Rajkot 3G Report Cluster 7 Ver 1.0

2014
Executive Summary Rajkot
[BENCHMARKING REPORT]
Benchmarking Report
Rajkot 3G_Cluster 7
LINKQUEST TELECOM LIMITED

1
Executive Summary
Operators
Technology
Band of
Operation
IDEA 3G
UMTS
2100
DOCOMO 3G
UMTS
2100
VODAFONE 3G
UMTS
2100
emographics of Rajkot
Rajkot is the fourth largest city in the state of Gujarat, India, after Ahmedabad, Surat, and Vadodara. Rajkot is
the 35th-largest urban agglomeration in India, with a population more than 1.28 million. This district is
surrounded byMorbi districtin north,SurendranagarandBotaddistricts in east,AmreliandJunagadhdistricts in
south andPorbandarJamnagar districtin west. The district occupies an area of 11203km. The district is named
after its headquarters, Rajkot city. The name of the city of Rajkot (literally means the city of princes) was
probably derived from Raju Sandhi, the co-founder of the erstwhileprincely stateof Rajkot in 1610.
CONFIDENTIAL Copyright 2014 Link Quest Telecom Limited
Link
Link Quest
Quest Benchmarking
Benchmarking Methodology
Methodology
Section
1
Drive Test Equipment

Benchmarking Setup
Post processing tool
Data Collection Details
Test Scenario
Voice Testing Algorithm
Data Testing Algorithm
Strategic Location Testing
Voice & Data KPI weightages
Key Performance Indicators Calculation
Methodology
Drive Test Equipment
Benchmarking Setup
RF Benchmarking audit is done to test the Radio interface and
draw competitive results
1. Data tests are categorized as tests for Ping test, FTP DL/UL, HTTP DL, Web Browsing and
1. Data tests are categorized as tests for Ping test, FTP DL/UL, HTTP DL, Web Browsing and
Email Send/Receive.
We have used script files for conducting drive on Nemo Invex, These script files contain the
various parameters that determine how the mobile devices behave during Ping test FTP DL/UL,
HTTP DL, Web Browsing and Email Send/Receive.
2. Following are precautions taken for the KPIs associated with a Drive Test : DT being
conducted within the specified timeframe which has been scheduled ,Adherence to
predetermined distance and route, Validity and accuracy of data being collected during the DT
drive
3. The system uses specially configured test (Calibrated) phones attached to controlling
devices in isolation chambers to perform various tests such as voice calls, data calls, video
calls etc. The equipment is flexible in configuration supporting a maximum of 20 phones on
the same testing platform.
Via BSS and
Internet
Internet
Core Network
Cloud
Cloud
RF
Interface
RF
Interface
5
FTP
Server
Tool
6
Data Collection Details

CLUSTER 7
City
Rajkot
Measureme
nt
Period
8/3/2014
Tests done
9 :00 AM to 7.00 P.M
Linkquest fixed Lines used

for MOS testing.
The drive route was created
to cover the dense
population area , key
commercial area, key
residential area. The route
consisted of Highways and
Main Roads.
Test Scenario
A Benchmarking Test drive was conducted by Link Quest Telecom in
Rajkot city to measure Voice & Data KPIs for 3G.

The operators and Technology considered for benchmarking are:
Generation
Test
Technology
Operator
All
Scanner
UMTS
UMTS operators
Idea
3G
Voice
UMTS
DoCoMo
Vodafone
Idea
3G
Data
UMTS
DoCoMo
Vodafone
8
Voice Testing Algorithm

Test Details
Specifications
No of Operators
tested
(Idea, DoCoMo, Vodafone)
Voice Test Algorithm

Call Duration
3 mins (180 Secs)
Idle time in between

calls
15 Secs
Continuous call for 3 minute duration

with 15 seconds of idle time. Speech
samples are sent and received which
provide the MOS score for voice
quality. This was repeated for the
entire duration of collection.
Data Testing Algorithm

Email Receive
GPRS
Attach
PDP Activation
PING
3 times 32 Byte
116.214.26.163 (FTP Server
ID)
FTP DL
15 MB File-GSM
FTP UL
1 MB File-GSM
PING
10 Different Websites
HTTP
10 Different Websites
Email Send
100 KB Email from SMTP

server
Wait time after the loop
15 Sec
Wait time between all test
2 Sec
100KB Email from POP3

Server
YouTube Streaming
180Sec of YouTube
Streaming
GPRS
PDP Deactivation
Detach
HTTP Websites
1 www. flipkart. com
2 www. naukri. com
3 www. espncricinfo.
com
4www. facebook.
com
5 www. google. com
6 www. irctc.co.in
7
www.moneycontrol.c
om
8 www.zedge.net
9 www.ndtv.com
10 www. youtube.
com
Voice & Data KPI

Weightages
5 KPIs are used to arrive at the Voice Quality Score and 5 KPIs are used to arrive at the
Data Quality Score. Following are the details of weightings assigned to different KPIs.
These are used for arriving at the final ranking of the operator.
Key Performance Indicators Calculation

Methodology
For Delay Time & RTT we have calculated score based on
*RTT or Delay Time Score=100 ((Actual Time * 100) / Max Time)
For calculating the Overall score , Values of all KPIs multiplied with the weightage
given to the corresponding KPI .
The results of each KPIs will be added to arrive at the final score and operators will be
ranked as per the score.

12
Management
Management Summary
Summary
Section 2
Voice Quality Score
Data Quality Score
All Over Network Weightage & Ranking UMTS

Voice
5 KPIs are used to arrive at the Network
Quality Score. Following are the details of
weightings assigned to different KPIs.
These are used for arriving at the final
ranking of
the operator.
Operator
Score
Rank
Idea 3G
72.56
DoCoMo 3G
82.62
Vodafone 3G
72.04
Idea leads at 2nd position in Voice UMTS Ranking.
All Over Network Weightage & Ranking UMTS

Data
5 KPIs are used to arrive at the Data
Quality Score. Following are the details of
weightings assigned to different KPIs.
These are used for arriving at the final
ranking of
the operator.
Operator
Score
Rank
Idea 3G
39.58
DoCoMo 3G
39.14
Vodafone 3G
40.38
Idea leads at 2nd position in Data UMTS Ranking.
Detailed
Detailed Voice
Voice Analysis
Analysis
Section 3
Scanner Performance Analysis
RSCP Distribution (Scanner)
EcNo Distribution (Scanner)
Pilot Pollution (Scanner)
RSCP ( Scanner)
Idea 3G
DoCoMo 3G
Vodafone 3G
Idea RSCP (Scanner)
Idea 3G
DoCoMo RSCP (Scanner)
DoCoMo 3G
Vodafone RSCP (Scanner)
Vodafone 3G
RSCP (Scanner) Comparison

Summary
Operator
Coverage Rate using

formula
Rank
Idea 3G
88.99%
DoCoMo 3G
68.67%
Vodafone 3G
90.60%
Vodafone has the best RSCP Coverage among all other operators
Grade RSCP dbm

A
-65<= x < 0
-75 <= x <
B
-65
-85 <= x <
C
-75
-93 <= x <
D
-85
-99 <= x <
E
-93
benchmarked.
F
x < -99
EcNo ( Scanner)
Idea 3G
DoCoMo 3G
Vodafone 3G
Idea EcNo(Scanner)
Idea 3G
DoCoMo EcNo(Scanner)
DoCoMo 3G
Vodafone EcNo (Scanner)
Vodafone 3G
EcNo (Scanner) Comparison

Summary
Operator
Coverage Rate using

formula
Rank
Idea 3G
83.68%
DoCoMo 3G
89.20%
Vodafone 3G
83.99%
Grade
EcN0
-9<=x
-12<=x<-9
-15<=x<-12
X<-15
DoCoMo has the best EcNo Coverage among all other operators benchmarked.
Idea - Pilot Pollution (Scanner)

Pilot
Pollution
DoCoMo has higher pilot pollution compared to other competitors.

27
Detailed
Detailed Voice
Voice Analysis
Analysis
Section 4
Voice Performance Analysis
RSCP Distribution (Dedicated Mode)
EcNo Distribution (Dedicated Mode)
MOS Comparison (Dedicated Mode)
Call Setup Time
Call Setup Success Rate
Call Completion Success Rate
Accessibility V/s Retain ability
Comparison
Voice Quality: MOS Comparison
HOSR Analysis
Serving System Analysis (Dedicated
Mode)
RAB Setup Success Rate Analysis
BLER Analysis
Active Set Size Analysis
RSCP - (Dedicated Mode)

Idea 3G
DoCoMo 3G
Vodafone 3G
Idea RSCP (Dedicated Mode)
Idea 3G
DoCoMo RSCP (Dedicated Mode)
DoCoMo 3G
Vodafone RSCP (Dedicated Mode)
Vodafone
3G
RSCP (Dedicated Mode) Comparison Summary
Operator
Coverage Rate using

formula
Rank
Idea 3G
78.77%
DoCoMo 3G
54.83%
Vodafone 3G
72.19%
Idea has best RSCP Coverage in benchmarked.
Grade RSCP dbm

A
-65<= x < 0
-75 <= x <
B
-65
-85 <= x <
C
-75
-93 <= x <
D
-85
-99 <= x <
E
-93
F
x < -99
EcNo (Dedicated Mode)

Idea 3G
DoCoMo 3G
Vodafone 3G
Idea EcNo (Dedicated Mode)
Idea 3G
DoCoMo EcNo (Dedicated Mode)
DoCoMo 3G
Vodafone EcNo (Dedicated Mode)
Vodafone
3G
EcNo (Dedicated Mode) Comparison Summary
Operator
Coverage Rate using

formula
Rank
Idea 3G
91.34%
DoCoMo 3G
92.68%
Vodafone 3G
90.01%
Grade
EcN0
-9<=x
-12<=x<-9
-15<=x<-12
X<-15
DoCoMo has the best EcNo Coverage among all other operators benchmarked.
PESQ MOS - (Dedicated Mode)

Idea 3G
DoCoMo 3G
Vodafone 3G
Idea MOS (Dedicated Mode)
Idea 3G
DoCoMo MOS (Dedicated Mode)
DoCoMo 3G
Vodafone MOS (Dedicated Mode)
Vodafone
3G
PESQ - MOS (Dedicated Mode)
Operator
Average (DL+UL) MOS
Idea 3G
3.34
DoCoMo 3G
3.47
Vodafone 3G
3.21
DoCoMo has the best MOS value among all other operators benchmarked.
Call Setup Time (CST)
Operator
Avg. Call Setup time

(Sec )
Min (Sec)
Max(Sec)
Idea 3G
6.29
5.56
9.87
DoCoMo 3G
3.44
2.17
12.93
Vodafone 3G
3.67
2.92
7.30
DoCoMo has best call set up time compare to other operators..
Call Setup Success

Rate
Total
Total
Over all
Establis Setup
CSSR
h
Failure
Operator
Total Call
Attempts
Idea 3G
44
44
DoCoMo 3G
43
43
Vodafone 3G
45
45
100.00
%
100.00
%
100.00
%
Call Attempts
Setup Failure
3G
2G
3G
2G
44
39
44
All operators have 100% call setup success rate in benchmarked.

45
CSSR
3G
2G
100.00
NA
%
100.00 100.00
%
%
100.00 100.00
%
%
Call Completion Success

Rate
Operator
Total Call
Total
Established Success
Total
Drop
Overall
CCSR
Call
Established
Drop
CCSR
3G
2G
3G
2G
3G
2G
NA
Idea 3G
44
43
97.73%
44
97.73%
DoCoMo 3G
43
43
100.00%
39
100.00
100.00%
%
Vodafone 3G
45
44
97.78%
44
97.73% 100.00%
DoCoMo has best call completion success rate compare to all other operators
benchmarked.
46
Accessibility V/s Retainability
All Operators have 100% CSSR & DoCoMo has best CCSR compare to all other
operators benchmarked.
47
Idea Call Drop Analysis
48
Idea Call Drop Analysis
S. No
Long
Lat
Call Type
RSCP(dBm)/
Rx Lev
Ec/No/
Rx Quality
Serving
System
Serving Cell
ID
70.79048
22.13546
Drop
-80.70
-21.30
UMTS FDD
50187
49
Handover Success Rate 3G
Soft Handover
IRAT Handover
Handover
Operator
Attempts
Success
Attempts
Success
Soft
Handover
IRAT
Idea 3G
463
463
100.00%
100.00%
DoCoMo 3G
545
545
100.00%
100.00%
Vodafone 3G
620
620
100.00%
100.00%
All Operators have 100% soft handover success rate & 100% IRAT success rate.
50
Success Rate
Voice Serving System Plots (Dedicated Mode)

Idea 3G
DoCoMo 3G
Vodafone 3G
Idea Serving System (Dedicated

Mode)
Idea 3G
DoCoMo Serving System (Dedicated

Mode)
DoCoMo
3G
Vodafone Serving System (Dedicated

Mode)
Vodafone
3G
Radio Bearer Setup Success rate
All operator have 100% Radio Bearer Setup Success Rate in Benchmarked.
55
Idea - BLER
All operators have comparable BLER during whole drive.
56
Idea Active Set Size
Idea has higher percentage of Active Set Size in Benchmarked.
57
Detailed
Detailed Data
Data Analysis
Analysis
Section 5
Data Performance Analysis
GPRS Attach and PDP Performance

PS Connection Statistics
Ping test Performance
Video Streaming Performance
FTP DL/UL Performance
HTTP Performance Analysis
Email Performance
Data Technology
PS Drop Rate Analysis
EcNo Distribution
Modulation & CQI
Attach Statistics
Idea has best Attach Performance among all the other operators benchmarked.
PDP Statistics
All Operators have 100% PDP Attach Success Rate while Vodafone has best PDP Context
activation time.
PS Connection Statistics
Idea has best PS connection Setup Success Rate while DoCoMo has best PS Connection
Setup Time.
Ping Test Results
DoCoMo has best RTT among all other operators benchmarked .

62
Streaming Results
Vodafone has best Streaming Performance among all other operators benchmarked .
63
FTP Download Statistics
Operator
Total attempts
Success
Drop
Time out
FTP DL Success Rate
FTP DL Throughput
Kbps
Idea 3G
18
16
88.89%
1621.57
DoCoMo 3G
15
12
80.00%
1092.95
Vodafone 3G
13
30.77%
809.86
Idea has best FTP DL Performance among all the operators benchmarked.
FTP Upload Statistics
Operator
Total attempts
Success
Drop
Time out
FTP UL Success
Rate
FTP UL Throughput
Kbps
Idea 3G
14
14
100.00%
858.09
DoCoMo 3G
13
13
100.00%
799.86
Vodafone 3G
12
12
100.00%
545.60
Idea has best FTP UL Performance among all the operators benchmarked.
HTTP Performance
Idea has best HTTP success rate while Vodafone has best HTTP Browsing Time.
Idea - HTTP Success Rate Details

URL
Total
Attempts
Success
Timeout
Success
Rate
HTTP DL
Time
www.espncricinfo.com
100.00%
24.91
www.facebook.com
12
12
100.00%
30.81
www.flipkart.com
10
10
100.00%
17.17
www.google.com
13
13
100.00%
23.34
www.irctc.co.in
100.00%
6.07
www.moneycontrol.com
100.00%
8.47
www.naukri.com
88.89%
9.62
www.ndtv.com
100.00%
23.38
www.youtube.com
100.00%
7.46
www.zedge.net
100.00%
14.85
Idea has poor accessibility to www.naukri.com.

Idea - FTP UL/DL & HTTP Failure
68
Email send Receive Success Rate
Email
Send
Success
Rate
Email
Send
Time
Email
Receive
Attempts
Email
Receive
Success
Email
Receive
Success
Rate
Email
Receive
Time
Operator
Email Send
Attempts
Email
Send
Success
Idea 3G
100.00%
9.36
100.00%
12.84
DoCoMo 3G
100.00%
7.36
100.00%
4.64
Vodafone
3G
100.00%
8.93
100.00%
6.64
DoCoMo has best Email Send & Email Receive Performance.
Data - Technology Plots

Idea 3G
DoCoMo 3G
Vodafone 3G
Idea Data Technology
Idea 3G
DoCoMo Data Technology
DoCoMo
3G
Vodafone Data Technology
Vodafone
3G
Idea Comparison Ec/No
Idea has best EcNo compared to other competitors.
APP FTP DL/UL ThroughputHSDPA
Idea has max. percentage of greater than 1024kbps throughput in FTP DL and UL compare to
other operators.
APP HTTP DL ThroughputHSDPA
Vodafone has max. percentage of greater than 512kbps throughput in HTTP DL compare
to other operators
MAC-hs FTP DL/UL ThroughputHSDPA
DoCoMo has max. percentage of greater than 1024kbps throughput in FTP DL and UL
compare to other operators.
MAC-hs HTTP DL ThroughputHSDPA
Vodafone has max. percentage of greater than 512kbps throughput in HTTP DL

compare to other operators
Idea CQI & Modulation Scheme

CQI
Modulation Schemes
Modulation and CQI
DoCoMo has better Modulation while Idea has better CQI compared to other competitors.
Management
Management Summary
Summary
Section 6
SWOT Analysis for Idea
Observations and
Recommendations
Threats
Vodafone has best Coverage.
DoCoMo has best Call Setup Time.
DoCoMo has best Email Send/Receive
Time.
DoCoMo has best RTT.
Idea Voice & Data Score can be

improved by optimize Network
Quality.
Opportunities
Idea
Strength
Retainability.
MOS Value.
Call Setup Time.
HTTP Browsing Time.
Email Send /Receive Time.
Streaming Performance.
Weakness
Accessibility.
Handover Success Rate.
Attach Performance.
FTP Downlink Performance.
FTP Uplink Performance.
HTTP Browsing Success Rate.
Email Send /Receive Success Rate.
SWOT Analysis for Idea
Observations and Recommendations

Idea has best Accessibility.
DoCoMo has best Retainability.
DoCoMo has the best MOS value.
Vodafone has best Coverage.
Idea has best Attach Performance.
DoCoMo has best RTT value.
Idea has the best FTP Download
Performance.
Idea has the best FTP Upload
Performance.
Vodafone has best Streaming
Performance.
DoCoMo has best Email Send/ Receive
Performance.
Idea stands on 2nd Rank in Voice & 2nd
Rank in Data in Rajkot Town (Cluster-7).
CLUSTER
7
84

Rajkot 3G Report Cluster 7 Ver 1.0

Enviado por

Dados do documento

Direitos autorais

Formatos disponíveis

Compartilhar este documento

Compartilhar ou incorporar documento

Opções de compartilhamento

Você considera este documento útil?

Este conteúdo é inapropriado?

Direitos autorais:

Formatos disponíveis

Rajkot 3G Report Cluster 7 Ver 1.0

Enviado por

Direitos autorais:

Formatos disponíveis

2014

Executive Summary Rajkot

LINKQUEST TELECOM LIMITED

CONFIDENTIAL Copyright 2014 Link Quest Telecom Limited

Drive Test Equipment

CONFIDENTIAL Copyright 2014 Link Quest Telecom Limited

Drive Test Equipment

CONFIDENTIAL Copyright 2014 Link Quest Telecom Limited

Data Collection Details

9 :00 AM to 7.00 P.M

Linkquest fixed Lines used

CONFIDENTIAL Copyright 2014 Link Quest Telecom Limited

Rajkot city to measure Voice & Data KPIs for 3G.

Voice Testing Algorithm

(Idea, DoCoMo, Vodafone)

Voice Test Algorithm

3 mins (180 Secs)

Idle time in between

Continuous call for 3 minute duration

CONFIDENTIAL Copyright 2014 Link Quest Telecom Limited

Data Testing Algorithm

100 KB Email from SMTP

Wait time between all test

100KB Email from POP3

CONFIDENTIAL Copyright 2014 Link Quest Telecom Limited

Voice & Data KPI

CONFIDENTIAL Copyright 2014 Link Quest Telecom Limited

Key Performance Indicators Calculation

given to the corresponding KPI .

ranked as per the score.

CONFIDENTIAL Copyright 2014 Link Quest Telecom Limited

All Over Network Weightage & Ranking UMTS

Idea leads at 2nd position in Voice UMTS Ranking.

CONFIDENTIAL Copyright 2014 Link Quest Telecom Limited

All Over Network Weightage & Ranking UMTS

Idea leads at 2nd position in Data UMTS Ranking.

CONFIDENTIAL Copyright 2014 Link Quest Telecom Limited

CONFIDENTIAL Copyright 2014 Link Quest Telecom Limited

CONFIDENTIAL Copyright 2013 Link Quest Telecom Limited

Idea RSCP (Scanner)

DoCoMo RSCP (Scanner)

Vodafone RSCP (Scanner)

RSCP (Scanner) Comparison

Coverage Rate using

CONFIDENTIAL Copyright 2014 Link Quest Telecom Limited

Grade RSCP dbm

CONFIDENTIAL Copyright 2013 Link Quest Telecom Limited

Vodafone EcNo (Scanner)

EcNo (Scanner) Comparison

Coverage Rate using

CONFIDENTIAL Copyright 2014 Link Quest Telecom Limited

Idea - Pilot Pollution (Scanner)

DoCoMo has higher pilot pollution compared to other competitors.

CONFIDENTIAL Copyright 2014 Link Quest Telecom Limited

RSCP - (Dedicated Mode)

CONFIDENTIAL Copyright 2014 Link Quest Telecom Limited

Idea RSCP (Dedicated Mode)

DoCoMo RSCP (Dedicated Mode)

Vodafone RSCP (Dedicated Mode)

CONFIDENTIAL Copyright 2014 Link Quest Telecom Limited

RSCP (Dedicated Mode) Comparison Summary

Coverage Rate using

Idea has best RSCP Coverage in benchmarked.

CONFIDENTIAL Copyright 2014 Link Quest Telecom Limited