Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
26 (2014)12 24
sad-asat tattva
VoThiVanAnh
r sad-asat-tattva
2
7
sad-asat tattva
VoThiVanAnh
O.
1971 (r sad a
s
a
cc
atattvaJ)
3 sad-asat-tattva
1. sad-asat tattva
III
>
a
s
a
cc
an
i
t
y
a
r
p
.s
a
ccya
t
a
t
t
v
a
t
a
l
;
s
a
d
a
s
a
t
t
a
t
t
v
a
t
a
sc
e
t
isvabha-trayaiyate /
/(
I
I
I
.3
)
) sadasat-tattva (
y
o
dd
a
n
gmedd
ek
h
ona)
2
c sad-asat-tattvatas ca
yod p
adangmedp
a
'
id
ekhona
(Dvandva
compoundDv) (sad
2
8
parini:pannalak:a:Q. a 1fl
nalak$'Y(l/
s
a
d
a
s
a
t
t
a
t
t
v
a
s ceti,
...sad t
ttvl
c
a
parini$an-
visuddhyambanatv t
a
t
t
v
a
r
p/e
t
a
tparinipanne svabhetattvarp , avipar tatvi
t
i
sambadhy /1
sadasattattva (
yoddangmedpa [
d
e
J khona)
(yod padangmedpadangdekhona)
sad-asat-tattva
ablative
+nominative
sad-asat-tattva Dv
( MAVBh)
tattva
tattva Dv
tattva J (visuddhylambana)
2.
sad-asat-tattva
2
9
r(
I 13
ab 2
(abhva)
(bhva)
Dv
tattva
3
.
3
.
1 w
sad-asat-tattva tattva
J 1.12
3
0
?
Kdh (
)( MAVk) d
III.3
14-15 2
20
Kdh ()
~ I. 13d
r~
Kdh () Tp (
)
sad-asat-tattva
3
1
3.2
()
(ubhti)
()
(* Paramarthasamudgata) ?
?{
v~~
Kdh (
)
J r
Kdh ()
~ r
<1>
2>
3
2
<3> (
Kdh ()
~ r 15
Tp ()
Kdh
@
1
1
.1
5
c
()
?
gzhan
dumi'
g
y
u
rbaJ
()
Tp ()
3
3
sad-asat-tattva
22 ab
c 30
~~~~
~ r
(bahuvrlhi compound Bv)
Kdh ()
visuddha
Kdh
3.3
Tp
Kdh Bv Tp.
K
d
h
.Bv.
Tp
~ r
Kdh
Tp
3
4
Karmadhaya
Tatpuru
J r
J 1. 13
1
1.
1
5
c
~ 1. 12
()
sad-asat-tattva
4.
4
.1
. r
~ III.ll
(III.llcd)
J (nirvikra) J (avipasa)
Sad-asat-tattva
3
5
sad-asat-tattva
mrgaJ
MAVBh
4_2.
MAV-III.llcd
I III.3~ XI
III.3 III.llcd 1. 5 V
r
@
Madhyamakahrdaya
i
k
W V Prafrad XXV
3
6
5.
sad-asat-tattva
visuddhylambanaJ
M AVBh: P
.
5
5
2
8
; D
.
4
0
2
7
; T.1 599.31. T. 1600.31; [
N
a
]
: G
a
d
j
i
n Nagao (
e
d
.
)
Madhyantavibha-blu~a 1964 Tokyo; [
T
a
]
: N.
Ta
t
i
a & A.Thakur(
e
d
.
)
Madhyantavibha-blu~a T
i
b
e
t
a
nS
a
n
s
k
r
i
tWorkS
e
r
i
e
s10, Patna , K
.P
.J
a
y
a
s
w
a
lR
e
s
e
a
r
c
h
Institute, 1
9
6
7
.
MA
VT
:P.5534; D.
40
3
2
;[
Y
a
J
: Susumu Yamaguchi (
e
d
.
) Madhyantavibha- tfka, Hajinkaku,
Nagoya, 1
9
3
4
.
~ :H
artmutB
u
e
s
c
h
e
r(
e
d
.
)Sthiramati 's T
r
i
y
t
Z
s
i
k
a
v
i
ja
p
t
i
b
hy
a
:c
r
i
t
i
c
a
le
d
i
t
i
o
n
s0
1t
h
e
S
a
n
s
k
r
i
tt
e
x
tandi
t
sT
i
b
e
t
a
ntranslation , V
e
r
l
a
gd
e
rO
s
t
e
r
r
e
i
c
h
i
s
c
h
e
nAkademied
e
rW
i
s
senachaften , Wien, 2
0
0
7
.
d~ :Trisvabhvanirdesa , S
usumuYamaguchi(ed.) 1972.
T0676.16; P
.
7
7
4
;D
.
1
0
6
.[
L
a
m
o
t
t
e
.
]
: Say
t
Zd
h
i
n
i
r
m
o
c
a
n
a Sr
a
: L'eYlication
d
e
s11( 'steres b
yE
t
i
e
n
n
eLamotte , P
a
r
i
s
:A
d
r
i
e
nMaisonneuve, 1
9
3
5
~ :T1594.31 ; P
.
5
5
4
9
;D.
40
4
8;1982 1987
P
.
5
5
5
1
;D.
40
5
0
:D.
40
3
8, P.5539 , T. 1579
~ :T1597.31 ;
~ rJ
~
:Tl 602.31
2007-2011
S
.J
a
i
n
i
:Abhidharmada w
i
t
h Vib h$aprabhvrtti , c
r
i
t
i
c
a
l
l
ye
d
i
t
e
dw
i
t
hn
o
t
e
sandi
n
t
r
o
d
u
c
t
i
o
n
2
n
ded.] , P
a
t
n
a
:K
a
s
h
iP
r
a
s
a
dJ
a
y
a
s
w
a
lR
e
s
e
a
r
c
hInstitute , 1
9
7
7
byPadmanabhS
.Jaini , [
2
0
0
5 n~
r: vastu
3
7
sad-asat-tattva
(Kim
J
a
eGong)
2
0
0
7 n
VoL
II
2
0
0
3 rMadhyntavibhga 1
2
0
1
4 r
r tattva
2
0
1
0 r:
1
9
7
1 r
sad
a
s
a
cc
atattvamJ
20 (1) ,
p
p
_
3
7
3
3
8
2
.
MAVBh.
[Na37 , 20-38 , 7
; Ta 18 , 17-
19 , 3J :
kima
t
r
asvabha-trayet
a
t
t
v
a
miyate /
ac c
anitya
I
p
.s
accyatattvata
]
.
t
ad-aat-tattvata~ c
e
t
isvabhva traya iyate /
/ (
I
I
I
.3abcd)
I
)
.
ar
p
.nityamasadi
t
ye
t
a
tparikalpita-svabhetattvama
v
i
p
a
r
l
t
a
t
v
[
/
J
p
a
r
i
k
a
l
p
i
t
a
l
a
k
!
?
a
paratantra-lakI s
ac ca na ca t
a
t
t
v
a
t
o bhrtatv i
t
ye
t
a
t paratantra-svabhe
p
. /parinipanna-lakaI).arp. sad-asattattvatas cety etat (
/
) parinipanna-svabhve
t
a
t
t
v
ar
tattvam/
[
P
1
3
a
1
a
5
;D10
b
3
b
6
J
Tib:yodpadangmedpadangdekhona. sad ac c
atattvam
1971
MAV
r.
[p8
4
b
8
8
5
a
2
;D 2
4
4
a
6
b
1
J
:yongssugrubp
a
'
imtshannyidn
i//yoddangmedpa [
d
e
J kho
iyodpadangmedpadangdekhonan
iyongssugrub [
2
4
4
a
7
Jp
a
'
i
nas
t
e/ bya ban
n
y
i
spomedp
a
'
i
mtshannyidde/g
n
y
i
spamedpayodp
a
'
ibdagnyid / /g
a
'
idmigs L '
d
i
rn
iyongs
bdagnyid // rnampardagp
adekhonas
t
e/phyinc
imal
o
gp
a
'
ip
h
y
i
rrozhesbya [
2
4
4
b
1Jba
sugrubpa'i o bonyidl
dangsbyorro//
I 5
3
8
((MAV- 1. 1 )
J
.sy
asya lak~al.lam/ (
l.
1
3
a
b
)
dvayhohyabhasyabha
J
.
/t
a
s
y
a chasya bha
J
. sy
at
lakal.lam i
t
y
dvaya-grya-grakasyha
h
a
v
a
ti
/[
T
i
b
.
P
5
a
3
4
;D
4
a
5
6
J
a
b
h vas
v
a
b
h va-laaatvarp.nyaty paridlpitarp. b
(I.13ab)
[Ya 4
7
.
5
1
2
;Bh&T3
9
.4
1
1
J
:bhaprati$edhavakatv abhasabdasyabhasabdab
h
i
1
v
e1'y e
!
j
o'
r
t
h
o'
v
a
g
a
m
y
a
t
ai
t
ib
h
i
1
v
a
S
a
b
d
o'tradhikaf:t, n
a
d
h
i
k
od
v
a
y
a
bh
i
1
v
a
t
:
fsnyatlak al)am
i
t
1y
a
t
inirdisyamedvayhasyasvantryame
v
a
t
r
agamyatesasavil)bhvavat na
c
y
a
t
edvayha
J
.sy
a
t /t
a
s
y
a c
du
}
:
l
khativaddharmatrpat , tasm evamu
a
t
e
t
y ucya abhi1va'a b
h
i
1
v
a
l
a
k
!
j
at
:
za
p
a
r
i
g
r
ht
a
t
v
a
dd
h
a
r
(I.l 2)
t
a
r
e
$
u paryanirdese$v
p
. paryyatal,l, parythabodhthac c
hy
a
t
a
y v
i
s
u
d
d
h
y
a
m
b
a
n
a
t
v
e
n
a
asammohthar
niscitatvat ryyrtha/ [
P
4
6
b
2
4
;D
2
1
1
b
7
2
1
2
a
1
]
.
tathat b
ha
k
o
t
i
s cimittar
p
.p
aramthat
dharmadhusc
aparyyl,l snyatyl,l samsatal,l/I.l 4/
ananyath'viparysatannirodhryagocarail,l/
h
e
t
u
t
v
cyadharm l
)r
p
.parythoyathrama
r
p
.
/
I
.
l5
/ [Nap.23].
(I .14)
(
I
.
l5
)
1982 p.362 o
[Ya 48 , 23-49 , 8
J :tve s
a
t
ivisuddhyambanaI
p
.
*nas
y
/v
i
s
u
d
d
h
y
a
t
e '
n
e
n
e
t
iv
i
s
u
d
d
h
i
r mrgall* dharmasvalakal)d
a
n
a
n
y
a
t
v
a
nm
a
r
g
a
l
a
m
b
a
n
a
r
r
znasyt, dhansvalak!jat:zavat /{} a
t
h
av v
i
s
u
d
d
h
y
a
r
t
h
a
m
p
.v
isuddhyambanar
p
.n
abhvasvalakI)am ambyamar
p
.v
i
s
u
d
d
h
i
mahati
ambanar
)
n
g
/ (*visuddhyambanar
p
.
: MAVBh visuddhylam
s
a
r
v
a
s
a
t
t
v
a
v
i
s
u
d
d
h
i
p
r
a
s
al
bana
r
p
.jnarp. MAVBh MAVT
smnyalakal.laceti
sad-asat-tattva
3
9
janarp.; .
.v
i
s
u
d
d
h
i
rmgal
)
.
:Ms.visuddhimrga l)., T
i
b
.rnamp
a
rdagpan
i
lammo) [
T
i
b
.
P
4
8
a
2
6
;D
2
1
3
a
3
6
J.
[
Lamotte5
0
5
1
J
:r
a
b'
b
y
o
rphungpornamsl
a~1
~ bstan c
i
n
g/r
a
b'
b
y
o
rskyemchedrnamdang/r
t
e
nc
i
n
g
'
b
r
e
lp
a
r'
b
y
u
n
gbadang/z
a
srnamsdang/bdenparnamsdang/khamsrnamsdang/dran
panyeb
a
rbzhagparnamsdang/yangdagp
a
rspongbarnamsdang/r
d
z
u'
p
h
r
u
lg
y
irkang
barnamsdang/dbangpornamsdang/s
t
o
b
srnamsdang/byangchubk
y
iyanl
a
grnams
dang/r
a
b'
b
y
o
r'
p
h
a
g
sp
a
'
ilamyanl
a
gbrgyadpal
a~1!E
~stan p
a
'
ip
h
y
i
rr
o//
~d/ /
(
T
0
6
7
6
.
1
6
.
0
6
9
1
c
2
5
2
9
)
[Lamotte 68 , 16-24; Peking7
7
4
.1
8
b
4
-7
]
:dondamyangdag'
p
h
a
g
s/c
h
o
srnamsk
y
idon
dampangobon
y
i
dmedpan
y
i
dgangz
h
ena/r
t
e
nc
i
n
g'
b
r
e
lp
a
r'
b
y
u
n
gb
a
'
ic
h
o
sgangdag
s
k
y
ebangobon
y
i
dmedpan
y
i
dk
y
i
sngobon
y
i
dmedpadedagn
idondamp
a
'
ingobon
y
i
d
medpan
y
i
dk
y
i
sngobon
y
i
dmedp
a
'
a
n
gy
i
nno//d
ec
i
'
ip
h
y
i
rz
h
ena/dondamyangdag
'
p
h
a
g
s/c
h
o
srnamsl
arnamp
a
rdagp
a
'
idmigspagangy
i
npad
en
ingasdondampay
i
np
a
r
yongss
ub
s
t
a
nl
a/gzhang
y
idbangg
imtshann
y
i
dd
en
irnamp
a
rdagp
a
'
idmigspamay
i
n
T
0
6
7
6
.
1
6
.
0
6
9
4
a
2
0
)
pas { }o (
(*paramrthena n
il
)
.
svabhvat , Tp) (paramrthal). ni l).svabhvat ,
d
ekhon
a
sngobon
y
i
dmamchispan
y
i
dchis d rnad
'i dmi'i mags t
e/d
el
ab
r
t
e
nn
a
sbcom
l
d
a
n'
d
a
sc
h
o
srnamsk
y
idondamp
a
'
ingobon
y
i
dmamchispad
en
y
i
dl
a
sg
c
i
g'
d
o
g
sp
a
r
mdzadl
a
g
ss
o// [
T
0
6
7
6.
1
6
.0696b21-27]:
p.1 25: d
eb
z
h
i
nn
y
i
dkunr
d
z
o
bt
uyodp
a
rb
r
j
o
dp
a
rbya'am/dondamp
a
ryodp
a
rb
r
j
o
d
p
a
rbyaz
h
ena/smrasp
a
/dondamp
a
ryodparb
r
j
o
dparbyas
t
e
/!~
M~~ T
1
5
7
9
.
3
0
.
0
6
9
6
b
2
2
2
4
[p '
i
.6
b
7
7
a
1
;
Dz
i
.
6
b
l
2
J
:duz
h
i
gdmanpa [
6
b
1
J dagy
i
n/duz
h
i
ggyanompadagy
i
nz
h
e
e/~
na/smraspa/gsumn
ig
n
y
igay
i
nno//n t
MM/ nyamsp
adangkh
lya
1
dp
rd
a
u'
grro
ba
'i
a
bda
gn
yi
d
k)
Q
y
ri do
i may
n
i
nno//yangdag [6b2J pa'i
she
s p
ayanggyanompay
i
n
t e/d
bzhin nyi
dky
ri*
s pyod
y
u
lpa'i dong
y
i
s
s 0// (*
P. o
m
i
t
sk
y
i
)
.T
1
5
7
9
.3
0
.0
6
9
8
a
2
4
2
6
.
[P '
i
.7
b
3
4
;
Dz
.
i7
a
3
4
]
:duz
h
i
gb
l
anayodpadag [
7
a
4
Jy
i
n/duz
h
i
gb
l
anamedpadagy
i
n
z
h
ena/smraspa/b
z
h
in
ib
l
anayodpay
i
nno//BMMd~
1~~/ /T
1
5
7
9
.3
0
.0
6
9
8
b
1
9
2
0
.
~ T
1
6
0
2
.
3
1
.
0
5
5
9
b
5
1
0
.
4
0
P
1
8
a
4
5
]
:g
a
lt
edeg
t
a
nmedp
a
'
imtshann
y
i
dyongss
ugrubp
a
'
ingobon
y
i
d
y
i
nna/dej
il
t
a
rnayongss
ugrubpan
y
i
dy
i
nl
a/c
i
'
ip
h
y
i
rnayongss
ugrubpaz
h
e
sbya
z
h
ena/gzhandumi'
g
y
u
rb
a
'
ip
h
y
i
ryongss
ugrubp
a
'
o//'idmiE)::in
padang/dgeb
a
'
ic
h
o
sthamscadk
y
imchogy
i
np
a
'
ip
h
y
i
rmchogg
idongyis yongs s
ugrub
paz
h
e
sb
y
a
'
o// (
*
P
.
g
y
i
;D
.
g
y
i
s
)
@ [
H
.
B
u
e
s
c
h
e
r124 , 1
9
2
1
J
: athanyaevama
p
i parinipanno navisuddhyambana
J
;
ts
y
p
a
r
a
t
a
n
t
r
a
v
a
t saqlklesmakatv / e
v
a
q
l p
a
r
a
t
a
n
t
r
a
s c
a na klesmaka
J
;
ts
y
/
parinipannd a
n
a
n
y
a
t
v
parinipannavat /
/
@ [
H
.
B
u
e
s
c
h
e
r142 , 6
J
:
k
u
s
a
l
ovisuddhambanatv kematvd anravadharmamayatv ca
[Nagao p.74;
lam n
i'
d
i
rrnamp
a
rdagp
a
'
is
g
r
a
sb
s
t
a
ntOJ
(
P
5
8
a
8
;D
5
3
b
6
)
Ratnkarak~nti Prajtiramitodesa
gsumpan
irnamp
a
rdagp
a
'
idondu [
1
3
8
b
3
J dmigsp
a
sdondamp
a
ryodpas
t
e/mamp
a
r
dagp
a
rbyab
a
'
ip
h
y
i
r/d
el
admigspay
i
ng
y
ikunn
a
snyonmongsp
a
rbyab
a
'
ip
h
y
i
rn
ima
y
i
nno//gzhang
y
idbangg
ingobon
y
i
dl
ayangyongss
ug
r
u
bp
a
'
irangb
z
h
i
ng
y
i
sdmigs
nadondamp
a
ryodp
a
r
*'
g
y
u
rl
a/kunb
r
t
a
g
sp
a
'
i[
1
3
8
b4Jr
angb
z
h
i
ng
y
i
sdmigsnan
ikun
r
d
z
o
bt
uyodp
a
r'
g
y
u
rt
e/kunn
a
snyonmongsp
a
'
idondudmigsp
a
'
ip
h
y
i
rr
o//kunn
a
s
nyonmongsp
a
'
ip
h
y
i
rdmigspan
irnamp
a
rbyangb
a
'
ip
h
y
i
rmay
i
nno// [
P
1
5
6
b
7
1
5
7
a
2
;
Dl 38b2-4J don damp
a
ryodp
a
r
:P
.dondamp
a
r
)
()
( Luo Hong
(V.27cd)
()
(
V
.
2
8
)
MAVBh
tad e
va h
i p
r
a
t
h
amadvayam/tasyltasy avasthltattadambanaqlnal
a
b
h
a
t
eJ
MAVBh [Na73 , 21-74 , 18; Ta 48 17-49 10J
sad-asat-tattva
4
1
1 vyavasthna
2 dharmadhtu
3 sdhya
4 sdhana
5 dhran
6 avadhran
7 pradhraI)
8 prativedha
9 pratnat
1
0
pragama
1
1 prasatha
1
2 prakar
nirvikrviparysaparinipattito dvayam!!3
.
1
1
c
d
!
!
a
s
a
r
p
s
k
p
:
amavikraparinipatty parinipannam!sarpsk:rtarp mgasatyasarpg
r
:
h tam
a
v
i
p
a
r
a
p
a
r
i
n;
p
a
t
t
y punarje
y
a
v
a
s
t
u
n
yavipary!!
@ MSA.VI.Tattva
i
MAV-III ()
2010
Ratnkaraknti Prajpramitopadesa
()
Jo (
@
Tib: Dl 42b5-6)
@ ()
@ XI 41 -2 p
p
.
9
4
9
5
;
@ [
H
.
B
u
e
s
c
h
e
r124-126]
nipannas t
a
s
y
apveI
)as
a
d r
a
h
i
t
a
t t
uy !21!!
a
t
aevas
anaivyonanya
Q
.p
a
r
a
t
a
r
p
t
r
a
t
aQ
.!
:
s
t
e'
s
m
i
ns
ad
r
:
s
y
a
t
e
!
!
2
2
!
!
anityativadvyonr
()()
( 21)
4
2
()
()(
)( 22)
'
@ @.:
@ MAVT [Ya2
2
9
.
5
9
;Ms7
4
a
6
7
J
mahayn
a
d
e
s
a
ndharmal
) suvisuddhadharmadh.tuni~yandatv.d viparyasapratipak lam
b
a
n
a
t
vcc
aparinipannal) s
v
a
b
hvai
t
yu
c
y
a
t
e/s
o 'rt/:t k
a
l
P
i
t
a
s
v
a
b
h
i
i
v
a
s
y
abhavati tu
parikalpitat sadasatta parinipanna i
t
yuktami
t
ya
p
a
r
e/r
()
[
T
i
b
:P
1
5
0
b
5
7
;D
3
0
2
a
7
b
1
J
@ K 21cd
avik.raparinipatty. s
aparinipanna [H.Buescher.1 24 8J
@ Abhidharmada- vibhii$iiPrabhiivrtti
(
s
a
r
vs
t
iv davibhra~ti)() (vaitua)
(P.S.
J
a
i
n
i [1977 ,
p. 282 )
Vasubandhu Sthiramati