Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
:
-
21-526-
"
1121
:
:
-'-
" 6883
73069
00-3449500 :
00-4330673 :
www.jdc.org.il/brookdale :
brook@jdc.org.il :
-'-
,'; - ,'; ,' .0033 . :
..33-499-
,'; ,'; ,' .0030 . :
.8002.30-433-
,'; ,'; ,' .0030 . :
.8000-8002.30-300-
-' ,'; ,'; ,' .0030 .
..30-433-
,'; - ,'; ,'; ,' .0030 .
. .8.30-430-
,'; - ,'; ,' .0030 .
:
. .0.30-463-
,'; - ,' .0003 . .46-88
.03-583-
-'- ," ,6883 73069
' ,00-3449500 : ,00-4330673 : ;brook@jdc.org.il :
jdc.org.il/brookdale :
.1
, ,
,
( ;Chiswick & Repetto, 2000 .)3777 , ,
, .
. ('- ;0003 , 0030 , -)
.
,
.
34-06 ,3773-3797
54 03,000- 00% .
,65-06 50%- .40-64
; ;
;
;
.
.
.2
, :34-06
3773-3797 .54-0
-
. 54-37 ,38-3 ,4-0
( 3784-3785 ,3786-3797 ) ( 3773-3770- ) .
: 3
; 38
, .
, : 4-0
( )33% ,08-06 ;65 38-3
( )30% ,65-07 ;40-64 ,54-37 ,40-64
.34-43
, , ,
,- .
.
, ( )00%- , .
0007 .0030 .3,494 .
.48% ;
. ,
- : , ,
, , .
. , ,
,
.
.
1 .
.
.3
.3773-3770
( )90% .38- .
, .
.
, 34%- 38
.
( )49% 3770 ,3773-
; 60% ,3784-3785 , 36%- .3786-3797 ,
63 37-.
: 90% ( 38 ) 33% : 4-0 45%-
60% .38-3 .54-37
.
1 .3770
" : ,0007
0007 .0007
ii
80%- 38 ; 35%- ,
, 3%- .
94% ,38 ; 49% 38%- .
2
8% -.
34%- 03% . 8-3 .
,38 30%- 30% 30 .
,38-3 30%- 65%- 8-3.
06% ,68%-
,-- , . 48% , 03%-
67% . .
.4
; .65-06
( )74%- ; . -
-
(.)6%
37 63-.
05% 05% ,08-06 07-05 67%- ;40-64 36%
.34-43
74% , . .
- ( 30% )
( .)6% -
( .)8% - 08%
30%- .
( )67% (.)09%
iii
.5 ,
34-06
. 3 :
30- ,
.
/ ,
-.
.
,3 ; 38-3
; 37 ,
. , -
,
.38 .
.
iv
38
36% 60%
.
, -
.
86% - 02 30 . 47%
.
64% 36%
00% , 3%- -; 3%
.
.56% 38-3
30 .
60% /
60%- .
47% ( 80% )38
38% , ( 06%- 30%- )38
.
.6
34-06 , ,
.
4
.
.
.
.
- .
.
98% 83% , 94%- .
96% : 95% ,
96%- .
:
,
, ( 54 0030 ,).
,
; :
30% 5-0 90% 33-4 83% 30 70% +36 80% . ,
. ,
( 80% .)85%
,
4% : 04% .
, 33% :
5% .
36% : ,38%.
65% : ,45%.
, ,
, , 87% .
; , 37% ,
vi
43% . , 43%
.
,
.
33% ,37%- .
( )
.
, , .
47%- 63 : 40
.
.
50 , 34
, 33% .
,
.
43%
. 66%
.
.7
. ,
.
,
,
.
,
.
vii
56% , 08% ,
0,003- (
3,834).
38% , 68% ,
5,000-.
- 83%
0,003- 69% -
.
:
-
53% 47% .
00% ,-
- .
44% .80%
00
60 .
, 9-5
5
.
.8 -
,
, ,
. .
,
" .
( .)0007 ,
.0030
.
viii
-
: , , , /,
,
.
.
( ) .
00% , , 03% .
40% .
.
43% ; 35% ,
.
89% .
.38
90% :
3 30%- ,38-3 69% ,38
. , 07% ,3
( )5% ( )04% .
: 35% ,
57% .
-
: , ( )35%
( ,)00% . 54% ,
( )00% ( )06% 50%-
, (' ) . ,
. , , :
( )53% ( )03%
.
, . ,
.
ix
.
90% 80%- .
( )83% .
( )
:-
( ,)65% ( )37% (.)34%
64% 3 30 39% .
.
( ,)45%
. )34%( 33-3
( .)58%-56%
.
97% " 30% : 39%- .
" :80%-
38 , 30%- .
,38 , .
( )06% ,
( )08% . , 40%- 73%
3 39%- 38-3 .
95% 86%- " .
73% .
. 90% ,
6
( )0007 .34% :
39% ( .)0008
6- 38-
: , ,
.
33% 50%,37%-
. 09% , , .
48% (
) 06% .
36% .
,
: ,3
( )53% ( .)54% , 38-3
,38 ( 35% ,43%-).
,
, , , .
,
.
.
/ .
38%-69% ( )
, .
: .,
,
,
. ,
.
.
.
,
,
.
xi
.9 -
. ,
.
,
( )87% .
04%-
. ( ,)67%
( )64% (.)63%
: 69%- ;7%-
40%- ( ;)64%
,00%-
56%- ;
, 63% 56%.
.50%-
- ( )40%- (.)60%-
3-
( )63% ( .)07% ,04%-
;
.
xii
38-3 ( ,)40%
( )65% (.)66%
38 ( ,)06%
( .)53%
,
( .)06% , ,
( )30%
(.)39%
95% ,
60% : 55%- . 39% , 7%-
. . , -
( , )
, . ,,
,
.
, " ?" " 95%
" 34%- " ," . 33% " " " " .
83%
,38 37%
.38-3
. , ,
.
,
.
,
. ( )60%
( )40%
.
:
. ,
.
xiii
.
.
xiv
, ,
, - , .
. , ,
.
, .
.
' ' ," , ,
, .
, .
xv
.0
1.1
1.2
1.3
3
3
3
3
.2
2.1
2.2
2.3
2.4
0
0
0
4
5
.3
.4
.5
5.1
5.2
8
7
30
.6
6.1
6.2
6.3
36
36
35
38
.7
7.1
7.2
7.3
7.4
20
00
00
04
08
.8
8.1
8.2
8.3
8.4
8.5 :
34
35
36
38
42
43
.9 -
9.1
9.2
9.3
9.4
9.5
9.6
9.7
46
46
47
48
50
40
53
44
.10
57
.11
11.1 3
11.2 ,393
30
60
30
.12 -
12.1
12.2
65
65
37
.13
71
94
:
:
:
:
:
99
99
97
83
84
84
:8
:3 ,
,
:0
:3
:6 ,
6
5
4
:5 ,
:4 / ,
:3 / ,
:6
:9 ,
7
:8 ,
:5
:7 ,
7
:30 :
30
:33 ,
30
:4
:30 :
,
35
:36 : ,
34
:35 : ,
33
:34 : ,
39
:33 ,
39
:39 : ,
38
:38
,
37
:7
:37 : ,
00
:00 : ,
06
:03 :
,
05
:00 ,
05
:06 :
,
04
:05
,
03
:04
,
09
:03 : ,
08
:09 : ,
07
:08
60
:07
, ()%
63
:60 , :
,
31
:63 :
,
32
:60
,
66
:2
:66 :
,
35
:65 :
,
37
:64 , :
,
50
:63 ,
41
:69 ,
42
:68 ,
56
:67 :
,
43
:50
: ,
44
:53
45
:50 ,
46
:9 -
:56 ,
59
:55 ,
47
:54 ,
58
:53 - ,
57
:59 (
) ,
40
:58
,
50
:57 ,
43
:40 ,
40
:43
,
46
:40 ,
,
45
:46 , ,
45
:45 ,
55
:44 ,
43
:43 ""
49
:00
:49 ,
48
:48 ,
58
:47
,
59
:30
30
:00
:33 3
,
33
:30 3
61
:36 ,
62
:35 39-3
,
36
:34 , 39-3
36
,
:33 ,
35
:39
35
:08 -
:38 ,
33
:37 ,
39
:90 ,
,
90
:93 ,
93
:
:3 , :
99
:
:3 :
, ,
97
:0 ,
97
:6 ,
80
:5 ( ) ,
80
:
:3 : ,
83
:0 ,
83
:6 ,
86
:5
,
84
:4 :
,
85
:3 :
,
85
:
:3
84
:
:3 ,
84
:7
:3
:0 ,
00
03
:2
:6 :
37
:08
:5
38
:
:3 ,
83
:0 ,
83
:6 ,
80
.1
1.1
,
( 0030 ,) . ,
,
, ( ;Chiswick & Repetto, 2000 .)3777 ,
('- ;0003 , 0030 ,)
.
34-06 ,3773-3797
54
.
: , , , ,
, .
. 00% (
).
1.2
:
.
1.3
0 .
:
( )6 ( .)5
38 ( .)4
3 ,
; ( )9 ( ,)8
- ( )7 ( )30
( .)33
( )30 ( .)36
.
.2
, ( ,)0.3
( )0.0 ( )0.6 ()
7
( .)0.5
2.1
, .
. , 00%- ,
, . 0007 .0030
.
.3770
.
":
,0007 0007 .0007
2.2
34-06 :
,3773-3797 .54-0
- .
,34-06 03,054 , 6 :
( 38-3 ,4-0 6 x )54-37- (.)3773-3770 ,3784-3785 ,3786-3797
, .
. ,3,494 394.
3 ( )
( .)394 48% ; .50%
;
.
7 ,
.
( , =)
. 34%
.
, ,
: , , .
. :
.08-06 ,
.
(' 3 ).
, ,
, ,
.
:0 , ,
"
100
26,245
58
909
4-0 :
3
763
51
90
)3
3786-3797 :
38-3 :
5
1,439
49
85
)0
3786-3797 :
54-37 :
4
1,189
57
100
)6
3786-3797 :
4-0 :
7
1,786
64
112
)5
3784-3785 :
38-3 :
15
3,854
57
100
)4
3784-3785 :
54-37 :
9
2,421
56
98
)3
3784-3785 :
4-0 :
4
976
70
123
)9
3773-3770 :
38-3 :
35
9,189
63
110
)8
3773-3770 :
54-37 :
18
4,628
52
91
)7
3773-3770 :
:8
( ); ()%
()
84,865
84,865
"
50.4
57.8
49.6
40.0
16.3
36.5
4-0
54.2
44.0
38-3
29.5
63.5
54-37
12.8
36.0
3786-3797
30.4
60.8
3784-3785
56.8
43.0
3773-3770
23.7
04.5
08-06
24.4
04.0
65-07
39.2
63.7
40-64
12.7
30.4
34-43
2.0
3.3
/
11.8
33.0
/ (/ )
52.1
40.5
/
34.1
63.8
/
6.5
5.0
9.6
30.3
9.7
13.4
39.4
38.7
8.0
4.7
"
26.8
29.1
2.3
,
.
,-
.
( .
' ).
2.4
. 0
8
- .
.
,
. 4-0 ,65 ( )33% ;08-06
,38-3 ( )30% 65 ;40-64 54-
37 40-64 .34-43
.3
: ( ,)6
( )5 ( .)4
( .)3
33% 45% ;4-0 ;38-3 60%- .54-37
:3 , ()%
"
84,865
3773-3770
3784-3785
3786-3797
06,900
7,975
3,349
"
*
98
86
66
76
()0
()5
68
7
(())3
()6
03
6
( , ,,
)
36
()5
()5
9
3
3
()5
4
.04%- .50%-
* p<.05 :
: " 00070009
.
, 34-06 3773 - .
.
( )95% . ,3786-3797
66% . ,
( )03% . , .
93% ( 38' .)0
80%- ( )38 ; 35%-
, ; 3%- .
40% , 08%- , .
:6 ,
()%
54-37
38-3
4-0
"
7,730
06,833
6,820
84,865
"
*
3
39
0
8
38
49
+
*
40
83
89
73
00
33
3
03
8
()6
3
5
22
4
(())3
9
.04%- .50%-
* p<.05 :
3 , .
8 - . " -" , 80%-
.
* p<.05 :
34% 4% 30 .
,38 30%- 30% 30
.
43% . ,
65% :
50% ;3786-3797 ( 3784-3785 ); 58%- ( 3773-3770 ).
:4 / , ()%
54-37
38-3
4-0
"
7,731
14,233
4,281
26,245
"
*
33
09
06
83
60
69
65
35
(())0
( )6
3
3
40
66
69
39
.04%- .50%-
* p<.05 :
06% ,-
68% , , .
( ) .
38 34% .
.4
.
( )9 ( .)8
:7 , ()%
54-37
38-3
4-0
"
3,698
7,466
2,070
13,234
" N
*
()30
86
83
48
67
()8
()7
07
43
7
30
80
4,033
6,752
2,211
12,996
" N
*
0
06
48
88
0
(())0
0
()0
0
50
68
82
300
66
()5
69
.04%- .50%-
* p<.05 :
" : 80%- 38 , 30%-
.
,38
67% ,30% . ,
.
73%-
3 34%- .38-3
:2 ,
()%
54-37
38-3
4-0
"
1,816
6,781
1,845
10,442
N
40
53
60
60
65
60
66
33
(())35
09
69
84
/
-1,710
1,295
3,015
N
-36
58
57
-()38
69
84
-()37
()34
07
/
-2,823
829
3,652
N
*
-30
93
46
-63
()36
87
-()7
()33
()9
/
.04%- .50%-
* p<.05 :
.5
.
.
5.1
, ,
. ,
. .)3( :
3 ; ( .)0 38-3 ( )30%-
( )70% ,
.
:9 ,
()%
3
6,820
N
()3
08"*
63
08"
56
*
50
"
30
( -)
0
34
-
36
3
-
7
8
-
38-3
06,833
08
64
68
07
36
37
36
9
9
8
.04%-
* p<.05 :
3 38-3 35,066 () . 090
. ".
0
1.5.5 6
6% .
56% 30 .
, -.
45% 50% :
30%- ,-- , -
. , ,
.
:
0004-0003
9
3 .50%
63% 3 -
( ) - .
-
- .
,37% - ,
36% : 3%- - 7% .
8% .
.
50%- - . ,
,
. , 34%- .
,8% 00% - , . ,
.
1.5.5 51-6
30% .
( )84%-
. ,
,
.
53% 30 .
. ,7% ,
, 38 30
.
50% , 07% : 36%-
,-- , -.
69% 38-3 - ( ) -
07% 8%- 00% .
36% : 7%- - 9% .
.
0007-0003
11
30 , 35%
- 7% 4%- 60% .
- .
.
- 8%( 00% , )38-3
.
( 40%- ,34%-) . ,
, ,
.
30%- 38-3 (' .)4
8% 0 05% . ,
30 . 53% , 30 09%-
38-36.
1.5.5
, 38
( 36%' 7) . 38 .
34-06 .30% 30
.
( ,64% 9%
) , ( ,)00% ( ,)33%
(.)33%
,
.
30
( 0007- ',
.)0033
11
:00 :
)%( 0
N
-2,534
, ,,
11
(())2
0
14
16
20
35
17
20
10
()7
3
()6
, ,,
11
(())1
13
)(11
(())0
.04%- .50%-
3 " 0007
35-04 .
0 " . ,
" " "
".
5.2
36%
00% , 3%- - 3% ,
,-- , ( . )33
:00 , ()%
54-37
38-3
4-0
"
7,731
14,233
4,281
26,245
"
03
56
63
35
*
(())2
17
39
13
/ *
19
25
19
88
)(3
7
4
4
-*
()6
8
5
4
*
.04%-
.50%-
* p<.05 :
38-3
.56% .03% 38
12
,383 :
30 .
8%- ,
.
.6
3 ( ,)3.3
( ,)3.0
,- ( .)3.6
6.1
0 .0
.
05% 05% ,08-06 65-07 67%- .40-64 36% .34-43
. .
30% ( 6% ) -.
, ()34%
- ( )7% .
38% ,38- -.
( )74% .
( )67% (.)09%
5.5 . ,
6.7 .
, .
13
:08 : 0 ,
()%
"
"
65-51
50-35
34-29
28-23
-3,335 10,290
6,399
6,221
26,245
*
00
0
()0
(())0
(())0
2
12
27
17
14
7
15
14
60
49
35
32
43
-
86
)(7
23
29
38
- 26
39
)(6
9
20
21
14
-
.04%- .50%-
* p<.05 :
3 " 0007 35-04
.
- 48% : 03%
. 35% : 67% .
: , ,08-06 ( )47%
- 9% 36%- ,09%- ,
, .34-43
6.2
: ( ,)36
( ,)35 ( )34 ( .)33
/
. /
,3 .
6.5.5
:
00% 5%- 5-3 .
.34-43 , 5-0
34-06 .
9% 33-4 , 03%- 30 .
8% ,05%-.
66% / 36 ,
- . .69%-
14
:03 : 0, ()%
"
"
65-51
50-35
34-29
28-23
3,335
10,290
6,399
6,221
26,245
*
0
75
37
0
0
86
5-0"
)())2
2
30
11
(())6
7
33-4"
24
))6
27
28
64
84
30"
/ +36"
))6
37
18
49
43
33
30
(())3
7
20
7
00
.04%- .50%-
* p<.05 :
3 " 0007 ,34-06
.
,30% 60% , ,
.
: 64-
64 . 30 ;
/ +36 .
69% 40-64 94%-
34-43 / +36 38% ,3%-.
. 08-06
,65-07
, .
- , , .
3 .
( 5-0 ) 65% ,34% .
30 38% ( 65%' 0
).
6.5.5
.
30%- 38%-
.
30%- -.
15
64
64.
40-64 .34-43 ,
,
.
,
(' 6 ).
( )80% 38
. 94%-
- 50%-
.
:06 : , ()%
65-51
50-35
34-29
28-23
"
3,335
10,290
6,399
6,221
26,245
"
*
12
40
84
70
59
22
25
30
8
02
35
23
)(4
0
06
31
12
0
0
9
/
- , *
27
48
89
89
61
43
32
9
9
25
20
17
(())0
(())0
12
))10
0
0
8
)(3
.04%- .50%-
* p<.05 :
6.5.5
, .
/ ()00%
( )35% ,
, ( )00% (.)33%
( )64 ( 64)
.
16
:05 : ,
()%
34-43
40-64
34-29 08-06
"
3,335
10,290
6,399 6,221
26,245
"
*
0
12
31
31
80
,
(())1
8
20
03
06
15
24
63
80
))5
14
13
7
00
))6
88
51
12
35
))3
.04%- .50%-
* p<.05 :
6.5.6
36% ( ).
5% 5% , 4%-
.
00% ( ") 8% .
3% , 8%- .
, 34%- /
.
:04 , ()%
40-64
34-29
08-06
"
10,290
6,399
6,221
26,245
"
10
20
16
13
/ *
()6
()8
()6
6
((6
)(7
6
6
)(5
)(5
9
5
30
25
15
88
*
11
9
()4
8
8
()3
()5
4
11
10
6
8
34-43
3,335
(())2
11
.04%- .50%-
* p<.05 :
17
6.3
39 38% , 48%- ,
. 30% , 33%-
.
:07 : ,
()%
34-43
40-64
65-07
08-06
"
0,593
5,117
3,331
8,720
08,280
N
*
66
63
77
84
42
68
22
16
()10
20
07
15
( )7
()6
12
/
67
17
()12
()9
16
4 *
- ( )
57
43
46
()25
65
29
()18
()23
85
/
N
08,059
3,833
2,857
4,572
0,697
*
85
89
52
14
30
84
(())1
(())1
16
/
(())6
(())5
20
4 *
- ( )
43
50
45
()37
30
29
()20
()20
26
/
.04%- .50%-
* p<.05 :
34
38
28
31
()39
43
40
47
, :
( 40 36%- ,)66%- ,
65 ( 84%- .)65%- "
" " " 65 .
- 33% . 00%- ( 3
) , ( 9% 7%- )
-.
18
.
, ( 33% )09% ( 00% .)04%
64 ( .' 5
)
:02 0
, ()%
34-43
40-64 65-07
08-06
"
596
845
406
246
2,093
N
()04
()63
87
40
40
67
()03
()04
80
711
1,451
167
047
2,496
N
()60
65
38
()63
64
30
(())8
()00
()05
.04%- .50%-
3
. ,
- ( 59% ,)63%
( 60% .)09%
/ )General Health Questionnaire( GHQ-
( ) ( & Goldberg
.)Williams, 1988 ,
- , . 5
30 (" " " ")
/.
,5
/ . ,GHQ-
.
19
.7
.
. ( )9.3
( .)9.0 ,
.
9.6 : ,
( ).
, 9.5
.
7.1
"
. ;
, ( 0030 ,
) .
( . ;3 ' 3- 0 )
:0 ()%
"
300
78
33
30
33
35
00
21
84
78
81
"
100
87 88 86
78
76 75
81
75
78
75
69
56
50
42
25
0
51-65
35-50
29-34
21
23-28
"
,65-07
.88% ( ,)94% 08-06 .
34-43 .37%
,)83%( 65-07 .
,40 .50%
06 .40 , 43 34
, , ( . , 6 )
:09 : 3, ()%
30" , 36
33-4
5-0
"
"
"
"
"
8,536
8,686
6,862
1,841
6,322
26,245
80
70
81
72
60
78
*
84
74
64
61
29
73
.04%- .50%-
* ;p<.05 : .
3 " 0007
34-06 .
, .
,
.
( 80% .)85%
5 30% :
07% .
( .' 3 )
7.2
,
; ,
.
: ( ,)00 ,
( ,)03 ( )00
( .)06
22
1.5.5
,
.
0
:80 : ,
()%
"
9,753
00,739
80,698
N
()4
5
5
/
15
12
13
/
33
7
03
*
60
03
89
/
8
40
24
*
04
8
04
*
/
/
/
.04%-
* ;p<.05 : .
3 " 0007
34-06 .
85
02
80
80
03
6
08
33
7
37
06
4
06
03
63
00
0
6
4% :
04% .
33% :
5% .
( )36% ( )38%
/.
(36%
,00%) ( 07% ,00%
) ( 05% ,36%).
(50%
,8%) ( 33% ,7%)
( 04% .)8%
,
.
23
1.5.5 ,
( .)74% 4% . ,30%-
.
:80 :
0, ()
"
37
46
42
*
28
34
31
(*)
63
53
60
59
49
58
()
* ;p<.05 : .
3 " 0007 35-04
.
:88 0, ()%
"
47.5
47.0
59.3
3 " 0007 35-04
.
50 .
63.
, .
,
: 47%-
. .
24
:83 ( 80.70) :
0, ()%
"
8
9,338
9,243
18,581
N
28
14
21
*
50
07
3.03- 3.04 ( 04.87")* 35
13
17
15
3.03- 3.4 () 63.04
9
00
05
3.43- 0 (*) 53.50
10
18
14
0 ( 53.53)
8
9
7
36
7
00
3.03- 3.04 ( 04.87")
36
33
08
3.03- 3.4 () 63.04
03
37
80
3.43- 0 () 53.50
54
45
69
0 ( 53.53)
* ;p<.05 : .
3 " 0007 35-04
.
0 30%- .
7.3
- ( ,)05
( )04 ( .)03
25
1.5.5
:86
, ()%
"
9,753
00,739
80,698
N
04
03
84
46
46
53
00
03
80
/
9
16
13
68
38
38
46
53
69
/
13
13
13
32
40
36
44
59
50
/
*
36
04
09
46
55
69
65
63
38
/
( )
37
31
34
45
48
67
38
03
09
/
* p<.05 :
,
97% . ( )46% ( )03%
( .)05 03% , . 33% ('
6 ).
83%
.
38% .
40%-
, ( 00% ) . 36%
(' 6 ).
.
26
1.5.5
.
.
,
.
:85
, ()%
"
9,753
00,739
80,698
N
*
7
00
05
/
50
53
60
65
60
33
/
34
7
08
* p<.05 :
( )43% , ,
, .
. .
,30% , .
1.5.5
: .
,
.
,
93% . 49% .
35%. ,
( )08% ( .)63% , 35% ,
( )03% (.)56%
93% 48%.
27
:84 : ,
()%
"
00,739
80,698
N
93
70
39
02
30
00
/
*
26
28
60
34
32
28
10
8
46
57
64
38
30
00
/
37
80
56
63
08
87
30
9
9,753
90
38
30
29
42
24
5
30
07
7
06
50
03
7
* ;p<.05 : .
3 " 0007 35-04
.
7.4
.
( .)0003 ,
,
.
, 10,65-23
( .)09
, -
( )08 - ( .)07
( )63-60
10 0% 54 , 65% .
,
.
28
( .)60 .
1.6.5
0
:87 : ,
()%
"
1,231
790
2,021
N
)(22
50
89
))))4
))((5
(())5
33
39
35
/
53
()33
30
,/ *0
67
58
68
8
38
08
/
04
34
88
0
,/
08
37
86
.04%- .50%-
* ;p<.05 : .
3 " 0007
34-06 .
0 ""
. .
. 65%
45% .
64% / (
) . .00%
, 37%
.)93% ,
;
, .
1.6.5
,
, , ,
, .
, , 50% , ,
29
, .30% . 08
.
:82
( ) ()%
%
%
50
300
( )
64
87
.3
0
0
.0
(())4
(())33
.6 /
0
0
.5
30
300
( )
()33
()37
.4
38
60
.3 /
63
43
.9
.04%- .50%-
87% ( ) 60% ,
.
.
, ( )37% ,
( )43% 60% . ,
.
.
: ?
33% ,
( ,) 37% .
87% :
, 43%- ,
.
99% .
. , ,
( )83% (.)90%
31
:89
, ()%
"
3
"
*
37
43
87
33
/
63
57
(())33
65
/
90
83
99
/
08
(())35
06
/
.04%- .50%-
*
3 " 0007
.55-06
1.6.5 ,
36% . 4% :
.
:30 , :
0, ()
"
,
36
49
41
*
35
47
60
()
,
()
42
45
47
98
38
43
36.3
30.0
40.9
* ;p<.05 : .
3 " 0007
35-04 .
( .)60
, 50 33%
( . 34 .)60
: 30 ,
88% ;
/ 36 , 97% ( -
31
5 ) . ,
.
( .)60
( .)63
:30 ( 80.70) :
0, ()%
"
8
0,094
440
0,754
N
)(25
0
)(16
*
()38
(())9
()06
3.03- 3.04 ( 04.87")
(())30
()04
)(20
3.03- 3.4 () 63.04
()37
()60
86
3.43- 0 () 53.50
)(18
43
30
0 ( 53.53)*
5
2
3
3
3
5
3.03- 3.04 ( 04.87")
7
5
4
3.03- 3.4 () 63.04
00
36
07
3.43- 0 () 53.50
33
98
49
0 ( 53.53)
* ;p<.05 : .
3 " 0007 35-04
.
0 35%- .
33%
( ) . 00.90 ,
. , 6%
, ( . )63
35% ( 4%
) 303% 304%- .
( )38% ( )9% .
60% ( 37% )
.
60
.
32
:38 0
, ()%
"
"
-1,231
790
2,021
N
(())7
()00
()06
/
59
)
60
(
60
63
63
34
/
(())8
(())30
()00
*
44
43
58
50
/
36
57
40
50
/
.04%- .50%-
* p<.05 :
3 " 0007 35-04
.
(' ,)04
( )45%
. ,
.
(' )63-60
,
, .
,
.
( 86% ,40%);
( - 87% - 33% ); ('
3 60) .
, .
1.6.6
. :
. : .
( 96% , 30% )
, , (' 30
) . 33% , ( )
33
.
( )0033
( .)30.33.0030 ( )0007
, .
. : ( )33%
( )66% ( 3% ) (" .)0030 , ()0007
. ,
60%-00% .
. : , ,
, .
. :
; ,
.
. :
.
,
( , ).
. 63% : ,
. 65% ,,
.
,
.
.8
, .
, .
( '',
;0009 0030 ,; :0003 , , ,)3 "
, .
.
,
( ) .
34
( )8.3
( .)8.0
, , , .
, " ( .)8.6
, -
( .) 8.5 ,
( .)8.4
8.1
-
-
" ( .)0007
.
,9 ,
.
, ,
.
:33 :
0, ()%
"
13,691
8,478
9,228
26,245
"
80
39
98
78
75
--- / *
5
04
9
8
*
11
()38
9
11
9
03
5
10
*0
)(2
)(8
)(3
3
*6
(())3
-8
4
*
98
93
74
90
99
--- /
2
33
0
2
4
4
9
4
0
7
00
4
2
6
3
0
6
5
6
30
38
7
.04%- .50%-
* ;p<.05 : .
3 " 0007
35-04 .
0 , , , .
6 , .
( ).
35
, .
- ( 98% 39%-);
,80% , ( .)94% 30% ,
, 60% , 8%
( ).
. , " ( 64% ,)0007
. 33%- ,
( )6% .
( )8%
( )33% ( 0% ,3%-).
- , ,
. ,
. -
46%( 04% :-) 69%( 38%--
) 03%( 33%-) 36%( 4%--),
, - .
, ()9%
( .)0% ,
( 7% .)9%
, ( )4% ()33%
( 0% ,4%-) .
( 65% ,64%-)
( 3% 00%-).
30%- ( 8% ) ,
, .
5% , 9% .
.
8.2
" ( )0007
.
. 6 .
36
66% : 4,000
94%- 30,000 39% ,57%- , .
,( 8%- 5% ) . 0,400
30% : 36,000 4% 39,000 68% ,00%-.
:3 :
)%( 0
100
75
75
49
38
33
22
5
17
12
50
25
0
27,111
23,111
21,111
6,111
3 " 0007
35-04 .
,
. , 65
.
:36 :
0, ()%
-
"
8
9,644
0,958
4,377
07,795
"
(*)
63
83
68
63
* 0,000
59
()35
69
39
* 5,0000,003
39
0
04
02
* 5,000
()
66
69
33
82
0,000
65
57
08
36
5,0000,003
66
35
43
32
5,000
.04%-
* ;p<.05 : .
3 " 000735-04
.
0 .
37
.
(' 00-03
).
,
. ( ) 0,000
:0007 3,834- 56% .
, 08% , 0,000.
( 67% 65% ) 5,000-0,003 ;
( 38% 68% ) 5,000 .
- ,83% , -
0,003 69%- -
.
. -
0,003 ( 68% .)33%
, 5,000
( 04% .)43%
( )30% ,
, 63% :
59% , 0,000
5,000-0,003 39%- 5,000 .
65% ,66% ,66%-.
,
, , - .
8.3
: , (
,)64 , , ,
( .) 63 , ,
" , .
.
1.5.5
3776
.
38
( 0030 ,) .
-
.
64 ,
( ).
53% , 47% .
- ,
, ( 34% .)30%
( 0030 ,) 94%-
.
. -
.
.
00% 63% 36% -
. .64
( 06% ,07%) . ,
( 35% ,4%).
66% , 64
, 34%- - .
- , )64%( ,
. , ( ,)00% - ,
. .
6.6 :
,6.7 . 30% :
3.773.00 ( 40% ) , 37%-
( 4% ).
39
:35 , :
0, ( %)
-
"
13,691
8,478
9,228
26,245
"
34
63
33
60
/ / *
36
()37
63
88
*
33
()34
66
83
*
3
64
00
06
*
6.3
6.3
6.0
3.3
*
30
()3
68
80
*0.770
36
98
57
40
*3.773.00
04
()33
36
09
*+0.00
0
30
34
44
59
/ /
08
04
64
89
5
8
5
5
8
0
3
7
6.7
6.9
6.8
3.9
65
50
30
65
0.770
48
46
68
50
3.773.00
8
4
0
5
+0.00
.04%-
* ;p<.05 : .
3 "
0007 .35-04
" 0007 .34-06
.
0 ,
.
1.5.5
, ( ) -
( )0030 ,
.
: ( 50% ,)33% ( 53% ,)95% ( 9% )64%
( 35% .)68% :
( 39% ;)34% ( 35% ;)93% (49%
.)30%
41
44% .
( 80% .)0007 ,
4% , ,
.
( )
;
- .
:34 , ()%
-
"
8,478
9,228 26,245
"
03
60
37
*
0
(())3
3
*
00
64
60
*
(())4
()5
7
*
74
89
93
*
()33
33
06
49
33
47
*
47
40
64
*
()7
35
06
45
40
57
40
43
55
(())6
()6
( , , ) 5
07
55
62
*
13,691
56
4
40
30
73
33
96
73
34
30
47
9
45
.04%- .50%-
* p<.05 :
-
, (.)74%
, ,
- . -
07% : 55%- 45%-
.
.
41
:37 , ()%
-
"
8,478
9,228 26,245
"
(())6
33
00
03
65
, 35
(())3
30
2
"
()35
05
84
*
69
47
59
13,691
30
68
3
63
36
.04%- .50%-
* p<.05 :
30%- , , .
; 30%- .
-;
.
, .
30% , ( ) ,
.
03% ( 39% ) 11 8%-
" . ( )30% " ( ).
65% , 50%-
".
6% ,
.
.
8.4
: -
() , - ,
- ( .)68
35 / "
" 0007 3504 .
42
:32 , ()%
"
13,691
8,478
9,228
26,245
"
/ ...
38
60
39
09
3
()8
3
4
()0
(())0
()0
8
9
()35
4
7
04
68
00
85
"
.04%- .50%-
04%
. - ( 3% .)37%
9%- .
( )35%
- ( ).
8.5 :
: (
)67 ( .)50
( .)53
, ( .)50
:39 : 0,
()%
-
"
13,691
8,478
9,228
26,245
"
*
30
(())4
36
08
43
66
69
66
69
30
40
66
/
30
9
7
00
43
68
59
62
69
44
55
60
/
.50%-
* ;p<.05 : .
3 " 0007 35-04
.
43
"
" N
13,691
8,478
9,228
26,245
,
, '?
8
(())3
8
2
59
03
59
65
65
58
66
35
33
00
30
08
8
,
, '?
33
8
39
04
54
57
33
50
07
60
34
86
30
36
9
9
.50%-
3 " 0007 35-04
.
0 0007 .
.
44
46% ( 39% )
( )8% ( )54% .
59% , - : ( )64% (.)30%
- , .
- .
07% ,
67%- . 37%
36% . .
:60
()%
"
" N
13,691
8,478
9,228
26,245
?*
64
()30
03
89
69
66
50
39
33
68
38
09
30
()37
35
03
?*
00
(())3
36
04
09
()39
63
82
63
55
64
36
00
66
03
88
?*
34
(())3
30
03
07
()30
05
85
50
45
43
64
33
08
36
04
.04%- .50%-
* p<.05 :
,
. ( )33%
( ,)08% ( .)65% ( )00%
.
45
, 36% :
04% , 53%- .
33% .
, -
.
:68 ,
()%
"
13,691
8,478
9,228
26,245
"
40
57
55
69
66
64
60
33
8
7
7
2
6
0
30
4
5
4
4
6
,
57% . , 66%-
. , 35% ( )8%
(.)3%
.
.9 -
-
, (
) ( ).
. ,
.
.
.
9.1
, ,
- .
.
46
39% ; 64%
. ,
00% , , .
38-3
.
:63 , ()%
54-37
38-3
4-0
"
7,730
06,833
6,820
84,865
"
*
09
53
63
35
39
38
34
07
38
33
35
06
38
7
7
08
00
03
03
88
* p<.05 :
9.2
()
. 55 54-
.
:66 , ()%
"
84,865
4-0
6,820
54-37
38-3
7,730
06,833
"
*
()5
(())3
()6
8
()5
36
39
00
07
48
40
63
60
09
04
82
08
7
()5
06
()6
()0
(())3
8
.04%- .50%-
* p<.05 :
43% ; 36%
; 35%
.
90% :
3 30%- ,38-3 69%- ,38
.
47
14
14
7
13
/
* p<.05 :
9.3
, 30%- ,00%-
(' 35) . ,3 90%- 38-
3 , 00%- .38
: , ,
( ).
- :
, ( )35% (.)00%
54% , ( )00% ( )06% 50%-
. .
, ,
: ( )53%
( ,)03% , , .
,
. ;
('
).
48
:64 - , ()%
54-37
38-3
4-0
"
4,028
03,863
6,060
83,546
N
*
49
36
94
46
03
05
37
88
38
30
3
08
()5
(())3
0
8
/
5,449
10,403
2,131
17,983
N
/ *
(())0
03
37
86
()3
63
37
88
53
69
30
37
53
3
0
07
/
7,437
9,121
1,340
17,898
N
*
07
54
93
60
00
60
34
84
63
00
()7
87
36
(())3
0
4
/
7,730
06,833
6,820
84,865
"
*
()5
00
46
88
8
07
63
83
40
50
34
39
68
7
(())3
04
/
.04%- .50%-
* p<.05 :
,
.
49% ( )53% ( .)33% 36% ,
.
.
,383 38 .
,3
.
49
:67 ( ),
()%
54-37
38-3
4-0
"
7,730
06,833
6,820
84,865
"
*
14
45
77
41
10
22
5
16
38
14
6
20
63
3
()6
03
/
7
13
7
00
*
7
53
82
44
()4
13
()4
9
6
5
()2
5
))((2
()3
(())3
8
/
81
26
11
40
/
.04%- .50%-
* p<.05 :
9.4
( )
:
, . ,
( ) .
9.6.5
,5
"
.
9.6.5
0007 ,0008
.
.
:62 ,
()%
54-37
38-3
4-0
"
7,730
06,833
6,820
84,865
"
88
66
50
70
*
87
65
41
67
*
* p<.05 :
51
90%
(( ;)34%- .)38-
39% .
, , 40%
3 70% .38
9.6.5
:69 ,
()%
54-37
38-3
4-0
"
7,730
06,833
6,820
84,865
"
/*
16
41
48
35
7
19
18
15
12
18
18
16
65
22
16
34
*
62
53
44
54
26
29
30
28
()5
13
12
00
7
5
14
7
*
43
31
27
34
24
18
14
19
13
17
18
16
20
34
41
31
.04%-
* p<.05 :
40%
; 46% .
.80%
, ,
95% 3 88%- .38
)33%( 3 )30%( 38-3 .)06%( 38
38
, .
51
9.5
. ( )40
( )43
.
.
:50 , ()%
54-37
38-3
4-0
"
7,730
06,833
6,820
84,865
"
21
18
17
19
""
43
42
39
42
""
27
27
30
27
""
9
13
14
12
""
33% ,
.
50% , ,37%- .
, :
, .
, ,
" : , . , .
, . , , " ( ,
.)0033
09% , , 60% ,
, .
.
,
, .
"" .30%
, " " (" ,)6% " (" ,)0% " ( )0%"
" (.)4%
.
52
:50
, ()%
54-37
38-3
4-0
"
7,730
06,833
6,820
84,865
"
*
16
21
41
23
""
20
10
6
13
""
56
64
45
58
""
8
5
8
6
""
* p<.05 :
48%
( ) 06% ,
, 36% (
).
, 3
,
; , ( )54%
.
. ( )68%
, ( )34% (( ;)37%'
3 ) . , , ()54%
.
,
; ,
( ''.)0009,
9.6
.
.
, , , ,
.
.
: ( ) , , .
53
, . :" , ,
, , , , ,
.
:58 0 , ,
()%
/
07 :
*07 :
9 :
35 :
65 :
**60 :
00 :
03 :
()
3 ,
* p<.05
** p<.05
:53 0 , ,
()%
** * 46
** 34
( )
40
*
38
* **
69
56
50
46
**
49
* **
3
** p<.05
* p<.05
. "
.
(
,' )33
.
( 69% ) ( 38%- ).
/ : /" /
, ,
54
. ,
.
- ( ' Taylor et al.,
.)1990
( , )3
(.)0030 ,
( )Taylor et al., 1990
:
,
:
( ,).
9.7
.
.
74%
74% .
3 , 94%- 00%-
. 43% ,3
65% .
:56 ,
()%
54-37
38-3
4-0
"
7,730
06,833
6,820
84,865
"
*
74
77
56
72
23
19
34
23
)(3
()5
30
5
/
*
72
79
70
76
25
20
24
22
)(3
))((1
3
2
/
.04%- .50%-
* p<.05 :
55
.
39%- .
: 4% 3 33%
383 03%- ( .38 )
,
.
:55 , ()%
38-3
4-0
"
06,833
6,820
84,865
"
*IETV-
13
9
16
14
6
15
24
14
19
49
71
50
DVD- *
76
53
73
*
)(2
)(4
2
12
12
9
25
26
80
61
58
69
54-37
7,730
27
20
14
39
76
))((1
))((2
8
89
.04%- .50%-
* p<.05 :
( )IETV
. 59% : 38
IETV- 09% 383 34%-
.3
.
( )96% ( )DVD
. , ,
,3 .
30%-
, .YOPI-
, :
56
6% 37 34%-
.37
( )KOOVEH
,
"" .
.
, , . ,
, ,
.
. .)3( :
)0( , .
,
.
:54 "" * ()%
54-37
38-3
4-0
"
7,730
06,833
6,820
84,865
"
13
8
5
9
6
)(2
))((1
3
/
9
6
)(3
7
/
72
84
91
20
/
.04%- .50%-
* p<.05 :
00%-
.
08% : 38
7% .3
,
.
.11
.
.
: , ,
. .
57
:57 ,
()%
84,865
"
34
*
30
4-0
30
38-3
06
54-37
*
30
08-06
3
65-07
03
40-64
06
34-43
*
23
*
11
59
-
33
.04%- .50%-
* , , ()p<0.05
34%- .
.
06% : 38
30% .3
- 59% :
33% 33%- .
,8% ,
.60%
:52 ,
()%
3,700
N
84
68
50
04
63
()3
/
()30
03
60
.04%-
58
84% :
( 30%- )
. ( 68% : 4%-
) .
04% ( 5%- ) / .63%
50% ( 3%-
) /.
30% ( 3%- )
,( 03%- 6%- )
.
60%- ,
/ ( ) .
(' .)66
:59
0, * ()%
54-37
3-38
0-4
"
7,730
06,833
6,820
84,865
"
52
90
97
20
33
7
()0
06
10
()2
(())3
6
()5
(())1
0
8
.04%- .50%-
* p<.05 :
3 , , , ,
( , ,
) . 80%-
35% , 5% , , 0%
.
. ,38 .
84% ,38 30% , ,-
4% .
-
80% , ( .)30 -
, - ( )50%
(.)43%
59
:40 ()%
N
0,600
80
42
-
51
-
()11
/
()35
/
(())6
.04%- .50%-
.11
( .)0009 ,
. 65-07
40%- +64 .70%-
07 37%( 34 4064 87%- )3443 ,
( 63% 4064 38%- ( .)3443'
3 )
,
.
38 .
.
11.1 6
.3
.
55.5.5
- , .
96% , . 3% -
;
.
( )73% ,
. ( )34%
.
61
:40 4 ,
()%
"
5,954
N
96
30
()3
7
,
96
34
4
.04%-
55.5.5
(.)Bennet et al., 2002
, 30%-40%-
, 34%-44%-
( .)0006 ,
:48 4 ()%
"
5,954
N
56
30-
29
303
9
4
()3
64
30-
05
303
05
4
39
.04%-
84% .
3 , 47% 3 39%
.
.
61
11.2 ,176
39-3 .
(- ) ,
. .
,
.
55.5.5
: .
.
:43 ,
()%
39-34 35-30
" 33-3
0,982 8,042
3,687 7,583
N
: *
07
58
34
58
/
55
64
03
30
09
()39
35
02
/
40
36
99
44
*
98
94
89
20
80
70
85
25
87
89
76
90
"
86
84
76
22
"
49
39
90
47
*
.04%-
* p<.05 :
40% 60%-
. 38% ,
/.
: 34%- 33-3 07% .39-34
- , 70%-33% .
, ,39-34 00%- 00% ,
, 33%- .
62
39%-34% ,39-30 , ,
.
39% .
( )49% ( .)90%-39% -
.
:46 07-4
, ()%
39-34
35-30
33-3
"
0,982
8,042
3,687
7,583
N
96
93
96
, , 78
( )90%
. . ,
- ,
.
55.5.5
- , .
:45 , 07-4
, ()%
39-34
35-30
33-3
"
1,928
2,168
3,427
7,523
N
81
77
82
80
75
76
98
86
*
* p<.05 :
80% 83% .
.
78%-.93%-
55.5.5
( ,)33 .
, ( )0%-
. .
4%- .39-34
63
:44 , ()%
39-34
35-30
33-3
"
0,982
8,042
3,687
7,583
N
(())0
(())5
(())6
()6
59
50
63
68
56
58
34
45
()8
()8
(())3
()4
.04%- .50%-
45% .
53% ( )68% ( )6% .
,39-34 57% , .
, ,33-3
.
8% 39-30 .
:47
()%
"
08,360
" N
27
47
03
/
20
48
60
/
25
53
00
/
19
56
04
/
21
54
04
/
64
55.5.6
,
, , ,
.
.
.
38% 98%- . (
.)39
.12 -
.
( ,)38
( .)37
( .)90
. , ,
( .)93
12.1
03%
( .)38
( ,)67% ( ,)64%
(.)63%
( 38-3 )40-60 ;40%
( 38 )34-43 ( ,)53%
.
65
:42 , (** )%
45-19
38-3
4-0
"
7,730
06,833
6,820
84,865
"
30
8
30
9
/*
53
65
63
35
06
40
07
39
*
09
03
35
88
*
60
66
05
30
30
()5
-5
"*
39
()0
-4
*
()6
()6
()0
3
33
38
06
02
/
66
03
66
89
0
00
05
09
83
3
37
06
00
88
0
30
30
33
00
6
9
30
9
9
5
3
()5
(())3
6
4
()4
()6
(())3
3
+3
.04%- .50%-
** /
* p>.05 :
69%- 40% . ()56%
,
( .)37
( )83% , ( )59%
.
, 3
3 .
. , 38-3 .38 ,
38
.38-3
66
:49 , ()%
45-19
38-3
4-0
"
7,730
06,833
6,820
84,865
"
/
59
53
44
65
39
00
39
02
39
00
36
09
---- 37
39
34
02
---- *
50
05
53
38
34
03
35
02
38
60
06
85
---- 09
04
00
85
---- *
43
63
30
64
36
35
35
06
34
04
36
80
---- 33
04
33
80
---- *
66
64
49
32
39
00
34
09
00
03
33
83
---- 08
37
30
80
---- *
07
54
80
64
30
37
7
05
07
39
3
09
---- 60
37
4
80
---- *
68
60
46
37
39
00
39
80
03
07
34
86
---- 05
39
34
09
---- *
39
36
53
09
0
03
34
39
07
3
34
00
30
07
0
33
37
30
05
6
35
33
30
05
5
9
7
3
2
4
34
8
()5
9
3
.04%-
* p>.05 :
67
:6 0 8
()%
60
50
39
43
40
43
37
35
40
31
22
20
9
3 : ""
0 : " " " "
5
: 69%- ;7%-
/ ( )64% ( ;)40%
00%- ,
( ;)56% ()
, 63% 56%.
,50%-
; , -
( )40%- (.)60%-
;
60% . ; 00% .
( 90% .) 33%
( ) ( 44%-
,59%).
,64% ,
,
68
( 59%' .)50
. -
( 35% ,53%-08% ).
3 ()63%
( .)07% , , ,
.
.
38-3 ( ,)40%
( )65% (.)66%
38 ( )06%
( .)53%
, .
, , ,
( )30%
(.)39%
12.2
,
55% : 60%- . 03% ,
. .
( 89%/ ) , ()83%
(.)85%
3
( .)40% .
.
44% 33%
.
97% ;
/ /
(' .)05 ,
( 38% ,83%- ,' ,)05
.
3
, .
69
38% . .
(' .)38
:70 , ,
()%
54-37
38-3
4-0
"
7,730
06,833
6,820
84,865
"
65
07
05
30
53
50
40
66
00
07
03
84
/
()N=09,905
38
08
07
84
36
40
40
53
37
00
03
80
/
8
35
33
08
58
50
50
63
55
55
59
65
/
*
03
50
40
32
30
53
56
69
35
35
9
03
/
)N=08,350( 0
60
60
00
30
44
46
43
56
34
39
07
04
/
63
65
07
38
58
69
50
60
03
07
07
87
/
03
07
05
87
59
68
50
60
09
66
63
38
/
63
07
06
82
45
30
30
52
34
33
39
06
/
* p>.05 :
3 .
71
.
:70 , ()%
54-37
38-3
4-0
"
7,730
06,833
6,820
84,865
"
*
81
69
75
74
,
14
15
17
15
,
)(4
12
5
8
))((1
)(4
)(3
3
.04%- .50%-
* p<.05 :
. :
? " ,".
37 ( )83%
(.)94%
38-3 37% ",
" .
,54-37 ,
, , .3
.13
('- ;0003 , 0030 ,).
3773-3797 ;54-0 65-06 .34-64
,
,
.
.
( 30 ) ,38
.
71
.0
38 30
30 , ,
.
.8
,
. :
,
. ,
.
.3
; , ,
.
.6 -
: ( 80% 40%-)
(.)90%
: 80%- ,80%-30%- , ,
( ).
: ( )84% .
: ( )33% . . 09% , .
.
: ,
, .
.5
( ,)95% , ,
, .
. ,
72
.
.
.4
.
- .
, .
.
,
, .
,
. 38 .
.
.0 5-0
3 , 30
. 36%- .
, ,
. 3
. .
,
.
.8 02-4
38-3 4-0 ,
. , ,
, 30
.
.3 02
38 :
5-0 . 30%- ,
. .
.
, , ,
73
.
, .
,
. ( )60%
( ) 40% .
" . ,
.
.
74
- ,'; -' ,' .0033 .
. , ,.
,'; '' ,' .0009 . :
" .8 ,.
.0003 . .8004 ,.
- ,'; ,'; ,'; ,' .0033 .
8009- . ,33-489--'- ,
.
'- .0003 . : ,,
. ,03-70-'- ,.
,'; - ,'; ,' .0007 .
8007- . ,07-453--'- ,.
,' .0009 . .
.
.0030 . ' .40.
,' .0030 . .
, ,.
,'; - ,'; ,' 0030 . .
:
. ,30-463--'- ,.
,'; - ,'; ,'; ,' 0030 . .
. ,30-430--'- ,.
,'; ,' .3777 . . ,77-633--'-
,.
,'; ,' .0006 . : , .'-
,.
75
76
:
:0 , :
()%
444
909
1,575
"
40
52
52
58
48
48
23
32
28
08-06
22
21
21
65-07
39
32
35
40-64
16
15
16
35-43
38.4
36.7
69.5
2
1
2
/
16
9
12
/
54
49
47
/
37
41
39
/
5
4
5
14
11
13
10
9
9
32
36
34
4
6
5
"
35
34
34
.
, .
: ( )n=909 ( )n=1,575
. "" ))response
( - 3 - 0 , ) , - """ ,"" , " "" .
. : = .3/
: , .
: .
77
.
, ,
. """ , "" , "" , ",
" " "".
78
:0 (") : ,
0
,
"
"
54-37
38-3
4-0
7,730 06,833
6,820
84,865
"*
38
14
0
27
1
5-0"
19
17
8
16
9
33-4"
)(5
26
53
24
30
30"
)(3
14
19
12
07
35-36"
()4
29
20
21
63
+34"
*
88
36
)(3
34
0
(())3
0
0
)(1
9
"
)(4
8
)(2
6
(())0
65
68
86
21
))((1
23
37
18
86
)(3
9
6
7
15
-
))((1
13
35
10
30
*
39
8
0
86
0
5-0"
33
()5
()6
7
2
33-4"
7
66
64
84
24
30"
/ +36"
9
50
49
33
37
(())3
36
36
00
30
.04%- .50%-
* p<.05
3 " 0007 34-06
.
:8 , ()%
"
84,865
"
24
5-0"*
7
33-4"
26
30" *
33
/ +36"
10
* p<.05 :
79
03,836
15
8
34
35
8
03,000
34
6
18
31
11
:3 ,
()%
54-37
38-3
4-0
"
7,731
14,233
4,281
26,245
"
*
33
93
300
59
06
00
0
02
65
8
0
06
09
(())3
0
9
/
- , *
26
80
100
61
42
15
0
25
26
()4
0
12
6
(())1
0
8
.04%- .50%-
* p<.05 :
:6 ( ) 0, ()%
34-43
40-64
65-07
08-06
35
59
76
82
45
43
33
18
16
87
22
8
6
2
2
/
47
30
22
14
87
4
- ( )
00
20
22
7
02
35
39
41
43
60
43
41
37
50
42
/
31
30
75
75
46
47
31
20
21
82
22
9
5
4
2
/
48
27
16
19
85
4
- ( )
20
21
26
18
21
43
38
38
31
37
37
41
36
51
68
/
3 " 0007 35-04
.
81
:
:0 , ()%
"
300
83
99
30
37
33
:8 , ()%
"
300
94
44
00
37
04
30
81
:3 0, ()%
"
100
80 81 78
74
77 78 76
73 74 73
70
66
75
63
59
57
50
25
51-65
35-50
29-34
23-28
"
1 " 0007
34-06 .
82
:0 : 0,
()%
36"
30" ,
33-4
4-0
" "
"
1,066
4,572
4,516
1,065 1,988
13,207
N
95
87
86
39
90
20
*
N
*
08,944
75
95
774 6,333
79
56
60
33
8,364
78
33
6,063
90
93
0,642
85
84
80
96
30
45
07
96
.04%- .50%-
* p<.05 :
3 " 0007
34-06 .
:8 , ()%
54-37
38-3
4-0
"
7,731
14,233
4,281
26,245
"
*
()4
60
44
87
7
00
37
07
()6
7
33
7
33
63
35
60
22
5
))((1
9
.04%- .50%-
* p<.05 :
:3 0, ()%
"
43
53
62
50
53
60
7
36
00
/
30
39
03
59
40
69
56
66
37
/
83
:6
0, ()%
"
58
57
69
39
09
80
33
30
08
05
30
09
3 " 0007
35-04 .
:5 :
0 , ()%
+36
30"
33-4
"
5-0" "
"
41
42
45
42
38
* 42
40
33
31
29
22
31
(*)
()
41
40
36
25
40
35
41
35
39
42
42
65
79
88
84
90
59
* ;p<.05 : .
3 " 0007 35-04
.
61
:4 :
0, ()%
"
0,888
740
0,928
N
28
54
38
45
44
45
09
(())0
07
/
40
40
50
68
50
39
(())33
(())30
()00
/
3 " 0007
35-04 .
84
:
:0
()%
"
2,901
6,669
10,190
4,558
" 24,312
*
35
19
15
38
23
""
()3
8
18
13
13
""
40
70
62
45
58
""
22
()3
5
()4
6
""
.04%-
* p<.05 :
:
:0 , ()%
"
40-64
65-07
08-06
10,290
6,399
6,221
" 26,245
*
10
51
74
34
0
21
36
24
24
0-3
38
11
))((2
21
5-6
31
))((2
0
21
+4
09 *
23
51
73
65
0
31
38
25
32
0-3
38
9
))((2
19
5-6
8
))((2
0
4
+4
09*
8
0
0
6
09 *
56
99
100
70
0
28
))((1
0
15
0-3
14
0
0
9
5-6
)(3
0
0
6
+4
34-43
3,335
))((3
)(8
21
68
53
40
11
))((3
)(5
))((3
25
29
42
.04%- .50%-
* p<.05 :
85