Você está na página 1de 51

'%

'

'"

'#

&

"

'%

'&

'

'"

"

&

Source
COTTON
Error
Total

DF
4
20
24

SS
475.76
161.20
636.96

MS
118.94
8.06

F
14.76

P
0.000

$!

#!

$!

#"

#!

!""!#

"

#!

"!

!""!#

"!

()*+,-.+* /+ 012345167

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"*+,,+-

!""#$%&'(#

"#

()*+,-.+* /+ 012345167

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"*+! ,#**!$ (&'%!"



#&

#'

#!

"

'

&

#!

!"#$% &'!"(

"

()*+,-.+* /+ 012345167

!"#$% &"!'$'(%()* &%!) !+ ),- .-/(01$%/

E 7HQVLOHVWUHQJWKVHHPVWRLQFUHDVHWRFRWWRQDQGGHFOLQHVDWFRWWRQ
F

!"#$%!&

5HMHFW+ DQGFRQFOXGHWKDWFRWWRQSHUFHQWDJHDIIHFWVEUHDNLQJVWUHQJWK

6HFWLRQ

&+$37(5

!"#$%&'





DF
2
15
17

SS
3.6478
7.6300
11.2778

MS
1.8239
0.5087

"(!

"'!

Source
TECHNIQU
Error
Total

")!

"%!

DF
3
12
15

!"#

"&!

"$!

!!

SS
489740
153908
643648

"#!

"$

"#!

!"#

MS
163247
12826

&%

!"#$%&'



9433

"

%"$$

133

433

9133

!"#$%&#" '# ()*+,-)./

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"*+,-./01

4823

5HMHFW+ 7HFKQLTXHVDIIHFWWKHVWUHQJWKRIWKHFRQFUHWH
E 3YDOXH 
F 5HVLGXDOVDUHDFFHSWDEOH

" !

+,-./01.- 2. 34567895:

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"*+,-

E 5HVLGXDOVDUHDFFHSWDEOH

&

%#$$

#$$

"$$

*"

"

Source
FLOW
Error
Total

'RQRWUHMHFW+ )ORZUDWHGRHVQRWDIIHFWHWFKXQLIRUPLW\

!"#$%&"'



!"#$%&'

!"#$%&'

!"#$%&'
!"#$%&'

!"#$%&'
!"#$%&'

$!"

!#

4723

4623

!""#$%&'(#

4523

!"#$%&#" '# ()*+,-)./

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"*+! ,#**!$ (&'%!"

P
0.000

!""#$%&'(#

'()*+,-*) .* /01234516

P
0.053

0323

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"*+! ,#**!$ (&'%!"

F
12.73

!!

F
3.59

0123

!"





!"#$%&'



!"#$%&'

'!&

'$

&

*")(

*")

")"

")

")(

("

Source
COATINGT
Error
Total

"

'"

DF
4
15
19

!"#!$%

&"

%"

#"

SS
1060.5
243.3
1303.7

$"

!"

MS
0.0464
0.0177

MS
265.1
16.2

%#

%"

"

'&"

'&"!

&"&

&"!

&"

$#



P
0.000

!""#$%&'(#

!"%$

$"

P
0.046

!""#$%&'(#

!"#$%&#" '# ()*+,(-./

!#

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"*+! ,#**!$ (&'%!"

F
16.35

!"$$

()*+,-.+* /+ 01234567

P
0.083

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"/0! 1#//!$ (&'%!"

F
2.62

Source
DF
SS
MS
F
CIRCUITT
2
260.9
130.5
4.01
Error
12
390.8
32.6
Total
14
651.7
5HMHFW+
E 7KHUHLVVRPHLQGLFDWLRQRIJUHDWHUYDULDELOLW\LQFLUFXLWWZR

)*+,-./,

F  

()*+,-.+* /+ :;20<:547

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"23.*456*

5HMHFW+
E 7KHUHLVVRPHLQGLFDWLRQRILQFUHDVLQJYDULDELOLW\

""

!"#$%&#" '# ()*+,-./

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"*+,-+ .*

Source
DF
SS
TEMPERAT
3
0.1391
Error
18
0.3191
Total
21
0.4582
'RQRWUHMHFW+
E 3YDOXH 
F 5HVLGXDOVDUHDFFHSWDEOH

!"#$%&'

!"#$%&'

!"

!"#$



!"#$%&'



!"#$%&'
!"#$%&'

Source
RODDING
Error
Total

Source
ORIFICE
Error
Total

25



()

G  

($

('

'

&

(%

!"#"$%

MS
226.67
7.35

'$
!"

/5

'%
#!$

SS
1133.37
132.25
1265.63

/3

MS
9544
5117

(&

#!"

!"#$%&#" '# ()*+,-

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"* +,+-.

DF
5
18
23

)*++,-.

!"#$%&#" '# *6()-768.

SS
28633
40933
69567

'&

"!$

DF
3
8
11

*&$- !"#$%&'$!$*122)34

5HMHFW+
E 3YDOXH 
F

23

!" #!$$

'RQRWUHMHFW+
E 3YDOXH 
F

F  

"

!"#$%&'$!$()*(+),,
!"#$%&#" '# ()*+,-*).

'

'#

"

&

4233

233

$"#

"#

!"#

!"#$%&'
!"#$%&'
!"#$%&'

#!

4233

233

423

23

/1

P
0.214

!""#$%&'(#

"!

!""#$%&'(#

*+,-./0-, 1- 234567

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"*+! ,#**!$ (&'%!"

P
0.000

!""#$%&'(#

2553

!"#$%&#" '# *6()-768.

*&$- !"#$%&'$!$./& 0-..& %"#!&$

F
1.87

F
30.85

2533

20

!"#$%&#" '# ()*+,-*).

*&$- !"#$%&'$!$./& 0-..& %"#!&$

2933

/0





!"#$%&'

G  

















06  VWDQGDUGHUURURIWKHPHDQ 





06
Q

"

"!

86





$!

/"0/1023

MS
7.375
0.497

$"#

"#

$!

%&'()*+(' ,( .0:;0/<.4

SS
22.124
7.948
30.072

MS
615.1
74.1

$"

"

DF
3
16
19

!"#$!%&

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"2 324356

Source
PREPMETH
Error
Total
5HMHFW+
E 3YDOXH 
F

G  
H  

"

%&'()*+(' ,( -./012.34

SS
1230.2
1555.8
2786.0

$"

"

$"#

"#

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"*+ (,+-.

Source
DF
AIRVOIDS
2
Error
21
Total
23
5HMHFW+
E 3YDOXH 
F

6HFWLRQ

!"#$%&'

!"#$%&'

!"#$%&'

P
0.000

"

!""#$%&'(#

!"#$%&#" '# ()*+),-(.

"9

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"*+! ,#**!$ (&'%!"

F
14.85

'())*+#,-.*

76

%&'()*+(' ,( -./012.34

P
0.002

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"/0! 1#//!$ (&'%!"

F
8.30

"6

56









[!"#



I%'%#(!!#
(







  

  







'R QRW 5H MHFW

5H MHFW

["%%



Fisher's pairwise comparisons


Family error rate = 0.184
Individual error rate = 0.0500
Critical value = 2.179
Intervals for (column level mean) - (row level mean)
1
2
3
2
-360
-11
3
-137
48
212
397
4
130
316
93
479
664
442
6LJQLILFDQFHGLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQOHYHOVDQGDQGDQGDQGDQG

FRQWUDVW  

FRQWUDVW  

06

66)*+,-./,0 "&

[!$%

 "
  




P!"#  P!$%  P "%%

P!"#  P!$%  P "%%

66)*+,-./,0!&

Fisher's pairwise comparisons


Family error rate = 0.117
Individual error rate = 0.0500
Critical value = 2.131
Intervals for (column level mean) - (row level mean)
125
160
160
-1.9775
-0.2225
200
-1.4942
-0.3942
0.2608
1.3608
1RVLJQLILFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVDPRQJWKHOHYHOV

Fisher's pairwise comparisons


Family error rate = 0.264
Individual error rate = 0.0500
Critical value = 2.086
Intervals for (column level mean) - (row level mean)
15
20
25
30
20
-9.346
-1.854
25
-11.546
-5.946
-4.054
1.546
30
-15.546
-9.946
-7.746
-8.054
-2.454
-0.254
35
-4.746
0.854
3.054
7.054
2.746
8.346
10.546
14.546
6LJQLILFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQOHYHOVDQGDQGDQGDQGDQGDQG
DQGDQGDQG


















DYHUDJH

FRQWUDVW

P




P!






P!




P"






P"




P#








06! 

P$






66







06! 

66



5HMHFW
5HMHFW
'RQRW5HMHFW
'RQRW5HMHFW

'HFLVLRQ

-1.777
6.277

1.40

'RQRWUHMHFW
'RQRWUHMHFW

'HFLVLRQ






6LJQLILFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQDOOOHYHOVH[FHSWDQGDQGDQG

Critical value = 2.101


Intervals for (column level mean) - (row level mean)
0.37
0.51
0.71
1.02
0.51
1.723
9.777
0.71
3.723
-2.027
11.777
6.027
1.02
6.973
1.223
-0.777
15.027
9.277
7.277
1.40
13.723
7.973
5.973
2.723
21.777
16.027
14.027
10.777
1.99
15.973
10.223
8.223
4.973
24.027
18.277
16.277
13.027

Fisher's pairwise comparisons


Family error rate = 0.330
Individual error rate = 0.0500





DYHUDJH

P






Fisher's pairwise comparisons


Family error rate = 0.0251
Individual error rate = 0.0100
Critical value = 3.055
Intervals for (column level mean) - (row level mean)
1
2
2
-18.426
3.626
3
-8.626
-1.226
13.426
20.826
1RVLJQLILFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVDPRQJWKHOHYHOV


FRQWUDVW



6LJQLILFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQOHYHOVDQGDQGDQGDQGDQGDQGDQG

Fisher's pairwise comparisons


Family error rate = 0.0649
Individual error rate = 0.0100
Critical value = 2.947
Intervals for (column level mean) - (row level mean)
1
2
3
4
2
-8.642
8.142
3
5.108
5.358
21.892
22.142
4
7.358
7.608
-6.142
24.142
24.392
10.642
5
-8.642
-8.392
-22.142
-24.392
8.142
8.392
-5.358
-7.608

P"





P#





"

!!"



'%&#
#

%&%

%&$

%&#

'%&#
$

()*+,-.+* /+ 0123124

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"*++,

"&6

5HMHFW
'RQRWUHMHFW
5HMHFW

'HFLVLRQ

"&5

#$%%&'()*+&

()*+,-.+* /+ 0123124

P
0.003





!&%

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"-.! /#--!$ (&'%!"




06! 

66

'%&$

%&%

%&$

%&#

P!





Source
DF
SS
MS
F
LOOM
4
0.3416
0.0854
5.77
Error
20
0.2960
0.0148
Total
24
0.6376
5HMHFW+ WKHUHDUHVLJQLILFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVDPRQJWKHORRPV
E 
F 
G 5HVLGXDOVDUHDFFHSWDEOH

P





'%&$



FRQWUDVW




DYHUDJH

Family error rate = 0.189


Individual error rate = 0.0500
Critical value = 2.120
Intervals for (column level mean) - (row level mean)
1
2
3
2
-0.9450
0.9450
3
1.5550
1.5550
3.4450
3.4450
4
0.4750
0.4750
-2.0250
2.3650
2.3650
-0.1350
6LJQLILFDQFHGLIIHUHQFHVDPRQJDOOOHYHOVH[FHSWOHYHOVDQG

Fisher's pairwise comparisons

Fisher's pairwise comparisons


Family error rate = 0.118
Individual error rate = 0.0500
Critical value = 2.080
Intervals for (column level mean) - (row level mean)
1
2
2
1.799
19.701
3
8.424
-2.326
26.326
15.576
6LJQLILFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQOHYHOVDQGDQGDQG

6HFWLRQ







!"#$%&'



!"#$%&'

!&$





!"#$%&'



!"#$%&'

"

!"#$%&'

(
V $!%&
&!'

"

01#230!4

V (! "#



(
V $!%&
 V (
&!'



=<



=>

<$

"())*+,-./*

&'()*+,)( -) 73089:/;5

<#

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"12! ,#11!$ (&'%!"

P
0.538

"())*+,-./*

F ,WFRXOGEHUHGXFHGWRWKLVLVWKHUHGXFWLRQRIDSSUR[LPDWHO\

E 

D  V (! "#

%6

%6

#$

&'()*+,)( -) 73089:/;5

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"34-563+7

"

&'()*+,)( -) ./0123405

P
0.008

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"12! ,#11!$ (&'%!"

Source
DF
SS
MS
F
CHEMICAL
3
54.0
18.0
0.75
Error
16
384.0
24.0
Total
19
438.0
'RQRWUHMHFW+ WKHUHLVQRGLIIHUHQFHDPRQJWKHFKHPLFDOW\SHV
E VHWHTXDOWR
F 
G 9DULDELOLW\LVVPDOOHULQFKHPLFDO

%#

#$

%#

&'()*+,)( -) ./0123405

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"*+,- ./0

Analysis of Variance for UNIFORMI


Source
DF
SS
MS
F
WAFERPOS
3
16.220
5.407
8.29
Error
8
5.217
0.652
Total
11
21.437
5HMHFW+ WKHUHLVDVLJQLILFDQWGLIIHUHQFHDPRQJZDIHUSRVLWLRQ
E 
F 
G *UHDWHUYDULDELOLW\DWZDIHUSRVLWLRQ

!"#$%&'

!"#$%&'

<"





&"!

"!"

"!

%!$#

!$!

!$#

(("#%

($"%#

"!$

!""#$%&'(#

'()*+,-*) .* /01234

"!#

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"*+! ,#**!$ (&'%!"

!"#$%&'

"!

&'()*+,)( -) ./0123

!"#$

!"

'%&$

%&%

%&$

&%)

&%(

&%'

$%&

$%$

F
8.92
4.39

"

!""#$

!""#$

"

!"#$%&#" '# ()*+,-

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"*+,,-.

P
0.000
0.007



Source
DF
SS
MS
F
P
TIPTYPE
3
0.38500
0.12833
14.44 0.001
SPECIMEN
3
0.82500
0.27500
30.94 0.000
Error
9
0.08000
0.00889
Total
15
1.29000
5HMHFW+ WKHUHDUHVLJQLILFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVLQKDUGQHVVPHDVXUHPHQWVEHWZHHQWKHWLSV
E 
F 5HVLGXDOVDUHDFFHSWDEOH

"!%

%"$&

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"(*+,-./0

'"$%

!"#$%&'

(&")*

E 

F

#!

'"#)

'"!)

'"*)

("')

("()

D
Source
DF
SS
MS
NOZZLE
4
0.102180
0.025545
VELOCITY
5
0.062867
0.012573
Error
20
0.057300
0.002865
Total
29
0.222347
5HMHFW+ QR]]OHW\SHDIIHFWVVKDSHPHDVXUHPHQW

6HFWLRQ

!"#$
!"#$%&'

!"#$%&'

!"#$
!"#$%&'

$"#

$"*

$")

!"#$%"&

$"'

$"&

$"%

!""#$%&'(#

$"$

!"!

!"

!"#

!"#$%&

%#$#

%#$#!

%#$#"

#$##

#$#"

#$#6

#$%%&'()*+&

#$"#

&'()*+,)( -) ./012345

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"*+! ,#**!$ (&'%!"

#$"6



%#$#

"

%#$#"

#$##

#$#"

#$#!

%#$#!

!"#$%&#" '# ()*+,-./

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"*+ !"#$

&$%$!

#$#!

"

'$!'(!"

()*+,-.+* /+ 012345667

"

!"

&'()*+,)( -) ./0123455

%&'()*+,'-&.'*'$"/$

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"1.+12+,

Source
DF
SS
MS
F
P
TEST
2 0.0014000 0.0007000
3.00 0.125
SUBJECT
3 0.0212250 0.0070750
30.32 0.001
Error
6 0.0014000 0.0002333
Total
11 0.0240250
'RQRWUHMHFW+ WKHUHLVQRHYLGHQFHRIGLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQWKHWHVWV
E 6RPHLQGLFDWLRQRIYDULDELOLW\LQFUHDVLQJZLWKWKHPDJQLWXGHRIWKHUHVSRQVH

$"(

!"#$%&#" '# ()*+,-../

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"*+! ,#**!$ (&'%!"

&$%$"

&$%$#

$%$$

$%$#

$%$"



+!" !

+!"!(

!"!!

!"!(

!" !

!" (

'$%#$

"

'$%#$

'$%$&

$%$$

$%$&

$%#$

$%#&

'$%$&

$%$$

$%$&

$%#$

$%#&

()*+,-.+* /+ 012345667



$%

*$))

$))

()))

*$))

$))

()))



!"

$))

()**+,-./0+

()))

+,-./01.- 2. 345653798

&

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"12! 3#11!$ (&'%!"

'

"

($))

*$))

$))

()))

#"!$%&'

()

+,-./01.- 2. 345653798

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"-,+ ./0

"

!" !

!"#$%&#" '# ()*+*,)-

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"*+,-.



12

"#$% !

!"#$%&#" '# ()*+*,)-

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"/012-.

Source
DF
SS
MS
F
P
LENGTH
3
72.66
24.22
1.61 0.240
WIDTH
4
90.52
22.63
1.50 0.263
Error
12
180.83
15.07
Total
19
344.01
'RQRWUHMHFW+ PHDQOHDNDJHYROWDJHGRHVQRWGHSHQGRQWKHFKDQQHOOHQJWK
E 2QHXQXVXDOREVHUYDWLRQLQZLGWKOHQJWK

+,-./01.- 2. 34565378

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"*+,

')

Source
DF
SS
MS
F
P
STORAGE
3
1972652
657551
4.33 0.014
LOT
8
1980499
247562
1.63 0.169
Error
24
3647150
151965
Total
35
7600300
5HMHFW+ WKHVWRUDJHWLPHVDUHVLJQLILFDQWO\GLIIHUHQW
E 3YDOXH!
F 
G 2EVHUYDWLRQVIURPORWDWGD\VDSSHDUVXQXVXDO2WKHUZLVHWKHUHVLGXDOVDUHDFFHSWDEOH

!"#$%&'

!"#$%&'

!"#$%&'

!"#$%&'

!"#$%&'

!"#$%&'

!"#$%&'

!"#$%&'
!"#$%&'

!"#$%&'

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"*+,-./,0

!"#$%&'

"

"

!""#$%&'(#



3RZHU!E





7KHUHIRUHQ!LVQHHGHG

Q





W





W







D Q





SRZHU!E





D!D Q !DQGW!7KXVE!DQGSRZHU!

D Q





)



D!D Q !DQGW!7KXVE!DQGSRZHU!

)





7KHUHIRUHQ!LVQHHGHG

Q



 W!!W !W"!W#!W$!) !Q

 W !W!!W"!W#!
Q 
)
Q
D  
D Q    Q  
 
9DULRXVFKRLFHV
D Q
Q
)
)








7KHUHIRUHQ!LVQHHGHG



P
0.009
0.031

3RZHU!E



Source
DF
SS
MS
F
LENGTH
3
8.1775
2.7258
6.16
WIDTH
4
6.8380
1.7095
3.86
Error
12
5.3100
0.4425
Total
19
20.3255
5HMHFW+ PHDQOHDNDJHYROWDJHGRHVGHSHQGRQFKDQQHOOHQJWK

6HFWLRQ



!"#$%&'

#$%&'()&% *& +,-.-/,0

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"*+! ,#**!$ (&'%!"



#6#

#6"

#6!

#6

$#6!

$#6"



$!#

$"#

"#

!#

!!"#

G  

"

!"#$%!&

!"#$%&#" '# ()*+*,)-.

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"*+,- .+/

213/

2130

131

130

13/

134

130

213/

2130

131

130

13/

134

$!#

$"#

"#

!#

2/

13/



)*++(,-$%.(

134

!"#$%&#" '# ()*+*,)-.

136

""#

P
0.017

$%&&'()*+,'

"!#

%&'()*+(' ,( -./0/1234

" #

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"./! 0#..!$ (&'%!"

P
0.000

20

135

!"#$% &'!"(

!"#$%&#" '# ()*+*,)-.

!"#$% &"!'$'(%()* &%!) !+ ),- .-/(01$%/

F
5.29

"##

.-/(01$%/2-"/1/),- 3())-0 2$%1-/

Analysis of Variance for SURFROUG


Source
DF
SS
MS
MATERIAL
3
0.2604
0.0868
Error
11
0.1804
0.0164
Total
14
0.4408
5HMHFW+%
E 2QHREVHUYDWLRQLVDQRXWOLHU

"

%&'()*+(' ,( -./0/12344

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"*++,-

Analysis of Variance for RESISTAN


Source
DF
SS
MS
F
ALLOY
2
10941.8
5470.9
76.09
Error
27
1941.4
71.9
Total
29
12883.2
5HMHFW+%
E 
F  
G 9DULDELOLW\RIWKHUHVLGXDOVLQFUHDVHVZLWKWKHUHVSRQVH

6XSSOHPHQWDO([HUFLVHV

!"#$%&'

!"#$%&'
!"#$%&'

!"#$%&'
!"#$%&'

"5#



$&#

&#

$&

$%

$!

$"

"

!"#$%

7#

"! /!01"

7&

'()*+,-*) .* 819:;34

!"#$%&'"(!)"%",+*3+ 4,

6#

Analysis of Variance for VOLUME


Source
DF
SS
MS
TEMPERAT
2
16480
8240
Error
12
12610
1051
Total
14
29090
5HMHFW+ 
E 3YDOXH!
F 
G

G 0HWKRG

"

'()*+,-*) .* /01234

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"*+,-./





$&#

&#

$&

$%

$!

$"

"

""6#

F
7.84

""<#

"!##

&'(()*+,-.)

"!"#

'()*+,-*) .* 819:;34

P
0.007

&'(()*+,-.)

!!5#

"!!#

"! #

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"01! 2#00!$ (&'%!"

!"5&

'()*+,-*) .* /01234

P
0.211

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"01! 2#00!$ (&'%!"

5





F
1.68

""7#

!"5#

'LIIHUHQFHV





Analysis of Variance for SCORE


Source
DF
SS
MS
METHOD
2
13.55
6.78
Error
21
84.77
4.04
Total
23
98.32
'RQRWUHMHFW+
E 3YDOXH!
F

D!Q !06!!
&RPSDULVRQV
YV
YV
YV
YV



!"#$%&'

!"#$%&'

!"#$%&'

!"#$%&'

"!%#

!!5&

"!&#

#5#

#5&

8611

611

0111



8176

171

176

$#5&



!"#$%&'

!"#$%&'
!"#$%&'

"&#

!"#$!%&

&"01$2#

!"#$%&#" '# <=-)>>?>/

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"/ 34-5,

DF
5
7
35
47

'())*+,-./*

!"#$%&#" '# ()*+,-+./

!##

SS
2825746
2710323
3175290
8711358

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"01! 2#00!$ (&'%!"

Source
ALGORITH
PROJECT
Error
Total
5HMHFW+
E

"##

!"#$%&#" '# ()*+,-+./

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"*+,-.+/0

Source
DF
SS
MEANWEIG
2
0.2227
AIRTEMP
5
10.1852
Error
10
0.7509
Total
17
11.1588
5HMHFW+
E 
F



8611

611

0111

MS
565149
387189
90723

8176

171

176

MS
0.1113
2.0370
0.0751

!"#$%&'
!"#$%&'

61

!"#$%&

P
0.000
0.002

41

31

!"#$%&#" '# ()*+,-+./

340"!#5

!"#$%&#" '# <=-)>>?>/

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"*673 +,8

F
6.23
4.27

51

P
0.273
0.000

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"*+ ,-./

F
1.48
27.13

21

011

#"!!

"!!

!!!

!""#$%&'(#

"!!

)

D Q



"!








3RZHU!E
















7KHVDPSOHVL]HVKRXOGEHDSSUR[LPDWHO\Q!

)URP&KDUW9,,E!DQGWKHSRZHU!E!

D  O

!!!

>                @


 
) 

1XPHUDWRUGHJUHHVRIIUHHGRP! D    Q
'HQRPLQDWRUGHJUHHVRIIUHHGRP! !#" $ ! % ! "

 )

D P!  !DQG

F 7KHEHVWFKRLFHLVDOJRULWKP

$%&'()*'& +' ,-./00102

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"*+! ,#**!$ (&'%!"



P  D  H !7KHQ \ !  \
"

H !  H "DQG

LVUHFRJQL]HGWREHWKHVDPSOHYDULDQFHRIWKHLQGHSHQGHQWUDQGRPYDULDEOHV

DQG \



$
H !"  H !%
' V$

#
$
7KHUHIRUH (
V$ 
V DQG ( 06& D
Q 
! #

7KHGHYHORSPHQWZRXOGQRWFKDQJHLIWKHUDQGRPHIIHFWVPRGHOKDGEHHQVSHFLILHGEHFDXVH
H !  H IRUWKLVPRGHODOVR
\ !\

Q 
H "  H #  H ! 

" $
!
\ !#  \ ! "
#
D Q  

H "  H"%

06

0LQG([SDQGLQJ([HUFLVHV

)URP&KDUW9,,,ZLWKQXPHUDWRUGHJUHHVRIIUHHGRP!D!GHQRPLQDWRUGHJUHHVRIIUHHGRP!D Q 
!E!DQGWKHSRZHU!E!
E
Q
D Q
O
E
3RZHU!E





7KHVDPSOHVL]HVKRXOGEHDSSUR[LPDWHO\Q!





!"#$%&'










!

"

)
"

06 !
06!

\#$  \ "$ "


\#$  \ "$ "
DQG 06
06! "

LVWRRODUJH

V"! 

 Q  

DQG

"

Q

\  \
#

F\

Q V"

"

G\

"

7KHQ 9 F <

"

"

"

"

"

"

\ 

"

DOZD\VKROGV8SRQGLYLGLQJERWKVLGHVE\Q

()*%(+*,(-

"

'

"

$$

"

DQGWKLVHTXDOVWKHVXPRI

"

7KHQ !#

! !
& '#
%
"

!$

"!

"

"!



) * #

!"

"!

! !! !

$
'
(
& (
%
!
!

PHDQRIP DQGP!7KHUHIRUH

$! 

! !! "

!!

!#

!" #
$
"

"#

WKHVTXDUHGGLVWDQFHVDORQJHDFKRIWKHIRXUD[HV
#
Q P"  P
"
'#
" !
ZHRQO\QHHGWRVKRZVWKDW
%HFDXVH )
d P !  P # 

DV
! $
/HWP DQGP!GHQRWHWKHPHDQVWKDWGLIIHUE\'1RZ P  [ !  P !  [ ! LVPLQLPL]HGIRU[HTXDOWRWKH

RWKHUWKUHHD[HV7KHVTXDUHRIWKHGLVWDQFHRIWKHSRLQWIURPWKHRULJLQLV

ZHKDYH 4  4  4

\
\

ZKLFKHTXDOV 66
7KHHTXDWLRQDERYHFDQEHREWDLQHG
Q
1
IURPDJHRPHWULFDODUJXPHQW7KHVTXDUHRIWKHGLVWDQFHRIDQ\SRLQWLQIRXUGLPHQVLRQDOVSDFHIURPWKH
]HURSRLQWFDQEHH[SUHVVHGDVWKHVXPRIWKHVTXDUHGGLVWDQFHDORQJIRXURUWKRJRQDOD[HV/HWRQHRIWKH
D[HVEHWKHGHJUHHOLQHDQGOHWWKHSRLQWEH $ !$ "$ #$ 7KHWKUHHRUWKRJRQDOFRQWUDVWVDUHWKH

"

"

&

V F Q

F 9 < IURPWKHLQGHSHQGHQFHRI <!#  <" #  < # 

,IEFDQGGDUHWKHFRHIILFLHQWVRIWKUHHRUWKRJRQDOFRQWUDVWVLWFDQEHVKRZQWKDW
E\

$OVR 9 < !

"

9 F <

XVHGLQWKHWWHVW

V!"  V""
ZKLFKLVWKHSRROHGYDULDQFHHVWLPDWH


LVUHFRJQL]HGDVWKHVDPSOHVWDQGDUGGHYLDWLRQ

FDOFXODWHGIURPWKHGDWDIURPSRSXODWLRQL7KHQ 06

06

% #

! $" $

%
\ !"  \ !&

ZKHQHYHU)" W ! W DQGWKHWZRWHVWVDUHLGHQWLFDO
!

&RQVHTXHQWO\ ) W $OVRWKHGLVWULEXWLRQWKHVTXDUHRIDWUDQGRPYDULDEOHZLWKD Q GHJUHHVRI


IUHHGRPLVDQ)GLVWULEXWLRQZLWKDQGD Q GHJUHHVRIIUHHGRP7KHUHIRUHLIWKHWDEXODWHGWYDOXHIRUD
WZRVLGHGWWHVWRIVL]H DLVW WKHQWKHWDEXODWHG)YDOXHIRUWKH)WHVWDERYHLV ! ! 7KHUHIRUHW! W 

1RZ

Q \ $  \ $$ #

7KHWZRVDPSOHWWHVWUHMHFWVHTXDOLW\RIPHDQVLIWKHVWDWLVWLF
_ \"  \ # _ _ \"  \ # _ LVWRRODUJH7KH$129$)WHVWUHMHFWVHTXDOLW\RIPHDQVLI
W
V ""
V #





ZKHUH V

"

Q

\  \
#

%HFDXVH V! LVWKHVDPSOHYDULDQFHRI

KDVDFKLVTXDUHGLVWULEXWLRQZLWKQGHJUHHVRIIUHHGRP7KHQ

! %

"

&
V!

Q V " 

KDVDFKLVTXDUHGLVWULEXWLRQZLWK1DGHJUHHVRIIUHHGRP1RZ

V"

E\DQDOJHEUDLFVROXWLRQIRU

DQG #! !



"$ 

06
V"
3 I D
d
d ID
 D
)" ( $ " )(% " $ 06# QV "  V "
( $ " )(% " $




V"

06
06

)
)
  d
d
 
3
*
*
"
D
D
Q
06
Q
06
D  1  D
#
#
V
  D  1  D




7KHUHIRUH

QV "  V "
KDVDQ )' $ " )&('% " $& GLVWULEXWLRQ
06#

06

V$
DQG 06 LVQWLPHVWKHVDPSOHYDULDQFHRI \!  \ "  \  7KHUHIRUH
Q
D   06
KDVDFKLVTXDUHGLVWULEXWLRQZLWKDGHJUHHVRIIUHHGRP8VLQJWKH
QV "  V "

V$

1  D 06%

LQGHSHQGHQFHRI06 DQG06!ZHFRQFOXGHWKDW

D   06

!

V$ 

9 <!

)URP([HUFLVH

FKLVTXDUHGLVWULEXWLRQZLWKD Q GHJUHHVRIIUHHGRP&RQVHTXHQWO\


D Q   06%
3 F 
 D
d
d F
D  D Q  
 D  D Q  
V$



D Q   06%
D Q   06%
$
3
dV d

F
F
D  D Q  
 D D Q  



8VLQJWKHIDFWWKDWD Q "1DFRPSOHWHVWKHGHULYDWLRQ

D Q   06 LVDVXPRILQGHSHQGHQWFKLVTXDUHUDQGRPYDULDEOHV&RQVHTXHQWO\ D Q   06 KDVD
V!
V!

Q   6

D Q  

\ !# \!$  \ !"  

06

" $

&
\ !#  \ !'

! %# %







V"

V"

V"
d 8

"

"

#  # V $
& '
Q
Q
#  # Q#O #  $ O $  " O "
& '
1
1

1  Q#
#  # $ Q# 
& '
1$

"

O # IURPWKHFRQVWUDLQW

D
#  # <##  #  # <#&  # <$#  # <$&   # <"#  # <"& D
& '
& '
'
'
'
'

9 ;  > ( ; @ 7KHQ

# GLVWULEXWLRQ

! #



& $
$
$
$
$
Q! ^ #  # V  O ! `
Q! >   L V  Q! O ! @
Q! O !
'
&L '
! #
%HFDXVH ( 06(
( 06
V$  ! #
D
D
D
WKLVGRHVVXJJHVWWKDWWKHQXOOK\SRWKHVLVLVDVJLYHQLQWKHH[HUFLVH

7KHQ

( <#%  <%%

9 <#%  <%%

DQG

V V

%# $" !

DQGIRUDQ\UDQGRPYDULDEOH; ( ;

$
Q! ^ 9 <!%  <%%  >( <!%  <%% @ `
! #

1RZ <#%  <%%

( 06

"

D




LVDFRQILGHQFHLQWHUYDOIRU
8 / 

$
Q! \!%  \%%
! #

"

V"

V"

d 8  

d 8  

V"  V"

V"

V"  

d 8




d
d
8   V "  V" /  

3 /   d

7KHUHIRUH

06

V"

V"

V"
/
8

d
d
/   V"  V" 8  

V"


d
  d  
8
/
V"

3 /   d

06
V"
KDVDQ )"
06! QV "  V "



d
d
8 V" /

3 / d

3 / d

)URP([HUFLVH
 D

 D

DQG

$VLQ([HUFLVH

V$ 



E %HFDXVHQGHWHUPLQHVRQHRIWKHGHJUHHVRIIUHHGRPRIWKHWDEXODWHG)YDOXHRQWKHULJKWVLGHRIWKHHTXDWLRQLQSDUWD
VRPHDSSUR[LPDWLRQLVQHHGHG%HFDXVHWKHYDOXHIRUDFRQILGHQFHLQWHUYDOEDVHGRQDQRUPDOGLVWULEXWLRQLVZH
DSSUR[LPDWH W D
E\DQG
& '! $(

 W %
)!&$& '! $( E\
D & '! $(

  
7KHQ Q
 :LWKQ"D Q "DQG )*-*+&$,+
 
&

7KHYDOXHFDQEHXVHGIRU)LQWKHHTXDWLRQIRUQDQGDQHZYDOXHFDQEHFRPSXWHGIRUQDV
  
 " 
Q

%HFDXVHWKHVROXWLRQIRUQGLGQRWFKDQJHZHFDQXVHQ",IQHHGHGDQRWKHULWHUDWLRQFRXOGEHXVHGWR
UHILQHWKHYDOXHRIQ

%"#(
D ,I$LVWKHZLGWKRIWKHLQWHUYDOWKHQ W D
!
& '! $(

%"#(
%
%
6TXDULQJERWKVLGHV\LHOGV W
$
D & '! $( !

$VLQ([HUFLVH W %
)!&$& '! $( 7KHQ
D & '! $(

06))!&$& '! $(
Q
$%





.,-

,-

%#$

#$

Source
material
temperat
material*temperat
Error
Total

DF
2
2
4
27
35

SS
10683.7
39118.7
9613.8
18230.7
77647.0

&+$37(5

,-

"

!""#$%&'(#

+--

!"#$%&#" '# (')"*

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"*+! ,#**!$ (&'%!"

!"#!$%

!"#$%&#" '# (')"*

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"*! !"#$%

#$

$$

#$

+,-



!"#!$%

%#$

#$

"

&'()*+,)( -) .-/(0

!
"

!
"

%&'()*&+

F
7.91
28.97
3.56

!"#$%!&

&"'()*$+',"#'*' $%"#($+

"

MS
5341.9
19559.4
2403.4
675.2

,QWHUDFWLRQ3ORW0HDQVIRUOLIH

0DLQIDFWRUVDQGLQWHUDFWLRQDUHDOOVLJQLILFDQW
E

6HFWLRQ

!"#$%&'

!"#$%&'

!"#



!"#$%&'

P
0.002
0.000
0.019

!"#$%&'



!"#$%&'

!"#$%&'

"#

)#((* +',-*

3!

Source
glasstyp
phostype
glasstyp*phostype
Error
Total

4!

&'()*+,)( -) ).'//-,-0

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"./! 0#..!$ (&'%!"

!"#$%

DF
1
2
2
12
17

2!

SS
14450.0
933.3
133.3
633.3
16150.0

%"!

%$!

$!

"!

$1!

"

!"#$% &



,*)

%$!

*)

*+

,+

&'()*+,)( -) !""#$%&

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"*+,"-.*!

*()

!"##$%&

*(+

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"*'&""+,-"#./0$.# 1. !""#$%&

F
273.79
8.84
1.26

&'#$(

$1#

&'()*+,)( -) ).'//-,-00

P
0.000
0.004
0.318

P
0.193
0.930
0.026

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"-&#+.

F
1.90
0.07
5.03

MS
14450.0
466.7
66.7
52.8

MS
355.6
13.7
939.4
186.9

0DLQHIIHFWVDUHVLJQLILFDQWWKHLQWHUDFWLRQLVQRWVLJQLILFDQW
F

5!

"!

&'()*+,)( -) ).'//-,-0

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"$)*#+,

%#

$!

$#

%"!

%$!

$!

"!

%"!

%$!

$!

"!

SS
355.6
27.4
1878.8
2242.7
4504.4

2QO\WKHLQWHUDFWLRQLVVLJQLILFDQW
E

DF
1
2
2
12
17

!"#$%&'

!"#$%&'

'()

"1!



!"#$%&'

!"#$%&'



!"#$%&'

Source
paint
drying
paint*drying
Error
Total

'7)

'+)

'6)

'($$)*+"!,)

'5)

Source
furnacep
temperat
furnacep*temperat
Error
Total

'2)

'4)

DF
1
2
2
12
17

'3)

2))

%!!

!!!

!"

*&!

*'!

*(!

*)!

*!

)!

(!

'!

$!!

#!!

!""#$%&'(#

"!!

!!

/-.



P
0.002
0.000
0.427

!"#$%&'

/-0

!"#$%&#" '# ("&#')*+

,' !"#$% &'( # -#(.$/'+

MS
F
7160
16.00
472671 1056.12
409
0.91
448

Fisher's pairwise comparisons


Family error rate = 0.117
Individual error rate = 0.0500
Critical value = 2.131
Intervals for (column level mean) - (row level mean)
800
825
825
-518.4
-445.0
850
-27.9
453.8
45.5
527.2

&!!

+,-./01.- 2. 3-1.2456

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"*+! ,#**!$ (&'%!"

30.

!"#!$%

#"

31.

$"

%&!
%"

32.

%!

3/.

/.

,.

2.

1.

%"!

&"

SS
7160
945342
818
5371
958691

3,.

""

&'( # )'*+'($)

!"#$%&#" '# ("&#')*+

! !"#$%

%RWKPDLQIDFWRUVDUHVLJQLILFDQW
F

'')

-"#./0$.# 1. !""#$%&

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"+.! /#++!$ (&'%!"

%#!

%$!

$!

#!

"!

,*)

,+

*)

*+

!"#$%&'

,-.



!"#$%&'

*'

*(

*)

&!

%!

$!

!""#$ !

#!

!""#$ !%

)!

(!

*'

*(

*)

'

"!

+,-./01.- 2. 34,/2156

*'

*(

*)

'

&!

+7-41. 4,- 218294:-8 ;< .0=28 92,9=-.6

1+2,'+-"+3 4&),#56 78 *+,,!)*+

()%%#*+',-#

)!

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"-/! 0#--!$ (&'%!"

!!

!"#$%&'

$!

%!

$!

(!

#!

%#&"#$'%

"!

+,-./01.- 2. 34,/2156

V








6DPHFRQFOXVLRQV

!!

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"-!.,!)&-

Fisher's pairwise comparisons


Family error rate = 0.195
Individual error rate = 0.0500
Critical value = 2.048
Intervals for (column level mean) - (row level mean)
40
60
80
60
-7.139
0.389
80
-9.264
-5.889
-1.736
1.639
100
-16.514
-13.139
-11.014
-8.986
-5.611
-3.486
G 1REHFDXVHWKHIDFWRUVGRQRWLQWHUDFW

'!

!"#$%&'

(&)*#+,

'

#!

+,-./01.- 2. 34,/2156

"!

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"*+,,!)*+

!!

)!

(!



!"#$%&'
!"#$%&'
!"#$%&'



+#,, -./0)

'()*+,-*) .* /(,012(34

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"12! 3#11!$ (&'%!"

!"#$%!&

"$

""



&$#!
!

!"#$%!&

&$#!

$#$

$#"

$#!

&"#%

&"#$

&$#%

$#$

$#%

"#$

&$#"

"

'()*+,-*) .* :-/(,0124

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"!*+#),*-

F 5HVLGXDOSORWVRQWKHORJVFDOHDUHLPSURYHG

"

'()*+,-*) .* /(,012(34

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"!*+#),*-

&$#"

$#$

$#"

$#!

&"#%

&"#$

&$#%

$#$

$#%

"#$

&"#%

&"#$

&$#%

$#$

$#%

"#$

Source
DF
SS
frequenc
2
209.893
environm
2
64.252
frequenc*environm
4
101.966
Error
27
5.424
Total
35
381.535
%RWKPDLQIDFWRUVDQGLQWHUDFWLRQDUHVLJQLILFDQW
E
Source
DF
SS
frequenc
2
7.5702
environm
2
2.3576
frequenc*environm
4
3.5284
Error
27
0.2529
Total
35
13.7092

!"#$%&'
!"#$%&'

F
404.09
125.85
94.17

MS
3.7851
1.1788
0.8821
0.0094

'$ () !*

'()*+,-*) .* :-/(,0124

!"#$%&'"(!)"%".)!/%!*0

'$ () !*

!"#$%&'"(!)"%".)!/%!*0
'()*+,-*) .* /(,012(34

F
522.40
159.92
126.89

MS
104.946
32.126
25.491
0.201

P
0.000
0.000
0.000

P
0.000
0.000
0.000

"$

"$



!"#$%&'

!"#$%&'

#!"

!""#$%&'(#

!"

!!" #



'%&"

'%&#

"

%&%

%&$

%&#

%&"

'%&"

!!" #

'%&#

()*+,-.+* /+ 01))*.23

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"&**!&'

'%&$

"

&

$&%

"

P
0.000
0.000
0.048

!"#$%

$&

!"#$%&#" '# ()!!"&*+

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"$*+#,-

&'()*+

Source
DF
SS
MS
F
doping
1
1.442
1.442
25.23
anneal
4
124.238
31.059 543.52
doping*anneal
4
0.809
0.202
3.54
Error
10
0.571
0.057
Total
19
127.060
%RWKPDLQIDFWRUVDQGWKHLQWHUDFWLRQDUHVLJQLILFDQW
E
,QWHUDFWLRQ3ORW0HDQVIRUFXUUHQW

$!"

'%&$

%&%

%&$

%&#

%&"

%$!

%$!#

$!$

$!#

&'()*+,)( -) .,/'+0123

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"*+! ,#**!$ (&'%!"

!"#

$!

!"#$%&'

#&%

-5-

-5,

-56

-54

7-54

7-56

7-5,



,-

,,

Fisher's pairwise comparisons


Family error rate = 0.258
Individual error rate = 0.0500
Critical value = 2.131
Intervals for (column level mean) - (row level mean)
1
2
3
4
2
-4.9187
-3.6113
3
-6.6662
-2.4012
-5.3588
-1.0938
4
-6.9487
-2.6837
-0.9362
-5.6413
-1.3763
0.3712
5
-7.4787
-3.2137
-1.4662
-1.1837
-6.1713
-1.9063
-0.1588
0.1237



!""#$%&'(#

!"#$!
$
r

!"#$%&#" '# ()!!"&*+

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"*+! ,#**!$ (&'%!"

F 7KHFRQFOXVLRQVDUHWKHVDPH

r V



D  E
Source
DF
SS
MS
F
P
hardwood
2
8.3750
4.1875
7.64 0.003
cookingt
1
17.3611
17.3611
31.66 0.000
freeness
2
21.8517
10.9258
19.92 0.000
hardwood*cookingt
2
3.2039
1.6019
2.92 0.075
hardwood*freeness
4
6.5133
1.6283
2.97 0.042
cookingt*freeness
2
1.0506
0.5253
0.96 0.399
Error
22
12.0644
0.5484
Total
35
70.4200
$OOPDLQIDFWRUVDUHVLJQLILFDQW7KHLQWHUDFWLRQRIKDUGZRRG IUHHQHVVLVDOVRVLJQLILFDQW

6HFWLRQ



!"#$%&'

!"#$%&'



!"#$%&'

!"#$%&'

#!"

!""#"$$

!!"

+,!-.&&-

$!

&'()*+,)( -) ).'(,/.01

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"1&)$2--$

!""

""

2"

!"

%$

"

%$

"

$3!

,,.

,/.

,-.



3/

3/

!"#!$%

3,

3,

,0.

30

30

,1.

31

,..

!"#$%&#" '# #4%!"+

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"*!+,!)&*

$36
%&&'(#)*

$35

46

!""#$%&'(#

44

&#!$% &$

!"#$%&#" '# #4%!"+

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"-,!)&*-)

F
40.25
26.23
14.58
15.75
6.93
1.38

45

!"#$%&#" '# #(!"&)(*+

$""

$34

P
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.003
0.263

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"*+! ,#**!$ (&'%!"

$3

&'()*+,)( -) ).'(,/.01

!"#$%&'"(!)"%",--.#+/0

Source
DF
SS
MS
cycletim
2
393.037
196.519
operator
2
256.148
128.074
temperat
1
71.185
71.185
cycletim*operator
4
307.519
76.880
cycletim*temperat
2
67.704
33.852
operator*temperat
2
13.481
6.741
Error
40
195.296
4.882
Total
53
1304.370
2QO\WKHRSHUDWRU WHPSHUDWXUHLQWHUDFWLRQLVLQVLJQLILFDQW
E

$"

#""

&'()*+,)( -) ).'(,/.01

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"*)!!+!""

31

%$

"

%$

"

!"#$%&'

!"#$ !"

!"#$%&'

$"$

23"

3/

3,

30

31

/.



"#!

#!

"#!

#!

'(')! *"

-.

!"#$%&#" '# #4%!"+

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"-.-'!*#/

2.

3/

3,

30

31

00

05
+* !, -%).!

!"#$%&#" '# #4%!"+

"

"

()$$'

$%&'()*'& +' ,+-&.

!"#$%&'"(!)"%""-!!$

!"#$

$%&'()*'& +' ,+-&.

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"&*+'!



"#!

#!

"#!

#!

"

1#!

0#!

*+,,$'- #.$

$%&'()*'& +' ,+-&.

/#!

!"#$%&'"(!)"%".,! /#..!$ (&'%!"

% &'!$((

$%&'()*'& +' ,+-&.

!"#$%&'"(!)"%",&)$*!""

P
0.502
0.010
0.023
0.677
0.000
0.377

,0

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"*.! /#**!$ (&'%!"

Source
DF
SS
MS
F
speed
1
1332
1332
0.49
hardness
1
28392
28392
10.42
angle
1
20592
20592
7.56
speed*hardness
1
506
506
0.19
speed*angle
1
56882
56882
20.87
hardness*angle
1
2352
2352
0.86
Error
9
24530
2726
Total
15
134588
E \![ !""#[$%&#'" [%'()"[ !""# %'()"
F

6HFWLRQ

!"#$%&'
!"#$%&'
!"#$%&'

!"#$%&'
!"#$%&'
!"#$%&'

,5

##!





!"#$%&'

!"#$%&'

!"#$%&'

"#

"#

"#

"

"

".

"

"#$%&' ()#$*

$%&'()*'& +' ',)%&-

,-).&' /)-0&0#'#12 /'-1 -3 14! !"#$%&'"

$%&'()*'& +' ',)%&-

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"+

!"#$%&#" '# # (%!")

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"*



,-

"#

"

,*

!"# $%&# " '# # (%!")

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"+

$%&'()*'& +' ',)%&-

P
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.070
0.736
0.910
0.575
0.000
0.822
0.270
0.270
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.157

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"*

Estimated Effects and Coefficients for score


Term
Effect
Coef StDev Coef
T
Constant
175.250
0.5467 320.59
A
8.250
4.125
0.5467
7.55
B
-10.375
-5.187
0.5467
-9.49
C
2.125
1.062
0.5467
1.94
D
-0.375
-0.187
0.5467
-0.34
A*B
-0.125
-0.063
0.5467
-0.11
A*C
-0.625
-0.313
0.5467
-0.57
A*D
9.125
4.562
0.5467
8.35
B*C
-0.250
-0.125
0.5467
-0.23
B*D
1.250
0.625
0.5467
1.14
C*D
-1.250
-0.625
0.5467
-1.14
A*B*C
-8.000
-4.000
0.5467
-7.32
A*B*D
-9.250
-4.625
0.5467
-8.46
A*C*D
-8.750
-4.375
0.5467
-8.00
B*C*D
-8.625
-4.312
0.5467
-7.89
A*B*C*D
-1.625
-0.812
0.5467
-1.49

!"#$%&'

!"#$%&'

$"

"
#
"#
!"

#!!

!!"#$

"!!!

!"#$%&#" '# #(!"&)(*+ ,-$*. / 0123

!!!



7KHHIIHFWVWKDWDSSHDUWREHLPSRUWDQWDUH$%'(DQGWKHLQWHUDFWLRQV$%'(DQG$%'

%&'()*
+#&'"

"

D
(VWLPDWHG(IIHFWVDQG&RHIILFLHQWVIRUVWUHQJWK
7HUP(IIHFW
$
%
&
'
(
$ %
$ &
$ '
$ (
% &
% '
% (
& '
& (
' (
$ % &
$ % '
$ % (
$ & '
$ & (
$ ' (
% & '
% & (
% ' (
& ' (
$ % & '
$ % & (
$ % ' (
$ & ' (
% & ' (
$ % & ' (
E



1RUPDO3UREDELOLW\3ORWRIWKH(IIHFWV

VWDQGDUGHUURURIWKHHIIHFWV!&RQVWUXFWDSSUR[LPDWHFRQILGHQFHLQWHUYDOVRQHDFKHVWLPDWHG
HIIHFWHVWLPDWHGHIIHFWr VWDQGDUGHUURU )URPWKHLQWHUYDOV$&'$'$%&$%'$&'DQG
%&'



-/,,

-0,,

-1,,

-+,,

+,,

1,,

0,,

/,,

.,,

!"#$

$!!

!"

!"#$%&#" '# #(!"&)(*

"!!

!!

!"#$%&!'()$*+!, -&$.)*+/0 1#%/


,!-.%#/&0' ()123
!"#$%&' ()*(+

#!!

#!!

"$!!

"%!!

"&!!

" !!

!!

&!!

%!!

$!!

"

!"#$%&#" '# #(!"&)*

!"#$%&'" (!)"%" *+



7KHQRUPDOSUREDELOLW\SORWRIWKHUHVLGXDOVLQGLFDWHVWKHDVVXPSWLRQRIQRUPDOLW\LVQRWYLRODWHG
7KHPRGHODSSHDUVWREHDGHTXDWH
G 7RPD[LPL]HVWUHQJWKWKHYDULDEOHV$%'DQG(VKRXOGEHLQFUHDVHG9DULDEOH&LVQRWVLJQLILFDQW
WKXVDQ\OHYHORI&ZRXOGEHDFFHSWDEOH

-+

%$!!

!"#$%&'" (!)"%" ,-*

% !! %"!! %#!!

6#$),#2 <:<<<<<<<
5/(#62 789:;77
-2 34

&!!$

&!(
&!$

&#!

&(!

&)!

&''
&'(

&'''

!"#$% &"!'$'(%()* &%!)

%DVHGRQWKHDQDO\VLVRIYDULDQFHWKHPRGHODSSHDUVWREHDGHTXDWH

6RXUFH')6HT66
$
%
'
(
$%
'(
$%'

!"#$%&'



!"#$%&'



!"#$%&'

F 7KHUHJUHVVLRQDQDO\VLVDQGILQDOPRGHODUH
7KHUHJUHVVLRQHTXDWLRQLV
VWUHQJWK $%'($%'(
$%'
3UHGLFWRU&RHI6W'HY73
&RQVWDQW
$
%
'
(
$%
'(
$%'
6 56T 56T DGM  
$QDO\VLVRI9DULDQFH
6RXUFH')6606)3
5HJUHVVLRQ
(UURU
7RWDO

&%

&

&#

"

&%

&

&#

"

&$

#!"

&4

&%

&#

!#

*+ !, -'&.!

&

'()*+,-*) .* /01(2)3

!#"

"

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"-.! /#--!$ (&'%!"

!" #$"

#!$

'()*+,-*) .* /01(2)3

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"*!"*+,"

&%

&

"#$%&'(%$ )% )(*+$%, -&+. / 0123

!"

&#

"

#!"

Adj SS
98.7713
4.4652
19.1101
19.1101

!#

!"



011!*-

!"#$% &"!'$'(%()* &%!) !+ ),- .++-/)0

7HVWSRVLWLRQLVWKHVLJQLILFDQWIDFWRU
F

Analysis of Variance for charge


Source
DF
Seq SS
Main Effects
2
98.771
2-Way Interactions
1
4.465
Residual Error
8
19.110
Pure Error
8
19.110
Total
11
122.347

Estimated Effects and Coefficients for charge


Term
Effect
Coef StDev Coef
Constant
-1.000
0.4462
cleanmet
-5.593
-2.797
0.4462
testpos
-1.280
-0.640
0.4462
cleanmet*testpos
-1.220
-0.610
0.4462

D  E

!"#$% &'!"(

!"#$#%&%'(

!"#$%&'

!"#$%&'

4 5.*6'#7
!4 5.*6'#7!
84 5.*6'#78
94 5.*6'#79

%&!'()!

#!$

'()*+,-*) .* /01(2)3

F
20.67
1.87

P
0.055
0.000
0.189
0.209

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"*'!&+,!-

Adj MS
49.386
4.465
2.389
2.389

T
-2.24
-6.27
-1.43
-1.37
P
0.001
0.209

!"



#$

#!

"

#!



!"#$% &'!"(

"

!"#$%&#" '# '&()"# *

!"#$% &"!'$'(%()* &%!) !+ )

! "!#$%&'(#

$FFRUGLQJWRWKHQRUPDOSUREDELOLW\SORWIDFWRUV$%DQG$%DSSHDUWREHVLJQLILFDQW
E  F 5HPRYLQJWKHWKUHHDQGIRXUIDFWRULQWHUDFWLRQVWKHDQDO\VLVDQGUHVLGXDOSORWDUHIRXQG
Term
Effect
Coef StDev Coef
T
P
Constant
35.938
0.6355
56.55 0.000
factor_A
-16.125
-8.063
0.6355 -12.69 0.000
factor_B
3.125
1.562
0.6355
2.46 0.057
factor_C
-1.125
-0.562
0.6355
-0.89 0.417
factor_D
-1.125
-0.562
0.6355
-0.89 0.417
factor_A*factor_B
-4.375
-2.187
0.6355
-3.44 0.018
factor_A*factor_C
-0.625
-0.312
0.6355
-0.49 0.644
factor_A*factor_D
-3.125
-1.562
0.6355
-2.46 0.057
factor_B*factor_C
1.625
0.812
0.6355
1.28 0.257
factor_B*factor_D
0.125
0.063
0.6355
0.10 0.925
factor_C*factor_D
-0.625
-0.313
0.6355
-0.49 0.644

Estimated Effects and Coefficients for inches


Term
Effect
Coef
Constant
35.938
factor_A
-16.125
-8.063
factor_B
3.125
1.562
factor_C
-1.125
-0.562
factor_D
-1.125
-0.562
factor_A*factor_B
-4.375
-2.187
factor_A*factor_C
-0.625
-0.312
factor_A*factor_D
-3.125
-1.562
factor_B*factor_C
1.625
0.812
factor_B*factor_D
0.125
0.063
factor_C*factor_D
-0.625
-0.313
factor_A*factor_B*factor_C
0.625
0.313
factor_A*factor_B*factor_D
-2.375
-1.188
factor_A*factor_C*factor_D
-1.125
-0.563
factor_B*factor_C*factor_D
-0.875
-0.437
factor_A*factor_B*factor_C
*factor_D
0.125
0.063

!"#$%&'

$"

$#

"

Effect

#!

+,

!!"#$

StDev Coef
0.2786
0.2786
0.2786
0.2786
0.2786
0.2786
0.2786
0.2786
0.2786
0.2786
0.2786
0.2786
0.2786
0.2786
0.2786
0.2786

"!

!"# $%&# " '# . '"/01 +/$)2 3 456*

)*+,'( -+*.'.$($/0 -(*/ *1 / ! 211!3/#

Coef
30.5312
5.9063
16.9687
4.8437
-0.4063
0.2187
3.9687
0.2187
-0.0313
0.4687
0.0313
-0.3437
0.2813
0.4062
0.1563
-0.5938

$
-?&0#8&' ()(((((((
.;6&?' @)ABC2B
9' *>

%##"

%#'
%#"

%!#

%'#

%(#

%&&
%&'

%&&&

Adj SS
11087.9
536.3
39.7

$!

$"



!"#$

Adj MS
F
2217.58 892.61
53.63 21.59
2.48

P
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.164
0.444
0.000
0.444
0.912
0.112
0.912
0.235
0.328
0.164
0.583
0.049

82( 9%!:<

82( 9%!:,

<7

82( 9%!:+

-7
82( 9%!:;

82( 9%!:-

,7

;7

+7

T
109.57
21.20
60.90
17.38
-1.46
0.79
14.24
0.79
-0.11
1.68
0.11
-1.23
1.01
1.46
0.56
-2.13

-31&0453!6#0$738 950:#$7;< =&4;


-!./%#0&1' ()*,2
!"#$%&' ()*+,

"

1RUPDO3UREDELOLW\3ORW

7KHDQDO\VLVFRQILUPVRXUILQGLQJVIURPSDUWD
F

Analysis of Variance for yield


Source
DF
Seq SS
Main Effects
5
11087.9
2-Way Interactions
10
536.3
Residual Error
16
39.7
Total
31
11664.0

11.8125
33.9375
9.6875
-0.8125
0.4375
7.9375
0.4375
-0.0625
0.9375
0.0625
-0.6875
0.5625
0.8125
0.3125
-1.1875

)DFWRUV$%&DQGWKHLQWHUDFWLRQ$%DSSHDUWREHVLJQLILFDQW
E
Term
Constant
factor_A
factor_B
factor_C
factor_D
factor_E
factor_A*factor_B
factor_A*factor_C
factor_A*factor_D
factor_A*factor_E
factor_B*factor_C
factor_B*factor_D
factor_B*factor_E
factor_C*factor_D
factor_C*factor_E
factor_D*factor_E

!"#$% &'!"(

!"#$#%&%'(

P
0.000
0.000

./

.,

"#

"

&!

%!

#!

!""#$ %&'(#

$!

"!

.,

"

!"#$%&#" '# ('")*+

!"#$%&'" (!)"%" ,

!"#$%&#" '# ('")*+

!"#$%&'" (!)"%" *



./

.,

./

.,

.,

.,

"

!"#$%&#" '# ('")*+

!"#$%&'" (!)"%" -

!"#$%&#" '# ('")*+

!"#$%&'" (!)"%" +

7KHUHVLGXDOVDSSHDUQRUPDOO\GLVWULEXWHGKRZHYHUWKHLUYDULDQFHDSSHDUVWRLQFUHDVHDVWKHILWWHGYDOXH
LQFUHDVHV
G

'%

'&

&

!"#$%&#" '# ('")*+

!"#$"%$&'($ )(*&$+",

!"#$"%$&'($ )(*&$+",

!"#$"%$&'($ )(*&$+",

!"#$"%$&'($ )(*&$+",

!"#$"%$&'($ )(*&$+",

!"#$%&'" (!)"%" *+! ,#**!$ (&'%!"


!"#$"%$&'($ )(*&$+",
./

.,

"

%"

$"

'"#$%#
!

&#"'$%$

("!!%&

"

!"#$%&

#!"'$%#

(#"#$%$



,WLVHYLGHQWIURPWKHSORWWKDWZHVKRXOGUXQWKHSURFHVVZLWKDOOIDFWRUVVHWDWWKHLUKLJKOHYHO

)#"$!% $

$#"$!%$

!"# $%&' ( )#*+, -&. /0#%1

I 7RLQFUHDVH\LHOGVHW$%DQG&DWWKHLUKLJKOHYHOV
J

!"#$

#"

""

%$&"'#(&)*$ +,*& -*' .)",/

$OOSORWVVXSSRUWWKHFRQVWDQWYDULDQFHDVVXPSWLRQH[FHSW%
H 7KHLQWHUDFWLRQ$%DSSHDUVWREHVLJQLILFDQW7KHLQWHUDFWLRQSORWIURP0,1,7$%LQGLFDWHVWKDWDKLJK
OHYHORI$DQGRI%LQFUHDVHVWKHPHDQ\LHOG:KLOHORZOHYHOVRIHDFKZRXOGOHDGWRDUHGXFWLRQLQWKH
PHDQ\LHOG

.,

!"#$%&#" '# ('")*+

!"#$%&'" (!)"%" .



&$'

\  \ (
!
"#$"% Q  






ZKHUH \



34 ..
::;<=>?
9DE>D
@F>D
:9>@
;>D
=@E><
E?F>;
D@><

34 5.
1
@@:=>9< :9>@9
9D>ED
;>D=
@>FD
;>;@
D>;D
;>;@
;>@<
;>;;
:F9>D=
E?F>;F <F>EF
<>@;
;>;;:

6
;>;;9
;>?:E
:>;;;
:>;;;
;>?E=

%/2&.









Analysis of Variance for y


Source
DF
Main Effects
3
2-Way Interactions
3
3-Way Interactions
1
Residual Error
4
Curvature
1
Pure Error
3
Total
11

$









%











Seq SS
52128
44038
9316
894
176
718
106377

&









\









Adj SS
52128.4
44038.4
9316.1
894.0
176.0
718.0

Estimated Effects and Coefficients for y


Term
Effect
Coef
Constant
414.58
factor_A
13.75
6.87
factor_B
127.75
63.87
factor_C
97.75
48.87
factor_A*factor_B
-21.25
-10.62
factor_A*factor_C
-137.25
-68.62
factor_B*factor_C
-52.25
-26.13
factor_A*factor_B*factor_C
-68.25
-34.12
Adj MS
17376.1
14679.5
9316.1
223.5
176.0
239.3

StDev Coef
4.316
5.286
5.286
5.286
5.286
5.286
5.286
5.286
P
0.001
0.001
0.003
0.454

0.74

P
0.000
0.263
0.000
0.001
0.115
0.000
0.008
0.003

F
77.74
65.68
41.68

T
96.06
1.30
12.08
9.25
-2.01
-12.98
-4.94
-6.46

7KHGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQWKHWKLVHVWLPDWHDQGWKHHVWLPDWHLQ([HUFLVHLVGXHWRWKHDGGLWLRQRI
FHQWHUSRLQWV

V (

7KHKDQGFDOFXODWLRQRI V ! LV

!"#$%&% '( )"*&"!+, ('* &!+-,%


.'/*+,
01
.,2 ..
5"&! 7((,+8%
9
::;<=>?
@AB"$ C!8,*"+8&'!%
:;
9DE>D
DAB"$ C!8,*"+8&'!%
:;
@F>D
FAB"$ C!8,*"+8&'!%
9
:9>@
9AB"$ C!8,*"+8&'!%
:
;>D
G,%&3/"# 7**'*
9
=@E><
H/*I"8/*,
:
E?F>;
6/*, 7**'*
F
D@><
J'8"#
DE
:@D?;><

D 1RWHWR,QVWUXFWRU,ILQVLJQLILFDQWWHUPVDUHUHPRYHG0LQLWDEZLOOLQFOXGHD/DFNRI)LWWHUPLQWKH
DQDO\VLVRXWSXWDQGWKH06( !"#$%!"&FRPSXWHGE\KDQGZLOOQRWEHHTXLYDOHQWWR06( !"#$%!"&FRPSXWHGE\

6HFWLRQ



0LQLWDE





13.75
127.75
97.75
-137.25

13.75
127.75
97.75
-21.25
-137.25
-52.25
Effect

Effect

Term
Constant
Block
factor_A
factor_B
factor_C
factor_D
factor_A*factor_B
factor_A*factor_C
factor_A*factor_D
factor_B*factor_C
factor_B*factor_D
factor_C*factor_D
factor_A*factor_B*factor_C
factor_A*factor_B*factor_D
factor_A*factor_C*factor_D
factor_B*factor_C*factor_D

%/2&.

















Analysis of Variance for y


Source
DF
Blocks
1
Main Effects
3
2-Way Interactions
1
Residual Error
2
Total
7

Term
Constant
Block
factor_A
factor_B
factor_C
factor_A*factor_B
factor_A*factor_C
factor_B*factor_C
Term
Constant
Block
factor_A
factor_B
factor_C
factor_A*factor_C

%



















-10.000
-0.750
-0.750
5.000
4.500
0.500
-3.750
-1.250
-1.500
1.500
-6.000
4.750
-0.250
-2.000

Effect

$

















Seq SS
9316
52128
37675
6363
105483

Coef
411.87
34.12
6.87
63.87
48.87
-10.63
-68.63
-26.13
Coef
411.87
34.12
6.87
63.87
48.87
-68.63

'
















Coef
183.375
-1.625
-5.000
-0.375
-0.375
2.500
2.250
0.250
-1.875
-0.625
-0.750
0.750
-3.000
2.375
-0.125
-1.000

&

















Adj SS
9316
52128
37675
6363

T
20.65
1.71
0.34
3.20
2.45
-3.44
Adj MS
9316
17376
37675
3182

YDUB

















StDev Coef
19.94
19.94
19.94
19.94
19.94
19.94

F
2.93
5.46
11.84

P
0.002
0.229
0.763
0.085
0.134
0.075
P
0.229
0.159
0.075



$



















Adj SS
141.187
466.250
165.250
3.063
76.562
122.625

2.187

-8.875
0.375
0.375
6.125
5.625
1.625
-2.625
-0.375
-0.875

4.375

'

















Coef
183.938
-3.437
2.563
-2.438
-4.438
0.187
0.187
3.062
2.812
0.813
-1.312
-0.188
-0.438

&

















Effect

%

















Analysis of Variance for var_1


Source
DF
Seq SS
Blocks
3
141.187
Main Effects
4
466.250
2-Way Interactions
4
165.250
3-Way Interactions
1
3.063
4-Way Interactions
1
76.562
Residual Error
2
122.625
Total
15
974.938

Term
Constant
Block 1
2
3
factor_A
factor_B
factor_C
factor_D
factor_A*factor_B
factor_A*factor_C
factor_A*factor_D
factor_B*factor_D
factor_B*factor_C*factor_D
factor_A*factor_B*factor_C
*factor_D

%/2&.

















Adj MS
42.25
126.13
41.30

P
0.000
0.336
0.011
0.820
0.820
0.151

Adj MS
47.062
116.563
41.313
3.063
76.562
61.312

1.958

StDev Coef
1.958
3.391
3.391
3.391
1.958
1.958
1.958
1.958
1.958
1.958
1.958
1.958
1.958

YDUB

















Term
Effect
Coef StDev Coef
T
Constant
183.375
1.607 114.14
Block
-1.625
1.607
-1.01
factor_A
-10.000
-5.000
1.607
-3.11
factor_B
-0.750
-0.375
1.607
-0.23
factor_C
-0.750
-0.375
1.607
-0.23
factor_D
5.000
2.500
1.607
1.56
Analysis of Variance for var_1
Source
DF
Seq SS
Adj SS
Blocks
1
42.25
42.25
Main Effects
4
504.50
504.50
Residual Error
10
413.00
413.00
Total
15
959.75

F
0.77
1.90
0.67
0.05
1.25

0.380

P
0.608
0.373
0.670
0.844
0.380

1.12

P
0.000
0.417
0.529
0.547
0.152
0.932
0.932
0.258
0.287
0.718
0.572
0.932
0.844

P
0.336
0.069

T
93.96
-1.01
0.76
-0.72
-2.27
0.10
0.10
1.56
1.44
0.42
-0.67
-0.10
-0.22

F
1.02
3.05





Run Block
1
1
2
1
3
1
4
1
5
1
6
1
7
1
8
1
9
2
10
2
11
2
12
2
13
2
14
2
15
2
16
2
17
3
18
3
19
3
20
3
21
3
22
3
23
3
24
3
25
4
26
4
27
4
28
4
29
4
30
4
31
4
32
4

Run Block
1
1
2
1
3
1
4
1
5
1
6
1
7
1
8
1
9
1
10
1
11
1
12
1
13
1
14
1
15
1
16
1
17
2
18
2
19
2
20
2
21
2
22
2
23
2
24
2
25
2
26
2
27
2
28
2
29
2
30
2
31
2
32
2

B
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+

B
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+

C
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+

C
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+

D
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+

D
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+

E
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+

E
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+

+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+

+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+



!"#$%&'





*!

)!

(!

'!

&!

!""#$%&'(#

%!

+,-./01.- 2. !

$!

#!

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"*+! ,#**!$ (&'%!"

"!

Analysis of Variance for y


Source
DF
Blocks
3
Main Effects
3
2-Way Interactions
3
Residual Error
6
Total
15

!!

Seq SS
1502.8
9040.2
2627.2
665.5
13835.7

Coef
35.938
-0.063
-8.062
1.563
-0.563
-0.563
-2.187
-0.313
-1.563
0.813
0.063
-0.312
0.313
-1.187
-0.562
-0.438



%#$

#$

%"

%#

"

0.823

0.30

P
0.055
0.001
0.017

P
0.934
0.000
0.013

F
0.01
62.35
8.85

P
0.000
0.934
0.000
0.057
0.013

F
4.52
27.17
7.90

!"#$% &'!"(

&'()*+,)( -) !

Adj MS
500.9
3013.4
875.7
110.9

P
0.000
0.014
0.487
0.054
0.000
0.785
0.033
0.011
0.033
0.130

Adj MS
0.063
539.562
76.562
8.653
3.229
10.687

T
48.87
-0.08
-10.96
2.12
-2.97

!"#$% &"!'$'(%()* &%!) !+ ),- .-/(01$%/

T
21.41
3.43
-0.74
-2.38
-8.59
-0.28
2.75
3.61
-2.75
-1.76

Adj SS
0.06
1079.12
76.56
95.19
9.69
85.50

Adj SS
1502.8
9040.2
2627.2
665.5

Coefficients for y
Coef StDev Coef
56.37
2.633
15.63
4.560
-3.38
4.560
-10.88
4.560
-22.62
2.633
-0.75
2.633
7.25
2.633
9.50
2.633
-7.25
2.633
-4.63
2.633

Analysis of Variance for var_1


Source
DF
Seq SS
Blocks
1
0.06
Main Effects
2
1079.12
2-Way Interactions
1
76.56
Residual Error
11
95.19
Lack of Fit
3
9.69
Pure Error
8
85.50
Total
15
1250.94

D Estimated Effects and


Term
Effect
Constant
Block 1
2
3
A
-45.25
B
-1.50
C
14.50
A*B
19.00
A*C
-14.50
B*C
-9.25

-16.125
3.125
-1.125
-1.125
-4.375
-0.625
-3.125
1.625
0.125
-0.625
0.625
-2.375
-1.125
-0.875

Effect

Estimated Effects and Coefficients for var_1


Term
Effect
Coef StDev Coef
Constant
35.938
0.7354
Block
-0.063
0.7354
factor_A
-16.125
-8.062
0.7354
factor_B
3.125
1.563
0.7354
factor_A*factor_B
-4.375
-2.187
0.7354

Constant
Block
factor_A
factor_B
factor_C
factor_D
factor_A*factor_B
factor_A*factor_C
factor_A*factor_D
factor_B*factor_C
factor_B*factor_D
factor_C*factor_D
factor_A*factor_B*factor_C
factor_A*factor_B*factor_D
factor_A*factor_C*factor_D
factor_B*factor_C*factor_D

Term

!"#$%&'


Run Block
1
1
2
1
3
1
4
1
5
1
6
1
7
1
8
1
9
1
10
1
11
1
12
1
13
1
14
1
15
1
16
1
17
2
18
2
19
2
20
2
21
2
22
2
23
2
24
2
25
2
26
2
27
2
28
2
29
2
30
2
31
2
32
2
33
3
34
3
35
3
36
3
37
3
38
3
39
3
40
3
41
3
42
3
43
3
44
3
45
3
46
3
47
3
48
3
49
4
50
4
51
4
52
4
53
4
54
4
55
4
56
4
57
4
58
4
59
4
60
4
61
4
62
4
63
4
64
4

B
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+

C
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+

D
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+

E
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+

+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
-



+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
-





"

!"#$

!!"#$

!"#$%&#" '# ()!*+, -.$/) 0 1+23

!"#$%$& &'( ! #' #) '*+ ,))+-'.

Analysis of Variance for var_1


Source
DF
Seq SS
Main Effects
3
99.450
2-Way Interactions
3
11.399
Residual Error
9
10.300
Lack of Fit
1
0.533
Pure Error
8
9.767
Total
15
121.149

Alias Structure
I + ABCD
A + BCD
B + ACD
C + ABD
D + ABC
AB + CD
AC + BD
AD + BC

D Design Generators:

D = ABC

Analysis of Variance for var_1


Source
DF
Seq SS
Main Effects
3
99.450
2-Way Interactions
3
11.399
3-Way Interactions
1
0.533
Residual Error
8
9.767
Pure Error
8
9.767
Total
15
121.149



Adj SS
99.4499
11.3992
0.5329
9.7668
9.7668

Estimated Effects and Coefficients for var_1


Term
Effect
Coef
Constant
2.7700
factor_A
1.4350
0.7175
factor_B
-1.4650
-0.7325
factor_D
4.5450
2.2725
factor_A*factor_B
1.1500
0.5750
factor_A*factor_D
-1.2300
-0.6150
factor_B*factor_D
0.1200
0.0600
factor_A*factor_B*factor_D
-0.3650
-0.1825

Adj SS
99.4499
11.3992
10.2997
0.5329
9.7668

Adj MS
33.1500
3.7997
1.1444
0.5329
1.2208

T
10.36
2.68
-2.74
8.50
2.15
-2.30
0.22

5)67%!*;

5)67%!*8

;4

5)67%!*-

94
5)67%!*:

5)67%!*9

84
:4

-4

Adj MS
33.1500
3.7997
0.5329
1.2208
1.2208

StDev Coef
0.2762
0.2762
0.2762
0.2762
0.2762
0.2762
0.2762
0.2762

Estimated Effects and Coefficients for var_1


Term
Effect
Coef StDev Coef
Constant
2.7700
0.2674
factor_A
1.4350
0.7175
0.2674
factor_B
-1.4650
-0.7325
0.2674
factor_D
4.5450
2.2725
0.2674
factor_A*factor_B
1.1500
0.5750
0.2674
factor_A*factor_D
-1.2300
-0.6150
0.2674
factor_B*factor_D
0.1200
0.0600
0.2674

$#

"

&ROODSVHXVLQJ$%'RQO\

6HFWLRQ

!"#$% &'!"(

F
27.15
3.11
0.44

P
0.000
0.088
0.527

P
0.000
0.032
0.029
0.000
0.071
0.057
0.833
0.527

0.527

0.44

T
10.03
2.60
-2.65
8.23
2.08
-2.23
0.22
-0.66

P
0.000
0.071

F
28.97
3.32

P
0.000
0.025
0.023
0.000
0.060
0.047
0.827

Effect
19.000
1.500
14.000
16.500
-1.000
-18.500
19.000

Coef
70.750
9.500
0.750
7.000
8.250
-0.500
-9.250
9.500

19.000
14.000
16.500
-18.500
19.000

Effect

Coef
70.750
9.500
7.000
8.250
-9.250
9.500

T
111.00
14.90
10.98
12.94
-14.51
14.90





Term
Constant
factor_A
factor_B
factor_C
factor_D
factor_E
factor_B*factor_C
factor_B*factor_E

Effect
1450.00
3650.00
-150.00
1750.00
650.00
250.00
-50.00



Coef
3025.00
725.00
1825.00
-75.00
875.00
325.00
125.00
-25.00

(









YDUB









(VWLPDWHG(IIHFW







*HQHUDWRUV' $%( $&IRU#!$5HVROXWLRQ,,,
$
%
&
'

































)DFWRU
$
%
&
'
$%&'
$&%'
$'%&

6LQFHIDFWRUV$%&DQG(IRUPDZRUGLQWKHFRPSOHWHGHILQLQJUHODWLRQLWFDQEHYHULILHGWKDWWKH
UHVXOWLQJGHVLJQLVWZRUHSOLFDWHVRID !"IUDFWLRQDOIDFWRULDO



P
0.006
0.005

7KHJHQHUDWRUVDUH( $%&) %&'&RPSOHWHGHILQLQJUHODWLRQLV, $%&( %&') $'()6LQFHWKH


UHPDLQLQJIDFWRUV$%'DQG)GRQRWIRUPDZRUGLQWKHFRPSOHWHGHILQLQJUHODWLRQLWFDQEHYHULILHGWKDW
WKHUHVXOWLQJGHVLJQLVDIXOOIDFWRULDO

Adj MS
F
552.833 170.10
703.250 216.38
3.250

P
0.000
0.004
0.008
0.006
0.005
0.004



Adj SS
1658.50
1406.50
6.50

StDev Coef
0.6374
0.6374
0.6374
0.6374
0.6374
0.6374

Analysis of Variance for rate


Source
DF
Seq SS
Main Effects
3
1658.50
2-Way Interactions
2
1406.50
Residual Error
2
6.50
Total
7
3071.50

Term
Constant
A
C
D
A*C
A*D

F4Estimated Effects and Coefficients for rate

! "! #! "! $%& # '$() *$+,) )-./0$.)& )11)2.-3

Constant
A
B
C
D
A*B
A*C
A*D

E Term



C
+
+
+
+

D
+
+
+
+

E
+
+
+
+

F
+
+
+
+

$#

Coef
30.4375
5.4375
16.8125
5.3125
-0.3125
0.1875
3.5625
0.3125
0.4375
0.6875
0.4375
-0.1875
0.0625
0.3125
0.3125
-0.8125

#!

"



!!"#$

"!

#$%&'()&% *& +,$-./ 0'1, 2 3.4

!"#$% &"!'$'(%()* &%!) !+ ),- .++-/)0

10.8750
33.6250
10.6250
-0.6250
0.3750
7.1250
0.6250
0.8750
1.3750
0.8750
-0.3750
0.1250
0.6250
0.6250
-1.6250

Effect

#$%&'()!
#$%&'()*
#$%&'()+
#$%&'(),
#$%&'()-

!"
*"
+"
,"
-"

D = AB E = AC F = BC
I = ABD = ACE = BCF = BCDE = ACDF = ABEF = DEF

Term
Constant
factor_A
factor_B
factor_C
factor_D
factor_E
factor_A*factor_B
factor_A*factor_C
factor_A*factor_D
factor_A*factor_E
factor_B*factor_C
factor_B*factor_D
factor_B*factor_E
factor_C*factor_D
factor_C*factor_E
factor_D*factor_E

E ( $%&'
F

Data Matrix
Run A B
1 - 2 + 3 - +
4 + +
5 - 6 + 7 - +
8 + +

Design Generators:
Defining Relation:
A + BD + CE
B + AD + CF
C + AE + BF
D + AB + EF
E + AC + DF
F + BC + DE
AF + BE + CD

!"#$%&'



Coef
30.438
5.438
16.812
5.313
3.562

&!

%!

!""#$%&'(#

$!

()*+,-.+* /+ 01)2&3

#!

!"#$%&'"(!)"%"*+! ,#**!$ (&'%!"

"!

'$

'%

'&

&

'%

'&

$ !"

$ !#

$#!"

#!#

#!"

!#

!"

$ !"

$ !#

$#!"



[

#!#

#!"

!#

P
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.000

!"

!"#$% &'!"(

!"#$%&#" '# ()!*+,

! "#$%&'"

Adj MS
F
1815.73 630.31
203.06 70.49
2.88
5.06
2.45
2.06

T
71.73
12.81
39.62
12.52
8.40

!"#$% &"!'$'(%()* &%!) !+ ),

Adj SS
5447.19
203.06
31.69
15.19
16.50

StDev Coef
0.4243
0.4243
0.4243
0.4243
0.4243

J 7KHPDLQIDFWRUV$%&DQGWKHLQWHUDFWLRQ$%DUHDOOVLJQLILFDQW

10.875
33.625
10.625
7.125

Effect

Analysis of Variance for var_1


Source
DF
Seq SS
Main Effects
3
5447.19
2-Way Interactions
1
203.06
Residual Error
11
31.69
Lack of Fit
3
15.19
Pure Error
8
16.50
Total
15
5681.94

Term
Constant
factor_A
factor_B
factor_C
factor_A*factor_B

6HFWLRQ

'$

'%

'&

&

[

B

!"#$% &'!"(

!"#$%&'

&

0.138

P
0.000
0.000

$"#

$"!

!"#

%!
$"#
$"!
!"#
!"!

%#

$"#

$"!

!"#

!"!

$"#
$"!
!"#

D [ [!!
[ [!!

[!! [ 
[![ 

7KHIHDVLEOHUHJLRQLVEHWZHHQWKVHVWZROLQHVZKLFKFDQEHVKRZQJUDSKLFDOO\RQWKH[ [!SODQH
E 2SHUDWLQJWKHSURFHVVZLWK[  DQG[! UHVXOWVLQ\ DQG\!FRPIRUWDEO\ZLWKLQWKHIHDVLEOH
UHJLRQ





0RYHXQLWVLQWKHGLUHFWLRQRI[ IRUHYHU\XQLWLQWKHGLUHFWLRQRI[!7KXVWKHSDWKRIVWHHSHVW
DVFHQWSDVVHVWKURXJKWKHSRLQW  DQGKDVDVORSH 



7KHUHDSSHDUVWREHDVDGGOHSRLQWLQWKHH[SHULPHQWDOUHJLRQ7KH\LHOGLQFUHDVHVDV[ LVGHFUHDVHGDQG
[!LVQHDUWKH]HUROHYHO

"

&!

&#

$QDO\VLVRI9DULDQFHIRU\
6RXUFH')6HT66$GM66$GM06)3
5HJUHVVLRQ
/LQHDU
6TXDUH
,QWHUDFWLRQ
5HVLGXDO(UURU
/DFNRI)LW
3XUH(UURU
7RWDO
7KHVHFRQGRUGHUPRGHODSSHDUVWREHVLJQLILFDQWIRUWKHLQWHUDFWLRQWHUP S  +RZHYHU
WKHVTXDUHWHUPVDUHQRWVLJQLILFDQW S  
F

E
(VWLPDWHG5HJUHVVLRQ&RHIILFLHQWVIRU\
7HUP&RHI6W'HY73
&RQVWDQW
[
[
[ [
[ [
[ [
6 56T 56T DGM  

EBC ''
:1;5524
67/0023
/0:62:
/21
/34526
326
/34321

/01213
4256/
/72/53
905234
02:53
9/125;/
:2:0
02:53
12;6:
9;20:
02;7:
9/2/34
/1205
02;7:
/2507
1201
42535
121;3
>9'? = 7023@
>9'?A.BCD =

E,.FG-H- %& I."H.,J! &%" G


'%K"J!
)L
'!? ''
>!N"!--H%,
0
:1;5524
OH,!."
6
67/0023
'?K."!
6
/0:62:
P,(!".J(H%,
/
/21
>!-HBK.F Q""%"
;
/34526
O.JR9%&9LH(
:
326
+K"! Q""%"
:
/34321
%(.F
//
:6/;;27

$%,-(.,(
8/
86
8/<8/
86<86
8/<86
' = /0241
EBC M'
L
+
;/:424 6327/ 1211/
/304424 072/4 12111
4;;2/
:2// 12//5
/21
1211 1270/
63;23
/23
1211 /2111
37/2:

+
12111
12111
1200;
12670
12//6
1270/
7/2;@

D $FHQWUDOFRPSRVLWHGHVLJQKDVEHHQXVHGEXWLWLVQRWURWDWDEOH
E  !"#
$%!&
'()!*



#
"

"

EBC M'
L
+
083766 /713/ 31333
/7/904 03/169 31333
08::
3183 31:69
84:92 00166 31333
/:38

+
31333
31333
31333
31333
31/08
31:78
31272
31380
31308
31333
2/13@

"



7KHTXDGUDWLFPRGHOIRU\ LV
 \


 [  [!  ["  [ [!  [ ["   [! ["

EBC ''
049:92/
00637/6
88/0
047/3:
6249:

$%!&
'()!*
/001023
/0100
031334
067127/
081/6
00137/
0/717/3
08128
2142/
09317:3
08128
031:97
4:1464
49140
01383
:1343
46102
314:2
31/89
46102
31308
/21330
0:16:
41443
87188/
0:16:
41:6:
7:1923
07196
81:34
=>'? < 2616@
=>'?A.BCD <

E,.FG-H- %& I."H.,J! &%" G0


'%K"J!
)L
'!? ''
=!N"!--H%,
2
049:92/
OH,!."
/
00/3//8
'?K."!
/
2364
P,(!".J(H%,
/
047/3:
=!-HBK.F Q""%"
09
6249:
%(.F
46
0/49293

!"#
$%,-(.,(
50
54
5/
50;50
54;54
5/;5/
50;54
50;5/
54;5/
' < 93179

!"#$%"! &'()*+! !,(!""-$%

!"

!"

$!"

7KHOLQHDUWHUPVDSSHDUWREHVLJQLILFDQW S  ZKLOHERWKWKHVTXDUHWHUPVDQGLQWHUDFWLRQWHUPVDUH


LQVLJQLILFDQW S DQGS UHVSHFWLYHO\ 
6LQFH[ LVWKHRQO\VLJQLILFDQWIDFWRUWRPLQLPL]HDVKLQFUHDVHWKHYDOXHRI[ !



+
21344 31333
31832 31/44
518:0 31309
7157: 3133:

&$

&$

&RQWRXU3ORWRI\

!
"!
#!
$!!
$%!
$ !

!
"!
#!
$!!
$%!
$ !

9
<
"$2* C$C#*
"$2* C$C#*

7KHGDUNHQHGVHFWLRQUHSUHVHQWVWKHVPDOOHVWVWDQGDUGGHYLDWLRQIRUWKHFRPELQDWLRQRI[ DQG[ ,IWKH


OHYHORILVFKRVHQIRUERWK[!DQG[ WKHQWRDWWDLQWKHGHVLUHGOHYHORIIRUWKHPHDQVROYHWKH
TXDGUDWLFHTXDWLRQIRXQGLQSDUWDXVLQJ\ [! DQG[  IRU["7KHOHYHORI["IRUWKLV
SDUWLFXODUVLWXDWLRQLVDSSUR[LPDWHO\

D'I 00
38953?6
6:;5678
?6>5?6;
?6>5?6;

D'I J0
G
2
745;7
85?? ;5;>7
6:;567 ?65?? ;5;;;
?35::
?35::



7KHPDLQHIIHFWRIS+DQGWKHLQWHUDFWLRQRIS+DQG&DWDO\VWDUHVLJQLILFDQWDWWKHOHYHORI 
VLJQLILFDQFH

D*%@A!#! ,( E%-#%*)& (,- .#!),!#"


0,F-)&
1G
0&H 00
J%#* ((&)"!
?
38953?6
?BK%A L*"&-%)"#,*!
3
6:;5678
M&!#'F%@ --,3?
?6>5?6;
2F-& --,3?
?6>5?6;
/,"%@
36
4865489

!"#$%"&' ((&)"! %*' +,&((#)#&*"! (,- .#!),!#"


/&-$
((&)"
+,&( 0"1&. +,&(
/
2
+,*!"%*"
3435678
35369 3765:4 ;5;;;
<=
659>6
?548>
35369
?56: ;5;?7
+%"%@A!"
B;53?6
B;5;7?
35369
B;5;6 ;5469
<=C+%"%@A!"
3357?6
6593?
35369
65;? ;5;;;

6XSSOHPHQWDO([HUFLVHV



'()!*
415/4
01820
531347
531347

&' ( ! )*$+,
&' (-./01 ! 2+$#,
89
7(
:/0
:/0 ;
)
2#A*+$A
2#A*+$A
B)22$A*
)
2#A*+$A
2#A*+$A
B)22$A*
22
)BBA)$)
)BBA)$)
#B#B$++
2%
%AB*2$2

$%!&
/0123/
21407
581872
75123:

7KHOLQHDUPRGHOIRU\ LVJLYHQE\
 \
  [  
 [!
F

! "#$"%
34567
&7=57>>?3@
D?@7.5
&7>?/4.E F5535
G3H.E

!"#
$%,-(.,(
65
69
67

E 5HVSRQVH6XUIDFH5HJUHVVLRQ

!"#$%&'



" !

"$

0HDQ

"#

"#

!!

&DWDO\VW

,QWHUDFWLRQ3ORWIRUYLVFRVLW

!"#$% &"!'$'(%()* &%!)

!"#$%$&

+?&.#8&' (
,;6&?' 0)*0*@>
9' *>

#!!'

#!
#!'

#&!

# !

#%!

#$$
#$

#$$$

"

!"#$

+3/&.453!6#.$738 95.:#$7;< =&4;


+!,-%#.&/' *)012
!"#$%&' ()((*

<;%$"/##
?/C ??
&'&&,7I*3(
&'&&&&3-(&
&'&&&-3)3(
&'&&&-3)3(
&'&&3)--&&

:DE ??
&'&&,7I*3(
&'&&&&3-(&
&'&&&-3)3(
&'&&&-3)3(

B
G
7'I* &'&))
&'3) &'*(*

3
&'&&&
&',&&'&3,
&'*(*
:DE F?
&'&&&I-7,3
&'&&&&3-(&
&'&&&,&(7,
&'&&&,&(7,

/
,-'(+
3',&
)'*7
9&'-7



7KHUHLVQRHYLGHQFHWKDWIODWQHVVGLVWRUWLRQLVGLIIHUHQWIRUWKHGLIIHUHQWJHDUW\SHV S  +HDW


WUHDWLQJWLPHDIIHFWVWKHIODWQHVVGLVWRUWLRQ S  7KHIDFWRUVGRQRWLQWHUDFW S  

:"%;1#5# !< =%05%">/ <!0


?!@0>/
AB
F%5" H<</>$#
3
39J%1 K"$/0%>$5!"#
,
L/#5D@%; H00!0
G@0/ H00!0
4!$%;
+

!"#$%"&' ((&)"! %*' +,&((#)#&*"! (,- (.%"*&!!


/&-$
((&)"
+,&( 0"1&2 +,&(
!"#$%"$
&'&()&&&
&'&&)*)+
./%0$12/
&'&,(3(& &'&&+*3(
&'&&)*)+
456/
&'&3*+(& &'&,))+(
&'&&)*)+
./%0$12/8456/ 9&'&&)(&& 9&'&&,+(&
&'&&)*)+

7KHUHVLGXDOSORWVDSSHDUWREHDGHTXDWH7KHUHLVDVLJQLILFDQWGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQWKHWZROHYHOVRIWKH
LQWHUDFWLRQS+ &DWDO\VW

"

!"#$%&#" '# ('#)%#'*+

!"#$%&'" (!)"%" *+,-&.&'

7KHLQWHUDFWLRQSORWVXSSRUWVWKHLQIRUPDWLRQIRXQGLQWKHDQDO\VLVRISDUWD7KHUHDSSHDUVWREHD
VLJQLILFDQWLQWHUDFWLRQEHWZHHQS+DQG&DWDO\VW
F 7KHPRGHOXVHGLVYLVFRVLW\ S+&DWDO\VWS+ &DWDO\VW

!"#$#%&%'(

7LPH

0HDQ

"!#!

!#!!

!#!

!#!$



!"#$%&'

!"#$% &"!'$'(%()* &%!)

)*+,-./*

!"#

"

-@&0#:&' ()(((((((
.=8&@' ()(++2+A4
;' 4

! %
! "

!'

!%

!&

!$$
!$%

!$$$

# ! "

!"#$

! "

-51&0675!8#0$95: ;70<#$9=> ?&6=


-!./%#0&1' ()234
!"#$%&' ()*+,

&'() *)+),- .!,/)012)3


4
5
012)3
7
5

4
4

;<!,'-1- $0 .!%1!<") 0$% ,!==!>1


6$/%")
?
66
@6
!"!#
$
%&'()
%&'()
-.#/
0
1*)1&
$&%$&
!"!#2-.#/
0
$$,0(
%%(%
34454
%,
$)'(0
,''
65/.#
'0
$'0''%

!"#$%
*)+),
6!,#

A
*'+%, )+)))
'(+&0 )+)))
0+%( )+))%



7KHUHLVDVLJQLILFDQWGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQWKHDSSOLFDWLRQOHYHOVWKHVDOWVDQGWKHUHLVDVLJQLILFDQW
GLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQWKHOHYHOVRIWKHLQWHUDFWLRQRIWKHWZR

7KHUHVLGXDOSORWVDUHDGHTXDWH7KHUHGRHVQRWDSSHDUWREHDQ\VHULRXVGHSDUWXUHIURPQRUPDOLW\RU
YLRODWLRQRIWKHDVVXPSWLRQRIFRQVWDQWYDULDQFH

"

!"#$%&#" '# ()*+&"##,

!"#$%&'" (!)"%" *#+!

!"#$#%&%'(

7KHLQWHUDFWLRQSORWIRUWKHHIIHFWVLQGLFDWHVWKDWWKHUHLVQRLQWHUDFWLRQEHWZHHQJHDUW\SHDQGWLPH7KHUH
LVDOVRQRVLJQLILFDQWGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQWKHORZDQGKLJKOHYHOVRIJHDUW\SH7KHLQWHUDFWLRQSORWGRHV

LQGLFDWHKRZHYHUWKHUHPD\EHVRPHVLJQLILFDQWGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQWKHORZDQGKLJKOHYHOVRIWLPH
F 7KHPRGHOXVHGLVIODWQHVV *HDU7\SH7LPH*HDU7\SH 7LPH

"#"(

"#"'

"#"&

"#"%

"#"$

,QWHUDFWLRQ3ORWIRUIODWQHVV

0HDQ
)!'

(!'

&!'

6DOW

"

*+,+-

,QWHUDFWLRQ3ORW0HDQVIRU)ODPPDEL

%"!

%#!

%$!

$!

!"#$

#!

"!

,40&/564!7#/$849 :6/;#$8<= >&5<


,!-.%#/&0' ()123
!"#$%&' ()(*+

1/0

!"!#

1/2

!"#$%&#" '# ()*++*,'--

!"#$%&'" (!)"%" ,!-!'

./0



7KHUHVLGXDOSORWVLQGLFDWHDVLJQLILFDQWGLIIHUHQFHDPRQJWKHVDOWW\SHVZKLOHWKHUHGRHVQRWDSSHDUWREHD
VLJQLILFDQWGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQUHVLGXDOVIRUWKHWZRDSSOLFDWLRQOHYHOV7KHUHLVQRDSSDUHQWYLRODWLRQRI
WKHQRUPDOLW\DVVXPSWLRQ

,@&/#9&' ()(((((((
-<7&@' AB)2?+(
:' ?1

&!!$

&!(
&!$

&#!

&(!

&)!

&''
&'(

&'''

!"#$% &"!'$'(%()* &%!)

530

!"#

540

"

'"&
#

'#&
$

510
5.0

10

.0

40

30

'%&

!"#$%&#" '# ()*++*,'-

!"#$%&'" (!)"%" *&'+

'$&

&

%&

$&

#&

"&

)URPWKHLQWHUDFWLRQSORWZHVHHWKDWWKHXQWUHDWHGVDOWKDVDKLJKHUIODPPDELOLW\DYHUDJHWKDQDQ\RIWKH
RWKHUILYHOHYHOV7KHUHPDLQLQJILYHOHYHOV 0J&O 1D&O&D&2 &D&O!1D!&2 DSSHDUWRKDYHVLPLODU
IODPPDELOLW\DYHUDJHV2YHUDOODSSOLFDWLRQOHYHOLQFUHDVHVWKHIODPPDELOLW\DYHUDJH
F

!"#$%&'
!"#$#%&%'(

!"#$%&'

.*%/C!#! ,( D%-#%*)& (,- ./#0*.))


2,E-)&
3F
2&G 22
I%#* ((&)"!
=
897<8@:
=AJ%C K*"&-%)"#,*!
8
;7:=;;
L&!#'E%/ --,?
;7;99:
5E-& --,?
;7;99:
1,"%/
:
8@76=96

.'H 22
897<8@:
;7:=;;
;7;99:
;7;99:

.'H I2
F
5
@7=<@96 ?8:7<9 ;7;;;
;7:=;;; 6=7?: ;7;;<
;7;==89
;7;==8:

!"#$%"&' ((&)"! %*' +,&((#)#&*"! (,- ./#0*.))


1&-$
((&)"
+,&( 2"3&4 +,&(
1
5
+,*!"%*"
6789:
;7;<=><
>;7<? ;7;;;
2,/'&-2#
;7:9<
;76@6
;7;<=><
:7?> ;7;;=
./#0*$&*
A=7@?;
A87?:;
;7;<=>< A=:7@= ;7;;;
2,/'&-2#B./#0*$&*
;7>;;
;76;;
;7;<=><
<7:; ;7;;<

!"#$%&$

CO
3
3
3

8") 88
32717<
3=27E=7
62=766

P8
G2<317
626777

O
7E4273

@
62666



6LQFHWKHVPDOOHUYDOXHLVSUHIHUUHGWKHQWRLPSURYHDOLJQPHQWDFFXUDF\LWVHHPVWKDWVROGHUVL]HVKRXOG
EHVHWDWLWVVPDOOOHYHO PP ZKLOHWKHDOLJQPHQWPHWKRGXVHGVKRXOGEHPHWKRG

8'*#/"
8'.9"#8&
-.&$(>"(
8'.9"#?-

-(+.M%&% 'B N+#&+(/"


8'*#/"
CO
88
H"$#"%%&'(
1
342714=
Q##'#
<
626EE=
',+.
=
34217E1

!" #"$#"%%&'( ")*+,&'( &%


-.&$(-// 0 1234 5 62147 8'.9"#8&:" ; 32<= -.&$(>"(, 5 62166 8'.9"#?-.&$(
@#"9&/,'#
A'"B
8,C"D
@
A'(%,+(,
123E=F6
626F7GF
G62F<
62666
8'.9"#8&
62147F6
626F7GF
=2<G
62667
-.&$(>"(
;32<=666
626F7GF
;7=247
62666
8'.9"#?6216666
626F7GF
F2=6
6266F
8 0 623<E4
H;8) 0 442FI
H;8)J+9KL 0 4427I

"

'&($

)$*&+(,*"-$ .!-* /-+ !"#$ ,,

7KHDQDO\VLVLQGLFDWHVWKDWERWKVROGHUVL]HDQGDOLJQPHQWPHWKRGVLJQLILFDQWO\DIIHFWDOLJQPHQWDFFXUDF\
7KHLQWHUDFWLRQEHWZHHQVROGHUVL]HDQGDOLJQPHQWPHWKRGLVDOVRVLJQLILFDQWLQDIIHFWLQJDOLJQPHQW 
DFFXUDF\
E



!"#$%&'



"!#$

"!#

!#!

!#

!#$

!"#$%&'

%&'()*+(' ,( -.,/+-001

!"#$%&'" (!)"%" *+'$!),-

! &
! #

$ !"

-@&0#9&' ()(((((((
.<7&@' ()33AB2C
:' ?

!"

!&

!'

!%%
!%&

!%%%

$ !#

!"#$

!"

-41&0564!7#0$849 :60;#$8<= >&5<


-!./%#0&1' ()*23
!"#$%&' ()*+,

!#

!"#$% &"!'$'(%()* &%!)

!"#$%"&'
*&+$
,
2
4
,72
,74
274
,7274

,'H I>
1./361
909/9.8
81/5:B
.9/9B.
B6/119
8/586

A
:/::9
:/110
:/99:
:/515
:/:BB
:/:63
:/:.1
:/990

0/:6

:/:03

F
A
./:. :/.B1
8/:6 :/:53
5/66 :/990



*M& +&N+&!!#<; &GE%"#<; #!


'&="%=#;& O - 99/8 - 9/50 , - 5/55 2 P 9/0B 4 - 1/5B ,2 P 5/B. ,4 P B/05 24
A+&'#)"<+
4<&(
>"?&@
*
A
4<;!"%;"
-99/8..
9/308
-0/:B
:/::9
,
-9/509
./:BB
-:/30
:/B51
2
-5/5.6
./:BB
-9/3.
:/933
4
9/013
./:BB
:/8B
:/151
%Q
-1/5B1
./:BB
-./9.
:/:88
%)
5/B.9
./:BB
9/09
:/910
Q)
B/0.6
./:BB
./06
:/:56
> O B/89.
L->G O 06/.R
L->GS%'HT O B1/9R

7KHHVWLPDWHRISXUHHUURUXVLQJWKHFHQWHUSRLQWVLVJLYHQLQ0LQLWDEDV+DQGFDOFXODWLRQVPD\
GLIIHUVOLJKWO\GXHWRVLJQLILFDQWGLJLWV
F 8VLQJWKHRXWSXWJLYHQLQSDUWE LWDSSHDUVIURPWKH0LQLWDERXWSXWWKDWWKHZD\LQWHUDFWLRQVDUH
VLJQLILFDQW S  ZKLOHWKHPDLQHIIHFWVDQGZD\LQWHUDFWLRQDUHQRW S DQG
UHVSHFWLYHO\ &XUYDWXUHLVDOVRLQVLJQLILFDQWZLWKS 
G 8VLQJ5HJUHVVLRQLQ0LQLWDEWKHUHVXOWLQJPRGHOVKRXOGEH

,'H >>
9.8/:8.
B95/585
81/5:B
81/3:8
B6/119
.B/930

((&)"! %;' 4<&((#)#&;"! (<+ '&="%=#;


((&)"
4<&( >"?&@ 4<&(
*
-99/8.
9/5.8
-8/6:
-./01
-9/50
9/3.3
-:/81
-3/33
-5/55
9/3.3
-./:B
5/16
9/0B
9/3.3
9/:0
-8/09
-1/5B
9/3.3
-./38
0/:1
5/B.
9/3.3
./90
99/13
B/05
9/3.3
5/B.
-3/16
-5/.B
9/3.3
-./::

((&)"!
((&)"
-./01
-3/33
5/16
-8/09
0/:1
99/13
-3/16

,;%=C!#! <( D%+#%;)& (<+ '&="%=#;


><E+)&
?F
>&G >>
I%#; ((&)"!
5
9.8/:8.
.-J%C K;"&+%)"#<;!
5
B95/585
5-J%C K;"&+%)"#<;!
9
81/5:B
L&!#'E%= ++<+
1
81/3:8
4E+@%"E+&
9
B6/119
AE+& ++<+
5
.B/930
*<"%=
99
89:/506

!"#$%"&'
*&+$
4<;!"%;"
,
2
4
,72
,74
274
,7274

7KHQRUPDOSUREDELOLW\SORWGRHVQRWVXJJHVWDGHSDUWXUHIURPQRUPDOLW\7KHDVVXPSWLRQRIFRQVWDQW
YDULDQFHPD\EHRIFRQFHUQ,WDSSHDUVWKDWWKHYDULDELOLW\LVORZHUIRUWKHKLJKOHYHORIWKHLQWHUDFWLRQ

"

!"#$#%&%'(

"



/0

-,B -7>8:6
??856
E686:
7>7856
;;87;
E5E8>>

!"#$

!"#$%&#" '# (")*+,

!"#$%&!'()$*+!, -&$.)*+/0 1#%/


+!,-%#.&/' ()012
!"#$%&' ()(**

!"#$%&'" (!)"%" +

!"#$% &"!'$'(%()* &%!)

/0
7
7
7
7
7
7

!"#$%"&'
1&-$
+,*!"%*"
8
=
+
.
8?=
8?+
8?.
=?+
=?.
+?.
8?=?+
8?=?.
8?+?.
=?+?.
8?=?+?.

17:58;7
<<89?

/0

"#



((&)"! %*' +,&((#)#&*"! (,- ./0


((&)"
+,&(
234567
942:;
3455<
949:;
3425<
:43;5
;4<<6
>;45:3
><46;<
>34@<;
><4@@:
>@45;2
>@47<6
>34755
><4377
>@49;2
>@43:6
<47:3
@42;<
>@4@:;
>@4@;<
@47;2
@43<6
><4@<;
>@49@:
<4::;
@45;<
>34:52
><4;77
><4:<3
>@45@:

7KHUHVLGXDOSORWVDSSHDUWREHDGHTXDWH

/-

6#$),#2 '=8=======
5/(#62 7893:;<
-2 34

#!!'

#!
#!'

#&!

# !

#%!

#$$
#$

#$$$

C
D
"F
"+
F+

-'.*+,

!"#$%&% '( )"*&"!+,


-'.*+,
/0
-3,4*,%%&'!
5
567869
=**'*
>
75?8;7
@'A"#
77
?7:8<?

!"#$%&'

!"#$%&'

!"#$#%&%'(

!"#$%&'

/-

"

0
<875

!"#$%&#" '# (")*+,

!"#$%&'" (!)"%" ,

!"#$%&#" '# (")*+,

!"#$%&'" (!)"%" *

2
:877<

$%

('")
&'()*+
'()),
'(&),
.(,,*
4,(--/
4-(+,*
4-('/*
-(',*

$!

$"

*&+",
,(-&.
,(-&.
,(-&.
,(-&.
,(-&.
,(-&.
,(-&.
,(-&.

(IIHFW

/&(*'
'(/)
'(2*
'(*,
4-(*+
4-(.*
4-('2
-('-

"

!"#$%&#" '# ()*+ ,-$./ 0 1234

"

1RUPDO3UREDELOLW\3ORWRIWKH(IIHFWV

(5 (

65 6
75 7

,5 ,

8469 7 &+(/:

8469;%<=> 7 2'(+:

8469 7 &,(-:

FP
,
,
,

6A9 66
,.'().
,'.(&&
,22(/.

!" # $%&' ( %&)) * ( %&$) + ( ,&-% .

6!EB5A
0
1

0"%MN#D# !K O%BD%"5A
6!EB5A
FP
66
8ACBA##D!"
.
+,'(''
RBB!B
,'
,/)(.&
?!$%M
,2
2)-(2*

6 7 .(&+/

?
&&()+
.(-)
'(*&
.(..

J
-(---(-,-(-,'
-(--/



Q6
,.&(+,
,+(-.

P
*(&*

8469;%<=> 7 /.(&:

?@A BACBA##D!" A9E%$D!" D#


FGH 7 &'(* I '()) 0 I '(&) 1 I .(,'
JBA<D5$!B
!AK
6$FAL
!"#$%"$
&'()*.&
-(*./2
0
'()),.
-(*./2
1
'(&),.
-(*./2
.(,,))
-(*./2

J
-(--'

%DVHGRQWKLVDQDO\VLVRQO\WKHPDLQIDFWRUV$%DQG&DUHVLJQLILFDQW5XQDUHJUHVVLRQDQDO\VLV
XVLQJWKHVHLPSRUWDQWIDFWRUV

6 7 +('*.

%3
%5
35
%35

-(---(-')
-(-.'
-(-'-(.&/
-(&-&
-()-*
-()++

%DVHGRQWKHQRUPDOSUREDELOLW\SORWLWDSSHDUVWKDWIDFWRUV$%DQG&DUHVLJQLILFDQW
F 5XQDQDQDO\VLVXVLQJWKHPDLQIDFWRUV$%DQG&DQGLQWHUDFWLRQVDPRQJWKHVHYDULDEOHVWRVHHLIDQ\DUH
VLJQLILFDQW

!"#$%&'!
!"#$%"$
0
1

1RUPDO6FRUH

#!!'

#!
#!'

#&!

# !

#%!

#$$
#$

#$$$



"#

"

!"#$

-41&0564!7#0$849 :60;#$8<= >&5<


-!./%#0&1' ()223
!"#$%&' ()*+,

$%&'()*'& +' ,-./

!"#$%&'" (!)"%" *

!"#$%"&'
*&+$
,
1
4
6
,81
,84
,86
184
186
486
,8184
,8186
,8486

"#

((&)"!
((&)"
-./0.
2-3/0.
25/0.
27./33
25/33
9/33
7/0.
2:/33
-;/7.
29/0.
-/7.
2-/.3
3/.3

"

.,

"

#!
"

!"#$"%$&'($ )**(+!

!
!"

!"#$%&#" '# ()!*+,"-. /0$1+ 2 3456

!
;7 <
=7 >

97 :

/7 8

!"#$%&#" '# ()*+

!"#$%&'" (!)"%" *

!"#$% &"!'$'(%()* &%!) !+ ),- .)$/0$"0(1-0 2++-3)4

./

"#

!"#$%&#" '# ()*+

!"#$%&'" (!)"%" *



$FFRUGLQJWRWKHSUREDELOLW\SORWIDFWRUV9)3DQG*DORQJZLWKWKHLQWHUDFWLRQV9)DQG)3*DUH
SRVVLEO\VLJQLILFDQW

7KHUHVLGXDOSORWVDSSHDUWREHDGHTXDWH

"

-@&0#9&' ()(((((((
.<7&@' 3)3A(3A
:' ,?

!"#$#%&%'(

!"#$%&'

!"#$% &"!'$'(%()* &%!)

!"#$% &'!"(

!"#$%&'

!"#$%&'

&G
EE905
7;909
5-;05
94--0;94094;0-

'3 G + ;;0EH

8
-0--,

3 7051 8 3 ,904 : 3 ;094 #F)


B
8
7-07/
-0--90;7
-0-,/
3,01-0-1E
3,07/
-0,;3709-0--,
390,-0-4,

6
;05;

@6
,
,
,
,
,

&G
EE905
7;909
5-;05
94--0;940-

O
E//09
,7,0E

6
;01E

'3 GI$<JK + 4/09H


8
-0--,

!"#$#%&%'(

-?&0#9&' ()(((((((
.<7&?' @()+,(,
:' *3

$!!"

$!&
$!"

$ !

$&!

$'!

$%%
$%&

$%%%

#"!

!"#$

"!

-41&0564!7#0$849 :60;#$8<= >&5<


-!./%#0&1' ()+23
!"#$%&' ()*+,

!"#$% &"!'$'(%()* &%!)



#$

"#!

" $

" !

"$

#!

"

!"#$%&#" '# ()!*+,

!"#$%&'" (!)"%" (

G )URPWKHDQDO\VLVZHVHHWKDWMHWWUDYHUVHVSHHGDQGDEUDVLYHJUDLQVL]HDUHVLJQLILFDQWDORQJZLWKWKH
LQWHUDFWLRQRIDEUDVLYHIORZUDWHDEUDVLYHJUDLQVL]HDQGZDWHUMHWSUHVVXUH6LQFHZHKDYHDGRSWHGD
KLHUDUFKLFDOPRGHOLQJDSSURDFKIORZUDWHDQGZDWHUMHWSUHVVXUHDUHDOVRLQFOXGHGLQWKHPRGHO
H

(!"%&
2
6
8
:
#F)

LC$MND=D (# 2$"=$C%&
(!"%&
@6
'&)"&DD=(C
4
711401
P""("
,/
97,90B(>$M
99
/9E/0/

+ ,,0E,

!"#$%&'(!)* + ,-, . /011 2 3 405/ 6


8"&<=%>("
?(&#
>@&A?(&#
?(CD>$C>
,--0499
90717
2
/01/4
90E/1
6
3405/4
90E/1
8
3705/4
90E/1
:
3,904-90E/1
#F)
3;09490E/1

@6
,
,
,
,
,
,

O
14/0,570/

%DVHGRQWKLVLQLWLDODQDO\VLVZHVHHWKDW3)DQGWKHLQWHUDFWLRQ9)DUHLQVLJQLILFDQWDWWKHOHYHORI
VLJQLILFDQFH
7KXVWKHUHJUHVVLRQDQDO\VLVDQGILQDOPRGHODUH

(!"%&
2
6
8
:
#F)
A#

LC$MND=D (# 2$"=$C%&
(!"%&
@6
'&)"&DD=(C
;
4,7,01
P""("
,;
9,4;0B(>$M
99
/9E/0/

!"#$%&'(!)* + ,-, . /011 2 3 405/ 6 3 7051 8 3 ,904 : 3 ;094 68: 3 70--26


8"&<=%>("
?(&#
>@&A?(&##
B
8
?(CD>$C>
,--0499
90797,045
-0--2
/01/4
90E-9
90/,
-0-,4
6
3405/4
90E-9
3,014
-0-15
8
3705/4
90E-9
3,04,
-0,4,
:
3,904-90E-9
3705,
-0--,
#F)
3;09490E-9
390,4
-0-7/
A#
370--90E-9
3,051
-0,1/
+ ,,0;,
'3 G + /-04H
'3 GI$<JK + 4E07H

F 5XQQLQJDUHJUHVVLRQDQDO\VLVXVLQJWKHVHIDFWRUVZHILQG

!"#$%&'

"

$!

"

$ "

$#!

$#"



!"#$%&'

#!

#"

"

"

"



"

!!"#$

(5 (

75 7

65 6

,5 ,

(IIHFW








!"#
()./'0.'
9
<
(
+

:341;
1322;
;322;
>:372;

$%%!&'



()!% *'+!, ()!%


123455
63417
63;:5
63417
:3862
63417
23862
63417
>63162
63417

81366 43444
637: 43275
:3:8 43477
237: 434=:
>63;= 4324=

,WPD\EHXVHIXOWRUXQDQDO\VLVZLWKWKHPDLQHIIHFWVRQO\WRVHHZKLFKPDLQHIIHFWLVVLJQLILFDQW

"#$

"#$!

"!$

!$!

!$

#$!

#$

!"#$%&#" '# ()*+ ,-$./ 0 1234

!"#$% &"!'$'(%()* &%!) !+ ),- .++-/)0

(VWLPDWHG(IIHFWV
7HUP
$
%
&
'
$%
$&
$'

)*+
6789:;
6>9A=

2QHSRVVLEOHGHVLJQLV
$%&'6XUIDFH5RXJK












































































)*+ ,
<79:55
=96:8

'
<95< 797=>

#$

(
#

"

!"#$"%$&'($ )**(+!

#!

+*

!"#$%&#" '# ()!*+,"-. /0$1+ 2 3456

+)



)URPWKHHVWLPDWHGHIIHFWVZHFRXOGWHQWDWLYHO\LGHQWLI\)3*DQGWKHLQWHUDFWLRQV9)DQG93DV
VLJQLILFDQW

,-%."/
+-%( #"&'

"&"

"&'

%&

%&

!"#$% &"!'$'(%()* &%!) !+ ),- .)$/0$"0(1-0 2++-3)4

(VWLPDWHG(IIHFWV
7HUP(IIHFW
$
%
&
'
$ %
$ &
$ '

$#

%&'()*+(' ,( -.&/01

!"#$%&'" (!)"%" ,

$#

%(
6789:;
6>9A=
66=97>

%DVHGRQWKLVDQDO\VLVRQO\IDFWRU%DSSHDUVWREHVLJQLILFDQWDWWKHOHYHORIVLJQLILFDQFH
&RPSDULQJWKLVUHVXOWWRWKDWRISUREOHPZHVHHWKDWWKH)DFWRUV$DQG&ZHUHQRWUHYHDOHGDV
VLJQLILFDQWLQWKHVPDOOHUGHVLJQ

9.0?@/A/ )% B0"A0.&! %)" +CD


!"#$%
&'
,./0 122%$34
5
?%4/*".@ 1##!#
:
B!3.@
>

:KHUH$ 9% )& 3DQG' *

$ "

$#!

$#"

$!

"

#"

#!

"

$ "

$#!

$#"

$!

"

#"

#!

"

%&'()*+(' ,( -.&/01

!"#$%&'" (!)"%" +

2QHSRVVLEOHGHVLJQLV
$%&''2,









































!"#$%&'

7KHUHVLGXDOSORWVDSSHDUWRLQGLFDWHWKHDVVXPSWLRQRIFRQVWDQWYDULDQFHPD\QRWEHPHW

"

!"#$% &'!"(

%&'()*+(' ,( -.&/01

!"#$%&'" (!)"%" *

!"#$%&'





?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?

#%) ? #!&
'%) ? '!&
'%& ? '!)
'$& ? '!(
'$) ? '%(
'$% ? '()
'%! ? '&)
'$! ? '&(
%) ? !& ?
%& ? !) ?
$& ? !( ?
$) ? %( ?
$% ? () ?
%! ? &) ?
$! ? &( ?

? $%& ? $!)
? $%! ? $&)
? #%! ? #&)
? #$! ? #&(
? #$% ? #()
? #$) ? #%(
? #%& ? #!)
? #$& ? #!(
'$%! ? '$&)
'#%! ? '#&)
'#$! ? '#&(
'#$% ? '#()
'#$) ? '#%(
'#%& ? '#!)
'#$& ? '#!(

?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?

%!( ? &()
%&( ? !()
%() ? !&(
$() ? !&)
$&( ? %&)
$!( ? %!)
$%) ? $!&
$%( ? %!&
'%&( ? '!()
'%() ? '!&(
'$() ? '!&)
'$&( ? '%&)
'$!( ? '%!)
'$%) ? '$!&
'$%( ? '%!&

?
?
?
?
?
?
?

#$%&
#$%)
#$%(
#$!(
#$&(
#%()
#$()

?
?
?
?
?
?
?

#$!)
#$!&
#%!&
#%!)
#%&)
#!&(
#!&)

?
?
?
?
?
?
?

#%!(
$%!(
$%!)
$%!&
$!&)
$%&(
$%&)

?
?
?
?
?
?
?

#&()
$&()
%&()
!&()
%!&(
$!()
%!()



&7192,3-10 &19237,10 %*5,.&192375


D
#15* %*5,.DJ G
/*53082,3- 444
/8-5
G
/*;0,912*5
@
&7192,3- @K=
#039L5 -3-*
$*-2*7 ;25 :23210>
I
MMM NOP! MMM 63Q* Q1,- *++*925 17* 93-+38-<*< R,2S 2R3AR1T ,-2*7192,3-5
%*5,.- (*-*712375
% " '# ! " '$
%*+,-,-. /*012,34 " '#% " '$! " #$%!
'0,15 62789287*
4 ? '#% ? '$! ? #$%!
' ? #% ? $! ? '#$%!
# ? '% ? $%! ? '#$!
$ ? '! ? #%! ? '#$%
% ? '# ? #$! ? '$%!
! ? '$ ? #$% ? '#%!
#$ ? %! ? '#! ? '$%
#! ? $% ? '#$ ? '%!

/8- ' # $ % ! & ( )


@ A A A A A A A A
B ? A A A A ? ? ?
C A ? A A ? A ? ?
= ? ? A A ? ? A A
D A A ? A ? ? ? A
E ? A ? A ? A A ?
F A ? ? A A ? A ?
G ? ? ? A A A ? A
H A A A ? ? ? A ?
@I ? A A ? ? A ? A
@@ A ? A ? A ? ? A
@B ? ? A ? A A A ?
@C A A ? ? A A ? ?
@= ? A ? ? A ? A A
@D A ? ? ? ? A A A
@E ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?

' ? #$(
# ? '$(
$ ? '#(
% ? '#)
! ? '#&
& ? '#!
( ? '#$
) ? '#%
'# ? $(
'$ ? #(
'% ? #)
'! ? #&
'& ? #!
'( ? #$
') ? #%

5"$%=<(B$F 5$%=("<$F ?&C<)B


5$%=("CG
D
H$C& ?&C<)BG
DI ,9
'&C(F!=<(BG J3
'!BCG
,9
'&KF<%$=&CG
,
5"$%=<(BG ,L,9
?&C<)B 8&B&"$=("C
! " #$% & " '$% ( " '#$ ) " '#%
%*+,-,-. /*012,34 " #$%! " '$%& " '#$( " '#%) " '#!& " '%!( " '$!) " #%&( "
#$&) " $%() " $!&( " %!&) " #!() " '&() " '#$%!&()
'0,15 62789287* :8; 23 37<*7 =>
4 ? '#$( ? '#%) ? '#!& ? '$%& ? '$!) ? '%!( ? '&() ? #$%! ? #$&) ? #%&( ? #!() ?
$%() ? $!&( ? %!&)

)URPWKHDQDO\VLVZHVHHWKDWIDFWRUV)3*9)DQG93DUHVLJQLILFDQW,QWKHDQDO\VLVRIZH
IRXQGRQO\9*DQG)3*VLJQLILFDQW



#
A
A
?
?
A
A
?
?

$
A
A
A
A
?
?
?
?

%
?
A
A
?
?
A
A
?

#$

"

!
?
A
?
A
A
?
A
?

!
#!

!!"#$

"

#$%&'()&% *& +*%,-. ,'/0 1 2345

"

"

!"#$% &"!'$'(%()* &%!) !+ ),- .++-/)0


6
76 7
!6 !
"6 "

>'G 11
58I7=9:
58?7=9:
5?7=9:
:7=9:
5?7:::

>'G H1
E
4
<?7<5?6 =;79? :7:::
?;75=9: <57I= :7:::
57?=9:
:75=9:
:7:? :7I<:
=7::::

#!%
#!

#'!

#%!

#&!

#$$
#$%

"

!"#$

!"#$%&!'()$*+!, -&$.)*+/0 1#%/


-!./%#0&1' (),23
!"#$%&' ()*+,

!"#$% &"!'$'(%()* &%!)



"#

"

"

!"#$%&#" '# ('")*+

!"#$%&'" (!)"%" *

7KHFRQFOXVLRQVDUHWKDWIDFWRUV$&DQG'DUHVLJQLILFDQWDORQJZLWKWKHLQWHUDFWLRQV$&DQG$'
F

>*%/B!#! ,( C%-#%*)& (,- .#&/'


1,D-)&
2E
1&F 11
H%#* ((&)"!
8
58I7=9:
=AJ%B K*"&-%)"#,*!
=
58?7=9:
L&!#'D%/ --,5:
5?7=9:
M%)N ,( E#"
=
:7=9:
4D-& --,;
5?7:::
0,"%/
59
=I5769:

((&)"! %*' +,&((#)#&*"! (,- .#&/'


((&)"
+,&( 1"2&3 +,&(
0
4
567869
:785;6
9<79= :7:::
<79::
=7=9:
:785;6
67:? :7:::
=7:::
57:::
:785;6
875< :7:55
87=9:
57?=9
:785;6
975: :7:::
A<7=9:
A=75=9
:785;6
A?7?6 :7:::
<7:::
=7:::
:785;6
?7=; :7:::

7KHIDFWRUVWKDWDSSHDUWRKDYHODUJHHIIHFWVDUH$'$&DQG$'
E 7KHUHJUHVVLRQDQDO\VLVLV

#$$$

#!!

'
A
?
A
?
A
?
A
?

!"#$%"&'
0&-$
+,*!"%*"
>
+
2
>@+
>@2

/8@
B
C
=
D
E
F
G

6#$),#2 '878888888
5/(#62 37898:;
-2 34

!"#$#%&%'(

!"#$%&'(!)* + ,-- . /0123 . 40,15 . 40,16 . ,7048 . 901235 : ,-0936. /0,138


6"&;<%=("
>(&#
=?&@
A
6
>(BC=$B=
,--0/-,0DE1
7E01D
-0--3
./0127
/07/1
.-04E
-012D
5
.40,/7
/07/1
.109/
-0--4
6
.40,/7
/07/1
.109/
-0--4
8
.,70D27
/07/1
.90/4
-0--35
.90127
/07/1
./071
-0-14
36
,-09/7
/07/1
E0/,
-0--E
38
./0,/7
/07/1
.-0DE
-0E/D

!"#$% &'!"(

7KHUHJUHVVLRQDQDO\VLVJLYHV

!"#$%&'

#"

"

$ !%#$

#"

$(!%#)

.,

$$!%#)

$(!"#

"

#"

$'!"#

$%!"# "

"

&!%#$

!"#

!"#$%&#" '# ('")*+

!"#$%&'" (!)"%" *

&XEH3ORW0HDQVIRU<LHOG

7KHUHVLGXDOSORWVDSSHDUWREHDGHTXDWH
G 7KHGHVLJQFDQEHFROODSVHGLQWRD GHVLJQDVVKRZQ

./

"#

"

.,

"

!"#$%&#" '# ('")*+



$%%!&'
!"#$$
%"$$$
&"%#$
-!"%#$
!"$$$

()!% *'+!, ()!%


%"%#$
$"&#&'
)"$$$
$"&#&'
)"'%#
$"&#&'
-%")%#
$"&#&'
%"$$$
$"&#&'

'"&' $"$$$
%"*& $"$%%
!"'$ $"$$$
-'"$) $"$$$
#"'' $"$$$



8VLQJWKHUHODWLRQVKLS VWGHYFRHI  VWHUUZHKDYH


   
)RUDFRQILGHQFHLQWHUYDOW !"#"$% 
7KHUHIRUHWKHFRQILGHQFHLQWHUYDOVIRUWKHHIIHFWVDUHJLYHQE\HIIHFWr 
RUHIIHFWr

,(
,+

!"#

(
+

,IZHFRQVLGHUWKHPDLQHIIHFWV$&DQG'DVVLJQLILFDQWZHPD\ZDQWWRLQYHVWLJDWHWKHLQWHUDFWLRQV
FRQWDLQLQJWKHVHIDFWRUV

7KHGDWDDUH0HDQ5DQJHIRUHDFKORFDWLRQ,WLVHYLGHQWWKDWWKHPHDQ\LHOGLVODUJHVWIRUKLJKOHYHOVRI$
DQG'DQGORZOHYHORI&

!"#$%&'

!"#$%&'" (!)"%" *

!"#$%&'



C'J 11
:6789><
96<>5;5
969>9A>
96>>8A5
96>>8A5

C'J K1
H
4
96=<A:9 :A6;< 96999
969=7A>
<6:= 9697;
969:7;>
96;A 968:7
969:5=8
969:5=8

4
96999
96999
96999
9698A
96::9
96999
96;A=
968=7
96A5;
96=78
9699=
96::>
96555
968<=
96<:=
968<=



%DVHGRQWKHDQDO\VLVIDFWRUV$%&DQG(DUHVLJQLILFDQW7KHLQWHUDFWLRQRI%(LVDOVRVLJQLILFDQW
F
DEFGH5DQJH

































































































C*%DE!#! ,( F%-#%*)& (,- (-&&.&#/


1,G-)&
2H
1&I 11
K%#* ((&)"!
>
:6789><
<@L%E M*"&-%)"#,*!
5
96<>5;5
=@L%E M*"&-%)"#,*!
=
969>9A>
N&!#'G%D --,=<
96>>8A5
4G-& --,=<
96>>8A5
0,"%D
85
<6>98<9

. / 0,1,2,3
0 / 1,2,3
1 / 0,2,3
2 / 0,1,3
3 / 0,1,2
4 / 0,1,2,3,4
0,1 / 2,3
0,2 / 1,3
0,3 / 1,2
0,4 / 1,2,3,4
1,4 / 0,2,3,4
2,4 / 0,1,3,4
3,4 / 0,1,2,4
0,1,4 / 2,3,4
0,2,4 / 1,3,4
0,3,4 / 1,2,4
E  !"#$%"&' ((&)"! %*' +,&((#)#&*"! (,- (-&&.&#/
0&-$
((&)"
+,&( 1"2&3 +,&(
0
+,*!"%*"
567899
969:;9: 89:6;5
%
96<:==
96:975
969:;9:
>67:
?
@96:;<>
@969;7=
969:;9:
@>697
)
@9695A=
@969=;<
969:;9:
@<697
'
9697<>
969=:=
969:;9:
:678
&
@96<:99
@96:9>9
969:;9:
@>6><
%B?
@96999A
@969998
969:;9:
@969<
%B)
969=99
969:>9
969:;9:
965;
%B'
9699>A
9699<;
969:;9:
96:>
%B&
969=>9
969:5>
969:;9:
96;<
?B&
96:<8<
9697<:
969:;9:
=6<5
)B&
@9697:5
@969=9A
969:;9:
@:67<
'B&
969:9A
9699>8
969:;9:
96<A
%B?B&
969=9A
969:>8
969:;9:
96A:
%B)B&
9698A=
969<8<
969:;9:
:6<5
%B'B&
@969=9A
@969:>8
969:;9:
@96A:

7KHJHQHUDWRUIRUWKLVIUDFWLRQZDV, $%&'
7RWDOO\FRQIRXQGHGWHUPVZHUHUHPRYHGIURPWKHDQDO\VLV

! '
! #

!"

!'

$ !%

-,./

-,.0

-,.+

,.,

,.+

,.0

,./

$ !"

!"#$

!"#$%&#" '# (!"")*

!#

!"

-,./

-,.0

-,.+

,.,

,.+

,.0

,./

-+

,30&/453!6#/$738 95/:#$7;< =&4;


,!-.%#/&0' ()12(
!"#$%&' ()**+

!"#$%&'" (!)"%" *

$ !#

7KHUHVLGXDOSORWVDSSHDUWREHDGHTXDWH

-+

,@&/#8&' !()(((((((
-;6&@' ()A1>1>2
9' >?

!&&
!&'

!"#$% &"!'$'(%()* &%!)

-+

"



"

!"#$%&#" '# (!"")*

!"#$%&'" (!)"%" !

-,./

-,.0

-,.+

,.,

,.+

,.0

,./

"!#$

"!#%

"!#

!#!

!#

!#%

!#$

H 8VLQJWKHPRGHO)UHHKHLJKW $

!&&&

!(

B'I J1
5659::8
56577<8

4
56555
5657:
567=9
56;>5
5658;
569=>
G
4
9695 565>7

!"#$%&#" '# (!"")*

!"#$%&'" (!)"%" +

!"#$%&#" '# (!"")*

!"#$%&'" (!)"%" &

)URPWKHDQDO\VLVZHVHHWKDWIDFWRU$LVVLJQLILFDQWLQDIIHFWLQJYDULDELOLW\LQIUHHKHLJKW

B'I 11
5678==
5677<8

((&)"! %*' +,&((#)#&*"! (,- .%*/&


((&)"
+,&( 1"2&3 +,&(
0
567889:
565;<7=
<69>
567>9<>
565<?::
565;<7=
;6:9
A565:?;> A565=979
565;<7=
A76>8
565??;>
565997;
565;<7=
76;;
56757;>
565>5?;
565;<7=
76:<
A565>9<> A565;?:<
565;<7=
A5688

B*%CD!#! ,( E%-#%*)& (,- .%*/&


1,F-)&
2G
1&H 11
J%#* ((&)"!
>
5678==
.&!#'F%C --,75
5677<8
0,"%C
7>
5697;9

!"#$%"&'
0&-$
+,*!"%*"
%
@
)
'
&

!"#$%&'

!"#$#%&%'(

!"#$%&'

!"#$%&'

!"#$%&'



:
@0@@@
@0@@@
@0@@@
@0@;@
@0@B>
@0>?@

@0A;>

:
@0@@@
@0@@@
@0@;=
@0>?@

$"#

$"!

!"#

$"#
$"!
!"#
!"!

!"#
$%"#

$&"#

:
@0@@@
@0@@@
@0@@@
@0@@C
@0@B>

$"#

$"!

!"#

D*M 77
>0;G>A;
>0@;=G;
@0;<AC@
@0@=<?=
@0@A;GC
@0@<>>?

!"!

$"#
$"!
!"#

D*M Q7
P
@0G<?;@ G?0>?
;0@@?=B ;@C0>G
@0@B=AG
=0<;
@0@@C><
@0@;@A@
;0>C
@0@@?@=

@0A@B

:
@0@@@
@0@@@
@0@;B



0D[LPXPYLVFRVLW\LVIRXQGE\FRPSXWLQJWKHGHULYDWLYHVZLWKUHVSHFWWR$DQG%RIWKHPRGHO7KHQ
VHWWLQJWKHVHHTXDWLRQVHTXDOWRDQGVROYLQJ

$'"#

<;C0AB@
?0=<;
F;;0C>?
F<0A@A
F>0;B?

3F7JL#*MN I CG0@K

7/8"9
@0@A>C=
@0@<<C=
@0@<<C=
@0@<BA<
@0@<BA<

3F7J I CB0=K

5+"6
;<0=>?@
@0>CBB
F@0A@G>
F@0;>A@
F@0@=C@

D$#%&'(' +6 O#4(#$." 6+4 &


7+,4."
8P
7"J 77
3"-4"''(+$
A
>0;G>A;
R($"#4
>
>0@;=G;
7J,#4"
>
@0;<AC@
3"'(*,#% 144+4
?
@0@=<?=
R#.TF+6FP(/
A
@0@A;GC
:,4" 144+4
A
@0@<>>?
+/#%
;>
>0>>B>?

7 I @0@CB@C

"42
5+$'/#$/
D
E
DHD
EHE

)URPWKHDQDO\VLVZHVHHWKDWWKHPDLQHIIHFWVDQGWKHVTXDUHWHUPVDUHVLJQLILFDQWEXWWKHLQWHUDFWLRQVDUH
QRW5XQQLQJDQDQDO\VLVXVLQJRQO\WKHVLJQLILFDQWYDOXHVZHKDYH

7 I @0@C<C<
3F7J I C=0>K
3F7JL#*MN I CG0>K
D$#%&'(' +6 O#4(#$." 6+4 &
7+,4."
8P
7"J 77
D*M 77
D*M Q7
P
3"-4"''(+$
G
>0;BAG;
>0;BAG;
@0A<>C@ AC0@B
R($"#4
>
>0@;=G;
>0@;=G;
;0@@?=B ;;A0<>
7J,#4"
>
@0;<AC@
@0;<AC@
@0@B=AG
=0BA
S$/"4#./(+$
;
@0@;>;@
@0@;>;@
@0@;>;@
;0<=
3"'(*,#% 144+4
=
@0@B;==
@0@B;==
@0@@??>
R#.TF+6FP(/
<
@0@>CAC
@0@>CAC
@0@@C?<
;0>>
:,4" 144+4
A
@0@<>>?
@0@<>>?
@0@@?@=
+/#%
;>
>0>>B>?

!" #$#%&'(' )#' *+$" ,'($- .+*"* ,$(/'0


1'/(2#/"* 3"-4"''(+$ 5+"66(.("$/' 6+4 &
"42
5+"6
7/8"9
5+$'/#$/
;<0=>?@
@0@A>@;
<>B0=C@
D
@0>CBB
@0@<<>;
?0C<;
E
F@0A@G>
@0@<<>;
F;>0>@>
DHD
F@0;>A@
@0@<GB;
F<0A?>
EHE
F@0@=C@
@0@<GB;
F>0>;?
DHE
@0@GG@
@0@ABC=
;0;=;





D $GLIIHUHQWHIIHFWFDQEHFRQIRXQGHGLQHDFKUHSOLFDWHDVIROORZV
5HSOLFDWH
5HSOLFDWH
5HSOLFDWH
5HSOLFDWH
$%&FRQIRXQGHG
$%FRQIRXQGHG
%&FRQIRXQGHG
$&FRQIRXQGHG

D

D

E

D
DE
E
F
E
D
F
E
F
DF
F
DE
DF
EF
DE
DF
DE
EF
DEF
DEF
EF
DEF
DF
DEF
EF
E
!"#$% !& '(#)(*)!+
,%-#%%. !& &#%%/!0
1%23)$(*%.
4
53!$6. 7)*8 #%23)$(*%.
B
9 !# :5; <#%2= >? @ :5 <#%2= A? @ 5; <#%2= 4? @ :; <#%2= B?C
:
>
5
>
;
>
:5 <&#!0 #%23)$(*%. >D 4D (+/ B?
>
:; <&#!0 #%23)$(*%. >D AD (+/ 4?
>
5; <&#!0 #%23)$(*%. >D AD (+/ B?
>
:5; <&#!0 #%23)$(*%. AD 4D (+/ B?
>
E##!# <FG ."F*#($*)!+?
>H
I!*(3
4>
,QFDOFXODWLQJDQLQWHUDFWLRQVXPRIVTXDUHVRQO\GDWDIURPWKHUHSOLFDWHVLQZKLFKWKHLQWHUDFWLRQLV
XQFRQIRXQGHGDUHXVHG

%





$%
EORFN





D


E


DE
D  E   DE

ZKLFKLVWKHVDPHDVWKHHVWLPDWHRIWKHHIIHFWRI$%
7KHEORFNHIIHFWLVHVWLPDWHGE\



$





7ZRWKUHHIDFWRULQWHUDFWLRQVFRXOGEHXVHGWRJHQHUDWHWKHEORFNVVXFKDV$%&DQG$&'7KLVZRXOG
FRQIRXQGWKHVHHIIHFWVDQG$%&x$&' %'ZLWKEORFNV7KHUHIRUHRQO\RQHWZRIDFWRUDQGQRPDLQ
HIIHFWVDUHFRQIRXQGHGZLWKEORFNV





7KH$%&'LQWHUDFWLRQLV

>   DE  DF  EF  DG  EG  FG  DEFG@  > D  E  F  G  DEF  DEG  DFG  EFG@

,IDELVPLVVLQJWKHQ$%&'LQWHUDFWLRQZLOOEH]HURZKHQ
>DE@>@ 
7KHUHIRUHDE RUDE 
$IWHUHVWLPDWLQJDERQO\WKH$DQG$'HIIHFWVDSSHDUVLJQLILFDQW



0LQG([SDQGLQJ([HUFLVHV

w\
  % 
w%
% 
7KHPD[LPXPYLVFRVLW\LVJLYHQE\
         

0RGHO $%$ %  \


w\
  $ 
w$
$ 


&'()*
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
-

!
+
+
,
,
+
+
,
,

"
+
+
+
+
,
,
,
,

#% !
,
+
+
,
,
+
+
,

$% "
,
+
,
+
+
,
+
,

/ % !"
,
,
+
+
+
+
,
,

0 % !"
+
,
,
+
,
+
+
,



7KHFRPSOHWHGHILQLQJUHODWLRQLV, $%' $&( %&'( %&) $&') $%() '()


$%&* &'* %(* $'(* $)* %')* &()* $%&'()*
7KHDOLDVVWUXFWXUHIROORZV LQFOXGLQJRQO\RQHDQGWZRIDFWRUHIIHFWV 
$ %' &( )*
% $' &) (*
& $( %) '*
' $% () &*
( $& ') %*
) %& '( $*
* &' %( $)
E 7KHFRPSOHWHGHILQLQJUHODWLRQLV, $%' $&( %&'( %&) $&') $%() '() $%&*
 &'* %(* $'(* $)* %')* &()* $%&'()*
7KHDOLDVHV XSWRWZRIDFWRUHIIHFWV DUH
$ %' &( )*
% $' &) (*
& $( %) '*
' $% () &*
( $& ') %*
) %& '( $*
* &' %( $)
F $OOWKHPDLQHIIHFWVFDQEHHVWLPDWHGE\DYHUDJLQJWKHHVWLPDWHVRIDQDOLDVVHWFRQWDLQLQJDPDLQHIIHFW
IURPHDFKIUDFWLRQEHFDXVHWKHWZRIDFWRUHIIHFWVZLOOFDQFHO

+
,
+
,
+
,
+
,

! % "#$
,
+
+
,
,
+
+
,
,
+
+
,
,
+
+
,



$ % !"#
,
+
+
,
+
,
,
+
+
,
,
+
,
+
+
,

7KHJHQHUDWRUVDUH( $%&) %&'DQG* $&'7KHFRPSOHWHGHILQLQJUHODWLRQLV, $%&( %&')


$'() $&'* %'(* $%)* &()*7KHDOLDVVHW$%' &'( $&) %() %&* $(* 
')*FDQEHXVHGWRFRQVWUXFWWKHEORFNV7KHQRQO\WKUHHIDFWRULQWHUDFWLRQDUHFRQIRXQGHGZLWKEORFNV

#
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,



"
+
+
+
+
,
,
,
,
+
+
+
+
,
,
,
,

7KHJHQHUDWRUVDUH) $%&'DQG* $%'(7KHFRPSOHWHGHILQLQJUHODWLRQLV


, $%&') $%'(* &()*
7KHGHVLJQFDQEHFRQVWUXFWHGLQIRXUEORFNVE\FRQIRXQGLQJ$&( $)*DQG%&( %)*ZLWKEORFNV7KLV
DOVRFRQIRXQGV$% &') '(*ZLWKEORFNV
<HVDWZRIDFWRULQWHUDFWLRQLVFRQIRXQGHGZLWKEORFNV7KHEHVWEORFNLQJVFKHPHFRQIRXQGVRQO\RQHWZR
IDFWRULQWHUDFWLRQZLWKEORFNV

!
+
+
,
,
+
+
,
,
+
+
,
,
+
+
,
,

7KLVXVHV$% &'(DVWKHHIIHFWWRFRQIRXQGZLWKEORFNV

+
,
+
,
+
,
+
,
+
,
+
,
+
,
+
,





%HFDXVHZ !GRQRWUHMHFW+!



=! 3YDOXH 3 _=_! UHMHFW+!8VLQJWKHFRQWLQXLW\FRUUHFWLRQ=! 3YDOXH 


UHMHFW+!

%HFDXVHU !U!"!# IRUQ +!LVQRWUHMHFWHG

%HFDXVHU dIRUQ UHMHFW+!

=! 3YDOXH 8VLQJWKHFRQWLQXLW\FRUUHFWLRQ=! 3YDOXH 

=! 3YDOXH 8VLQJWKHFRQWLQXLW\FRUUHFWLRQ=! 3YDOXH 











3 =  




 7KHUHIRUHZLWKQ 

G  E

3 5 ! _ P



 7KHUHIRUH5 KDVDELQRPLDOGLVWULEXWLRQZLWKS DQGQ ZKHQ

F 7KHVLJQWHVWWKDWUHMHFWVLI5 dKDVD EDVHGRQWKHELQRPLDOGLVWULEXWLRQ

D D 3 =!  


;

E  E 3

 _ P 
V Q

%&$' "

P 7KHQE 7KHYDOXHRIELVJUHDWHUIRUWKHVLJQWHVWWKDQIRUWKHQRUPDOWHVWEHFDXVHWKH=
WHVWZDVGHVLJQHGIRUWKHQRUPDOGLVWULEXWLRQ



#%$
H

a   
S E 3 7\SH,,HUURU 3 5 !_ P

a  
a  ( ;  DQG3 ;_ P
)RU P

E %HFDXVHU  !GRQRWUHMHFW+!
a 
F E 3 7\SH,,HUURU 3 5 !_ P

 6ROYLQJIRUOZHILQGO DQG( ;  O 



%HFDXVHU dIRUQ UHMHFW+!



D  I [



3YDOXH 3 5 t_S  %HFDXVHU !GRQRWUHMHFW+!







=! 3YDOXH 3 =!  8VLQJWKHFRQWLQXLW\FRUUHFWLRQ=! 3YDOXH 



#%$
OH !" IRU[!DQG OH !"



=! 7KH3YDOXH 3 _=_!  8VLQJWKHFRQWLQXLW\FRUUHFWLRQWKH3YDOXH 


%HFDXVHZ UHMHFW+!

%HFDXVHZ !GRQRWUHMHFW+!

6HWZ PLQ Z%Z$ %HFDXVHZ !Z!"!% GRQRWUHMHFW+!



6HWZ PLQ Z%Z$ %HFDXVHZ !Z!"!# GRQRWUHMHFW+!


=! 3YDOXH 
=! 3YDOXH 








Kruskal-Wallis Test on strength


mixingte
N
Median
Ave Rank
Z
1
4
2945
9.6
0.55
2
4
3075
12.9
2.12
3
4
2942
9.0
0.24
4
4
2650
2.5
-2.91
Overall
16
8.5
H = 10.00 DF = 3 P = 0.019
H = 10.03 DF = 3 P = 0.018 (adjusted for ties)
* NOTE * One or more small samples
5HMHFW+!

6HFWLRQ

6HWZ PLQ Z%Z$ %HFDXVHZ Z!"!# UHMHFW+!





=! DQG3YDOXH 

=! 3YDOXH 

6HWZ PLQ Z%Z$ %HFDXVHZ Z!"!# UHMHFW+!

%HFDXVHZ$ !Z!"!$# GRQRWUHMHFW+!



6HFWLRQ



3YDOXH 3 5 t_S Q  


%HFDXVHZ UHMHFW+!

%HFDXVHZ UHMHFW+!



3YDOXH 3 _=_! 





U !  Q

 Q

%HFDXVHZ !GRQRWUHMHFW+!
)URPH[HUFLVH=! 3YDOXH GRQRWUHMHFW+!



6DPSOHPHGLDQ Z Z  UHMHFW+!









3YDOXH 3 5 d_S   7KHH[DFWSYDOXHFRPSXWHGKHUHDJUHHVZLWKWKHQRUPDO


DSSUR[LPDWLRQLQ([HUFLVHLQWKHVHQVHWKDWERWKFDOFXODWLRQVZRXOGOHDGWRWKHUHMHFWLRQRI+!7KH
FRQWLQXLW\FRUUHFWLRQLPSURYHVWKHDFFXUDF\RIWKHQRUPDODSSUR[LPDWLRQ

3YDOXH 3 5 t_S   

6HFWLRQ





8VLQJWKHELQRPLDOGLVWULEXWLRQZLWKQ DQGS 3YDOXH 3 5 d_S  

a 
+ P
a  
+ P

6DPSOHPHGLDQ 
8VLQJWKHELQRPLDOGLVWULEXWLRQZLWKQ DQGS 3YDOXH 3 5 d_S  





6DPSOH0HGLDQ 
8VLQJWKHELQRPLDOGLVWULEXWLRQZLWKQ DQGS 3YDOXH 3 5 t_S  



6HFWLRQ

&+$37(5

Rank
7.6
12.4
15.8
6.2
10.5









GRQRWUHMHFW+

P
0.1334

6.000
Median
4.000

Median
10.01



test1
N =
8
Median =
1.4000
test2
N =
8
Median =
1.6500
Point estimate for ETA1-ETA2 is
-0.2000
95.9 Percent CI for ETA1-ETA2 is (-0.4999,0.1001)
W = 53.5
Test of ETA1 = ETA2 vs ETA1 not = ETA2 is significant at 0.1415
The test is significant at 0.1377 (adjusted for ties)
Cannot reject at alpha = 0.05

=  3YDOXH XVLQJWKHFRQWLQXLW\FRUUHFWLRQ3YDOXH 

Sign test of median = 6.000 versus <


N Below Equal Above
y
15
9
2
4
'RQRWUHMHFW+

Sign test of median = 10.00 versus not = 10.00


N Below Equal Above
P
y
10
5
0
5
1.0000
8VLQJFRQWLQXLW\FRUUHFWLRQ3YDOXH 

%HFDXVHZ !Z

! "

3YDOXH  XVHWKHFKLVTXDUHGLVWULEXWLRQ

6XSSOHPHQWDO([HUFLVHV

3YDOXH  XVHWKHFKLVTXDUHGLVWULEXWLRQ





Z
-1.27
0.83
2.31
-1.88

Kruskal-Wallis Test on UNIFORMI


FLOW
N
Median
Ave Rank
Z
125
6
3.100
5.8
-2.06
160
6
4.400
13.0
1.97
200
6
3.800
9.7
0.09
Overall
18
9.5
H = 5.42 DF = 2 P = 0.067
H = 5.44 DF = 2 P = 0.066 (adjusted for ties)
'RQRWUHMHFW+

Kruskal-Wallis Test on angle


manufact
N
Median
Ave
1
5
39.00
2
5
44.00
3
5
48.00
4
5
30.00
Overall
20
H = 8.37 DF = 3 P = 0.039
'RQRWUHMHFW+

Kruskal-Wallis Test on strength


method
N
Median
Ave Rank
Z
1
5
550.0
8.7
0.43
2
5
553.0
10.7
1.65
3
5
528.0
4.6
-2.08
Overall
15
8.0
H = 4.83 DF = 2 P = 0.089
H = 4.84 DF = 2 P = 0.089 (adjusted for ties)
'RQRWUHMHFW+













DF = 2
DF = 2

P = 0.000
P = 0.000 (adjusted for ties)

Z
-4.31
-0.09
4.40



Kruskal-Wallis Test on VOLUME


TEMPERAT
N
Median
Ave Rank
Z
70
5
1245
12.4
2.69
75
5
1220
7.9
-0.06
80
5
1170
3.7
-2.63
Overall
15
8.0
H = 9.46 DF = 2 P = 0.009
H = 9.57 DF = 2 P = 0.008 (adjusted for ties)
5HMHFW+

Kruskal-Wallis Test on SCORE


METHOD
N
Median
Ave Rank
Z
1
8
23.50
15.1
1.29
2
8
21.75
8.1
-2.14
3
8
23.05
14.3
0.86
Overall
24
12.5
H = 4.66 DF = 2 P = 0.098
H = 4.66 DF = 2 P = 0.097 (adjusted for ties)
'RQRWUHMHFW+

H = 25.30
H = 25.45
5HMHFW+

Kruskal-Wallis Test on RESISTAN


ALLOY
N
Median
Ave Rank
1
10
98.00
5.7
2
10
102.50
15.3
3
10
138.50
25.5
Overall
30
15.5

)URPH[HUFLVH=  3YDOXH 3 =!  





=  3YDOXH 5HMHFW+


=  5HMHFW+

6HWZ PLQ Z+Z, %HFDXVHZ UHMHFW+





3YDOXH 3 5#t_S   ZKHUH5#LVWKHQXPEHURIGLIIHUHQFHV;$%&'(%;)&*%(

Test of median = 6.000 versus median < 6.000


N for
Wilcoxon
Estimated
N
Test Statistic
P
Median
y
15
13
19.0
0.035
5.000
5HMHFW+

Test of median = 10.00 versus median not = 10.00


N for
Wilcoxon
Estimated
N
Test Statistic
P
Median
y
10
10
28.5
0.959
10.00
'RQRWUHMHFW+








L


Q Q  


Q Q   Q  


VLQ FH

( [




D VHTXHQFHVDUHSRVVLEOH
E %HFDXVHHDFKVHTXHQFHKDVSUREDELOLW\XQGHU+ WKHGLVWULEXWLRQRI:!LVREWDLQHGE\FRXQWLQJWKH
VHTXHQFHVWKDWUHVXOWLQHDFKYDOXHRI:!

9 5

9 5 9 [ L!
E\ LQGHSHQGHQFH


9 ; !   !  >( ; @!


  

  
7KHQ

( [ L
!

[L
!

ZKHUH

( 5

DQG

8QGHUWKHQXOOK\SRWKHVLVHDFKUDQNKDVSUREDELOLW\RIRIEHLQJHLWKHUSRVLWLYHRUQHJDWLYH'HILQHWKH
UDQGRPYDULDEOH; DV
 UDQN LV SRVLWLYH
;
UDQN LV QHJDWLYH

7KHQ



 E
















Z!
3URE 
















!
F 3 Z !  
G %\HQXPHUDWLQJWKHSRVVLEOHVHTXHQFHVWKHSUREDELOLW\WKDW:!H[FHHGVDQ\YDOXHFDQEHFDOFXODWHGXQGHU
WKHQXOOK\SRWKHVLVDVLQSDUW F 7KLVDSSURDFKFDQEHXVHGWRGHWHUPLQHWKHFULWLFDOYDOXHVIRUWKHWHVW





0LQG([SDQGLQJ([HUFLVHV











=>8 =? :)+)8( - '





















' (>D*9=>E( 6GH:>I6I



!@,98)7* GD,9
2 K,7*6
2 <<<<<
2 !"# $
%&' ()*+, - 3;&3;1.
2 !67869:)76
- /&.%504
2 "!"# <
%&' ()*+, - '
2
2 =>8 =? :)+)8( - '



VXEJURXS

3UREOHP

L<D,9
<<<<<
!"# $
%&' ()*+, - %.&4'%0
!67869:)76
- %4&'14.
"!"# <
%&' ()*+, - %'&.0/.




5DQJH





;EDU



J(8)+,86I
E9=H6(( +6,7 - %4&%;
E9=H6(( ()*+, - ;&4;1'5
+6,7 K,7*6
- /&5/

;' (>D*9=>E(F ()C6 /

6 '#%()
6 !!!!!
2 !"# $
%&' ()*+, - 33&1453
2 !67869:)76
- /&5/
2 "!"# <
%&' ()*+, - '
2
=>8 =? :)+)8( - 3
2 =>8 =? :)+)8( - '
<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<
!@,98# A=8@
B=9+,:)C6# B=

!"#$ #%& '#%() ! *%+,+#- .,/&0


1$2"-)3 45!4

!"#$
!!!!!
!"# $
%&' ()*+, - %.&/.01
!67869:)76
- %4&%;
"!"# <
%&' ()*+, - %3&'533

6HFWLRQ

1RWHWRWKH,QVWUXFWRU0DQ\RIWKHFRQWUROFKDUWVDQGFRQWUROFKDUWVXPPDULHVDUHFUHDWHGXVLQJ6WDWJUDSKLFV)RU
0LQLWDEXVHUVWKHVXEURXWLQH,DQG05&KDUWVXQGHU&RQWURO&KDUWVZLOOSURYLGHVLPLODU
UHVXOWV

&+$37(5
&+$37(5














VXEJURXS

3UREOHP

FKDUW

/&/

' "U

8&/ '! U
&/ 

 

 





















/ #$%&'($)# -012$3-3



!"#$ #%& '#%() ! *%+,+#- .,/&0


12#$,+%( 3$4"-)5 67!8
!"#$
9 '#%()
!!!!!
9 !!!!!
:1;< =
8>? @+(5# A 67>BCDD
9 :1;< =
8>? @+(5# A 67>E?EF
1)%,)$-+%)
A 6?>F6C7
9 1)%,)$-+%)
A B>F7
;1;< !
8>? @+(5# A 7>FD7?B
9 ;1;< !
8>? @+(5# A ?
9
4/, 4G -+5+,@ A ?
9 4/, 4G -+5+,@ A ?
H@,+5#,)&
I$4J)@@ 5)#% A 6?>F6C7
I$4J)@@ @+(5# A 8>CFKCD
5)#% '#%()
A B>F7





9 :;<"=;>
9 !<;??;
9 .<>:?A;

#+,- .

8&/ &/  $ U     


&/ 
/&/ &/  $ U     

 [










FKDUW

5DQJH

;EDU








!" #$%&'($)#*
4#5+675-3
)'(1-## 6-78
)'(1-## #+&67
6-78 @78&-











VXEJURXS

3UREOHP






















FKDUW

FKDUW


   




8&/ ' U  


&/ 
/&/ '!U  





   




U
 G
G

  


8&/ &/  $ U
&/ 
/&/ &/  $ U







7KHUHDUHQRSRLQWVEH\RQGWKHFRQWUROOLPLWV7KHSURFHVVDSSHDUVWREHLQFRQWURO
E 1RSRLQWVIHOOEH\RQGWKHFRQWUROOLPLWVWKHOLPLWVGRQRWQHHGWREHUHYLVHG

5DQJH

;EDU








FKDUW

 

[ 

U

G

' "U





% &'!6)
3/
31
;#<9- &/
&1
/
1

!"#$

$&
$(%$
$(%#
$#%'
$#%&
$#

% &'!()

"!

&1
&/
78"9$+8:

"

*$+",-. &/!0

31

3/

#!

4236'!6

&24/(05'!(

1210(6510
121034(50
121036160

!"#$%&' (#)*+,- ./01


20*"#
3 4"&',
00000
3 00000
!"# $
%&' ()*+, - '&'.%/0'.
1 !"# $
%&' ()*+, - 2&34%.056%
!7897:;)87
- '&'.<3%0.
1 !7897:;)87
- 3&</56/
"!"# 6
%&' ()*+, - '&'.</'/.
1 "!"# 6
%&' ()*+, - '
1
=>9 =? ;)+)9( - 4
1 =>9 =? ;)+)9( - <
66666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666
!@,:9# A=9@
B=:+,;)C7# B=
<4 (>D*:=>E(F ()C7 4
' (>D*:=>E( 7GH;>I7I
5(9)+,97I
E:=H7(( +7,8 - '&'.<3%0.
E:=H7(( ()*+, - %&30</J56/
+7,8 K,8*7
- 3&</56/

V

P

/&/

8&/ '! U  


&/ 



   








   

D ;EDUDQG5DQJH,QLWLDO6WXG\








FKDUW

8&/ &/  $ U
&/ 
/&/ &/  $ U

D  [



7KHUHDUHVHYHUDOSRLQWVRXWRIFRQWURO7KHFRQWUROOLPLWVQHHGWREHUHYLVHG7KHSRLQWVDUH
DQGRURXWVLGHWKHFRQWUROOLPLWVRIWKH5FKDUWDQG



























VXEJURXS











(

(









!"#$ #%& '#%() ! J%+/+#4 K/F&L


01#$/+%( 2$3"4). 56!A
!"#$
8 '#%()
!!!!!
8 !!!!!
90-: ;
<=> ,+(.# ? A=@@C6<
8 90-: ;
<=> ,+(.# ? C=B56<
0)%/)$4+%)
? 7=CE<7
8 0)%/)$4+%)
? 5=5<CE
-0-: !
<=> ,+(.# ? 6=5C@7A
8 -0-: !
<=> ,+(.# ? >
8
3F/ 3G 4+.+/, ? >
8 3F/ 3G 4+.+/, ? >
D,/+.#/)&
H$3I),, .)#% ? 7=CE<7
H$3I),, ,+(.# ? >=77B5>E
.)#% '#%()
? 5=5<CE

5DQJH

;(


;EDU

!"#$ #%& '#%() ! ')*+,)& -+.+/,


01#$/+%( 2$3"4). 56!7
!"#$
8 '#%()
!!!!!
8 !!!!!
90-: ;
<=> ,+(.# ? >=>7<<@A
8 90-: ;
<=> ,+(.# ? 5=<5<BCD!<
0)%/)$4+%)
? >=>7CBEE7
8 0)%/)$4+%)
? 7=C5@CBD!@
-0-: !
<=> ,+(.# ? >=>7C7<>5
8 -0-: !
<=> ,+(.# ? >
8
3F/ 3G 4+.+/, ? >
8 3F/ 3G 4+.+/, ? 5
D,/+.#/)&
H$3I),, .)#% ? >=>7CBEE7
H$3I),, ,+(.# ? C=7A577D!@
.)#% '#%()
? 7=C5@CBD!@
3UREOHP
5HYLVHG/LPLWV
;(














3UREOHP















(VWLPDWHG
SURFHVVPHDQ 
SURFHVVVLJPD 
PHDQ05   



VXEJURXSVVL]HVXEJURXSVH[FOXGHG

,QG[_05 
_
8&/VLJPD _8&/VLJPD 
&HQWHUOLQH _&HQWHUOLQH 
/&/VLJPD _/&/VLJPD 
_
RXWRIOLPLWV _RXWRIOLPLWV 

&KDUW%RWK1RUPDOL]H1R


D
,QGLYLGXDOVDQG05  ,QLWLDO6WXG\

&KDUWLQJ3UREOHP

6HFWLRQ

E 1RSRLQWVIHOOEH\RQGWKHFRQWUROOLPLWVWKHOLPLWVGRQRWQHHGWREHUHYLVHG






VXEJURXS
7KHUHDUHQRSRLQWVEH\RQGWKHFRQWUROOLPLWV7KHSURFHVVDSSHDUVWREHLQFRQWURO

5DQJH

;EDU


















VXEJURXS

3UREOHP



















V

P
PU
G

[








(VWLPDWHG
SURFHVVPHDQ 
SURFHVVVLJPD 
PHDQ05   



VXEJURXSVVL]HVXEJURXSVH[FOXGHG

,QG[_05 
_
8&/VLJPD _8&/VLJPD 
&HQWHUOLQH _&HQWHUOLQH 
/&/VLJPD _/&/VLJPD 
_
RXWRIOLPLWV _RXWRIOLPLWV 

&KDUW%RWK1RUPDOL]H1R


D
,QGLYLGXDOVDQG05  ,QLWLDO6WXG\

&KDUWLQJ3UREOHP



7KHUHDUHQRSRLQWVEH\RQGWKHFRQWUROOLPLWV7KHSURFHVVDSSHDUVWREHLQFRQWURO



05  




,QG[













VXEJURXS



3UREOHP



















V

P

PU
G










(VWLPDWHG
SURFHVVPHDQ 
SURFHVVVLJPD 
PHDQ05   



VXEJURXSVVL]HVXEJURXSVH[FOXGHG

,QG[_05 
_
8&/VLJPD _8&/VLJPD 
&HQWHUOLQH _&HQWHUOLQH 
/&/VLJPD _/&/VLJPD 
_
RXWRIOLPLWV _RXWRIOLPLWV 

&KDUW%RWK1RUPDOL]H1R

 D ,QG[DQG05  ,QLWLDO6WXG\



&KDUWLQJGLDPHWHU



7KHUHDUHQRSRLQWVEH\RQGWKHFRQWUROOLPLWV7KHSURFHVVDSSHDUVWREHLQFRQWURO

05 

,QG[









*+/

%&
%!
%'
%"
$%$
$%&
$%!

"!

'*
'(
23#4!"35

"

!"#$%& '()'*

,*

,(

#!

*+'0',(
*

*+1,(',.

0+('/(1

'*+*,-,

'*+(.(/

V

P
PU
G

[









(VWLPDWHG
SURFHVVPHDQ 
SURFHVVVLJPD 
PHDQ05   



VXEJURXSVVL]HVXEJURXSVH[FOXGHG

,QG[_05 
_
8&/VLJPD _8&/VLJPD 
&HQWHUOLQH _&HQWHUOLQH 
/&/VLJPD _/&/VLJPD 
_
RXWRIOLPLWV _RXWRIOLPLWV 

&KDUW%RWK1RUPDOL]H1R

 D
,QG[DQG05  ,QLWLDO6WXG\

&KDUWLQJ3UREOHP



7KHUHDUHQRSRLQWVEH\RQGWKHFRQWUROOLPLWV7KHSURFHVVDSSHDUVWREHLQFRQWURO

*+,

*+1
789,: *+6

"
"
"
()*%+
"



#$

"
#$
56/7-.68

"

#%

#%

*%

#4*=%"!

%=*= "

!!4* ""

&

&&$*##$

V

P

PU
G









V V
PLQ


V V




3 = ! 
  3 =  
 




%\V\PPHWU\WKHIUDFWLRQGHIHFWLYHLV>3 ;"86/ @!



E $VVXPLQJDQRUPDOGLVWULEXWLRQZLWKV! 86//6/ DQGDFHQWHUHGSURFHVVWKHQ


V! 86/P &RQVHTXHQWO\86/P!VDQGP/6/!V
V

3 ; ! 86/ 3 = !

6LQFH3&5DQG3&5 H[FHHGVXQLW\WKHQDWXUDOWROHUDQFHOLPLWVOLHLQVLGHWKHVSHFLILFDWLRQOLPLWVDQGYHU\
IHZGHIHFWLYHXQLWVZLOOEHSURGXFHG

 3&5

D ,IWKHSURFHVVXVHVRIWKHVSHFLILFDWLRQEDQGWKHQV! 86//6/ WKHQDVVXPH [


VLQFHWKHSURFHVVLVFHQWHUHG
V  86/  [  [  /6/  86/  P

V 86/  P /68  P

6HFWLRQ



"

,-./012 #&3##

7KHUHDUHQRSRLQWVEH\RQGWKHFRQWUROOLPLWV7KHSURFHVVDSSHDUVWREHLQFRQWURO

9:;$<

'()*+

&%
&!
&$
&
!"
!%
!!





3&5

RU V



     


PLQ


 
 
PLQ>
 @

86/  [ [  /6/
PLQ


V
V





  
 



86/  /6/
 V




3 ; ! 86/

  3 =  


3 = ! 

86/  P
3 = !

V





3 ;  /6/



  3 =  
  

3 =  

  

3 = 



/6/  P
3 = 

V



D $VVXPLQJDQRUPDOGLVWULEXWLRQZLWK P !DQG V


7KHUHIRUHWKHSURSRUWLRQQRQFRQIRUPLQJLVJLYHQE\
3 ;/6/ 3 ;"86/ !
!



  3 =  
  

3 =  

U
G!




E $VVXPLQJDQRUPDOGLVWULEXWLRQZLWK P !DQG V !

/6/  P
3 ;  /6/ 3 = 

V

6LQFH3&5!z3&5WKHSURFHVVLVVOLJKWO\RIIFHQWHU



6LQFH3&5H[FHHGVXQLW\WKHQDWXUDOWROHUDQFHOLPLWVOLHLQVLGHWKHVSHFLILFDWLRQOLPLWVDQGYHU\IHZ
GHIHFWLYHXQLWVZLOOEHSURGXFHG



U
G!

3&5

D  V







  

3 = !



3 = ! 
  3 =  
  

86/  P
3 = !

V

3&5

3&5

  
 







PLQ>
 
 @

86/  [ [  /6/
PLQ


V
V
     
PLQ


 
 

86/  /6/
 V

U
G!




 RUPP

P DQGV! 86/ [ ! P/6/



V 
 V
3&5 " PLQ



V
V
6LQFH3&5DQG3&5!H[FHHGXQLW\WKHQDWXUDOWROHUDQFHOLPLWVOLHLQVLGHWKHVSHFLILFDWLRQOLPLWVDQGYHU\
IHZGHIHFWLYHXQLWVZLOOEHSURGXFHG

7KHUHIRUH

$VVXPH [

,IWKHSURFHVVXVHVRIWKHVSHFEDQGWKHQV! 86//6/ DQG



86/  /6/


3&5
 86/  /6/ 

  

 3&5
 
:LWKWKH3&5PXFKOHVVWKDQXQLW\WKHSURFHVVFDSDELOLW\DSSHDUVWREHSRRU

  


  
  

3 = !

 3 = 



3 = !   3 =  


 [ 
3 ; !   3 ;  

 V

3&5 #3&5WKHSURFHVVDSSHDUVWREHFHQWHUHG

6LQFH3&5H[FHHGVXQLW\WKHQDWXUDOWROHUDQFHOLPLWVOLHLQVLGHWKHVSHFLILFDWLRQOLPLWVDQGYHU\IHZ
GHIHFWLYHXQLWVZLOOEHSURGXFHG



7KHUHIRUHWKHSURSRUWLRQQRQFRQIRUPLQJLVJLYHQE\
3 ;/6/ 3 ;"86/ !
!



3 ; ! 86/





3 ; ! 86/
  

3 = !


3 = ! 
  3 =  

86/  P
3 = !

V

  
 





     


PLQ


   
PLQ>@

86/  [ [  /6/
PLQ


V
V

86/  /6/
 V

     
PLQ


   
PLQ>
 
 @

86/  [ [  /6/
PLQ


V
V



7KHSURFHVVLVFDSDEOH

3&5



$VVXPLQJDQRUPDOGLVWULEXWLRQZLWK P !DQG V !


86/  /6/   

3&5

 V
 

7KHSURFHVVFDSDELOLW\LVPDUJLQDO



3&5

3&5

  

7KHUHIRUHWKHSURSRUWLRQQRQFRQIRUPLQJLVJLYHQE\
3 ;/6/ 3 ;"86/ !
!



  3 =  
  


3 =  

  

3 = 




$VVXPLQJDQRUPDOGLVWULEXWLRQZLWK P !DQG V !


/6/  P
3 ;  /6/ 3 = 

V




PLQ>@

86/  [ [  /6/
PLQ


V
V
     
PLQ


   

 r  




     


PLQ


 
 
PLQ>@

86/  [ [  /6/
PLQ


V
V

6LQFHWKHSURFHVVFDSDELOLW\UDWLRVDUHOHVVWKDQXQLW\WKHSURFHVVFDSDELOLW\DSSHDUVWREHSRRU

3&5

$VVXPLQJDQRUPDOGLVWULEXWLRQZLWK P !DQG V !


86/  /6/   
3&5

 V
 

P r V


$VVXPLQJDQRUPDOGLVWULEXWLRQZLWK P !DQG V !
!

7KHQDWXUDOWROHUDQFHOLPLWVDUHWKHQ

7KHSURFHVVFDSDELOLW\LVSRRU

3&5



!
$VVXPLQJDQRUPDOGLVWULEXWLRQZLWK P !DQG V !


86/  /6/

3&5
 V
 

(VWLPDWHG
PHDQ3 
VLJPD 



VXEJURXSVVL]HVXEJURXSVH[FOXGHG

RXWRIOLPLWV 

1RUPDOL]H1R

3&KDUW

8&/VLJPD 
&HQWHUOLQH 
/&/VLJPD 


3&KDUW,QLWLDO6WXG\

&KDUWLQJ3UREOHP

6HFWLRQ

















VXEJURXS











(VWLPDWHG
PHDQ3 
VLJPD 



VXEJURXSVVL]HVXEJURXSVH[FOXGHG

RXWRIOLPLWV 

1RUPDOL]H1R

3&KDUW

8&/VLJPD 
&HQWHUOLQH 
/&/VLJPD 

3&KDUW5HYLVHG/LPLWV

&KDUWLQJ3UREOHP

7KHSURFHVVLVRXWRIFRQWURO7KHFRQWUROOLPLWVQHHGWREHUHYLVHG7KHVDPSOHVZLWKRXWRIFRQWURO
SRLQWVDUHDQG



3UREOHP





!,#

!,-

!
" #!
%&'()*&+

0)*'123 "4##
5267%28 9737:%

#"

"

#!

!"#$% &'"(%)

#"

"

!"#$% &'$ ()&)*%+

,'#()*"(#(-& -

!" #$%&

'#()*"'#+

$!

!, ;#;;!, !# -$
!,! #;#

"

#!

!"#$% &'"(%)

#"

"

.%("+,'"("""

&'#()"*

%("+,'%($-%



7KHFRQWUROOLPLWVDUHFDOFXODWHGZLWKRXWWKHRXWRIFRQWUROSRLQWV7KHUHDUHQRSRLQWVRXWRIFRQWUROIRU
WKHUHYLVHGOLPLWV

"

8&KDUWIRUGHIHFWV

6DPSOHVDQGKDYHRXWRIFRQWUROSRLQWV7KHOLPLWVQHHGWREHUHYLVHG
E

"

7KHUHDUHQRSRLQWVRXWRIFRQWUROIRUWKHUHYLVHGOLPLWV

!,.

!,/

!"#$% &'()*

!"#$% &'()*





!"

!-

"

"$

"
%&'()*&+

/)*'012 !34"$

,5!$",-

!-56 #-

"

#!

!"#$% &'"(%)

#"

"

&&KDUWIRUGHIHFWV
#

.*'"+,%"'*-"&

$%&'(")

*'"+,%#&'"-

0,% 0D *)3)%? @ 46
E?%)3#%232#(
@ >=45>5C4
?)/3#
@ >=>45AA<C



!"#$% & '()%)#* +%,-.


!"#$%)(/ $01*23 45&67
!"#$%
&&&&&
8!9: ;
<=> ?)/3# @ >=4AB55<
!2(%2$*)(2
@ >=45>5C4
9!9: &
<=> ?)/3# @ >=4>65A

7KHUHDUHWZRSRLQWVEH\RQGWKHFRQWUROOLPLWV7KH\DUHVDPSOHVDQG
7KH8FKDUWDQGWKH&FKDUWERWKGHWHFWHGRXWRIFRQWUROSRLQWVDWVDPSOHVDQG

"

#"

"

7KHSURFHVVLVQRWLQFRQWURO7KHUHDUHVHYHUDOSRLQWVEH\RQGWKHFRQWUROOLPLWV

0+$ 0D )(3($? @ 7
E?$(3"$2,
32"'
@ C=476CA
?(.3"
@ 6=C5<5B

!"#$ % &'($(") *$+,!"#$('. /#01)23 45%67


!"#$
%%%%%
8 9: ;
<=> ?(.3" @ 4A=B><A
2'$2#)('2
@ C=476CA
9 9: %
<=> ?(.3" @ >

!"#$% &'()*

-#

-$

"

#$

&'()*+',

#%

$!

-# $36

-#3 35#

-#6"33.

"

#%

&'()*+',

#$



7KHUHDUHQRSRLQWVRXWRIFRQWUROIRUWKHUHYLVHGOLPLWV

-#

/ -$

-.

-!

!"#$%& '()*+
,%-./%0 1.&.2/

!"#$% & '()*+(, -*.*%+


!"#$%*/0 $123(. 45&67
!"#$%
&&&&&
8!-9 :
;<= +*0.# > =<6=74?@
!(/%($3*/(
> =<45A;;;
-!-9 &
;<= +*0.# > =<4=?@?6
1B% 1C 3*.*%+ > =
D+%*.#%(,
.(#/
> =<45A;;;
+*0.#
> =<=476?;A

$!

34'3787*

34*3+'78
34'(5666

7KHVDPSOHVZLWKRXWRIFRQWUROSRLQWVDUH
7KHUHDUHVHYHUDOSRLQWVDUHRXWRIFRQWURO7KHFRQWUROOLPLWVQHHGWREHUHYLVHG

-.

-!

/*+(012 #34$%









8&/

3 =    3 =  
 @
3 =    >  3 =  
  

  =  
3 



3 =    3 =  
>  3 =   @  >  3 =   @

3   =  

   ;  P   


3




V




P!



    

7KHSUREDELOLW\WKDWWKLVVKLIWZLOOEHGHWHFWHGRQWKHQH[WVDPSOHLVS!!



E  $5/
S 



V

3   ;  

D  V !


7KHSUREDELOLW\WKDWWKLVVKLIWZLOOEHGHWHFWHGRQWKHQH[WVDPSOHLVS!!



F  $5/
S 








V
   

V

 P 
E  V
Q 
3 ;
   ;  P   


3

V



Q
V

  

D  P  

3   =  
3 =    3 =  
3 =    >  3 =   @
    

7KHSUREDELOLW\WKDWWKLVVKLIWZLOOEHGHWHFWHGRQWKHQH[WVDPSOHLVS!!


E  $5/

S 


   ;  P   




3

V



  V !P!

3   ;  

D  [

6HFWLRQ







3 =    >  3 =   @


    




 V ! !



3   =  
3 =    3 =  
3 =    >  3 =   @
    

   ;  P   




3

V!




V

 P!

  V ! !





3   =  
3 =    3 =  


   ;  P   




3



V!

V



  

7KHSUREDELOLW\WKDWWKLVVKLIWZLOOEHGHWHFWHGRQWKHQH[WVDPSOHLVS!!


E  $5/


S 



5
G

3   ;  

D  V


7KHSUREDELOLW\WKDWWKLVVKLIWZLOOEHGHWHFWHGRQWKHQH[WVDPSOHLVS!!


E  $5/

S 



5
G

3   ;  

D  V

V
5

 V ! !
G
Q
3   ;  


D  V



 P!





3   =  

 V ! !




 P!

3   =  

   ;  P   


3




V!


V

 V ! !



3   =  
3 =    3 =  
3 =    >  3 =   @
    


  ;  P   



3

V!





V

 P!




7KHSUREDELOLW\WKDWWKLVVKLIWZLOOEHGHWHFWHGRQWKHQH[WVDPSOHLVS!!


E  $5/

S 



5
G

 ;  _P
3 


D  V

3 =    3 =  
  

7KHSUREDELOLW\WKDWWKLVVKLIWZLOOEHGHWHFWHGRQWKHQH[WVDPSOHLVS!!



E  $5/
S 



5
G

3   ;  

D  V

3 =    3 =   @
  

7KHSUREDELOLW\WKDWWKLVVKLIWZLOOEHGHWHFWHGRQWKHQH[WVDPSOHLVS!!



E  $5/
S 



3 =    3 =  



3 =    3 =  

3   =  


7KHSUREDELOLW\WKDWWKLVVKLIWZLOOEHGHWHFWHGRQWKHQH[WVDPSOHLVS!!



E  $5/
S 



 P!
   ;  P 
  
3




V!




   ;  P   


3





V!


5
V
 V ! !

G
Q
3   ;  

D  V





%!

%"

%#

"

&

'()"# $ % &

!!"# $ % &

#&

!" !"#$ %#&'(!

#$

&8680&KDUWIRUSXULW\

"$

"&

'()"# $ % &

!!"# $ % &

D V!
E

# !"

!"

"

'()"# $ % &

!!"# $ % &

#$

)#' !"#$ %#&'(!



("

!"#$%!& '!(")$

'

!"!# $%&' ()& *+%,-'-&

7KHSURFHVVDSSHDUVWREHLQVWDWLVWLFDOFRQWURO

%!

%"

%#

"

'"

# !$%&"

!$%&"

"$

7KH&8680FRQWUROFKDUWIRUSXULW\GRHVQRWLQGLFDWHDQRXWRIFRQWUROVLWXDWLRQ7KH6 YDOXHVGRQRWSORW
EH\RQGWKHYDOXHVRI+DQG+
E
&8680&KDUWIRUSXULW\DG

6HFWLRQ

!"!#$%&'( )!"

!"!#$%&'( )!"

!"!#$%&'( )!"



%!

%"!

%#!

%$!

$!

#!

"!

'()"# $ % &

!!"# $ % &

PP
V

%!

D ZLWKWDUJHW!DQGDVKLIWWRLVDVKLIWRI

  
!VWDQGDUGGHYLDWLRQV)URP7DEOH

$5/!7KHKRXUVRISURGXFWLRQDUH  !
E 7KH$5/!+RZHYHUWKHWLPHWRREWDLQVDPSOHVLVQRZ  !
F )URP7DEOHWKH$5/ZKHQWKHUHLVQRVKLIWLV&RQVHTXHQWO\WKHWLPHEHWZHHQIDOVHDODUPVLV
  !KRXUV
PP
  
VWDQGDUGGHYLDWLRQ)URP7DEOHWKH
G ,IWKHSURFHVVVKLIWVWRWKHVKLIWLV
V Q
 
$5/IRUWKLVVKLIWLV7KHUHIRUHWKHWLPHWRGHWHFWWKHVKLIWLV  !KRXUV$OWKRXJKWKLV
WLPHLVVOLJKWO\ORQJHUWKDQWKHUHVXOWLQSDUW E WKHWLPHEHWZHHQIDOVHDODUPVLV  !KRXUV
ZKLFKLVEHWWHUWKDQWKHUHVXOWLQSDUW F 

D $VKLIWWRLVDVKLIWRI

  
!VWDQGDUGGHYLDWLRQV)URP7DEOH$5/!

PP
  
!VWDQGDUGGHYLDWLRQ)URP7DEOH$5/!
E ,IQ!WKHVKLIWWRLVDVKLIWRI
V Q
 


RI$5/!

E :LWKWKHWDUJHW!DQGDVKLIWWRLVDVKLIWRI

#!

  
!V)URPZLWKK!DQGWKHURZ


"./0&).1 2.,/-&

$!

&8680&KDUWIRUFRQFHQWU

7KHSURFHVVDSSHDUVWREHLQVWDWLVWLFDOFRQWURO



!"#$ #%& '#%() ! *%+,+#- .,/&0


!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
!"#$
1 '#%()
!!!!!
1 !!!!!
2345 6
789 :+(;# < =>89?@?
1 2345 6
789 :+(;# < 989>A7BCD
3)%,)$-+%)
< =>
1 3)%,)$-+%)
< 989?C=>
4345 !
789 :+(;# < =78B@D
1 4345 !
789 :+(;# < 9
1
E/, EF -+;+,: < 9
1 E/, EF -+;+,: < 9
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
3G#$,5 HE,G
IE$;#-+J)5 IE
K:,+;#,)&
L$EM):: ;)#% < =>
L$EM):: :+(;# < 989?9>?B>
;)#% '#%()
< 989?C=>

6XSSOHPHQWDU\([HUFLVHV







! !"#$%&' (!




























VXEJURXS



3UREOHP









     
PLQ


   
PLQ>@














H ,QRUGHUWRPDNHWKLVSURFHVVDVL[VLJPDSURFHVVWKHYDULDQFHV ZRXOGKDYHWREHGHFUHDVHGVXFKWKDW
[  /6/
 IRUV
3&5!!7KHYDOXHRIWKHYDULDQFHLVIRXQGE\VROYLQJ3&5!!
V
  

V
V 

V

V 
7KHUHIRUHWKHSURFHVVYDULDQFHZRXOGKDYHWREHGHFUHDVHGWRV !  !



F  3&5

86/  /6/   



V
 
7KHSURFHVVGRHVQRWPHHWWKHPLQLPXPFDSDELOLW\OHYHORI3&5t
G
86/  [ [  /6/
3&5
PLQ


V
V

7KHSURFHVVLVLQFRQWURO
5
V
E  P [ 
G

5DQJH

;EDU

;




3   =  
3 =    3 =  
  

'

'(')

'('*

. '(+,

'(+-

'(,

'(,)

#$
!"#$%!&

"

.$%"/01 +23),

#%

'('+-+44+

'(++

'(,'4*-5

!"#$% & '()%)#* +%,-.


!"#$%
&&&&&
!"# $
%&' ()*+, - '&.'%/01
!234256)32
- '&77
"!"# 8
%&' ()*+, - '&'707%%7
9:4 9; 6)+)4( - '
<(4)+,42=
+2,3 > - '&77
()*+,
- '&'%7./?



!"#$% & '()%)#* +%,-.


+#/0*1 +)213 ( 4 566
!"#$%
&&&&&
7!89 :
;<6 =)>/# 4 6<?@A;@B
!1(%1$*)(1
4 6<??
8!89 &
;<6 =)>/# 4 6<6B;A5A?
C,% CD *)/)%= 4 ?
E=%)/#%1/1#(
4 6<??
=)>/#
4 6<655?5BA

7KHUHDUHQRSRLQWVEH\RQGWKHFRQWUROOLPLWV7KHSURFHVVLVLQFRQWURO
E


7KHSUREDELOLW\WKDWWKLVVKLIWZLOOEHGHWHFWHGRQWKHQH[WVDPSOHLVS!!


 $5/

S 



   ;  P   


3



V!



3   ;  

I  V ! !

"

#$

&'()*+',

#%

- !.%$%#

-##

-#<%.<!

"

#$

&'()*+',

#%

:;:*:?+>?

:;':<='<

:;'>'>:*



7KHUHDUHQRSRLQWVEH\RQGWKHFRQWUROOLPLWV7KHSURFHVVLVQRZLQFRQWURO
F $ODUJHUVDPSOHVL]HZLWKWKHVDPHQXPEHURIGHIHFWLYHLWHPVZLOOUHVXOWLQPRUHQDUURZFRQWUROOLPLWV
7KHFRQWUROOLPLWVFRUUHVSRQGLQJWRWKHODUJHUVDPSOHVL]HDUHPRUHVHQVLWLYH

- .

- %

1 - /

-#$

-#0

-#"

!"#$%& '()*+# ,%-./%0 1.&.2/


34&5$% 3.6%7 89+::

!"#$% & '()*+(, -*.*%+


/#.01( /*2(3 4 5 677
!"#$%
&&&&&
8!-9 :
;<7 +*=.# 5 7<>?>?7@
!(4%($1*4(
5 7<>7A;>A
-!-9 &
;<7 +*=.# 5 7<7@7B6?B
CD% CE 1*.*%+ 5 7
F+%*.#%(,
.(#4
5 7<>7A;>A
+*=.#
5 7<76>?BA

7KHUHLVRQHSRLQWEH\RQGWKHXSSHUFRQWUROOLPLW7KHSURFHVVLVRXWRIFRQWURO
7KHUHYLVHGOLPLWVDUH

- .

- %

1 - /

-#$

-#0

-#"

1*+(234 #05!$(
674,23 6893 : ; $

Você também pode gostar