architectural details derived from ancient
Roman grotto decoration, reminds us of decora-
tive projects of the early sixteenth century,
such as those by Raphael in the Vatican loggias.)
‘There is something more to be said about the
juxtaposition in the Medici armeria of New World
objects, and in the frescoes depicting the strug-
ale between indigenous Mexicans and Europe-
fans, with their references to antique Roman
decoration. In the sixteenth century there was a
desire on the part of Renaissance humanists to
understand the New World within its widest
possible context. One way to achieve this was to
stress points of commonality of ancestry on
both sides of the Atlantic. Much was discussed
in intellectual elite circles about the origin of
‘the New World gods and their links with
ancient Greco-Roman deities. The erudite cul-
‘tures of the Renaissance were fascinated by the
confection of genealogies that connected con-
tempors
of England as the new Astrea, or the kings of
Spain as descendants of Hercules were among
‘many such examples. In order to more fully com-
prehend the increasing mass of inevitably con-
{fusing information about the Americas that was
emerging in Europe during the early modern
period, such genealogies were fashioned to cre-
ate familial associations between the American
y rulers with ancient heroes; Elizabeth
pantheon of gods and those of the Greco-Roman
‘world. In 1615 the antiquarian Lorenzo Pignoria
‘wrote a gloss in the form of an appendix toa
well-known description of the ancient gods of
‘the Mediterranean world, The 1615 edition of
Vincenzo Cartari's Imagini deli dei de glantichi
attempted to forge connections between them
‘and the deities of the peoples of the New
World.” De las Casas, the champion of the Indi
ans, stressed in his writings the importance of
‘the similarities that their beliefs shared with
‘the systems of worship of the European pagan
world. As the historian Michael T. Ryan has
commented, “genealogy was powerful medicine
against the confusions introduced by novelties,
it served as an appropriate prophylaxis against
the impact of the new worlds... To understand
new peoples, their language, beliefs, customs, it
was necessary to uncover their ancestors and
establish creditable chains of transmission back
to the earliest days of mankind.... The upshot
of these fantastic forays into exotic pasts was to
make the new worlds into very old, to reduce
‘the uniqueness to similarity.”
Reducing the unknown to more recognizable
terms was, of course, a major step in the process
of assimilation and conquest, at least culturally,
from a European humanistic point of view.
Objects played a key role in this project of domi-
nation through familiarization. Gotd and silver
items, as well as the other indicators of the
unfamiliar material culture that reached Europe
from the New World, were, in the early moments
of the contact, considered fantastical metaphors
of "exotic" peoples. Yet the strangeness embod-
ied in these items could be neutralized through
‘a more nuanced awareness of their forms and
‘Spanlro (Sta 588. reo
a. Ladowea Bul, Monian
Solndep Argent, Ut,
original use. The things that appeared so awe-
striking to Durer in the 1520s were, by the late
sixteenth century still objects of curiosity, but
‘through their display (and, in some eases, altera-
tion and manipulation) were becoming less won-
drous and more easily absorbed intoa European
consciousness, They also began to be visually
assimilated by a wider audience. By 1574, when
Francesco de’ Medici became grand duke of
‘Tuscany, the family collections of curiosities
‘were moved to the newly constructed Uffizi
and became accessible to the public. This is not
to say, of course, that New World objects had
lost their attraction or power. But they eventu-
ally became focal points for the interests of
scientific-minded collectors such as the
Bolognese nobleman and naturalist Ulisse
Aldrovandi, founder of the first botanical gar-
den in his native city, in which plants from the
Americas were cultivated.»
Private curiosity cabinets continued to be
formed well into the eighteenth century
throughout Europe, and many of them con-
tained objects that attested to an enduring
centhrallment with the suggestive powers of the
“things" of the Americas. Throughout this
Wondrous Objects 19