Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Program Plan
Student Name
David Mueller
s2942319
Bachelor of Environmental Health
&
Angus Glover
S2941502
Bachelor of Nutrition and Dietetics
Needs Assessment
Program Plan Public Health
Due: 01/11/20145
Weight: 30%
Word limit
none
Word Count
4175
Submitted
Draft: 30/10/2015
Content
1.0
Formative Research
1.1
Cultural Determinants
1.2
Health Services
1.3
Social Determinants
1.4
Environmental Determinants
1.5
Individual Determinants
Page 3
2.0
Program Goals
Page 5
3.0
Program Objectives
3.1
Cultural Objectives
3.2
Health Services Objectives
3.3
Social Objectives
3.4
Environmental Objectives
3.5
Individual Objectives
Page 5
4.0
Program Focus
Page 7
5.0
Program Strategies
Page 7
6.0
Strategies
Page 8
7.0
Page 10
8.0
Budget
Page 14
9.0
Evaluation Plan
Page 19
10.0
References
Page 22
1. Among rural Indigenous populations health care services generally arent; physically
accessible, affordable or culturally competent. As a result of this approximately 26% of
Indigenous people over the age of 15 have trouble accessing health care (AHRC, 2008). The
cost of healthcare is of concern whereby 32% of indigenous Australians were unable to access
health care as a result of costs. One of the major factors affecting access to health services is
the culturally incompetent aspect of health care whereby Indigenous people may feel
uncomfortable in a health service setting. In some cases there are language barriers as well as
mistrust between Indigenous patients and Non-indigenous health care providers due to
historical mistreatment of Indigenous people (AHRC, 2008).
2. Accessible health care services are a vital component of health, particularly in the early
detection, prevention and treatment of health issues such as diabetes. They are also a focal
point for education and promotion of health making them of critical importance in the fight
against type 2 diabetes incidences in rural Indigenous communities.
1. The social status in the Australian society plays an important role in the overall health of its
people. Within it, First Australians are placed in one of the lowest social classes and
socioeconomic patterns and health outcomes are influenced from it. It is proven that people
living in higher social classes have better health than people on the lower end of the hierarchy
(Shepherd, Li & Zubrick, 2012).
2. The understanding of how to treat an illness, especially of chronic illness is based on two
different models. Whereas the Western concept is based on an individual's responsibility, in
Aboriginals believe it is also the responsibility of the family and even the whole community,
which can be described as collective management. Once the community support breaks
away, there is a major impact on the health outcome of the individual, because primary
support for health and curing illness comes from the community and not from the health
system (Barnett & Kendall, 2015).
1. A study undertaken at communities at the Murray River looked into Aboriginals interaction
with the environment and how the lifestyle changed since the arrival of the Europeans. The
results show a major shift in the Aboriginal life on several levels such as family activities, their
diet and a rise in costs for food. This is because the life of the Indigenous population was
tightly linked to the river, but changes to its flow and natural fauna, shifted the traditional
lifestyle and food sources over only a few generations. With the result that more money needs
to get spend on food and the health is decreasing among this communities (Willis, Pearce &
Jenkin, 2004).
2. Fresh food scarcity plays another major role in the development of bad health outcomes in
rural communities. Here is the excess to fresh vegetables and meat the limiting factor and not
the lack of money. Food stores in rural areas do not stock all the time fresh articles and the
stock gets mostly replenished every two weeks, in accordance with Government payments.
This results in a scarcity of fresh healthy food after a few days and people are forced to by
processed food which last a long time on the shelfs and are influencing the health negatively
(Scelza, 2012).
1. The behaviour of an individual in terms of diet, physical activity, alcohol consumption, illicit
drug use and smoking heavily influences ones health. Indigenous people in Australia generally
display poorer health behaviours in comparison to the non-indigenous population. Indigenous
people over the age of 15 were shown to be 10% less likely to consume the recommended
fruit intake compared to non-indigenous Australians, while 66% of Indigenous people in 201213 were considered overweight/obese. These figures are similar to Non-indigenous figures
although obesity rates among this were shown to be 1.5 times higher in comparison with Nonindigenous Australians (AIHW, 2014).
2. The individual's experience with racism is not only based on a personal scale, but also from
experience from family members, friends and community members. Another problem is that
these experience are given to the next generation and they are reinforced by an individual's
experience which at the end will lead to sceptical and negative view on the western health
system (Barnett & Kendall, 2015).
If we can successfully establish the target of Indigenous cultural centres, then we expect to
see improvements in cultural health within rural Indigenous communities in FNQ and as a
result see a decrease in type 2 diabetes prevalence.
2. To implement more culturally appropriate and effective type 2 diabetes prevention healthcare
in rural Indigenous communities in FNQ, in doing so decreasing current incidence rates by 25%,
by 2020
If we can implement culturally based and culturally appropriate diabetes health services, then
we should see an increased success rate in the prevention and treatment of type 2 diabetes
in rural indigenous communities in far north Queensland.
If we decrease the cost of healthcare, then we would increase accessibility and opportunity
for treatment and information, resulting in an expected decrease of prevalence of type 2
diabetes within rural Indigenous communities in far north Queensland.
2.
To improve promotion of health services by 30-50% as a means of preventing and treating
type 2 diabetes within rural Indigenous communities in FNQ by 2020.
If we improve promotion of available health services, then we expect to see more individuals
seeking health care and as a result a reduction in the prevalence of type 2 diabetes within
rural indigenous communities within FNQ.
2. Improving the delivery of fresh food to 80% of rural FNQ First Australian communities
minimum once a week and store them in sufficient cool rooms by 2020.
If we can manage to deliver fresh healthy food at least one time a week to remote areas in
FNQ with sufficient storage facilities, than people are empowered to buy and use them.
2.) Building of community discussion groups between First Australians and New Australians to
understand each others culture in 80% of FNQ communities.
If we building discussion groups in FNQ about historical events that led to misunderstanding in each
other culture, than awareness and feeling of being equal will develop.
5 Program strategies
To implement more culturally appropriate and effective type 2 diabetes prevention healthcare in
rural Indigenous communities in FNQ, in doing so decreasing current incidence rates by 25%, by 2020
Strategy 1 Building Healthy Public Policy
Introduction of mandatory Indigenous cultural courses for healthcare providers in 60-70% rural
Indigenous communities in FNQ.
If healthcare providers have the knowledge of the Indigenous cultures perception of health, then
those healthcare providers will have the resources and ability to implement culturally appropriate
diabetes healthcare to Indigenous people within rural FNQ.
Strategy 2 Reorienting Health Services
- Introduction of free type 2 diabetes screenings in healthcare services throughout 80% of rural
Indigenous communities in FNQ.
If diabetes screening is provided free for indigenous Australians in rural FNQ, then we should see an
increased number of people seeking diabetic health services and as a result enable healthcare
providers to impart preventative knowledge and information to those who receive diabetes screening.
6 Activities
Strategy 1 - Introduction of mandatory Indigenous cultural courses for healthcare providers in 60-70%
of rural Indigenous communities in FNQ.
Seek government funding for the resources needed to implement the program
Create a curriculum for the mandatory Indigenous cultural course to be based on
Hire a program co-ordinator to oversee the teachings and implementation of the program
Seek approval for official accreditation of the program as a recognised qualification
Strategy 2 - Introduction of free type 2 diabetes screenings in healthcare services throughout 80% of
rural Indigenous communities in FNQ.
Strategy 5 - Establishment of at least one major sporting/leisure ground within 50-60% of rural
indigenous communities in FNQ
Seek
Government
Funding For
necessary
resources
Create
Curriculum
For
Indigenous
cultural
course
Seek
approval for
official
accreditatio
n of the
program
Hire
program coordinator &
staff
to
implement
the program
Jan
201
6
Feb
201
6
Mar
201
6
Apr
201
6
May
201
6
Jun
201
6
Jul
201
6
Aug
201
6
Sep
201
6
Oct
201
6
Nov
201
6
10
Jan
2017
Feb
2017
Mar
2017
Apr
2017
May
2017
Jun
2017
Jul
2017
Sep
2017
Oct
2017
Nov
2017
Dec
2017
Jan
2018
11
Seek approval
and
any
funding from
local council
Appoint
community
based
committee
Establish
goals
and
objectives
Establish
regular
meeting place
and times
Unforeseeabl
e
timing
issues
allowance
Feb
201
8
Mar
201
8
Apr
201
8
May
201
8
Jun
201
8
Jul
201
8
Aug
201
8
Sep
201
8
Oct
201
8
Nov
201
8
Dec
201
8
12
Feb
201
9
Mar
201
9
Apr
201
9
Ma
y
201
9
Jun
201
9
Jul
201
9
Aug
201
9
Sep
201
9
Oct
201
9
Nov
201
9
Dec
201
9
13
8.0 Budget
8.1 Strategy 1 - Introduction of mandatory Indigenous cultural courses for
healthcare providers in rural Indigenous communities in FNQ.
Total budget = $500 000
Labour requirement
Costs
Recurrent?
annual $
non Labour
requirements
costs
Recurrent?
annually $
1x Curriculum Developer
50 000
Yes
work clothing
1000
yes
1x Program coordinator
40 000
Yes
transport with
government car,
petrol
3000
yes
Total annual
90 000
4000
118 800
5280
9 900
440
$475
200
21 120
14
1x Program coordinator
20 x Health care
provider payments
(doctor)
Costs
annual $
Recurrent?
non Labour
requirements
costs
annually
$
Recurrent?
work cloth
1000
yes
40 000
Yes
transport with
government car,
petrol
3000
yes
20 x 15
000 = 300
000
yes
Materials for
training
5000
yes
Media promotion
20 000
yes
10
no
Medical resources
000
Total annual
340 000
39 000
448 800
51 480
37 400
4 290
1 795
200
205 920
15
Labour requirement
Costs
annual $
Recurrent?
non Labour
requirements
costs
annually
$
Recurrent?
1x Curriculum
Developer
50 000
Yes
work clothing
1000
yes
1x Program coordinator
40 000
Yes
transport with
government car,
petrol
3000
yes
30 x Education provider
30 x 5000
= 150 000
yes
Materials for
training
5 000
yes
Educational
resources
10 000
yes
Total annual
240 000
19 000
316 800
25 080
50,710
2 090
1 267 200
100 320
16
Labour requirement
Costs
annual $
Recurrent?
non Labour
requirements
costs
annually
$
30 x Health committee
payments (30 different
communities)
30 x 10
000 = 300
000
Yes
Materials for
meetings
5000
1x Program co-ordinator
40 000
Yes
resources
5000
yes
yes
reservation
costs
1000
yes
Total annual
340 000
11 000
448 800
14 520
37 400
1 210
1 795 200
58 080
Recurrent?
17
Labour requirement
Costs
annual $
Recurrent?
non Labour
requirements
10 x purchase of
council land
costs
Recurrent?
annually $
10 x 80
000 =
800 000
ground planner
30 000
no
10 x construction costs
(including materials)
10 x 500
000
= 5 000
000
no
10 x Maintenance costs
10 x 30
000 =
300 000
yes
Total annual
5 330
000
800 000
7 035
600
1 056 000
586 300
88 000
7 035
600
1 056 000
no
18
request a report from the healthcare provider on what changes they have made to their
practice to make it more culturally appropriate and how they feel the changes have impacted
their practice (negatively or positively) with focus on the effect it has had on the Indigenous
communitys health behaviours.
What the impact free diabetes health screening has had on the amount of people seeking type
2 diabetes related health treatment
Keep a medical record of number of people seeking the free screening and compare with data
from the number of people who sought diabetes screening before implementation of the free
service
Provide patients with a brief survey asking how the free service has impacted their knowledge
and behaviour in relation to type 2 diabetes.
19
Whether the program has been successful in educating the youth about preventing type 2
diabetes from affecting them in the future and the dangers associated with having diabetes.
Provide a test at the beginning and completion of the program to gauge how successful the
program has been in improving the knowledge of type 2 diabetes.
At the start of the program implementation and at the completion of the program
Whether the goals and objectives set out are being reached
Request a monthly report from each meeting outlining the main points of discussion and the
subsequent community programs that are being implemented as a result of these meetings.
Whether the development of the sporting ground has improved physical activity levels of the
community and in turn improved health in relation to type 2 diabetes
20
Healthcare providers ask patients how often they use the facility upon consultation and report
findings
Culturally appropriate analysis of all patients health by healthcare providers including heart
rate, blood pressure and BMI levels (provides an indication of the overall health of the
community)
21
10.0 References
Aboriginal Health and Medical Research Council (AHMRC). (n.d.). Definition of Aboriginal Health.
Retrieved from:
http://www.ahmrc.org.au/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=35&Itemid=37
Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS). (2009). Diabetes in the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander
people, 2004-05. Retrieved from:
http://www.abs.gov.au/AUSSTATS/abs@.nsf/Lookup/4724.0.55.001Main%20Features42004
-05
Australian Bureau of Statistics. (2012). Topics @ a Glance Aboriginal and Torre Straight Islander
Peoples Education, Learning and Skills. Retrieved from:
http://www.abs.gov.au/websitedbs/c311215.nsf/web/Aboriginal+and+Torres+Strait+Islande
r+Peoples+-+Education,+Learning+and+Skills
Australian Human Rights Commission (AHRC). (2008) A statistical overview of Aboriginal and Torres
Strait Islander peoples in Australia: Social Justice Report 2008. Retrieved 15 August 2015
from:
https://www.humanrights.gov.au/publications/statistical-overview-aboriginal-and-torresstrait-islander-peoples-australia-social#Heading331
Australian Institute of Health and Welfare (AIHW). (2014). Health Behaviours of Indigenous
Australians. Retrieved from:
http://www.aihw.gov.au/australias-health/2014/indigenous-health/#t4
Australian Institute of Health and Welfare (AIHW). (2015). Diabetes. Retrieved from:
http://www.aihw.gov.au/diabetes/
Barnett, L. & Kendall, E. (2015). Principles for the development of Aboriginal health interventions:
culturally appropriate methods through systemic empathy. Ethnicity & Health. 20(5), 437452. doi:
10.1080/13557858.2014.921897
Browne, J., Hayes, R. and Gleeson, D. (2012). Appropriate health promotion for Australian Aboriginal
and Torres Strait Islander communities: crucial for closing the gap. Global Health Promotion.
19(2), 58-62. doi:
ANGUS GLOVER & DAVID MUELLER
22
Davis TM, McAullay D, Davis WA, Bruce DG. (2007). Characteristics and outcome of type 2 diabetes
in urban Aboriginal people: The Fremantle Diabetes Study. Intern Med J. 37(1): 59-63
Dick, D. (2007). Social determinants and the health of Indigenous peoples in Australia a human
rights based approach. Retrieved from:
https://www.humanrights.gov.au/news/speeches/social-determinants-and-healthindigenous-peoples-australia-human-rights-based
Durey, A. and Thompson, S., C. (2012). Reducing the health disparities of Indigenous Australians:
time to change focus. BMC Health Services Research. 12(1), 151-162. doi:
10.1186/1472-6963-12-151
Euteneuer, F. (2014). Subjective social status and health. Current Opinion in Psychiatry. 27(5), 337343. doi:
10.1097/YCO.0000000000000083
GarciaRamirez, M., Martinez, M., F., Balcazar, F., E., SuarezBalcazar, Y., Albar, M., J., Domnguez, E.
and Santolaya, F., J. (2005). Psychosocial empowerment and social support factors
associated with the employment status of immigrant welfare recipients. Journal of
Community Psychology. 33(6), 673-690. doi:
10.1002/jcop.20072
McDermott, R. Li, M. Campbell, S. (2010). The Medical Journal of Australia. Incidence of type
2 diabetes in two Indigenous Australian populations: a 6-year follow-up study. 192 (10): 562565. Retrieved from: https://www.mja.com.au/journal/2010/192/10/incidence-type-2diabetes-two-indigenous-australian-populations-6-year-follow
Otim, M., E., Asante, A., D., Kelaher, M., Doran, C. and Anderson, I., P. (2015). What constitutes
benefit from health care interventions for Indigenous Australians? Australian Aboriginal
Studies. 2015(1), 30-42.
Scelza, B. A. (2012). Food scarcity, not economic constraint limits consumption in a rural Aboriginal
community. Australian Journal of Rural Health. 20(3), 108-112. doi:
10.1111/j.1440-1584.2012.01270.x
23
24