Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Artifact
Republic
Julius Caesar
Assassinate
Augustus
Pax Romana
Diocletian
Citizenship
Corruption
Attila
Autonomous
Clovis
Public works
Multicultural
Romance Languages
Constantine
Students will work with a partner to brainstorm a list of important facts concerning the
Roman Empire in sequential order. The teacher will walk around the class to observe these
lists to make sure that students remember key facts concerning the Roman Empire because
if students struggle to recall these facts, than more review will be necessary.
Progress Monitoring:
- While students discuss lyric ideas will, the teacher will walk around to see if some
students need more assistance in coming up with ideas. Modeling and added scaffolding
will be determined based on student discussions.
- The writing process with the whole class will allow the teacher to determine how well the
class has mastered the content and their ability to use that content with higher order
thinking and creativity.
Summative: students will complete the last stanza independently. They will turn this in on
Friday, unless this lesson has to carry over to the next day. The song is worth 10 points 4
points for at least two facts, 4 points for the facts being in chronological order, and 2 points
for creativity.
Accommodations for English Learners, Striving Readers and Students with Special Needs
Two students in my class, one who is a SSN student and one who is an EL and SNN student,
will need more individualized help during the writing process. Both are strategically seated
next to students that have proven to be good support for these students. The teacher,
however, should also walk around and help both of these students with the brainstorming
process.
Having the whole class write the song with the teacher will give these students great ideas
to help them write their own stanzas after class. The teacher should, however, offer these
students time during lunch or ISP to come in and get more help from the teacher in terms
with the writing process. Both students are very smart, but they will need extra support.
The teacher should also tell the special education teachers about the assignment and what
you expect so that they can work on this assignment with them during their study hall as
well.
Resources (Books, Websites, Handouts, Materials)
-
Sultan
Urban
Textile
Social Mobility
Souk
Letter of Credit
Taxonomy levels. As the teacher is lecturing, the teacher should also walk around to make
sure students are engaged with the guided notes and the vocabulary sheet. If students are
struggling varying adjustments will need to be made.
Summative: Evaluation of students guided notes that include answers to the various
questions, analyses of some of the sources, and their favorite snowball will help the
teacher determine if the objectives and goals of the lesson were met. It will also help the
teacher determine if students had difficulties in some topic areas and if the lesson and
lecture was successful or not. If the snowball activity is not done, the exit slip will also
serve as a summative assessment.
Accommodations for English Learners, Striving Readers and Students with Special Needs
The vocabulary sheet where the basic definitions are already given and students are
required to add descriptions to the definitions and create pictures that represent individual
words and guided notes provide a scaffold to aid ELL students and students with
disabilities. Depending on the severity, the guided notes may have to be filled out more to
allow this student to focus on just one of the sheets, the vocabulary sheet. The guided notes
will be very similar to the PowerPoint and a multitude of pictures will be shown as well.
Questions span from knowledge/comprehension to Synthesis/Evaluation in order to allow
advanced students to go deeper into the content as well.
Resources (Books, Websites, Handouts, Materials)
- Hart, Diane (2006). Medieval and Early Modern Times: Teachers Edition. Boston,
Massachusetts: Pearson Education Inc. (CH 3.3 and 4.1)
- The DBQ Project: Why did Islam Spread so Quickly?
- Google Images
- PowerPoint Presentation and guided notes
- Paper
- Pen/pencil
Hijra
Medina (previously named Yathrib)
Sunni
Shiites
Content Delivery (Method of Instruction) Time: 5 min
The teacher will instruct students to work with their partner to create their comic strip
using toondoo.com. This comic strip needs to depict a scene from Muhammads life or from
the origins of the Islamic religion. The teacher will also remind students that, due to
cultural respect, they cannot represent Muhammad as a person or object. He can only be
represented by a common shape in order to not be disrespectful to the Islamic religion that
prohibits the visual characterization of Muhammad or the use of icons. The teacher should
walk around and help students print the comic strips when they are done.
Student Engagement (Critical Thinking & Student Activities) Time: 40-45 min
Students will work with their partners to create their comic strip that must have 3 or more
slides. Students will create this comic strip using a website where students can create
unique comic strips called Toondoo.com. This was a website I found on a teaching
strategies website where teachers post various lessons and different tools to use in the
classroom. In the comic strip students will need to create at least 3 slides, use at least two
characters, have at least one dialogue/thought bubble, one quote, and make the story
legible, easy to understand, and creative.
Lesson Closure Time: 5-7 min
The lesson closure for this computer lab day will be to have students contribute to a 5
minute discussion. The teacher will ask students what they thought about toondoo.com and
about making their own comics what did they like? Dislike?
Assessments (Formative & Summative)
Entry-Level: The teacher will ask various questions about toondoo.com to determine if students
remember how to use the program. If students are having a difficult time recalling this information,
than the teacher will have to re-teach how to use the program.
Progress-monitoring: The teacher should walk around while student pairs are working on their
comics. Redirecting and support should be given when needed, whether it has to do with the
toondoo.com program or the content as a whole. It is important to make sure students are being
respectful of the topic as well.
Formal Summative: Students will be given 30 points for the comic. The guidelines and points will be
outlined in the rubric. When the teacher is observing students in the computer lab, the teacher
should be marking up students who are not working with their partner. This will be shown in their
participation portion of the grade. Students will also be asked to reflect on this technology and
discuss what the positive and negative characteristics of this type of technology. It has been proven
that adding a reflection element in lessons promotes a positive environment, encourages critical
thinking, and makes students feel responsible for their education.
Accommodations for English Learners, Striving Readers and Students with Special Needs
Students will work with a partner on the comic strip. This will help students to be able to
communicate with their partner, share their ideas, and mold these ideas together. The
actual creation of a comic strip will also help students visualize the content in addition to
summarizing the important parts. After all the comics are done, they will be put together on
a PowerPoint for students to reference to as well. This will also allow creative and
advanced students to be pushed.
Resources (Books, Websites, Handouts, Materials)
-
Paper
Guided notes worksheet
Comic rubric
Computers
Hart, Diane (2006). Medieval and Early Modern Times: Teachers Edition. Boston, Massachusetts:
Pearson Education Inc. (Ch 3.1)
- www.toondoo.com
b. Support claim(s) with logical reasoning and relevant, accurate data and evidence that
demonstrate an understanding of the topic or text, using credible sources.
c. Use words, phrases, and clauses to create cohesion and clarify the relationships among
claim(s), counterclaims, reasons, and evidence.
d. Establish and maintain a formal style.
e. Provide a concluding statement or section that follows from and supports the argument
presented.
CCSS.ELA-Literacy in History. WHST. 6-8. 5: With some guidance and support from peers
and adults, develop and strengthen writing as needed by planning, revising, editing,
rewriting, or trying a new approach, focusing on how well purpose and audience have been
addressed.
CCSS.ELA-Literacy in History. WHST. 6-8. 7: Conduct short research projects to answer a
question (including a self-generated question), drawing on several sources and generating
additional related, focused questions that allow for multiple avenues of exploration.
CCSS.ELA-Literacy in History. WHST. 6-8. 9: Draw evidence from informational texts to
support analysis reflection, and research.
Lesson Introduction (Anticipatory Set/Hook/Accessing Prior Knowledge) Time: 7-10
min
Students will get with their class partners to brainstorm 2 reasons for why we should study
the Byzantines. The class will share their 2 reasons and the teacher will write these
answers on the board. Students will then be given about 3 extra minutes to pick their top 3
reasons for their partner paragraphs.
Vocabulary (Content Language Development) Time: n/a
Students have been working with this vocabulary since the first day working with this DBQ.
After 5 days, students should have full knowledge of these terms.
Imperial Capital
Constantinople
Hagia Sophia
Justinian
Crusaders
Content Delivery (Method of Instruction) Time:7 min
The teacher will review the Answer-Cite-Explain (ACE) format that the class has been using
all quarter. The teacher will then review how this format can fit into a paragraph format for
them to use with their partners:
Answer topic sentence/thesis
Cite concrete material/fact
Explain argument/expansion
Cite concrete material/fact
Explain argument/expansion
Cite concrete material/fact
Explain argument/expansion
Answer (Conclusion) rewrite thesis
This format/color codes lines up with the format the English teacher uses making it easier
for students to write well in both classes. The teacher will explain how the 3 reasons the
students chose will be the source for each of their Cite-Explain components of their
paragraph. The class will then be taken to the computer lab to write their partner
paragraphs on the Byzantine Empire. Students will be encouraged to explain why
historians, especially the writers of their textbook, have downplayed the Byzantine
Empires influence in history.
Student Engagement (Critical Thinking & Student Activities) Time: 35-40 min
Students will work with a partner to write an 8-sentence paragraph about why we should
study the Byzantine Empire and why it has not received the recognition it deserves in their
textbook specifically. Students will use the format provided above and their 5 documents
about various accomplishments and characteristics of the Byzantine Empire from the DBQ
to write the paragraph with their partner.
Lesson Closure Time: 7-10 min
Students will first talk with their partner and another partner group about why they think
historians and especially their textbooks have not emphasized the Byzantine Empire in
history. The teacher will then bring the class back together to have a whole-class
discussion. If the class does not seem to be drawing the conclusion that the winners write
history and since the Western World, which is more affiliated with Rome and Greece, has
dominated the World since the Age of Expansion that this has affected what aspects of
history have received more attention throughout the years, than the teacher will need to
ask guided questions to get the students to this conclusion. While students are constantly
asked to evaluate their textbooks as a source with a bias and perspective, this lesson
focuses more on this skill because it calls historians into question concerning basic public
knowledge of the Byzantine Empire vs. the Roman Empire and why there is an off-balance.
Assessments (Formative & Summative)
Entry Level:
Having students brainstorm ideas for their paragraphs will demonstrate to the teacher that
the class will be able to write successfully on this topic. If the class is not able to brainstorm
many ideas as a class, than re-teaching will need to occur in order for the teacher to feel
confident about their ability to write successfully on the topic.
Progress Monitoring:
While partners are working on their paragraphs, the teacher will walk around the
computer lab to make sure that students are successfully working through their materials
and paragraphs. The teacher will stop whenever needed at various students
desks/computers to provide further support or advice.
Summative:
The paper will be graded out of 30 points. The teacher will follow the rubric that was
passed out to students before starting the paragraph. In this rubric, organization and
highlighting is where most of the points are given since they have not written a formal
paragraph yet and need more practice in writing sentences that demonstrate higher levels
of critical thinking successfully.
Additionally, the teacher will determine from student response whether the class made the
connection between history written by the winners and the lack of popular knowledge on
the Byzantine Empire. This will demonstrate a higher level of critical thinking and the
knowledge that cultural perspectives of people and historians influence how we view and
study history.
Accommodations for English Learners, Striving Readers and Students with Special Needs
With the population of students I have, the only other modification that will be needed is
more time. I have two students in my class who have an IEP and they have a resource class
together where they get one-on-one support from a teacher or aid. These students will be
asked to outline their paragraph using bullet points together so that they can then write
their paragraphs over the span of a week in their resource classroom with the additional
support. Both of their IEPs require more time, but it would be impractical to do this if they
had an average student as their partner who does not get the same time modification this
is why these two students will work together. With these modifications, the students
should be successful with this assignment.
Resources (Books, Websites, Handouts, Materials)
-
Class computers
Paper
Highlighters
DBQ documents
CCSS.ELA-Literacy in History. WHST. 6-8. 4: Produce clear and coherent writing in which
the development, organization, and style are appropriate to task, purpose, and audience.
CCSS.ELA-Literacy in History. WHST. 6-8. 9: Draw evidence from informational texts to
support analysis reflection, and research.
Lesson Introduction (Anticipatory Set/Hook/Accessing Prior Knowledge) Time: 7 min
Students will be asked to make a Chicken Foot individually at their desks. A Chicken
Foot looks something like this:
1) Fact/Support from Doc
Thesis Argument
Using this diagram, students will write a simplified form of their thesis. They will need to
make an opinion and find/write three facts to support their claim.
Vocabulary (Content Language Development) Time: n/a
The class will have already defined and analyzed these definitions before this lesson.
- Conquistadors
- Pre-conquest
- Tribute
- Chinampas
- Deities
- Huitzilopochtli
- Agriculture
- Sacrifice
Content Delivery (Method of Instruction) Time: 10 min (total)
During this lesson the teacher is meant to be a facilitator. The teacher will instruct students
to write their names on the 2 chips that were passed out to each student and then to go to
one of two sides of the room that represent either agricultural achievements or human
sacrifice. The two sides will then have about 5-7 minutes to plan a strategy. The teacher
will remind students to also figure out what counter-arguments the other side may use in
order to better strategize; this requires students to use both analytical and critical thinking
skills in preparing for the debate.
After the groups have had an opportunity to collaborate, the teacher will bring the class
back to discuss the rules. The teacher will first do this by asking the class what the various
rules are and what they should be focusing on during this debate, such as things we
struggled with during the previous debate. This is important in order to allow students to
reflect on their own abilities to analyze historical documents and arguments. The teacher
will fill in any missing rules or goals that were not addressed after about 3 minutes. The
teacher will also stop the debate after 15 minutes to notify the class that if they would like
to switch sides, this is the time to do so and that the debate is now open meaning students
can move sides throughout the debate.
Student Engagement (Critical Thinking & Student Activities) Time: 40 min
Students will participate with their team during the debate to construct and argue a valid
argument about what historians should focus on when studying the Aztec society
agricultural achievements or human sacrifice rituals. Students will need to draw upon their
6 documents and the analyses they have made about these documents in correlation to the
overarching question. Each student can only speak twice making it so that students have to
work as a team and support their teammates in creating arguments. Students will also need
to listen to the opposing side and create counter-arguments based off of these arguments.
Lesson Closure Time: 5 min
Students will need to write 4 bullet points in the form of an exit slip. Students will need to
write down 2 things that they did individually, or as a class, well and 2 things that they or
the class need to work on for the next debate. This happens at the end of every debate in
order for students to reflect on their abilities concerning this academic skill because I
believe personal reflection is one of the best, if not the best, to grow as an academic.
Assessments (Formative & Summative)
Entry-Level:
While students create their own individual Chicken Foot, the teacher will walk around
and observe the students writing. The teacher needs to be looking for not only completion,
but logical pieces of evidence in the toes of the Chicken Foot in order to feel confident in
the classs ability to participate in the debate. If students are struggling, then some reteaching or re-directing will be necessary. This will also provide an opportunity for the
teacher to help struggling students.
Progress Monitoring:
During the teams strategizing time, the teacher will walk around and observe the students
discussions. The teacher should be looking for their ability to think analytically about not
only the documents, but about how historians should approach writing history. The
teacher should chime in when necessary to guide students to more complex thinking and
encourage teamwork as well.
Summative:
The actual debate will be the class summative assessment. While not all students will have
participated, they will have participated as a team to provide and support arguments.
Depending on the arguments and counter-arguments made, I will be able to determine if
students were able to critically and analytically think about the content and the debate
question that pertains to a repeated historical controversial argument.
The exit slips will also allow the students to demonstrate their knowledge of their own
skills in terms of debating, which requires analytical thinking.
Accommodations for English Learners, Striving Readers and Students with Special Needs
Considering my own population, the only thing that may need to be modified is the Chicken
Foot. I still want it to be an individual activity because it needs to represent their individual
opinion, but I would not make them directly quote or cite a fact from the document. I would
instead have them state an observation from a Document and then write which document
it came from so that students in their team can help them during the collaboration segment
of the lesson. Most of this lesson has students working as a team and not all students are
required to participate in the debate portion, making any shy students more comfortable to
participate behind-the-scenes.
Resources (Books, Websites, Handouts, Materials)
-
Pencil/pen
Documents
Chicken Foot worksheet
what they see on the map. After the 2 minutes, students will be asked to get with their
shoulder partner to predict how people may have lived or how the environment might
have affected Arabs during this time. The teacher will randomly select three to five
students by the use of cards to see what the student and their partner came up with.
Vocabulary (Content Language Development) Time:
These terms will be further explained and expanded on during the think-aloud and outline
of the section A Tribal Culture.
Rub al-Khali
Oasis
Nomadic
Sedentary
Bedouins
Content Delivery (Method of Instruction) Time:
The teacher will instruct students to follow along as the teacher reads the text. The teacher
will stop after each paragraph to think-aloud about the material presented and right down
notes. The teacher needs to make sure to stop and highlight the vocabulary words.
Towards the end of the A Tribal Culture the teacher should ask the students what they
think is important from each paragraph. This should take anywhere from 7-10 minutes.
The purpose of this is to demonstrate to students how to extract important information
from a text and record this information in a quick, efficient manner. The teacher will also
take this time to describe why and where nomadic and sedentary tribes settled and
traveled based on the discussions from the introduction activity on the map of the Arabian
Peninsula.
Next the teacher will pass out a sheet of paper with two exerts: one highlights the positive
characteristics of nomadic tribes and the other highlights some of the negative
characteristics.
Leave time at the end of class to introduce the timeline project and hand out the rubric.
This timeline project will require students to identify 8 important dates involving the
expansion of Islam throughout the Middle East, Asia, Europe, and Africa. Student will
further need to explain why each date is important in a creative way of their choice. This
project is due November, 19.
Student Engagement (Critical Thinking & Student Activities) Time:
Students will work with their shoulder partners again to read, determine if it is a pro or
anti nomadic culture argument, annotate the document, and record important points made.
The teacher will give the students a maximum of 10 minutes to do this with their partners.
After this partner work, students will meet with a group that did the other exert and teach
each exert to each other. Students should record what they learn about the other exert on
their foldable. The teacher should set a timer so that each group gets 5 minutes to talk
about their excerpt and for the other two students to record the information.
Lesson Closure Time:
Students will do a quick write about whether they would like the nomadic lifestyle or not.
They will need to use at least one fact that they learned from this lesson.
Assessments (Formative & Summative)
Entry Level:
During the Lesson Introduction, the teacher will assess if students can recall their prior
knowledge on how environment impacts its inhabitants and how. This will be important
because the teacher will need to explain why the two primary ways of life were nomadic
and sedentary and why the people settle in specific places. This will take much more time if
students do not understand this initial connection. Taking notes on the text will also
demonstrate how well students are able to take effective notes. The teacher should try and
ask students what they think should be written down to get a better idea of where they are
at in their note-taking abilities.
Progress Monitoring:
While students work with their partners to analyze, annotate, and record notes on their
assigned exert, the teacher should be walking around to make sure the students are
identifying the exert accurately as a pro or con argument and if they are recording efficient
notes. The teacher should also monitor how students are teaching their assigned exerts to
each other and that the students are recording appropriate notes from their peers.
Summative:
The summative assessment will be the quick write paragraph. This will demonstrate
individual knowledge of the material and the ability to use various sources in their
argument. Format should be in paragraph form, but it is the ideas that are of most
importance.
Accommodations for English Learners, Striving Readers and Students with Special Needs
Having the teacher complete the notes in a read-aloud/think-aloud format for the English
learners, striving readers, and students with special needs will allow them to follow along.
This will provide a framework for how students should approach analyzing a text and
taking notes on the same text. Student will then work with partners to go through the same
process of analyzing a shorter text and taking notes. Students who are English learners,
struggling readers, or have special needs will be strategically partnered with a proficient
English speaker that is relatively more advanced than them. Students will then work in
slightly bigger groups of four to share ideas. This group work will help students who are
struggling and need accommodations because they will be able to listen to their peers and
discuss their ideas in a smaller, less intimidating, environment.
Lastly, during the quick write, students will be able to use their notes. Depending on the
proficiency level of the English Learner and the severity of the special need of a student, it
may be necessary for the student to use bullet points instead of a paragraph form or for a
list of sentence starters to be given to the student. These modifications will depend on the
student.
Resources (Books, Websites, Handouts, Materials)
Hart, Diane (2006). Medieval and Early Modern Times: Teachers Edition. Boston,
Massachusetts: Pearson Education Inc.
(Ch 3.1)
Students will need to define these vocabulary terms in their sections. Students will, however,
have already done a gallery walk with vocabulary posters that included these terms in a previous
lesson.
Citizenship
Corruption
Attila
Autonomous
Clovis
Content Delivery (Method of Instruction) Time: 10 min
The teacher will briefly introduce the section on the fall of Rome and the graphic organizer. The
teacher will then have the students split off into 7 groups for each of the factors for the fall of
Rome. The teacher will instruct students to complete their section in their graphic organizers.
Students will need to highlight any of the vocabulary words in their section and be ready to
define them. They will have 10 minutes to do this. The groups will then present their sections to
the class. The teacher will instruct the class to record what student groups present.
The teacher will then discuss some of the big reasons for why Rome fell in more depth and
different historians' perspectives on the fall of Rome throughout history that were not included in
their textbook. The teacher will further explain how the rise and fall of empires throughout
history is a theme and that there is never one reason that leads to the fall of an Empire. Each rise
and fall, however, does have unique factors that must be understood in order to understand the
time period and culture of the Empire.
Student Engagement (Critical Thinking & Student Activities) Time: 40 min
Students will work with their group to fill out their section of the graphic organizer. Groups will
then present their section to the class. When other groups are presenting, the students will record
their information down on their graphic organizer. Finally students will actively listen to the
teachers small 5 minute lecture on historians perspectives on the fall of Rome (and other
Empires) throughout history.
Lesson Closure Time: 7 min
Exit Slip: Which factor do you think was the most influential to Romes collapse?
Why is this important to know in terms of studying future Empires and societies?
Assessments (Formative & Summative)
Progress monitoring: the teacher will walk around the room to the various groups to make
sure students are working well together, staying on task, and drawing the important
information from the text. The teacher should also do this while students take notes on the
other groups presentations.
Informal Summative:
- Students will be graded according to participation during the presentation since this is
the students first presentation. This presentation, however, will inform the teacher how
students work together, their competency in the content, and their strengths and
weaknesses in terms of presenting.
- The exit slip will allow the teacher to determine if students were able to master the
content using this type of lesson or not. It will also demonstrate their ability to argue their
point.
Accommodations for English Learners, Striving Readers and Students with Special Needs
Based on my current EL and SNN population the accommodations inserted into the lesson
will allow these students to be successful. The two accommodations are the graphic
organizer, which will visibly display the content in a way that is easier to understand, and
the small group work/presentation. Having these students work in a small group will
hopefully give them more opportunities to participate and experiment with their language
usage and vocabulary. Additionally, these students would not be comfortable presenting
independently and may become nervous to participate in class as a result. Presenting with
a group, however, will give them the opportunity to participate in a safe environment and
make them more comfortable to present in the future.
Resources (Books, Websites, Handouts, Materials)
-
Hart, Diane (2006). Medieval and Early Modern Times: Teachers Edition. Boston,
Massachusetts: Pearson Education Inc. (CH 1.3)
Jenga Game
Constitutional Convention
Founding Fathers
Plantation owners
Enslaved African Americans
Bankers
Farmers
Workers
Runaway slaves
in kind
Debtors
Bonds
Students will then listen to the teacher as I read the resolutions out loud. After reading one
the teacher will ask groups to raise their hand if they agree or not. If a majority does not
agree, than the class will debate the terms of the resolution until a majority vote is reached.
Students will raise their hands to voice their opinions and not interrupt other students
when speaking.
Lesson Closure Time: 7 min
The teacher will then pose the question why do you think our Constitution is different
from the U.S. Constitution? They will have 3 minutes to discuss with the person next to
them and then they will need to write about it with the remaining class time and turn it in
to the teacher before leaving.
Assessments (Formative & Summative)
Entry Level:
Having students pick the burning issue that affects their group the most and writing an exit
slip about it will demonstrate that students understand the mindset of their
character/perspective and are correctly able to identify what this group cared about during
the formation of the U.S. Constitution. Having the groups create their own Resolutions will
prove that the students have understood their roles.
Progress Monitoring:
As the students work around the room as travelers or negotiators, the teacher will walk
around and observe students making deals and alliances with each other. The teacher will
be particularly observant as to whether students are staying in character and keeping the
discussion academic. If students are not struggling to make deals, then the activity is not
working. Students need to walk away from this activity understanding how difficult it was
for people at this time to reach conclusions that everyone agreed with.
Summative:
While the character and burning issues worksheets with questions were done the previous
day, they will be collected during this period. I did not want to collect them the day before
because I wanted them to be resources for the students to use during this days activities.
These worksheets, however, will demonstrate that each individual student understood
their character/perspective and were able to think like them when answering questions
about the burning issues of the U.S. Constitution.
The class Constitution will demonstrate 2 things: (1) that students were able to think like
their character and accurately personify their perspective and (2) were able to have an
academic discussion, critically think about these issues, and compromise to reach various
conclusions. Students will understand the struggles that the Founding Fathers faced while
creating the Constitution through this activity and how the U.S. Constitution had to mold
various perspectives into something constructive.
The exit slip, however, will push students to understand that not everyone was represented
in the U.S. Constitution and how, if our population was included, the U.S. Constitution
would be very different. The exit slip will have students critically think about why various
perspectives were not included, why, and what this meant for the United States and its new
government.
Accommodations for English Learners, Striving Readers and Students with Special Needs
With the student population I have, nothing more than further explanation will be needed
because all of the activities involve group work. If the class is not having a whole class
discussion, students are walking around with a partner to various other groups or are
working with their small group to complete various activities. The only independent
activity is the exit slip. I had students write using complete sentences, but if I had more
severe students I would allow them to use bullet points and/or explain their ideas to me
independently. Students should not have any problems understanding their characters
perspective after having the previous day dedicated to this task. Depending on student
population, however, it may be necessary to offer a shorter character description or a
translated copy in their native language. For my population, however, this was not needed.
Resources (Books, Websites, Handouts, Materials)
Zinn Education Project Constitutional Role Play worksheets and character descriptions
Post-its
Overhead projector camera
Poster
Markers
Students will know about the various Muslim scholars and the imperative contributions
Muslims people made in philosophy, medicine, science/math, geography/history,
art/architecture, and calligraphy/literature (stories, folk tales, and poetry). Students will
describe and reflect on several scholars and analyze the contributions made by Muslim
people by writing on a foldable, presenting their material to the class, and listening to other
students present, while taking notes on their material on their foldable. Students will refer
back to prior knowledge on Muslim trade and analyze how philosophies, ideas, and
inventions traveled as well through a discussion. Students will also apply this knowledge
about Muslim scholars and their contributions through a discussion about how these
contributions have impacted the modern world today.
California State Content Standards
7.2 Students analyze the geographic, political, economic, religious, and social structures of
the civilizations of Islam in the Middle Ages.
6. Understand the intellectual exchanges among Muslim scholars of Eurasia and
Africa and the contributions Muslim scholars made to later civilizations in the areas of
science, geography, mathematics, philosophy, medicine, art, and literature
Common Core Literacy Standards
CCSS.ELA-Literacy in History. WHST. 6-8. 1c: Use words, phrases, and clauses to create
cohesion and clarify the relationships among claim(s), counterclaims, reasons, and
evidence.
CCSS.ELA-Literacy in History. WHST. 6-8. 2d: Use precise language and domain-specific
vocabulary to inform about or explain the topic.
CCSS.ELA-Literacy in History. WHST. 6-8. 4: Produce clear and coherent writing in which
the development, organization, and style are appropriate to task, purpose, and audience.
CCSS.ELA-Literacy in History. READ. 6-8. 4: Determine the meaning of words and phrases
as they are used in a text, including vocabulary specific to domains related to history/social
studies.
CCSS.ELA-Literacy in History. READ. 6-8. 5: Describe how a text presents information (e.g.,
sequentially, comparatively, causally).
Lesson Introduction (Anticipatory Set/Hook/Accessing Prior Knowledge) Time: 5-7 min
Day 1: The teacher will need to assess prior knowledge on the new trade routes that were
developed with Muslim expansion throughout Europe, Asia, and Africa. The teacher needs
to ask where these trade routes were, who Muslim civilizations traded with and what was
traded. After asking these questions and redirecting students to correct answers (and reteaching if necessary) the teacher will ask: what else do you think traveled through these
trade routes besides goods? Allow students about 10 seconds to think about these
questions and then call on students to share ideas using name cards. If a student says ideas,
inventions, philosophies, etc. than expand on that. If students do not get to one of these
answers in 3-5 minutes, the teacher may need to call on volunteers or will need to ask more
guided-questions in order for the students to reach this conclusion. It is imperative that
students realize that ideas, inventions, and philosophies traveled through these routes
before moving on with the lesson.
Day 2: The teacher needs to ask the class to come up with a list of 7-10 things that they
learned yesterday. They also need to come up with at least two reasons for why it is
important that we learned these things.
Day 1: Students should talk to their group about anything they found in their section that
they did not know or that surprised them. The teacher should walk around to facilitate
these small group discussions.
Day 2: Students will participate in a whole class discussion on these two questions: How
did Muslim scholars contribute to the medieval world? and How have these contributions
affected the modern world today? The teachers should tell the students that we want to
get three answers from each category before the bell rings.
Assessments (Formative & Summative)
Entry Level Assessment (Formative):
This assessment will occur during the Lesson introduction when the teacher asks questions
about trade routes developed after and during Muslim expansion. If the students are quick
and correct with their answers, the teacher can feel confident about moving on with the
lesson. If students struggle with the questions and have a hard time grasping the concept
that ideas and inventions can travel through these trade routes than re-teaching will be
needed.
Progress Monitoring (Formative):
This will be happening throughout the entire class time, for the most part. When the
teacher asks questions during the pre-read, it will be to make sure that students
understand the organization of the text and predict about the content based on the
headings, pictures, and vocabulary discussed by the teacher.
This assessment will also occur when the students are in groups. When the students are
working, the teacher will need to walk around to make sure everyone is participating and
understanding the content. This observation will also need to occur when student groups
are presenting and the rest of the class is taking notes. The teacher will need to walk
around to make sure that students are taking notes and filling out their foldables correctly
as their classmates present their information.
Lastly, the teacher will use this form of assessment when listening to the groups. If the
groups are stating good facts, than the teacher knows the students understood the content.
If the teacher has to interject a lot to extend on a fact presented, than the teacher knows
that the content was not understood by most students in the group.
Summative Assessment:
There will be two summative assessments. The foldable itself will be collected and graded.
It will be worth 30 points (5 points for each section). It will be graded mainly on
completion since the teacher will have already heard all the facts and seen all the
vocabulary terms and pictures. Students will need to turn this in before leaving the
classroom.
The second summative assessment will occur during the lesson closure when the class
answers the two questions: How did Muslim scholars contribute to the medieval world?
and How have these contributions affected the modern world today? If the class can
answer these questions effectively as a group, than that means that the class is able to
apply their knowledge from the lesson to not only a broad question looking at the entire
medieval world, but also to the modern world they live in now. Application is one of the
best ways to prove mastery of content.
Accommodations for English Learners, Striving Readers and Students with Special Needs
The foldable in of itself is an accommodation for English learners, striving readers, and
students with special needs. It allows for students to organize the information from the
textbook in a simpler, more visually appealing way. Additionally, working and presenting
with groups will allow these students to learn the content in a less stressful environment,
while also participating in a community using conversational and academic English
vocabulary. This will also allow advanced students the opportunity to teach and lead
skills that are very useful and will keep these students active in the lesson. Also, going
through the section slowly before students have to read, will allow students to gain
background knowledge on the content before exploring it on their own. The pictures
students will have to create will also provide a visual aid for E.L. students, struggling
readers, and students with special needs. It may be necessary, however, to copy a version
of the other sections of the foldable for the students to use so that they can concentrate on
the presentation. This will be necessary for students who have a hard time taking notes
that are not more guided. Lastly, integrating the content into the world today will make the
content more interesting and appealing to these students.
Resources (Books, Websites, Handouts, Materials)
- Colored paper
- Colored pencils
- Pencils
- Overhead projector camera
- Hart, Diane (2006). Medieval and Early Modern Times: Teachers Edition. Boston,
Massachusetts: Pearson Education Inc. (Ch 4.4)
partners. The teacher should show a correct version of the map on the overhead projector
to allow students to fix their maps if needed.
Vocabulary (Content Language Development) Time: n/a
Most students should know about these terms, but they will be defined in the beginning of
the lesson and used constantly throughout the entire lesson.
Cause
Effect
Consequence
Political Cartoon
Content Delivery (Method of Instruction) Time: 15 (total)
The class will then flip the paper over to the Reasons for the fall of the Roman Empire
Matrix. The teacher will put a political cartoon up on the overhead projector from the
1980s-90s. The class will have a whole-class discussion (the teacher can choose to have
some of the cartoons discussed in small groups first) on the problem revealed in the
political cartoon. I will then further explain the cartoon and guide students to make
connections between the issues in the cartoon and issues Rome faced this should be done
both in whole-class discussions and in small groups.
Students will then be asked to individually rate from 1-10 the issue brought up in the
political cartoon in terms of importance for each of the 3 categories: the Roman Empire,
80s-90s US, and US today. The purpose is for students to connect the issues that the United
States faced and is facing now with the problems that lead to the fall of Rome in order for
them to see the continuity of themes throughout history.
Student Engagement (Critical Thinking & Student Activities) Time: 30 min (total)
Students will then participate in small group and whole class discussions to examine
various political cartoons from the 1980s-1990s and compare the issues presented in these
cartoons to issues that the Roman Empire faced and that the US faces today. As they work
through each cartoon with the class, they will record their information in a matrix, which
requires them to do a rough sketch of the cartoon, an explanation of it, and the
corresponding ratings.
Lesson Closure Time: 5-7 min
The class will first participate in small group discussions concerning the following
question: What does this mean for the United States? The teacher will then ask an
individual from each group to share something interesting their group came up with that
was not already discussed.
Assessments (Formative & Summative)
Entry-level: the fast map will serve as a review for students. They will need to go back in
their book and draw information from the video clip, which was a review, and draw a map
of the Roman Empire that explains how it fell. This will allow the teacher to determine if
more review is needed before moving on to an activity that requires higher order of
thinking.
Progress monitoring: As the class works through the political cartoons and the matrix
together, the teacher will be able to determine if students are able to achieve higher order
thinking about the Roman Empire through student responses. The teacher should use these
responses to determine how much they should guide students to discover certain
connections and when to let them think out-loud and reach these conclusions in small
groups because some relationships may be harder to grasp.
Informal Summative:
- At the end of the class, the students will turn in their matrix. It will be graded based on
completion since the class will be doing it together. The teacher will read the answers
students did with a partner in more detail to make sure there were no major issues
- The final discussion on the question what does this mean for America? will determine
if students were able to make a connection between the struggles of the Roman Empire
and the current and past struggles the US faces.
Accommodations for English Learners, Striving Readers and Students with Special Needs
While students are working on the map independently, the teacher should walk over to
both students to read the directions with them and physically describe what they should
do. The teacher should go to the appropriate pages in the book that will help them to
complete the map the best. Having these students then get help from a partner and then
from the whole class will allow them to mold and change their map accordingly.
Students will then work through the political cartoons with the whole class, as well as with
small groups in order for them to watch and listen to the process of examining a political
cartoon and giving additional meaning to it. It will also allow these students to pick up new
vocabulary words as the class works to find the similarities and differences between the
challenges the Roman Empire faced as well as the US.
These students will need no further assistance to fill out the matrix based on their
academic levels.
Resources (Books, Websites, Handouts, Materials)
-
Pagan
Kaba
Islam
Quran
Ramadan
Mecca
Medina
Content Delivery (Method of Instruction) Time: 15 min
The teacher will go through Doc B (verses from the Quran) with the class together using
the overhead projector. Out of the first three documents (which were designed for a 7th
grade history class), this is the most complicated so it will be important for the teacher to
walk the class through this document. After the class has closely read the document,
students will attempt the questions individually. The class will then go over the questions
as a whole-class discussion.
The class will then be split up so that half the class will be working on Doc A (Arabian
Peninsula trade map) and the other half will work on Doc C (the spread of Islam map).
Students will work with partners to complete their Document. The class, as a whole, will
then go over the documents and their corresponding questions. Students who were
responsible for their particular document will need to participate more to help the other
half of the class.
Student Engagement (Critical Thinking & Student Activities) Time: 30-35 min
Students will read and annotate Doc B with the whole class and the answer the pertaining
questions on their own. Students will then participate in the discussion answering/going
over the questions for Doc B as a class.
Students will then work with their partners to critically read and answer the questions
pertaining to their selected document. The class will then come back together to go over
and discuss the answers to Doc A and C.
Lesson Closure Time: 5 min
The class will then refer back to the categories made on the board and have a small
discussion about where the three documents belong within these categories.
Assessments (Formative & Summative)
Entry Level: As the students create bigger categories to place their ideas about the answers
to the question How did Islam spread so quickly? the teacher will be able to determine if
the class has enough background knowledge to tackle the DBQ.
Progress Monitoring:
- As the teacher is reading through Document B, the teacher will ask various guided
questions about the document to check for understanding about the Islamic World and its
quick expansion. The teacher will then walk around as the class works on the questions
pertaining to document B to provide extra help or support when needed.
- When the class comes back together to work on the questions from document B or
discuss the questions from the other two documents, the teacher will determine if the
class has mastered the material based on student response.
- After students are divided up, the teacher will walk around and observe the partners
working together on their individual documents and questions.
Summative:
- Students will turn in these documents and their pertaining questions. Based on their
responses and annotations, the teacher will be able to determine if the class mastered the
content of these documents and the process of critically reading/ annotating.
- Having the students use the documents and place them in one of the various categories
will determine if students are able to use the documents in a higher level of thinking
manner.
Accommodations for English Learners, Striving Readers and Students with Special Needs
Going through the most difficult document as a class will not only allow this document to
not be a speed-bump for my EL and SSN students, but it will also demonstrate, again, how
to properly annotate and close read a document. While I want students to try and tack the
questions by themselves, it should be much easier after I have gone through the document
and with me walking around and observing. Additionally, having the student work with
pairs and with the whole class to tackle the other two documents should be enough
support for my EL and SSN students.
Resources (Books, Websites, Handouts, Materials)
-
Documents A, B, and C from the DBQ: How did Islam spread so quickly?
Pencil
Highlighter
Overhead projector camera
value of building a just and moral society or that women could sue for divorce. The
purpose of this is to show how our perception of Muslim life and the values of Islam have
been molded by some extremist groups and that this re-shaped Islam is what they tend to
see in American media. The purpose of these discussions is to understand that there are
many people who follow Islam and that our stereotypes are damaging to those people who
are not part of the extremists groups.
Student Engagement (Critical Thinking & Student Activities) Time: 15-20 min (total)
Students will participate in writing the guided outline and participate in the reading and
small discussions that coincide with the guided outline and Muslim Daily Life Quiz taken at
the beginning of class. Additionally, when the teacher asks the students to outline a section
independently, the students should do so.
Lesson Closure Time: 7 min
Students will do a quick write and point out one thing that they liked about Muslim lifestyle
and one thing they did not like. They need to describe why they like/dislike these aspects.
They should be encouraged to think about how these various lifestyle practices are similar
and different to their own and to what they thought Muslim lifestyle was like before this
class.
Assessments (Formative & Summative)
Entry Level: Students will take a survey quiz in order for the students and the teacher to
get an idea about what the class knows about Islamic culture and their lifestyles. This will
allow the teacher to determine where in the lesson students will need more in depth
instruction.
Progress monitoring: As the class goes through the process of writing the guided outline
and participating in small discussions, the teacher will be able to determine through
observation and student responses if the students understand the material and are able to
reflect on their own preconceptions and stereotypes coming into this lesson. The teacher
will need to slow down or stop when appropriate to allow for re-teaching moments or
further expansion.
Summative: This quick write will allow me to determine if the class mastered the material
and were able to use higher levels of thinking by comparing the material with their
personal lives and pre-existing opinions. This will also allow me to determine if their
writing has improved and where more practice and support is needed.
Accommodations for English Learners, Striving Readers and Students with Special Needs
Using the survey will, hopefully, get all of the students excited and interested in the
material. It will also give them a good amount of background knowledge about the material
before the class begins working on the guided outline. Doing the outline together will allow
my EL and SSN students to be more successful because they will have support from their
whole class. I will also allow for students to work through various sections with a partner
or individually so that they can practice outlining and extracting important information in
various environments. Finally, the informal quick write will hopefully allow my EL and SSN
students to write more because they will not be preoccupied with format. This will be a
great way to extract content information and analyze their grammatical issues.
Additionally, depending on the student, the teacher should allow various student to write
their quick write using bullet points if needed.
Resources (Books, Websites, Handouts, Materials)
- Hart, Diane (2006). Medieval and Early Modern Times: Teachers Edition. Boston,
Massachusetts: Pearson Education Inc. (Ch 4.2)
- Overhead projector
- Paper
- Pencils/pens
Islam - Quran(vs)Sunnah
Goals & Objectives
Students will understand the differences and similarities between the Quran and the Sunnah and
their significance in Islam culture and civilizations. Students will analyze primary documents
that contain quotes from each source and create a graphic organizer for each document.
California State Content Standards
7.2 Students analyze the geographic, political, economic, religious, and social structures of the
civilizations of Islam in the Middle Ages.
3. Explain the significance of the Qur'an and the Sunnah as the primary sources of
Islamic beliefs, practice, and law, and their influence in Muslims' daily life.
Common Core Literacy Standards
CCSS.ELA-Literacy.RH.6-8.1 Cite specific textual evidence to support analysis of primary and
secondary sources.
CCSS.ELA-Literacy.RH.6-8.2 Determine the central ideas or information of a primary or
secondary source; provide an accurate summary of the source distinct from prior knowledge or
opinions.
CCSS.ELA-Literacy.RH.6-8.4 Determine the meaning of words and phrases as they are used in a
text, including vocabulary specific to domains related to history/social studies.
CCSS.ELA-Literacy.RH.6-8.5 Describe how a text presents information (e.g., sequentially,
comparatively, causally).
CCSS.ELA-Literacy.WHST.6-8.2a Introduce a topic clearly, previewing what is to follow;
organize ideas, concepts, and information into broader categories as appropriate to achieving
purpose; include formatting (e.g., headings), graphics (e.g., charts, tables), and multimedia when
useful to aiding comprehension.
CCSS.ELA-Literacy.WHST.6-8.2b Develop the topic with relevant, well-chosen facts,
definitions, concrete details, quotations, or other information and examples.
CCSS.ELA-Literacy.WHST.6-8.2d Use precise language and domain-specific vocabulary to
inform about or explain the topic.
CCSS.ELA-Literacy.WHST.6-8.2e Establish and maintain a formal style and objective tone.
CCSS.ELA-Literacy.WHST.6-8.2f Provide a concluding statement or section that follows from
and supports the information or explanation presented.
Lesson Introduction (Anticipatory Set/Hook/Accessing Prior Knowledge) Time: 5
Students will be asked to pick a word from the word wall that students created in class the day
before using the vocabulary words for this lesson. Each student will create a sentence using the
selected word in their journals. The teacher will walk around the class to make sure students are
writing and staying on task. After 3 minutes (that should be measured by a timer), the teacher
will select random students to share their sentences using name cards of Dojo.
*These words on the word wall have the definition and a picture on them.
Vocabulary (Content Language Development) Time: n/a
During the lesson the day before, students will have worked together and individually to create
more vocabulary words for the word wall (sometimes the teacher does the words on the word
wall and sometimes students do a word at home on their own for homework). The instructional
method varies depending on the words for the section. Each word has the definition below and
an illustration.
Quran
Mosque
Alms
Fasting
Pilgrimage (Hajj)
Sunnah/Hadith
Ablution
Deity
Salat
Zakat
Ramadan
Content Delivery (Method of Instruction) Time: 10 min
The teacher will provide a short 5-7 minute lecture using a Venn diagram to show some
similarities and differences between the Quran and the Sunnah. Students will have a blank Venn
diagram drawn in their notebooks to fill out as the teacher talks about these two religious texts.
The teacher needs to stop to ask students about various aspects of the Quran and Sunnah that
may surprise the students based on their stereotypes and preconceptions of Islam as seen in
American media.
Next, the teacher will pass out the four documents and assign each student one document. The
teacher will need to go back over the poster in the classroom that demonstrates how to analyze a
primary text.
BEFORE THE FIRST READ
What is/are the:
- Source
- Author
- Audience
- Date
- Context
- Reason
READ ONCE (1)
- Highlight vocabulary words
- Circle unknown words/phrases and find them
READ AGAIN (2)
- Highlight key ideas
- Write short sentence summarizing each section
The teacher needs to instruct students to do the second read and its activities with their reading
partner. Finally the teacher will instruct the class to divide into four groups based on their
documents 5 Pillars (Quran), afterlife beliefs (Quran), Jihad (Sunnah), and remaining sinless
(Sunnah) to create a graphic organizer on a poster using the document they analyzed. All
people with document one should be in the same group and so on.
Student Engagement (Critical Thinking & Student Activities) Time: 35 min
While the teacher is giving the short lecture (5-7 min), students will take notes on a Venn
diagram in their notebooks. Next, students will follow the primary analysis process that students
have learned to do with every primary source (this process is on a poster on the wall). During the
second read, students will read and do the activities for the second read with a partner.
Students will then go into one of the four groups, depending on the primary source they have. In
these groups they will create a poster with their peers on their primary source from either the
Quran or the Sunnah. On this poster, students need to create a graphic organizer that
demonstrates how they think the text is structured.
Each group will present their posters to the class. While each group is presenting, the class
should quickly draw the graphic organizer used on the back of that primary source to use while
writing their own three paragraph essay.
At the end of the class after each poster has been presented, the class will participate in a
discussion about the differences between the Quran and the Sunnah in terms of their
messages/teachings and how Muslims use the 2 documents. The teacher will then ask the
following question half way through the debate: how do you think the content and purpose of
these two documents influences Muslims today? Does it bring people together, cause
translation issues, or both?
Lesson Closure Time: 5-7 min
Students will be asked to first talk to a partner about something they learned or gained insight on
from the analysis of the Quran and the Sunnah. Students will then write down their insight and
reflect on their partners insight as well on an exit slip.
Assessments (Formative & Summative)
Entry Level Assessment:
While students write a sentence using a vocabulary word from the word wall, the teacher
will walk around to make sure students are using the vocabulary words correctly. If there is a
student struggling, the teacher needs to stop and guide them through the activity of creating a
sentence with the word. The teacher will also call on students randomly to make sure that
students are able to use these words, demonstrating understanding and application of the content
from the previous day needed for this lesson. If most of the students are struggling it is
imperative that the teacher pauses the lesson and goes back over these vocabulary words.
Progress Monitoring Assessment:
While students are working on their primary source, independently and with their reading
partner, the teacher will walk around the classroom and observe. If students are struggling with
the analysis process, guided help will be necessary. If students are struggling with reading the
document, it may be necessary for them to do the entire activity with a partner. The teacher
needs to offer guided help/support as needed.
The teacher also needs to be observing and providing extra support when needed while
students are creating their posters/graphic organizers in their groups. When students are
presenting in their groups the teacher will need to make sure that each group clearly understood
their assigned documents. Additionally, the teacher needs to be walking around the classroom to
make sure that students are drawing other students graphic organizers on the back of the other
primary sources. If students do not write this down, it will be very hard for students to write their
essays.
Summative Assessment:
The summative assessment to measure whether students understand the significance of
these religious texts and how they are similar and different, in addition to their ability to analyze
primary sources and use them in a discussion. It will also demonstrate students abilities to relate
what they have learned to current event situations between Muslim groups around the world as
well as reflect on their own stereotypes and judgments that they might have made before coming
to class. It will also reflect on the current class environment and if these students are able to have
a mature academic discussion on an issue that it slightly more sensitive than others because it
does deal with Islam as a religion and the misconceptions that Americans may have about these
religious texts because of extremist groups.
Accommodations for English Learners, Striving Readers and Students with Special Needs
Poster/Word Wall:
A poster outlining the steps for how to analyze a primary document will be posted on the wall for
students who are English Learners, striving readers, and have special needs to refer to.
Additionally a word wall will be available on the wall containing all the vocabulary words they
need to analyze the documents. These references are critical for these students to do well and are
valuable tools.
Dictionaries/phones:
Depending on school policy, students may use phones to look up words/phrases that are
confusing to them. Depending on the school, IPads may also be used. If these are not available or
allowed, dictionaries should be available for students to use to look up anything they do not
know.
Partners:
Students will work with a partner when doing the second read through where they have to
summarize the meaning of each section and highlight key words or phrases in the primary
source. Having a partner during this process will help to guarantee that these students understand
the document because they are able to listen to what their peer says about the document. It will
also give a student who is an English learner, striving reader, or who has special needs the ability
to talk about what they are thinking, receive feedback, and build upon that. Students will then
work with a group in creating a graphic organizer, allowing for these students to listen to even
more of their peers discuss the primary source and analyze it. This will allow these students to
discuss and learn how to analyze the document in a less stressful environment. They will also be
given the opportunity to help present if they feel comfortable, but either way they will be part of
the community presenting.
Nothing, however, replaces teacher intervention, guided help, and scaffolding. The teacher
should be constantly observing students and addressing any issues that arrive with the material
immediately.
Resources (Books, Websites, Handouts, Materials)
-
Hart, Diane (2006). Medieval and Early Modern Times: Teachers Edition. Boston,
Massachusetts: Pearson Education Inc. (Ch 3.2)
Posters
Notebooks
Markers
Overhead camera (if not available you can demonstrate the Venn diagram in other ways)
Quran.com
Sunnah.com
Shays Rebellion
Articles of Confederation
Anarchy
Remedy
Pardon
Pacify
Manure
Why would the idea of poor farmers rebelling be scary to many of the
people at the Constitutional Convention?
Do students agree with Jeffersons assertion about the tree of liberty?
How does this letter challenge or expand the textbooks account?
Why might many textbooks make it seem like everyone wanted a strong
central government after Shays Rebellion?
Student Engagement (Critical Thinking & Student Activities) Time: 30-35 min
Students will actively participate in the close-read and annotation of the text excerpt as
well as listen and follow along with the teacher as I review the content of their textbook.
Students will need to highlight and annotate along with the teacher by watching and
observing how the teacher handles the text using the overhead projector camera.
Students will then work independently and with a partner to tackle the close-read and
annotation process of the letter written by Thomas Jefferson, which reveals that Thomas
Jefferson did not think that the Articles of Confederation needed to be changed. Students
will first read the text independently following the normal class procedure of circling
anything confusing and highlighting anything important. Students will then go through the
document line by line with their partner making notes and making additional sections
highlighted according to importance.
Students will then participate in going through the 5 questions in the worksheet and
writing down their answers after working through the questions first with the whole class
or a partner. Finally, students will contribute to the whole class, formal discussion about
the various documents and the idea of having a strong central government. This discussion
will focus on the three primary different perspectives of Shays Rebellion and its impact
throughout the United States and its role in the dismissal of the Articles of Confederation
and the formation of the U.S. Constitution. It will also discuss the idea that not everyone
hated the Articles of Confederation, which their textbook does allude to.
Lesson Closure Time: 5 min
Students will chose one of the discussion questions to write about in the form of an exit slip
on the back of their worksheet. Students will be asked to write as much as they can in the 5
minutes they have to write.
Assessments (Formative & Summative)
Entry Level:
Reviewing the Shays Rebellion content from their textbook and going through the closeread/annotation process while asking guided questions will allow the teacher to make sure
that students understand the content as well as this academic process of reading historical
sources. The teacher will evaluate students knowledge of the content, 2 perspectives
represented in the 2 texts, and the close-read/annotation skill through student responses
to the guided questions. If students are struggling with understanding the differences and
similarities of the 2 texts or with the reading process, than the teacher will need to slow
down the lesson, modify, and re-teach in order for the class to move forward.
Progress Monitoring:
While students work through Thomas Jeffersons letter independently and with a partner,
the teacher will walk around and observe. This letter shows a very different perspective on
Shays Rebellion and the Articles of Confederation that may show most students. Since it is
such a different perspective, it will be important for the teacher to stop at various groups to
check for understanding using questions and to add extra support or help for students who
are struggling.
Additionally, going through the worksheet questions that focus primarily on Jeffersons
perspective will allow the teacher to determine if the class can move forward to critically
thinking about 3 different perspectives because if they do not understand Jeffersons after
working through it independently and with their peers, than re-teaching will be needed.
The last question also asks students to describe how Thomas Jeffersons perspective is
different from the textbooks. If class struggles a lot with this question, then the discussion
will not be possible without re-teaching.
Summative:
The class discussion will demonstrate to the teacher, based on student responses, that
students understand the differences and similarities of their descriptions of Shays
Rebellion and its role in U.S. history. Students will also extend their thinking to discuss the
characteristics of a central government and the problems and benefits that come with this
type of government. Students will also need to use these three perspectives to try and think
like people during this time to understand why some people liked and disliked the Articles
of Confederation after Shays Rebellion.
The ext slip will hold each individual student accountable by having them chose one of the
6 discussion questions and write their opinions of it. Students will expand on the class
discussion and solidify their ideas about what these documents meant to them in terms of
understanding Shays Rebellion, the multiple perspectives at the time, and how this
affected the U.S. government.
Accommodations for English Learners, Striving Readers and Students with Special Needs
Working with the more complex and longer document first with the whole class and the
teacher will hopefully allow students to be more successful working with the smaller text
from Thomas Jefferson independently and with a partner. This shorter text also has more
defined words at the bottom allowing for more support. If the student cannot read this text
independently, the teacher may have to read it with the student, have students read the
entire passage together, or provide an audio recording or translated version of the text. My
current student population does not need these modifications and should be able to work
through this document with the current modification incorporated into the lesson, but if
they are struggling I will need to modify. Additionally, I have a very vocal class that does
very well with discussion, but in other classes it may be better to divide the class into
groups and have these groups work through only one of the discussion questions and then
share their thoughts with the class after having worked through it as a group. Lastly, I will
allow some students to write using bullet points if they struggle writing fast using complete
sentences.
Resources (Books, Websites, Handouts, Materials)
-
Meet-and-greet worksheet
Pen/pencil