American Roots of the Indian Independence Movement - NYTimes.

com

http://india.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/08/14/american-roots-of-the-indian-i...

Log In Register Now Home Page Today's Paper Video Most Popular Times Topics Search All NYTimes.com Thursday, August 16, 2012

India
World U.S. N.Y. / Region Business Technology Science Health Sports Opinion Arts Style Travel Jobs Real Estate Autos Africa Americas Asia Pacific Europe Middle East

Advertise on NYTimes.com

1 of 18

8/16/2012 8:54 AM

American Roots of the Indian Independence Movement - NYTimes.com

http://india.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/08/14/american-roots-of-the-indian-i...

August 14, 2012, 8:58 am12 Comments

American Roots of the Indian Independence Movement

By NARESH FERNANDES

Courtesy of S.P. SinghBhagwan Singh Gyanee, extreme right, who was the president of the Gadar Party from 1914 to 1920, delivering a lecture in the United States in the 1930s. In June 1916, an Indian living in California wrote a letter to The New York Times emphasizing how profoundly Indians in the United States had been influenced by the political values of their adoptive country. Residence in the U.S. has not made [Indians]who returned home imbued with revolutionary ideas but it has made them republicans. He added, The whole country has been stirred by their vision of a United States of India. The writer of the letter was Ram Chandra, the editor of Hindustan Gadar, the newspaper of the San Francisco-based Gadar Party. The party took its name from the Urdu word for mutiny or revolt. (The word is sometimes transliterated as Ghadar.) In its inaugural issue in November 1913, the newspaper had stated the partys intentions clearly: To bring about a risingbecause the people can no longer bear the oppression and tyranny practiced under English rule.

2 of 18

8/16/2012 8:54 AM

American Roots of the Indian Independence Movement - NYTimes.com

http://india.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/08/14/american-roots-of-the-indian-i...

Most of the members of the Gadar Party were Punjabi, though their sympathizers were drawn from across India. Many of them had served in the British army or police services in places like Hong Kong and Shanghai and had moved to the United States to work as farm laborers or on building the railroads. A few were students at U.S. universities. As India celebrates the 65th anniversary of its independence from Britain, the role of the Gadar Party and other Indians in the United States in helping the cause is garnering increased attention. Some of the new work is the result of African-American scholars examining the influence of the Indian struggle for freedom on the U.S. civil rights movement. Long before Martin Luther King began to study Gandhis works, African-American groups had established links with visiting Indian freedom fighters. Among them was Lala Lajpat Rai, who spent five years starting in 1915 as a political exile in the United States. He counted W.E.B. Du Bois among his friends, and also met with Booker T. Washington. Other research into the subject represents the growing Indian-American communitys attempt to prove that its history in the United States is longer and more nuanced than is commonly known. These include a recent book by the historian Maia Ramnath, Haj to Utopia: How the Ghadar Movement Charted Global Radicalism and Attempted to Overthrow the British Empire. Another initiative in this direction is the South Asian American Digital Archive, which was founded in Philadelphia in 2008 to document and provide access to the diverse and relatively unknown stories of South Asian Americans. Its collections chronicle a wide range of community experiences, and include several documents and photographs that throw light on the links between Indian-Americans and the Indian independence struggle. Historians will undoubtedly debate the legacy of the Gadar Partys contributions to the overall freedom struggle for years to come, said Samip Mallick, 31, the archives executive director, in an e-mail interview with India Ink. But, symbolically, it is a really unique, extraordinary and inspiring story. The story of the Gadar Party is the story of a new immigrant population advocating for their own political enfranchisement, both through their support for decolonization around the world as well as through their fight for civil rights in their new home country. Here are excerpts from that interview: Q. How did the Gadar Party influence Indias freedom struggle? A. The Hindustan Gadar Party started off as a San Francisco-based anti-colonial political organization, which advocated the complete independence of India from British rule. The specifics of its founding are slightly murky, but its clear that in 1913, a group of activists based on the Pacific Coast, including Har Dayal and Sohan Singh Bhakna, were organizing migrant laborers (most of whom were Punjabi Sikhs) and helped found what would later be known as the Gadar Party, its aim being the overthrow of British colonial rule of India through revolutionary means. The Gadar

3 of 18

8/16/2012 8:54 AM

American Roots of the Indian Independence Movement - NYTimes.com

http://india.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/08/14/american-roots-of-the-indian-i...

Party published a newspaper titled Gadr in Urdu, followed by a Gurmukhi editions and apparently Gujarati editions. Copies of the newspaper as well as the partys pamphlets were disseminated throughout the world, including Japan, China, Hong Kong, Burma and the Philippines, and eventually Gadar bases sprung up in those areas, as well. Gadar leaders also often wrote of the mistreatment of Indian immigrants in the U.S., which tells us that this was more than simply a nationalist organization.

Courtesy of South Asian American Digital ArchivesThe Dec. 1923 issue of the United States of India, a Gadar Party publication. The Gadar Party received considerable support from the German Foreign Office, which arranged funds and armaments in a plot to incite a pan-Indian revolution (later known as the Annie Larsen affair) in 1915. The conspiracy was discovered by British and American intelligence, and led to the Hindu-German Conspiracy Trial of 1917, in which 29 party members were convicted in the District Court in San Francisco. The Gadar Party continued to exist after the trial, and in 1920 began to publish the Independent Hindustan, a journal containing editorials, essays and news items relating to the global movement for Indian independence. In 1923, the party began to publish The United States of India, for several years. The full runs of these publications are available online through our Web site. Q. Which other organizations in the U.S. supported Indian independence? A. Alongside the Gadar Party was the India Home Rule League based in New York, founded by Lala Lajpat Rai, which advocated home rule for India. The I.H.R.L. produced a monthly journal from 1918 onward titled Young India. When Lajpat Rai left the U.S. in 1919, the editorship duties were handed off to Jabez T. Sunderland, a Unitarian minister who was a close associate of Rai and a longtime advocate for Indian independence. Another critical organization was Friends of Freedom for India, which was closely associated with the Gadar Party and led by Agnes Smedley and Sailendranath Ghose. Their mission, according to its own membership ads, was to maintain the right of asylum for political refugees from India and to present the case for the independence of

4 of 18

8/16/2012 8:54 AM

American Roots of the Indian Independence Movement - NYTimes.com

http://india.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/08/14/american-roots-of-the-indian-i...

India.

Courtesy of South Asian American Digital ArchivesRabindranath Tagore, left, and Sudhindra Bose at the University of Iowa in United States. Incidentally, all three groups the Gadar Party, the I.H.R.L., and the F.F.I. enjoyed support from Irish nationalists, and published articles from Irish/Irish-American supporters. Other supporters of Indian freedom who traveled and lectured in the U.S. include Rabindranath Tagore, Kamaladevi Chattopadhyay, Ram Manohar Lohia and Vijaya Lakshmi Pandit. Q. What was the U.S. governments position on the Indian freedom struggle? A. This is a pretty complex question, but it seems that before WWI, the U.S. government took a formal position of neutrality whenever possible, even while maintaining surveillance on the activities of Indians in the U.S. who advocated for independence. A few key American political figures like William Jennings Bryan, a member of the Anti-Imperialist league, wrote against British rule in India (Bryans 1906 essay British Rule in India was actually reprinted and circulated by the Gadar Party), but this wasnt official state policy by any means. During WWI, the U.S. worked with British authorities to crack down the activity of Indian revolutionaries in the U.S., on the grounds that the Gadar radicals relationship with the German government was a violation of the neutrality laws. This resulted in the Hindu-German Conspiracy case of 1917.

5 of 18

8/16/2012 8:54 AM

American Roots of the Indian Independence Movement - NYTimes.com

http://india.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/08/14/american-roots-of-the-indian-i...

Courtesy of South Asian American Digital ArchivesThe first issue of Young India published in Jan. 1918 by the India Home Rule League based in New York. Advocates for Indias freedom made much of President Woodrow Wilsons Fourteen Points speech during WWI, which called for a free, open-minded, and impartial adjustment of all colonial claims, seeing this as a step forward towards decolonization and publishing praise for the president in Young India and various Gadar pamphlets. But even while most knew Wilson didnt have India at the forefront of his mind when making such a claim, as historian Erez Manela puts it in The Wilsonian Moment, Wilsons claim became part of their rhetorical arsenal for independence. Q. What explains the recent spurt of books about the links between Indians in the U.S. and the freedom movement? A. Part of the reason is that connections are being drawn between Asian-American Studies and what has traditionally been known as area studies. Also, transnational or diaspora studies, once seen as a footnote, has given us new focal points for examining the history of the freedom movement in India. The frame for analysis isnt so nationally bound anymore. However, while it is true that there are a number of new academic works on the Gadar Party and transnational involvement in the freedom struggle, there has been ongoing interest for many years in keeping these histories alive, beginning with even those who were themselves involved in the freedom struggle and worried that the tremendous sacrifices they made fighting for Indias independence would be forgotten and lost to history. In 1953, writing from Mexico City, former Gadar Party member Pandurang Khankoje wrote to Bhagwan Singh Gyanee, asking the past leader for information to keep the story of Gadar alive. People in India are anxious to know about you all, Khankhoje said. We are getting old and the history of our movement should not get lost. In the U.S. there have been a number of individuals, including T.S. Sibia, Jane Singh, Ved Prakash

6 of 18

8/16/2012 8:54 AM

American Roots of the Indian Independence Movement - NYTimes.com

http://india.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/08/14/american-roots-of-the-indian-i...

Vatuk, Irene Joshi, and others who have independently researched and worked to raise awareness about these important histories. There have also been organizations formed such as the Hindustan Gadar Party Memorial Committee to draw public attention to and publicly commemorate these histories. One of their major efforts was for the dedication of the building at 5 Wood Street in San Francisco as Gadar Memorial Hall, which is now owned and operated by the Indian Consular Office. What is unique now, from the perspective of our work, is the opportunity provided by the digital medium to unify and provide universal access to dispersed archival materials in a way that was completely unimaginable even five or 10 years ago. Q. How did the South Asian American Digital Archive go about collecting its materials? A. Materials in the archive come to us generally in two ways. First are the materials that are held by individuals in their private collections. These are materials that have been collected over the years related to an individuals family history or their own lives. Materials such as these would often stay in the basement or attic where they are kept and the important stories contained within these materials would not be widely shared. We work closely with such individuals to provide digital access to photographs, letters, journals and other such objects through our website while the original copies remain with their current owner. Second are materials in institutions or archival repositories around the country. Few materials related to South Asian Americans are included in existing archives. For the vast majority of repositories, materials related to our community fall outside the scope of their collecting efforts. The materials that are available in archives are spread widely in collections across the country, making it difficult even for individual researchers to find the materials they need for their work and especially difficult for members of the community to access them. We have collaborated with a number of institutions to provide digital access to materials in their collections that are relevant to South Asian American history, but that may have otherwise been overlooked. An example of such a collaboration is with the University of Pennsylvania Rare Book and Manuscript Library, which has a series of correspondence between Har Dayal, one of the leaders of the Gadar Party, and his close friend Van Wyck Brooks as part of their collection of Brookss papers. Collaboration with the University of Pennsylvania allowed us to provide digital access to these letters and allow users anywhere in the world to read Har Dayals words in his own hand for the very first time. Naresh Fernandes is a freelance journalist who lives in Mumbai. He is a Poiesis fellow at New York Universitys Institute for Public Knowledge. He is the author of Taj Mahal Foxtrot: The Story of Bombays Jazz Age. Facebook Twitter

7 of 18

8/16/2012 8:54 AM

American Roots of the Indian Independence Movement - NYTimes.com

http://india.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/08/14/american-roots-of-the-indian-i...

Google+ E-mail Share Print Previous Post From Nalli Nihari to Malpua, Mumbai Offers Hearty Ramadan Fare Next Post Image of the Day: August 14

12 Comments
Share your thoughts. All Reader Picks Newest Write a Comment

1. Adam S. USA Flag Before 1957 there was no Pakistan and Bangladesh. It was only India. So, Independence was for India. America inspired Indian leaders who sought freedom from Britain for obvious reasons. Their Constitution was also inspired by the American Constitution. Speaking of "hegemony" (a favorite among Chinese of teh 1970s and sicne then of Pakistanis), it was Islamic hegemony from aroungd AD 1000 that the inhabitants suffered under until the arrival of the British. You might think of the British rule as a period of India from virtual servitude under the foreign Islamic rulers to Independence. Aug. 15, 2012 at 1:17 p.m. Share this on Facebook Share this on Twitter

2. Mindy Contractor NY Flag

8 of 18

8/16/2012 8:54 AM

American Roots of the Indian Independence Movement - NYTimes.com

http://india.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/08/14/american-roots-of-the-indian-i...

Excellent article. Thank you. Aug. 15, 2012 at 1:15 p.m. Share this on Facebook Share this on Twitter

3. Vijayendra Kumar Washington DC Flag A very informative article. I was delighted to read it and was a new learning for me. This is a very good example of good journalism in India Ink. Aug. 15, 2012 at 1:14 p.m. Share this on Facebook Share this on Twitter

4. cdeuskar@gmail.com Cambridge, MA Flag To be fair, the equivalent of Indian independence from British Rule is not American independence from British Rule. The exact analogy would have been if the Native Americans had forced European settlers out of North America and set up their own democracy, or, alternatively, if Europeans had settled in India in large numbers, decimated the native population, and then formed their own nation on Indian soil. Aug. 15, 2012 at 1:14 p.m. Share this on Facebook Share this on Twitter

1. Mitra Brisbane Flag Very good point!

9 of 18

8/16/2012 8:54 AM

American Roots of the Indian Independence Movement - NYTimes.com

http://india.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/08/14/american-roots-of-the-indian-i...

Aug. 16, 2012 at 12:39 a.m. Share this on Facebook Share this on Twitter

5. Jacqueline Ruiz Cleveland, Ohio Flag I am delighted to read about SAADA and the importance of preserving primary documents from the South Asian community. SAADA is currently undergoing their first phase of raising funds to continue this type of work. Please visit their website and make your contribution today. If we do not support this type of work we will have no one to blame but ourselves when stories go untold. - Founder of the Asian Indian Heritage Project in NE Ohio Aug. 14, 2012 at 11:29 p.m. Share this on Facebook Share this on Twitter

6. rss California Flag This is the America I remember growing up in Africa. Aug. 14, 2012 at 10:42 p.m. Recommended2 Share this on Facebook Share this on Twitter

7. Zahid Zaman New York, NY Flag Fascinating read on the anniversary of South Asian independence from British colonialism. I

10 of 18

8/16/2012 8:54 AM

American Roots of the Indian Independence Movement - NYTimes.com

http://india.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/08/14/american-roots-of-the-indian-i...

had no idea South Asian republicanism was so inspired by the American variety! I do wish that the author had chosen more inclusive adjectives i.e. South Asia instead of India to describe the independence movements since the other South Asian countries were not just seeking reprieve from foreign colonialism but Indian hegemony as well. Aug. 14, 2012 at 10:42 p.m. Share this on Facebook Share this on Twitter Read All 4 Replies

1. NA Boston, MA Flag "...wish that the author had chosen more inclusive adjectives." How about "the Indian subcontinent?" "...describe the independence movements since the other South Asian countries" Like which ones exactly? Pakistan's. Until the early 30s, Jinnah was a staunch supporter of at least Indian self rule if not outright independence. And in case you didn't notice, the publications were called Young India and United States of India. "Indian hegemony?" Our neighbors really do suffer from a strange, untreatable strain of inferiority complex. Aug. 14, 2012 at 11:29 p.m. Recommended5 Share this on Facebook Share this on Twitter

2. Sad non-resident alien New York, NY Flag There were intellectual roots, too. Mahatma Gandhi got the idea of civil disobedience from an 1849 essay titled "Civil Disobedience", by American Transcendentalist writer Henry David Thoreau. The text of that beautiful essay is easily available online, if you are interested.

11 of 18

8/16/2012 8:54 AM

American Roots of the Indian Independence Movement - NYTimes.com

http://india.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/08/14/american-roots-of-the-indian-i...

Also, the influence completed full circle with the American Civil Rights movement, with Martin Luther King, Jr. being influenced by Gandhi's ideas. In the photo of his famous "I have a dream" speech, you may have noticed MLK's supporters standing behind him wearing Indian-style "Congress caps". And then again, the Indian Dalit Panther movement was inspired in part by the AfricanAmerican Black Panther movement. More recently, while many Indians rejoiced at Obama's 2008 presidential election victory, Dalit groups cheered especially loudly. It is sad that people often equate the American idea of freedom with that country's military misadventures. While we respond to them with the criticism and resistance they deserve, we should not forget to cherish American intellectual and cultural influences that inspire freedom in millions around the world. Instead of going to malls, Indian tourists in the US should visit Harper's Ferry. Aug. 15, 2012 at 1:18 p.m. Recommended1 Share this on Facebook Share this on Twitter

3. SM India Flag LOL.. Quite predictable response. Its actually not your fault but the people who built your country. I hope it gets better for your next generation, I really do. Aug. 15, 2012 at 11:26 p.m. Share this on Facebook Share this on Twitter Read More Comments
Ads by Google what's this?

IIM-C announces 1 Yr Prog

in Business Analytics for 3+ yrs Working Professionals. Apply Now!

program.niitimperia.com

12 of 18

8/16/2012 8:54 AM

American Roots of the Indian Independence Movement - NYTimes.com

http://india.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/08/14/american-roots-of-the-indian-i...

Search This Blog

Previous Post From Nalli Nihari to Malpua, Mumbai Offers Hearty Ramadan Fare Next Post Image of the Day: August 14
Follow This Blog

Twitter RSS Latest News of India

Letter from India: Floundering Foes Help Indian Lawmakers Exhibition Review: Indian Art Exhibition Makes a Rare Stop in China The Female Factor: In India, the Tender Trap's a Vise India Bus Plunge Kills Many

Times Topics | India

Advertise on NYTimes.com

India Ink on Twitter

HARI KUMAR

Absconding Gopal Kanda shame on Delhi police and Haryana Govt. about 16 hours ago

VIKAS BAJAJ

Correcting link: Indian art, which is rarely seen in China, makes it way to Beijing via London and Rome: http://t.co/S5TiqPdv about 17 hours ago

13 of 18

8/16/2012 8:54 AM

American Roots of the Indian Independence Movement - NYTimes.com

http://india.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/08/14/american-roots-of-the-indian-i...

VIKAS BAJAJ

Grandmas Grow Gold in Swaziland, great piece by @lpolgreen http://t.co/q7X1VVGO about 19 hours ago
VIKAS BAJAJ

Indian art, which is rarely seen in China, makes it way to Beijing via London and Rome: http://t.co

Special Series

Ruth Fremson/The New York Times

From the rise of a new private sectorand the billionaires that sustain and exploit itto the beginning of a vast national identity database, articles in this series examine the messy and maddening road to progress in India. Previous Articles in the Series About India Ink This report on India from the journalists of The New York Times and a pool of talented writers in India and beyond provides unbiased, authoritative reporting on the country and its place in the world. India Ink also strives to be a virtual meeting point for discussion of this complex, fast-changing democracy its politics, economy, culture and everyday life. More about the blog E-mail the editors Our writers Follow us on Twitter Archive

Recent Posts August 14 1

14 of 18

8/16/2012 8:54 AM

American Roots of the Indian Independence Movement - NYTimes.com

http://india.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/08/14/american-roots-of-the-indian-i...

The Making of the Indian National Flag

The tricolor flag, made from hand-spun and handwoven cotton, is produced by a small manufacturing unit in the southern Indian state of Karnataka. August 14 3
Science Minister Vilasrao Deshmukh Dies at 67

Mr. Deshmukh died of multiple organ failure in Chennai on Tuesday. August 14

Image of the Day: August 14

Boxer Mary Kom received a warm welcome on her return home. August 14 12
American Roots of the Indian Independence Movement

Gadar Party was among the several U.S.-based groups that mobilized support for Indians fighting the British back home. August 14
From Nalli Nihari to Malpua, Mumbai Offers Hearty Ramadan Fare

Some of the nondescript eateries cook up the best Ramadan dishes. Global Business News
The NBC Sports Network Gets an Olympics Assist

August 16, 2012, 3:11 am

Ecuador to Let Julian Assange Stay in Its London Embassy

August 16, 2012, 3:08 am

Germany Reopens Investigation of Facebooks Photo Archiving

August 16, 2012, 3:08 am

15 of 18

8/16/2012 8:54 AM

American Roots of the Indian Independence Movement - NYTimes.com

http://india.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/08/14/american-roots-of-the-indian-i...

Australian Court Strikes Down Tobacco Challenge

August 16, 2012, 3:07 am

British Employment Defies Weak Economy

August 16, 2012, 3:07 am Read all Global Business News NYTimes Opinion Friedman Krugman Kristof Cohen
Average Is Over, Part II

Whats preventing Americans from taking our education challenge seriously?

Get It Right on Gas

We can have a natural gas revolution that transforms our whole country or one that just transforms the electric grid. Whats it going to be?
Why Not in Vegas?

Mitt Romneys visit to Israel shows just how much of a wedge issue the Republican Party has made of Israel.
Debt, Depression, DeMarco

Most of the blame for our persistently depressed economy lies with the scorched-earth opposition of Republicans.
Crash of the Bumblebee

What would policy makers have to do to save the euro and will they do it?
Money for Nothing

Why do the markets love government debt? The answer might tell us something important about the nature of our economic troubles.

16 of 18

8/16/2012 8:54 AM

American Roots of the Indian Independence Movement - NYTimes.com

http://india.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/08/14/american-roots-of-the-indian-i...

War Wounds

This veteran wishes he had lost a limb. Instead, he has to watch himself lose his mind.
Obama AWOL in Syria

Why is Obama passive as thousands of Syrians are dying? Top strategists want him to act now.
Blissfully Lost in the Woods

Heres a little advice for the overburdened and overconnected: take a hike.
Saving Private Romney

Romney's choice of Ryan has the merit of opening a serious debate about the debt undermining America.
Britains Olympics Whiplash

From the land of gloom to the land of glee with Bolt-like speed.
Dream, Baby, Dream!

Mitt Romney piles on the foreign policy foolishness, and manages to miss the Mideasts great cultural shift.
TicketWatch: Theater Offers by E-Mail

The other running mates

ALSO IN OPINION

Where should Mark Bittman go? What should be eliminated from the Olympics?

Ads by Google

what's this?

17 of 18

8/16/2012 8:54 AM

American Roots of the Indian Independence Movement - NYTimes.com

http://india.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/08/14/american-roots-of-the-indian-i...

Class 1 to Class 12
Free NCERT Solutions, Test Papers, Lessons, Animations, Videos, Puzzle

www.MeritNation.com

Home World U.S. N.Y. / Region Business Technology Science Health Sports Opinion Arts Style Travel Jobs Real Estate Autos Site Map 2012 The New York Times Company Privacy Your Ad Choices Terms of Service Terms of Sale Corrections RSS Help Contact Us Work for Us Advertise

18 of 18

8/16/2012 8:54 AM