Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Recommended Reading Consumer Deleveraging? LEI Revisions To Growth Visible Hand Of The Fed Economic Policy Uncertain Richmond Fed Survey Real Housing Recovery The Bond Bubble
401k Plan Manager No Change This Week Click Here For Current Model Allocation. Disclaimer & Contact Info.
Over Bought and Extremely Bullish One of the questions I received by email this past week was: Just how overbought is the market currently compared to previous bull market peaks? This is a great question. However, before I can answer it we need provide some basic background for context. Most investors fall into the trap of thinking that the market can move in one direction for an indefinite period of time. When markets are rising it is assumed they will never correct again and vice versa. The reality is that market prices, like the hound dog in the Foghorn Leghorn cartoons, are tied to a stake. The dog could chase Foghorn until he reached the end of his rope and then wham he was yanked back to earth.
The chart below shows the S&P 500 as it ranges between its run of rope. The boundaries, represented by the blue lines, are where the current price would be 2 standard deviations above, or below, the moving average, solid green line, which is our anchor point.
page 2
For those non-geeks reading this missive when prices reach 2-standard deviations above, or below, the average price, statistically that movement has encapsulated 95% of its normally distributed potential movement in that direction (34.1%+13.6% / 50% = 95.4%).
RECOMMENDED READING
Is The Consumer Deleveraging Really
The light blue shaded areas in the chart of the market above show when the S&P 500 has reached such EXTREMELY overbought levels AND is pushing 2-standard deviations above the mean. At the beginning of these shaded areas the market is pushing higher and exuberance is building in the market. The belief becomes that the market will not correct anytime soon. Of course, it is generally not too terribly long after the onset of such complacency that the market takes away a large bulk of the gains and provides a much better entry opportunity for patient investors. The next chart is the same chart as above but I have overlaid the Volatility Index to illustrate the extreme complacency that sets in just prior to the market correction.
LEI Revisions Show Slower Growth The Conference Board released the LEI index with a full set of backward revisions which showed that LEI has been growing slower than estimated since end of the last financial crisis.
The Visible Hand Of The Fed There is clear evidence that the recent market push is driven by the Federal Reserve.
page 3
As you can see during these periods of exuberance the Volatility Index has dropped to extremely low levels of fear. Today, the VIX is at the lowest level since 2007.
RECOMMENDED READING
COTD: Economic Policy Uncertainty The problem is that while market participants have become wildly bullish in recent weeks the economic data has continued to either remain weak or get worse.
COTD: Richmond Fed Survey The latest release of the Richmond Federal Reserve Manufacturing Survey showed little to excited about.
Real Housing Recovery Story While the belief was that the Government, and Fed's, interventions would ignite the housing market creating an self-perpetuating recovery in the economy - it did not turn out that way.
You will notice that the indicator WILL NOT get you out right at the top or in at the bottom. However, it does tell you when the trend has changed for, or against, you. Currently, the market is still on a longer term buy signal and remains a buy the dips market for now. However, it is the top part of the chart that is the most important. When this indicator has reached extreme overbought levels, as it is currently, it has signaled that the market was beginning to reach the potential peak for the current cycle. It doesnt mean that the market is about to imminently crash. This is a monthly chart so these topping processes can several months. Nonetheless, it is a warning sign that is juxtaposed to the many bullish analysts in the market right now predicting that we are entering into a new secular bull market we arent.
page 4
There are many similarities between the current market and previous market peaks. But the chart below shows the greatest similarity yet. This chart was featured in the article this past week entitled The Visible Hand Of The Fed.
As I stated then: It is clear that the visible hand of the Federal Reserve is firmly in control of the markets at the moment as liquidity flows are increased. However, extrapolating the current advance indefinitely into the future becomes somewhat dangerous. Each previous program cycle has ended with a fairly nasty decline, in both the markets and the economy, as the fundamental drivers were being supported solely by artificial interventions. Those declines would have likely been far worse had they not been halted by the next round of liquidity injected goodness. While the Fed programs that we have witnessed since the financial crisis are historically unique - liquidity driven markets are not. We have witnessed the effects of excess liquidity in the bull market cycle prior to the 2008 financial crisis. The only difference during that cycle was that, through government intervention, real estate was turned into an ATM allowing mortgage equity withdrawals to be the liquidity source for the economy and the markets. The chart below shows the extremely high correlation between these two bull market cycles. There are many similarities between the peak of the market in 2008 and today. Investor sentiment is pushing extreme levels, the markets are exceedingly overbought, earnings are weakening, complacency is higher, multiples are expanding, the consumer is beginning to sputter and headlines are beginning to push the boundaries of manic optimism. One doesn't haven't to think back too far to remember that at the peak of the markets in 2008 there was no recession in sight, even though it had already started, as it was a goldilocks economy. Earnings were expected to continue to grow into the coming year and equities were the only investment of choice. Come to think of it - that is what we heard in 1999 as well.
page 5
Historically, when this ratio has reached the extreme levels that are currently present it has been coincident with a market peak. Currently, as shown with the stock market above, the ratio is pushing 2-standard deviations of its mean as investors sell bonds to buy stocks. Of course, this is exactly the emotionally driven behavior that you would expect to see for average individuals that get sucked into to panic buying market peaks and selling market bottoms. The chart on the next page inverts the ratio above to bonds versus stocks. This creates a clearer buy/sell indicator. When the lower indicator reaches extremely oversold conditions the SELL indication is given when it turns sharply up. While the indicator would have gotten you out very early in 2011, leaving you to be regularly chastised for such stupidity by the media for next several months, it would have saved you from the near 20% plunge that following summer. The same held true this past September as QE3 was introduced. Conversely, when this indicator peaks and turns back down that has given a clear buy indication as well.
page 6
Fact: Yes, occasionally, a stock will have a massive comeback from its 52-week lows. These are the exceptions and not the rule. Rule: Dont buy bounces of bottoms until trends confirm a return to sustained positive price action. This will be when they hit a new 52week high following a proper basing process. Fact: Only 1 in 4 stocks outperform the S & P 500 during their life time. The biggest winners spend the majority of their time on the 52week high list. Rule: These are the stocks that you generally want to focus on buying. However, all trends end and generally when there seems to be nothing in the world to stop it. AAPL is the most recent example. Fact: Tops are clear only in hindsight. Rule: As shown in the charts above the market usually gives plenty of signs of a trend change and enough time to exit. You just have to be willing to pay attention and set aside the greed factor. Fact: Not every breakout to a new 52-week high is a valid buy signal. Only the ones from proper technical setups are. Rule: Pay attention to the details and not the media hype. Successful trading, you are not an investor, requires attention to details and the flexibility to move when necessary.
STREETTALK ADVISORS
What makes us different? Its really pretty simple. We believe that managing risk is the key to long term success. Conserve the principal and the rest will take care of itself. Risk = Loss Seems like a simple concept yet most people take way too much risk in their portfolio which is fine as long as the market goes up. The problem comes when it doesnt. Managed Risk = Returns By applying varying levels of risk management to a portfolio of assets the potential for large drawdowns of capital is reduced thereby allowing the portfolio to accumulate returns over time. Total Return Investing We believe that portfolio should be designed for more than just capital appreciation. There are times when markets do not rise. During those periods we want income from dividends and interest to be supporting the portfolio. If you are ready for something different then you are ready for common sense approach to investing.
Let me repeat that last part. Despite what you think, or what you are told, you are NOT AN INVESTOR. You are a speculator, a trader, who buys electronic pieces of paper in a company that you neither have control or real knowledge in order to sell those electronic pieces of paper at a higher price than where you bought them. Thats it. Everything else is Wall Street marketing machine enticing you to keep you money invested for the long term while they trade all around you at your expense. If you dont believe that previous paragraph look at your annual profits versus those of the major banks. The Wall Street Casino is a huge business, and very much like going to Las Vegas, you either learn to play by the rules or you become part of the profit margin. The market is extremely over bought, extremely bullish and much overvalued. A correction is coming. It is just a matter of time and will likely be bigger than you can currently imagine. While I am NOT recommending that you sell everything you own on Monday and go hide into cash I am suggesting that the risk is rising. As stated above the market will give us plenty of time to liquidate our positions and move to cash the only question is whether, or not, you will be paying attention. Have a great weekend. Lance Roberts
page 8
page 9
STREETTALK ADVISORS
Lance Roberts Director of Fundamental & Economic Analysis Michael Smith Director of Alternative Investments Luke Patterson Chief Investment Officer Hope Edick Compliance Officer Leah Miller Operations Manager Lynette Lalanne General Partner Streettalk Insurance Office Location One CityCentre 800 Town & Country Blvd. Suite 410 Houston, TX 77024 Tel: 281-822-8800 Web Sites www.streettalkadvisors.com
FOR APPOINTMENTS
Brooke Sanders fis@streettalkadvisors.com
page 10