GDFD

2
JEB ?E= 7 ELAHIE@=@A +=J E?= @ 4E /H= @A @ 5K .=?K @=@A @A 1 B H JE?= ?E= @= + FKJ= A +E
2H CH= = @A 2 I /H=@K=
7JE E = K JE 8=
@A ,E=CH= =I @A ,A?EI @ AIF= =J I @A
H=@= F=H= HAFHAIA J= A
AIJ=@ I =JE C LA
4A@AI @A )KJ
-IJ ? IJE? I
) = 2=K = 5= A CKA 5? =HE
,EIIAHJ= HAGKEIEJ @A F=H?E= AIJHA A
=FHAIA J=@= >JA ?E= @= + @ +E
? CH=K FKJ=
HEA J=@ H 2H B ,H 2=K
0A HEGKA A A A .AH = @AI
2 HJ ) ACHA &
4AIK
. H = EI I @A @A =CA IEIJA @A =CA K I E CK=CA I ?=F= AI @A @AI?HALAH IEIJA =I @A B H = I B H = EI I? DA?E@ I ? @A I CH= @AI A ? F AN I - JHAJ= J I AIJHKJKH=@ I ? ) CAH= @A =CA = >C = @A
FAH EJE @ = IK= =L= E= = HAFHAIA J= =CA @EI?HAJ CAH= =
GK= JEJ=JEL= JE?= @A
AIJHKJKH=@ I FAH EJA = FH JE?= = @ AIF= AIF= @A AIJ=@ I @A AIJ=@ I
@A IEIJA =I @A J= F HJA F @A =FHAIA J=H HAIK J= A = C HEJ CH= @A K
FH > A = @A ANF I
@A IEIJA =I =JH=L I @A B H = EI KI
AH @A AIJ=@ I E =JE C LAEI A JA AIF=
A =H = A = A J -IJA JH=>= D
@ I AIJ=@ I =FHAIA J= K F=H= B H = EI
=JE C LAEI
@AIA =@ = FH ?AII @A
?=F= @A CAH=H A =H = A =H I
@A AIJ=@ I =JE C LA 455 @AIIA = C HEJ =
@A 4A@AI @A )KJ
=J I -IJ ? IJE? I 5) KJE E = @ ,E=CH= =I @A ,A?EI =FHAIA J=H K = FHE AEH= LAHI B H = EI 5)
K JE 8= H=@= ,, ) E@ E= FHE ?EF= @A ? FH L=H = IK= LE=>E E@=@A F=H=
)>IJH=?J
@A E C B H = EI I =HA = CK=CAI ?=F=> A B @AI?HE>E C = IOIJA M=O = ? F AN ME C EJI GK= JEJ=JELA AL= K=JE @A I E = IOIJA =JE? = AH 0 MALAH JDA >AD=LE H E = = >ECK KI
6DA IJHK?JKHA@ B H = EI I ?= HAFHAIA J =HCA = @ @A E C B IOIJA I MEJD IK?D ?D=H=?JAH M EIIKA 7IK= O IJHK?JKHA@ EI BJA =
EIJE?I EI IJE = FH > A FHAIA JI = = C HEJD J J =J=
IE ?A JDA IF=?A IJ=JA ANF IE
B H = EI I MEJD @EI?HAJA IJ=JA IF=?A FHAIA J = =HCA K >AH B K HA=?D=> A IJ=JAI 6DEI M H => A J CA AH=JA = @ IJ HE C JDA HA=?D=> A IF=?A IJ=JA B = 5J ?D=IJE? )K K JE L= KA@ ,A?EIE ,E=CH= ,, 6DEI AM JA?D EGKA =E I ,, B H 5) EI = L= K=> A =FFH =?D AJM H 5) KIE C
=E O LAHEBO JD=J JDA =FF E?=>E EJO B
5K
HE

!
1 JH @K . H = EI
2
#
I @A
@AC= A
' '
4A@AI @A 2AJHE
,EIF=H= @ 6H= IE AI E EJ= > K @ AII A 5ACKH= = I=BA AII
4A@AI @A 2AJHE -IJ ? IJE?=I 5) 4A@AI @A )KJ =J I -IJ ? IJE? I
! " # # $ %
-IJ=@ I
?=EI A / >=EI
6EF I @A 6H= IE AI ! " -IJHKJKH= @A K = 5) -NA F @A @A 5)
!
! !
,E=CH= =I @A ,A?EI
,, F=H= 52 -NA F @A @A =CA
K JE L= H=@= F=H= 52
! ! !#
"
" " "! ""
)F E?= @ ,E=CH= =I @A ,A?EI 5)

)JK= @A @A )H = A = A J F=H= 5) ,, F=H= 5) ) EIA @= + F ANE@=@A @ ) C HEJ @ ) C HEJ
K JE 8= H=@= F=H=
" " " #! #$
1 F A A J=
#
# #
F=H=JEL A JHA
@A =CA @A I 5)
,, A 8AJ H @A *
A=
#% #% #&
-NA F I @A
$
$
EIA @ 4A H@A = A J @ I )KJ

@A =CA
=J I
% %
-NA F I @A
+ IE@AH= AI .E =EI 4ABAH ?E=I
%% &
EIJ= @A 6=>A =I
! " # $ % & '
.K 4A = + + + IK IK
f HAFHAIA J=@= FA
@ @A +
,E=CH= = @A ,A?EI @E A+ A= I
*E IAG
HE= IJHK @ ,, ?E=
! !% "% $ $$ $& % %! %# =J I
+ @E ?=
F=HJE D= A J @A 4A?KHI I F=H= +
A JHA -LA J I A -IJ=@ I + F=H=JEL A JHA @A @A ? A A HE= F=H= HE= F=H= @A @A
,, A 8AJ H @A * +
= J=H @ I .E I B I F=HJE D= A J @A 4A?KHI I E = JAI
-NA F -NA F -NA F
@A -LA J I 5E ?H
E = JAI A JHA 2=HAI @A )KJ
JEF I -LA J I 5E ?H = J=H @ I .E I B I
EIJ= @A .ECKH=I
4AFHAIA J=
/H
?= @A K = 4A@A @A 2AJHE
HL HA @A )JE CE>E E@=@A @= 4A@A @A 2AJHE @= .ECKH= ! " # $ % & ' ! " # $ % & ' + + + -NA F -NA F @A K = 4A@A @A 2AJHE -IJ ? IJE?= @A @A A
5)
! &
+=@AE= @A -NA F
=H L -GKEL= A JA = *E
@A
5)
@= .ECKH= "
& ! !!
@A ,E=CH= = @A ,A?EI
HE= F=H= .K
,, F=H= BK
min(a, b, c)
@A ,, ,, 4A@AI @A 2AJHE 2HE AEH= ,EIF IE 5ACK @= ,EIF IE
F=HJE D= A J @A 4A?KHI I F=HJE D= A J @A 4A?KHI I F=HJE D= A J @A 4A?KHI I @A 5) ? H@A H@A @E " )KJ =J I @A @A
!$ !& !' "
-NA F -NA F + +HE= +HE= +HE= +HE= +HE= +HE= +HE= +HE= ! " # +HE= +HE= +HE=
,, F=H= ,, F=H= A+ IAG
5) 5)
" )KJ " )KJ
=J I =J I
"! "" "% "' "' # # # # # # # # #
K J @A +
?E=
-IJHKJKH= @A -IJHKJKH= @A -IJHKJKH= @A -IJHKJKH= @A -IJHKJKH= @A -IJHKJKH= @A -IJHKJKH= @A -IJHKJKH= @A -IJHKJKH= @A -IJHKJKH= @A -IJHKJKH= @A
,, 2=II ,, 2=II ,, 2=II ! ,, 2=II " ,, 2=II # ,, 2=II $ ,, 2=II % ,, 2=II & ,, 2=II ' ,, 2=II ,, 2=II
$ % & ' ! ! ! !! !" !# !$ !% !& !' " " " "!
-IJHKJKH= @A ,, @A ,, 5) ! @A ,, + F=H= ,, 5) 5)
,, 4AIK J= JA @ 5) 5) E = JAI A JHA 2=HAI @A )KJ =J I " IK @A @A @A @A A HE= F=H= @A I 5) @ELAHI I =J I ,, @A @A
# #& #' #' $ $ $ $ $ $! $! $" = J=H @ I ! .E I B I A A HE= F=H= HE= F=H= @A @A = J=H @ I .E I B I + $# $$ $% F=HJE D= A J @A 4A?KHI I $& %! %" E = JAI
-IJHKJKH= @A K
-LA J I 5E ?H 2=HAI @A )KJ 5) @A " 5) @ +
= J=H @ I .E I B I ,, 4AIK J= JA F=H= + + + F=H= F=H= ? @ + @ + IK IK
F=HJE D= A J @A 4A?KHI I JEF I -LA J I 5E ?H = J=H @ I .E I B I
-NA F -NA F
EIJ= @A 5EC =I
2 52 5) 255 455 ,, 62 ,)/
2AJHE
AJ AJ =J= AJM H
# $ $ $ $ ,E=CH= AJ ! $ !
5J ?D=IJE? 2AJHE 5J ?D=IJE? )KJ
2H @K?J 5J=JA 5F=?A 4A=?D=> A 5F=?A 5J=JA K JE L= KA@ ,A?EIE 6A F HE A@ 2AJHE
,EHA?J )?O? E? /H=FD
"
#
1 JH @K
7 @A =? I E E?E=H= = @ I= B H = EI @A I # @A @A =CA K = E CK=CA I @A @A =CA =H L # = B= K C A HE?= K CH IACKE@= ?= F=H= HAFHAIA J= = @= @ ?=@= @A '# GKA B E ? F A A J=@ ! A 4AEIAH A =LA >AHC
I B H = EI
AIJ ? IJE?= J
AL K @ @AI@A &' GK= @
I AIJK@ I I >HA +=@AE=I @A
E E?E K I AIJK@ I I >HA 4A@AI @A .E = @A -IFAH= I % F H EJJ A " *=I AJ +D= @O K J A 2= =?E I
@A I I =H L + I = AEH= F @A
=>IJH= AI @A K @A
FH > A = @ I + @A
K @ HA= #
. H = EI
I? I
+=@AE=I @A K = AIJHKJKH=@ I
E =@ I @A B H = EI
AIJHKJKH=@ I F H IAG A JA A JA B H = EI F AN I
=FHAIA J=HA
@K =H @A HAFHAIA J=H K
A BHA J=H @E ?K @=@AI F=H= @AI?HALAH
@A I CH= @AI A ?
I B H = EI IJHE AI @A IAH K
I ?
DA?E@ I ?
AIJHKJKH=@ I IKHCEH=
AIF=
E JKEJ @A = A E =H J=EI HA E ?E @A '$ ? @A AIJ=@ I @EI?HAJ = FH F IJ= HAFHAIA J= @ =J I AI @A IK>IEI =
B H = EI B H = EI
@A 4A@AI @A 2AJHE 2 B E E JH @K E@ ?=F= @A @AI?HALAH IEIJA =I ? @A I ? I F=?J I ' @A K
HA= E@=@AI ? > AJEL
F AN=I =JH=L I @A A J= J ? 5)
B H = EI IEIJA = ?
@A 4A@AI @A )KJ >=IE?= A JA K =? A ?E= ?=IE
-IJ ? IJE? I 5) FH F IJ F H 2 =JA=K FAH EJA = HAFHAIA J= JA =I J= J ?
A=@ I @A '& JA E JAH@AFA @
F HJ= A J E @AFA @A JA GK= J ?
+ ? AIF=
= ANEIJ
?E= @A B H = EI IEIJA A I ?
I @A IK
@A =CA @ AIF= @A A
?=F= AI @A HAFHAIA J=H IEIJA =I CH= @AI A @A AIJ=@ I *=IE?= A JA = ANF I @ HE= F=H= HAFHAIA J=H I @EBAHA JAI AIJ=@ I A = = IAH B ? @A AIJK@ 5 K AI @A = = AIF= =J I -IJ ? IJE? I AIF=
F AN I A AHCA @A AIJ=@ I ?
FH > A = @= ANF I A AL=@ ? @A
=F E? LAEI = HA= E@=@A @A K F=H= L HE I B H = EI ? FKJ=?E =EI ANEIJA JAI KJE E =
- @AHA =H AIJA FH > A = ?
4A@AI @A 2AJHE A 4A@AI @A )KJ @A E@A JE ?=H F IJAHE H A JA
AIJHKJKH=I @A @=@ I @A J= = D FH F H?E
AIJ=@ I FH @KJ 255 =
@A AIJ=@ I =JE C LA @
$ @A 455 -II= => H@=CA =IIK A GKA I AIJ=@ I @AI A?AII HE I C=IJ I ?
+)2 67
1 64 ,7
=JE C LAEI @ FKJ=?E
@A
J= >
=H = A =@ I ?=KI= @ =IIE
=EI A @A =H = A = A J
-IJK@ I =F E?=@ I = B H = EI IJH= GKA AL= @ IA A FAH % A AH= ? J= =FA =I = F H
@A
@A =CA
@A 4A@AI @A 2AJHE -IJ ? IJE?=I 52 @A F AN I @A K = = AEH= ? A AIF= F=?J= A @A @A 455 *=IE?= A JA *K?DD B H = EI @A 52
F II LA @AI?HALAH IA IEIJA =I CH= @AI A ? =JE C LA @ E AH A +E=H@ & % FH FKIAH=
= AEH=I A ?EA JAI @A @AI?HALAH
AIJ=@ I =JE C LA @A K JE 8= H=@= ? =I FAH= AI ?
@A I CH= @AI A ? DA?E@= ?
F AN I F=H=
GKA = JAHE H A JA F=?J= A A ?= F=H=
@A @EB ?E HAFHAIA J= K I?
2=H= = CK I ?=I I = AIJHKJKH= @A @=@ I ,E=CH= =I @A ,A?EI ,, B E KJE E =@= @ALE@ = B=J @A IAH ? E IAH AI A >KI?=I
> AJEL @AIIA JH=>= D B H = EI @A @A =CA 5) ?=F= @A A ?

-IJ= =@=FJ= A L = = ALA J I ,, F=H=
=@=FJ=H A JA
= ?
?AEJ @A JHE>KE
,, =F E?=@ A
52
& % F=H= @A K = C HEJ ,,

?
) FHE ?EF= ? AIF=
IA B=H FA = @AI?HE
IJ= JAI A BK ?E B H = EI
JH=H A =H = A =H I
JAH ?KE@=@ =@E?E ?=EI A IE ?H B H = EI
@A AIJ=@ I =JE C LAEI A
K = AIJHKJKH=
@A 5) 2 H
KI @A J=N=I ?
=EI =FHAIA J=@=I @A KI @A
E = JAI F=HJE?K =HE@=@A ANEIJA JA @ = C HEJ FH F IJ ? @A 5) =E @=
I= EA J=H GKA AIJ= FHE AEH= LAHI EIA @= ? F ANE@=@A @ = C HEJ
FHA ?KF= IA ? =FHAIA J=@= =
= LE=>E E =
B ?= @ = CK =I GKAIJ AI @A FAHB H = ?A ,A B=J @A AIJ=>A A?AH IA K = KA ?E= IEIJA = I B H A =I L=HE LAEI GKA E
E@ E= @ @AIA FA D GKA AIJA =FHAIA J=H =K A J=@=I
>JAH IA = AIJHKJKH= @A @AIA LA =KJ ? 2=H= J= J @EIF IJ I AH ? + ANF H=@ F H AIIA AIJK@ =J I I
,,
=EI ?
F=?J= F II LA GKA HAFHAIA JA @ I =KJ =J I = AIJHKJKH= @A IJH=
@A
K ,, ?
=IFA?J J= > GKA I
?AEJ @A H@A ,, E KA ?E=
? KI AI =GKE =FHAIA J=@=I @A AH @A
GKA = H@A
@ I HAGKAHE@ I FA = AIJHKJKH= >A
A?AII HE @A HA@K AI JE E =
7 @A *
? A=
F=H=JEL @ = C HEJ I ? =
=JK= F=H= CAH= ,,
A =H = A = A J KJE E =@ A J= > =FHAIA J=@
5)
8AJ H
L= J ? E?= GKA KJE E = = L FHE ?EF= @ ?
GKAIEJ ?
IK
= @A
HE=
F=H=JEL AIJ=>A A?E@ A JHA = >=I =I J ? E?=I
% 2-25 = BAHH= A J= =JK= A JA KJE E =@= F=H= = HAI K =GKE FH F IJ AIJ=?E @A AIJK@ A - J HE= A ? F=H= GKA HE= @A K @A IEIJA =I @AI?HEJ I A @A 5) 5) !
A ?= @E@=J= = E JACH= IEIJA A FAH = @A = @A
@ = C HEJ
*=IE?= A JA = BAHH= A J= 2-25 F IIKE ) FHE AEH= AJ=F= ? @ I AIJ=@ I @A K KEJ IK ? K @A A B=J H = IACK @= AJ=F= =I FH >=>E E@=@AI @A
AJ=F=I @EIJE J=I F=H= >JAH = I K FHAF=H=H =I E B H = AI @ ?E= A 5) A @A = GK= J FE? =GKE A ? IK @A
?=@= AIJ=@ C >= F II=
IAH ?= ?K =@=I ,AII= B H = = >JA FH ?AII @A CAH= FKJ= ? I EIAI ? IK
=JE C LAEI @ HA AL= JA 2=H= FH ?AII @A CAH=
HA= E =@= = FHE AEH= AJ=F= @= I K @= IACK @= AJ=F=
HE= @KH= JA KJH=I = IK
2-25
E F HJ= JA GKA = E ?E @= ? A @A +27
HE= IA = JE E =@ FE? @A
HE= @KH= JA
= L I @A AIJK@ @AIIA JH=>= D @ I B H = EI ,, F=H= +=F JK IA
@A? HHAH @AIIA JH=>= D =FHAIA J= FHE AEH= A JA K = >HALA @AI?HE AIJK@ @A 52 = C HEJ B H = EI +=F JK +=F JK GKA I 52 A 5) +=F JK +=F JK AIF= ! HAIK A KI @A & % J= > >=IA=@ A @A 5) )E @= K JH=>= D I HA= E =@ I F H ) =L= E= ? ,, K = @= ? E AH A +E=H@
B H = EI " =FHAIA J= ,, F=H= I A = @A =CA @= L=
?=F= @A CAH=H A =H = A =H
@A AIJ=@ I =JE C LA KJE E = @ = 8AJ H @A * A=
F ANE@=@A @AIJA = C HEJ +=F JK @ I =KJ
=FHAIA J=@= AIJA
F=H=JEL A JHA = J ? E?= JH=@E?E =FHAIA J=@ ?E= @= H@A A JA =IIE ? +=F JK
J ? E?= >=IA=@= A AIJHKJKH= @A ,, -
# =JH=L I @A ANA F I @A =J I HA =?E ? KI
$ =FHAIA J= = E
=@= =I J=HAB=I @A JE E = ANF H=@ I
% =FHAIA J= = ?
@AIIA JH=>= D HAII= J= @
IK= = FHE ?EF= ? => H=
IKCAIJ AI @A BKJKH I JH=>= D I = IAHA
&
+)2 67
1 64 ,7
'
. H = EI
AIJA ?=F JK ? HABAH @AI @A )KJ
I @A
@AC= A
A >=I= A J JA HE? = HAIFAEJ @ I B H = EI FHAA @A @ ? I KJE E =@ I
=FHAIA J= IA K ?
?E= AIIA AIJK@
?AEJ I > IE? I I >HA 4A@AI @A 2AJHE 2 A 4A
=J I -IJ ? IJE? I 5)
2
4A@AI @A 2AJHE
4A@AI @A 2AJHE 2 > AJEL @A @AI?HALAH @EI?HAJ IA @ FHE ?EF= @A K E?=
2AJHE
AJI
B H = EI ? IEIJA =I ?
=JA
JE? >=IA=@ A I
CH=B I GKA JA AIF= @A AIJ=@ I
@A =H A = = EI=H A JA =F E? LAEI A @A =CA JA
F HJ= A J @A IEIJA =I ? ? HHA JAI A =II ?H
-IJA B H = EI FH J ? A J @A I @A ?
IE@ = F = A JA KJE E =@ A
@ELAHI=I HA=I J=EI ? @A
A HA@A =HGKEJAJKH= @A ? A ? =J LA @ ? AI
FKJ=@ HAI IEIJA =I @EIJHE>K @ I F = A =
= KB=JKH=I LAHE ?=
A I JAIA @A ?EH?KEJ I @ECEJ=EI A GK=EIGKAH KJH I IEIJA =I
F II LA B= AH IA K = =L= E= ) AIJHKJKH= @A K = 2 K J @A JH= IE AI @A A T P ) @A JH= IE

F IJ= F H K ? A?J=
K J @A KC=HAI @A
E =@ I 2 K
E =@=I 6 A K =@ I ? E =@ @A
K J @A =H? I @EHA?E
=@ I B H =@ I F H P T
HAIF I LA F H @A I
I =H? I @EHA?E A A A J @A
I KC=HAI I JH= IE AI A =I JH= IE AI = I KC=HAI
@EII
=H?= J= >
?D= =@ @A J A LAEI > I
E@A JE ?=H =I JH= IE AI D=>E EJ=@=I = @EIF=H=H )I E =@ I @A ? K AH @A E@ @A
=H?=I @EIF
I KC=HAI @
K J
AH @A =H?=I
=H?=
E@ @A =@E?E
GKA =H?=I
HAFHAIA J=@ FA ?
M ) ?=@= @EIF=H @A K =
IK E@ @A J @ I I IAKI KC=HAI @A A JH=@= A K
=@ = J @ I I KC=HAI @A I= @=
= JH= IE
t
KC=HAI FHA@A?AII HAI GKA = E A J= KC=HAI IK?AII HAI = JH= IE t
+)2 67
. 4 ) 15
5 ,-
,-/) -
. H =
A JA F @A IA @A
E =H K = 4A@A @A 2AJHE ?
K = GK @HKF = @ JEF
P, T, W, M0 )

@A P = {p1 , ..., pn } K J EJ A
K J
EJ A
L= E @A KC=HAI T = (t1 , ..., tn )
K ?
? K J
L= E @A JH= IE AI IA @ P =H? IA = @EBAHA JA @A AH =H?=
T = W : (P T ) (T P ) N
@A =H? I A JHA KC=HAI A JH= IE AI K A JHA JH= IE AI A KC=HAI @ALE@= A JA F FAI @A K F @A IA @E AH F H E>AH@=@A @A E CK=CA ? K J @A =H?=I @EIF ? HHAH ANEIJA M0 HAFHAIA J= = E E?E= GKA
@AH=@ I +=I GKA AIJA =H? I KC=HAI LAEI
= JAI @ FHE AEH @EIF=H @A K = JH= IE
/H= ?= A JA
I KC=HAI I
HAFHAIA J=@ I F H ? H?K I =I JH= IE AI F H >=HH=I A I =H? I HAFHAIA J=@=I F H J A I @A JH @ I ? H?K I 5A = K K
@EHA?E
=@ I F H IAJ=I )I
=H?=I I
KC=H GK= GKAH ? @A K A L=E F=H= J ?
A?J=@ F H K = JH= IE FAI W (u, t) 5A = L K ANEIJA K
J IA W (u, t) > 0 A J
KC=H GK= GKAH ?
ANEIJA K
=H? GKA F=HJA
A?J=@ F H K = JH= IE FAI W (t, v )
J IA
W (t, v ) > 0 A J
=H? GKA F=HJA @A J A L=E F=H= L ?
7 = JH= IE
KC=H A
K = A JH=@= F=H= K = JH= IE GKAIJ ) = C= A JA K F=H= J=
IA ANEIJA K KC=H
=H? @EHA?E
=@ @ J=
KC=H F=H=
7 = A JH=@= F @A IAH HAFHAIA J=@= FA = IACKE JA K = I= @= @A K = JH= IE 2 H IK= LA KC=H A GKAIJ
K
IA ANEIJA
v P
K
T | W (v, u) > 0
=H? @EHA?E
=@ @= JH= IE
K = I= @= F @A IAH ? KC=HAI HAFHAIA J=@ I
HAFHAIA J=@= FA = IACKE JA @A A JH=@= @= JH= IE F H p2 A p3
vP
T | W (u, v ) > 0 ) .ECKH= JA
t1 =FA =I
KC=H p1 A GK= J GKA I KC=HAI @A I= @= I
3K= @ K = JH= IE E
=H? F IIKE FAI F
=E H GKA AH A
A?AII HE
IK
@A F
=H?=I F=H= GKA AH @A =H?=I
J @EIF=HA
= LAH@=@A F=H= GKA J F II= @EIF=H=H
A?AII HE K
ECK= = L= H @ FAI @ =H?
J @ I I KC=HAI GKA I
A JH=@= F=H= AIJ= JH= IE
4-,-5 ,- 2-641
p1
t1
t2
p2
p3
p4
p5
t3
t4
t5
t6
p6 t7
p7
.ECKH= 4AFHAIA J=
/H
?= @A K = 4A@A @A 2AJHE
,EIF=H= @ 6H= IE AI
) ANA?K K ? @EIF=H =H?=I D=>E EJ=@= A
@A K = 4A@A @A 2AJHE =? ? HH= E K =
JA?A =JH=L I @ @EIF=H AIJA = D=>E EJ=@= GKAIJ
@A JH= IE AI JA D= =H?= K
2=H= GKA IAH AH @A
A?AII HE GKA K = JH= IE AGKEL= A JA = FAI @ =H? A =H?= K
2=H= K = JH= IE
IE@AH=@= D=>E EJ=@=
A?AII HE GKA J @ I I KC=HAI @A A JH=@= ? @EIF=H F @A ? HHAH A K = L=
7 = LA GKA K = JH= IE
J AIJA =
IAH =JE CE@=
@EIF=H @A K = JH= IE I KC=HAI @A I= @= . H =
J GK= GKAH ?
=H?=I @ I KC=HAI @A A JH=@=I A CAH= ?
=H?=I
A JA F @A IA HAFHAIA J=H AII= FAH=
M W (p, t) + W (t, p)
@A M 7 = IAG =H?= ANEIJA K = IAG HL HA >A ?
L ?
K J @A
=H?= AI =F I
@EIF=H @= JH= IE
t IAH ABAJK=@=
?E= @A JH= IE AI GK=EIGKAH =H?= ?E= @A @EIF=H I = F=HJEH @= J @=I =I F II LAEI IAG
@EJ= K = IAG =H?=
?E= @A @EIF=H I IA = F=HJEH @A K =

=H?=
M1 =JE CA IA K = KJH=
Mk GK= GKAH 7 =
AIF=
Mk
@EJ= =JE C LA IA AI = ) HL HA @ I @= @ I
E E?E= M0 GKA AL= =J =
@A =JE CE>E E@=@A @A K = 2
.ECKH= HAFHAIA J=
@A AIJ=@ I =JE C LA ? B H = @A JH= IE AI A JHA I
?E=I @A @EIF=H I A
+)2 67
p1
t1 M1 M0
. 4 ) 15
5 ,-
,-/) -
t2
p2 p3
t3 M3 t4
t5
p4 p5
M2
t6
p6 p3
p2 p7
M4
M5
M6
p6 p5
t6 t5
p4 p7
t4
t3
p6 p7
M7
.ECKH=
HL HA @A )JE CE>E E@=@A @= 4A@A @A 2AJHE @= .ECKH=
E EJ=
> K @ AII A 5ACKH=
= I=BA AII
7 = 4A@A @A 2AJHE F @A =FHAIA J=H =I FH FHEA@=@AI @A E EJ=
A IACKH=
7 =2
@EJ=
E EJ=@=
K
K =FA =I E EJ=@= IA F=H= J @ I I AIJ=@ I =JE C LAEI @ E EJA @A =H?=I IA @ AIIA K L= H EJ
@A
J @ I I KC=HAI @= HA@A JA
7 = 4A@A @A 2AJHE K = =H?= A
@EJ= IACKH= IA
E EJA
@AIJ= B H ECK= =
JA
IA
NE
J @ I I KC=HAI
=H?=@ I @= HA@A A
GK= GKAH AIJ=@ =JE C LA
) C HEJ
5O > E? 6H=LAHI= 2AJHE
AJ =FHAIA J=@ A
=A
HAIF AIF=
I LA F H CAH=H = =I ? >E JA @A AIJ=@ I =JE C LA AIJA = C HEJ ANJA I AI A J= J
HL HA @A =JE CE>E E@=@A @A K = 2 @ ? F H @A HAIJHE 2 7 ANA F FH JE?
A =H = A
K = AIJHKJKH= @A *,, - J - JHAJ= J
= AI @A ?= E D I =H = A =@ I = AIJHKJKH= @A *,, HAFHAIA J= ANE>E@ FA = .ECKH= IA = E EJ=@= A IACKH= = FHA EII= @A GKA = 2
= LAH@=@A ANEIJA IACKH=I
@ ) C HEJ
5O > E? 6H=LAHI= 2AJHE
AJ F=H=
?=I @A HA@AI IAH =FHAIA J=@ ?
IAH > AJEL @A AIJK@ @AIIA JH=>= D
=EI @AJ= DAI
4-,-5 ,- 2-641
! 4A@AI @A 2AJHE -IJ ? IJE?=I
B H = EI J= @A =CA
@A 4A@AI @A 2AJHE 2 @AI?HALA I E ? KE ? @ ? ?AEJ I @A JA F F HJ= A J @A
A JA = AIJHKJKH= ?
CE?= @A IEIJA =I F EI F=FA B= IA A?AII HE
6 @=LE=
?AEJ @A JA F F IIKE K
E F HJ= JA = @AI?HE @A IAH HAFHAIA J=@
KEJ I IEIJA =I A F H AII= H=
) E ? KI
@ ? AA
?AEJ @A JA F KJJ
B H = EI
@A 4A@AI @A 2AJHE GKA B E FHE AEH= A JA $ ? DA?E@ ?
E JH @K E@ F H
AH E A .=H>AH $ A K>AHA =JHE>KE K JEL J H ? " ' K J "
4A@AI @A
@EIF=H @=I @A J @=I =I F EI
2AJHE 6A F HE =@=I 62 -II= FHE AEH= => H@=CA

JH= IE AI ANEIJA JAI A @ALE@ = AIIA HA= E@=@AI ) =JHE>KE E F HJ= JA - J AIJ= FAH EJA = HAFHAIA J= @A K
JA F
N F=H=
K IA E A ?EA JA F=H= HAFHAIA J= =E H @A HA= E@=@AI = GK=
@A L= HAI L=HE LAEI = @EIF=H @=I JH= IE AI J H
K IA A?AII HE
B=J H JA F L=HE LA
E E?E K IA I FHE AEH I AIJK@ I I >HA 4A@AI @A 2AJHE -IJ ? IJE?=I 52
@AJ= D=@= A JA @ ?K A J=@ I A
4A@AI @A 2AJHE -IJ ? IJE?=I 52 @= =II ?E= HA@A AIIA @AJAH E EI @A K L ? A IE ?H ?AEJ E = = @A =CA
B H = EI A ?E= A =L= E=
@A
@A =CA
@A 4A@AI @A 2AJHE =?HAI?E@ @EIF=H @A ?=@= JH= IE ? HH ?E= @=
JA F @EIJHE>K @ ANF B= IA F II LA
A JA F=H=
@A IEIJA =I A L LA @ ?
p1 p3 t3 p4 t1 p2
t4
t2
.ECKH= ! -NA F
@A K = 4A@A @A 2AJHE -IJ ? IJE?=
"
+)2 67
. 4 ) 15
5 ,-
,-/) -
) AIJHKJKH= @A K = 4A@A @A 2AJHE -IJ ? IJE?= F IIKE I A JA FA = -GK= ?=@= pi HAFHAIA J= K @A F H =?HAI?E@ @ ? K J ANA F A = @A @EIF=H I @=I JH= IE AI ) .ECKH= ! =FHAIA J= K KC=H ?=@= ti K = JH= IE
AI
I A A A J I @AI?HEJ I = JAHE H
l1 l2
lm GKA HAFHAIA J= =I J=N=I

@A
@A 4A@A @A 2AJHE -IJ ? IJE?=
A JA A =I J=N=I @A @EIF=H
F=H= =I JH= IE AI t1 t2 t3 A t4 HAIFA?JEL= A JA +=>A I= EA J=H GKA F=H= ?=@= JH= IE ANEIJA K = J=N= @A @EIF=H GKA @AJAH E = E JAHL= @A JA F
t@
@EIF=H
@E A JHA
@=I JH= IE AI
5)
4A@AI @A )KJ
=J I -IJ ? IJE? I
B H = EI A ? =KJ
@A 4A@AI @A )KJ
=J I -IJ ? IJE? I 5) B E FH F IJ F H 2 =JA=K IEIJA = ? ?E= ?=IE K = ? A =J GKA I @A IK>IEIJA =I ? @A E@ F H K @EIF=H=@=I =JH=L I = +=@= IK>IEIJA =
'&# A IK= E@ E= > IE?=
HAFHAIA J=H K
F HJ= A J E @AFA @A JA A E JAH@AFA @
=J AIJ ? IJE? A F H JH= IE AI A JHA I AIJ=@ I @AIJA =KJ
@A ALA J I = AIJ=I =II ?E=@=I
7 B H = EI
=KJ
=J
K J
EJ @A AIJ=@ I K J= A JA ? ) @A JA F E = ANF JH=J=@ ? A ?E=
K J
EJ @A JH= =J I AIJA
IE AI A JHA AIJAI AIJ=@ I ! @ALA IA = B=J @A GKA @A JA F ?
AIJ ? IJE? I =JHE>K @= = I =KJ
K = L=HE LA = A=J HE= GKA = AI?= =
J K= >A@A?A K = @EIJHE>KE
)I FH NE =I IK>IA AI @AIJA +=F JK EI 5) = F AN I @A @A IJH=H ? @EJ I ?
=FHAIA J=H
?AEJ I > IE? I HABAHA JAI = B H = A JA
AIJ= => H@=CA
?=F= @A @AI?HALAH IEIJA =I =JK=
5)
4-,-5 ,- )76
)6 5 -56 + 561+ 5
-IJ=@ I
?=EI A / >=EI
B H = EI HAIA J= @ @A @A 2 H
5)
KJE E = IA @=I
AI @A AIJ=@ A @A JH= IE AI A JHA I AIJ=@ I F=H= HAF HA =?E =@=I = =FA =I K AI 5) E? =KJ =J HA =?E =@ I = JA F = L HE I =KJ =J I @
@ I ALA J I -NEIJA J= > F @A ANEIJEH
JH= IE AI GKA AIJ
JH= IE AI GKA AIJ
? HHA @ @A =? H@ ?
J=N=I AIFA? ?=I ) FH NE = IK>IA
ANF E?=H A
@AJ= DAI I JEF I @A JH= IE AI ANEIJA JAI A =J
AIJ=@ E @ELE@K= @A ?=@= =KJ 5) 5) @A E@ ? =? >E =
?D= =@ @A AIJ=@
?=
AIJ=@ C >= @A K =
=J ? F A JA @=
@A J @ I I AIJ=@ I
?=EI @A ?=@= =KJ
6EF I @A 6H= IE AI
)I EC= AI ANEIJA JAI A JHA I AIJ=@ I @A K ?E=@ =I JH= IE AI ANEIJA A IAKI HAIFA?JEL I ALA J I F @A
=KJ
=J I
@A
E =@=I @A JH= IE AI )II ? HHAH )I JH= IE AI B H A ANF E?=@ = IACKEH @A E = JAI 5)
ALA J I GKA @AJAH E = IAH ? =IIE ?=@=I A @E ?=H
GK= @ AIJ=I F @A @EBAHA JAI JEF I ?
, EI JEF I @A JH= IE AI F @A
AIJ=@ C >= @A K ?=EI @E ?= @A
JH= IE AI
=KJ =J IE K
?=EI A JH= IE AI IE ?H
@ @A A = AIJ=I AIJ AIJ=@ @A J= A= A JA
E = JAI 6H= IE AI
=II ?E=@ I ALA J I =EI @A K =KJ
AIJ=@ @A =FA =I K A = AIJ=I AIJ
?=EI 6H= IE AI IE ?H
@E ?=
=J @
=II ?E=@ I ALA J I
IE ?H
E = JAI
?=EI A IE ?H E JAHL= @A E = JAI F @A J= > IAH ?D= =@=I @A JH= IE AI BK F @A ANEIJEH J=N=I ?
) >=I JH= IE AI
?E
=EI 1IJ
? HHA F H GKA =II ?E=@ = @EIF=H @= JH= IE @A @EIF=H =II ?E=@ = AIJ=
IJ= JAI GKA @AJAH E = - J
GK= GKAH ALA J @
F @A JAH =II ?E=@ K = J=N= ? -II= BK
IJ= JA
AH HA= F IE
JEL K K = J=N= BK ?E
= =L= E=@= F H K = BK
@AFA @A @ AIJ=@ @ I @A =EI
$ =KJ K ?E =KJ CAH=H BK ?E =J I A HAIK J= A =EI E F A =EI K@= @E ?= K
+)2 67
. 4 ) 15
5 ,-
,-/) -
AH HA= F IEJEL GKA @AJAH E = IA K =EI I =KJ =J I @ +=F JK @E
@AJAH E =@ ALA J AIJ IJ= JAI J=N=I BK @A " AL=H A A ? IAG K IA = J=N=I I AIJ=@ I @ I ? J= AII= ?E= F=H=
=FJ = @EIF=H=H ,EBAHA JA A JA @A JH= IE AI =II ?E=@=I = J=N=I ? =I @A AIJ=@ K E@EHA?E =FA =I AIJ=@ @ =KJ = C HEJ ? =J = GK= AIJ= FAHJA ?A A FH F IJ K J @A AIJ=@ I ?
=J I = I GK=EI A = @AFA @A 455 @A K @A 5)
E F HJ= JA FHA EII= =
@A @AJAH E =H
! -IJHKJKH= @A K = 5)
) AIJHKJKH= @A K = 5)
FHAA @A K
K J @A =KJ
=J I A K
K J @A ALA J I
E A K = BK
JEF
@A =JE CE>E E@=@A F . H =
A JA K = 5)
HAFHAIA J=@= F H K = JKF = @
5)
@A
) - .
!
K
!
K J @A =KJ
=J I GKA ?
FHAA @A N =KJ
=J I
A=@ I A(i)
@A i
[1..N ] E F
K
K J @A ALA J I ? ?
F IJ F H E ALA J I
A=@ I ej
@A j [1..E ]
"
K = BK
dom(S ) A codom([0..1])
@A
@A dom(S ) HAFHAIA J= J @ I =I F IIE>E L= H =II ?E=@ = BK @A K
E@=@AI @A AIJ=@ I C >=EI @ AIF=

!
A codom([0..1])
@A AIJ=@ I FH @KJ 255 A

=@ J=@= = K J @ I
5)
@A
E@ ?
J=
N (i) i=1 S
@A S
E JAHL=
K J @A
@A i =J j
@A? HHAH @AIJA JH=>= D
J=
i j HABAHE @ IA = K
AH
E ? KIELA FAHJA ?A @ = ?
AH I =JKH=EI A =
i j HABAHE @ IA = K
AH FAHJA ?A JA
= E JAHL= i A j E ? KIELA ? K J @ I AH I HA=EI " ? JANJ @AIJA JH=>= D KI= IA = AJH= e F=H= IA E@A JE ?=H K F= =LH= F @AHE= IAH KI=@= IA FAH@= @A CA AH= E@=@A
ALA J
F H
GK= GKAH KJH= AJH= K
5)
4-,-5 ,- )76
)6 5 -56 + 561+ 5
% K J S (i)
AIJ=@ I ?=EI @ =KJ
=J A(i) A | S (i) |
AH @A AIJ=@ I ?=H@E = E@=@A @ ?
) @A FA = BK
@A GK=EI AIJ=@ I F @A
IAH =JE C LAEI K = ?= JH HE AIJ= =II ?E= @AHA ?
=@ I A L= H 0
@A =H?= @
5) I?
@=@=
@A =JE CE>E E@=@A ) BK =JE C LAEI +=I ?

@A 5) F H
@A =JE CE>E E@=@A F =II ?E= = I AIJ=@ I C >=EI @A P SS
L= H 1 IA A AI I I ANA F JA A =JE C LAEI = K @A
E =J
E C LAEI *=IE?= A JA = BK
@A =JE CE>E E@=@A JA ? HHAIF GKA HAFHAIA J= K
E JKEJ @A A E E =H I AIJ=@ I C >=EI GKA = HA= E@=@A ANFHAII=@= F H AIJA 2 H F=HJE D= A J @A HA?KHI I @A AH @A HA?KHI I B H
IEIJA = @A ?
IA N ? EA JAI @EIFKJ= @ R HA?KHI I H GKA AH @A ? EA JAI F @AH IAH =JE C LA
B ?E @A E =CE =H IA GKA IA
AIJ=@ C >= GKA HAFHAIA J= J @ I I ? EA JAI KJE E = @ K
HA?KHI
RSS
@A
IK>?
K J @A P SS GKA ? K J @A AIJ=@ I =JE C LA
FHAA @A J @ I I AIJ=@ I x J=EI GKA F ( x) = 1
E =@ I @A ?
" -NA F
@A
@A
5)
) .ECKH= " A GK=JH ALA J I IE ! ? BK ?E = ) E JAHFHAJ= J=N= IA =KJ
ANA F
@A
@A
5)
@ EI =KJ J=
=J I K
ALA J IE ?H
E = JA e2 ? IJ= JA A
?=EI e1 e3 e4 e5 @= BK
AIJA ANA F
= J=N= @ ALA J e1 @ AIJ=@ 0(1) F=H= =KJ =J A(2) AIJ
A JA @A =KJ
E@= FA = J=N= fe1 @AI?HEJ= FA =
KJE E =@= FA = BAHH= A J= 2-25 AIJ=@ 1(1) AIJ=@ ? HHA J=N= = AEH= ? F=?J=
f @A
@EIF=H @= JH= IE AIJ=@ 0(2)
=J A(2) AIJ
K J=N= IA AI @EIF
2(2) 5A
=J A(2) AIJ
AIJ=@ 1(2) = JH= IE KI @A BK
@ AIJ=@ 0(1) F=H= 1(1) E>E E = K =
ECK= = AH K IE ?H
E F HJ= JA >IAHL=H GKA
A AN LA @A @AI?HALAH ? E = JA
F HJ= A J I = JAH =JEL I =JH=L I @ KI @A K
IE F AI ALA J ?=
) .ECKH= # @A +I
IJH= = +=@AE= @A
=H L + AGKEL= A JA F=H= AIJ=@ E E?E= I
@A
5)
=FHAIA J=@
FA = .ECKH= " )IIK E @ GKA
AIJ=@ 0(1) 0(2)
A JA # @ I $ AIJ=@ I @AIIA
=JE C LAEI 2=H= HAFHAIA J=H J= ?=H=?JAH IJE?=
A?AII HE HAFHAIA J=H I AIJ=@ I
&
A(1)
0(1)
+)2 67
A(2)
0(2) e4 e2 1
(1)
. 4 ) 15
5 ,-
,-/) -
6EF ?
-LA J
6=N=
e1 e2 e3 e4 e5
fe1
e2 (1 ) e2 (2 ) e5
e1 2
(2)
IO ? ? ?
1 e3
(2)
fe1 =
st A(2) == 0(2) +
st A(2) == 2(2)
.ECKH= " -NA F
@A
@A
5)
C >=EI =JE C LAEI =JH=L I @ KI @A K = BK >JA @A K = BK =IFA?J F H A = LAH@=@A = J=HAB= @A @A J= LA IA = @ @A =JE CE>E E@=@A IA = @A E @A K = BK
@A =JE CE>E E@=@A 6 @=LE= A @A @A =JE CE>E E@=@A F=H= F II LA A ? IAH ?
= CK I ?=I I = 5) @A KI
GKA HAFHAIA JA I AIJ=@ I =JE C LAEI @
K = J=HAB= JHELE= @A I ?HE=@ I A +=I = BK K
I A ? H= =@ H F=H= AI? D= @ KI @AIIA B H = EI E@= =E @= =IIE
JH=H IA J @ I I AIJ=@ I =JE C LAEI
J @=I =I F IIE>E E@=@AI FHA?EI=
FKJ=@=I JH= A @ =IIE
@AIA =@ = IEIJA =
0(1) 0(2)
2
0(1) 2(2) 1(1) 0(2)
1
0(1) 1(2)
1(1) 2(2)
1(1) 1(2)
.ECKH= # +=@AE= @A
=H L -GKEL= A JA =
@A
5)
@= .ECKH= "
IE@AH= @
@A
ANE>E@ FA = .ECKH= # = BK
@A =JE CE>E E@=@A @ALA >HEC=J HE=
A JA AN? KEH
AIJ=@ C >= 1(1) 1(2) A F @A IAH HAFHAIA J=@= F H
F =!
st A(1) == 1(1) && st A(2) == 1(2)
5)
4-,-5 ,- )76
)6 5 -56 + 561+ 5
'
B=J )
5)
KI @A ANFHAII AI BK ?E AI A
=EI @A 5) ?
AIJ AIJHEJ= A JA E EJ=@ = J=N=I @A ALA F @A J= > IAH ANFHAII=@=I F H BK F AN I @A K = B H = ? =EI JA @A I 5) AI ,A F=?J= I IE@AH=@ K = F @AH I= ?=H=?JAH IJE?= @AIIA IEC E ?=JEL= = C HEJ
J I 2H >=>E E@=@AI @A H JA= A J @ = F IIE>E E@=@A @A KI @A BK @EII ?KIJ ? FKJ=?E B H = EI
K = LA GKA FAH EJA = @AI?HE
@A IEIJA =I ?
= F=H= CAHA ?E= A J @A J=N=I BK ?E HE?=I F=H=
A JA @A?HAI?E@ ?
@AIA L LE A J @A I K AI K
F=H= FH @KJ I JA I HE=EI CA AH= E =@ I ! -IJA +=F JK AIJA JH=>= D J ? E?= @A JE E = EI =FHAIA J K K B H = EI @A A >=I= A J JA HE? = HAIFAEJ @ I B H = EI @A =CA @A 4A@AI @A 2AJHE @A AIJ=@ I AIJA =F E?=@= & % I AIJK@=@ I B H = B ? @A
HABAHA ?E= @A AIJK@ F=H= K = LA GKA
@ =H = A = A J @ AIF= =J I -IJ ? IJE? I I +=F JK I EH
@A 4A@AI @A )KJ
= L FHE ?EF= @AIJA JH=>= D =FHAIA J=H A @A 2
@A AIJK@ F=H= FH F IE AIJ=@ I =JE C LA @A AIF= B H = EI @A 5) I FH NE
@A J ? E?= IE E =H F=H= JE E = B H = EI
@ =H = A = A J @ AIF=
=EI @AJ= DAI = J ? E?= @A JE E = A = FH F IJ= @A J ? E?= IE E =H F=H=
@A AIJ=@ I ANEIJA JA F=H=
!
+)2 67
. 4 ) 15
5 ,-
,-/) -
!
! ,E=CH= =I @A ,A?EI
-IJA ?=F JK CAH=H 455 F=H= AIJ >=IA=@
K JE L= H=@= F=H= 52
HABAH A ?E= AIIA JH=>= D K = AIJHKJKH= @A & % HAIF I LA F H
=FHAIA J= = J ? E?= KJE E =@= ? B H = EI @A 52 A =H = A I JH=>= D I FH F IJ I F H
,, -IJA AIJK@
E AH A +E=H@
!
,, F=H= 52
,=@ =CA A I ? A
FH > A = @= ANF I CAH= A =
@ AIF=
@A AIJ=@ I ANEIJA JA AIJA =
I B H = EI
I @A
@A @
AIJK@ @A J ? E?=I = JAH =JEL=I GKA = IAH B ? @A AIJK@
=II ?E=@=I = A?AIIE@=@A @A @A AIJ=@ I @ I
=H = A = A J @A AIJHKJKH=I @A @=@ I @A J= = D FH F H?E
= = AIF=
52
= KJE E = *,, ?
@A ,E=CH= =I @A ,A?EI IEIJA A IAKI
*E
HE= *,, $ IKHCA ? =JE C LA @A K @ I @= AIJHKJKH= =EI =
K = AIJHKJKH= @A *=IE HE I JAEH I
@A @=@ I = JAH =JEL= ?=F= @A =H = A =H =FA =I = F H ?= A JA K J=EI ?
K = AIJHKJKH= @A @=@ I GKA =H = A = =FA =I L= HAI >E @ I ) HA = I A JHA I @ I LE E D I @=@= F H F
A
@A A ?=@A= A J
GKA @AJAH E =
=@ A =>=EN HAIFA?JEL= A JA IAKI @ I = AIJHKJKH= 52 E EJ= IA J= >
,ALE@ = E F IIE>E E@=@A @A =H = A =H IA L= HAI @EBAHA JAI @A A A @A *,, GK= @ =F E?=@= = =H = A = A J @A AIF= = HAFHAIA J=H I ?D= =@= @A CH=B =? ? E? @EHAJ ,)/ ) .ECKH= $ HAFHAIA J= F=HJA @ = IAH IACKE@ GK= @ =L= E= @= BK F=H= *,, AGKEL= A JA = BK @ I L= H =L= E=@ @= BK A JA 4A@AI @A 2AJHE E EJ=@=I A 5ACKH=I
@A AIJ=@ I =JE C LA A
) AIJHKJKH= @A *,,
f ANFHAII= FA = 6=>A =
D I =EI = AIGKAH@= HAFHAIA J= @ I D I
I =H? I GKA ?= E D B= I =
@ K AIJ=@ H=E x1 F=H= I
f F=H= =I L=HE LAEI x1 x2 K x3

@ H=E
- GK= J GKA I =H? I GKA F=HJA
@= H=E x1 F=H= I
=EI = @EHAEJ= HAFHAIA J=
L= H LAH@=@AEH 2=HJE @ IA @
A IACKE @ IA I =H? I
! =J ?DAC=H IA = I ?=@= LA
+)2 67
,1)/4) )5 ,- ,-+15
7 61 8)
4),) 2)4) 52
@ I
D I ANEIJA JAI @A =? H@ ?
L= H =JHE>K @ F=H= = L=HE LA xn A
F II LA ?DAC=H IA = L= H K =L= E=@ FA = BK
f HAFHAIA J=@ FA I
@ I
JAH E =EI A @= AIJHKJKH= @A *,,
x1 0 x2 0 x3 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 x3 1 1 0 0 x3 1 1 0 0 0 1 x2 1 x3 1 1
.ECKH= $ -NA F
@A ,E=CH= = @A ,A?EI
*E
HE= F=H= .K
6=>A = .K
f HAFHAIA J=@= FA
,E=CH= = @A ,A?EI
*E
HE=
f x1 x2 x3

> AJEL @A F AN I F EI
AIJK@ @A *,, =F E?=@ = B H = EI = ELE=H AIJA = FH > A = @= ANF I A= @ AIF= =H = A = A J @A =FA =I
@A 4A@AI @A 2AJHE -IJ ? IJE?= JALA @A AIJ=@ I F=H= IEIJA =I CH= @AI A ? 455 @ @A
,A B=J @=@ I
JH=>= D I F IJAHE HAI =FHAIA J=@ I F H
E AH A +E=H@
& % A E IFEH=@ I AIIA KI @A K = AIJHKJKH= @A
FHE AEH ANFAHE A J HA= E =@ ? =EI F @AH I= @A
= AIJHKJKH= @A *,, FH F A
E =@= @A ,E=CH= =I @A ,A?EI
K JE 8= H=@= ,,
,,
K = ANJA I IAKI
@= AIJHKJKH= @A *,, F=H= I
CE?= >
A= =
>E
HE= 7
,,
F @A =H = A =H A
@ I K AIJ=@ I L= HAI E JAEH I GK=EIGKAH J=EI ? @ I @= AIJHKJKH= HAFHAIA J= I F II LAEI L= HAI GKA AIJ=I F @A

=IIK EH )
) = C= A JA = AIJHKJKH= @A *,,
=I L=HE LAEI @ IEIJA =
A GK= J GKA I =H? I K E D=I HAFHAIA J=
!
,, 2)4) 52
!! ,, AIJ=H E EJ=@ = =H = A =H =FA =I L= HAI >E ,, GKA HAFHAIA J= = BK E HE I
CH= @A @EBAHA L= HAI E JAEH I
= @ IA = B=J @A
K ) .ECKH= % ANA F E ?= K = AIJHKJKH=
A JHA JH I
E = > ?
a 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 2 1 c 2 2 1 2 1 c b b 2 2
.ECKH= %
,, F=H= BK
min(a, b, c)
2=HJE @ IA @ I @ I JAH E =EI GK= @ a =IIK A
@ H=E A IACKE @ L= H 0 =H? ?
I ?= E D I ANEIJA JAI HAFHAIA J=@ I FA I =H? I =J L= H E A JHA a b A c 2 H ANA F @ JAH E = 0 =H? F IIKE =EI = KJH ?= E D= A J L= H 2 =H? L= H @A c
F II LA @AJAH E =H IA GK=
L= H 0 EC= = H=E a @EHAJ =
AIGKAH@= K = LA GKA ANEIJA JA =IIK A GKA a JA IA = 0 =H?
A?AII HE JAIJ=H I @A =EI L= HAI @A b A c L= H 2 =H? =EI = @EHAEJ= A b J= > AE E I L= HAI A JHA a b A c E II FHA?EI =L= E=H
=EI = @EHAEJ= @A b F HJ= J =E @=
L= H @A c )IIK E @ GKA
=EI = AIGKAH@= K 1 =H? @ JH HE IA L= H @A c B H 2
HAIFA?JEL= A JA 0 K
1 +=I ?
2 HJ= J
= ?=H=?JAH IJE?= @EBAHA ?E= =FHAIA J=@= FA = AIJHKJKH= @A =H = A =@ I @A AIF= @A =CA I 52 @A AIJ=@ I F=H= B H = EI @A
,, FAH EJA GKA L= HAI =EI F @AH I= 52 ) 5A @A E KIJH=H @A =CA ,, =
E JAEH I GK=EIGKAH IA = >EJ @A HAFHAIA J= !
@ I @= AIJHKJKH= -IJA J H = = KJE E = @ = AIJHKJKH= @A
EH =FHAIA J=H ANA F I @A
= J ? E?= =GKE HABAHA ?E=@=
+ GKA HA
?AEJ I @A JE E = = A A D H=
I ECK=
IA FHA E F HJ= JAI @A IAHA CAH=
A ?E
=@ I A =L= E=@ I K = LA A HA@K FHALE= A JA ,, =JE = IK=
J ? E?=I A
JE E = AI @A H@A =
=> H@=@=I F=H= *,,I I
A JA E F HJ= JAI F=H= GKA K = AIJHKJKH= @A
!" B H = =EI ?
+)2 67
,1)/4) )5 ,- ,-+15
7 61 8)
4),) 2)4) 52
F=?J= F II LA -IJ=
KIK=
A JA @A
F=?J= @A J @ ? A @A H
E =@= @A B H = ?=
E?=
I=>E@ GKA FH FHE= A JA @=I HA = CK AD H H
= >=I AIJHKJKH=I @A *,, A H@A =@=I A HA@K E@=I $ CH=I @A HA@K @A H@A @A A ?E ?HEJ HE AIJ=>A A?E@ ,A B=J =@=I A
,, I =JE CA I >HA K ANEIJA K =EI ?
= IK= B H = ?= ,, IJH=
E?= IA AIJELAHA
FH ?AII @A ?
? HHA =JH=L I @= =F E?= H@A =@ @A =? H@ ? EH GK= GKA = >JA @=
DA?E@ F=H= @A
A D H ?HEJ HE A JA =JE CE@= B H = EI @A
= IAH =F E?=@
-IJK@ I HA= E =@ I =J A J F=?J= K ?
GKA J H = = AIJHKJKH=
AH @A AIJ=@ I I +=F JK =EI =FH FHE=@ F=H=
=JH=L I @ JAIJA @A J @=I =I F IIE>E E@=@AI ANEIJA JAI $ >KI?= @A K = DAKH IJE?= GKA @AJAH E A 5) ) AIJHKJKH= @A = HAFHAIA J= =FA =I ? @ AIF= @A AIJ=@ I ?HEJ HE @A H@A @A
$ EH ANAH?EJ=H AII= E@ E= A A E E =@ I IA = JAH=H
,, H@A =@= A HA@K E@= AIJ=@ I HA@K @= JAI I
E =@= @A ,E=CH= =I @A ,A?EI @A? HHAH @AIIA AIJK@ =
K JE 8= H=@= E?=
H@A =@ A 4A@K E@ 4
,, 6 @=LE=
AI = IAH HABAHA ?E=@= = IK= B H = ?=
,, F EI J @=I =I AIJHKJKH=I =GKE =FHAIA J=@=I AIJ=H
52
?HEJ HE @A H@A = CK ?HEJ HE =@E?E CAH=
AIJ=>A A?E@ I > K ?HEJ HE @A F=HJE
@A ?
FHALE= A JA F=HJE?E
=@ @A
=? H@ ? @ B=J @ = C HEJ @A
IE@AH=@ K = J=HAB= E @AFA AIJK@ @ ?HEJ HE @A F=HJE A =H = A = A J A @ALA ,A AH @A @EIF IJ I ,, ) 5A 52 LAEI @= I ! LAEI EH
@A JA GKA @ALA IAH HAI LE@= = FHE HE 5ACK @ HAGKAH AIB H = = @A E IAH JH=J=@ A AIJHKJKH= @A AI? F AIFA? ? ,, E
E AH A +E=H@ @ = C HEJ @A 52 F=?J=
@A CAH= HAFHAIA J=H
F H =FHAIA J=H K E@=I F=H= A GKA I IK> AH @A AIJ=@ I
JA = L=IJ F=H= AIJK@ A ANFAHE A J @= AIJHKJKH= A
AH @A F=HJE AI @A )E @= = H@A KA ?E=H @A F=HJE?E ANA F
KA ?E= @ @EHAJ= A JA = ?
= ? HHAJK@A
@A I K IK>IEIJA =I I = @= AIJHKJKH= @A @A
@= AIJHKJKH= EH E =FHAIA J=H K
= A J A H@A = A J F=H= K
) C HEJ @A =? H@ ?
FH F IJ A = CK
& @A
IJH= ?
>JAH @A 52
,, =JH=L I @= IE K = B E F=HJE?E
@ @EI
F=H @=I JH= IE AI @A K = 52
-IJA =IIK A GKA
=@ A H@A =@
?HEJ HE FH AIJ=>A A?E@
A B=JE = @ @AII= B H = AII=I AJ=F=I
FHE AEH F=II FH F IJ FA LA GKA AIJ=I =BAJ= I A J =FA =I @EIF=H=@=I E D= $
) C HEJ
E D= !
@EIF=H @A JH= IE AI =EI @A K
?=EI K = E = JAI IK>IEIJA =
IK>IEIJA =
?= = GK= FAHJA ?A
)I JH= IE AI IE ?H
C =F I =BAJ= @ IE K J= A= A JA
-:- 2
,-
,- )/-
!#
) C HEJD
S M0
,,-NF HAM0 E E?E= E = 5 =H?=
E E?E= ?=EI K J @A =H?=I GKA D=>E EJ= = JH= IE
HAFA=J
! " # $ % & '
S DoLocals(S ) OS
@EIF=H= JH= I ? ?
CK=H@= 455 = JEC
Intersect(S, (t)) F F ire(xk , , t) S U nion(S, F ) F
t t @EIF=H=H
K J @A
=H?=I =JE CE@=I =F I = JH= IE
=@E?E
=F =S
EB (O == S ) JDA
HAJKH S
A @ EB K JE B HALAH
= C HEJ FAH = A?A A K
*=IE?= A JA ?H @A ,,
F IE K = @
@EIF=H @A JH= IE AI
?=EI A IE = AIJHKJKH=
E = JAI =J GKA
AIF=
@A AIJ=@ I =JE C LA 455 IA = CAH=@ A =H = A =@
-NA F
@A
@A =CA
-IJ= IA J ? IJE?= ?
=FHAIA J= K = HAFHAIA J=
ANA F @ AIF=
@A IEIJA = KJE E = @
@A =CA
4A@AI @A 2AJHE -I ,,
@A AIJ=@ I =JE C LA KJE E = @ = AIJHKJKH= @A F=HJE D= A J @A HA?KHI I AIJ=@ 7IE C A AIIA @A
) .ECKH= & E KIJH= K FH ?AII I ?
IEIJA = @A ?
ANEIJA
F=HJE D= @ 4 HA?KHI I +=@= IK>IEIJA = F IIKE @ EI KC=HAI Si GKA HAFHAIA J= KI =H?=I ANEIJA JAI =H?=I @EIF IE ?H LAEI A E = JAI AH @A HA?KHI I @EIF AH @A HA?KHI I A KJE E = LAEI A GK= J GKA
AIJ=@ 5 AAFE C ?E I A Ui HAFHAIA J= @ KC=H 45 HAFHAIA J=
47 HAFHAIA J=
A JHA I i IE ) .ECKH= &
)I JH= IE AI tai A tri I
I FH ?AII I A I HA?KHI I
CA HE?= F=H= FH ?AII I A 4 HA?KHI I =I J A I? ANA F IJHK I L= HAI @A
@A N = 4 " FH ?AII I A R = 2 HA?KHI I ?
F=HJE D=@ I F=H= = ?
@ AIF=
!$
+)2 67
,1)/4) )5 ,- ,-+15
7 61 8)
4),) 2)4) 52
S1
... ... ... ...
SN
RS R
ta1
taN
U1
UN
RU
tr1
trN
.ECKH= & +
F=HJE D= A J @A 4A?KHI I
@A
4A@AI @A 2AJHE
AIJ=@ I =JE C LA 2HE AEH= A JA = 52 @= J ? E?= @A ,, AIIA ?=I
FHA?EI= IAH F=HJE?E
=@= A JH =
IK>IEIJA =I F=H= =F E?= I HA?KHI I HAFHAIA J= IA K KJH
?HEJ HE @A F=HJE
=IIK A GKA ?=@= FH ?AII HAFHAIA J= K J J= @A # IK>
IK>IEIJA = KC=HAI 5 A 7 A GK= J GKA I KC=HAI GKA ? IK>IEIJA = KC=HAI 45 A 47 - J IEIJA =I + IAG A JA A JA AH @A
F=H= L= HAI @A N = 4 - R = 2 JA LAEI @= AIJHKJKH= @A
,, JAH K
J J= @A #
#
) E => H@=CA
@A LAHE ?=H IA = H@A =IIK A GKA
GKA I IK>IEIJA =I I
HAFHAIA J=@ I = AIJHKJKH= @A @=@ I AIJK@=@=I ) FHE AEH= = H=E @= AIJHKJKH= LAEI
KA ?E= K
AH @A AIJ=@ I A?AII HE I @K=I => H@=CA I B H= IK>IEIJA = GKA ? JH = I HA?KHI I @EIF

LA # IACKE@ HAIFA?JEL= A JA FA I 2H ?AII I " LA

) IACK @= => H@=CA =IIK A GKA = H=E
LA " LA
!
LA !
= A JA
LA
A
E E?E=@= FA
2H ?AII
LA # IACKE@
IK>IEIJA =
HAIFA?JEL= A JA FA I 2H ?AII I GKA ? JH = I HA?KHI I @EIF
LA " ! LA
LA ! A "
A
LAEI
) 6=>A =
=FHAIA J= = ? @E ?=
KJE E =@= = ?HE=
@= AIJHKJKH= @A
,, =FHAIA J=@=
FA =I .ECKH=I ' A
)I ?E ? FHE AEH ? K =I @= 6=>A = A= JE = ? K = =FHAIA J= = ? @E ?=
HAFHAIA J= KJE E =@= A
?=@= K ?=@= K
@ I @ I
LAEI @= AIJHKJKH= @A LAEI K
,,
2H ?AII
? K = HAFHAIA J= I KC=HAI S1 A U1 A IK= ? @E ?=
ANFHAII= >=IE?= A JA @ EI AIJ=@ I
-:- 2
,-
,- )/-
!%
F=HJE D= A J @A 4A?KHI I F=H= + IJHK @ ,,
6=>A =
+ @E ?=
@A
2H ?AII
2H ?AII
2H ?AII !
2H ?AII "
4A?KHI 45 47
+ @E ?= =
S1 , U1
=
S2 , U2
=
S3 , U3
= ?E I
S4 , U4
= L= H @A ? @E ?= KI
@EIJE J I 3K= @ 2H ?AII AIJ
HAFHAIA J=@ F H 0
K IA =
S1 A U1 2 H U1 -II= 2
GK= @
2H ?AII AIJ A
L= H @= ? @E ?=
K IA = S1 A
AI = ? @E ?=
KJE E =@= F=H= J @ I I @A =EI 2H ?AII I
! A " ) ? @E ?= A?AIIEJ= KC=HAI
=F E? LA = I 2H ?AII I A
HAFHAIA J=@= F H n/a K = LA GKA A?AIIEJ= IA =FA =I @A HAIFA?JEL= A JA
@ EI L= HAI @EIJE J I F=H= HAFHAIA J=H =I F IIE>E E@=@AI ANEIJA JAI ) ? K = 4A?KHI @A JH I ? @E ?= AI @EIJE J=I ANFHAII=I FA I L= HAI 0 1 K 2 GKA IEC E ?= @ EI KC=HAI @EIF @EIF LAEI A @ EI A LAEI A AH A KI KI K KC=H @EIF LA A K A KI A AH
2=H= = > I I ?=I I @K=I CKH=I @A ANE>E@=I HACH=I @A JE E = IK>IEIJA = @A ? IK= B H = ?=
,, HAFHAIA J= @ ,, A
AIF=
@A AIJ=@ I =JE C LA I IA = =F E?= @=I ,, A
)I .ECKH=I ' = A = =FHAIA J= JH A @A HA?KHI I = H=E
B=IA E E?E=
F=H= HAIFA?JEL= A JA = FHE AEH= FH ?AII
= H=E A IACK @= @EIF IE
=I .ECKH=I ' > A > ANE>A
E?= F=H= = >=I
+ I
IE@AH= @ GKA J= J =I FAH= AI A?AII HE=I F=H= HA= E =H =I HA@K AI JE E = @A K @A =E H AH @A @ I F=H= HAFHAIA J=H IA ,,I ? @ H=E >JALA K AI AIF= KI @AIA =@ I = IEIJA = =L= E= IA I @EIJE J I 2H ?AII HAFHAIA J=
?
GKA = KJE E = FHE AEH= @EIF IE LA GKA ? F=H=@ ?
@A AIJ=@ I K =
IJHK @ I 2AH?A>A IA GKA = A D H HAIK J=@
AH @A HA@K AI A?AII HE=I B E @A =FA =I $ !# AIJ=@ I E E?E=EI ' AIJ=@ I AH @A HA@K AI A?AII HE=I F=H= = IACK @= @EIF IE
=EI
GKA B E @A % !& AI - J AI
AIJ=@ I E E?E=EI
HABAHA JA = KJE E = F= A
AIJ=@ I
@A A F=H=@ =
=EI )
H AH
@EII AH @A ?
AH
= @A
@ I @= FHE AEH= @EIF IE
@ I F II LA F=H= HAFHAIA J=H IA K JH= AIJ=@ I @= IACK @= @EIF IE
@A AIJ=@ I ?
= @A AIJ=@ I =FHAIA J=@ FA = IACK @= @EIF IE
H ' AIJ=@ I F=H= = FHE AEH= @EIF IE
!&
+)2 67
,1)/4) )5 ,- ,-+15
(a) 0 1
7 61 8)
4),) 2)4) 52
(b) 0 1
.ECKH= ' +
,, 2HE AEH= ,EIF IE
@A JHA =I @K=I => H@=CA I JAIJ=@=I = AIJHKJKH= @A =EI JE E =@= @A HAFHAIA J= IACK @ ? @E ?= @ AIF= AIJ=>A A?E@= FA = 6=>A =
,, =FHAIA J=@= A
' > ANFHAII= = B H = @A 52 @= .ECKH= &
@A AIJ=@ I =JE C LA F=H=
.E =
A JA =
@A @AJAH E =H IA
AIF=
@A AIJ=@ I =JE C LA ANFHAII FA =I AIJHKJKH=I @A @ H=E @AIJ=I A IACKEH I ?= E D I ANFHAII I FA I @= B H = HA@K E@= @= AIJHKJKH= A ?E =@=I =EI H FE@= A A ?= ,,I
,,I @=I .ECKH=I ' A >=IJ= F=HJEH IA @ =H? I ANEIJA JAI =J =JE CEH IA I E KIJH=@= FA @A IAH KJE E =@= K = LA GKA AIJ=
@ I JAH E =EI ) KJE E =
@AIA D > @A ?=@= K = @=I .ECKH=I
F IIKE ?= E D I HA@K @= JAI
-IJA +=F JK
HABAHA ?E K ?
?AEJ I E F HJ= JAI @= J ? E?= @A =H = A = A J @ AIF= =JE C LA @ @A F=H= B H = EI @A @A =CA 52
@A
AIJ=@ I GKA LEI= =FA =I = F H
-:- 2
,-
,- )/(a) 0 1 2
!'
(b) 0 1 2
.ECKH= +
,,
5ACK @= ,EIF IE
)E @= K @A ,,
FAGKA I FH NE
DEIJ HE? @= AL K I +=F JK I EH
@= J ? E?= B E => H@=@
A = @ ?
= KJE E = E =@= @A =F E?=H IA
@A *,, A F IJAHE H A JA F=HJE @ IA F=H= K = AIJHKJKH= @A @=@ I KJE E =H @A 5) K = J ? E?= = C= = B H = EI
=EI F @AH I= @A
A >=I= A J =GKE =@GKEHE@ =
"
+)2 67
,1)/4) )5 ,- ,-+15
7 61 8)
4),) 2)4) 52
"
" )F E?= @ ,E=CH= =I @A ,A?EI

)FHAIA J= IA AIIA ?=F JK @A AIJ=@ I =JE C LA F=H= K = >HALA HABAH J ? E?= >=IA=@= A ,, = C HEJ @A
K JE 8= H=@= F=H= 5)
A =H = A = A J @ AIF= ,, 2HE AEH= A JA L= =FHAIA J=@= IACKE@= @=
FH F IJ F=H= CAH= @A =CA 5) 5)
B H = EI
KJE E = @ IA
?E= I >HA = =JK= J ? E?= KJE E =@= A
" )JK=
@A
@A )H = A = A J F=H= 5)
) =JK= J ? E?= @A CAH= EI @ F IE AIJ=@ F AN I @A 5) @A HAGKAH K = F IE = F IE ? HHAIF HAIK J= A ? HHAIF @A JA C=IJ I A
A =H = A = A J @ AIF= >=IA=@= A K GKA
@A AIJ=@ I =JE C LA F=H= A= AIJ=@
B H =
KJE E = K = => H@=CA
8AJ H @A *
I +=@= F II LA AIJ=@ @AJAH E =@ ? +=I ? JH HE =
HAFHAIA JA AIIA LAJ H 5A K =IIE = =@= ? B= I )JK= A =IIE = =@= ? A AI
=JE C LA
@A JA @ LAJ H
LAH@=@AEH
LAJ H
A JA AIJ= J ? E?= AIJ E F A >EJ F=H= HAFHAIA J=H ?=@= @A I CH= @AI A ?
A J=@= = BAHH= A J= 2-25 !
HAGKAHA @ =FA =I K
H AI @A =H = A = A J @A
HE= F=H=
) B H K = F=H= ? ?K 8AJ H @A * ?=@= AIJ=@ @A K ? A= I
@ ?
IK
@A
HE= F=H= K @ AIF=
@A
5)
GKA KJE E = = J ? E?= +=F JK IACKE JA #
>JE@= =JH=L I @= @ELEI
@A AIJ=@ I FH @KJ F H & K = LA GKA A D H @AJ= D=@= A= IA ,, AIJ=>A A?E@
HAFHAIA J=@ F H K
>EJ =FA =I -IJ=
F=H=JEL A JHA = >=I =I J ? E?=I 8AJ H @A *
)E @= @A 8AJ H @A * => H@=CA
EH = BK A= I =
@A =JE CE>E E@=@A =II ?E=@= = ?=@= =E HE= @ I ?=I I K HAIF FH ?AII ? @A =JE CE>E E@=@A I LA F H CKE=H
@A F AN
5) F H
KJE E = @ @A CAH=
J @ @KH= JA =
= @=J HE F=H= J=
) BK
= C HEJ
" @A E
+)2 67
"
)2 1+) ,
,1)/4) )5 ,- ,-+15
7 61 8)
4),) 2)4) 5)
@ I AIJ=@ I =JE C LAEI @
@A
HAIJHE CE @
I AIJ=@ I
FAHJA ?A JAI = HA= E@=@A
F H AIJA HAFHAIA J=@=
"
,, F=H= 5)
) E@ E= @A =F E?=H = AIJHKJKH= @A F=H= = ELE=H I FH > A =I @A ANF I ) = C= A JA = GKA KJE E =H ,, F=H= =H = A =H AIF= D A =F E?=@ A
,, A @ AIF= 52
5)
IKHCA ?
K = = JAH =JEL= E JAHAII= JA JH=@ I = =JK= => H@=CA @= J ? E?= GKA FHE AEH= LAHI 5)
@A AIJ=@ I A ? ?DAC= IA = K
@A AIJ=@ I =JE C LA A
)I AJ=F=I @A F=HJE K A 52
@A
IK>IEIJA =I A H@A = A J ? B H = EI =J @
= AIJHKJKH= @A 5)
,,
FH HAGKEIEJ F=H= = J ? E?= = IAH =F E?=@= =IIE ) ?=H=?JAH IJE?= @A =EI B ?E 7 ?HEJ HE IE F AI @A F=HJE ,, ) JAH =JEL= A JA =EI @A K =KJ =J F H
BK @= A J=@ FA = J ? E?= AIJK@=@= J H = AII= @ELEI @A K LA @= B E =GKE L=HE= JAI = ? HHAJK@A
@K =HE@=@A =FHAIA J=@= FA @A
=IIK A GKA ?=@= =KJ F @AHE= IAH F=HJE?E LA F H ANA F
AIJHKJKH= @A =IIK E @ AIJK@=@= JH=HE= = CK GKA F @A E
=@ @A K = B H = @EIJE J= @A LAHE ?=H IA IA AIJ= A H@A E F E?= I
6 @=LE= AIJ= = JAH =JEL= BKJKH = =I GKA
=I @A GK= GKAH B H = F @A LEH = IAH ANF H=@= >A AB ?E =@E?E = = J ? E?= ,A B=J KA ?E=H = JE E = @= AIJHKJKH= @A ,,
I ?HEJ HE I @A F=HJE
@= J ? E?= =GKE FH F IJ=
A(1)
1
l2 l1 l3
A(2)
1
l4 l5
A(3)
1
l6 l7
A(4)
1
l8
s1
s1
s2
s2
Nvel
Nvel
Nvel
Nvel
.ECKH=
@A
5)
" )KJ
=J I
"
,, 2)4) 5)
"! ?HEJ HE @A F=HJE =J I IAH @A @A =J @ K =KJ I ? =J F=H= ?=@= LAEI @= AIJHKJKH= IE@AH= @ K LA @= AIJHKJKH= @A ,, @A CKE=@= FA 5) ? ,, E@A JE
- J = H@A " =KJ A
IA A?E
=@
GKA I =KJ
@EIF IJ I 2 H ANA F
?=@ H @A ?=@= =KJ
F IJ F H
=J I HAIFA?JEL= A JA H JK =@ I FA I E@A JE ?=@ HAI F IIKEH " LAEI @EIJE J I
! A " .ECKH= = AIJHKJKH=
,, GKA HAFHAIA J= AIIA
7 = F II LA H@A
H@A
= IAH =F E?=@= .ECKH= IAHE= F=HJE @ IA @ =J I E@A JE ?=@ I FA I H JK I @ IA I =KJ =J I " ! A? @ H=E @EIF
@ H=E =J !A"
@ I
JAH E =EI @= AIJHKJKH= @EIF H I =KJ IAHE= F=HJEH IA @ .ECKH= !
KJH= F II LA
B H A E KIJH=@ FA =
Nvel 1
A(1)
Nvel 2
A(2)
........................
Nvel 3 A(3)
........................
Nvel 4 A(4)
.ECKH= -NA F
H@A
,, F=H=
@A
5)
" )KJ
=J I
)I H@A I =GKE AIJ=>A A?E@=I I >E = AI ANEIJA JAI ,A B=J K B=J H @EHAJ= A JA = JE E = I I ANFAHE A J I =@=I A ECK= +=F JK = H@A
=FA =I @ EI F II LAEI ANA F I @A JHA A GKA I =KJ ,, > =J I I H=
KEJ=I KJH=I ? ,, KA ?E= @A GKA
@EIF IJ I = AIJHKJKH= @A @EII = 5A ,, +
KEJ E F HJ= JA @A IAH @AJAH E =@ = FHE HE K = LA GKA J= ?=H=?JAH IJE?= E @= AIJHKJKH= @A @ I =KJ @E AI A @A = H@A $ =F J= =I ? =J I = AIJHKJKH= @A ?HEJ HE @A H@A GKA = AIJHKJKH= @A L=HE=@= =
$ =FHAIA J= @ELAH
AIJ=>A A = IA K = DAKH IJE?= GKA IKCEH= K A JA A ?=
? KI AI E E?E=EI HABAHA ?E =EI JE E =@=
,, J H = IA
""
+)2 67
"
)2 1+) ,
,1)/4) )5 ,- ,-+15
7 61 8)
4),) 2)4) 5)
Nvel 1
A(4)
Nvel 2
A(3)
........................
Nvel 3 A(2)
........................
Nvel 4 A(1)
.ECKH= ! -NA F
H@A
,, F=H=
@A
5)
" )KJ
=J I
)IIE KJE E = @ A IE ?H
BK @= A J=@ A ,, A 5) @A @A ) C HEJ
52
= C HEJ >=IAE= IA
@A CAH= = IE K =
@A AIF=
@A AIJ=@ I =JE C LA ?=EI =EI IK>IEIJA = = GK= A A
@A @EIF=H @ I ALA J I
E = JAI @
@EIF=H @A ALA J I @EIF=H @A ALA J I IE ?H
?=EI =BAJ= =FA =I
FAHJA ?A A GK= J GKA IK>IEIJA =I @
E = JAI =BAJ= IE K J= A= A JA @ EI K
FHE AEH F=II @ ) C HEJ L= A JA HAFHAIA J= A? IAG ?E=I I J I IE ?H E = JAI K I AIJ=@ I ? ?=EI
@A
A @ EI ?
K J I @A AIJHKJKH=I @A IAG ?E=I (Cq (e) ) @A
,,I GKA HAIFA?JE I AIJ=@ I ? @E AI ALA
@E AI (Cd (e) ) A ?
CAH=@ I F=H= ?=@= ALA J @
E @AFA @A JA A JA @AIJAI IAHA
I AIJ=@ I ? I AIJ=@ I ?
@E AI d Cd (e) HAFHAIA J= IAG
I AIJ=@ I GKA D=>E EJ= I AIJ=@ I =JE CE@ I
ALA J e = IAH @EIF=H=@ @AF EI GKA ALA J e
?E=I q Cq (e) HAFHAIA J=
@EIF=H=@
) J=HAB= @A CAH= ) C HEJ ? @E AI A ? IAG
@ I AIJ=@ I ? ?E=I HA =JEL I =
@E AI A ? @A 5)
IAG
?E=I AIJ ANF E?=@= A
@AJ= DAI FA I AIJ=@ I @A E@ I
! 6 @=LE= F=H= K
A D H A JA @E A J @ FHE AEH F=II @ = C HEJ =FHAIA J=@ FA = .ECKH= " AIJ
= 6=>A = ! A E KIJH=@ I = .ECKH= "
"
,, 2)4) 5)
"#
) C HEJD
/AH=
,,/A AH=JE
Inicial
Cd(e) A Cq (e)
RSS Inicial
! " # $ % & ' ! " # $ %
HAFA=J
modif icado f also
B H = ALA J e @ B H = d Cd(e) A
? HHAIF @A JA q Cq (e) @
EB d RSS A q RSS JDA

RSS U nion(RSS, q ) modif icado true
A @ EB A @B H A @B H K JE
modif icado
B Hi=N J 2@
E@A JE ?= AE E = @ I HAFAJE@ I F=H= i @ RSS @ I HAF E?=@ I HA@EHA?E = @ IF JAEH I @ LA i 1 @ RSS
A @B H
"$
+)2 67
"
)2 1+) ,
,1)/4) )5 ,- ,-+15
7 61 8)
4),) 2)4) 5)
) C HEJD ! /AH= Cd(e) A Cq (e) B H = ALA J e @ B Hi=1J N @

! " # $ % & ' ! " # $ % & '
EB A(i) F IIKE ALA J e JDA EB ALA J e F IIKE J=N= BK ?E = JDA

Cd(e)
LA i AIJ=@ I D=>E EJ=@ HAI @A A(i) LA i AIJ=@ I D=>E EJ=@ HAI @A A(i) LA i AIJ=@ I @AIJE @A A(i) @A = BK AH
A IA
Cd(e)
A @ EB
Cq (e)
A IA EB ALA J e F IIKE J=N= BK ?E = A @AFA @A @A A(i) JDA

Cd(e)
LA i AIJ=@ I @A A(i) LA i @ J ?=HA LA i @ J ?=HA @A = BK AH
A IA
Cd(e)
A @ EB
Cq (e)
A @ EB A @B H A @B H
"
,, 2)4) 5)
"% @A =FHAIA J=@ FA = .ECKH= " B E F=HJE?E =J )E @= =KJ =KJ =J A(2) HAFHAIA J= LA =@ A IK> @A I LA @=
)IIK E @ IA GKA JA IA K IK> @A AIJHKJKH= @A
F=H= ?=@= =KJ
=J A(1) HAFHAIA J=
,, A GK= J GKA
6=>A = ! 4A =
A JHA -LA J I A -IJ=@ I +
@E
A+
IAG
?E=
ALA J
AIJ=@ I ?
@E
AIJ=@ I ?
IAG
?E=
e1 e2(1 ) e2(2 ) e3 e4 e5
d1 d2 d3 d4 d5 d6
-IJ=@ I ? @E
q1 q2 q3 q4 q5 q6
d1

d2

d3

d4
d5
d6
Cd(e1) = {d1} Cd(e2) = {d2, d3} Cd(e3) = {d4} Cd(e4) = {d5}
-IJ=@ I ?
IAG ?E=
Cd(e5) = {d6}
q1

q2

q3

q4
q5
q6
Cq (e1) = {q1} Cq (e2) = {q2, q3} Cq (e3) = {q4} Cq (e4) = {q5}
Cq (e5) = {q6}
.ECKH= " +
K J @A +
@E
A+
IAG
?E=
) = EI= @ = 6=>A = ! A .ECKH= " >IAHL= HAIFA?JEL= A JA @A ? A B H A @A K E@ FA GKA F @A L=HE=H @A 1..n +=@= @AJAH E =@
I GKA I AIJ=@ I ?
@E
A? =KJ @E
IAG =J @ A?
?E= I @A IAG ?E= ?=I ?E=
E =@ I F H dn A qn ) L=HE LA n HAFHAIA J= K LA @= AIJHKJKH= @A ,, HAFHAIA J= K =JK= ?HEJ HE @A F=HJE LA @=I AIJHKJKH=I @A =FA =I K I AIJ=@ I ? =KJ @E I =KJ =J @ A? IAG ) ANEIJ =J I @ @A
L= H E JAEH IAG A ?E=
?E= @A AIJ=@ I ? @A -
,,I E E?E=EI AIJ @EHAJ= A JA =II ?E=@= = ANEIJ KJH=I F= =LH=I @E A? IAG 2 H ANA F I AIJ=@ I ? ?E= @ AI
?E= @ ALA J = I GK=EI A AI HAFHAIA J= @A K EH ALA J =F=HA?AH A ANEIJEH =FA =I LA @A
,, =II ?E=@ = =KJ
=J AIFA? ?
ALA J e3
?= = A(2) A F HJ= J
HAFHAIA J=@ I F H d4 A
"&
+)2 67
"
)2 1+) ,
,1)/4) )5 ,- ,-+15
7 61 8)
4),) 2)4) 5)
q4 =F=HA?A
K JH=
=FA =I
LA
@= AIJHKJKH= @A ANEIJ
,, -
d4 A q4
@E =F=HA?A AI =KJ
LA AIJ HAFHAIA J=@ ? A? IAG ?E= F=H= AIJA @EII ?E= @A FH >=>E ALA J e2 =F=HA?A HAFHAIA J=@ =KJ =J A(1) )
D HE AI
J= GKA IEC E ?= = IE@AH= @ GKA ALA J =F=HA = =KJ =J A(2) A =EI
?E= @A AIJ=@ I ?
LA @= AIJHKJKH= ? ?=I K @K=I LA AI FA F=H= HAFHAIA JA ,, AIJ ? F=H= GKA
ALA J e3
=EI @A K = LA
=J ANEIJ
E@=@AI J= ALA J HA?A>A @EBAHA JAI E@A JE ?=@ HAI dn A qn 2 H ANA F
e2(2 ) A e2(1 ) 2=H= J= J

@E ? E F E?= K J d1 @A
= JH= IE = ANEIJ
e2(2 )
AIJ=@ I d2 q2 A GK= J GKA e2(1 ) J=N=I BK ?E @E?E = I AIJ=@ I ? @EIF=H @ ALA J 2 H ANA F
HAFHAIA J=@ F H d3 A q3 IJH= GKA
?=I @A ALA J I GKA LA @= AIJHKJKH= @A ,, @AJAH E =
?E= @A AIJ=@ I = JAH =JEL I
A JA =II ?E=@= = ANEIJ
?E= @A 0 K 2 = AIJHKJKH= HAIK J= JA @A =II ?E=@= = e1 =IIE
ALA J e1 F II= @EIF=H=H K = LA GKA = BK
) IACK @= AJ=F= @ ) C HEJ ? ? K J 455 K J @A AIJ=@ I E E?E= AIJ=@ I
E D= ? DA?E@ I ?
AIFA?E ?=H
AIF=
@A AIJ=@ I E E?E= F=H= @A K? K
455 F @A IAH E E?E= E =@ ?
AIJ=@ C >= E E?E= @
=JE C LAEI =JH=L I @ KI @A K = BK
,A B=J
= FHE ?EF= BK ?E @ I AIJ=@ I ? = @EIF=H=@
= E@=@A @ ) C HEJ @E IAG E IAG
E D=I ! = ! ?
IEIJA A ?
F GKA
K J 455 A?AII HE LAHE IA = =@ I
FAH = A?A JAIJ= @ =JH=L I @= =@E )? @E
I AIJ=@ I ?
F=H= J @ I I ALA J I A ?E= = AIJHKJKH= @A ? K = LA . H = K J RSS
@E ?= @ =EI @A
,, HAIK J= JA GK= @
@A F=H=@= @
LAHE ?=@= GK= @
@E ?=@ A J @ I @E =@E?E
I ALA J I e JA D= ?= IA I AIJ=@ I ? ?
A JA AIJ= AJ=F= @ = C HEJ +=I = ? @A JAI = ALA J e I
@E AI d Cd (e) RSS F=H= ?=@= ALA J e @ ?E=I q Cq (e) ? HHAIF
I=JEIBAEJ= J @ I I AIJ=@ I ? K J RSS ?=I q
RSS
JH=J= A J @=I J=N=I BK ?E FA = C HEJ K =I LA GKA = K @E ?=H IA = AIJHKJKH= @A @A K = J=N= BK ?E GK= @ K @A
=EI @KH= JA @EBAHA ?E= F=H=
F FHE ?EF=
B H = EI
B=J H E F HJ= JA => H@=@ )= J =@= F=H= ?E= GKAIJ F IIKE K @AFA @A
@A 5)
,, HAIK J= JA @EBAHA IA J= IEJK= =EI J=N=I BK ?E
ALA J A
= IACKE JA ?=H=?JAH IJE?=
@A BK @= A J= E F HJ
KJE E = J=N=I BK ?E
=EI E F A =EI @E ?=
K@=
=I @A AIJ=@ K E@E AIJ=@ = GK=

) C HEJ
HA?E
=EI
I =KJ
=J I @
@A
K IA = J=N=I BK ?E
=FA =I
A = FAHJA ?A A
AIJ=@ = GK= A = @AFA @A -II= FHA EII= AIJ HAFHAIA J=@=
"
,, 2)4) 5)
"' @ K@= =I = AIJHKJKH= ,, HAIK J= JA
! FA =I E D=I E D=I " A HAIFA?JEL= A JA E F FA @A JAI )I .ECKH=I @A # = # HAFHAIA J= F=H= # J= > ? K J d1 D=>E EJ= =FA =I @A 5) E E?E=EI 0(1) 0(2) ? B H A J= > @A
=FA =I F=H= I AIJ=@ I FAHJA ?A JAI A @AI?=HJ= @ GK=EIGKAH
@E ?= AI F=H= I AIJ=@ I @A
F=II = F=II = >JA
@= AIJHKJKH= @A ?
,, HAIK J= JA
ANE>E@ FA = .ECKH= "
AIJ=@ C >= KJE E =@ =EI ANFHAII=I FA LA
F IJ FA I AIJ=@ I F=HJE?K =H = .ECKH= K = LA GKA ,, E E?E= = JAH=@
IJH=@ FA = .ECKH= # 2=II = ANEIJ ?E= @A 0 =KJ
I= EA J=
JH=J= A J @=I J=N=I BK ?E AIIA ?=I = AIJHKJKH=
= C HEJ
@EIF=H=@
@= AIJHKJKH= @A @EIF=H @A d1 JA
@EIF=H @A d1 LA K = LA GKA
,, HAIK J= JA =F I
LA HAFHAIA J=
=J = GK=
ALA J e1 FAHJA ?A
Nvel 1
0 Disparo d1
Nvel 1
Nvel 2
Nvel 2
MDD Inicial
.ECKH= # +HE=
-IJHKJKH= @A
,, 2=II
Nvel 1
Nvel 1 Disparo d2 Nvel 2
Nvel 2
.ECKH= $ +HE=
-IJHKJKH= @A
,, 2=II
+=>A I= EA J=H GKA @ F=II = F=II # .ECKH=I @A # = ' = AIJHKJKH= IA @E ?= = ?=@= L= EJAH= @ = C HEJ
,, HAIK J= JA
#
+)2 67
"
)2 1+) ,
,1)/4) )5 ,- ,-+15
7 61 8)
4),) 2)4) 5)
Nvel 1
Disparo d3
Nvel 1
Nvel 2
Nvel 2
.ECKH= % +HE=
-IJHKJKH= @A
,, 2=II !
Nvel 1
Nvel 2
.ECKH= & +HE=
-IJHKJKH= @A
,, 2=II "
Nvel 1
Disparo d5
Nvel 1
Nvel 2
Nvel 2
.ECKH= ' +HE=
-IJHKJKH= @A
,, 2=II #
Nvel 1
1 Disparo d6
Nvel 1
Nvel 2
Nvel 2
.ECKH= +HE=
-IJHKJKH= @A
,, 2=II $
2 H
@ F=II $ = F=II .ECKH=I @A = # J @ I I AIJ=@ I ? IA @E @E ?= A DK = = AIJHKJKH= @A F=H=@= FH F IJ= FA = C HEJ
@E
B H=
=FJ I
= @EIF=H=H F H
,, HAIK J= JA - J
F=II
.ECKH= # =JE CA = ?
K = LA GKA J @ I I AIJ=@ I
"
,, 2)4) 5)
# @E ?= L= B E E F IJ= ? = =@E @ I AIJ=@ I Cq (e)
Cd (e) B H=
@EIF=H=@ I A A DK =
Nvel 1
Disparo d1
Nvel 1
Nvel 2
Nvel 2
.ECKH= +HE=
-IJHKJKH= @A
,, 2=II %
Nvel 1
1 Disparo d2
Nvel 1
Nvel 2
Nvel 2
.ECKH=
+HE=
-IJHKJKH= @A
,, 2=II &
Nvel 1
Disparo d3
Nvel 1
Nvel 2
Nvel 2
.ECKH= ! +HE=
-IJHKJKH= @A
,, 2=II '
,AII= B H = = AIJHKJKH= HAIA J= B H = ?= ? @ AIF= JHKJKH= @A ? F=II @ ) C HEJ E?= 4 IEIJA = =F E?=
,, HAIK J= JA >JE@= =F I @A 5) @= AIJHKJKH= @A A ?E =@=I A
FHE ?EF= @ ) C HEJ @A JH= IB H =A
HAF JE IK=
K J @A AIJ=@ I =JE C LAEI @ HABAHA JA = HA@K @=I HACH=I @A HA@K ,, ) AJ=F= @A HA@K
455 6 @=LE= =E @= HAIJ= K ,, =
HAFHAIA J=@= FA =I E D=I " = % @ ) C HEJ A KJE E =@=I F=H= JE E = ? IEIJA = L=HHA@KH= @= AI = @ IA @ I @KF E?=@ I A HA@EHA?E FH ?AII @A HA@K
@A AIJ=@ I ANEIJA JA *=IE?= A JA ,, = F=HJEH @ I
@ I JAH E =EI A E E =@ IA
+)2 67
"
)2 1+) ,
,1)/4) )5 ,- ,-+15
7 61 8)
4),) 2)4) 5)
Nvel 1
1 Disparo d4
Nvel 1
Nvel 2
Nvel 2
.ECKH= " +HE=
-IJHKJKH= @A
,, 2=II
Nvel 1
Nvel 2
MDD Resultante
.ECKH= # +HE=
-IJHKJKH= @A
,, 2=II
IF
JAEH I @ I
@ I@ I @A K
LAEI IKFAHE HAI F=H= K LA E JAEH F ANE@=@A ,,
E? ANA F =H @A
AI
L= H ) HACH=
HABAHA JA = A E E =
?=I @AIJA =IIK EH J @ I I L= HAI F II LAEI =E H F=H= >JA @ I AIJ=@ I =JE C LAEI HAFHA
=F E?=@= F EI AIJ= E ? KE K = ? IA J=@ I FA = AIJHKJKH= @A
,, HAFHAIA J=@ FA = .ECKH= $ =F E?= @=I HACH=I @A HA@K
=FHAIA J= IA A
IK= B H = ?= AI
E?= F EI =F I =
= AIJHKJKH= FAH = A?A ?

1 E?E= LA .E = ,,
AH @A AIJ=@ I
LA
.ECKH= $ -IJHKJKH=
,, 4AIK J= JA
) =F E?= AH=@ K =
@=I HACH=I @A HA@K
@ 455 ?
JE = AJ=F= @ = C HEJ =L= E=H IA = E ? KI
=E @= ?
IE@ =EI =
ANFAHE A J E E?E= .KJKH I AIJK@ I F @A FHE ?EF= @ = C HEJ @AF EI @ ?
@= AJ=F= @A HA@K
= @ B H E D= " JH=HE= >A AB ?E I =@E?E
"!
15- ,) +
2 -:1,),- ,
) / 416
#! 6= E@ E= F @A LEH = A D H=H +=>A
= C HEJ
H?
IK
@A
HE= @KH= JA = CAH= @KH= JA K = =L= E= HE= ?
@AIA FA D @ = C HEJ I= EA J=H GKA = E ? KI ? = IK K @A @AJAH E =H IA =E H @A +27 J= >
=I @A GK= GKAH B H = @=I HACH=I @A HA@K 2 HJ= J A C= D @A
B E ANF H=@= F H AIJA AIJK@
F FHE ?EF= F @AH HAFHAIA J=H K @A ?KIJ >A AB ?E B= IA IA A?AII HE IK @A +27 ?
F=H=@ = =K A J @ ?
FA I=H
"! )
EIA @= +
F ANE@=@A @ ) C HEJ
) = J=
EIA @= ?
F ANE@=@A @A K
= C HEJ
HABAHA IA = JA F @A ANA?K ) C HEJ
GKA
AI @ AIF=
=FHAIA J= F=H= HA= E = GKA HAFHAIA J= =
@= J=HAB= FH F IJ=
IAH =GKE =L= E=@ =JH=L I @=
=E H CH= @A = GKA AIJA F @AH =IIK EH @KH= JA = CAH=
@A AIJ=@ I =JE C LA F=H= 5) *=IE?= A JA F=HJA ) C HEJ =FHAIA J=@= FA ) C HEJ ) C HEJ ? F IJ @A JH I CH= @AI AJ=F=I = IAHA =L= E=@=I ) FHE AEH= = FHE ?EF= @ 2 @A IA @= ,,
=FHAIA J=@= = E D= A HABAHA IA = CAH=
@A AIJ=@ I Cd(e) A Cq (e) @AJ= D=@= A JA = J= > @A HA@K @ALA IAH ? @= AIJHKJKH= @A IE@AH=@
! ) IACK @= AJ=F= E F HJ= JA = IAH =L= E=@=
HAFHAIA J=@ A JHA =I E D=I ! A ! 2 H
,, HAFHAIA J=@ A JHA =I E D=I " A % @ ) C HEJ @E AH GKA AIJAI JH I CH= @A F=II I HAFHAIA J= J=HAB= @A CAH= F=H= AGK= B H = EI A =H = A = A J @ AIF= 5) 2 HJ= J = E@ E=
=I FHE ?EF=EI L=HE LAEI =II ?E=@=I = ANA?K @A AIJ=@ I =JE C LA A K = AIJHKJKH= @A =JA
?DAC=H IA = K = B H K =
JE?= ANFHAII= FA =
" =>=EN A GKA HAFHAIA J= = CH= @A = @A J=EI L=HE LAEI
N
@A x y A z HAFHAIA J= ?E=H @EHAJ= A JA
O

" KA
=I L=HE LAEI =II ?E=@=I = ?=@= K = @=I JH I AJ=F=I A GKA E
@AIA FA D @ = C HEJ HABAHA IA = ) C HEJ E KA ?E=H ! )L= E= @ IA IAK @AIA FA D AI ?
) FHE AEH= F=HJA E D= @ ) C HEJ ? ? KE IA GKA JH I IK> AJ=F=I I
E F HJ= JAI A F @A
#"
+)2 67
"
)2 1+) ,
,1)/4) )5 ,- ,-+15
7 61 8)
4),) 2)4) 5)
= @ B H = ALA J A =FHAIA J=@ F HJ= J E LA e HAFHAIA J= AIJA B=J H ) @EII ?
= E D= A K AH= J @ I I ALA J I ANEIJA JAI
=KJ
=J
AH @A ALA J I AIJ @EHAJ= A JA =II ?E=@ = ?
F ANE@=@A =GKE =L= E=@= ) L=H
= @ B HE J
=FHAIA J=@ FA = E D= = C HEJ
J= >
KA ?E=H @EHAJ=
A JA = CH= @A = =FHAIA J=@= FA GKA HAFHAIA J= FH FHE= A JA .E = ?K I - J ? @ ?
-IJA B=J H IAH HAFHAIA J=@ FA = L=HE LA N
AH @A =KJ
=J I @ IEIJA =
F ANE@=@A @A ANA I ,,I E E?E=EI ?E= @ @A
A JA AIJ= FHE AEH= AJ=F= J= >
AIJ @EHAJ= A JA =II ?E=@= = ? AII= B=IA IAG
K J @A E IJHK AI HAFHAIA J=@ I FA =I E D=I ! = $ =E H =GKE HAFHAIA J=@= FA
IJHK @ I =JH=L I @= =JHE>KE = CH= @A = @A H@A
@A AIJ=@ I D=>E EJ=@ HAI A AIJ=@ I ?
AH
NE
@A AIJ=@ I @A J @ I
I =KJ
6 = C HEJ
=J I @
IA A J ?
@A
-IJA =IFA?J IAH =GKE HAFHAIA J=@ FA = L=HE LA =JA JE?= GKA HAFHAIA J= = ? F ANE@=@A @
= FHE AEH= F=H?A = @= B H K = "
B H A = AGK=
e
O
= IAG

FHE ?EF= @ ) C HEJ ?E= AIJA ?=I = > I ,,I JAH ? @ I? A?AII HE
" HAFHAIA J=@ + ? KE IA ,, GKA
) IACK @= F=H?A = = IAH =L= E=@= @E HAIFAEJ = FA =I E D=I @A ! = ! AIJ=@ I ? A J HAFHAIA J= @E ? JH= ? = @ B H = 455 A =F E?= I AIJ=@ I ?
Cd(e) Cq (e) HABAHA ?E=@
= E D= $ JAIJ= J @ I I
GKA AIJA F=II AIJ @EHAJ= A JA =II ?E=@ =
=E H CH= @A = @=I AIJHKJKH=I @A
Cd(e) Cq (e) HAIFA?JEL= A JA
FE H ?=I
J= = D
NE
@
J
AH @A AIJ=@ I ANEIJA JAI

AH NE IA )E @= =
I =KJ
=J I @
@A
@A
2 HJ= J
IE@AH= @ GKA = L=HE LA K J I Cd(e) Cq (e)
HABAHA IA =
@A AIJ=@ I @
F=H= ?=@= K
B H = ALA J A E D= #
@A 2 HJ= J
B=?E
A JA E@A JE ?=@ ?
@EHAJ= A JA =II ?E=@
= ? IE@AH=@
AH @A ALA J I @
= L=HE LA e HAFHAIA J= AIJA =IFA?J = E =@ = E D= ! =E @= FHA?EI= IAH ? FE H ?=I
= @ HAFA=J K JE E E?E=@ AIJA ?=I
= E D= ! A
AH @A LA AI GKA AIJA =
IAH ANA?KJ=@ @AFA @AH
"!
15- ,) +
2 -:1,),- ,
) / 416
## - J =EI K = LA = L=HE LA e @ALA IAH
@
?
NE
IE@AH=@=
AH @A ALA J I ANEIJA JAI
@A
,AII= B H = ?DAC= IA = IACK @= F=H?A = @= B H K = HEJ ? B H A HAFHAIA J=@ A "!
=JA
JE?= F=H= ?
F ANE@=@A @ = C
e
= HAIF I B=J @A HA@K @= AIJHKJKH= B H E = A J @ IF
e2 2 J

" !
HABAHA ?E=@ FA =I E D=I @A " = $ @ ) C HEJ ,, HAIK J= JA A E E = @ I B=J HAI HA AL= JAI AIIA ?=I NE =@E?E @A ALA J I E =@=I = KA ?E=
I LA F H E@A JE ?=H I
@ I HAFAJE@ I @= AIJHKJKH= @A JAEH I @A A ?=@A= A J
I =JH=L I @ HA@EHA?E F HJ= J
AH
NE
=
@A =KJ B HE J
=J I HAFHAIA J=@ FA = L=HE LA GKA @AJAH E = @A

)E @= AH ,, HAIK J= JA " " GKA J= >
L= H @A N F=H= ?
J= = D @=I AIJHKJKH=I @A HAFHAIA J=@ FA IAH AL=@= A ? HAFHAIA J= = AGK= J= ?
,, E E?E=EICd(e) Cq (e) GKA B H= = L=HE LA e AIJ J= > HA@K E@=
K J 455 - J = =E @=
@EHAJ= A JA =II ?E=@= A @ALA
B H A ANF E?EJ=@ FA = JAH?AEH= F=H?A = @= AGK=
e
.E = A JA
e2 2
e
" " "" )
A?AII HE HA@K EH IA =I CH= @A =I HAFAJE@=I =FHAIA J=@=I FA = AGK= AI =I IA I >HAF A IA @ A?AII HE ? IE@AH =I =EI @A K = LA
K = LA GKA =I JAH?AEH= F=H?A = A E E =@= A @ALA = C HEJ 2 H IAH
e
AIJ A >KJE@= = FHE AEH= F=H?A = @= AGK=

+DAC= IA F HJ= J = AGK= HAFHAIA J=@= FA = AGK= "#
" " A F HJ= J F @A IAH F ANE@=@A @
= FHE AEH= A IACK @= F=H?A =I HAFHAIA J=
CH= @A =I @A H@A I @EBAHA JAI
= JE@=I
= GKA HAFHAIA J= = ?
=GKE AIJK@=@
e
+ K NE IE@AH= AI AH @A =KJ $ LA AI ? =EI = HAIFAEJ @= AGK= =J I @ >H=H B H A AGK=
e2 2
" # I= EA J= GKA A ?=I
" # AH @A AIJ=@ I
JA F @A ANA?K
@ = C HEJ
F @AH =K A J=H A
" $ HAFHAIA J=@= =>=EN
(2e)2 (2)2
4e2 42
16e2 .2
" $
#$
+)2 67
"
)2 1+) ,
,1)/4) )5 ,- ,-+15
7 61 8)
4),) 2)4) 5)
" " 1 F A A J=
@ ) C HEJ
FH J JEF @ ) C HEJ
=GKE =FHAIA J=@ B E E F A A J=@ > IEIJ= J= > + =IIE ? A C= =@ A
>EJ @ CHKF 2-/ AIJK@ I @= AI AI = HA= @AIJA ,A A?= EI
2AHB H = ?A -L= K=JE @A E JAHAIIA ) E CK=CA B=J HABAHE I = AIJA ? 5) =E @= ANEIJA JA A
/H KF F H K @A FH CH= = K FH J JEF B E ? >AHJ
B E KJE E =@= F=H= = E F A A J= @ KI @A BK
F EI = E F A A J=
GKAIJ AI HABAHA JAI = FAHB H = ?A @A JAIJAI = @A =CA @A LAHE ?=H = ? HHA I FH NE I
) E F A A J= JK@A @ = C HEJ
@AIJA FHE AEH FH J JEF LEI= = HA= E = =GKE FH F IJ =JH=L I @A ANA F I @A J= > F=H= FAH EJA = HA= E = A D H=@=I @E A ? @=I J ? E?=I IAG IJH K ?
=FHAIA J=@ I ,A B=J
+=F JK I -IJ= FHE AEH= LAHI
@A = CK I JAIJAI @A FAHB H = ?A = I=>E@ =JH=L I @ I A= A I +=F JK HE= @KH= JA A D HE= @A J= ,, A 8AJ H @A * IK EH >=IJ= JA
@A E@A JE ?=H F II LAEI HA=I = IAHA JAIJAI HA= E =@ I F=H= ABAEJ I @A ? # GKA = AJ=F= @A CAH= ) C HEJ ANA?K AJ=F= -IJA +=F JK F=H= B H = EI =FHAIA J K @A @A =CA ) C HEJ 5) F @A IAH @ = C HEJ @ I AIJ=@ I ? +=F JK
= C HEJ
?E= FHE AEH= AJ=F= E F IJ= FA
A D H=@= K = LA GKA @A
% HABAHA ?E= K = F II LA = JAH =JEL= F=H=
?=F= @A CAH=H A =H = A =H AIF= )E @= = = EIA @= ? KA ?E= I +=F JK I EH @A =CA = JA F @A ANA?K KJE E =H
@A AIJ=@ I =JE C LA HAGKAHE@ @KH= JA
F ANE@=@A @AIJA B E =L= E=@= ? FH J JEF E F A A J=@ = E K ?E= @= H@A @ I
E JKEJ @A @AJAH E =H GK=EI =I L=HE LAEI GKA E = HA= E = F=H= HA= E = FH F IJ IA = ? =KJ =J I ? @= J=HAB= FH F IJ= FH L=@= =? F=?J= I FH NE @A JAIJAI @A ANA F I @A
@A GKA = ? HHAJK@A @ = C HEJ IAH =FHAIA J=@ I
)E @= ANFAHE A J I GKA @AJAH E = @= AIJHKJKH= @A ,, J= >
#%
# +
F=H=JEL A JHA
K A
,, A 8AJ H @A *
? F=H=JEL @ C=IJ @A @A =CA I
A=
A
I
HE= F=H= =I J ? E?=I ,,
)FHAIA J= IA AIIA ?=F JK A 8AJ H @A * HA =JEL=I = ? A= IK = @A
I -NA F I @A
=FHAIA J=@ I AIJ=>A A?A @ IA ?
? KI AI
HE= F=H= = >=I J ? E?=I
# -NA F I @A
@A =CA
-IJ= IA 255 @A ? A
=FHAIA J= @ELAHI I ANA F I 5) @A I 5) ? 455 HA@K E@ I A
@A =@ I ? A= I?
,, ) E@ E= HA = = ?
EH =K A J= @ IK = @A
HAI GKA # =
@A AIJ=>A A?AH IA K
F=H=JEL A JHA =I J ? E?=I @A
,, A 8AJ H @A *
HE= F=H= =H = A =H IA I AIJ=@ I =JE C LAEI
,A B=J @A A ? I I A
= A=
@A AIJ=>A A?AH IA K
F=H=JEL @ C=IJ @A A=
HE= F=H= ?= ?K =@ ? ?
KI @A IK IK ,,
,, = = @A >OJAI @ @=
A 8AJ H @A *
I FHE AEH= A JA A?AIIEJ= IA A JA @AH ? ?=I @ 8AJ H @A * AIF= @A AIJ=@ I FH @KJ @ L= H @A K @A
HE= F=H= = > I A =FA =I K
I F=H= ?= ?K =H IA
HE= >=IJ= @ELE@EH IA
F H & A >H= @ IA GKA AIJA ?=I @= J ? E?= =EI F JAEH I @A A ?=@A= @A ?=@= A JA @E
>EJ F=H= =H = A =H ?=@= F II LA AIJ=@ @ @= AIJHKJKH= @ J=>E E = @ K
KJE E =@ I F=H= =H = A =H A J @A " >OJAI ?=@= ?
J J= @A >OJAI F=H= =H = A =CA *=IE?= A JA ?=@= I @ I LE E D I = @
AIJHKJKH= @A
,, ) .ECKH= % ANE>A = AIJHKJKH= @A K @A A HE= =GKE HABAHE@ A ?=@A= A J ?
,, F=H= B=?E EJ=H =@ A =>=EN
A J @ ? ?K
A?AIIEJ= =H = A =H K
L= H E JAEH @A 0 = N A
,AII= B H = =I B H K =I = IACKEH HAFHAIA J= F=H= ?=@= K = @=I J ? E?=I
?= ?K =H IA
IK
= @A
HE=
#&
+)2 67
2)4)618
- 64-
,, - 8-6 4 ,- *
-)
4 bytes 2 bytes
x
4 bytes
Total = 10 bytes por nodo
.ECKH= % -IJHKJKH= @A K
,,
HE= 8AJ H * A=
I = [P SS 8] bytes
HE=
,, = [ K
@ I
,, 10] bytes
#
@A I 5)
@A I 5) ALA J I IE ?H @A A & ALA J I IA J= K
A IA
IA
JE?= GKA L=HE= =FHAIA J=@ I AII= IK>IA
AH @A =KJ
=J I A
K J @A
E = JAI A 5) ?=EI
?=EI I
=FHAIA J=@ FA = .ECKH= & F IIKE " =KJ 255 @ @ I =FHAIA J=@ FA = .ECKH= ! F IIKE # =KJ ?= 255 @ @A K @ I F K? =E H F H @A FAGKA
=J I $ ALA J I IE ?H
E = JAI
=FA =I & AIJ=@ I A ?
" AIJ=@ I C >=EI
=JE C LAEI 455 ) AIJHKJKH= J J= @A % @A 5)
,, CAH=@= FA = J ? E?= AIJ =FHAIA J=@= FA = .ECKH= ' A =FHA
=J I % ALA J I IE ?H =E @= ?
E = JAI A
=FA =I ALA J
IE@AH=@ FAGKA
# AIJ=@ I A AIJ=@ I C >=EI =JE C LAEI 455 ) AIJHKJKH= =FHAIA J=@= FA = .ECKH= ! A F IIKE ' @A 5) ! 2=HAI @A )KJ
,, CAH=@= FA = J ? E?= AIJ
=J I .ECKH= ! @AI?HALA K
@A
$ =KJ
=J I
#
-:- 2
5 ,-
,- )/-
#'
(1)
(2)
0
s
2
0
l2 l4
l1
l3
s2 s 6 2 s1 s 5 1
s2 2 s1
(3)
(4)
0
s
5
0
l6 l8
l5
l7
s4 s 6 2 s3 s 5 1
s4 2 s3
.ECKH= &
@A
5)
.ECKH= '
,,
@A
5)
IA ? -IIA
J=N=I BK ?E K AIF= @A 5)
=EI ! ALA J I
?=EI A $ ALA J I IE ?H
E = JAI 7 ? K
@A
5)
F=?J
@A AIJ=@ I FH @KJ @A % ' AIJ=@ I F H F IIKE K = E JAH@AFA @
455 @A =FA =I & AIJ=@ I
?E= = I F=HAI ?
B H A ANF E?=@ =>=EN
=KJ =KJ =KJ
=J A(1) A A(2) F IIKA =J A(3) A A(4) F IIKA =J A(5) A A(6) F IIKA
ALA J I IE ?H ALA J I IE ?H ALA J I IE ?H
E = JAI s1 A s4 E = JAI s2 A s5 E = JAI s3 A s6
$
+)2 67
2)4)618
- 64-
,, - 8-6 4 ,- *
-)
(1)
(2)
0 s1 1 s8 s2
0 s7 1
(3)
A
s
1
(4)
A
s
1
(5)
4
l1 s
5
4
s
3
4
s
3
s s
5
l1
l1
0
s 5s 6 s 7s 8 s1s2 s3s 4
3
s8 s1s2 s4
2 s3
0
s 5s 6 s 7s 8
3
s8 s1s2 s4
2 s3
0
s 5s 6 s 7s 8
3
s8
2 s3
6s 7
6s 7
s5 s
s5 s
s1 s
s1 s
1 s1 s 2 s3 s 4
1 s1 s 2 s3 s 4
1 s 1 s 2 s3 s 4
.ECKH= !
@A
5)
.ECKH= !
,,
@A
5)
,, HAIK J= JA GKA HAFHAIA J= 455 @ @A 5)
@A
ANE>E@ FA = .ECKH= !! A F IIKE & =J I " ALA J I IE ?H
s1 s
s 5 s6 s 7 s 8
s 5 s6 s 7 s8
s 5 s6 s 7 s8
s5 s
6s 7
s4
" =FHAIA J=@ FA = .ECKH= !" F IIKE % =KJ ?= 255 @ @A >A =E H ?
s3s 4
s3s 4
@ I E = JAI
A =FA =I ALA J ! % AIJ=@ I ? J ? E?= F IIKE "$
F=H=@ = I ANA F I = JAHE HAI ,, CAH=@= FA =
=FA =I ' AIJ=@ I C >=EI =JE C LAEI 455 ) AIJHKJKH= @ I A AIJ =FHAIA J=@= FA = .ECKH= !# ? F=H=JEL @ I "
) 6=>A = " B= K
@A I =FHAIA J=@ I =J =GKE EIJ= @ @= AIGKAH@=
#
-:- 2
5 ,-
,- )/-
6EF
-LA J
6=N=
$
A(1)
0(1) l1 2(1) s4 s1 1(1) s4 2(2)
A(2)
0(2) s1 1(2) l2 l3 2(3)
A(3)
0(3) s2 1(3) s5
? ? ? ? ? ? IO IO IO IO IO IO
l1 l2 l3 l4 l5 l6 s1 s2 s3 s4 s5 s6
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
A
0 l4 2(4)
(4)
A
0 s2 1(4) s6 2(5) l5
(5)
A
0 s3 1(5) l6 2(6)
(6)
(4)
(5)
(6)
s3 1(6) s6
s5
.ECKH= ! 5)
-LA J I 5E ?H
=J I
.ECKH= !!
,,
2=HAI @A )KJ
=J I
F=H= @EHAEJ= I IACKE JAI @=@ I F=H= = J ? E?= ,, A ? IK
@A = @A
5) A
=L= E=@
255 @
@A
455 @ IK A= I
@A = @A A
FAH HE=
?A JK= @A AIJ=@ I C >=EI =JE C LAEI FAH?A JK= @A 455 I > 255 ?
HE= F=H= J ? E?= 8AJ H @A *
>IAHL= @ IA = 6=>A = " LAHE ?= IA GKA J= @ K J J @ A AL=@ @A ? IK = @ IA 255 5)
@A I 5)
255 FAGKA ,, ?
AI
=FHAIA
AH @A AIJ=@ I E =JE C LAEI = J ? E?= = @A A HE= @= J ? E?= ,,
FA I= 2 H ANA F FAH?A JK= @A @A # =E H J H
! GKA F IIKE =FA =I " @A AIJ=@ I =JE C LAEI I > =E @= A
+)2 67
2)4)618
- 64A 7
,, - 8-6 4 ,- *
(3)
-)
s7 6
s
(1)
(2)
l1
10
0 s1 1 s8 s2
0 s1 s7 1
0 s14
s10
s s
2
5
s5
4
s 11
13
s12 2 3 s3 A
(5)
s4
A 7
l1
(4)
s7 6
s
s
10
s7 7
l1
s
10
0
s10
5 s1 s14
s5
0 s14
s10
s s
2
5
s5
s14
s14
s5
s10
s
s10
1
s
s
2
4
s 11
1
s
4
s 11
13
13
s12 2 s3 3
s4
s12 2 s3 3
s4
.ECKH= !"
@A
5)
"
6=>A = " +
F=H=JEL A JHA
,, A 8AJ H @A *
A=
@A 5) 5) 5) 5) ! "
255 & # % ' ! %
455 " & '
455 # " $
,, & >OJAI ' >OJAI & >OJAI "$ >OJAI
8AJ H @A * >OJAI $! >OJAI ' >OJAI
s5
s1 1 s1
s s
2
4
s 11
4
s 11
13
13
s12 2 s3 3
s4
s12 2 s3 3
s4
(6)
A s7
(7)
s7 6
s
s
10
7
l1
7
l1
6
s
s
10
5 s1
A=
$ !&" >OJAI
2 H
IE@AH= @ A
@A
5)
" E= @A
@A A
255
F K?
=E H A ,,
AH @A AIJ=@ I
=JE C LAEI
H GKA = A?
HE= KJE E = @ IA
@A ?AH?= @A '%
#
-:- 2
5 ,-
,- )/-
$!
.ECKH= !#
,,
@A
5)
"
100000 Metodo MDD Metodo Vetor de Booleanos
10000 Consumo de Memoria
1000
100
10 10 100 1000 10000 100000 1e+006 Tamanho do PSS
.ECKH= !$ +
F=H=
@ +
IK
@A
HE= F=H=
@A I 5)
@ELAHI I
/H @ I =?E = FAGKA
? !$ J= > A ?EA JA
HAFHAIA J= AI
? @A
F=H=JEL @A KI @A F IIKE @ K
HE= F=H= I ANA F I 5) @A I 5) ? AIF=
A ?E
L= A JA FAH?A>A IA GKA
,, F=H=
@A AIJ=@ I
CH= @A FAH?A JK= @A AIJ=@ I E =JE C LAEI
JE K= @ = ? AJ= @A @=@ I F=H=
AIJ=>A A?E A J @ ?
F=H=JEL A JHA =I J ? E?=I
$" =L= E= IA = IACKEH A 455
+)2 67
2)4)618
- 64-
,, - 8-6 4 ,- *
-)
? IIE?
@A
= J=H @ I .E I B I I B I=
F=HJE?K =H = =L= E=
@AIJA
FAH EJA =K A J=H IA
AH @A
@A L=HE=H IA >=IJ= JA I L= HAI F=H= 255 A
? IIE? =@ ?
@A
= J=H @ I .E I B I = F = A JA ?EJ=@ =EI K L =KJ =EI ? =J I =@E?E
= EJAH=JKH= 5) L 5) =@ I = @A @A
& B E =L= E =@ !
L= HAI @A ! " # $ % & ' A E = JAI
I B I ) ?=@=
I B =@E?E
L I ALA J I IE ?H
=K A J= @ IA
@AII= B H = =I L=HE LAEI GKA JH= A
F ANE@=@A = AIIA
?=I @A ! .ECKH= !% =KJ @A =J ?
I B I
@A
5)
F IIKE ' ALA J I IE ?H KI @ C=HB ? GKA =
E = JAI A AIJ ANE>E@ FA = @EHAEJ= A AIGKAH@= -
I KC=HAI D A E HAFHAIA J= I AIJ=@ I U A L HAFHAIA J= FHE AEH C=HB ? A JHA A I B FAC= =
HA?KHI C=HB AIJ A =
U so K Livre
AIF=
@A AIJ=@ I FH @KJ =IIK A GKA IEIJA = GKA I KJH I FAC= F=H= GKA C=HB
HAFHAIA J=@ F H $ AIJ=@ I ? C=HB ? -IJA @A
=FA =I AIJ=@ I =JE C LAEI 455 -IIA AIGKAH@= FHE AEH= A JA A GK= J F HJ= A J =IIE JHE? A?AII HE @A KI @ HA?KHI
@EHAEJ= 6= ?
@A=@ ?
HAFHAIA J= = HAIJHE
P
s3
1 4
P
s6 s s
7
P
s9
s2
s5
s8
L s3 s 6 U s 1 s4
L s6 s 9 U s5 s7
L s 3 s9 U s2 s8
.ECKH= !% = J=H @ I .E I B I
,, HAIK J= JA GKA HAFHAIA J= @ I F=H= =H = A =H 455
455 @
@A
ANE>E@ FA = .ECKH= !& A HAGKAH !
#
-:- 2
5 ,-
,- )/-
$#
.ECKH= !&
,, 4AIK J= JA F=H=
@A
= J=H @ I ! .E I B I
) 6=>A = # =FHAIA J= @A * @A A= ,, @A A= I F=H= IJH= IA AH @A 8AJ H @A * GKAIJ FH @KJ ? /H ? IK @A GKA 5)
? @A
F=H=JEL @ C=IJ @A 5) ?
HE= F=H= =I J ? E?=I @A I B I E BAHE H ? AIF=
,, A 8AJ H + B H A J @ F=H=@ = @A A @A AIJ=@ I
! " # $ % & ' A C=IJ @A A HE= >A
I B I =K A J= ? I ,A B=J
IAG A JA ?HAI?E A J @ 255 A @E E KE
@ 455
=EI A ?EA JA JA @ K CH= @A
AIIA C= D @ IA FHE ?EF=
A JA FA = ?=H=?JAH IJE?= @
=FHAIA J=H K IE@AH=LA ? !' J= > = @A @ I A
AH @A AIJ=@ I E =JE C LAEI =F E?=@ I = K
A JA A AL=@ HAFHAIA J= HE= = > I A ? F=H=JEL @A @A A HE= F=H= ANA F @ I I B I? ,, F=H= L= H >=EN EIA ? ? KE
J @ I -IJA @A
IJH= = A ?E
?E= @ KI @A 255 -IJ= = = @A I B I JAIJ=@ A
I B II
A JA GK= @
=FHAIA J= K AH @A I B I
255 CH= @A A K
@A AIJ=@ I =JE C LAEI IA FHA 255 ? = A? ?
H GKA @ J J= =FHAIA J=@ FA =EI ) A? =E H HE= ?= A E= @ ? AH @A A= I IK
C= D ABAJEL @= J ? E?= E E?E= IA ? ?AH?= @A "$ $#$ AIJ=@ I K J H IK @A # + = @A E= @ ? A IE@AH= @
=E H K ECK= = $ GKA F IIKE HE= F=H= $ ,, GKA B E @A
I B I AIJ A
'' %' # >OJAI C=IJ I FA = J ? E?=
JH= % '% %' >OJAI C=IJ I FA = J ? E?= 8AJ H @A *
$$
6=>A = # + IK
+)2 67
2)4)618
- 64-
,, - 8-6 4 ,- *
-)
@A
HE= F=H=
@A
= J=H @ I .E I B I
.E I B I ! " # $ % & '
255 $ '$ % %%$ "$ $#$ %' '!$ $%' $$ %% $'$ $ "$$ %$ !$ %'% #$ %$ %& !!$
455 ' % $' "& '&# !%& # %" ! &$ !! "$
455 # # ! ' ! # $ ! ' "
,, ! >OJAI $# >OJAI !# >OJAI %# >OJAI # ## >OJAI # >OJAI !# >OJAI "" %# >OJAI &' '# >OJAI %' # >OJAI
8AJ H @A * % >OJAI
A=
$ >OJAI '% >OJAI # &! >OJAI !" '' >OJAI ' '# >OJAI #' % >OJAI % ##& % >OJAI "# !"' $! >OJAI % '% %' >OJAI
1e+009 Metodo MDD Metodo Vetor de Booleanos 1e+008
1e+007 Consumo de Memoria
1e+006
100000
10000
1000
100
10 1 2 4 Numero de Filosofos 8
.ECKH= !' +
F=H=
@ +
IK
@A
HE= F=H=
@A
= J=H @ I .E I B I
FH NE @A FH ?AII I A 255 A 455
@A
5)
=FHAIA J=@
@A
@A +
F=HJE D= A J @A 4A?KHI I -IJA @A =GKE =L= E=@ F IIKE $ @EBAHA JAI L= HAI @A
HAFHAIA J= N FH ?AII I ?
F=HJE D= @ R HA?KHI I
AH @A HA?KHI I IAH L=HE=@ @A
= $ ANAH?EJ= @ IA =IIE
? ?
K J @A =KJ =KJ
=J I GKA HAFHAIA J=
@A
@A +
F=HJE D= A J @A 4A?KHI I =J GKA ? JH = AH @A
F IJ F H K
=J F=H= ?=@= FH ?AII A KJH =KJ
#
-:- 2
5 ,-
,- )/-
$% AIJ=@ I GKA HAFHAIA J= F=HJE D=@ I JAHA HA?KHI A =KJ KI A HAIFA?JE I ! AIJ= HA?KHI I
HA?KHI I
=KJ
=J GKA HAFHAIA J= I FH ?AII I F IIKE =KJ ?=I @A F=HJE D=@
L= A JA Ocioso (Sleep) A Em U so (U sing ) AIJ=@ F=H= ?=@= HA?KHI ? A KI -LA J I IE ?H E = JAI rn E>AH= @ I R0 R1 R2 GKA HAFHAIA J=
=J GKA HAFHAIA J= I HA?KHI I F IIKE K HA?KHI I ? KI
HAIFA?JEL= A JA HA?KHI I A
E = JAI an A JHA I =KJ HA?KHI I A
=J I @A FH ?AII I A
=J @A HA?KHI I I FH ?AII I F=I A AIJK@
= ?=
IE ?H I=
HA?KHI I GK= @ K
FH ?AII F=II= @ AIJ=@ Ocioso F=H= KI GK= @ =KJ @A
AIJ=@ Em U so -LA J I
=J I GKA HAFHAIA J=
@ AIJ=@ Em U so F=H= Ocioso ) .ECKH= " ANE>A
5) F=H= ANA F
(1)
(2)
(16)
S a1 U r1 a2
S r2 U
....
a16 U
r16
a1, a2, ...a16
a1, a2, ...a16
a1, a2, ...a16
R0 r1, r2, ... r16
R1 r1, r2, ... r16
R2
....
r1, r2, ... r16
Rn
.ECKH= " +
) 6=>A = $ =FHAIA J= @A * A= I F=H= AH @A HA?KHI I F=H= + ? @ AIF= B H A J @ @A @A A
? @A
F=H=JEL @ C=IJ @A @A ? ! " # $ HA?KHI I ?
HE= F=H= =I J ? E?=I @A ) @EII
,, A 8AJ H
F=HJE D= A J @A HA?KHI I ? F=HJE D=@ I
$ FH ?AII I L=HE= @ IA AIJ= =FHAIA J= @ 455 E BAHE H CKH= AI JAIJ=@=I
I L= HAI @A 255 A 455 A FAH?A JK= @A 455 I > 255 F=H= J @=I =I ? AH @A HA?KHI I =K A J= ? ,, @A GKAIJ IJH= IA A= I ,A B=J =EI A ?EA JA JA @ K CH= @A C=IJ @A A
IAG A JA =K A J @ 255 A @E E KE HE= IA FHA >A AIIA C= D @ IA FHE ?EF= ANA F
F=H=@ = 8AJ H @A *
A JA FA = ?=H=?JAH IJE?= I B I
=FHAIA J=H K
AH @A AIJ=@ I E =JE C LAEI =F E?=@ I = K = JAHE H @ I
@A AIJ=@ I FH @KJ CH= @A @=
AI = B H = GKA
$&
6=>A = $ + IK
+)2 67
2)4)618
- 64-
,, - 8-6 4 ,- *
-)
@A
HE= F=H=
@A
4A?KHI I
255 $ ""
455 !% $'% #% $ &&# " &'! HAFHAIA J= IK @A = @A = @A 5) A ?
455 # # #
,, %' >OJAI % >OJAI !! >OJAI #% >OJAI %' >OJAI ANA F
8AJ H @A *
A=
! %$& >OJAI "' # >OJAI $# #!$ >OJAI & ' >OJAI '& !" >OJAI @ ? F=HJE D= A J @A IJH= = A ?E ?E= C= D 8AJ H @A
! " # $ /H @ KI @A NE ? * A=
!'! $ # " && $## !$ %&$ "! ? " J= > ? ,, F=H= AIJA ? IK
F=H=JEL F=H= A HE= = > I
HA?KHI I @AIJ=?= @ IA @ F=H= I?
J @ I -IJA @A J @ ,, >JALA K
F=H= J @ I I L= HAI @A HA?KHI I JAIJ=@ I HE= F=H= = > I ,, J @ I '& !" >OJAI F=H=
AH @A HA?KHI I $ = GK=
C= D @A '&
F=H= @ IA
JH= =FA =I %' >OJAI F=H= = J ? E?=
100000 Metodo MDD Metodo Vetor de Booleanos
Consumo de Memoria
10000
1000
100 1 2 4 Numero de Recursos Compartilhados 8
.ECKH= " +
F=H=
@ +
IK
@A
HE= F=H=
@A
-IJA ?=F JK * A= IA IA J=@ I ?
=FHAIA J K K = I HEA @A IK
@A I 5) = @A
=L= E=@ I FA =I J ? E?=I @A 8AJ H @A A HE= )L= E= @ I @A I =FHA A= I ,, I > = J ? E?= 8AJ H @A *
,, = GKA @E HAIFAEJ = ? IJ=J K IA GKA @A I 5) ? K
C= D ABAJEL @= J ? E?= @A FAH?A JK=
AIJ =II ?E=@ =
KEJ >=EN @A AIJ=@ I =JE C LAEI K J= A JA
#
-:- 2
5 ,-
,- )/-
$' @A AIJ=@ I FH @KJ ? KI @= J ? E?= @A =E HE= A K IE@AH=LA A JA CH= @A 8AHE ? K IA ? >E = IJEJKE IA F H IE @A @K=I E I @A F=H= =?
@A I GKA =FHAIA JA ?E= @A K
AIF=
GKA =FA =I = ANEIJ
A AL=@
AH @A AIJ=@ I E =JE C LAEI ,, ,A B=J
I ?=H=?JAH IJE?= E @E?=JEL= F=H= F HJ= JAI ?=H=?JAH IJE?=I GKA I F K? I A @A @A ,, AIJHKJKH= @A A H GKA F=H= = E
A AL=@ FAH?A JK= @A AIJ=@ I E =JE C LAEI A
A AL=@ J= = D @A 255 L=HE= @A =? H@ ? = L=HE= )E @= ? @A H@A I @ I =KJ +=F JK =J I =
@A % %%$ AIJ=@ I I I +=F JK I EH KA ?E= = ? ,, E
FHAHH C=JEL=I @AJAH E = JAI F=H= = AI? D= @= J ? E?= ANF H=H ? @AIJ= = JH= =I FHE ?EF=EI
I FH NE
F=?J=
? => H= AI =FHAIA J=@=I FA
FHAIA JA JH=>= D =IIE
IKCAIJ AI @A JH=>= D I BKJKH I
%
+)2 67
2)4)618
- 64-
,, - 8-6 4 ,- *
-)
%
$ )
EIA @ 4A H@A = A J @ I )KJ

? = H@A AH @A @EIF IE = @A
=J I
@ I =KJ =J I I LAEI @= AIJHK = CK I @A I
)FHAIA J= IA AIJA ?=F JK JKH= @A 5) B H= ,, F @A E KA ?E=H JAIJ=@ I A =I ?
@ I HAIK J= JAI 2=H= J= J
? KI AI I
=GKE =FHAIA J=@=I
$ -NA F I @A
@A =CA
2=H= ANA?K ) C HEJ @A
@ I JAIJAI @A H@A JA = AIJHKJKH=
B H= ,,
AI? DE@ I = CK I =EI ?
@A I 5)
A JAIJ=@ I ? @A @AJAH E =H IA 455 @
E F A A J=@
8 HE=I H@A I ANEIJA JAI B H=
ANF H=@=I =
K = DAKH IJE?= GKA =F
F=?J= F II LA GKA HAFHAIA JA
HAIK J=@ @ I JAIJAI =F @A IE ?H ,, IAHE=
J= GKA K = > = H@A
F=H= @EIF IE
@ I =KJ
=J I = AIJHKJKH=
= JAH I =KJ
=J I GKA J
E JAH@AFA @
?E= I
?E=
=KJ
=EI FAHJ F II LA
=J I GKA F IIKA
LAEI
@= AIJHKJKH= )KJ
=J I GKA F IIKA ?E=I BK ?E
E JAH@AFA @ =EI A JHA IE
ALA J I
E = JAI K @AFA @
*=IE?= A JA JH I ? >E = @A H@A HA@K ) C HEJ GKA HAIK J= A
@A I 5)
B H= AH @A
JAIJ=@ I A =L= E=@ I =I IACKE JAI ? AH @A A ? @ I =F I = =F E?= AH = @A @ I
@E AI F=H= ?=@= @= AJ=F= @A @A H@A A H AH
FH F IJ= =L= E K IA
@ I = JAI @= =F E?= JH=H GK= = ? A HA? >E =

K
NE
A .E =
,, =EI ?
@= AJ=F= @=I HACH=I @A HA@K
> AJEL @AIIA JAIJA F=?J
@A HA@K AI A?AII HE=I K
.E =
NE
FHE AEH ANA F
.ECKH= ! @AI?HALA K
@A
$ =KJ
=J I IA
J=N=I BK ?E
=EI
% ! ALA J I
+)2 67
15- ,
4- 4,- ) - 6
, 5 )76
)6 5
?=EI A $ ALA J I IE ?H
E = JAI 7 ? K
@A
5)
? = IA
F=?J
AIF= @A
@A AI 5)
J=@ I FH @KJ @A % ' AIJ=@ I F H F IIKE K = E JAH@AFA @
455 @A =FA =I & AIJ=@ I -IIA = JAHE H #
?E= = I F=HAI ?
B H A ANF E?=@
6=>A = % -NA F
@A -LA J I 5E ?H
=J I
H@A
=N %' &! &! $& ! ! # " 455 &
= & & & " ! ! " " " "
A(1) A(2) A(3) A(4) A(5) A(6) A(3) A(4) A(1) A(2) A(5) A(6) A(3) A(4) A(5) A(6) A(1) A(2) A(5) A(2) A(6) A(1) A(3) A(4) A(3) A(5) A(6) A(1) A(4) A(2) A(3) A(5) A(4) A(1) A(6) A(2) A(3) A(1) A(5) A(2) A(6) A(4) A(1) A(3) A(5) A(6) A(2) A(4) A(3) A(1) A(5) A(2) A(4) A(6) A(3) A(2) A(5) A(4) A(1) A(6)
255 % ' )L= E= @ I =GKA =I A I F IJ=I
AH .E = @A
GKA = E JAH@AFA @ LAEI @= AIJHKJKH= @A
@ I CAH=@ I 6=>A = % LAHE ?= IA GKA =I ?E= A JHA I F=HAI @A =KJ =J I AIJ ,, F=HAI A(1) A(2) A(3) A(4) A A(5) A(6)
A D HAI H@A I
=FH NE =@= A JA @EI
AH .E =
&
IACK @ ANA F BK ?E ? =EI ' ALA J I =FHAIA J=@ .ECKH= " @AI?HALA K ?=EI A " ALA J I IE ?H AIF= =J I @ = .ECKH= " GK=JH =KJ E = JAI AIF= @A @A % =KJ =J I IA J=N=I @A
@A AIJ=@ I FH @KJ @
J=>E E = # AIJ=@ I A GK= J GKA B H A ANE>E@ I =KJ ?E= E @ELE@K= ? JE
@A AIJ=@ I =JE C LAEI 455 HAFHAIA J= =FA =I $" GKE J =KJ ?=EI L= A JA GKA =I =J I AIJ =FH =J A(5) F IIKE E JAH@A @A
AIJ=@ I + FA @ @ EI
AIJA ANA F
A(1) A(2) A(3) A A(4) A GK= J GKA I
=J I A(6) A A(7) F IIKA
=FA =I ALA J I
>IAHL= @ IA A D HAI H@A I I
AH .E = @A
=GKA =I A
@ I CAH=@ I 6=>A = & LAHE ?= IA ?E= A JHA I F=HAI @A =KJ
GKA = E JAH@AFA @
$
-:- 2
5 ,-
,- )/-
%!
E = JAI
6=>A = & -NA F
JEF I -LA J I 5E ?H
H@A
=N "$ $$ $ " # $ $ " #! % '& $ "
= # # # $ $ % % ' ' ' ' ' !!
A(1) A(2) A(5) A(3) A(4) A(6) A(7) A(6) A(1) A(2) A(5) A(3) A(4) A(7) A(6) A(7) A(1) A(2) A(5) A(3) A(4) A(1) A(2) A(3) A(5) A(4) A(6) A(7) A(1) A(5) A(2) A(3) A(4) A(6) A(7) A(1) A(2) A(5) A(3) A(6) A(4) A(7) A(6) A(1) A(7) A(2) A(5) A(3) A(4) A(1) A(2) A(3) A(4) A(5) A(6) A(7) A(5) A(1) A(2) A(3) A(4) A(6) A(7) A(1) A(2) A(5) A(6) A(3) A(4) A(7) A(1) A(6) A(2) A(5) A(3) A(7) A(4) A(6) A(1) A(2) A(7) A(5) A(3) A(4) A(1) A(2) A(6) A(5) A(7) A(3) A(4)
255 #
455 $"
A(1)
s1 l1 s1..s4 0
(5)
A(2)
s2 l2 s1..s4 1
(5)
A(3)
s3 l3 s1..s4 3
(5)
A(4)
s4 l4 s1..s4 5
(5)
(1)
(1)
(2)
(2)
(3)
(3)
(4)
1(4)
s1..s4 2
(5)
A(5)
4
(5)
s1..s4 s4 s2
s1..s4 6
(5)
7(5)
s2 s3
s1 s4
s3 s4
s2 s3 l5
s2 s1
A(6)
l6 l7 0
(6)
A(7)
l8 l9 1
(6)
(7)
1(7)
.ECKH= " -NA F
JEF I -LA J I 5E ?H
E = JAI
%" NE =@= A JA @EIF IJ=I E @AFA @A JA L= H @A # =BAJ=
+)2 67
15- ,
4- 4,- ) - 6
, 5 )76
)6 5
AH .E =
AH = @A FH NE I
# 6= >
AH
>IAHL= IA GKA = F IE ,, K IA = ? = @A
@ =KJ A
=J H
@ I @= AIJHKJKH=
J= J GKA I
F=HAI A(1) A(2) A A(3) A(4) AIJA =
@ I FAH = A?A ?
JAH?AEH A @A J=N=I ? 5) HAFHAIA J= %
JE
ANA F
=L= E=@ .ECKH= "!
L= A JA ?=EI A ?
? IIE?
@A =EI
= J=H @ I .E I B I E = JA 2 H ?=EI ? =FA =I = @A AA
@AIIA ANA F I B I ? AIF=
F IIKE A DK J=N=I BK ?E
ALA J IE ?H
" ALA J I
=EI % ALA J I I B FAC= =
IJ= JAI
@A AIJ=@ I FH @KJ @A
HAFHAIA J=@ F H &% AIJ=@ I ? FHE AEH A JHA A J=N=I BK ?E = ? C=HB ?
"& AIJ=@ I =JE C LAEI 455 -IIA ? F HJ= A J =IIE I =KJ =J I @ @A JHE? F IIKA
=IIK A GKA
C=HB ? -IJA
AIGKAH@= FHE AEH= A JA A GK= J GKA I KJH I FAC= A?AII HE F=H= GKA E JAH@AFA @ IEIJA = HAFHAIA J= = HAIJHE @A KI @ HA?KHI C=HB =FA =I ? ?E= BK ?E
@EHAEJ= 6=
@A=@ ?
=EI + =H= A JA J @ I
I IAKI @ EI LE E D I E A@E=J I
A(1)
A(2)
A(3)
A(4)
A(5)
A(6)
A(7)
T (1) gl1 r1 L(1) gr1 R(1)

? ? ? ? ? ? ?
T (2) gr2 r2 R(2) gl2 L(2) fgl1 fgr2 fgr3 fgr4 fgr5 fgr6 fgr7
? ? ? ? ? ? ?
T (3) gr3 r3 R(3) gl3 L(3) gr1 gl2 gl3 gl4 gl5 gl6 gl7 fgr1 fgl2 fgl3 fgl4 fgl5 fgl6 fgl7
? ? ? ? ? ? ?
T (4) gr4 r4 R(4) gl4 L(4) r1 r2 r3 r4 r5 r6 r7 r5
T (5) gr5 R(5) gl5 L(5) r6
T (6) gr6 R(6) gl6 L(6) r7
T (7) gr7 R(7) gl7 L(7)
6OFA -LA J 4=JA 6OFA -LA J 4=JA 6OFA -LA J 4=JA
gl1 gr2 gr3 gr4 gr5 gr6 gr7
fgl1 = (st A(2) == T (2)) fgr2 = (st A(1) == T (1)) fgr3 = (st A(2) ! = L(2)) fgr4 = (st A(3) ! = L(3)) fgr5 = (st A(4) ! = L(4)) fgr6 = (st A(5) ! = L(5)) fgr7 = (st A(6) ! = L(6))
fgr1 = (st A(7) ! = L(7)) fgl2 = (st A(3) == T (3)) fgl3 = (st A(4) == T (4)) fgl4 = (st A(5) == T (5)) fgl5 = (st A(6) == T (6)) fgl6 = (st A(7) == T (7)) fgl7 = (st A(1) ! = R(1))
.ECKH= "! -NA F
= J=H @ I .E I B I
=EI K = LA A JA GKA =I AIJ
>IAHL= @ IA
AH .E = @A
=GKA =I A
@ I CAH=@ I 6=>A = ' LAHE ?= IA ?E= A JHA I =KJ
L=
A D HAI H@A I I
GKA = E JAH@AFA @
=J I LE E D I @A H@A
@EIF IJ I =FH NE =@= A JA
AH .E =
"# 3K= GKAH KJH= @EIF IE
$
-:- 2
5 ,-
,- )/-
%#
6=>A = ' -NA F
= J=H @ I .E I B I
H@A
=N %$ %#% &!$ &!#
= "# #! & "
A(1) A(2) A(3) A(4) A(5) A(6) A(7) A(1) A(7) A(2) A(6) A(3) A(5) A(4) A(1) A(4) A(7) A(3) A(6) A(2) A(5) A(1) A(3) A(5) A(7) A(2) A(4) A(6)
255 =F E?=@= HAIK J K A J=@ I = JAI @= HA@K K = AIJHKJKH= @A NE &% ,,
455 "& KEJ FE H ? IE@AH= @ = > I .E = AH @A AI
A =F I = HA@K
%$
+)2 67
15- ,
4- 4,- ) - 6
, 5 )76
)6 5
%%
% +
IE@AH= AI .E =EI
= C HEJ F=H= =H = A = A J @ 455 F=H= @A 52 = KJE E = @A B H = EI 5)
-IJA AIJK@ =FHAIA J K K KJE E = @ = AIJHKJKH= @A .AHH= A J=I 52 ?E ? = = AIF= AH @A AIJ=@ I HAIA J=@ I &
,,
?=I @ B H = EI J @ I >=IA=@ I A ,, @A
@= AIJHKJKH= @A
,, F=H= =H = A = A J @ 455 GKA KJE E = @A AIJ=@ I I
IJH K IAH ? =H= A JA LE LA A L= J= I= % & AIJHKJKH=I @A @=@ I @A J= = D FH F H @A I A JHA =E HAI I NE
?=F= AI @A HAFHAIA J=H
104 A 106 &

@A I
J @ >=IA=@ A
IJH K IAH ?=F= @A HAFHAIA J=H
CH= @A = @A 9.18 10626 A =?HA@EJ= IA GKA
@A I =E @=
F II LAEI @A IAH HAF
= C HEJ IK K = A? A J H @A L=IJ E= A
=GKE FH F IJ F=H= A JA LE LA = A >A HE= = @A
B H = EI
@A 5)
@A +=F JK
IJH K =JH=L I @A ANA F I @A " @A 255 IJH=H= GKA ? =E HAI GKA 104 A ? 255 A J H @A
@A =CA I IAH ECK=
6AIJAI =FHAIA J=@ I A
E BAHE H F=H= ANA F @A @A ?
@A I GKA F IIKA @ I .E I B I
AH @A AIJ=@ I E =JE C LAEI ?AH?= @A HE= F=H=
I @A 1% @A AIJ=@ I =JE C LAEI ,A B=J I B I ? 255 @A 106 ? K
1010 B E IKFAHE H = 99% A F=H=

@A '&
F=HJE D= A J @A HA?KHI I ?
) ?
@EII
= >JA ? ?
@ 455 @ = @A E
@A @= BK
5)
IA
A?AIIEJ=H @= CAH= @A = @AIIA B H = EI
@ AIF= J= > ) J ? E?=
@A ,,
AIJ=@ I FH @KJ >A IE@AH=@ K = ANECA =FA =I GKA K
@A =JE CE>E E@=@A @ FKJ=?E
F @A IAH
A D HE= F=H=
JH=J= A J ?
K J @A AIJ=@ I E E?E=EI IA = E B H =@ = FHE HE
B=J @A = BAHH= A J= 2-25 HAGKAHAH K = GK= JE@=@A A AL=@= @A H= JA = =L= E= 5) = B=IA @A CAH= @= I K @ AIF= AIJ=?E HE= @ @A 2-25 GKA =L= E= =I FH >=>E E@=@AI @A FAH = @A AIJ=@ I =JE C LA @ ?E= @A
HE= @EIF @A K
LA @K @A @KH= JA =L= E=
IACK @= AJ=F= @= ANA?K
I AIJ=@ I C >=EI A AL K AIJA JH=>= D =
%& B H = @ ? IK @A A
+)2 67
51,-4)
-5 .1 )15
HE= KJE E =@ @KH= JA = ANA?K B ?=H= =FA =I ? IK J K IA GKA FE? @A @E
@ = C HEJ = @A A A? A
I JAIJAI =F E?=@ I @AIJA GKA = IA J= ?
= I ANA F I @A @ = C HEJ ) ? @EII IJEJKA
@A =CA
HE= F EI
CK @= AJ=F= @ 2-25 E E?E= 2 H FH F IJ ) C HEJ = HA= E = F ?=KI=I @AIIA FH > A = = AJ=F= @A CAH= IAH HA=L= E=@= ? JH=J=H IA @A FH F IJ= F=H= = HA@K
HE= C=IJ @KH= JA = ANA?K EIAI =F = IAG ?E= @AIJA = C HEJ FHE ?EF= @ALA ) > I JA =I ,, =GKE
F=HA?AK IAH A AL=@ @A AIJ=@ I ? @ KI @A A
2HE AEH=I =
@A HA@K AI @= AIJHKJKH= @A
,, =FA =I =F I HE= @KH= JA = CAH= B H=
F IIE>E E@=@AI @A JH=>= D I BKJKH I @A FAIGKEI= A GKA A D HE=I GKA E JAHBAHA = B H =E =
=GKE ANF H=@=I F H
@= ? HHAJK@A @= J ? E?=
) AJ=F= @A CAH= FH F A @A = AI I 7 = F II LA
@ I AIJ=@ I ? JE E =
@E AI A ?
IAG
?E=I =FHAIA J=@ FA E = JAI A
) C HEJ
=H = A = A J = FHE HE @A J @ I I AIJ=@ I (Cd (e) ) A (Cq (e) ) F=H= J @ I I ALA J I @ IAHE= =H = A =H I ALA J I IE ?H =J I AIJAI ? HHA @ ? CE?=I @ >A ? @A K = AIJHKJKH= -II=I E B H @EII AH @A =KJ K J I? A @E GK=EI =KJ IAKI AIJ=@ I HECA 5) F H ANA F @ I?
GKA E@A JE GKA A KJH= AIJHKJKH= ? =J I ALA J I @ AIF= A? FA IAG
A?AII HE=I F=H= @AJAH E = =I E B H = AI J F ?=EI @A
K J (Cd (e) ) A (Cq (e) ) = F IJAHE HE )
AH @A AIJ=@ I B= IA A?AII HE = >=I AIJHKJKH=I FAH EJEH EIA HA A@E= @ =IIE ? IK
,AII= B H = @KH= JA = ANF H= = CAH= AN?AIIEL @A HE= HAGKAHE@
=JE C LA @
?E= @KH= JA = =
IAK =JK= =H = A = A J = FHE HE
) HA@K " = % J= > A @A A
@A
@ I HAFAJE@ I = AIJHKJKH= @A F @A IAH HA=L= E=@= LEI= @ = @A
,, =FHAIA J=@ FA =
) C HEJ
E D=I FE? @A C= D
A D HE=I @A FAHB H = ?A 7 = E@ E= IAHE= HA @A LAHE ?=H IA ANF H= J= FHA EII= 6 @=LE= = =@E @ALA ?KE@=@ I= A JA =L= E=H IA K
= E =H ?E? I @A HA@K AI @KH= JA HE= @E E KEHE= ,A B=J = HE= ? @ I F=II I @A HA@K
FHE ?EF= @AIJA = C HEJ ,, F=H= 52 IK
FHE ?EF= @ ) C HEJ
F=H=@ = =K A J @ ?
@A +27 IAH L E@
) HA= A ?E =
?E= @ = C HEJ = C HEJ
=GKE FH F IJ =E @= AIJ
HA = @EIF
= GKAIEJ I @A FAHB H = ?A @A J @=I =I BK ?E LAEI -IFA?E ?= A JA = E@=@AI B H JH=J= A J
F @A =E @= IAH =L= E=@= ? A JA FH F IJ=I FA
F AJ= A JA F EI = E F A A J=
%' @EHAJ @A BK KJE E = IF JA ? AI J=N=I BK ?E =EI FH F IJ FA J=N=I BK ?E @ I =KJ ) C HEJ ! =E @= B E E F A A J=@ =EI F=H= =KJ B H = EI 5) I
ANA F I =GKE =FHAIA J=@ ? @= J ? E?= @A ? LAHI @A JAI IA ?
=EI B H= =J I ?
JH=J=@ I @A B H = E F ?EJ= =JH=L I @= J=N=I BK ?E =J I ? HHA @ = C HEJ A J=EI FHA
KI @A J=N=I BK ?E
=EI +=>A I= EA J=H GKA AIJ= FHE AEH= LAHI
> AJEL FH L=H IK= LE=>E E@=@A A ? HHAJK@A @A KI F=H= FH L=@=I =JH=L I @ I ANA F I @A
HH C=JEL=I B H= E F A A J=@
@A =CA I JAIJ=@ I =JH=L I @ FH J JEF
?HEJ HE @A H@A =FHAIA J=@ I IE ? I = AEH= +=F JK
GKA I =KJ $ +
=J I I
@EIF IJ I = AIJHKJKH= @A =J I GKA F IIKA IAH @EIF IJ I AIF=
,,
J= >
B=J H E F HJ= JA F=H= JE E = JH= IE AI IE ?H =EI ? F=?J=
@AIJ= -IJA B E ANAH?EJ=@ =JH=L I @A ANA F I @A IJ=J K IA GKA I =KJ E JAH@AFA @ =EI FH NE =EI @ALA
@A =CA I ?E= A JHA F II LA
E = JAI A J=N=I BK ?E ,, =
LAEI @= AIJHKJKH= @A
@A HAFHAIA J=H IA
@A AIJ=@ I =JE C LA @A K =
) ?
F ANE@=@A @ = C HEJ J= = D @ =KJ @ = C HEJ
FH F IJ B E ?KE@=@ I= A JA =L= E=@= A @A =J A ?=I NE ?=H AH J J= @A ALA J I @ AH @A ALA J I A $ LA AI =E H @A
IJH K GKA J=
JA F @A ANA?K JA = GKA I @A =E H CH= @A =
@AIJA AIJ GK=@H=JE?= A JA =II ?E=@ = @K=I E F HJ= JAI L=HE LAEI @ IEI )JH=L I @= FH L K IA GKA A AH @A =KJ =J I @ >H=H
JA F @A ANA?K
,A JHA @A =EI J FE? I @A E JAHAIIA ECK= IE@AH=@ I E JACH=@=I AI LAHI A D HE=I = C FH=
A JA L E@ I = IAHA
=FH BK @=@ I F H FH F IJ
? = BAHH= @ @=
F @A IA ?EJ=H = E JACH= +
@ = C HEJ
A J= 2-25 6 @=LE= IAHE= E JAHAII= JA GKA =I FH J JEF ANEIJA JA @ = C HEJ
A D HE=I =GKE A A ?=@=I IA = A D HE=I A ?
FHE AEH= A JA I E@=
IAG A JA A JA = FH F IJ= @A E ? KI
= BAHH= A J= 2-25 @=HE= IA =FA =I =F I AIJ= AJ=F= @A E @AFA @A JA
+ K = FH
B H A HAII= J=@ EII H= B B H = EI
KEJ =E @= FHA?EI= IAH BAEJ @A 5) GKA GK= @ ?
=I =?HA@EJ= IA GKA AIIA AIJK@ E E?E= IA = @ AIF= @A AIJ=@ I I E@=@=I JH=H B H = EI E GKAIJE @A 5) LAEI >A AB ?E I
JA @A E B H = @A HA= E@=@AI ?
= HAIFAEJ @A J ? E?=I @A JE E = F AN=I KJE E = @ IA
=JE C LA F=H= = E F A A J=
&
+)2 67
51,-4)
-5 .1 )15
&
4ABAH
?E=I
)JEB = @ * 2 =JA=K 5J ?D=IJE? )KJ
=J= AJM H I B H
@A E C F=H= A IOIJA I 1---
6H= I=?JE
. *=I AJJ
5 BJM=HA - CE AAHE C % '!& ''

+D= @O 4 K J = @ . 2= =?E I AHI FA + IA@ = @ ENA@ AJM H I B
3KAKAI MEJD ,E AHA J + =IIAI B +KIJ ! ) *A 6 8AH =C " * *AO=AHJ / . HE KIE C 5J ?D=IJE? 2AJHE 2 ? = @5 EJ *HA
KH =
B JDA )+
"& $ '%#
AH 2 .AH = @AI * 2 =JA=K = @ 9
5JAM=HJ 6DA 2-25 5 BJM=HA 1 E EI 75) ! 5FHE CAH
1 2AHB H = ?A 6
5 ! 7H>= = = @
JE?A
=J E
-L= K=JE
B?
FKJAH IOIJA
@AFA @=>E EJO
AJI 1 2H ?AA@E CI B JDA 11th 1 JAH =JE K A '& 1--- +
= 5O F IEK
.=K J
6 AH= J +
FKJE C F=CAI " $ 2 HJ = @

AAH = @
FKJAH 5 ?EAJO 2HAII
# / * ?D 5 /HAE AH 0 @A 5 I AM ; H
5 6HELA@E 3KAKAE C
AJM H I = @ I
=H L +D=E I
D 9E AO
@A E C = @ 2AHB H = ?A -L= K=JE

; 75) ''& A=
MEJD +
FKJAH 5?EA ?A )FF E?=JE
$ 4 - *HO= J 5O > E? *
= EFK =JE
MEJD H@AHA@ >E =HO @A?EIE
@E=CH= I )+
FKJE C 5KHLAOI
= @ 2
"! '!!& '' A FAH 0EAH=H?DE?= HA=?D=>E EJO CH=FD CA AH=JE ! &!# =JA E 5JAM=HJ - 5K =E = =HCA =H L @A I AM B H 2AJHE AJI
% 2 *K?DD
. H =
&
AJD @I E 5OIJA I ,AIEC

5 ,
; +DK C / +E=H@ = @ ANE? ;K ) + 75) )FHE F=HEI 1 12,25
0A * 2 =JA=K 9 @A E C
B 5JHK?JKH= . H = EI I B H
ANJ /A AH=JE
5 BJM=HA 2H CH=
2HAII
5. /5
21 9 H ID F 5= J= .A
" )+
& ' / +E=H@ 9D=J = IJHK?JKH= M H @ 1 2 2
4-.-4
+1)5 *1* 1 /4 .1+)5
2H ?AA@E CI B JDA 'JD E JAH =JE @A I 2 2 F=CA ! 9=IDE CJ
=
,+
9 H ID F
75)
2AJHE
AJI = @ 2AHB H = ?A
FKJAH 5 ?EAJO
1--- +
/ +E=H@ = @ ) 5
E AH 5J H=CA ) JAH =JELAI B H =HCA 5JHK?JKHA@ 5J=JA 5F=?AI 1 'JD
1 JAH =JE -L= K=JE

! 4 4 ,7 )@@EI " , + '$ # ) 6DA $ 2 A =? I =? I =
= +
BAHA ?A
@A E C 6A?D EGKAI = @ 6 +5 F=CAI ""#% 5J FAH=JE

=
I B H +
FKJAH 2AHB H = ?A
L K A "# B
.H= ?A ''% 5FHE CAH 8AH =C
AJM H I B M=EJE C E AI
I 4AIA=H?D # #&# '#%

'$!
>ID F E A GKAKAE C IOIJA I - 0 F?H BJ
= =CA A J 5?EA ?A !" =J= JDA HO = CK=CAI = @ ?
1 JH @K?JE
J =KJ
FKJ=JE
9AI AO '%' EJJ A ) FH B B JDA GKAKAE C B H K = L = W
FAH=JE C 4AIA=H?D ' !&!!&%
=HI=
/ *= >
= @/ +
JA 2AHB H = ?A
@A I B
K JEFH ?AII H IOIJA I
16 2HAII '&$ AH E = @ , .=H>AH 4A? LAH=>E EJO B + K E?=JE 2H J ? I 1 F E?=JE I
B = 6DA HE?= 5JK@O 1--- 6H= I=?JE % ) 5 E AH
K E?=JE
"' !$"! '%$ @E=CH= I 1 1
- ?EA J IJ=JA IF=?A CA AH=JE
B /52 I KIE C @A?EIE
JAH =JE
= +
BAHA ?A
,AFA @=> A 5OIJA I = @

K A 1--- +
AJM H I ,5
F=CAI $!%$"$
9=IDE CJ & ) 5
,+ 75)
FKJAH 5 ?EAJO = @ IJ H=CA KIE C @A?EIE
E AH = @ / +E=H@
- ?EA J HA=?D=>E EJO IAJ CA AH=JE
@E=CH= I 1 2H ?AA@E CI B JDA 20th 1 JAH =JE
= +
BAHA ?A
)FF E?=JE
I = @ 6DA HO
B 2AJHE
'
AJI F=CAI $ # 9E E= I>KHC 8) 75)
K A ''' 5FHE CAH 8AH =C AJI
O 2AHB H = ?A = = OIEI KIE C IJ ?D=IJE? 2AJHE
1--- 6H= I=?JE
+
,
FKJAHI + !' '!'% '&

A= @/ KJJ =?H - AJI HAFHAIA J=JE & %&% % '%! B F=H= A IOIJA I 1--- 6H= I=?
JE
FKJAHI +
4-.-4
+1)5 *1* 1 /4 .1+)5
&! *=@E= 2AJHE AJ ) = OIEI 7IE C * A=
- 2=IJ H = EFK =JE L K A &# B * 2 =JA=K
4 EC
+ HJ=@A = = @ 4
1 #JD 1 JAH =JE
= +
BAHA ?A
=H=C I= 5F=E
)FF E?=JE
= @ 6DA HO B 2AJHE
AJI
+5 F=CAI "$"!#
''" 5FHE CAH 8AH =C = @ IO ?DH E =JE @A I B H @EI
JDA IJ ?D=IJE? IJHK?JKHA B F=H= A EI
JHE>KJA@ = C HEJD I 1 2H ?AA@E CI B JDA '&# )+
51/ -641+5 ?
BAHA ?A
A=
IKHA A JI = @
'&# )+ ! 2HAII
@A E C B +
FKJAH 5OIJA I F=CAI "%#" )KIJE
6AN=I 7 EJA@ 5J=JAI
4AEIAH = @ 5 5
=LA >AHC % !!!
A= L= KA = = OIEI B ? IA@ '& = @ @A EJE
K JE?D=E GKAKAE C AJM H I
KH =
" .
B JDA )+
9 5O
I 6DA @AI?HEFJE
B 3KAKAE C 5OIJA I >O K AHE?= 2AJHE
AJI )KIJH= E= 6A A? #
K E?=JE
4AIA=H?D ! ! '& FKJAH I?EA ?A =FF E
5 6HELA@E 2H >=>E EJO IJ=JEIJE?I MEJD HA E=>E EJO GKAKE C = @ ?
?=JE
$ 9 2HAII
I - C AM
K>AHA
@ + E I 2HA JE?A 0= 6E A@ 2AJHE
AM ; H
; 75) '& 1 2H ?AA@E CI
AJI = @ 2HA E E =HO 2AHB H = ?A -L= K=JE
B JDA 7th )
K= 5O F IEK
FKJAH )H?DEJA?JKHA
= *=K A .H= ?A '& )+

GDFD

Enviado por

Dados do documento

Título original

Direitos autorais

Formatos disponíveis

Compartilhar este documento

Compartilhar ou incorporar documento

Opções de compartilhamento

Você considera este documento útil?

Este conteúdo é inapropriado?

Direitos autorais:

Formatos disponíveis

GDFD

Enviado por

Direitos autorais:

Formatos disponíveis

2

@A ,E=CH= =I @A ,A?EI @ AIF= =J I @A

H=@= F=H= HAFHAIA J= A

) = 2=K = 5= A CKA 5? =HE

,EIIAHJ= HAGKEIEJ @A F=H?E= AIJHA A

=FHAIA J=@= >JA ?E= @= + @ +E

HEA J=@ H 2H B ,H 2=K

0A HEGKA A A A .AH = @AI

FAH EJE @ = IK= =L= E= = HAFHAIA J= =CA @EI?HAJ CAH= =

GK= JEJ=JEL= JE?= @A

AIJHKJKH=@ I FAH EJA = FH JE?= = @ AIF= AIF= @A AIJ=@ I @A AIJ=@ I

@A IEIJA =I @A J= F HJA F @A =FHAIA J=H HAIK J= A = C HEJ CH= @A K

AH @A AIJ=@ I E =JE C LAEI A JA AIF=

@ I AIJ=@ I =FHAIA J= K F=H= B H = EI

@A AIJ=@ I =JE C LA 455  @AIIA = C HEJ =

K JE 8= H=@=  ,,  ) E@ E= FHE ?EF= @A ? FH L=H = IK= LE=>E E@=@A F=H=

EIJE?I EI IJE = FH > A FHAIA JI = = C HEJD J J =J=

IE ?A JDA IF=?A IJ=JA ANF IE

=E O LAHEBO JD=J JDA =FF E?=>E EJO B

,EIF=H= @ 6H= IE AI E EJ= > K @ AII  A 5ACKH= = I=BA AII 

4A@AI @A 2AJHE -IJ ? IJE?=I 5) 4A@AI @A )KJ =J I -IJ ? IJE? I

6EF I @A 6H= IE AI ! " -IJHKJKH= @A K = 5) -NA F @A @A 5)

)F E?= @ ,E=CH= =I @A ,A?EI 5)

EIA @ 4A H@A = A J @ I )KJ

+ IE@AH= AI .E =EI 4ABAH ?E=I

 ! " # $ % & '

HE= IJHK @ ,, ?E=

F=HJE D= A J @A 4A?KHI I F=H= +

A JHA -LA J I A -IJ=@ I + F=H=JEL A JHA @A @A ? A A HE= F=H= HE= F=H= @A @A

= J=H @ I .E I B I F=HJE D= A J @A 4A?KHI I E = JAI

-NA F -NA F -NA F

E = JAI A JHA 2=HAI @A )KJ

JEF I -LA J I 5E ?H = J=H @ I .E I B I

!$ !& !' "

,, F=H= ,, F=H= A+ IAG

" )KJ " )KJ

"! "" "% "' "' # # # # # # # # #

$ % & ' ! ! ! !! !" !# !$ !% !& !' " " " "!

,, 4AIK J= JA @ 5) 5) E = JAI A JHA 2=HAI @A )KJ =J I " IK @A @A @A @A A HE= F=H= @A I 5) @ELAHI I =J I  ,,  @A @A

-LA J I 5E ?H 2=HAI @A )KJ 5) @A " 5) @ +

= J=H @ I .E I B I ,, 4AIK J= JA F=H= + + + F=H= F=H= ? @ + @ + IK IK

F=HJE D= A J @A 4A?KHI I JEF I -LA J I 5E ?H = J=H @ I .E I B I

2 52 5) 255 455 ,, 62 ,)/

5J ?D=IJE? 2AJHE 5J ?D=IJE? )KJ

2H @K?J 5J=JA 5F=?A 4A=?D=> A 5F=?A 5J=JA K JE L= KA@ ,A?EIE 6A F HE A@ 2AJHE

,EHA?J )?O? E? /H=FD

AL K @ @AI@A &' GK= @

I AIJK@ I I >HA +=@AE=I @A

A BHA J=H @E ?K @=@AI F=H= @AI?HALAH

E JKEJ @A = A E =H J=EI HA E ?E @A '$ ? @A AIJ=@ I @EI?HAJ = FH F IJ= HAFHAIA J= @ =J I AI @A IK>IEI =

@A 4A@AI @A 2AJHE 2  B E E JH @K E@ ?=F= @A @AI?HALAH IEIJA =I ? @A I ? I F=?J I ' @A K

HA= E@=@AI ? > AJEL

@A 4A@AI @A )KJ >=IE?= A JA K =? A ?E= ?=IE

-IJ ? IJE? I 5)  FH F IJ F H 2 =JA=K FAH EJA = HAFHAIA J= JA =I J= J ?

A=@ I @A '& JA E JAH@AFA @

F HJ= A J E @AFA @A JA GK= J ?

FH > A = @= ANF I A AL=@ ? @A

=F E? LAEI = HA= E@=@A @A K F=H= L HE I B H = EI ? FKJ=?E =EI ANEIJA JAI KJE E =

- @AHA =H AIJA FH > A = ?

4A@AI @A 2AJHE A 4A@AI @A )KJ @A E@A JE ?=H F IJAHE H A JA

AIJHKJKH=I @A @=@ I @A J= = D FH F H?E

AIJ=@ I FH @KJ 255 =

=JE C LAEI @ FKJ=?E

@A AIJ=@ I =JE C LA 455 @AIIA = C HEJ =

K JE 8= H=@= ,, ) E@ E= FHE ?EF= @A ? FH L=H = IK= LE=>E E@=@A F=H=

,EIF=H= @ 6H= IE AI E EJ= > K @ AII A 5ACKH= = I=BA AII

! " # $ % & '

"! "" "% "' "' # # # # # # # # #

$ % & ' ! ! ! !! !" !# !$ !% !& !' " " " "!

,, 4AIK J= JA @ 5) 5) E = JAI A JHA 2=HAI @A )KJ =J I " IK @A @A @A @A A HE= F=H= @A I 5) @ELAHI I =J I ,, @A @A

AL K @ @AI@A &' GK= @

E JKEJ @A = A E =H J=EI HA E ?E @A '$ ? @A AIJ=@ I @EI?HAJ = FH F IJ= HAFHAIA J= @ =J I AI @A IK>IEI =

@A 4A@AI @A 2AJHE 2 B E E JH @K E@ ?=F= @A @AI?HALAH IEIJA =I ? @A I ? I F=?J I ' @A K

-IJ ? IJE? I 5) FH F IJ F H 2 =JA=K FAH EJA = HAFHAIA J= JA =I J= J ?

A=@ I @A '& JA E JAH@AFA @

AIJ=@ I FH @KJ 255 =

F II LA @AI?HALAH IA IEIJA =I CH= @AI A ? =JE C LA @ E AH A +E=H@ & % FH FKIAH=

& % F=H= @A K = C HEJ ,,

? KI AI =GKE =FHAIA J=@=I @A AH @A

?AEJ I > IE? I I >HA 4A@AI @A 2AJHE 2 A 4A

=J I -IJ ? IJE? I 5)

4A@AI @A 2AJHE 2 > AJEL @A @AI?HALAH @EI?HAJ IA @ FHE ?EF= @A K E?=

F II LA B= AH IA K = =L= E= ) AIJHKJKH= @A K = 2 K J @A JH= IE AI @A A T P ) @A JH= IE

IK E@ @A J @ I I IAKI KC=HAI @A A JH=@= A K