A Manufacturer’s Guide to
Depyrogenation — the inactivation or re-
moval of bacterial endotoxins — can be
achieved in many ways. The depyrogena-
tion method to be used is determined by
both the physiochemical nature of the en.
dotoxin and the nature of the material to be
depyrogenated. The following feature ar
cle describes the various depyragenation
processes that are currently available; this |
information can help the manufacturer se-
lect the most appropriate process.
uacurers of pharmaceutical products ae responsible
Missive ett recs rnp ren
that tet product wil not produce Tove reactors
shenaiminatredtopatens- Alu potnia yori con
tEminans ot pharmacetcls ean be eter mirobal or monm
Era theone of mon concerto pharaeutal manufiaatrs
'themntconmon andy fart rs potent pen = haste
Mendon
Endotoxin an neprl component of te outer el sure of
gram-negative bacteria (Figure 1). Toe endotoni shed rom
rang beers date rccased mo eewironmen hen
teria de and decompose Hecnusepranenepatie bacteria are
found unversy iar, water ands tation cor
‘mony contaminates the vw ater ana processing equipment
Shed nthe manufacturing of paraneals
nits nar ste, tats endotoin acl that consists
of tc: an pron: th compl acterized
by se nepave charge. ht sab. and hgh molecular weit
‘When ily ports, endxonn aos no ora tia
‘Marlys Wears is manager of microbiologs/psragen technology at
Baxter Healthcare Corporation, Box 490, Route 120 and Wilson
Ra. Round Lake, IL 60073. Frederick Pearson Ill is vice presi
dent of scientific operations at Cell Technolog’, Inc. 1658 Vltec
Lane, Boulder, CO 80301,
*To wnom correspondence should be addressed.
Depyrogenation
Marlys Weary* and Frederick Pearson 111
its chemical composition i referred to as a lipopolysaccharide
(LPS) Depyrogenation can be achieved by inactivating or remo
ing endotoxin. depending onthe physiochemical nature ofthe LPS,
The Physiochemical Nature of LPS
LPS consists of three distinet chemical regions: the innermost ip
1 A. the intermediate core polysaccharide, and the outermost O
Specific polysaceharide side chain that is responsible forthe par
Heularendotonin'simmunospecifiity (Figure 2).
Lipid A. Lipid A is composed af a simple disaccharide of gl
cosamine, winich is highly substituted with amine- and ester
linked long-chain fatty acids (Figure 3). The most common
Aamine-linked fatty acid is B-hydroxymyristic acid. a I-carbon,
Straight chain. Ester-linked faty acids commonly found include
capric. lauric. myristic. palmitic, and stearic acids — thats, stu
‘ated. straight-chain faity acids with even numbers of carbon a
‘om in their chains. The lipid A moiety is responsible for pyroge
icity. as well as for complement activation. B-lymphocyte
mitogenicity. and most ofthe 30-plus other biological activites,
associated with endotoxins,
Endotoxin tends to exist in high molecular weight aggregates
parly because of lipid A’ hydrophobicity. The lipid A component
Of LPS rotates away from the aqueous environment. and bilayer
sheets or vesicles with diameters of <0.1 jm are formed. These
structures apparently ate stabilized by the surrounding divalent,
calcium and magnesium cations that are attracted tothe negatively
charged LPS molecule
Inthe absence of surface-active agents, bacterial endotoxin in an
aqueous environment normaly have meoiecular weights enceeding
1.000.000 daltons. But i the stabilizing calcium and magnesium
ions are removed from the endotoxin’s environment. the bilayers
break down into what seem to be micelles with molecular masses in
the 300,000- 1.000.000 dalton range. Inthe presence of surfaces
tiveagens such as detergents or bile salt, these micelles can be fur
ther broken down to molecular masses between 10,000 daltons and
20.000 daltons. Each stage is completely reversible. Irthe surface
active agent is removed by dialysisand the divalent cations are rein
troduced to the LPS. first micelles ad then membranous structures
reassemble. Below 10,000 daltons, an LPS of irreversile size &x
isis that has no biologial activity (3).Figure 1. Diagram ofa gram-negative cell membrane, including the et
eee
O-speciic
side chains
Upopolysaccharice
Lips
Phosoholipid
Protein
Lpopretein
‘Outer membrane
Perilasmic space
| inner memorane
== Cytooiasm
jotoxin ipopolysaccharide and outer membrane,
Endotoxin can be inactivated by detoxifying or by destroying
the LPS molecule, Endotoxincan be removed froma substance by
‘sing methods based on its affinity for binding 1o various surfaces,
‘or its physical characteristics. such as size, molecular weight, and
electrostatic charge. Some of these depyrogenation methods.
however, are suitable only for materials that can tolerate or con.
form to exacting conditions. The pharmaceutical manufacturer
‘can choose from among the following methods, matching an ap
propriate method to each product.
Inactivation of Endotoxin
‘Acid and base hydrolyses. Depyrogenation by means of alkaline
‘or acid hydrolysis inactivate lipid A and thus effectively reduces,
‘or eliminates the biologic activity of LPS. Lipid A is linked tothe
core polysaccharide by 2-keto-8-deoxyoctonie acid (KDO), an
cight-carbon sugar acid that is unique wo bacterial LPS. Acid hy
drolysis acts on the acid-lable ketosidic linkage to separate lipidspecie core
posacenarde | —potsacchaide upen
Region! Regontt Regn
Figure 2. Geneva structure of a tipopalysaceharide: i=
Polysaccharide chain, common polyeac-
Id A toxic egion, Reprinted trom Aseptic
lf amaceutes! Nanaia cureay et ester
Pr
{A from the remainder of the LPS molecule. Because the released
KDO and its atached core polysaccharides act as solte carriers
for the molecules lipid portion, the free lipid Ais insoluble in
squcous systems and is pyrogenic activity is reduced or elim
nated. Galanos etal. demonstrated. however. that when fee lipid
‘A was combined with bovine serum albumin. the pyrogenic
‘equaled that of intact endoconn (3). Acid hydrolysis also my act
‘on the lipid A fraction. altering the molecule’ conformation and
‘masking necessary functional sts, or st may cleave off fatty acid
‘molecules at different rates, further affecting lipid solubility and
thus pyrogenicity. Acid hydrolysis, using 0.08 N HCI for 30 min
a 100 °C (4) oF 1.0% glacial acetic acid for 2-3 hat 100 °C (5)
has been used fr depyogenation,
Unlike acid hydrolysis, allatine hydrolysis does aot reduce o
eliminate pyrogenic activity by removing KDO oF fatty acids. In
alkaline hydrolysis. the major chemical and biological alterations
Of the degraded molecule result fom the saponification of fatty
acids (6) In 1956, Neter et al. reported that neither heat alone
(100 *C. 24 h, pF7.2) nor hydrolysis in 0.25 W/ NOH at $6."
for 6 min appreciably reduced the pyrogenicity ofthe LPS of E's
herichia coi or Salmonella aborus equi (7). But exposure 0
(0.25 N NaOH at 56 °C for Th produced 8 moderate loss of pyro
enicty for the E.coli LPS and 2 marked reduction for the 5
‘abortus equi LPS. Niwa etal. (6) reported that depyrogenation is
enhanced when LPS undergoes alkaline hydrolysis with 0.1
[NaOH in either 955 ethanol or 80% dimethylsulfoxide
Oxidation. As eary as 1912, Hort and Penfold reported that,
Salmonella tsphasa cells lost their fever-producing capacity after
they were washed in H.O, (8). The exact mechanism of H.0.'s
action on LPS isnot known, but peroxidation ofthe fatty acids in
the lipid A region of LPS has been suggested. In 1945, Campbell
and Cherkin reported tht a gelatin solution was rendered nor-
Dyrogenic when boiled with0.1 MH.O. for2 hor autoclaved with
0.044 H.0. at 116 °C for 20 min (9). Tauband Har used H.0.t0
detoxify pyrogens in sterile Water for Injection (WF) USP. not.
HONKY
FA-O-cH °
Figure 2. Lipid A structure. Reprinted ttom the cover of
Pyrogens (1868), by F.C. Pearson Il, courtesy of Marcel
Deter ine,
‘mal saline. and dextrose-saline solutions (10), They found the
‘most effective treatment to be boiling in the presence of 0.1%
H.O. for 2h. Under these conditions. the final solution also ay
free of peroxide. This procedure was successfully adapted by
Menezel for large-scale depyrogenation of infusion solutions at a
Tel Aviv hospital (11),
Cave and Novitsky demonsteated tht the inactivation of endo
toxin by H.O. depends on time, pH, and concentration (12). Us
ing as Idle ay 27% H.O. a1 68 °C for | h. these researchers ob
served ~90% reduction of endotoxin, When the H,0. con
centration was inreased to 27°, virtually 100% destruction was
achieved with's
Onidative dspyrogenaton offers several advantages over acid
and base treatments. Hydrogen peroxide is safely handled. can be
ccasily eliminated from solution, and apparently inactivates endo
toxin under nonextreme condition (or example, low concent
tion of H.0. allow temperature). H.O,'s ciet disadvantage isthat
‘tmay adulierate a solution or product. Other reported oxidative
‘methods may offer advantages in specifi applications” These
‘methods include treatment with molecular oxygen (13). hype2, endo
toxin aggregates are negatively charged and behave like anions
Thus. they can be removed by cations adsorbents, suchas asbes~
‘os, which has a positive charge at pH values of <8 3. Inaddivon
tothe electrostatic atraction, the fine stongly branched asbestos
fibers provide a large surface area tha allows the creation of @
epi fiter Because the pores in depth filters are in random and
tortuous configuration, they retain panicles throughout the ma
tix by mechanical means such as sieving, sedimentation, inerst:
tial impingement, and interception, Thus, depth fiers can retain
‘ore particles before clogging than can screen filers ofthe same
Fating, Pyrogen adsorption efficiency, however, depends on the
concentration and molecult sie ofthe cssolved substances, The
effectiveness of asbestos fers is lost with high molecular weight
Protein solutions because of “adsorptive” displacement. In recent
eats, FDA has restricted the use of asbestos filters for processing
Small and large volume parenterals. and depth iers comaning
‘atrils other than asbestos have become widely used
“Membranes produced from polyamies (nylon) or wth arsine
‘covalently bonded to their surfaces exhibit net positive charges in
aqueous solutions of