-

.., , ..,
,

XIII

2012

 947 (08)
63.3(2)

89

89 : c \ .-.
.., , .., ,
. XIII. .: , 2012. 520 .
ISBN 978-5-905040-03-0

ISBN 978-5-905040-03-0

947 (08)
63.3(2)

, 2013

... :
(1812)..................................................................................7
...
:
- 1813. .............. 27
... ..
11 1845.
...................................................................................... 42
... 18531854.
............................. 74
... ,
:
.... (19051906)......................97
... :
? . .................................... 112
.
: 19181919.
...................................... 121
... : .
2 (1933) ...................145
.
:

............................................................................ 269
5

.., ...
19871992.
.............319
. -
:
............................................................................ 338
...
(20092010) ....................... 358

..: ...
1812: . ., 2012 ............. 379
. ............. 387
..: ...
. 19141918. , 2010 ..........415
. -
.............................................................................. 477
... :
(
.)...............................481
XIII ..............516

..

:


(1812)

(21) 1812 . I
. . ,
.
, : , , , ,
, , , , .
, , ,
, , ,

, .

,
, , ,
, , <>, ,
7

, 1.
,
2.
-- I ,
, ,
3. , ,
, , . ,
.
:

4.
, I,
,
, 1

3
4

XIX XX . (). . 1. . VI. ., 1962. 145.

.363365.
. .: . .745.
. 406. : . 1870. 89. .15271528. .
, : . 1812. . . .II. . ., 1912. .3132. .. I
- // -. .VI.. 4. .118119.
. . : . . 1812 . . II.
/ ., ., . , . , . ... ., 2009. .159.

. . : . 1892. 5. .534.
. : .. 1812. ., 2005.
.8990.
..
1812// 1812. : . . ., 1962. .5253. ...
. .152160. . . .XI..,
1895. .159. I .., 12 1812. . .VI.
150. .370373. .. .., 12 1812.

. ,
, .
,
, .. , --
. ,

1812.5 ,
,
. , ,

. ,
, I ,
.
. 1811. .

. ,
,
, . 22
1812. I :
, .
,

.
,
5

. 138. .345350. .. .., 29 1812 . . . 21. ., 1877.

.435446. .. I, 29 1812. . ,
,
. .. . 1812. ., 1978. .102103.

 6. ,
. , , ,
( )
,
7.
-, , I, , . -
,
, . ,
:
,
; - ,
8. , , ..
.
.. .
,
, 1812 .,
,
, 6

7
8

.. . / . ... .III. ., 1952.

. 851852. .: . .
1812. .I. 1812. ., 2008 ( 1877.). .45.
. . 18061812 . . III. ., 1887.
.... . ., 1962. .. . . //
/ . .., .., ... .,
1992. .120134. . . 18. I, / . . ... ., 1997. .169203. .. 1812 // . 2001. 1. .317.
. 1812// . 2012. 2. .6871.
. .VI.. 745. . 405.
. .364.

10

.


1812.9.

.., 10. , (. ..)
-
,
" ",
- 11.
, .
.: ,
, 12. , , . , , , ,
;
13.
9

10

11
12
13

. 1892. 12. .617642. 1893. 1. .8799. : .. 1812. .II.. 185220. I 1812. :

. .VI., 1871. .166. . 1901.
1. . 218222. - . 1912. 2. . 151169.
3. .187214.
.. .5354.
: . .. // J j
18041813. , 1983. .341353. .: ..
1812 - . , 1987. .1821.
. . 343. . . . 52. .: ... .
., .. 2 . . 10. .436. , .
.. ( )// . V
- . , 2002. .155.

11

 . , , ,
. , ,
, , .
26
(17891815).
: , ,
, , ,
, , , ,
14.
,
, ,
,
.
( ) , ( .)


. ,
, ,

.

15. 1979. ..
,

14

15

. .: ..
1812. . ., 2012. .9697.
- , . ., : .. . ., 1987. .73.
, , : . . . ., 1983. .253263. .. I
[1925]// . . ., 1990.
.: . . -
I// . . ., 1995. .145154.

12

 () ,
16. ,

, . , -
, 17.
, ,

, .
,
,
,
.
, ,

, .
,
. . 16

17

. . : // . 1979, 4.
.6581. . : . . / . . .
... ., 1986. .88113. .. : .. ? ( ) //
/ . .. . / . ..
. . . ., 1989. . 274278. . . .,
2000. .2728 .
,
1808 1809.
de facto.
,

. .: ..
: ( XVIII
30 . XIX). ., 2007. .291327.

13

 XIX, ,
:
(. ..)
, ,
,
, ( ,
, ? . .). ,
18.
, , , .
.

,

.
.
,
. - , ,
19.

-20.
18

19
20

. 16401870 / . ... ., 1986. .175

177.
,
: . . . --, 1997.
.6365. .. 1812. . 2.
. : //
: . .IV.., 2007. .3435.
, XIX,
, .
, ,
-

14

, ,
,
21, .
,
, ,
.
.
,

.
, ,
, / -. 22, .
,
, .
(: ,
) :

. ,
, , , , ,
- , , ,
, , , , , 23.

21

22
23

. .: . .
1812. . 1.
. .
XIX XX//
. .120.
..-.
(19311956.). ., 2009.
. . //
. 1941. 9. . 3. 1934 .

15

 ,

.
24.
, , ,
, ,
. ,
,
, , 25. ..
, ..,
XIX , ,
26.
,
. , , ,
, , , , . 27.

24

25

26

27

. , , .
.., , . .. ..

. ., 1950. .: ..
: . .?// . 1991. 2. .316.
.. 1812. . ., 1988. .1434. . 18131815.: , , // (). 2004. 12. .7283. .
// . 1992. 67. .180.
.. 1812. .113115. ,
.
..- (17981807). ., 1962. .335358, 411420. ..
: -
XIX. ., 1972. .4262.

16

 (
), ,
28.
,
, ,
, . , XIX ,

, ,
. , (
),
, 29.
,
(
),
30.

, , ,
I. 18011803.

31. -

28

29

30
31

, :
..- - 18061807.// . . -
. .XXV. ., 1962. .171192.
.., .. (
18071808.)// . 1969. 6. .5266. ..
.105.
., 18071814.
.
,
. .. . .36. .: .. 1812. .1819.
. .175.
: XIX . ., 1995.
.2738. . . 18. .7797.

17

,
.
,
,
. I ..,
11 (23) 1804.32 .
1806 1807., ,
.., ,
, 33.
, , , .
. .
. .. ,
, , 1806. 1812.34
: ,
18061807. -
1812., - (,
) . ,
I, , ,
32

33

34

. . II. ., 1964. 50. . 138151. . 79. . 664665.

.:
. . 2. ., 1913. .2744. : ... . .196201. .. .9597. 18011805.:
.. : 18011812.
., 1966. . 1.
. .
1807.//
.
18041813. / . . ... ., 2005. .5764.
..
( 1801.
1808.)// J j .115.

18

 . , :
,
, I
..35.
.

- , XVIII,

36. . .
. . 37 .
35
36

37

. . ., 2000. .59, 63, 65, 93.

. ., 1868. . 1. .238
256.
XVIII. ., 1984. . 305, 306. .399407. .. - XIX.//
. ., 1972. . 98107. . .
- XIX .
// . (XVIII. 1878.). ., 1995. .440.
.. .153187. . J J //
j j. . IV.
, 1914. . 1. . 9095. j . .
. , 1926. MilutinoviK.Prvi ideolozi federalistike misli kod junih
slavena// Rad Jugoslavenske akademije znatnosti i umetnosti. Kn. 330. Zagreb,
1962. S. 8891. . j J -j
1804// . j .
, 1996. .7381 .
. . //
. . 3. .170171. ..
(1811.) .// - . . . . ., 1972.
.359386. . . -
18091822. ., 1976. .2223. ., . : //
Imperium inter pares: (1700
1917). . / ., ., .. ., 2010. .214216.

19

, .
, , ,
,
, , .
1804. 38.
, .
.
,
1809 ., , ,
.
,

18101811 . .
, ,
39,
, .
, ,
. , ..,
(
), 1812.40
38
39

40

18041813. . . 1. ., 1980. 16.

.4244.
., ,
.. 18 1810.: - (). . 14 209. . 170.
. 24. . 670. . 5354. . . :
(18041835.)// :
( XIX XX.). .
. ., 2007. .205.

-
18111812 . , . . .

20

, , , , 29 1811 .41 ( ,
..,
, , 18061807
18121813. ... 42.) 27
, 50
,
. ,
(- ) , ..,
43.
. , , ,
44.
, , , ,
41

42

43

44

. . 14 209. . 5/165. . 68. . 35. . 67. ..

.., 1 1811.
.
. : .. 18121813.//
1812 , . . XIII
. , 2005. .159185. . .. 1812.//
,
. , 2008. .216251.
. . 14 209. . 5/165. . 68. . 35. . 45. . .
.., 3 1811. . . 89. .. .., 7 1811.
, ,
[] , , ,
[],
. 2 []
, 25 ,
. . . 3/163. . 24.
. 12. . 5153. . . . . , 17 1811 . , , ,
. .
.5/165. . 68. . 35. . 22.

21

 ,
. , ,
1811.,
, ,
, ,
45. , ,
.
46.
,
1811.,
, .
, --,
,
, . 21 1811.
47, (
, ..), ,
. ,
, .., ..,
.
, .
I,
, , .
, 18061811 . 17
45
46

47

. . 811. ... ..
.., 7 1811.
, , ,
, ,
, . .
.89.
. . 1922. , , , . 1811.
,
. , , 1 , , .

22

 I 48.
, , , . . ,
49.
. . :
, , -,
, , , ,
. , , ,
, ,
.
, , ,
. ,
. , ,
,
,
, , ,
, 50.

.
. .. , 51.
48

49

50
51

. . 846 (). . 16 (1). . 431. . 1. . 12. ,

, ( )
... .
,
, ,
,
. .
. 431. . 7 .
... . 1. .458. : .
. . XVIII
XIX. ( , -
). ., 1990. .146148. ..
. . . 1980.

23


1806
1807.
. ,
,
, ,
, .

, . , ,
, , .. 52.
, ,
, , .
, ,
, 53.
[]
, , . ,
, ,
, , ,
.
,
54.


52

53
54

. .82. .
.: . // / ..; . . . ., 2005. . 80101. . .
. . ., 2007. .139176. . . , , ,
. ., 2010.
. . 846 (). . 16 (1). . 431. . 7. . 55.
. . 1012. . 6. . 3. 4. ( 9 1811.
.. ).

24

. 14 1810.
: , , ,
,
. ,
, . ,
, ..
, ,

,
55. 25 1810., -, ,
56.
, -
, , .
. .
. ,

57. 1812. ,
58.
55

56
57

58

. . 7. . 1418.
9 1811., (.
.6. . 11).
: , ,
, , , ,
, , , ,
(. . 18.).
. . 2.
. .VI. 144. .360362.
,
.
3 (15) 1812 .
. . 172.
.431432. 13 .
, , 1811. .

25

 .
,
, .
( ), I .
, ,
59. ,

.
, . 18 1812.
I ,
.. .. 60.
, , .
() .
,
. , .

1812.
.
,
,
, , , .

, , 18041811. .

59
60

185. .456459. . .., 24 1812.

.: ..
18041813.// . . 17. / . . ... ., 1997. .170171.
.. .5354.
.. 1812. .II.. 207.

..

:
-
1813.

1812 .

, , : ?
,
. . 18/30 1812 ..,
,
.
,
I - III.

, , ,
. ,
- .
27


.
.
,
3 1813 .. . , ..
, ,
.1
.. ,
, ,
, ,2
,
, ,
..3
8/20 1813 . . .
,
. ,
, .4

. , .5
.
,
. .
61873 .,
4.600 . , ,
, , , , , , ,
.6

, ,
.., ,
13 1813, 31313 . , 7596 .
1
2
3
4
5
6

.. . .V.., 1956. . 63.

.
. . 66.
. . 86.
. . 100.
: ReboulF.Campagne de 1813. . 12. Paris, 19101912; UsselJ. de. tudes sur lanne 1813. La dfection de la Prusse (dcembre 1812
mars 1813). Paris, 1907.

28

11373 , , , 50282 .7
,
,

, , 5 .. ..
. 15. .

..
, , .
. .

.

, 29 1812 / 10 1813
- ..
.
, , , , ,

.
,
,

;
,
.8
3/15 1813. ,
60. ., ,
. . ,
7
8

.. .V.. 105108.
. . 41.

29

, .
, ,
,
, , .9

. 15/27 1812
. . ,
22 , 700
200 ,10 54 ,
20 20 , 250 , -
85 , .11 - ,
-,
.. , .12
25 1812 / 6 1813 - , , -
- ,
,
, , , , ,
, ,
, .13
28 1812 / 9 1813 ,
. .
, ,
. ,
, , ,
,
.14 ,
9
10
11
12
13
14

. . 63.
. . 29. . 1/153. . 28. . 38. . 96.97.
. . 846. . 16. . 3511. . 319320.
. . 317.318.
Geschichte des Frhjahrsfeldzuges 1813 und seine Vorgeschichte. Bearb. von
[A.] Holleben. Bd. 1. Berlin, 1904. S. 72.
. . 846. . 16. . 3903. . 9898.

30

 .
3/15 1813. ,

.15 4/16 1813
.16
, , 3/15 1813
17 , :
,
, ,
, , ,
,
, .18 .
8/20 1813 , ,
. , , , ,

, .
;
,
[]
.19
15
16
17

18
19

. . 103. . 1/208. . 45. . 2. . 33.

. . 846. . 16. . 3903. . 9898.
.. 2/14 1813., . 29 1812 / 10 1813. (DroysenJ.G.Das Leben des
Feldmarschalls Grafen York von Wartenburg. Bd. 2. Berlin, 1852. S. 35, 46).
Geschichte des Frhjahrsfeldzuges 1813 und seine Vorgeschichte. Bearb. von
[A.] Holleben. Bd. 1. S. 7273.
: .. . . .V..,
1956; 1813 .
. . . ., 1964. .

. ,
(Geschichte des Frhjahrsfeldzuges 1813 und seine
Vorgeschichte. Bearb. von [A.] Holleben. Bd. 1. S. 73). , , ... ,

31

 , 1) , ,
. ,
, .
, . ,
, , 2)
[1 .] ,
.20
, , , ,
. ,

,21 1813. .
,
.22
9/21 1813,
, 11/23 1813. ,
13/25 1813 , , ,
, 14/28 1813
: ;
,
, .23

20
21
22
23

. , . . . . 9/21 1813
(. . - (18121815) //
. 1905. . 102. . 221).
., (DroysenJ.G.Das
Leben des Feldmarschalls Grafen York. Bd. 2. S. 5960).
.. ., ,
...
. . 846. . 16. . 3903. . 9393.
. . 103. . 1/208. . 45. . 2. . 154.
DroysenJ.G.Das Leben des Feldmarschalls Grafen York. Bd. 2. S. 59.
. . 846. . 16. . 3903. . 156157.

32

 , , ,
:
,
. ,
3,
.24
, , 6/18 1813
..-.25 []
,
,
, ,
.26.
- .27
24
25

26
27

. . 157.
. 18041807 .
, , 18071808.
, , . 18081812 . .
. . , , , ,
(Saint-Rn-Taillandier M. Allemagne et Russie.
Le baron de Stein et la politique allemande de 1813. Paris, 1858). 12/24
1812, I, . .
( . .
1812 // . 1892. . LXVI. . . 383404).
4/16 1813 . , , 6/18 1813,
(. . - //
. 1905. . 101. . 905; . 102. . 221224).
1813. .
. . ., 1964. . 2627.
. , .., , ,
I. .
, , , , , , , ,
,

33

 10/22 1813.28 -
( )
.. 29,
.30
,
- .
, ,
. .
11/23 1813., ,
,31
.32
, , 17/29 1813
,
.
, ,

28

29

30

31

32

(DroysenJ.G.Das Leben des Feldmarschalls Grafen

York. Bd. 2. S. 62).
StulzP. Frendherrschaft und Befreiungskampf. Die preussische Kabinettpolitik und die Rolle der Volksmassen in den Jahren 1811 bis 1813. Berlin, 1960.
S.213.
.
, - 1810., . .
..-., - ,
.. .
, .. ., .
. , . ,
, -
, ,
. , .
, , ,
. ,
, -
1813. , , ,
.
DroysenJ.G.Das Leben des Feldmarschalls Grafen York. Bd. 2. S. 63.

34

 .
. .33
, , , .

.
,
. , ,
, .34
,
.
,
.
, , .., .35

,
,
.
12/24 1813 7/19
1813, ,

., .36
33
34

35
36

Ibid. S. 64.
, ,
. .
, .
, -III.
HardenbergK.A.Denkwrdigkeiten des Staatskanzlers Frsten von Hardenberg. Hrsg. von L. von Ranke. Bd. IV. Leipzig, 1877. S. 339.
UsselJ. de. tudes sur lanne 1813. La dfection de la Prusse (dcembre 1812
mars 1813). Paris, 1907. P. 157. . 24 1812 //

35

 ,
, , . ,
,
. ..37
, 11/23 1813
, . ., 13/25
1813 ,
, ,
.38
.
14/26 .., 19/31 1812.
.
, , 9/21
1813,

37

38

5 1813
. , , , 7/19
1813. 9 1813 . .,
28 1812 / 9 1813 29 1812 / 10 1813
.. ,
. . , ,
,
. , .,
,
, , , , , , (NatzmerE. von. Aus dem
Leben des Generals Oldwig von Natzmer. Berlin, 1876. S. 9299).
DroysenJ.G.Das Leben des Feldmarschalls Grafen York. Bd. 2. S. 65.
, 1813., . ,
,
(PertzG.H.Das Leben des Ministers Freiherrn von Stein. Bd. III. Berlin,
1851. S. 208). ..-. 13/25 1813
, , , , . .
.
DroysenJ.G.Das Leben des Feldmarschalls Grafen York. Bd. 2. S. 69.

36

 ,
, .39
.40
,
,
.

, . 23 /
4 1813, ,
, 26 /
7 1813 .41
,
, 24 / 5 1813.
,
8 ,
14; ,
, ; ,
.42
- ., - ,
.43 , , . ..- ,
,44 , , .
, , 2000 .45
39
40

41
42
43
44
45

Ibid. S. 71, 80.

16/28 1813 12 , ,
, , ,
(Ibid. S. 72).
DroysenJ.G.Das Leben des Feldmarschalls Grafen York. Bd 2. S. 7382.
. . 846. . 16. . 3907. . 6162.
. . 62.
. . 9596.
. . 91.

37

 ,
, , 3 ..--,
,
, , , ,46 , .
8/20 1813 7342 .
, 3136 .
- .. .47 ,
, -- 5000 .,
.48
, -
.., , ,
, ,
, ,
, ,
.49 , .
, ,50
,
.51 ,
46

47
48
49

50
51

12 ,
,
, , ..--, .
. . 846. . 16. . 3907. . 143.144.
. . 143.
. . 144. ..
28 / 9
1813 2 35 , ,
5/17 1813, 8/20
1813, .. , ..-- (. . 103, 106).
. . 3903. . 280280.
. . 3907. . 8485.

38

 ,
.52

, , , , ,
..

;
,
, .53
,
. ,

,


.
-.
, ,
, , , 27 / 8
1813
,
,
.
-,
.
. ,

52
53

. . 6162.
. . 3903. . 330330. . . 3
.. ,
. .
., .. (DroysenJ.G.Das Leben des Feldmarschalls Grafen York.
Bd. 2. S.71).

39

 , .54
31 / 12 1813
27 / 8 1813 ,
, ,
, , .55
1/13 1813 . -.
, ,
[] ,
.56
, 5/17 1813
.
, 15/27 1813.57
, , 16/18 1813

,
.58

.59 ,
.60
54

55
56
57

58
59
60

1813. . 4950; .. .
. .V.. 187188. ....
27/8 1813., ... 31/12 1813, .,
. (Geschichte des Frhjahrsfeldzuges
1813 und seine Vorgeschichte. Bearb. von [A.] Holleben. Bd. 1. S. 7980).
Geschichte des Frhjahrsfeldzuges 1813 und seine Vorgeschichte. Bearb. von
[A.] Holleben. Bd. 1. S. 80.
Ibid. S. 80.
Ibid. S. 80. . 7/19 1813 .
.. .. ,
... .
Ibid. S. 80.
. . 846. . 16. . 3907. . 6164.
.. ,
5/17 1813 ., , .

40

, ,
20. . , , .61
. . 9/21
1813 ,

, ,

, ,
, ,
, .62
. , ,
,
- .
. .
- .
, ,
1812.

61
62

,
.., , ,
[] , . . (
1813. . 61).
. . 846. . 16. . 3907. . 6464.
... . . .V.. 252.

..

..
11 1845.

1815.
,
,
-.
. ,
-
, ,
300, 350 .
:

,
. , .
18151853.,
1831., .
,
, I.
42

 1830
, ,
, . ,

, 1815. I ..1.

: , ,
, ,
.
18271841.
33% 2.

, ,

, .
..

, -
.
, , 11 1845.
, -
, 18311855. .
,
I. . -,
,
, - . -,
1
2

-.... . . 1. .,
1882. . 30.
.: DalyJ.C.K.Russian seapower and The Eastern question (18271841).
Annapolis, 1991. P. 191. I . : .. XIX
(, ). ., 1882. . 268271.

43


. , ,
, ,
.

,
.
.
, ,
. ,
.

, , .


1812 .

, , 20000 30000 .3
, 1812 .
.
. ..
.
, -
18281829. .
.
, , . ,
1828., 70000 4.
3
4

- . .
1812. . 1. ., 1843. . 69, 79.
KaganF.W.The military reforms of NicholasI.N.Y., 1999. P. 90.

44


, ,
, , 5.
1828 . ,
,

, . 1812
.
,
6.
18281829.
- .
7. , ,
. X ...- , , , 8. .
.
- 1830
1831. 1833. ,
, ,
.
,


. .
5
6
7

... 1829. . . 1.
. ., 1905. . 62.
KaganF.W.Op. cit. P. 8996.
.. ,
. ., 1888. . 8. . 18251888.
. 118.
. . .
. ., 1889. . 135.

45



.
1845. , ,
.
, ,

.
, , -
18301840
.
, .
. , , - ( ),
,
.
, .
( 1834 )
18321841. ,
1840 9.
,

. ,
, .
, ,
, , ,
, 10.
, 1832., , , ,
, .
9
10

.. . ., 2000. . 145146.
..- 1831. ., 1890. . 50.

46

 2 1837.
,
11.
: ,
- . , 2
, , , --
. , . -

1832.
,
. , ,
. . ,
,
-,
,
.

, , .
, , ,
,
. , , -. ,
, , ,
.
.
: , , . -, , : ; ,
; .
11

... . . 147.

47

 18301831.12
, 18321839.
- . . 13.
, 2000 ,
,
14 .


. ,

.

, . (
) .

. ,

, , ,
. ,
1831. .. ,
15. ,
.
,
, , ,
,
400000 . , , 1839.
, ,
12
13

14

15

.. . . 46.
. . - . . 5. ., 1896.
.203208, 301. . : ..
I. .
.. . . ., 1999. . 136137.

,
, , .
... . ., 1890. . 73.

48

 , 25
, , I, II, III, IV , I III
390831 . 303346 .

23425 16.
800 . ,

.

.
, , . ,
,
- 18481850.,
-- 1859 ., .
,
17.
, ,
,
.
,
, . 1840. ,
, , ,
I - . .
. ,
. (
16
17

. . 38. . 4. . 359. . 171190.

. . . . 2. .; ., 1928. . 185.
McElwee W.The art of war Waterloo to Mons. L., 1974. P. 30.

49

 )
18. ,
, ,
, , ,
, .

1840
.


1830 19, .
18301840 .
,
1850.
, 20. . ,
.
.
. 490000 .
, 1840., .
, .

, 1850.
. I , , ,

.
18
19
20

. . 432. . 1. . 91. . 10 .12, 29.

. // .
1834. 13. . 9396.
BucholzA.Moltke, Schlieffen and Prussian war planning. Oxford, 1993. P. 36.

50

 . . , ,
. , 18301840 .
,
, 23 ,
19 21.
, ,
, , .
, ,
, . ,
76 ( 10 )
.
,
68 . 77
.
,
-
- (. . (846). . 16.
.1216. .117.).
, . . , I , .
: 1)
, , 2) : 26
, , 3) :
26
, .
.
.

21

... . . 147148, 152.

51


. 11 1845.
, ,
, ;
, ,
.
, .
,
,
, .
, , , 6 8 ,
,
.

22 , ,
, 100 7 .
. , , ,
, .
. , , 23
,
, , 26
, ,
.
:
1) 26 :
115000 . 368 ,
34000. 192 24; 149000 560 .
22
23
24

( ).

( ).
, ,
:

52

2)
45000 . 184 .
3) 24

32000 . 64 .
, , , 10 .
13 .
, ,
, ,
. , ,
,
, , 25 , , 26,
, ,
, ,
;
, .
, 77000 .
24827, 115000 . 368 , , , ,
34000 . 192 ,
. :

, , ,
,
. , ,

25
26
27

3000 .
( ..).
. (
I).
14000 ( ..).
,
( I).

53

 ,
, , ,
, ,
7 8 , , ,
.
, , ,
, , ,
,
, , .

, ,
, , ,
.
1) , ,
; ,
, , ,
. 28.
,
,
. ;
,
;
.
, ,
,
, ; , ,

, ,
, ,

28

( ).

54

, .
, ,
29

.
2)
.
. ,
248 ,
560, 656. 1833. ,
40
. 1812
,
. 12
36 ; ,
, .
,

: , ; ,

, . ,
4 8
600 48 ;
.

.
, , 96
.
3) , ,

30 ;
29
30

( ).

( I).

55


31.
,
, . , ,

64 , .
4) ,
,
50 , ,
1815. .
.
, ,
18000 ., ,
, , , , ; , 18000 . ,
, -.
5)
32
50 .
6) .
4 . ,
2000 - , 12 .
, ,
,
31

32

, , ,
(
..).
( I).
,
( I).

56

; , ,
.
,

, , 64 ;
, 18000 , 50 , ,
, 96 . 149000 . 560
108000 . 408 .
.
,
,
.
, ,
, ,
.
-

57

.
.
820 - .
:
663 - .
38 1/17 625

( 1 ) 10.894 57.
- 124 ;
, 62.
, , ,

150.
894
1/12 ,
26
74.
820
568 -
.
17 1841 .
, , ,
,
18 ;
15 .
6 , , 8 .
160

6, 15 ,
136
58


, , , .

923 . :
-
984.

,
.
, 26
, 1/15 61.
923
:

1/15, , 1/12,
,
, .

464 - 160.
:

, .
, , .
, , , .

59

.

,

26
-

46

37400

68

7800

184

2750

79

64400

98 12600

248

5061

99

80800

110 14500

248

6276

164 133800

110 14500

376

77106

257 210000

424 61200

928

:
:
8,


6 ,
3, 2, 4 ; ,
16
32. 3,
3

6, 7
16


:
104000 . 376


: 72000.
312


: 81000.
408


: 101000.
472

106

96000

119

19000

368

31

28200

38

6000

192

137 124200

157

25000

560

137 124200

157

25000

560

162 146800

185

29400

656

233 210900

241

38300

848

233 210900

241

38300

848 :
22000. 80

 : 26
,

,
-

30

24

3
9

16

46

37400

30

12

18

16

12

33

27000

30

3
8

( )

1
2
4
11

4

38

96

40

32

16

4800

38

3000

128

56

32

32

4800

64

26

: 2

:
8,

6, 3, 2
.
, 3 -
4 8
16
32 7 ,

;

24
(
50 )

1
1

12

4
11

4

12

20

16400

12

1
1

12

16

12

12

65

53000

4
10

16

24

4
11

( )

12

10
(

11
(

12
(

)

5

(

)

1900

;

2435 (
5061
)

32
32

;

3650 (
6276
)

32

32

128

32

32

32

16


1
3

.
(
)

1 - - 1

2 2

2
1

3 1

6 ,
17

(2 )

( )

12

12

24

24

24

24

24

24

32

32

40

25

70

93

76200

314

257

210000

386

32

32

16

16

16

16

16

16

16

16

16

96

96

40

46700

320

232

58200

38

3000

640

283

;

5180 (
77106
).
7


7
17

 : 26
,

1 2

12

33

(
)

2 3

12

3 5

12

5 9

12

10

12

( )

6 11

12

12

12

( )

95

2 3

14

48

16

11

14

48

16

14

14

14

72

24

14

14

72

24

109

240

80

24

24

26

1 1

( )

1091

98700

12

1 1

3 6

( )

21

342

30900

: 5 ,
4 7

12

12

( )

25

22600

1
2

(2700 .) .
( ...)
(2700 .) .
( ...)

119

19000

272

96

16

16

14

72

24

24

72

24

38

6000

144

48

14

14

;
; 2435
(
5061 )

72

24

28

4400

72

24

7 13

12

14

12

( )

8 15

12

16

12

( )

21

71

64100

2393

216300

( )

6 (5400 .) .
( ...)

14

14

72

24

14

14

72

24

56

8900

144

48

241

38300

632

216

;
; 3650
(
6276 )

..

18531854.

XVIII.,
1. .


. , -

, ,
,
2. ,
1

..
XVIII. 1830. // . ., 1974. . 538; .., .., ..,
.. XVIII .. , 1997. . 34; . . . ., 2003. . 305365; .. // www.fap.ru/index.
php? nt=news&id=9895.
.
.: ..
// : :
VI ., . , 2830 2002 . ,

74

 , ,
XVIII
3. , , . .
, , ,
,
, 4.
,

5.

4
5

2003. . 714. :
. XVIII . ., 1978; . . . , 2008. . 12;
. . ( XVI
XIX , ). -
: 2 . ., 1896; ,
.
, 1995; . : VIIII . ,
2003. . 12; .. XIXV.
. ., 1997; .. : 2. .,
1889. . 2: . .
; . . , XVIII . ., 1883; Anderson M. S. The Eastern Question, 17741923: A Study
in International Relations. London, 1966; Bitis A. Russia and the Eastern
Question Army, Government and Society, 18151833. Oxford; New York, 2006;
KoviM.Disraeli and the Eastern Question. Oxford, 2010; de Lamartine.,
Laurens H., Basch S. La Question d'Orient: Discours et articles politiques
(18341861). Paris, 2011; De la politique anglo-franaise dans la question
dOrient. Bruxelles, 1854; La question dOrient // http://www.diplomatie.gouv.
fr/fr/le-ministere/archives-et-patrimoine/expositions/expositions-diverses/
napoleon-iii-et-l-europe-le/article/la-question-d-orient; SowardsS.W.TwentyFive Lectures on Modern Balkan History: the Balkans in the age of nationalism// http://staff.lib.msu.edu/sowards/balkan.
., ., : .. : - 18061812. . , 1978. . 4;
. XVIII . ., 1978. . 5.
. 18751877. // www.nbu.bg/public/images/File/departamenti/istoriq/3.pdf.
. . : . ,
, . ., 2001. . 7155, 310322; ..
. 18291864 . , , . ., 2009. . 171;
.. XIX. , 1961; . .

75

, ,
.
.
, ,
.
18531854.
-
. , , - .
20 . ., 1963. . 34; Macfie.L.The
Eastern Question 17741923 (Seminar Studies in History). London and New
York, 1996. ( )
. ,
. Near East ( ; )
Middle East ( ; 1850 .)
, ,

( ) (.
, http: //ru. wikipedia.
org, Middle East, Near East http: //en. wikipedia. org).
. , ,

,
. ( , ) .
,
. , ,
. (
),
,
( ;
. . , ).
,
.

76


(
)
, .
, 6.
, -
,
. , , XV.,
( ) .
.
,
.
. - .

,
. ,
. -
. XVIII.
( )
. ,
. . , ,
7.

8
6
7
8

XV.,
, .
. : 4. .; ., 1999. . 4. .
. 482.
,
: () (). - ,

77


, ,
. , (
, , )

.

,
, , ,
.
. . .9.
, . . ,
, -
. -
()10, -

9
10

, (., ., :
. . : 6 .
., 1871. . 1. . 1. . 1).
.. // http://www.
cnsr.ru/news.php?id=1399.
. . 17201860. ., 2011; . . - 18771878 . ., 1956; . . 18531856 .: 4 . ., 1876; . .
II, I . 2 .
., 1829; ..- 1774 (
). ., 1955; .. 1853
1856. ... .,
1878; . . :
6. ., 18861888; .. 1829.
: 3 . ., 19041905; . .
18531856: 2. ., 2002; .. .
18771878. . ., 2005; . ,
1899; . . - 18771878 .
. ., 1906; .. II: 17871791.: 2. ., 1880; -

78

-
11 -.
-
.12
, , , ( ) ,

.

,
. ,


. ,
. (
), (
).
,
. .
-- ,
.

11

12

.. 18061812.: 3. ., 18851887;
.. 1769
1774. ., 1866, ., 1874. . 3; .. : 5.
., 20062007; .. 1828 1829: 2 . ., 1836.
. ,
(-, , )
.
. . 18131828 . ,
1967; ..
XIX . , 1961; . .
. , 1958;
.. 20
. ., 1963.

79

 ,

,
(, ) , 13. ,
, .
, ,
. ,


14.
XVIII XIX.
, XVIII .
, XIX XX. .
. .
,
. , ..,
,
, 15.

. - . 13
14

15

. XVIII .
., 1978. . 56.

( ) (.. . ( XIX ) //
. ., 2011. 3. . 8291; .. , 18561907:
- . ., 2012; . :
/ . . ... ., 2004). ,
,
.
.. 20
. . 5.

80

 ,
. -
,
, .
XVI .
, 16.
, , ,
.

,
.
( ,
,
;
)
.
. ( )

. ,

, , . 17.
16

17

.. . ., 2010. . 78116; .. (II XV XVII). , 1991;

. .
XVII ( ). , 2004; ..
// . 2012. 1. . 115120; NewmanA.J.Safavid
Iran: Rebirth of a Persian Empire. London; New-York, 2006; SavoryR.M.Iran
Under the Safavids. Cambridge, 1980.
. . 18131828 .; .. -
. , 1988; .. 18071808. //
. , 1974. . 5487; .. 18081809. //
. : , 1974. . 2. . 8794; ..
18531856 . . ., 1971;
.. XIX; ..

81

 -
, .
XVIII .

18
19. - .
20. .
21

18

19

20

21

; .. 20 .; -..

.: . . . . . , 1984;
Cambridge History of Iran: in 7 vv. Cambridge University Press, 1991. Vol. 7.
P. 297426; KellyL.Diplomacy and murder in Tehran. New York, 2006.
..- 2060 XIX.: .
. . . , 1983; ..- //
. . 2. 1915. 591 .; ..- // . 1916. . 52. . 5. . 351392; -
.---. - . .
., 1877; .. -
- 18491852 //
. 1875. . 9; War
and Peace in Qajar Persia. Implications past and present. London; New York,
2008. . 2146, 88109, 125173.
.. XIX
. , . . , 1900; .. : XIX. ., 1963.
. . - 2060 XIX .; Ka
veh Farrokh. Iran at War 15001988. Oxford, 2011. . 202206; TekdemirA.G.A.XIX. Yzylin ilk eyreinde osmanli-iran ihtilaflari ve 18211823
savai // www.ardahan.edu.tr/karadeniz/web/upload/icerik/4/4.7.pdf.
Andreeva.Russia and Iran in the Great Game. Travelogues and Orientalism.
London; New York, 2007 . 131155. - XVIII .
: .. -:
: . . . . , 2010; . - . ., 1989.

82

, 22.
,
., 18771878 .23 ,
, ,
. ,
. . ,
,
. ,
24. , . -
, ()
().
, , . , ,

, 25.

.
,
22

23

24
25

.. : 4. ., 19631978; .
1883.
( )// , .
1883. . 4. . 35110; 1884. . 11. . 133.
.. XIX. , 1971. . 6062; .. 20 .; . .
(70 ) //
. . . , . 1957. . 110: . . 24. . 5125; TekdemirA.G.A.XIX. Yzylin ilk eyreinde
osmanli-iran ihtilaflari ve 18211823 savai.
, : 2. ., 2006.
.1. . 107112.
.: .. . ., 1999. . 160163; .. : . . . .
, 2001. . 82107; .
// : . ., 2002. . 613.

83

 26. ,
.
,
.
:
, , , 27.
, ,
,
. ,
, -. .

, . . (, -,
- -, -)
- ( 17361747 .)28.
, , ,
. , ,
29.
26

27

28

29

. . , , , . ., 1909. . 118119;
., . : ? // .
., 2001. 5. . 136. .:
( ). .,1978. . 4348.
-
,
.
.. 18531856. . . 244. - .: xworthy.The Sword of Persia:
Nader Shah, from Tribal Warrior to Conquering Tyrant. London, 2006.
. XVI XVIII.: . . . . .
, 2006; . . -

84



(
-). ,

.
, .,
,
.
, ,
.
-. 18211823 .,
,
30. ..,
18371838.31, , ,
,

30
31

(18701905.): . . . . ., 1991; . .
XIX XX .: . . . . .
., 2007; . . - -
(XVIXVIII .): . . . . . .,
2011; ..-
XVIII: . . . .
. , 2011; .. . //
. 39. . ., 1963. . 5671; ..
XIX XX: . . . . ., 2011; .
XVIII XX: . . . . , 2011.
..- 2060 XIX. . 48.
. . ,
-, 1837 1838 // , . 1885.
. 16. . 140; .. 18371841. // fttp://
lib.herzen.spb.ru/text/bugayeva_15_39_58_61.pdf; . .
30 50 . : . . .
. , 2010. . 150189.

85

 -32.
33.
XVIII . - .
(
) .
18261828.

1829 .
. - ( 18341848.) ( 18481896.),
,
34. ,
1830 . - ,
.
, ..
() ..,

, 35.

. ,
.
1830 . 32

33
34
35

- - - .
.
.
. .
.
- 18041813., -
18211823. - 18261828.
. 25 1833. .
. 1883. . 1883. . 4. . 42.
.. 30 50 . : . . . . , 2010.
.. 18531856. . 223.

86

 , 36. 1850 .
,
, .
1850 .
.
, ()
. , .

. ,
37.
1853. .
, ,
. ( -
- -38,
-)
.
.

,
.

,
,
1828.39 .
36

37

38
39

... , 1978; .. 30 50 . ; ..
. ., 1844. . 1; . 2; . .
, 18321838. ., 1967.
- :
// ,
. , 1885. . 10. . 745752; .. 30 50 . . . 221244.
-.
, 10 1828 .,
- 18261828 . , , , 10
(20000000 ), 1850 .
.

87

-
, ,
. ,
60000 ( 40000) . . . ,

(. ..)40. 1853., , ..

41.
1853. .
-
... , 1826., - 18261828.
- 18281829 . 42.
40
41
42

. . 746.
.
(? 1859) ... ,
1814. , 1815.
, 1818. . 1820.
.
, .. - 2 . 1821.
1824. . 1826. ..
1
, . , , -, - .
1827 . -. 25 1828 .
.
.. ,
, , , , -, .
1829. .
. .

. 1834.
, 1837.

, 1838. . 26
1850. .. 25

88

 ..
...

..43.

, ,
- ... ,
. , , , , .
.
,
44.
, . ,
.
45. ,
, - -
,
.

...
46 . 20 .. -
47. -

43
44

45
46
47

. 4 . 4 1859.
-.
.., .... . .,
1977. . 9697.
.: .. XIX. . 80143; . . :
XIX. . 6881.
..- 2060 XIX. . 96.
.

. . 747.

89

 .
,
, ,
, 48.
, . .
.
.
, ,
. - 1853. . ,
,
, .
, . , ,
. -,
1848. , , , ( ,
)
.
.
- . ,
. , ,
,
49.
.
48

49

. . . 18291864 . , ,
. ., 2009. . 228.
(..
18531856. . 232251; ..
30 50 . . . 235).
. . . 18291864 . . 227; . . 18531856 . . 232251; .. 30 50 . .
. 235.

90

.. 1853. . .., , ,

, 25 50. ,
, , ,

, . 6 1853.
(
, ,
) . .

, , ,
,
, , .
.. ,
, , , ,
, 5152.
50
51

52

. . 747.
1 = 500. ; 1 = 10 . ,
, (. , . toman) c
XVII 1932. 10000 .
10 000, . XIIXIV. -
10000 , XVIII.
- . - (17941797),
, 1794.
8,2. - (17971834)
5, 2, 1, , . 18101828 .
4,6, 3,5. 18061852.
989 , 1, 3, 5, 20, 30, 50 100: , . (1848
1896) 1877 . , 900
3,225, 1878 2,85. 1883.
46,65. 1925.
(19091925).

. . 746.

91

 -53,
-,

-
. , .
54. .. .

. (
) 1853. , 55. ,

56. , ,
, ,
53

54

55
56

, - ( (
. . 745752) , , :
, .. . ., 1952. . 175176). ,
. ,
,

.
(.: ..
4050. . //
. ... 1960. . 152. . 33:
. . 3962; .. XIX. , 1971; .. -
18561857. ., 1959). 1852. (..
- 18561857. . 43).

. . 747. (.: ..., 2006) ,
-
.
, , .
.. 30 50 . . . 236.
.. . 18291864. . 498.

92

 ,
.
, 6 1854. 57. ,
- 58. 1853
1854. - .
59. . . ,
, , . .

. . . , ,
,
..60.
,
57

58

59
60

.. - 18561857. . 51. .. 14 ( . .
30 50 . . . 237). ,
, .., .
, , , ,
(
.
. 748). , -
18531854., , ,
. ..,
, .
, , ,

(Kaveh Farrokh. Iran at War 15001988. . 209210).
. ,
. ,
-.
.
.: . . - 18561857 .
.5051.

. . 748; .., .... . . 9899.

93

 61.
,
, .
1854 .
,
62. ,
.
,

, , , 63.

.., , . . .
,
, 64. 1854 .
..
.

,
65.
. ,
,
61
62
63
64

65

. . 748.
.. . 18291864. . 187220.

. . 750.
.. 1838. . 1848. -
(.. vs . .
., 2002. . 480).

. . 750.

94

 1854.
, .
1854. ..
.. .. .
, 66. 29 1854.

67.
, - , 68,
69,
.

, . , ,
- ..
..
1855.70 :
71.
, , . ,
72
.
,
. ..
. 1853. ,
66
67

68
69
70
71
72

. . 751.

. . 752; 11 (, 1888. . 11. . 499)
27 , 29.
.. . 18291864. . 228.
.. 18531856. . 242243.
. :
, 1888. . 11. . 543.

. . 752.
.. 18531856. . 248.

95


73.
,
, .
, ,
, , , .
.

73

. .
XIX. . 83.

..

,
:
....
(19051906)

, 1905 .
,

. ,

. , - 1, 1903., ,
,
1

1901. - .
(), ., ., ., . ( ). . - ., ., .,
. ( ), . , . ., .
( ), - .
(), ., ., . ( , ),
.. ., ., ., .,
., . ., . (),
., ., ., ., ., . .

97


, 1905.
, .
.
- ( 18901910.), .
1901. -
, , .
2,
().

- ( 1905.
, , 2

(. ., 18611938)
, , , , , honoris
causa (1933),
(1928). . , ,
, , . 18991918 .

. 19051906 . .
, .. (18401919),
, - .
1919. , 19211922. , 19251927.
(). , ,
. .: . .
., 1887; Mesjanici i sowianofile. Szkice z psychologii narodw sowiaskich. Krakw, 1888; Byron i jego wiek. Studia porwnawczo-literackie. T.I:
Europa Zachodnia. Krakw, 1894; -
/ . ... , 1896; Byron i jego wiek. Studia porwnawczo-literackie. T.II: Czechy, Rosja, Polska. Krakw, 1897; Pestis
perniciosissima. Rzecz o wspczesnych kierunkach myli katolickiej. Warszawa,
1905; Die Grundprobleme Russlands. Literarisch-politische Skizzen. Aus dem
Polnischen bersetzt von Adolf Stylo. Wien; Leipzig. 1907; Walka o dusze
modziey. Z czasw rektorskich. Wilno, 1927; Od Petersburga do Leningradu.
Wilno, 1934; Wobliczu koca. Wilno, 1937; .

98

, , ) .., 3:
.. .., ..,
..4.


(18991918) ... .. (F-33),
. . ,
(
.) (, : . . 33. . 341.
. 14 (1)5, 58 (2), 911 (3), 1215 (4)).
.. 6 ,

. ..
, ,
. .., .., .., ..3

5
6

. : .. :
(19071911) // (). ., 2011. 2. . 3547.
.. : .:
. / .. // . , 1989. 11. . 161170. : . . . . .
/ . . // . , 1990.
1. . 117156. . . . :
. // . Warszawa, 2008. 10.
.3541. . .
. .: ., ..
(2004) (www.russianresources.lt/archive/Zdz/Zdz_0.html).
.
(http://www.russianresources.lt/archive)
1887 .
, . .
, -, .

99

, .., ...
,
,
-, . ..
,
., ., ., . , .. 7, ,

. 19031911.
-
.

, , , ,
- . ,
.. ,
: ,
, , .
..
.. (18711944) ( Demain
... , (. 2).
- ,
,
,
. . .

,
,
- .
,
, 24
7

Pascendi Dominici Gregis, 1907.

100

() , ,

, . 1904. .. .. . . . .
( ), 1907. -
8
(,
1909). 19051908 . ,
,
.
,
9, , ,
,
.
1905. .. ..
( - ) (. 2, 3).
. . , 1903 . , 8

. .. 1907.: .
( ) . , ,
,
(Pachmuss, T. Intellect and Ideas in Action:
Selected Correspondence of Zinaida Hippius. Mnchen, 1972. . 683).
1906. .. .. (, 18781940); , - ,
; , , , - ,
. : , .., .., ..,
.., ... ,
. (.: .. .. / ... // . ., 1992. 10.)

101

 , ,
.. : , , ,
(. 2). 1906.
, .. , ,
,
...
1907. .. .. - ,
.. ..,
.. ..
.., (
,
).
.. -
. ,
,
.
10 (
) ...
.. . , . ..11.
,
, .
, . ,
...., , ,
(. 2).
10

11

, ., : , ,
. .: 1 // . . 167.
7 [ 1908] // .

102

 1907 . - Pascendi Dominici

Gregis12. 13 14, ,
, ,

-
. -
.
(.15,
. , . -),
.16 . 17
18.
.., ..19, 12

13
14

15
16

17

18

19

8 1907 . X Pascendi
Dominici Gregis, , , 1910. - ,
.
. // . ., 1908. . 9. . 87.
., .: . . // .
., 1907. 9, 10; . -
- // . 1908. ; . // . ., 1908. 5.
. / .. //
- . ., 1908.
. / . . // - .
., 1908.
. Medievalism. A reply to Cardinal
Mercier (. ) . ( . .,
1908. 47. 29 . . 2638).
Times' Sabatier
Tyrrel', .. ( 3/16 1907). .: ., ..
(2003): www.russianresources.lt/archive/Zdz/Zdz_3.html#15b; (.. 10/25 1908 // ).
.. - // -
. ., 1908.

103


.20, ..21 .
..22 ..
, . ..
<>-<>
23 ..
. . 24. . . , 25,
.. (1903).
, ,
. , ..
,
, .
, ,
(. 4).
. . 1908 .
:
, -
(. 1). , ..20
21
22
23
24

25

.. : Pascendi Dominici
Gregis . ., 1908.
.- : ,
. , 1911.
(18741930) , , .
.. // . .,
1908. 8 . 2. . 3940.
, , <> . .: (1908) ( ., .. .
(2003): http: //www.russianresources.
lt/archive/Zdz/Zdz_2.html).
.. // . .,
1908. 8 . 2. . 3940.

104

 :
[] ,
(. 4).
: . 1908. ..
.., . ., . . .
,
.
.. .. .
. .
..26 1905 1906. ,
.
- - . , ,
.., ..,
- 27
. 28 (
), ,

, ,
.
26

27
28

: .. : ....
/ . . .. // . 2010. 4. . 101111. (
, ,
... .)
4 ( . // . , 1989. 11.
.169170).
. (17991878) ,
.

105

....
1.

, 18. VIII. 05.

. !
, , , , -
, ..
,
, ( ,
-
). ,
, ,
. 29 , ,
. 30
, Eukena 31. ,
, , ,
32. -

29
30
31

32

...
Zdziechowski.Pestis perniciosissima. Rzecz o wspolczesnych kierunkach mysli
katolickiej. Warszawa: E.Wende i spolka, 1905.
(Rudolf Christoph Eucken) (18461926),
-, 1908.;
; - ,
; .
, , .
(18481915) , .

106

 , ,
33 (!34).
.
,
,
.
, . ,
, ,
, , (
!) , ,
.
,
, !
. , ,
( 35) (., 26).
, . , , , (, , 36) ?
, .
P.S. <> <> .

2.

. 30. XII. 05 ( )

!
.
, ,
33
34

35
36

, .
. .
( ) (18511930) , ,
.
.
(15751624) , ;
(17651841) , .

107

 , .
Demain37
. ..

, .
Annales de la philosophie chretienne38, . , ,
, . ,
, , ,
.
, 39. - 40
,
, , .
, - , .
, , . , <> , , ,
- .
, , (
37
38

39
40

Demain () ,
. .
. 1905 (Annales de philosophie chrtienne)
1913., .
, .
24 1905 .
. ,
; , ; .
19 24 , , ,
, . ,
24 1905.,
. ,
. 1917. .: . . 3. ., 1907. .XXV. 26 963.

108

 ,
,
). , <> <>,
, , ,

.
, , .
<> <> , , ,
, .
3.

.., 26 [- 1906].

!
41,
,
. . ,
, ,
, ,

(<> <>
,
<> ,
).
, ,
. , 2 ,
, . ,
, , ,
. (,
, ,
,
.) 41

, 1906.
: . . :
. ., 1906.

109

 -<> ,
, .

.

..

, 17 <> [1906].
4.
!
.
, ,
<> .
. ,
(., 42) , , . ,

, ,
, (?!) 43.
42

43

, (
) (18551918), ,
1917. II. 27 1918.
.
17 1905 . , - , . (),
- .
,
( C. ., 1905. 78. 28. . 3). , , ,
(. // . ., 1905. 11.
24; . // . ., 1905. 17. 23
; . // . ., 1905. 13. 31).
II 31 1905.
,
.
. 27 1905.
. .: . . 8. . 2. ., 1997. . 696.

110

 44 ,
, <> <>
,
, .
<> <> , 45.
(
)
: .
.I, . IXIII 1694 , . 1674. ., 1906,
2 . (
) . , 1906.

. , ( ), ,
,
, ,
, ,
.

44

45

27 1905. .
.
.
, , . 1906.
II , , ,
- ()
(19171918). 1906.
1870. 1 - ,
.

..

:
?

.

(). ,
.
.. ..

1. ,
, . ,
,
. (1918), , :
()
, 19051907. 1917.2.
.

.
1
2

: pro et contra / ., . . . . . . ., 1998.

.178183, 373378.
: . ., 1990. . 19.

112

 .
1905 ., , ,
.
.. : , ,

, ,
. , ,
, , ,
(!) .
, (
, , ), :
, ,

. ,
, . , .
- -.
, ,
- . ,
.
,
, -
3. ,
,
.
, ,
, 1917. 1909.
, ,
.
3

; : . . 19091910 / ., . .. . . . ., 1991 (: ). . 208; 2 .

.124. (
. , ,
,
,
, .)

113

 , , . , 19061907.
.
. , , , .
.. : ,
. , , ,
, ,
, .
,
. , ,
, . () , , ,

,
,
.
, - .
,
, , ,
. , , ,
4. ,
, .
. .. 5,
.

1907., . , , .. . . . , ..,
,
4
5

. . 105106.
. . , . -
. 19021909. ., 1996. . 281296.

114

 II 6.
, .
.., ,
,
. ? , , , . .
. . : ; ,
:
, , , ,
,
, .
7. , ,
,
. 1908.
. .
, ,
.
, , , ,
. . :
,
. ,
. XVII,
XVIII , ,
, 8. :
. -6
7
8

.. . 2. ., 2001. . 2. . 6869, 117; ... . . 255258.

.. ? // .. . ., 1991. . 9293.
. . 45, 144145.

115


. , .
, , . , ,
. ,
,
1905 . ,
9. , ,
.
..: , ,
, , , , , ,
10. , .

( ), .
(
). (, ,
, ) .
, ,
.
.., .. .. .
. , ;

, . : ,

, , 11.
9
10
11

. . 136143.
. . 444.
. . 135.

116

.. ..
.
: ,
. ,

, , , "-" "-". , ,
.
, , .
.
, .
, ,
,

, , ,
.

. , ,
:
, ,
. ?

. () ,

. -,
, ..
-
, . ()
, .
117


, 12.
. . . .
. :
. , . ,
, .
13.

( ), , ,

. ,
, 14 ?
, , ,
. : . ,
. ,
,
. : 1908.,
,
- ..15,
. . 30 1908., .., 16. ,
1909.
12
13
14
15

16

. . 141142, 150152.
. . 75, 184.
... . . 307308.
. . // -
- (): :
19071917: 3. ., 2009. . 1. . 367. 13 1908.
. // . . 399, 416417.

118

 17:
,
.
, , . . ,
, . , , , : ?.
,
1905 . .
( ,
; ),
.
( ) .
. :
, , ,
: . ,
, ,
. () . .

, , , 18.
? , - .
.

19 .
, .
, :
, , (. ),
. ,
, , 17
18
19

... . . 292.
. . 380381.
. // . . 23.

119

 ,
,
. , . (!)


,
. ,
.
,
20. .
. . , ,
:
, , .
.
: , ;

(, ) , , ,
, ,
, , 1917.
. , , ,

.
, , .
.

20

.: .. // : 2004/2005. ., 2007. . 371372.

:
19181919.

19181919 .
, .
,
,
.
, .1 ,
.
1918.
. , 1918 . .
, 1

.: Kotakallio, Juho. Suomen ja Ison-Britannian tiedusteluyhteisty

19181927, pro gradu. Helsingin yliopisto 2004; Pankakoski, Johanna.
Varjonyrkkeily itrajalla, Venlisten emigranttien poliittinen liikehdint
Suomessa vuosina 19181927, lisensiaatintutkimus. Helsingin yliopisto 2005.

121


. ,

.

. , ,
.2
.
,
.

. , ,
,
.
, .
1918.
.3 ,
.
,
,
, .

,
, .
19181919. , , .

2

Ahti, Martti. Salaliiton riviivat, Oikeistoradikalismi ja hykkv idnpolitiikka 19181919. Espoo 1987, 1015; Hyvmki, Lauri. Kommunismi ja
jlkiaktivismi, julkaisussa Suomalainen Suomi 5/1958, 278.
Ahti 1987, 35.

122


.

.
, 19181919 .

.
,

.4
,
.

1910 ., ,
. , ,
19181919.
,

.5

,
.6
4

Ahti 1987, 73; Ahti, Martti. Ryssnvihassa, Elmo Kaila 18881935, Aktivistin,
asevoimien harmaan eminenssin ja Akateemisen Karjala-Seuran puheenjohtajan
elmkerta. WSOY, Helsinki 1999, 119.
,
:
1900 .
, .

,

123

 : ,

. , Abteilung
III b III,
. ,
,
, , ..
, ,
.

, , . , .
,
.
,
, .
( ), .,
.7
, .8

. , .
.: Arimo, Reino. Saksalaisten sotilaallinen toiminta
Suomessa 1918, Pohjois-Suomen Historiallinen Yhdisty. Rovaniemi 1991, 98;
Kuussaari, Eero. Heimosodat 19181922, I osa, Taistelu Petsamosta. Suomen
Heimosoturien Liitto, Helsinki 1939, 34; Nevakivi, Jukka. Muurmannin legioona, Suomalaiset ja liittoutuneiden interventio Pohjois-Venjlle 19181919.
Tammi, Helsinki 1970, 1516; Vahtola, Jouko. Suomi suureksi Viena
vapaaksi, Valkoisen Suomen pyrkimykset It-Karjalan valtaamiseksi vuonna
1918. Pohjois-Suomen Historiallinen Yhdistys. Rovaniemi 1988, 213219;
von der Goltz, Rdiger. Toimintani Suomessa ja Baltianmaissa. WSOY, Porvoo
1920, 134136.
Kansallisarkiston Srnisten toimipiste (SA), Helsinki, yleisesikunta (YE),
4/2202 D1, III osasto, selostus yleisesikunnan III osaston thnastisesta toiminnasta sek ehdotus sen vastaiseksi jrjestelyksi, Eino Suolahti 31.12.1918;
. : Ahti 1987, 7475.
,

124

 ,
, .
, , ,
, , .9

: ,

.10

1918. .11

, ,
1918 .,
.12
,
.. ,

10
11

12

. ,
,
.
SA, YE, 4/2202 D1, selostus yleisesikunnan III osaston thnastisesta toiminnasta sek ehdotus sen vastaiseksi jrjestelyksi, Eino Suolahti 31.12.1918; .
: Ahti 1987, 119; Lackman, Matti. Etsiv Keskuspoliisi 19191937, julkaisussa Turvallisuuspoliisi 75 vuotta, sisasiainministeri. Helsinki 1994, 19.
SA, sotahistoriallinen toimisto (T) 19 167/3, Haapalaisen retkikunta, yleisesikunnan pllikn von Redernin kirjoittama kirje 11.8.1918; Vahtola 1988, 336, 338.
Schlustein ,
. , , . . : Arimo 1991, 90, 102104; Kuussaari (Heickell) 1939, 170; Polvinen, Tuomo. Venjn vallankumous ja Suomi
19171920, II osa, toukokuu 1918 joulukuu 1920. WSOY, Helsinki 1971,
4552; Vahtola 1988, 312345.
von der Goltz 1920, 117118; SA, Heimosota-arkisto (HSA), Kuisman retkikunta, Kuisma 13, Eero Heickellin kirje tohtori Volter Rihtniemelle Kajaaniin
22.11.1918; SA, T 19 167/2, Suomen vapaaehtoisten armeija 1918, Elja Rihtniemen kirje Eemeli Kemppaiselle 10.07.1918.

125

 , ,
.13
-
,
. 26
-
.
1918 .
,
, , , - .14

1918. .
. ,
,
.
.
,
.
,
13

14

Elfvengren, Eero. Sotilastiedustelun synty, julkaisussa Salaisen sodan sivut,

Ohto Manninen 60 vuotta, Maanpuolustuskorkeakoulu, Helsinki 2003, 2526;
Kosonen, Matti. Raja railona aukeaa, Tiedustelua Neuvosto-Karjalassa vuosina
19201939, Kustannusyhti Ilias Oy, Joensuu 2001, 18; SA, heimosota-arkisto (HSA), Koillisrintama, K11, kapteeni Johan Wilhelm Snellmanin raportti
12.8.1918.
Marttina, Paul. Miesten syjilt sijoilta, Muisteluksia Vienan ja Aunuksen vainovuosilta, WSOY, Helsinki 1935, 2972; Nevakivi 1970, 177; SA, T 19 167/3,
majuri M.Ropposen kirjoitus retkikunnan toiminnasta, kirjoituksessa ei ole pivyst; SA, T 19 167/3, rautatiekirjuri K.V.Levanderille kirjoitettu todistus;
SA, T 19 167/3, III osaston raportti Haapalaisen komennuskunnan toiminnasta
yleisesikunnan plliklle 12.09.1918.

126

 .
: , .15
, ,
,
1919.
, .. .16
,
, .
, .


. , , , , ,
, () ..

, ,
.
, , .

-, ,
.

.17

,
.
,
15
16
17

Ahti 1987, 7377; Ahti 1999, 105.

Ahti 1987, 78; Ahti 1999, 119120.
SA, HSA, Viron vapaussota, emissariaatti, F1, luettelo tiedusteluosaston tyntekijist.

127

 . , , ,
. , , ,
,
. , ,
, .
,
1919.
,
.
, 1919. ,
, .
,
.
,
.

. , .
, .
,

, .
19191920. .

1919. . :

. ,
. ,
.18
18

SA, T 19 164/12, aktivistikeskus 1919, ohjelmaluonnos, ei pivyst. 1919 .

.

128

 , , , , .
, ,
, . , , ,
, , : ,
, ,

, .19
, .

.
,
. , ,
,
. ,
, ,
.20
,
, ,
-. ,
.
:
,
, . 19

20

SA, T 19 164/12, ohjelmaluonnos, ei tarkkaa pivyst.

,
, ,
,
,
, .
Ahti, 1987, 115; Ahti 1999, 126; KA, Kai Donnerin kokoelma, I5, pivkirja
7.3. ja 27.3.1919.

129

 .
, .21

1919. ,22 .
1919. - .

, , .
, , ,
.23

(
) ,
.
-,

.

, .
-
,
21

22
23

Ahti, 1987, 115; SA, pikkukokoelmat (PK) 2541, Eero Kuussaaren (Heickell) kokoelma, Aunuksen retki 1919, Pietarin retki 27.05.1919, 1.
, , ; , , . ,
: Kansallisarkisto (KA), Helsinki, Kai
Donnerin kokoelma, I5, Kai Donnerin pivkirja sek siihen liittyvi asiakirjoja
19181919, pivkirja 07.05.1919: , ,
. ,
. ,
.
, ( ).
Ahti, 1987, 113119.
Mainio, Aleksi. Etelisen alueen tiedusteluosasto ja Viron vapaussota, julkaisussa Sotahistoriallinen aikakauskirja 30, 2010, 104123; SA, PK 2541, Aunuksen retki 1919, Pietarin retki 27.05.1919, 2.

130

 ,
35. ,

.24
, , 100000
15 . - , 15
.25 19
- ,

.26 ,

.
,
. ,
,
.27
22 1919. ,
,
. .
24

25

26
27

KA, Etsiv Keskuspoliisi (EK-Valpo I), henkilmappi 10892, Juho Vanhasen

kertomus toiminnastaan ITO: n palveluksessa 06.03.1925; KA, EK-Valpo I, henkilmappi A: 3444, Taavi Vanhanen, viittaus ITO: n pllikn kirjoittamaan todistukseen, ei pivmr; Kansalliskirjasto (KK), Helsinki, Toivo Kaukorannan
kokoelma, Coll. 279.129, Viron vapaaehtoinen avustusretkikunta, tiliotteita, Viron
vapaaehtoisen apuretkikunnan Inkerin osaston menoista tilitys 30.05.1919.
KK, Toivo Kaukorannan kokoelma, Coll. 279.129, laskuja, Eero Heickellin allekirjoittama kuitti 13.03.1919; KK, Coll. 279.129, tiliotteita, Sulo-Veikko Pekkolan
allekirjoittama kuitti 19.03.1919; KK, Coll. 279.129, tiliotteita, lasku 6.
SA, PK 2541, Aunuksen retki 1919, Pietarin retki 27.5.1919, 2.
SA, PK 2541, Aunuksen retki 1919, Pietarin retki 27.5.1919, 2; . : KA,
Inkerin arkisto, V, Pohjois-Inkerin hoitokunnan kokouspytkirja 26.11.1919 ja
siihen liittyv Eero Heickellin kirjoittama liite 25.11.1919.

131

 ,
, .28
, ,
, ,
, .
.29

2126 ,
.30
23, 30
. , , ,
.
,
.31

,
,

. ,
, .32
,
-,
.
,
28

29
30
31
32

KK, Coll. 279.129, tiliotteita, E.Heickellin 21.03.1919 allekirjoittama lasku 1 ja

E.Heickellin 23.3. allekirjoittama lasku 3 ja Tuomas Wanhasen 22.3. allekirjoittama lasku 8; SA, PK 2541, Aunuksen retki 1919, Pietarin retki 27.05.1919, 24.
SA, PK 2541, Aunuksen retki 1919, Pietarin retki 27.05.1919, 4.
KK, Coll. 279.129, Viron vapaaehtoinen avustusretkikunta, tiliotteita, lasku 2,
E.Hmlisen 21.03.1919 allekirjoittama palkkauslista.
SA, PK 2541, Aunuksen retki 1919, Pietarin retki 27.05.1919, 4.
KA, EK-Valpo I, henkilmappi 10892, Juho Vanhasen kertomus toiminnastaan
ITO: n palveluksessa 6.03.1925. ,
1919.

132

 , ,
. ,
.
,
. , , ,
.33
: ,
,
. ,
, .
, ,
.
,
. , .
, .
30 4 ,
. ( ) ,
500 .34 ,
,
. ,
.
,
.35
33
34

35

SA, PK 2541, Aunuksen retki 1919, Pietarin retki 27.05.1919, 5.

.. 1919. ., 1929. . 181;
. 01.04.1919 ( ); SA, PK 2541, Aunuksen
retki 1919, Pietarin retki. 27.05.1919, 67.
. 01.04.1919 ( ).

133



. ,

.
,
.36 Wapaus (), ,
:
, .
.
, .
, .
. .
15 , 45 .37
1215 , , 50 ,
. , , , ,
.38
: ,
, ,
. , ,

.39
36

37
38
39

(). 01.04.1919 ( ); .., .., .., .. ,

, ., 1987. . 263; .. XIX XX. ., 2004. . 109; .
01.04.1919 ( ); SA, PK 2541, Pietarin retki. 27.05.1919, 67.
Wapaus 01.04.1919, Rjhdys kaupungin vesilaitoksella.
Ahti 1987, 113, 117118; SA, PK 2541, Pietarin retki. 27.05.1919, 67;
Wapaus. 02.04.1919, Pietarin neuvoston pakollinen mrys.
(). 1.4.1919 ( ).
, 1943 ., , .
Suomen Kuvalehti. 1943/4, Inkerilisten Pietarin retki. 1919. 1919. -

134

 , . ,
. , 1 .
, 30,
,
, .
,
:
, .40
,
, .41
.
.
, ,
. ,
-. ,

()
. ,
.. .
,
. , .

40

41

,
.
(). 02.04.1919 ( ); . 03.04.1919 ( . ); SA, PK
2541, Pietarin retki 27.05.1919, 6; Wapaus. 01.04.1919, Rjhdys kaupungin
vesilaitoksella; Wapaus. 02.04.1919, Pietarin neuvoston pakollinen mrys.
. 01.04.1919 ( ).

135

, ,
.42
,
. ,
,
, . , -
, .43
, , . , ,
,
.
, .
,
, . ,
, , ,
, . ,
.
, .44
42

43
44

, , , . 1987. . 263264; Leggett, George.

The Cheka: Lenins Political Police, The All-Russian Extraordinary Commission
for Combating Counter-Revolution and Sabotage, December 1917 to February 1922, Clarendon, Oxford 1981, 317, 319; Wapaus 02.04.1919, Pietarin
neuvoston pakollinen mrys; Wapaus 03.04.1919, V. I. Leninin sanoma
Vastavallankumoukselliset tuhottava.
Ahti 1987, 118; SA, PK 2541, Pietarin retki. 27.5.1919, 7.
Ahti 1987, 118119; , , , . 1987. .263
264; SA, PK 2541, Pietarin retki 27.05.1919, 79; .: SA, PK 2112/1, Eero Kuussaaren
(Heickell) kokoelma, sotilaskomitean puheenjohtaja Y.O.Ruuthin ja kansliapl-

136

 ,
. 5
, ,
, , :
.
, 42 , 16
:
,
, ,
, , .45

, ,

.
,
, , , .46
,
.


,
.47 1919. -

45

46
47

likk Toivo Kaukorannan allekirjoittama todistus Eero Heickellille, 15.05.1919;

Wapaus 02.04.1919, Pietarin neuvoston pakollinen mrys.
SA, puolustusministerin arkisto (PMA), ea1, ministeri ja adjutantuuri, yleisesikunta III huhtikuu 1919, III osaston pllikn kapteeni Isak Alfthanin salainen
raportti 05.04.1919.
SA, PK 2112/2, henkilkohtaista kirjeenvaihtoa, Matti Ropposen shkeet vnrikki Holger Hongistolle 23.03. ja 28.03.1919.
.: KK, Coll. 279.129, Viron vapaaehtoinen
avustusretkikunta, tiliotteita, lasku 9, tili vrvyksist Inkeriss tiedustelutoimintaa ja sabotagea varten, toukokuu 1919.

137

 ,


.
, ,
,
.
- , .
:
,

.
, , ,
, , , .
.48
,
.49
.

1919. ,
, ,
.50 , , ,
,
48

49

50

Ahti 1987, 135, 149150; Ahti 1999, 142; Polvinen 1971, 208210; SA, HSA,
Aunuksen retki, Aunus 17, Eero Heickellin muistiinpanot 21. ja 28.05.1919;
Vihavainen, Timo. Suomi neuvostolehdistss 19181920, Suomen Historiallinen Seura, Helsinki 1988, 124, 137.
SA, PK 2112/2, henkilkohtaista kirjeenvaihtoa, yleisesikunnan pllikn Ignatiuksen kirjoittama ja majuri Somersalon vahvistama lupapaperi Heickellille
6.6.1919.
Ahti 1987, 135150; Nevalainen, Pekka. Rautaa Inkerin rajoille, Inkerin kansalliset kamppailut ja Suomi 1918, Suomen Historiallinen Seura, Helsinki 1996,
65; Polvinen 1971, 188192; Vihavainen 1988, 137.

138

 . ,
,
.
: , , , 28
.51
,
.
150000 ( ),
. 4 ,

.52
8 ,
. . .53
,
, - .54
,

.55

,
, , , ,
, , , , ,
.
,

51

52
53
54

55

Ahti 1999, 142143; KA, Kai Donnerin kokoelma, I5, Anckarstrmin eli
Eero Heickellin kirje ElmoE.Kailalle, Viipuri 16.06.1919; SA, HSA, Aunus
17, Eero Heickellin muistiinpanot 28.05.1919.
Ahti 1987, 155; SA, HSA, Aunus 17, Eero Heickellin muistiinpanot 28. ja
31.05. sek 5. ja 06.06.1919.
SA, HSA, Aunus 17, Eero Heickellin muistiinpanot 08.06.1919.
.: Lhteenmki, Maria. Maailmojen
rajalla, Kannaksen rajamaa ja poliittiset murtumat 19111944, SKS, Helsinki
2008, 149167; Nevalainen 1996, 65, 67; Polvinen 1971, 195202.
Ahti 1987, 123, 158160; Polvinen 1971, 198, 202.

139

 , .56
-
, -
. , , ,

,
, 17
, , :
,
.
,
.57
, . , -
,
, .58

, .

.

,
( ).
56
57
58

Ahti 1987, 153155; Polvinen 1971, 199.

SA, YE, III osasto, 4/2202 D1, vnrikki Kopperin allekirjoittama III osaston shke II divisioonan plliklle ja rannikkopuolustuksen komentajalle, 17.06.1919.
Ahti 1987, 183, 202, 207; Hoover Institution (HI), Stanford, Nikolay Yudenich
Papers, box 13, file 68, 03.04.08.05.1919, ,

; HI, Nikolay Yudenich Papers, box 13, file 66,
27.05.1919, ; KK,
Coll. 279.119,
, , , . 17.07.1919; Nevalainen 1996,
80, 96; Pankakoski, 2005, 101111.

140

 . ,
.59
: .

,
. ,
, , .

:
. ,
, , ,
.60

. , ,
.61
, , : ,
. , , .62
59

60
61
62

, ., : Agar, Augustus. Baltic Episode, A Classic of Secret Service in Russian

Waters. Naval Institute Press, London 1963; Brook-Shepherd, Gordon. Iron
Maze, The Western Secret Services and the Bolsheviks, Pan Books, London
1999, 139147; Ferguson, Harry. Operation Kronstadt. Hutchinson, London
2008; Jeffery, Keith. The Secret History of MI6, 19091949. The Penguin
Press, New York 2010,175177; . -6: , ., 2000. . 6179; Kotakallio 2004, 3847.
KA, Kai Donnerin kokoelma, I5, Eero Heickellin kirje ElmoE.Kailalle, Viipuri
16.06.1919.
KA, Kai Donnerin kokoelma, I5, Eero Heickellin kirje ElmoE.Kailalle, Viipuri
16.06.1919.
Ahti 1987, 156; KA, Kai Donnerin kokoelma, I5, Eero Heickellin kirje ElmoE.Kailalle, Viipuri 16.06.1919; SA, HSA, Aunus 17, Eero Heickellin muistiinpanot 05.06.1919.

141


, . ,
.
22 () ,
.
, , , .
,
.
,
.63
1919 .
.64 ,
.
, ,
,
. ,
. , ,
.65
63

64

65

KA, Kai Donnerin kokoelma, I1, kirjeit Kai Donnerille v. 1919, Eero Heickellin kirje
Kai Donnerille, Rautu 12.11.1919; KK, Coll. 279.11, kirjeit Toivo Kaukorannalle, Eero Heickellin kirje Toivo Kaukorannalle, Rautu 04.10.1919; SA, PK 2112/1, PohjoisInkerin vapaajoukkojen entisen komentajan Elja Rihtniemen kirjoittama todistus Eero
Heickellille, Terijoki 24.11.1919;
.: Ahti 1987, 202204; Nevalainen 1996, 7882, 96; .. , , 19181920. ., 2001. . 171; Vihavainen 1988, 153.
,
. ,
. KK, Coll. 279.11, kirjeit Toivo Kaukorannalle, Eero Heickellin kirje
Toivo Kaukorannalle, Rautu 04.10.1919.
KA, Kai Donnerin kokoelma, I1, Eero Heickellin kirje Kai Donnerille, Rautu
12.11.1919; Nevalainen 1996, 124, 149150.

142


19181919 .
,

.
, .
,
, , .
,
.

, . .
,

.

, .
.
, ,
.
.
,
.
,
. , . ,
.
, ,
,
143

.
,
. ,
,
.
,
,
.
, ,
, .
, ,
.
,
. 1919 .
,
.
1919 . .
,
. 19181919.
, ,
. ,
1920 .
.

..

: .
2
(1933)

, :



.
. 1933 .
.
14 1903. ,
-. . .
.
. 1924 1929. . ,
. , ,
. . 1930
.. , , ,
, 1933.
-
(), .
145


- ..-
1932 . . . 17
1933 . . 1933 .

.
.
, ,
,
.
.
-, : 1930 .
, .
. , , , :
, , 1920
( ),

.
( ) ( ) ,
.

,
,


.
.
. 1933.
. - ( ) ..
: ..
146

- (), , , , ..
. . : ,
, , , , , -,
, , .
:
: . ,
, , , , . 155 1.

1930 ,
.
1930
1931 2.
,
,
,
.
: .., .. ..
. , .
.. .. .
, .. .
1500 ,
, .
,
19281933. 193639.,

.
, ,
.
,
1
2

.-38683.. 12. . 226.

.... 19251936. .
. . 1995. . 194, 217, 220.

147

,
, .
1925 , , . 3 ,
, ,
, ,
.

.... : ,
, 3.
. . -, , .
,
:
, ,
4.
..
( ), :
, .
.
, , . ,
5.
: ,
, -.,
,
. 3
4
5

. -36036. . 3. . 44.
. . 31.
. . 26.

148

 , .
, .
,
,
6.
..
, , ,
:
,
193133. .
, , - 7. ,
, 1933.
.
3
, . 1937
. :
, ,

-. , ,
, , , ,
.


, . .
,
, .

. : ,
6
7

. . 6.
. . 51.

149

 ,
, , 1931., ..: ( , ,
,
, ..),
, (
, ) ..8.
3 1931 . : 10 [] : 1)
9[]. 2) 7[],
5[] , 3) 7[],
40 [] , [] . 4)
7[], 5) 9.

..- 1933 .: , . , , :
, . ,

: -
.
..-.
..- : .., ...
1932.
..
.
, ,
, . ..10.
- ( ) , .
8
9
10

1931. . 2. . 1999. . 2. . 459.

, .- 27056. . 14. . 129.
. . 16. -. . 220. .
http://www.sakharov-center.ru/asfcd/auth/?t=page&num=6040

150

 - : . .
.
, ( . , .
), . 1932 ;
, ( ), , . ,
; , . ,
11; , ,
; ,
. ,
( ) :
. . , 1932
; ,

.
? , ;
. ,
12. ,
.
.
,
-
(18891937). .
, ,
. 1912
, 1914
. .
11
12

.. 1933.
-. . . ... ; . .., .. , .., .. .,
2000. . 191192.

151

 1914 , 1917 , . 1919

. 1920
, .
1921. . 1922 .
, , ,
, 13.
.. ,
.., 15 1923 , ... 16 1923 28
1926 . 3 .
, , , , , 40 .
( ,
[] [] 14.
. 1926.
-, 1929 .15
. , , .
1929
. 5810. ,
16.
1929 . . ,
, . 1923
..-,
1930 .
1933 ..
() ... 13
14
15
16

. .-36 036. . 1011.

. . 12.
, . .
. .-36036. . 6.

152

 , ,
.
, .
14 15 . .
.
(16, 17. 18, 19, 20, 21,
22) 2 67
,
(
1926. )
.
1
, .
1929. 1933.,

, - ( , .,
; 2, ,

, , ,
( ).
,
:
-, :
) () (.. , , , );
)
;
) , ,
; -;
)
;
)
( ,
) ;
153

) []
[] .
, .
, ,
, , ,
, ,
(..
, , , ). , (
)
. , ,
.
, , ()
, , ,
, -
.
, , () ,
, . .
( ).

,
, , . , ,
: ,
.
, , ,
15 ,
.
(), . ..-
: ,
..- (.. .
154

 .
, , , , (),


(1913.), , . ,

, :
1)
;
.
2) , ;
(),
(,
..);
, .
(),
,
, ()
, .
, ,
,
, .. ,
.. , ..
.
,

, (
, , ).
155

 - .
,
. , .
- .
, , :
1) , ,
, , , ,
;
(192830.); 1930. ()
,
;
2)
; ,
( ) ;

.
3) ;
, ,
..; 1932.
(
, , ;
..), , 1933.
.

() . ,
1932 . , , :

, 192831. ,
156

, , , ,
,
, ,
-, , ..
() 23 1932 .
,,
, ,

.
( ). ,
.
, ,
.
,
. ,
, ,
: .
, ( )
,
, , , , , . (
),
, .
, ,
, . , ,
26 ,
,
, , .
, .
, , , ,
.
157


, ,
, , ,

.
:
, , .
, ,
?

, .
.
, 1 1933.
.
104.17

: , ,
,
..18.
, ,

. . , . . -,
, , , .
? ,
-
...
,
. :
17
18

. -36036. . 1819.
. 42.

158

 - ,
, .
.. .
.. 1933., , , , . ,

192728 1932 (
..):
.
[] 1932 ,
- .

[] , .
1932 :
, .
, , , ,

. ,
.
, , ,
. , , , , ,
, .
, .
, ,
.
, ,
.
.
, . , .
, , ,
20
. , ,
, .
159

 , , .
. , 19,
, , .
. , .
.
. ,
.
, 20 .[]
,
, .. .

- 1932, , ,
.
[]-, ,
.
20.
,
, , .
.

...

( ) :
1932 - ,
, .
,
.
, (,
) . , ( ,
) ,
. , ,
19
20

.
. .-36036. . 4. . 1921.

160

 2 . . ,
( , .).
,
.
.
.
, .
, ,
. ..
, . .
1 2 ( ),
,
.
. ,
..,
.
21, .
,
, .

, , ,
.., . , (!) . , ,
, .
, . ,
.
.
.
21

1999. , .. . . ?
, , . []: . .: , 1999.
560 . ISBN 5-7082-0061-8.

161

 . . ,
, :
,
-.
,
, , , .
, .

- .
, -

.
, , , ,
, . - , ,
, + , .

, .
.., ..,
,
.
, ,
( ).
. . , , 2
3 , .
, 22.
, 21 1932 . , , ,
, , ,
1925 .
22

. .-38683. . 5. . 35.

162

. . , ,
, ,
-:
,
- . , , . .
, .
[] . []
1932. .. ( ).

-,
.[] .[] 23.
. . . , 23
1933 :
,
, 24.
, .
7 . . :
,
. ,
,
. : ,
,
. , .
4 . (
. []
, , ,
, ,
.
. . . ,
, ., []. ,
...
23
24

. .-36036.. 5. . 1415.
. .-36036. . 2. . 19.

163


. .. ,

... , . . ,
[]
. ..,
.. ,
, ...
. ,
.
,
, , . , ,
25.
, , .
, , .
.
7 1933 :
.. ..- , .
, , ,
.
. 4.
, , .
, ,
-
-.
.
: 34 ,
, .
25

. .-36 036. . 1. . 3334.

164

 11 ,
.

. ,
,
. ( 34)
.
, , . , ,
, .
.
,
, , ,
, ,

.
,
.

. , .
,
.
,
, ,
.
, ,
,
.
, ,
, ,
, ,
.
165

 , , .
,
,
.
, ,
. ,
.
, , , .
,
,
. ,
, , , .

(-),
, , ,
() () ..
, , , , , ,
,
. .
, ,
,
, ,
, - .
, ,
, , . . . , ,

, 166

,
.
, , ,
,
, .
,

, , .
, .

, ,
.
.
?.
, ,
, ,
, ,
.
,
!, .


, ,
. ,
, , ().
, ,
, ,
,
. .
, , - ,
.
, , .
167

, ,
, , .,
- , -
, ,
,
,
, .
,
,
, .
.

(). , ,
.
,
,
. , , ,
.

,
, ,
.
, , , ,
.
, - ,
, .
168

 , .
, , ,
. , .
,
.
,
.
, ,
, ,
. .
, , , , ,
,
.
,
, XX.
. ,
, ,
, ,
, ,

, .
,
, .
, .
.
,
.
23, , 4, ,

, - , ,
.
169

, , ,
. [] , , . ,

, .
, .
,
,
- ,
, , ,
,
.
,
, ,
,
,
. []
, , , ,
,

( , , , ..),
, 26.
..
: ,
, .
, ,
.
- ,
, , ,
, , . .,
26

. .-38683. . 5. . 3440.

170

.. , , , , (),
,
, ,
,
.

.
,
,
. ,

.

,
1933. []
23 .
, 27.
,
.. .
. . -
, :
. - ,
,
.
,
,
, ,
, ,
.
- . 28.
27
28

. . 5657.
. . 61.

171

 (18911937)29 : ,
, -, , , -
. -. , .
. , . , ,
30. ,

.

:
, , ,
, . , ,
, , ,
. ,
, , "", ,
,
, ,
.


. : ,
. , ()
.
,
29
30

1933. 5 . 1937. .
. . 5960.

172

,
, .
, . .
31. , ,
, .
, , . ,
.
23 1933 . :
,
7732. .

. . - . 1937,
. .

,
, . ..- 3 . 19371939,
. . .
, 1937. ..-,
.. .. 3 33. 10 1935.
.. .
34.
31
32
33

34

. . 59.
. . 172.
, .-36.0536. . 5. . 250.
28 1933. []
, - ,
, .
, . : .. 14/II-33 ., - 17/II,
. . 18/II-33 .
. , . 14/II-33.
, . 252.

173

1937. - 1936. , .
.. . 23
1933 . 8 1933
. . 2
, . .
11
.
, , . ,
, , ,
, ,
35. 1937.
:
36,
.
.. , , , 20 1933:
,

. , 37. .
, ,
80 .
35

36
37

8 1933.:
1. , 2. . . 3.
, 14/233.
4.
, 14/233. 5.
, , ,
17/233. ,
. 6. , 18/233. 7. - , 8. , , -,
-,
, : 19/233.
14/233 . 9. -
14/233. 10.
,
( . . 12. . 54).
http://www.pravenc.ru/text/159028.html
-38683. . 5. . 185.

174



2 38

I.
-
, , ,
.
,
,
-,
.
, , ,
, ,
.
,
, , , ,
.
, ,

, , , ,


38

. .-36 036. . 5. . 72206 ( -6. 6 ).

: . .-3868. . 5. . 177299.

175

, , , ,
.
, , , , -
-
- , ,
- .
. .
..,

,
, , .
-
.
, , ,
, . . , .
,
, , 1917.

,
.
-
,
,


.
- ,
, , 176

 ,
.

,
- . . ,
- ,
,


.

,
,
,
.
,
() ( )
, , ,
,
,
- .
,
- .
: ,
, , . .

.
, , ,
,
, , ,
.
177


,
, , , ,
, , .

, , , ,
, , , ,

, , ,
.
,
, , ,
.


, , , , , .
,
,
,
.
. , , ,
.
178

 ,
.
,
-
.

,
,
,
, .

, ,
, -.

,
,
- .
, - , .
,
.
.
,
. . , 179

,
, , ; , , , , ,
, , .
, , ,
,
, ,
, ,
.
, , , ,
.
,
, . ,
.
, .
,
, , .
, .
,
,
, ,
, , .

,
,
.
,
, .
. ,
,
180

 , .
,
,
.

.


, , - , ,
.
, , ,
,
, , .
-
, ,
.
-
,
.
-.
- 1901 -,
.
19051906 . ..,
, ,
.
,
.
181

 , , ,

,
, .

.

-.
, -. ,
,

, ,
,
. .-.
.
, ,
,
, -
.
,
.
,
2 ,
...

,
.
1917 . .
, , 182

 -
.

,

.
,
.
III 1917
, .
..,

,
,

, , ().
,

. ... , .
,

.
...
- (), .., . . , 1
.
.[] ... .. , .
...

, ,
183

 .
.
....

(), ,
.
-
..-. (),
.
.
, , .
,
, -
,
.
,
,
,
.
, ,
,
,
(), .
.
.
.
184

 ,
(), ,
.

,
,
[] []
, ()
,
- .

, .

, ,
.
(),

.


,
.
,
,
, ,

; , , , ,
185

 , ,
- ,
,
,
, -,
. , ,
()
- ,
.
.
,
.
.
, ,
, ,
, - .
2
2 .

,
, . , ,
.
, -
.
186



.
-

().
, , - ,
- ,
.
, , ,
,
,
. .
,
, , .

-,
-.
-
..,
... .
, - ,

(), , ,

, -
16 ().
, - 187

 , ,
,

.
,
, ,
, .
20 1933. .
II.

.... ()
, III
, ,

- ,
.
15
,
,
- .
.
, , , , ,
188

; ,
, , ;
,

, 8
, -,
- -, -
.
()
, , , .
.

, , .

, . .
. ,

.
-
. , , (),
,
,
, , , .
, , , ,
, , ,
.
, , ,
,
189

, ,
, , , , , ,
,
, ,

, .
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , , .
,
150000000 ,
, , , , ,
.


, ,
, - , , .. ..
. .
[] [] . , .

.
, ,
, , , , ,
,
, . , ,
, , .
190

 , .
, , , , ,
. : , , .
, ,
, -,
, -.
,
.
, .
,
. , ,
, , (). ,
, ,

, , , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , , , , , , , , ,

- .
,
,

.
:
.
,
.
, ,

.
191

 ()


. . .

.
,
.

- .
.

,
,

,
, .., .. .
,
, ,
, , , ,
,
.
. ,
[] [] , , , , , ,
, 192

 ()
,
, ,
.
, , .
, , , ,
, .
-
.
, m/v, ,
.
.

. .

. ,
,
,
, ,
, , -
.
- ,
, .
, ,
.
193



-
. , , ,
,
, , , - .

.
, , , ,
,
.
, ,
-
. ,
,
-,
.
. , ,
. , ,

.

. ,
,
, ,
,
, .

,
, , , 194

, , -,

.
, ,
, .
7
, ,
, , .
, , , 2
.
, 16 .
, ,
,
.

.

.
, , (
) 1/3 1/2
.
, , ,
,
. -, , , ,
. . , ,
, .
,
195


. !

, .
- ,
, , .
, ,
, ,



.
,

. .

,
. - , .
,
, ,
-.
, , ,
,
1917.
.
196



,

.
, ,
, ,
, -, ,
.
,
,
.

- .
, ,
, , , ,
, ,
- ,
, , , , ,
, ,
. .
, , . . -
. ., - .
, ,
, .
()
( )
, , / .
197


, .

,
.

, / ,
1917.

,
-
-.
14 () , , .
, -,
.

,
,

,
, .

,

198

 / .

,
, - ,

, , .
. ,
, [] - ,
.

192930 .
.
, ,
,

.
- ,

/
, - ,

.
, ,
, , ,
- , ,
.
,

199

 ,
,
.
, ()
III ,
, ()
(
1928.).
, ,
, ,

,

.

,
, .
, , ,
,
, , ,
.
.
,

.
.
, , ,
, .

.
, , .
200

 1213 .
. . . .


- ,
,
.
.

, ,
.
, .

.
, , ,
.
,
,
.
1933 . , .

,
, , ,
.
-
, ,
,

.
,

. Post factum
201

 -
.

- .

, ,
,
/ .
,
, .
,
,

.


.

, , ,

, , - ,


.
202


, ,
.
,
,
, / -
,

, , ..

.
()
,
. ,
,
.

, ,
, , ,

.

.
, ,
. . ,
.
15
,
, ,
.
,
203

 ,
,

,

.
,
-
, .

,
,

.
, , ,
, ,
, .

.
, ,


.

,
, , ,
, .
,
,
.
, ,
,
.
204

 , , ,
() ,
.
,

.
,
,
,
,
.

.

,

,
, ,
.


. , .
, , -
,
.
, ,
,
,

- , ,
,
.
205


, .
, , .

,
.
, , , , ,
.
: , , , , ,
.
, .

,
, ,
, ,
.


,
, ,
.. .
.
206


,


.
, ,


.


,
, .

,

. , ..
, ,
,

.
, , ,

. .
,

,

.
207




.
,

,
.

.
,
,

, ,
.
,
, ,
,

,
,
, , ,
, . ., ..

, , ,
, ,
2 (
), , , 10 .
208

,
. ,

-
.


. . , . ,


, , ,
, .

.

, , .
,
- . , ,

,
.
, , .., ,
( 75.,
5 .
. 810 209

 ,
), ,
, - , , ,
, , ,
, ..
. . , , . . . , , , ,
, , ,
. , .,
( .), ,
, ,
, , -,
, , , , ,
, , , , , , , , .,
, ,
.. .. , ,
, , , , ,
. . ,
, , , , ,
, , , ,
.
,
,
-
.., ,
. , 10%,
.
4050%, ,
.
210

 , 150. ,
, ,
110120., ,
100 ., ,
75. .. .

, , ..
, , ,
.
, ,
.


,
.
, ,
, , , ,
, ,
, ,
, ..
,
,

,
.
, - .
,
-,
,
, -211

 . , ,
.
,

.
, ,
.
,
,
.
, , .
, , .
,


-- .
.
.
, , ,
, , .. . .

, , .
, .. .
Volens nolens , , .
, ,
,

, , ,
, , ,
.
, , , , , , , 212

,
, , ,

.

, , , .

. , .
, , ()
.
,

.
, , , .
, , -, , ,
, .,
, , , , , ,
,
, ,
,
, , ,
, ,
,
.
()
,
,
213


,
- .

,
,
,
.
,
, , , , ,
.
. .
, -
, .
. (..).
,
.


. , .
, ,
.

.
, .
, , ,
,
214

 . ,
, .., .
,
, ; ,
,
, , ;
,
.
, , , (
) .
, , , ,
- -, , . ,

, .
, ,
, ,
,
, ,
. .
, , ,
-, , ,
, , ,

.
, , ,

. , , , ,
215

 , , , ,
,
, .

,
.. . .
, , ,

; ,
,
., ,
.
, ,
. .
.
, ., .. , .. ,

- .
,
-;
,
, , , ,
, ,
.
() ,
,
, 15
. ,
, .


,
216

 .
, , ,
, , ,

.
, ,

.
,
, -, ,
.
, ,
, ,
, ,
. ,
,
, .
-
, , ,
, , , ,
.
, ,
, , ,
, , .

, ,
, ,

.
,
. 217

, . ,
.

,
,

. -.
,
.
.

.

,

, , ,
,
150. .
.
.

, ,
, ,


,
, ,

218

()
,
.


, ,
, , -.

,
-, , ,
.
17 1918. 18

, ,
.

,
, .
, ,
, , , ,
, ,
, :
, .
219

 ,
, , , , ,
, , ,
.

,
.
,
, ,

.

,
, .
. ,
, ,
, ,
.
,
99% .
,
-,

, , .
,

, ,
.
,

220

 , , , []
, ; , ,
, .., ,
. . ,
.
, ,
.

- .
, :
()
, ,
, , ,
,
, ,
, ,
,
,
.
()
.
, .

2
,
221

 , - , , ,

.

.
, - ,
,
,
.
.
,
, - ,
,
(), .
?
()
.
.
, (), ,
.

.

.
.
.

, , , .
222

 , , ,
.
.
.
, , , , .
, , , .
, (),

, , , , , ,
, , .
. ,
, .
.
.

.
.
.
, ,
.
. -
(), .
, , , -
. - . .
223

 ,
- (, ).
, -,

.
, , ;
,
.
, -
,
.


, ,
,
,
.
,
,
. , ,
.
,
, , .

, () ,
,


.

224

 .
,
.


, , ,
, ,
.
,
,
,
,
(). ,
,
, .. .

,
..,
, ,
,
.
, ,
,
, .

,
,
.
,
, .
225


, ,

,

.
,
, ,
, .
,
.
, , .
,
,
.

.
, , ,
.., ,
, .
,
, ,
.
, , . .
226

,
.
,
. . ,
,
.


.
,
, .

.
. , , .
,
.
,
.
,
.
, ,

.


.
, ,
227

 , ,
.

-, .
-.
,
, . .
-,
-, .
, , .

.

.
,
,
.
,
. , .


, .
, , , .
, .
,
, , ,
6 , , ,
, 228

, , 12 ,
, ,
.

.
, .

- ,
,
,

, , , .
,
.

, , , . 10 20 , ,
, 12
, ,
.
. , ,
,
, , , ,
. , , ..
, , , - .
, , , ,
.
, .
229

 ,
: . .
, : ?,
, , : !,

().
, -
,
, , , ,
- .

,
() , ,

,
, , ,
, .
.
, ,
,
, , , ,
.., ,
, ,
.
,

- ,
230


.
.
, ,

.
,
,
, -
, , -,
, , , , , ,
.
, , ,


.

, , ,

, , ,

.

, ,
, , , ,

.
231


.

, ,

, .
,
, ,
,
, ,
- .

, , -
,
-

.
, , , , ,
.
, ,
:
1)

().
2) .
3) , .
4) .
5) .
6) .
,

.
232

 , ,

- .
, , .
I

, , , .

.
.
,
.
,
.
,
, ,
,
, ,
.

, , - ..
, ,
,

,

.
, , , , ,
233


.
, ,
.
,
.
, , .
2

,
, . .
, , . ,

, , , , ,
.
,
- .


.
, ,

.

-
234

 , , ,
.
,

.
III. -

, -
,

.

-

.

, ,
, ,
.
, - 15
()
.

, , , .
235


.

.

,
.

,
, . , .
,
-
.

1917 ,
.
,


.
- ,
.


-
,
236

,
, .
- .

, , .
,
,
, .
-

,
- :
1) , .
2) .
3) , ,
.
4) , , ,
.
5) ,
,
.
6)
,

.
237

7)
, , ..



.

, ,
,
,
.
,

, ,
,
,
.
, .. , ,
,
,
.
,
.

:
,
;

238

 ; ; , ,
,
;
, ;
; , , , , ,
, ,
;

.
, ,
.



.

, , ,
, , , ,
.
, , ,

, .

, .

.
,
,
239

 .
.
(, ,
..) ,

,
.

,
.


,
.

.
,
,
.

.


.

.
, .

,
.
240


. ,
,
, .



, .

:
1.
.
2. 6 7 .
3. 48 .
.
4. 4 .
5.
, .
6.
.
7. , , ,
,
.
8.

5%- .
9. .
241



,
,

,
.


,
. , ,

,

, .


.


.
,

,
, , - .

, ,

, ,
242

, , .

(),
:
1. .
2.

: ) ,
;)
, ,
.
3. ,
, .
:
) -
;
) ,
;
) [] , , , , ;
) ;
)
.
4.
,
243


,
.
5. ,
, .
6. ,
/ ;
) , . .
;
) ,
.

7. -
, , , ,
,

.

,
,

.


244

 ,
.
,
.
,

.
:
1. .
2.
,
.
3.
,

.
4. ,
.

5.
,

, , , ,



,
,
245


, .

, , ,
:
)
, -
-;
)

, .
, -
, .
.

,
, ().


,

.

, :
246

)
.
) ,
.
) .
)
.
) .

:
) , .
) , .
) .
)
.
), .
)
.

,
, :
) .
).
) .
) .
), .

, ,
247

 .

.



:
1. .
2. .
3. .
4. .
5. \ .
6. .
7. - .

, .

.

, .
/

, ,
.


248

 -
.


.

- , - .

,

, .

, , ,
, .

,
, , .
,
,

.

.

:
249

1)


.
2)
,
, .
3)
.
4)
.
5)

,
.
6)
.
7) .

.
,
,
,
,
, ,
,
250

, ,


, ,

.
,
,
,
, , ,
,
, , .



,
,
,
.
, , ,
,
- .
,


, ,
,
- 251

 -
.
, ,
(),
, ,
-
.
- ,

,
-
, ,
, ,
.
IV.

()

.
,

.
- .

,
.
252


.

, ,
.
-

.
,

,

, .


.
()
, .
, - :
2) .
, ,
:
,
, ,
, .
, 253

 ,
.

, ,

().
, , ,

.


. ,
,

,
.



,

.


254

 ,

..., ... (), .. .
,
,
,
,
,
.


, -
, .
,
.
1) .
2) , ,
/ .
3) , , , .
4) -
.
5) .
6) ,
.
7) ,
.


255



,

.
,
,
.
, ,
,

.
1) .
2) .
3) .
4) - .
5) .
6) .
7) .
8) .

,

.

, , ,

, , .
, ,
.
256


.
,
, .
, ,

,
.
,
, , ,
.



.


,
. ,

,

.
-

- ,
, , .
.
257

 / -

.
.

,
,
, ,
.
, ,
, ,
, , .
, , - .
.

, .

, -, .


,

.
,
,
.
258

 - .



, ,
.
, , ,
, , .

. .

,
.


,
. , , , , ( ..).

-
, , ,
. (35 )
, , ,
, ,
.
,
, .

-
.
259

 :
1) .
2) .
3) .
4) , .
5) .
6)
, .

, , , , - .



, - ,
, , , .
.
.

, .
, ,
.
,
,
, ,
.
260



.
, ,
, .
-.

- , ( )
, .

- .
- ,
,


.
, ,
, ,
, , , , ,
, (
. . 1 . .), , , -
.
.
() ., (?) ., ., (?) .
..
.
. :

:
261


.
( )

.
:
.

.
,
!

, ,
?! : , .

, , ,
,

( )

.. !
. :
. , .
,
,
.

?
.
-..,
,
,
, ,
, Verite ().
,
, 262

-, -
.
.
,
.



.
, , , .
.
,
, .

, .
,
, ,
, , .
.

.
.

,
263

 ,
, ,
. .

, .


(), ,
.


.



.
.
:
1) , .
2) ,
.

.

-

,
.
,
264

 , .

, .


,
,
,
,
, .


.

, .

,


. ,
- , ,
.


2- , .
:
265


,
.
1
I.
1) (), !
2) ,
.
3) .
4) - .
5) .
6) .
7) , , , .
8) .
9) .
10) .
II.
1) .
2) .
3) .
III.
1)
.
2) ,
.
3) .
IV.
1) .
2) .
2
- .
1.
266

1. .
2. .
3. .
4. , , , .
5. .
6. , .
7. .
8.
.
9. -
.
10. .
2.
1. .
2.
.
3.
.
III.
1. .
2. , .
3. 6 .
IV.
1. .
2. .
3.
.
V.
1. .
267

2. .
3. .
4. .
5. .
6.
.

.
. 2 . .

:

1

.

. ,
, .
:

, . ,
1

Operational Art and the Curious Narrative on the Russian Contribution: Presence and Absence Over the Last 2 Decades The Russian Military
Thought Today and Tomorrow: Essays in Memory of Mary FitzGerald, Stephen
Blank and Richard Weitz eds., Carlisle Barracks, PA: US Army War College,
Strategic Studies Institute, 2010.

269

 .2
,
.3
,
. ,
, , , .4

.
2

3
4

David Chandler. Napoleon, Operational Art and the Jena Campaign, in:
Michael D. Krause and R. Cody Phillips, eds., Historical Perspectives of the
OperationalArt. (Washington, DC: TheU.S.Army Center for Military History,
2005), pp. 2765. ,
,
, , - ,
1813. . Claus Telp.
The Evolution of Operational Art, 17401813: From Frederick the Great to
Napoleon (London: Frank Cass, 2005). ,
,
. :
, , , ,
,
.
,
,
, . . Gnther E. Rothenburg. The
Art of War in the Age of Napoleon. (Bloomington, Indiana: Indiana University
Press, 1978), . 146156.
Chandler, p. 17.
., , Clifford J. Rogers, editor. The Military Revolution Debate:
Readings on the Military Transformation of Early Modern Europe (Boulder,
CO: Westview Press, 1995); Geoffrey Parker. The Military Revolution: Military Innovation and the Rise of the West, 15001800 (Cambridge: Cambridge
University Press, 1996); MacGregor Knox and Williamson Murray, eds., The
Dynamics of Military Revolution, 13002050 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2001).

270

 .
, ,
, ,
, XIX.

,
,
,
.
, , , -
1809. .

(Napoleons Last Victory and the Emergence of Modern War).
,

.
o
, ,
, , , , .5
, , ,
.

. , ,
. 6
5

RobertM.Epstein. Napoleons Last Victory and the Emergence of ModernWar.

(Lawrence, Kansas: University Press of Kansas, 1994). , 1812 . ,
La Grand Arme .
JamesJ.Schneider. The Loose Marble And the Origins of OperationalArt.,
Parameters, (March 1989), pp. 8599; and JamesJ.Schneider. Theoretical

271

 .7 (Vulcans Anvil)

.
, ,
- , ,
1980 .
-
(AirLand Battle).8
.

,
. . .
x
x, .

7
8

Implications of Operational Art, in: ClaytonR.Newell and MichaelD.Krause,

eds. On OperationalArt. (Washington, DC: TheU.S.Army Center for Military
History, 1994), pp. 1730.

. ,
, .., ,
, ,
- . .: William McElwee, The
Art of War from Waterloo to Mons (Bloomington: Indiana University Press,
1974), pp. 147183, 114116.
James Schneider. The Structure of Strategic Revolution: Total War and the
Roots of the Soviet Warfare State (Novato, Calif.: Presidio Press, 2005).
William R. Richardson, FM 1005: The AirLand Battle in 1986, Military
Review 66, no. 3 (March 1986): 411; Huba Wass de Czege, Lessons from the
Past: Making the Armys Doctrine Right Enough Today. Landpower Essay, No.
062, (September 2006). On the origins of AirLand Battle see: JohnL.Romjue.
From Active Defense to AirLand Battle: The Development of Army Doctrine,
19731982 (Fort Monroe, Va.: U.S.Army Training and Doctrine Command,
1984), pp. 6673.

272


.
.
.9 ,

,
,
.10 ,
, ,
. ,
, ,

,
,
, .

,
,
.11
9
10

11

.. // . .,
1978. .VI.. 5354.
. . . ., 1937. . 9697.
,
,
.
Bruce W. Menning. Operational Arts Origins, Military Review, 77, no. 5.
September-October 1997, pp. 3247. ,
. . .

,
. -

273

 , 1920 .: , a .12
. ,
,
, .
,
, ,
1942.
1945 .

.13
1980 .

.
,
, -

12

13

,
, ,
. .: .. . ., 1962.
. 910. , . . ,
18 19 .,
: " ", ,
19701980
.. :
.S.H.Irwin, Brian Holden Reid J.J.G.Mackenzie. ,
. .: Telp. The Evolution of Operational Art, 17401813, p 1.
David Glantz. Military Operational Art: In Pursuit of Deep Battle. (London:
Frank Cass, 1991).
,

.
.: DavidM.Glantz and JonathanM.House. When Titans Clashed: How the
Red Army Stopped Hitler (Lawrence, KS: University Press of Kansas, 1995).
, .

274

 . ,

, e a
, a
.14
,
,
.
,
1985 .. ,
, 1978.15
.
, ,
, .
-
.16 14

15

16

Jacob W. Kipp. Conventional Force Modernization and the Asymmetries of

Military Doctrine: Historical Reflections on Air/Land Battle and the Operational Maneuver Group, in: Stockholm International Peace Research Institute,
The Uncertain Course: New Weapons, Strategies and Mind Sets. Edited by
CarlG.Jacobsen (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1987), 137166.
Sir John Winthrop Hackett. The Third World War, August 1985 (London:
Berkeley, 1978). 1970.
.: WilliamK.Sutey. The Deterrent Value of US Army Doctrine: The Active Defense and Airland Battle in
Soviet Military Thought. A monograph, (Ft. Leavenworth, KS: School of Advanced Military Studies, 1993).
Richard E. Simpkin. Race to the Swift: Thoughts on Twenty-First Century
Warfare. (London: Brasseys Defence, 1985). See also: RichardE.Simpkin and
John Erickson. Deep Battle: The Brainchild of Marshal Tukhachevskii. (London:
Brassey's Defence, 1987).
1990. , ,

275


,

1982 ., 1986 .
.17 , ,
(TRADOC), (Combined
Arms Center) - (Command and
General Staff College).18
(Military Decision Making Process MDMP),
.
,

, .
,

.19 ,
, o .
(TheU.S.Army War College) :
,
.

, , -

17

18
19

. .: Christopher Bellamy. The Evolution of Modern Land
Warfare (London: Routledge, 1990), pp. 240243.
John S. Brown. The Maturation of Operational Art: Operations DESERT
SCHIELD AND DESERT STORM, in: Krause and Phillips, eds. Historical
Perspectives of Operational Art, p. 439.
Romjue. From Active Defense to AirLand Battle: The Development of Army
Doctrine, 19731982.
James R. Locher, III. Victory on the Potomac: The Goldwater-Nicholas Act
Unifies the Pentagon (College Station, Texas: Texas A & M University Press,
2002), pp. 314.

276

 .
:

, , ,
.20
- , .
,
, .
, ,
,
(JOPP).21

.
,
. , . 1980 . -
, , ,
20
21

U.S.Department of Defense. Joint Forces Employment: Operational art. http://

www.js.pentagon.mil/doctrine/jrm/opart.pdf. accessed 25 January 2009

. , ,
- (SAASS)
. SAASS, ,
- .
. ,
. (Joint Advanced Warfighting School)
(Joint
Forces Staff College by National Defense University) ,
. -
.

277

 1994 .22
. , ,
1990 ., 2005 .23 Desert Shield
Desert Storm ,

, .24

,
,
.

,
,
, ,
22

23

24

ClaytonR.Newell and MichaelD.Krause, eds., On OperationalArt (Washington,

DC: TheU.S.Army Center for Military History, 1994). , , 1990 .
:
B.J.C.McKercher and MichaelA.Hennessy, eds., The Operational Art: Developments in the Theories of War (West Port, CT: Praeger, 1996)
, ,
,
, , . .: Shimon Naveh. In Pursuit of Military Excellence: The Evolution
of OperationalArt (London: Frank Cass, 1997).
, 1995 . - , ,
, . .: Shimon Navveh.
Operational Art and the IDF: A Critical Study of a Command Culture. Center for
Strategic & Budgetary Assessment (September 30, 2007), pp. 12.
Krause and Phillips, eds.. Historical Perspectives of the OperationalArt. p. iii.
.
, .
Brown. The Maturation of Operational Art: Operations DESERT SCHIELD
AND DESERT STORM, in: Newell and Krause, eds., On Operational Art,
pp.454466.

278


.25 ,

.26 1990 .
, .

,
.27

(Operation ALLIED FORCE)
. ,
,
.28
, , , , , .
,
,
25

26
27

28

(RMA) .:
Thierry Gongora and Harold von Riekhoff, eds., Toward a Revolution in Military
Affairs? (Westport, Connecticut: Greenwood Press, 2000.)
.
.: WilliamA.Owens. Lifting the Fog of War (New York: Farrar, Straus and
Giroux, 2000).
Erik Dahl. Network Centric Warfare and the Death of Operational Art, Defence Studies, Volume II, No. 1 (March 2002), pp. 124.
Thomas Z. Ruby, Effects-Based Operations: More Important Than Ever,
Parameters, (Autumn 2008), pp. 2635. ,

(Effects-based operations). effects-based
operations ,
. .: John Andreas Olsen. John Warden and the Renaissance of
American Air Power. (Dulles, VA: Potomac Books, 2007).
Dag Henriksen. NATOs Gamble: Combining Diplomacy and Air Power in the Kosovo
Crisis, 19981999 (Annapolis, MD: Naval Institute Press, 2007), pp.189191.

279

 . ,
.
, ALLIED FORCE
, . 1991. 1 (JP 1),
, 30, ,
(joint campaign)
,
.29

- ,
,
,
.

.
, .. , e
.30
,
.
, , ,
.
,

.31 (Operation ENDURING FREEDOM)
,
.32
29
30
31
32

Peter F. Herrly. The Plight of Joint Doctrine after Kosovo. JFQ, (summer
1999), p. 99.
WilliamS.Lind et al.. The Changing Face of War: Into the Fourth Generation,
Marine Corps Gazette (October 1989), pp. 2226.
.
Paul Wolfowitz. Thinking about the Imperatives of Defense Transformation,
Address to the Heritage Foundation, 30 April 2004, http://www.heritage.org/
research/nationalsecurity/hl831.cfm. accessed 25 July 2007.

280

 (Transformation)
(CENTCOM)
,


. , .33
, ,


, . , , ,
Washington Post,
.34 , ,
.
, ,
(SAMS)
- (AirLand Battle Doctrine),
, .
35. ,
, , ,
XXI .

33

34

35

.: Williamson Murray and RobertH.Scales, Jr.. The Iraq War: A Military

History (Cambridge, Mass: Belknap Press, 2003); and John Keegan. The
IraqWar (New York: AlfredA.Knopf, 2004).
.: ThomasE.Ricks. Fiasco: The American Military Adventure in Iraq (New
York: Penguin Group, 2006); and MichaelR.Gordon and BernardE.Trainor.
Cobra II: The Inside Story on the Invasion and Occupation of Iraq (New York:
Pantheon Books, 2006).
Huba Wass de Czege. The Logic of Operational Art: How to Design Sound
Campaign Strategies, Learn Effectively and Adapt Rapidly & Appropriately,
unpublished essay, January 2009, /2.

281

36. ,
1990 ., ,

.37
,


,
(Global War on Terrorism)
.
, Unified
Quest, TRADOC,
, ,
- .
,
, (emerging
situation) ,
.
(Systemic Operational Design),
-
,
, .
, .
, ,

.
, 36
37

.
.

282

 .38 ,
, ,

. :
,
, ,
.39 ,
XXI., ,
, ,
,
. , (SOD)
.

.
525-5-3000, TRADOC, ,

: . ,
, , ,
(sic!), .40 2008.
525-5-500

(Commanders Appreciation and Campaign Design).41

38

39
40
41

/ Dr. Naveh or, how I Learned to Stop Worrying and Walk through
Walls. Haaretz. Com (1 November 2007), http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/
spages/917158.html. , DEFENSE SHIELD
2002 .
Shimon Naveh. In Pursuit of Military Excellence: The Evolution of Operational
Theory (London: Frank Cass, 1997), pp. 209238.
TRADOC Pamphlet, 525-5-300, 91.
TRADOC Pamphlet, 525-5-300 Commanders Appreciation and Campaign
Design,

283

 ,
, , .42
:

,
.
. ,
,
, .
,
, .. , 1960 .
1968. ,
,
. ,

, (destruction). (disruption)
(destruction) . ,
, a e . 43
,
, , ,

, .44
42
43
44

. . i.
Milan N. Vego. A Case against Systemic Operational Design, Joint Forces
Quarterly, No. 2, (2009), pp. 7071.
I.Susiluoto. (1982) Origins and Development of Systems Thinking in USSR:
Political and Philosophical Controversies from Bogdanov and Bukharin to
Present-Day Re-Evaluations, in: Annales Acadamiae Scientarum Fennicae,
Dissertationes. Humanarum Litterarum, v. 30, (Helsinki, 1982), pp. 1617.
-

284


.
,

. .
,
. ,
, .
, ,
,
.

.
,
,
. , .
,
, , .

.

(A Normal Totalitarian Society).45
,
, ,

45

1960 . ,
. 1950 .
. ,
,
,
Weltanschauung.
Vladimir Shlapentokh. A Normal Totalitarian Society: How the Soviet Union
Functioned and How It Collapsed (Armoonk, NY: M.E.Sharpe, 2001).

285

 .46
, .
, :
1. ().
2. , .. , ,
.
3.: ().47

, ,

,
.
, . ,
, [ ]
,
. , ,
, .48
,

, 1980 .
.
. .
, ,
. , ,
, .

46

47
48

. .:
. ., 2003; - (http://www.locatetv.com/tv/zagadki-istorii/3361034),
: . ., 2003.
. // . ., 2004. . 151.
. . 153.

286


.
, ,
, . , , ,
.
.
, , ,
.
,
,

. ,
. .

,
:
, ,

, ,
.

, , .49 , , ,
,
,
.
, ,
, 49

. . . ., 1965.
.312. , , ,
.

287

 , , ,
.
,
,
.
, .
... -, - , ,

, , . . .
,
.50 ,
.
, , .
, ,
,
, .51
, , ,
, , .

. ,

, , ,
.
,
.52
50

51

52

.. : // . ., 1972. . 14,
. 17362.
Avraham Yassour. The Empiriomonist Critique of Dialectical Materialism: Bogdanov, Plekhanov, Lenin. Studies in East European Thought, Vol. 26, No. 1
(July 1983), pp. 2138.
. :
, 19 1917.//

288

 .
(
),
.

, ,
.
, .. -, , ,
:
(an sich), (fr sich).

- , ..
.
, ,
,

- , .53 , ,
.

. , . .
, ,

. .
1926 .
, . 1928.

53

, 11 1997. . : A. A. (
). , , , 19011928. // / . .. ... . 1. ., 1995.
. 189190.
. //
. 3 . ., 1995. . 1. . 92107.

289

, .
,
.
. ,
, ,
: ,
.54 , , ,

.
. , (19171928),

, .
, , ,
(19291941).
(19411953). (19531964).
(19641985). ,
, .
, . .
.

.
, - ,
, ,
, , .55
54

55

Anthony Mansueto. From Dialectic to Organization: Bogdanovs Contribution

to Social Theory. Studies in East European Thought. Vol. 46, No. 1 (March
1996), p. 37.
1990 . .: Patricia Kennedy
Grimsted. Increased Reference Access to Post-1991 Russian Archives, Slavic
Review, Vol. 56, No. 4 (Winter 1997), pp. 718759; and Patricia Kennedy
Grimsted and Vladimir Petrovich Kozlov. Archives of Russia: a directory and

290


, .
.56

.

, ,
. , ,
,
, : ,
, ,
. , , .57 ,

,
. -
,
,
.58 . -

56

57
58

bibliographic guide of repositories in Moscow and St. Petersburg. Armonk, NY:

M. E. Sharpe, 1997). ,
, .: Library of Congress, Manuscript Reading
Room, Dmitri Antonovich Volkogonov, A Register of His Paper in the Library
of Congress (Washington, DC: 2000), http://www.loc.gov/rr/mss/text/
volkogon.html.
Rachel Donadio. The Iron Archives, The New York Times (22 April 2007),
http://www.yale.edu/annals/Reviews/review_texts/Donadio_Iron_Archives_
NYT_04.22.07.html, accessed 15 December 2008.
.. . ., 1949.
.4148.
1960 ., , - ,
-
, 1849. 1917.
1968.,
. , 1849. 1949. ,
, ,

291


,
,
, .59
.60
. . ,
, ,
, -

59

60

. , . ,, , , , ..
, 1947. .
,
1917 1946 ., .

- .
RaymondL.Garthoff. How Russia Makes War: The Soviet Military Doctrine.
(London: G.Allen & Unwin. 1954). ,
,
RAND ,
, , , ,
. .: RaymondL.Garthoff. A Journey through the Cold
War: A Memoir of Containment and Coexistence (Washington, DC: Brookings
Institution Press, 2001), pp. 910.
Think Tanks: RAND - ,
. .: Paul Dickson. Think Tanks. (New York:
Ballentine Books, 1971), p. 69.
, .

.: Dennis Showalter. A Dubious
Hertiage: The Military Legacy of the Russo-German War, Air University Review, (MarchApril 1985), http://www.airpower.maxwell.af.mil/airchronicles/
aureview/1985/mar-apr/showalter.html.
.: Kevin Sutor. To
Stem the Red Tide: The German Report Series and Its Effect on American
Defense Doctrine, 19481954, The Journal of Military History, Vol. 57, no. 4
(Oct.Dec. 1993), pp. 653688.

292

 .61
1980 . ,

,
,
.62

1956. .
XX .
, , ,
,

.63
, , ,
.


. ,
, ,
, .. . ,
, ,
.
operating art ( ) , ,
, .. , 61
62

63

Michael Cherniavsky. Corporal Hitler, General Winter, and the Russian Peasant// The Yale Review, Volume LI, No. 4 (Summer 1962), pp. 547558.
David Glantz. American Perspectives on Eastern Front Operations in World
War II. A paper delivered at the Soviet-American Colloquium on Problems of
World War II in Moscow on 2326 October 1986 // Foreign Military Studies
Office, http://fmso.leavenworth.army.mil/documents/e-front.htm.
Nikita Sergeevich Khrushchev, Special Report to the Twentieth Congress of the
Communist Party of the Soviet Union, (February 2425, 1956), http://www.
uwm.edu/Course/448-343/index12.html.

293

 ,
, .

[] .64
operating art ,
. ,
1920 .
operating art ,
.

,
.
,
, ,
, , - , ,
.
1960 . ,
.

. , 1964., :
64

John Erickson. The Soviet High Command: A Military-Political Histor, 1917

1941 (London: Frank Cass, 2001), pp. 313, 717.
1962. . ,
, . ,
.
, -
. ,
. ,
.
, ,
.
,
,
. . .: . . ., 1926. . 6365.

294

 , ..

,

.65

.
,
.

.66
, , , ,

.67
65

66
67

.. / .
.. ., 1964. .I.. 26.


. ,
. -,
. ,
. .:
/ . . .., . .
.. ., 1969. . 124.

. , , ,
.
,
, , ,
; , .
, . . ,
,
, , .. ...
..... ., 1990. . 185199.
.. // : 2. ., 1964. . 1. . 3150. . : .
: // . 11 1999.

295


.

, , .
,
,
. , , , , ,

.68 , ,
.
, ,
1920 . ,
.


.

, ,
.
,


.

1920 ., .69 , 68

69

Lennart Samuelson and Vitaly Shlykov. Plans for Stalins War Machine: Tukhachevskii and Miltary-Economic Planning, 19251941. New York, 2000,
pp.48.
.
Jacob W. Kipp. Two Views of Warsaw: The Russian Civil War and Soviet
Operational Art, 19201930, in: B. J. C. McKercher and Michael A. Hennessy, eds., The Operational Art: Developments in the Theories of War. (West
Port, CT: Praeger, 1996), 5186. . : Norman Davies. White Eagle,
Red Star: The Polish-Soviet War, 19191920 (New York: St. Martins Press,
1972); and Jozef Pilsudki. Year 1920 (London & New York: Pilsudksi Institute
of London, and Pilsudksi Institute of America, 1972).

296

 .
. 1920 .
-
, .
.

. -
.
, .70
, ,
,
,
, . , ,

1903.
,
, .
, ,
.
. , ,
, , , .71
,
1925.72
70

71
72

. . . : - .
.: . 1984. . 9192. .:
Jacob W. Kipp. Two Views of Warsaw: The Russian Civil War and Soviet
Operational Art, 19201930, in: B.J.C.McKercher and MichaelA.Hennessy,
eds., The Operational Art: Developments in the Theories of War (West Port, CT:
Praeger, 1996), 5186.
.. //
. 1921. 2. . 39.
. .., , , ,

297

 , ,
, , ,
.73

, ,
.74
30 .
.
.
,
, .
, ,

.75

73
74

75

. .: ....
. . 1985. . 203205. , ,

,
(. . 229234).
.. // ..
. . I, . 3150.
Walter Darnell Jacobs. Frunze: The Soviet Clausewitz, 18851925 (The Hague:
Martinus Nijhoff., 1969).
. .: JacobW.Kipp.
Lenin and Clausewitz: The Militarization of Marxism, Military Affairs, XLIX,
No. 4 (December 1985), 184191. ,
1934., , ,
.
, , .
.: JacobW.Kipp. General-MajorA.A.Svechin and Modern
War: Military History and Military Theory, Introductory essay for: Kent Lee,
editor, A.A.Svechin, Strategy (Minneapolis: East View Publications, 1992),
p. 51. .: . . ., 1934,
A.A.. ., 1935.
- -

298



,
.
, 1967.

,
, .76 ,

,
. 3 , ..,

, , , ,

.77 ,
.
, ,
.
,
.78

, , -

76

77
78

1939. .: Alvin Coox. Nomonhan: Japan against Russia, 1939 (Stanford, CA:
Stanford Universiy Press, 1985).
.: JacobW.Kipp. Barbarossa, Soviet Covering Forces and the Initial Period
of War: Military History and AirLand Battle, The Journal of Soviet Military
Studies, I, No. 2 (June 1988), 188212.
A. M. Nekrich. June 22, 1941 (Columbia, SC: University of South Carolina
Press, 1968). .: P.G.Grigorenko. The Concealment
of Historical Truth A Public Crime, in: P.G.Grigorenko. The Grigorenko
Papers (Boulder, CO: Westview Press, 1976). .
.. . ., 1983. . 1. . 12.
. . . :
. ., 1974.

299

 .
.
1975.
1983. .
. 1999.

- .79 ,
, ,

.


.
. , ,
. ,
,

. SS-20
. . ,


- , .
,
, 1960 1970 .

- .
79

John Erickson. The Road to Stalingrad, London: Cassell, 2007; John Erickson,
The Road to Berlin: Stalins War with Germany, Volume Two, New Haven, CT:
Yale University Press, 1999.

300


,

.80 - -
-
1980 .81
, ,
, ,
, 82

,
. , , ,
. ,
,

1973. FM 1005, TRADOC 1976., 80

81

82

- .
- .

, - ,
.
.: Robert Herrick, Soviet Naval Strategy (Annapolis US Naval Institute, 1968);
Nicholas George Shadrin. Development of Soviet Maritime Power (Washington,
DC: Georgetown University, 1972), unpublished dissertation; Kenneth Hagan and
Jacob Kipp, U. S. and U. S. S. R. Naval Strategy, Proceedings, C. No. 11,
(November 1973), 3742; Michael McGwire et al. Soviet Naval Policy: Objectives
and Constraints (New York: FrederickA.Praeger, 1975); Michael MccGwire et
al. Soviet Naval Influence: Domestic and Foreign Influence (New York: FrederickA.Praeger, 1977).
Christopher A. Ford and David A. Rosenberg. The Naval Intelligence
Underpinnings of Reagans Maritime Strategy, The Journal of Strategic
Studies. Vol. 28, No. 2 (April 2005), pp. 379409.
DavidR.Jones, ed. Soviet Armed Forces Review Annual. Vol. 1 (Gulf Breeze,
FL: Acadmic International Press, 1977), p. vii.

301

 1980 . .83

. 1945.84
,
,
, operational art (
)
.85
,
. , ,
,
. : ,


.86

, , ,
, ,
.
1943.
.87
, .
83

84
85

86

87

Richard M. Swain. Filling the Void: The Operational Art and the U.S. Army, in: B.J.C.McKercher and MichaelA.Hennessy, eds., The Operational
Art: Developments in the Theories of War. (West Port, CT: Praeger, 1996),
pp.147172.
Peter Vigor. Soviet Blitzkrieg Theory (London: Macmillan, 1983).
David Glantz. Soviet Ground Doctrine since 1845 (sic) // Air University Review, March-April 1983. http://www.airpower.maxwell.af.mil/airchronicles/
aureview/1983/mar-apr/glantz.htm. . : David Glantz. The Nature of
Soviet Operational Art // Parameters. Spring 1985. P. 63.
A.A.Kokoshin and V.V.Larionov. Origins of the Intellectual Rehabilitation of
A.A.Svechin. In: Svechin. Strategy, pp. 113. . : .
// . 17
2008. 15.
David Glantz. Zhukovs Greatest Defeat: The Red Armys Epic Disaster in operation Mars, 1942. Lawrence, KS: University Press of Kansas, 1999.

302

 , .

.

. , 1905.
,
.88
,
- ,
,

1945.89
, ,
.90
, ,
88
89

90

BruceW.Menning. Bayonets before Bullets: The Imperial Russian Army, 1861

1914. Bloomington, IND: Indiana University Press. 1992.
David Glantz. The Soviet Airborne Experience. Ft. Leavenworth: Combat Studies Institute. 1984. David Glantz. August Storm: Soviet Strategic Offensive in
Manchuria, 1945// Leavenworth Paper no. 7. Ft. Leavenworth: Combat Studies
Institute, 1983. : August Storm: Soviet Tactical and Operational Combat in
Manchuria, 1945// Leavenworth PaperNo. 8. Ft. Leavenworth: Combat Studies Institute, 1983.
David Glantz. 1984 Art of War symposium, From the Don to the Dnepr: Soviet Offensive Operations December 1942 August 1943 / A transcript
of Proceedings // Carlisle Barracks, P: Center for Land Warfare, US Army
War College, 2630 March 1984; 1985 Art of War symposium, From the
Dnepr to the Vistula: Soviet Offensive Operations November 1943 August
1944/Atranscript of Proceedings// Carlisle Barracks, P: Center for Land
Warfare, US Army War College, 293 May 1985; 1986 Art of War symposium,
From the Vistula to the Oder: Soviet Offensive Operations October 1944
March 1945 / A transcript of Proceedings // Carlisle Barracks, P: Center for
Land Warfare, US Army War College, 1923 May 1986. DavidM.Glant,
d., The Initial Period of War on the Eastern Front, 22 JuneAugust 1941//
Proceedings of the Fourth Art of War Symposium. Garmisch. October 1987.
Cass Series on Soviet Military Experience. Vol. 2. London: Frank Cass, 1997.

303

 .
, .

, , , .91

(SASO), 1986 .
TRADOC .
-
(SSRC) ,
.92 SSRC
,
.93 SASO SSRC . ,
, ,

.94
91

92

93
94

. . David Glantz and JonathanM.House.

When Titans Clashed: How the Red Army Stopped Hitler. Lawrence, KS: University Press of Kansas, 1995. ,
, .
. . . : David
Glantz. Zhukovs Greatest Defeat: The Red Armys Epic Disaster in Operation
Mars, 1942. Lawrence, KS: University Press of Kansas, 1999; Aleksandr Semenovich Orlov. Operation Mars: Was It Large Disaster or Part of the Victory at
Stalingrad? http://www.armchairgeneral. com/rkkaww2/battles/mars42_Orlov.htm, accessed 23 December 2008.
SASO .: JacobW.Kipp.
FMSO-JRIC and Open Source Intelligence: Speaking Prose in a World of
Verse// Military Intelligence Professorial Bulletin. JanuaryFebruary 2006.
pp.4550.
C. N. Donnelly. Red Banner: The Soviet Military System in Peace and War.
Clousdon, Surrey: Janes Information Group, 1988.
JacobW.Kipp. Mass and Maneuver and the Origins of Soviet OperationalArt.
In: Karl Reddel, ed., Transformation in Russian and Soviet Military History//
Proceedings of the Twelfth Military History Symposium, USAF Academy,
1986. Washington, DC: United States Air Force Office of Air Force History.
1990. Pp.87116.

304

 , ,
.
,

,

,
. ,
() 1950 .

. - .., , 1954 1985 .
, .. , .

, ,
. -
, 1970 1980 .,
19501960 .
, 19601965. .95 1950 . - ,
.

,

, - - . - 1962 1968.
95

John G. Hines, Ellis M. Mishulovich, and John F. Shull, Soviet Intentions,

19651985& Soviet Post-Cold War Testimonial Evidence, Washington, DC&
BDM Federal, 1995, pp. 5455.

305

..,
.96
, ,
, . . ,
1965 1975 .
,
.
, ,
, a 67 .97


. -

. . ,
, .
,


.

, , -
.


.98

-
,
SS-20. 1970 . , ,
,
96
97
98

/ . . ... ., 1962.
Hines, Mishulovich, and Shull, pp. 5556.
. . 1920.

306

 .99
, ,

56. 1979. ,
.
19801981. ,
.
,
, .100 , , - ,

. - , ,
.
, , ,


, , , .101
1979.

. ,

. , , , ,
, , , 1970 .
. , . Ghulam Dastagire Wardak, The Voroshilov Lectures: Materials from the Soviet General Staff Academy, Vol. I, Washington, DC:
National Defense University Press, 1989, pp. 257313.
100 Hines, Mishulovich, and Shull, p. 23.
101 . . 24. P.H.Vigor.
Soviet Blitzkrieg theory, Hong Cong: The MacMillan Press, 1985, pp. 183205.
99

307

 .102
40000
, 5000. 1980 .
-
(
II),
. ,

. ,
, ,
,
, . ,
. ,
,
, ,
, .103
,

, .

.

.104
.

102 Hines,

Mishulovich, and Shull, p. 25.

The Labor of Sisyphus: Forecasting the Revolution in Military
Affairs during Russias Time of Troubles. In Thierr Gongora and Harold von
Rieckhoff, eds. Toward a Revolution in Military Affairs? Westport, CT: Greenwood Press, 2000, pp. 87104.
104 Hines, Mishulovich, and Shull, p. 7273.
103 JacobW.Kipp.

308

 1979 . .


.
,
,
, .
.
,
, .
,
.
, ,

.
,105 , , .

,
,
,
. , , ,
,
.
.
, 1930 .,
,
.
,
,
105 ..

. : , ,
. ., 1987. . 234245.

309

 .106
, ,
,
,
.
-
. , . - .. ..
,

. ,

.107
.
,
,
.

,
,
, ,
.108
, 106

. ? //
, 9. 2002. . 6493. . : JacobW.Kipp.
The Changing Soviet Strategic Environment: Soviet Military Doctrine, Conventional Military Forces, and the Scientific-Technical Revolution in Military Affairs.
In: Carl Jacobsen et al, eds. Strategic Power: USA/USSR. London: Macmillan,
1990. . 435456.
107 . , : A.A.Svechin. Strategy, Minneapolis, MD: East View Publications, 1992. . : Andrei Afanasievich
Kokoshin. Soviet Strategic Thought, 19171991, Cambridge: Massachusetts
Institute of Technology Press, 1998.
108 WilliamE.Odom. The Collapse of the Soviet Military. New Haven, CT.: Yale
University Press, 1998, pp. 388404.

310

 ,
, , .
, , , .
, .
, ,
,
.109

.
. , ,
, , , ,
. . . ,

, ,
,
. ,
, ,
.110
, ,
,
. , ,
.
1991.
.

. .111
109 Vitaly

Shlykov, Fatal Mistakes of the U.S. and Soviet Intelligence: Part One,
International Affairs, Vol. XLII, Nos. 5/6, 1996, pp. 158177.
110 .. . ., 1988. . 62 .
111 . . . . 2005.

311

 .
, .112


.
.
-
.113
,

. e ,
.114

, , , ,
.115


, ,

. ,
,
112 ..-

/ //
. ... ., 1980. .39.
113 . . . . .,
1995. . 398.
114 Jacob W. Kipp. Foresigt and Forecasting: The Russian and Soviet Military
Experience. College Station, Texas: Center for Strategic Technology Stratech
Studies, 1988, p. 262.
115 JacobW.Kipp. The Nature of Future War: Russian Military Forecasting and
the Revolution in Military Affairs, a Case of the Oracle of Delphi or Cassandra?
The Journal of Soviet Military Studies, Vol. 9, No. 1, March 1996, pp. 145.

312

 , .
IFOR SFOR
. ,
,
.

.116

, , ,
.

, .
.
,

-99.
,
, , ,
.117
,
1999 ., , . 1990 .
,
. ,
, .
116 JacobW.Kipp.

The Russian Armed Forces, the Draft Military Doctrine, and

the Revolution in Military Affairs: the Oracle of Delphi and Cassandra Revisited, in: MichaelH.Crutcher ed., The Russian Armed Forces at the Dawn of the
Millenium, 79 February 2000, Carlisle, PA: Center for Strategic Leadership,
2001, pp. 324334.
117 Jacob W. Kipp. Russian Non-Strategic Nuclear Weapons, Military Review,
Vol. 81, No. 3, May-June 2001, pp 27-38.

313


,
. ,

,
, (, ,
)
.
, ,
,
.118
- .,
- , ,
, ,
. , ,
, ,
. , ,
, ,


. 1999.,
, .119 , ,
,
, .., , . ,

, ,

.120 ,
118 ..

?.. (
2025). ., 1995.
119 . . ., 1999. . 3546.
120 . . 157207.

314

. . ,
,
,
.
- .., - ,
.121

. , .122
.123
.
, .
.


. ,

.124
-
,

. . 121 . .

. . . .,
1987. . 77.
122 . .
,
// . 2, 1994. . 8184.
123 Vladimir Pirumov. On the Concept of Russias National Security, Russian
Executive and Legislative Newslletter, No. 9, 1995, p. 15.
124 .., .., .. .. . ., 1998.

315


.125
,

,
,
.
.126
,

,
, .127
.
,
.128 , .129
,
- XXI -
.130 , , ,
.131
,
.
125 ..

.
, . - . ., 1995.
126 .. . . ., 2001. . 4254.
127 .. : ,
, . ., 2001. . 269278.
128 Makhmut Gareev and Vladimir Slipchenko. FutureWar (Ft. Leavenworth, KS:
Foreign Military Studies Office), 2007.
129 . // . 11,
2002. . 78.
130 . - // . 12. 2004.
131 ... // .
2. 2006. . 2433.

316

 .132

,
- . ,
, ,
. (
) , ,
, .
, , , .

. , ,
. ,
-
,
.133 .. ,
- .134

,
, . ,
,
(effects-based operations), .


132 ..

.. : // . 6. 2006.
. 7580.
133 . ., . . : . ., 2005.
.5992.
134 .. // . 5. 2005.
.6776.

317

 ,
,
. , .
.
,
.

, .
.135 , ,

. , , ,

, , .

.

135

. . , 2004 (The World New

Military Revolution Series).

.., ..

19871992.

20
,
,
, ,
. , , , ,
.
.
, . ,
,
,
.
, .
, , , , ,
, .

. ,
319


. ,
,
.


. ,

. 19851991. .
, , , .
. , ,
, , ,
.

.
, .
- .
,

.


,

. ,

, ,
,
.

.
,

.
,
.
320

 ,

, . , ,
. ,
,
, , , , - .

,
. , ,
.
,
. ,
. ,
. ,
.
: 1985. (
, ,
); 1986. (
); 1987. (
, ); , ,
1988- 1990- .1
, 1985 1986 , , ,
, . 1987
, 1990, 1991, 1992,
.
:
1 . 23 198717 1989.
2 . 1989 1990.
3 . 1990 1992.

. 23 1987 ,
1

Park, A.Turning-points of post-communist transition: Lessons from the case

of Estonia. In: Proceedings of the Estonian Academy of Sciences 44/3. Tallinn:
Estonian Academy Publishers, 1995, pp. 323332.

321

 - 1939. .2
,
. ,
, , ..,
, ,

.

.
, ,

.
1986
1987. (Eesti Muinsuskaitseselts) (EMS) .

1986 1987. 12 1987.

.
.
.
,
.
11 1988 . .
, .3
2

.. // 12. 1990; ., . ,
. . 1992.
, (Isamaa ja Res Publica

322

 1988.
.

-
(Molotov-Ribbentropi Pakti Avalikustamise Eesti Grupp, .
MRP-AEG), 23 1987.

,
. .
. , ,
, ,
. , , , .
, 1995.
,
. IME (Isemajandav Eesti).
1987 Edasi.

. 1987
,
(
). 1991, ,
1987.
,
, .
Liit) , 2006
Res Publica. ,
(Eesti Reformierakond),
90 .

323


. IME
.
,
.4 19881989 , ,
.
, (
) ,
, , . :
, . ,
. ,
, , , 1991 .
IME , . , .,
.5 ,
, ,
,

. 19871990.
,
1991.
IME
-
.
-II. 1971
. ,
. ,
4

. . : // . : . ., 1991..101109.
P.IME // . , 1990.
28.

324

 , ,
,
.
:
1. , .
2. , ,
, .
3.
.6

.

(), . .
, .
(19881993.), , , , ,
. ,
.
,
,
.
.
, ,
. ,
. . . :
.. -
6

. . -II
[19711972] http://www.hot.ee/r/russconference/history/history-14.html

325

 . 1985 1987 , .7 ,

.
. .
, -
.
,
, . , ,
. ,
, ,
, .. ,
,
. ,

,
: , - ,, ...

. .8
, . . , , . . .
. . ,
- .
.. : 1988 (. ..) , , , . ,
; ,
7
8

. . . ., 2004. . 159.
...., 1997.

326

 , ,
, . ,
. ,
, .
, ,
, .9
: , , :
.
, ,
,
. , ,
. ,
!10
, ,
.
, ,

.
19952012.
,
,
...11
- .
1987 . .
.
,
,
. ,
. 9
10
11

.. . . 1. . 1995. . 510.
. () // .
31 2011.
. . ? . .,
2011.

327

 6 1988,12
13 ()
.
Mtleme veel,13
,
. 15 , , .
()

(12 1988.). 15
. ,
, 14 1988
. 30 1988 Edasi ,
.
, .
, ,
, .14 14
.
12 1989 .
. . ,
,
.15
1988
. 1989 . :

,
12
13
14
15

.. ? // . 1988,
6.
.
.
. http://ilja-nikiforov.livejournal. com/75 708.html.
12 . 1988. , 1988. . 13.

328

 .
? , .16
,
.
: ,
, ,

, .17
,

. .
.,
, ... ,
.
.
4 1989 14 . 1 .
. . ,
, ,

.18 .
.
, ,
, .
, .
1988 (
16
17
18

. // 1, 115
1989.
12 . 1988. , 1988. . 171
XIY . , 1989.

329

),
().
16 1988 .
.

. , .
, ,
, ,
.
17 1989 ,
, .
, -
, .19 ,

,
.
.
.
.

. . , ,
.. 1989: ..
.20 12 1989
-
, 1940. .
19
20

. , 1989.
. ? // 9. 1990. . 5.

330

, , .
, , .
, ..,
:
- ,
1940. .21
1989 . , , ,
.
.
,
1989 , .

() .
, ,
1988.
(!). 2 1988.

.
23 1988.
, , . 20 1988.
-- . ,
. .
24 1989 .
-- , .
--
:
21

. . .
. ., 2004. . 200.

331

8 1990 .
, , , .
, 7
1990 ,

1940 .22 ,
1988 1990
, .
. 23 1989 ..
. , 50
,
1 ,
600 .
: ! , .
. .
.

. , . .
1940.
24 1989 (),
() ()
().
, , , ,

.
, . ,
17 1940 , ,
22

http://www.peterburg.estemb.ru/pervaja/estonija/
gosudarstvo/newwin/aid-374

332

 ,
. 24 1990 .
.
591508 34345
. 107 ,
104, 70 39.
, ,
. 11 1990.

.
. ,
. .
-
.23
.
,
. ,
.24,25
, :
1. , ,
.. , .
23

24
25

, , ,
, , .
. http://www. russkie.
org/index. php?module=fullitem&id=23970
, .

333

2. , ,
.
3. ,
,


19201940.
, .. . ,
,
19201940.
1990.,
(. . ,
) . ,
.26
23 1990

. 8 1990
.
1990 . .
,
,
, . 1990

, . , - . ,
,
. , 1940 ,
26

: http://www.estonica.org/

334

 , ,
()
().
. , , , ,
?
,
.
,
.
1990
.
, , . 1990
() .
21 (26 1991) 22 (28
1992) . 22 ()
.
( ). 26 1990
20 , ,
. 1990
() (Eestimaa Kommunistlik Partei). 21
(), 15 1990,
.
, 1991 .
, ,
.
,
,
, -
( ) .27
27

. -: 10 . http://www.wdi.ru/print.
php?art=1697753412-07-2001

335

16 1990
( ) , .
1991
. . 78% .
. , ,
,
.
20 1991
.

de jure, de facto.


.
, 21 1991.
-, ,
,

, .. .28
. ,
1940.

( ) . (
) :
, .29
28
29

, .
// 25 21 1991.

336

24 1991 . 6 1991 .
17 1991 .
20 1991.

10 .
28 1992.
7 1992 . :
: 1990 . .30
, 1991, 1992
ad integrum .31
.
1. , 1987
1992,
. , , .
2. , .
, - .
3.
.
, , - ,
.

30
31

40.19 1992.
restitutio ad integrum .

-
:

,

.

,
, ,

. ( , ) ,
.
,
1917,
19411945 ,
() , .
338

, ,
: , , .
,
; ,
. , ,
,
. , .
, ,
, ,
, , .

,

.
()
, .

.
, ,
.1

,
, .
1

. .: . . . 1. ., 1994; . . --,
1954; RimschaH.Ruland jenseits der Grenzen 19211926. Ein Beitrag zur
russischen Nachkriegsgeschichte. Jena, 1927; Volkmann Hans-Erich. Die russische Emigration in Deutschland 19191929. Wrzburg, 1966; Wrangel v.,
Wilhelm Freiherr. Die russische Emigration // Staat und Volkstum. Bcher des
Deutschtums 2. Bd. Herausgegeben von Dr.K.L. v. Loesch in Zusammenarbeit
mit U.H.Ziegfeld. Berlin, 1926. S. 297310.

339

 , , , .

, . (
,
, , .)

, .
,
,
,
.2
,
. 1991

, 1 1993, .
,

,
. ,
,
, ,
.

, , , , , , , ..,
.
2

., .: SafranW.Diasporas in Modern Societies: Myths of Homeland and

Return // Diaspora. V. 1. 1. 1991. P. 8399; Sheffer G. Ethnic Diasporas: A Threat to Their Hosts? // Inter-national Migration and Security / Ed.
by M. Weiner. Boulder, San Francisko, Oxford, 1993. P. 263286; Tllyan
Kachig 1996: Rethinking Diaspora (s): Stateless Power in the Trans-national
Moment. Diaspora 5: 1, p. 335; Cohen, Robin 1997: Global Diasporas: An
Introduction. London: University College of London (UCL) Press.

340


,

,
,
. ,
.3 ,
, ,4
. ,
,

.
, , ,
,
-.5
,

, ,
,
, , .
,
. ,
3
4

, 2000:
// 3, . 632.
. .: Safran, William 1991: Diasporas in Modern Societies: Myths of
Homeland and Return. DiasporaV. 1, 1, p. 8399; Tllyan Kachig 1996:
Rethinking Diaspora (s): Stateless Power in the Trans-national Moment.
Diaspora 5: 1, p. 335.
Glick Schiller, Nina, Basch Linda, Blanc-Szanton, Cristina 1992: Transnationalism: A New Analytic Framework for Understanding Migration. In: Glick Schiller, N., BaschL., Blanc-Szanton, C. (Ed.) Toward a Transnational Perspective
on Migration. Race, Class, Ethnicity, and Nationalism Reconsidered. New York,
The New York Academy of Science, pp. 124.

341

, ,
,
.6

. ,

.

.
,
, .
: ,
,
, ,
;7 ,
,
-, .

- .
,

,

. , 6

Pries, Ludger 2001: The Approach of Transnational Social Spaces. Responding to New Configurations of the Social and the Spatial. In: PriesL. (Hg.) New
Transnational Spaces. International Migration and Transnational Companies in
the Early Twenty-first Century. London. Routledge, pp. 333.
Faist, Thomas 2000a: The Volume and Dynamics of International Migration and
Transnational Social Spaces. Clarendon Press, Oxford.
Faist, Thomas 2000b: Grenzen berschreiten. Das Konzept Transstaatliche
Rume und seine Anwendungen. In: Transstaatliche Rume. Politik, Wirtschaft
und Kultur in und zwischen Deutschland und Trkei. von Thomas Faist (Hg.),
S. 956. Bielefeld.

342


,
( ) . ,
,
. ,
,
( )
( ).
,
, .
, , ,
, , .
. -, ,
. ,
, ,
. -.


, ,
,
1990 .8
8

Glick Schiller, Nina, Basch Linda, Blanc-Szanton, Cristina 1992: Transnationalism: A New Analytic Framework for Understanding Migration. In: Glick
Schiller, N., Basch L., Blanc-Szanton, C. (Ed.) Toward a Transnational Perspective on Migration. Race, Class, Ethnicity, and Nationalism Reconsidered.
New York, The New York Academy of Science, pp. 124; Glick Schiller, Nina,
Basch Linda, Blanc-Szanton, Cristina 1997: From Immigrant to Transmigrant:
Theorizing Transnational Migration. In: Pries, Ludger (Hg.). Transnationale
Migration. Sonderband 12 der Zeitschrift Soziale Welt. Baden-Baden: Nomos

343


, ,
. ,
,
. ,
, , ,
.
,
(social fields), . , ,
, , , ,
.. , , .
,
.9 , ,
,
.10 ,
. (
, -), ( ..)
, , ,
.
, . .

10

Verlagsgesellschaft, pp. 121140; Basch, Linda; Glick Schiller, Nina; BlancSzanton, Cristina 1994: Nations Unbound. Transnational Projects, Postcolonial
Predicaments and Deterritorialized Nation-States. USA, Switzerland, Australia,
Belgium, France, Germany, Great Britain, India, Japan, Malaysia, Netherlands,
Russia, Singapore. Langhorne: Gordon and Breach.
Glick Schiller, Nina, Basch Linda, Blanc-Szanton, Cristina 1992: Transnationalism: A New Analytic Framework for Understanding Migration. In: Glick Schiller, N., BaschL., Blanc-Szanton, C. (Ed.) Toward a Transnational Perspective
on Migration. Race, Class, Ethnicity, and Nationalism Reconsidered. New York,
The New York Academy of Science, pp. 12.
Der-Karabetian, Agop 1993: Vielfltige soziale Identitt als Reflektion der Mod
erne. In: Identitt in der Fremde. (Hg.) von Mihran Dabag und Kristin Platt.
Bochum.

344

) .

.
) , ,
,
.
, ,
.
,
,
.
, , , ,
, , .
) , , , , ,
,
.
) , , .
, ,
.11 ,
. , (
) .12
,
( ), 11

12

(Basch, Glick Schiller, Blanc-Szanton 1994:) Basch, Linda; Glick Schiller, Nina;
Blanc-Szanton, Cristina 1994: Nations Unbound. Transnational Projects, Postcolonial Predicaments and Deterritorialized Nation-States. USA, Switzerland,
Australia, Belgium, France, Germany, Great Britain, India, Japan, Malaysia,
Netherlands, Russia, Singapore. Langhorne: Gordon and Breach, pp. 3035.
, pp. 78.

345

 , . ,
. .

,
( ). , ,
,
,
. ,
, .

.
,
, , : , .
,
. ,
. , ,
,
, ,
13. , , ,
-
;
a priori, , - , (,
) .
, - ,
.
,
, . 13

Anderson Benedict 1998: Imagined Communities. Reflection on the Origin and

Spread of Nationalism, London-New York, Verso.

346

 (transnational social fields), . ,

, .

. -, ( ), -
, . , -
,
, . ,
.
, ,
. ,
,
,
,
.
,
. ,
. , , , .14
,
,
, . , ,
,
, . , . ,
() . , ,
14

Glick Schiller, Nina, Basch Linda, Blanc-Szanton, Cristina 1992: Transnationalism: A New Analytic Framework for Understanding Migration. In: Glick Schiller, N., BaschL., Blanc-Szanton, C. (Ed.) Toward a Transnational Perspective
on Migration. Race, Class, Ethnicity, and Nationalism Reconsidered. New York,
The New York Academy of Science, p.IX.

347


.
. , ,
,
; , , , .
( )

. ,
( ),
.
, , ( ) .
( ,
) , , ,
.
, .
,
, ()
. ,
?
, .15
,
,

( ). , . ,
15

Faist Thomas 2000a: The Volume and Dynamics of International Migration and
Transnational Social Spaces. Clarendon Press, Oxford; Faist, Thomas 2000b:
Grenzen berschreiten. Das Konzept Transstaatliche Rume und seine Anwendungen. In: Transstaatliche Rume. Politik, Wirtschaft und Kultur in und
zwischen Deutschland und Trkei. von Thomas Faist (Hg.), S. 956. Bielefeld.

348

 Transnational Spaces
: (
) .
. ,
i

(Transstaatliche Rume), .

. ,
,
.
, ,
. , ,

.16 , ,
:
, , (Kollektive),

, , .
, ,
,
. , , , .
, ,
. , , ,
.
-, . ,
,
,
16

Faist, Thomas 2000b: Grenzen berschreiten. Das Konzept Transstaatliche

Rume und seine Anwendungen. In: Transstaatliche Rume. Politik, Wirtschaft
und Kultur in und zwischen Deutschland und Trkei. von Thomas Faist (Hg.),
S. 10.

349

. ,
, ,
, .
,
,
.
, ,
. .
, , ,
(
).
,
, ,
. (Regierten). ,
, ,
200
, ,
- .17
,
.

.
, ,
. (Raum und Ort) , ( ..)
,
. ,
.
, ,
,
.18
,
17
18

, S. 14.
, S. 15.

350

 .
.
,
( ,
, , , , (social fields), ),
, ,
.

, ,
, (,
. ).
,

.
?
, ,
, . ,
.

, ,
,
. , ()
. ,
, . , .

? ?
, . , 351


, .

. ,
.
,
,
19. ,

,
. ,
. () . .20
, .
,
, .
,
-
( )
, , ,
.21

, -
. .

, , ()
19

20
21

Thomas, Alexander 1993: Psychologie interkulturellen Lernens und Handelns.

In: Thomas Alexander (Hg.): Kulturvergleichende Psychologie. Gttingen,
Hogrefe, S. 380.
, 2006: . , 20002005.
, .
Assmann, Jan 1988: Kolleltives Gedchtnis und kulturelle Identitt. In: Assmann
& Hlscher (Hg.). Kultur und Gedchtnis. Frankfurt am Main. Suhrkamp.
S.919.

352

 ()
, .22
,
.
. . ,
(, ,
, ..)
,
.
,
,
, (,
) . , ( ) ,
, , ,
.23
, ,

, .
-
,
. , ( 1990),

.
,
22
23

, S. 15.
Rosaldo, Renato 1994: Cultural Citizenship and Educational Democracy. In:
Cultural Anthropology 9 (3), pp. 402411.

353

 , ,
,
. ,
,
.
.
( ) , . . ? , ,
- ( )
.
. ,
, ,
.
, ,
.

,
- , , . ,
, ,
, ( )
,
.
- :

, - , ,
354

 -
.
1.-
,
. , , .
, , ,24
. , .25 ,
. ,
.
- (,
) .
2. - :
2.1. ;
2.2. , , (, ,
), ,
. ,
( ),
.
,
,
,

. -
,
;
2.3. ( ) , .
24
25

Safran, William 1991: Diasporas in Modern Societies: Myths of Homeland and Return.
DiasporaV. 1, 1, p. 83.
Tllyan Kachig 1996: Rethinking Diaspora (s): Stateless Power in the Trans-national
Moment. Diaspora 5: 1, p. 1214.

355

, ( ) ,
,
, .
, , ,
. , ,

. ,
, .
3. -

.
,
, -
, ,

. , ,

, ,
( ) ,
. ,
- ,
,
,
.
4. -
, () .
-

,
- .
,

,
356

 , , ,
( )
. , -

, ,
, .
5. -

, . ,
,
- , , ,
.
, - , ,
(),
;
, . , ,
,
. , ()
,
.
()
. 090300687 /.

..

(20092010)

, ()
, . ,
, ,
, , . (, 2008). ,

, ,

, 1990
( 2009: 24). 1990

, .

, .
,
(, 2011: 64).

1990 , 358

 ,
(, 2001), , .
, ,

.
,
, , ,
,
(, 2006: 23).
; ,

.
.
, ,
2010 .
-
. 17 - 10 . 13
14 .
16
30 .
. 900 ,
350 . , ,
55 65, 100
.
,
( )
. SPSS.
359

 .
(, ). , , ,
.
,
:
, ()
,
.
() .
, ,
, ,
.
. , ,
.
(
)
.

(68,7%)
. 16 23
77,1% .
23 30
. , 61,8% , . ,
, .
360

 1.
(, %)

69,6

70,0

76,6

57,6

23,8

18,0

18,8

25,8

6,5

12,0

4,7

16,7

100,0

100,0

100,0

100,0

.
, , ().
76,6% .
-
,

. 57,6% ( 1).
,
,
. :
(,
) 75,4 .
(52,7%), ,
.
, ( )
(6,7%),
, , 12,2% 20,5% ( 2).
. .
, 361

 2.
(, %)

52,7

66,7

75,4

35,1

12,8

17,9

12,2

20,5

6,7

100,0

100,0

100,0

,
.

58,9% . 16 23 65,9% .
23 30
( 52% ).
. 65,6%
.
(62,5%).
- , 51,7% 51,1% .
, , ; ,
, , , ( 3).
,
. 65,5% .
61,8%.
(55,8%),
( 4). , 362

 3.
(, %)

62,5

51,7

65,6

51,1

32,7

37,9

20,4

38,9

4,8

10,3

14,0

10,0

100,0

100,0

100,0

100,0

4. (, %)

65,5

61,8

55,8

30,9

25,5

34,6

3,6

12,7

9,7

100,0

100,0

100,0

, : ,
.
,
.
, ,
,
. ,
, ,
.
363


, 55
65, ,
. , 38,2%
. 43,6%
, 23,1% 33,3% , . 57,6%
.
33,3% .
, , , .
20%
, 66% . ,
. ,
, , , ,
.
, , , ,
(26,1%).
.
, , ,
, ,
.
, , , ,
.
()

(12 ).
364

 5. (%)

12

36,4

27,2

35

19,2

26,7

6,7

16.0

37,7

30,1

100,0

100,0

36,4% . (35) 19,2%

( 5).

. 60,3% . ,

(21,3%) (8,8%). ,
7,9%
, .

, , , ,
, ( , ..),
. ,
, , ,
.
. ,
, , ,
,

( 6).
365

 6.
(, %)

64,1

30,8

6,8

7,7

3,8

10,2

12,8

53,8

73,5

10,3

11,5

8,2

2,6

0,0

0,7

2,6

0,0

0,7

100,0

100,0

100,0

(12) (35). 27,2 26,7

, ( 5).
, ,
. 44,2
. , ,
. ,
. 29,1 .
.
(19,9%) .
.
, (12 ) ,
366

 7.
(, %)

44,4

23,5

25,6

27,8

11,8

20,7

19,4

52,9

48,8

2,8

2,9

0,8

0,0

0,0

0,8

5,6

8,8

3,3

100,0

100,0

100,0

, ,
(35).
, : , ,
,
.
, , ,
, , ,
, , .
, , , .
, , .
,
(48,8%),
.
367

 8.
( , %)

12

10,3

40,0

35

7,7

10,0

15,4

10,0

66,7

40,0

100,0

100,0

9. ( , %)

2,6

30,0

0,0

5,0

71,8

50,0

17,9

5,0

0,0

5,0

7,7

5,0

100,0

100,0

38,2%
. (66,7%), , , ,
,
.
20% , 40%
.
( 8).
368


. , , 17,9%
.
( 9).
,
.
.
,
. , (
)
, .
,
.
, .


, , ,
. ( 10).

(75,7%). -, ,
, ,
, , . ,
. ,
,
, 57,7% , 40,9%
, ,
.
369

 10.
( , %)

75,7

74,8

18,0

21,8

11,3

18,9

5,9

4,4

5,4

8,3

4,6

3,4

2,5

2,4

20,9

10,2

5,4

4,4

(18% ),
,
.
, , ,
,

.

,
,
.

( 11), ,
,
370

 11.
( , %)

76,9

69,4

76,9

50,0

76,9

84.3

10,3

16,7

3,8

2,9

4,8

4,1

14,3

8,3

0,0

0,0

0,0

0,0

0,0

2,8

3,8

2,9

0,7

0,8

0,0

0,0

7,7

17,6

0,7

3.3

5,1

2,8

0,0

0,0

0,0

0,0

2,6

0,0

7,7

14,7

10,9

4,1

5,1

0,0

0,0

11,8

6,1

3,3

, .

(74,8%). 52,8%
, 42,2%
. ,
, .
, ,
, ,
.
, (21,8%).
. ,
18,9% ,

371

 , , .1 ,
,
.
( 11).
16,7% 8,3%
( 11),
,
, .
50%
, , , - .
17,6%,
, .
, ,

- .

(97%) .
,
(78,6%).
-
.
, , , , ,

(, 2008).
1

: http://soderkoping.org.ua/
page11392.html

372

 12. ( , %)
, , ?

0,3

3,1

73,3

50,3

12,9

23,1

3,7

2,9

13,2

10,9

12,6

10,9

3,2

2,3

15,5

6,3

11,2

15,7

,
,
.
,
.

.
73,3 . (
, , ),
(..
). , .
373

 13. ( , %)

64,9

74,5

76,9

74,5

75,9

38,7

13,5

14,5

0,0

1,8

1,0

2,8

2.7

3,6

5,1

10,9

0,0

18.9

2,7

0,0

2,6

3,6

3,6

6,0

0,0

5,5

0,0

0,0

0,0

3,7

9,5

1,8

7.7

3,6

5.6

7,8

6,8

0,0

7.7

5,5

13,8

22,1

13,2, 12,9 12,6 , ( 12).

,
.

( 13), , , .
13,5% , ,
,
,
. ,
( 11).
, ,
,
( 5,1% ).
374


50,3%
( 12), ,
39,1% ,
.2 ,

, . 23,1% ,
, ,
. ,
,
, (
), .3 .
, 10,9 . , . ,
,
. ,
,
, , ,
.
(74,5%) (74,5%)
( 12), , ,
-
.

(14,5% ), ,
. ,
( 11), 2

,

.
.
: http://soderkoping.org.ua/
page11392.html

375


, .
10,9% ( 12) .

. ,
,
, 38,7%
( 12). , 18,9%
, .., ,
. , 22,1%
.

(79,4%)
. 20,6 . (68,3%)
.
28,3%.
,
,
.
, .
.

,

. , ,
,
. ,
.
376



. , ,
, ,
(, 2010).
,
. ,
.
,
, . -,
, . ,
.
,
. ,
,
, .

,
,
. ,
,
.
,
. , , ,

(, 2008). ,

.
, , .
377



( : ), 09-03-00 687 / . 20092010.
:
1.. . / .
.. ., 2001.
2.. // -: . . 2009.
3... : ( , 19922002). ., 2006.
4... // weekly. 355356 (2008): http://
demoscope.ru/weekly/2008/0355/tema01.php.
5. . . //
weekly. 355356 (2008): http://demoscope. ru/weekly/ 2008/0355/tema04.php.
6... // weekly. 355356 (2008): http://
demoscope.ru/weekly/2008/0355/tema05.php.
7..., .. : - // . 5. ., 2011.
8... // :
. , 2010: weekly. 455456: http://demoscope.ru/weekly/2011/0455/analit02.php.

..

...
1812:
. ., 2012

, . .
. , ,
. .
, : , .
, .
,
.
. ,
, .
, ,
1812, , ,
mainstream academic society.
. , ,
.
. , .
, , , .
, : . , , ,
, .
379

 , , , ,
,
, , ,
, , ,
. ,
200 1812,

homo consumeris homo sapiens.
. ,
, ,
. , .
.
, ? ,

, , .

,
. ,
, , ,
, , , . .
, ,
, . ,
.

,
.
1812 . .
. 1
1

LievenD.Russia against Napoleon. The battle for Europe, 18071814. Penguin

books. 2009.

380

 , .
: , ,
,
, , , ,
.
,
,
1812, .
. .
. , , ,
, .2
. .,
XIX , .
.
, , , .

, , .
.
, , ,
, , ..
, , . .
.
, ,

. , ,
,
. , I
(!) .
2

.. 1812. . ., 2012. . 1213.

381

 .
,
,
, .
, .
,
.
,
. .
, , .

. , , . ,
. 1991 .
1917. , , .
, ,
, , , , ,
, , , . . ,
, . .
,
.

? (
: , ,
, , , , , ?).
: ,
. ,
, ,
,
,
382

, . , ,
I. scholar society. ! Vow!
Mein Gott! , parbleu!

,
, , , ,
. , ,
, , ,
. ,
, . , , .
.

.
:
I , ,
, : , ,
, , .
, ,

, , ,
.
, ,
, ?3 ,
: , ..
100
.
. ,
.
3

. . 67.

383


principium comparationis. ,
- XIX ,
. XVIII
,
.
, , , .

. ,
( ),
,
. . I, ,
.
, .
, , 1789 1815.,
, , , ,
.
, ,
. , .
, . ,
. ,
, I 1816., , :
4. 13 (25) 1814. I
, 5.
4
5

. . .
. ., 1889. . 134.
XIX XX.
. . 1. 18011815. . 7. 1813.
1814. ., 1970. . 692694.

384

 6.
?
, .
.
. , ,
. ,
.
; ,
7.
,
, , ,
I
8. , ,
,
I, .
, ,
, , ,
,
, , , , , .
, . , , . ,
XIX,

.
, . , , .
.

6
7

... ., 2004. . 328.

.. , 1 1815 // ,
. , 1894. . 15. . 72.
... . . 17.

385

 ,
.

9.
, . , ,

I. ,
.
, , .

1812. , ,
, .

. . 138188.

. . . . ., 2005. 224 .; ...

(1914 1917.). ., 2003. 432 .; ...
(19141917). , 2004. 472 .

, , -
. ,
( ) ,
. :
, ,
. . ,
, ,

, .

, ,

Sanborn, Joshua. Liberals and Bureaucrats at War // Kritika: Explorations in

Russian and Eurasian History 8, 1 (Winter 2007). P. 14162.

387

 2. ,
, .
,
, ,
3.
, , , ,
.
, ,
,
. ,
, ,
. ,
2

MichaelT.Florinsky. The End of the Russian Empire. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1931; William Ewing Gleason. Alexander Guchkov and the End
of the Russian Empire. Philadelphia: American Philosophical Society, 1983;
Pavel P. Gronskii and N. I. Astrov. The War and the Russian Government:
The Central Government. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1929; . . : . , 1936; P. N. Miliukov and Arthur P. Mendel. Political Memoirs,
19051917. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press, 1967; P.N.Miliukov
and Richard Stites. The Russian Revolution. Gulf Breeze, FL: Academic International Press, 1978; Raymond Pearson. The Russian Moderates and the Crisis
of Tsarism, 19141917. Basingstoke, UK: Macmillan, 1977; Richard Pipes.
Struve, Liberal on the Right, 19051944. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1980; ..
: , , . , 1932; Thomas
Earl Porter. The Zemstvo and the Emergence of Civil Society in Late Imperial
Russia, 18641917. San Francisco: Mellen Research University Press, 1991;
Thomas Riha. A Russian European: Paul Miliukov in Russian Politics. Notre
Dame, IN: University of Notre Dame Press, 1969; Melissa Kirschke Stockdale.
Paul Miliukov and the Quest for a Liberal Russia, 18801918. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, 1996.
, : .. . 2. ., 1967; ..IV . ., 1976; .. , 19141917. ., 1967;
. . .
. ., 1967; .., .. . ., 1980; .. 19051917.
. ., 1977.

388

 , , ,
.
, , , ,

(. 11), , .
(. 31) .
() .
, 19
( ), .


, , , ,

.
. ,
. ,
, ,

.
,
.
, ( 1914 1915),
: ,
, : 1915. ,
.
,
, ,
II ,
, 389

 . ,
( 1915 1917),

1915.
1917. , ( 1917),

, .. 2 1917.
,
( ) .

, , ,
.
.
,
1914.
.
1915., ,


. 1916 .,
, , 1
?, 18
16 ,
, .
1917.,
.
,
, ,
.
. 1914.
. 1915.
(
390

 ) , . -
1916 . ?.
(
) ( .),

. , 1917., ,
,
.
,
, ,
. ,

,

/,
-
.
, ,
, , (. 33).
, , ,
, ,
.
,
, ,
.
,
,
, . , ,
, 391

 ,
. , ,
,
. , , , ,
"" " ". "
" " " (. 57).
, 1915 .
. , ,
,
(. 75). ,
1916 . ?,
, , ,

(. 221). .
. , . , ,

,
, ,
.
,

.
,
, , , , . . ,
,
,
.
,
:

392

 ,
, , ,
.
, ,
.
,
, ,
.
.
,
4. , , ,
. , ,
,
, . , , , ,


,
5.
.
. ,
1915.,
, ,
.
, ,
. ,
, () !6
4

5
6

., ,
,
1915.
(Struve, Liberal on the Right, p. 210219).
Stockdale. Paul Miliukov, p. 230.
- . . 3. . 1.
., 2000. . 104.

393

, . ,
, , 7.
, , ,

1915.
,
,
. ,
,

, 8. ,
,

. , ,
,
, . ,

,
,

.
. .
, .
9. , ,
.


7
8

. . 112.
(. 579) ( ) ,
.
,
, . . (
, , (), , ..) (. 9).

394

 .

, ,
.
,
. , ,

,
.
,
, . , ,
,
,
. ,

. , .
. , :
, () (). ,
,
,
.
, , , . 1,
" "
1915., 1916. ,
, 1915.,
,
, .
, ,
..
395

..,
1916. . , 1916., ,
...
: . . .
1916. . ,
" "
.
II. , ,
. ,
. ,
, .
2 , ,
,
, , . ,
, .
,
,
(. 165). ,
,
, ,
: . ;
; ; ; 10.
, ,
. ,
, , . , ,

. ,
, 10

. . ., 1991. . 20.

396

, ,
.
, ,
, ,
,
. ,
, ,
- ,
- .

. , .
,
, ,
. ,
, , .
, , .

.
,
:
, .
. ,
, , ,

(. 18).
,
.
.
,
. ,
( ),
. ,
, 397

 ,
.

.
,
, , ,
.

, ,
II .
,
.
,
.
, ,

, . ,
, (
, ..) .
, II ,
.
,
(
) ,
,
. , - ,
( , ), .
, ,
-.
,
.

398

, . ,
, , .
, ,
,

, ,
. ,
,
. , ,
.
, , -
, ,
. ,
, , .
..
, ,
, , ,
(. 205). , ,
: ,
- . ( :

-, ,
.)
, (, ) ,
, ,
. ,
: , (
399

 ..),
11.
, ,
,
,
, ,
. ,
, , 1917 .
,
12. :
, , .
,
,
. ,
, ,
, ,
, .
,
. , .
.
.
(
, )
, ,
. ,
11

12

. . 250 , 1916: , .
, 2003. . 485487. ,
.

,
,
. .: .., . (19071917). ., 2003. . 191204.

400

 1917.13 .
, (
-
, ,
) (
, , )
. 2,
,
, . 3,
,
.
,
, ,
14.
.
. ,
,

,
200 , . , , . , ,
,
? ,
. , . ,
,
. (. 27),
.
13

14

.: . . . ,
19171939 // . . : , , .
, , 2627 1999. ., 2000.
.358383.
: Michael Karpovich,
Two Types of Russian Liberalism: Maklakov and Miliukov, in Continuity and
Change in Russian and Soviet Thought, ed. ErnestJ.Simmons. Cambridge, MA:
Harvard University Press, 1955, p. 129143.

401

 ,
,
1890 . (. 65), , , , ,
, .
, , ,

, ,
, ,

(. 55). , , ,
.
,
.

. ,
3 1916 .,
, (. 106107).
,
, , ,
. .
, 15. ,
. ,
, ,
, .
, 15

., , , 7 1915 .:
- . . 8991.

402

 .
,
,
,
. , ,

.
, . ,

(. 182). ,
,
, ,
(. 139140).
, , ,
, , , ,
.
,
. , (
). ,
,
, . , , , ,
,
,
.
- .
, , . ,
,
.
:
.
,
(. 173). 403

,

.
,
, ,
, ,
. , . ,
,
, , .
1920 ., : ,
.
, (. 154).
:
.
,
. , .
,
, . ,
,
, ,
. ,
,
, .
,
.
,
,
, , 1905
, , ,
, 404

 .
.

, .
,
, , ,
.
. ,
,
, , . ,
.
: ,
, ,
,
. , , ,

,
.
(. 6467).
, , 16.
,
,
.
, ,
, . ,
,
, .
,
, .
16

.... //
. 1, 19 (1999). . 43.

405

 ,
. ,
, ,
, ,
(Oxford), 17.
, ,
,

, , .
: ,
, II . ,

,
.
,

. , ,
, , ,
. , ,
. 27 1915.,
,
.
,
, .
: 17

. : Simon Blackburn, ed. The

Oxford Dictionary of Philosophy. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1996; John
Scott and Gordon Marshall, eds. A Dictionary of Sociology. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2005; Iain McLean and Alistair McMillan, eds. The Concise Oxford Dictionary of Politics. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2003; A Dictionary
of World History. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2000; Jan Palmowski, ed.
A Dictionary of Contemporary World History. Oxford: Oxford University Press,
2003; and Joel Krieger, ed. The Oxford Companion to the Politics of the World,
2nd ed. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2001.

406

 ,
. , ,
,
. , ,
, , . , ,, , ,
, ,
? 1915. ,
, ,
, , ,
, ,
, (, . 161).
( ,
) ,
. , 3
1916., ?, ,
, 18. ,
,
.
, , ?
,
1916 . , ,
. , ,
. ,
. ,
, . :
: ,
, ,
, ,
, . ,
, .
18

: , 19061917. . 4 . / .
... ., 1995. . 4. . 6367.

407

 , ,
. ? , , , , , ,
, , , , . :
,
: ?
, . (
, . :
!).
,
, .
. 2 [ , ], ,
, . .
. , ,
,
, . , . ,
-, ,
, . ,
, ,
.
, . . , ,
.
,
, ,
. , ..,
.. ,
, , ,
.
,
, . 3 , ,
, ,
.
408

, ;
, ,
(.. ),
(.. ) .
, ,
, , .
, ,
, ,
,
, , ,
.

,
,
,
. , ,
, ,
, , , , . ,
,
. , ,
- .

. ,
. ,
,
,
.
.

. ,
409

 , 19. ,
, , .
. , , ,
.
, .
6 1915.
, ,
.
, ,
, , .
, . ..,
, 1915.,
. , , , ,
, ,
.
,
, . ,
,
.
.
,
( ,
, ), .
,
,
.
,
, 19

Carl von Clausewitz. On War, ed. and trans. Michael Howard and Peter Paret.
New York: Knopf, 1993, 85.

410

 . ,
, 1915.
,
20.
:
.
,
,
(
, , - .).
, , , , ,
,
, .
, ,
, ,
, -
.

, ,
, ,
.
(
..,
)

. ,
,
,
, ,
21.
20

21

. : Peter Holquist.
The Dilemmas of an Official with Progressive Views: Baron Boris Nolde.
Kritika 7, 2 (2006), p. 241273.
: Norman Stone. The Eastern Front,
19141917. London: Penguin, 1998; . ; Thomas Fallows.

411

 , , , . , ,
, ,
, ,
. ,
, ,
,
. , , ( )
,

. ,
,
, ,
1891., . 1908., ,
,
22.

, ,
, ,
, . .
, ,
, . , ,
, (

22

Politics and the War Effort in Russia: The Union of Zemstvos and the Organization of
the Food Supply, 19141916 // Slavic Review 37, 1 (1978), p. 7090.
(4 1908).
//
, 1908. . 3. ., 1988. . 650653.

412

 ) . ,
.., 1915. : , ,
,

, , ,
23.
,

, .
, 24.
, ,
. ,
, , ,

, .
, , ,
.
,
,
, .
. ,
,
,

(. 18). ,

23
24

(). . 1278. . 5.
.205. . 1112.
,
, . ,
, ,
, .

413

 ,


. ,
,
. , ,
.
,
, 25.
,
, XX,
,
. , ,

.
, ,
.
,
. ,
, ,
,
.
.

25

Stockdale. Paul Miliukov.

..

...
.
19141918. , 2010

, ..,
,
.
1955. ..1 , ,
, , .
: ,
, . .. , , , , , , ,
. , , :
( . ..) ,

.

, -, ,
, (. 44). :
1

..- . ., 1955.

415

 .
, .

, ,
, (. 40).

,
, .
(,
, ,
. .). . . ;
.
, ,
, .
, -
( , ,
XVIII 17011870.):
.
( 1906 .)
?
, , , ,
, . (
, .. 1937.:
, 2).
,
.. , 2

. : .
// . . ( . . 17.) ., 2000. . 494.

416

 1917
,
(, ), -
.. -
.
.
/ (,
, .17 1990
2000 ., -
,
.. ..3,
1993 .
, ). ,
,

(. 359). ,
,
(. 366).
1917.
, ,
..
, .
, . ..,
, , , ,
.
, , , ,
,
, 3

.., .. .. ., 1993.

417

 (. 57).
.
, ,
1917
. , ,
.
,
.
, , . 32,
( : ) . ,
.
, (), - ( . 21), , ,
( , )
-, ( , ) ( ).
( . 37).
:
. ( ) ,
.
. . , , .
. 28,
.
,
. ,
(
) :
( , -418

),
.. , ,
.
,
.

(, ,
10%,
).
, ,

.
,

(. 26). ,
, . ,

.
( ). - : ,
(, , , , ).
, ,
,
! ,
( 9,
11 12 ). , 1906. ( -
)
, .. , , ,
, .
, . . . . ,
419

 ,
,
(. 38). ( )
, -
.
.
,

(.34), ..
(.. ..)
( XIX. -).
,
.
, , , .., 19101914. 16 106 .

,
, , , ;
,
. 4 . [. ..]

67 . . ( , 11 . 23
. ). , ,

, , . 11 . .
, 56 ., .
[] , ,
8 12 . 1 . 3 , (3 6 ) ),
7 . 10 .
;
!4 ,
, , 4

... . 19141915. , 1932. . 67.

420

 ( ..),
.

. 35,
.
.. .., . ( -
19021907 . . . )
,
. . 5.
. . 6 ,
- , 19121914. ,
!
- , , 19021917. ..,
. [] ,
, . .
7 41
.., 18991900. , 7 , ,
[. ..] ,
. -
.: ! !
, , !,
[].
8.
, ,
, 5
6
7
8

.. . ., 1988. . 128.
. // . ., 1991. 2. . 92;
3. . 135; 4. . 104105.
. . -
// . 1961. 47. . 5.
.. . (
-) // . 19001920.
. 2. ., 2001. . 7; . 3. ., 2001. . 8.

421

 .,

.
, 1914 .
- (. 42). ( )
, , :
. , ,
: .. , ,
, ,
, (. 25). ,
,
. : , .24, .. ,
(
. . .)
.
,



(. 67).
: 19141917. , .
, ,

(. 42). . , . 67, ..
, ,
, , 19141917.,
.
;
. , ..422

 20 . ,
, .. 70 ,
9.
;
, , / ..
(
) , 1920 .
. [] ,
,
1929.
- 10.
1914 .

, 1914 .
. :
) )

(
, ). ( 1914.
). .
.
, , , ,
, . .
, , .
.

9

10

.. 19141918. . 1. ., 1938. . 24;

. .
. ., 1974. . 167.
. . 33 987. . 1. . 681. . 105.

423

, ,

.

1914 1924. ..:
, ,
.
( ,

. ..) 11. ,
,
. ,
,
.
, . . ( . . , 2 . 4, )
... ,
1912. (, 1881. -), ,
, ,
, , , , . , 20 .,

, ,
,
(
- .., 1907.,
-
, , , ). , , , ,
11

. // . .V., 1924. . 193.

424

 "",
, , , , 12.
, , .., ,
. , .. .. , 1914.

, , .
, , ,
: , , .. , ,
13.
, 1914.
;


1914. (
80 :
). .
, ,
, , , , (-)
. .. , ,
. , , , 1915.
- 2

12

13

. //
. . 188; . // . . 273;
. // . . 317.
. // . .V.. 193.

425

 (- ) 26 1914., 14.
( -, ).
, 4 ,
.. ,
( 300, , ,
) .

2 ..,
200
. ,

, , .
..
500. ,
,
, , .
, ,


1914,
, 137
35 ( ) 15 . (, , ),
.. 10 15,

. ?
14

15

.. . 19141917.
, 1931. . 1425.
. . 13/26 15/28 1914. // - . - . . 3. ., 1920.

426

 ,
( !) .
, , ,
, ...
10 - ...

27 ,
, .
, . , , ,
27 ,
.
- 4
105
, .. .
27 7

, 108

. 18 ,
,
106
.. .
, ( ,
27 , )
. . , 1914 -.

( ) 20 , - ,
81
21 . . . 427

 ,
,
( ), .
, - 2
..

. ,
, 16.

7 - 1 . ,
, -17, .
, ,
, , , .. ,
.
,
, .
, , -
. , , 2 1914.
,
, , ,
,, , , 1935
:
, ,
, ,
16
17

, . // 191415. 44. 20 1915. .87.

- 2. 7 - //
. 1968. 91. . 37.

428

 6 ,
. ,

..- 2
, 26 , 7 ,
!
( ), , , ,
( 7 ),
( )
, ,
,
( ),
, ,
. ,
, ,

, 1914 7 (
- )
.
, ,

, , (22 1914. , - ), . ,

9 13 -
..
( , , ,
, , ), ,
, .
, 1935. 429

 ..
,
,
18. , 24 ,
, , .
,
(21
) . 19,
.
, 6 ..
.
,
, ,
, . ,
, . ,
,
, . ,
,
,
- 1914
1914
. .. ,
, ?
,
. , ,
- ..
- 1
(- )
2020 (
18
19
20

. . 19141920. ., 2007. .1921.

- .
. , 1959. . 2627.
.. 1914.
(13 ). , 1940. . 6975.

430

 )
. 137 ,

( 10 . . ) , 21.
(
10 )
? , , .

, ,
, . 105
, ,
,
. ,
, ,
. , 27 - ..
: [] , ,
22. ,

( ), 27
. , 108
, 107
13 -
21 ,
. 2 4
, ( 21
22

. : .. . . 28.
. 27 . 4 (17) 1914.
7 (20) //
. . VIII. , 1926. . 169.

431


..), ,
, 23.
6 2 ..,
6 . . .
, (. ) ,
,
, ,
,
7 16 (14 4
, ).
3
1 ..,
8! , ,

, , . (, ),
3 ,
, ,
, ,
, : . ,
16 ( - ), 3 , ,
,
,
!
1 ...
, 1912.
.. , 24, 23
24

- . . 26.
.. . . 8.

432

: (sic!) 56% 1914

(9 16)

. 81
( ) 2 ,
: .
, , :
. ,
. . -
...
,
. ,
( , 5 ..25)
67%.
, ,
.. ( ,
) 1 - ,

. 1 ,
, 26,
10 3 ..
1 ,
. ,
1915 4 -
(1914. -) .. ,
; ,

, , , .
, ,
25
26

. // . 1967. 84.
. : .. 1914. . . 79.

433

 27 ( , - ), .


. ( , -
1 24 6 ..

, . -
2
25 7
.. , .) -
- .. ( 23 , , , ,
)
..,
, .
- 1
..,
, 26 ,
,

,
28 27

28

. 1914 . . , 1936; - 2. 7 -
// . 1968. 91; ,
. //
191415. 44. 20 1915.; . . (1914.) // . 1962. 5455;
.-
19141920. , 1932.
, . // 19141915. 44. 20 1915. .87.

434


( ).
.
,
6 (
. . - 2, 27 ,
7 ,
2 ).
, ,
.
21 6 , 10 . -,
,
.. (
1 ,
).
. . ,
.. (, ,
)
, ,
. -
106 , ..
. , 1 , ,
.
(
. ,
29) ,
,
. 5
2 ... 29

.. 1914 .
. , 1926. . 147.

435

 27

( , , , ) .
,
27 . , ,
, ,
( )
.
.
, 4 6. - ..,
4 ,
,
. , , 30
,
, 35
, , 1914
( ..) .
; 10 -
.., 11 ,
,
, ( ).
,
.
..31
195 49
30

31

. 27 . 7 1914
( ) // .
1931. 8. . 22.
.. . (18111920). , 2000. . 85.

436

 1920 1914. 19
700 ,
, .
20 3
,
- .. , , .
, ,
. . ,
..
13 - ,

3 .
, , 25
1914., ,
. , , , , , . 5 .. (
) ,
.
119 30
,
( )32.
, 4 16 106
. . :
, ,
..33.
,

6
2 15 .
,
, ..
32
33

. 119 // - . 2004. 2 (4). . 21.

... . . 29.

437

 .

, , ..34,

, - . 13 1914. 3
,
12 12 .. , ,
, 35.
,
. - .. - ..
2 81 21 20 1914 .
( ,
). 2 , ,
; ,
,
(). ,
( ) :
,
.
, ,
, ,
( ).
, :
,
. ,
34
35

. . 191418. . 1. .;
., 1930. . 31.
.. . 1914 //
- . 1950. 6. . 4.

438

 ( ).

,
( ) :
, . ( ) ,
,
. , ,
,
( , ) ( ).
2 1 ,
.
( ,
, )
. 2 4
,
:
( 1 ) ,
2. 2 ,
. ,
,
. ( ) 4 3, 4
. ,
, ,

:
,
( . ..) 36:
36

. : .. 1914. . . 190.

439

 ,
.
,
. ,
;
,
2 .
1
, ,

4,
( 1 ).
,
( 4
,
, :
).
, , ,
, ( ), .

:
( ,
),

1914 ,
- 37.
,
. , 7 -
..
. 23
,
, , .
37

. . (1914.) // . 1962. 5455.

440

 , , , , .
,
, ,

, , , . ,
. (18 ,
, , ,
5
2 - ... ,
,
.)
, , , 1914
. 6 , 10 23
24 6
, 100200 (
1912), 300400
, .
45 12 ,
15 ,
. (, ,
, , .
,
) , 1914
.
..,
.
1914 441

 (
, ..
..), .

. .
.. .., 106
27 , (, ,
)38.

, - ..
99
25 - .. 39.
118 30 - . . , (
) 1915
.
,
,
40.
, ,
(
). ,
!
- 2
, - 27 , 14

38
39
40

... . . 32; .. . . 22.

, . // 191415. 44. 20 1915. .88.
.. .
1915. .,1940. . 46.

442

 22 -
,

( )
-
..: , ,
,
, .
- 2 - . .
, ,
, ,
41. , , , ,
( , )
1914 -
13 - ...

. ,
... , , ,
6
2 ,
19151917. ... , () ,
.
,
42 13 - ,
..,
, ,
43.
, 1 .. 21
41
42
43

. ... // . 1935. 141142. . 34.

. . . 3132.
.. . . 8.

443

 ,
3 . . ,
,
, !

1914. 115 29 . 6 -
,
29 25, ,
- ,
...
?
, ,
. , 29 -
.. ,
, , .
, , ,
44. 105
,
( ) 27 - . . . , , ,
45. 27 108
: , 1915.
(
. . ),
,
( )46. 40 10
1915.
44

45
46

-. 29. . ( ) // . . VIII. , 1926. . 229.

.. . . 169.
... . . 9.

444

 3 ,
47.

, . 4 160 40
.. ,
30 ,
, ,

(
40 )48.
(
).
.. 2 147 37 ,
(- , )
, 49, -.


,
-, ,
1914. () , ,
1914 ,
. , .
,
47
48

49

. 40 // .
1960. 41. . 8.
, .
// 191415. 36. 25 1915.
. 70; . . (
. ) // . 1964. 456. . 14.
... // . 1966. 78. . 4.

445

 II III 1907. 100 .., , , ,

,
, , .
50. , 1914,
.
, ,
, , ,
, ... 56
1914. ,
1160 . 1 ..
(20 )
(!)
. 2 -
.. , 2 ,
, ,

. , , .
95% 1914
,
, 1914. . ..
,
, (
, )51.
:


( 50
51

. // . 1964. 67. . 11.

... . . 1. . 24.

446

 ), ,
(, , 1914.
) . ( ..
).
, ..
, , ,
, , , ()52.

. -
1 2 - . 4 , 1 , ,
105 1 , . .

, (
). 2 14
. .

1 , - .. (-
3 ), .. (1 1 )
.. (4 ) ,
.
; 53.

1914
-
4, 5 9 - .
4 20 . - 1 52
53

.. . . 4. ., 1994. . 176.
. 2
() 1914. ., 1936. . 186.

447

 ..,
, (17 800
) ( .
..), 114,3
10 54. ,
, -
- .. 3 ; 81 21 - .., ,
,

9 - 2 -
.. 26 82,8,

1914
.
160 40
..
30 .
(
,
)
,
,
.
, , . [] , , 1920. ...
:
55. - .. 1923 ,
54
55

, . // 191415. 44. 20 1915. .86.

.. . . 34.

448

105 27
( 4 1914.) 183 46 ( 13 )

(
56). , , . , 1919. 27 ..-57,
, (
) .. 3
,
. 4,
( , , , , ,
). 2

, , ,
,
40 ,
(, ). , ..
, ,
, , 58. ,
2 46 .. (
), 46 ..
(
) 56
57

58

. : . . . .,
2009. . 360.
-. III 4/17 1914. // - . -
. . 1. ., 1919. . 8285.
.: . 2 46 . , () 13/26 1914. (
, ) // - . . 1. . 5761.

449


( )
.. 9
3 . ,
,
( ) 13 1914 ., ; ,
(.. ). ,
,
; , , (
) 4 , .
15 1914.
, 137
35 ..
,
, (, , )
.


5 - ( ) ..59. , ,
,
7 (
)
. 26
. .
27 . . ,
1315 ,
( 28
..). 13

59

.. . ., 1933. . 50.

450

 , 5
, :

- .. , 20 . , ,
60,
10
1415 . ,
38 . .
,

(
,
10 ).
, 37
.. 15

, , ,
, , , ,
,
. , ,
. , , , 1 4 2 - ,
. .
- 61,
, .. .., .
(
) , , 25 1914. ,
13 4 .. ,
60
61

. 27/14 28/15 . 1914. ., 1926. . 28.

.. . 1914. ., 2006.

451

 27 , ,
, , 14 , (,
). 15
..
( )
,
( ). 27 3
.. 1 ;

.. ..,

,
-
4 9 - , . ( 20 ), -
..
; . - 1 - ..
2427 ,
, . 2
- . .
26 ,
, -
2 - ..
24 !
,
, :
,
, .
, ,
,
, ,
452

(
). ,
.
, 1 - .
115 29
4
; , ,
105 27
. . . 107
..
, 8 .

26 ;
103 ..
2628 .
68 - 17 ..
. 3
-,
.
. 195 49
..,
, , 20 1914. , .
,
1
1 ...
(:
) 62
. . ,
62

.. 1 1914 // . 1959. 35. . 16; 36. . 2; 37. . 8.

453

 81 21
20
63. , 2 ( 5 )
, - .. .
2
.., 2 .

29 64.
. .
.
. . ,
13 ,
( ), .
:
. . , ,
; - . . ,
, , (,
); - ..,
,
, . - . . ,
6 ,
, , -
1315 6
2 .
. . ,
21 11 (
-). 63
64

.. . 34.
. (29 . 1914.) // . 1964.
34. . 9.

454


. 14
40 10
. .

( ).
- ..
,
,
, .
1914

: -
. . - 1914.,

. , ,
, (
, , , .).

! ,
(
1912.), , . 65. , ,
-
1914 . , . . ,

,
;


66.
65
66

. . ., .,1926. . 208209.
... . . 248249.

455

 . - : 9
. . , 13 ,
5 3 .
- - . .
20
5 6 - 1 , , . , , ,
.
-
-- , 137 ..,
,
, ( 15 ) 4 35
.
1914
,
- .
27 1 ( )
106 ..
5 27 ,
- . 105 ,
.. 1 27
. 6 2 :
10 21
.. ,

. - 1315 23
.. (
- 24 ) 456

 2 6
, (,
14
, ,
). 2 - , 11 , 2 1
.. (
)

, 30 40 . ..

,
. . .
(
), (.. ,
, ).
67.
, ,
.., ,
, ,

, 68.
,
1914 .
, .. ,

, , . ,
69. ,
67
68
69

.: .. (19001917.). .IV..,
1948. . 109110, 410, 412.
. // . . VI. , 1925. . 70.
.. . .IV.. 186.

457

 ...
, , 19 ,
13
, , 68 - 17
149 150
38 : .
, ,
, . ,
5 17
;
... ,
, ,
, ,
: ?

70.
(
, , 1 38
, . .
).
, ,
.
,
: ) - ) .

70

.. 19
2627 1914. // . 1935. . .7576,
81, 82, 84.

458

 1914
. ,
. . (
), , 20 ., . . : - ( . ..)

71. ,
, () , 1914.
- -
.., ;
,
[] 72. : (..
, , .
..), ,
( . ..) .
,

. , , ,
,
.. , :
19141918.

, []73.
, ,
511 71

72
73

.. . . 3. ., 1994. . 139; . .
.150.
. : .. (19001917.). .III.
., 1949. . 293.
. . . 157; . . .IV.. 62, 63, 122.

459

 .. (-), 74.
, 20 . .., 1914
.
-
. . , ,
1914. ;

( , ). ,
75. ,
, ,
:
;
,
,
. 3040.
: ,
, []; . (,
)
( , :
, 8
1914 . ,
)76.
..
74
75
76

. // . 1956. 21. .8.

. . . 157; . . .IV.. 63, 94, 151152.
.. . .III. . 100, 301; .IV.. 122,
137, 153, 412.

460

 . ,
, ,
,
.
:

.
,
: , , ,
,
. :
( ,
.. 19141915. ..) . , ,
,
: , ,

(. . . ..)
77!
. ,
. ,

.
.
. ,
.., ,
, (
. ..) ,

; 78. , 87
77
78

. .III. . 284, 299, 301; .IV.. 123, 412413.

. .IV.. 182, 186.

461

 35
25 27 ,

25 27 .
60. 6 27 .. ,
105 27
100 25 .
, 27 25 ..
( , , 97
,
). 40
, 118
30

13 , . ,
1738 1 38 5
17 ,
:
,
(

)79. 14 (
) 1178 , 2527
: , 11 78 93 ,

. 1 2 52 .. .., 22 , - ,
( ) ,

4 5
-
79

.. 19
2627 1914. . 81; . . . 54.

462

 - . 13
15 1617 13 -
. ., 13 15 80.
25 / -
3 / 1 , 17
- . . .
81,
, ,
, .
27
26 ,
2 26 ,
1 (, ). 2
82, ,
1

83. 1914., ..,
, ,
. ,
,
80
81
82

83

. : .. 1914.
.1. - . .; ., 1929. . 211.
. . // . . , 1930. . 12.
.. . 26
1 2 - . ( ). .,
2009. . 3940.
.. . .III. . 97.

463

 ( . . .)
84.
,
. , , - :

85.
6 ( ,
10) 1
;
- 1315 1,
56 6 2 ; 15 41
8
26 (
2628) 2 26 : 13
46 25
, 2 46
( ). -
, ,
17 38 86
,
1914,
, . ,
1914 ,
, ..87.
, ,
,
. , - ,
84
85
86
87

. 10 .
2629 1914. ., 1938. . 103.
.. . .IV.. 186.
. . ., ., 1929. . 114, 117.
.. . ., ., 1929. . 60.

464

17 1914. ( ) 2 2
,
, 12 16 ,
, 3 -
..-
12 24 ,
,
88. (
,
.., 2 -
3 (- ) -.
,
89.)
1914
. , .., ,
19
, 13
90.
, ,
.
( )
, 1914
. ,

88
89
90

, . // 191415. 44. 20 1915. .86.

. // . 1937. 191. . 5.
.. 19
2627 1914. . 82.

465

 3
. . ,
,
91.
.. .., 1914
5 32 - . 13 32
2
32 ,
4

92.
2
52 ..
22 : , ,
, , 93.
7 - 4 -
..-, . . ,
27

94. 6

.
,

( - .. 3 - 3 ),
( 1 6 ..
1 10 ), (..
91
92

93
94

. . .
1914. 1915. // . 1973. 122. . 11.
... - ,

5 // . 1965. 72. . 17.
.. . 1) // . 1964. 68. . 9.
. // . 1958. 33. . 16.

466


21 )95. , ,
. ,
,
8 ,
(6 ).
, 1914. 8 .
,
96. ..:
97.
98. ,
: 1 27
.. ,
/ 17 38
, 13 , /
.
,
.
, 1914 ;


99. , , ,
(

95

96
97
98
99

XV . // . . VII. , 1925. . 277; ...

. . 12; .. . . 5.
. : .. . .III. . 100.
. .IV.. 137.
.
. . 412.

467

 4 2
11
1
23
. . ).

, 4 5 32
. , 1914.

( ),
,

. . 5 .. 13
,
, ,
! .
1914
.
,
. .
, .. , 100.

. - :
1 27
- .. , ( )
,
101. , , ,
.., 27
, .
:
25 . , []
100 ...

. . 61; .. .
. 4. . 231.
101 .. . . 176179.

468

 40 . 102. - 2 15
- . . 15 6 8
15 ,
41
. 10
51 ..
,
202 , 204 - 51 103. 4 -
- .. (
10 -
2 ), - ( 914 ) ,
,
,

104.

1914.
, ..,
. :


.
, 105.

.
- :
102 ..

1914 .
. . 147.
103 .. . .III. . 140.
104 , . // 191415. 44. 20 1915. .86.
105 .. . ., 2010. . 82.

469

2751 ;
10 24
- ... 2
10 6
- ..
70
(, 1913 . 6 , 6,
, , )106 4 -
75 - .., 10 , - , 297 75
(-
), 5 6 . 5
10 .. 14
,
5

10 ,
, ,
,
.
26 ( )

- ..
107
-,

106 .-

1914. -
. ., 1940. . 31; . . . 206.
107 .: , . 2
(89 1914.) // - .
1939. 2. . 115116.

470

 (sic!) .
, -
1914 . , . .
- 1914 .
, .
, .., ,
,
.
,
, , .
, ,
[]
, , 108.
, .., ;
(, 109,

. ..).
. . , , 1914 .
(, . ..) ,
110,
.. ( ).
, .. (, , / ). 1914
..
108 .

// . .V.. 193; . VI. . 68.

109 . . VI. . 63.
110 ... . . 64.

471

 , .. . , ,
111. , 1 -
, .., 4 29 .. , ,
1 112,

,
. 27 -
..,
..-,
,
. 7 ,
,
, 1
:
, , ( )113
17 . 1 (25, 28, 30
40) - . . , . . ,
.. .. . 5 -
, ( ) ,
.
19
13 17 - .. , 38 - ..
114
111 ..
112

. . 4. . 176.
. . . . ., 1996.

.405.
113 ..

// ... . . 28.
19
2627 1914. . 79.

114 ..

472

 . 5 - .., 10
14 ,
, 7 - .. , ,
. 7 ..-115
,
.

( . . ) :
. , 1 - ( ) ; 2
-
15
... ()
, ,
,

, 37
. - , ,
, 41
5 - ()
19
- ... , ,
( 18
- -),
, (
)
115 ..

. . 36, 37.

473


1914. .
..
1914 .. (,
(.. . ..)
116),
.. ( ), (
) . (
. ..)
,

117.
,
: , ,
, , 118.
, 1913 .
, , , . ,

. ,
, 119. 1940 ..: 1914
120. , 19 1914. 4
-
116 .

// . . ( . . 16). .,1999. . 81.

117 .. . . 498, 500.
118 .: .. ,
( , ) // ( ..). ., 2010. . 247255.
119 Drang nach Osten.
. 1913 // . ., 1993. 89. . 15.
120 .. 1914.
. . 8.

474


, . [] ,
,
; , ,
;
, ; ,
121.
3
( 10 - ) ..: [] ,
, .
, , , . [] ,
, ,
. , ,
. []
, .
, 122.
, , ..,
,
, 1914.
, ,
.


1914.
,
.. .
121 .

. 56.
. . . ( 1914
1918.)// - . ., 1992. 11. . 6869.

122

475

 - .., - .. ( -
) ... . , ,

(. 91),
. .
,

! ,
.,
, .. , , .

-
..

10 ... ... ( 1999)1

,

..: 1920 .
, 2010 ,
11 , : ,
- 20,
. , , ,
" ".
.. .
- ..-:
,
,
. 3
.
1

.... ... (
1999) // . .
., 2000 ( ). . 548598.

477

 (),
1 ,
.
.. , 19261929.
. . ,
, (..,
..-, .. .).
, , , :

.
. 1929. .. . , 19301931.
, :

, . .
1929 19301931 . .
: - (1929)
- (.: .
1929, 1011); , , 19301931.,
(.: . .
., 1936)2.
.
..
19361937, 2010.
, - .. ..,
, , .
.
( , , 1930 .,
, 2

.. . . 587588.

478

), ,
,
, 1937:
17 .,
5 .
! ,
, 3.

, .
. -, . .
10, 5
.
1933. , .
5, 1937.
,
, , , . . ,

... , ,
1936 .
..- ,
1933 4.
, .
.. ..-
, 1999 2010: .. ,
.
1946.
3
4

.. 19361937. ., 2010. . 795.

-.. .. //
... ., 1997. .XVI.

479

, .. ..-
, , ,
.., .., , .., .. ..,
,
.

( )
.
.
,

,
.
, ,

. , .

,

- .
250 .. ( ) . ,
.

..

:

(
.)

. ,
, ,
,
, . .
. ,
: ,

.
,
,
,
( ), ,
..
-,
- . .
19411945. (., , , 2007),
, , . 19411945.
. - ...
481

 , ,

-. ,
. ,
.
, . . . , . ,
. . 1. ,
. . 180 ,
25 ( ) ;
. ,
( ). . (
, ) ,
627 , 15
. ( )
, ( ,
) , , ,
.
, .
,
, , , ,
, ,
. , - , .
, , .
.
, .

, ,
.
1

. . ? // . 1992.
11; . . . . .,
1998. . 236265; .. // .. . , 1998. . 42116.

482

( /, ,
, ) 1117
-, 10 ,
.
. -,
( 3011 ). , ,
,
.
.
( ) 708 ,
, .
( ) ,
, ,
. , ,
,
19411945. (, , - ). , ,
. ,

( ,
).
,
:
-88, -109, -126 .. . ,
Ju-88,
Bf-109, Hs-126 .. :
? ? ?
: ( ), .
.
( , ,
)
,
483

 .
. ,
( ,
),
, .
,
.
. ,
, , ,
, (
). , , , ,
. ,
, . ,
(), (), ()
, - ,
.

, ,
,
. ,
. ,

.
. .
, , ,
,
,
, .
,
, . ,
484

 , ,
, ,
.
812 (), ,
, .
.
2. . ,
, (176 )
, : 17,
13, 12+13!
. 16 4.
.
?
? , ( ). , , ,
. ,
.
, ,
. ,
, .
-,
. ,
(, )
. ,
, . ,
(
2

3
4

., . . 812
III // . 1822 (
); . (
1944.) // . 2005. 2. . 2529.
. . ., 2010. . 40, 86, 436.
.. . . 16 .
19431945. ., 2012.

485

). ,
? , , 20+8,
15+8.
( 30+9 28+9)5. ,
? ? ( ) , , ?
? .
.
, -. , ,
63 ,
64. , . , ,
: 11.04.44 -24 -109,
8 .
. 6. :
65 , ,
64. , ,
65. .
-, ,
, . ,
.
12
. ,

, .
, (
, ). ( ,
)
, , ,
5

. 19411945.
., 2007. . 33, 316; . 19411945. . ., 2008. . 32, 393.
. , . 290292, . 240.

486

 .
,
( ),
.
, , , ,
, , .
,
, , , , .
,
,
, .
.

, , , ,
.
: (, , : ) (, )
.
, , . ,
,
.
,
. .

16 (
). (
. . ., Regnum, 2011)
, , .
, . ,

.
, ,
, , . (,
487

) , , .
16
: , , . ( ,
, 59 ,
.)
, , , ,
(
, ).
,
55 /16 20 (),
216 /9 ( ), 6
, 4 : 40, 41, 42, 57, 100, 104, 159,
163 . 170, 484, 494, 979
.
, ( ), ,
. ,
( 16, 100 104 ), ,
16 (, 129 ,
). , ,
, () , ( )
,
(. . , . . , . . ,
.., .., ).
, 33
55 /16 , . 25 . 21 (, , , , , ,
, , , , , ,
, , , , , ,
, , ;
100 ) : , (, ) ,
. ( ),
488


, ( )
( ).
( ,
), , .
75,7% !
33, 34: (. ).
. 45 /100 29
( )
18 , 65%.
298/104 21
13 , 62% ( , 1
). 57 ( ),
(). 82% (
).
, , .
,
. ,
, ( ,
, ,
.), ,
. .
,
, . ,
27 1943. 16 -87
( ),
, ,
97. , ,
( ):
7

. . 16 . . 206868. . 1. . 373 .374; . 3. . 12, 13;

.20046 (9 ). . 1. . 14. . 120.

489



24.08.43
1
-189 .
27.11.43 1
-87
.
04.06.44
1
-190
16.07.44
1
-190 .
16.07.44
1
-190 ..
22.08.44
1
-190
20.02.45
1
-190
18.04.45
1
-190 -.
23.04.45
2
-190 .
10+0
: . . 16 . . 206 869. . 1 ( , 1943.). . 167 .168, 373 .374;
. 2 ( ,
1943.) . 24; . 3 (
, 1943.) . 2, 12, 13; . 206
869. .1 ( , 1944
1945 .) . 612, 18, 19, 2124; . 3 (
, 1944.). . 4041, 80 . 82; . 20046 (9 ).
.1. . 14 ( , 1943.). . 23, 120; . 22 ( , 1944.). . 5556, 104 ., 155155 .; . 36 (
, 1945.). . 98, 217, 231.
,
, , , ,
, ( , )
.
,
(, 16, 100 104 , ),
: ? , ,
, ,
, , .
490

 . ,
( 6065%) . 6065%
() ,
.
, .
, , , , , . , ,
, ,
, .
.
. , , , .
, ,
. , ,
,
. : , .

.
;
.

( -
) .
,
8. , ,
8

, . 16 ( . . . ). ,
. ,
. ,
, .
( , )
. , ,
, . , -

491

 , . ,
( ),
, ,
. , ,
, ,
, ,
, . ( ) ,
, . . , , 7 1943.

(. 120). , - , ? , , (
).
, ,
! (. 16
. . 206 868. . 1 (). . 58.59.)
!
. , ,
, , 26
1943. (, , , . 225),
. (. . 252.253). ( )
( .
).
,
(1 1944.). 6 -
(0258 18.11.44) , , 16 ,
( ), . (.20527 (6 ). . 1.
. 72 ( 6 , 1944.). .265265 .).
. . , ,
. , , ,

(, , ). , ,
, . ( , , ). ,
, ,

492

 ,
, . .
.
,
. .
.
, , , . , ,
, . , , , ,
. ,
, ,
.
, ,
, (, , ) .. , . , , , . , (,
), ,
5 65 ( 64?) , , , , . ,,
: 5 15, 15
30, 30 , , ,
. , .
-, ,
.
, ., .9.
,
, . ,
, ,
, .
, , .
, , ,
() .
,
, 9

, . . .
19411942. ., 2006; . . . 19431945. ., 2006.

493

 . (
), ,
3040% ( ).
,

.
,
, .
, , , (,
10;
, .,
11), , (?) , , .
, ,
, 19411942., . , 16 19431945.
,
, 216 /9 .
1941 ( , ) 1942.
. 1941.
(, -
,
12), 1942.
. , , .
1942. , 16
. , 10

11
12

, , . .
, ,
,
, (
). -126
(24 1942., ), -189 (6 1942., ).
.
( ), . .:
. // .
: . , ?!. //
. 31. . 18.
. . 20076 (20 ). . 1. . 32. . 128, 140.

494

, ,
, . ,
( ?)
- -
13.
, , ,
,
. -,
, . , , () ( ),
,
. ,
, ( , . .). ,
,
, .
,
.
, 16, 42, 57, 100 104 , 1943 . 216 (
9), 68 ,
,
. 30 .
16
, , , , , ,
, .
1944 1945. , .
-, ( )
( ) ,
, ( ). , , , ( )
55 ,
26 1941. .
:
13

. . 20 046. . 2. . 14. . 341341.

495

 1.
55

20

(1941)

(1942)

101

-110

-109

-24 -111

1 ( 14):

22.06.41 31.07.41 ;
16 ;
20 ;
101 101 20 ;
20 (1941.); 20
(22.0612.08.41.).

(,
, ) : ? ?
, -110 109 , -88,
-88 -87, -126 -
. ,
, .
,
, , . ,
16 ( -16),
1942., (, )
, 1941.,
. , , -109
3 (
14

: . . 20076 (20 ). . 1. . 40. . 18; .20214

(229 ). . 1. . 4. . 52, 62. ( ) 216 ; . 20076. . 1. . 23. . 3; . 41. . 3;
.2. . 12, 13; . 4. . 68 .

496

). ,
( ) 20 , 3 55 15.
. ? ,
, -16, , ?
, ,
3 , .
( ),
-16. , , -109
30 ,
.
. ,
, 30 .
, ,
. . , ,
. , ,
.
, ,
?
?
,
?
, , ? ?
,
? ,
, ,
,
-.
, .
,
, 15

. . 20214 (229 ). . 1. . 4. . 53; . 20 076. . 1. . 5. .41;

. 2. . 204. , , ,
. ,
, , 16 .
100 104 ,
.

497

 , ,
:
) ( ,
);
) , ;
) ,

,
(
).
-
.
, ,
, ( ) . , , , ,
.
, : , , ,

(, , ,
)
. ,

.
( ,
..) .
, 100 ,
16 1943. -109
, . . (170) , -109
.
16.
16

. . 100 . . 207 597. . 5. . 1, 6, 8; . 20 046. . 1.

.13. . 199.

498

 , ,
. ( , ?
. .)
. , , , ,
. ,
, .
: . , , ,

,
( , ).
, , , ,
- ()
, .

( ), , .

, , ,
.
( )
. ,
, . ,
, . ( ),
,
( )
, .
, .. .
, , , .
(
) , . ,
499

,
( ) (!),
.
( 1942.)
, 16
17.
, . , (,
) 9 , 6 4 , ,
, . .
(
45/100),
, .
,
, , .
: ,
. , ,
(
). ,
, ..,
. , 438 , 484
( 16 ), 247 .

, ,
, ,

. , ,
, , .
, , , . ,
,
17

. . 319 (4 ). . 4798. . 12. . 107124 .

500

(, )
,
, .
, 18 1943.
-111. ,
[]
. -111
, . 216 ,

- 18.
, , , .
,
-111 . , , ?
. , 216 10.5. 1.06.43.,
,
-111 , 19. ,
, ,
, ( 22 ,
, ).
,
, . ,
, , ,
, .
,
, ,
. .
-88, (16 ) 16 1942. .
:
, . . , ,
.
18
19

. . 16 . . 206868. . 1. . 77 .78; . 20046. . 1. . 13.

. 154.
. . 319. . 4816. . 1. . 159.

501

 ,
,
,
20. , , -88
.
, . ,
9 1943. . -109.
,
, , . ,
:


07.07.42 1/3 -189
16.07.42 1/3 -88

15.04.43 1
-88

20.04.43 1
-109
21.04.43 1
-109 .
04.05.43 1
-109 .
08.05.43 1
-215 .
08.05.43 1
-109 33.7 (. )
09.05.43 1
-109 . .
16.05.43 1
-109
16.05.43 1
-109
9+2
: . . 16 . . 206 868. . 1 ( , 1943.). . 15, 2526, 51, 56 .57,
60 . 61, 64 . 65, 75 . 76; . 2 (
, 1943 .). . 3, 7, 8,
1117, 19; . 3 ( ,
1943.). . 1, 2; . 296 916. . 1 (
, 1942.). . 90; . 20046 (9 ). . 1. . 13 ( , 1943 .). . 117,
20

. . 16 . . 296 916. . 1. . 90; . 20 214. . 2. . 2. .112

112 .

502

124, 125 ., 139, 143, 144, 152152 .; . 20214 (229 ). . 1. . 4

( ). . 53, 65; . 2.
. 2 ( 229 , 1942.). . 112112 .; . 319 (4 ). .
4816. . 4 ( - ).
. 240; . 4798. . 25 ( ). . 89.
, (
16) ,

.
:
-,
(, -126, 5 1941.). ,
() .

, . , ..
( -110 -109 ).
.
, . 13 1942.
-111, , ,

(, , 50 ).
216 ,
, ,
: 700 , 60021. , :
, , 1942.
,
( .
, 45 , ).
, 216 .
, 10 1943 .
( ), -88, 21

. . 100 . . 207 597. . 5. . 6; . 20 046. . 2. . 1. .69

70.

503

 22. ,
, , ,
( , ,
). , .
. , , ,
,
.
. , , ,
,
. ,
, ,
.
( ), ,
, , , .
, ,
.
, . , ,
. , , .
. .
, , ,
, ,

, .
, , ,

.
,
( , ).
.
, ,
, . ,
, , ,
22

. . 20 046. . 1. . 13. . 73, 76.

504

 ,
.

(
),
.
.
,
, .
,
. ,
,
, , ,
.
, , , .
. : , , ,
(0+1 4+). ,

. , (,
, ).
, , (
)
. .
, . , , ,
.
***
,
( 22) 16
. , , ,
. . ,
, ,
( ) .
505

 . ,
. . , 16 ,
. 1943 .
45, ,
. 16 . 45 ( ),
,
.
, ,
17 1943 . , (
16.0016.40) , ,
(

), -87 40 , -109 (
10 ). ,
, 9 ,
. , -87 -109.
, ,
.
: .
, .
-87,
// . ,
, .
, , -109 -//
. . ,
, 9 23. , (. 1).
, 30 1944., .
, -129. , , -88.
,
23

. . 16 . . 206 868. . 1. . 412414; . 3. . 16; . 4. .115

116, 133; . 20 046. . 1. . 14. . 140140 .

506

. 1

,

. ?
, 1944.
( 12.4513.25) -129, .
. ,
-129, , , ,
(
297 427 ),
-88. . ,
. ? 9
, -88, ( -190). ,
,
16, 10 ,
1944., , 30
-88 (. 2)24.
24

. . 16 . . 206 869. . 1. . 2; . 206 874. . 1. . 14; . 3.

. 23; . 20 046. . 1. . 22. . 44 .; . 26. . 39.

507

. 2

508

 , :

45
1943
16
1943 1945

29.08.43
1
-88
-
17.12.43 1 -87
. .
17.12.43
1
-109 -..
30.05.44
1
-88

21.07.44
1
-87
..
25.07.44
1
-190 -.
23.12.44
1
-190
20.01.45
1
-190 .
10.04.45
1
-190 .
9+0
: . . 16 . . 206 868. . 1 (
, 1943.). . 179 . 180, 412 .413, 414;
. 2 ( ,
1943.) . 24; . 3 ( , 1943.) . 2, 16, 17; .206869. .1
( , 19441945.)
. 2, 5, 810, 15, 17, 21, 23, 24; . 206874. . 3 (
, 1944.). . 23; .20046 (9).
. 1. . 14 ( , 1943.). . 28, 140 .; . 22 (
, 1944.). . 44 ., 104105., 120121, 288289, 155155
.; . 36 ( , 1945.). . 31
., 190; . 2. . 11 ( ). .146147,
383383 .
. . - , ,
( ).
, ,
(, ,
., , 509

 ) 25:
27.06.41
28.06.41
02.07.41
07.07.41
21.07.41

1
1
1
1/.
1

-126
-111
-88
-109
-109

, ,
16 (1942.),

20 . ,
.
( ), ,
. ,
, . ( 2).
2

16

20

101

20

20

26.06.41 -23

-109

27.06.41 -24

-24

-88

-24

28.06.41 -88

-88

-88

()
(-88)

-88

-88

02.07.41
03.07.41 -88*

-88*

-88*

07.07.41

-109 .

21.07.41 -109

-109

-109

-109

-109

-109

: * , 2 ,
.
25

., . // . 29. . 10.

510

 ,
22.6.41 31.7.41 ,
55 1941., .
. : 26.7.41 12.40 ( )
-23. , ,
. , , ,
, 25 !
: ,
.
, , ( 29 ): 26
12.40 1 -23 ( ,
). ,
. ,
.
,
, . , .
: -23 -109 ( 101),
, , . ,
,
.
,
55 ( 1941.) , , (
)
-24 . ,
29 26.
: , ? ,
,
.
, ,

( ), . ,
.
26

. . 20 076. . 2. . 3. . 116; . 20 214. . 1. . 4. . 47.

511

 ? . (,
)
. , .
, 29 , .
, : .
, (,
).

.
,
,
. . ,

. , 29 . , ( ) 26
29
. , .
, : ,
, 26 ;
;
, ( 45 ).

( , 10.45 )
-24. ,
( , -88, ).
,
-126, , .
? : , ,
-126 ,
( ).
( -88), ,
, .
, . , ,
512

 16 , , 20 ,

.
( ; ),
.
, (-16
-24). , ,
-88, 101, (, ), ,
.
. () , -111, , , ,
101 -88. , ,
, . 16 :
(, ), .
, , : 101,
-88, 20
-111. ,
(. ).
, ,
, .
.
, , ( , ,
) 20.20. -88
( ) 15.00! , .
, , , ,
(
, 19.00).
3 , .
3 .
, , ,
. , 7

 . 15.00 (-126).
, , -88,
1942.
(
), -109. ( ,
1941.), 7 6.00 - 6 -109, 1 -10927.
(, ) .
, , , ,
1941. , ,
. (, ,
),
.
, -109, 21 ,
.
, , , 6
( ?) .
! , .
:

, 1916

26.06.41 1
-23
27.06.41
1
-24
28.06.41
1
-88

02.07.41
1
-88

07.07.41
1/. -109

21.07.41
1
-109
()
5+1 4 ( -88)
140
: ,
27

. . 319. . 4820. . 2. . 31.

514

 25 1941. ,
.
: . . 20076 (20 ). . 1. . 2 ( 20 ). . 33, 94; . 4 (
20 ). . 16 ., 61; . 23. (
20 ). . 3, 4; . 40 (
55 ). . 18; . 41 (
101 ). . 3, 4; . 20046 (9 ).
.2. . 2 ( 216 , 1942.).
.19; . 20214 (229 ). . 1. . 4. (
16 ). . 52, 62, 63.

 XIII

, ()
, ,
( )
,
,
- ()
,

()
,
. .. (,
)

-

, ()
. .. ()
516

 ,
()
(Jacob W. Kipp) Dr., Adjunct Professor of
History at the University of Kansas, Professor Emeritus of the US
Army School of Advanced Military Studies

()
(Aleksi Mainio)
()

,

,
-
(-)

, . .. ()
(Joshua Sanborn)
Lafayette College (, )
, ()

()


XIII

-
. . , ,
. . , ,

115088, , 2 , 16, . 1, 227
www.ridr.ru

25.12.2012. 6090 116.

Old Standard. . .
. . . 40,95. 500 .
.

-
150049, , . , 97