1430 ADPF 54 - Voto Min. Cezar Peluso

Supremo Tribunal Federal

! " #
$

!" " #

$

# #

"%'

$()*#()+##(),#---#'.

# "

/

.

" " $
1 2

# 2#
/3
2 #"
2

# 4
3

$
%&'(&)*+.)/0/''13&4/53/64*+.7)9:$ ;0<6=64'>(3.)0.
/5?3&.)13&4'@$
5

5

# 7

4

8

2
3
7
$
3#
#
"

4 # 2 2 "
9

/3$

# 2 2 2
# # # " 2

#
":
2
! $'
"

4 )9:$ #
;": A&B4 "
# 8
#

C3.0/''.$=$$$>'

#
# 2 2

" ? 5
#? 5

'=0/''+. =)&(13&4 / C/354)/)(/ B/ 5=B4)*4' .= 0.)(D)=.
C3.0/''43>'/#2

$=$$$>.

#2 ":

5 #
"
&
'
'
'
'
&
&
<
'
&
'
'
'
>
>
&
&

!

$'

#
2
7

#
@A

#
"

# B
@ 2

B
"

B " !
$
-"
#

B "

# $$

#

"
!

" !

# 0.) 6/ F=46& '&
&)'(4=34 =) C3.0/''. B/'(&)4(. 4 'A.6G/3'& '/)H4
'.6=H&.)/ B& 0.)(&)=&(7 / '/)H4 )/0/''&(7 B& =6(/3&.3&
'(&5.6&/'(/3)&B$(
' / # "/

5"

"
."
%
C3.0/''.#

'=0/''+. 0.)(D)=4 B/ 5=B4)*4' B/ 40.3B. 0.5 B&3/(3&H
=)&(13&4B/B/'/)A.6A&5/)(.4=(I).5.#
!

"

#
3#9

8
#

5
7
.
#22C/
"

$
E #7
2

3
#
#

# 2 2 5 # " #

54 $F2

2
04C40&B4B/B/5.A&5/)(.4=(KG/).$
I&''.)+..(L5.'/5?3&M/'0.)G/64B.'#

.2
7 %

2

# 2

7
# !
/
#

# 2C/
# 2#
.
#

"
# #

2

!

$J
N# =0&4).$ $K

-

$L

$" $M#
3 (N,,#$(O+*$P
"$
)

"
&
'
'
'
'
&
&
<
'
&
'
'
'
>
>
&
&

/ 4 2#
2

"

# 5 #

#2 2

#

#

"

/
5
#3/46&B4B/C3<>O=3DB&042#
"
?
"
#

$
I#

#5

#
#

"
# 5

# 3
:
5 " 5
$ I

#
5 #!

"
5
#

2. 2
"
5
3

#2 !
8

#

/

$
1 # #2(.B.'" " Q 2#

# 7 #
3
7

Q
2

.#
5

2
$1

!3#"
7
#

5

.

5 # R
;

$J)

# 3 # "
#
# /
A&B4

7
#

.
# 2

$;

!

!
"#

%#
$S7

4 5

"

5"
3 /

2 2

. R
;
"

#" # #
7 #
2

C/'F=&'4'B/0<6=64'/5?3&.)13&4'C31(&044?.3(&A4$
)
7$(*T
?$
M

"
&
'
'
'
'
&
&
<
'
&
'
'
'
>
>
&
&

!

7
4
/
A&B4 &)(34=(/3&)4#
#
G34A&B/H#

8

= $()*$'.
>$ #
3
2 4

##

#
7

3

$U

. 2
V
2
/
52
V
I

" 7

"

2

5"

7
#
2 5
4 5
#

P ""#
@2

7

?
$ F

2

"
2 $E #
9 2
.7

#2
2#
# 7

$F

Q.354*+.
# 2 2

"

! #
&)'/3&3 ). R(/3.$ I
? )=)04
'/3+.

9 B$J
"

# # 2
# #
"

.
2
5.3(//)0/Q16&04M#

5

;&
'
!

() )*+(+,**-./&()&

!

0

!

!

'
1'

#

!

'

2
0
34 /5

!

!'

6
'

2
0
34 7234),+89:*-

'
"#
1
'

*

"
&
'
'
'
'
&
&
<
'
&
'
'
'
>
>
&
&

$
4
# 2
!
#
2 % "
#
!?R
=
> "7

! 3 ; '

!

0 '

;
%*#2 " W
=
>
/
9
!

.
#

#

7
#2 %2 4
/

#
< !

?

"'@
# 1
!

# 1@

#

!

'

1

'

!

!
0
J$ "

2 4
.#27 .
R.
!
=
3;

J># # #'46A43A&B4'$
'"$S $' #
#2;

!
A

BC&

0
'

!

1

#

<

'
<
'

'

0

%B" T N V$(M3(T
?>$
'"$# # W R; '

D0

1

?

" E
% =$ )T3)+
?>W
# ;D

'
1

A 1

FG

3

0
"

%

8 # 3#

5

#
;'

;

E

E

'

;BC

#
E !

1

!

%B !
#$)*O
?>$
T

"
&
'
'
'
'
&
&
<
'
&
'
'
'
>
>
&
&

" TW
=
>"

2"
"

" R ;
1
H !

'
1 !

D

I

?

K
L
"K
L ! KLJ+W
=
> "7
#

"
#
2

" 3
X#
"

5

2 W
7
"

#
2 #
5
2 A&B4$ #
# 2
% #

!?Q #
#5

5
32
! 4
. 5 "7
W
= >

#
#

/
#27
# ;
!

1'

!

#0
!
!

0K
L
?#

0 !

0 % ,$ E

2 "

"7
.
#
2

#
#

. "

$ E #
#

5
2 2
" #

5

5"
#
#.
8
5
$
E #" 5

.
'" 3#
#
? !"
= "

# $ (T(
?> !
B4
/

#$)MN
?>$
+
W #$)M3)*

?#$$
M #$)*O3)*($K 3

?
YM#
$
$N+$
+

"
&
'
'
'
'
&
&
<
'
&
'
'
'
>
>
&
&

"
"7
N 2
!
/
#
2#
?#

7

#

. $
$ 3<>/X06='+. B4 6&?/3B4B/ / 4=(.).5&4 O=3DB&04'V ). 04'. B/
0.5C.3(45/)(. (&C&Q&04B. 0.5. 03&5/$ /)F=4B345/)(. B4
&)(/33=C*+.B4G34A&B/H4)/)0/Q16&04).(&C.B/6&(&A.B/4?.3(.$
"
25

5

#

"

" $ "
#
#
2#;

#

@

'

BCN
&
'

0 ! 1

"#
%(O$
# # #

7
$I4
3# "#
$()*'.

#
7
25#

#
2 #
"

# ;

1

! 1J(($ #

$
N
'

4 . " # $
W R;&6
'

234),-OP:9+
1
!

N

'
P99-N
)+8-
4
Q

BC
RK&,)& !
:

% =$)X3),
?#$$>$ Z
YN$*M*[NX
# # . " . "7
#
4

#
#&33/A/3'&?&6&B4B/B4C434B4043BD404$
(O
$(,3(N$
((
# 3(=3.$ ) 2

# 6
4&DSMDM 3N S&T6MG M U 2?DGDVMD?$
$ '

# K
L'L\\\3-\#$*),$
X
Y

E !
7
" 2;

@

%() " 9 (M# 2
"

# 5!#

# 5 2

"
4
$
5#

2 !

#
" "7
# " #
5
$I#
" .
# #

#
.

#"
:
4
/

5
3
$E7
#

5
# %

# 2

" 7

$ E #

35
#9

#

#

!# " %
%

"5

# #

$ F

]
? "

# 2

#

#

" "7
$ I#
#

.

;

J(*#2
7

# YN " .
(T#
"$
F2# 7
# " #!
#"
#
- #$ Z N N =$))
()

?>$
'
#
#

L
$ N ="$
(M
NO3N(>R;&
"! 1

BC
"

E BCA
1

BC

'!

E
%
(*
7$(+M
?$
U "
;

J =$ )O,
(T

?>$
,
Y

%

4

7
: #

#8#

5
#

5

2

7 /
! $I "

# 2 2
# 2/
#
"

#
"
# 4

(+$ "

= #

# > =##

#
>$ E 4 5

" # 3

2# " #
"

!

32 2" $L

" "
%

5

3# 5
# "

/

3 #
!

"
%
4 5
#
3#2

# "

5!

'

K9
$
'"

#
5

7

;

E

?

#

0'

"#
0

'

#

! W
E#
J(X$
E 2 # 3
#
.
#
%

4

# 7

I $
.
5
# 2 '
/

#

2

" $Z %9
2/
#
5

Q
(, Q#

$ ! P V V &
(+

#)$#E^_`R #(NNO# $
(X
$N+$
(,
;6

2
M!
4
!"##$!% !

N
Y

8
5
! #5
#

! 4
.

"5
# %

$ I

#

#

5
##$4$#

#

# "

.

7
#2
4

5

! 7

5
#2#

#

5
"
$
1
. # #

R

#
#4
# 2

$ I "
.
35

5

#

#
/
#77$

"
3
. W 2

R
5
# 4

# #
4 $
2
" "

"

#
#2
# 3
. !
2
"

4

#5"
$L #% 5 ## #
" "
" #
/

2
2
#

5

$
" 4

#

5
#

!
5
# 2
" .
2 2
%

.
/
#2 "
#

& ' ( * +,.J#
3L
$WS #I L
'
Y($O++=0$)9$[[#
1
I
>$
(O
Y

#;
'
'

2 !

NBC 1.5
%(N$5
9

"

#

7
# L
$
WS #2 "
#;
0

E

!
,P8
2 !
N

$=$$$>G

!
E

@ E
J)O$

##
1$I4 $2

5
# /
# 2
2 /# #
; #
!

,P8
2 !
N

! 1

E
R

%)($ 2
# # 4

#
"
.

#

"
%

$

"

4

.
.
%
#

" 5"
"
3

/
$L

# !

5
#2

"
; #

! J))$
I
" (&C&0&B4B/ 2#

! # #" #%"

$

#

"
#

#
/

7

(N
$(+$
)O
$))X3)),$
)(
$))X$
))
1 2 N X 0 !0 !0 X .Y

5 Y

!
!0

0M

0
E 1
00

X 0"/X !$J=N\N V&5.)$20 X
$)R
V0?E
Y
X
N0

0X$4"R4"a

b#(NN*#$+)>$$# #
N ] !V ^_ !V Y ` V S
=$>#G

!

1 RL
#)OO+#$*)M3*)*$
((
Y

!!

$
$B&G)&B4B/0.)'(&(=0&.)46C6/)4B4A&B4&)(34=(/3&)4
7 %
#

" 25 # #

?#
" 4''4''&)4(./ " 3
$I
8 #

/
R

# 9 52

#

5

#% 2 2
#

4
" #2# # .
5.5/)(. B/ /X/0=*+.#
5 4 5
#
4
73$
1

# " 45

R

" 3
=2# "
#
/#
# 4

> "

% " #"
#
.
#
2 2 5 5
2
7
5

$E
9
2#
#

5

"
5
$
U
.

# #
5
5

#

V "

/
5

'

#
"
3# #

" #
# ;
J )M$
E#
#
2;

E
#

cd

#
!
0 G c d R
! D

&

#
!#" #2 ;
J# 2 "
;

)M

J
=!>$ I 8
# #
"

2
4
#

# 2#
"

7
# ;
"
Z
;

!

IE

E

J
()
Y

! #
!
"
!
J)*
I
2 "

)9 :$ #

94

2
3
"

2 R
;=$$$>

7
2#
4
4

#
G34B=43 . B&3/&(. 7 A&B4 0.5 4 3<G=4 &5C/3(&)/)(/ 2#
#

#
a.5&0DB&.

2

4?.3(.#

5/).3 B&G)&B4B/ O=3DB&0.>0.)'(&(=0&.)46 4 A&B4 &)(34=(/3&)4
=$$$>$
2

$

#

#5

#
#
#
5
#

8

$
'
3# 5# 5

5

3

#2
./5&)/)(/G34=B/B&G)&B4B/
/(=(/64F=/4.)'(&(=&*+.B4 /CR?6&043/'/3A44.0a454B.
B&3/&(. 7 A&B4# 2 # # .

4
/

$
/3

!# .

"
a.5&0DB&.#
"

"

#
# 4# %

.

#2
"
# $$ )T

7

2# 5
#
A46a45/).'
5

5

2 ]L 4
#
#
&)Q4)(&0DB&. = $ ()M '.
># 2#

"5
5
#
"
)*
# "$NT$
)T
'
3#4#

;
'

[9BC

0! J= $+(#
$--#;J>$
7#

" #

2
7
5
#2

"

%
$
(M
Y

5
= $ ()( '.
># # !

?

5
= >#

#'/5&''.
'&G)&Q&F=/# 5
#

#
F=/ 4A&B4B.&)Q4)(/A46a45/).'B.F=/4B/F=46F=/3.=(34
C/''.4$
33
2# 4#

"

$L #

2C

# 72

7

# 7# $ !# " 5
# 2# I #
!
74
= $(TT'.
>]
5

5
3

4 #
# 2

5
$
5
2
#
4.
5

# )/5
'/5C3/< 4.A46.3).354(&A. B/'(/#
5

!
#
#
#%"
4 .
03&5/'B/
4?.3(.a.5&0DB&.#

#B/5.B.//5'/)(&B.
46G=5'/C3/'(44'='(/)(43C/3/G3&)4(/.3&4B/F=/.B&3/&(.7
A&B4'/3&4'='0/(DA/6B/G34B=4*M/'4X&.6KG&04'
5
"

$J
' " # #2

# /
;
. 5

"#
M

&

#

"

"
"#

<

BC

' "

'

E

!

!
!
#"#

'

"# &0 1'

(*
Y

0 &

D

0
"

#
!
&
"# "
0

! 1

BC D

c " " d
"

'
0

BC

Y

"

"#
0

"

$J
I '=O/&(. B/ B&3/&(.# !#

#

2#

#

# " #

#
"
5
#
4

# 2

A&B4#

? $ )Y'.
'

$ # 5# 4#
#2
= $T*)'.

'

>$

#2 "
#2
" 5
= $ ($XXN# # '.
'

>$ F

# 2 7

= $($XN,'.
'

>$2 2
#
#

45

#

#2# 3 #

#

5

2#

#

#2

$ I#
#
2 5
#

]

"
# %
2 29
#2

#

$I#2#
#
"

2 "

$
S$A46.3&)/'(&51A/6B4A&B4V&)(34.=/X(34=(/3&)4V)+.B/C/)B/
B/ '=4 F=46&B4B/ .= B=34*+.# . 3&'0. B. '=3G&5/)(. B/ C31(&04' B/
/=G/)&4//=(4)1'&4$
(T

# 2 2
#
#
"

7 #
# 4#
" #
2 .
#
"
"

#
4 #
5
2 45
.

#
# 22 4

#
? 7
7
#
5 $ ()) '.
= 45

5
>$

#
# 5"

#
4
2
"/ )+#

"73
#
"
"
#

7 %!

#2 #
%
$ '

!?

3P K9
R;

BC
!

0
M

\G

R

"#

I !

'

E
0FN

\%)X$
3

. # "
#
" 7
/
#

"

# $$F
#
# "

?
: 9
"
4 #
2
! #
#
$

#

5 #

.
5
#

! "
5"

.
#
"

2"
#

7
#2 ##

$e
#

Q
2 " / " Q# 73
'# # "
'Eff# $ "
)+
T N R;

0
1 E

!

?

E

1
E0

%=$
O+
?>$
)X
7$ON $
(+

5
"

7 #2 #

#
/
$'
3#7 "

#;

"#
$J),

#

"
? 4
/

7
#
"
# # ! 7
3 %

$ /
"
/
#

#
#

5
#

%

? . 2 "
$ !

#

! 7

"
#

3
"

#

"#
# #
#.2

:

])N
1 !

!
5

#

B # T !R;

'
c
/
d#

S
c "
" # +*T

d &

V

\N

0E

%MO
),
$(T+$
)N
'"$ b$ &N

# $ $K Z
$1RL
#
(NN,#$XMW $ &6Q $ $L
e K
$,g$Z
R
' P`
# (N*N# $ )),3))NW N # 4QQ4/66.$ &

1
L $
R
f I

#(,,,#$(N*(NTWSP #
4=6=$>$H 7

$ $e

$Tg

$1 R'
Z #$)M3)*$

J$)R
E

MO
L
$
(X

"
"5 $E
2# .

.

#
$
#
#!
5

. ##$!$# "

7
#2
! #
# ; '

J## 3

5
#
73
" 7
$

"
#

# # #

5
3

#
4
4 2 "
8
#

"52
"

$ - 5

2

!

7
#

#
2
#

#
7

5
$

#

# 2 2
2
=
2"#
#

"
# " >$
" "
# # 2 #

$
E #72 "

;

E %M(#72!
5
22 2 # # #
" "
#
#
2 # "5

52
#
"
$F2

# 5
#
"
# "

#
4
.

"
%
"
9 $
#7
#

4

"

2

!
$
M(
$+3X(T$
(,

# " 3 ;
%M)
7
#
$
#
#
!
]
!

"

I
V

MM&'

"

'

G
1
"#

2
'
JM*$ #
#2 2 ;
E
!
0

J 2 #
4
/

#
"
"
"
3

$ #

5

"
3#
# " $
E # " 7
4
3

$ 3# # "
3 2
"
?
5
3

R #

# 45

5

5
# # ? !#

#5
"5
#2

7
#"

#

#

# 5

"
#

%
# "

5
3

#2

#2

7
$
#
" 7
/
$"

# )9:$ #2
# 2
3
7
#
.
/
R
;
3

#2
M)
$X(T$
MM
! # ;

J='/&)H=5
.B>#4
2; 0

J=
$ $L
17' 1 `$((g$
.
RI$!#)OO*# --#$M)$P
"

>$
M*
$N*$
(N

.4
#@

I

B$
%
.
3@

'!

VBQ

4 #
2
5
#
"
! $ 3
2# 3 7

.

7
#
I

!
#

4

9
'

# 2

2 2 /
$J
1
# 2 # /
#

! 3 " $ !
"

!
%
#

"

"
"

/
# "
R; E
E

!
"

! "

D Q 0
@ E

'
I %MT
F5

7
M+2#
#

5

.
MX#2
!
MT
$ O+# Y ,$ 4

.3
" #
YN "=$(+*
?>
c \=$
(NN
?>$
M+
I "

#

=; X
%C#2
7 $
'
!
%
$ W
MX
R;&

0
"
'
!

Q ^ E
R ! 0

0
0

!

,(,O.
5,8

'@
! E !

I E

$J=$)M
?>$
)O

#2#% " :
#

#"

$#

7
7 "
$
F 2 " 7
"

?# 2]
BC&
&YN3 ) O+ 1
I 0
'

'

N

0

! JM,
L # .
5
#
. 7 # 2#
# 2 # "#
!

7

# # 2 # %

4

# /3
$
2

4 #

" #
"
"

#
.

#
/

5

5
$
" # "
#
$1 "

;
#
E J #
7#27
#

5

5
/5G/346#2
2

$
!"

"
3P K9
#
R;

'

0
0

1

0
' !'
4 0

!'

YN "V $ (+*

?$ E
#

M,
c \ "
" "
"

/
=$ (NN3)OO

?>#
!
$L # "

"

/
#7 %
7
R;0

'

D
E

'
KE L "#1

BC

'

BC% =$
(N(3(N)
?>$
.

#

#
4

# /3 !
5
Q
#?

# 2

$
)(

0$JMN
1
" 2! 5

2 "

9 #

##
#
/3

4
# 2 $ '
T !# 2 % !
" #; 0 0

[
0
+O

"
0
0

BCA
0
FJ*O

/
2
" #2##
!
# " 5

# 7
"

#
5
#
"
5
# #
?
# $$ E
"

/

" 3
$ '

3#
# 7

# V1

! " # 2

#
33

7 V
"

4 $
2
5
# #

# " 5

*( "
"
" ]
#

.
#
.

# 2
5
" #
2" .

. 7 #2

5
= >$*)
2
3
7
#
2

# 2
MN
7$O, $
*O
;

J#)R
E

L
$
*(
' "

)9:$ $
*)
'"$! # /6'.)$2

!
$Mg$KSR# $#$)+M#Y
TN$
))

!
5

# 3#
"
#
# % 2

3
$E

4
#.

W #
2
"

#2
)9:$ $
S$'B&Q&0=6B4B/'/B&A/3GL)0&4'B/B&4G)K'(&0.$0.)'/F=/)(/
4G34A45/)(.B.3&'0.B//=G/)&4$

4
7 #
2# 2
#
$I2
22

2 7
7

# #

# 2
"
#
"
73
"? .
# 2

2 $ 1 5 2 #
7
# "

7

" " 9 V
#
3#7
/
9

! Q

"

Q
"
5
#
5 # #

.
#

25 "

"

# ! ;
5

4
J2 $
/

?

#" # "
=

#
5"
# ; "
J
;
J*M>
" "
$

"2 # "
"
&
VD.
5

*M

1
0

X

2

3 X 4

% =LF\-'$
1
1 $1 5
.b
. 1 $

.P
I

5 $4N

_ ! G
!
Y

V
DL !)OOT#$(*>$
)M

# $ S #

.
L S#;

$J** F
.
#"
#2

2
V

# #
7
"

"
2;
0Q !

1
!
1G1GE
!

1 BC
!
0
" U

%*T #
#2
7
;
!

!

#

!

!G
1

0
% *+
#
2#

3

5"
#7

"
.
#
# # 5
?
"

$ "
# "

#
7

#

"
?
#
"

7

?
" 3
" V

/

"

7

/
9
#
#
"
5"
7
"

" .

2

"
# 2

? ! 2 1 .
d
NY #
7# %

"

#2
#
"

R
;Ne
"

!
R "

"
!
B" $ - %
"

**
$,X
?$
*T
^Y #$()+3()X

?$
*+
7$(X
?$
)*
<
>
>

" !

!
#

h !
!

A43&.G34B.B&546Q.354H&.)/
!

!!

i$ 1

"
2

# !

"

#!
"

!

A43&4?&6&
" $Z
!

"
j A43&4?&6/#
A43&4?&6/ j

"
$ Z
"

A #

$
k 2
2

"

" !
"
W ).)'&B/A/(=((4A&4C/)'43/0a/
F=/'(4546Q.354H&.)/'&4=)4/)(&(7'(3/((45/)(/B/Q&)&?&6/$
ZB
2
"
B "

#

# A43&/(7

!

"
!

B $
Z B&QQ&0.6(7 B& 064''&Q&04H&.)/
"
B "
).)f=)4546Q.354H&.)/B&(&C.(=((.>)=664#
A2

#

" !

0a/ C4''4V '/)H4 '.6=H&.)/ B& 0.)(&)=&(7V B4& F=4B3& 5/).
G34A&4&F=4B3&B&&)B=?&(4?&6/4)/)0/Q46&4$a
"
!

A2

&5C.''&?&6/$J*X
#
" ? #

7

.

!

?
5"
#
2 9
5
V
/

?
#
# 2/
2 " 2 25!

% %

" NM

1

*X

! )($O+$(NN+#$ON#
5 R[[^^^$ $
[

["[)*$"$P
"
$
)T

"
"
"
"
&
"
'
"
"
"
&

O
<
>
>

#

5
%

%

$ I /
7

4# 2#
#

#

# "
#

# "
*,# 2

#
! #
3 "*N$
I #

.
#2
"

#
%
# 2
! # 2 "

# 25
3
5"
#
4

" 4
/

.

4
$I #
! #
B

$

2 2#;

!1 !,99`BC
00

% TO#
7 2

? &B/)(&Q&04*+.C3/0&'4

(OOm #

" $1 2#

"

.
# "
#
5

#" #2Q

?

4 BC
*,

'

! !

0

1
0
G

!
%BS S V$,*
?>$;H
"

1
1 ! ! 1 BC

!
1 G 0
!
1
0 0
'

BCH

!

4BCD

%B^Y V$()X
?>$
$#$4$# " !c ='"
*N
E
a'Z>NP =a

b"#'"L

>#2#

4 L SP$
# #
#2;0

0X%#2;4
00X
0U
X "

!
! 1
% =L
; @"7
BJ$
'"/
E
f
f
Q NN#$*X3*N>$
TO
L
$ Y# "$MT$
)+

"
"
"
"
&
"
'
"
"
"
&

O
<
>
>

3

2 "
$'

# 9
# V]4

!N

;
!

!

0!

+

*
5
6
''7%T(
2

# /

!
3
5"
2 "

.
#

3

"

" ?
"
#

3

$ I "#
#

#
2
5

"
#

2"

5

$

8

L

#
7# 8

5
$

/# #
#

4

9

7 5
$I

2

9 #
#

# $
S$ &5C3.C3&/B4B/ B4 4)46.G&4 0.5 4 (.3(=34# 4='L)0&4 B/
'.Q3&5/)(.8
VR)&0.O=3&B&045/)(/4C3/0&1A/6$

3#
#2
!" " !
"
% # 2
73 "

7 % $T)
F
2

2 #
#

$ 2 #
# #

5
3

3
T(
7$(*(
?$
T)
$(,$
)X

"
"
"
"
&
"
'
"
"
"
&

O
<
>
>

45 # #
? #

# #
"
."
# 3# 5
"
TM#"
9"5
#
T*#

%
#
!

!
2
" " #
"

;
/
J$
I 2$
"
2;2
'
3

B O) MMMC ! '

'

#

BR

CJ$TT # 2 ?
2

#

5
2"

$

" 2! # 2 7
!#

"
.
! " %"

R "
2#

# 7 $L
2
#
#6/G465/)(/
$ #

!/3#
.

#2 "
&)O='(.
&)(/)0&.)46 2

5
5
$ #
. #

"
7
5
?
#
K 4
/
"
."
2 ; '

TM

J "

$ ! P #

# "
2

=; %C
#

#; E
!

%;
Q
'

'

%
#;
#!

'

!

#

#

%
7
# #

## 2
#
5
$'"$;& !0
0 !0J$)RV0S O+$O,$)OOT$
T*
'"$"$)O$
TT
$(,$
),

"
"
"
"
&
"
'
"
"
"
&

O
<
>
>

#
4 #

#

%

" $

# "
8

"

C3.C.'&(46"
$- 3R2
#
9
#

%V" " #" ;.5
.5

JT+V I #
"
Z

# 2#

73 %#
4
.

VU #
S

7
#2#
3 "
" #
!
3

E 0
4

V
"$g YN " # 2
# 5

: I 2

4

.
$TX
I #
7# ! 7 2 4

&)O='(&*4
#25
%
5
$
! ].
#7
R
;"

2

W
%
$
" "
$ I 2

5
"

# 2

.
2
5

4
/
" "
$
E2

3
3"

#
8
#
#

%

$ 1. 2 2
5

#
"
# 4(.'&)O='(.'2 $
V B4=(.$ N
!
0

#
5
T+
n R[[^^^$
$$[ o

o
$ 4Vp)*ON)q#O*$OT$)OO+$
Z
3R;D
'
"# 0

'@
TX
BC

G

!

!
&

! 1

!
0

%=$(+T
?>$
)N

"
"
"
"
&
"
'
"
"
"
&

O
<
>
>

"

7
4(. 4)(&O=3DB&0.#

$L
"
#
$JT,$
L " .
"
"
4. # ."
I #

"
2
4
"
5
; JTN $
I 7# 2
# !#
" 7
#2#
2 "
#
5
# 27"

#
2/
5
"
# 2 "

: #% #

#4

/

#

"
'

K9
# 2 2

"

#
34 $
I !
3#
#
5
# "
# %

# 2 ;
c7
" d
E !

!

'

! 1A BCV

? !

Y

!

! 1

!

A
'

$J+O
.
7

"7

$E7#
. # 5

4

!
7
"4
.
#

?
25
'.
$
!#

# $
T,
$NT$
TN
7$(+*
?$
+O
$)(+3)(X
?$
MO

"
"
"
"
&
"
'
"
"
"
&

O
<
>
>

#2
.

"
2
##.
#"
.

" $'2

! "
#

2#%! 7
.
5
#
7" ! #
#"
2 O='(.
&)O='(.
/
#
7

7

$ 5# 7

# "/

#

7

"
$
?3
# # 2

5
# 2#
4
/
52
#

!

$
L
#
3

#
4
2

"

#
#7"

#"

/
# 2 7

: 2
"

9
#

# 2

! %

#

?

5
!$
#
2#
#
.
"
52
#4 # #

"
#
4# # 2

! 5
$
' #

#
ZNN #

7
2
R
;L #

7
2 #/
#

"

2
"

#2

2 / %

M(

"
"
"
"
&
"
'
"
"
"
&

O
<
>
>

2

"
!?
#2#
5
2
/

J$+(
2 # # "

#7
!

#
#

# #

$ "
5

# 2 " .
! #
"
5 5
7
%

"5

$
E # .

2

5
" #

47 #

4
.

# 2

/
#2
22

5
7
2 $ E
# 3 ##2
#
"7
"
"
##
"

"
2

5

# 5

" !
# 2
.
# "

5

25
$E7#
2
"

#

! 2

5
5 #" #
#
"5

7

3 #2
#
$
L +)#2 "
" ' # " 3
+(
Y
$KS31R# *Y# I
#-#(g$#(N++#$(XM3(X*$
+)
4

. "
"
L
$
N 3
=U$$# "$ ()+>R ;<
c"

3"5
3

M)

"
"
"
"
&
"
'
"
"
"
&

O
<
>
>

.

2
?
7

# 2

2/
$
E
"
# 5

%" #/

5
#
7 4
$ #

#"
#2

!#

!2/
# 2

#&)/A&(1A/6#
/

&)O='(4#

2 2 # 45

4 #"
2#.
" 9
# " $
!3#

#
"
"
4 # "

4
#

5

#

.

#"
?.

# 2
"

# 7" #
"
# "

2 " 4
2 $E
"
#
2
4
/
#"
#2
# $
# #
!#

"
#

/
# 45

$' "
Q #
2 " Q.

5
#% ! +M#%
# "

## # 2
d
!
!'

D
'
'

E D " '

K

L

'
! 1
"

Q

0
'
&1 1

0

E
$J
L
$ N #"
#
+M

! ;

%
=
$
S1# "$(M(3(M)>#2#;

!
MM

"
"
"
"
&
"
'
"
"
"
&

O
<
>
>

# 5

7

$L 22
2
"

7
2#&)O='(.

#

%5

"
" 5
&)O='(&*4 ]
I .

# 5

5
8

# 2

.
2 5

2

##

#

9
2
2
5
$ e7# #

2
5
2"
" V1 7# 7
.
4
# 5

#

5

$U. "

S
V
U " "
# #
8
#
!32

"

# 9
2 2/
#

!# "7
#

#
4 # 4
$
#
!

%
!
# 2 # #

#
7
#

#
8

#

$

"

5
7

$
#

2
#
# ?3 7 "
7
; J
.
"
#
2

5
" "5

=
># 2
! "7
#
. #

#

7 2
"
= >$ !#

$
E

6G

BC
0

I
1
0 4 0 0

!

"#
%="$(),>$
M*

"
"
"
"
&
"
'
"
"
"
&

O
<
>
>

E

#
!
" 7

2 2
# 7#
4
/
5
#

"
.
#24

#

"
#2 #
&)O='(4#

"
/
# 2# # %

/
5
$2
#7
2#

#

/
4

% 2#

" % &)O='(&*4
"
#

#

#

$

#
!
#
3P K9
R ;

B 1
a C

!
B

'
"C

'

B

Z
C

%+*
S$ &'0.B/A&B4
3&'0.7'4RB/;QD'&04VC'DF=&04.='.0&46@
B45+/#'&(=4*M/'B&'(&)(4'$
2 "

+T # 2
.
A&B4 %

7 7
/
#

$ (),#
$ -# '.
# 2#

5

! #
! #

4#
5

/
#
"5
"
4
$ E #
! " 2
# # !
#
%
"
#
%
#

#

#
"

?
!#
+*
7$OX $
+T
$OX$
MT

"
"
"
"
&
"
'
"
"
"
&

O

5

.4
%
#
"

"

4
/

$I#
# 2$
"

% 9 "
: " #7
#
#
2 ;

!

! 1
!
I 0

1
0

!
D
"

0
E
IQJ++# 2# #

!

.
% 9 #

5
7
#
#

! ! 3 .

4 $ #

#
5

4

!]
S$ .5C/(L)0&4 /X06='&A4 B. .)G3/''. 40&.)46 C434
).354(&H43 4 '&(=4*+.>C3.?6/54$ 5C3.C3&/B4B/ B4 4(=4*+. B.
0.5.g6/G&'64B.3C.'&(&A.e$
'
#

/
#
!

4

$ #

#7 "

#2;
!

E

0
1
,P+.
2 !

N5%+X 1 ' "!# 5
2

!
#
5

5
$ 5# 5# 2 #
2;
;
2
"
!#

!

1 '

"# <
2
!

D
0K '

L

++
$N+$
+X
$(T($
M+
h

E %+,

#

.

4

4

#

%

$E #
7# #
5
#
2 # #
/

"

# 52
#
2
#
5 5 5
7

# " 4

#
"

4 5

"$
E # #
' 2#

#

. 4

# 3

# 2

/

$.
#
R
; 2
#
3
4Ka-LII-K13#

5

5
# 5

I 7

#
/

# 4 2 7

2 %
5"
#

4 9
2

#2
2

$J
I 3 L
$ S#
!

R;
BC
V3'

E

BCD

V3

"#

1
0

BCJ$I
+,
$(T*3(TT$
MX
h

#
# 2
+N 2
#

#
. 4
#;

?V3

1

2
!
D
%XO$
E # #

#

#

. $ "

2" 2
1
2 ?

#

! 3
'

2

2#
.

# !" 'E
#

!

?

#2 ]
h$ &5C/3(&)L)0&4 B4 &)A.04*+. B.' iB&3/&(.' '/X=4&' /
3/C3.B=(&A.'j$
#"

2 7

#
# "

# ;
E

JX( #%2

3
!
: #
3

!

#2

$

#
L

1 9#3 R
;&3/&(.'3/C3.B=(&A.'

#"

7 # 2 "
# 2
"
2
$

" ?#
#

"
$
U
#1$I4 $# 4
/
;

+N

!
J
XO
$)(X$

# &)$ ^Y # $ (,*
?W

X(
c \#$(,X
?#" !#$)(*
?$
M,
h

4 4

#

/
$
&3/&(.''/X=4&'

4

4

/
#

?

?
= >

= >$

= >
= >4 $

4

# # " $

4

#

"5
$

2 2
4 $

4

4 R 4
# 4
#

4
# $

4

$

4

!
1[e-[-1$

9 2

#

2

$
&3/&(. 7 &)Q.354*+. / 7 /B=04*+. '/X=46 /
3/C3.B=(&A4$jX)
# "
#2 4

?
7
4
#

4
/

X)
f
$L

1 9$1
%1 9$ ?
7
I
$ ;

4
#

$J
f 5
R
L

1 9#
)OO+#
$
O*$
R[[ $ $ $[ [

[
o

o4
o)OO+$"
MN
h

##

#
7
#
2/
"
"
# "

5 #

5
$
h$.)06='+.$

!?4 # 3# "
#
!%

# &5C3.0/B/)(/ $
*O
h

1430 ADPF 54 - Voto Min. Cezar Peluso

Enviado por

Dados do documento

Direitos autorais

Formatos disponíveis

Compartilhar este documento

Compartilhar ou incorporar documento

Opções de compartilhamento

Você considera este documento útil?

Este conteúdo é inapropriado?

Direitos autorais:

Formatos disponíveis

1430 ADPF 54 - Voto Min. Cezar Peluso

Enviado por

Direitos autorais:

Formatos disponíveis

Supremo Tribunal Federal

          

Supremo Tribunal Federal

   $L

Supremo Tribunal Federal

Supremo Tribunal Federal

Supremo Tribunal Federal

Supremo Tribunal Federal

= "   

W  #$)M3)*   

Supremo Tribunal Federal

# 3(=3.$ ) 2

Supremo Tribunal Federal

Supremo Tribunal Federal

Supremo Tribunal Federal

Supremo Tribunal Federal

1 2      N    X 0 !0 !0 X .Y

Supremo Tribunal Federal

Supremo Tribunal Federal

   # "$NT$

Supremo Tribunal Federal

'  " #  #2  

Supremo Tribunal Federal

Supremo Tribunal Federal

 # 22 4

7$ON  $

Supremo Tribunal Federal

'"$  b$ & N

Supremo Tribunal Federal

Supremo Tribunal Federal

  ! #       ;  

Supremo Tribunal Federal

$ O+#     Y ,$     4

I    "

 R;&    

Supremo Tribunal Federal

YN    "V $ (+*   

Supremo Tribunal Federal

7$O,  $

'"$!  # /6'.)$2

Supremo Tribunal Federal

Supremo Tribunal Federal

^Y  #$()+3()X   

Supremo Tribunal Federal

Supremo Tribunal Federal

Supremo Tribunal Federal

Supremo Tribunal Federal

Supremo Tribunal Federal

  3  "

Supremo Tribunal Federal

:  #%    #

Supremo Tribunal Federal

Supremo Tribunal Federal

   2   #    #   "

    

Supremo Tribunal Federal

 4 #  "

Supremo Tribunal Federal

  # 2 #     # 

Supremo Tribunal Federal

   "   7 

7$OX  $

Supremo Tribunal Federal

Supremo Tribunal Federal

$L

= "

W #$)M3)*

# 3(=3.$ ) 2

1 2 N X 0 !0 !0 X .Y

# "$NT$

' " # #2

# 22 4

7$ON $

'"$ b$ &N

! # ;

$ O+# Y ,$ 4

I "

R;&

YN "V $ (+*

7$O, $

'"$! # /6'.)$2

^Y #$()+3()X

3"

: #% #

2 # # "

4 # "

# 2 # #

" 7

7$OX $

R[[ $ $ $[ [