CIVIL PROCEDURE

Case Outline
Atty. Melissa Romana P. Suarez
Modes of Discovery Rule 23-29; AM 03-1-09
Rule 23
Topic
Sec. 1

Case Title
RP [PCCG] v. SB
Producers Bank v. CA
RP v. SB and Lucio Tan
Elena Ong v. Judge Mazo
Ayala Land [ALI] v. Judge Tagle
Philippine Computer v. Judge Hernandez
Disini v. SB

Citation
Solano
Tautho
Uy

Alabastro
Alvar
Anima
Arafol

GR
90478
100495
112710
145542
153667
168776
175730

Date
Nov 21, 1991
Jan 29, 1998
May 30, 2001
Jun 4, 2004
Aug 11, 2005
Jul 17, 2007
Jul 5, 2010

Aug 17, 1999

Aug 16, 2004
Dec 9, 2005
Jul 10. 2006
Oct 31, 2008
Dec 16, 2011

People v. Webb
Jonathan Landoil v. Mangudadatu
Jowel Sales v. Cyril Sabino
Rudencio Tiu v. CA
Pajarillaga v. CA
RP v. SB

Bajenting
Bungabong
Camello
Canada
Ceballo

132577
155010
133154
142596
163515
152375

Sec. 11, 12,

14

Pfeger Dulay v. Rodrigo Dulay

Cerbo

158857

Nov 11, 2005

Sec. 16, 18

Fortune Corporation v. CA
San Luis v. Judge Rojas
Espiritu v Tankiansee

Cervantes
Cuabo
Datukon

108119
159127
164153

Jan 19, 1994

Mar 3, 2008
Jun 13, 2011

Case Title

Citation

Case Title

Citation
Diesto
Gonzales
Jambangan
Juezan
Juyo

Sec. 4

Basadre

Rule 24
Topic

GR

Date

GR
101682
117574
105997
118438
153034

Date
Dec 14, 1992
Jan 2, 1997
Sep 26, 1997
Dec 4, 1998
Sep 20, 2005

Sec. 4

Rule 26
Topic
Sec. 2

Briboneria v. CA
Concrete Aggregates v. CA
Spouses Bella v. CA
Allied Agri-Business v. Cherry Valley
DBP v. CA

Limos v. Spouses Odones

Lim

186979

Aug 11, 2010

Citation
Logramonte
Lumanag
Madriaga

Mendoza

GR
103922
172175
154988
164805

Date
Jul 9, 1996
Oct 9, 2006
Jun 21, 2007
Apr 30, 2008

Citation
Mier
Morales

GR
98-1159
02-1396

Date
Aug 3, 1998
Mar 15, 2004

Citation
Morilla

GR
122629

Date
Dec 2, 1998

Case Title

Citation
Murcia

GR
128609

Date
Jan 29, 2004

Case Title

Citation
Pader
Remollo

GR
159275
152375

Date
Aug 25, 2010
Dec 16, 2011

Case Title

Citation
Remoroza

GR
121404

Date
May 3, 2006

Case Title

Citation
Reyes
Sagarino
Salmite

GR
02-1699
01-1459
09-2183

Date
Oct 15, 2003
Jan 31, 2005
Jul 7, 2009

Rule 29
Topic
Sec. 3,5

Case Title
Santiago Land v. CA
Spouses Zepeda v. China Bank
Jaravata v. Karolus
Solidbank v. Gateway Electronics

Rule 30
Topic
Sec. 2

Case Title
Matias v. Judge Plan
Azucar v. Judge Ocampo

Topic

Case Title
Pepsi-cola v. CA

Sec. 3
Topic
Anama v. CA

Sec. 4
Topic
Sec. 5

RP v. SB
RP v. SB

Topic
Saludo v. CA

Sec. 8
Topic
Sec. 9

Umali-Paco v. Judge Quilala

Nieva v. Alvarez-Edad
Concerned Lawyers v. Judge Pornillos

Rule 31
Topic
Sec. 1,2

Case Title
Active Wood v. CA
People v. Judge Mangrobang
People v. SB
Spouses De Vera v. Agloro
Philippine Savings Bank v. Manalac
PNB v. Gotesco
Bank of Commerce v. Judge Bernabe
Deutsche Bank v. CA

Citation
Sarno
Seredrica
Solano
Sy
Tautho
Uy
Yap
Alvar

GR
86603
130907
14945
155673
145441
183211
172393
193065

Date
Feb 5, 1990
Nov 27, 2001
Aug 21, 2003
Jan 14, 2005
Apr 26, 2005
Jun 5, 2009
Oct 20, 2010
Feb 27, 2012

Citation
Anima
Arafol
Anima
Arafol

GR
123346
122216
L-23683
164195

Date
Dec 14, 2007
Mar 28, 2001
Jul 30, 1969
Feb 6, 2007

Citation
Camello
Canada
Ceballo
Cerbo
Cervantes
Cuabo

GR
138739
161817
165496
159189
168151
183965

Date
Jul 6, 2000
Jul 30, 2004
Feb 12, 2007
Feb 21, 2007
Sep 4, 2009
Sep 18, 2009

Citation
Datukon
Diesto
Gonzales
Jambangan
Juezan

GR
160242
156474
156304
166393
163280

Date
May 17, 2005
Aug 16, 2005
Oct 23, 2006
Jun 18, 2009
Feb 2, 2010

Citation
Juyo
Lim
Logramonte

GR
170320
14886
153867

Date
Jul 27, 2000
Aug 21, 2003
Feb 17, 2005

Rule 32
Topic
Sec. 2,3,9
Sec. 3,5,10
Sec. 10
Sec. 11

Case Title
Manotok Realty v. CLT
Aljems Corporation v. CA
Apurillo v. Judge Garciano
Apo Fruits v. CA

Rule 33
Topic
Sec. 1

Case Title
Radiowealth v. Del Rosario
Celino v. Heirs of Santiago
Park v. Choi
Manila Banking v. University of Baguio
RCL of Singapore v. The Netherlands
Uy v. Chua

Rule 34
Topic
Sec. 1

Case Title
Asian Construction v. CA
Mongao v. Pryce
Meneses v. Secretary of Agrarian
Reillo v. San Jose
Sunbanon v. Go

Rule 35
Topic
Sec. 1, 2, 4

Case Title
Garcia v. CA
Evangelista v. Mercator
Wood Technology v. Equitable

Bitanga v. Pyramid Construction

NPC v. Vda. De Capin
De Carlos v. Sandoval
BPI v. Yu
Atty. Gubat v. NPC
Cocofed v. RP

Topic
Sec. 3

Case Title

Lumanag
Madriaga

Mendoza
Mier
Morales
Morilla

Citatio
n

Mallilin v. Castillo
Garcia v. Llamas
Consunji v.Duvaz
Eland v. Garcia
Ybiernas v. Tanco-Gabaldon

173526
175176
179922
184122
167415
177857

GR
136803
154127
155174
173289
178925

Aug 28, 2008

Oct 17, 2008
Dec 16, 2008
Jan 20, 2010
Feb 26, 2010
Jan 24, 2012

Date
Jun 16, 2000
Dec 8, 2003
Aug 4, 2009
Feb 19, 2010
Jun 1, 2011

Rule 36
Topic
Sec. 1

Topic
Sec. 4

Case Title

Citatio
n

Borromeo v. CA
Consolidated Bank v. IAC
PCI Bank v. CA
Marchadesch v. De Yepes
Mocorro v. Ramirez
Dela Pena v. CA
Bongcac v. SB

Case Title

Citatio
n

Heirs of Sy Bang v. Rolando Sy

GR

Date

L-82273
73777
120739
151160
178366
177828
156687

Jun 1, 1990
Sep 12, 1990
Jul 20, 2000
Nov 11, 2004
Jul 28, 2008
Feb 13, 2009
May 31, 2009

GR

Date

114217

Oct 13, 2009

Rule 37
Topic
Sec. 1

Topic

Case Title

Citatio
n

Cansino v. CA
RP v. Hidalgo
Multi Trans v. Oriental
Co v. People

Case Title
Estate of Macadangdang v. Gaviola

Citatio
n

GR

Date

125799
161657
180817
160265

Aug 21, 2003

Oct 4, 2007
Jun 23, 2009
Jul 13, 2009

GR

Date

156809

Mar 4, 2009

Sec. 2

Topic
Sec. 3

Topic
Sec. 6

Topic
Sec. 9

Case Title

Citatio
n

RP v. Yang Chi Hao

Case Title

165332

Citatio
n

Terana v. Judge Sagun

Case Title

GR

Citatio
n

Jaban v. City of Cebu

Datu v. Sy

Date
Oct 2, 2009

GR

Date

152131

Apr 29, 2009

GR

Date

138336
143701

Feb 16, 2004

Mar 23, 2004

GR

Date

119118
179955
173379

Feb 19, 2001

Apr 24, 2009
Dec 1, 2010

GR

Date

Rule 38
Topic
Sec. 1

Topic
Sec. 2

Topic
Sec. 3

Case Title

Citatio
n

Valencia v. CA
Sy Bang v. Rosauro Sy
Afdal v. Carlos

Case Title

Citatio
n

PCI Bank v. CA

Case Title
Mercury Drug v. CA
Manipor v. Ricafort
Cerezo v. Tuazon
Purcon v. MRM
Samonte v. Naguiat

120739

Citatio
n

Jul 20, 2000

GR

Date

138571
150159
141538
182718
165544

Jul 13, 2000

Jul 25, 2003
Mar 23, 2004
Sep 26, 2008
Oct 2, 2009