Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
2009
www.che.com
K
i
r
K
P
a
t
r
i
c
K
a
w
a
r
d
H
e
a
t
-
t
r
a
n
s
f
e
r
f
l
u
i
d
s
r
e
t
r
i
e
v
i
n
g
P
l
a
n
t
-
d
e
s
i
g
n
d
a
t
a
v
o
l
.
1
1
6
n
o
.
1
3
d
e
c
e
m
b
e
r
2
0
0
9
13
PAGE 17
Building A
Better Dryer
Screeners
Target Efciency
Retrieving
Plant-Design Data
Millichannel
Reactors
Focus on
Level Measurement
And Control
Heat-
Transfer
Fluids
PAGE 32
Facts At Your
Fingertips:
Control Valves
01_CHE_120109_COV.indd 1 11/19/09 9:52:20 AM
It takes the right uids to achieve high levels of performance,
productivity and economy. For operating supplies that meet critical
functional and protection needs in demanding applications, choose
performance uids from Dow. We supply advanced, proven, and
reliable solutions for heat transfer, lubrication, uid power, freeze
and corrosion protection, and deicing.
WIhE8M
8iIicooe
IheraI FIuids increase processing efciency and economics in
high temperature processing environments. www.dowtherm.com
WIhE8M
, WF88I
aod W6AL
IycoI-based
heat IraosIer FIuids help prevent system corrosion and freeze
damage in water-based HVAC, food and beverage, and other
systems. www.dowfrost.com
N8kL
flow control
valve* cinches the spout concen-
tricallyon a horizontal axis for
easier tie-offs and greater flow
control, and vertically in a tight
zigzag pattern to prevent leaks.
In addition, it resists jamming,
breaking and leaking, and allows
full-open discharge from bag
spouts of all popular diameters.
USDA Dairy Accepted.
Cinch spouts concentrically
with POWER-CINCHER
clamp ring*
creates a high-integrity, sealed
connection between the clean
side of the bag spout and the
clean side of the telescoping
tube. This prevents contamination
of the product, while eliminating
the plant contamination that
occurs when falling material
rapidly displaces air and dust.
It also stretches the spout down-
ward in combination with the
TELE-TUBE
telescoping tube*
(at right).
Eliminate dust during
hook-up/discharge with
SPOUT-LOCK
clamp ring*
The BAG-VAC
system vacuums
displaced air and dust from the
receiving vessel and returns clean
air to the plant. The vacuum also
causes empty bags to collapse
dust-free prior to disconnect,
eliminating the dust emitted
during manual flattening of
empty bags. With optional
double-wall telescoping
tube, it vacuums any parti-
cles dropped from spout
creases during discon-
nect, while eliminating
awkward access ports.
Prevent dead spots and pro-
mote flow with TELE-TUBE
telescoping tube*
Eliminate dust during
disconnect and bag collapse
with BAG-VAC
system
The TELE-TUBE
telescoping
tube* pneumatically raises the
SPOUT-LOCK
No Pooling: eliminates
the pooling found in
globe-type bodies.
DUB Al
13th Annual World Congress
GLOBAL CONFERENCES,
STUDIES, PROJECTS
MAACK BUSINESS SERVICES
Maack & Scheidl Partnership
Plastics Technology and Marketing
Plastics Technology and Marketing
CH-8804 Au/near Zrich, Switzerland
Tel: +41-44-78130 40
Fax: +41-44-78115 69
E-mail: MBSpolymer@bluewin.ch
www.MBSpolymer.com
GLOBAL CONFERENCES,
STUDIES, PROJECTS
MAACK BUSINESS SERVICES presents
Save
the
date!
Organized by: For more information:
110 William Street, 11th Floor
New York, NY 10038
Attn: Conference Department
Phone: +1 212-621-4978
Fax: +1 212-621-4970
www.mbspolymer.com/DB2010
Email: events@chemweek.com
GLOBAL CONFERENCES,
STUDIES, PROJECTS
MAACK BUSINESS SERVICES
Maack & Scheidl Partnership
Plastics Technology and Marketing
Plastics Technology and Marketing
CH-8804 Au/near Zrich, Switzerland
Tel: +41-44-78130 40
Fax: +41-44-78115 69
E-mail: MBSpolymer@bluewin.ch
www.MBSpolymer.com
GLOBAL CONFERENCES,
STUDIES, PROJECTS
MAACK BUSINESS SERVICES
16538
Hear about the |atest deve|opments |n p|ast|cs and po|ymers
Quest|on speakers d|rect|y about the|r |atest products
and serv|ces
Meet w|th potent|a| customers, co||eagues, and contacts
from the M|dd|e East p|ast|cs and po|ymers |ndustr|es
Compan|es who attended |ast year:
ADBlC Akzo Nobel Polymer Chemicals Albemarle APPC
Astra BASF Borealis Borouge Chemtura Cosmoplast
Evonik Degussa ExxonMobil Gulf Stabilizers lndorama
lPCC LyondellBasell Milliken NATPET NAPCO Nestl
Novaa Oman PP Oriental Petroleum Pliant P&G
Petro Rabigh Polyplex QAPCO Reliance SABlC
Samsung Total Shell SlNOPEC Songwon Sun Ace
Taghleef TASNEE TetraPak Zamil and more!
Who shou|d attend:
Senior executives and managers in Production, Purchasing,
R&D, Sales/Marketing and Business development at:
Polymer producers Plastics convertors and end users
Pipe system suppliers and Packaging producers
Additive suppliers and compounders Machinery suppliers
Tab|e-top expos|t|on
Group d|scuss|on pane|s
Hosp|ta||ty funct|on rooms
Major sponsors
Supported by:
16538 Maack Dubai_PPCWK.indd 1 11/20/09 11:04:45 AM XX_CHE_1209_Full_pg_ads.indd 10 11/23/09 7:45:49 AM
C
hanges in the rate of corrosion in
water tubes have been detected
within minutes by an externally
mounted monitor developed by the
Center for Nuclear Energy Research
(CNER, Fredericton, NB, Canada; www.
unb.ca/cner). The data were obtained in
online tests over the past 18 months on
a black liquor recovery boiler at a kraft
mill operated by Irving Pulp and Paper
Ltd. (Saint John, NB). Details were pre-
sented at the recent TAPPI Conference
(see story above).
The monitor operates on the principle
of hydrogen effusion. In the corrosion
process, two moles of hydrogen atoms
are produced for every mole of iron that
is dissolved into water, explains Kelly
McKeen, a CNER project manager. The
atomic H
2
migrates through the wall of
the steel tube and recombines to form
H
2
gas, which is captured in CNERs
hydrogen effusion probe (HEP). The
HEP measures the rate of H
2
pressure
increase and converts it to a corrosion
rate of millimeters per year.
The HEP consists of a silver cup that
is clamped to the outside of the tube, sil-
ver tubing, a pressure transducer and a
valve. McKeen points out that silver is
practically impermeable to H
2
. The sys-
tem is operated under vacuum and the
valve is automatically opened to allow
evacuation of the H
2
and to restart a
cycle after a predetermined pressure
setpoint is reached.
McKeen says the main advantage of
the HEP over conventional methods, such
Non-invasive probe measures corrosion inside boiler water tubes in real time
A
multi-stage wet scrubber that combines
the removal of sulfur, hydrogen chloride,
sulfuric acid mist (SAM) and particulate
matter (PM) in a single unit has reduced
sulfur dioxide emissions by an average of
99.7% in its first large-scale commercial
installation on a coal/oil-fired swing boiler.
PM emissions were reduced to 0.005 grains/
dscf (dry standard cubic feet; 12.5 mg/Nm
3
),
according to Kimmo Peltonen, a product
manager with Andritz, Inc. (Roswell, Ga.;
www.andritz.com), who spoke at the recent
TAPPI Engineering, Pulping and Environ-
mental Conference in Memphis, Tenn. An-
dritz markets the technology together with
EnviroCare International (American Can-
yon, Calif.; www.envirocare.com).
The installation is on a 420,000-lb/h
boiler at a large pulp-and-paper mill. Pre-
viously, smaller systems had been installed
in rotary kilns and municipal sludge incin-
erators, says Peltonen. In the first stage of
the process (flowsheet), large particles are
removed from hot fluegas by an atomized-
water-spray quench. From the quench, the
stream enters the lower half of a scrubber-
separator vessel a vertical, cylindrical
unit, where the upflowing gas is scrubbed
by a countercurrent water stream.
The gas flows up through a Venturi stage
that consists of about 40 parallel Venturi
tubes, each preceded by a high-pressure
liquid atomizer. The combination of the Ven-
turis with finely atomized sprays causes
multiple collisions between the droplets
and fine particles left in the gas, resulting
in high particulate capture as well as acid
absorption, says Peltonen. Final cleanup is
achieved by a set of dual-orifice mist-elimi-
nation trays. Most of the water used in the
process is recycled to the Venturi stage after
makeup water and caustic have been added.
The rest is collected in a sump at the bot-
tom of the scrubber-separator and recycled
to the quench section. Dissolved solids con-
centration is controlled by blowing down a
fraction of the recycled water.
Peltonen says the installed cost is ap-
proximately 50% that of a traditional ar-
rangement of a dry electrostatic precipita-
tor (ESP) followed by a wet scrubber or wet
ESP. Chemical costs are minimized by re-
using alkali present in the fly ash.
Note: For more information, circle the 3-digit number
on p. 62, or use the website designation.
CHEMICAL ENGINEERING WWW.CHE.COM DECEMBER 2009 11
(Continues on p. 12)
Edited by Gerald Ondrey December 2009
Cleaned fluegas
to atmosphere
Fluegas
from boiler
Quench
Quench
pumps
Quench
recirculation
tank
Venturi stage
recirculation
tank
Venturi stage pumps
inlet & throat pumps
Tray pumps
Caustic
Makeup water
Blow down
Mist eliminator
Preventing droplet carry over
Tray 2
Flushing removal of dirty mist
Tray 1
Removal of SO
2
& HCl,
and all PM>1 micron
Removal of
coarse PM
(particulate
matter)
and some SO
2
and HCl
True venturi tubes
Condensation and
agglomeration of H
2
SO
4
,
fumes and submicron PM
Removal of any remaining SO
2
All-in-one fluegas scrubber cleans
up sulfur and particulate matter
The power of osmosis
Last month, Statkraft (Oslo,
Norway; www.statkraft.com)
opened what is claimed to be
the world's frst osmotic power
plant. Although the prototype
is very small (designed for 10
kW), the company believes
data gained from the pilot
study will lead to a commer-
cial-scale unit by 2015.
The plant is located along
the coast at Tofte, south of
Oslo. Fresh water fowing into
the sea is diverted to a vessel
containing a semipermeable
membrane (spiral-wound,
cellulose acetate) with brine
(Continues on p. 12)
06_CHE_120109_CHM.indd 11 11/19/09 10:11:50 AM
CHEMENTATOR
A
process that produces 7585 gal of ethanol
per dry ton of mixed cellulosic waste feed
will be commercialized by BlueFire Ethanol
(Irvine, Calif.; www.bluefireethanol.com).
The plant, to be built in Lancaster, Calif.,
will convert 130 dry ton/d of feed (post-sorted
municipal solid waste, including green waste)
into 4-million gal/yr (about 12,000 gal/d) of
ethanol when it goes into production in the
fall of 2010. It will mark the first commer-
cial use of a process developed by Arkenol,
Inc. (also of Irvine), although the process has
been tested in three pilot plants.
The process uses concentrated sulfuric
acid as a catalyst to transform cellulose and
hemicellulose feedstocks into glucose and
xylose (C6 and C5) sugars. The yield is 1.53
times those of processes that use a combina-
tion of dilute sulfuric acid and enzymes for
hydrolysis, says John Cuzens, senior vice-
president of BlueFire and a former principal
with Arkenol.
Coarsely ground feed is dried to less than
10% moisture, contacted with 75% concen-
trated acid, and cooked at about 85C and
ambient pressure for under 30 min. The
hydrolyzed C6 and C5 sugars and acid are
then separated from lignin and other sol-
ids, which are used as boiler fuel for process
steam and plant power. About
98% of the acid and 100% of
the sugars are recovered in a
simulated moving-bed chro-
matographic separator. Acid
is recycled and the sugars are
converted to ethanol by con-
tinuous fermentation, using yeast (conver-
sion is 100% for C6 sugars and 20% for C5s).
The sugars may also be converted to higher-
value products, using heterotrophic algae,
bacteria or fungi.
Cuzens says the key elements of the pro-
cess are the use of concentrated acid and of
chromatographic separation, which recovers
the acid rather than neutralizing it and dis-
posing of the waste. The Lancaster plant will
have an operating cost of $1.502/gal (not in-
cluding a $1.01/gal tax credit), he says, and a
full-scale plant of 50-million gal/yr will have
an operating cost of below 80/gal.
H
aldor Topse A/S (Lyngby, Denmark;
www.topsoe.com) has signed a design
contract with an undisclosed client in
China for a new plant that will produce
substitute natural gas (SNG). When
the plant comes on stream in 2011, it
will produce close to 180,000 Nm
3
/h of
SNG using Topses methanation pro-
cess, called TREMP. The plant will be
the first large-scale order for TREMP
technology, says general manager Jens
Perregaard, New Technologies, Tech-
nology Division.
The Topse high-temperature metha-
nation process (for flowsheet, see CE,
February 2007, p. 11) uses coal-derived
syngas (H
2
-to-CO ratio of slightly above
3), which has been passed through a
sulfur-tolerant shift and acid-gas re-
moval unit for removing H
2
S and excess
carbon (as CO
2
). In order to protect the
methanation catalyst Topses nickel-
based MCR from poisoning, the feed
is first passed through a sulfur guard
bed to remove traces of sulfur compo-
nents. Desulfurized feed is then mixed
with recycle gas to control the maxi-
mum temperature rise and passed to
the first methanation reactor, where H
2
reacts with CO and CO
2
to form CH
4
.
The reaction is performed in a reactor
with a very large DT and at the same
time with a technology preventing the
formation of nickel carbonyl. The DT
ensures that heat can efficiently be re-
covered from the exothermic reaction
and used for generating superheated,
high-pressure steam. The cooled gas
then passes through two or three meth-
anation reactors in series for complete
conversion. Products leaving the last re-
actor are cooled and compressed to meet
pipeline specifications. The SNG is typi-
cally 9496 mol.% CH
4
, with a heating
value of 950978 Btu/scf.
The commercial debut for a process that makes natural gas from coal
12 CHEMICAL ENGINEERING WWW.CHE.COM DECEMBER 2009
on the other side. Water from
the fresh side passes through
the membrane due to the con-
centration difference, thereby
increasing the pressure on the
brine side. This osmotic pres-
sure equivalent to a 120-m
column of water (about 12 bar)
is then used to drive a tur-
bine for making electricity.
The company estimates the
global potential of osmotic
power at 1,600 to 1,700 TWh/
yr equivalent to 50% of the
EUs total power production.
Efficient Cl
2
production
The oxygen-depolarized
cathode (ODC) of Bayer
MaterialScience (BMS; Le-
(Continues on p. 14)
Acid
reconcentration
Steam
Lignin
Filter
1st stage
hydrolysis
Acid/Sugar
Biomass
Dilute sulfuric acid
Sugars
Lime
Gypsum
Chromatographic
separation
Acid recovery
Yeast recycle
Water
Condensate
return
Concentrated sulfuric acid
Solution
Steam
Sugar solution
Solids
Pump
Water
Continuous
fermentation
Distillation and dehydration
Ethanol product
Ethanol
beer
Process
water recycle
as weight-loss coupons, ultrasonic measure-
ment and other types of H
2
probes is that
it provides a realtime, online response. Also,
it can be operated at temperatures above
350C, compared with a maximum of about
250C for other H
2
probes. The systems
rapid reaction to an increased corrosion rate
was proved during a boiler shutdown, when
the tubes were drained and cleaned with
inhibited hydrochloric acid. McKeen says
CNER is now negotiating with a petroleum
company to do a test in a refinery.
CORROSION INSIDE BOILER WATER TUBES
(Continued from p. 15)
Higher yields and lower cost are expected
for this biomass-to-ethanol process
(Continued from p. 12)
06_CHE_120109_CHM.indd 12 11/19/09 10:12:37 AM
To learn more about Honeywell field solutions, please call
1-877-466-3993 or visit www.honeywell.com/ps
2008 Honeywell International, Inc. All rights reserved.
expanded solutions
Honeywells field solution portfolio keeps
getting bigger and bigger.
Reliable and cost-effective, we offer a constantly expanding
portfolio of field solutions to satisfy a broad range of your
process needs. From analytical sensors and transmitters, to
pressure and temperature transmitters, to flow and tank
gauging solutions, Honeywell offers many solutions. Honeywells collection of field solutions
let you tackle any job with ease to improve business performance.
H
F
S
_
E
x
p
S
o
l
u
t
i
o
n
s
A
d
0
5
-
0
8
P
u
b
:
C
h
e
m
i
c
a
l
E
n
g
i
n
e
e
r
i
n
g
T
r
i
m
S
i
z
e
:
7
.
8
7
5
"
x
1
0
.
7
5
"
B
l
e
e
d
:
8
.
1
2
5
x
1
1
C
o
l
o
r
:
4
c
HFS Exp Solutions Ad Chem Eng 05-08 4/24/08 1:55 PM Page 1
Circle 11 on p. 62 or go to adlinks.che.com/23021-11
XX_CHE_1209_Full_pg_ads.indd 13 11/20/09 9:33:47 AM
I
ncineration is becoming the only via-
ble method for sewage sludge disposal
as landfilling or spreading sludge onto
farmland is no longer permitted in some
countries. Today, sludge is commonly in-
cinerated in large, centralized incinera-
tors or as an additive in coal-fired power
plants or cement kilns. An alternative to
these costly and inconvenient options
small, localized incinerators has been
developed by Huber SE (Berching, Ger-
many; www.huber.de), in cooperation
with partners in a three-year project
supported under the European Commis-
sions Life program.
The new incinerators are based on
Hubers sludge2energy process (flow-
sheet). Sludge is first pre-dried in a belt
dryer to a solids concentration of up to
90% by blowing hot (90C) air through
the belts. The cooled air is reheated
with heat recovered from the incinera-
tor and recirculated through the dryer.
A slight underpressure is maintained in
the dryer to prevent the release of air,
vapors and odors. Dried sludge is then
conveyed to a small furnace. The hot flu-
egas from the furnace passes through a
heat recuperator that transfers the heat
to compressed ambient air, which drives
a micro gas turbine and electricity gen-
erator. Even small systems can produce
enough electricity and supply sufficient
heat to run the entire process nearly au-
tothermally, says the firm.
Formation of oxides of nitrogen are
prevented by staged combustion, fluegas
recirculation and selective, non-catalytic
reduction. Acid gases (such as SO
2
and
HCl) are neutralized by lime addition,
and remaining organic components are
adsorbed by activated carbon.
Huber is designing the first sludge2en-
ergy demonstration plant for the Bavar-
ian city of Straubing. This first plant
will have a capacity to incinerate 2,200
metric tons per year (m.t./yr) of dried
solids and will generate approximately
100 kW of electric power. Startup for the
plant is planned for the end of 2010.
14 CHEMICAL ENGINEERING WWW.CHE.COM DECEMBER 2009
CHEMENTATOR
verkusen, Germany; www.
bayermaterialscience.com) will
be used to produce chlorine on
an industrial scale. BMS is in
negotiations with Uhde GmbH
(Dortmund, Germany; www.
uhde.biz) to build an ODC
plant scheduled to start up
in 2011. The OCD technology
(see CE, February 2001, pp.
3135) enables electrolysis
to be performed at a lower
voltage, thereby generating
energy savings of up to 30%.
BMS has been using this tech-
nology to recover Cl
2
from HCl,
and has been operating the
largest HCl electrolysis plant at
its site in Shanghai since 2008
(CE, October 2006, p. 16).
Direct polymerization
Last month, construction on
a production plant for thermo-
plastic methacrylate resin was
completed in Shanghai. The
facility will mark the commer-
cial debut for the Continuous
L
ast month, a photocatalytic water-clean-
ing system that removes organic and
inorganic contaminants that are difficult
to breakdown from wastewater was inau-
gurated at the German Aerospace Center
(DLR; Stuttgart; www.dlr.de) facility in
Lampildshausem. The so-called RayWOx
system features a new type of solar receiver
consisting of glass pipes. Wastewater mixed
with an iron salt the iron ion serving as
photocatalyst and hydrogen peroxide
flows through the tubes until the absorbed
solar radiation has decomposed the contam-
inants. In pilot trials, the RayWOx process
has been shown to be effective for decon-
taminating water containing pharmaceuti-
cal agents; X-ray contrast media and hor-
mones as well as chlorinated hydrocarbons
from contaminated groundwater; harmful
substances in exhaust-air scrubbing solu-
tions from textile manufacturing; and toxic
materials in municipal wastewater.
The system operating at Lampildshausem,
developed in collaboration with Hirschmann
Laborgerte GmbH (Eberstadt) and KACO
new energy GmbH (Neckarsulm; www.kaco-
newenergy.de), has a solar reactor 49-m long
and 470-cm wide and can clean about 4,500
L of industrial wastewater, removing of all
oxidizable contamination in 2 h (given suit-
able weather conditions). The demonstration
unit is able to completely clean the cooling
water from the engine test facilities at the
DLR Institute of Space Propulsion, which
is contaminated with rocket fuels and their
combustion products, such as hydrazine and
its derivatives, and nitrite.
The hydrazine derivatives are slow to de-
grade with previously applied ultraviolet
(UV) oxidation technology, notes Christian
Jung, a scientist at the DLRs Institute for
Technical Thermodynamics. The UV reac-
tors consume large amounts of electrical
energy for powering lamps, and for fast
pumping to dissipate waste heat and UV
oxidation typically needs 23 times more
oxidant (H
2
O
2
and caroate), he adds. In con-
trast, the oxidant requirement of the iron-
catalyzed RayWOx process is close to the
theoretical demand, which saves 5080% of
the H
2
O
2
required, he says.
Modular construction of the RayWOx
technology makes is easy to install and well
suited to building systems of any desired size.
KACO new energy has commercialized the
technology under the RayWOx tradename.
Using the sun to decontaminate wastewater
(Continues on p. 16)
T G
Sewage sludge
4% DM
Sludge
25% DM
Sludge
90% DM
Buffer
storage
Air
Ash Future
phosphate
Heat for drying
Preheated
combustion air
Hot air
Flue
gas
Flue gas
Stack Residue
Dryer
Flue
gas
Flue gas
cleaning
Combustion
Heat
recovery
Air
Dewatering
Filtrate
Off gas
Onsite incineration of sewage
sludge to be demonstrated
(Continued from p. 12)
06_CHE_120109_CHM.indd 14 11/19/09 10:13:21 AM
*75019_2*
DOC PATH: Production:Volumes:Production:MICROSOFT:MECHANICALS:75019_Dynamics:DOCS:75019_2M_Dynamics_M4.indd
IMAGES:
75020_BACKGROUND_SW300_01.tif CMYK 450 ppi 100% Up to Date Production:MICROSOFT:_MASTER_ART:75020_Dynamics:75020_BACKGROUND_SW300_01.tif
75020_Schorr_Tag_SW300_02.psd CMYK 1200 ppi 100% Up to Date Production:MICROSOFT:_MASTER_ART:75020_Dynamics:75020_Schorr_Tag_SW300_02.psd
75020_Steele_Tag_SW300_02.psd CMYK 1200 ppi 100% Up to Date Production:MICROSOFT:_MASTER_ART:75020_Dynamics:75020_Steele_Tag_SW300_02.psd
75020_Price_Tag_SW300_04.psd CMYK 1200 ppi 100% Up to Date Production:MICROSOFT:_MASTER_ART:75020_Dynamics:75020_Price_Tag_SW300_04.psd
75020_Desai_Tag_SW300_06.psd CMYK 1200 ppi 100% Up to Date Production:MICROSOFT:_MASTER_ART:75020_Dynamics:75020_Desai_Tag_SW300_06.psd
75020_Mitsu_1Tag_Right_SW300_04.psd CMYK 1164 ppi 103.03% Up to Date Production:MICROSOFT:_MASTER_ART:75020_Dynamics:75020_Mitsu_1Tag_Right_SW300_04.psd
75020_Mitsu_2Tag_Left_SW300_02.psd CMYK 1215 ppi 98.72% Up to Date Production:MICROSOFT:_MASTER_ART:75020_Dynamics:75020_Mitsu_2Tag_Left_SW300_02.psd
75020_Rowe_Tag_SW300_04.psd CMYK 1200 ppi, 1437 ppi, 1281 ppi 100%, 83.49%, 93.67% Up to Date Production:MICROSOFT:_MASTER_ART:75020_Dynamics:75020_Rowe_Tag_SW300_04.psd
75020_Mitsu_1_SW300_01.psd CMYK 1666 ppi 14.4% Up to Date Production:MICROSOFT:_MASTER_ART:75020_Dynamics:75020_Mitsu_1_SW300_01.psd
75020_Price_SW300_01.psd CMYK 2040 ppi 11.76% Up to Date Production:MICROSOFT:_MASTER_ART:75020_Dynamics:75020_Price_SW300_01.psd
75020_Schorr_SW300_01.psd CMYK 2681 ppi 8.95% Up to Date Production:MICROSOFT:_MASTER_ART:75020_Dynamics:75020_Schorr_SW300_01.psd
75020_Rowe_SW300_01.psd CMYK 2876 ppi 8.34% Up to Date Production:MICROSOFT:_MASTER_ART:75020_Dynamics:75020_Rowe_SW300_01.psd
75020_Desai_SW300_03.psd CMYK 2735 ppi 8.77% Up to Date Production:MICROSOFT:_MASTER_ART:75020_Dynamics:75020_Desai_SW300_03.psd
75020_Johnson_SW300_01.psd CMYK 2287 ppi 10.49% Up to Date Production:MICROSOFT:_MASTER_ART:75020_Dynamics:75020_Johnson_SW300_01.psd
75020_Mitsu_2_SW300_01.psd CMYK 2122 ppi 11.31% Up to Date Production:MICROSOFT:_MASTER_ART:75020_Dynamics:75020_Mitsu_2_SW300_01.psd
Microsoft_Logo_Black.ai 35.33% Up to Date Production:MICROSOFT:_LOGOS:Microsoft_logo:Microsoft_Logo_Black.ai
Because_its_everybodys_business_LOGO_LOCKUP.eps Up to Date Production:MICROSOFT:_LOGOS:Misc:Because_its_everybodys_business_LOGO_LOCKUP.eps
dyn-CRM_cmyk.eps Up to Date Production:MICROSOFT:MECHANICALS:75020_Dynamics:SUPPLIED:dyn-CRM_cmyk.eps
FONTS:
Felt Tip Woman Regular True Type
-banhart- ver : 010 Regular True Type
Segoe Regular, Bold OpenType
FILE: 75019_2M_Dynamics_M4.indd
SO5 Artist: Ravil Tabi
SO5#: 75019_2
Client: Microsoft
Brand: Dynamics
Job Name: Asset Building
JWT #: MST-DYN-M06683
Campaign: Manufacturing - CRM
Proof: 4 Page: 1
PP: Christian Colasuonno
PM: Nick Vitale
AD: Mary Warner
ECD: None
CD: Louis-Philippe Tremblay
CW: Larry Silberfein
AE: Michael McKloskey
Saved: 11-18-2009 5:26 PM
Printed: 11-18-2009 5:26 PM
Print Scale: None
Printer: 4880-1_SWOP3_133
Media: Print
Type: Magazine
Vendor: None
INKS:
Cyan
Magenta
Yellow
Black
INK DENSITY: 300
Safety: 7 x 9.75
Trim: 7.625 x 10.5
Bleed: 8.125 x 11
Gutter: None
Pub Date: 12/01/09
Publication: None
Ad#: 9529
Microsoft Dynamics CRM lifted a heavy load for our staff
by managing our relationships more efficiently.
im
prove com
m
unications
w
ith our dealers
cu
st
o
m
iz
e
e
a
sie
r a
n
d
ch
e
a
p
e
r
so
lu
t
io
n
s fo
r im
p
ro
v
e
d
R
O
I
get the right parts, to the right place,
at the right time
automate more processes
reduce time spent on service calls to rectify errors
DQG
D
Q
G
DQG
DQG
D
Q
G
D
Q
G
W
e K
D
Y
H
W
R
keep track of sales and distribution of over
18,000 pieces of equipm
ent globally
Microsoft Dynamics
CRM integrates information from different sources and puts it in one place,
at one time, so everyone in your company sees the information needed to make better decisions
faster. Its simple for your sales and support people to use, and its ready to fit your company right
away. So you can spend less time on service calls and more time building stronger relationships.
To learn more about the efficiencies Microsoft Dynamics CRM can create for your business,
go to microsoftdynamics.com/manufacturing
S:7
S
:
9
.
7
5
T:7.625
T
:
1
0
.
5
B:8.125
B
:
1
1
PC and is by Fluor
Daniel, Inc. The light hydrocarbons in natural gas and hydrogen in synthesis
gas are less soluble in PC than in the other solvents. PC cannot be used for
selective H
2
S treating because it is unstable at the high temperature required
to completely strip H
2
S from the rich solvent. The FLUOR Solvent process
is generally limited to treating feed gases containing less than 20 ppmv;
however, improved stripping with medium pressure ash gas in a vacuum
stripper allows treatment to 4 ppmv for gases containing up to 200 ppmv H
2
S.
The operating temperature for PC is limited to a minimum of 0F (-18C) and
a maximum of 149F (65C).
Gas Solubilities in Physical Solvents
All of these physical solvents are more selective for acid gas than
for the main constituent of the gas. Relative solubilities of some selected
gases in solvents relative to carbon dioxide are presented in the following
table.
The solubility of hydrocarbons in physical solvents increases with
the molecular weight of the hydrocarbon. Since heavy hydrocarbons tend
to accumulate in the solvent, physical solvent processes are generally not
economical for the treatment of hydrocarbon streams that contain a substantial
amount of pentane-plus unless a stripping column with a reboiler is used.
Choosing the Best Alternative
A detailed analysis must be performed to determine the most
economical choice of solvent based on the product requirements. Feed gas
composition, minor components present, and limitations of the individual
physical solvent processes are all important factors in the selection process.
Engineers can easily investigate the available alternatives using a veried
process simulator such as ProMax
Flash Dryers
Custom designed
for your application
Ease of operation,
high on-line availability
Flexible add-on
to other process
applications
Pilot plant testing
OEM replacement
parts and service
Circle 19 on p. 62 or go to adlinks.che.com/23021-19 Circle 18 on p. 62 or go to adlinks.che.com/23021-18
13_CHE_120109_WW.indd 30 11/20/09 10:18:31 AM
Do you see a leaf?
We also see a challenge to convert waste
into new resources.
No single entity is responsible for environmental protection. Our industries,
communities and environmental service providers must all work together. As a world
reference in waste management, Veolia Environmental Services focuses on a
sustainable future by treating more than 68 million tons of waste annually and
converting it into raw materials, energy and recycled goods.
CHEMICAL ENGINEERING_USA Leaf 200 x 273 mm PPR Q Remise 12/11 Issue Dec. 10/2009
TAF - BAT
The environment is our universal challenge.
Learn more about the innovative material reuse solutions we implemented
for Autoliv, Inc.
| veolianorthamerica.com
VEBE_0906259_LeafUS_200x273.qxd:_ 12/11/09 15:16 Page 1
Circle 31 on p. 62 or go to adlinks.che.com/23021-31
XX_CHE_1209_Full_pg_ads.indd 31 11/20/09 9:44:31 AM
F
aced with increased workloads
and time and budget constraints
that often restrict external train-
ing support, many chemical pro-
cess operators are forced to get the
most out of their heat transfer system
with less help. This article offers rec-
ommendations for how to carry out
proactive maintenance on heat-trans-
fer fluids, to maximize their useful life
and minimize problems associated
with fluid degradation, such as exces-
sive downtime for unplanned mainte-
nance when the heat transfer system
has become unsafe or is no longer able
to carry heat in a reliable manner. It
is useful for anyone developing or re-
freshing asset-care-management pro-
grams related to heat-transfer fluids
and systems.
Discussed below are the most com-
mon fluid-related problems encoun-
tered by heat-transfer systems and a
variety of potential solutions. While
individual system designs and varia-
tions in process and operating condi-
tions make each application unique,
all heat-transfer fluids share many
common attributes, making these
recommendations widely applicable.
Ultimately, our goal is to educate
those involved with the operation
and maintenance of liquid-phase
heat-transfer systems, both large and
small, that use an organic-based heat-
transfer fluid. The organics include
chemical aromatics, fluids based on
petroleum derivatives, silicone or gly-
col, the polyalphaolefins (PAO; also
referred to as API Group IV-based
fluids) and more. A properly designed
and operated heat-transfer system
can be the biggest ally in maintain-
ing (and even increasing) productivity
while reducing overall maintenance
and production costs.
It starts with smart selection
The selection of the heat-transfer
fluid whether at the system design
phase, or on an ongoing basis after
commissioning should not be taken
lightly. Fluid selection should not be
dictated solely by the purchase price
or any single physical characteristic.
Rather, a variety of factors should be
considered:
The potential impact on workers of
a given fluid, in terms of adequate
training and protection that must
be implemented to address hazards
related to potential exposure to the
fluid, in both its vapor form (inha-
lation risk and mist concentration)
and liquid form (skin contact). In ad-
dition to direct exposure, the choice
of the fluid could impact productiv-
ity engendering additional handling
and paperwork protocols involving
other internal resources within the
company, such as the health and
safety advisors, medical care per-
sonnel, personnel in the receiving
department and so forth
Freight charges related to delivery
of fresh product
Cost associated with the pickup,
handling and disposal of the used oil
and drums
Proven fluid performance beyond
fresh oil data (for instance, if vendor
data is able to demonstrate the re-
tention of fresh oil properties after
some time in service, as demon-
strated by extensive oxidation and
thermal stability data)
Can the current system accommo-
date the fluid being considered (in
terms of compatibility with sealing
materials, existence of a properly
sized expansion reservoir, suitable
match between the fluid properties
and the existing hardware, such as
the pump and safety-relief valve)
Miscibility with current heat-trans-
fer fluids if partial (rather than full)
changeout is needed
Documented success by the vendor
in your type of application
Level of liability coverage, service
and expertise the fluid maker and
distributor bring to the table
Feature Report
32 CHEMICAL ENGINEERING WWW.CHE.COM DECEMBER 2009
Feature Report
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
n-Hexocosane (C26H54)
COC flash point : 215C / 419F
Molecular weight : 366.7 grams/mole
n-Dodecane (C12H26)
COC Flash Point: 71C / 160F
Molecular weight: 170.34 grams/mole
Excess Heat
n-Tetradecane (C14H30)
COC flash point : 99C / 210F
Molecular weight : 198.4 grams/mole
Heavy carbonaceous residues
Maximizing Heat-Transfer
Fluid Longevity
Proper selection, monitoring and
maintenance can protect fluids
and components from damage due to
thermal degradation,
oxidation damage and contamination
FIGURE 1. In this example with heat-transfer fuid n-hexa-
cosane, thermal degradation occurs when excess heat
drives the cracking of a straight-chain hydrocarbon
(not shown is the formation of reactive free radicals,
which have been omitted for clarity)
Gaston Arseneault
Petro-Canada Lubricants, a Suncor Energy business
14_CHE_120109_SAS.indd 32 11/19/09 1:23:35 PM
Further discussion of initial fluid
selection is beyond the scope of this
article, but is covered in Ref. [17].
Over time, the most common
threats to the life of heat-trans-
fer fluids (and sometimes the en-
tire system) include the following:
Thermal degradation
Oxidative degradation
Process contamination
Contamination by other materials
Each threat is discussed below, along
with findings from real case studies,
and practical recommendations for
how to deal with these challenges.
THERMAL DEGRADATION
Regardless of the chemistry of the
heat-transfer media, thermal degra-
dation can occur whenever the heat
source provides more energy than the
heat-transfer media can absorb and
carry away at that particular time [8].
Figure 1 shows a simple example
of the thermal degradation of a typi-
cal petroleum-based heat-transfer
fluid (n-hexacosane) with ISO viscos-
ity grade 32. In this case, the fluid is
a distribution of molecules of various
lengths, averaging 26 carbons long.
As shown in Figure 1, when the en-
ergy submitted to the fluid exceeds the
threshold necessary to start breaking
the stable covalent carbon-carbon
bonds, the result is the formation of
shorter hydrocarbons. The example
in Figure 1 shows the scission (crack-
ing) of a perfect straight, long-chain
alkane into shorter molecules, such
as dodecane (C12) and tetradecane
(C14), each having a lower boiling and
flashpoint and viscosity compared to
the starting C26 hydrocarbon.
The systematic result of thermal
degradation is a reduction in the
overall fluid viscosity and increased
volatility, which increases the risk of
leakage and loss through evaporation.
Thermal cracking increases the vapor
pressure, lowers the flashpoint and
fire point, and sometimes, reduces au-
toignition temperature (AIT). As the
name implies, the AIT is the tempera-
ture at which the fluid vapors are hot
enough to ignite spontaneously in ab-
sence of an ignition source [9, 10].
As shown in Figure 2, the problem
worsens if left unaddressed. Reynolds
discovered in 1883 [12, p. 86], that
low-viscosity fluids offer the best heat
transfer behavior in a forced-convec-
tion situation such as a typical heat
transfer system. Based on these find-
ings, one may think thermal cracking
is advantageous from a thermal con-
ductivity point of view. However, the
resulting drop in viscosity is not nec-
essarily favorable.
Safety risks
The concern is that the associated po-
tential reduction of the AIT of the de-
graded fluid can make the operation of
a closed system unsafe if the operat-
ing temperature nears or exceeds the
AIT. Moreover, shortened molecules
are not the only species formed during
thermal degradation of the fluid.
On the other hand, an open system
that is, one in which the heated
fluid is constantly in contact with the
atmosphere is even less forgiving.
Any drop in the heat-transfer fluids
flashpoint and fire point (defined as
the temperature at which the fluid
sustains a fire for five seconds in the
ASTM-D92 Cleveland Open Cup,
or COC flashpoint test apparatus)
could jeopardize the entire operation,
considering that the fluid was likely
chosen, in part, based on its fresh oil,
open-cup flashpoint rating (to which a
safety margin was likely added).
Efforts to determine a definitive re-
lationship between a drop in flashpoint
and a drop in AIT have not proven suc-
cessful. Fortunately for users, in many
cases where a petroleum-based fluid
exhibits a relatively low flashpoint, we
have seen the AIT remained high, but
this is not always the case.
The performance data shown in
Table 1 demonstrate how progressive
thermal degradation leads to steadily
diminishing flashpoint and viscos-
ity of the heat-transfer fluid. The gas
chromatography distillation (GCD)
test consists of a simulated distilla-
tion of the fluid in the laboratory. In
the cited example, the initial distilla-
tion point (GCD 10%) drops over time,
which again confirms the increased
concentration of low-boiling compo-
nents present in the fluid.
Performance problems
Another major consequence of thermal
cracking is the formation of carbona-
ceous residues (Figure 2), which result
from reactions of recombination. To a
certain extent, these particles can be
compared to soot that is produced dur-
ing fuel combustion in a diesel engine,
where it is documented that soot is
harder than the metallic components
of the engine [13].
Such unwanted carbon residues are
not only abrasive toward the piping,
but they also tend to stubbornly ad-
here and harden onto the hot surface
points, forming an insulation layer
inside the pipe. This occurrence often
forces the user to increase the heater
set temperature (increasing energy
consumption) to maintain the desired
operating fluid temperature.
As a general rule of thumb, Wheeler
[14] reports that the widely used
heat-transfer fluids based on poly-
alkylene glycols (PAGs) begin to ex-
perience thermal degradation near
250C (482F). Meanwhile, Wheeler
also reports that the thermal degrada-
tion of uninhibited polyethylene glycol
results in a mix of five organic acids
[15]. The formation of these byproduct
acids leads to increased corrosion over
time in high-temperature systems.
Of similar importance is the fact
that even systems running at tem-
peratures that are considered to be
relatively mild (for example, around
149204C or 300400F), are not ex-
CHEMICAL ENGINEERING WWW.CHE.COM DECEMBER 2009 33
FIGURE 2. Excessive thermal stress often results in a breakdown of the heat-
transfer fuid, and the carbonaceous byproducts can build up on the inside surfaces
of pipes
All photos: Petro-Canada Lubricants, a Suncor Energy business
14_CHE_120109_SAS.indd 33 11/19/09 1:24:59 PM
Feature Report
34 CHEMICAL ENGINEERING WWW.CHE.COM DECEMBER 2009
empt from the ravages that elevated
temperatures can bring, in terms
of the thermal cracking of the heat-
transfer fluid. For example, consider a
system in which the fluid experienced
a change in physical properties, com-
bined with oil-flow issues (for instance,
from a defective pump, a fluid contain-
ing solids, or some piping restriction
or pluggage) or a problem with the
heater (for instance, the heater coil or
electrical element has baked-on car-
bon that acts as an insulation layer
forcing a higher energy demand to
maintain the target fluid outlet tem-
perature). Such factors can cause a
rise in the skin-film temperature (the
temperature of the fluid immediately
touching the heated surface).
Any combination of the conditions
mentioned above can cause the skin-
film temperature to be significantly
higher than the temperature of the
fluid circulating in the center of the
heated pipe (which is called the bulk
oil temperature). The larger the gap
between skin film and bulk oil tem-
perature, the more energy the fluid
tries to distribute within itself through
turbulence. At some point, the fluid at
the heated surface will receive more
energy than it can absorb (its heat ca-
pacity), carry and release (its thermal
conductivity), resulting in thermal
degradation of the fluid.
Minimization strategies
Discussed below are ways to minimize
the thermal degradation of a heat-
transfer fluid in open systems.
Use the right fluid for the job. By
choosing a fluid with a high thermal
stability, Guyer and Brownell [16]
suggest that most problems associ-
ated with localized or temporary tem-
perature excursion can be prevented.
Ashman [17] also emphasizes the im-
portance of using a heat-transfer fluid
with a suitable thermal stability for
the application. Hudson, Sahasrana-
man [6, 7] and many others acknowl-
edge that petroleum-based fluids of
pharmaceutical quality produced by a
severe hydrogenation and hydrocrack-
ing process (also referred to as white
mineral oils) tend to have greater
thermal stability compared to petro-
leum base oils that are produced from
other refining methods [6, 7].
Use appropriate venting. Venting
involves the periodic release (from the
fluid and the system) of the light, more
highly volatile hydrocarbons that form
during thermal cracking. Venting is
typically carried out by circulating
some of the hot fluid to the expansion
reservoir, so that those molecules with
a relatively high vapor pressure can
naturally migrate into the gas phase
above the fluid. Then, depending on
the system design, the vapors are re-
leased directly into the atmosphere or
sent to a collection drum or tank, al-
though laws governing volatile organic
compounds (VOCs) and other environ-
mental trends cause most users to
collect the condensed low-boilers and
properly dispose of them.
Fresh fluid needs to be added pe-
riodically, to maintain the desired
fluid level (to prevent pump starva-
tion and cavitation when the system
charge contracts after a shutdown). As
a precautionary note, users should re-
member that fresh fluid must never be
added directly into the hot oil stream;
rather it should be added into the ex-
pansion tank or other cool reservoirs
connected to the system.
Venting continuously or for extended
periods is not advised, because the re-
sulting rise in the bulk fluid tempera-
ture in the expansion tank will accel-
erate oxidation (discussed below).
We recommend the use of an oil-
analysis program to determine the
rate of generation of low-boilers dur-
ing any operation. With proper vent-
ing and analysis, users can establish
how often, and for how long, the fluid
must be periodically vented, in order
to safely operate a high temperature
system with a fluid that stays in good
condition (maintaining characteristics
that are similar to the fresh oil for as
long as possible).
Adopt proper startup and shut-
down procedures. The successful
startup of any heat-transfer system is
important, since the faster the heat-
transfer fluid reaches its desired op-
erating temperature, the faster the
facility can produce its products and
begin to fulfill orders. This becomes
even more important for systems that
stop and start up regularly.
One may say that running the pump
and the heater for a few extra hours
to accommodate a slower, more-gentle
startup is not cost-effective, but for
many applications, such an approach
pays its own dividends. For instance,
by maintaining a more-gradual heat-
ing profile at startup, the fluid will
be able to effectively remove heat and
reduce the risk of thermal degrada-
tion, and minimizing the formation
and buildup of baked-on residues. The
net result will be extended planned-
maintenance intervals and greater
component life expectancy.
Shutdown procedures also impact
system efficiency and fluid life. For
instance, Stone [19] and others recom-
mend maintaining oil circulation after
TABLE 1. ANALYSIS DATA SHOWING THERMAL DEGRADATION OF
THE HEAT-TRANSFER FLUID AT A MEAT-PROCESSING FACILITY
Sample
date,
mm/dd/yy
Flash-
point, C
(COC)*
Water
content,
ppm
(Karl
Fisher)
Viscosity
at 40 C,
(centist-
okes, cSt)
Gas chromatoraphy distillation
(GDC)**
10%
boiling,
C
90%
boiling,
C
%
boiling
below
335C
04/04/00 154 660 27.0 327 512 10.49
08/10/01 155 580 23.2 307 507 14.40
06/11/02 175 313 22.7 317 490 12.80
09/09/02 171 51 21.2 201 481 31.90
12/09/02 161 220 20.5 304 489 16.20
03/12/03 175 42 19.8 294 490 19.00
After startup and shutdown procedure modification of April 2003
06/11/03 169 156 23.0 310 497 15.70
New fluid
properties
209 35.6 382 498 0.80
* COC represents analysis via the ASTM-D92 Cleveland Open Cup (COC) flashpoint test
apparatus.
** GCD = gas chromatography distillation. The GCD test consists of a simulated distillation of
the fluid in the laboratory. Comparison with the fresh-oil boiling curve allows for the detection of
lighter and heavier molecules in the fluids.
14_CHE_120109_SAS.indd 34 11/19/09 1:30:24 PM
CHEMICAL ENGINEERING WWW.CHE.COM DECEMBER 2009 35
the heater is turned off until its been
cooled to 65C (150F). The refrac-
tory material in a furnace is designed
to retain heat for as long as possible,
so stopping the oil flow immediately
after the heat source has been turned
off provides an opportunity for the
stagnant fluid to crack, forming low-
boiling fractions and carbon residues.
This negatively impacts the life of the
fluid and the overall heater efficiency.
With regard to smaller systems
such as temperature-controlled units
(TCUs) or extruders, many designs
have improved greatly in recent years
and now maintain fluid circulation for
some period of time following shut-
down as a common approach.
An insufficient shutdown interval
was the overall problem at the facil-
ity whose degraded fluid was shown in
Table 1. After a service call, it was de-
termined that the 249C (480F) sys-
tem was shut down on Friday evening
with only a short circulation period
following shutdown. It was fired up
again at 7:00 a.m. on Monday, to allow
for production to start at 9:00 a.m.
A full system shutdown and clean-
ing was deemed impossible by the
user at that time, so the fluid was left
untouched, but better future prac-
tices were implemented. The last set
of results in Table 1 shows that two
months after the initial analysis, the
rate of generation of low-boilers had
diminished (as seen in the percentage
boiled below 335C). As a direct result,
the facility did not add any new oil.
The increase in kinematic viscosity
and flashpoint, and the fact that the
strainer no longer collected carbon
residues in any appreciable amount,
provided evidence of improvement.
Consult your suppliers about
proposed design or operational
changes. Business is booming, more
production is expected from the plant,
more parts must be produced, and
lines need to be added. Do you need to
increase the operating temperature?
What about the flowrate, is it ade-
quate? What does your heater manu-
facturer think of the proposed addi-
tion? Operators should get as much
input as possible from their system
designer. manufacturers, and parts
and fluid suppliers before any major
changes are implemented. Stone [18]
recommends that operators should
maintain an updated list of contacts
and keep it handy for questions or
troubleshooting help.
It is relevant to document the skin-
film temperature in the current sys-
tem and in the proposed operating
conditions. Make certain your fluid
supplier confirms your current heat-
transfer fluids ability to handle any
new operating parameters.
Maintain, inspect and perform
preventative maintenance on sys-
tem components. Even though liq-
uid-phase systems commonly operate
above the flashpoint of the fluid (but
below its auto-ignition temperature),
the risk of fire should be very low in
a normal, well-designed system, espe-
cially one that is kept oil-tight, leak-
free and subject to regular inspection
and maintenance [19].
For any system where heat is pur-
posely generated to raise the fluid
temperature, ensuring proper opera-
tion of the heat source is critical to
achieve optimum performance. Daily
inspections, using a consistent check-
list of items to monitor are recom-
mended [18, 20]. For instance, fired
heaters should be inspected for flame
impingement, especially if the burner
is oversized or cycles frequently. In
the case of flame impingement, the
flame (whose temperature is typi-
cally on the order of 1,0931,650C, or
2,0003,000F) subjects the oil tubes
to excessive localized heat flux, which
can cause tube deformation and cok-
ing (resulting from thermal degrada-
tion, as seen in Figure 2), and leakage
with increased risk of fire [21].
In the case of systems equipped with
immersed electrical heaters, excessive
watt density, lack of fluid turbulence
around the hot tubes, or insufficient
flowrate often causes premature deg-
radation of the fluid. Such degrada-
tion can be offset in part by proper
fluid selection and maintenance prac-
tices [22, 23].
In any system, the oil-circulation
pump can be compared to the heart,
moving the fluid around. The pump
should be well-maintained. Specifi-
cally, drive bearings on the electric
motor and pump seals should receive
proper attention. Centrifugal pumps
should ideally operate at or near
their best efficiency point (BEP), with
bearings well-maintained and seals
working properly. Finally, the expan-
sion reservoir, piping, connections
and valves should be selected and
maintained appropriately, as part of a
world-class maintenance program.
Meanwhile, the life blood of the op-
eration the fluid itself should
be tested regularly. While further
discussion of the types of tests, their
significance and data interpretation
is beyond the scope of this article, the
FIGURE 3. These illustrations shows the type of varnish (left) and sludge (center,
right) that can result from oxidation-related degradation of a petroleum-based, chemi-
cal aromatic and polyalkylene glycol (PAG) fuid
14_CHE_120109_SAS.indd 35 11/19/09 1:32:17 PM
Feature Report
36 CHEMICAL ENGINEERING WWW.CHE.COM DECEMBER 2009
American Society for Testing and Ma-
terials (ASTM) Method D5372 should
be followed to properly monitor the
condition of heat-transfer fluids [24].
OXIDATIVE DEGRADATION
For the purpose of this article, we de-
fine fluid oxidation as the reaction of
the heat-transfer fluid with oxygen
from air. The oxidative degradation of
organic compounds is extremely com-
plex, as it involves a series of chemical
reactions that result in the formation
of high energy, unstable and reactive
free-radicals and peroxides. One initial
free-radical allows for the possibility
of forming two radical species, which
results in the formation of a variety
of oxygen-containing species, mainly
organic acids. These long-chained or-
ganic acids may be weak on their own,
but as their concentration grows in
the fluid, the oil eventually becomes
more corrosive [25].
These acids also polymerize often
to a level that is sufficient to modify
the fluid properties, causing an in-
crease in viscosity, discoloration and
eventually, precipitation as lacquer,
varnish and sludge [26] such as that
shown in Figure 3. The varnish for-
mation is seldom a concern in heat
transfer applications because of rela-
tively large pipe diameters and valves
with high tolerances. However, further
oxidation will lead to the formation of
heavier acids and sludge. Oxidation-
related sludge is not very soluble in
heat-transfer fluids, so it tends to ad-
here to metallic surfaces or settle in
areas of low flow and low turbulence.
Such sludge also tends to settle at
the bottom and the sides of the ex-
pansion tank, and can also circulate
throughout the system and make its
way into control valves.
Fluids for a specific project are gen-
erally chosen based on their proper-
ties in a fresh state. Any alteration of
the fluid physical properties (resulting
from degradation or contamination)
could negatively impact the heat ab-
sorption and dissipation capabilities
of the heat-transfer media.
Table 2 provides oil-analysis data
for an uninhibited, chemical aromatic
(synthetic), heat-transfer fluid that ex-
perienced oxidation in a large 27,000-L
(7,132-gal) system in Europe. (In this
context, the term uninhibited refers
to the fact that the fluid does not con-
tain additives such as anti-oxidants
and rust-corrosion inhibitors to pre-
vent degradation.) The acid number
(AN) as determined by ASTM D664
Method and used to quantify the level
of acids in an oil sample was in-
creasing over time.
The distillation of the fluid, repre-
sented by the GCD 10% boiling point,
shows the initial boiling is at the same
temperature as fresh oil, so thermal
degradation does not seem to be an
issue in this example. We notice the
viscosity has risen by 30% over time
and the end of the distillation curve
(GCD 90%) is shifting toward higher
temperatures, indicating the increas-
ing presence of heavy compounds not
found in the fresh oil.
An increasing amount of insoluble
particles are forming, and the AN
values are rising. By connecting the
dots, we conclude that oil oxidation
is causing an increased formation of
heavy acidic polymers that will foul
the low-flow areas of the system. This
degraded oil, with its higher viscosity,
cannot deliver the same performance
capabilities as fresh oil, and in todays
context of high energy costs, any loss
of efficiency is costly.
In the example discussed above, the
company could not afford a shutdown
to clean its system this year. Instead,
operators opted for a partial fluid re-
placement of 50% of the entire charge
this year (incurring an expenditure
of roughly $175,000, excluding waste
oil disposal and labor) and are plan-
ning a full drain, clean, flush and refill
next year. In general, fluid oxidation
imposes great cost penalties on any
system; the selection of a fluid with
better oxidation stability could have
avoided this massive spending and of-
fered many more years of useful life.
Minimization strategies
Discussed below are several options
that are available to avoid or minimize
potential oxidative degradation.
Inert gas blanketing. In closed sys-
tems, the most effective way to elimi-
nate the potential for oxidation is to
install an inert gas blanket in the ex-
pansion tank headspace. Hudson [29]
provides details and recommenda-
tions on how to install such systems.
The basic principle relies on substitut-
ing air (which contains oxygen) with
an inert gas (most often nitrogen, al-
though carbon dioxide and argon may
also be considered) in the only location
where warm oil can come into contact
with oxygen from air the expansion
tank headspace. Displacing oxygen
that might react with the fluids virtu-
ally eliminates oxidation.
The pressure of the inert gas is
maintained slightly above atmospheric
pressure. Gas-blanketing systems, in-
cluding the safety-relief valve, require
ongoing inspection and maintenance
to prevent inert gas leaks and limit
unnecessary, costly gas consumption.
Choose a fluid formulated for the
job. Oxidation-inhibitor additives are
also available to enhance the perfor-
mance of heat-transfer fluids. Most
chemical aromatics sold today contain
one or a few varieties of molecules
and do not contain any performance
enhancing additives such as antioxi-
dants or rust and corrosion inhibitors.
The additives that are used in heat-
transfer fluids are different from the
ones found in other industrial lubri-
cants that are not subjected to such
elevated temperatures. Specifically,
in the case of antioxidants, some tech-
nologies combat oxidation by reacting
with free radicals before they can lead
to acid formation, while others attack
intermediate peroxides [25].
Fluid selection is complicated by
the fact that it is extremely difficult
to determine the oxidation stability
of a heat-transfer fluid by its techni-
cal data sheet. Even though many of
the heat-transfer fluids on the market
today are unadditized, their respec-
tive marketing materials often praise
their fouling resistance and promote
their outstanding oxidation stability.
Thus, users should assess all product
claims with a critical eye.
In general, systems with an enor-
mous amount of oil tend to be more
forgiving because it takes a longer
time to oxidize a larger volume of fluid
to a point where it raises concerns in
terms of oil analysis results. In these
cases, user experience, references,
testimonials and competitive bench-
marking studies should be evaluated
in conjunction with vendor data, to
14_CHE_120109_SAS.indd 36 11/19/09 1:33:10 PM
CHEMICAL ENGINEERING WWW.CHE.COM DECEMBER 2009 37
assess the likely longevity of a fluid
for the application at hand and avoid
costly changeouts in large systems.
Compared to closed or blanketed
systems, open systems allow the hot
fluid to come in direct contact with
air, making oxidative damage a harsh
reality rather than a possibility. In
these cases, the importance of choos-
ing a robust product to maintain high
productivity standards becomes even
more important.
For example, an electronic company
operating an open system at 175C
(350F) was replacing its heat-trans-
fer fluid every six months, after which
time the fluid had become viscous and
dark with a burnt odor. Switching to a
fluid with better resistance to oxida-
tion enabled longer service life. In fact,
judging by the oil-analysis results, the
oil properties still look like new after
more than 24 months of service in
these harsh conditions. This obviously
saves the facility money in terms of
time, labor and fluid purchases.
In closed systems with no inert gas
blanketing, the key is to maintain the
fluid temperature in the expansion
tank below 65C (150F), if possible.
The main reason is because there is a
direct relationship between the tem-
perature and the rate of oxidation. For
instance, the rate of reaction between
a petroleum-derived oil with oxygen
(doubles for every 10C (15F) increase
above 80C (175F) (with slight varia-
tions depending on the author) [28], so
the higher the temperature the more
severe the degradation. And this does
not take into account the fact that the
oxidation reaction is exponential and
is accelerated by contaminants such
as copper or iron particles, water and
other catalysts.
Oxidation could occur in systems
with a design that allows the oil to
circulate through the expansion res-
ervoir with full flow, either directly
after the heater or on the return from
the heat users. Such design exposes
the hot fluid directly to oxygen from
air, thereby acceleraing oxidation and
greatly reducing fluid life.
Using the oil-analysis results, fluid
oxidation can be monitored by paying
close attention to acid number (AN)
and gas chromatographic distillation
(GCD) results.
MINIMIZING PROCESS
CONTAMINATION
Process contamination can be ex-
tremely damaging to the heat-transfer
fluid and the system components. As
is often the case, logic suggests that
contamination is unlikely since the
pressure is greater on the fluid side,
but real life experience has shown on
many occasions that process mate-
rial can enter the heat-transfer fluid
stream. The urgency required to fix a
process leak really depends on the se-
verity, the type of contaminant (chem-
istry), and the heat transfer media
it comes in contact with. The case of
contamination by water is discussed
in the next section, although water is
sometimes part of the process.
For example, in the oil-and-gas in-
dustry, a natural-gas-extraction fa-
cility may experience an unintended
leak of the process hydrocarbons into
the heat-transfer fluid system. Being
hydrocarbon-based, the heated gas-
eous molecules will mix very well with
heat-transfer fluids of a similar chem-
istry, such as petroleum-based fluids,
chemical aromatics and PAO Group
IV synthetic fluids ([4] provides de-
tails on competing fluid types). Within
a short time, the viscosity of the entire
fluid charge will be greatly reduced
and its overall volatility increased.
In a situation such as this one, em-
phasis must be put into venting the
heat-transfer fluid to release those
light hydrocarbons into the proper col-
lection device in order to maintain a
safe operation, and if at all safely pos-
sible, to keep the unit running until
the next shutdown opportunity to re-
pair the leak.
Another example of process con-
tamination in the petroleum industry
occurs frequently at asphalt termi-
nals. Similar to the example discussed
above, any unintended ingress of as-
phalt in the heat-transfer fluid circuit
will mix very well with most of the
fluids, since the majority are based on
long hydrocarbon chains. However, the
highly viscous hydrocarbon asphalt
will quickly thicken the fluid.
We have seen heat-transfer fluids in-
crease to several hundred centistokes
or even become too thick to measure
at 40C (104F), thereby ruining the
fluids ability to transfer heat effec-
tively. The heavy asphalt components
will also coat the system internals and
plug small lines, meaning a full sys-
tem cleaning and flushing will even-
tually become necessary to restore the
system to efficient operation.
In some cases, the contaminant it-
self may be inert to the fluid but it
may still react with traces of moisture
to form acidic or insoluble compounds.
These byproduct contaminants can ac-
celerate rust and cause corrosion and
fluid degradation.
Depending on the process contami-
nants that are inadvertently leaking
into the fluid system, it might be pos-
sible to detect them (qualitatively)
via oil analysis, using the common
elemental analysis method like In-
ductively Coupled Plasma Atomic
Emission Spectrometry (ICP-AES).
Sometimes the contaminant can be
detected indirectly after it has reacted
with another compound in the fluid.
In some cases regular oil analysis will
not detect the process contaminant
and specialized methodology and in-
struments are needed, such as those
found in specialized research-and-de-
velopment facilities.
A quantitative evaluation to de-
termine the type and extent of the
contamination generally requires so-
phisticated equipment (such as an
electronic microscope, or gas chroma-
tography coupled with mass spectrom-
etry), as well as well-trained analysts
TABLE 2. OIL-ANALYSIS DATA DESCRIBING A FLUID THAT HAS EXPERIENCED OXIDATION
(SOURCE : PETRO-CANADA LUBRICANTS, A SUNCOR ENERGY COMPANY)
Sample
date, mm/
dd/yy
Flash point
(COC), C
Water
content,
ppm
(Karl
Fisher)
Viscosity
at 40C,
cSt
Acid num-
ber (AN*),
mg/KOH/g
Solids
(insolu-
bles), wt.%
GCD
10%
boiling, C
90%
boiling, C
% boiling
below
335C
05/12/04 193 301 30.4 <0.1 0.1 333 423 10.5
04/25/06 179 382 29.6 0.11 0.24 324 426 11.0
04/15/08 201 138 39.4 0.23 0.48 336 431 9.4
*Acid Number (AN) is obtained using ASTM D664 titration method, which is used to quantify the levels of acid in an oil sample.
14_CHE_120109_SAS.indd 37 11/19/09 1:35:49 PM
Feature Report
38 CHEMICAL ENGINEERING WWW.CHE.COM DECEMBER 2009
who are knowledgeable about the
product being tested and informed on
what contaminant types to look for.
Whenever a process leak is sus-
pected, it is advisable to reach out to
your fluid suppliers technical contact
immediately and explain the situa-
tion. A sample of the fluid should be
analyzed right away.
OTHER SOURCES OF
CONTAMINATION
In addition to contamination that
can arise from process materials (dis-
cussed above), heat-tranfer fluids may
also become contaminated by the envi-
ronment (rain or snow), condensation,
foreign liquids (such as the wrong fluid
put in the system), or the ingress of
air. For systems where the expansion
reservoir is outside and vented to the
atmosphere, it is critical to have at
a minimum an enclosed tank with a
180-deg, goose-neck pipe on the top.
This may sound very basic, but we
were once called to investigate un-
usual noise coming from the hot oil
piping at a saw mill. After assessing
the noise, we climbed up to the top of
the burner building to examine the
expansion tank. The 12-by-12-in. steel
cover normally bolted to the side of
the 250-gal expansion tank was lay-
ing on the catwalk, covered by a foot
of dirt, wood dust and snow and no
one could remember who had been up
there last. Rainwater and snow falling
directly into the expansion tank from
the open hole was responsible for the
high water content we later measured
in the fluid and the knocking noise in
the piping below.
New construction or recently cleaned
systems or heat exchangers are not
typically flushed before commission-
ing. However, in systems where a full
or partial cleaning was performed,
traces of aggressive cleaning fluids or
water-based solutions that are not re-
moved could accelerate corrosion, foul-
ing or create their own polymerization
and insoluble residues [29]. In newly
commissioned systems, aside from the
typical wood debris, welding rods and
rags, residual water from pressure
testing is most often the culprit for
startup problems. Unlike many indus-
trial applications, water in the heat-
transfer fluid is more easily detectable
by operators and unforgiving because
it is heated above its boiling point dur-
ing service in most applications.
Entrained water will affect various
fluid chemistries in different ways.
In lubricating and circulation fluids
based on mineral and synthetic Group
IV PAO oils, prolonged exposure to
water may cause the following [30]:
Hydrolysis or precipitation of
oil additives (for those oils that
have them)
Accelerated rust and corrosion of
system internals
Accelerate degradation (oxidation)
Cause pump cavitation and wear
Create a gargling noise in the expan-
sion tank and knocking in the hot
oil piping
Based on years of examining real-life
oil-analysis results, we can say that
in general, water does not appear to
pose immediate productivity concerns
at concentrations below 500 ppm (0.05
wt.%), although we have encountered
certain, more-sensitive systems where
lower concentrations did have a notice-
able impact. However, residual water
at concentrations above 1,000 ppm
(0.1 wt.%) becomes alarming and calls
for investigation and removal.
In the case of mineral oils, the best
practical way to remove the water
from a heat-transfer fluid while the
system is running involves more of a
two-step process. First, vent the fluid,
allowing the water vapor to migrate
into the expansion tank. Once inside
the expansion tank, some of the steam
will have sufficient vapor pressure to
leave through the vent pipe or safety-
relief valve when it opens.
In the case of PAG-based fluids,
the numerous oxygen atoms in their
structure produces strong hygroscopic
behavior that is directly proportional
to relative humidity in the environ-
ment. Wheeler [15] reports that at 50%
relative humidity, pure ethylene gly-
col absorbs 20% water at equilibrium.
This can cause serious concerns.
Lastly, operators must take steps to
guard against potential contamination
by airborne vapors or particles that
could affect the fluid. Just think of a
saw mill example, where entrained
cellulose dust from the wood dust may
not degrade the fluid itself, but will
affect the fluid's ability to flow, which
will reduce the thermal efficiency and
accelerate fouling in the system [29].
Such an occurrence is more likely to
happen if the expansion tank is lo-
cated in a very dusty environment.
Minimization strategies
Discussed below are a variety
of techniques for minimizing con-
tamination that can threaten heat-
transfer fluids.
Investigate and fix. All cases of con-
tamination should be investigated and
fixed, and such incidents should also
be reported to your fluid supplier, for
advice on the potential impact on the
fluid. As mentioned earlier, sometimes
the contaminant can be evacuated,
boiled off or it could ruin the fluid and
foul the system in a short time.
Flush new constructions or re-
cently cleaned systems before
startup. Operating companies and
builders seldom factor in the cost of a
system flush, since they often assume
the blowing of the water will be done
correctly and the contractors will not
leave debris in the piping. Unfortu-
nately, discovering such contaminants
after the system is running can prove
to be costly down the road. While no-
body needs the extra costs of flushing
a new system (especially when the
fluid of choice is relatively expensive,
like PAGs or silicone-based fluids), it
is nonetheless a good practice. With
systems filled with mineral oils, cir-
culating a virgin base oil of the same
viscosity as the heat-transfer fluid of
choice is a cost-effective way to remove
any potential contaminants.
Keep an eye on filters and strain-
ers. Solids collection in the oil filters
or strainers should be noted in a log
book and monitored closely, preferably
with photos taken. The size, texture
and color of the deposits all tell a story,
and such residues can be sent periodi-
cally to a laboratory with sophisticated
analytical equipment for accurate
identification.
Keep in mind that different solids
may come from more than one source,
and may become discolored, so dont
jump to conclusions.
Similarly solids from the previ-
ous fluids may reside in the system
for a long time before an event such
as pipe work or partial fluid replace-
14_CHE_120109_SAS.indd 38 11/19/09 1:36:43 PM
CHEMICAL ENGINEERING WWW.CHE.COM DECEMBER 2009 39
ment creates enough disturbance
to loosen them. We see this in cases
where a used furnace is bought and
commissioned without cleaning and
flushing prior to the connection to
the main system.
Often solids may have a familiar
smell or texture that suggests an
origin, but could well be something
else. For example, a plant was using a
heat-transfer fluid that caused valve
malfunction because of deposits accu-
mulating inside the valve spools. The
black, abrasive deposits looked and
felt like carbon particles (abrasive,
gritty between the fingers). However,
lab analysis identified the material as
copper sulfide, formed by the localized
chemical attack of sulfur present in
the fluids base stock onto the copper
from the brass valves.
The facility could have spent sev-
eral thousands of dollars in parts and
labor to upgrade all the valves to more
expensive stainless steel. Instead it
switched to a properly formulated fluid
based on highly refined API Group II
base oils containing only traces of sul-
fur. This replacement fluid has proven
to be harmless to copper components
after years of service, and has had
the added benefit of extending oil
changes considerably, based on oil-
analysis results.
Edited by Suzanne Shelley
Author
Gaston Arseneault is a se-
nior technical advisor with
Petro-Canada Lubricants, a
Suncor Energy business (1310
Lakeshore Road West, Missis-
sauga, Ontario, Canada L5J
1K2; Phone: 973-673-3164;
E-mail: garseneault@suncor.
com), located in the Newark,
N.J., area. With the company
for more than ten years,
Arseneault holds an M.S.
in analytical chemistry from the Universit de
Montral in Canada and is a member of Society
of Tribologists and Lubrication Engineers, from
which he has obtained the Certified Lubrication
Specialist (CLS) and Oil Monitoring Analyst
(OMA I) certifications. He also holds the Ma-
chinery Lubrication Technician I certification
from the International Council for Machinery
Lubrication.
Circle 20 on p. 62 or go to adlinks.che.com/23021-20
References
1. Guffey II, G.E., Sizing up heat transfer flu-
ids and heaters, Chem. Eng., Oct. 1997, pp.
126131.
2. Shanley, A., and Kamiya, T., Heat transfer
fluids: A buyers market, Chem. Eng., Sept.
1998, pp. 6366.
3. Arseneault, G., Seven criteria for selecting
heat transfer fluid, Process Heating, January
2008, pp. 23.
4. Arseneault, G., Safe handling of heat trans-
fer fluids, Chem. Eng. Prog., April 2008, pp.
4247.
5. Crabb, C., A fluid market for heat transfer,
Chem. Eng., April 2001, pp. 7376.
6. Hudson, J., Choosing the heat transfer fluid,
Process Heating, January 2007.
7. Sahasranaman, K., Get the most from high-
temperature heat-transfer-fluid systems,
Chem. Eng., March 2005, pp. 4650.
8. Guyer E.C. and Brownell D.L., Handbook
of Applied Thermal Design, McGraw-Hill,
ISBN 0070253536, 1988, pp. 546.
9. Singh, J., Heat Transfer Fluids and Systems
for Process and Energy Applications, CRC,
ISBN 0824771915, 1985, p. 214.
10. Petro-Canada, TechData: Handbook of Pe-
troleum Product Terms, Revised Edition
89.06, 1989.
11. Kay, J.M., and Nederman, R.M., Fluid Me-
chanics and Transfer Processes, ISBN
0521303036, 1985, p. 18.
12. Peters, M.S., Elementary Chemical Engi-
neering, McGraw-Hill, 1984, p. 85.
13. Petro-Canada, TechBulletin: The Truth
About Soot, Edition 89.06, 1989.
14. Society of Tribologists and Lubrication Engi-
neers (STLE), Basic Handbook of Lubrica-
tion, 2nd ed., 2003, Section 3, p. 8.
15. Wheeler, K., Technical Insights into Uni-
hibited Ethylene Glycol, Process Cooling &
Equipment, July/August 2002.
16. Guyer, E.C., and Brownell, D.L., Handbook
of Applied Thermal Design, McGraw-Hill,
ISBN 0070253536, 1988, pp. 547.
17. Ashman, L.A., Troubleshooting problems in
heat transfer systems, Process Heating, Octo-
ber 1988, www.process-heating.com.
18. Stone, C.D., Eight tips to extend your ther-
mal fluid systems service life, Process Heat-
ing, April 2003.
19. BP (British Petroleum), Transcal Heat
Transfer Fluids, BP Printing, England, Doc-
ument # MP59, 1979.
20. Arseneault, G., Preventative maintenance for
heat transfer systems, World Pumps, April
2008, pp. 4043.
21. Vinagayam, K., Minimizing flame impinge-
ment in fired heaters, Chem. Eng., pp. May
2007, pp. 7073.
22. Klein, R., Immersion heaters: Selection and
implementation, Chem. Eng., January 2006,
pp. 4450.
23. Arseneault, G., Preventive maintenance for
heat transfer systems using electrical im-
mersion heaters, Process Heating, November
2006, p. 12.
24. ASTM International, ASTM D5372-04: Stan-
dard Guide for Evaluation of Hydrocarbon
Heat Transfer Fluid, 2004, p. 3.
25. The Lubrizol Corporation, Ready Reference
for Grease, The Lubrizol Corp., Wickliffe,
Ohio, Version 2.00, May 2007, pp. 3637.
26. Singh, J., Heat Transfer Fluids and Systems
for Process and Energy Applications, CRC,
ISBN 0824771915, 1986, p. 179.
27. Hudson, J., The Expansion Tank, Process
Heating, September 2007, accessed online at
www.process-heating.com.
28. Society of Tribologists and Lubrication En-
gineers, Alberta Section, Basic Handbook of
Lubrication, 2nd ed., Section 26, 2003, p. 8.
29. Guyer, E.C., and Brownell, D.L., Handbook
of Applied Thermal Design, McGraw-Hill,
New York, 1988, pp. 550.
30. Bloch, H.P., Practical Lubrication for Indus-
trial Facilities, The Fairmount Press, 2000,
pp. 464465.
14_CHE_120109_SAS.indd 39 11/20/09 10:23:43 AM
M
ost chemical engineers in-
volved with operating large
chemical process facilities
have encountered the fol-
lowing challenge: Several large engi-
neering contractors built the facility
in multiple phases, using different
computer-software models. Retriev-
ing drawings or data in both digital
and non-digital form in such a situ-
ation only adds complexity to opera-
tions, maintenance and revamp activ-
ities and often introduces yet another
problem to solve in each instance.
Obviously, these plants would be bet-
ter off with one complete computer
model of the entire operating facility.
And with the recent shift by software
vendors to support interoperability, a
single model can be achieved without
having to reenact the design of the
entire plant.
Interoperability is a term used in-
creasingly in engineering circles to
refer to the sharing and exchange of
digital information. In principle, its
as if all members of a networked engi-
neering team can exchange data freely
across different software products and
sources of engineering content. How-
ever, integration is not achieved with
the simple click of a mouse. Informa-
tion is often locked away in silos, so
creating a complete knowledge base
from disparate engineering infor-
mation can seem like knitting with
spaghetti. Such spaghetti conspires
against plant information integrity.
The role of engineering portals
At the individual interaction level, the
operations engineer would be much
more effective with common, transpar-
ent access to all engineering content
via one engineering portal that sup-
ports integrated operations. An engi-
neering portal is primarily read-only.
The purpose is to give the (operations)
engineer the widest access to all plant
information from his or her screen,
which helps in planning and decision
making. The purpose of the portal is
not to carry out changes in engineer-
ing design (greenfield or brownfield).
Changes should still be carried out
in the integrated engineering and
design software applications where
the engineering design changes are
mastered. Typically changes are car-
ried out in two-dimensional (2D) and
Feature Report
40 CHEMICAL ENGINEERING WWW.CHE.COM DECEMBER 2009
Feature Report
Neil McPhater
Aveva Group plc
Smooth Your
Retrieval of Plant-
Design Data
AREAS RIPE
FOR INTEGRATION
Integrating similar model
types (such as 3D mod-
els) from different soft-
ware vendors
Integrating data between
different types of models
(such as 3D models with
P&IDs)
Integrating similar model
types but different types
of data (such as 3D me-
chanical and 3D process
design data)
Even after construction and startup,
plant design data are needed for operations,
maintenance and revamps. But working with a
plethora of formats and platforms introduces
its own set of challenges
15_CHE_120109_RM.indd 40 11/19/09 3:14:23 PM
three-dimensional (3D) design appli-
cations. Once the design or changes
to it have been completed according to
the engineering approval process (ap-
proved for construction, approved for
fabrication and so on) the correspond-
ing data appropriately version con-
trolled might be downloaded to the
engineering portal to help manage
construction planning, for example.
Such portals require, in particular,
structure to navigate throughout the
portal to make engineering sense
of the diverse content. This is where
structured and intelligent 2D and
3D models originating from plant
design can add substantial value to
the portal by making navigation user
friendly for the engineers who are
using it.
Long after project design and con-
struction is complete, plant owners
and operators can reap rewards from
such systems by organizing ongoing
operations around it. A major oil and
gas producer, for example, uses intel-
ligent, 2D inspection-piping isometrics
as its engineering bible for both on-
shore and offshore plant maintenance.
Meanwhile, legacy 3D data for the
same plant from other plant design
systems can be transferred to the
portal, so that all maintenance and
engineering upgrades can be man-
aged together on a single system.
Such data structure and information
integration are made possible by con-
temporary data standards such as
the International Organization for
Standardizations (ISO) 15926 stan-
dard, which has advanced so it can
bridge the 3D gap between legacy and
incumbent plant data with no loss of
engineering intelligence, for example,
in piping or steelwork.
This article helps bring home the
benefits of interoperability and the
costs that result from its absence.
Costs of doing nothing
The lack of a single computer model
and structure for an entire operating
facility can be found everywhere and
represents a serious obstacle to the
engineering industry. Indeed, a report
from the National Institute of Stan-
dards and Technology (NIST; Gaith-
ersburg, Md.; www.nist.gov) estimates
that inadequate software interoper-
ability may cost the U.S. capital facili-
ties industry $15.8 billion annually
nearly 2% of the industrys revenues.
Some other reports and industry au-
thorities set the cost at twice the NIST
estimate. These reports suggest that
the chemical process industries (CPI)
and the architecture engineering and
construction industries experience the
greatest pain.
The reality is that information tech-
nology often is incompatible across
software products and, specifically,
data models. Paradoxically, while engi-
neering data standards were intended
to address the issue and enable so-
called digital convergence, they have
actually been part of the problem.
Nevertheless, recent progress in stan-
dardization is making inroads in sev-
eral key facets of interoperability (see
box, left, for more).
How does digital convergence
bring value to chemical engineers?
The catalytic ingredient for value
through digital convergence of plant
design data is the networked engi-
neering team. In this context, interop-
erability delivers collaborative advan-
tage on three specific dimensions. The
first is its total number of users in the
collaborative network. An associated
sub-dimension is the number of net-
worked engineering teams working to-
CHEMICAL ENGINEERING WWW.CHE.COM DECEMBER 2009 41
STANDARDS MAKE
INTEROPERABILITY POSSIBLE
I
n the mid-to-late 1990s, the Norwegian Posc Caesar Assn. (PCA), assisted by the
Dutch SPI-NL consortium established and developed ISO 15926 for the Offshore
oil and gas industry that has now become an international data standard. In recent
years, Fiatech has brought fresh U.S. vigor to accelerate the deployment of ISO 15926
and ensure its wider acceptability. This American-European double act is speeding up
industry adoption of market-acceptable standards.
As PCAs efforts over the last decade have shown, the development and successful
adoption of such data standards and methodologies as ISO 15926 and BIM (the Build-
ing Information Model being adopted in architecture and building design) take time
and effort. When handling projects measured in millions of dollars per day or even
per hour engineers are justifiably cautious about adopting new practices. For in-
stance, market adoption of BIM by structural engineers isnt expected to reach a tipping
point until after 2015.
However, the extent of Norways ambitions is exemplified by its vision of the offshore
future integrated operations. It strives toward a digital infrastructure and information
platform to enable remote operation from an onshore control center of unmanned oil-
and-gas production facilities in the North and Barents Seas within the next decade.
What you need to know about standards
There are many technical ins and outs to standards that are not important for a chemi-
cal engineer. The main thing to keep in mind is to stipulate applicable data standards
on commercial contracts. The consequences can be significant when close cooperation
between engineering contractors and sub-contractors is necessary during the design
and construction contract or during project handover to the owner/operator.
In fact, the handover phase is where a lot of valuable engineering intelligence can be
lost if standards are not part of the process. Companies giving out engineering orders,
for instance, should dictate in their contract to suppliers where data are part of the
deliverable, that the data be provided in a standard format such as ISO 15926.
FIGURE 1. A digital
information hub is the
ultimate interoperabil-
ity solution, providing
a centralized and
secure integration
platform for col-
laboration between
different types of
teams and their
needs to either
create, change
or simply read
plant design
data
15_CHE_120109_RM.indd 41 11/20/09 2:06:26 PM
Feature Report
42 CHEMICAL ENGINEERING WWW.CHE.COM DECEMBER 2009
gether in that network. In general, the
value of a network increases dispro-
portionately depending on the greater
the number of users. For example, this
is true on a much larger scale for tele-
phone networks.
The second value dimension reflects
the number of sources of engineering
content. Another way to describe this
is the number of information silos
connected together. As with network
users, the greater the number of in-
formation silos that can be inte-
grated, the greater the potential to
deliver value.
Finally, the third dimension of
business value from the network
represents the number of business
boundaries spanned by the networked
engineering team. Business boundar-
ies include the number of geographi-
cal sites spanned, functions crossed,
organizations covered and links in the
supply chain.
Ripe opportunities in the CPI
Integrating P&IDs and the 3D
models that parallel them. Many
plant engineers still rely on hard-
copy schematic drawings, or P&IDs,
many of which have been produced at
a number of different stages on differ-
ent computer systems. It is much more
efficient, however, to have the P&IDs
in a consistent digital format. In order
to do so, all the P&ID data must be as-
sembled together. This will let the en-
gineers manage the entire plant in a
consistent way that hasnt previously
been possible.
The missing piece for assembling all
of this data together is one common
language. Fiatech (Austin, Tex.; www.
fiatech.org) an industry consortium
that provides global leadership in iden-
tifying and accelerating the develop-
ment, demonstration and deployment
of fully integrated and automated
technologies to deliver business value
throughout the life cycle of all types of
capital projects like its European
counterpart PCA, has determined that
ISO 15926 be the common denomina-
tor. In theory, the use of standards is
very straightforward, but often gets
complicated in practice.
The most basic requirement that has
been met for solving the interoperabil-
ity challenge is that software vendors
are now beginning to deliver the in-
teroperability demanded by their cus-
tomers by complying with ISO 15926.
This enables all P&ID schematics
across the entire plant to be consoli-
dated and managed consistently. And
it gives plant engineers the ability
to check consistency between the 2D
schematics model and the 3D model of
the plant. A second data standard that
is going to have increasing importance
is Mimosa. This sets out a standard for
plant operations and maintenance. Al-
though less utilized than ISO 15926,
Mimosa is likely to have at least as big
a business impact.
Integrating 3D mechanical design
of equipment. Another challenge for
interoperability has been the inte-
gration of 3D computer aided design
(CAD) systems for mechanical design
with those for plant design. Histori-
cally, mechanical CAD with its em-
phasis on manufacturability has been
incompatible with multi-disciplinary
3D plant design. The disconnection of
these two systems is a key opportu-
nity for efficiency improvements.
Consider, for instance, a plant engi-
neer who is faced with an upgrade of
a specialized piece of equipment, such
as a reaction vessel. But this new item
has a different shape from its decom-
missioned predecessor and has been
designed using 3D mechanical CAD
software. Interoperability between
these two 3D systems would ensure
accurate spatial arrangement and en-
gineering tie-in.
How can this new piece of complex
equipment be incorporated into the
existing plant without loss of engi-
neering integrity? Recent advances
allow complex, mechanical equip-
ment items to be stored as intrinsic
parts of a 3D plant-design database.
A data standard called STEP AP 203
can transfer 3D mechanical CAD data.
Airbus and Boeing use it to digitally
verify that jet-engine designs from any
manufacturer can be installed first
time on their airframes. Using STEP
AP 203, the plant engineer can also
integrate the new equipment design
into the plant design with no loss of
engineering integrity, enabling error-
free and timely installation.
Required infrastructure
What sort of infrastructure is needed
to overcome barriers to interoperabil-
ity and deliver sustainable value from
ever increasing volumes of digital in-
formation on operating plant assets?
Fundamentally, a centralized and se-
cure integration platform, or digital
information hub (Figure 1), is required
to provide a neutral, collaborative en-
vironment that is independent of soft-
ware application and data format.
Such a digital information hub
needs to address not only longterm
information integrity of the opera-
tional plant, but also take into ac-
count shorter term requirements for
greenfield engineering projects, not to
mention smooth data handover for op-
erational startup.
In this hub, engineering content
from disparate data and document
STEPS TO TAKE TOWARD
INTEROPERABILITY
W
hen executed effectively, the ele-
ments below will deliver value
individually from interoperability.
The more points executed together, the
greater the beneficial business impact.
Engineering content
Employ data standards in a pragmatic
value-driven way now; no need exists
to wait for postponed perfection
Compare and integrate P&IDs with 3D
plant design
Migrate mechanical equipment items
from 3D mechanical CAD into the 3D
plant design system without loss of in-
telligence
Business directives
Prescribe data deliverables from proj-
ects to be contractually binding, prefer-
ably in the form of an accepted indus-
try data standard like ISO 15926
Be able to define/redefine business
processes in a flexible way to suit
value/supply chain
Be able to redefine document workflow
in a flexible way
Integration platform
Use proven, quality tools to capture
and validate data from third parties
Take advantage of flexible and generic
data associations
Be able to integrate non-engineering
enterprise data with the operational
engineering plant model
Be able to integrate realtime engineer-
ing operations data with operational
engineering plant models
15_CHE_120109_RM.indd 42 11/19/09 2:15:30 PM
CHEMICAL ENGINEERING WWW.CHE.COM DECEMBER 2009 43
sources needs to be harmonized and
controlled with appropriate portal ac-
cess given to networked engineering
teams in plant activities like mainte-
nance and revamps. It must support
flexible administration of team pro-
cesses and related document work-
flow. It must also use data standards
to accommodate extensive data cap-
ture and validation from widely used
third-party authoring tools, as well as
enterprise-wide systems.
A proven way to harmonize dispa-
rate structured and unstructured data
in engineering portals is to associate
topical data with related data in a ge-
neric way. Such generic data modeling
also underpins the ISO 15926 data
standard. This way, data associations
required for operations activities can
be easily set up. For example a reac-
tion vessel mentioned above may be
connected to Pump 123, be contained
in P&ID number 456, be part of a
maintenance workpack AB12 and be
available as a specialist piece of equip-
ment P123.
Conclusion
Data interoperability is a longterm
trend that inexorably changes the
business environment. Yet, its as much
about the journey as the destination.
This journey offers chemical and other
engineers the potential to overcome
software incompatibility and add value
progressively in achievable steps.
Already, substantial value is being
gained in the marine- and building-de-
sign industries by the pragmatic use of
appropriate standards like ISO 15926.
The CPI is the next frontier. Wider
use of networked engineering teams
and the molding of working practices
to take account of digital convergence
and thereby enable greater advantage
from the collaborative power of com-
puter networks. A digital information
hub appropriate to your operational
needs can deliver value both now
and in the future.
Edited by Rebekkah Marshall
Author
Neil McPhater is product
marketing manager in-
teroperability & special proj-
ects at Aveva Solutions Ltd.
(High Cross, Madingley Road,
Cambridge CB3 0HB, U.K.;
Phone: +44-1223-556626;
Fax: +44-1223-556666; Email:
neil.mcphater@aveva.com;
Website: www.aveva.com)
an Aveva Group plc company,
where he has responsibility
for interoperability strategy and deployment in
Aveva products. Originally trained as a mechani-
cal engineer in his native Scotland and on ship at
sea, McPhater worked in Switzerland, Germany
and England before turning his attentions to the
application of computers to support engineering.
He first joined Aveva at its Cambridge headquar-
ters in 1980 involved in a wide variety of software
development, marketing and management roles.
This included responsibility for delivering inte-
gration and translation solutions to the process
industries. Over the last 15 years he has been
an international champion of business benefit
derived from data integration using standards in
the process industries in such initiatives as Epis-
tle, ISO 10303 (STEP), PISTEP, POSC Caesar
Assn. and Fiatech. This experience is academi-
cally reinforced by an MBA (IT Hybrid) awarded
in the year 2000. McPhater has also served on the
Computer Committee of the Institute of Mechani-
cal Engineers for a number of years and has been
a member of the German Verein Deutscher Ing-
enieure (VDI) for the last three decades.
Gorman-Rupp has been manufacturing pumps for chemical applications since the 1930s. They can
be found in chemical and petrochemical plants, canneries, commercial laundries, pharmaceutical and
automotive plants. Whether your application requires standard centrifugal, self-priming centrifugal,
submersible or positive displacement pumps, youll nd the right Gorman-Rupp pump for the job.
445
Circle 21 on p. 62 or go to adlinks.che.com/23021-21
15_CHE_120109_RM.indd 43 11/20/09 10:27:31 AM
T
he desire to move from batch to continuous processes
for the production of high-value organic molecules has
become more widespread in recent years as evidenced
by the increasing number of related studies published
in the literature. The benefits of continuous flow include
increased product yield, increased utility and energy uti-
lization, improved safety and greater automation. A quest
to improve the overall production economics for smaller or-
ganic molecules and many inorganic chemicals forced this
change on the bulk chemicals industry many decades ago.
But strong interest has not yet translated into the wide-
spread use of continuous processes for specialty chemi-
cals, fine chemicals and pharmaceutical manufacturing.
This article proposes that the use of small-scale reactions
can provide the missing link that brings continuous opera-
tion within practical reach.
Consider, first, that the great number of publications that
describe laboratory experiments involving dozens of differ-
ent chemistries (for instance, experiments that are seeking
yield improvements or hazard reductions, or simply dem-
onstrating the translation of a batch process to continu-
ous mode), often champion the use of microreactors. These
ultra-small-scale devices work on the principle of creating
short characteristic transport lengths (on the order of tens
or hundreds of micrometers) with their very small, internal
physical structures, and this helps to improve mixing and
heat transfer rates.
However, pilot and production plant managers are often
resistant to adopting microdevices, wary of blockage or
damage, and uncertain in the face of a general absence of
demonstrated high-capacity units. This article explores the
following questions: Is it necessary for fine chemicals and
pharmaceutical chemical manufacturers to move all the
way from stirred-tank reactors (STRs), with volumes on
the order of hundreds or thousands of liters, down to mi-
crodevices, whose channels have dimensions on the order of
hundreds of micrometers, in order to realize improvements
in heat and mass transfer? Or might there be some use-
ful intermediate size of equipment that would enable con-
tinuous production and provide the desired performance
advantages?
This article presents the case for that middle ground, dis-
cussing reactors whose critical dimension are of the order
of millimeters (so-called milliscale or millichannel reac-
tors) and explores relevant information and approaches
for using such milliscale reactors to carry out small-scale,
continuous reactions. Relevant questions that users should
answer when considering what equipment to utilize are
also addressed.
Scales of reactor
In any reactor, continuous or batch, the main performance
characteristics are how well mixing, mass transfer and heat
transfer can be carried out. One of the main purposes for
using continuous-flow reactors is to gain increased control
and improve the homogeneity of the reaction mass. This is
based on the expectation that continuous operation yields
more-consistent and predictable mixing and heat transfer
capacity, and allows for the precise setting of operating pa-
rameters, all of which lead to improved product quality.
The microdevices used in the laboratory today are, be-
cause of their dimensions, good tools for demonstrating
fast chemistry that is, rapid reactions that are nor-
mally finished within a few seconds. The question we are
Feature Report
44 CHEMICAL ENGINEERING WWW.CHE.COM DECEMBER 2009
Engineering Practice
Martin Jnsson and Barry Johnson
Alfa Laval
Millichannel Reactors:
A Practical Middle Ground for Production
Diameter volume
Stirred
tank reactor
Pipe Millichannel Micro-
channel
Flow regime
Turbulent Intermediate Laminar
FIGURE 1. As shown (left to right), the progressive downsiz-
ing of reactor devices brings with it corresponding changes in
the dominant fow regime
Reactors with millimeter-scale
dimensions provide mixing,
heat transfer and other advantages
over devices with larger dimensions,
and increased robustness compared
to microdevices. Here are tips
to consider for using them
16_CHE_120109_EP_SAS.indd 44 11/19/09 3:48:27 PM
considering here is: Can milliscale devices give sufficient
performance benefits, in terms of mixing and heat transfer,
while giving producers an option for robust production in
an industrial environment?
As shown in Figure 1, as the characteristic dimensions of
competing devices get smaller, there are competing changes
from a reaction engineering viewpoint (for instance, the
movement in and of the liquid decreases as the flow be-
comes laminar, so there is less help from the fluid in gener-
ating mixing and heat transfer; thus the dominant mixing
mechanism becomes diffusion). During progressive down-
sizing, the surface-area-per-unit-volume increases, thereby
aiding thermal control. Another way of thinking about the
fluid dynamics is that in large vessels we must consider,
macro-, meso- and microscale mixing phenonenon, in the
middle domain meso and macro scale mixing takes place,
while in microdevices, only micromixing takes place.
Mixing in the milliscale device will generally be much
more uniform than in a stirred tank of similar capacity,
thereby providing a less-varied processing history for all
molecules and yielding a more uniform product.
The actual geometry of the flow path in a milliscale pipe
or channel can also be designed (although with potential
tradeoffs in terms of pressure drop) to increase the mix-
ing and heat-transfer performance of the device, bringing
it closer to what might be achieved using microchannel de-
vices. Inserts in a pipe (called static mixers) or channels
with varying diameters or added twists and turns along
their length are additional options to increase the fluid dy-
namics inside the reactor. Such structures help to break
up larger fluid structures and reduce transport distances.
Several milliscale devices bring greatly improved mixing,
retention time and plug-flow characteristics to low Reyn-
olds number (laminar) flows through enhanced flow in
their radial direction caused by Dean vortices.
When investigating inter-phase mass transfer using
such milliscale devices (for instance, for immiscible liquid-
liquid systems), the speed at which individual molecules
cross the phase boundary cannot be greatly affected. But
the rate of generation of surface area and the total amount
of surface area available for mass transfer can both be in-
creased, thereby increasing the overall mass-transfer rate.
In addition, more-advantageous modes or flow regimes,
such as plug flow or engulfment flow, can be established in
continuous devices with smaller channels.
In addition to the performance characteristics mentioned
above, the degree of plug flow also needs to be considered
when evaluating continuous reactor options. In general, the
degree of plug flow is determined from the residence-time
distribution of the reactor, and indicates the uniformity of
processing history that each molecule or fluid element ex-
periences. A typical target requirement for plug flow in a
reactor is a Bodenstein number of 100 or greater. This can-
not be achieved in a straight milliscale pipe (Figure 2).
The process requirements and capabilities of any contin-
uous reactor must also be matched to the practical capabil-
ities of the feed pumps that are coupled to them. Perfect
plug flow calls for perfect pumps if the required feed
ratios are not achieved at all times in a perfect plug-flow
reactor then there will be unreacted material remaining at
the outlet. Thankfully for pump manufacturers and process
developers, all reactors do have some extent of axial disper-
sion that can act to correct initial stoichiometry devia-
tions created by fluctuation in the flows from real pumps.
CHEMICAL ENGINEERING WWW.CHE.COM DECEMBER 2009 45
TABLE 1. AVERAGE PROPERTIES RELEVANT TO TEMPERATURE CONTROL FOR THE DEVICES SHOWN IN FIGURE 1
Reactor device Stirred-tank reactor Pipe
(Static mixer in
shell-and-tube
configuration)
Millichannel
reactor
(Plate reactor)
Microchannel
reactor
(Glass chip)
Device dimension 1 m 12.5 mm 2 mm 100 micrometers
Surface area, m
2
/m
3
4 300 1,500 40,000
Overall heat transfer coeffi-
cient (HTC), U
av
(W/m
2
K)
400 1,000 3,000 10,000
Volumetric heat transfer
coefficient,* MW/m
3
K
0.002 0.3 4.5 400
Note: Volumetric heat transfer coefficient = HTC x surface area per unit volume. The volumetric heat transfer coefficient can be combined with a low
estimate for the temperature difference between the utility and process temperatures (1 to 10 K) and used to screen which reactors would be capable
of controlling the heat output from a particular exothermic reaction.
0.20
0.10
0.00
Time (s)
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50
0.30
0.40
Inlet probe
Outlet probe
0.50
0.60
0.70
0.80
P
r
o
b
e
v
o
l
t
a
g
e
(
V
)
FIGURE 2. Shown here is a residence-time distribution from
a milliscale device corresponding to a Bodenstein number of
roughly 150. Key features to note are the fact that the shape
of the peak changes little on passage through the device, and
there is no long tail on the outlet peak, which would indicate
retention of material in the device
16_CHE_120109_EP_SAS.indd 45 11/19/09 3:49:41 PM
Engineering Practice
46 CHEMICAL ENGINEERING WWW.CHE.COM DECEMBER 2009
Table 1 shows some of the average properties
that are relevant to temperature control for the
devices shown in Figure 1.
To illustrate the suitability of the different
scales of flow devices shown in Table 1 for re-
moving the heat generated in a reaction, we
consider a simple neutralization reaction where
all of both reactants are added together very
quickly. This would be considered a very fast
process and therefore difficult to control in the
case of a batch reactor. (The solution in a batch
reactor would be to slowly add parts of one re-
agent to all of the second reactant.)
Neutralization of 1 m
3
of a one molar acid so-
lution in a reactor (independent of type), with
a residence time of 60 seconds, would release
60,000 kJ of energy in 60 s, creating heat output
of 1 MW. This heat will be removed by the mil-
liscale and microscale reactors discussed above,
and it might be made to fit in the larger shell-
and-tube reactor by spreading out the process
along the reactor length by using multiple reac-
tant feed points.
However the calculation does not account for
variations in the reaction rate as it proceeds.
More realistically for a second-order kinetic pro-
cess, 75% of this heat might be released in the first 10 s of
reaction, giving an initial heat-release rate of 4.5 MW that
would need to be accommodated by the reactor. This fur-
ther reduces the options to milliscale and microscale chan-
nels. It does not, of course, mean the reactor will provide
isothermal operation along its entire length, but the extent
and timescale of the temperature rise does limit the occur-
rence of side or degradation reactions.
Converting batch to continuous
Typically for an exothermic reaction, either the feedrate
to a batch reactor will be designed or controlled such that
the temperature in the vessel does not rise significantly
(isothermal operation), or the operating temperature will
(also) be decreased to reduce reaction and heat release
rates (although this is a more costly option). These modi-
fications to a true batch operation are important not only
from a safety perspective, but also from a product-quality
perspective.
For instance, with longer operating times (on the order
of hours) associated with many batch processes, it is impor-
tant to design a system that avoids or minimizes potential
thermal degradation. Further complicating the issue, the
temperature inside a tank reactor can vary significantly
throughout the vessel, but point or averaging measure-
ments often do not record such variation.
When we consider a continuous reactor, the simplest op-
eration mode is to add all the reactants together at once.
This approach leads to high initial reaction rates and
therefore high rates of heat evolution. In a reactor with
relatively large dimensions (that is, not on the milliscale or
microscale), this would cause the temperature of the reac-
tion medium to rise. It is the magnitude of this rise and
the time that the molecules are exposed to higher tempera-
tures that influence the degradation of product quality.
To combat this phenomenon, continuous reactor devices
with higher heat-transfer rates are necessary and the type
of reactor must be determined by the amount of energy re-
leased, the heat transfer timescale, and the kinetics of the
degradation processes. Because many of the smaller-scale
reactor technologies are relatively new, it is important to
discuss requirements with the reactor supplier.
The high thermal capacities of milliscale and mi-
croscale devices (Table 1) can help to limit and control the
temperature rise to a much greater extent than with a
stirred-tank reactor that accompanies so many organic
chemical reactions. So the question for the process devel-
oper becomes: Can I withstand a small, non-isothermal
temperature profile along the reactor? In other words, will
a temporary excursion even one that lasts just a few
seconds cause significant product degradation? Even
if significant deviation from isothermal operation is not
an option, there is the added possibility of using multiple
feed points along the reactor, in essence to help spread
out the exotherm, although this might complicate the en-
gineering.
Moving to industrial scale
Continuous reactors for replacing current small-scale,
batch-production equipment (for instance, for use by fine
chemicals and pharmaceutical manufacturers) must be
capable of providing residence and reaction times rang-
ing from a few seconds to many minutes, and yet still be
capable of throughput rates on the order of one or more
metric tons per year (m.t./yr). These simple criteria call for
a reactor volume on the order of 0.11 L. Such a unit has
FIGURE 3. In this small-scale, continuous reactor installation, the utility
and reactant supply are shown on the left and the reactor is on the right.
The reaction channel dimensions are 2 mm. Although the reactor footprint is
very small, this apparatus could perform many campaigns in a year, making
tens of kilograms of pharmaceutical candidates. Or, if ftted into an existing,
multipurpose batch plant (using existing reactors as feed and collection
vessels), such a setup could produce 10 m.t./yr of a single product
16_CHE_120109_EP_SAS.indd 46 11/19/09 3:53:17 PM
CHEMICAL ENGINEERING WWW.CHE.COM DECEMBER 2009 47
a relatively small footprint and could be accommodated in
most standard fume hoods thereby opening the way to
industrial-scale production, for at least clinical phases, in-
side the laboratory setting (Figure 3).
To reach even greater production levels for instance, to
produce a 1,000 m.t./yr or more larger reactor volumes
(to 20 L) are required. This scaleup of production capacity
also means the reactor would have to move out from the
fume cabinet to a larger-scale production plant.
When it comes to scaling up promising lab-based reac-
tions, the following options should be considered:
Traditional scaleup move from a smaller-diameter
flow path to a larger-diameter flow path. This ap-
proach can be applied to pipes and milliscale channels. An
increase in channel diameter from 2 mm to 10 mm provides
a 25-fold increase in area, and correspondingly, potential
throughput rate. However, the user, or supplier, must be
sure that the required performance is maintained, particu-
larly for flows with low Reynolds number (laminar). For ex-
ample, the plug flow characteristics of a simple pipe would
degrade significantly. This degree of increase of the chan-
nel dimensions is significantly less than for stirred tanks,
so using traditional chemical engineering principles can
provide a faster and more robust procedure, thereby reduc-
ing development time.
However, the main limitation of the traditional scaleup
approach is the decrease in surface area per unit volume
of reactor which affects the heat removal. But this is
significant only in the very fast reactions.
Numbering up use a greater number of the same
reactor device that was used in the laboratory. This
approach has been considered for many years as the route
to achieve greater throughtput using microreactor devices,
and as a concept, this approach is very attractive. The claim
is that because the fluid dynamics and heat transfer will
remain the same in each of the many repeating channels
or devices, such a larger-scale setup will produce the same
quality of product as that of the laboratory setup.
However, the ability to achieve large-scale production
may require hundreds or thousands of microchannel de-
vices, which will engender considerable engineering re-
quirements for distribution, manifolding, measurement
and control of divided flows.
A combination of scaleup and numbering up can also be
applied with milliscale reactors so that the number of ac-
tual units required can be reduced, while still achieving
considerable scaleup. Recently DSM Pharma Chemicals re-
ported a small-scale, continuous nitration process produc-
ing 25 m.t. of product over a four-week campaign. This pro-
cess used several parallel lines of devices with individual
channel cross-sections on the order of 12 mm
2
and dem-
onstrated that it is practical to combine limited numbering
up with limited scaleup.
Important performance criteria
What is often overlooked is that in addition to mixing and
cooling capabilities, competing reactor options for indus-
trial-scale production should also be assessed for their per-
formance capabilities in the following areas:
Solids. Resistance to blockage or availability of strategies
to remove any buildup inside the reactor before fouling
becomes an issue
Physical robustness. This refers to the ability of the reac-
tor to remain unaffected by small changes in shape or
finish
Cleanabilty and inspectability. This is especially impor-
tant in fine chemical and pharmaceutical applications
Flexibility. Modern plants have to enable multipurpose
operation
Mechanical design. The design must be considered
with regard to its ability to meet industry and regulatory
standards
Solids handling. The specter of entrained solids hangs
ominously over the application of any small-scale, continu-
ous reactor device. Most chemical processes run the risk of
involving solids, whether intended (reactants or products)
or unintended (byproducts, fouling, debris or as a result
of loss of process or equipment control). The risk of solids-
related problems very often precludes consideration of mi-
crodevices for use in applications that require reliable and
uninterrupted production runs.
There are two primary options for addressing the problem
TABLE 2. COMPARISON OF CAPABILITIES FOR DIFFERENT REACTOR TYPES
Reactor device Pipe
(Static mixer in shell-and-
tube configuration)
Milliscale channel
(Plate reactor)
Microscale channel
(Glass chip)
Device dimension 12.5 mm 28 mm 100 micrometers
Surface area (relative) 100 1,000 10,000
Mixing time (relative) Medium Medium-fast Fast
Solids handling Possible Possible Limited
Flexibility Limited Good Limited
Scaleup Limited work on chemistry Limited work on chemistry Numbering up represents a
big engineering challenge
Production
equipment
Industry standard Industry standard Limited due to potential
safety issues
Cleaning options CIP and manual CIP and manual CIP only
16_CHE_120109_EP_SAS.indd 47 11/19/09 3:54:37 PM
Engineering Practice
of solids-related damage: 1) Transform the process in some
way to remove the solids involved (that is, by going back
to the chemists); or 2) Select equipment whose dimensions
are large enough to manage any potential entrained solids
without detrimental effect (an engineering approach).
Reactor devices with milliscale channels will handle
some solids entrained in liquid flows, but currently there
is very little information available to the end user, and the
knowledge base is further restricted by a lack of extensive
literature on scales less than one inch, and of systems for
pumping slurries. Because particles with a diameter of
100 micrometers or less can often be assumed to remain
suspended in flow, the ability to keep velocities as high as
possible for particles larger than this is an important con-
sideration during reactor selection.
Physical robustness. The robustness of the process (that
is, its ability to keep producing products that meet speci-
fications) is a reflection of both the chemistrys ability to
withstand small deviations in operating conditions and in
the performance of the reactor itself. Hence, the resistance
of the reactor to being changed by the process is important.
The ultra-small structures of micro devices are susceptible
to damage and erosion by particles over the operating life-
time. Similarly, any solids deposition could quickly affect
the heat transfer and alter the flow patterns significantly.
Cleanabilty and inspectability. The users ability to
clean and inspect any reactor is of enormous importance,
and unfortunately, this aspect of reactor selection often re-
ceives too little attention. Today a number of sealed reac-
tor-plate units (made from glass, plastic or metal) are on
the market. In a number of examples, such reactors have
been shown in a laboratory setting to perform the target
chemical reactions successfully (Figure 4).
However, when scaling up the process to commercial
FIGURE 4. Some
milliscale reactors
can be fully dis-
mantled for clean-
ing and inspection.
Up to 25 plates can
be stacked in the
unit shown, each
with a potential
throughput of sev-
eral hundred liters
per hour, and they
can be connected
either in series or
in parallel
48 CHEMICAL ENGINEERING WWW.CHE.COM DECEMBER 2009
Circle 22 on p. 62 or go to adlinks.che.com/23021-22
16_CHE_120109_EP_SAS.indd 48 11/20/09 1:30:46 PM
CHEMICAL ENGINEERING WWW.CHE.COM DECEMBER 2009 49
production, it is less clear if and how those responsible for
quality in production and cleaning will adopt these sealed
units. Will there be a demand to visually inspect a produc-
tion reactor or will cleaning in place (CIP) be acceptable to
regulators? From an efficiency standpoint, CIP is the fast-
est way, but the ability to open a unit and inspect it might
still be necessary to validate the CIP method.
Meanwhile, in reactor devices where plates, channels or
pipes can be opened, other issues arise. For instance:
Microscale and other small channels are very difficult to
inspect visually
If a numbering-up approach is used to increase through-
put volume, then the number of channels or plates to be
inspected may become large. If, as some claim, these ul-
tra-small-scale reactors themselves become inexpensive
enough to become disposable, there would still be a work-
load associated with acceptance, validation and commis-
sioning steps that must be repeated with each new set of
disposable reactors
In general, more-uniform reaction mixtures and increased
fluid motion might limit the deposition of solids. Modu-
lar continuous units, which can be disassembled and in-
spected in an hour or two, are available to ease inspection
and cleaning.
New strategies for continuous-flow reactors, such as the
use of short, periodic flushing cycles to reduce deposits mid-
campaign (steps that resemble CIP practices), may also be
considered, since associated startup and shutdown times
are short. However, what still needs to be developed are
consistent, industry-wide operating and quality-assurance
and quality-control (QA/QC) protocols to govern their use.
Flexibility. Flexibility is the hallmark of the traditional
STR, which can be utilized for heating, cooling, mixing, re-
action and separation. However, the STR flexibility brings
its own associated costs. For instance, lower performance
leads to deoptimization of the process to reduce the duty,
and greater safety concerns when operating with large
volumes of hazardous processes or harmful reagents. Any
continuous reactor technology must offer the user some
flexibility to be able to perform all of these different pro-
cess operations with different performance requirements,
and unlike the STR, be able to have different throughputs
(in terms of turn up and turndown, which requires spare
capacity in the pumping and utility systems).
When it comes to millichannel reactors, flexibility can be
achieved by using reactor systems that offer modular con-
struction, whereby channels or pipes of differing size can
be configured in a common frame or shell. The alternative
to this would be a multi-reactor plant where a number of
different reactors are permanently installed in a way that
Dry Screening Reaches New Heights
The new APEX
s
p
r
o
c
e
s
s
i
n
d
u
s
t
r
i
e
s
t
h
e
g
a
t
e
w
a
y
www.achemasia.de www.achema.cn
B
e
i
j
i
n
g
,
P
R
C
h
i
n
a
1
-
4
J
u
n
e
2
0
1
0
China's most international
event for the chemical process
industries welcomes YOU!
Chemical Apparatus and
Plant Construction
Process Technology
Petrochemistry
Maintenance and Quality Assurance
Environmental Protection
Water Treatment
Pharmaceutical Industry
Biotechnology
Food Industry
Agrochemistry
Laboratory and Analytical Techniques
Packaging and Storage Techniques
Resources Development
Circle 24 on p. 62 or go to adlinks.che.com/23021-24
16_CHE_120109_EP_SAS.indd 50 11/20/09 7:33:11 AM
Accurate level measurement
in steam applications
Dynamic Vapor Compensation (DVC)
is a new option available for the Rose-
mount 5300 Series of High Perfor-
mance Guided Wave Radar (GWR)
level transmitters (photo). DVC elimi-
nates accuracy errors associated with
varying pressure and temperature
that occur in vessels where steam
vapor is present, such as in boilers,
boiler feedwater heaters and steam
drums. Unlike traditional technolo-
gies, such as displacer and mechani-
cal gages, the DVC option, which com-
prises of a probe with built-in reflector
and software, is corrosion-resistant,
offers improved safety with a gastight
dual seal, has no moving parts and is
maintenance-free. Designed for chal-
lenging level and interface measure-
ments on liquids, slurries and solids,
the 5300 series GWR transmitters
have minimal installation require-
ments. The DVC uses a reference re-
flector at a fixed distance on a rigid,
single probe to measure the vapor
dielectric. This measurement is then
used to automatically compensate for
vapor dielectric changes resulting in a
final accuracy of within 2% (compared
with up to 30% specific gravity error
in density-based level measurements
or up to 20% for GWR if no compen-
sation is made). Emerson Process
Management, Austin, Tex.
www.emersonprocess.com
This pump protection switch can
be used in a variety of situations
The Gladiator pump protection switch
(photo) can be used in applications
where pipe or wall mounting with
minimal protrusion is required. It can
also be used to detect the presence of
liquids to ensure the pump will never
run dry. The switch has immunity
to build-up and monitors materials
with a wide range of dielectric con-
stants. Designed to operate in tough
industrial environments, the switch
is simple to set up and calibrate, and
is temperature stable. The Gladiator
communicates using
Modbus, HART, or Pro-
fibus protocols. A re-
mote amplifier can be
positioned up to 500
m (1,640 ft) away from
the unit. Applications
include monitoring liq-
uids in the petrochemi-
cal, food-and-beverage,
water and wastewater
industries, as well as
monitoring levels of
dry powdered material
for industries including
cement, glass, pharma-
ceutical, mining and
minerals and fertilizers.
Hawk, Melbourne,
Australia
www.hawkmeasure.
com
An easy way to measure
level is introduced
The Level Sensor (photo)
for continuous level mea-
surement uses the principal of buoy-
ancy by weighing an inert plastic
chain, secured below the fluid surface,
determining the inverse of liquid level
and converting it to an analog, digital
or wireless electronic signal for indi-
cation, alarming or other applications.
The products are easy to install, easy
to use and easy to maintain. These
level instruments install with screw
or flange connections; may be repaired
in place, by replacing modular com-
ponents; interface with most common
industrial signals or protocols; meet
standards for explosion-proof or in-
trinsic safe applications; and use no
moving parts to foul, drift or degrade.
Levelese, Inc., Denver, Colo.
www.levelese.com
Measure levels in challenging
environments
The PT4500 and PT4510 submersible
pressure transmitters (photo) have
been optimized for detecting the level
of water or other media with simi-
lar density in challenging
industrial environments. To
deliver accurate level detection, a
transmitter is placed at the bottom of
the tank holding the liquid, and the
transmitter then converts the pressure
reading to an analog 420-mA-output
signal. The electrical connection to the
transmitter is routed through the top
of the tank and contains power and sig-
nal wires. It also includes a breathing
tube that is used as a reference port to
determine the atmospheric pressure
outside of the tank. These IP-68 rated,
stainless-steel pressure transmitters
may be used in industrial applica-
tions, as well as hazardous classified
areas. Turck, Plymouth, Minn.
www.turck.us
A radar level transmitter
that is economical
The Model R82 radar transmitter
(photo) is based on pulse-burst-radar
technology, and is an economical so-
lution for simple applications. The
26-GHz, loop-powered, non-contact
transmitter provides ease of configu-
ration with either the menu-driven
four-pushbutton, two-line by 16-char-
CHEMICAL ENGINEERING WWW.CHE.COM DECEMBER 2009 51
Note: For more information, circle the 3-digit number
on p. 62, or use the website designation.
FOCUS ON
Level Measurement
And Control
Emerson Process Management
Levelese
Turck
Hawk
Magnetrol
17_CHE_120109_CUS.indd 51 11/19/09 4:06:20 PM
Focus
52 CHEMICAL ENGINEERING WWW.CHE.COM DECEMBER 2009
acter display, HART digital communi-
cation or PACTware. This allows com-
plete configuration via the local user
interface, or remotely with the added
capability of capturing echo wave-
forms and viewing trend data, diag-
nostic conditions and all transmitter
configuration parameters. Magnet-
rol, Downers Grove, Ill.
www.magnetrol.com
Measure submersed solids
under water
The SmartBob-SS sensor (photo) is de-
signed for applications of submersed
solids under water, such as measuring
the level of settled salt. The Smart-
Bob-SS sensor drops a weighted bob
through the liquid; when the bob comes
into contact with solid settled material
at the bottom of the tank, it retracts
and sends a measurement to a Smart-
Bob control console or a PC loaded
with eBob software. The SmartBob-SS
sensor comes configured with a 3-in.
standpipe for ease of instal-
lation, a stainless-steel cable
that stands up to corrosive
materials, and a SureDrop cap
that prevents the weight from
being retracted into the pipe
and protects the device from
unwanted material entering
through the standpipe. Bin-
Master, Lincoln, Nebr.
www.binmaster.com
A hand-held device to measure
levels in non-metallic containers
Designed for use in a wide variety
of applications, the C-Level sensor
(photo) is a quick, inexpensive way
to detect the level of liquid or solids
within non-metallic containers. The C-
Level provides a quick assessment of
partial containers and offers accurate
level identification, accurate to within
in., without opening or weighing
drums. The device is powered by a
standard 9-V battery and includes a
power-saving automatic shut-off fea-
ture. Applications include inventory,
plant operations, auditing, quality
control and others. Tecmark Corp.,
Mentor, Ohio
www.tecmark.com
Detect and control interfaces
with this switch
The FlexSwitch FLT93S flow/level/
temperature switch provides accu-
rate interface detection and control
in applications such as the operation
of separation tanks and other ves-
Find out how your company can
attain Growth and Sustainability
in the Chemical Industry
Post Recession.
The Third Annual India Chemical Industry Outlook
February 11-12, 2010 Mubai, Iodia
Presented by:
Save the Date!
16672
Tecmark
BinMaster
17_CHE_120109_CUS.indd 52 11/23/09 7:38:17 AM
CHEMICAL ENGINEERING WWW.CHE.COM DECEMBER 2009 53
sels with mixed density media. The
FLT93S Switch monitors, controls and
alarms flowrates or levels of critical
fluids, such as foams, emulsion lay-
ers, liquids and slurries. Its rugged
industrial design and housing pro-
vide reliability and long service life
under harsh plant environments. The
FLT93S Switch is a dual-function, in-
sertion-style instrument that offers ei-
ther flow/temperature sensing or level/
temperature sensing in a single device.
Unlike density displacers, which are
often used for level and interface con-
trol, the FLT93S Switch relies on the
specific heat-transfer properties of the
media to identify the interface of dif-
ferent products. With its thermal dis-
persion sensing capability, the FLT93S
monitors the interface of products with
similar densities and can identify the
interface between various types of
media including foam, emulsion lay-
ers, liquids and slurries. The FLT93S
Switchs dual-switch-point option al-
lows one instrument to control two dif-
ferent product interfaces. Two or more
switches are used to control product
discharge and intake at specified
points. Fluid Components Interna-
tional, San Marcos, Calif.
www.fluidcomponents.com
Transmit level data with
this wireless system
The DX80 (photo) provides a low-cost
method for transmitting data between
process sensors and higher level sys-
tems, such as DCS or SCADA sys-
tems. The DX80 includes two devices,
a node (wireless transmitter) that
resides in the field and interfaces to
measurement devices, and a gateway
(wireless receiver) that resides in the
main control panel and interfaces to
a PC or PLC. Each node accepts up to
two analog and two discrete-switch
inputs. Each gateway accepts up to 55
nodes. The DX80 wireless transmit-
ter and receiver communicate via a
frequency hopping spread spectrum
(FHSS) radio system that ensures the
message is delivered and is secure.
The DX80 is available in two different
models: the 900 MHz frequency (U.S.,
Canada and Australia) or the 2.4 GHz
(rest of world) ISM (instrumentation,
scientific and medical) band. The sig-
nal range is three miles, line of sight,
and especially suited for tank farms;
plastic pellet, cement, and aggre-
gated storage silos; and hydrocarbon
storage tanks. K-TEK Corp., Prai-
rieville, La.
www.ktekcorp.com
Dorothy Lozowski
C
M
Y
CM
MY
CY
CMY
K
ChemEnggII09half-ol.pdf I0/I?/?009 9.44.S? AM
Circle 25 on p. 62 or go to adlinks.che.com/23021-25
K-TEK
17_CHE_120109_CUS.indd 53 11/20/09 10:40:13 AM
Visit CE Lit Online
at che.com
Circle 295 on p. 62 or go to adlinks.che.com/23021-295
Literature Review
Featuring Brochures and Catalogs of Products and Services for the CPI
ALL 316SS Solenoid Valve up to 6 Pipe Size
All wetted components are made from 316SS. This rotary shaft
type solenoid valve completely isolates the fluid from all magnetic
solenoid components. Easily handles cor-
rosive or viscous fluids. Available in to 6
pipe sizes. For literature or same day quota-
tion contact:
CLARK-COOPER DIVISION
Magnatrol Valve Corporation
855 Industrial Hwy - Unit # 4
Cinnaminson, NJ 08077-1933
Phone: 856-829-4580 - Fax: 856-829-7303
E-Mail: techsupport@clarkcooper.com
Website: www.clarkcooper.com
DECEMBER 2009
CHE.COM
NEW 3 Inch Stainless Steel
2-Way Solenoid Valves
Magnatrol now offers its popular Stainless Steel
Solenoid valve in a 3 inch size. Full port; require
NO differential pressure to open and are easily
serviced while in the pipeline. Applications in-
clude Deionized Water, Ammonias, Vegetable
Oil, Fuel Oil, Gas, Steam, Solvents, Cryogenics
and Oxygen. Valves are of a packless con-
struction with continuous duty coils for all AC and DC voltages,
available normally open or normally closed with 150 and 300lb
flanged connections. For literature or same day quotation contact:
MAGNATROL VALVE CORPORATION PHONE: 973-427-4341
E-MAIL: info@magnatrol.com WEB SITE: www.magnatrol.com
Circle 293 on p. 62 or go to adlinks.che.com/23021-293
EquipNet provides asset management ser-
vices to world-class chemical companies
Our offerings include asset
evaluation and appraisal, site
reconfiguration consulting,
project management, and sales
and marketing. These services
yield a large supply of high-
quality process equipment and
unused MRO parts available for
sale at the EquipNet Market-
Place, the largest website of its kind. Contact: E.J. Paturzo,
Managing Director: Chemical (781) 821-3482 x100
epaturzo@equipnet.com www.EquipNet.com
Circle 290 on p. 62 or go to adlinks.che.com/23021-290
BWB Technologies
Model XP Flame Photometer
The BWB- XP is a high quality, high perfor-
mance instrument employing modern technol-
ogy to measure alkali and alkaline earth met-
als Sodium (Na), Potassium (K), Lithium (Li),
Calcium (Ca) and Barium (Ba). Liquid samples,
when introduced to a flame fuelled by pro-
pane or lpg, will emit light of a specific wavelength, the intensity of
which will be proportional to the concentration of the ions present.
The principle has been understood for over one hundred years, but
the BWB-XP brings 21st century technology to the technique, mak-
ing analysis more reliable, accurate and simple than ever before.
BWB Technologies www.bwbtech.com/ce
Circle 292 on p. 62 or go to adlinks.che.com/23021-292
Delta Cooling Towers, Inc.
Cooling Towers
Delta Cooling Towers manufactures
a complete line of corrosion-proof en-
gineered plastic cooling towers. The
towers incorporate a high efficiency
counter-flow design and carry a
15-year warranty on the casing, which
is molded into a unitary leak-proof
structure of engineered plastic. All
models are factory assembled, simple
to install and nearly maintenance free.
1-800-289-3358 www.deltacooling.com
sales@deltacooling.com
Circle 294 on p. 62 or go to adlinks.che.com/23021-294
Design Flow Solutions
Design Flow Solutions is the
most comprehensive, cost ef-
fective engineering aid available
for complete hydraulic analysis
of complex piping systems. This
powerful software package
provides engineers with complete
hydraulic analysis of complex
piping, effective solutions to fluid flow problems, fast, reliable refer-
ence information. See our website for more information and to down-
load a free evaluation copy: ABZ, Inc., 4451 Brookfield Corp. Dr.,
Suite 107 Chantilly, VA 20151 Phone: (800) 747-7401 Fax: (703)
631-5282 Email: sales@abzinc.com www.abzinc.com/che
Circle 291 on p. 62 or go to adlinks.che.com/23021-291
18_CHE_120109_LIT.indd 54 11/20/09 3:08:07 PM
Literature Review
Chemical Engineerings Literature Review DECEMBER 2009
Cleveland Wire Cloth
Wire Cloth
Specializes in high temperature, corro-
sion resistant, and specialty metals and
alloys for process functions, as well as
OEM components. Wire cloth is woven to
precise, customer requirements. Catalog
includes application data, design guide-
lines, technical specifications, ordering
information, and a new, interactive CD with
a wire cloth specifications calculator.
Tel: 800-321-3234 (U.S. & Canada) or
216-341-1832; Fax: 216-341-1876;
cleveland@wirecloth.com;
www.wirecloth.com
Circle 298 on p. 62 or go to adlinks.che.com/23021-298
Literature Review
2009
Contact: Helene Hicks
212-621-4958 hhicks@che.com for advertising information. March closing: 2/12/10
Chemical Engineering is the preferred
publication among CHEM Show Attendees
Provides the most useful how-to engineering information
Offers the most in-depth global coverage
of the chemical process industries
Best delivers technical news that is helpful in your job
ONE publication would choose if could receive only ONE
Chemical Engineers
Total Circulation: 65,325*
Domestic: 57,418*
ncludes: USA, Canada, Mexico,
US territories, other
Qualified Circulation CP 7 Segments*
Chemical & Petrochemical
Petrol Refining
Nonferrous Metals
Stone & Clay
Pulp & Paper
Food & Beverage
Rubber & Miscellaneous
Other Manufacturing
* (BPA Audit June 2009)
MARCH, JUNE, SEPTEMBER & DECEMBER
DECEMBER
The Wayman Group, 2007 CHEMshow survey
(Coming Soon 2009 CHEMshow Survey)
Place Your Ad Here!
Advertise in Chemical Engineer-
ing Literature Review, a special
bound-in-the-magazine supplement
that can showcase your latest cata-
logs, brochures, and spec sheets.
Reach over 266,700 engineering
professionals who turn to Chemical
Engineering every month for just this
kind of production information.
Contact: Helene Hicks
Inside Sales Manager
Phone: 212 621-4958 Fax: 212 621-4976
hhicks@che.com
www.che.com
Mag Hydroxide
Mixing Magnesium Hydroxide Is Fast & Easy With Pulsair
Pulsair can mix mag
hydroxide in all kinds of
tanks: steel - stainless steel
- polyethylene - fiberglass
- concrete - wooden - totes
and drums No special
requirents No internal baffels No structural supports No rein-
forcments Low maintenance Most installations take less than
a day Retrofit exisitng caustic or storage tanks. Sound easy? It is
easy! Call Pulsair Systems for additional Information and pricing
800-582-7797 Or by email sales@pulsair.com Pulsair Systems,
Inc., Bellevue, WA; Tel: 800-582-7797; www.pulsair.com
Circle 296 on p. 62 or go to adlinks.che.com/23021-296
Measure Color for Optimal Quality
The UltraScan VIS spectrophotometer objec-
tively quantifies slight lot differences in yel-
lowness and color for clear and chromatic
chemicals. It measures both reflected and
transmitted color, and meets CIE and ASTM
guidelines. As recommended by the CIE,
spectral data is measured, and tristimulus
color calculated, from 360 to 780nm. Its light
source is controlled in the ultraviolet region
for the accurate measurement of whitening agents. APHA, Saybolt,
Gardner, ASTM D 1500, Yellowness, Whiteness and Haze can be
measured. The sphere minimizes effects introduced by sample haze.
www.hunterlab.com 703-471-6870 info@hunterlab.com
Circle 297 on p. 62 or go to adlinks.che.com/23021-297
18_CHE_120109_LIT.indd 55 11/20/09 3:15:01 PM
56 CHEMICAL ENGINEERING WWW.CHE.COM DECEMBER 2009
PRODUCT
SHOWCASE
Circle 202 on p. 62 or go to
adlinks.che.com/23021-202
Circle 203 on p. 62 or go to
adlinks.che.com/23021-203
PTFE or FKM
diaphragms.
PVC, Polypro or
PVDF bodies.
Available with
or without
gauges.
Gauge
Shields for
harsh environments.
PLAST-O-MATIC VALVES, INC.
CEDAR GROVE, NJ 07009
(973) 256-3000 Fax: (973) 256-4745
www.plastomatic.com info@plastomatic.com
Compact and Economical, Plast-O-Matic
Gauge Guards prevent dangerous leaks and
allow dependable instrument readings from
full vacuum to 250 psi.
Protect pressure or vacuum
instruments from clogging,
corrosion and damage.
SEALS/GUARDS 2C AD-07 8/15/07 8:59 AM Page 1
Circle 201 on p. 62 or go to
adlinks.che.com/23021-201
Krytox
Fluorinated Lubricants
miller-stephenson chemical company, inc.
California - Illinois - Connecticut - Canada
e-mail: support@miller-stephenson.com
www.miller-stephenson.com
Krytox
Sterilization
Reverse Osmosis
Heat Transfer
Fluids
Hydrocarbon Properties
Focus on Filtration
Facts at Your Fingertips: Valves
Preventing Caking
Lessons-Learned
Systems
CHE subscribe 1-2h09.pdf 8/7/08 11:16:21 AM
19_CHE_120109_Classified.indd 56 11/20/09 2:08:29 PM
Intelligen Suite
The Market-Leading Engineering Suite for Modeling, Evaluation,
Scheduling, and Debottlenecking of Single & Multi-Product Facilities
Use SuperPro Designer to model, evaluate, and
debottleneck batch and continuous processes
Switch to SchedulePro to schedule, model,
and debottleneck multi-product facilities
SuperPro SchedulePro
Tracking of equipment occupancy
in multi-product facilities
Tracking demand for resources
(e.g., labor, materials, utilities, etc.)
Inventory tracking for raw materials,
intermediates, products, and wastes
SuperPro Designer is a comprehensive process simulator that facilitates modeling, cost analysis, debottlenecking, cycle time
reduction, and environmental impact assessment of biochemical, specialty chemical, pharmaceutical (bulk & fine), food, consumer
product, mineral processing, water purification, wastewater treatment, and related processes. Its development was initiated at the
Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT). SuperPro is already in use at more than 400 companies and 500 universities around
the world (including 18 of the top 20 pharmaceutical companies and 9 of the top 10 biopharmaceutical companies).
SchedulePro is a versatile finite capacity scheduling tool that generates feasible production schedules for multi-product facilities that
do not violate constraints related to the limited availability of facilities, equipment, resources and work areas. It can be used in
conjunction with SuperPro (by importing its recipes) or independently (by creating recipes directly in SchedulePro). Any industry
that manufactures multiple products by sharing production lines and resources can benefit from the use of SchedulePro. Engineering
companies use it as a modeling tool to size utilities for batch plants, identify equipment requirements, reduce cycle times, and
debottleneck facilities.
Visit our website to download detailed product literature
and functional evaluation versions of our tools
INTELLIGEN, INC. 2326 Morse Avenue Scotch Plains, NJ 07076 USA
Tel: (908) 654-0088 Fax: (908) 654-3866
Email: info@intelligen.com Website: www.intelligen.com
Intelligen also has offices in Europe and representatives in countries around the world
R
e
cipe D
B
Circle 240 on p. 62 or go to adlinks.che.com/23021-240
19_CHE_120109_Classified.indd 57 11/20/09 2:08:50 PM
HSC Chemistry
7
Outotec's new innovative process calculation software contains an
updated flowsheet simulation module and a thermochemical
database expanded to over 25,000 species. With 22 calculation
modules and 12 databases at your fingertips, HSC 7 is an invaluable
tool for any process engineer or scientist because one laboratory
experiment may cost much more than a single HSC license.
Once the compass gave us a competitive edge when navigating in
foggy waters. Today modeling and simulation give us a similar
advantage when we navigate oceans of data with hundreds of
variables. This is the only way to utilize the current massive
information overload. The new HSC 7 provides us with an easy
simulation tool to steer process development and research.
Ask for the 32 page Whats new in HSC 7 paper from:
Outotec Research Oy
Email: hsc@outotec.com, Tel: +358-20-529 211
www.outotec.com/hsc
Circle 241 on p. 62 or go to
adlinks.che.com/23021-241
19_CHE_120109_Classified.indd 58 11/20/09 2:09:14 PM
CHEMICAL ENGINEERING WWW.CHE.COM DECEMBER 2009 59
SOFTWARE
Circle 243 on p. 62 or go to
adlinks.che.com/23021-243
Circle 242 on p. 62 or go to adlinks.che.com/23021-242
HTRI Xchanger Suite
JOB FUNCTION
20 Corporate Management
21 Plant Operations incl. Mainte-
nance
22 Engineering
23 Research & Development
24 Safety & Environmental
26 Other
EMPLOYEE SIZE
28 Less than 10 Employees
29 10 to 49 Employees
30 50 to 99 Employees
31 100 to 249 Employees
32 250 to 499 Employees
33 500 to 999 Employees
34 1,000 or more Employees
YOU RECOMMEND,
SPECIFY, PURCHASE
(please circle all that apply)
40 Drying Equipment
41 Filtration/Separation Equipment
42 Heat Transfer/Energy Conserva-
tion Equipment
43 Instrumentation & Control Sys-
tems
44 Mixing, Blending Equipment
45 Motors, Motor Controls
46 Piping, Tubing, Fittings
47 Pollution Control Equipment
& Systems
48 Pumps
49 Safety Equipment & Services
50 Size Reduction & Agglomeration
Equipment
51 Solids Handling Equipment
52 Tanks, Vessels, Reactors
53 Valves
54 Engineering Computers/Soft-
ware/Peripherals
55 Water Treatment Chemicals
& Equipment
56 Hazardous Waste Management
Systems
57 Chemicals & Raw Materials
58 Materials of Construction
59 Compressors
Fax this page back to 800-571-7730
New Product Information December 2009
JustFAXit! or go to
Fill out the form and circle or write in the number(s)
below, cut it out, and fax it to 800-571-7730.
www.che.com/adlinks
Go on the Web and fll out the
online reader service card.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
120
121
122
123
124
125
126
127
128
129
130
131
132
133
134
135
136
137
138
139
140
141
142
143
144
145
146
147
148
149
150
151
152
153
154
155
156
157
158
159
160
161
162
163
164
165
166
167
168
169
170
171
172
173
174
175
176
177
178
179
180
181
182
183
184
185
186
187
188
189
190
191
192
193
194
195
196
197
198
199
200
201
202
203
204
205
206
207
208
209
210
211
212
213
214
215
216
217
218
219
220
221
222
223
224
225
226
227
228
229
230
231
232
233
234
235
236
237
238
239
240
241
242
243
244
245
246
247
248
249
250
251
252
253
254
255
256
257
258
259
260
261
262
263
264
265
266
267
268
269
270
271
272
273
274
275
276
277
278
279
280
281
282
283
284
285
286
287
288
289
290
291
292
293
294
295
296
297
298
299
300
301
302
303
304
305
306
307
308
309
310
311
312
313
314
315
316
317
318
319
320
321
322
323
324
325
326
327
328
329
330
331
332
333
334
335
336
337
338
339
340
341
342
343
344
345
346
347
348
349
350
351
352
353
354
355
356
357
358
359
360
361
362
363
364
365
366
367
368
369
370
371
372
373
374
375
376
377
378
379
380
381
382
383
384
385
386
387
388
389
390
391
392
393
394
395
396
397
398
399
400
401
402
403
404
405
406
407
408
409
410
411
412
413
414
415
416
417
418
419
420
421
422
423
424
425
426
427
428
429
430
431
432
433
434
435
436
437
438
439
440
441
442
443
444
445
446
447
448
449
450
451
452
453
454
455
456
457
458
459
460
461
462
463
464
465
466
467
468
469
470
471
472
473
474
475
476
477
478
479
480
481
482
483
484
485
486
487
488
489
490
491
492
493
494
495
496
497
498
499
500
501
502
503
504
505
506
507
508
509
510
511
512
513
514
515
516
517
518
519
520
521
522
523
524
525
526
527
528
529
530
531
532
533
534
535
536
537
538
539
540
541
542
543
544
545
546
547
548
549
550
551
552
553
554
555
556
557
558
559
560
561
562
563
564
565
566
567
568
569
570
571
572
573
574
575
576
577
578
579
580
581
582
583
584
585
586
587
588
589
590
591
592
593
594
595
596
597
598
599
600
If number(s) do not appear above,
please write them here and circle:
ADVERTISING SALES REPRESENTATIVES
Name Title
Company
Address
City State/Province Zip/Postal Code
Country\ Telephone Fax
Email | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |