Emory1 5

Case 1:09-cv-01186-HTW Document 1-5 Filed 05/04/09 Page 1 of 57
Green be g
rig
[
i .+l
Page
Invoice No .
11
2148457
File No .
1 02091 .010100
exhibits and testimony clips for hearing ;

review plaintiffs counsel's requests regarding
hearing testimony and rulings ; emails with
arbitrator and plaintiffs counsel regarding
hearing details
04/23/08
GB Creation of Trial director deposition database

to create clips that will be imported into
Power Point
2.60 hrs 200 .00 520.00
o41z3/os
DAB Review internet postings for references to

Murtagh; review of charts for perjury and
withheld documents to verify all appropriate
documents referenced are included as
exhibits in binders for use at the hearing on
our motion for sanctions
7.00 hrs
04/23/08 TDW Review and revise outline for hearing

argument ; review and revise summaries of
185 .00
1,295 .00
3.60 his 354,00
1,260 .00
9.00 hrs
185 .00
1,665 .00
11.60 hrs
260 .00
3,016 .00
perjury, withheld documents, and spoliated

evidence; select additional exhibits for
hearing use
L_J
04/24/08
DAB
04/24/08
LCE Finalize withheld documents, spoliation, and

perjury exhibits for production to C . Culotta
and arbitrator pursuant to arbitrator's April
21, 2008 order ; review invoices for attorney
fee petition ; review and revise T . Wozniak
affidavit in support of attorney fees; revise
letter to C. Culotta regarding exhibits and
testimony; exchange enroll correspondence
with C . Culotta regarding witness testimony
Conference with L. Edelmann and T .

Wozniak regarding -upcoming hearing on
motion for sanctions; review, analyze and
prepare attorney fee petition ; prepare exhibits
for use at hearing, including spoliation
exhibits and withheld exhibits
rnw:zz
Tax II} : 13-3613083
Greenberg Traurig . LLP I Attorneys at Law `The Forum 13290 hforlhside Parkway I Suite 400 1 Allanta, Georgia 30327
Tel 678.553 .2100 1 Fax678 .553 .2212 wwwgtiaw.com
Original Invoices (1i-18-O8~ APO-462
~:
Greenberg
Tra
Page
. 12
Invoice No . . 2148457
File No .
102091A10 100
and exhibit exchange ; review arbitrator's
decision regarding testimony via telephone ;
confer with T. Wozniak regarding potential
objections to same ; confeTence with B . Lane
regarding scope of attorney fees award ;
revise and finalize proposed order granting
Emory's sanction motion
04124/08 BTL Research Georgia case law to determine 3 .60 hrs 260.00
basis for seeking attorneys` fees for
expenditures beginning during investigation
stage of case in preparation for submitting
exhibits on fees incurred
04/24/08 BEM Pull exhibits for witness, deposition, perjury, 7 .5 0 firs
and hearing notebooks ; review Murtagh
production and index for notebooks
~ .. .
x4124108
TDW Meeting with D, Burger and L. Ede3mann

regarding finalizing exhibits for sanctions
hearing; emails with plaintiffs counsel and
arbitrator regarding witness testimony ;
telephone conference with B . Morrison
regarding same ; review fee petition filed
with court ; review and redact invoices postdating original fee petition ; review and revise
affidavit to accompany fee request; finalize
hearing exhibits and demonstrative evidence
04/25/08 DAB Preparation of exhibit binders for use at

hearing on motion for sanctions ; receive and
review plaintiffs exhibits; analyze deposition
testimony cited by plaintiff for use in
upcoming sanctions hearing
150.00 1,125 .00
7.60 hrs 350.00 2,660 .00
10 .60 hrs
04/25/08 LCE Continue preparing for hearing on sanctions 12 .30 hrs

motion ; exchange correspondence with C .
Culotta regarding untimely delivery of
Murtagh exhibits; review Murtagh exhibit
0 .-
936 .00
185.00
1,961 .00
260.00 3,198 .00
TDW:i,z
Tax ID : 13-3613083
Greenberg Tra uri g, LLP I Attorneys at Law I The Forum 13290 Nor thside Parkway I Suite 40 6 1 Atlanta, Georgia 30327
Tel
wY+w.gnaw. com
E P O- 463
ee b
Traurig
-~ [
T.ri
Page 13
2148457
Invoice No .
File No . 102091 .010100
list and witness list ; conduct preliminary
review of categories of documents and
exhibits produced by Murtagh for hearing;
strategy conference with D . Burger, B .
Moskowitz and T . Wozniak regarding action
items and Murtagh's production ; conference
call with B . Morrison regarding same
04/25!08 BEM Review and index Murtaghs exhibits for
sanctions hearing ; research Murtagh's
witnesses and create relevant witness binders
?.50 hrs
15 0.00
1,125 .00
04125/08 DLS Preparation and duplication of exhibit CDs

for upcoming hearing on motion for
sanctions
0.70 hrs
1 85 .00
129 . 50
04/25/08 TDW Review Dr . Murtagh`s witness and exhibit

lists, deposition transcript designations, and
related portions of "new evxdentiarV"
materials submitted by Dr . Murtagh;
telephone conference with T . Bichelberger
regarding sanctions hearing and Grady's
position/presentation; telephone conference
with B . Morrison regarding proposed plan
for addressing Dr. Murtagh's submission ;
ernails with plaintiffs counsel regarding
plaintiffs exhibits lists not matching exhibits
7.80 hrs
35 0 .00 2,730,00
A4/26f08 LCE Review hundreds of documents identified as

"near evidence" by Murtagh ; continue
preparing for hearing on sanctions motion ;
continue drafting oral argument outline for
sanctions hearing
8.50 hrs
260 .00
2,210 .00
O4I26/08 TDW Review Dr . Murtagh's exhibits; review

research regarding Dr. Murtagh's witnesses
2.80 his 350 .00
980.00
04/27/08 TOW Revise outline of arguments for hearing ;

review potential rebuttal exhibits ; outline
6.20 his 350 . 00
2,170 .00
Tvw:r z
TaxID : 1 3-3 6 13083
Greenberg Traurig, L.LP { Attorneys at Law I The Forum 13290 Northside Parkway I Suite 400 I Atlanta, Georgia 30327
Tel 675.553 .21 00 1 Fax 678 .553 .12 1 vmwgtlaw.com
Original Invoices (11-18-08) EPQ-464
G eb rg
Traurig
! r
'#rr
Page 14
Invoice No . 2148457
File No.
102091,010100
potential rebuttal issues
04/28/08
GB
Creation of additional clip to be used during 1 .20 hrs 200.00 240 .00
arbitration
04128108 DAB Review of internet postings ; review of

Murtagh's deposition testimony designations
and creation of summary re same ; strategy
meeting with T . Wozniak and L . Edelmann;
assist with final preparations for hearing on
motion for sanctions
14.50 hrs 185 .00 2,682 .50
04/28/08
14 .40 hrs
260 .00
3,744 .00
04/28I08 GF Research whether under Georgia law a court 3 .30 hrs

cann assess attorneys fees and costs against
funds owed under the settlement agreement
action for use in motion for sanctions
290 .00
957 .00
04128108 BTL Draft bench brief regarding authority for

sanctions; update research regarding same
10.30 hrs 260.00
2,678.40
04/28/08
BEM Index all Murtagh's deposition exhibits ;

create relevant notebooks for hearing ;
prepare exhibits for attorney hearing binder
1 0.00 hrs
p4/28108
TDW
LCE Preparation of cross-examination materials

for Murtagh's 30 potential witnesses ;
continue reviewing Dr . 1Vlurtagli's proposed
exhibits, including six pro se motions and
exhibits ; revise outline for oral argument ;
strategy conference with T . Woaniaic, D .
Burger and B .Maskowitz
Telephone conference with K . Alexander

regarding rebuttal arguments for sanctions
hearing; review K . Alexander's email
comments regarding same; review and
respond to Dr. Murtagh's objections to
Emory's exhibits; prepare for cross-exam, of
Murtagh's witnesses
150.00 1 ,500.00
5 .60 hrs 350 .00
1 ,960 .00
TDW :LZ
Tax TD: 13-363083
Greenberg Traurig , LLP I Attorneys at Law I The Forum 13290 Narthside Parkway I Suite 400 1 Atl anta , Georgia 30327
Tel 678 . 5RJt%4 J&I www' gtla+n +- corn
EPO - 465
reen
40 Trung
Page
Invoice No.
File No.
~L J
15
2148457
102091 .010100
04/29/08
DAB Complete summary of deposition

designations by Murtagh ; research regarding
Murtagh'S proposed witnesses; assist in
preparation ofcross-examination exhibits;
meeting regarding final preparations for
motions for sanctions hearing ; final
preparation of exhibits for hearing
14.1 0 bZs
185 .00
2,608 .50
04/29/08
LCE Final preparation for hearing on Emory's

motion for sanctions; strategy conference
with T . Wozniak ; exchange correspondence
with C . Culotta regarding k McNaugbton's
participation in hearing on behalf of Dr .
Murtagh; prepare for rebuttal presentation
15 .20 hrs
260 .00
3,952 .00
04/29/08 '
BTL Revise Emory's bench brief on authority for

sanctions ; research supporting authority for
aU relief requested in motion for sanctions
260 .0
2,2 10.00
04/29/08 BEM Prepare for sanctions hearing ; strategy 10 .00 hrs

conference with D . Burger; create index for
multiple binder; pull exhibits to Murtagh's
witnesses ; prepare all notebooks and
equipment to go to sanctions hearing
150.00
1,500.00
04/29/08
DLS
185 .00
740 .00
b4129148
R'I' Prepare index and witness exhibits in

preparation for upcoming hearing
4.20 hrs
04/29108
TDW Final sanctions hearing preparation ;

regarding same; review research regarding
plaintiff s newest lawyer, A . IvlcNaughtan;
emails with plaintiffs counsel regarding
witnesses testifying by telephone ; review
research for cross-examination ; outline likely
9.30 hrs 350.00 3,255 .0
8 .50 hrs
Research regarding Murtagh potential 4 .00 hrs

hearing witnesses
185 .00 777.00
TDW :LZ
Tax ID : 13-3613083
Greenberg 7raurig , LLP } Attorneys at Law I The Forum 13290 Northside Parkway I Suite 4 00 I Atlan ta , Georgi a 30327
Tel 67&55d
;
www
.
ngi nal nvoi c~ese (1 ~- i &08 )`
-~~ ~m
EPO- 466
Greenberg
Page 16
Invoice No, 2148457
Fide No .
102091 .010100
cross-examination topics for each witness ;
review and select exhibits for potential
witness cross-exam
0413010$ GB Set up of video presentation at arbitration

conference room
1 .80 ors
200.00 360 ,00
04/30/08 DAB Final preparations for sanctions hearing ;

attendance and assistance at sanctions
hearing
5 .00 hrs
185 .00
925 .00
a4l30I08 LCE Final preparation for and participation in

hearing on Emary's motion for sanctions
11 .50 hrs 260 .00 2,930 .04
04/30/08 TDW Attend sanctions hearing; meeting with T.

Eichelberger and L . Edelmann regarding
follow-up items
11 .20 hrs 350 .00
3,920 .00
Sub-total Fees : 123,635 .00
Timekeeper Summa
Total
Timekeeper Hours Average Rate

Todd D . Wozniak 104.80
Lindsey C . Edelmann 156.10
Glianny Fagundo
3 .30
Brett T.
Lane
28 .50
Deb A . Burger
128 .30
David L, Strickland 4 .70
Roslyn Thomas 4.20
Brett E . Moskowitz 63 .20
Gerard Buitrago 13 .70
Caroline T .
Le
3 .20
TOTAL:
510 .00
350.00
260.00
290.00
260.00
185 .00
185 .00
185 . 00
1 50.00
200 .00
125 .00
36,680 .00
40,586 .00
957 .00
7,410 .00
23,735 .50
869 .50
777 .00
9,480 .00
2,740 .00
242.42
$123,635 .00
Current Services Rendered :
4ao.oo
123,635 .00
Tvw :Lz
Tax ID : 13-3613083
Greenberg Traur ia. LLP I Attorneys at Law I The Forum 1 3290 Norfhside Parkway I Suite 4001 AUanta, Georg ia 30327
Tel G78 .553;210Q J Fax 678~3.2212 J awdw- g flaw. Cpm
OngEnal Invoices X11-18-08}
EPO-467
AVW
ureenberg
Trudg
Page
Invoice No.
File No .
Expenses :
Business Meals
Color Copies
Federal Express Charges
Off-site Printing and Copying Charges
Photocopy Charges
Telephone Expenses
Information and Research
17
21 48457
102091 .010 1 00
125 .16
1,997 .00
11 .70
1,004.80
1,954.05
0.50
2,139.77
Sub-total Expenses :
7,232 .98
Total Current Fees and Expenses :
S 130,867.98
Total payments & credits received since your last

billing statement . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .$
-63,521. .44
TDW :LZ
Tax ID : 13-3613083
Greenbery Traurig, LLP I Attorneys at Law I The Forum I 329p Nor khside Parkway I Suite 400 1 Rflanta . Georgia 3Q327
Tel 678.558Trj,%j
www. gtlaw.com
E PO - 468
Origina l Invoices
(11-18-08)
EPO-
469
~.
Greenberg
Truri
Page
Invoice No .
File No .
Bill Date
1
2120423
102091,0 10 100
April 9, 2008
Ernory University/Emory Healthcaze, Inc .

101 Administration Building
201 Dowman Drive
Atlanta, Georgia 30322
Attn : Elizabeth Clark Mamison
Associate General Counsel
Adv . James J". Murtagh, M .p . (Breach of Contract)
Legal Services through 03/31/08 :

0.
Is
Hours Rate
Amount
Q3143108.
DAB Review of webmail account for potentially

relevant emails
1 .90 hrs
03/03/08
LCE Draft letter to C . Culotta regarding providing

reference letter with an original signature to
Eisenhower Army Medical; conference with
T . Wozniak regarding potential sur-reply to
Dr. Murtagh's motion to strike Emorys
motion for sanctions and sanctions motion
strategy
0.70 hrs 260 .00 182 .00
03/04/08
TDW Review and revise letter to C . Culotta

regarding reference requests ; review and
comment on proposed response to plaintiffs
reply to motion to strike Emory's motion for
sanctions; telephone conference with L.
Edelmann regarding plaintiffs prior position
that Judge Shoob lacked authority to issue
contempt remedies because his claims were
2.80 hrs 3 50 .0 0 9 80 .00
185 , 00
351 .50
TI)W :LZ
Tax ID : 13-3613083
Greenberg Traurig, LLp I Attorneys at Law I The Foru m 13 290 N orthside Parkway ( Suit 4 00 E Atlanta, Georgia 3 327
Tel 67 8.553.2 1 00 1 Fax 678. 553.22 1 2 www.gtlaw.cOm
Origina l Invoices (11-1 8-081
E PO- 4 70
Greenberg
Page 2
Invoice No, 2120423
File No .
142091 .010140
in arbitration
03/05/08
DAB Multiple communications with J . Lapid

regarding invoice ; reevaluate services
performed; review research regarding
collection of judgment against Dr . Murtagh
1.60 hrs
185 .00 296.00
03105148 LCE Draft correspondence to Arbitrator

address ing arguments set forth in Murtagh's
reply in support of his sanctions motion ;
review Murtagh's recent filings for references
to an appeal of Judge Shoal's contempt
order; conference with T . Wozniak and H.
Pace regarding same .
4.20 hrs
260.00
03106108 DAB Conference with T . Wozniak regarding

collection of judgment issues
0.50 hrs
185.00 92 .50
03/06/08
LCE Review transcript from hearing on motion to

unseal records, Murtagh's briefs supporting
his recusal motion, and Murtagh's response
to Emaary's fee petition for references to
Court's inability to dismiss claims froth
arbitration ; revise Emory's letter clarifying its
position on issues raised in Murtagh's reply
in support of his motion to strike Emory's
motion for sanctions; confer with T .
Wozniak regarding same; conference with D .
Burger regarding deposition summary ;
continue identifying exhibits to use in
hearing on Emory's motion for sanctions
4.20 hrs
260 .00
1,092 .00
03/08/08
TDW Review and comment on proposed letter to

R. Deane regard ing plaintiff s motion to
strike
1 .20 his 35 0.40
420 .00
03/09/08
TDW Emails with Grady's counsel r egarding

payment of Arbitrator's bills
0.40 his 350 .00 140 .00
1,092 .0
Tax ID : 1 3-3613083
Greenberg Traurig, LLP I Attorneys at Law I The Forum 1329 Northside Parkway I Suite 400 1 Atlanta, Georgia 34327
Tel 678.553.2100 Fax f78 53 .2212 I www.gtlaw.com
Original ~nvoices ~~1-18-08) EPO- 471
eenb
'E"rf
T aurig
!
03/10/08
Page 3
File No .
102091 .010100
2.40
hrs
444 .04
DAB Online research regarding intetae# post ings
185,00
referencing Murtagh with particular attention
to activities surrounding previous contempt
hearings
. .
03/10/08
LCE Finalize and serve Emory's letter clarifying

its position on issues raised in Murkagh's
reply in support of his motion to strike
Emory's motion for sanctions ; exchange
correspondence with B. Morrison regarding
same; review correspondence from C .
Culotta regarding Eisenhower reference
request; confer with T . Wozniak regarding
same; conference with D . Burger regarding
Washington whistleblower week activities
1 .10 Yirs
260.00
286.00
03!10/08
TDW Review new internet postings and

whistleblowers week agenda ; review and
revise letter response to plaintiffs reply in
support of its motion to strike ; telephone
conference with B. Morrison; telephone
conferences with T . Eichelberger regarding
Grady's payment of arbitrator's fees
2.30 hrs
350 .00
805 .00
43J1 1108
LCE Examine internet postings and related links ;

investigate owner of Washington
whistleblower week website and domain
name; conference with T . Wozniak regarding
possible violation of contempt order; prepare
correspondence to B . Morrison regarding
same; examine correspondence from C.
Culotta regarding issues with Dr . Alexander's
reference letter; confer with T. Wozniak
regarding C . Culotta's request for a personal
reference letter from Dr. Alexander
2.30 h ers
2b0 .00
598 .00
03/11/08
BEM Pull relevant sections of Murtagh's 2007

deposition transcript regarding his
withholding documents and relevant
4.00 hrs
15Q .00
600.00
TDW :LZ
Tax ID : 1 3-3613083
Greenberg Traurig, LLp I Attorneys at Law I The Forum 1 3280 Norlhsid9 Parkway I Suite 400 1 Atlanta, Geprgla 3p327
Tel 67&
.0law
.'~3gina-f I&voicfs tT1=i8=URj
.com EPO- 472
Greenberg
Traurig
Page
Invoice No .
File No .
4
2120423 .
102091 .010100
exhibits; highlight relevant text in transcript

for possible use , in sanctions hearing
03/11/08
TDW
Emails with plaintiffs counsel regarding 1 .50 hrs

reference requests; review Internet postings;
meeting with L . Edelm. ann regarding
potential violations of oontempt order;
emails with B . Morrison
350 .00
525 .00
Q3l12/08 DAB Research previously filed privilege logs

submitted in the underlying litigation and
review of documents listed
0 .70 hrs 185 .00
129 .50
03/12/08
0.80 hrs
260 .00
208 .00
03/13108 DAB Online research regarding internet postings 2 .20 hrs

that possibly violate contempt orders ; review,
webmail account for possibly relevant emails
185 .00
407 .00
03/13/08
350.00
700.00
LCD Prepare correspondence to B . Morrison

discussing service of subpoena daces tecurn
on certain individuals to establish a violation
of contempt order; confer with T. Wozniak
regarding same ; examine at-issue website for
new postings
TDW Review recent Internet postings ; emails with 2 .00 hrs

plaintiffs counsel
03/14/08 DAB Online research regarding Internet postings
0.50 hrs
185 .00
92.50
03/14/08 LCE Examine Arbitrator's decision denying Dr .

Ivlurtagh's recusal motion; confer with T .
Wozniak regarding same ; telephone
conference with C. Culotta regarding
Eisenhower reference request ; examine C .
Culotta's objection to Emory's letter
clarifying its position oin motion to strike
Emorys motion for sanctions; review
correspondexice between T . Wozniak and B .
Morrison
1 .30 hrs
260 .00
338 .00
TDW :LZ
Tax ID: 13-3613083
Green erg Traurig, LLP I Attameys at Law' I The Forum 1 3290 NorEhside Parkway I Suike 404 I Att anta, Geo rgia 30327
Tel 678 . 558
J w'
r~g naltinvoi~s . 1 1='78-Q8
~'~~. ~
EPO- 473
Greenberg
Traurig
Page 5
Invoice No.
2120423
File No. 102091 .010100
03/14/08 _ TDW Telephone conference with C. Culafta
regarding personal reference from D r. .
Alexander or other Emory physicians ; emails
with B . Morrison regarding same; review
Arb itrator's decision regarding recusal
motion; meeting with L Edelmann and D.
Burger regarding sanctions hearing ; emails
with B. Morrison regard ing personal
references
3 .40 hrs
350.00 1,190 .00
03/17/08
DAB Review of deposition testimony and

summary of Murtagh's August 29, 2007
deposition
1 .20 hrs 1 .85 .40
222 .00
03/17/08
LSE Review correspondence from C . Culotta

regarding Eisenhower request; examine T .
Wozniak's response to same ; review T.
Wozniak's request that Arbitrator set a date
for hearing on Emory's sanctions motion ;
conference with D . Burger and B .
Moskowitz regarding strategy for hearing on
0.70 his 260 .00
182 .00
03117/U8 TDW Review email from C . Culotta regarding

Eisenhower Medical Center; draft letter to C .
Culotta; telephone conference with B.
Morrison regarding plaintiffs reference
requests and hearing on motion for sanctions ;
emails regarding same
1 .700 hrs
350 .00
595 .00
03/18/08
DAB Online research regarding Internet postings;

review of webmail account for potentially
relevant eznails
2.80 hrs
185 .00
518 .00
03/19/08
DAB Review of deposition testimony and

summary of Mrzrtagh's August 29, 2007
deposition
2.50 hrs 1 85_00
462 .50
Tvw :Lz
Tax ID : 13 .3 61 3 0 83
Greenberg 7raurig , LLP I Attorneys at Law I The Forum 1 3290 NorUrside Parkway I Suite 440 1 Atlanta , Georgi a 30327
Te l 678.F .21
) www .O aw.com
EP O- 474
Greenberg
Traurig
03/19/08 BEM
Page
5' Invoice No .
2120423
10209 1 .010100
File No .
Review deposition exempts,- view deposition 1 .50 his
150 .00
225 .00
AVD and highlight relevant parts of DVD
regarding Murtagh's failure to produce
documents
03/20/08
DAB
Online research regarding Internet postings ;

review webmail account
1 .701us
185 .00
03/24/08
DAB
Online research for internet postings by

Murtagh and/or his associates
0.30 hrs
1 85 .74 55 .50
03/25/08
DAB
Online research regarding internet postings ;

rev iew webmail account
2 .l 0 hrs
185 .00
388 .50
03/25/08
BEM Review DVD of 1vlurtagh's 2 007 deposition;

highlight multiple clips of Murtagws
statements regarding withholding
documents; record clips on transcript
5 .00 bra
150 .00
750 .00
03/26/08
DAB Continue work on deposition summary of

August 29, 2007 deposition of Murtagh;
multiple telephone conferences with
litigation support regarding video clips of
Murtaghts testimony for use at upcoming
contempt hearing ; research information
available online regarding whistleblower's
week noting changes from previous postings ;
review and compare other Internet postings
regarding Murtagh to previous information
available online
5 .60 hrs
155 .0
4.30 hrs
185.00 795 .50
03127105 DAB Summary of Murtagh deposition testimony

and selection of deposition testimony clips
for use at upcoming contempt hearing
03/28!08 DAB Review and selection of additional testimony 4 .20 hrs

to use at contempt hearing from Murtagh's
August 30, 2007 deposition-testimony,
summary of Murtaghh deposition testimony;
185 .00
314.50
1 ,036 .00
777 .00
TDW : LZ
Tax ID: 13-3613083
Greenberg Traurig, LLP I Attorneys at Law I The Forum 13290 Northside Parkway I Suite 400 1 Atlarrta . Georgia 30327
Tel 671
.'OnginaR l nvoices8(Ti=48=[l
~ I www.gflaw
.com
EPO-
475
01
Greenberg
Traurig
Page 7
Invoice No . : 2120423
File No . 14209 1.01 0100
review of internet postings
03/28/08
6.70 hrs
CTL Prepare video clips of J . Murtagh's

deposition for hearing use
125 .00
837 . 50
Prepare video clips of J . Murtagh's

3.60 hrs 125 .00 450 .00
03/31/08
DAB Telephone conferences with C . Le regarding

deposition clips of Murtagh's August 29,
2007 depositiontestimony
0.20 hrs 185 .00 37 .00
03/31/08
CTL Prepare video clips of J . Murtagh's

2 .30 hrs
x3129/0$ CTL
1 25 .00 287.50
Sub-total Fees : 18,902.50
Timekeeper Summary
Timekeeper
Hours Averagg Rate
Total
'add D, Wozniak 15 .30 350 .00

Lindsey C . Edelmann 15 .30 260 .0
Deb A. Burger 34.70 185 .00
Brett E. Moskowitz
10.50
150 .00
Caroline T . Le 12,6 125 .00
5,355 .00
3,978 ,00
6,419 .50
1,575 .00
1,575 .00
TOTAL:
88 .40
21 3 .8
Current 'Services, Rendered:
$18,902 .50
18,902 .50
Exp8T150S :
Color
Copies
24M
8 .37
Photocopy Charges .
2.70
Professional & Legal 3,500.00
Service Comp any Charges 2,370.83
Telephone Expenses 0 .08
0
Tvw:LZ
Tax ID : 1 3-361 3 483
Gresnberg Trauri g . LLP I Attorneys at Law I The Forum (32913 Northside Parkway I Su ite 400 J Atla nta , Georgi a 30327
T$1678.553.2100 /Fax E78. 5b32272 1 www. gUaw.com
Origin a l Invoices (11 - 15 -08 )
EPO476
Greene
rauri
!
Page
Invoice No .
File No .
2.96
2120423
102091 . 010100
5,908 .94
Total Current Fees and Expenses : $
Previous Balance (see attached statement) :
Total Amount Due :
24,811 A
$ 38,710 .00
$
63,521 .44

billing statement. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .$ -31,859 .26
TDw; Lz
"fax ID : 33-3 61 3 083
Green6erg 'iraudg , LLp I Attorneys at Law I The Forum 1 3290 Northside Parkway I Suite 404 1 Attanha , Georgia 30327
Tel 678. 553.210c~] ~ Fax 678 .5, 3 .2212 ~ www ggaw.com
O rigina I nvoices (1 18-08)
EPO- 477
O riginal Invoices (1 1-18-08)
EPO- 478
~reb rg
40- 'rri
Page
Invoice No .
File No .
Bill Date
1
2092675
102091 .01010 0
March 11, 2008
Emory University/Emory Healthcare, Inc .

201 Dowman Drive
Attn : Elizabeth Clark-Morrison
Associate. General Counsel
Adv . James J. Murtagh, M.D . (Breach of Contract)
Legit Services through 02/29/08 :

Hours
Rate Amount
02/01/08 DAB Review Emory webmail account for relevant

emails ; review recent Internet posting for
references to Murtagh and related issues
1 .70 hrs
185 .00
314 .50
02/01/08 LCE
Review third-party subpoena responses to

identify email addresses used or created by
Murtagh that he failed to disclose in
violation of Arbitrator's December 12, 2005
decision; review plaintiffs deposition for
relevant statements regarding his failure to
produce material documents; review
production of B . Skellie and T. Nugent to
identify documents improperly withheld in
decision; confer with T. Wozniak regarding
same
7 .3 0 hrs
260 . 00 1 , 898 ,00
02104/08 LCE
Review Murtagh's reply in support of motion

for recusal of arbitrator ; review cases cited in
4.10 hrs 260 .00
1,066.00
TD W:LZ
Tax ID : 13-3613083
Greenberg Traurig , LLP I Attorneys at Law I The For um 1 3290 tJo r thside Parkway I Sui te 400 1 Atlanta, Ge orgia 30327
T e l 678:
01~ I www.gt law.
Orig na~lhvoic~$ 1 f 18 com
EPO - 479
reen
Tr u
'
ir/
~ 1 ~YY~
~I%
Page
Invoice No .
File No .
2
209267
102091 .010100
Murtagh's reply brief; review AAA rules

regarding waiver of objections; telephone
conference with T. Eichelberger regarding
Murtagh reply brief and potential responses
to same; review Georgia rules of professional
conduct to identify an actual or potential
conflict requiring disqualification
02/04!08
TDW Review plaintiffs reply in support of motion

for recusal; telephone conference with T .
Eichelberger regarding same; review AAA
rules and federal arbitration act regarding
recusal issues; telephone conference with B .
Morrison regarding response strategy
4.00 hrs
35 0.00 1,400.00
02/05/08
DAB Review Emory's webmail account for

relevant emails ; review documents to include
in sanctions hearing binder
2.40 his
1 85. 00
444 .00
42faS108 LCE Research federal caselaw on ripeness for

motion to disqualify arbitrator or judge,
1Vlurtagh's ability to appeal order on Emory's
motion for sanctions, and waiver ; conference
call with B . Morrison regarding Muftagh's
reply in support of recusal motion and
potential response strategies ; revise
correspondence to arbitrator requesting
conference on Muttagh's motion for recusal
and motion to strike ; prepare citations for use
in same; confer with D . Burger regarding
proposed exhibits for hearing on Emory's
motionn for sanctions ; strategize with T .
Wozniak regarding end-game strategy
5.00 hrs 260.00
1,300 .00
02/05/08
MER Review and comment on recusal issues ;

telephone conference with T . Wozniak
regarding same
0.70 hrs
02/05/08
TDW Revise e-mail to arbitrator requesting hearing
5.90 hrs 350 .00 2, 065 .00
450 .00
315 .00
7Dw :Lz
Tax II? : 13-3b134$3
Greenberg Tsau d g, LLP I Aitomeys at Law I The Forum 13290 Northside Parkway I Suite 400 1 A#anta , Georgia 30327
Tel fi7B .9 ,
J w"
ng nalEl nvoi ~s 11378-O S)
.~~. ~
EPO - 480
Greenberg
Tru
Page
Invoice No.
File No .
3
2092675
102091 .41 01 00
on plaintiffs motion for recusal and setting

forth Emory's position that the AAA is not
the proper body to rule on motion ; review
research for recusal issue and proper body to
rule on it; meet with L. Edelmann regarding
same; review select e-mails captured by
webmail account as well as new Internet
articles; meet with L. Edelmann regarding
end game strategy
02/06/08
LCE Review Internet postings collected by D.

Burger regarding Emory and Grrady ; prepare
correspondence to B . Morrison regarding
Provocateur webposting ; review electronic
data from Emory's wehserver collected by D .
Burger; research federal and state cases on
jw7.sdactiaana.1Iesues relating to Murtagh's
recusal motion for use in telephone, hearing ;
confer with T. Wozniak regarding same
02f06/08 TDW Draft outline of arguments for sanctions

hearing and on recusal motion; review select
exhibits for same
4.80 hrs 264 .00 1 ,248 .0
0.90 hrs 350 .00
315 .00
333 .aa
02/07/08
DAB Review of webmail account for relevant

emails
1 . 80 hrs 185 .00
02/07108
LCE
4.80 hrs
Draft talking points and supporting authority

for use in conference call on Murtaghs
recusal motion; continue preparing exhibits
for use in hearing on Emory's motion for
sanctions ; review C . Culorta's
correspondence to arbitrator supporting
Murtagh's motion for recusal ; research issues
of waiver and jurisdiction contained in C.
Culotta's correspondence ; prepare
memorandum summarizing same ;
conference with T. Wozniak regarding
hearing strategy on Murtagh's recusal motion
260 .00
1,248 .00
TDW:LZ
Tax ED; 1M6 1 3d83
Creenberg Traurig . LLP I Attorneys a t Law I The Fgrurn 13290 Norfh slde Parkway [ Suite 40 0 1 Atlanta, Georgi a 30327
Tel 678.553 .2100 1 Fax 678,563.2212 1 wtivwgtlaw, can
Original Invoices (11-18-08) EPO- 4 81
Greenb rg
Traurig
\i
r
Page 4
Invoice No. : 2092675
File No . 102091 .010100

and motion for sanctions
9--
02/07/08
TDW Review additional research regarding recusal 1 .70 hrs

motion issues relative to plaintiff s most
recent e-mail arguments ; e-mail to arbitrator
prompting telephone hearing on motion for
recusal
350.00
595 .00
02/08/08
LCE Review B . Merrison's comments on C.

Culotta's letter-brief on waiver and
jurisdictional issues ; review coiTespondence
from Arbitrator Deans regarding hearing on
Murtagh's motion for recusal ; prepare
correspondence confirming hearing on
February 13, 2008; review correspondence
from T . Eichelberger and C . Culotta
regarding same
0.30 hrs 260.04
78 .00
02/08/08 TDW Telephone conference with B . Morrison

regarding plaintiffs surreply on motion for
recusal ; e-mails with arbitrator regarding
hearing on same
0.80 hrs 35 0 . 0 0
280 .00
02/11/08
LCE Conference with T . Wozniak regarding

strategy and action items for hearing on
Murtagh's motion for recusal and motion to
strike
0.30 Firs 2 60.00
78.00
02/12/08
DAB Review of electronic data on Emory's

webserver for references to Murtagh and
related issues
2.1 0hrs 1 85 A0
388 .50
02/12/08
LCE Analyze Eleventh Circuit authority on

objection waivers ; prepare materials and
cases for use in telephone hearing on
Murtagh's motion for recusal and motion to
strike ; review same with T. Wozniak;
prepare correspondence to the arbitrator on
timing of the telephone hearing on MurtagWs
2.40 hrs 260 .00
624 .00
TDW :LZ
Tax ID: 13-3613083
Greenberg Traudg, LLP I Attorneys at Law I The Forum 1 3290 Northside Park-way I Suite 400 1 Atlanta , Georgia 36327
Tel 678. 5332140 1 Fax 678. 553. 2212 1 w~vw. gtlaw ,cc Grn
O riginal Invoi ces { 11 -18- 08)
EPO- 482
014,
uIreoftenberg
~ Traurig
Page 5
File No .
102091.0101 00
motion for recusal and motion to strike

02/12/08
TDW Prepare for recusal hearing ; review cases

cited by parties for same; outline argument
2.00 hrs 350.00
02/13/08
LCE
4.70 brs
260.00 1,222.00
02!13/fl8
TDW Prepare for telephone hearing regarding

motion to recuse and mvtaann to strike
Emory's motion for sanctions ; review select
cases cited by both sides ; review plaintiffs
last minute letter and e-mail briefs regarding
AAA administration and new counsel ;
respond to same ; participate in conference
call with arbitrator regarding motion to
recuse ; e-mails with B . Morrison regarding
same
6.60 hrs
350.00
2,310.00
Q2I14/08 TDW Review research regarding plaintiffs new

counsel ; revise e-mail to B . Morrison
regarding same ; review recent internet
postings
1 .20 ors 35 0A0
420 .00
02/15/0 LCE Examine Murtagh's statement on legal

authority discussedd in hearing on Murtagh's
recusal motion and Murtagh's request that
TDW :LZ
Tax ID : 13-36 1 3083
0.50 hrs 260 .00
130.00
0:.
Review documents from Emory`s web server ;

review C . Culotta's request for Emory to
consent to AAA administration ; review C .
Culotta's request to postpone hearing on
Murtagh's recnsall motion ; confer with'.
Wozniak regarding response to same ; review
cases for possible use and discussionn at
hearing on Murtagh's recusal motion ; prepare
for hearing on Murtagh's recusal motion ;
participate in hearing on Murtagh's recusal
motion; conduct preliminary research on
Murtagh's new counsel M. Harrison; conduct
Internet search to determine if Murtagh has
made postings in violation of contempt order
700 .00
Greenberg Traurig , LLP E Attorneys at Law I The Forum I 3290 Northside Parkway I Suite 400 j Atlanta, Georg i a 30327
Tel 678.553 .21001 Fax 678 .553 .2212 1 www.gtlaw. cam
O riginal I n voices ( 11 -18-0 8)
EPO - 483
GreenberTraur
0
Page 6
Invoice No . 20 2675
102091 .010100
File No .
arbitration be terminated ; confer with T .
Wozniak regarding same
02/18/08
LCE Conduct Internet research to identify any

disparaging postings possibly posted by Dr .
Murtagh; prepare correspondence to T .
1 .80 hrs 260 .00 468 .00
02/19/08
DAB Review Internet postings pertaining to

Murtagh and his whistleblowing efforts and
peer review
1 .30 hrs
1 85.00
240 .50
02/19/08
LCE Prepare correspondence to B, Morrison

regarding recent Internet postings possibly
related to Dr. Murtagh ; confer with D .
Burger and T. Wozniak regarding the same ;
examine and update chart of pr. Murtagh's
lies under oath for use in hearing on Emory's
1 .90 hrs 260 .00
494 .00
02/19/08
BEM Review and organize Internet research ; locate 3 .50 tits

documents and exhibits and correspondence
for review
150 .00
02/19/08
TDW Review select Internet postings related to Dr .

Murtagh ; meeting with L. Edelmann
regarding sanctions hearing ; emails with B .
Morrison regarding Dr. Murtagh's email and
Internet activity
2.50 tits
350 .00 875 .00
02/20/08
LCE Examine reference request forwarded by N .

MacDonald and B. Morrison; investigate
reference requesting agency and prepare
correspondence to T. Wozniak and B .
Morrison regarding same ; continue preparing
chart identifying documents and information
withheld in violation of Arbitrator's
December 2005 order compelling discovery
for use as an exhibit at the hearing on
3 .1 0 tits 260 . 00
~-
TDW:LZ
Tax ID : 13-3613083
Greenberg Traurig, LLP ] Attorneys at Law I The For um 13290 Northsid e Parkway I Suite 400 1 Atlanta, Georgia 30327
Te l 678 .
Onginal Irivoi~ce67(1 518?8? I ~' ~~.c~
EPO- 484
525 .00
806.00
Greenberg
.
~ ~ Traurig
Page 7
File No . 10209 1 .010104
Emory's sanctions motion ; confer with B .
Moskowitz regarding identification of
disparaging statements in documents
withheld from Murtagh
02f20/08
BEM Review and analyze third-party documents

that Murtagh withheld in violation of
arbitrator's order compelling discovery ; mark
relevant text and organize documents in
binder accordingly in preparation for
sanctions hearing
3.50 bra
150.00
525 .00
02/21/08
BEM Review and analyze third party documents

that Murtagh withheld in violation of
arbitrator's order compelling discovery ; mark
relevant text and organize documents in
binder accordingly in preparation for
sanctions hearing
'
3 .00 hs
150 .00
450 .00
02/23/08
DAB Review of information on the internet

pertaining to Murtagh and his
whistleblowing efforts and peer review
1 .70 hrs
185 .00
314 .50
02/25/08
DAB Review and edits to Emory invoices for

November 2007 to the present for
submission with new attorney fee petition ;
review of electronic data on Emory's
webserver; research regarding D. Sorinc;
begin review and summarization of
Murtagh's August 29, 2007 deposition
5. 10 hrs
185 .00 943 .50
0/25/08
LCE Review electronic data from Emery

webserver; prepare correspondence to B .
Morrison regarding the same ; review
correspondence from N . MacDonald and B .
Morrison regarding reference requests ;
.
prepare script for N . MacDonald use in
follow-up reference request phone calls ;
conference with T . Wozniak regarding chart
6.30 hrs
260 .00 1,63 8.04
TDW:LZ
TaxID : 13=361308 3
Greenberg Traurig, LLP (P,itameys at Law I The Forum 1 3290 Northside Parkway I Suite 400 1 Atlanta, Georgia 30327
Tel 578.55OS
EPO- 485
gi
I n l nvoiae sT~~~i~~ www ~w'0Qm
Greenberg
Traurig
Page
8
2092675
Invoice No .
File No. ~ 10209 1 .010 100
of evidence withheld by Dr. Murtagh;
continue drafting chart of evidence
improperly withheld by Dr . Murtagh in
Decision; confer with D . Burger regarding
attorney fees petition and examine F,xnary's
fee petition submitted to Judge Shoob
TDW Review select electronic data from Emory
webserver; review Interlocutory Injunction
and contemptt order for possible violations ;
emails with B . Morrison regarding same ;
revise telephone script for N . McDonald's
call with potential recruiter for Dr . Murtagh;
emails with IT experts regarding tracing
recipients of Dr. lViurtagh's email and "blind
copy" information
3 .90 hrs 350 .00 1,365 .00
02/26/08
DAB Prepare summary of Murtagh's August 29,

2007 deposition testimony
2.60 hxs 185 .00 481 .00
02/26/08
LCE Review correspondence from S . 1Vlorrason,

C. Culotta, and T . Wozniak regarding Dr.
Murtagh's need for a reference letter for
temporary position at Army facility ; identify
disparaging comments contained in
documents improperly withheld by Dr.
Murtagh in violation of Arb itrator's
December 12, 2045 Decision compelling
discovery; telephone conference with IT
expert regarding ab ility to identify bcc's frame
email
2.10 hrs 260 .00 546.00
02/26/08
TDW Ernails with Plaintiffs counsel and B .

0 .90 hrs
Morrison regarding response to latest referral
requests ; review settlement agreement
requirements
350 .00
315 .00
07.127/08
DAB Prepare summary of MurGagh's August 29,
2.80 hrs
185 .00
51$ .00
TDW:LZ
Tax ID : 13-3613083
Greenherg Traurig, LLP I Attorneys at Law I The Forum 1 3290 Northside Parkway I Suite 400 I Atlanta , Georgi a 30327
Tel 678. 55 3.210 Fax 878. 53 22 1 2 4 www .g ~aw.cam
Original Invoices (~1 - ~$ -08)
EPO- 486
reebr
Traurig
Page 9
invoice No . 209267
File No .
102091 .010100
2007 deposition testimony LCE Conference call with B . Morrison and N.
MacDonald regarding Dr . Murtagh's request
for a signed reference letter ; confer with T.
Wozniak regarding the same ; continue
preparing chart of evidence improperly
withheld by Dr. Murtagh in violation of
Arbitrator's December 12, 2005 Decision for
use at hearing on Emary's motion for
sanctions
2.70 hrs
260.00
702.0
a2rz7/as
TDW Telephone conference with B . Morrison and

N . McDonald regarding reference request
and original signatures of Dr . Alexander;
telephone conference with C, Cullotta;
meeting with L . Edelnaann regarding
evidence for sanctions hearings ; review
select evidence materials
2.60 hrs
350.00
910 .00
02/28/08
DAB Continue review of Murtagh's August 29,

2007 deposition testimony ; conference with
L . Edelmann regarding summary of
Murtagh's deposition testimony
1.10 hrs 185 .00
203 .50
02/28/08
LCE Review correspondence from C . Culotta and

J. Murtagh regarding Dr . Alexander's
reference letter ; telephone conference with
C . Culotta regarding the same ; examine
invoices for attorneys fees and costs incurred
by Emory between October 2007 and
January 2008 and redact privileged
information; examine Mtutaglz's reply in
support of his motion to strike Emory's
3.00 hrs 260.00
780.04
1 .40 hrs
490.00
02/28/08 TDW Meeting with L . Edelmann regarding

plaintiff s request for reference request with
original signatures ; review settlement
TDW :LZ
't'art II?: 13-3613083
350 .00
Greenberg Tra udg, LLP I Attorneys at Law J The Forum 13290 Norths ide Pa rk way ( Suite 400 1 ABarsta , Georgia 30327
Tel fi 78. 5
9igg11 Invoices'j~13fiS~8~ ~. ~~.~
E P O- 487
reenber
r
i
ir! l i AW /
+iA
Page
Invoice No .
File No .
agreement regarding same ; review plaintiffs
reply in support of motion to strike
10
2092675
102091 .010100
0 129/08
LICE
Prepare cover letter for N . McDonald to

submit to M . Khan explaining Dr.
Alexander's signed reference letter ; examine
Murtagh's reply in support of his motion to
strike Emory's motion for sanctions and
Emory's response to his motion to determine
if any new, unaddressed arguments warrant a
response ; conference with T . Wozniak
regarding Murtagh's reply in support of his
motion to strike Emory's motion for
sanctions
1 .80 hrs
260 .00
468.00
o 2/z 9rQs
TDW Telephone conference with B . Morrison

regarding Eisenhower reference request for
plaintiff and response to same ; review
plaintiffs reply in support of his motion to
strike Emory's motion for sanctions ; meeting
with L . Edelmann regarding potential
sunreply; telephone conference regarding
same
2 .60 hrs
350 .00
910,00
Sub-total Fees :
33,740.00
Timekeeper Summary
Timekeeper
Mickey Ross
Todd D . Wozniak
Lindsey C . Edelmann
Deb A. Burger
$rett E . Moskowitz
TOTAL:
Hours
Average Rate Total
0.70
37.00
56.90
22.60
10,00
4so,aa
350 .00
260 .00
.0O
185
150 .00
315 .00
12,950 .00
14,794 .00
4,181 .00
1,500 .00
127 .20
265 .25
$33,740 .00
TDW :LZ
Tax ID : 13-3613083
Greenberg 7raurig , LLP I Attorneys at Law I The Foru m 13290 Narthside Parkway I Suite 4001 Atlanta, Georgia 30327
Te l 678 .55a g~~al
)WWW tIaW.0o
.n
j lnvoices~11 - T~ 08
.g
rn
EPO- 488
Greenberg
Traurig
Invoice No.
File No .
Expenses :
Photocopy Charges
Professional & Legal
11
2092675
102091 .01010
$
33,740 .00
8.95
25 .35
2,732 .54
2,203 .16
4,970 .00
38,710.00
Previous Balance (see attached statement) : $ 31,859.26

Total Amount Due :
70,569.26
Q.QO
TDW:LZ
Tax ID : 13-3613083
Greenberg Treu rig , LLP I Attorneys at Law I The Forum 1 3290 Norths3de Parkway I Suite 400 1 Atlanta , Georgia 30327
Tel 678.
I
_com
APO- 489
90rginal
l
nvoi ~5~1 1- 7fa~ 1 vwuvw .gdaw
L~
E
Original Invoices (11-1 8 -08)
EPO- 4 90
MGreenbergTraurig
0
.
Page 1
Invoice No .
2183987
File No. 102 091 . 0 1010 0
Bill Date July 8, 2008
201 Dowman Drive
Adv. James J . Murtagh, M.D . (Breach of Contract)

Hours Rate
06/03/08
DAB Review of internet postings and webserver

references for Murtagh ; update case
notebooks
2.70 hrs
Amount
185 .00 499 .50
06/QblO$ DAB Review and analyze webserver e-mails and

Internet postings with regard or reference to
Murtagh
0 .90 hrs 185 .00 166 .50
06/09/08
1 .10 hrs
DAB Research internet postings and Emory's

webserver for postings made by Murtagh
1 85.00
203 .50
06fi210 8 DAB Research internet postings and Emory is

webserver for postings made by Murtagh
2.60 hrs 185 .00 481 .00
06/16/08
0.70 hrs 260.00
18 2.00
1 .14hrs
385 .00
LCE Review Internet search results
06/1710$ TDW Revise summary of whistleblower week

activities; review and revise report regarding
Internet postings regarding K . Alexander and
350 .00
TDW :JS
Tax TD : 13-3613083
Greenberg 7 ra vrg , LLP I Attorneys at Law I Th e Forum 13290 N orthside Pajlcway J Suite 400 1 Atla n ta, G e orgia 30327
Tel 678
j
.55angina l lnvoice~,~f1-'1 S o8~
.~
la'N.c
~7
EPO- 4 9 1
-M
GreenbergTraurig
Page 2
File No .
102091 .010100
his family
06/20/08
LCE Finalize memorandum on Murtagh's

activities during Washington whistleblower
week; prepare correspondence to B.
Morrison regarding same
0.40 hrs
260. 00 104 .00
06/23/08
DAB Review arbitrator's order
0.30hrs
185 .00 55 .50
06/23/08
LCE Review arbitrator's order on Emory's motion

for sanctions ; conference with T . Wozniak
regarding fee petition
0.50 hrs 260 . 0 0
06/23/08
TDW Review arbitrator's award ; telephone

conference with Grady's counsel regarding
same and regarding potential request for
damages; outline issues for fee request and
potential request for damages; email B.
Morrison regarding same
2 .30 hrs 350 A0 805 .00
06/24/08
DAB Conference with T . Wozniak regarding the

arbitrator's fee award, review of time entries
for reissuance of invoices
0.50 hrs 185 .00 92 .50
Q6124/08
TDW Emails with K . Alexander and B . Morrison

regarding fee application and damages
issues; meeting with D . Burger regarding
compilation of fee petition ; review 13-5-1 a
fee standard
1 .80 hrs 35 0.00
06/25/08
DAB Research Internet for recently posted articles

on peer review and whistleblowers by
Murtagh; conference with T . Wozniak
regarding arbitrator's order and submission of
fee petition
1 .30 hrs
06/25/08
TDW Review invoices for sanctions fee petition ;

segregate awardable fees from unawardable
fees
4.40 hrs 350.00 1, 540 .00
U]
Uj
1 30. 00
6330.0 0
185.00 240.50
'TD w:rs
Tax m: 13 -361308 3
Greenberg T raurig, LLP I Attorneys at Law I The Forum 1 3290 Northside Parkway I Suite 400 1 At lanta , Geo rgia 30327
Te1I www .S Uaw. com
EPO- 492
MGreenbergTraurig
Page
Invoice No.
File No.
3
2183987
102091 . 010100
06/26/08
TDW Review and segregate fees for sanctions

award fee petition
3.00 hrs 350 .00
1 ,050.00
06127108
TDW Review and segregate fees for sanctions

award fee petition
1 . 80 hrs 35 0 .00
630.00
06130108
DAB Meeting with T . Wozniak regarding fee

petition ; review of invoices for particular
references to fees and costs properly allowed
by arbitrator to include in fee petition ; begin
drafting fee petition
4.30 hrs 18 5 .00
795 . 50
Sub-total Fees : 7,990 .50
Timekeeper Summary
Timekeeper
Hours
Average Rate
Total
Todd D . Wozniak 14 .40 350 .0

Lindsey C . EdeImann
1 .60
260 .00
Deb A. Burger 13 .7 185 .00
5,040 .00
TOTAL :
29 . 70
269 .04
EUenses :
Messenger Services
Off sits Printing and Copying Charges
Photocopy Charges
Telephone Expenses
416 . 00
2,534 .50
$7 , 990 . 50
21 .37
773 .08
63 .00
4,769.30
0.56
4.00
5,631 .31
dub-total Expenses :

W.
7,990 .50
13,621.81
'I' DW :7S
Tax ID : 13-36 1 3083
Green bergTrau dg , LLA I Attorneys at Law I The Forum (3290 Northside Parkway I Suite 400 ( Atlanta , Georgia 30327
.cpm
Tel 678 . 5~
jj
rginal
l
~nvoices$( ''1~82 )E "'~ '9~~aw.cpm
EPO- 493
m GreenbergTraurig
Page
Invoice No .
File No .
Previous Balance (see attached statement) : $
Total Amount Due :

billing statement. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .$
10
4
2183987
10209 1 .0 1 0100
130,867 .98
144,4$9 .79
-14 ,772.92
TDW :JS
Tax ID : 13-3613083
Greenberg Trauri g , LLP I Attorn eys at Law I The Forum 1 3290 Northslde Parkway I Suite 400 1 Atlanta, Georgia 3 0327
Tel
I w'^^^+. gtiaw.cwrt EPO- 494
M GreenbergTraurig
is
Page
5
Invoice No. 2183987
File No. 102091 .010100

Account Statement
Date Invoice #
Fees Due Expenses Due
Other Due
Interest Due Total Due
45/07148 2148 457
123,635 .00 7,232 .98
0, 00
0.00 1 30,8 67 .98
123,635 .00 $ 7,232 .98 $
0 .00
Totals ; $
0 . 00 $ 130,8 67 . 98
TDW: JS
Tax ID; 1 3 -36 1 308 3
Greenberg Trau rlg , LIP I Attorneys at Law I The forum [ 3290 Norths ide Par kway I Suite 400 1 AUa rrta , Georgia 30327
Tel
www.gtiaw. com
EPO- 495
O riginal Invo ices ( 11 - 18 -08 )
EPO-
496
m GreenbergTraurig
Page
Invoice No .
File No .
Bill Date
2205390
10249 1 .010 100
August 7, 2008

201 Dowman Drive
Attn: Elizabeth Clark-Morrison
Adv . James J. Murtagh, M .D . (Breach of Contract)
F_l`J
is
Legal Services throw
07/31/08 :
Hours Rate Amount
07/01/08
DAB Research internet for postings by Murtagh

with emphasis on recent sanctions hearing
and order issued by arbitrator ; review of
invoices for particular references to fees and
costs properly allowed by arbitrator to
include in fee petition
6.00 hrs 185 .00
1,110-00
07/01/08
LCE Examine B . Bird's motion to withdraw as

opposing counsel ; strategize with T.
Wozniak regarding propriety of filing
oppositions to same, fee petition and motion
for fees associated with default on
counterclaims
0.90 hrs 264 .00
234A0
07/01/08
HRP Analysis of arbitrator's award and opinion;

conference with T. Wozniak regarding
motion for fees pursuant to OCGA 13-6-1 -1
and for punitive damage award ; research
regarding availability of such damages in
0.60 hrs
330,00
198 .00
TDW :JS
Tax ID: 1 3-3613083
Greenberg Tra urig , LLP E Attorneys at Law I Th e Fo ru m 13290 North side Parkway I Suite 400 { Atlanta, Georgi a 30327
Tei
www,gtlaw.com EPO- 497
m Green bergTrau rig

U]
Page 2
File No.
102091,010100
default context
07/01/08
TDW Review B . Bird's motion to withdraw ;

meeting with L . Edelmarin regarding
opposition to same ; telephone conference
with H . Pace regarding motion for damages
award ; review research regarding potential
for punitive damages award
2.20 hrs 350 .00 770.00
07103108 TDW Meet with H . Pace regarding motion for

damages and 13-6-11 fee award
4.80 hrs 350 .00 280.00
07/t17/08 TDW Review and comment on draft affidavits for

fee petition ; review select research for
damages motion
1.00 hrs
350 .00
350 .00
0714$/08 HRP Analysis of Georgia authority concerning

enforceability of OCGA 13-6-11 fees in
default setting ; draft motion for award of
damages and fees,
3 .90 hrs 33 0.00
1,287 .00
07/09/08
1. 10 hrs
DAB Draft affidavit of T . Womiak to accompany

fee petition to be filed as a result of
Arbitrator Deane's June 23, 2008 order
185.00 203 .50
07/x9108 HR .F Continue preparation of motion and

supporting memorandum of law requesting
award of monetary judgment of attorneys
fees based on OCG A 13-6-11 ;
correspondence with T . Wozniak and L .
Edelmann regarding same
5.80 hrs 330 .00 1,914 .00
07110/08
8.40 hrs 1 8 5 .00 1 ;554A0
DAB Compile attorney fee petition in accordance

with Arbitrator Deane's ruling ;
communications with L . F-delmann and T.
0 7/Ip108 LCE Examine motion for fees and costs under

0.C .G .A . 13-b-11 ; conduct additional legal
3.10 hrs 260 .00
806.00
TDW:JS
Tax ID : 13-3613083
Green b erg Traurig, LLP I Attorn eys at Law I The Foru m 13290 Narthsid e Parkway I Sui te 400 1 Atlanta, G eorg ia 30327
Tel 67 8.55M A 01M' fr wS-O&%&29M www.gtlaw .co m
EPO- 498
M Green be rgTrau rig

0.
Page 3
File No .
102091 .010100
research on cases in support of motion ;
revise legal argument section of Emory's
motion for costs and fees
07/10/08
HRP Conferences with L . Edelrnann regarding

availability of nominal and punitive damages
for each of claims asserted
0.30 hrs 330 .00 99 .00
07/10/08
TDW Review and revise motion for damages ;

review research regarding same
1 .00 hrs
07/11/08
DAB Compile fee petition in accordance with

Arbitrator Deane's ruling
9.30 hrs 185 , 00
1,720-50
5.20 hrs 260 .00
1,352.00
g'711 1lOS LCE Correspondence regarding availability of

nominal and punitive damages in default
context ; review correspondence identifying
the claims being asserted in arbitration
against Dr. Murtagh by Emory and Grady ;
continue drafting fact section of Emory's
motion for entry of monetary judgment on its
successful counterclaims in arbitration;
revise chart of legal fees for inclusion in
submission of fee petition to arbitrator in
compliance with June 23, 2008 decision ;
confer with D . Burger and T. Wozniak
regarding same
07/11/08 HRP Draft motion for fees, nominal damages and 5 .70 hrs
punitive damages ; analysis of Georgia law
35 0 . 00 350 .00
330 .00
1,881 .00
regarding availability of both in default

context
07/11/08
TDW Review and revise motion for damages and 1 .60 hrs
13-6-11 fees ; review and revise affidavit for
fee petition ; telephone conference with L.
Edelmann regarding same
350.00 560 .00
07/12/08 LCE Draft declaration of T . Wazuiak for 6 .10 hrs 260 .!0 1,586 .00
TDW:JS
Tax ID : 13-3613083
Green berg Traurig , LLP Attorneys at Law I The Forum j 3290 Norihside Parkway I Suite 400 j Atlanta, Georgia 30327
Te l 678 .5564141 FjMib&#0'$, 2Mwww.gt law. cam
APO - 499
Green bergTrau rig
Page
Invoice No .
File No .
2205390
1 02. 091 .01410 0
submission to arbitrator in support of

Emory's award of attorneys' fees and costs ;
continue drafting sections of Emory's motion
for monetary damages and finl judgment ;
research additional cases in support of same ;
continue revising time entries to support fees
petition ; confer with T . Wozniak regarding
particular attorney fees requests for work
related to contempt motion and hearing
185 .00 925 .00
07113!0$ DAB Review, analysis and selection of time

entries from August 2005 to the present
regarding our 13-6- 1 1 fee petition
5.00 his
07/13/08
LCE Revise and finalize declaration of T .

Wozniak for submission to arbitrator in
support of Emory's award of attorneys' fees
and costs; revise Emory's motion for
monetary damages and final judgment ;
research additional cases in support of same ;
finalize time entries to support fees petition ;
draft proposed orders on Emory's attorney
fees-award and request to withhold July 2008
settlement payment to set-off future award of
fees and expenses ; exchange correspondence
with H . Pace regarding pleading standard for
punitive damages
7.40 hrs 260 .00
1,924 .00
07/13/08
TDW Review and revise fee petition for sanctions

award ; review and revise motion for eutry of
monetary judgment
2.00 hrs X50 .00
700 .00
07114/08 DAB Conference with L . Edelmann regarding

filing of fee petition and additional
information required from Jones Day
regarding arbitration fees
0 .50 hrs
185 .00
111 .00
07/14/08
5 .70 hrs
260 .00
1,482 .00
LCE Identify additional costs and expenses to

submit to arbitrator in support of Emory's
TD W:JS
Tax ID : 13-3613083
Greenberg Traarig, LLP I Attorn ey s at Law I The Forum 13290 i Varthsi de Pa rkway I Suite 40 0 1 Atlanta, Geo rg i a 30327
Te l
www.gtlaw .co m
EPO- 500
M G reenbergTra u r ig
0
Page
Invoice No .
File No .
5
2205390
102041 .010100
award of attorneys' fees and confer with T .

Wozniak and T . Eichelburger regarding
same; compare fees and expenses requested
in forthcoming letter to Arbitrator Deane
regarding same to ensure no duplication in
awards ; finalize proposed order on Emory's
attorney fees award and proposed order
granting Emory's request to withhold July
2008 settlement payment to set off future
award of fees and expenses ; confer with T .
Wozniak regarding same and revisions to
Emory motion for monetary damages and
final judgment ; revise motion for monetary
damages and final judgment; exchange
correspondence with B . Morrison regarding
upcoming filings ; revise cover letter to
Arbitrator Deane setting forth Emory's
request to withhold July 2008 settlement
payment to set-off future award of fees and
expense ; confer with T . Jones of Jones Day
regarding billing rates for attorneys assigned
to Emory arbitration
07/14/08
260 .00
78 .00
3.90 hrs
350 .00
1,365 .00
3 . 80 hrs
185 . 00
703 . 00
BTL Review Murtagh's local counsel's motion to 0 .30 hrs

withdraw in preparation of drafting response
07d1 4r0$ TDW Revise fee petition for sanctions award ;

revise motion for monetary judgment ; revise
research regarding default judgment, punitive
damages and fee award
07/15/08
DAB Telephone conference with 13. Jones at Jones

Day regarding arbitration hourly fees from
200 through 2008; conference with L.
Edelmann regarding Jones Day invoices ;
review of arbitration invoices from 2005 to
the present ; review, analysis and calculations
to verify fee petition exhibit totals prior to
submission to Arbitrator Deane
'rnW:Ss
Tax ID: 13-36 13083
Green berg Traurig , LLP I Attorneys at Low I The Forum 1 3290 Norths lde Parkway ` Suite 400 1 Atlanta, Geo rgi a 30327
EPO- 501
Tel 678.55IM" I
$$1--2A4Wwu+w. gtiaw. wrrl
M Green bergTraurig
0
Page
6
File No . 102Q91 .0101 04
07/15/08
LCE Examine proposed revisions and comments

provided by B . Morrison on Emory's motion
for award of monetary judgment and final
judgment ; revise and finalize Emory's
motion for award of monetary judgment and
final judgment and exhibits in support of
same ; confer with D . Burger regarding
arbitration fees and amount to request in
Emory's fee petition; finalize letter to
Arbitrator Dune setting forth the amounts
requested in Emory's fee petition and
requesting that Emory be permitted to set off
the July 2008 settlement payment; calculate
amount of fees and costs owed by Murtagh
after set-offs and release of escrow and
include same in proposed order
4.80 hrs 260 .0 1,248.00
07/15/08 TDW Review and revise affidavit for sanctions fee

petition ; review and revise motion fo r
damages ; review Grady's fee petition
3.30 hrs 3 5 0. 00
07/21/08
BTL Review plaintiff s local counsel's motion to

withdraw ; research Georgia case law on
counsel's withdrawal ; draft opposition to
motion to withdraw
5.00 brs 260 .00 1,300 .00
07/22/08
LCE Examine court's order granting B . Bird's

motion to withdraw; confer with T . Wozaiak
regarding same
0.20 firs 260 .00 52 .00
07122/08'
BTL Draft Emory's opposition to plaintiff's local

counsel's motion to withdraw
3. 60 hrs 260 .00 936 .00
07/22/08
TDW Review court order on motion to withdraw
0.30 hrs 350 .00 105 .00
07/23/08 LCD Examine correspondence from B . Morrison

regarding upcoming escrow payment ;
conference call with R . Schmoll regarding
0.3 0 hrs
1,155 .00
260 .00 7 8 .00
Tvw:rs
Tax ID' 13-3613083
GreenbergTrau ri g , LLP I , 4ttameys at Law I T he F orum 13290 No rthside Pa rkway I S uite 4 00 1 Atlanta, Georgia 30327
Tel 678 .55&MOQJ IKa via&~68 ,WM ]www. gtla w.com
E PO- 502
M Green bergTraurig
0
Page
Invoice No .
File No.
2205390
102091 .0 1 Q1 fl0
need for Arbitrator Dea ne to irule on escrow

issue prior to July 25
07/24/08
TDW Review arbitrator's order regarding not

paying settlement amount into escrow ;
regarding same ; emails with plaintiffs
counsel and arbitrator regarding plaintiffs
counsel's request for reconsideration
1 . 10 n rs
07/28/08
LCE
0.4 0 hr s
Examine arbitrator's order on escrow

_ payments and subsequent clarification of
orders; review C. Culotta's objections to
arbitrator's order on escrow payments ; confer
with T,Wozniak regarding same and C .
Culotta's failure to identify local counsel in
this matter
3 50.00
3 85 . 00
260 .00 104 .00
is
Sub-total Fees : 28,906-00
Timekeeper Summary
Timekeeper
Hours
Todd D . Wozniak
17 .20
Lindsey C . Edelmann 34 .1
Brett T. Lane
8 .90
Hayden R. Pace 16 .3
Deb A . Burger 34 .20
TOTAL:
110 .70
Average Rate
Total
35UQ
260 .00
260 .00
330 .00
185 .00
6,020 .00
8,866 .00
2,314 .00
5,379 .40
6,327 .0
261 .12 $2 8 ,906.00

Expenses :
Facsimile Charges
Photocopy Charges
28,906.00
22.00
5.55
5,280.68
TDW : rs
Tax ID : 13-3613083
Greenberg Traurig, I .LP I Attorneys at Law I The Forum 13290 Northside Parkway I S uite 400 1 Atlanta, Georgi a 30327
Te1 6 7 8 .55&?~N EI lff#iSi@g,f8,b%j
.guaw , OOm
EPO503
~7_
M Green bergTrau ri g
Page
Invoice No .
File No .
828 .71
2205390
102491 .01010
6,135 .94
Sub-total ExpensesTotal Current Fees and Expenses :

35,042.94
144,489 .?9
TDW:JS
Tax ID : 13-3 6 13083
Green berg T raurig , L LP I Attorneys at L aw I The Foru m 1 3290 N orthside Parkway f Suite 4p4 I Atlanta, Georgia 30327
Tel 678. 65~QII www. gtl aw.cro m
E PO- 504
O r iginal Invoices
(11-18-08)
E PO- 505
mGreenbergTraurig
0
Page 1
Invoice No .
2239903
File No .
102091-010100
Bill Date September 18, 2008
Emory UzxiversityfEmary Healthcare, Inc .
1 O1 Administration Building
201 Dowman Drive

Attn: Elizabeth Clark-Morrison
Adv. James J. Murtagh, M .D . (Breach of Contract)
Legal Services thra uzh 4$13110$, :

.
Hours Rate Amount

48/DUOS LEE Review Dr. Murtagh's respanse in opposition
to Eznory's request to set -off July 2008
escrow payment and arbitrator's decis i on
awarding same ; confer with T. Eichelberger
regard ing potential response strategy
0.40 hrs 26 0.00 104 .00
08102108 TDW '
1 .00 hrs
Revi ew C. Culotta's opposition to request to

cease payments to escrow ; review appellate
issues raised in response
350 .00
350 .00
08/04/08
TDW Discuss defense strategy with B . Morrison
0.50 hrs 350 .00 17 .00
08/13/08
TDW .
0.40 hrs 350.00 140.00
08/14/08
TDW Review arbitrator's decision granting plaintiff

extension to respond to mot i on for damages
TDW : LZ
Tax ID : 13-3613083
Telephone conference w i th C . Culotta

regarding plaintiffs request for extension of
t im e to respond to moti on for judgment and
damages
0.40 hrs 350 .04 140.00
G re en erg Tnurig, LL P I Attorneys at Law I The Forum j 3 2 90 Northside Pa rkway I Suite 4 44 1 Atlanta, Ge org ia 30327
Tel 678,563 .210 01 Fax 6 78 . 5 53 .22 1 2 1 wvuw .gt Eaw.c vm
Origin a l Invoices
(11-18-08)
E PO- 506
mGreenbergTraurig
Page 2
File No .
102091 .010100
08/15/08 LCE Review Murtaglt's response in opposition to
Emory's petition for attorney fees and outli ne
arguments; review documents relied on by
Murtagh in support o f his claim that he has a
viable feder al whistle blower claim in this
litigation ; confer with T. Wozniak regarding
same ; examine Arbitrator's August 14, 2008
decision
1 .50 hrs 260.00
OS/15108 TDW Review plaintiffs response to sanctions fee

petition; telephone conference with T.
Eichelberger regarding same ; outline reply
arguments
2.90 hrs
350.00 1,015.00
08/18/08
LCE
conference with T . Wozniak regarding

strategy for reply brief on Emory's fee
petition
0 30 hrs
260 .00
08/18/08
TDW
Review emails between plaintiffs counsel

and arbitrator regarding extending deadlines
for plaintiff to respond to motion for
damages
0.40 hrs 35 0A0 140A0
08/21/08
ICB
Confer with Todd- Wozniak regarding

internet defamation legal issues and website
practices
0.40 his 735 .00 294.00
08/2 1/08
Tvw
Telephone conference with 1. Ballon

regarding strategy for dealing with web
posting regarding Emory and K . Alexander;
telephone conference with K. Alexander
regarding same
0.80 hrs 350 .00 280.00
08/22/08
LCE Analyze cases cited by Murtagh in response

in opposition to Emory's fee petition ; draft
Emory's reply in support of fee petition
6.30 hrs
260 .00
390.00
78.00
1,638 .00
08/22/08 TDW Identify companies who can cause "google 1 .60 hrs 350 .00 56D .00
TDW:LZ
Tax m : 13-3613083
Greenberg Trauri g, I.LP I Attorneys at Law I The

Tel 578 . 5 fA-ji
Forum 1 3290 Northside Parkway / S u ite

I www.gtE aw.com
400 1 Atlanta , Georgia
30327
E PO - 507
GreenbergTraurig
M
0.
Page
Invoice No .
File No .
3
2239903
12091 .010100
search hits" to be moved down priority list ;

telephone and email K . Alexander regarding
same; review plaintiffs response to fee
petition ; review and revise reply brief for
same; review cases cited by plaintiff
LCE Review Murtagh's response in opposition to 4 .80 bra
Emory's motion for damages and order of
final judgment ; draft Emory's consolidated
reply in support of fees petition and request
for damages
260 .00
1,248 .00
08/24/08 TDW Review plaintiffs response to Emory's

motion for damages award and select cases
cited therein ; outline reply arguments ;
meeting with L. Edelrnann regarding same
2 .30 hrs
350 .00
805 .00
0 8/25/08
5 .20 hrs 260 .00
1,3 52A0
08/24/08
LCE
Examine cases cited in Murtagh's response in

opposition to Emory's motion for damages
and order of final judgment; research cases in
support of Ernory's motion for damages ;
continue drafting Emory's consolidated reply
in support of fees petition and request for
damages
08!25/08 TDW Review plaintiffs response to motion for

damages
0.60 hrs 35 0.00 21 0.00
08/26/08
TDW Meeting with L . Edelmann regarding

arguments for consolidated reply brief;
review cases cited by plaintiff
1 .40 hrs
350 .00
490 .00
08/27/08
DAB Shepardize cases cited by plaintiff in his 0 .30 hrs

response to Emory's damages petition
185 .00
55 .50
08/27/08
LCE Review revised consolidated response in 0 .70 bra

support of Emory's July 15, 2008 fee petition
and motion for damages ; review comments
provided by B . Morrision on proposed brief
260 .00
182 .00
TDW :LZ
Tax ID : 13-3613453
Gresnberg Tra urig, LLP I A ttorneys at L aw I The F orum 13290 Northside Parkway I Suits 400 1 Atlanta, Georgia 3 0 3 27
. xnihwcwf*-1i-w I www.yraw.com
Tel s78
EPO- 508
GreenbergTraurig
E
Page
Invoice No .
4
2239903
File No . 102091 .010100
08/27/08
TDW Review and revise consolidated reply in

support of fee petition and motion for
damages ; review select portions of
Arbitrator's rulings and bearing transcripts ;
review follow-up research
2.20 hrs 35 0.00
770.00
08128108
DAB Review and proof reply brief
L10 hrs 185 .00 203 .50
08/28/08
TDW Revise consolidated reply to plaintiffs

responses to sanctions fee petition and
motion for damages
0 .70 hrs 3 50 .00 245 .00
08/29/08
DAB Complete cite checking reply brief
2.00 hrs 185 .00
08/29/08
TDW Revise reply in support of fee petition and

motion for damages ; telephone services
specializing in pushing down "Google hits"
1 .00 hrs 350 .00 350 .00
370 .00
Sub-total Fees : 11,5$5 .00
Timekeeper Summarv
Timekeeper Hours Average Rate
Total
735-00
Ian C . Balkan 0 .40
Todd D . Wozniak 16 .20 3517 .00
260 .00
Lindsey C. Edelmann 19 .20
185,00
Deb A. Burger 3 .40
294 .00
5,670 .00
4,992 .00
629 . 00
295 .54
$11,585 .00
TOTAL:
39 .20
Current Services Rendered : $

Expenses
:
Photocopy Charges .
11,585 .00
-7 .99
0.45
3,619 .97
TDW:LZ
Tax ID : 13-3613053
G raenberg 'Fraurig , LLP I Attorn eys at Law I The F o rum 13290 Narthslde parkway I Suite 400 1 Atia rs fa, Georgia 30327
Tel 678. 58
12 1 w nnv .gtlaw. cflm
nginaQi hvoices8(1 i "8-0 S)
EPO- 509
GreenbergTraurig
Page
Invoice No .
File No .
255 . 66
5
2239903
102U9 1 .01 Q100
3,868 .09
$
I5,453 .09
-35,042 .9
TDW :LZ
Tax ID : 13-3513 08 3
Greenberg Trauri g , LLP I Attorn eys at Law [ Th e Forum I 329D Northside Parkwa y / S u ite 400 1 Atlan ta, Georgia 30327
Tel 678.5 M4 VMNPO13'I%2W "nni.gtlaw .com
EPO - 510
L_ J
Original Invoices (11-18-08)
EPO- 51 1
Original Invoi ces (11-18-08)
E PO- 512
S G reenbergTraurig
Page
I
File No . 102091 .01010
Bill Date October 10, 2008
201 Dowman Drive
Adv. James J . Murtagh, M .D . (Breach of Contract)

.
.
0
Hours Rate Amount

09/02/p8 LCE Revise and finalize Emory's consolidated
reply in support of its fee petition and motion
for damages ; confer with T . Wozniak
regarding same and petition for fees under
O.C.G.A. 13-6-11 ; conference with T. Jones
regarding outstanding arbitration fees owed
by Emory; interview IT experts for methods
for mitigating damage to Emory arising from
Provocateur article ; prepare correspondence
to K. Alexander regarding same
5.50 hrs 260 .0 1,430 .00
09/02/08
1 .00 hrs 350 .00 350 .00
TDW Meeting with L. Edelmann regarding

damages proof, finalize consolidated reply in
support of fees and damages
09103/0$ DAB
Telephone conference with L . Edelmann

regarding fee invoices
0.10 hrs 185 .00 18 .50
09/03/08
Redact attorney-client information and fees
3.90 hrs
LCE
260 .00
1,014 .00
TDW :LZ
Tax ID : 13-3613083
Green b erg Traurig, LLP I Attorneys at Law I Th e For um 13290 N orthside Pa rkway (Suite 4001 Atlanta, Georgi a 30327
Tel 678.553 .2'E 00 ] Fax 678.553 .2212 1 www_g52w.com
Original I nvoices (11-18-08) APO- 513
M G reenbergTraurig
Page 2
File No . 10209 1 . 01 0100
associated solely with Murtagh's claims
against Emory from invoices dated from
September 2007 to the present date ;
exchange correspondence with T.
Eichelberger regarding Grady's failure to
timely pay arbitrator fees and expenses ;
confer with T . W ozniak and D . Burger
regarding petition for fees pursuant to
O .C .G .A . 13-6-11
09/03/08
TDW
Emails with T . Eichelberger regarding

Grady's payment of arbitrator's fees
0.40 hrs 350.00 140. 00
09/04I08 DAB Review of invoices for petition for fees

regarding damages
4.80 hrs 195 .00
09/04/08
2.60 ors 185 .00 481.00
DAB.
r
~ Edelmann
09/05/08 -
Review and revise invoices for petition for

fees regarding damages ; conference with L.
regarding same
88 8.40
DAB Review and analysis of King & Spalding and 4 .3Q hrs 1$S .OQ 795 .50
Greenberg Traurig invoices for attorney fees
. and costs regarding damages affidavit to be
filed by T . Wozniak; begin drafting affidavit
09/05/08
LCE Continue redacting invoices for attorney client information and fees related to
counterclaims to submit in support of fee
award pursuant to Emory's motion for
damages ; confer with D . Burger regarding
same
4.90 hrs 260 .00 1,274A0
09/06/08 L CE Prepare affidavit of T. Wozniak to support

fees requested under O .C.G.A . Section 9-11, 13 and compensatory damages associated
with Dr . Murtagh's fraudulent emails
1 .60 .Ts
.
260 .00
09/07/08
2.00 his
350.00 700.00
TDW Review and revise fee petition for damages
416 .00
motion
.10
TDW:LZ
Tax ID : 13-36 1 3083
Atlanta
Georgia 30327
G reen be rg Traurig , li.P I Attorneys at Law I The Foru m 1 3290 hf o rthside Parkway I Suite 400 / .
Tel 678.553,2100 ~ Fax 878. 53 .221 2 ( www.gtlaw. cam
Original I nvoices (11-18-08)
EPO- 514
m Green ber'gTraurig
0
Page 3
File No .
102091 .010100
is
09/08/08
DAB Review and calculation of invoice totals for

inclusion in fee petition for damages ;
creation of chart of invoices for use in
determining total amount to be recovered
from plaintiff regarding damages
2 .10 bra 185 .00 388 .50
09/08/08
LCE Revise affidavit of T. Wozniak in support of

Emory's motion for award of damages and
final judgment on counterclaims ; review
claims expenses and fees to ensure consistent
with those allowed for under O .C.G .A . 13-611
1 .80 hrs
260.00
09l08/08 TDW Revise letter regarding defamatory web

postings ; review and revise damages petition
1 . 50 hrs
350. 00 525 . 00
09109/08 CAB Conference with L . Edelmann and S .

McQueen regarding filing of additional
petition for damages ; review and revise
invoices for submission as exhibits to
affidavit of T . Wozniak ; draft
correspondence to Arbitrator Deane ;
calculation of invoice totals for damages
amounts
3 .80 kazs
1 85 .04 7 03.00
09/09/08
LCE Draft proposed order on Emory's motion for

award of damages and final judgment on
counterclaims ; revise cover letter to
arbitrator regarding Emor~s request for
attorneys fees and damages ; confer with T .
Wozniak regarding evidence in support of
fee petition
2. 1 0 hrs
260.00
09/09/08
TDW Revise affidavit for damages claim
0.90 brs
350 .00 315 .00
09/10/08
DAB Conference with L . Edelrmannn regarding

additional invoices for consideration and
inclusion with affidavit of T . Wozniak
6 .501rs
1 85 . 00 1 ,202 .5 0
468 .00
546.00
TDW :LZ
Tax ID : 13-3613083
Greenberg Traurig, LLP I Attorn eys at Law I The Forum f 3290 Northside Parkway I Suite 400 1 Atlanta, Georgia 30327
Tel 678.5brrlJitra~ ~ ~i~ces$( ~~~1~~j~ ww~rr.gUaw,com EPO- 515
M Green bergTraurig
0
Page
Invoice No .
File No .
4
2257019
1 0209 1 .010100
regarding damages; final calculations of

damages for fee petition ; conference with T.
Wozniak regarding filing of affidavit and
attachments; preparation of exhibits for
attachment to affidavit of T . Wozniak;
Telephone conference with T . Jones at Jones
Day regarding outstanding invoices for
arbitration fees and costs ; reconciliation of
Jones Day invoices and calculation of total
fees paid to the arbitrator
09J10148 LCE Telephone conference with T. Wozniak

regarding fee petition in support of Emory's
motion for award of damages and final
judgment on counterclaims ; review finaUed
letter to Arbitrator, proposed order, and
affidavit of T . Wozniak
1 .30 hrs 260 .00 338 .00
09110/0$
TDW Review and revise affidavit, proposed order

and fee petition on motion for damages
4.00 hrs 350 .00 1,400.00
09/16/08
TDW Review C . Culo tta's supplemental request for

a hearing on fees ; emails with B . ClarkMorrison regarding same
0.50 hrs 35 0.40
09/21/08
DAB Review plaintiffs claim that there are

discrepancies inn fee petitions ; review and
compare fee petition submitted duly 1 5, 2008
wwith fee petition submitted September 10,
2008 ; compile summary of all differences
6 .70 hrs 185 .00 1,239.50
09I22I08 DAB Preparation of fee petition documents and

memoranda regarding findings from review
ofthe fee petitions submitted to Arbitrator
Deane ; meeting with L. Edelmann regarding
same
09/22/08
I*'--
1 .90 hrs
TDW Review comparison of fee petitions 1 .20 hrs

regarding plaintiffs counsel's claim that there
175 .00
185 .00 351 .50
350 .00
TDW:L2
Tax ID : 13-3613083
Greenberg Tr2urig , LLP I Attorneys at Law I The Forum 1 3290 Norfhs ide Parkway I Suite 400 1 Atlanta, Georgia 30327
Tel 678 . 53. 21 DpI Fax 678 ,f5~~?~12 I www .g Haw. com
rEg i na Ihvoices ~ u }
E PA- 516
420.00
m GreenbergTraurig
Page
. S
2257019
Invoice No .
142091 .010100
File No .
are discrepancies between the two ; telephone
conference with B . Morrison regarding
potential hearing on fee petitions
40
Q9/23/08 LSE Telephone conference with T . Jones

regarding submission of payment of
arbitrator fees by all parties and status of
Murtagh's hearing request; review potential
inconsistencies between July 15 and
September r d fee petitions
0.90 hrs 260. 00 234 . 00
09/25/08
0. 8 0 hrs "350 .00 28 .00
TDB Telephone conference with B . ClarkMorrison regarding potential hearing on

damages and fees issues; revise letter to R .
Deane regarding same
0.50 hrs 260 .00
09/26/08
LCE Draft correspondence to Arbitrator Deane
responding to C . Culotta's request for
evidentiary hearing
09/26/08
130 .00
4.40 hrs 350,00 140.00
TDW Ernails with B . Clark-Morrisan and N.

McDonald regarding Dr . Murtagh reference
request
dub-total Fees : 16,363 .00
Timekeeper Stunmarv
Hours
Average Rate
Total
Todd D . Wozniak
12 .70
Lindsey C . Edelmann 22 .50
Deb A . Burger 32 .84
350 .00
260 .00
185 .00
4,445 .Q0
5,850 .00
6,068 .00
240 .63
$16,363 .00
Timekeeper
TOTAL :
68 .00
$ 16,363 .00
TDW : LZ
T ax ID: 13-3613083
Greenherg 7rau ri g , LLP j Attorneys at Law I The Forum 1 3290 Northside Parkway I Suite 400 1 Atlanta, Georg i a 30327
Tel s7sNA
99rt~o~`e %7~.z
I wwvv. gHaw. corrr
EPO- 517
mGreenbergTraurig
Page
Invoice No .
File No .
Expenses :
Photocopy Charges
2257019
102091 .010100
45.60
1,350 .76
84 .19
1,480 .55
Total Current Fees and Expenses: ~
17,843.55
Previous Balance (see attached statement) : $ 15,453 .09

Total Amount Due:
33,296.64
0'.00
F-1
LJ
TDW :LZ
Tax TD: 13-3613083
Greenberg Traurig, LLP I Attorneys at Law E The For um 13290 Northside Parkway I Suite 400 1 Manta, Georg i a 30327
Tet
wvrw , gt law.com
EPO - 51 8

Emory1 5

Enviado por

Dados do documento

Descrição original:

Título original

Direitos autorais

Formatos disponíveis

Compartilhar este documento

Compartilhar ou incorporar documento

Opções de compartilhamento

Você considera este documento útil?

Este conteúdo é inapropriado?

Direitos autorais:

Formatos disponíveis

Emory1 5

Enviado por

Direitos autorais:

Formatos disponíveis

Case 1:09-cv-01186-HTW Document 1-5 Filed 05/04/09 Page 1 of 57

exhibits and testimony clips for hearing ;

GB Creation of Trial director deposition database

2.60 hrs 200 .00 520.00

DAB Review internet postings for references to

04/23/08 TDW Review and revise outline for hearing

3.60 his 354,00

perjury, withheld documents, and spoliated

LCE Finalize withheld documents, spoliation, and

Conference with L. Edelmann and T .

Original Invoices (1i-18-O8~ APO-462

Case 1:09-cv-01186-HTW Document 1-5 Filed 05/04/09 Page 2 of 57

TDW Meeting with D, Burger and L. Ede3mann

04/25/08 DAB Preparation of exhibit binders for use at

150.00 1,125 .00

7.60 hrs 350.00 2,660 .00

04/25/08 LCE Continue preparing for hearing on sanctions 12 .30 hrs

260.00 3,198 .00

Case 1:09-cv-01186-HTW Document 1-5 Filed 05/04/09 Page 3 of 57

04125/08 DLS Preparation and duplication of exhibit CDs

04/25/08 TDW Review Dr . Murtagh`s witness and exhibit

A4/26f08 LCE Review hundreds of documents identified as

O4I26/08 TDW Review Dr . Murtagh's exhibits; review

2.80 his 350 .00

04/27/08 TOW Revise outline of arguments for hearing ;

6.20 his 350 . 00

Case 1:09-cv-01186-HTW Document 1-5 Filed 05/04/09 Page 4 of 57

04128108 DAB Review of internet postings ; review of

14.50 hrs 185 .00 2,682 .50

04/28I08 GF Research whether under Georgia law a court 3 .30 hrs

04128108 BTL Draft bench brief regarding authority for

10.30 hrs 260.00

BEM Index all Murtagh's deposition exhibits ;

LCE Preparation of cross-examination materials

Telephone conference with K . Alexander

5 .60 hrs 350 .00

Case 1:09-cv-01186-HTW Document 1-5 Filed 05/04/09 Page 5 of 57

DAB Complete summary of deposition

LCE Final preparation for hearing on Emory's

BTL Revise Emory's bench brief on authority for

04/29/08 BEM Prepare for sanctions hearing ; strategy 10 .00 hrs

R'I' Prepare index and witness exhibits in

TDW Final sanctions hearing preparation ;

9.30 hrs 350.00 3,255 .0

Research regarding Murtagh potential 4 .00 hrs

185 .00 777.00

Case 1:09-cv-01186-HTW Document 1-5 Filed 05/04/09 Page 6 of 57

0413010$ GB Set up of video presentation at arbitration

200.00 360 ,00

04/30/08 DAB Final preparations for sanctions hearing ;

a4l30I08 LCE Final preparation for and participation in

11 .50 hrs 260 .00 2,930 .04

04/30/08 TDW Attend sanctions hearing; meeting with T.

11 .20 hrs 350 .00

Sub-total Fees : 123,635 .00

Timekeeper Hours Average Rate

Current Services Rendered :

OngEnal Invoices X11-18-08}

Case 1:09-cv-01186-HTW Document 1-5 Filed 05/04/09 Page 7 of 57

Total Current Fees and Expenses :

Total payments & credits received since your last

Case 1:09-cv-01186-HTW Document 1-5 Filed 05/04/09 Page 8 of 57