Você está na página 1de 14

 

  
 

   
 
   
 
  
        
    



    


   
 

  
       
     !       
           
        "   
 
 
      # 
         
   

        
        
            
       
  $%  
      
     
         #   
    
  
 $   
    
  
      
      
   #     

        
  
     &'! ( ' &)  !   
           

 
 
#  % 
  
   
   
   
     
      
 
   
 *+ ,    -
 .  
 
 
   /   ! 0
 
      
      
      
      

    
        
            
           
          
 
  
          
    
        
  
 
      
  
 %       
"  %       
         

  


  
    
     
     
        
  
       
    
           
         

  
         
    !  "     
           
             

            
#        
     
          
         
             
  
     
  
        
       



 

  


  
    




 

  
    
  

     
    

          
      
     

          
            
            
   
             
           
      
   
 
  
 
 
       
 

    
    
      
  
  !  "  # $%&$' 
 (  )     
 $*  + (

&

  


            
      
   
 
         
  
   1 2    
 
           0 & 
  
   
     
           
  1 2         
       
    % 
             3!
  
  
      
           
           
             
          1 2   

      


   
    
    " 
            4"  

        


   
 
         
 
5              

    #        


             
   
     

      

      
 (             
         1 2  
       
  6

     
      
          
 
        
        
   
         
     "      
        
  
 

(   
      
         
     1 2  
   

            


             
  
                
 (         
 
       
   
                 
7    
        
          
               
        4   % 

 

0 &8 1/   1 2    +


9
 
           


            


          
 
    
        
           

             
      
         :   


 (   
 ;    
   
  <   
      

  =  
       
 2   4         
)     >   1 2  
            
         
 
  ?

   

+       


    

    ( <!      
         
        
  1/
     
    
           ( &&!  
         

  
        
          
         
  #       
           


         


 
          
   

             


+     /      
         & 
@ & )! (      (9+  @!  >5 
 &! 7    
     
           
    5     +  $ & !
         
 
          
      ,2#4.    

  
  #     
          
 :  
    #  2#4      
    
   A  
          
 
  :  #    B!   
           

   
     
   
  ( ? B!     
2#4
  
  
    
 

    
#   
       
 
  
  ( &)!  

 
     
 
   (       
           
 "          
          %    
  ( & &?!         
    +>(9 ,+ >   ( 
 9  .      
      
 

 
+  
         
 
       
 
  (   B &B <!     
          
    
  ( 3! 1    
    
   : 
     



     :      

          


 
   3!       
    "        
          
       #    
        
  
           
              

 
      

#        / "   


     
        
             @
(            
      #  /      
   
         
          
          + 
    
?! +
     
2   4       ;    
      &3!
(   
        
   2   4  (     
            
2   4          
               #
/      /    8
 2 &8  %   %C
 2 8     %C
 2 <8  %   C
 2 )8     C
 2 8  %     C
 2 ?8       C

    2   4 
 ?  
           

    
    2   4 

   
    
     
 
"              
           (  
    
  "   
        %     
%          
          /    
        D 
   
           
=             


   



 

    

        #  ( ,     


       
"  " #    (

<

/      


 /       
         !8
 D   D   D 
,&.
          
    
       /
        
    
           
 
     
        
 D   D   D 
,.
            
8




















 






          /  
    ,        .    
              
    
       
  =

   
 

            
& 0 
    
    
  /  E + 

      , D .
#          
     
         
  
        

             8




,<.

,?.
              
  
    6
      
    /
  !8
E
(      

    

  
 ,&   .     
 D  
,).  

      ,&   .   
  (
 /   "  


    @


      
# 
            
  
      8
2   4     / 
  
  
  
 (   
   ,&   . ,B.
/    
       
,&
 .F
   
   
<  
   /     E +
   
   
   
 

 
      ,&   . 
 

            
 

     /       


 
       ,&   .    /
   
   /    
(          7  , .   
 
8
     / 
  C     
         , .   
,, .  ,&   ..  ,3.
 /   +     , .    

    /   +  D     
  &@!8
)        
    
    /  E 4


D  
, .         
#          

             /              

                


       8
)
  D











    
 

 








 
















      







 



































































     "  ,?.     


     /     
 .
,'.  
  /    8
,  .  
(  /  
  

    

D
,&@.
           

  
 
               
      / 

   
  G 1  
        
 
 
  G          
#     
                     
         
              G   
    
  (   
               
        1 2              
  
       =                   
    
          "   
     
                   1 2  #
 
     
       
          
       
       /          
/             #   /           
        
    
       
                 
      
                     
   
                   
  
 
  
       
        
      
         1 2  
 
 
(       

    !
  
 9
 +  2        (          

         


2   4            
    >   1
       /        2    9+   &!     
       
      #  
  + >  1 2  

                          
        
     
            
 /          0 /  
         
    
         
      
     
 

      
             

     # 
              
   
/           9
 +  2     < ( 
     (                        
   /
             8
    
 
C
         /       +  &8
       
    /  +  8
C
  4      
            +  <8
C
    /       
C

        /      +  )8

,&






 







 !   

 !   


 !  




 !     

#J1 > (218     


  
    
   
 
     #J1 > (21 C
 +K11> >5A=8
      
  
     &
   
+K11> >5A=     
    ,&
+K11> >5A=.C
 1I19 $5#(A9 2(9  2#L8   
   
       
   
 1I19 $5#(A9 2(9 
1I19 $5#(A9 2#LC
 +#1 >5A=8         
     /        
  
      +#1& >5A=
     &C
 $(+ K(918    ;
   
        
=         
  
   
 (      
       1I19 >5A=  
            
       ,  .   

    1I19 5#$(+    


,  .
  %       
   
     & 
<  )
      +#1& >5A=
+#1 >5A= +#1< >5A=  +#1) >5A=
         
   
    
 1I19 $5#(A9 2(9
 1I19 $5#(A9 2#L  # 
            
           
 $(+ K(91       
  
,  .           
  <       ) ( 0 
   
          
           
   +K11> >5A=       &  ,&
+K11> >5A=.          
  /
     #J1 > (21 
  
   :     
             
  
           
            2
           
        , @ @. 
        
  

 
           
   
       
  
          6  &<!8
+  &8   C +  8 <3B C +  <8  
 +  )8 B)B 
(   &
         
     =  
  :   
     +      
             
  <
         +
>  1 2 

 





             


       12  ( 
  
               
   "   ,2+1. 
   
       2    
      8
 D ,  H .
,&&.

 H             


          ( 
  
         
 
 2+1      
A            
        (  

          

      1 2     


  
 6

    
          "
  +            

           
             
          
   +      :     
             1
2           
 

 

 

 

 



   


 

(   
        
            
     
       8
 1I19 >5A=8        
  C
 1I19 5#$(+8    ;    C
?

       


     
  /      "  ,&@.  
 9
 +  2       
  (            
             

     
      
           

0 8 +         



          
 
       $ 
          

            
    )  &B <!
$ 

1I19 >5A=
@&
1I19 5#$(+
@ 
#J1 > (21
&@ 
+K11> >5A=
@3
1I19 $5#(A9 2(9 &@ 
1I19 $5#(A9 2#L @ 
+#1& >5A=
@@
+#1 >5A=
@
+#1< >5A=
@)
+#1) >5A=
@<
$(+ K(91
@ 
(   1
&@@ M
4  5 
@ 
+ 0 +:
&@@/&@@ 
 
@& 


0 <8 +       


(              

  :       : &&?  


              
           :   
  /         /  0 <
2         @  
    /
  %      
    
    

   /    / , @/ @ .
  % 
 
      
 A
          /
  
%           
   
 
     &   
           
  
               
     /       
        ,    .  
 : 
 
 /    
 %   
  ,  .  
     / ,
  .  
  %        
   
 
      
      
    ,       
 .
         
    
       #  0 )
 
             
@@    

%

"  



   


#  




    

(  + >  1 2     


               
   (         
                
   / ( 
    /    
              
       
  /        
  (    
      

     
       


&
   '

&@3 N
) N
<?? N
3& N

< N
&B& N
&?? N
&)@ N

BB N
3 N
@
@

30000
Simple Prediction

25000

Number of Transmissions

+  &
+  
+  <
+  )
100

High-load
Medium-load
Low-load

20000

15000

10000

95
5000

Energy (J)

90
0
10

20

30

40

50

60
70
80
90
100
Prediction Time (seconds)

110

120

130

140

150

0 8 A      >  

85

80

   
      +
>     &@@   &@@/&@@ 
      0 ?  
  
             
           
1
      : <@ 

   
     ( 0
B
           0
           
         =      
       
 
  
  
        0 3  
  
    &     % 

  
    
    
     
    
         
(  / /
        
     
    #
               
/     /          
            
      
      
       
 
         
   

     
      
( 0 '
   2+1      ?@@@
          
 
    
    
           
  

75
0

50

100

150

200

250
300
Time (seconds)

350

400

450

500

0 )8 1 $  6  2  K


 

    + >  1 2    
           /   
"  ,&@.          
 "  ,&@.
         

   

      
            
            
          / 
  #         
           
     + >       
             
            

   9         
      (  + >   
     "       
          
(            
            
        0     
        &@@@  
   &@@   &@@/&@@  A   
            
    
(   / 
     ;
            

 



" #
 
 
$ 


<! 2  = 
7   O    # 
> 4         
  
  (
 M
@@&
)! 9 = M 6   $ 1  # 
      (
   )3'P)'3 > / #
:  +# # @@&
 ! 9  = M  6   $
1  O>+ 
    :  
   
 B83P<) A  @@@
?!    2 4  M #   
 M   Q + (94
&''&
B! K  $   J  +M >   K  1
O  4/      
 
 
  (
 @@&
3! M 1  $ 1    
:  
  
  (

(   
    9
 +  2

      
   
2   4     
 
   
           
   1 2  
  
 
  1 2          
         

      1/     
 >        
        
0          8
 >  
      
   
         
         
       
              (
      
 / 
    (       
            
  
      
       #  

         
         
 
 =  2# +#
 (  4  >  1 2  
@@&
       
          '! $ 1  5 O  M 6   + J

 (            /   9/    8     

            


  (
          
     
   ?<PB@ + 

#
+#
&'''
 4          1 2 
             &@! 5 O O  

       
J
 #  >  &''?
&&! +  O   : (  > 
      
 8   
%

 2>1O
&!  
9

+ 

 <&, . A  @@&
8--

- --/ 


&!  5 6:  M J   6 =    
! O #    $ 0 K O >   J  #          
 6 2      
 8
  
  (
K

      (
   &B)P&3  + 
   6  9  
 # +# &'''
A  &''3
'
% & 

  %

% & 

  
'(
%
   


 ) 
 
$
 *%)$'(+

% &
   

 





 %   


& ,  % %  '--(

& 


 
'--( %
  & 
  ) 

& 
 $   *%&)&$+! .    & 

  ) 
  %
  .


/
    
 

& 

  
0 
 12% 
   


  

   
 

)
 $  & 



1  
   3





 
 $ 

$
   



& 

  
0
 12% 
   


  

   
 

&<! M 6 5 +:


:  #  + 6  $ 4
 J >  +        

   (

9 @@@
&)! 4 (  

 5 O   $ 1  $
  %8       
      
  (
   ?P?B = 
2# +# @@@
& ! M 2 J  5 6 J :  J + M >  9/
   8 2 
    
  (
   B&P
B3 +  &'''
&?! M  J   5  6:   6 
=     9       
    
  
 
(
 +  # # &'''
&B! $  9  = 5 =   #  
   ,#>+. OKA=14A2 @@& 9
 @@&
&3! #   > 
 2O
6 +
 1   1     &''&
&'! + >   # +   2 = +    +
+8    
   
  (
& 

  
4 %

   


 1 
  $  
&    #
  5
 $


& 

 

   
   


  

   
 

% & 

  56%5

12% %,  ,   


  
/
 

& ! 3 7 



!  $  & 



& 

  
8 1 
    
 
!       

 




<! #  +  4  4  6   2  =


+     $     :  
  
    (
   &??P&B' 5 (  M
@@&
)! 1 +   +6
 4  9  (  5/
2 # +  #    #  4 
   >         
    
   

  (

  BP3B 5 (  M @@&
 ! J +   M O  I #
   OM > 
>    :  
 

 
 B8&?PB
A  @@@
?! #   $  1 4 #   
        
  (
   &P< 
5 (  M @@&
B!  R M  6   $ 1  #
     
   

  (
 9

R  9R +# M @@


3! R  M S  5  O   $
 1  5       

  
  (

A  0K +# 2  @@

   &@)P&&& =  2# +#


@@@
@! OM >   M J     

  (

 )<   &P3   @@@
&! M  2 5   2 M # M K
 + M $  >   +  5 >
        


  

 
 <<,B. @@@ M
! +  5
 >
 6  0   &''3
&@
    
1

%  

1 9    
 & 




 

   


  
  

  '--(




  
   



  
   
  '--(

% &
    




  
   


  

   
  '--(

% & 

  
'( %
 
1 :   


 
%  

   $ 

 *%/955 '--'+

% .
  
   /
   


*./;-'+

100

100
Correct
Naive
Simple Prediction

95

Correct
Naive
Simple Prediction

95

90

90

85
85
Energy (J)

Energy (J)

80
75

80

75

70
70
65
65

60

60

55
50

55
0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

100

200

300

400

Time (seconds)

- .    /     -   .

700

800

900

1000

100
Correct
Naive
Simple Prediction

95

Correct
Naive
Simple Prediction

95

90

90

85

85

80

80
Energy (J)

Energy (J)

600

-
.    / 0    -0   .

100

75

75

70

70

65

65

60

60

55

55

50

50
0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

100

200

300

400

Time (seconds)

500

600

700

800

900

1000

Time (seconds)

-.    / !    -!   .

-.    / 1    -1   .

100

100
Correct
Naive
Simple Prediction

95

Correct
Naive
Simple Prediction

95

90

90

85

85

80

80
Energy (J)

Energy (J)

500
Time (seconds)

75

75

70

70

65

65

60

60

55

55

50

50
0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

100

200

Time (seconds)

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

Time (seconds)

- .    /     -  


 .

-#.    /      -   


 .

0 ?8 6   


&&

100

100
Correct
Naive
Simple Prediction

Correct
Naive
Simple Prediction

98

95

96
94

Energy (J)

92

Energy (J)

90

85

90
88
86

80

84
82

75

80
0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

100

200

300

400

Time (seconds)

500

600

700

800

900

1000

Time (seconds)

- .    /     -   .

-
.    / 0    -0   .

100

100
Correct
Naive
Simple Prediction

Correct
Naive
Simple Prediction

90

90
Energy (J)

95

Energy (J)

95

85

85

80

80

75

75
0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

100

200

300

400

Time (seconds)

500

600

700

800

900

1000

Time (seconds)

-.    / !    -!   .

-.    / 1    -1   .

100

100
Correct
Naive
Simple Prediction

Correct
Naive
Simple Prediction

95
95

90
Energy (J)

Energy (J)

90
85

85
80

80
75

70

75
0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

100

200

Time (seconds)

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

Time (seconds)

- .    /     -  


 .

-#.    /      -   


 .

0 B8 2  


&

100

100
Correct
Naive
Simple Prediction

99

Correct
Naive
Simple Prediction
99

98
98

Energy (J)

Energy (J)

97

96

95

97

96

94
95
93
94
92

91

93
0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

100

200

300

400

Time (seconds)

500

600

700

800

900

1000

Time (seconds)

- .    /     -   .

-
.    / 0    -0   .

100

100
Correct
Naive
Simple Prediction

99

Correct
Naive
Simple Prediction

99

98

98

97
97
Energy (J)

Energy (J)

96
95

96

95

94
94
93
93

92

92

91
90

91
0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

100

200

300

400

Time (seconds)

500

600

700

800

900

1000

Time (seconds)

-.    / !    -!   .

-.    / 1    -1   .

100

100
Correct
Naive
Simple Prediction

Correct
Naive
Simple Prediction
99

98

98

Energy (J)

Energy (J)

96

94

97

96

92
95

90

94

88

93
0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

100

Time (seconds)

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

Time (seconds)

- .    /     -  


 .

-#.    /      -   


 .

0 38 K
  
&<

5
Simple Prediction

MSE

0
0

1000

2000

3000
Time (seconds)

4000

5000

6000

- . 2"  
5
Simple Prediction

MSE

0
0

1000

2000

3000

4000

5000

6000

Time (seconds)

-
. 3   
5
Simple Prediction

MSE

0
0

1000

2000

3000

4000

Time (seconds)

-. 4  

0 '8 >  D &@@ ,&@@@  .


&)

5000

6000

Você também pode gostar