Case 1:16-cv-21156-MGC Document 18-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/05/2016 Page 1 of 14

Exhibit 1

Case 1:16-cv-21156-MGC Document 18-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/05/2016 Page 2 of 14

Adam Schefter on Twitter: "ESPN obtained medical charts that show Giants DE Jason Pi... Page 1 of 13

Search Twitter

Have an account? Log in ..,.

Adam Schetter 0

+.!.

Follow

@AdamSchefter

ESPN obtained medical charts that show

Giants DE Jason Pierre-Paul had right
index finger amputated today.

()~~ !:'INGER c{ Otl~et I L~ee' .cob:t,'l!~ht s::

srt.!.'t' 'rH.lCKliE.s:; TP r:xtRE;t-nrrE:s

;:;r~Ji,l?'l'
'i.,,Pwr:~:

He Comro~tli:S :
.
.

~.H~Wr :E~DE.X r":Hi;GE~ AAY

~E~r~C1'lON,
S?.t.X'f
'fHJ.'CI<m~
-'

'-

!~tl~D

P::-ivr:.t~

7,658

H.i\tU;> HP.,JOR,
Corr.rntm:a:

t::!:~RMATO?,F.J' 1':-w:n~.ES

2,921

4:04PM- 8 .Jul2015

"""

free dominguez @freedominguez 9h

@AdamSchefter SO INCREDIBLY UNETHICAL

t.~ 2

15

....

file:/I/C:/U sers/KFritzJDesktop/Case%20Folders/JPP%20-%20crisis%20mgmtlAdam%20...

4/15/2016

Case 1:16-cv-21156-MGC Document 18-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/05/2016 Page 3 of 14

Adam Schefter on Twitter: "ESPN obtained medical charts that show Giants DE Jason Pi... Page 2 of 13

Aly @phoenixethos 9 9~earch Twitter

Q
Have an account? Log in
@freedominguez @Adc::mSchefter How does ESPN get your medical chart?
Just pointing that out. *Chuckles*

'"'"

*1

free dominguez @freedominguez 8h

@phoenixethos HIPAA 101. someone violated it. and for a journalist to be
complicit SMH.

*2
View other replies

Aly @phoenixethos 9 8h
@freedominguez You're HIPPA trained Free that's awesome.

free dominguez @freedominguez 7h

@phoenixethos i used to work for one of the top healthcare law firms.
0&11

*1

View other replies

Aly @phoenixethos 9 7h
@freedominguez ~ ,;:. -J_,. ~~ ~ .~~.

CO <I

James Harrison @jharrison9292 12h

.@AdamSchefter You're a real piece of sh*t for putting that picture up!

'll

3.8K

5K

View other replies

richard bodine @clickdbocline 1211

@jharrison9292 @IHopeDavis @/\damSchefter it's actually against the law for
them to have that, ever hear of HIPAA laws?

11

View other replies

Josh Sveom @JoshSveom 10h

@dickdbodine @jharrison9292 @IHopeDavis @AdamSchefter HIPAA does not
regulate what the news media can report firstamendmentcenter.org/hipaanewsgath ...

file:///C:/U sers/KFritz/Desktop/Case%20F o1ders/JPP%20-%20crisis%20mgmt/Adam%20...

4/15/2016

Case 1:16-cv-21156-MGC Document 18-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/05/2016 Page 4 of 14

Adam Schefter on Twitter: "ESPN obtained medical charts that show Giants DE Jason Pi... Page 3 of 13

3
OGC
Search
Twitter

Have an account? Log in ...,

View other replies

richard bodine @dickdbodine 10h

@JosllSveom @jllarrison9292 @IHopeDavis it DOES when the records they
publish have the patients NAME on them

*2

t.'l

01>0

Larry Bernard @karasoth 9h

@dickdbodine @JoshSveom @jharrison9292 @IHopeDavis THIS: whomever
gave this to ESPN has between 1~10 years of federal prison time due them

*2

t.'l

.....

Josh Sveom @JoshSveom 9h

@karasoth @dickdbodine @jharrison9292 @IHopeDavis if it can be proven
who did it and Schetter does not have to give up his source

t.'l

Larry Bernard @karasoth 9h

@JosllSveom @dickdbodine @jharrison9292 @IHopeDavis Looking at the
image on the screen it can be done from the screencap

Josh Sveom @JoshSveom 911

@karasotll @dickdbodine @jharrison9292 @IHopeDavis I take it you work at
this hospital and can decipher the screen What is the source's name?

*
Show more

Mike Agogliati @NnikeaJOglic1ti 1h

@AdamSchefter dude ... do HIPPA laws mean anything?

*
Show more

Akbar Gbajabiamila @Akbar_Gbaja 6h

@AdamSchefter #HIPPA? Privacy maybe needed here.

t.'l

*8

.....

file:///C:/Users/KFritz!Desktop/Case%20Folders/.TPP%20-%20crisis%20mgmt/Adam%20...

4/15/2016

Case 1:16-cv-21156-MGC Document 18-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/05/2016 Page 5 of 14

Adam Schefter on Twitter: "ESPN obtained medical charts that show Giants DE Jason Pi ... Page 4 of 13

Search~nnore

Have an account" Log in ..,.

Larry Bernard @karasoth 8h

@AdamSchefler And you could have not shown this and not put people in
jeopardy (and still had the story)

*1
Larry Bernard @karasoth 9h
@AdamSchefler the hospital could be liable for 533 Million in fines (and possibly
more) over this

eoo

Larry Bernard @karasoth 9h

@AdamSchefter so how do you feel about helping some shlub hospital
employee destroy his life?

000

Larry Bernard @karasoth 9h

@AdamSchefter mondaq.com/unitedstates/x ...

*
Larry Bernard @karasoth 9h
@AdamSchefter opic.org/privacy/imshea ...

Larry Bernard @karasoth 911

@AclamSchefter IF you gave your source anything DoJ could classify as
personal gain he is in jail for 10 years

Larry Bernard @karasoth 9h

@AdamSchefter kb. iu.ecfuid/ayzf

t.1

Q(l(i

Larry Bernard @karasoth 9h

@AdamSchefter of the actions that constitute an offense. Specific knowledge of
an action being in violation of the HIPAA statute is not req

t.'l

Larry Bernard @karasoth 9h

@AdamSchefter Knowingly
The DOJ interpreted the "knowingly" element of the HIPAA statute for criminal
liability as requiring only knowledge

file:///C:/U sers/KFritzJDesktop/Case%20Folders/JPP%20~%20crisis%20mgmt/Adam%20...

4/15/2016

Case 1:16-cv-21156-MGC Document 18-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/05/2016 Page 6 of 14

Adam Schefter on Twitter: "ESPN obtained medical charts that show Giants DE Jason Pi... Page 5 of 13

011>0
Search
Twitter

0..

Have an account? Log in

Larry Bernard @karasoth 9h

@AdamSchefter commercial advantage, personal gain or malicious harm permit
fines of $250,000, and imprisonment for up to ten years.

t.'l

Larry Bernard @karasoth 9h

@AdamSchefter Finally, offenses committed with the intent to sell, transfer, or
use individually identifiable health information for ...

t.'l

*1

Larry Bernard @karasoth 9h

@AdamSchefter you realize whomever shared JPP records with you can go to
federal prison for 10 years for doing it?

t.'l

*1

Kosher Samosa @qu1j0t3 11 h

Can you explain how obtaining & distributing this personal medical information is
legal? @AdamSchefter

t.'l

......

Larry Bernard @karasoth 9h

@qu1j0t3 @AdamSchefter obtaining is legal so long as @espn didn't incentivise
the leak

Rob Parker @parkerdigilal 1211

.@1-\clamSchefter JPP was stupid with fireworks. No sympathy there. but no one
has the right to reveal his medical records. Loss of respect.

t:l

View other replies

Larry Bernard @karasoth 9h

@parkerdigital @AdarnSehefter You could have published the story without
publishing the record

t.'l

*1

......

Brian McDonough @DrBrianMcD 13h

@AdarnSchefter @Buster_ESPN very disappointed in your judgement. ESPN
should not permit this behavior. Patients deserve privacy#HIPAA

file:///C:/Users/KFritz/Desktop/Case%20Folders/JPP%20-%20crisis%20mgmt/Adam%20...

4/15/2016

Case 1:16-cv-21156-MGC Document 18-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/05/2016 Page 7 of 14

Adam Schefter on Twitter: "ESPN obtained medical charts that show Giants DE Jason Pi... Page 6 of 13

4Search Twitter
.....

Have an account? Log in

Larry Bernard @karasoth 9h

@DrBrianf\/lcD @AdamSchefter @Buster_ESPN amen!

000

Brad Cooper @btcoop71 13h

. @AdamSchefter Most electronic health records have audit trails to determine
who released this. Your source is screwed.

t.'l

*1

000

View other replies

Larry Bernard @karasoth 9h

@btcoop71 @AdamSchefter and Prob going to jail

t.'l

The Joseph @JosephTDavis 12h

@AdamSchefter buncha suckas acting like espn ain't got lawyers.

View other replies

llOO

Larry Bernard @kmasoth 9h

@JosephTDavis @AdarnSchefter ESPN is fine. Whomever gave it to them is
going to jail though

*
Larry Bernard @!karasoth 8h
@f\damSchefter btw folks every time you sl1are this tweet its another HIPPA
violation #HIPPA

Show more

Larry Bernard @kara&oth 9h

@AdamSchefter Whomever shared this is getting 1, 5, or 10 years In jail

t.'l

000

Show more

file:///C:/U sers/KFritzJDesktop/Case%20Folders/JPP%20-%20crisis%20mgmt/Adam%20...

4/15/2016

Case 1:16-cv-21156-MGC Document 18-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/05/2016 Page 8 of 14

Adam Schefter on Twitter: "ESPN obtained medical charts that show Giants DE Jason Pi... Page 7 of 13

Search Twitter

R1ck Fre1he1t @RickFreiheit 12h

@AdamSchefter HIPPA violation??

Have an account? Log in "'

eee

Rick Freiheit @RickFreiheit 10h

@AdamSchefter @dlukasz1 02 it's a HIPPA violation if I'm correct to say

t,'l 1
View other replies

C>G&

Larry Bernard @karasoth 9h

@RickFreiheit @AdamSchefter @dlukasz1 02 Whomever gave this to @espn
violated the heck out of JPP HIPPA rights

*
Larry Bernard @karasoth 9h
@AdamSchefter And since every hospital employee is trained on hippa @espn
because of this you guys are sending some one to jail

*
Show more

Jay Gatsby @LaslCharrnander 13h

@AdamSchefter @cardeaframez SO yall just gonna say fuck HIPAA huh??

CAR-dee-AYE @cardeaframez 12h

@LastChmmander @.t\damSchefler exactly! Somebody losing a license

View other replies

Larry Bernard @karasoth 9h

@cardeaframez @LastCilarmander @AclamSchefter Actually some one is
LIKELY going to jail

*
Show more

1 .~G,i)l

@seanmishler @SeanM1shler 1011

file:///C:/Users/KFritzJDesktop/Case%20Folders/JPP%20-%20crisis%20mgmt/Adam%20...

4/15/2016

Case 1:16-cv-21156-MGC Document 18-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/05/2016 Page 9 of 14

Adam Schefter on Twitter: "ESPN obtained medical charts that show Giants DE Jason Pi... Page 8 of 13

@AdamSchefter @MichiganNatioD2 HIPPA violation?

*1

Search Twitter

Q.

Have an account? Log in "'

'\ HaiiToTheVictors "\ @MichiganNation2 1Oh

@Sean Mishler @AdamSchefter yes a big one

0&0

Larry Bernard @karasoth 9h

@MichiganNation2 @SeanMishler @AdamSchefter And it could cost the
hospital 533 mil

....

'\ HaiiToTheVictors "\ @MichiganNation2 5h

@karasoth @SeanMishler @AdarnSchefter lmao, ummmm no

......

Rob Parker @parkerdigital 12h

This is illegal. Nice going
RT @AdamSchefter: ESPN obtained medical charts that show Giants DE Jason
Pierre-Paul had index finger amputated.

Lisa Nguyen McDowell @ltsGiriFriday 0h

Who does this. Shameful RT @AdamSchefter ESPN obtained medical charts
that show Giants DE Jason Pierre-Paul (cont) tLgd/n._1 sn0822

*1
S.C. @.Chaseylnc 9h
@ltsGiriFriday I think dude posted it by mistake .. the guy who lost his finger. I
saw a pic of his hand earlier. AWFUL!!!

Lisa Nguyen McDowell @ltsGiriFriday 911

@Chaseylnc CJ or JPP's finger? Smh at both of them

S.C. @Chaseylnc 9h
@ltsGiriFriday JPP's hand! Look like the shit was blown OFF

Lisa Nguyen McDowell @ltsGiriFriday 9h

@Chaseylnc Cj lost two fingers too. Yes. CJ.

file:/I /C:/Users/KFritz/Desktop/Case%20Folders/JPP%20-%20crisis%20mgmt/Adam%20...

4/15/2016

Case 1:16-cv-21156-MGC Document 18-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/05/2016 Page 10 of 14

Adam Scheftet on Twitter: "ESPN obtained medical charts that show Giants DE Jason Pi... Page 9 of 13

0$0

Search Twitter

Have an account? Log in ..,

Mentel Hardy @MonteiNFL 10h

@AdarnSchefter How much did you pay for this?

*1
~

Charles McDonald @McDraft2 1Oh

@MonteiNFL that's what I'm saying man. No one gave this info up for free

View other replies

eee

NFC Doug @sandiamond1 10h

@Mc0raft2 @MonteiNFL some hospital worker got a nick chunk of change? lol

.t.'l
View other replies

ooe

Mentel Hardy @MonteiNFL 10h

@sandiarnond1 @McDraft2 Either that or they are ridiculously dumb and got
finessed.

t.'l
-

NFC Doug @sandiamond1 10h

@MontE:INFL @Mc0raft2 Yeah could be a sports fan or something like

that. Usually costs a job

*1
Omar Niamatali @soopnan 11 h
@AclamSchefter You just violated JPP's rights as an American. Congrats? It
would have come out eventually, but there's no low to low 4u.

*2
James Pappachen

@jpappachen 1111

@soopnan @AdarnSchefter Pretty sure this is illegal. Right @HHSGov ?

t.'l

Kale Wright @PolarisKale 11 h

Ever see a #lawyer hit reverse & leave somebody in the bus lane? Watch
@ESPN attys fly away from @AdamSchefter over this OR pic. #Skid marks

*1

600

file:///C:/Users/KFritzJDesktop/Case%20Folders/JPP%20-%20crisis%20mgmt/Adam%20...

4/15/2016

Case 1:16-cv-21156-MGC Document 18-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/05/2016 Page 11 of 14

Adam Schefter on Twitter: "ESPN obtained medical charts that show Giants DE Jason ... Page 10 of 13

Hatsune Danny @djdcluet;e:; 13iJ

@AdamSchefter @Javo?r'Yff!f~1wrw knows that's a vibfatlon 51f~ri@61YR~At? Log in
Heard of HIPPA??

*1

....

Hatsune Danny @djddueces 13h

@AdamSchefter HIPPA violation. You're going to jail or someone is getting
sued. Good job.

"""

Ned Brown @Esoxgolf 12h

@AdamSchefter You would think he has legal grounds to go after ESPN. A bit
surprised the ESPN lawyers didn't say something.

*1
BJaRz @BJaRz 12h
@Esoxgolf For what?

Ned Brown @Esoxgolf 11 h

@BJaRz To go into medical records without the the consent of Pierre-Paul.
Looks like someone screen grabbed private medical records.

BJaRz @B.JaRz 11 h
@Esoxgolf ESPN/Schefter wouldn't be held to HIPAA violation. That's on the
provider.

Ned Brown @Esoxgolf 11 h

@BJaRz Don't you think they would get sucked in? Last think the NFL and it's
teams want is for medical records being published.

View other replies

BJaRz @BJaRz 11 h
@Esoxgolf hhs.gov/ocr/privacy/hi. ..

.. ., ..

Ned Brown @Esoxgolf 10h

@BJaRz A good read for everyone because it's going to apply in situations. If I
was NFL still would take it to my partner ESPN.

file:/1/C:/U sers/KFritz/Desktop/Case%20Folders/.TPP%20-%20crisis%20mgmt/Adam%20...

4/15/2016

Case 1:16-cv-21156-MGC Document 18-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/05/2016 Page 12 of 14

Adam Schefter on Twitter: "ESPN obtained medical charts that show Giants DE Jason...

&OG

Search Twitter

Page 11 of 13

Have an account? Log in .,..

Aaron Stanley King @trendoid 2h

@adamschefter Dumb move man. You better get your blog ready because
you're not going to be on ESPN much longer. #HIPAA #Violation

*1
Aaron Stanley King @trendoid 2h
@AdamSchefter Is the $50,000 max fine from the government for a #HIPAA
worth trending as biggest jerk of the day, so far.

*
M @The_Lion_ 3h
You're wrong for posting that man medical records bruh. Straight trash move.
@AdamSchefter

ooe

theOvlsion @Truth_305 311

@The_Lion_ @AdarnSchefter" Espn obtained " smh

GOO

Melody Butler @Melody Butler 1Oh

Everytime someone retweets @AdamSchefter's #HIPAA violating pic abt
#f\IYGiants #JasonPierrePaul, a bell rings #shame pic.twitter.com/7uwlyXklc8

t.'l

GOO

Tiffany @Fusarium 1011

@MelodyButler srsly violation.

Jon Hochberg @Jon_Hochberg 12h

@AclamSchefte1 probably not smart to post someone's medical chart. There are
federal laws that protect that privacy.

*1
' Coach Joe Amelio @Jamelio1230 11 h
@Jon_ Hochberg @AdamSchefter #hippalaw

t.'l

#teamWEOW @bunktuzzi44 12h

@AdamSchefter hipaa? Or nah?

file:///C:/Users/KFritz/Desktop/Case%20Folders/JPP%20-%20crisis%20mgmt/Adam%20. ..

4/15/2016

Case 1:16-cv-21156-MGC Document 18-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/05/2016 Page 13 of 14

Adam Schetter on Twitter: "ESPN obtained medical chatts that show Giants DE Jason ...

&&o

Search Twitter

Page 12 of 13

Have an account? Log in

Andrew Hash @Smokinhash45 12h

@bunktuzzi44 a very blatant HIPM violation. Someone's getting fired and
@AdamSchefter should be suspended for tweeting out patient info

t.'l

*2

Jippylarue @jippylarlle 13h

@boondagger @AdamSchefter No regard for HIPAA Disgraceful. Forward to
attorney general, disgusted to see posted. No integrity.

*4
bob. @BeeOhBeeRT 13h
@AdamSchefter Isn't this illegal?

eoo

taz @tazwuzhere 13h

@BeeOhBeeRT @AdamSchefter youtu.be/27RpCngRRbQ?t= ...

t.'l

*1

Nick Verbitsky @nbits60 1411

@AdamSchefter @BWilliamsonESPN how does that not violate HIPAA law?

t.'l

Charley Grant @CGrantWS.I 13h

@nbits60 @AdamSchefter @BVVilliamsonESPN that's an excellent question

Michael Pallanti @MikePDaTruth 1211

@AdamSchefter @troy _jefferson Ummmm HIPAA violation much doe?

Troy Jefferson @troyjefferson 12h

@MikeF-'DaTruth @AdamSchefter i would be more upset at the guy who sent
him the pic ... if he gets his hands on it, imo it's fair game

Michael Pallanti @MikePDaTrllth 12h

@troy _jefferson @AdamScl1efter Yup agreed. Still though, whoever at the
hospital leaked that document is in BIG trouble

t.'l

OGQ

file;///C:/Users/KFritz/Desktop/Case%20Folders/JPP%20-%20crisis%20mgmt/ Adam%20...

4/15/2016

Case 1:16-cv-21156-MGC Document 18-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/05/2016 Page 14 of 14

Adam Schefter on Twitter: "ESPN obtained medical charts that show Giants DE Jason ... Page 13 of 13

Hatin'-Ass Pat @HatinAeliiFthl'\~her

Q
Have an accounl? Log in
@ACEKWEST51 0 @Ad::~mSchcftcr who c3res, cuz, no one said JPP was smart

Tweet unavailable

Hatin'-Ass Pat @HatinAssPat 12h

@ACEKWEST510 @AdamSchefter Schefty, no, JPP, very much so

*
New to Twitter?
Sign up now to get your own personalized timeline!

Sign up

2015 Twitter

About

Help Ads info

file:///C:/Users/KFritzJDesktop/Case%20Folders/JPP%20-%20crisis%20mgmt/Adam%20...

4/15/20 l 6