Scribd Logo
Fazer o upload

Bem-vindo(a) ao Scribd!

  • Global Arbitration Review

    Enviado por

    Ale
    243 visualizações49 páginas
    Vol_2_Issue_2

    Direitos autorais

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Formatos disponíveis

    PDF ou leia online no Scribd

    Você considera este documento útil?

    Este conteúdo é inapropriado?

    Denunciar este documento
    Vol_2_Issue_2

    Direitos autorais:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Baixe no formato PDF ou leia online no Scribd
    Sinalizar o conteúdo como inadequado
    243 visualizações49 páginas

    Global Arbitration Review

    Enviado por

    Ale
    Vol_2_Issue_2

    Direitos autorais:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Baixe no formato PDF ou leia online no Scribd
    Sinalizar o conteúdo como inadequado
    de 49
    GLOBAL ARBITRATION cag Conference diey ® GLOBAL ARBITRATION IMEINERNATONAL JOURNAL OFPUBLCANDPawatcAReneaTON — REVIEW a GLOBAL ARBITRATION REVIEW complements existing journals and differs significantly from current publications by being news-led and based on original in-house surveys and research. Each issue contains: anaes ARBITRATION NEWS: community changes and ——_—z intelligence; people and clients SIGNATURE SURVEYS: ‘Women in Arbitration’, ‘45 under 45", ‘Global Arbitration Review 100', ‘Rating the Venues’ INSTITUTION SURVEYS: focusing on a particular institution, including interviews with chief executives, and analysis of the arbitration bar in that seat CONCISE TECHNICAL FEATURES: covering specific areas of arbitral practice COLUMNS & DEVELOPMENTS: in brief, by special correspondents INTERVIEWS: leading arbitrators, institutional figures and key in-house counsel (COMMUNITY NEWS Freshfields, Clifford Chance and Herbert Smith prosper in partner elections 2007 Boroving vintage for new any oi Lando sh. In Eos, D'Agosino international arbtraton poriness, nnd sans fra cen net dates lowing vatious promotions Grea ow oe the Trace Bin Tuya Init yeor three of he biggest shops | pesos. Fad svecessul candidates during iow’ ens werk te gti acer flection, snd raed rouse indir Ao il fe ‘Grogs Pecos 3, ning he iy Cor Cha send internation aon ‘era Froils Beaute Dene Jin™ pares Mancow Jo Bessy ch Sr Diagn sat Here Seth ondTimr—goblbad often int it [Aolog Sx Chrd Chace Aitloe wes Me Aponino a Hebe Sth day bt fom Monto Agenino eve Lone tnd ‘ks na strep porn terry Beehey in addon NovhRobiny36inPiand)__ thr Camas finden Sets sd Une Pade, 3a Rome have been rmsd. Canal Eaope tobe pn Soci nk ncn et es each om Alen & Oy Znfconmercalubitton othe comme! preety our eppeon ta You wt | ‘Shere ects ney ems Hit hurr fr ht po e-T hat Frown pnb ower wok needa appened when IB eocunted Ges ‘Soong Tl ane he Repu of Els wel ergy ands eed, ‘i ating on the Bk empower [oberoler gob co-ca of Lathan ms aio, ‘
  • | wevreseny nt ‘Sree od ade mi Haren trek ond set aretaloge n he cttve ‘nacional jn Ga Ley ad Siistemmnet hinirgoncre | anbeny Si hele sntteenne | rar Ang Gl ol Mig Sinatra ‘Spey Ct ons hl ens | og al po US monn ‘Teng ne om he rio eet ‘USE enn ngcinedin chk fa | mince lg me eed Stove sain eee rie ne ‘Sovnr eta Gl Calton dt ‘Acockaoanbmd vrhoclaecie | Akaiag te ationon Gang Kon | tnd ne nd ger unde ese he raion Chane | ed cen neon singly tnd | Gh Cal Mn aor rin Sevmocesueslla StS enous | enable pec decopmnt an econ copay i arbst emer ange of owner th beer “The Enh High Cour ober at bth of | nv ten ce 18 en ig ihcrabwel owns othe Ane | whe Gag Kren apne mismpseon |G lof ema exis Te cay ao ‘ingor spronaoneminangtcirmce nd iten enide tend oe he | Sem Ce Seren SABMr fo alte eee Gxae_| Londen te pe chee dam ocks | Thc Rep of Aros signed 1 Me ere 208 hen SABMer tog Sash |e on ‘tr! ine Fay ser mcg bce Arona wing conan oar |"" Dan owl pro igh ls | Tmt ene Te sen rye own telangeonpinyBncosiSpercet | iLPaniemaketkencskl peony | eon bacmed ‘SverShavideeTi Reece Goxpich | contend ee prpa be wtAracl apie at ivan | dance ho decay wich | CASE. FOR GLOBAL GOLD MING ‘menos dogo ei ode ek | omen epee weus te | * Kang Sling LP Shbvieriueoow sued pong Ae | gate ef onto ee fe Pete Dik Bho fn Hon, Ken lagen Sot As Thetd na percon | Gaon” Fewer ttn nd soa de Conc ete reece ae lichen of Sdn ApS ‘Noon Meigs LEY Boop nero +t Sate cee Sout ASia) | fmm sbnten gran vhoae al Shere {a Ses owt) {in puceang commenti bach ote 5 loose QC ot i) Sotto tianrcksamebhe | Bangladesh fies aim over courts (Se ont oppo tengocetn lt hove enero sre couse FoR a OLA Cclgkintte noe whine | Fanncomapagesvsetantea ne Pros ny Nose Phe fered SEES cst ety Nos nonce comes rornonrsutaNcx anos | Gide Koonce wee pra asa Cane Fetus ‘Sih Sel Te Pop lof a Orca Ragen SO Ce Town ois Ch Chae Tai oad prong pe eq Soiccc See Ricid pbs Qe Ded Fon QC and | ab nar ny Baga ar Tow Ed Fn and al Fun in| Sogn Hoenn Londo rome se seg er coe + immed bpRaeph rents? | Senin rt an cous. Foe sasuise COUNSEL FOR GERUNG-KONTERN GENERAL het evan te USS2 ‘Daan Ch Pace eunence vce ain mage The SID Ber ‘cls Sen tn Pens Cou Chamba ecco sn) eur ina (Ghee How Jsin otey QC London ‘en wh dc ato mod de Snot owaeroe Whowiaoamckoy + “hme Runs Sines ge ee oon pte ate Reb Lah sl Gn Hin Sots phar noch hannaborg Investment Cases | Sontag tt? neem! nn TU eer oe decorator] ey seems ae ee sninjancdon| ca eee 2g herd oh om, Aueccutherckedoccutinvemert | eh Nnagege nie ge whch ering enlist ‘prize cimeitbecaueitvepsccta piv monn ning mo US ae| eat ef ca Ire sey one Eg oe ee wcey td ee ‘ened new ot UR out gra —_| aon spuae Amen ee mga | bing ppc pe bot ‘eto plains aerate Sean limsent_| Akin pn ened we et ten hin re mde BU Dap Wig, DC Tec ne ie he wtnson rnd. Nik Aus Cory Sd Re ee ee sassng tient | Recueil Bgl bl oo Gai Ke Covet anes Cog UR | oe re cata The gran | dpc cng ost ‘beckon sorting yw natonon | Sates nacre supe, | id pce eve ed Feld Leadon ope pain nermors US, Sefton the USA ed |The Fa Cour ft Sates J of Disk ace he oot igh OC tun ove we he preceding, rg an "When Rectang peel agin erent sf demande Sipe Cots a me ce yet dabei nce (Grek nero SID tan (Seine hes Seer (Ars) + Pip on Bene ee pps Toad Ani Cat Mog nM Penna Hosa QC Me Re ao She Hoan Diss ‘Were Mahara (ers) Rica Lama ih ame QC (UR) COUNSEL FOR SPER SPAINICC ARBRATON Fern Rater ae Rett (Gra Meg nf Ps Din oi + Nae Thy reno prs of opel de Ppa Couns FoR THE PORES REFUBLC OF 2 a Hin in Dik CAFTA claims are go Iho ver exon uae DRCAA eters (On 13 Mach, US nonanent company Rao spon Ger Not erat Crpnson of he We id wold be pong ato ean he [Brera of he Danan Rept Rand Dew ang poet by Rogen Alf snd Ee Romer af acne Ten Wangan DC Mino mone ofthe Stee DR-CAFTA | ees The ar eangny ena at {permet some of genie ‘aa bc een pene dng Icey te iy hx ge abo cd sp hs peo ental ck 97 rings rea, 10h he Gunman es sen dee dns on psa ove a ha tent and dling irene ae eg ck The ey fie dee bg pili th agin Vig who ren ih Rad Deepens "The pee i ke alice abe ioe ‘Shen nk Gon yf inde eapopion wl ws ee me ‘ns ced ed mond en "The DR-CAFTA doe recientes 2 chime owt itt of a fe “Sys meno ete ng ene ‘rae aye 19 dy Hang od ‘be nsec no we a Be ete ‘angry ca ose Under te ‘ems ISD res OSD Adal acy ‘oor UNCTTRAL on he ce ‘reenter te SID opts. Baaitin Rea yn ely organ ‘ere Repo Ton Capa of "te Wes et nuns UNCTTRAL eet opi te ovat ele ‘npr sedan ran of roy ‘comer wi connate chet Sygate ean snp ate ig comme Riad Sai seine wt Dominates armen lo srs th ese come 5s agp Wr need ay pe of caren capa The Doin Rep ne ‘ened US fr len Gate Sen Han ‘rat Carper fe Wer ea ast se nlon in amaps cong ons hr ing a the gre ha peed Intenso cag ai [COUNSLTOROC AND ERROVAS GUATEMALA Pare i Caso de Sia Georg Tg Scone ee Rep pees len Foe ad Rath Ee Ror Wagon, Nee: Reps gp wc US er hing ting of ORCCAFTA {CLAM AGAMST THE DOMINICAN EEUBUC EOS 1 RUST CORPORATION GFTHE WEST (CASES OF THE MONTH ‘Chay Ge Sen Hin LLP mer age hansen New | Ony tribunal consinted ‘A weuta har en constodh O's ‘aon aot iam cach re Rose of “Thee rg t eema | Cote ir Seon ane pa Wekingon. DC. ‘Theo res, Ostend Peet cagorion so Oc xan ad Prshcton Cnangbothofehe US hae somed Da Wie af Now oan er ied parce he spanned pcan he coh sie Bite Sr of Fer rte son aie Ye Foe Qe Cn prose fr ‘Thea campus ca he dain emer gly le: ero ih ‘expo den The exe ma peed yan. In Seber ot ee Cs ear ingest dan pane Ec ceed ol cmpay Pend Suess fai wh de ee ys ce ening we ning dd emery mpl bot wih attr ould be ‘srg er On peo fr pros ns andthe i roid ecg te ‘el hcl May Dai Wiis QC mls Free QC a teh edn thc ea Teta Mh Cm te "Ys Fare QC sien (Cr) Dasa QC ter Zain Ip Ser ane couse r0R occibeNALPROLEA CORPORATION AND OCCRENTAL BOLORATON ‘eum Caran Las Ab + Dawei nd Rang LLP tie Oct srry eed Maha bein Quite Briner to preside over Peru claim ‘ution solo cortct arm apne me Fepubte oP “The wed mpd Rober inet hae ad ‘See The pa as oy cosas 027 March Ae Ew ® Ra of Pr (CASES OF THE MONTH ‘hw way a lero Ge Tor, andi psy whe ty wc expe» Sle ‘ScdenceeammamicerDiguteri Whine | auborbet young ugh seemed | "es an- Chip Hoe i Pia DDG US compuy Agus Ene hs oman ageemencupht fl wha ups hela Kaen Seb ‘Wim Rovey Res Canaan nbc a3) | Sea Sco 78 slows arene covey | = Une ef a sey Se Cheon chara of Mane US wat om US ate Ptr Abin een Pe “Ts Repti of eb chomn Meson “aol as US ca ne pstnay teens Uzbekistan panels constituted sttirsor Cs on Wee oon Wer} Gham geen exe cmc In tov no esesare Uy Sou Resor senesfSvie! bees | smn om Newmont bing agar he Resse of hom. pen oe whund Hes pumer ac | Ober dreamers form ihe Sapene | nan mney Pen cat et ew Sachin Catto ppd over sre i ‘New Se in a eo Sed he ICSID mesons Apwts Engst USSD | unger Ona Gl ea | enol Cee fr Seen een ston an ly 06 The ce ‘iran atom ne oT Gd | Dept Who DC ee Seino dint rong misins Muang Campy The ogy oredr | eaopion of Teed ei Bt ‘eng a Po eey ene [ficrconme wah me-omed ning compa | ten bod te Afstesaa f be “Agunon Enc = ee i xlrsion, Ryne n 1 Ox Colla cuie | Sexton Caer of Comme lie 2 incon an wonseenon afl ed pe” | gen US wali elgg pra cim. | neve ese, Meats poner debe gems cenresan nade Rye Reyes ie Gld |” Tae SID ato, Newmont he Int dorson ef cect ou lemapnty Maing peng ence fr apd ting | apne Ma Lande oC The Repaic Sedelder US fem Dale Ege ch | et deo ated ais mine ee ‘Utsia apptaed Cheopher eee inan SI ato gine Pou Thereof eda 182 gr ppeet Genco fhe UK Ver oe aula atari teesmeGoomehrpemcmAcran sends ann ro AROTRAL PANEL ean lal Gal GB tt ied) Sori chap othe ul Newent Rober Bane pet Sean) Irene hm th ys Rep i te arses pen Schnee he US ile Row QC (na hence pated fom Ox Ons sere ‘Uta hace Jon Deshey othe + Chat son oboe ede) Tomei agar US led ouch Newt Man rein joe sine be Noreen Dart Geog ged wae wth to Usb oes 1952 RSE FOR AGUATTA ERGY Mts RZ mee comedic ear coer py an med Pinon he LLP ‘hee or oy nV ‘ue No an and rege Pre Li sil yas Mk ih Nl pacer Rb Ted ine of Ueki Newntwke# orth [es it Landon nd Eng Sern Howton Haley MeCly LLP us waiagon he | USHS0 aon Newt can iat he Ut Venti cup ta ner the| | gree experi! isa wont CONSE. FORTHE REPUBIC CFPERU ‘nw Gal dons dniy steric | Kangen rn Aros Newnan Tan Ea [emma non whe dace py | whew or ce he re co Pees Eke Frm Gam naa bg Thay cin FT| lye gen wm rg S&C LP ‘Sou became ele ont prt > pid ua Usk yy Newent Pts Cn Ln, Abby Cen Sy sth ie anand ote | Ea py {lfmuon Pon nWabpon.DC” Sure gery mated cancers ‘nerd cnt bon” ARSTRAL TRAUNALATICSO US allows 1782 request for SW eee pri UR) fnvestment case coms. FoR OWS GOLDIN THEUS Mactknke eam) Aigcaumdionrga Urinngcorpay | PROCEEONGS Giger Grerwaed UK) jekcoeumens arate temaus + Clit Chance Chan ruta nen lvosent baton fees fon Rech and Di Diarin | ARBIRALRELNAL A THESTOCCHOAM ‘Trecwerppem ote thf ocomn whch | Kings, DE hans ov Conner peancdrcuen The Near (Seti "Frc ied inn + Supe Sete (09 sib wy been Ora Gall agin | CLAN HX JACK BARBAREL ancy 8) {femme Repel wr UNCITRAL alr The|* Lover ee PC ‘oto finn & Con | Ay Dow Ely Now Jey ae ar er mg i ee cost in Now Jy pomed Ova eine er cion || ASTRAL PALL 2 Canon Bang LLP rnd OF SA ji athe se cout | Pemacn Orgone (Chie) |” Farner Thor let site ys conte’ i map ore goremgsuh | + Cae Bower (5) ‘sets Mapa pes Feo ite ‘iene Aube Spucpmer Cael | Rens Mine poy mc) Jinan Gatos singers De hune Londco sn cue! r Or Cld in feieson se [Thos deco rewards COUNSELFOR ONS GOLDIN HE ARSON. | COWS FORTHE REPIBIC OFUERSTAN Fctne US curbed ssn Dn Cid Ce 2 Date Pte LP Soyo aion Pe Atl Sheps London Paar Da Rian New "oe Rocher ed Chee ‘ce cord Be Lega ad \Wahngan,DC and cower Onn olin | COUNSELFOR TH KEG REPUBUC INTHE Naren kaon USpcrding em" Tie ju sped | ARSTRATON ‘iy Kanon oom ENERGY CHARTER TREATY POWER SURGE Claims under the Energy Charter Treaty are on the rise. David Samuel explores why aisha pic srt he contig fons eo te Sees | nd wag edge ap eed Seociccemy Upc —inyurviattpemee onthe | “hewn econ entices nore comiyt tet yector nhs Mine af Eg eed ey the | Eng Ges Tel nen ‘mane Noe Ean reel hw ioe arian fet o_| Teepe beat sherpa oa « ‘hal we psn Wood Theta dle we monger me Nya ng | tae was aero ee ccofhandy supp Titer ced | Scie planet deny | otronned gun who wee ees Temapirca pln mre | remanent npened tie | tng ea Tes ded ‘Sonoma Enc Chery tome tere! | Nyon ed teed sre “Turks mitesendin Lava cme | fname pce aps | et lithe meno chednee winds Cherny | wists ted fron meee | Ses te ee nt Theuioe'baindtadeepy C07 an | untgninpaane camer” | leat er capep pa Wig Sroecsh eng sto ado poniete” |" ane rye acdskophle | stra er ene ew cya a cal ee ont it mee a ean oe ‘ute rece Tae ere ar le pei nga bey ae coe Wh ey is sa ig nt Spee poke ttn enn ln incu pice nol oe ‘Sonn pnts te fr ‘ehtrabemal ots ml es Sittteteaetimyouermyes [No area of enterprise is | mich ee Minato how vy deemers _|:ls volatile as energy. With | Sgereebrorsmmetas Pee seri pon fr ng ire ey Iydececsy em abr icc money, polities, national Srovingie migrant inde guiete —|secUIrity, privitisation and | Rewwble sy cm oy mes 6p em Tk mile intinddewe mien (the environment all in | Sutlyanebant te eeste he e ef ot pred on open fom tse eva fe nena wit arag | Ca wed nee Secopnameflaremmp inde cap bee, |wvind up in litigation | srarapaaaee enn ene por Uinta foe pone rd (Sincerity ey Ay the mix, even allies can | {U8#66 ilion cubic feet pr near on avenge) oionly ita douke-secrcy wife | Lane depen dict ting the ‘ete for upzding oa ies, H hea. This sytem send war it fom eectrcny Tn Lerego mond opr he date Pn et the polonang Der" ifthe al proces coed the toder gute of Asc Rn toa ‘heme The ste conpny wed ut could Ica beer fier tot Lai Soni Ty deercy a anil tthe pce fore | amen i rt ihe ine she paver_—_| timation stn bt One) eed Rosse cose agree hl er igre aod he | ht te ote dg the er ee 0 pr ct "Te ofthe anal pce vised ce | pci i oui te dou hed been | finan he pes we: kang coe Lavin But one aening the worn o Bes, | tory pended | Siete hal Swed nn Nyame Sea "The Latin orranee was symp to |" Nye nthe oly camp: of he Ent ‘omer con! prpton cong hd she al power getaron ebel Laneneso | Chae Teay mer leis The ty Aisgnoricsass rt He thd bene witha ibet ower eqng 9 honour te hn pode he van wo awh ee pprecwer inl tenn 199 fl owner of te doale i Laven atc er oar | ons nd one on ra Nb ‘Wind ores jet epee won cr | by the nal cos ata Ponte Rigs Ree sary te date Forced proceed wh he abieaion, | Cor Bs rnin sa “The Lain ed bso ok the green de of wing ‘Ato goe i he wer a A Laneneg bine a court Nam Rowe, | rcs poise we theo | fhe recs a ted Sleds dm nse theEnny Charter Testy wat wt ing about he ENERGY CHARTER IKEANY of be Energy Charney ew i {nope The ean not al Behe meen yy DN ‘Nor sl pon = bts nw ty ‘So br anny gow peming ‘amici cored eer that he US enrhe o tb xspe 1991 te son of Rou aber he hen trast othe nly fe Sot peo ‘meen Union ie ring an yet th Ao hee teria fence he pont sti, sth net qt worked ‘Thebie om es profesor Thomas Wales The ey Cha Try a at on Canney thy ple nh option pc ‘nd ya as We ra ols ae anounced then ten ack, sia dled ~ plein Sth heen comprise pute {© tee ier in there ps itoring eee he Teh cen i gully” eee soi theron per eV Ene LLP ema he ay for lA Reno ipecal ear (Te Een ion er 207 page 7 The Rise of Ene ‘Chae Te Arba) Are omg ‘9 ost sone y nave of er ‘renber sat the petri ened pois 08 om ste, bog has en once ‘Stoll aber rele Ton an {ited by oe any at he bot ells ei decoy he car The nance fom the European Union Jogging?” | pratt ste The be of ur the ‘Fem yus ines ey onpeion nt | mr pt on» Keo ich a Bhs Ihe OECD wo crates weds way 00 | wt meen protean yt Eneray Carter | The prod of Kansan, Nunn {Reayifyu wil poed outta | Nace aw peg ed tora sere deed ‘reson on do sing pact cou” he "ote ed he ier Ken pont Re “Or mcs arne pin Ro aoe onc We se “ye penis ae Fans of the Energy Peseergirpewennpsane-tereinagl Charter Treaty view it as. | toe mena pach tmuened Ts a post-Cold War miracle. | Sinmngs vest acon Be eb” Ie would be impossible | seursaey iaon wih rion to engineer such an een pone econ gn agreement today, at least | Kamgrat micas in Europe Chr olor he eyo I pei ina le sc he might ober ot eed Sse eee they ei arr ‘jth oro pea hey guy tern de bien Yu can pe ou ae ‘ip ts sch Ras ed Nery The Een Cantera mgt were | te ier ie heyy al ee ce be sho hoped byw al pet opiate | mai orate Are 40) the ey the wey cneed fs Bal ot USSU 80. | cz ero ey nw hee he Navore ch » Rosa ey ned aact_| been wel wo clle ane vee om ‘auc They a et a yen aig il | lowe the ert be ete hs 2 die pois ging he hyo eleGnace. | ben acapned with an open af of tron, ‘Treetjee ern and paper wan | Asoure the contin nce ‘svc cought te NGO meee he | ee One of won ore cab a {ron doalcce nein cue chang) and_| "at Sherran& Sing ung prion Seton npn pti aya | pn nw rae Ran ob of TEx Soviet protectoratcs tht signed up ‘bligons reins 0 be seen A member of ec | ees See ean: Sinai | seca Se roa | ee eee ENERGY CHARTER TREATY es sonmi Geen |i | onde mnt tent over ecran [wise case 5] anoay reowwer | row ern Croa Poa | rowsate ates moro sneaeies [ice fuamreuglenamens|inesix | ussizratcn — |detim tramer [senate avoid | Meinacprrotng feroncanonatond |wonaword |rorvesaraurst |aaveatyttn near reo sonar cre Tones or scne oven [ees ern ons erweece [ptm ond ° free [pace cues |ipurteoonocona) lonchie hn str torr rarenonss [pond wosoraxy |e ce tah nd | orate wang ramacerantim eso — |catsone sectors ws. mon — | arctan | dgtan ay a reveal ere fmol” |taveradcien | oman an Seng ur |fomes horton agate Sopa ese Scge Gran] ones [wie caw Foe 3 Ivveenseae even! eden can aren rae cette ous _|senton now nome starey atng anal arctan totam icc |awtea ow Doms |rmetowon| usa ratinto [ante adr’ [atin * naman ve Trenvens” |reanemeramant — |ttoedare Cvane ‘orate Jona mown set evaretepste |osocm ran sree 4 Mectae UF eae a coer cats Jom congo on ya pope “aman ome med orn noma |e, a feemoeeiel 1 art Forcast Seer! faeecanencce [rae frmtewrce [anata aims [teemmstaapur [aneyoumn sent erates” Sinn mee” fee nments, owmmetiete, | (ectennaers se ees foe? [cee [emicoae [treme glee saad va Beran ao vw Perna ENERGY CHARTER IREATY 0s “coup hater eth son eomeroancpem [eso |rwrema Jaman tin anata nn neo ron Ce ‘oon cm tee [ota Beonarconscnnts [nares scree “| mest” [eros cae" [ssmnanexrnae Fontes fecowemrse mse ceentna fame mew even tans ce eemmocmmnse [ent lave senty fetmetns ¢ fect lenses froreti Sore — retary |e fooumemee [aearn|imcsemn — [omncrims —_ [amtowrar sere af eet | [emanate [acme freien | rccero Bt ime Saran |e acces Annan st | sceneries Camncomae eso umetmos orien fraemmm fom som mr en learner lacear [omwnetn” — (Stttmvemtene (ete pa on : Soccer [roe feo eruraa en sot attr ner (ence ee ScrnowtegSas” fret cen é SSmeiceancs fron non mito [pote a Saree retanenctt [eso [aware reine [oes pert rw en jceeresten| [cect come [irtainenes [Stesecnonn eeceasaranes| [Satara [ees mcrae ot |e eee ‘soho 8) se anaer | eparia Noe re hoos [Avoca Joovecth ca ed, [owen Pam panes, wo gon tecee crnmnt fesoan 707 vocab ce oman ore ee Average inne on sn eapsaon om cody sgremen at ive bc une way wth te conference of ‘eng firmer Bet ae pre of be venetian thigh ne the ste Ao Geel an attotoa The asin ‘cc deca if anion | ios des eye ey 190 Send he sei of yh ple ‘plas a BV btn an he wad tone "Al wea ie te ape ae pbc ain eure The pot eo pi sed, ‘ee am sted oats Seat che ‘ey in the os fre Soviet ae ekg ‘ht gratis Hs peepon at thy ‘und meting ecole sac aout the ne of reo ow =H pe of ‘coming mee ied Ul dy ad Bese compte! en rama he tay oe play ofa fo ‘he emergence of pecs The NAFTA + Th deloed i el cP ery CChirer Tet more comple Wale oes bs ‘Semetly sed r fesndigby 3om- ‘pect He ws ppd espe fr Nan tr, ove expert pian the Pe ed Plone ss nd eid on eel be tbe of prope capt Wie ‘Enpern Uni eee cer wath ore ‘final BU opel egy ees ‘thre th dee tse eng pone \Comen Wile"Many sion bane, ENERGY CHARTER TREATY sem eso nae in pra witht capri io EL ny ie “key th BU lnk bth be EU cory dee an the FU areas spect The EU Cisne ving es wth the ECT od cue i nee fs" Tone ace he ste commision had an cen come 6 ane mgr pone Puchae semen whoa fil compen, "The ton pes ou a th woe ‘neonate wih go under the Energy (Charen These he posal weap ‘eeen am EU infingeoes peeing aint = reubtor dt ar ace he ewe os tn eer champion, on the one and nd ‘bien unde de BCT on the teh “Abs of amen poate sae sheiy comes he tay ming of + rfetonal ott: Ano Sl ‘soci at Alen & Overy LLR ae eam Soke dace the ety wie pong std t Corie On eesig pe Psice be rained bir ang ts pst Thy ny hae 3 erry a Je Sadie wat one ome, ng (ath abo soning ie me oa speared nh bry oa eae 2 pay how erin prt wae saped ‘omc y which ate dlp fa eae ‘o nené the mec or fd the onience ‘Sra war anig che Tt te hobby bec of ey or pe eS Si fi conpaiy ith ay Tas ng soe in more ye” Adan be hese soit nm working cach af ery Char egy bed yd pet Fe orcsinn, rare ‘Dados pap Seen sch, fares ten Orey LE “Oppotinis ones pone fw te ep pfeon Shou youd sonthing a stein’ ip eh mt seme the he cet ICngesaie No en great ema on Se ‘Confer cu fr iso books {od jour Cat bo nd abe peso loin aan 0 he and ole whe as ow crac and meme he ck wean oye. tog Yoo confer he gan Why a oe Paddler? The a dingy wae dog daw in sor fr eng meting we ich "apucsiss poner de i ofthe ey Chane Tan He we he ne eu fe ssh under isco was the powe-eareson Ge [AES ABS UK biryani | hsaeenit owned in Hany wb {roca iy Ta oe cing ‘es pee owing changes inthe el de Te ocr ca ge png ‘propre basnor gue (lotnby sound ately oon ‘ogra de ach a angen poet Pcs pee at when agpomertes ‘eb the dl pati Aeon ho Se tee chang tthe mle he orm a0 AES fred prensa ben ‘atoning change of pveraner Sot mak ener exly sopping he emg ae ‘Alfio, apse concent itn inves ny Deen the U aod Ha “Th ih shore hs het spewed whe eng ea on heaton psn, ENERGY CHARTER TREATY jeton w Jorieon 30 0.0 “quran ate nonce) Nonna GARE TSE WRE bresirent colo “road” deri) opicton fou fompate cae ‘afm as cod pouty Bu led et jc an ey Bot ee en hg soy sont 82 ony ath ety = et nal poe oe Secon hd edn bain ate “And ed cof pole 20 er Al he dpm of ebionhes bes aly mt eat is ue mar eur nt er 20 you woul ee ecm So you ‘worth dt you mat be ing ome” Towa Sr eye lw en ‘itn option and cm onder ia ‘So re the cone ot ey bro. le to pei te [Eo mpporte ad enol the oe of ‘owang be Sop othe uc neon levee en be dpe pbc kp Noel er he ee ted ning ht “Jngch wo fae pho the x an ei ie ed The ye ia in oe pominat i he etre Tass Aa Jaga sl dong Eogy Carat “ey cme mor sd one ea ee He sind the memo wrote" pte” ss goeramens ing made ee ‘Soper the wen neni The ae 25 “It is pretty easy to get a top chairman right now to clear his schedule for an Energy Charter case. It’s something they all want to have on their cv" wr ct (hen thre eld eins aut). Ofthne eh da he a 26 ‘Became age be Iai ing fe are so to he ane FUSS bllon, USS billon sd eer {US80 blon pneromen re opening so ee spree ge Sever veel earywigt ition curs and given the thntne the te nde agg oop he "Te comp man the ey me fies eral pow compas no ‘Aion heey Fopng pin che ‘fort ecm wb wen he pal amr no mile sre epcing i ppear on ec Fling + (esppoidt Enegy Chars Teaty com The Se of ene mic Ye Foes, Berane Creme, Dard Wills QC and Michal any SC ge epen Scheel t-pain irr ae Chats Brower, Mac Isard QC a in Paton. ry ph we [vsti ty al wat aon te CX Rev tor os ben py othe polmmen proces on hee cat, by dae ‘Hanatener Suan He sy abi e Sec en ih aks wining ‘nelly calenging and» be diet” Pen ay enn ca Many re have reel tate eral ater ‘repragan Enc Chae Tey co 00 teaches Then ere ee fd Fenestra te ned rot thd cc sgpler UAS he cn ng, ty oe he a ein conto pet "Gang mch cas othe ea Fopuhoo, Without high-paying Resin bos eth mhs the nner of cine woul be ‘en hig Afer tenet ne of ces ‘Shas why, een edhe ane bewon owe qnion ened ne eonne” ona wee I bled epi enlrence eet Een Chater ‘ed won, which ws Rel Sk ‘aWatingen DC ono ew Sepen gc oe ms engi oa rer tee sn ENERGY CHARTER TREATY pcr "Showsng thn sce copy comes cece enantio proce the Free ‘Sh rdependce wo ind they Torin eon npr conor IME Ihab cae they eed he exper ‘Tht natn sea teed of ee oth dele ean ope I ‘mfr ate ge poe parca pss ron une ih AES. “Fecal RB EON- Rota, Ei ENEL and (CoeseUS, RUE (Geman and EOBW/ WH {Geran ing aga on anche nd king money parading he ve ud hehe he cdo lh The ll poplin en ens ping rads the Hickout oben captucd n» Helywvo H Fo Top The film bills itself'as “corruption, assassination and rioting over electricity in the fo-mer Soviet Republic of Georgia” naan a ting oe eric me eer ove Repl f Goo [| aloe, th th elecry ev che wha red a by pore chao: Devin Sed hued alsing ir sew deiner a pron ped by | ‘onep of wina eaing pet chewing | ek fo epithe aero lb | fest satcon snd AES sige oleae | th tack The estos we yey bee | Sey hey rece pone ig | techni The inter oreng sper sit tnthe Grogan make Las dough, they sf Reson compay UAS Te ae ‘Fenpoplr eee eats Reon ver ele Eurin ok toe ees iw FON Regn ENN th secwed the compan of ang Baga oF | Sette sr eine ope In Seb cere bem ean point | hs jar Talo owe or law taper sponte of ciate pene combine) i: espn 4 3 « 2 q I or Fee wee eotisoa ve ~~ ENERGY CHARTER TREATY edhe BOT seri» itn in it gh? ‘ht cata ote ni Sic ot asnelaeotin er MAA “te. wnhAP ted etme, cain oun eh emery of Sot eptoeremiy i Bera Macedon ok he ae shut esting sound Shope ike, mina coi pn the ‘iy aterm Pae eati oere er ‘ripened by AESY ot fom Cop send te bammeneen wh hw coed ‘Seebuines. In he coud fence "Cm Raley Con Un, Sia Barr athe poy are In jne 2 the Tor over pele maar ont doce pas ed by Skt ln Te ponrbea ope hen, Sic ad wie ing compensioa The tna pa of Cam ion a TIME magpie ‘Not fs Bones Ac Uy Ate Bs Gy 2 ~ Ue athe grant ‘Sed te banner ene Ge Pay (he Yong ay) wor mang ene ells ne pot Un he wl ing igh ice te,» roof schol orm Sad Enry Carer rey arom ng to tee cn Wau he Ener Charter Treaty eer the Cypriot ompary moe Patt cmpeier wold ve a tre -nberaion on Pol sn Tae ne at ‘Sneed eine eg Terk doce outce oewihhe ECT" coment et Tefen no er ey ai Sed Merson sera er ep see brea he mn fon Bsn Morr hn ce wos agen fr OSEA2 ‘lion The money ec an fmt Moro, rein the Eup Us The {Uncon Hsu Eanes Ser elie esas om Soni cing the [aumento be on por wath Sneath rome Sc Sper id wk (Cra pe ab dt ‘SEU entrap Te to nto be been Ide inser of dps nce hey fee deen in 1991-The get ie gees ne bere Tuc te cent examples othe neyo fend he dposese yon re the be ‘Shine Thessedon eto mn alue ‘ic wally reprint conten of former ‘han Nha Kooy plead iio wor Alo ee ie Erol bl Kbotaondy ese Vii a Yr able meu te tere Yk cosh oop Unftanty ot shbolen ey re doen eos se of Man a {Capes Te mos thm oe he Ent ‘Chane ra: Fi hugh hey he 0 eh prone af dps egies proce le seer three ‘leis. our parca emerge he ‘ten pinal append he dof cine ve ed bre ston ‘ear el hs a of abe Thy would Ske the ey colle an eo gin bot avig ar har on ter can ght be Re a ied Clery Got Sen le ppinl jd Supe Schobel ‘bora ee ces cord ese Tike hs apsine Pols {ed ap ioe he Ur mg Aeon ‘Soe ve hae Alen ar Grey LLP Some ‘noe Bn iy no nea mek ‘tome o the pov ant cn of pone an ie rer eucting pil aca t, te aps bent teen npc" oly pe Seem oxi i eat aw rms with experene unde he ‘mp ofthe dcoment the ae Ens Cares Tey ek cod who 2 raya tay Bosh groupe are ha Ere fie how sn ewes wl become xsi tha The ey ou they bce these for cont ps igen ‘sshd Tat oom depen on he mts thine ich he ore cut —he ‘Beory dat ay teachf ipion nen gm The getaned Ihe we singy on pl ening They tk Flic we Shoe Chobe of Comat Serine by eters of he sou i Spey tod ot 0 we og (Greer hey prac wad gc) {iyo being ingest pceedige ‘Bempion, Rca Spon ice he wah ‘ey and EU bach ore Seay on bs ee dea Theo ‘Sh woul he own he ment of he ‘eon pc doa wl be xy pec pls on a Eig pi {he gmc? Mabe inp The Roe vc or ese apy 0 Segre ge rastnown mance Ser yer red rn Ri ‘att cos per pane twee ‘ering we i Earp bt tout lena wero be cht by peso) ‘operon Seed ove bean encoueig FNFRGY CHARTFR TREATY. i es deh pat tome nnaten overenest me ely encom tate spnie 0 Inauseng ly alam mane eggs agrcance linae ~tes boca outa curir a bah eel met Re igh onda he [Cthoreceenen sation varied rretan e at ie ea| tare cpp fetes pe 0 ine com ero ar gee ‘heh hal enc ih a rack {Non Hy hw ao brn aod “nee Enresig4 word ed by Presers Naal aye a Kan Het ha been resin press on Psa ets A lw eo Stara Apeent ory fro Sn Kanon Nes settee new | ier tnt The lw ppd Soca bt he ope of harder | Stebel by on aa hry tng rect in Robt oH BCE val presi in he comer Bathe oi fr ae ore ry han termes a wting theme ot of ew ero 3 jr wo ke unemployed le Songer fe eceponl probe hyve ye in cet yr Een be US he ‘ntonry hs ee! prea ie ik oe ‘ony hh wl ae ce rec in usar ber ll Nera woul ve Become pc wth [AGI the campy mmge seine fat psn te a cen pros ink Roa wat ed Bown by ‘Shou come wih can cen” ue be ery pid ey went her Tepe oo Them ing might charge For mw nap th Energy Care ‘ry ok Big ep ndey end snd ns eis. ENERGY CHARTER TREATY GATEWAYS TO THE ENERGY CHARTER TREATY Stephen Jagusch, partner, and Anthony Sinclair, associate, of the international arbitration group at Allen & Overy LLP address the notions of investment and investors that exist in the ECT x th bt i oo ci, | san edn he Np ae. | oie ee penn which she nae pr gr ofc Tir cny es evn in | Cysts or ese “rns cng fom ecn ue>| cpl n sorbate ape th poco at wold ney he ar En The po conf aksan | Wat Conasing he aed a WY incseneesintmat tom item po yer | eo gr tr oe ‘elyilewity sire person | saben ning Bath oops Suh an enor fx comrcing pet ty Ral cougy eerste | Carnmuacn en concn pean cre tee ey ad ns have eee Neng Eno the wri get induery | epee at theory. yet in pore of || n excel cumstances al eine ‘cour Gran apeninat sonal grt | bonged ini owe me, Clery dew oe_| Bom cnpegin kre epost SEUSSIH lion Some 80 percent of ote como de European Commoner, wuld ee hee arora recat we detonate enten_| that premnn a esor “agian eal ote et sheen star (Acuna Eupean Commision baw cscommercal oot susan with {The Eno Caer Tey the mom th poet ofa energy sees nd the curry who Ls xe. This sigan reroll ions he |ayetene Vole be nai of peeten | tonto qulietan tere) proeetea Promaon sl pooner memento foc eso inthe ery | rok cured o sowing xe {The fandnce wim of te ea derby | Chur Tey. Dot lg compey ane ening US the Secret ht ene the Energy Chet” Ar ithnwtinentotecion weaier | Shablder saa 0 bing esd {Cote ple body dia gt ne | genedinewn bee pew moquenens | cing at tse Sapte in» tothe Eng Cherian) to epics tbe me i re 0 ey andere ue lesb ek therefrom ney tne. by cetngsprcton of te Energy Charter Tay ine tates The Eng Chae Tey ay Vel pling ded ofr tobe ore by al the dine mu uy aan inves ands | cmd pesto oeery Kin eon Fcsingspcrarent ho minimising he scod the apa atl ane | Second dey ney a eg ‘aks mucacd wah enegemedkweonenn sin the ening of hve tema we athe | whee cone fe "Undeing ears ‘eapThe pry fhr ance cosh vt” | nol ty he Expy aster Conon th Arthe at ofthe ty se chipeson_ the ane oi facet mera | recs ack I). thee econ ‘he enya ang with dpe anion inthe who (whore spenonand the what” "Tes osu the, se hapa peta dap bereeh ine a wc an eat ret lorcet The eon rece Imran ep pices cy (recon poison ow o icing thei | sions relesonl sy empairon o Be Eccl nips enemy cnpae in accor Ueto who may ee foe be reson | tu canal nea acter ‘tere cpl entr and angst Egy Chater Tay uy bee | coo ew ince tin pesto ‘alo pl poss Antu pon who | ne te neg Charro how fenyguafy i anomenor under ehe ey | Dorris pee ab Ey Cr ‘eshing cg an oro hc prt | puna ENO alpen | Tey cam ece > pe a in Gx wl a he conning partes tobe dope | eng tecaeahip cnaty af cwhe | potent cis unde spe ots ad Sng ont rosie f the vonmimons in peering it Contncing so ite estat eo). One iar Fru of be comic pov agesd Pury corde mt app lan'The | he A a ca, pel cone rimmed dp otc cca, brah ofthe deidon cb Eating | cot soc mates pling oe 2 otepoeromted ations fur lt of ster othe vs wi rma castes | potuon pace maj sect os tesaranve andor eigenen mater of ina oe poche worn othe pee ey ha wo poset atiwonenn | athe poducan fad ofa or | wohl ek oe oping roron ofthe wey nobly prmasnt ee oan eras “he cg Chater Tony fons howe desler 22 sd 25 hich cl or aerence >|" wat ae mor commen lp fesem In contin a rms ht pena guy dhe ‘Bee by goer oc esypivnged | deermiain se natonaly orp etn, sapere nee of Easy Chater Tea cer an ple ton abo |e prea svat eater eo dope clas by race o + urpres srs Prec conn tesnentoiowermcnm'c | nef the nl e ofeporaenteany sent conation thie win wc only incon oan alkged each ofan lice ofimerorson ora company se sus) eiincrprted Ari 170) dh he ction wou in It esos nel he nemo Cor afurce | spece qn of wheter sha at may ‘wo confined by the it Eatay Chater Treaty theme sposch i arcle IG. which | to Reg dimes rw othe ENERGY CHARTER TREATY I ote wean A mite compey ey be esrb a egal ety ope inane ‘he e's conractng ry b wic St whch owed or ona by morale 1 Bai hse ede on he pon nds ore 10) In dace ww fe wl sy cones soe ‘he appeton of ele 7) ed oy ‘sce aight xd proeon or ch Ses ee Reogusing hi aie 27 of the Ener Charter Tey sep a eens ‘clio ound a re 25050) ate ICSID Connon anes 3 coma ate orf, roid the haste ae eced owe trio beout reign The Eerey Chae ety coins dion uti ina pec Bel of mene (nr poteiy mor exenae a a ‘ator poral etn pono sd Potein wen The only oben ouaieion Ntsc aoa be ono wh “The Uneraning to ce I) noe by he ty hrs Cm oe seco Thaw stent the xploon ‘Suton ang, pohcton, ergs Secoominonng hl nen ran stl se proce Eom ei so roduc ar wih cen pie expo, Sed san acer cnr cor, evel sl pseu pod cecal ‘peng imesnent tthe o nd e Te actoumed sen Albnogh pas di {ne ore oer se ang eo dpe {re cece io use oe). hea ‘yy eect nein (on) "Acofng ae 16) moms 0 wh he egy Chae ey spe ey nf nt The he los» rome li of eng of angie ad mange se yw orem. “Thi was deed bythe ns ua comings bal noe of Ios word Arce i) cot a tex ay psecon Th ee ‘ren ion ng geen vl ‘Slecquenty ape to ect ete ‘in he faceoff wear om he proton ofthe Energy Che “Ten teed the eect) at oti the con paragraph fale 16, Tis hee] eer oh te ey no {ore of i Tey for the Conraing Pay of {pple only eae cng meen er The definition of investment is probably at its broadest where it refers to “claims to money and claims to performance pursuant to contract having an economic value and associated with an Investment” The Eargy Charter Ty ein of nwt sb bros whee iran oa ac ed ci wo [necro nd socal wis Ieee” (ace 1) el "any ah iy eon oy Sete rl 160). “Toe provisos hve een consid the tn Poet Ll Pe Rye Rei onion nthe ayo guy = moe [Repti tern etre oneal gh ‘tera deery conc cin to moey {e-payment anemia hd been cone by olen of he Bie ora The cnt end at Peat soul diet ayo ety KEM sd ad ged ome of the goo ‘Toe aera! wn ck ong th hs oman in nen mae tha ‘tical el fer ert th Cac (no nae any sur of mney o prope ‘captains bao nthe Kye Repu Sarwar conmce Keowee the of Bat ering th wh of ace 116) te ody mening he ht fhe rey het prose i el ‘heigl cont and contend In eiecom plgner comes see ging in imeuneat wis te mening of ere HO ae The deco ane ay eld oy de Ses Cou of Appa Inshore ‘Prosar omen cde panne or (pander dered ar ate nde tutonomou ent othe messing oF tem oo ef ese 1 oat ‘thch shold ix fe onde rl cee ee ha ea NAFTA apy xe fom he don ‘ie ogc osetia ye SID ‘eso ne ced a le Sgt aan nese nt eh TCSID ‘stout ion ning to eh to ‘nthe round tate a ment cute ‘apled my be ob th a emerging sd fetonomoan meaning fhe ee eer ‘Sein the FCSID Comenton Asem of” tea certain duion adn execation ‘fea ema «tnt comment ed eta not cn eto te deen “Iesoen occ cn fr IID pele 10 evap hed epi noon fh tern at ip pres owed in nero atic a lent some ICID erate th nc cn ony note ata ancy op ‘nd bjt gue tof econ ENERGY CHARTER TREATY Q&A WITH GRAHAM COOP Graham Coop is general counsel of the Energy Caster Secretariat. Here he discusses its role, including the tracking of investor-state arbitrations under the ECT. He and colleagues explain how the charter’ constituency may enlarge — 5 hp \Whot fs your bockaround exp ounces ened othe cu T then | pis a peopl con nd ree Te opin New Zed wher Ftoks coe enon coue who se eon esto | fs esi some eek Coco MI solimatdege ore by ssw depend" | comr won snarl als | they a frog sou et ce he we tee oro pace with ane New Zand. |" Weko hve sem cont wit te ewes | en be mre hp a deting em te famed Gn Then moved Fused | ad there rent wbo come wo | pac orang oe Most ined Fils worked afr 0 yan | our ween gon Unig rman, | Come quate cope el we way ‘hic revere ene wocing th on Pion |e nai se caren caer wich | anges ous He tn ou wuld GeaGa'qemnmoinermonal Bintan” | ame ee icv curate When | Gon ape The Fee ow mateo fiche nh own Barge How offen have you found youset Sn en seen Bevin wring partner roceniy? Fre tec od of heey nd at cy couple of ee, Unni scone ‘ruc poop fr Feels Pi oe ad ‘Sietago ue over at ney fee Scoot ay auexon sor ioaotntjanea |W are quite happy to be |" Demo Speia Londo xapieserwid ised ag a sparring partner | sltlaxgetron the claimant se 0 ore ‘the every and fsratoe deparonent ‘P SP repponcenis’ counsel a60 aeceping the ‘fepecmpeace sees lif they want to come and | Sirorieoacet i reulaa eaters ane talk about the arguments | **>** eel fom both sae. teu aol laeperae, [they plan to run st mastbetcntng Stecifmeartendenmh tices |) ty kee mln mod isa sr ek seth nse nan Sigeentunametes tay ory | dims rd coeaae ore LhStaseaton RomUaechae me lth a soci pan fhe rcv ne seca and 08, Estee crlnon Sel wo nk ‘En Chesed, | ecg el gh neat ne | urge waa cn onset esse Ssiocntotinpcliccy trie” |misitestcreettligy wiketso | berg tation Devwesn Egerton wy | af eg ey a toca ce? plaice nates pe et Itasca deci en Sitonteetancta ead atr | tusy "encourage" —wtotise | wasn se pate Socotra {bidet ancouetingonyos you |S ms rst may pet "neta ewer tine |g waSSpge crv ens eens iret Thee” Oot at egy teed | Soca el eieitinrae my apes tucesy |etyeingpinae vty etocone” | fede esr sh oe Eaaiercrkeesiomsrcem sin ake ermene hyping | necticut ye Bonerama /pmartermigeess | Beata tensa ad Nevertheless, does the Secretariat track | might react Bur we can only realy do chat ‘You have to be usted not ro pass om the secret SORRSTLSRR attire [pay emahsertntare cme | elon iperer cose we fone Thedgtventeaijernmeti | wncont bps ene ke Neve docomidrit prt of ourresponsly so | Sue Iason meat tte tnx Seon ele won a ang ede Joe ENERGY CHARIER TREATY Wed ie the eo eae bt whet edo io te weg ert, Teak to some inhouse counsel who ‘wot Tor mejor ol companies ney ‘Sppecr shal soy, uisteresed By the weary, One noua Courat imaor olf] cs eon of ne reat ‘Sr poltica| ochiovement and saw I ow oi ineresing os pat oe ik Iansgement londketpa” ul for ff bang relevant oie dota Soy Heme slat wa, He Took he viow ‘nal stem woud woysbe able to ragotinte ashonae" st of protections ‘rechy with aor! stole. hat ctite ‘ypicat bins c realy at sof geatest IBlevence fo smaler companies ond tentepreneus? srg aba and doa. Hing the ove jon nyse. inp, why 99 saree? ‘sare eat ct Fh ay Turing to he member sors, now wet informed avout he ru and bot of te eat or. soy. he micitvel ici in the minsties or pstces sc ints oy nt ey wel formed =n the epg The ey fallow = wet eto be oe ort ‘ofenoce Sane andthe meting fe oning groupe Thy ae que we ered ‘rople of oune ste tt red on the ‘Sy ml infor el cay somes * repo bt that at hy bone te ‘peste need De yu pay any educational, when Fer eign Ta, pn Sonera doe sone ‘ove ede an face Series teoman a och pi fom Woud tne Secretatit ever ogre to fhe.on amicus btn on ECT bared ftiroton® Tienes raiocde ones [ETAT Wn tee i arcee eorranticact cir IF che member states were to give us express permission to provide amicus briefs, then I personally would welcome such a development Second an irl trl wich ess sented aude os dapat mii I intr be se to spond poses tnprsiy beeen he tes So fee mit ‘anger beset lp chil egcon ‘er ecoming ied atmo pled ‘shower our ee sa might mo tekone or pong scree, Fate what we we goings foun he gunn eg ade the "On the ete indie member se vereto gem ee prmiaon pone ithe mined" one of ‘he eons wy you Reet {pony wo weicone ch» dopant wold i pct tener ord Snr tink, thong hte ember tr ‘he near fre que de pe it ‘etn me expen sen fom How about. ina particu care, both ‘he vestr en the ropondent stale {gave het exoress permsion for he Secretariat to le an omicus bot? “Thr wood eure a elo il chjecon tne on our deny of parity cr ater ember at mt ic these wcrc we hd ayo the poe Iberpeatone might cnn th rt tier dept in wha hey ge become Soybdine ie 1 Sk woh i pubic nerpotoins onthe meaning ot parts of he tectye td eo exeption Te it relly nly one ierpreton a ew ie ‘Sppsced by common tee We a pe on thon Secon ca reso widen | pic mito soues poo of the Sale in dt he ey preven ‘members Eom cing 9 pe fp {the mile of pce peso Cone: the Rasa Fea Si reel ths drs depute eh Ube our 2006 a a Ro ct 0 rythe een beret pnt at esd amt torn neg pes Thi wee foe tes ce. sheen onan pr ding ‘pee with peice apa ender entsy ‘ply conc ceri dow nt cain apy cette orn hd), Sond, Capron py conte Ssh Slog eed on 31 December 200, {db ino pipe of rat (i the way a when poi 1 conus upping Gling te enpry ‘non-linear doer ae ton Cinder nile afte tena de trot proviso ea fhe ean of ee ‘hin nore decd ‘You mentioned the rovaue préparatekes der the avout Yorandicu amor done Abe ramber of acre the pp ete ed ‘indexed yr We a ach woking Isthe recly an instument that con keep pave ith changing tends ond the Few ogardast For exampe, hs yor Bumword e earboreneuta ‘The ny dow el th ener icky ENERGY CHARTER TREATY snd ted event pea Ines nore del ned an ae io ote raion ern ay by iste Scr at change very ay On he ‘amendmen Or ty oad dean nino termite ot pe rahe pd verion As ext the tering tea lie wth the WTO. ey Ts amendee wl come no ee What ar the chances of Ruslan Te ery eu cl. We He Rat "We ok hat itn Row lng bene ti et eng in ene, Om tbe ther ha hese se cer pol comme rents Rani choos ae a the ony suc fe rhe ay ow closely does the Secretarat rack poltcolievel disagreements between ember satese Ie depend oe eof agree on 2 Noga on 3 ony Ine yr ding he tren The Seti abo pi de ateson a Bebrw od eae apne Se se Healy hos mace bean the bulking oh common vocabulary regarsn3 investment eso enaing even {hase who choose To pagotiote cect protection fohave a ler negofation? seer eal become pb sw ‘tv Thwe tarp tine Atavus wi tbe ea Way ci the US decide agaist sgringt “Thins brn pce wp The oil tr commgh in culing Sacco tod io np in pet pen ‘You have ed werk on ‘mode greements Have these boon ‘Completed, ond whien might hey be eaopedt Fh ol men i wt the won of dwping Tat Prot oat ‘noel ements th cov bee ay {ios-borde ol nd pple poet So he ‘Stet has ee ing ti frst sok yon, tpeomcm fo weve conte dooping If for understandable political or commercial reasons Russia chooses not to ratify, the treaty will stil exist. Russian ratification is not the only source of life for the treaty ‘ner 208 tend maemo to Tel Adsory ek ces grup af er dhe orm ndury a protec ‘elutes = and we wl bcs ein {© the conten pray ah od a se ‘Weave pce de ne Erwcen ich ind ead ther kg he me pj So the pene et code of betpcc rs ‘Songun Ta chen apc tb tesco eo nl be mee Sm fed dei eon, The teat, because of ts geogrophic Scope, ros the pass hat lament coud in tect ing avert lime flation to te samme se fact Difarntelaments win th of Corporate family coud each bing @ ‘Salm. Hos the Seeretait ven aught {ote posibity of contodietory ection? ‘neti in ere de oe ibe ‘nveamot ay comes in exile the ne ol CUE ep ‘Rep det aul bo appear the ECT Cee deerme» ny {ete ane can each be doe Whyrn the ex! two yoars hove more Tek mye ence py 2p fhe ih {he [elec dao En Chee “reay aa mabe theres omehing our pin sou ewes bang ioe ie? Neel ying they spy pe Altes at ty shoul even ace ‘Ble he casey pic ye ‘er of oes Teal estan wet ne ew Profedstaound ess ye Tht wold troy Weve tad 13 crn 1 es Tha ‘tog ht be aay enor cny The one cea where he Secreotat nos ton expla oversght oe in cipues ficle tole wpitaton. ere have been fo eases of hot type yl, have hee, {rough been any necr mises? ‘e FUTURE MEMBERSHIP OF THE [Baer ote ht poi, Cop) collages ‘ie darn ‘Ne here ony state accessions inthe Pipeline Pesan lana taco pret nd Pan hr score expecting hppa the em PY ‘Ngan sce aceon sod Ie timportant oe tire meer howe bes no! ony obsevers, bul active [Eartha Os dlr pre Wh Seti ec Gece oo 1 _croeies te ee g rea ay eh th ithe Beene wl hve bc dg tor Alghoniton. where wil you cm at eo da With Apnian woe pa and Is the Sit on tecrting. hen, purely your ineitonol copay 9 eat [| he Ke Reps mata Be “ay nt dein om rin he Hana | a ier Ther wl wy be ote dn Aone Da te Ea ‘rb taste conor imoke he canal | bana igh andr cna tcl, Soas dpe ow se can ely ‘een dae i ace 7 reerpetty | camaynkenaonal vada ne cary | Ye acaged i ple ep ps oh to den eigen The nal | rl vammen em Al ew rig depend on rene ight aetna ‘rent fir hen sugested toy | sole ape in dem with purl ena aan sonal ow Ale 26 ‘ppliatan fae 7 won erate only | Ene Chacer ay ‘reds yo ap cones eed ‘lth rement ial ha been me, “The che af rite rams inj at_—_| eth bythe i he Exergy eee ny onary conn woul df che | pore An mer wl fa edie | Chaerteay,May ee cs hte ned, leis expenses, tween pring meron titan uner | nthe dsiion ene cm aden Te Pn decison howe wo stinng | the ney Chae Tramps lores | onl onc end ey cin Those inepetin of he Eneay Chae Trey and wey ora nee covet Te er may | den send old ot che tuba Taher toa coll we afew vw | done sigh uns Somer wt igae| of saci dau oe Jone cour Poe heres op ver ngs "mbox’ | eon core ening nd png fs har sae ob So ating» ey ‘oman er Ecey Chae Tay prison | fe cer ote aut cet dcop | boc dm om eral bl bert ‘bout hina wien comin fm he | sce dapat oon sey | thew dtr ce Sonu ple ete atl ace micle 0 deny | "Tar eanglg ont onconmon fran | Aci Cop Te dene Rep SID eve ENERGY CHARTER TREATY Desember 2,4 126200), Under th ‘ody ofc the finches ae ‘sl rsh fh ay pled 1B fran (For nr enn Uo Sone Depts Reston nde te Ene {hare re Which Fo? Whih Ron Podinghore Meaty ep cn 19 Na + pag 34 04), Spee frig» weeny ving eed the suc ofp igh (Cher Tey ci lr er oe Weimer beep nai poste hte peo okie ‘Simple tener gh dee 9 ir atom or contac won Te a {ony ot deny comet br teemece or ile damage Sg oe an Tiere ode ne egy Charter Tan retreat ag hme pce ton rome tect any atemp to git ola expel the ney Chere which vould ae Armee ceding othe preva union rede ver fom trig gain 9 Iaer pont The Ener Cher Tey so Ah vops fy the nonce rater ch 1 wae“ right inate or eomtiue Belo ‘oct ny poseringh p die tesa ofthe dung Pay hat alee tes teach of NAFTA Chap) ay pny lp ter expe the ‘atten bt mig lbs beh font ‘Newer, ipl preceding ey Inte 269)9)0) om of ep eee the hose nore ia nae ID beiag Energy Cher Teay cir oe bor robe abarion comme part Plc te tetoed a dee Terme lene ding on sn hse och fect eiborls anae of Se onde pt i ofthe Egy Chere Forums Ean here ww ech of concedes ht by he ae oul The Petrobart tribunal explicitly rejected any attempt to graft 2 collateral estoppel principle into the text of article 26 feces aaa of erp chins ders 13 ofthe Ener Caer Tey oF nvcmea sped by bth oe Eoeey ‘Soul btn etme ey a a eran timer en dee oar ponding theme ol Ge done ne Energy Chane Tete ot Cour Lit Bape and Reps Goh, "Thi agptch he Bence conieny td egy Aten ver might leo hve he ten his Her swe ah ie om ad oh pce ay teste gol ows te dpe one to incde ts Enensy Charter Tey ‘Shir wan dei gio pushy ‘the ino hooves oie ia he bw te eines he ty hs Ben incorpo espe dey by cor Ts goin ‘font nin ch Energy Chanter Toy onc uty Eves the bomee ge ‘tee = whe fr cage he lovee comer ees with he at nrg Cater in i be shed a se ied ba eno eo onc Tes pes chee burl we ese ot comma nd wey cine i ies ie chae of rete oomes sol nett pong ier ey onanon The mae una ence fr bing [Eery Cte Tey ci commence 2 ey-bd hen aph coent Th i ope aie 249) gee a ange of opto fo sch Eaey Char “Tewy ipa ety deed nour en the dpe dogh 2 prooy greed ‘echanino racommon) se ‘hough te ICSD rte ata Sede the SID Aor! acy ale, ‘Kua eam of eh ston 8 bond Ie chet: Never we pm 2 ‘este only where the ndoiy a bet one tern in ace eID ren Rosh ae ‘ened eo he te te ops, {Carer Tey snow one ena Inde eon see Nee runeat Con to bet of tater aa ent the pectin tanh nemo arian. Bure ly to mating ce nc the ney Che Tay otal pling. ‘shor smtrng he itil ements ‘ep ICSID AND AD IOC COMPARED. COMPARING ICSID AND AD HOC TREATY ARBITRATION: WILL CHANGES IN ICSID SENIOR MANAGEMENT SPUR CHANGES? A new survey comparing ICSID rules with others shows room for improvement for the Washington centre. Barry Appleton, of Appleton & Associates Ineernational Lawyers, explains the research. smo ns den ates he | San cia i on | hg hee Peg eTenimen | nied St tito ta | Rae sr gh in en aertan oma ace | a pone von eng sprae| a SI cme ek ee eee imc Sense can pcmeon, | ewe bee en hd cata te Thaw auerpang ames | TID cee we os te pe Ss 2am eer aoe wb pcen_| wd it ntcnon pcs tdethe |e ie thet Tra Sevens gol emed o'oet 200) blued | CRD comenon Inston cious oft |Incoupnn rein epson sen Semin canes) wasn iat eee” | Matin oe a eh Siceccinaentarmatictas, | qoukrinontip ita preneegs we | session sc aoe ici amdesusieswrse | Zeneumeestatcn face ste sats pcs WincimdouecapetiyacUaes” | Sasi Ucppthapoae Thine See scape conten scone Rago rion co | UREA tc SSirinsecemntthGmerete — [mupaneetonkteenac eepeer | Sam age ane Soingircopchenrh targa aw | Semicon ascarid” | Srubtee rene Se soe ‘cmon ue oe hve aid de of Siow te pr‘ ett the eoie 3 LL ern Ree nh eho fit et ‘Be ICID op emege + owe opr aes pel alia SESS eens mame RIN percet of epost ety Ce iesin- 835% at ofl mpl of 273 repel erent dere 1S ‘Sion decided 1 sete UNCTTRAL ‘hea least ube ot of tooo an I UNCTTRAL cain) wer donee by ini) ICSID ater UNCITRAL rly Of a poe Seer omnea rl etme ety st 99 po cone Se oF | "PD repo brain i) he been | mICSID AF 8.00% BUNGTRALS 90% ICSID AND AD HOC COMPARED. gute 2:1CSID rginasin~ average dime 76 dye Ma st pang 187 SG» Ft (ir awed arquagap 8) anne Hae gg (HL 389461 jricon sterson ‘a Rough ew SID etal ave foun onary ew any wil ete Thesis le mere un ‘Tsininon tn 3 pre condon 1 ‘esiaton [or more om hse Mins ‘Bc, The Colao Frod Regent loins Tess» Meter ef raion, io o Prose om TeSID reso ar ne 23 Noe 12000, OF eure eh a ea Tring pid met dono ye ecg im UCHTRAL nd rao No.of daye o888a8 Arbitration Rules ericson pases ~ how one? ‘oh rte decton wer cee ore ht oul acu osc Secret en te adminis pton | he decor ot tad re Te set ain For ctanpe thee snd | att Keg mat be in se frm of | Seon me fr sa LCSD run wa 191 eer Bejisietoe cuungeanaershe | writen infos genment aber |_| ese he pre fra UNCITRAL TESID conenton tha we act {Bin hgh acl or imped kro by | Seton wt 130 dap Ue he HSI ‘tcl memento ese S| te genet As seo Seri has | Adin Flys, a ok a Judond cabege nerd 16D | Gcyesegtion nt cheating peed | seage f 12dps, ‘ceding hn cir UNCITRALorTESID | fama he or moat nd) "san an UNCFTRAL inert aston acy proceding | Sec lncamnt syste tee | er ily oe ron wd ses crasn oving at SDN | une tthe wing pd cate | ape nde ESD le Ang he “urnon ces rl in ny Geese ik | cima ony athe wing | {CSD cnt bol the read the ngs ‘onion cheng: Onhe sonny | jedi ty ele the an hear by | jade eon 38 dp) abo bathe toncus cf eview ay heighten eek of | foveal en for expe rca reed rth bores jars Srseconl chang ying suche | sain Et Cop made (WL SSB a€ | ett The ong sal ws the Tc Poy Fearon reeue tthe dapaing prs | fatgcph 8 a approche yon by oer Con» Re of Chie TCSID ce No ‘Anthro to ag scout eke | br icaing Land Ce Ree (WL| ARVN, awa 8 My 202) which ok fngneny of SID jr eng ‘ue 1) of he rial SID Arbo Rey which madd thal proces ene GOUNCETRAL rls sirup hector Flew Chine vers umber of arin pases (o dstrmie hte he proceeding ould nina ora seponte arto pe nde eber bec he SID Sereaiat Fins on sine pace fe ‘ering sy ime whee cone i svt Mow ben! imme ees conan 2 oti pes whey the govern neds {ober aur e xcence oft dapsee ee an ean Be git The SID Ses te Sees. Sacra geste ts See cenercauec eae parm] far cter eres eee 2x» ° ° -Aitration Rls ICSID AND AD IOC COMPARED 233 tachi he ey we Gr nga ACD ‘Solon hewg Te oc leg ped AKC cea R27 sno radon 20081 S100 (1 Oster 209) a 8c. Canency ein ta inl ny Aas arin, 8 December, 1908 WE OE Sly ve a | pee) | mci eee eet ll Arbitration Rules ‘mont fe hone made unde che | and toned fn» deen neato fhe ewig” to eons he ee fr the SID AatiiomlFoity. pain he thing | stron ston hold ln ied, ok cf teppei Sect ea at the ICSID cee The fat _| aga cece a ona at Comueny ICID bak cr wad dco ok 9 i othe _roealy ein fom dig the proceeds ‘hve (a SOABI Sd fsk the ICSID | Why dows ICSD aehiration take longer? wes Barings fhe The xen dye ‘rl 90 dae rtd ‘number ofadmirsve sa Sacto ——mICSID sre teats 1SID bm “The study shows hwnd ICSID | ply reso my acount rth eager Sana prwly d— watwth os upc evolon abe gan lnge at aan oes ane by ICSID than sensing te ava oe ily csing asap thn estas baoed by a hoc under non aon ue the preceeding ding they acl Zeprschs or een smesanent way sean: | Pete msi he Scumnen ICID eficy rl that {Slnmteed ty ater intaione sche Be |waapascle day nang OF 1D ‘panda econ ube pce within Schon Cher of Commerce Ariraion | prceeing The [CSID ruc muntte tet fom th ne being Ins Aibouph he Solon Chambers eions shoul whe sce within 120 dp of By camara rl 5 of te Skim Inde ley few metre chim in| he coe o paces, nd ony oecnnry Cheer CommaceAbonInsee ‘Senge merit dion wat eiodWonly_| an the abun ek an nstonnl 6 dp fr Riles ea ta ned te eral egren witin emt of the eral ‘hc dhim oe eure Ase a ‘ena peri oes be pine by ‘er he etl Chane wat 195 Figur Times orien phe, {fyb he verge tne ede he SID ‘ah The expe ofthe Schon Chamber ry ebton decide n= mck sree tine an ake pce apenas LCSD er Uncrate ‘ie iy meg om he eee ef snare reon ty he SID ‘Stow Thee cunt wich ‘Sued aati va hve bee ld tock of dipach: Of come mc poi e rb rte epuing prs we = Torte repuatos ofthese te ce ‘Therese no mandy vce andes 100 No of days es AF UNOTRAL n=s7 nes. ner METHODOLOGY ANTESUMT INJUNCTIONS AN'TI-SUIT RELIEF — AN IMPERFECT WORLD Paul Mitchard, partner ac Skadden Arps Slate Meagher & Flom (UK) LLP, consicers the best place to seek an anti-suit injunction of dat ageemet he cro nny nis {pant nt ean nrg ee hn you ‘orn comaring nse see Recent in he Ease fb Tk ‘ho Te Fon Con 37] UEHL [nj AN ER 0) 29 (et) he Howse Lt {cnet so whe cen anther ker ero | Treat fan ation green tough he Eagan Cot for dct saves whee pry A fom cvntry Aan ‘ese in perf a meen oy ‘Covi dpa teeen prs Bo be seed by tree curry Day Sd ete ct of proceeding by pe 8 Seinen Pry A hen hr amber ‘pons conte he proce coy (Com jaideton ore mers beh ck ‘once cel wana ba sting ‘coun Ds ck injunctive ree a he eure i counny yr (ve ct a "Adraed to op =the doen amy oh esc (oven tie prc one say be pene Tes prt sue she ose th he heron agement an ma he foe ese Aon uncon yee eso een de py nbc Jepaog your epi cod og cio etre cor king tof ‘OPTIONS () 70 @» EVALUATED {Const he proceedings sountry CP ‘Wher the corso coum Che pation impr san nd he {hr eour ow jain tr te cut spon Seton a he En rien Act retin Enda Ws al dh made eon pedis calleg ricicon sek aay afte som ponent pet oa ort oo eae sy be oneste The cour inh coats, {regs ouy ne apn fr kof nyt, gh eo oy ‘inane ain yn tent awh sehr el he Io our hd ge uy et tthe mein no arch npn ed "lef coe peed it oe ch An outne ese wh sl he eed Test cs he on option sek Sek nance ne om abtors country DE IF he jrcton of cour in omey (C2 conee ay then eeu ue ‘ey te oy etn pied {anteaapnetonmcang teespoy ‘om parsing he coding in oun C Met sk pve gar od ee Sve emmy ppm proc ene tine for eme-rmarng ppeetet Berth oe el fue fc ‘Son re lesb prcedngs he be enumencd nate spon wl se ‘ply es angle stro apposed bye mon il The nda corn oy (bal enough gra minnon oud ante tf preg te pa of ee th cin a bet tr sire ‘ensayo fen core te oct ogy Gebel {pce poison now be dicot, hc ee nd og a th fehl eae el ih uo aplcon ped Inde ston el wil en me ‘cum cron ob te mel ‘wa in the Gt ince in cern en a or a fom tls a cere ne oh fad» fry ly bade atin ah oo {re fring tr fr for oe pt reece oft mer oh Cy Dba sef e aimsa Me ‘cad sin pre te sing Fess o the git tee ence [Thecour into ati erpoweet ge mcy meri eae ‘str empl nde Engh Aon ‘es 19% cen 4) Bor ee nay ot be pel wie ty 8 pyar whom oe ‘Sincton sgh reo toe fe cot er eagle Se Nee adn a a a AC HPP AE {A jenn wl ony aed orang spay wh amen he raion of ie rors, So eet co ee ang tae pole Ening cn matey ‘Bien yb oe rg be exec "Adhere ‘han ew wl una be ose 2 ‘ie deo baer icon gated Commplce mgt we tthe ecetone of a ANTLSUIT INJUNCTIONS incourry C proceeded fo judge, | bythe fence in The Ft Cm Ui int | ied os an fronts in he pie Cotes ring on tetera the bon, aac ben ben epson in gad | of anon (vind ads oer ‘SaWcsn summary nto een hl hat | hea sane jaro hoe Seo nhc ri om outs in ‘sai ele ld ot tei a he ae | By ome Kaan Bo bed cotemas counery BP ‘lectuiejstton tv andthe ee| afte ad Tso Coa Kean Bae {Grinsy spay Bs dome Whee the kyl Camel Ap ang the come ew nee gon wa he ke ‘pn Bae nit jean and ‘Thal ang Manson Era) Ld cou re Sothery Dstt of Ne Yor, ‘thee th core pny conared ote» Naw toume os La The Ha Bhan which eed he amen of he ea lt ‘leh thru whey mates [20 EWCA Gr 15982051 Uo Rp 67) | ac The dict cour abo ned a it (fm court mu ie co em fll by Coat rt nance Th P| nnn pring Rai fon pring, {risa sbjesos ose toke "Cas ef emmentar aa te vow | pl presi in he Cn ds {Sree by ee ene ating fem | are vn a caso toon | ane ch sepia akg ae iSepumonljoicson tthe cour horses be ded ny Sey Som te | poh arnt fhe el wad fg DThe erence of oon jricioen | tau cle urate ces ‘ese The corded t proper Tap ghetactoromcdie ch nthe pment "The Biman Cou oar once res | ocean he nnn wth lene Stave or trcqublonorswiniogp I help fr gratag ch ee prod deg rein nd we the per of ‘oc o cer te pac cumty Ben | by te Eng Cot pe athe now Hose ad hte eee ae [evo psi Gr nn-compance shpat ee af i Chat Compas ean cop ith ny er hat iyo be maT roe wes welche Mine Sr um Spor The de | mound rec wh ihe ns ose ours connty Bae nt conser el (95) ny Rp 47250)" nknon | fk In nthe ee ait cura New indo rug ts cgi aged no ged ret he en Yok et at a-ring see (CEny wom mame sutncnon sie | fs New or tenon ag the panne "The wigs of nxonl cour ogratt_| he aston esc ouch | ad chr ge pe congas peeing snc ntion es Hisar Engin ce pom ep the pli oe | de pe amps Fo ging ay nd he US wow ther common ew ‘Spe de open Car st funder penn ot corm he Janeen lacking Cyper snd te Beh bee. Secon ab fhe Uti we Sue Vin nde which se fowl by ome Aaoayin OT ea Ln Las Mae | LEC Mae Commie 45 Sip Cop. ‘cern Earpenn meso urs econ of | Ses WCAC 710, 8) 20 W785, SDNY. 5 Deeb 309. ‘Shsisag pres ponding ntact of | 2 Uy Rep 17,19) Longe La Newscv isis, San apse elon the pele "Whar cory eo he core of which lo uy sa be bel oi gan When | heparan ae a ie dope Stoking sich ict mys eronen |e ouy wh com dace not ae Towed te cfg pu Soule | ates fan Engh our sing ghd and. AL we ne eo depen opon he ied pomply sd not uke any ep te_—_| ene ieee ow aurgan Eogcnunenes hw alice sei fot feces poeeding teting ote mei ofthe | coat wl wad defo enc teil pry sing uc wi {Se Dyconae in some ine jrcictons | ert whichever coy th purer spe fx an non agement may before n he ‘Beeston bs bento ene the econ | che mal fcc opt Tht apeld_ ce frre precinct Jhon wt cout wine the eeing | py aomany oat eld he ou any ote se whe te posting re ess ‘roenngs ave ecn brow freee gh nl fen be sate whee 0 Tn gin nl Wie a ring of “The opp vcw fxprcd hyn | neti fo fl bn ay ne ‘sich pcesig conamnce ine | iy Ro Cad ft dam) eae ae yb conse porn EU snenberos be cof wide | bo, 2005,pangp 339) wee wa mater rete Sry mjc fon cur Eugen Curator fp sor thn emerson ashe eee a fhe bon maybe ae at ui relctncngn jist afte | pu dec in cn ereing"he | Soa efron hn he et our Ges wine Expen Unan | conn often com ete | efi re wl ete uy king ‘Sisto compat wh the Bowel | rEg auto mc he careponding ec sp stason geen =p 9 be Replat (Coane Rep EC) No (Spent of ter outcome ding | com ace curry i wich opponent "Hh of 22 eceer 200 om ron | whe et whos perl jraseon =| Sond aang hc ot el re td te Reception ind Efron of Enndsw ea |] Nifong Srloneo in Coiand Commesed Mater). | toc tir dopeny igo oe abeatoo rag he Eaopea Cato ae Te Teele Eopeon Court of oe hand t_| Eng emson af ys omon Fa Combat th loa core ha ‘Storer aan npncon sted be andi | pment ne diay Baie fouaceal |e Eup Uni And ec i pp ‘tuna eget trates | cr pte econ a ana cury, lf whee he coe eae of te ‘Famer EU member te Engin woth hse for | {pone nor calc fen eee otowing ecco Time Gee | aged ot i view ners pac ones wes ing nen in ean pref he wo ‘cso [to 2 Uo Rep oyna Bu | ural ving pry who awn af |‘Thes spy cntrng to eon (Ger Gril USAT sae CY 201) | deen each oan aren wih | aeons wih an ray dons ate at {gd Rep 229 and dope sero | ee ey Aik x pvt stone biel poectdng i oan mensncd | Inthe Uso cant cn eempi an | cfr ch pecs uy be ng on of tov ince 124@), dutrfe Bev aytiy recogs apache ‘Snel a i pes Shes of Engi cono putanin” | pmo gone inp fant (lef mn de cometh ech ation | he mo Ro oda Co LLC maa “semen whe pret eo Europese | Prunes Met Dar Ca Ba Ng "Te eri hed of Sle An Eamon i Ire sty ouk ea abe aed, Pum (5 Sopp 2428 (36) Foaan ad ohn go TAIN AMERICAN ARBITRATION ROUNDTARIE ON YOUR MARKS, GET SET ... STOP POSE Were ster eC eee ee yarce aCe red Sebastian O’Meata husted a sundtable for members of dhe ICC's LainAmerica group, past and present fate To what extent do you fea ret an ‘oiration cole hs fly et Uoin america? LATIN AMERICAN ARBITRATION ROUNDTABLE Se eae eee eee eee Seisentnaters. [Soca sate cece ec eee eee noms ‘oltnghattac anata [eevee espe ce caper ret pe meeeteeee Siettevscimraatomaetiee! | to lca digutes However, the ier In Brazil, we've had SMhastiorascielaemesclapee, (cultural revolution in SMe cere [Sibitation in the past (Meumizeinste wacertnanens, |10 years. If you look at cocci Mg te, (the ICC's statistics, you Geena tems ua oe eae Chie stipe nee!ton dey ad {Brazilian parties took memon cose iesdrinstiestetont Lpart in [CC arbitrations, pibeeeernee ‘whereas this year — and meet aoe civeaoa’, |it’s not finished yet ~ you aie eaeene ape aeldz ‘convention i 2912 and a series of decisions by Arnoldo Wald Seon aetee eae Sor puma ee crit |e tetee se tn aap ran pares tok putin ICC wean, fr fue and i pol owe of whew hi yar" ot bed yer jou nd er, pope seeing ina tc ree #-Theve hve ben some pole | ct pon tern ito ue, ine nly we thon tthe mg be | jg he en, who tl endo be ery fete jen eben etn Ate me Snes ge mer of toks har been pblsed | Aci Ataten The geo at wo age nthe tet mor din 100 yeu Weve | Gon. ne aig soa tron wih Ls tose tener gent in bieson | Arsen pre you can wae te Be ‘Bamber ot sre rar hepato | weve son very ng rod a rome hee wile pes ofretion Ihe to be maid. Ast itor Flying pce nn Ary che ‘ry sn cle of ei aon and | newt 0S oe a Ad wuld tery ne mere Calta | eh Ina bce we ae eens number Aobten inched its donenc eon At | ofenes woe el coarse tree Sesame cme enon sine uty 190s |e abttuom oc in cheomencr whee § {Se densgpment fen neraonl women | een NewYork, Genes Pas wl are ‘clneTam cen i en ped logy [ec yin Ad ge a tae Se by song geht tc Bax |v cece othe ae of orton, [Amur spon wo reton Idan bles | Ante onl sch nee ve bt ‘aren We we ins seion whe bron | ply ght mcnon oot ink Hep w ey partner || ovr ica geome 20 Common epeence srt wolerepoa, | many dre coe, at ere Sins) ren cng nese at ere, ow Corer aly ae wih hat Thre we | Seem ee Welk Pe, ney snenown both npc an in he ENC whee ow tt a change. ‘Amen couse A cet sample af th (Geving abicaon cl’ etn Ameria (Piet arte now widely he isc whch pont md eet ‘hbvan change ne ‘cures we ok the on ping of [et Amo I you goon ep Fer ‘ieee ok Aina te ‘ae yout the progeny te Supe Coe ‘econ ne Cote Gn ich sad Sie psy of reing an aed onthe ‘ar Aen airs coal eg Asses paca vew of iron, Be ‘uh ad pn pg epi, {heel ofan atl anv ey oad {i al core Tata be gn } seang neta peopl one inl wh you ‘Sera fy mt of Something eh bei ht Ta eine sig fon At fog area of ety ch mode ‘ne comerl coe coming eof at prcpuon of tie arc reste fe prdcpaion of Lata Ansricn aye Uric thee nine! ato ele Bae ihe cur hare eredo ao he he his be emer ng tne cen we se ‘cto Latin Are wpe ‘An enporont pat of what imeart by ‘Sroirator clr’ eho sient fo which the Haclay - ot level unaartaras ‘rc bination an wher Peopla have mentioned the eae 0 ledueata jiges. How much success do You tee there has eenin doing fis? forts oon eed orig ctor, Ic in theo deco td chat ‘ee aaron, nd th somthing tha fer beyond guenon of etm knowledge Imo» qin os ein hat ey Trough by frcpsen. The eof ges an ‘ir atinasonwatebing pred oe LATIN AMERICAN ARBITRATION ROUNDTABLE gsi which they haw ct Th her point lek pecaion bec a se ‘besa ps be deg a pen ine with eb bowl the wed wl a {ea wo pc In ation Bcue Be may ony pt oe ave he ys nay ee Lan eee jet dering of eto Seat the one hobo Cora ning concen ik ‘hare ICC ha eon ha i oe ein cron ny pte mon-raning tom ‘heady cnt ee" and pray Sheng st ee he TOC hs peed {panne cin, aw ove ‘ope din wi be pane Aneninn here neve a ry ‘ring Sane wih ug one Sopreme Core wey sano he ose consegcncs of whet mgt be sen ns coo a i pres athe tr ve ‘Goble ent exper ht ob te Sul seer pec ae Dy id here abe crenata ro rie the peewee be ieee ect al the js The ICC we stoned o ake ling ale, eae tl tat, Phenomenon thts been ee eewhore htm be cle tht olde thv ‘cong joi kare rol shout [bint and econo decoping ‘eon ough er cour ese ‘War Br hea ett bot Jin eight cour Four our Serene gn ech am oe fe slo, see compen ues ce nemo ne ote ‘irc bee Ba neh capi fr ‘ner There poy Brian pe lesen oro Pe vent he tortor emer dot there 83 rosie olan The pre of he Supe Cau gen wato so dene te wae of ‘he poem chk toe cs omen hone ‘hina fr ee ens tot of ee ‘Yume The ony way at jade an ‘ay tare sour atin Sy hewing is Soli bron Hs erg proces ed | Be Bese sarpsingy poe OF couse some Secon ave en td tik oa ys inj pice thaw desons othe Ive be eco te apne ine ‘oes bon ave hg emacaly ‘eset ofthe cour So ere ly ‘fort ear i eI ik wold ‘hans cots whee er eto rote a thers im peal pied thee ICC wate hn 303 Meso iy was tech yn the wor or oe ‘tenon by apcmene fe prin Wee swe te the i 10 af ae be doen ofecelen Scien sce | ‘We have held in Mexico three separate eight-week courses for Ljudges, and we've found that their attitudes to arbitration have changed dramatically as a result of these courses” Claus Von Wobeser tego me al coe drain Nee Yor re ‘Sy teen to make dein othe Bel. Where oes Latin America rank compared fo other reionsin terms of ‘he relabiy of cour docsions® er bt Ltn Anerson | fret onerdetope tanec. Wel you's expect Latin Amstica tobe ‘a polentialy move comalccted verve | Shan Geneva or Per but wot aout sar Eastern Europe® Jono be ie th col he pres Sue Crom ena Lai Artin cour ae bean ae enough oer eer etic in aro bol Br mone {nme ng 0 ba op epaon reas neh Be il What apni time ha ihe we el be deci sev ampled bce wee a arg oc, ‘Be Used Sate well ned ieee ‘een Tha ra ein ory omy {oer bere the elon rion fete Usted Sas he Und Kgl ed France oth on nda wh igo [ios Ames For ei or rng et, ‘Mon natin Aen yy too mus pbs Whe belie ‘You ceaty nave @ boctlosh in teas! acgentna, ogainst CSD-me ‘rbtrators ut aos Mot men have o agora elect anh development at orbtrofonn generat the cur independence bec oe Inco hula beset pl Indeenene bec the ge wep lets peaen a ae inet eat of ‘he eu ch Yue ging get bd

    Você também pode gostar