‘urouarep nequesy TO. TH BRITISH LIBRARY 2oCUMENT SUPPLY CENTRE ARIEL
ADP REQUEST
13 -aug-03010 29198969 |
_B COPY _ COPYRIGHT FEE PAID {NAN
¥3-aug-03073 | 9978388" __| “7$0.193500
RBK REVIEWS IN ECONOMIC GEOLOGY
SOCIETY OF ECONOMIC GEOLOGISTS,
001 VOL 14 PP.i57 - 181
MATIC AND STRUCTURAL CONTROLS ON THE
ICHARDS, J. P. AND TOSDAL, R. M. |
7410123
[7790.193500
ie MIMI
| 29198969 fre ont
oaks of dte of receipt uness recalled alr, |
‘Bza074 FXBKS9
sae |
SARA R RS REESE REESE EERE tne ether brary indicated plese return loan to |
ARIEL ‘The Bish Library Document Supply Cente, Boston Spe,
Wetherby, West Yorkie, United Kingdom, L523 780.
EMAIL: PDG_LIBRARY@PLACERDOME COM
British Library Document Supply
Copyright Fee Paid copies
The contents of the attached document are copyright works. Unless you have the
permission of the copyright owner, the Copyright Licensing Agency Ltd or another
authorised licensing body, you may not copy, store in any electronic medium or
‘otherwise reproduce or resell any of the content, even for internal purposes, except as
may be allowed by law.
If the document was sent from us to you by any electronic means (including fax
transmission), you are agreeing to the terms of supply, which are available at
wwrwbl.uk/services/documenvedd.heml,Soci of Banana Gg
Revowe 12001,
Chapter 6
Magmatic and Structural Controls on the Development of
Porphyry Cu = Mo = Au Deposits
RM, Tosa
Mineral Defeat Research Unit, University of British Columbia, Venrmen, BC V6T 124, Canada
AND J. P, RICHARDS
Department of Earth and Atmuspherc Scones, University of Allerta, Edmonton, AB T6G 283, Canada
Abstract
Porphyry Cu + Mo 2 Au deposits require the coincidence aid postive interaction of a series of individ
ually eommonplace geological processes. They, and all sheir enezially associated deposits, are a natural
Consequence of convergent maggin magi, and rellect the dynamic interplay between magmatic, hy
tirouhermal, and tectonic processes. Magis generated diring mbelacton rise Into the upper erst, cou
‘nonly along zowes of lithospheric weakiies, where they pend in tabular magma chambers at depths of 6
kim or deeper The chambers grow hiterally by chamber flogr depression (cantilever mechanism) znd
some roo lifting (piston mechanism). Apophyses rise from the pazenal magma chamber and ntrde 10
within | to 3 ki of the surtace, where they may undergo volaule exsohution and erstalization 2s por
Dhyritic stocks, Eriplacement of porphyry stocks sfacilitated by sirctural snisobpy in dhe reat rocks. Ase
fending hydruitierml fluids exsolved from the porphyry stocks and the underlying parental magma
Chamber are focused into the cupola, aking adamtage of vertical structural and rheological anisewopies
Intradaced either before or ducing porphyry emplacement
From a simetural standpoint, three recurseat processes enhance permeability in the fori of fracture oF
brecein networks through which hydrothermal fluids pass an preepitate minerals. Fracture-producing
events ate related to fntusion of pre, sy i poster porphiry stocks or ckes to nearsuriace depths
(055 kan), phase separation an! volume expansion ofa hydrothermal Mud through a varies of meehie
nisms and tectonicalyindced failure. Concenitie and radial factare patterns rellet magnate processes
‘whereas more lincararnas of veins rellet tectonic insences. The resaling diferent vein array are com
tony vertically and temporally distributed in the porphyry system: concentric and radial ataye are move
Common above or in the tipper pats of the stocks, whereas Tinea arrays dominate at depth, forming asthe
System cools and the phon solidifies, Orthogonal and conjayate arrays of wins characterize all sales and
il pars of porphyry systems, Veins from a particular paragetetic stage da not have unique orientations, but
Father oocir with all orientations spat of that ysten, The enmmon comgate to orthogonal interven =
litionships in porphyry Cu depos requires repetitive exchange of principal sess orientations, evens that,
sv Tacltated by conchiions of lew dtferen al horizontal stew. Such sures Conditions indicate that may
ppoepiyry Cu deposits form in specific environments where the magmatic are s under a nearneutalsiress
ate, These conditions occur eer in aveas removed from aetve deformation, or during periods of sitess
elevation and low stain i che magmatie ace, Achievement of these conditions i Gane ahd space is Tel
to be infrequent and taster curing the life ofa convergent margin, which may explain the spatial and
temporal clustering of deposits in lange porphyry dsuies
Introduction tion of these deposits from a physical and geochemical
Pogninyay Cat = Mo + Au deposits, hereafter referred to as
porphyry Cu deposits, are associated with shallow-level plu
{onic complexes emplaced in maginatic ares at convergent
plate margins (Figs. 1, 24; Sillitoe, 1972, 1997; Sutherland
Brown, 1976; Titley, 1982; Sawking, 1990), Since their first,
recognition as important sources of metals (Ransome,
1904, 1919; Lindgren, 1905, 1933, 1997; Emmons, 1927),
much work has been devoted to ninderstanding the forme
standpoint (Burnham, 1967, 1979; Gustafson and Hunt,
1975; Cathles, 1977; Burnham and Ohmowo, 1980; Beane
and ‘itley, 1981; Candela, 1989; Cline and Bodnar, 1991
Hedenquist and Richards, 1998). In addition, the question
‘of why there is considerable variation in the size of these
types of deposits has been pondered (Clark, 1993). Ocher
studies have focused on structural controls on vein and
fraccure distributions within porphyry Cu deposits, and
their spatial and paragenctic relationships to porphyry
stocks (Relirig ancl Heidrick, 1972, 1976: Gustafson and
Hune, 1975; Tiley and Heidrick, 1978; Heideick and Tiley,158 YONA AND RacsHAnDs
Onin eg apan
i
hay
Vee
Ree
(= Austaia
uN
ey
a
Pacific Ocean
Porphyry belts of the Circum-Pacifie
@® Oxidized magmatic belt:
Porphyry Cu Mo+ Au
1 Cenozoic prpisry Caz Mo Au deposi stong converge plate margins nthe
‘érea-Pacieroplon. PNC - Papua New Gunes apie or Tromp (08)
1982; Wilkinson et al., 1982; Lindsay et al., 1995). These
studies demonstrate that porphyry Cu deposits are inthe
enced not only by magmatic and hydrothermal processes,
but also by regional tectonics at the time of formation. In
fact, the prevailing tectonic sewing and strucwaral frame-
‘work may strongly influence not only the size and form of a
porphyry system (Sillitoe, 1994, 1997; Skewes and Stern,
1995) but also its location (Rebrig and Heidrick, 1972,
1976; Tidey and Heidrick, 1978; Heidrick and Titkey, 1982),
Richirds et al, 2001).
‘This chaprer reviews the interplay between magmatism
and eynamic structural environments in the development
‘of porphyry Cu deposits, Critical to this goal is the general
model of porphyry Cus deposits, which highlights the need
for constructive interaction between magmatic, magmatic-
hydrothermal, and tectonic events in the formation of pore
phyzy Cu deposits. It is equally important to consider
emplacement mechanisms of shallow-level plutonic com
plexes in the upper crust because porphyry Cu depositsare
restricted to these envizonments, Throughout this chapter,
\we draw liberally on welllesctibed examples of poxphyry
Cu deposits to illustrate vatious points. Most exat
from the southwestern Unived States and from die Andes of
Penti and Chile. This geographic focus is not incended to
indicate that other porphysy Cus provinces are insignificant,
‘but merely reflects past history of geologic investigations,
availabilty of liverauure, and our personal experiences.
General Porphyry Model
Physicochemical model
Important characteristics of porphyry Cu deposits sum
sized herein are basecl on the primary physiochemical tut
iesof Lindgren (1987), Hemley and Jones (1964), Sheppard
etal. (1969, 1971), Lowell and Guilbers (1970), Rose (1970),
Roeder (1971), Sillitoe (1973). Gustafson and Hunt
(2975), Hollister (1975), Sheppard and Gustafson (1978),
Sutherland Brown (1976), Eastoe (1978), and Reynolds and
Beane (1995), and reviews by Gustaion (1978), Beane and
Tiley (1981), Titleyand Beane (1981), Ticley (1982), Hunt
(1991), Kirkham and Sinclair (1996), and Hedenquist and
Richards (1998),
Porphyry-type systems are so-namedd because of their spar
tial andl genetic association with porphyritic intrusions (Fig.
24). Commonly, such intrusions are characterized by phie=
nociyst assemblages consisting of onc or more of the mine
crals quart, K fellspar, plagioclase, hornblende, and biotite
(rarely pyroxenes and olivine) in a fine-grained matrix.
Rock compositions vary from granitic to dioritic or rarel
yabbroie, ane are of cale-aikaline to alkaline parentage
(Brown, 1982). Parental magmas are believed to be modier-
ately watertich as indicated by the presence of hyeiraus phi
focryst phases such as amphibole and biotite, whose stabi
squires atleast $ wt percent HO in the melt (Holland,
1972; Burnham, 1979}, Water concentrations are probably
keMAGMATIC AND STRUCTURAL CONTROLS ON PORDHTRY Gu = Mo x Au DEPOSITS 9
A Generalized porphyry-related base metal systems, B
0 fe 8 oa — Sate
steko
7 vow SS Stas, EEE 0
veveall 24 |
1,2, Anavomy ofa ponphysy Cut Mo 2 Au deposit and other spatial reed
depois General modelos roned magia hdotermal set sow pote
‘El nlges between» prpiyy Ch deport centered on compote porphyry ate
Sm ara taped om sive, 108). Te pry Cu ep ane on | Gi cet |
cra tnd pnd byt charaeterts tea depot pes Nowa ponte the were | Loney f
ae ee ck naeatchse ental wc Petpsent renee Pf a
Cpu dominate lone cine suchas Cope Cason tthe Bate Mountain Mi \ \onm |
ing Dies (Teeter, 200), bere nther em sich tone mse FE TA |
Pera Clie he pop € epost dominate pespheral depois ae ae ( / |
oown aston a tn 198; Gar eal, 190), Be sipted dst of AV LAWS |
bpetotheral aeraton ans miners an cn porphyry Ou deposit PATE doug Lt
{Stajed tem lowet and Cte, 190). ab fed apie ster ay | [EC | |
‘Shrunk = anya = natn MN L
‘ha; hs chlor: ep = chalet fand borate; ep
“Eton: Kle = Rfelespnr, mag = magnet:
quate se = series st = sphalente su. ulation,
not higher than 5 wt percent, however, because ofthe com
mon presence of plagiocise phenocrysts (Gil 1981). Fuld
‘esolution from the melt upon racking saturation leads to
5 sudden rive of dhe magina soleus temperaiare, which
{uenches the matrix and gives rise tthe porphyrive exe
thre, This mnagmatederived lydrothersal ui in nim,
Iimpicated in te transport and depeniton of meals to form
porphry mineral deposit
“The hydrous ane ofthe melt derives from magnagene-
the upper mantle by subdhction of altered oecanie crust
{Fig. 2). Sab dehydration during descent to ~100 ks depth
Inctisomaties the overlying mate wedge, theseby generat
ing conditions suitable Tor extraction of hydrox basalt
trays by decompression melting (Hanlin, 1081 Arc
thse 1904), As these maginas ascend foward the surge, a
Combination of proceses, including depresurintion and
Crystallization of anhydrous sinctal phases, Leads to 2
‘crease in yoluulesolubilty and an ineFeae fn the vole
oladenites p= pes
ena kl
content ofthe residual siieate melt, eventually leading to sa
tration (Burnham, 1957, 1979; Whitney, 1975). Atthis point,
‘separate volatile phase is exsolved, which becomes concen-
trated at the top of the magma chamber (Figs. 4and 5). In
calealkaline to alkaline are magmas, this waterich volatile
phase will abo contain other watersoluble valatile compo-
hhents such as Cland § species. Depending on the depth
(pressure) of emplicement, intial volatile exsolution yields
either (1) a high-pressure, homogeneous, supercritical,
‘aqueous fluid with salinity in the range 2 to 10 wr percent
NaCl equiv, or (2) at shallower depths (above approximately
5 km) two immiscible duids, consisting ofa low-slinity vapor
phase and a highsalinity brine (Burnham, 1979; Cline ant
Bonar, 1991; Shinohara, 1994; Gustafson and Quiroga,
1905; Heclenquist and Richards, 1998; Hedenquist et al,
1008). These fluid phases can transport base and precious
metals as chloride and possibly bisullide complexes (Candela
and Holland, 1984, 1986; Willi 1995; Gammons
‘and WilliamsJones, 1997; Loucks and Mavrogenes, 1999).160 Tosbas AND rucHaRDS
Fr 3. Geometry ofa magmatic ae formed aan abide comer
plate margin Hideous magmas are generated i she mate wedge ane
Thune te homphere along broad deformation aes undergoing ning
Shvnso¥stikeslp mation depenting up he egee of oly aon
ihe convergent agin, Madi ian de oat Banga. (188).
Exsolution of a volatile phase from magma necessarily
involves a large positive change in volume (Phillips, 1973:
Burnham, 1979; Burnham and Ohmowo, 1980). Depending
‘on the sbess regime and the structure andl permeability of
the confining host rocks, this volume change may be accom
modated by pervasive brecciation of the voladle-saturated
carapace of the intrusion, or direct escape toward the surface
along fale zonesor breccia pipes (Fig). Both mechanisms
involve creation of fracture permeability and porosity into
which ore minerals may subsequently be precipitaced,
thereby leading to formation of porphyry deposits.
Hydrothermal fie exsolved at magmatic temperatures is
initially in equilibrium with the coexisting magma and its
mineral phases. High-emperature alteration assemblages
(Fig. 28), therefore, consist of minerals such as quari7, K
feldspar, biotite, anhyelrite, and magnetite (the “potassic”™
alteration assemblage; Lowell and Guilber, 1970; Gustafson
ine! Hunt, 1975). Base metal sulfide minerals, typically com
jnations of chalcopyrite, bornite, and molydenite with
prrite (Fig. 2B), are deposited with these alteration minerals
as cisseminations and in thin, commnonly wavy or ductilely
deformed, wispy veinlets that lack parallel vein walls. These
cearly veins were termed "A veins” by Gustafson and Hunt
(1975), based om their study of the El Salvador porphycy
Chile, These veins ure usually cue by inugamineral
ry stacks where such stocks are present. Marginally
er "B veins" at El Saltador are quartesich with more abun
dant molsbdenive and chalcopyrite, and suaighter vein
walls; these veins cut all but postmineral stocks, The
siraighter vein walls ane mineral exruses within these veins
indicate formation at lower tempecacures than the A veins,
A tonne
See tee.
4 oe
ee
wie / 1
ingin the cup
{land app
sve (9) Beneath an icherm of =870° 0 °C, which Marke she
byitae-dcile transition, Within this one, brine and scum” interact
wit the conate tock leming the potnie alteration sage: Above the
trursiton zone, crcalating fie wader hrstatie presure ater the
ovis racks to poopie inner sean anne ad
‘cooling porphyry Cu deposit the bile-dcte ranion gradually cok
lapses onto the cari potas alteration zone, leading to philic over
pponting andthe infhoe of meteor fide inc the satent If he brie
Deedee transition fk sddenly perched er breached because of
‘econ of later magma he id it rapes Teng i den
{earaon (rom those to hadron Hula presuies (ee Te se
Nock on diagram), The fluidsaturated carapace undergoes siden
pane separation leading to seam pts brine plas psa: with the
poventa’ expulsion of metal bearing hd upwattl ino the epthertal
Ensironment. Within the porphycy Gu ensironment, these explosive
pressure transitoas tigger the formation of ldrathermal beecas
Kapted from Fournier, 198,
As the high-temperature fluid migrates away from the
parent magma, it rises owing to buovaney andl begins to
cool. Tso processes may happen, as Follows
1. Ifthe fluid was exsolved originally as x homogeneous
supercritical phase, then upon cooling it will likely intersect
its solvus and separate into liquid and vapor phases. This
phase separation event involves a further inercase in vol
lume Ieading to additional fracnure permeability ane brec-
ciation, most commonly in the fhuidsoaked earapace abore
or at the top of the porphyry stock. Phase separation may
also occur curing sudden pressure crops stich as massive
hydrofracturing, sudden removal of lithostatic load, oF rup-
‘huting of the britdle-ductile transition zone separating the
from the overlying hydrostatic envizon=
ly dissolved in the high-temperature
Aid as SO, will react with water and disproportionate to
form H,8 and sulfurie acid (Burnham, 1979)MAGIATIC AND STRUCTCRUL CONTROLS OX PORPENIRY Gu Mou DEPOSITS
ay Sa :
ere sy |
fi) 8
ens of ares ake Oe
Stone de)
ZTfLiesone Ta) (Quen manent of Hea ron
[= seiesary a okanic oc (7) (Quay monroe of eLeod Hil assion
Mosans mek) EGE] stamvock hai
‘Fu 5 Relationship between porphyry Ca depos, porphyry stucks ad dlites 6 underline ntl magna chan
hemnhiel common’ em tpi 6 hiv or grester 8 Exlstonar model forthe esol of hie saline
juss el rm ular pons and he peace of a Md os th wot Zone where a ponphgry Cu depos
ithe (Dien, 187). Th Trapped long she rn of colin boss channeled ped along
‘orn
Ge The Ane Stnon phy Ca dey
cesses deer parteo! the Lake i porph
‘Gated wit dies emanating fon granite (Dales, 287) Jur
Jorn Ie = Ts162
These processes generate a new set of veins and breccias
characterized by gangue and alteration minerals stable at
lower temperature and pH. In particular, an inevease in activ
ity of sulfate inthe fluid owing to SO, clisproportionation will
result in yolursinous precipitation of anhydrite and further
release of more acid in the form of HCI (Burnham, 1979). In
{eldsparrich host rocks, the characteristic alteration assem
blage from dese acidie fluids is fine-grained muscovite
(sertete) with quartz (“phyllic” aeration assemblage, Fig. 2B;
Lowell and Guilbert, 1870). In addition, sulfide minerals are
precipitated in zesponse to the inerease in H,S activity. Asso-
ated D veins (Gustafion and Hunt, 1975) are coarse-grained
and sharply defined with strong alteration haloes, and consist
of slide minerals (abundant pyrite, with lesser Cu Fe-slfide
minerals, sulfosalt mineral, sphalerite, and galeria), any-
dite, and minor quart. Typically, the highest grades of hypo-
gene Cn ore are present close to the boundary between the
potassic and phyllic alteration zones, again reflecting the
Insereased activity of HS in the fie as.a result of SO, dispro-
portionation. The phyllic alteration zone is commonly
observed as a shell surrounding the potasie core of the por
phyry system (Lowell and Guilbert, 1970), and may have a
liamexer of several hundred meters toa few kilometers,
Separation of a vapor phase may lead to the formation of |
a low-density vapor plume rich in acidic volatiles such as
80, HCI, HE and CO, (Fig. 4). Cooling and condensation
lof these vapors at shallow depths causes intense acid leach-
ing (‘advanced argillic” alteration; Fig. 4), characterized by
total destruction of primary minerals to Teave an insoluble
residue of quartz, clays (kaolinite or pyrophyllite), alt
‘minum hycroxides (diaspore), and alunite, Such alveration
zones, being very porous and permeable, may serve as hests
to high-sulfidation sivles of epithermal mineralization
(Hedenquist eta, 1998; Hedengquist, 1995).
Emplacement ofa hot body of magia into the shallow
crust npieally involves interaction with local ground waters
(Fig. 4). The degree of that interaction depends on crustal
permeability but in many cases hydrothermal convection
Cells driven by heat front the intrusion ean be shown to
have operated over radi of many Kilometers (Taylor, 1974;
Tidley et al., 1986). The fluids involved are typically dilute
ground waters, and the alteration arising from thei flow is
Characterized by hydration, producing minerals such as
hlorite and epidote, commonly with earbonate minerals
(*propylitc” alteration: Fig. 2B),
Many variations upon the general porphyry model have
been recognized throughout the world, particularly in
terms of the sequence of sulfide minerals deposited in
veins. For example, at Mineral Hill, Atizona, molybdenite is
Une oldest sulfide mineral recognized and much ofthe cop-
per sulfide mineralization is paragenetically younger, ger
erally associated with Daype veins (Wilkinson et ul, 1982)
Nevertheless, the general sequence of alteration and sul
fide mineral deposition described above characterizes the
majority of porphyry Cu deposits, regardless of their size.
From a structural standpoint, three processes contribute
to fracturing during porphyry Cu formation, and each
process enhances permeability in the form of fracture or
Tosa, AND RUCHTARDS
breccia networks through which hydrothermal fluids may
flow and precipitate minerals (Figs. 5-7): (1) intrusion of |
pre» syn, and postmineral porphyry stocks or dikes, which
may be intruded to neaesurface depths (1-3 km; Koide
and Bhattacharii, 1975); (2) exsolution of hydrothermal
fluid from a cooling parental magma chamber, with
"upward focus into the soidilied or partially solidified stocks
and warm wall and roof rocks (Fig. 5A); and (8) phase sep-
aration of the hydrothermal fluid, Each event involves vol
tume expansion and fracturing wherever the fhuid pressure
exceeds the ambient minimum effective sires (63’ = 5 ~ Py,
‘where Ps the Mluid pressure plus che censile strength ofthe
rock; Jaeger and Cook, 1979; Sibson, 2000). Multiple or
recurrent pulses of hydrothermal activity, which are com
mon in porphyry systems, lead to repetition of fracturing
and superimposition of veins and alteration, leading to
increased complexity.
Veinsdominated versus breccia dominated porphyry Cu deposits
Porphyry Cu deposits developed within noncaleareous
country rocks have 2 considerable range of morphology
and show variations besween yeinlominated and breveis-
dominated systems with considerable overlap berween the
two. Vein-lominated porphyry Cu deposits represent a re
atively simple environment: veining events are consistent
With emplacement ofa porphyry stock, exsoltion ofa mag:
matiederived hydrothermal fluid with local influx of exter-
nal fluids, and cooling of an evolving magmatiedriven
hyelrothermal system, These deposis are the most common
variety of porphyry Cu deposits, with numerous well4locu-
mented exampies (see volumes edited by Titley and Hicks,
1966; Sutherland Brown, 1976; Tiley, 1982; Pierce and
Bolm, 1995; Schroeter, 1995),
The other end-member is breccia-dominated (Sillitor,
1985), Breccias in the porphyry Cu environments have i
range of morphology and genesis, being formed from
igneous, maginatichydrothermal, and phreatomagmatic
processes. The most common wpes of breccia are pre- to
sy-mineral bodies that are irregular w pipe like in shape
and are characterized by angular clasts, sharp or grada
tional contacts against enclosing rocks, and an intimate
association with porphyry stocks or dikes. The breceia
matrix consists of igneous rocks or hydrothermal siieate
and sulfide minerals (Richard and Courtright, 1958;
Camus, 1975; Zveng and Clark, 1895). Postmineral bree-
cias commonly but not always have a milled rocklour
matrix and rounded clasts; they are referred to as pebble
breccias. These breccias essentially excise parts of a prior
hydrothermal system (Richard and Courtright, 1958),
although locally, such as at Toquepala, the pebble breccias
are intramineral and contain chalcopyrite in the matrix.
Zweng and Clark (1995) proposed zhat breccia-dominated
porphyry Cu deposits form at shallow levels based upon
uid inclusion data from Toquepala. They suggested that
yein-dominated deposits would more commonly form at
slightly greater depths. Implied in their model isa primary
influence of the lithostatic load of the overlying column af
rock on breccia formation (see discussion below).MPIC AND STRUCTURAI, CONTROLS ON PORPHRY Cu» Mo # Aw DEPOSITS
Mu
“ones of dilation
4 tnesion induced
Facts
Sy) Myy
wg
intrusion-induced
Tractures
roof uplift along steep faults by piston mechanism
oof extension above expanding pluton
progressive lateral development of steep faults as pluton expands
PED
| 4
tate growth by \P A
cantilever
mechanism
_—
focusing of exsolved hydrothermal uid 2 sera growth
crystallizing mygma by cantilever
ve
magma input
Fic General mois forthe Tornntion oa ular raniae Davo ak versng porpiny Gv dona halon
levelnin sheers A Computer smiation of growing tabslae batolt fed Icom below (Australian Geocymamics
[cet Croup, #7) Suiorizonal actress propagate outward fom the expanding psf te >
Siar plo, Rng above the gioweng badd are storks extending to shal Teel in he ers. The tae ofthe
Fan b daplaced opwar by dhe shallow stock, whone explacement develops coneensie facture and aut woe
elas inehee step facure nemorky in toe uneiogsoleaniccarspace B.A tabular plo expans tara nd
(Gurren bra canever estas iting of the plan ron’ along ep dipping normal aul acorn
Seine teniea exjansion he sock, Upward expansion of ce pun may be aed Dy tpg of oo! rks ad
osentialy yar ning, Root uphf ibeh acompanied estesion, whic Teas to weak rons to kh apap
cercracke un nitude hee apopmeses Reus ihe sent of ecoosed nagmatederied bydsteral Mts ane >
quent oe fnraton (ae ig for oxarples) PCD = porphin Cir = Ma AU depos
168racial dyke
TOSDAL AND RICHAIS
‘map view) "808 of plane containing E
Simple
9} and 6,
_MAGMATIC AND STRUCTURAL CONFROLS ON PORPELYRY Gx Mo = Ae DEPOSITS 165
Convergent Plate Margin Magmatism
Porphyry Cu deposits are the end result of a complex
sequence of events initiated by magmagenesis at conver
‘gent plate margins, and itis, herefore, useful to review the
process of magina ascent and emplacement in the lithos-
pheve, Convergent margin niagmatism is linked 10 subdue
tion of an oceanic plate heneaih an overriding continental
or oceanic plate, upon which the arcis constructed (Fig. 3).
In this environment, plate motion vectors are commonly
oblique at varying angles to the plate margin, and stress
transinitted to the overriding plate, and the resulting defor~
mation, reflect the degree of obliquity: Strain is partitioned
into are-normsal (convergent ar divergent) and are-paralle]
Gurikeslip) components A wide range of structural siyles
in, thus, be expected in the upper plate depending on the
degree af convergence obliquiry, convergence rate, and the
angle of subduction (Pitch, 1972; Dewey, 1980; Jarrard,
1086). Of additional imporsance is whether trench retreat
or advance occurs at the plate margin (Hamilton, 1988;
Royelen, 1993). In the former situation (irench reueat), the
overall tectonic setting will be extensional, or cranste
sional where a significant degree of net convergence oblige
tity is present, in the latter ease (trench adhance}, contrac-
tion of transpression dominates. Regardless of convergence
‘geomeusy, some relationship between strike-slip tectonics
and magmatism, including porphyry magmatism, is present
in convergent margin ares, although the relative impor-
tance of strike-slip motion will vary (e.g., Glazner, 1991; de
Saint Blanquat etal, 1998). The ubiquitous association of
plutoni¢ and voleanic complexes and anajor fault zones in
ares implies that rising magma concentrates in zones of
defoxmation, 4 corellary to this observation is either that
deformation is erucial to the emplacement of magma, or
that magma assists dhe deformation processes which, in
tum, helps its ascent to higher crustal levels (McCaffrey,
19925 de Saint Blanquat etal, 1998), Paterson ané Schmidt
(1909; see also Schmidt and Paterson, 2000) have argued
that many plutonic complexes are not necessarily emplaced
along faults but eome to rest in the less deformed rocks
between major faults. However, their analysis applies to
contractiomal orogenic belts characterized by thrust faults,
rather than transpressional or ranstensional strike-slip
ones in volcanic ares (RFehards, 20004),
Exactly how magaia moves through te crust is poorly.
understood, Nevertheless, there is general agreement that
the following factors are important (Hogan and Guilbert,
1005; Hutton, 1997): (1) magmas, being fluid, will aways
move dosen a hydvadynaznic gradient toward regions of low
pressure; (2) in the absence of significant magmatic over-
Pressure, the density contrast between a granitic melt and
the surrounding rocks will drive the melt upwards to an
“equilibrium” level of neutral buoyaney in the erust; (3)
increasing vapor pressure during late stages of crystllizae
tion generally increases magma pressures, (4) the lithost
tic load of the overlying crust may act as u pressure seal hin-
dering the rise of magma; and (5) temperaturedependent
viscous resistance to magma flow inhibits ascent, Mayguatie
overpressure may drive magmas beyond their level of neu:
tral buoyancy, commonly resulting in violent eruptions.
Overpressured magmas may intrude by forcing open dikes
by penetrating old faults or fractures (Bussell et
al, 1976; Delaney et al., 1986; Ida, 1999), The prevailing
testa stess field controls the orientations of dikes, favor
ing intrusion along older faults oriented at high angles 10
the least principal stress (G,). Alternarively, tectonic stress
and resultant strain may episodically create reduced pres
sure or tensional zones in the crust, such as pulkapart zones
at fault intersections or jogs, which may focus magma
ascent (Hutton, 1988; Tikoll and Teyssier, 1992: Grocott et
fly 1994; Richards eta, 2001), Thus, she varied styles and
mechanisms of magma emplacement in the erust involve
‘an important dynamic interplay benseen teetonie and mag-
matic processes, The final three-¢imensional form of the
stock is controlled by strain rate, magma supply, country
rock versus magma theologie differences, and tectonic
environment (Castro and Fernanele7, 1998; Corriveau et
tl, 1998; Hogan etal, 1908; Paterson and Miller, 1998, by
Yoshinobu etal, 1998; Wikon and Grocot, 1999),
Groth of a magma chamber
‘Magmatism at the Barth's surface or in nearsurface enc
ronments is a manifestation of the relative effects of tec-
tonie stzess ancl magmatic overpressure, Whereas tectonic
lor vertical stress acting on magna decreases with decreas-
ing depth, the effect of magmatic overpressure should
remain essentially unchanged because of hydraulic con-
neetivity to depth. Hence, final emplacement of magina at
shallow erusial levels will in large part but not entirely,
‘reflect magma dynamies or magma overpressure (Takacla,
1904; Hutton, 1997; de Saint Blanquat et ala, 1998; Ida,
1999). Coherent magma chambers recharge and grow
through the aggregation of small pulses of magma, perhaps
through the intrusion of multiple dikes or lobate bodies
(Petford et al., 1995, 1984). Buoyant diapirc rise of magona
br lateral translation by pushing aside of wall rocks helps
‘ereate room for an expanding pluton (Tikoff etal, 1999),
dde Saint Blanquat et ul, (1998) proposed that magma
ascent into the crust stops where the magma becomes cxpar
ble of deforming or displacing its enclosing wall rocks,
thereby creating space for a growing or ballooning magma
chamber. Evidence for varying amounts of walkrock strain
around plutons atall depths of emplacement lendls support
to this model.
Granitoids emplaced at high levels in the erust tend to
have tabular shapes with Hat tops and bottoms and stcep
sides, and lateral dimensions that are much larger than
their vertical dimensions (Fig. 5B, C: Hamilion and Myers,
1967; Dilles, 1987; McCaffrey and Petford, 1997). Such
magma chambers grow abowe narrow vertical feeder zones
or dikes and spread laterally as sill-ike intrusions that
inflate by floor displacement or by roof-lifiing (Fig. 6:
Johnson and Pollard, 1973; Pollard and Johnson, 1973;
Corry, 1988). Floor depression leading to lopolithic com
plexes seems to he the most common form of granitoid
emplacement except at high-crustal levels (500 km) carthquake
activity, which has been shown ta generate enhances! seis-
‘mic activity in active geothermal and magmatic systems
(Hill et al., 1993), Evidently, propagation of seismic
energy into a magmatic or hydrothermal system is suff
Gent to induce gas separation leading to volume expan-
sion (Linde eval, 1904; Sturtevant etal. 1995). The mag-
matic pressure increase could give rise 10 voleanie
‘eruptions (Sahaglan and Prousseviteh, 1992), whereas in
the hydrothermal environment of a porphyry Cu éeposit,
increased fluid pressures could be sufficient to tigger
rupturing of the pressure seal above the porphyry system,
leatling to generation of breccia pipes.
‘Tectonic Setting of Porphyry Cu Deposits
Assimple mode! of porphyry Gu deposit genesis involves
formation from hydrothermal fluids exsolved from cale-
alkaline so alkaline maginas in a subyoleanic are enviror
ment. However, many shallow-level porphyritic pluton!
complexes are devaid of or have anly weak porphyrysivle
mincralization, The barren Paleocene ring complexes of
the San Jeronimo superunit in the Peruvian Coastal
bacholith are examples from an are otherwise rich in por
phyry Cu deposits of broadly similar age (Bussell, 1985;
Pitcher, 1985; Zweng and Clark, 1995). On a more global
scale, porphyry Cu deposits are sparse in the western Pacific
(Uyeda and Nishiwaki, 1980), with notable exceptions int
Papua New Guinea and the Philippines (MacDonald and
Arnolal, 1994; Sillitoc, 1997; Hedenquist et al., 1998). In
addition, porphyry Cu formation is characteristically
episodic and localized, being concentrated during limited
time ranges within narrow, margin-parallel belts (Sillitoe,
1972, 19HR; Tiley and Beane, 1981; Clack et al, 1982
Damon et al., 1983). These considerations suggest that
tdditionsal factors rmust be involved in letermining whether
‘1 porphyry Cu deposit wll form or not, including derails of
-magma chemistry (e.g, water content, oxidation state) and
tecionie setting (Uyeda and Nishiwaki, 1980),
‘A review of structural settings of porphyry Cu deposits
indicates that there are uo unique environments into which
these deposits are emplaced. They are found within strike-
slip fault zones with only limited displacement contempe-
rancous with mineralization (Maksaev and Zentilli, 1988;
Clark et al. 1990; Sapie and Cloos, 1994; Lindsay et al,
1905), within regions affected by slightly older to concur
rent Gunspressional or contractile strain and uplift (Titley
and Heidrick, 1978; Heidrick and Tiley, 1982; Olson, 1989;
Tomlinson, 1964; Silitoe, 1907), in areas undergoing Ii
ited extensional deformation (Presnall, 1997), and in areas
lacking major active fault ystems (Silitoe, 1997). Many but
not all deposits are localized along older fault systems that
provided crustal permeability (Heidrick and Titley, 1982:
Richards etal, 2001). Significant porphyry Cu deposits are,
however, seemingly absent from regions undergoing large:
scale extensional strain, a negative association that has long
been recognized, and which seems to preclude those arcs
or times within ares where such tectonies dominate. A com
‘mon theme throughout these convergent ares is dhe limited
deformation that is demonstrably contemporaneous with
porphyry Cu development,
‘Times of porphyry Cu generation have been causally cor
related with times of shallowelipping subduction (Sillitoe,
1972; Nielsen, 1976; Uyeda and Nishiwaki, 1980; Titley and
Beane, 1981), increased convergence rates (Clark et al.,
1990), subduction of aseismic ridges (Skewes and Stern,
1995), subduetion zone reversals (Solomon, 1990), or fole
lowing uplif (Sillitoe, 1997). Many but noc all porphyry Cx
deposits in Arizona (McCandless and Ruiz, 1993), southern
Perit (Clark etal., 1990), Chile (Maksaev andl Zentili, 1988;
Skewes and Stern, 1995; Richarels et al., 2001), anel Papua
New Guinea (Titley and Heidrick, 1978; Sillitoe, 1997)
formed near the endl af major periods of maginatisin, con-
tuaetile of transpressional strain, and uplitt. Silitor (1997)
stiggested that rapid uplift in an are is an essential prec
sor to the formation of giant porphyry Cu deposits, which
Appear near 10 or justafter the end of that event
‘The above observations, combined with the nearcircular
plan of many porphyriesand the common depositscale or[MAGMATIC AND STRUCTURAL CONTROLS ON PORPHYRY Cu Mo Aw DEPOSTES 175
centations of associated veins and dikes, suggest that por
phyry Cur deposits are developed during periods of lowelif
ferential or nearisotropic horizontal sivess in the are. The
achievement of such stress states is likely driven by finde
mental changes in subduction geometry and convergence
rates, For example, changes in the coupling of stress
between the subshucting and overriding plate may Iead to
shifts in the location of zones of upper-plate deformation
‘with respect to the magmatic arc, either inboard toward the
backsare or onthoard toward the convergent margin. This
shiftin the locus of ceformation relative to magmatism may
permit the are to approach a neutral stres state. The giant
Miocene and Pliocene porphyry Cu deposits in central
Chile (Los Pelambres, Rio BlancoLos Bronces, EL
‘Teniente) seem to fit this scenario becanse they formed in
the hanging wall of fold-and-thrust belt that lies to the
east in the Argentinean foreland (Jordan et al., 1993;
Ramoset al, 1996). In an alternative scenario, relocation of |
‘he voleanie are may be accompanied by relaxation of com-
pressional or transpressional stress in an old, established,
plutonic-voleanie are, resulting in late-stage clevelopment of
porphyry magmatism. The late-Hocene-early-Otigocene
porphyry Cu deposits of northern Chile are proposed to
hhave formed during such a period of stress relaxation folk
lowing a prolonged episode of Eocene transpression and
effusive voleanie activity; relaxation coincided with flatten-
‘ng of the subduction angle and subsequent inland shift of|
magmatism (Maksaev and Zentlli, 1988; Clark, 1993;
Richards etal, 2001).
“These characteristics may be speculatively tied to models
‘of magmagenesis and crustal emplacement as reviewed
above (Fig. 13). First, the simple textbook form of a
destructive margin—that of orthogonal compression, deep-
‘crustal or mantle melting, and widespread effusive magma-
tism—is not conducive to porphyry Cu formation (Fig.
1A), Neither is a state of arc rifting (extension), where
crustal melting is shortcircuited and mantlederived
basaltic melts ascend directly to the surface (Fig. 188) con-