 3~ ~ ~ 3 Z r l n5 n . t h ~ g ~ ~ n5Ir1 3 d h > d n u ( ~h~ ~n :5n1 ~

1 3 g Q A n 0 %OIL

o>og?dnu Q X I ~ Z A ~02 X ~
A005, r\C?lkn~"@ A m 2

&{(AOI~? 50~93 1DX 1)Th3l?d31(1013y~DX)d 10d 39D303 3 9

1 1 1 35 h ~ 1pd130 ILL 3t1 n!ouo h ' 5 b m d q y 5h2 mqrl o ~ ~b2nlh3 r l n!dh~m 1 1 2 ~ j 3 d m 3 g 110, '5)rl~n1kngnn gn1Aoyyn~ADA? 3rl no2 bAoyn3 A ~ n1nyp193>n L 13~!~rlh0 ((elk?)) 13rlg~Og I D A 1 3 %X 50~03 Mg 1 3 ? 3 2 0 1 1 1 nA O L 5!3fln .hk h X)D]Plt 1103

-yzutdau
-1OX Ah2

531023~ .n~3rlgX31d3~ 5n01 ?n1rl01~1you 13% 1nn h 0 3 g ~ y ~ 1X I A O A

pdobn

50gby11

ndnu

' ~ ~ 2 ~ 2 AP)X12 0 ~ 1 0 ~

-0Ag3 AC9Afl0ld0 hfIOl1$11I3h 5 3 A p 1 1 31 1 1 3 !32Dll~h0~ DA )1~ A90QhOd 1 3 1 3 1 0 -hdg hngrlm~oldo A ~ ID>! L 53zhzgnnnl 5~~1~nTlhd13Xlu3 512 'n130lprl01)fimyk

h ' x ) ! ~ ~ o A o~ I ~h x )'2 ( I I ) D L D I ~ z ~ x~ ~3 ~ I . u3rl g r l ~ n n ~ ~3 n 0 r'zo!ouo , 10 590?l0 -1~nXhrl5no1 gun 10~3rlo1do inn!3 5noneg 902n3yn3 no1 5009rl o I D X ~ X O L bnlny h ' n 1 3 ~ n y~ n l f l ~ ~ ~ nl ~ y'h30!rlgnddn23rl ou 5~n1~n3n0hde 10
-3rlrlno

dnk bd3 .A(r)Ag3 A01 A O 2 A ? l l 501~90ld3~ 59131 1Orl 390303 nod AIr~bg~lg ~ h sth>lpyah z inn 5 b ~ m h 5 L L T ( 35 1 u 32h090nn konn ~lp3 A ~ A I D X ) ) ~pJjl, A~LD I X ) L ~ ~ Db )m ~$ u9~mg a01 ~ X I D X ) ? H I ~ quqja 5h2 5bmy$ul3 532h353~110131 5 n gdohn (zoo9 5og9rl 5o~flldn3nhn~ o 133]nx nou o y ~ d 02 3 f l n 0 0 ~ 0 ~ n ~ n n n A rill npnrlb bxum> 13x9 nou oprlhr, 0 1 2 3 n1l 1n113ngd~ .n!dhlm~ 5nod~ gun h IDA^^ 5Nhoyn3 5h2 5099rl o ~ D L ~ ~ nou Q I o~nn L ~ IIS)IV .5[1koyn35bn -uo13ynow 5h1 mogrl h~m](fius bn~zongoh 1~123~pXAn21~3 5 n ) ~H oI1 nlg
X)~DX)X19I)19h2 3d ~ T ( ( ~ o ~ ~ ~ o 730 X D 1\39 X ) 'h01kk300dll DlOl.31 D1d 3 1 1 n 0 0 1 1 l . 3 9

: -01n 5~1rl0 AV 4nog(1ri5nololgz h~okd31yynn mn Anovylp0owr nou 53w&~ao ! hu, 5n)3nllM35 1 1 1 5odd 02 131g3n23rl gyun 'qn~mh 'LLD(OID!IIDI~ h C~nv

EONIKH TAYTOTHTA

opdvcy avBpdxlvog xAq0vopdg xov porpb{~ratp a ioropr~rj ~Gapr~rj ~ m ii~paraa, KOI VO& pdeoug K ~ roropl~&g I pvqp~g, p a paci~rjSqpdoia KOVAj ~0l@a, KOIV~/ O I K O V O ~ ~Kal U KOCVU yla bAa ra p&a;lrl VOplK6 8lK~ldflam , Kar vxo,yp~C;W~r~. Ef, 0ptopo6, hotx6v, TO EOvoq sivat pta ~otv6rqra KOI- '

I%,

..

Fp
: ! '

$'

!'
b

'4
y : LC.

"

fG

< ! .

&

VF

4,

Kat aurfi, sivat Kat ~ 6 a ( p t ~ ~fo i t v o ~ q rAhha a. ~vh yta nq ethnies o 6sap6q p& ro btiacpoq sivat buvardv va sivat p6vo tazopt~6qKat oup$oht~ 6 5yla , TO 68voq sivat uht~6q Kat xpaypart~6q:r a 60vq ~ a r i ~ o u 666v cpq. ME ahha h6yta, os K ~ B E n~pinrooq, TO Eevoq axatrsirat va 6taBErst optopkva E ~ V O T ~ K((orotx~ia)). U Ta rsleuraia cpuot~Ci pxopsi va xivat ava~ar~pyaopEva, xp6ypa xou oupflaiva ouxva. Qor6o0, TO E0voq sivat abav6qro xopiq ~&notouS ~otvodq p60ouq Kat avapvfioaq xou ouv66ovrat p~ q v ndrpta yq. Ataxtor6voup, hotxbv, K ~ R O ~KUU K ~ ~ K ~ Torqv ~ T U& x o ~ 671 q ra kevq ~ p a r i < o v r ao t q Woq ~ 0 v o r t ~ h xupfivov. v npbypxn, ax6 svvotohoy~M Kat ~oropt~ G f iK O ~ ~0~ ~0 , nK Kf i O ~ V ~ Kat T ~E T ~~ v o ahhqhosxt~ah6nrovrat ~ 0s o q w v r t ~ 6 ba0p6. napa ralira xp6~strat yta Gtacpopsrt~iq Evvo~qKat toropt~6 pop(p0para. llohhd ax6 ra ' ~ a p a ~ r q p t o rrou t ~ aE0voy axoumb[ouv ax6 n c ,~ 0 v o n ~ E Kol~6nlr&q: q ot rsksmaiy SEV K ~ Z O I K O Iaxapai)~ q r a o q ((61~fi)) row ndrpta ytl. q ~ouhro6paTOUS pnopsi va pqv sivat 6qp6ota fi ~otvfi yta 6ha ra pEhq ouxva 6sv 6~a0frouv Kat o d r ~ i v aaxat pairqro va 6taefrouv Eva ~ o t v 6 o6ozqpa ~arap~ptopo6 cpyaoiaq fi o t ~ o vopt~fi sv6rqza. at sxiqq, ~ E V ~p&@&zat va E~ouv~otvo6qvopt~obc, K W ~ ~ K Kat E ~ K O ~ V &yta 6h0U< 61~athpara Kat u~C~PE(;MEY. ' 0 1 1 0 < 606p ~aura , r a yvopiopara zov ~Bvhv sivat xpoi6vra rqq sni6pauqq optopt!V o V Et61Kh~ KO~VOVIKC;)V Kat I O T O P ~ K ~ (VT U V ~ ~ K K ~~ V VW OTOY XPO~~RUPXovrsq ~0vort~o6q nupfiv~ fi ~ E~VOTLKC~, ~EIOVO~TE~. Ax6 q v ahhq p&pt& 0a xpExst va sntoqpavbi m c ,ux6p~st 6uvarorqr a va oxqpa~torsiEBvoc, ~ o p i q va xpoundpxn a p o a ~ a x o t aethnie. CE apK&TdKp6rq TO ~ ~ V O ~~ S ~ U ' G ~ U T pioo ' I ~ K 7qq E 7tp0oXh8~ta~ V a UUYKEpUoro6v ot aohmopoi 6ta6mtKhv ~updzov (Kupiq Eupozaiov) psravaorhv - 6 x q ortc, HIIA, rqv Apysvnvfi Kat q v Auorpahia. CE dhhy nsptxrhostq o ~ q p a r i o r q ~ a v6a v ~ p a r qax6 nphqv sxapxiaq auro~paropthvot oxoiy E ~ X ~ ER VLPU~ 070Y E~ U ~ K ~ Z O O U q U )llU ~ KO~V~ yhhooa ) KUL @ I ~ ~ K E ~ Q p ~uptdrspo ~ a p a 6 ~ t y rq p a A a r t v t ~Awpt~fi. ~j EKE^ q 61a6t~aoia qqpartopo6 EBvouq E,s~ivqos an6 ~y shir rwv ~psohhv, h6yw rqq axouoiac,

hn0la~ E U ~ ~ ~ E K~P vo ~ TTI ~ KO~V~TTJ'CUG. ~~ < T E ~ ~ 6pw, K & o q 6 8 l d p ~ ~q la q siaq yta ro 1sxqpartop6 C0vow 8tan1or60q~s q av6y~q va Gtapopqmq {Ex~pl~Tfl & t K ~ ~ t K f i , xthtavfi, @ht$tavfi K.hn. K O ~ ~ T O Kat ~ VU ~ Unpoq0si q dtatrepbrqra rov ~ a p a ~ r q p t o r t ~ h sv ~ o p t oobp$oha, ra a{kq, wq K.~z- 'tOU ~ 6 &xi6$0u 0 ~ 60~0w!' A~6pa 1 1 1 0 066 sivat 70 Sihqppa nou a v r t ~ r o n i ~q s tuxo-oaxapt~fi (hvq rqq Acppt~fiqEKE^ 6qptoupyfi0q~av anot~ta~ ~6 parq ROU, av 6sv jrav so~sppkva~ I - E ~ V O Zx6vroq ~ K C ~ ,sh6xtorq uxEoq sixav ps ry ucptorapsvsq E ~ V O Z ~ K KE O~~ V ~ T ~ Aura T E ~ . ra a x o t ~ t a ~p a & rx qp s t a o r ~ ~ va s ~ahht~pyfioouv Evav aptyhq ~6acptK6 xarptortop6, pta aioeqq xohnK& V O ~ I ~ O ( P P O Q7tPOq ~ V ~ 20 ~ V E O ( ~ ~ ( ~ T UK TO P ~ T O Kat ~ fqV &pBpuaKfinoh17t~fi 20U K O ~ V ~ T ~ T Ta U .U V & { ~ ~ T ~ T KUp 6 ~ Rou y&vvli0q~av oT?l 0 ~ ~ 6 Xaa ax6 zbrot~c, ~6acpt~Eq ~ 0 1 ~ 6 r qa rv ~a qy ~ d o r q ~ a va v ouvsvhoouv or0 ' xhaiolo rou w r a - a x o t ~ t a ~ o xohtr1~06 6 ourrfipuroq Eva nhq0oq ax6 eth; nies, ~ 0 v o r t ~ Bpabopara a Kat E ~ V O T I K E~arqyopisc, ~ R~VO orq % fo q i noLrt~hv puepio~ovK a t K O L V W V I K ~ Vo p t o ~ ~ r f i XOU o~~ RvE ~ ~ ~ U ~ X $U E -V T E E ~ o c , r6rs psra56 rout, op&6&q, p& anorEhsopa va ttq 06qyfioouv, a ~ 6i pa Kat xapd rq BChqml rouq, 0s viouq ayhvsq yta rov Chay~o t o v nsvt~phv x6pov Kat q q otohtrt~fic, ~{ouaiaq.K&ro an6 amEq a c ,ouv0fi~sq ot ~ub~pvojosq ~ h i rot , oxoisq ouxva orparohoyfi0q~av an6 rqv ExtKparfo~&ptl E ~ V O K ~ O K~ ~ V~T~ fi~ TOV T U E'I[IKPUT~(I'T&~O Q U V O L O ~ IE ~~ O V~O ~T I K ~ V oums~phoswv, pnfi~av orov napaop6 va Gtapopcphoouv pta vEa xodrrrpu0ohoyia Kal pa oup$oht~fi rdtq, 6x1 p6vo yta va voptponotfioouv ra ouxv6 auzapxtch Ka0sorhra rouq ahM K a l yta va axorpE~ouvrqv anathq E V ~ ~ ~ E I ~ K V ~O V T ~ K~ ~UV~ K ~ O ~ Q fi E Kat W Va x o o ~ t o r ~ ~twlpara. ~a CE au.rEq rtc, xsptnrcimstq, TO ~ p & ~ o ~pqotponoti)Bq~s c, yta va 6tapop(p6o a pta ((XOX~ZIK~ Bpqo~~ia)) rqq onoiac, ot pbbt, ot avapvliostq r a o6pboha ~ . l n 0a . xap6o~ouvTO hstroupyt~6 too66vapo rqq ano6oaq fi avsxap~oiy ~upiap~qc, ethnie Exo$voq, o ox&6taopEvoc, cTxqpartop6q ~ 0 v h v orqv uxo-oaxapt~fi Aqpi~fi unovoei noq ~ i v a~ t ( ~ 1 va ~2 ~6 arao~~uaor06v ra ouorart~6 ROU 0a ouy~porfioouv pta Kat~0bptaE ~ V O Z I K~aur6rqra ~~ Kat ouvsi6qq, q onoia B a ouvsvhoat 1-15 u(ptor&psveqethnies ouy~svrphvovraq os ~ b n o t o $a0p6 rq voptpocppoobvq rouq at ~vooparhvovraqn c ,

" ria BtCt ~

PI. E

E V &I'YPCL(Pfi I ~

70" E ~ V I K I O ~ O 0~ T) v A a 7 1 ~ 1 K f iA p ~ p ~ ~ bk f iMasur ,

(1966)-

x i O q ~ ~ ouvapnaor~lcrj a

v~wq rou Anderson (1983, KE(P. 3).