Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
by
Jeremy J. Beaudry
2002
Meaning Building:
by
Thesis
in Partial Fulfillment
of the Requirements
December 2002
Meaning Building:
APPROVED BY
SUPERVISING COMMITTEE:
_____________________________
Michael Benedikt
_____________________________
Stephen L. Ross
To Mom, Dad, and Meredith for unwavering support
Nothing touches a work of art so little as words of criticism:
they always result in more or less fortunate
misunderstandings. Things aren’t all so tangible and sayable
as people would usually have us believe; most experiences are
unsayable, they happen in a space that no word has ever
entered, and more unsayable than all other things are works
of art, those mysterious existences, whose life endures beside
our own small, transitory life.
architecture means, this work begins with my story because I am the subject
of this thesis and because, as such, I am mostly responsible for the meaning I
“find” in the world; that is, the meaning I make of it. That is meaning
building, which is really what this thesis is written of. (Notice I did not write
“written about.”)
everyday, and, as such, I could not see it. The walls around me and the roofs
over my head were invisible. In fact, that which I experienced and perceived
was life spilling over the edges of architecture: inside to sleep and eat,
my father standing in the doorway, my mother walking down the hall. The
vi
Later, there was a time when architecture happened to me and I
Where did it come from? It was familiar yet vague; it was the place I had
never been but revisited everyday for the past year. Some ancient loggia in
Italy—in Cinque Terre, by the sea? or in Rome, on the bank of the Tiber?
(The previous year, I had lived in Rome and studied art and art history.) I
became obsessed with the image. I made paintings about it, returning to it,
exploring it (at this time I was working in a dingy studio in the midst of a
With the passing of a few years, architecture and its memory has
Teatro del Mondo built for the 1980 Venice Biennale—and it’s like that image
World floating on a barge around the canals of Venice, and how can it be
that I remember it? Of course, I knew I had never seen it before, never
vii
stepped foot inside this tiny little theater. But it still meant so much to me,
and I knew it
Fig. 1. Aldro Rossi, Il Teatro del Mondo, Venice, 1979. Reprinted from
Gianni Braghieri, Aldo Rossi: Works and Projects, 3rd Ed. (Barcelona 1997), 118.
was a place that I would always miss. (A while later, I returned to Italy and
drifting by—rocking gently in front of San Giorgio, docked at the Piazza San
Marco, mimicking the old customs house near the Giudecca.) Rossi writes in
viii
A Scientific Autobiography: “In order to be significant, architecture must be
autobiographies converge.
cautionary epigram—that there is much about a work of art, much about the
verbal dimension in this project by including elements that are visual (my
paintings and drawings, for example) and that are analogically related to the
focus of this thesis. Do not always look for answers in what can be patently
“said.”
is difficult to give each of them the credit they deserve. That said, I am
seminar in the fall of 2001, many challenging and fruitful discussions with
ix
Communication, who provided many insightful comments during the early
stages of my work.
x
+ table of contents
preface | vi
+ active memory | 45
bibliography | 101
vita | 107
xi
An Architecture of Memory (1st Room)
1
+ introduction: meaning building as thesis
together to mean more than the sum of those individual components.1 Bound
space where the richness of memory and the progressive practice of making
circumvents the reductive and the taxonomical, and retreats from definitive
statements; it desires to be of its subject rather than about it. By seeking out
this analogical system, this approach also points to the character of the
1
I am indebted to Steve Ross for my understanding of the concept of “more-
than-ness”, which is very similar to holistic thought, although “more than”
that, too. For his treatment of this concept, see Ross (1990 and 1999).
2
design throughout his entire oeuvre, it is so because in that diligence he sees
practice, though, the larger scope of this inquiry concerns what I call meaning
Meaning. Building.
Meaning building.
Building meaning.
together to form the identity of social groups. Memory is also the thread
which links the lived-in now with the past and the future: what I remember
of my past contributes to who I am now (at this very moment) and in many
2
I am grateful to Andrew Kramer, who is partly responsible for the genesis
of the phrase “meaning building”.
3
I believe that Aldo Rossi, whether stated explicitly or not, ultimately
took this claim to task out of the necessity to temper his early polemics about
work is a deeply felt reverence for the power of memory, both his own as
verging a nostalgia, at the very least. For Rossi, the process of memory
matter of necessity, the repetitive, obsessive, and dynamic nature of his own
creative practice.
time and to history. In terms of the former, a building will inevitably age—
word only to describe surface qualities) as the physical object registers the
indexical marks of its use over time—the scratches and blemishes, coats of
and activities which occur there and transform construct a narrative about its
4
history, which may be manifest through style or type. Each and every
building will always visibly express its relationship to time in this way just
the semantic fullness of the word context. Not only does context denote “the
circumstances that form the setting for an event, statement, or idea, and in
histories, and a building will always display a portion of its history to us.
3
Concise Oxford Dictionary, 10th ed., s.v. “context.”
5
equilibrium or frequency of resonance in time. (Bloomer
1987:30)
possible type and quality of building, and to some degree we will feel
boundary between the “container” and the “contained” dissipates, when the
6
An Architecture of Memory (4th Room)
7
+ working definition of an analogical system
aνa- : the usage of the prefix ana- denotes “up, back, again,
intensification”
speaking is, perhaps, not the ideal gerund here; the action is more of a
pointing to, a gesturing towards in which the analogy is suggested rather than
4
Pocket Oxford Greek Dictionary, revised ed., s.v. “aνa-” and “-λογος.”
8
described: “Analogical thought is archaic, unexpressed, and practically
images and sounds, words and ideas, objects and textures. The great
understanding.
postmodern eras, claiming that the turn of the twentieth century gave rise to
ideas”—analogical thinking
9
is not reductive, or at least not reductive once and for all.
Instead, it presents momentary or emergent insights by noting
similarities, rather than identities, that suggest trajectories to
pursue rather than resting places to inhabit. […] Analogies do
not present or assert positive entities, invariants, essences.
Instead, they offer insight and frameworks of understanding
born of relationships that can always be apprehended as
provisional, the source of beginning rather than ending.
(2000:24)
10
An Architecture of Memory (13th Room)
11
+ middles: territories of meaning
intersection of the individual parts of the analogy, that zone created by the
occurs in both plan and section. As a site, the zone of meaning in the
analogical system is often ambiguous, never a statement of “once and for all”
and freedom, room for “play.” Yet, also as a site, this area has boundaries,
12
Fig. 2. Superimposition and superposition in an analogical system.
Paintings and digital manipulation by the author.
13
or, rather, a set (largely unquantifiable) of all available meanings, which is
interpretations.
meaning arises from the rich interaction of vectors, inflections, and frames (see
the words of Focillon, any “construction of space and matter” (1948:2). While
never autonomous from its substantive “skin”: “The rigid parts of the frame
still retain a certain geometry, but their articulation is mobile and their
equilibrium results from the play of tensions that run through the system as
directional thrust, a selection made at a given instant. For Cache, the vector
even more entrenched (and technical) in the concept of inflection, that image
14
Fig. 3. Points of inflection.
there are the “extrema”—the maximum and minimum points which are
points
and minimum points as those images which are most readily perceptible in
the world: the peaks of mountain tops, the edges of lakes, the most popular
movie, the worst team in the league, “the best possible images.”5
Conversely, inflection
5
By image, Cache means “anything that presents itself to the mind” (1995:3).
His sense of this term is greatly influenced by the writing of Henri Bergson,
especially Matter and Memory (1911).
15
is the mark of images that can’t be the best, and that are thus
outside the world and its inclines, though they are a part of it.
Take any surface. Generally, we describe its relief in terms of
summits and crests, basins and valleys. But if we can manage
to erase our coordinate axes, then we will only see inflections,
or other intrinsic singularities that describe the surface
precisely. They are the sign that the best possible are not
given, and that the best are not even called forth. (1995:36)
or an anticipation” (1995:17).
16
An Architecture of Memory (49th Room)
17
+ tacit knowing and material practice
The “middles” which arise in the analogical system become the site
“once and for all”) in a moment of ineffable clarity; and this moment of grace
the image discloses about the patient. The x-rays and their identifying
18
deliberately and rationally contemplating its sign (1981:138-141; see Shiff
terms: the proximal and the distal—where the proximal is the totality of the
particulars in the tacit relation and the distal is the comprehensive meaning
Borrowed from the field of anatomy, the terms are appropriate considering
in terms of the world to which we are attending from our body” (1966:16)—
incorporating the particulars into our body via proximity and extension, that
19
Polanyi accepts the theory of gestalt as a particular model of tacit
meaningless until they are attended to at a certain distance, being the distal
this conception of tacit knowing may become clearer. The tacit relation
consists of the marks on the x-rays (proximal) and the meaning of the marks
never able to articulate the proximal, over time come to associate (attend
recognize that tacit knowing is the fundamental power of the mind, which
creates explicit knowing, lends meaning to it and controls its use” (1969:156).
generated via tacit knowing. In Vision and Painting, Norman Bryson uses the
historical analysis (1983). Reaching far back into the annals of time, his
investigation begins with Pliny’s account of Zeuxis and his rival painters,
one of whom is so skilled in the art of trompe l’oeil that he in fact deceives
the great Zeuxis, who mistakes a painted image of a curtain for the real
20
representation in the western world—a “natural attitude” which has as its
32). Bryson tells us that this attitude within the field of art history has
historical relativism; that is, the “Essential Copy” is still the desirable aim
philosophy of science, Gombrich posits that the painter during any given
depicts his world. Therefore, the challenge to the artist is to test these
called) still arrives at the same intellectual impasse: the “doctrine of mimesis”
the rigidity and social isolation of formalism with the assertion of the
practice encompasses not only the work of the painter, but also the work of
21
the viewer: both are involved in tacit operations, “improvisations-within-
22
An Architecture of Memory (21st Room)
23
+ selected buildings by Aldo Rossi
24
Fig. 4. Top: Aldo Rossi, Monument and town square, Segrate, 1965. Photo
by the author.
25
Fig. 6 & 7. Aldo Rossi, Gallaratese housing block, Milan, 1969-70. Top: Photo
by the author. Bottom: Reprinted from Aldo Rossi, Aldo Rossi: The Life and
Works of An Architect, 49.
26
Fig. 8 & 9. Aldo Rossi, San Cataldo cemetery, Modena, 1971-78. Photos by
the author.
27
Fig. 10 & 11. Aldo Rossi, San Cataldo cemetery, Modena, 1971-78. Photos by
the author.
28
Fig. 12 & 13. Aldo Rossi, Fontivegge commercial district, Perugia, 1982.
Photos by the author.
29
Fig. 14. Top: Aldo Rossi, Town hall, Borgoricco, 1983. Reprinted from Aldo
Rossi, Aldo Rossi: Architect, 119.
30
Fig. 15. Bottom: Aldo Rossi, New building for the Bonnefantenmuseum,
Maastricht, 1990. Reprinted from Aldo Rossi, Aldo Rossi: The Life and Works
of An Architect, 273.
31
Fig. 16. Top: Aldo Rossi, Contemporary art center, Vassivière, 1988.
Reprinted from Aldo Rossi, Aldo Rossi: Architect, 148.
Fig. 17. Bottom: Aldo Rossi, Teatro del Mondo, Venice, 1979. Reprinted
from Aldo Rossi: The Life and Works of An Architect, 88.
32
An Architecture of Memory (22nd Room)
33
+ from The Architecture of the City to A Scientific Autobiography
career which provide opportunities to mark and assess his creative and
practiced writer (says Rossi: “My education was basically a literary one…”
[Rossi 1994:15]), Rossi set forth his theories in several published articles,
Perhaps more relevant to this project, though, these writings reveal Rossi’s
changing attitude towards his thesis and its expression in his creative
practice.
architectural design and urban design based upon a rigorous study of the
history of the Western city (Berlin and Rome are prime examples) which is
34
geography, urban ecology, and collective psychology.6 As an impressive
scholarly work, The Architecture of the City clinically catalogues and codifies
and typology in architecture, thus laying the groundwork for a thesis which
will inform all of his subsequent creative work. The “precise meaning” of
architecture, and they are not dependent upon—that is, not causally related
to—a specific, fixed function. In this way, Rossi repeatedly refers to the
6
Rafael Moneo’s early article on Rossi, which appeared in Oppositions and
was probably America’s first introduction to Rossi’s work, begins with an
excellent and concise analysis of The Architecture of the City (1976).
35
a new typology of architecture, one which Anthony Vidler has identified as
the “third” typology in an essay from 1977 (1978).7 This “third” typology
posits the city itself as the foundation of architectural types in defiance of the
primitive hut: primitive man, seeking shelter, “discovers” the form of the
rustic hut in the trunks of trees (columns), the boughs (lintels), and the
on its own history apart from the history of Nature. In this way, architecture
7
See also Vidler’s article “The Idea of Type: The Transformation of the
Academic Ideal, 1750-1830” (1977) for lengthier history of type and
architectural theory.
36
At the end of the 19th century, as the onslaught of the final decades of
the Industrial Revolution prepared the way for the mass production of
describes this kind of causal relationship between social conditions and the
37
Rossi seems to have cultivated his interest in “research in
architecture” through his study of Etienne Boullée (a study which led him to
translate Boullée’s Architecture, essai sur l’art into Italian and write an
include Boullée in that history), placing Rossi as one of the architects at the
historical periods, and Colquhoun speculates that this ambiguity may have
prompted Rossi to ally himself with the term (1975:365). Either way, the
rationalism of the young Italian architects of the mid-1960s with whom Rossi
(Colquhoun 1989:84).
38
made objects simply because the experience of the city is bound by
urban artifacts, each with its own individual locus within the city, each a
third typology) come together with the permanence of type to stress the
continuity of the city through time, the link between the past and the
…it is an event and a form. Thus the union between the past
and the future exists in the very idea of the city that it flows
through in the same way that memory flows through the life
of a person; and always, in order to be realized, this idea must
not only shape but be shaped by reality. (1982:32, 131)
the evolution, constructions, and destructions of the city do depend upon the
decisions made by those in power, the people who use the city do much to
39
influence this largely unwritten history. The city as collective memory “does
not tell its past, but contains it like the lines of a hand, written in the corners
of the streets, the gratings of the windows, the banisters of the steps, the
antennae of the lightning rods, the poles of the flags, every segment marked
form of the city—the residential areas (the quartier), primary elements and
monuments, the persistence of the plan through time. The belief is that this
whole comprised of many fragments and will inform the design of new
structures for the city (and Rossi claims that this process is applicable to
With this very laborious and elliptical text, Rossi emulates the role of
Colquhoun has exposed as part and parcel of the paradoxical doctrine of the
40
functionalism and “a mystical belief in the intuitional process” of design
discern the emotional essence of his interests in architecture and the city:
At that time, I was not yet thirty years old, and as I have said,
I wanted to write a definitive work: it seemed to me that
everything, once clarified, could be defined. I believed that
the Renaissance treatise had to become an apparatus which
could be translated into objects. I scorned memories, and at
the same time, I made use of urban impressions: behind
feelings I searched for the fixed laws of a timeless typology. I
saw courts and galleries, the elements of urban morphology,
distributed in the city with the purity of mineralogy. I read
books on urban geography, topography, and history, like a
general who wishes to know every possible battlefield—the
high grounds, the passages, the woods. I walked the cities of
Europe to understand their plans and classify them according
to types. Like a lover sustained by my egotism, I often
ignored the secret feelings I had for those cities; it was enough
to know the system that governed them. Perhaps I simply
wanted to free myself of the city. Actually, I was discovering
my own architecture. (Rossi 1981:15-16)
This passage from the first pages of A Scientific Autobiography explains his
obstinacy in the early text, but its tone also exemplifies the timbre of Rossi’s
creative work as it reached maturation in the years after publishing that 1966
41
“treatise”. Now, it is the poetic, rather than—as the title of the
Architecture of the City, with all of its complicated subordinate concepts, but
handful of specific places and things from his native north Italy: the statue of
Il Carlone, the chapels of the Sacri Monti, Filarete’s column in Venice, the
anatomical theater in Parma. Yet, in spite of, and because of, this insistent
going, and this momentum propels Rossi forward into the future through a
42
…Rossi repeats a scheme that he has already experimented
with, displaying his work as the result of the final screening of
the progressive depositing of “residues” of different types just
as, in Rossi’s special cultural world, the city is the form of a
whole made up of parts, of differences, and above all of a
sedimentation of the forms and types that endure the attrition
of history. (Dal Co 1979:69).
Autobiography. For Rossi and his colleagues of the 1960s, the resurgent
interest in architectural types provided a way to mend the rupture with the
past for which the modernists had been responsible. If modernists stripped
the question: “As every city carries within it the landscape and architectural
43
this kind of “memory image”, Rossi allows his conception of typology to
search for those meaningful moments in his life leads him to exchange a
8
Quatremère de Quincy’s definition of type, as quoted by Rossi: “The word
‘type’ represents not so much the image of a thing to be copied or perfectly
imitated as the idea of an element that must itself serve as a rule for the
model… The model, understood in terms of the practical execution of art, is
44
memorable architectural forms is the foundation of Aldo Rossi’s modus
A Scientific Autobiography.
an object that must repeated such as it is; type, on the contrary, is an object
according to which once can conceive works that do not resemble one
another at all. Everything is precise and given in the model; everything is
more or less vague in the type. Thus we see that the limitation of types
involves nothing that feelings or spirit cannot recognize…” (Rossi 1982:40).
45
An Architecture of Memory (40th Room)
46
+ active memory
corpus would reveal (like the historiography of any field) dominant and
(see Brewer 1995). In the face of such a large quantity of research and
this project: namely, the role of memory in the work and process of Aldo
that the mind employs “generic knowledge structures that guide the
knowledge, and “unconscious” in that they are deeply embedded into our
9
I owe my introduction to this particular body of research on memory to
Remembrance and the Design of Place by Francis Downey (2000).
47
forefather of contemporary schema theory as published in Remembering
which held that memory is episodic, such that specific, actual “traces” of past
experience our stored directly for later recall. For Bartlett, memory is a
dynamic process:
Brewer and Nakamura (1984:125-6) find that Bartlett actually proposed two
memory today.
48
Attention Schemas influence what objects and events are encoded
information at the instance of input, such that the memory will contain
upon the type of schema and the time interval between input and
recall.
relevant information.
scenario: a trip to a baseball game. Having been both a player and spectator
games. Each baseball game I have attended is integrated into this baseball
includes information like the structure and rules of the game, the sensual
qualities of the baseball field and stadium, the various activities and rituals
49
of the spectators and players, etc. There are also a number of sub-schema,
such as the experience of eating a ballpark hotdog and using the stadium’s
baseball game many of the so-called episodic details of that experience may
were too incompatible (and also, too insignificant) with my “baseball game”
is integrated.
that our memories are not only our own but are true, which may be in part
due to the high level of detail of the imagery that accompanies our memories
leading to harmful false memories (see Belli and Loftus 1995), some
discrepancy between what really occurred and what I believe to have occurred is
50
individual memories, and thus work together to build each individual’s
The implications of this are that alienation from a group may lead to
pathological. We may also wonder if, at any point, the memory of the group
personal and organic relationship between memory and the sense of self.
Especially in our own time, we are inundated by the Image, that hyperactive
(1968:238). Are we then faced with “a memory crisis of too many images,
Boyer also tells us, in The City of Collective Memory, that the other
10
Not everyone admits this “crisis of memory.” Marita Sturken, for example,
claims that cultural memory in the modern and postmodern eras, rather than
be lamented as corrupted or pathological, must be understood as a
“changeable script” which abandons wholeness in favor of “cultural
reenactment” as means to emotional and psychological healing (1997:19).
51
urge to break with convention, with received notions of the way things are.
Benjamin perceived a similar dilemma in his own time, noting that narrative
themselves which might enable the spectator “to think through dream
of ourselves and personal identity (in effect, constituting our personal lore,
effulgent mass of visual culture and the equally bright and complex strata of
52
inevitability of temperament necessarily establishes a
harmony among the most disparate elements. However
incoherent a given existence may be, its human unity is not
upset. All the echoes of memory, if one could awaken them
simultaneously, would form a concert—pleasant or painful,
but logical and without dissonance. (Quoted in Boyer
1994:479)
to the visual world—that is, our desire to scrutinize the vast field of images
the mind, yet this montage refers directly (we hope) to our uniqueness as
53
An Architecture of Memory (25th Room)
54
+ selected drawings by Aldo Rossi
55
Fig. 18 & 19. Top: Aldo Rossi, Architecture, 1972. Reprinted from Vittorio
Savi, L’architectura di Aldo Rossi (Milan, 1985), 87. Bottom: Aldo Rossi, Urban
Composition with Monument, 1973. Reprinted from Aldo Rossi, Aldo Rossi:
Projects and drawings 1962-1979 (New York, 1979), 154.
56
Fig. 20-23. Top left: Aldo Rossi, Study for a Monument to the Resistance, 1970.
Reprinted from Vittorio Savi, L’architectura di Aldo Rossi, 49. Top right: Aldo
Rossi, The Hand of the Saint, 1976. Reprinted from Vittorio Savi, L’architectura
di Aldo Rossi, 88. Bottom left: Aldo Rossi, Composition with S. Carlo – cities and
monuments, 1970. Reprinted from Aldo Rossi, Aldo Rossi: Drawings and
Paintings, 95. Bottom right: Aldo Rossi, Composition with Bridge, 1970.
Reprinted from Aldo Rossi, Aldo Rossi: Projects and drawings 1962-1979, 15.
57
Fig. 24-27. Top left: Aldo Rossi, Untitled, 1981. Top right: Aldo Rossi,
Untitled, 1993. Bottom left: Aldo Rossi, Untitled (Casa Bay), 1975. Bottom
right: Aldo Rossi, Gauloises caporal, 1971. All reprinted from Aldo Rossi, Aldo
Rossi: Drawings and Paintings, 105, 8, 119, 106.
58
Fig. 28-30. Top left: Aldo Rossi, L’architecture assassinée, 1974. Top right:
Aldo Rossi, Il Teatro del Mondo, 1987. Bottom: Aldo Rossi, Dieses ist lange her
– ora é questo perduto, 1975. All reprinted from Aldo Rossi, Aldo Rossi:
Drawings and Paintings, 64, 150, 171.
59
Fig. 31-33. Top right: Aldo Rossi, The Hand of the Saint, 1973. Top left: Aldo
Rossi, Architettura razionale e immagini celesti, 1974. Bottom: Aldo Rossi,
Untitled, 1984. All reprinted from Aldo Rossi, Aldo Rossi: Drawings and
Paintings, 90, 93, 40.
60
An Architecture of Memory (6th Room)
61
+ Aldo Rossi and meaning building
engaging a way of thinking about his work which is “not reductive” but
understanding his meaning are of the subject rather than about it. As early as
his introduction to the second Italian edition of The Architecture of the City,
Rossi had begun to articulate the idea of the “analogous city”, an analogy in
his writings and projects were infused more with the narrative of his
62
process: through the activity of remembering and repetition he filtered a
his buildings in such a way that it would invigorate architecture with a new
buildings he had discovered and cited in The Architecture of the City: the
square in Lucca, the tiny fishing huts along the Po River valley—buildings
strict sense that is no mere figure of speech. The body of the symbol changes
slowly, but its meaning inevitably grows, incorporates new elements and
throws off old ones...[A] symbol, once in being, spreads among the peoples.
1986:192).
Meaning building.
Meaning building.
63
Building meaning.
and then object transgresses its own boundaries back into the realm of
action…
he anticipated people would live with and within his buildings, seeing in
emergence of relations among things, more than the things themselves, always gives
rise to new meanings” (Rossi 1981:19; emphasis mine). Perhaps, like this:
Confront the built form—it reminds you of other buildings and other experiences
you have had before—this new building feels familiar and established in your
different, it’s meaning has changed from what you thought it should be because of
the change in how you use the architecture—“the given” is expanded, enriched with
64
whose form and position are already fixed, but whose meanings may be
minimal buildings, does not really predicate any specific aesthetic quality
is ambiguous (silent) about its relationship with that type or its attitude
towards the history of that type is to enter into a strange architectural world
familiarity with something already seen and recognized, and the alienating
This semantic ambiguity in his buildings has been the source of both
positive and negative criticism. On the one hand there are his admirers, who
65
And they are willing to suspend the associations of his buildings with Fascist
Responding to Rossi’s projects for the Modena cemetery and the Gallaratese
Architektur steht sprachlos und kalt [My architecture stands mute and
walls stand/mute and cold, in the wind/the banners creak.” And this
an essential feature of analogical thinking where the world lies just beyond
11
See pp. 18-22.
66
Indeed, “tacit” comes from the Latin tacitus, meaning “silence.” In the
silence (tacitus) of Rossi’s forms and buildings, meaning and knowledge are
Michael Polanyi and Harry Prosch write that “all knowing is action…
[it is] participation through indwelling” (1975:42, 44; emphasis mine). Tacit
knowing depends upon our ability to focus our attention away from the
these subsidiary parts working as a whole (see also Ross 1990 and 1999). For
canvas. In such a picture, if we move too close to the painting and focus on
the particulars (the dots) which form the image, that image—its joint
meanings upon the inhabitants so that the experience becomes not about the
declaration “Here is Architecture” but one where the user, taking full
and meanings within the space according to how it is engaged and used—in
not inconsequential, but it can never be the focus of attention. For Rossi, this
67
that the inhabitants supply their own words and warmth and life to the
acquired from his own experience of the tacit operations of the connotational
compelled to interpret the sign “as material work, practice of painting and of
architecture back from the brink of total abstraction by his careful insistence
on the power of memory to connect him, his writings, his drawings, his
68
The latent structure upon which all of these analogical associations hinges is
dome. In each design, however, these generic elements are instantiated with
69
relationships fostered by the correspondences of unexpected typological
elements (see Rossi 1976:74; 1981:19, 35), and therefore become episodic
which situates the inhabitants within the context of a larger cultural and
deformation and evolution of the schema. Schema depend upon “an active
present moment when we remember. For Rossi, the inventive nature of this
70
advanced on his journey, because the traveler's past changes
according to the route he has followed: not the immediate
past, that is, to which each day that goes by adds a day, but
the more remote past. Arriving at each new city, the traveler
finds again a past of his that he did not know he had: the
foreignness of what you no longer are or no longer possess
lies in wait for you in foreign, unpossessed places. (Calvino
1974:29)
mute and cold” (generic), yet drawings and paintings which stand
drawing as a material practice allows Rossi’s heart and hand to give itself
transformed into an active engagement with the past which can lead him to
touches the present and infuses its wisdom onto the world of experience”
degenerative nostalgia.
71
An Architecture of Memory (33rd Room)
72
+ drawing on architecture drawing on memory drawing on meaning
drawing practice. Frequently exhibited, this graphic work, too, has been the
process.12 And, of course, Rossi’s own writing about his drawings assists in
this mystification: “…I made the same drawings over and over, searching for
the web of connections in the life of man” (1981:66). That Rossi was such a
artistic life, which can be considered as distinct or separate from his life as an
all of his creative media (Huet 1994:15). Yet the relationship between his
12
e.g. Peter Eisenman’s introduction to the American edition of The
Architecture of the City (1982:3-11).
73
architecture and drawings and paintings (and writings) is not as simple as
of creativity equal to all others. The drawings are both of these things, but
system, each of the analogues “retain their individual intensity while being
nor are they writing. They possess formal properties specific to the medium
other.
74
buildings and sites, nor are they architectural project drawings—sections,
example, compare Figs. 4 and 7 with 18 and 19 and Figs. 8 and 17 with 20-
23). (Of course, due to the practical nature of the profession of architecture,
Rossi and his studio did produce both technical and presentation drawings
when dealing with clients and the actual construction of buildings.) Not
striving for any kind of pictorial realism, they are not illusions of three-
drawing (or the model), the same poetic act that has always magically
revealed the truth of reality: a process similar to the gnostic search for truth
are the raw materials of Rossi’s prolific drawing practice. And these
75
materials are generally handled with an adeptness whose variable pace
any particular sitting (e.g. Fig. 20 and 28). At times, images are carefully
cohesive solidity by his attentive use of color and light and shadow,
therefore just surpassing the level of “sketch” (e.g. Fig. 21). Collage elements
there may a studied level of detail imparted to the objects within the
composition (e.g. Fig. 33). More often than not, though, the drawings are
laid down to suggest light and shadow or merely to rescue some object from
the corpus of Rossi’s drawings according to both their chronology and their
76
this kind of organization by virtue of Rossi’s persistent repetition of a
says as much:
The immediacy with which Rossi constructs his drawings—making do, like
the bricoleur, with whatever material, whatever images he has on hand (see
Lévi-Strauss 1966 and Koetter and Rowe 1996:279-86 for more on the practice
signifies (his line roams the page, like someone in a dark room who must
feel his way through it) consume this catalogue of observations, memories,
sometimes surprised and attentive when new elements appear. The coffee
pots, the small cabins, the smokestacks and the monumental cubes from the
throughout the body of work. As a process and a record of that process, the
special quality of the drawings is that maybe they are never brought to a
77
point of completion but are always provisional, always capable of being
continued. So, in fact, Rossi does make the same drawing over and over
which depicts two buildings and one unbuilt project by Palladio set
Rossi the idea of the “analogous city”, a compositional model in which “the
coffeepots, soda cans, phonebooks, and cigarette packs, objects which clearly
cube, cone (e.g. Fig. 24-27). His drawings of these kinds of items obviously
78
reference the long tradition of still life painting in the history of art,
79
Fig. 34. Capriccio, Goivanni Antonio Canaletto, 1753-59. Reprinted from
Aldo Rossi, The Architecture of the City, 166.
are to understand these forms. Are the coffeepot and the phonebook
Venice, these drawings invite us into the space of memory and imagination
80
images which suggest a reality unto themselves that is analogous to a so-
light and punctuated by long shadows. Eugene J. Johnson has noted that a
monumental cityscapes, was held in Milan in 1970 and they surely had an
landscapes and modeling them with a wintry light and deep, dark shadows
(e.g. Fig. 21 and 27). De Chirico, too, made the same kind of painting again
and again, and part of these images’ infectious power lies in their
dramatically in that stark light and reproduced several times over in that
moment like the memory of some exceptionally haunting and beautiful time
(Harries 1982:65-6). Rossi draws (on) the memory of this moment repeatedly
Rossi also claims an affinity with the work of Mario Sironi and Giorgio
14
81
I have always known that architecture was determined by the
hour and the event; and it was this hour that I sought in vain,
confusing it with nostalgia, the countryside, summer: it was
an hour of suspension, the mythic cinco del la tarde of Seville,
but also the hour of the railroad timetable, of the end of the
lesson, of dawn. (1981:80)
82
An Architecture of Memory (60th Room)
83
+ epilogue: l’architecture des ombres
account in his Natural History, written in the first century AD. Even at that
time, though, the story was already ancient, part fable, part history.15 The
story is easily told: the daughter of Butades, a potter from Corinth, traces the
outline of the shadow of her lover on the wall as he sleeps the night before
he departs to fight in a war. Thus, the simple act of inscribing the projected
the desire to wrench from time that which is transient and fleeting—the
lover gone to war—by fixing its shadow in time and place and, by visual
synecdoche, fixing the thing itself. In essence, the image of the lover is an
image borne of the negative, of the absence of light, where the only
contiguous presence uniting the real and its image is the outline, the border
To mark the shadow of her lover is also to mark the shadow of the
15
I first discovered this story and its depiction in western painting in a
contemporary art theory seminar taught by Richard Shiff. See also A Short of
History of the Shadow by Victor I. Stoichita (1997) for more on the significance
of shadows in the history of western art.
84
Fig. 35. L’architecture des ombres (First Iteration). Drawing by the author.
wall gives her cause to remember him, but the image must be completed by
the young woman in her imagination in order to fully express the vital
presence of her absent lover; the outline must be filled in with all the
when, after news of the lover’s death in battle, Butades fills in the outlines of
the image with clay, thus modeling in relief an effigy of the departed (and
so, says Pliny, inventing the plastic art of sculpture). However, in this act of
85
memorial perhaps the father has gone too far, has passed into the world of
reified realism where the portrait of death takes precedence over the shadow
In Pliny’s myth the act of painting transforms the negative into the
imperative which binds the figure to its shadow and which suggests the
Aldo Rossi, of course, is one such devotee, and the poetic of “the architecture
and inspiration in this passage from Boullée’s Essai, which he quotes in his
86
a special application to architecture... (Quoted in Rossi
1989:46)
effect that night as she contemplated her lover and his shadow cast upon the
earthen wall by the light of a flame. Can we empathize with the prick of
pain she might have felt at his looming departure and the urge to stave off
87
the agony of that separation by doing something, by lovingly capturing that
daughter, he marks the outline of the shadow of the past in order to arrest it
space between memory and imagination, between the event and the
memory of the event, between the object and its shadow. It depends upon
shadows, and that that image may suggest an historical continuity, a link
between the irretrievable past, the fleeting present, and the unrealized
88
architectural codes in order to anticipate and accommodate future events, he
89
An Architecture of Memory (61st Room)
90
+ appendix A: consequential data
drawings, and prints that I have made over the course of my research and
writing for this text. Recall from the preface that my architectural odyssey
work continues that project with hopefully more complexity and more
well as those which appear at the beginning and end of each of the previous
sections) represent the body of work I have made “in response” to many of
memory and the practice and process of painting and drawing and
my visual thinking on that subject. For me, they are an essential contribution
91
An Architecture of Memory (11th Room)
1 of a series of 70
lino-cut print, acrylic on paper
4 x 4 ½”
92
There Is No Place
acrylic, latex on canvas
40 x 50”
93
Whitewashing
acrylic, latex, oil on canvas
40 x 50”
94
Chunk
acrylic, enamel on canvas
21 x 24”
95
Chez L’eau
acrylic on canvas
21 x 24”
96
Ur-urban
acrylic, enamel on canvas
24 x 21”
97
L’architecture des Ombres (2nd iteration)
lino-cut prints on cut paper, pins,
acrylic, vellum, thread
60 x 52”
98
L’architecture des Ombres (2nd iteration)
details
99
+ appendix B: excerpts from A Scientific Autobiography
100
Likewise in my projects, repetition, collage, the displacement
of an element from one design to another, always places me
before another potential project which I would like to do but
which is also a memory of some other thing.
Because of this, cities, even if they last for centuries, are in
reality great encampments of the living and the dead where a
few elements remain like signals, symbols, warnings. When
the holiday is over, the elements of architecture are in tatters,
and the sand again devours the street. There is nothing left to
do but resume, with persistence, the reconstruction of
elements and instruments in expectation of another holiday.
(20)
It turns our that this idea of the interior, like the green of the
garden, is stronger than the building itself. You can already
read the project in existing houses, select it from a repertory
which you can easily procure, pursue it in the variants of its
production, in the actor’s cues, in the atmosphere of the
theater, and always be surprised by Hamlet’s uncertainties,
never knowing whether he is truly a good prince, as
everything conspires to make us believe.
Perhaps a design is merely the space where the analogies in
their identification with things once again arrive at silence.
The relationships are a circle that is never closed; only a fool
would think of adding the missing part or changing the
meaning of the circle. Not in purism but in the unlimited
101
contamination of things, of correspondences, does silence
return. The drawing can be suggestive, for as it limits it also
amplifies memory, objects, events. (35)
102
experiencing something after desire is dead; for this reason I
have always loved unbuilt projects… (57)
103
We could speak of every project as if it were an unfinished
love affair: it is most beautiful before it ends.
And for every authentic artist this means the desire to
remake, not in order to effect some change (which is the mark
of superficial people) but out of a strange profundity of
feelings for things, in order to see what action develops in the
same context, or how, conversely, the context makes slight
alterations in the action. (78)
104
displacements, or assimilated into new projects, new places,
and new techniques—other forms of which we always catch a
glimpse of life. (84)
105
+ bibliography
106
Bryson, Norman. Vision and Painting. New Haven: Yale University Press,
1983.
________. “Now This Is Lost: The Theater of the World by Aldo Rossi at the
Venice Biennale.” Lotus International 25 (1979): 66-74.
107
Deleuze, Gilles. The Fold: Leibniz and the Baroque. Translated by Tom Conley.
Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 1993.
Harries, Karsten. “Building and the Terror of Time.” Perspecta: The Yale
Architectural Journal 19 (1982): 58-69.
Koetter, Fred and Colin Rowe. “Collage City.” In Theorizing a New Agenda
for Architecture, ed. Kate Nesbitt, 268-93. New York: Princeton
Architectural Press, 1996.
108
Lévi-Strauss, Claude. The Savage Mind. Chicago: The University of Chicago
Press, 1966.
Moneo, Rafael. “Aldo Rossi: The Idea of Architecture and the Modena
Cemetery.” Oppositions 5 (1976): 1-30.
109
________. “Introduction to Architecture, essai sur l'art." Translated by Diane
Ghirardo and Feruccio Trabalzi. UCLA Architecture Journal 2 (1989):
40-49.
________. Aldo Rossi: Drawings and Paintings. Edited by Morris Adjmi and
Giovanni Bertolotto. New York: Princeton Architectural Press, 1993.
________. Aldo Rossi: The Life and Work of an Architect. Edited by Alberto
Ferlenga. Cologne: Konemann, 2001.
Shiff, Richard. Afterword to Critical Terms for Art History. Edited by Robert
S. Nelson and Richard Shiff. Chicago: The University of Chicago
Press, 1996.
110
Stoichita, Victor I. A Short History of the Shadow. London: Reaktion Books,
1997.
Vogt, Adolf Max. Review of The Architecture of the City and A Scientific
Autobiography, by Aldo Rossi. Journal of the Society of
Architectural Historians, 42, no. 1 (1983): 86-8.
111
+ vita
Born the only son of John and Barbara Beaudry in 1974 in Cedar Rapids,
hog-tied in Texas. From 1990-93 he studied art with the esteemed Claude J.
Falcone at Penncrest High School, and later received a BFA in painting from
the Tyler School of Art in 1997. The next three years outside of academia
Permanent address:
Media, PA 19063
112