Southeast
Asian Culture and
Heritage in a
Globalising World
Diverging Identities in a Dynamic Region
Edited by
RAHIL ISMAIL, BRIAN SHAW
and OO! GIOK LINGChapter 5
Morphogenesis and Hybridity
of Southeast Asian Coastal Cities
Johannes Widodo
Morphogenesis of Southeast Asian Cosmopolitan Cities
Within Southeast Asia. cosmopolitan settlements have been growing and developing
around the coastal areas of the South China Sea, Java Sea, and Malacca Strait (the
‘Mediterranean of Asia’, see Figure 5.1), since the beginning of the inter-insular
and inter-continental trades dating at least from the first century. In the past, this
region was politically unified under various maritime kingdoms, continuously
shaped and enriched by various cultural layers and elements, constantly nurtured
and developed throughout its history
From the fertile Mekong delta region, the source of rice culture of Southeast
Asia, the first kingdom of Funan was established around the Mekong delta around
100-600 CE, followed by several other inland kingdoms of Chenla (600-790 CE),
Pagan (849-1287 CE), Khmer (790-1431 CE), Ayuthaya (1350-1767 CE), and
Champa (192-1471 CF). Srivijaya maritime power (600-1290 CE) took effective
control over the main trading routes of Melaka strait and Java Sea. It was the
period when Hindu-Buddhist cosmology and its materialisation of culture spread
across the region. [slam entered and spread throughout Southeast Asia through
various trading routes. From the west the Arabs, Persians, and Indians (Gujarat
and Tamil) came to Malay Peninsula and the west coast of Sumatra, to northern
coast Java and all over the archipelago in the thirteenth to fourteenth centuries,
From the north came the Chinese Muslim traders, peaking especially during the
voyage of Ming dynasty’s admiral Zheng He (1405-1433) in the fifteenth century.
‘The Chinese traders and immigrants from Southern China had been settled down
in the coastal cities of Southeast Asia since as early as the twelfth century, and
getting more intensive from the fifteenth century onward.
Located thus, at the crossroads of global maritime trading routes, Southeast
Asia has been very open towards the various cultural influxes. These cultures
were then transplanted, adopted, absorbed and nurtured locally, then expressed
into unique but yet closely linked culture, language, architecture, and artifacts.
The settlements are formed by complex layers of various cultures, ideologies,
‘economies, and ecosystems, and manifested in the hybrid urban morphology and
architectural typologies. Here cultural and geographical ‘boundary’ is always
blurring, overlapping, or intersecting, and has never been clearly defined80 Southeast Asian Culture and Heritage in a Globalising World
it LIT
Medit f Asi
jediterranean of Asia Z>
ay
“se SU
oy . we
i NN
Figure 5.1 Mediterranean of Asia
Source: Figure by author, Johannes Widodo.
At the dawn of Southeast Asian urban maritime civilisation, the vessels from
China, Japan, and Ryukyu’ sailing (o the south made use of the northern monsoon
between January and February, returning home by the southern monsoon
between June and August. Indian and Arab ships went eastward by the southwest
monsoon between April and August, and returned by the northeast monsoon from
December. During the cyclone periods or the changing monsoon seasons, these
traders stayed in Southeast Asian ports (such as Samudra Pasai and Melaka) and
inhabited the markets. while waiting for their tcading partners from the other parts
of the world. Metaphorically the city is like a boat or a vessel, loaded by people.
goods, activities, rituals, and symbolism. The trading ships and immigrant boats
were not only carrying people and goods. but also conveying cosmological and
1 Thekingdom of Ryukyu, located at the currently known Okinawa islands, appeared
around the fifteenth to sixteenth century growing as intermediary trading hub between Fast
‘Asia (China and Japan) with Southeast Asia, before the European disrupted and dominated
the maritime trade in this region.Morphogenesis and Hybridity of Southeasi Asian Coastal Cities gl
geometrical patterns (like architectural typologies, urban grids, and hierarchy of
spaces) from original sources into the new landscapes, implanting new layers in
the new lands. People from different places, islands or continents are kept moving,
communicating, and intermingling, influencing each other and producing hybrid,
fused, diverse architecture and material culture.
For more than two millenniums of urban history, cities in this region have been
demonstrating their ability to preserve primary elements and basic morphological
patterns. Never ending processes of layering, transformations, and hybridisation,
is probably the best way to describe its dynamic and sustainable characters.
Diversity, eclecticism, fusion, acculturation, adaptation, can perhaps describe the
nature of Southeast Asian architecture and urbanism from the past into the present
and hence into the future.
ering Process of Urban Morphology
The vernacular building tradition in Southeast Asia is the outcome of local climate,
building materials and techniques, also indigenous beliefs and rituals, The people who
live inland are mostly involved in agriculture, with rice-culture as the most dominant
activity, Those who live in coastal areas are traders and seafarers. The architecture
in this region is the reaction to equatorial and tropical warm-humid climates.
Architecture is also adapted to earthquakes, especially within an archipelago which
is continuously rocked by active volcanoes and continental plate movements. The
building construction method is similar to the shipbuilding technique, and the flexible
structural system is well adapted to absorb destructive forces of the earthquake.
Rivers systems have been the lifeline of human settlement, Early settlement that
bore the seeds of urbanity appeared near the waterfront, as the connection point
between the outside worlds and the interior hinterland. The waterfront settlement
nucleus in the Malayan, Indonesian, and Cambodian contexts is called Kampung.
According to some locals, Kampung (in languages currently described as ‘Bahasa
Malaysia’ and ‘Bahasa Indonesia’), or Kompong (in Cambodian) originally refers
to the area on the riverbank near the landing point and on the path to the settlement
further uphill from the waterfront.
In subsequent centuries, Indian cosmology (Hinduism and also Buddhism)
was transmitted from India to Southeast Asia and East Asia through trades and
migrations, applying a new layer of ordering principles and meaning into vernacular
spaces and structures. [t is believed that human lives exist in between vertical and
horizontal universal orders, metaphorically summarised in the tripartite hierarchical
sub-division of upper-middle-lower (see Figure 5.2). This cosmological sub-
division follows the metaphor of the human body, the head, the torso, and the
fect, parallel to the metaphor of the universe, sky, ground, and underworld. This is
known as the concept and ordering principles of the ‘Mandala’?
2 ‘Mandala’ is a Sanskrit term meaning ‘circle’ or ‘completion’.82 Southeast Asian Culture and Heritage in a Globalising World
Figure 5.2 Superimposition of two tripartite cosmological hie
of space
Source: Sketch by author, Johannes Widedo,
The physical remains of the cultural heritages from this period were almost
vanished due to the non-durable materials such as brick and timber they used
in the building construction, but many Hindu-Buddhist made of stones temples |
still survived (such as Angkor in Cambodia, Borobudur and Prambanan in Java).
However from the archeological findings it is evident that the layout of the cities in
this region showed clear underlying Indian cosmological principles, harmoniously
merged with the local vernacular planning and design traditions. \
Islam entered and spread throughout Southeast Asia through various trading
routes in the thirteenth to fourteenth centuries. The Arab, Yemeni, Gujarati, and {
Tamil traders from West Asia and South Asia were the earliest agents of the spread
of Islam in Southeast Asia, followed by the Chinese Muslims, the latter especially
iMorphogenesis and Uybridity af Southeast Asian Coastal Cities 3
during the voyages to Southeast Asia and the indian Ocean of Admiral Zheng He
of the Ming dynasty in the fifteenth century. The process began from the urban
centres along the northern coast of Java (Gresik, Tuban, Demak, Semarang) and
northern tip of Sumatra (Samudra Pasai in Aceh), then spread to other coastal port
cities in the Malay peninsula and Indonesian archipelago (Melaka. Palembang,
Makassar. Banjarmasin, Ternate, Tidore, Ambon, etc.), and southern Philippines
(Mindanao, Palawan, and the islands around Sulu sea)
Islam introduced new typology and vocabulary in Southeast Asian architecture
and urban forms such as the Islamic orientation towards the Qiblat (praying
orientation towatds Mecca). The natural and peacefull fusion processes of the
new Islamic design principles into the building and urban spatial typology from
the previous periods took place during this period. The hybrid architectural style
is @ tangible manifestation of the cosmopolitan spirit and the tolerant nature of
the Southeast Asian urban culture in embracing and incorporating new foreign
elements, Patrons, artists and builders from different ethnic and cultural groups
worked together and coordinated their artisiry and skill to construct new and anique
building tradition and architectural form, for example Kampung Kling mosque in
Melaka (Figure 4.2),
Figure 5.3. Kampung Kling mosque in Melaka
Notes: Tangible architectural manifestation of cultural fusion and hybridity of Javanese,
Indian, Malay, Chinese, Portuguese, Dutch and other Architectural elements and detailing.84 Southeast Asian Culture and Heritage in a Globalising World
The coastal region of Southeast Asia was the first place where new cities and
coastal settlements appeared as a result of this international wading network.
During the cyclone periods or the changing monsoon seasons, the traders stayed
in Southeast Asian ports, while waiting for their trading partners from the other
parts of the world to come. During their stay the crew and passengers of the
ships populated the city and mingled with the local population. Many of the carly
Chinese colonies were developed near river estuaries closed to the pre-exisied
indigenous villages. Some of these early settlements then grew into flourishing
entrepéts® (such as Pattani, Melaka, Palembang, and Semarang) thanks to the
vibrant international maritime trading. The Chinese architectural elements
blended with the local-vernacular design features created numerous variations of
fusion building styles.
The voyages of Admiral Zheng He to Southeast Asia and the Indian Ocean during
the Ming Dynasty left tangible traces along the coastal regions of Southeast Asia
in the form of Chinese settlements. These new coastal towns were well integrated
into the pre-existing structure of the original coastal villeges, mostly situated
near the river estuaries and shorelines. The morphology of these cosmopolitan
settlements consisted of an interrelated double nuclei. It is a common occurrence
in coastal Southeast Asia that an old Chinese temple is located adjacent to an
ancient mosque within the old urban core, close to the waterfront, at the middle
of a multi-racial cosmopolitan community. Both of these areas were separated
but interconnected by a market place not far from the harbour. The market place
was the common urban centre, a meeting place for the locals and foreigners to
mect and to exchange. It was a public place with a strong cosmopolitan character.
Unique identity, belief, and material culture of each group were preserved and
nurtured, and at the same time a new communal hybrid identity would be created
and developed, based on mutual respect and the spirit of tolerance.
On every Southern Chinese immigrant boat, a special shrine for Mazu* was
installed to safeguard the compass, the steering wheel, the sailing direction, and
all passengers aboard. Once the boat reached the destination in the South Seas and
they decided to settle down, the ship would be dismantled and the shrine would be
reconstructed near the landing place at the shore or riverfront. The new settlement’s
spatial structure of the diasporie southern coastal Chinese was a reconstruction
of the cosmological pattern of the immigrant boat, where the Mazu temple was
placed at the end of the axis facing the harbor and two masts were placed in front
of the temple (such examples in Palembang, Melaka, Yangon.