Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
1LFRODL &RSHUQLFL
Zabytkoznawstwo i Konserwatorstwo XLIII, Toru 2012
- 3UIIHU 0X]HXP 3U]\URGQLF]H 8QLZHUV\WHWX 6WHIDQD %DWRUHJR Z :LOQLH :LOQR >QDG
ELWND ] $OPD 0DWHU 9LOQHQVLV QU @
0=QDPLHURZVND3UIIHURZD0X]HXP(WQRJUDF]QH8QLZHUV\WHWX6WHIDQD%DWRUHJRZ :LO
QLH L MHJR SU]\V]R /ZyZ:LOQR >QDGELWND ] .ZDUWDOQLN (WQRJUDF]Q\ /XG
6HUMD W @ : 2OV]HZVNL =DRHQLD 0X]HXP (WQRJUDF]QHJR SU]\ 8QLZHUV\WHFLH 6WHIDQD %D
WRUHJR L LFK UR]ZLQLFLH Z SUDFDFK 0DULL =QDPLHURZVNLHM3UIIHURZHM >Z@ 3U]\V]R HWQRORJLL SROVNLHM
Z MHM WHUDQLHMV]RFL UHG = -DVLHZLF] 7 .DUZLFND 3R]QD V
: +RXERZLF] 3L ODW SUDF\ WHUHQRZHM 0X]HXP $UFKHRORJLF]QHJR 8QLZHUV\WHWX 6WHIDQD %DWR
UHJR Z :LOQLH 5RF]QLN $UFKHRORJLF]Q\ W V
: +RXERZLF] 0XPMH HJLSVNLH Z :LOQLH :LOQR
452
M B-T, S M
G]F\FK]HZV]\VWNLFK]DPLHV]NDQ\FKNRQW\QHQWyZ:UyGGDUyZ]QDOD]D
VLVSXFL]QDDUW\VW\F]QDSRPLHV]NDMF\PZ /RQG\QLH$OHNVDQGU]H:HUQH
U]HREHMPXMFDEOLVNRRVLHPVHWMHJRSUDFRUD]NROHNFMDOLF]FDRELHNW\
$OHNVDQGHU :HUQHU U]HELDU] PDODU] JUDN L SHGDJRJ
XURG]RQ\ Z URG]LQLH R DUW\VW\F]Q\FK NRU]HQLDFK VLJDMF\FK ;9,, ZLHNX
]ZL]DQ\ E\ Z PRGRFL ] 7RUXQLHP /HJLRQRZHP L /ZRZHP 3R Z\EX
FKX ,, ZRMQ\ ZLDWRZHM ]RVWD GHSRUWRZDQ\ Z JE =ZL]NX 5DG]LHFNLH
JR L RVDG]RQ\ Z RER]LH SUDF\ : URNX SR XPRZLH 6LNRUVNL0DMVNL
GRVWD VL GR 3ROVNLHM $UPLL QD %OLVNLP :VFKRG]LH SRG GRZyG]WZHP JH
QHUDD :DG\VDZD $QGHUVD :UD] ] ,, .RUSXVHP SU]HE\ NUDMH %OLVNLHJR
:VFKRGXL (JLSWVNGQDVWSQLHWUDGR:RFKJG]LHZDOF]\SRG0RQWH
&DVVLQR: URNXSRGMVWXGLDPDODUVNLHZ XWZRU]RQHMSU]H]SURIHVR
UD 0DULDQD 6]\V]NR%RKXV]D 6HNFML $UW\VWyZ L 6WXGHQWyZ 6]WXN 3LNQ\FK
RQLHU]\ ,, .RUSXVX .RPSDQLL .UHVRZHM QD $NDGHPLL 6]WXN 3LNQ\FK
Z 5]\PLH : URNX Z\MHFKD GR :LHONLHM %U\WDQLL Z NWyUHM SR]RVWD
D GR PLHUFL 6WXGLRZD JUDN Z 6LU -RKQ &DVV 6FKRRO RI $UW Z /RQ
G\QLHD QDVWSQLHSUDFRZDZ &DPEHUZHOO6FKRRORI $UWVDQG&UDIWV%\
:WRUXVNLP0X]HXP8QLZHUV\WHFNLPSU]\MWRQRZDWRUVNQDJUXQFLHSROVNLPNRQ
FHSFM ZHGOH NWyUHM MHVW MHGQRVWN MHGQRURGQ EH] SRG]LDX QD G]LD\ ] MHGQ\P LQZHQWD
U]HP VWD\P RUD] LQZHQWDU]HP GHSR]\WyZ 3R]ZDOD WR QD V]\ENLH ZSLVDQLH RELHNWyZ GR
HZLGHQFMLL DWZH]DU]G]DQLH]ELRUDPL,QWHQV\ZQ\QDS\ZRELHNWyZSRZRGXMHHQLHOLF]
QD NDGUD PHU\WRU\F]QD QLH MHVW Z VWDQLH QD ELHFR RSUDFRZ\ZD ]ELRUyZ 6WG Z\EUDQH
PX]HDOLD V SU]HND]\ZDQH GR V]F]HJyRZ\FK EDGD Z UDPDFK SUDF GRNWRUVNLFK L PDJL
VWHUVNLFK 3RGREQLH E\R ] NROHNFM $ :HUQHUD NWyUHM F] RSUDFRZDD 3DQL 0DJRU]DWD
%DND7KHLV3RU0 %DND7KHLV$IU\NDVNDNROHNFMD$OHNVDQGUD:HUQHUD] 0X]HXP8QLZHUV\
WHFNLHJRZ 7RUXQLX3U]\F]\QHNGREDGDQDGIRUPL IXQNFMV]WXNLDIU\NDVNLHMZ NRQWHNFLH]ELRUyZ
PX]HDOQ\FKSUDFDPDJLVWHUVNDSRNLHUXQNLHPSURI- 0DOLQRZVNLHJR,QVW\WXW=DE\WNR]QDZ
VWZD L .RQVHUZDWRUVWZD :\G]LD 6]WXN 3LNQ\FK 8QLZHUV\WHW 0LNRDMD .RSHUQLND Z 7R
UXQLX 7RUX
6 0DMRFK 7U]\ WRQ\ G]LH V]WXNL *RV 8F]HOQL QU V LGHP )DVF\QXMFD
NROHNFMD 'ZDM RNVIRUG]F\ QDXNRZF\ Z WRUXVNLP 0X]HXP 8QLZHUV\WHFNLP *RV 8F]HOQL
QU V
$0 %RUNRZVNL =DVRQ\ L F]HOXFLH $OHNVDQGUD :HUQHUD 7\G]LH 3ROVNL ;
QU V >SU]HGUXNZ6]WXNDSROVNDZ :LHONLHM%U\WDQLLZ ODWDFK$QWRORJLDZ\
EUDSU]\JRWRZDGRGUXNXL ZVWSHPRSDWU]\0$6XSUXQLXN7RUXV @
0% 7RSROVND :HUQHU $OHNVDQGHU >Z@ (QF\NORSHGLD SROVNLHM HPLJUDFML L 3RORQLL UHG . 'RSLH
UDD W 6 7RUX V - : 6LHQNLHZLF] $UW\VWD SLNQD L QLH W\ONR Z V]NR
]DNOWHJR $OHNVDQGHU :HUQHU $UFKLZXP (PLJUDFML ] V
453
454
M B-T, S M
U]HED LEHML OXGX -RUXED ] 1LJHULL LO GZLH ODONL DNXDED OXGX $V]DQWL
] *KDQ\ LO PDVND NDSHOXV]RZD FKLZDUD OXGX %DPDQD ] 0DOL LO
PLQLDWXURZDPDVNDVW\OLVW\F]QLH]EOLRQDGRU]HE\OXGX%DXOH] :\EU]HD
.RFL6RQLRZHMLOLSRGJyZHNOXGX.DPEDWWD](WLRSLLLO.ROHN
FMU]HELDUVNX]XSHQLDMRELHNW\FRG]LHQQHJRX\WNXGZLHGZXF]FLRZH
PDORZDQHW\NZ\OXGX7XUNDQD] .HQLLLSLQDF]\FHUDPLF]Q\FKSRZVWD
\FK Z SyQRFQHM F]FL $IU\NL
1LH]QDP\SRFKRG]HQLD]ELRUXFKRGREU\VWDQ]DFKRZDQLDMDNL SUR
IHVMRQDOQD SRGVWDZD GR NWyUHM SU]\WZLHUG]RQR U]HE ] NRFL VRQLRZHM
PRJ VXJHURZD Z SU]\SDGNX U]HE ]DNXS\ DQW\NZDU\F]QH /RQG\Q
SR GUXJLHM ZRMQLH ZLDWRZHM QDOHD GR QDMZDQLHMV]\FK RURGNyZ DQW\
NZDU\F]Q\FK L FHQWUyZ REURWX G]LHDPL SRFKRG]F\PL ] $IU\NL :UyG
DQW\NZDULDWyZ RIHUXMF\FK DUWHIDNW\ SR]DHXURSHMVNLH ]QDOD]D VL &HQWDXU
*DOOHU\SURZDG]RQDSU]H]'LQDKL -DQD:LHOLF]NyZZ NWyUHMPRQDE\
R ]QDOH ZV]\VWNR RG REUD]X F]VWR GREUHJR GR PDVNL PXU]\VNLHM
R NWyUHM ZDFLFLHO GDZD ]DZV]H XF]FLZH LQIRUPDFMH F]\ MHVW SUDZG]L
ZD F]\ WH SRGURELRQD 5]HE\ DIU\NDVNLH JURPDG]L WDNH Z /RQG\
QLH 0DWHXV] *UDERZVNL SURZDG]F\ *UDERZVNL *DOOHU\ Z NWyUHM :HUQHU
ZLHORNURWQLH Z\VWDZLD VZRMH SUDFH
1DF]\QLD ]RVWD ]DNXSLRQH SRGF]DV SRGUy\ :HUQHUD GR 3yQRFQHM
$IU\NL *HQH]D SR]RVWD\FK RELHNWyZ PRH E\ RSDUWD MHG\QLH QD DQDOL]LH
IRUP\ L SRUyZQDQLDFK ] DQDORJLF]Q\PL SUDFDPL
1DMFLHNDZV]\P RELHNWHP NROHNFML MHVW VWDWXHWND ] NRFL VRQLRZHM
SU]HGVWDZLDMFDXU]GQLNDGZRU]DQLQDZ VW\OX.UyOHVWZD%HQLQXQULQZ
087.:LO0LHU]FDQLHFRSRQDG FPZ\VJXUNDZ\NRQD
QD ]RVWDD SU]\ X\FLX RVWU\FK QDU]G]L NWyU\FK ODG RGQDOH PRQD QD
MHM SRZLHU]FKQL L QLH ]RVWDD XNRF]RQD
:LHOH DUWHIDNWyZ ] %HQLQX WUDR GR (XURS\ ]D VSUDZ EU\W\MVNLHM
DQHNVMLNUyOHVWZDZ UZ F]DVLHNWyUHMRJUDELRQRSDDFZDGF\ RE\
D WDNH ]D SRUHGQLFWZHP SRGUyQLNyZ L PDUV]DQGyZ G]LDDMF\FK QD SR
- : 6LHQNLHZLF] 3ROVNLH JDOHULH V]WXNL Z /RQG\QLH Z GUXJLHM SRRZLH ;; ZLHNX /XEOLQ
/RQG\Q V
0%RKXV]6]\V]NR:LHOLF]NRL MHJR&HQWDXU*DOOHU\7\G]LH3ROVNLQU V
- : 6LHQNLHZLF] RS FLW IRW
455
456
M B-T, S M
ZLDQD E\D WDNH ]H VNDU\NDFMDPL Z SRVWDFL GXJLHM SURVWHM OLQLL ELHJQFHM
SU]H] URGHN EU]XFKD 3R]D FKDUDNWHU\VW\F]QD GOD SRUWUHWyZ ZDGFyZ ]QD
QDMHVWWDNH] NUyOHZVNLFKU]HEPRVLQ\FK%HQLQXL ,IH2 Z\VRNLPVWD
WXVLHVSRHF]Q\PSU]HGVWDZLRQHMSRVWDFLZLDGF]\SDVWNDQLQ\SU]HZLHV]RQ\
SU]H] UDPLRQD L WU]\PDQ\ Z GRQLDFK SU]H]QDF]RQHM Z NXOWXU]H .UyOHVWZD
%HQLQX Z\F]QLH GOD PF]\]Q SR LQLFMDFML D WDNH QDV]\MQLNL 2GLJED
R]GREQD RSDVND ZRNy JRZ\ L SDV\ NRUDOL QD QLHXNRF]RQ\FK QRJDFK
1D SRGVWDZLH DQDOL]\ IRUPDOQHM L SRUyZQDZF]HM ]DR\ PRQD L
U]HED SRZVWDD Z ;9,,, Z :VND]XMH QD WR VSRVyE NV]WDWRZDQLD SDU
WLL ZRVyZ FKDUDNWHU\VW\F]Q\ GOD WHJR RNUHVX PDMF\ RGQLHVLHQLH WDNH
Z U]HELH EU]RZHM 1LH XOHJD ZWSOLZRFL L FHFK\ VW\OLVW\F]QH IRUP\
XWUZDORQ\ NDQRQ SU]HGVWDZLDQLD SRVWDFL WDN EOLVNR ]ZL]DQ\FK ]H VRE
ZDUV]WDWyZ G]LDDMF\FK QD MHGQ\P GZRU]H SU]HQLND\ VL D ]DWHP SHZ
QHFHFK\VW\OLVW\F]QHPRJ\E\VWRVRZDQHZ W\PVDP\PF]DVLH]DUyZQR
Z SHQRSODVW\F]Q\FK U]HEDFK PRVLQ\FK MDN L GUREQHM SODVW\FH ] NRFL
VRQLRZHM F]\ GUHZQD 6SRVyE NV]WDWRZDQLD SDUWLL EU]XFKD SRVWDFL GZR
U]DQLQD FKDUDNWHU\VW\F]Q\ MHVW ]DUyZQR GOD U]HE ] ;9,, MDN L ;9,,, Z
:UyG HNVSRQDWyZ QD EHUOLVNLHM Z\VWDZLH %HQLQ .LQJV DQG 5LWXDOV &RXUW
$UWV IURP 1LJHULD ] U ]QDOD]\ VL VWDWXHWNL ] NRFL VRQLRZHM L OLF]QH
U]HE\PRVLQHGDWRZDQHQDZLHN;9,,,R DQDORJLF]QLHXNV]WDWRZDQ\FK
SDUWLDFK ZRVyZ RF]X EU]XFKD V]DW ELXWHULL 'DWRZDQLH W\FK RELHNWyZ
RSLHUDR VL QD EDGDQLDFK PDWHULDRZ\FK
. &XUQRZ 3UHVWLJH V
)RUP\ MDNLH Z\NRU]\VW\ZDQH E\\ SU]H] ZDUV]WDW RGOHZQLNyZ L U]HELDU]\ SU]HQLND
\ ] MHGQHJR ZDUV]WDWX GR GUXJLHJR ' ,QQHK 7KH *XLOGV :RUNLQJ IRU WKH 3DODFH >LQ@ %HQLQ
.LQJV DQG 5LWXDOV RS FLW V
%%ODFNPXQ:KRDUHWKH)LJXUHVLQ%HQLQ$UW"7UDQVODWLRQVIURP,YRU\WR%URQ]H>LQ@%HQLQ
.LQJV DQG 5LWXDOV RS FLW V %DGDF]ND ]ZUyFLD XZDJ L Z]RU\ ] NyZ VRQLRZ\FK
L U]HE ] NRFL SU]HQLND\ GR G]LH RGOHZQLF]\FK WZRU]RQ\FK SU]H] ZDUV]WDW ,JEHVDQPZDQ
. &XUQRZ RS FLW V $QDORJLF]Q\ VSRVyE NV]WDWRZDQLD EU]XFKD E\ UyZQLH
FKDUDNWHU\VW\F]Q\ GOD U]HE ] ,IH NWyUH RGG]LD\ZDR QD U]HPLHOQLNyZ ] %HQLQX $)&
5\GHU$ 5HFRQVLGHUDWLRQRI WKH,IH%HQLQ5HODWLRQVKLS7KH-RXUQDORI $IULFDQ+LVWRU\
9RO 1R V 5HODFMH DUW\VW\F]QH SRPLG]\ W\PL GZRPD RURGNDPL LVWQLD\ MX
RG RNRR ;;, Z ' ,QQHK RS FLW V
: DUW\NXOH 3 -XQJHD SU]HGVWDZLRQH ]RVWD\ PHWRG\ GDWRZDQLD JyZ PRVLQ\FK
SRFKRG]F\FK ] RWDU]\ SU]RGNyZ ] NROHNFML (WKQRORJLVFKHV 0XVHXP Z %HUOLQLH ]RE
3 -XQJH $JH 'HWHUPLQDWLRQ RI &RPPHPRUDWLYH +HDGV 7KH ([DPSOH RI WKH %HUOLQ &ROOHFWLRQ >LQ@
457
458
M B-T, S M
VFHQFMHSRUWXJDOVNLHQDWRPLDVWVWDWXHWNDDPHU\NDVNDSU]HGVWDZLRQD]RVWD
D Z WUDG\F\MQ\P VWURMX -HVW RQD GDWRZDQD QD RNUHV RG ;9 GR ;9, Z
:LHONR U]HE\ L MHM FKDUDNWHU\VW\F]QH FLFLH RGVSRGX PRH ZLDG
F]\ L MHVW WR IUDJPHQW ZLNV]HJR SU]HGPLRWX :JELHQLH RG VSRGX
L SU]HEDUZLHQLDNRFLX Z\ORWXVXJHUXMLU]HEDVWDQRZLDSLHUZRWQLHU
NRMHV]W\OHWXQRDOXESU]HGPLRWXNXOWRZHJR7RUXVNDVWDWXHWND] NRFL
VRQLRZHM Z\PDJD ZFL MHV]F]H GDOV]\FK DQDOL] D WDNH EDGD PDWHULDR
Z\FK NWyUH SR]ZROL\E\ QD GRNDGQH XVWDOHQLH MHM SRFKRG]HQLD RUD] F]D
VX SRZVWDQLD
:NROHNFML$OHNVDQGUD:HUQHUD]QDMGXMHVLUyZQLHNLONDU]HEGUHZ
QLDQ\FK ] SLHUZV]HM SRRZ\ ;; Z -HGQ ] QLFK MHVW JXUD HVNLHJR EOL
QLDNDLEHMLQU LQZ087.:LOOXGX-RUXED] 1LJHULL0LHU]\
FP Z\VRNRFL L Z\NRQDQD ]RVWDD Z PLNNLP GUHZQLH R F]HUZRQDZ\P
NRORU\FLH SUDZGRSRGREQLH LURNR : ]DJELHQLDFK ]QDMGXM VL ODG\ SR
SURV]NXGU]HZQ\PNWyU\PQDFLHUDQRODOND ZSDUWLLIU\]XU\ LQG\JR-HVW
WR W\SRZ\ SU]\NDG IRUP\ NDQRQX U]HELDUVNLHJR ] WHJR UHJLRQX $IU\NL
: .UyOHVWZLH -RUXEyZ NXOW EOLQLW LEHML UR]ZLQ VL Z SRRZLH
;9,,, Z VSRZRGRZDQ\ GX PLHUWHOQRFL ZUyG QLHPRZOW RUD] MHG
Q\P] QDMZ\V]\FKQDZLHFLHZVNDQLNyZQDURG]LQEOLQLDF]\FK.DQRQ
LEHMLQDU]XFDWZyUFRPFLOHRNUHORQIRUPQDU]XFRQWDNHSU]H]LFK
IXQNFM X\WNRZ GODWHJR WH ODONL ] UyQ\FK UHJLRQyZ ]DPLHV]NLZDQ\FK
,ELGHP
336 1\ODQGHU 7KH )UHTXHQF\ RI 7ZLQQLQJ D 5XUDO &RPPXQLW\ ,Q :HVWHUQ $IULFD $QQX
DO RI +XPDQ *HQHWLFV 9RO V
.DGDODONDPLHU]\RN FPZ\VRNRFLFKDUDNWHU\]XMHVLSURSRUFMMHMPR
GHOXQHNMHVWVFKHPDW\F]Q\L ZDOFRZDW\3U]HGVWDZLRQHZ ]DZV]HZ SR]\FMLVWRMFHMZ UR]
NURNX R QLHSURSRUFMRQDOQLH NUyWNLFK QRJDFK L UNDFK EH] Z\UDQLH ]D]QDF]RQ\FK NRODQ
L RNFL ] XZ\GDWQLRQ\PL FHFKDPL SFLRZ\PL SRVWDFL V VWDW\F]QH ,FK FHFK FKDUDNWHU\
VW\F]QVUFHXRRQHXNRZDWRZ]GXFLDDFKDUDNWHU\VW\F]QHZ\VRNLHIU\]XU\XZ\GDW
QLRQHJRZ\]HVFKHPDW\F]QLHSRWUDNWRZDQ\PLWZDU]DPLR XZ\GDWQLRQ\FKRF]DFKXVWDFK
L QRVDFK] GX\PLRGVWDMF\PLXV]DPLZ NWyU\FKF]VWR]DPLHV]DQRR]GRE\=RE0 %D
ND7KHLV 5]HE\ EOLQLW LEHGL )RUPD L VW\O Z\EUDQ\FK UHJLRQyZ .UyOHVWZD -RUXED 1LJHULD >Z@
.XOWXU\ $IU\NL : ZLHFLH WUDG\FML SU]HPLDQ L ]QDF]H _ &XOWXUHV RI $IULFD ,Q WKH ZRUOG RI WUDGL
WLRQV FKDQJHV DQG PHDQLQJV W ,9 UHG $ 1DGROVND6W\F]\VND 7RUX V
,EHML QLH W\ONR VWDZLDQR QD GRPRZ\FK RWDU]\NDFK DOH WDNH QRV]RQR Z FKXFLH QD
EU]XFKX WDN VDPR MDN \ZH G]LHFL ,ELGHP
459
460
M B-T, S M
SU]H] -RUXEyZ UyQL VL PLHG]\ VRE MHG\QLH GHWDOHP IU\]XU\ PRGHOXQ
NLHP WZDU]\ XNV]WDWRZDQLHP NRF]\Q VWURMHP ,VWQLHMH NLONDG]LHVLW UH
JLRQDOQ\FK RGPLDQ W\FK U]HE
3RFKRG]FD SUDZGRSRGREQLH ] PLDVWD 2JERPRVR MHGQHJR ] JyZ
Q\FK RURGNyZ U]HELDUVNLFK SURZLQFML 2MR U]HED ] NROHNFML :HUQHUD
RGSRZLDGDIRUPRPVWRVRZDQ\PZ W\PUHJLRQLH3U]HPDZLDM]DW\PVND
U\NDFMH WZDU]\ FR Z SU]\SDGNX ODOHN ] SLHUZV]HM SRRZ\ ;; Z PR
H PLH EH]SRUHGQLH RGQLHVLHQLH GR PLHMVFD SRFKRG]HQLD : SXEOLNDFML
,EHML 7KH &XOW RI <RUXED 7ZLQV ]DPLHV]F]RQR IRWRJUD ] U Z\NRQD
QZ PLHFLH2JERPRVRZ 2MRSU]HGVWDZLDMFNRELHWWU]\PDMFZ GR
QLDFK GZLH DQDORJLF]QH JXUNL EOLQLW LEHML
3R]D OHNNLPL SU]HWDUFLDPL L XE\WNLHP Z SDUWLL QRVD LEHML ] 7RUXQLD
MHVW GREU]H ]DFKRZDQD : ]DJELHQLDFK UHOLHIX IU\]XU\ ZLGRF]QH V SR
]RVWDRFL SR LQG\JR D Z SDUWLL UN GRQL VWyS L Z SDFKZLQDFK SURV]
NX GU]HZQHJR NWyU\P QDFLHUDQR NXOWRZH VWDWXHWNL FR ZLDGF]\ PRH
R W\P L E\D RQD X\WNRZDQD L MHVW DXWHQW\F]Q JXUN NXOWRZ 'RGDW
NRZRZ XV]DFKSU]HZLHUFRQRRWZRU\Z NWyU\FKXPLHMVFRZLRQHE\\R]GR
E\ R F]\P ZLDGF] OHNNLH SU]HWDUFLD
: NROHNFML XQLZHUV\WHFNLHM ]QDOD]\ VL WDNH GZLH ODONL DNXDED OXGX
$V]DQWL ] *KDQ\ GDWRZDQH QD ;; Z .RELHW\ Z FHOX ]DSHZQLHQLD VRELH
SRGQRFL VSRNRMQHJR SRURGX L ]GURZLD GOD VZRLFK SU]\V]\FK SRWRP
NyZQRVL\ODONLSU]\WURF]RQHGRSOHFyZSRGSRZLDGDMFZ WHQVSRVyEEy
VWZRP L FKFLDE\ XURG]L SLNQH G]LHFNR
3RG]LDUHJLRQDOQ\QLHMHVWWRVDP\]HZVSyF]HVQ\PSRG]LDHPDGPLQLVWUDF\MQ\P1L
JHULL OHF] ] SRG]LDHP UHJLRQDOQ\P .UyOHVWZD -RUXED 0RQD ZUyG QLFK Z\UyQL PLQ
VW\OHUHJLRQX2MR,MHEX(IRQ(NLWL,JERPLQD:\UyQLRQRSRQDGLFKW\SyZ)3R
OR- 'DYLG&DWDORJXHRI WKH,EHML9ROV9RO=ULFKVV9RO=ULFK
VV
6 -RKQVRQ 7KH KLVWRU\ RI WKH <RUXEDV /DJRV V V
- 3HPEHUWRQ ,,, (UH ,EHML $Q $IUPDWLRQ RI /LIH LQ WKH )DFH RI 'HDWK >LQ@ * &KHP
HFKH ,EHML 7KH &XOW RI <RUXED 7ZLQV 0LODQ V
=RE 0 %DND7KHLV /DOHF]NDFyUHF]ND ODONL SRGQRFL $NXDED OXGX $V]DQWL *KDQD
L LQVSLUDFMH >Z@ &LDR V\PEROLF]QH &LDR PHG\F]QH &LDR HVWHW\F]QH 0DWHULD\ ] .RQIHUHQFML 1D
XNRZHM ]RUJDQL]RZDQHM SU]H] 6HNFM 'DZQ .RD 1DXNRZHJR 6WXGHQWyZ +LVWRULL 6]WXNL
8QLZHUV\WHWX yG]NLHJR yG U yG V /DONL DNXDED V JyZ
2ELHODONLVSU]\NDGHPNDQRQXDNXDE\NWyU\SRGREQLHMDNVWDWXHW
NLLEHMLFKDUDNWHU\]XMHVLRJyOQLHSU]\MWIRUPSU]H]WZyUFyZWHJROXGX
/DONL RG]QDF]D\ VL VWDUDQQRFL Z\NRQDQLD L Z\NZLQWQRFL PRGHOXQNX
SRQLHZD PLD\ VWDQRZL PLHMVFH GOD GXV]\ SU]\V]HJR G]LHFND -DN SRG
NUHODNV-DFHN3DZOLNFHORZRHVWHW\]RZDQRU]HE\WDNDE\VSRGRED\VL
RQH SU]RGNRP EG GXFKRP GODWHJR DUW\FL $V]DQWL VWDUDOL VL DE\ DNX
DE\RG]QDF]D\VLV]F]HJyOQ\PSLNQHP&]DUQDODOND]H]ELRUyZXQLZHU
V\WHFNLFKQU LQZ087.:LOPLHU]\ FPZ\VRNRFL]RVWDD
GRNDGQLH RSUDFRZDQD 7\ MHM JRZ\ ]GREL S\WNL ]JHRPHWU\]RZDQ\ UHOLHI
NWyU\QDZL]XMHGRDV]DQFNLHMV\PEROLNLDGLQNUDVWRVRZDQHMWDNHZ ]GR
ELHQLX WNDQLQ FHUDPLNL F]\ GHWDOX DUFKLWHNWRQLF]QHJR 1D MHM SRZLHU]FKQL
]DXZDDOQH V SU]HWDUFLD FR VXJHUXMH H E\D VWRVRZDQD Z FHODFK NXO
WRZ\FK 'UXJD DNDED Z\NRQDQD ] MDVQHJR GUHZQD QU LQZ 087
.:LOPLHU]\ FPZ\VRNRFLD MHMRSUDFRZDQLHQLHMHVWWDNGR
NDGQH %\ PRH Z\NRQDQD ]RVWDD QD SRWU]HE\ U\QNX SDPLWNDUVNLHJR
1LH PQLHM MHGQDN RELH U]HE\ SUH]HQWXM MHGQ ] QDMOHSLHM UR]SR]QDZDO
Q\FK L QDMF]FLHM SRZLHODQ\FK IRUP WUDG\F\MQHM V]WXNL DIU\NDVNLHM
: ]ELRUDFK 0X]HXP 8QLZHUV\WHFNLHJR Z 7RUXQLX ]QDMGXMH VL UyZQLH
PDVNDFKLZDUDOXGX%DPDQD] 0DOLQU LQZ087.:LO0LH
QLHSFLHVNLHM0DWRVZRMHNRU]HQLHZ PLFLHR G]LHFNX$NXL NRELHFLHNWyUDQLHPRJD
PLHG]LHFL0LHMVFRZ\V]DPDQ]DOHFLMHMHE\Z\NRQDQLHODONLNWyUPLDDRSLHNRZDVLMDN
SUDZG]LZ\PG]LHFNLHP:NUyWFH$NXDXURG]LDG]LHZF]\QR QLH]Z\NHMXURG]LH.$QWX
EDP $NXDED >LQ@ .R $QWXEDP *KDQDV KHULWDJH RI &XOWXUH /HLS]LJ V
7\SRZD ODOND DNDED PLHU]\ RG FP -HVW WR VFKHPDW\F]QLH XMWD SRVWD ] SD
VNG\VNRZDWJRZR PD\FKRF]DFKXVWDFKL Z\UDQLH]DU\VRZDQ\FKEUZLDFKSU]HFKR
G]F\FK Z ZVNL QRV ]DU\VRZDQ\FK SRQLHM SRRZ\ Z\VRNRFL G\VNX WZDU]\ 2GZURFLH
G\VNX ]Z\NOH ]GRELRQH MHVW S\WNLP UHOLHIHP :DOFRZDW\ WU]RQ SRF]RQ\ ] G\VNLHP JR
Z\ VWDQRZL WXyZ QD Z\VRNRFL NWyUHJR ]Z\NOH XPLHMVFRZLRQH V PDH VWRNR
ZDWH VFKHPDW\F]QLH XMWH SLHUVL QD Z\VRNRFL NWyU\FK VFKHPDW\F]QLH SRWUDNWRZDQH UFH
XIRUPRZDQH ] NUyWNLFK ZDOFyZ OXE VWRNyZ /DONL ZVSyF]HVQH V EDUG]LHM QDWXUDOLVW\F]
QH L F]VWR SU]HGVWDZLDQH V ] XIRUPRZDQ\PL NRF]\QDPL
-- 3DZOLN 5ROD V]WXNL Z DIU\NDVNLP NXOFLH SU]RGNyZ >Z@ $IU\ND QD SURJX ;;, ZLHNX
7 .XOWXUD L VSRHF]HVWZR UHG -- 3DZOLN 0 6]XSHMNR :DUV]DZD V
3 $SSLDK $NDQ 6\PEROLVP $IULFDQ $UWV 9RO 1R V
' =DKDQ $) 5REHUWV 7KH 7ZR :RUOGV RI &LZDUD $IULFDQ $UWV 9RO
1R V
461
462
M B-T, S M
U]\RQDFPZ\VFPV]HUZ\NRQDQD]RVWDD]OHNNLHJRGUHZQDZW]Z
W\SLHZHUW\NDOQ\P-HVWWRU]HEDSRFKRG]FDPDVNLNRV]RZHMZ IRUPLHVW\
OL]RZDQHM ]JHRPHWU\]RZDQHM SRVWDFL DQW\ORS\ Z\U]HELRQD ] MHGQHJR NDZD
ND GUHZQD ] ZWyUQ\P QLHVWDUDQQLH RSUDFRZDQ\P SUDZ\P URJLHP 0DVNL WH
]ZL]DQH E\\ ] NXOWHP ]LHPL L UROQLFWZHP RUD] V\PEROL]RZD\ ERJD )DUR
LPLW\F]QHJRGXFKDSUDF\3U]HGVWDZLD\]DPLHV]NXMFWHUHQVDZDQQ\DQW\ORS
NWyUHMGXJLHURJLV\PEROL]RZD\SURVRL RGQRVL\VLGRREWRFLL XURG]DMX
0DVNL WH SRZVWDZD\ Z NLONX ZDULDQWDFK L E\\ FKDUDNWHU\VW\F]QH GOD GD
QHJRUHJLRQX]DPLHV]NLZDQHJRSU]H]%DPDQyZ: UHJLRQLH%DPDNRU]HELR
QR QDWXUDOLVW\F]QH DQW\ORS\ R IRUPLH KRU\]RQWDOQHM QDWRPLDVW W\S R IRUPLH
DEVWUDNF\MQHM QD NWyU VNDGD\ VL VFKHPDW\F]QLH XMWH SRVWDFL QS DQW\ORS\
PUyZQLND L NDPHOHRQD SRFKRG]L ] UHJLRQX 6HJXQL : UHJLRQLH 6HJX VNG
SRFKRG]LU]HEDWRUXVNDWZRU]RQRPDVNLKRU\]RQWDOQH:HGXJ'RPLQLTXH
=DKDQL $OOHQD5REHUWDIRUPDPDVHNRGSRZLDGDDURG]DMRZLKRGRZDQHJRQD
GDQ\P WHUHQLH ]ERD L LQQHM UROLQQRFL
0LPR F]FLRZHJR XV]NRG]HQLD UyJ XE\WNL Z SDUWLL XV]X U]HED WD
MHVW DXWHQW\F]Q VWRVRZDQ Z NXOFLH FKLZDUD PDVN QD FR ZVND]XM ODG\
SRV]QXUNDFKNWyU\PLSU]\WZLHUG]DQRU]HEGRNRV]DXV]NRG]HQLDL SU]H
WDUFLD QD ]DNRF]HQLX RU\JLQDOQHJR URJX 0LHMVFDPL ZLGRF]QH V ODG\ SR
SLJPHQFLH V]F]HJyOQLH Z SDUWLL S\VND L JU]ELHWX PDVND E\D ZLF SLHUZRW
QLH SROLFKURPRZDQD 0RJD E\ WH ]GRELRQD HOHPHQWDPL PHWDORZ\PL QD
FRZVND]XMOLF]QHZJELHQLDD WDNHSU]HZLHUFRQHXFKRZ NWyU\P]DZLH
V]DQR NROF]\NL 0DVND SRFKRG]L ]DSHZQH ] SRRZ\ ;; Z
'RVZRMHMNROHNFML$OHNVDQGHU:HUQHUQDE\WDNHPDPDVNSUDZ
GRSRGREQLHSLHUVLRZ]EOLRQDVW\OLVW\F]QLHGRNUJXVW\OXOXGX%DXOH]D
=RE V , +DKQHU 0 .HFVNpVL / 9DMGD $IULFDQ PDVNV 7KH %DUELHU0XHOOHU &ROOHFWLRQ
0XQLFK%HUOLQ/RQGRQ1HZ <RUN V
65 :RRWHQ $QWHORSH +HDGGUHVVHV DQG &KDPSLRQ )DUPHUV 1HJRWLDWLQJ 0HDQLQJ DQG ,GHQWLW\
WKURXJK WKH %DPDQD &LZDUD &RPSOH[ $IULFDQ $UWV 9RO 1R V
%DPDQD 7KH $UW RI ([LVWHQFH LQ 0DOL HG -HDQ3DXO &ROOH\Q 1HZ <RUN V
' =DKDQ $) 5REHUWV RS FLW V
-HVW WR ]ZL]DQH ] IDNWHP X\ZDQLD PDVNL Z F]DVLH PDVNDUDG JG]LH XGHU]D VL URJD
PL R ]LHPL : U]HELH WRUXVNLHM Z ]DJELHQLDFK URJyZ ]QDOH]LRQR RVDG ]LHPQ\ D WDN
H OLF]QH SU]HWDUFLD L ]DU\VRZDQLD IDNWXU\
463
464
M B-T, S M
7UXGQH GR LGHQW\NDFML E\R PLHMVFH SRZVWDQLD PDVNL 1LH PRQD ER
ZLHPMHGQR]QDF]QLHVWZLHUG]LF]\U]HF]\ZLFLHMHVWWRWZyUU]HELDU]\%DX
OH FKR PDVND XWU]\PDQD MHVW Z W\P VW\OX 3RGREQH WZRU]\\ OXG\ ] QLPL
VVLDGXMFHMDN<DXUHF]\*XURZ\NRQXMFHU]HE\L PDVNLR SRGREQ\P
PRGHOXQNXWZDU]\=D%DXOHSU]HPDZLDMFKDUDNWHU\VW\F]QHVNDU\NDFMHQD
SROLF]NDFKL F]ROHPDVNL] NROHNFML:HUQHUD6RQHDQDORJLF]QH]H]QDQ\PL
] NROHNFML PX]HDOQ\FK U]HEDPL WHJR OXGX 3RGREQH VNDU\NDFMH SROLF]NR
ZHRGQDOHPRQDQDIRWRJUDLNRELHW\%DXOH] MHMPDVNSRUWUHWRZZ\
NRQDQHM Z U ]DPLHV]F]RQHM Z SXEOLNDFML $UQROGD 5XELQD 5]HELDU]
XFKZ\FLSRGRELHVWZRSRSU]H]QDGDQLHPDVFHLQG\ZLGXDOQ\FKFHFKFKDUDN
WHU\VW\F]Q\FKSRUWUHWRZDQHM0DWRRJURPQH]QDF]HQLHZ V]WXFH%DXOH$UW\
FLSRWUDOLZ\GRE\GHF\GXMFHDVSHNW\RVRERZRFLWZRU]F]ZL]IRUP
NWyUD Z\PXV]DD SRUyZQDQLH ] PRGHOHP 3KLOLS 5HYHQKLOO SLVD :\NRQD
QHG]LHRV]WXNLMHVWUR]XPLDQHMDNRRGG]LDXMFHQDZLG]DMDNZ SU]\SDGNX
%DXOH JG]LH SRP\OQLH Z\NRQDQD U]HED MHVW SRUyZQ\ZDQD ] PRGHOHP
-HGQRF]HQLHPRQD]DXZD\LGHDOL]DFML XWU]\PDQLHU]HE\Z NDQRQLHSOD
VW\NL%DXOH: NDWDORJXNROHNFML%DUELHU0XHOOHU]QDMGXMHVLEOLQLDF]DPDVND
PEOR)RUP\REXWZDU]\SU]\SRPLQDMPDVN] 0X]HXP8QLZHUV\WHFNLH
JR 1D F]ROH ]RVWD\ GRGDQH SRGREQH WU]\ SDU\ VNDU\NDFML Z IRUPLH NUyW
NLFK SDVNLFK QDFL $QDORJLF]QH MHVW XMFLH XNyZ EUZLRZ\FK QRVD L XVW
D V]F]HJyOQLH VSRVyE NV]WDWRZDQLD WZDU]\ L PLNNL PRGHOXQHN
0LPR SHZQ\FK ZWSOLZRFL PDVND WRUXVND Z\GDMH VL E\ QDMEOL
V]D U]HELDUVNLP WUDG\FMRP %DXOH WDNH ] XZDJL PLQLDWXU\]DFM VWRVRZDQ
:LOOLDP - 'HZH\ 7RVKLNR 0 0F&DOOXP -HURPH )HOGPDQ +HQULHWWD &RVHQWLQR
5 * :LOFR[ 6OHHSLQJ %HDXWLHV $IULFDQ +HDGUHVWV DQG 2WKHU +LJKOLJKWV IURP WKH -HURPH / -RVV
&ROOHFWLRQ DW 8&/$ V J
$NXUXP NXEHN Z\NRQDQ\ ] JyUQHM F]FL ] W\NZ\
$'RQRYDQ7XUNDQD)XQFWLRQDO$UW$IULFDQ$UWV9RO1RJ
465
466
M B-T, S M
Bibliografia
$QWXEDP .R $NXDED >LQ@ .R $QWXEDP *KDQDV KHULWDJH RI &XOWXUH /HLS]LJ
V
$SSLDK *ORYHU $NDQ 6\PEROLVP $IULFDQ $UWV 9RO 1R V
%DND7KHLV 0DJRU]DWD /DOHF]NDFyUHF]ND ODONL SRGQRFL $NXDED OXGX $V]DQ
WL *KDQD L LQVSLUDFMH >Z@ &LDR V\PEROLF]QH &LDR PHG\F]QH &LDR HVWHW\F]QH 0D
WHULD\ ] .RQIHUHQFML 1DXNRZHM ]RUJDQL]RZDQHM SU]H] 6HNFM 'DZQ .RD
1DXNRZHJR 6WXGHQWyZ +LVWRULL 6]WXNL 8QLZHUV\WHWX yG]NLHJR yG
U yG V
%DND7KHLV 0DJRU]DWD 5]HE\ EOLQLW LEHGL )RUPD L VW\O Z\EUDQ\FK UHJLRQyZ .UyOH
VWZD -RUXED 1LJHULD >Z@ .XOWXU\ $IU\NL : ZLHFLH WUDG\FML SU]HPLDQ L ]QDF]H _
_&XOWXUHVRI $IULFD,QWKHZRUOGRI WUDGLWLRQVFKDQJHVDQGPHDQLQJVW ,9UHG$Q
QD 1DGROVND6W\F]\VND 7RUX V
%DPDQD 7KH $UW RI ([LVWHQFH LQ 0DOL HG -HDQ3DXO &ROOH\Q 1HZ <RUN
%HQ$PRV 3DXOD 0HQ DQG $QLPDOV LQ %HQLQ $UW 0DQ 9RO V
%HQ$PRV *LUVKLFN 3DXOD 7KH 6\PEROLVP RI $QFHVWUDO $OWDU LQ %HQLQ >LQ@ %HQLQ
.LQJVDQG5LWXDOV&RXUW$UWVIURP1LJHULDHG%DUEDUD3ODQNHQVWHLQHU:LHQ
%HUOLQ3DULV&KLFDJR V
%ODFNPXQ%DUEDUD:)URP7UDGHUWR3ULHVWLQ7ZR+XQGUHG<HDUV7KH7UDQVIRUPDWLRQ
RI D )RUHLJQ )LJXUH RQ %HQLQ ,YRULHV $UW -RXUQDO V
%ODFNPXQ %DUEDUD : :KR DUH WKH )LJXUHV LQ %HQLQ $UW" 7UDQVODWLRQV IURP ,YRU\ WR
%URQ]H>LQ@%HQLQ .LQJVDQG5LWXDOV&RXUW$UWVIURP1LJHULDHG%DUEDUD3ODQ
NHQVWHLQHU :LHQ%HUOLQ3DULV&KLFDJR V
%OLHU6X]DQQH3,PDJLQJRWKHUQHVVLQLYRU\$IULFDQSRUWUD\DOVRI WKH3RUWXJXHVHFD
$UW %XOOHWLQ 9RO 1R V
%RKXV]6]\V]NR 0DULDQ :LHOLF]NR L MHJR &HQWDXU *DOOHU\ 7\G]LH 3ROVNL
QU V
%RUNRZVNL $QGU]HM 0 =DVRQ\ L F]HOXFLH $OHNVDQGUD :HUQHUD 7\G]LH 3ROVNL
; QU V >SU]HGUXN Z 6]WXND SROVND Z :LHONLHM %U\WDQLL Z OD
WDFK $QWRORJLD Z\EUD SU]\JRWRZD GR GUXNX L ZVWSHP RSDWU]\
0 $ 6XSUXQLXN 7RUX V @
&XUQRZ .DWK\ 3UHVWLJH DQG WKH *HQWOHPDQ %HQLQ 0HQV ,GHDO $UW -RXUQDO
9RO 1R V
'DUN 3KLOLS %HQLQ %URQ]H +HDGV 6W\OHV DQG &KURQRORJ\ >LQ@ $IULFDQ ,PDJHV (VVD\V LQ
$IULFDQ,FRQRORJ\HG'DQLHO) 0F&DOO(GQD* %D\1HZ<RUNV
'HZH\ :LOOLDP - 0F&DOOXP 7RVKLNR 0 )HOGPDQ -HURPH &RVHQWLQR +HQULHWWD
:LOFR[ 5* 6OHHSLQJ %HDXWLHV $IULFDQ +HDGUHVWV DQG 2WKHU +LJKOLJKWV IURP WKH -H
URPH / -RVV &ROOHFWLRQ DW 8&/$ /RV $QJHOHV
'RQRYDQ$ODQ7XUNDQD)XQFWLRQDO$UW$IULFDQ$UWV9RO1RV
*XV]HN ,QJD .R]RZVND (ZHOLQD 0DMRFK 6DZRPLU 2OV]WD%ORFK 0DJGDOHQD
$QFLHQW SRWWHU\ DQG JODVV IURP WKH FROOHFWLRQ RI WKH 8QLYHUVLW\ 0XVHXP LQ 7RUX _ &H
UDPLND L V]NR DQW\F]QH Z ]ELRUDFK 0X]HXP 8QLZHUV\WHFNLHJR Z 7RUXQLX FDWDORJXHV
RI WKH FROOHFWLRQ IURP 8QLYHUVLW\ 0XVHXP LQ 7RUX _ 3RODQG _ .DWDORJL ]ELRUyZ 0X
]HXP 8QLZHUV\WHFNLHJR Z 7RUXQLX YRO 7RUX
+LPPHOKHEHU+DQV.XQVWXQG.QVWOHUGHU%DXOHXQG*XUR>LQ@+DQV+LPPHOKHEHU
1HJHUNXQVW XQG 1HJHUNQVWOHUGHU %UDXQVFKZLHJ V
+RXERZLF] :RG]LPLHU] 0XPMH HJLSVNLH Z :LOQLH :LOQR
+RXERZLF] :RG]LPLHU] 3L ODW SUDF\ WHUHQRZHM 0X]HXP $UFKHRORJLF]QHJR 8QLZHU
V\WHWX 6WHIDQD %DWRUHJR Z :LOQLH 5RF]QLN $UFKHRORJLF]Q\
W V
,QQHK 'DQLHO 7KH *XLOGV :RUNLQJ IRU WKH 3DODFH >LQ@ %HQLQ .LQJV DQG 5LWXDOV
&RXUW$UWVIURP1LJHULDHG%DUEDUD3ODQNHQVWHLQHU:LHQ%HUOLQ3DULV&KLFD
JR V
-RKQVRQ 6DPXHO 7KH +LVWRU\ RI WKH <RUXEDV /DJRV
-XQJH3HWHU$JH'HWHUPLQDWLRQRI &RPPHPRUDWLYH+HDGV7KH([DPSOHRI WKH%HUOLQ&RO
OHFWLRQ>LQ@%HQLQ .LQJVDQG5LWXDOV&RXUW$UWVIURP1LJHULDHG%DUEDUD3ODQ
NHQVWHLQHU :LHQ%HUOLQ3DULV&KLFDJR V
0DMRFK6DZRPLU)DVF\QXMFDNROHNFMD'ZDMRNVIRUG]F\QDXNRZF\Z WRUXVNLP0X]HXP
8QLZHUV\WHFNLP *RV 8F]HOQL QU V
0DMRFK 6DZRPLU 7U]\ WRQ\ G]LH V]WXNL *RV 8F]HOQL QU V
1HYDGRPVN\ -RVHSK ,QQHK 'DQLHO ( .LQJVKLS 6XFFHVVLRQ 5LWXDOV LQ %HQLQ %HFR
PLQJ D &URZQ 3ULQFH $IULFDQ $UWV 9RO 1R V
467
468
M B-T, S M
=DKDQ 'RPLQLTXZ 5REHUWV %OHQ ) 7KH 7ZR :RUOGV RI &LZDUD $IULFDQ $UWV
YRO 1R V LO
=QDPLHURZVND3UIIHURZD 0DULD 0X]HXP (WQRJUDF]QH 8QLZHUV\WHWX 6WHIDQD %DWRUH
JRZ :LOQLHL MHJRSU]\V]R/ZyZ:LOQR>QDGELWND].ZDUWDOQLN(WQR
JUDF]Q\ /XG 6HUMD W @
Summary
African artifacts from the collection of Aleksander Werener
possessed by the University Museum Toru
$UWLFOH SUHVHQWV $IULFDQ FROOHFWLRQ GRQDWHG E\ $OH[DQGHU :HUQHU
SROLVK SDLQWHU VFXOSWRU DQG JUDSKLF WR 1LFRODXV &RSHUQLFXV 8QLYHUVLW\ LQ
:HUQHUOLYHGLQ/RQGRQVLQFHWKHHQGRI ,,:RUOG:DUZKHQKHFUHDWHGWKHUHVW
RI KLV OLIH $OO LQKHULWDQFH RI WKH DUWLVW LV 8QLYHUVLW\ 0XVHXP LQ 7RUX 7KH LQ
WURGXFWLRQ RXWOLQHV WKH PHPRLU RI WKH DUWLVW
7KH VHFRQG SDUW RI WKH WH[W LV FKDUDFWHULVWLF EDWFK RI $IULFDQ REMHFWV
7KH FROOHFWLRQ LQFOXGHV VFXOSWXUH RI LYRU\ IURP .LQJGRP RI %HQLQ )LJ
ZRRG DQG VPDOO JXUH ,EHML LPDJH RI WZLQV IRUP WKH <RUXED SHRSOH RI 1L
JHULD IURP WKH ,YRU\ &RDVW J WZR GROOV $NXDED ZRRGHQ ULWXDO IHUWLOL
W\ GROOV IURP *KDQD RI $VKDQWL SHRSOH )LJ WKH $QWHORSH KHDGGUHVV 0DVN
&KLZDUD RI WKU %DPDQD SHRSOH RI 0DOL )LJ PLQLDWXUH 3DVVSRUW 0DVN
ZKLWFKLVDVPDOOSRUWUDLWKXPDQIDFHRI %DXOH3HRSOH)LJSDLQWHGJRXUGV7XU
NDQD 7ULEH RI 1RUGHQ .HQ\D KHDGUHVW .DPEDWWD SHRSOH RI (WKLRSLD )LJ DV
ZHOO DV YH RI SRWWHU\ IURP 1RUWK $IULFD
469
[470]
[471]
,O,EHMLOXG-RUXEDUHJLRQ2JERPRVR2MR1LJHULDSR;;ZGUHZ
QR QDFLHUDQH S\HP GU]HZQ\P F]HUQLRQH 0X]HXP 8QLZHUV\WHFNLH
Z 7RUXQLX QU LQZ 087 .: )RW 6 0DMRFK
[472]
,O $NXDED OXG $V]DQWL *KDQD SR ;; Z GUHZQR F]HUQLRQH 0X]HXP 8QLZHUV\
WHFNLH Z 7RUXQLX QU LQZ 087 .: )RW 6 0DMRFK
[473]
,O$NXDEDOXG$V]DQWLSR;;ZGUHZQR0X]HXP8QLZHUV\
WHFNLH Z 7RUXQLX QU LQZ 087 .: )RW 6 0DMRFK
[474]
,O0DVNDNDSHOXV]RZDFKLZDUDOXG%DPDQD0DOLSR;;Z
0X]HXP8QLZHUV\WHFNLHZ7RUXQLXQULQZ087.:
)RW 3LRWU .XUHN
[475]
[476]
,O 3RGJyZHN OXG .DPEDWWD (WLRSLD SR ;; Z GUHZQR 0X]HXP 8QLZHUV\WHFNLH
Z 7RUXQLX QU LQZ 087 .: )RW 6 0DMRFK