Dr.

Orly Taitz, ESQ

fn her capacify

as the President

of

Defend Our Freedoms Foundation

29839 Santa Margarita Parkway, STE 100

Rancho Santa Margarita CA 92688

Tel: (949) 683-5411; Fax (949) 766-76:03

E-Mail : d r taitz@yahoo.com, orly .taitz@gmail.com

IINITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA

Dr. ORLY TAITZ, ESQ, PRO

SE

$ $

Plaintiff, Y.S

Patrick Donahoe, Postmaster

David C. Williamso Inspector

General,

General

$
S

for the United States Postal

Service

Respondent
T

aitz v Donahoe Complaint

APPEAL OF THE DE FACTO DENIAL OF INFORMATION AND

PRODUCTION OF RECORDS UNDER FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT sUSC 552 PARTIES
Dr. Orly Taitz, ESQ President of Defend our Freedoms Foundation-plaintiff

Kevin Donahoe, Defendant, is sued in his official capacity as a Postmaster

General

David, C. Williams, Defendant, is sued in his official capacity as an Inspector

General of USPS

JURISDICTION
Defendants represent Federal agency and are sued under the Federal statute 5USC 552

ALLEGATIONS
1.

A year ago, on June 20, 2AI2, Dr. Orly Taitz, ESQ, President of Defend Our

Freedoms Foundation (DOFF), hereinafter "Taitz", submitted

to the

Postmaster

General and the Inspector General for the USPS a criminal complaint. Exhibits B
and C.

2.Inher complaint Taitz provided a sworn affidavit of Chief Investigator of the

Special Investigations Unit of the U.S. Coast Guard, Jeffrey Stephan Coffman,

attesting to the fact that Barack Obama used

Taitz v Donahoe Complaint

forged Selective Service

Registration which contained a fabricated 1980 cancellation USPS stamp. Forgery

was flagrant, as the stamp has "1980" is a four digit year, made as a one piece. The

stamp affixed to Obama's forged Selective Service (SSS) registration contained a

two digit year cancellation stamp. Taitz also provided a report of the

press

conference by Sheriff Arpaio of Maricopa County, AZ, which confirmed that the
stamp on Obama's SSS, was a forged/fabricated stamp. The article showed in detail

how forger used 2008 stamp, cut the year "2008" in hall used "08" and placed it
upside down as "80",

to show that Obama registered for the Selective service in

1980. Forger funher blocked the top part of the "80", as the bottom loop of "8" is

larger , than the top loop, so the forger blocked a pffit of the loop on the top to
make it look more authentic, less like a forgery.

3. For a period of a year Taitz did not receive any response in regards to her complaint, which was received by the Postmaster General and the Inspector
general of USPS by certified mail.

4.Taitz filed a Freedom of Information request seeking a response,

as to what

was done in regards to her complaint. FOIA 5 US552 requests for information
have to be answered within 20 days. Taitz did not receive any information. In light

of no information for a year, such lack of response is akin to a refusal by the

Federal agency to provide information. As such Taitz is seeking an appeal of such refusal. Taitz v Donahoe Complaint
a .'

5USC 552 states

(a) Each agency shall make available to the public information as follows:

(1) Each agency shall separately state and currently publish in the
Register for the guidance of the

Federal

public-

(A) descriptions of its central and field orgarization and the established places
at which, the employees (and in the case of a uniformed service, the members) from whom, and the methods whereby, the public may obtain information, make
submittals or requests, or obtain decisions;

(B) statements of the general course and method by which its functions are
channeled and determined, including the nature and requirements of all formal and

informal procedures available;

(C) rules of procedure, descriptions of forms available or the places at which

forms may be obtained, and instructions as to the scope and contents of all papers,
reports, or examinations;

(D) substantive rules of general applicability adopted as authorized by law, and

statements of general policy or interpretations and adopted by the agency; and

of general applicability formulated

(E) each amendment, revision, or repeal of the foregoing.

T aitz

v Donahoe Complaint

Except to the extent that a person has actual and timely notice of the terms thereof, a person may not in any manner be required to resort to, or be adversely affected by, u matter required to be published in the Federal Register and not so published. For the purpose of this paragraph, matter reasonably available to the
class of persons affected thereby is deemed published in the Federal Register when

incorporated by reference therein with the approval of the Director of the Federal
Register.

(2) Each agency, in accordance with published rules, shall make available for
public inspection and copying-

(A) final opinions, including concurring

orders, made in the adjudication of cases;

and dissenting opinions, as

well

as

(B) those statements of policy and interpretations which have been adopted by
the agency and are not published in the Federal Register;

(C) administrative staff manuals and instructions to staff that affect a member
of the public;

(D) copies of all records, regardless of form or format, which have been
released

to any person under paragraph (3) and which,

because

of the nature of

their subject matter, the agency determines have become or are likely to become
the subject of subsequent requests for substantially the same records; and

(E) a general index of the records referred to under subparagraph (D);

Taitz v Donahoe Complaint

unless the materials are promptly published and copies offered

for sale. For

records created on or after November 7,7996, within one year after such date, each

agency shall make such records available, including

telecommunications or,

by

computer

if

computer telecommunications means have not been

established by the agency, by other electronic means. To the extent required to

prevent a clearly unwarranted invasion of personal privacy, ?n agency may delete

identifuing details when it makes available or publishes an opinion, statement of policy, interpretation, staff manual, instruction, or copies of records referred to in
subparagraph (D). However, in each case the justification for the deletion shall be

explained fully in writing, and the extent of such deletion shall be indicated on the

portion of the record which is made available or published, unless including that indication would harm an interest protected by the exemption in subsection (b)
under which the deletion is made.

If technically feasible, the extent of the deletion

shall be indicated at the place in the record where the deletion was made. Each
agency shall also maintain and make available for public inspection and copying

current indexes providing identi$ing information for the public as to any matter
issued, adopted, or promulgated after July

4, 1967, and required by this paragraph

to be made available or published. Each agency shall promptly publish, quarterly or more frequently, and distribute (by sale or otherwise) copies of each index or
supplements thereto unless it determines by order published in the Federal Register
T aitz v Donahoe Complaint

that the publication would be unnecessary and impracticable, in which case the
agency shall nonetheless provide copies

of such index on request at a cost not to

exceed the direct cost of duplication. Each agency shall make the index referred to

in subparagraph (E) available by computer telecommunications by December

1999.

31,

A final order, opinion,

statement of policy, interpretation, or staff manual or

instruction that affects a member of the public may be relied on, used, or cited as
precedent by an agency against aparty other than an agency only

if-

(i) it has been indexed and either made available or published as provided by
this paragraph; or

(ii) the pariry has actual

(3)

and timely notice of the terms thereof.

(A) Except with respect to the records made available under paragraphs (1) and (2) of this subsection, and except as provided in subparagraph (E), each agency,
upon any request for records which

(i) reasonably describes such records and

(ii) is made in accordance with published rules stating the time, place, fees (if
any), and procedures to be followed, shall make the records promptly available to
any person.

(B) In making any record available to a person under this paragraph, an agency
shall provide the record in any form or format requested by the person if the record Taitz v Donahoe Complaint

is readily reproducible by the agency in that form or format. Each agency shall
make reasonable efforts

to

maintain its records

in forms or formats that are

reproducible for purposes of this section.

(C) In responding under this paragraph to a request for records, an agency shall make reasonable efforts to search for the records in electronic form or format,
except when such efforts would significantly interfere with the operation of the agency's automated information system.

(D) For purposes of this paragraph, the term "search" means to

review,

manually or by automated means, agency records for the purpose of locating those
records which are responsive to a request.

(E) An agenay, or part of an agency, that is an element of the intelligence

community (as that term is defined in section 3(a) of the National Security Act of
1947 (5Q U.S.C
paragraph

40Ia (O)) tt1 shall not make any record available under this

tocommonwealth, or

(i) any government entity, other than a State, territory,

district of the United States, or any subdivision thereof; or

(ii) a representative of a government entity described in clause (i).

(4)

(A)

Taitz v Donahoe Complaint

(i) In

order

to carry out the provisions of this

section, each agency shall

promulgate regulations, pursuant

to notice and receipt of public comment,

specif ing the schedule of fees applicable to the processing of requests under this
section and establishing procedures and guidelines for determining when such fees should be waived or reduced. Such schedule shall conform to the guidelines which

shall be promulgated, pursuant to notice and receipt of public comment, by the Director of the Office of Management and Budget and which shall provide for a
uniform schedule of fees for all agencies.

(ii) Such agency regulations

shall provide

that-

(I)

fees shall be limited to reasonable standard charges for document search,

duplication, and review, when records are requested for commercial use;

(II) fees shall be limited to reasonable

standard charges

for

document

duplication when records are not sought for commercial use and the request is
made by an educational or noncommercial scientific institution, whose purpose is scholarly or scientific research; or a representative of the news media; and

(III) for any request not described in (I) or (II),

fees shall be limited to

reasonable standard charges for document search and duplication.

In this clause, the term "a representative of the news media" means any person or entity that gathers information of potential interest to a segment of the public,
uses its editorial skills to turn the raw materials into a distinct work, and distributes

Taitz v Donahoe Complaint

that work to an audience. In this clause, the term "news" means information that is about current events or that would be of current interest to the public. Examples

of

news-media entities are television or radio stations broadcasting to the public at

large and publishers

disseminators

of

periodicals (but only

if

such entities qualify

as

of o'news") who make their products available for purchase by or

subscription by or free distribution to the general public. These examples are not

all-inclusive. Moreover, as methods of news delivery evolve (for example, the

adoption of the electronic dissemination of newspapers

through

telecommunications services), such alternative media shall be considered to be news-media entities. news-media entity

A freelance journalist shall be regarded

as working for a

if the journalist can demonstrate a solid basis for expecting

publication through that entity, whether or not the journalist is actually employed

by the entity. A publication contract would present a solid basis for such an
expectation; the Government may also consider the past publication record of the
requester in making such a determination.

(iii)

Documents shall be furnished without any charge or at a charge reduced

below the fees established under clause (ii) if disclosure of the information is in the

public interest because

it is likely to

contribute significantly

to public

understanding of the operations or activities of the govemment and is not primarily

in the commercial interest of the requester.

Taitz v Donahoe Complaint
10

(iv) Fee schedules shall provide for the recovery of only the direct costs of
search, duplication,

or review. Review costs shall include only the direct costs

incurred during the initial examination

of a document for the purposes of

determining whether the documents must be disclosed under this section and for

the purposes of withholding any portions exempt from disclosure under this
section. Review costs may not include any costs incurred in resolving issues of law

or policy that may be raised in the course of processing a request under this
section. No fee may be charged by any agency under this

section-

(I) if the costs of routine collection and processing of the fee are likely to equal
or exceed the amount of the fee; or

(II) for any request described in clause (ii) (ID or (III) of this subparagraph for
the first two hours of search time or for the first one hundred pages of duplication.

(v) No agency may require advance payment of any fee unless the requester has
previously failed to pay fees in a timely fashion, or the agency has determined that
the fee

will

exceed $250.

(vi) Nothing in this

subparagraph shall supersede fees chargeable under a

statute specifically providing

records.

for setting the level of fees for particular types of

Taitz v Donahoe Complaint

1t

(vii) In any action by a requester regarding the waiver of fees under this section,
the court shall determine the matter de novo: Provided, That the court's review
the matter shall be limited to the record before the agency.

of

(viii) An agency shall not assess

described under clause

search fees

(or in the case of a requester

(ii)[D, duplication

fees) under this subparagraph

if the

agency fails to comply with any time

limit under paragraph (6), if no unusual or

exceptional circumstances (as those terms are defined for purposes of paragraphs

(6XB) and (C), respectively) apply to the processing of the request.

(B) On complaint, the district court of the United States in the district in which
the complainant resides, or has his principal place of business, or in which the
agency records are situated, or in the District

of Columbia, has jurisdiction

to

enjoin the agency from withholding agency records and to order the production of
any agency records improperly withheld from the complainant. In such a case the

court shall determine the matter de novo, and may examine the contents of such
agency records

in camera to determine whether such records or any part thereof

shall be withheld under any of the exemptions set forth in subsection (b) of this
section, and the burden is on the agency

to sustain its action. In addition to any

other maffers to which a court accords substantial weight, a court shall accord substantial weight

to an affidavit of an agency concerning the agency's

T aitz v Donahoe Complaint

t2

determination as to technical feasibility under paragraph (2)(C) and subsection (b)

and reproducibility under paragraph (3 XB).

(C) Notwithstanding any other provision of law, the defendant shall serve an
answer or otherwise plead to any complaint made under this subsection within

thirty days after service upon the defendant of the pleading in which
complaint is made, unless the court otherwise directs for good cause shown.

such

[(D) Repealed. Pub. L. 98-620, title IV, $ 402(2),Nov. 8, 1984,98 Stat. 3357.]
(E)

(i) The court may

assess against the United States reasonable attomey fees and

other litigation costs reasonably incurred in any case under this section in which
the complainant has substantially prevailed.

(ii) For purposes of this subparagraph, if the complainant

a complainant has substantially prevailed

has obtained relief through

either-

(I) a judicial order, or an enforceable written agreement or consent decree; or

(II) a voluntary or unilateral

change

in position by the agency, if

the

complainant's claim is not insubstantial. (F)

(i)

Whenever the court orders the production

of any agency records improperly

withheld from the complainant and assesses against the United States reasonable
attorney fees and other litigation costso and the court additionally issues a written

Taitz v Donahoe Complaint

13

finding that the circumstances sulrounding the withholding raise questions whether
agency personnel acted arbitrarily or capriciously with respect to the withholding,

the Special Counsel shall promptly initiate a proceeding to determine whether

disciplinary action is warranted against the officer or employee who was primarily responsible

for the withholding. The Special Counsel, after investigation

and

consideration

of the evidence

submitted, shall submit

his findings and

recommendations to the administrative authority of the agency concerned and shall

send copies of the findings and recommendations to the officer or employee or his representative. The administrative authority shall take the corrective action that the Special Counsel recommends.

(ii) The Attorney General shall(I) notify the Special Counsel of each civil action described under the first sentence
of clause (i); and

(II) arxrually submit

preceding year.

a report

to Congress on the number of such civil actions in the

(iii) The Special Counsel shall annually submit

taken by the Special Counsel under clause (i).

a report to Congress on the actions

(G) In the event of noncompliance with the order of the court, the district court
may punish for contempt the responsible employee, and in the case of a uniformed
service, the responsible member.
T aitz

v Donahoe Complaint

l4

(5) Each agency having more than one member shall maintain and make available

for public inspection a record of the final votes of each member in every agency
proceeding.

Agency wrongfully withheld information in relation to any actions by the

agency in response to the criminal complaint by Taitz.

Per 5 USC 552 the burden is on the agency and the response is required within 30 days of the service of the appeal.

As such Taitz is seeking any and all records from the Postmaster General and the Inspector General for the USPS in relation to evidence provided by Taitz,
showing that Barack Hussein Obama currently occupying the position of the U.S.

President used

fabricated Selective service Certificate

with a

fabricated

cancellation USPS stamp.

This is the most irnportant matter of the U.S. National secuity, matter of public
concern and should be investigated expeditiously.

CONCLUSION

1. USDC should invalidated the refusal by the Postmaster General

and

Inspector general for USPS to provide information and should order them to

Taitz v Donahoe Complaint

15

provide any and oral information, as to what steps were taken in response to the
complaint filed by Attorney Taitz

2. Due to the fact that the individual using a forged Selective

service

registration and the fabricated USPS stamp is currently usurping the position of the

U.S. President this matter is the number one matter of the U.S. National security
and has to be expedited. An expedited hearing on the matter should be help within 20 days.

3. Attomey for DOFF Taitz should receive reasonable compensation for the
time spend on investigation and litigation of this matter.

4. Court should order any other relief that this court deems proper and just.
/
'?" ''l'-?' ' /e/c'r

lsl Dr. Orly Taitz, ESQ

President of the Defend Our Freedoms Foundation

aitzv Donahoe Complaint

t6

AO 440 (Rev. 06/12) Summons in

Civil Action

Umrpo Srerps Drsrnrcr CouRT

for the

DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA
DR. ORLY TAITZ, ESQ, IN HER CAPACITYAS THE PRESIDENT IF DEFEND OUR FREEDOMS FOUNDATION
Plaintiff(s)

CivilAction No.
PATRICK DONAHOE IN HIS CAPACITYAS POSTMASTER GENERAL, DAVID WILLIAMS IN HIS CAPACITY AS INSPECTOR GENERAL OF THE USPS
Defendant(s)

SUMMONS IN A CIVIL ACTION

To:
(Defendant's name and address)

PATRICK DONAHOE IN HIS CAPACITY AS POSTMASTER GENERAL 475 L'ENFANT PLAZA SW WASHINGTON DC 20260

A lawsuit has been filed against you.

Within

2l

days after service of this summons on you (not counting the day you received it)

the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. The answer or motion must be served on the plaintiff or whose name and address are: ORLY TAITZ, ESe

are the United States or a United States agency, or an officer or employee of the United States described in Fed. R. Civ. P. 12 (a)(2) or (3) you must serve on the plaintiff an answer to the attached complaint or a motion under Rule 12 of

or 60 days if you

plaintiff s attomey,

29839 SANTA MARGARITA, STE 1OO RANCHO SANTA MARGARITA, CA 92688

lf you fail to respond, judgment by default will be entered against you for the relief demanded in the complaint. You also must file your answer or motion with the court.

CLERK OF COURT

Date:

071o1t2013
Signature of Clerk or Deputy Clerk

AO 440 (Rev. 06/12) Summons in a Civil Action (Page 2)

Civil Action No.

PROOF OF SERVICE (This section should not be Jiled with the court unless required by Fed
This summons for
fuame of individual andtitte,

Civ. P. a

Q)

if any)

was received by me on (date)

il
f,

I personally served the summons on the individual at (place)

on (date)

;or
(name)

I left the summons at the individual's residence or usual place of abodewith

, a person of suitable age and discretion who resides there,

on (date)

, and

mailed a copy to the individual's last known address; or

, who is
(name oforganization)

I served the summons on (name

of individual)

designated by law to accept service ofprocess on behalfof

on (dnte)

;or ;or

I returned the summons unexecuted because

Other (specifu):

il

My fees are $

for travel and $

for services, for a total of

0.00

I declare under penalty of perjury that this information is true.

Date:
Semer's signature

Printed name and title

Server's address

Additional information regarding attempted service, etc:

AO 440 (Rev.06/12) Summons in a Civil Action

UMrEo SrarBS DTsrruCT

for the

COURT

DISTRICTOF COLUMBIA
DR. ORLY TAITZ, ESQ, IN HER CAPACITY AS THE PRESIDENT IF DEFEND OUR FREEDOMS FOUNDATION
Plaintif(s)

)
) ) ) )

PATRICK DONAHOE IN HIS POSTMASTER GENERAL, DAVID WILLIAMS HIS CAPACITY AS INSPECTOR GENERAL OF THE USPS
Defendant(s)

CAPACIryAS IN

]
) )

ciur ActionNo.

SUMMONS TN A CIVIL ACTION

To'. (Defendant's name and address)

DAVID, WILLIAMS INSPECTOR GENERAL OF THE USPS 1735 N. LYNN STR. STE lOOOO ARLINGTON ,VA22209

A lawsuit has been filed against you.

or 60 days if you days after service of this summons on you (not counting the day you received it) are the United States or a United States agency, or an officer or employee of the United States described in Fed. R. Civ. you must serve on the plaintiff an answer to the attached complaint or a motion under Rule l2 of P.12 (a)(2\ or (3) the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. The answer or motion must be served on the plaintiff or plaintifls attorney, whose name and address are: ORLY TAITZ, ESQ

Within

2l

29839 SANTA MARGARITA, STE 1OO RANCHO SANTA MARGARITA, CA 92688

If you fail to respond, judgment by default will be entered against you for the relief demanded in the complaint. You also must file your answer or motion with the court.

CLERKOF COURT

Date:

O7lO1l2O13
Signature of Clerk or Deputy Clerk

AO

2140

(Rev. 06/12) Summons in a Civil Action (Page 2)

Civil Action No. PROOF OF SERVICE

(This section should not beliled with the court unless required by Fed This summons for
(name of individual and title,

Civ. P. a

Q)

if any)

was received bY me on (date)

il

I personally served the summons on the individual at

(place)

on

(date)

;or
(name)

D I left the summons at the individual's residence or usual place of abodewith

on (date)

, a person ofsuitable age and discretion who resides there, , and mailed a copy to the individual's last known address; or

D I served

the summons on

(nome of individual) (name oforganization)

, who is

designated by law to accept service ofprocess on behalfof

on

(date)

;or ;or

il fl

I retumed the summons unexecuted because

Other (specfu):

My fees are $

for travel and $

for services, for atotal

of$

0.00

I declare under penalty of perjury that this information is true.

Date:
Server's signature

Printed name and title

Semer's address

Additional information regarding attempted service, etc:

JS44 (Rev. l2l12)

CIVIL COVER SHEET

DEFENDANTS
Patric Donahoe, in his capacity as Postmaster General, David Williams in his capacity as lnspector General of the USPS
County of Residence of First Listed
(t N
Lr.

providedbylocalrulesolcourt. Thisfbrm,approvedbytheJudicialConfi:renceoftheUnitedStatesinSeptemberl9T4,isrequiredfortheuseoftheClerkofCourtfbrthe purposeofinitiatingthccivildocketsheet. (SF:t': INSIRlJC'IIoNSoNNDXTPAGEoFTHISI'ORtul.)

I. (a) PLAINTIFFS

Dr. Orly Taitz, ESQ, in her capacity as president of Defend Our Freedoms Foundation

(b)

County of Residence of First Listed

(EX(.-El'T

Plaintifi

Orange COUnty. CA

Defendant lrya5b$Slgn
r Nlr r' F' .ASL: S ONLY)

!C

IN

LLS.

PI"AINTIItt (:ASES)

s.

P r.4

NOTE: IN LAND

T}IE TRACT OF LAND INVOLVED.

(IJ

CONDEMNATION

CASES, USE THE LOCATION OF

(C)

Attorneys (Firm Name, Atldress, andTelephone Number)

Attorneys

Knovn)

II. BASIS OF JURISDICTION p'tu."on "x" inoneBoxonb,) n3 Federal Question DI U.S. Govemrrenl
PIaintiff
({/.5. Government Not a

III. CITIZENSHIP OF PRINCIPAL PARTIES

(l.or Ditersity
Case.\ Onl)))

(Ptace qn

"x"

in one Rox Jbr Ptaint{J

and One Box.fitr Delbndant)

I'ar\,

CitizenofThisState
Crtizen ofAnother

P'IF D I

DEF

C
O

Incorporated or Pdncipal ofBusiness In This State

Place

PTF J 4 n 5 D 6

DEF

J
O

X2

U.s. GoYemment Defendmt

a4

Diversity (Indicate Cittzewhip

Stat

J 2

IncorporatedardhincipalPlace
ofBtrsiness In Another State
3

oJ

Pyties in lten I[])

CitizenorSubjectofa D3

tl

ForeignNation

f,

IV. NATURE OF SUIT

O I l0 Insurace

in One Rox

D
O O D

120 130 140

Muine Miller Act

D
D

Negotiable Inshument 150 Recovery of Overpa)'ment & Enforcement of Judgment l5l Medicre Act 152 Recovery of Defaulted
Student Loans (Exchdes Vterans) I 53 Recovery of Overpayment

D
O

of Vctcril's Berefits 160 Stockholders' Suits

195 Contract Product 196 Frechise

ofPrope*y 21 USC 88 I D 365Personallnjury 3l0Airplane l-I 690 Other Product Liability D 315 Airylme Product Liabiliry D 367 Healdr Cae/ Phamaceutical il 320 Assaslt Libel & Personal Iniury Slander D330FederalEmployers' ProductLjability .l 368 Asbestos Personal Liabiliq, InjuryProduct O 340Maine Liability D 345 N'luine Product PERSONAL PROPERTY D 710 Fair Labor Standads Liabiliff Act D 350MotorVehicle 0 3T0OtherFraud O 371 Truth in l"ending D 720 Labor^.{aragement fl 355 Motor Vehicle

PERSONALINJURY

PERSONALINJURY

625 Drug Related Seiare

D D

422 Appeal 28 USC 158 423 Widrdrawal 28 USC 157

3
D

375 False Claim Act 400 State Reapportiomrent

il

4l0Antitrust
-130

O D
830 Patent 840 Trademark

A 0 il

Bants md Barking

450 Comerce 460 Deportation 470 Racketeer Influenced md

fI
D D
O

D
O
861 862 863 864 865

Compt Orgmizations Consmer Credit 490CablelSatTV

.180

HrA (l39sfir)
Black

D D D il X
O

850 Securities/Comodities./

Lug

(923) 890 891 893 895

Exchilge
Other Statutory Actions

D l90OthsContact

I 3

Liability

Personal Injury D 362 Pwsonal Injur5,O

360 Other

ProductLiability D
D

380OtherPersonal
Properry Dmage 385 hoperty Damage Product Liability

D D

il
D

Relations 740 Railway Labor Act 751 Furily mdMedical Leave Act 790 Other Labor Litigation 791 Employee Retirernmt Income Securi4r Act

DIwC/DIww (40s(g)) SSID Tide XW

RSI (405(g))

Agricultual Acts Enviromental Matters Freedom of Infornation

Act

896 Arbitratian 899 Administrative Proceduc

D
870 Taxcs (U.S. Plaintiff or Defbndant) 871 IRS Third Party 26 USC 7609

D 210

Lild

Condemnation

220 D 230 D 240 D 245 290

Foreclosue
Rent Lease & Ejectment

O D

Torts to Lild Tort Product Liability

0
tr

All

Other ReaI Propedy

Habeas Corp6: 440 Other Civil Rights D 463 Alien Detaiuee 441 !-oting D 5 I 0 l\{otions to Vacate 442 Rnploynent Sentence 443 Housing/ D 530 General Accommodations 445 Amer. w,Disabilities - o 535 Death Petralty

Act/Review or Appeal Agency Decision 950 Constitutionality of

State statutes

of

D 446 Ans w/Disabilities D

Other 448 Educatiou

Employment

t] o
n o

Other:
540 Mardanus & Other 550 Cilil Rights 555 Prison Condition 560 Civil Detainee -

D D

462 Naturalization .165 Other Imigration

Actions

Conditions of Confinement

V. ORIGIN pto." ", "X" in One Box Only) from X I original n 2 Removed State Court
Proceeding

-l 3

Remanded from Appellate Court

fl 4 Reinstated or D
Reopened
cite

5 Transferred from
Another District

O6
divqsu

Multidistrict Litigation

Cite the U.S. Civil Statute under which you are filing (Do not

jurisdictional statut* unless

VI. CAUSE

OF ACTION Brief

5 USC 552

descrrotron of cause:

VII.

REQUESTED IN

Request for information under FOIA CHECK IF THIS IS A CLASS ACTION

ttNDER RULE 23, F.R.Cv.P.
(See

DEMAND

CHECK YES only if demanded in complaint

COMPLAINT: VIII. RELATED CASE(S)

IF ANy
DATE FOR OFFICf, USE ONLY RECEIPT

JURYDEMAND: D Yes EWo

DSCKETNUMBSp 11402

instructions)

JUDGE Royce C. Lamberth

SIGNATURE OF ATTORNEY OF RECORD

AMOLTNI

APPLYING IFP

JUDGE

MAG. JIIDGE

JS 44

Reversc (Rev. l2112)

INSTRUCTIONS FOR ATTORNEYS COMPLETING CIVIL COVER SHEET FORIU JS 44

Authority For Civil Cover Sheet
The JS 44 civil cover sheet and the information contained herein neither replaces nor supplements the filings and seruice ofpleading or other papers as required by law, except as provided by local rules ofcoutt. This form, approved by the Judicial Conference ofthe United States in September' l974,is required fbt the use of the Clerk of Court for the purpose of initiating the civil docket sheet. Consequently, a civil cover sheet is submitted to the Clerk Court for each civil complaint filed. The attomey fi1ing a case should cornplete the form as follorvs:

of

I.(a) (b) (c) U.

Plaintiffs-Defendants. Enter names (last, first, middle initial) of plaintiff and defendant. If the plaintiff or defendant is a govemment agency. onlythefullnameorstandardabbreviations. Iftheplaintiffordefendantisanofficialwithinagovemmentagency,identifufirsttheagencyand
then the official, giving both name and title.

use

CountyofResidence, Foreachcivilcasefiled.exceptU.S.plaintiffcases,enterthenameofthecountywherethefirstlistedplaintiffresidesatthe
time of filing. In U.S. plaintiff cases, enter the name of the county in which the fnst listed defendant resides at the time of filing. (NOTE: In land condemnation cases, the county ofresidence ofthe "defendant" is the location ofthe tract ofland involved.) Attorneys. Enter the firm name. address. telephone number, and attomey of record. If there are several attorneys, list them on an attachment, noting in this section "(see attachment)".

Jurisdiction. The basis ofjurisdiction is set forth under Rule 8(a), F.R.Cv.P., which requires that jwisdictions be shown in pleadings. Place an "X"
in one of the boxes. If there is more than one basis ofjurisdiction, precedence is given in the order shown below. United States plaintiff. (l) Jurisdiction based on 28 U.S.C. l345 and 1348. Suits by agencies and officers ofthe United States are included here. United States defendant. (2) When the plaintiff is suing the United States, its officers or agencies. place an "X" in this box. Federal question. (3) This refers to suits under 28 U.S.C. 1331, wherejurisdiction arises under the Constitution ofthe United States, an amendment

totheConstitution,anactofCongressoratreatyoftheUnitedStates.
precedence, and box

IncaseswheretheU.S.isaparl,v,theU.S.plaintiffordefendantcodetakes

or 2 should be marked. Diversity of citizenship. (4) This refers to suits under 28 U.S.C. 1332, where parties are citizens of difl'erent states. When Box 4 is checked, the citizenship of the dif'I'erent parties must be checked. (See Section III below; NOTE: federal question actions take precedence over diversity
cases.)

III. IV. V,

Residence(citizenship)ofPrincipalParties. ThissectionoftheJS44istobecompletedifdiversityofcitizenshipwasindicatedabove.
section for each principal party.

Markthis

Nature of Suit. Place an "X" in the appropriate box. If the natwe of suit cannot be determined, be sure the cause of action, in Section VI below, is

sufficienttoenablethedeputyclerkorthestatisticalclerk(s)intheAdministrativeOfficetodeterminethenatureofsuit.
one nature of suit, select the most definitive.

Ifthecausefitsmorethan

Origin.

Place an

"X" in one of the six boxes.

Original Proceedings. (1) Cases which originate in the United States district courts. Removed from State Court. (2) Proceedings initiated in state courts may be removed to the district courts under Title 28 U.S.C., Section 1441. When the petition for removal is granted. check this box. Remanded from Appellate Court. (3) Check this box for cases remanded to the district court for further action. Use the date of remand as the frling
date. Reinstated or Reopened. (4) Check this box for cases reinstated or reopened in the district court. Use the reopening date as the filing date. Transferred from Another District. (5) For cases transferred under Title 28 U.S.C. Section 1404(a). Do not use this for within district transfers or multidistrict litigation transfers. Multidistrict Litigation. (6) Check this box when a multidistrict case is transferred into the district under authority of Title 28 U.S.C. Section 1407. When this box is checked, do not check (5) above.

VI. VII. Vl[

CauseofAction. Reportthecivilstatutedirectlyrelatedtothecauseofactionandgiveabriefdescriptionofthecause.

Donotcitejurisdictional

statutes unless diversity. Example: U.S. Civil Statute: 47 USC 553 Brief Description: Unauthorized reception of cable service Requested in Complaint. Class Action. Place an "X" in this box if you are filing a class action under Rule 23, F.R.Cv.P. Demand. In this space enter the actual dollar amount being demanded or indicate other demand, such as a preliminary injunction. Jury Demand. Check the appropriate box to indicate whether or not a jury is being demanded.

RelatedCases. ThissectionoftheJS44isusedtoreferencerelatedpendingcases,ifany. Iftherearerelatedpendingcases,insertthedocket

numbers and the correspondingjudge names for such cases.

Date and Attorney Signature. Date and sign the civil cover sheet.

LAW OFFICES OF ORLY TAITZ 29839 SANTA MARGARITA. STE 1OO RANCHO SANTA MARGARITA, CA 926S8 PH 949-683-5411 FAX 949-766-7603 oRLY.TAtTZ@cMAtL.COM

05 30 2013
OFFICE OF INSPECTOR GENERAL US POSTAL SERVICE 1735 N LYNN ST STE lOOOO ARLINGTON VA 22209 Fax 703-248-4626 e-mail: '. ',.: -, , ,, , -l _j.i

Rl.Ql.'ES'l'r()l{ lxr()Ri\l,r'l'l(}\

['\l)tiR
t

F-REED()M (tF .r.551

l\]'()lll\tA't't(]ti

,.1("t'5

;\rtrr ('hicl-l-( ll,\ ( )llice r ( )l'licc ol'lhe Insgrclrr (-iu'nr-'nll I ur l.SI)S

I)ctrl sir nrdnr( ln ,lrrnc

ltr-

l(tlI

ltrrc

sutrrttittcr.l

lrrc r:olnpl;rinlr:

L :.

(,'r)rllpluinl .rdr-lrcsscri lrr tltr: I\rrl,ntarlcr ( iulttrul

('runpllilrt

rtrldtcs.sc.l ur

lltr

lttspe{l{}t'

(iulcrill ol'thc

I lSl'}S

I nrtr id,:d iul uluL'nr;rhlc cr idcrtr:c thlt Bar;rch I lusrcin ( )bltttir usgil s llagrltttlr l:rhriclttrl

t SlrsstiullpinhirirllegedSslsetircScniccltcgrstratiun. lltclirrgrn isllugnutt-ilsIiSl)Sttsss

.r.l rligit ptlsl;rl st.lrnp. rrhilc ( llr;irur's allrgc.l S\S rceistr:rtirrtt crrrrtililtr.-cl
:r

I ,ligil .stutrtp;rttil

hrnrs othcrsign: ul'lorggyl , Itlc;r.e. rcr- anitchsd il d(lF\ rrl tltc \t\otrl al'lir,iarrt ul -lcllrc] Stcplutlt

('ol'linalr - Chicl'lrrrcsligatorul'lltc S1^*cial lrtrustigirtions uttit rrl'the [;S ('oitsl (itrrrrd (rct),
t ;rrrr rcqtresling .lr1 md l,uslnt.tster

lll r.hrurulr{ntr

gfr}ctill('rl lrr lhc ltrrpcctor ( rcncral ul lltc

SPS nrr.l

tlt

ol'I

Sl)S irr rcsF.tntr til tl)\ cilnlpl[ilrt. I am rct.lttcstirrg cxpcditc.l hiltrdling ill'tltr.'

somplainl. *c this is the ntost egrcgious lilrgery in rhe history ol'the tinitcd Statcs. usc of a
fbrgr'd ldcntiilcation documcnt by an individual occnpying the position of thc President of the

Unitcrl Stalcs and Commander in Chicl- i\ddirionult]' I am attaching 155 pagc,s of e,xhibils
sltowing lvtr. Obiuna using other lbrged and lraudulentl]- obtained tDs. such as a Social Serurity

numhet rthir-'h \\a.t neter assigrtcd to lrim. tbrged hirth ccrritlcatc ard so on.

If I do not rc{:eive

a re..;Fr}ru;{: tn

this FOIA request within 3t} da1's I will considcr a le*eal action to

uhtainrcquesteddocuments.

Sincerelv.
/si llr. {}rl1'Taitz- ESQ

I e" --tt/ _. it f

_-___^

I'rcsident Deftnd Our Frccdoms lioundaliorr

S.$ Cangressnran lJnrret lssa, SS John

('huir ol'rhe I louse Oversight Committee

fioodlatte Chair ol'thc l-lousc.ludiciary Commitree

State of l'uxas

l J*.
I

ilounty oiMontgoncr-r

'LITFMA\,TT
.[ei]bry, Stcphcn Collinan, being clul-y sworn] on oath dr;poscs and rays.

l, l. 3
,|5,

6
7,
S-

'I'he inlbrmation contuined irt this ailidavit is based on I am a residcnt of Tcxas, my personal knorvicdge. I anr a liccrrsed Privirlc htvestigrttrr iliccnsed A610963) in the Starc c'f Texa-r. I am a rerired Rcsidcnt Agent in Chargc/Special Agcnt from thc I)elxrtment trf Homeland Securiq,having retircd after f0 I'enrs during.lune 2007t am a retired Chief invesrigator rvith the Unitcd States Coast tiuard lrtvcstigativ+ Scrncc (Reservei having retired after 2? .'"ears during fuIarch 1010. I was fnrrncrll- nn lnvestigiilor wlth the OfFrcc of the Attorne-v General tvith the "l-exas sening kom August f008 Lurlii I quit druirrg Septcmber !{}09. Statr- of [Jrr m]'o1r'n nnr.l not as an Iirvcstigator or Spccial Agent r,vith any stale cr lideral agcilcy t ltrrkcd into circumstanccs surrounding theu U.S. Senator lJarack ()biunu'.c Selective Sen'ice rcgistration, I have utilized the $electivs Scrvice's "Chr:uk A Registration" onlinc l'tmction (UfUf=-sff.gl! numcrous timr:s to veri$'rvhether a rcqrdred registratiun lrlas properl-v completed, On ur about Februaq, 13, 2008= I sent an email lo iol'ornralionti:r.l5sl.glr-J- ashing *'hy $cnator (Jbanra's registration didn't -chorv up lvhcn queried srn th* Selcctive

9.

Scn' i ce rvirbsile ( p511;ss'gq l:i, On the snmc da,r,- {Iebruary 13, 2tl08i I received an ernail liom fd-q.t4p[A1:f,1lSs.go\, :itating "sir; Iherc may be an eror in his file ormmy othcr rea$ons rvlrv his registrarion ctnlot be confirmcd on*ltne. ilorvevcr. I diri confirm u'ith uur Data h'Ian*gcrrent Ccntur tlrat he is, indccd, registered rvrth the Selcctive Sen'isr: Slstem. itr conrpliance u'ith Fr:deral llu'- SincereJv, Janrce L' T lughcs.iSSli". lt]. Ou Septcmbcr l.:0iJ8 I vicrued rr tcluviscd inten'iuw in utrch thcn Si:nalar {-)banur statcd that hc regrsturcd ltrr the Selcr:rit'E Sstn:cc vl'hsn hc graduated fionr high sr:hool, ! rccrllcd that Scnntor {Jbarnir Eadualed lrum high schtroi ip- 1979 urrri lhe Sclcctivc Servic:c rcgi-etrution rtr.lttir*ntcnls $ctt ncrt rcinsljiuttlil until
l 9fiO.

!. I "slbtntflsd

ir Fr1:cclLrnr (Jl'l11bn-:talir"rn Acl tF{JtAl to rhu Scle stive Scfli'icu Sysl.inn tbr Sunirtnr {)bama's Selectiv,; Strvice rsgistr*tiort. 1 receirL:tl it cr:D1' uf a Sclective Scrvice regrsualicn in tlte ni*re nf tsarack I Iussein Ol.atttil strd a cti:'i oI ir c*:npulct Siirccn print out with a datc of 09,'0!i,'fiS.

12. Rcvreiving tlrcs+ crrpirs

I nritcd lar'cral nrers 0l'concem. Fur crample, I ntrl,.:t'i tlral on thu rcgi.dration copv thc signature of tire registrlnl r'','as datlC .luly 3'.i. 1$lrrJr htrr the i-'niictl Sl{rtes l,oslal caccelli.lti*rt starnp intiicrrting d;rt* recuitur.l rt'as -'l''lo !I)" block rr'*s dated tht prcvi6us {a1' r'f .luiv ?9. l{0' I also nrrted thal lhc cltsckr:d indiqating that the n':gislrant did nr'rt prelient rur IIJ rvhen thc rcl:istralion

ii,{t'
,i

\vils tatii to haui: bten prusr:nic<.l ttr tltt pc*stal clerk-. 'l'he nrosi otrlstandtng ilipr.-cl r-rt-llte rcgistrltron c';rd wts that tirc atbrcm*iliioned l-1.S. Fostai Llanc{-'llarion Stnmp hud r:nlv e t'sr digiit '.'*ilr insretil *f thr usu*: iiiur rligit 1.car. I 3 . DuritrE m\. :tL:i1.re nrt l:tan -surl'isu rvith thc US i\rm-y ltour I 973 tr-r I g?7, i scruuJ it.i;r crdllleral dufr'as t-rtrc ol'mv nnit's nrail uicrk. I-)uring thnt -se;r,iuc I ryirs ianri;iar rl':th LlS Prrstal rcgulations and pnrcctluius. h rva-r rn;,' undr.:r-.rtlndrn*q rhal thc i-, $ Fcsta! Canceliaiion slorili) r'rils a tirur digrt -y-;ar arrd not E tr."'o rligit lcar I alsrr Lnsrr' lhat the da...-. month- un,l yeilr ol'thilt lrrod'll posial caur;+lls.tiorr slirrnir arr ri:rnovrrtill inscns that thr postal clerk chnngcr a.. approprinlu" I i:ar'* ncr,tr scdn ii l',vr,1 tligit insert frrr thar nru.lel p().qte[ tflt$ellalirrn sFmpr, l:f, {-11:;p si:\jtial }r'rri-ks, I rrsearchecl thu is;ut orr thc irrlemul lrfirmpting to tlncl autnther rnciderrl lthr:i'- lhfi1 luudel canceliation starnp hrtd a truu digit 1'tirr insluard ui' the usual tbur rligit r-$ar. ; ues ttnable trt t'inil anl' uther instunr:e s'her* ll:*t ruorlcl prr:'slnl cancelIaliun sllrrrr'r.r hacl a t'lvo digit velr insteittl uithc usual frrur drgit le*r. I 5. t.ising try training irnd c.rpcrir:ncrrs, J Bnallzed the inxge rri thr: ]rcrstitl sklmp un th,; cupy n[the regtstration. h i-* rn]'Gunclrlsrlrn ltt::t i,r it]rlI "^i111qg{!gipu iiigit r':ar insert cnrlinr in "{JS-'r.,.'as nrndified hv uutting r:l.l-thc lirsl 1r',r.r rlrlilts iuril lernsertirq rhi.r "(t8" upsidc dor.rn into thr: postal canLrcllatron slrurlLr 10 jndicate "[-he anlv fbur digit ycar endins in "{J8" I felt that r.r.uulr] hu' a yeirr ol-''t10". ruasonablr ;rvailablt lvouJd hu a'-2{-)08" 1'lar itrscrt I 6. t-llr rhe cupy ul lhe c'ornprrl$r scrErn prinlrru:. Iccci!'ed under ihe I-tllA ; nrrficuri lhat ihcru wal a linr trrarkctl D.N arrd thu numL'cr of "$t)li!t 70t ti{.-i1". I slsu :'rotcd lhal orr the c(lFt' rll- th* Sc'lective Scn'icc registratir-rrt carcl thcrr-- rvas a -'{iiit}f|ll{llil:'srnrilar ;ir:nilrer rn thu upp,.:r right hand cLlmcr- 'fitis nr:tnllr:r rvas 'l"hc nuurher on lho rr:gisualiun cnftl flFFuarrll to lru a "Batcs'- gpe 5rrint thut ar{omuticaIiy changes *ith cach itnpresston 17. Thc diffi;rcnucs Lrerrveen thc Ll-N runnher orr ttri r:ornpulcr lurtc!) prinlout and the rcgisrralirrir c*rtl prirtaut itFpffirs to bc the adilition ul'tltt tllgit ''l{'- I kttorv rtl n{r r.ftsr.'u iirr tht *tidrtiort of the "ii"' iru the ilLN. lr\. llasu{ Lqr rtlv *hs{:n'atj$ns- il}:iL'srch. expcri,;rrcc atrc training, i1 is mv Lrc}ici thttt tlu: Sel*ctiv: Senicu rugistration card I rc[cived irtrdert]rc treedtrrn Oi' Infrrrrnation Act rrquest under ih.: n*mt o{'Bflrack- {Jhama lius hicn oltsrerJ.
f

ii ;_-i7 'i !it,.i"1'Xr!

,! 4- 4 :i f. i!

,lL.'--?
t.lo ii

.fgtid;i' Stcphr:l

m.u:

Slorn

h-r

tlti

Dnd sirbsGrilrcd

beliru mc this

.t: ;i)

',
-l-1Lr-:t

."'-i/dfrLAA
i, t*fl.L5
1.1rii"t'1 Pr,$utt-

1:

.--lli*inti#,i?;,'o

i;i,#'"1+ {,tor".!'-j ri 2
1."

%."r;?iF,lit.o

RIl{8 HrSsosY mEXrT

sd&,fip.i
LAST TISIS:
FTRST T}TdE: C$RR3IIT ADDSE$8:

8SR8AA

.iQ!;.ffi5-53t;3

allB-coDB,/ffPE:
lPlt
10118

11o

Blatgl EoSsErr[
16r.? S BERSIBIrIa, EOmIrEIrg
SO$OIJFTU

oB}ilrh

DITEr

PAEE OOl OF

OG2

09/09/og

crrY/srrrElzw:.
DTIE OF BTEIE;

9gR!f,lrtrT lIlDRlS9: cr"Y/sTrTElsxtt

151? S BEngrarn.ElE 1008

HI

96826 96826

88llt:
TtrAPHOf,A:
DI.iT:

Jte08 000

0s/o*/51
0000

TEeltS.*ClrOt
RELBTID 9Sl{:

Dlrr:

oe/0*/to

9089 708 0632

BElSOtr

S
0

IIDICIIIOR:

&s,st ectrolr DllE:

osl04lsD oo 0000000

PRBSS: CLRIR

=->

Bl{D

PF? g*> PAfil ErcmnD

P88

--> PAIE Iq[l$TD

-a

Exh ib

ir 1

State of

Texas

)
)
ss.

County ofMontgomery

AIT'IDAVIT
Jeffery Stephen Cofuan, being duly sworn" on oath deposes and says: is based on my personal knowledge. 2. I am a licensed Private Investigator (licensed A620963) in the State of Texas. 3. I an a retired Resident Agent in Charge/Special Agent from the Departrnent of Homeland Security having retired after 20 years during June 2007. 4. I am a retired Chief Investigator with the United States Coast Guard Investigative Service S.eserve) having retired after 22 years during March 2010. 5. I was formerly an Investigator urith the Office ofthe Attorney General with the State of Texas serving from August 2008 until I quit during September 2009. 6. On my ovm and not as an Investigator or Special Agent with any state or fbderal agency I looked into circumstances surounding then U.S. Senator Barack Obama's Selective Service registation. 7. I have utilized the Selective Service's *Check A Registation" online firnction fuUnUg5s.gov) numerous times to verify whether a required registation was properly completed. 8. On or about February 13, 2008, I sent an email to information@sss.gov asking why Senator Obama's registration didn't show up when queried on tle Selective Service websile (wwwsss. gov). 9. Onthe same day (February 13,2008) I received an Email from informatign@ss$.gov stating "Sir: There may be an error in his file or many other rcasons why his registration cannot be confirmed online. However, I did conlirm with our Data Management Center tht he is, inded registered with the Selective Service System, in compliance with Federal law. Sincerely, Janice L. Hughes/SSS". 10. On September 7, 2008 I viewed a televised interview in which then Senator Obama stated that he registered for the Selective Service when he graduated from high school. I recalled that Senator Obama graduated from high school n 1979 and the Selective Service registratiom requiremenls were not reinstituted until
1980. 11.

1. I am a resident of Texas. The information contained in this affidavit

I submitted a Freedom Of Information Act (FOIA) to the Selective Service System for Senator Obarna's Selestive Service registration I received a copy of

a Selective Service registration in the narne of Barack Hussein Obama and a copy of a computer sueen print out with a date of 09/09/08. 12. Reviewingthese copies I noted several areas of concern. For example,I noted that on the registration copy tle signature ofthe registrant was dated July 30, 1980, but the United States Postal cancellation starnp indicating date received was dated the prwious day of July 29, 80. I also noted that the 'T{o ID" block was checked indicating that the registant did not present an ID when the registration

was said to have been presented to the postal clerk. The most outstanding aspect of tle registration card was that the aforementioned U.S. Postal Cancellation Stamp had only atwo digit year instead ofthe usual four digit year. 13. During my active military service with the US Army from 1973 to 1977,I served as a collateral dury as one of my rmit's mail clerk. Dming that service I was farniliar with US Postal regulations and procedures. It was my understanding that the US Postal Cancellation stamp was a four digit year and not a two digit year. I also knew that the day, montlq and year of that model postal cancellation stamp are removable inserts that the postal clerk changes as appropriate. I have never seen a two digpt insert for that model postal cancellation stamp. 14. Over several weeks, I researched the issue on tle intemet attempting to find any other incident where that model cancellation stamp had a two digit year instead of the usual four digit year. I was unable to find any other instance where that model postal cancellation stamp had a two digit year instead of the usual forn digit year. 15. Using my taining and experiences,I anatyzedthe image of the postal cancellation stamp on the copy ofthe regisfration. It is my conclusion that a four *08" was modifiedby cutting offthe first two digits digit year insert ending in and reinserting the "08" upside down into the postal cancellation stamp to indicate *08" I felt that would be a year of "80". The only four digit year ending in reasonably available would be a'2008" year insert. 16. On the copy of the computer screen p'rintout received under the FOIA I noticed *8089 708 0632". I also that there was a line marked DLN and the numbff of registation card there was a noted that on the copy of the Selective Service similar nwnber in the upper right hand comer. This number was "0897080632". The number on the registration card appeared to be a "Bates" type print that

automatically changes with each impression. 17. The differences between the DLN number on the oomputer soreen printout and the registration card printout appears to be the addition of the digit "8". I know of no reason for tle addition of the "8" in the DLN. 18. Based on my observations, research, experience and training, it is my beliefthat the Selective Service registration card I received rmder the Freedom Of Information Act request under the name of Barack Obama has been altered.

Sworn to me and subscribed before me this

ae

day ofJanuary 2013.

ad[,]il,
-NueR G.N-LS
NorA0.,{ PuBuc

Rrt{s HrsfoRs nsaEnII scnEm{

IAET SA}IE: FIRST NNdB:
CURR$IT ADD8^ES9:

,iiffii#*ffiF.F*ttry. OBBIIB llnegr Silsssff

m.Es8-c1rDE/rrg8:

Lao

PA{IE 001 0F O*2 DiaTEr 09/09/ss

erTY/sTlTE/grp:
PBR$ETHIT .IDDRB{IS:

cITY/sTATx/zr*:
DATE OF BIRTET SSAII:
TEIrEPEOIIE:

151.? s sERgnafIA agf 1008 EQmliti,,u T5T.7 g BSRETArIA AP? XOOS mlto&xll:u

HI

96825 96826

08/04/51

DLII:
TRSNSACTIOIT DA?E:

808 000 0000 so89 ?08 0632 oel04/8o oe/or/Eo -00 0000000
0

REISOS:

IIAST ACTION DAPE:

REIIATED SSN:

IISDICASOR:

PRBSS:

CTrE:BR

=->

END

PF? ==1 P3g BASSIBRD

PF8 =a> PAgfl FOM{ARD

-l

Exh

ibit

u0I[0 A ,:

WNDEXCLUSIVE

SHEFIFF

Selective Service regulation changed days after probe announced

Published: 0511012012 at 8:27 PM

"CE DETVIANDS CBPIVIA DFPN FECIS-TFA]ICN

rJh
Ads bv Google (hftp://www.qooole.com/url? ct=abq&q=hftps://www.qoogle.com/adsense/supporUbin/requeslpf/o3Fcontacto/o3Dabq alco/o26url%3DhttpJhvww.wnd_@mt2012105/sheri

"&

.FRCMFR ccFsr

(HTIF//!{\A!\\ NrccrwAr rrHCR/.ccF(qr/)

Ahnrr I Fmeir

xis%%?t3,$i*ffi#:?94?fi3'3,'l..!hsr&Jt;tufi uii$?ilG;;u,ih"E;;",ia;,la,ouo-

Cqi-Q&sig-AOD6_4-2hrs-Ot2oTZGaBtBx_tQA5O41i95w&ctient=ca-pub-)yaUoAitahATqvbGiiBDm pU4utxunOXoGzgWzAhNktliSpSircaKGvyef

4.$za-u.o.t-xie.sajlaauulr=nq:lirarwvi
Jcvv/

Frnd

oE UgJoxAnAt

OnePoliticalPlaza com(http://www.googteadservices.comlpagead/aclk?
5j8
h

out wnat the oeThocrats ooh't Wanf voit tb-kndvf .ftb-aciTn'E now.

LwuFv

.yrh

on-eporiti&rpla'a coillin jipffiurriJsqnewsie-ft;;;r;"2"21"i;"z"aOAil*lstcgnii2ni-dirr--eruii ynuraurrHtugaeofri4rcusg=af tJ;uNnx1 rdm-u i rvrh-iijznrdsrtV<ir,rrxrwxui'.

sa=L&ai=CtgwjJLQUZv3lrH-wQHz3YGQBJ-JjLoD!iNm 1 nAjbcBEAEgSZPSFl DAtlo2Ylvtne5obloSAZoAGsooXgASgBAagDAaoEmAFp0JT

kr6aS hxMSV-H vC6 3h_7JKk-uxtbEZxm Nw1 NEFwCZTh6bVesNqyqTUTqxYDQnf\IgS>zvpsUfyZdJiVs4uOM I UHcVL-xCM43wSRiAcTvtNoulxX6tUpGAZHq4G0kbj0yaJ4gGAYAHr5X6Ag&num=1&cict=5Gg_-N5SH87CHStgJFy-

0lYqd04e0pmtQqE6QUaheD2LPTHF2s-8A\6K-cH5J6ZlCeKlRm -HIGHM-MkaaH
CqiQ&s ig=AOD64_2hrsOb20TZGaBlBx_lQAS04tig5w&client=ca-pu

4362624082965872&adurl=http;i

br/ww.onepoliiicalplaza.com/in.jsp7o3Furlo/o3Dnewsletter.jspo/o26src%3Daw)

t9
Providing proof that Sheriff Joe Arpaio intends to continue his investigation of President Obama's eligiblity, his Cold Case posse has pressed the director of the Selective Service System not to destroy any microfilm records that may yet exist of Obama's 1980 draft registration form. ln an emergency letter Wednesday to Selective Service System Director Lawrence Romo, Mike Zullo, the lead investigator in the Cold Case posse, asked for reassurance that the microfilm records still exist.
Ads by Gooqle
(http :/A,vww.qooo le.com /u rl ? c1=ab g &q=httPs :/Arvww.qooo I e.com /ads en s e/s u pporubin/r

"We would like to be assured of the disposition of the microfilm reel or reels containing President Obama's Selective Service registration form,'Zullo wrote. "Please indicate whether or not you have possession of the microfilm reel or reels containing President Obama's records or access to them."

walk-in Ig!,:-Eg!.i,?
Disa bled,
!,ge.Ilip
i

zlo5ls heritf-joe-

(http i//www. groogleads e rvic

=CGtlrjZL'QUf ^=L&a YDoa@QHw9YGYA6,c8sd:

e s a

_a,"

{"

-"1

f?9 g:"1"^
-"

"*

9pyzax%!ft
7.8 @ Al

d xtVT
'

BzDJn

1^QPAB-llcL u a GvKi

The concerns were raised after Arpaio's office received official confirmation from the Selective Service System that Obama's paper draft registration records have been destroyed after being microfilnred.
ln addition, an aticlo published Monday by rhe Washingtnn Tirnas "Communities" sncial muniticq waehingtOntinFs nnm/noighbOrhOOd/frecdOropreSS_ iournaliSm eaetin not-free/?012/may/7/qrrestinn-surrounrting_presidcnt_obamaS_ch.aft_card/) reported new Selective Service privacy rules might allow existing microfilm records to be destroyed as
well.

OOGaABXSD tJ3oPIAOGoA,Y .

wGq BJ8BTg@AFj la ngY2o I B Fi OwOJr oas PdhZODTdo JJr

oi

-.L.Y..,.-.]'.'.\.tl

KWOoElaLobsxRvN-{v(Jodl un eery1-$ 59lt

i

nT(Mlvt

azp l{VkTwoHWieKTGHrngyl

",

6BxloO\AltwwECGl

ExeJOU|
zJ

gf+o[gs3ox+ rdoniu

Na nj c

ggWgFiryl-q,*f.d.-. rr r Jok:<rr iv kBuTXIWAs{rrkSSuUQkxdI iz

ivRQYBl d FESTbe FfzSRn v/o
V5 d2 I a
W,..

Zullo expressed concern the microfilm records of Obama's draft registration form might already have been destroyed.

gltnrJRf# iAYBoAeh

nq,,l .lr #.'.1,g"ii-:ist% N gBl .QQaTeCM_Oja N4 &s i

"ln the unfortunate event the microfilm reel or reels containins President obarrra's qqy-qf"05$*liiid=^d3$,]t Selective Service registration form has been destroyed, can you please advise of the date Pl.lF.:rlviSPSiycaKGvYetQS3cl the records raere destroyed and the location at which they \ ere destroyed," he asked. -

3;?3ffit#:j53frti%
4362240&2% 5672&adu.l .;L. i^;l, h-^^ tA

lh#^.i,i.^;,

tf,..H#1,[lF,,S1i,.nd:5i31n

Zullo's letter gave Romo 10 business days within receipt of the letter to respond.

Available.

#j;{;t+#1'{*igrl$ l"J:"T:H;:::"",H:;:"ffi:T,,::;ff"':"*"
SareqtepTuhcor/trre Selective Serviceadmitsdestruction

servce svs'{em n 200e bv

e- Estimates
(l'ttp.v&/Mi14/iqoogle?.dservic619

es.comJDaoead/aclk?

Romo a letter directly asking if the Selective Service System still retained the original paper

a;':t J'iZ%r rj)ld'97-"na's

g

dra

ft

re s i stra ti o

fo

YDoa6wQHw9YGYA6GSsd

aryzaxszddi7xl cBABlPGTiginal, authentic Selective Service registration form for Barack Obama from July 29, 1980, 7,P-?41%i.I.I,F..Br?P{'lll9tf or not you have possession of this document," Arpaio wrote. "tf the docurnent is in your

wcqe,laarocz[Fjtangy2eie it available for inspection by my Sheriffs Office investigators. We will travel to your facility to
fl OvO;Jg_g as Pg hZODTgq J qiKWOoSlaLobsxRvNRTKMIt/lVfLMRoofY4

OQGaABx8DU3gPIAQGoA

to5Oh.

;hL;Urir;"-nV,;i;1i'fi;tanavan,
cy4Op0
s

associate director of public and intergovernrnental affairs for the Selective Service

oiBxloo\,\ttr,vwEccliEleJctjl paio with a letter indicating the agency had destroyed Obama's original paper and ink draft
xQX4.16otxUzJ Na m

qavdc6eWtil4PilkBuTX2WAsfrrks3U U0bdl j-r,hovsrore*rbeHzSRqvs no; it was destroyed in '1980," Flahavan wrote. "Per agency policy and practice, when a V5q4aqltn{:lBl-FinvlS4ei"n record is created from the registration card, the card is microfilnred and the paper card is then v6s h&n um = 1.&cid=5GhP2s ..r.\-.;-.i./.,! ii... F-;{_ ...,-.)n policy for more than 30 years.,' NgBLQEaTeCV_oja N4&s i'' our

g=AOD64_2utYa31'pXQDTSedTb-;afe? 85uDXBb8g&client=ca-

rnttp1lrlivwusat65i!p1uig6intheFederalRegisterSept.20,
n1#reg-e9!img!e/)- after WND

!l!;f^Clnf"f.,::i!g15 @v.vashington Tines article, Alan Jones noted that the Selective Service System publisbed-nerar 4362624 08296 5872 &ad u rl

reported Sept. 16, 1 , (http'4v\4 4/v.wnd-com/'ol 1 /09/345585/) that Arpaio had "01 commissioned the Cold Case Posse to open an inquiry with full subpoena porler into the alleged forgery of several Kate Middleton rtnents, including his long-form birth certificate and his Selective Service draft registration form.
(http/www.gbogleadservicls the first update to Selective Service privacy regulations in
es.com/pagead/aclk?

Photos

1'l years.

the new regulations reclassify the status i..1=Li3ii9le$I*9!Iia* YDoa6wQHweY9vryfqNS

uoqu.lvure; oceentgSzes Fyproviso
gCUl,,tyogzT-

of draft registration forms from "record copies" to "nonthat "non-record copies" are subject to disposal.

further allow the Selective Service System to destroy microfilm copies of Selective Service , SlsDvAEBoAMBooSbA a6 =1Fgy-z7,rq!9ijkqr.n-s4tions certain circumstances' gsiCdFU"lf'"ii i;n,;Cil;
A7q ybGj i BDm
p

U4 u lxu

nOX

O&g!!zAh

Nklyj SPqiyca KG

vYe{QS3caseaj F7dH7b9wu

eikOwOdeinXziCJdgbteiih certificate and his Selective Service registration form are forgeries.
DEFNBJms9vCghqZRa_d

in Phoenix, Arpaio announced the Cold Case Posse had found probable cause that $1.*!+:.-i?lY-Ipi.\gtiYnterence RDVDNT234tAqsHeFdtLPi

1:F!BNalc$rbB99&4i4s selective service registration form, with the Post office date stamp, July 29, 1980, in the lor*er
vn D ka o |AYB rQ )Y9-r-Y-Yf $Ae6w14E&num =2&cid=5G
J
I

hP2sNgBLQEaTeCV*0jaN
4t&sigj=46p5,,4r-1:NlPoQJRgviewed
lW,

a number of authentic Selective Service registration forrns obtained from the federal
Act req uests.

&client=ca-pub4 3 6262 4 O 829 6 5 87 2 &ad u rl

$ql5ff

PS

trft31,#9eedom of tnformation
i

iittp

/l o

c al sh Trrin vw.styr b 6iuyro.* rl'l 4 g gokbooUKatelo2EMi{! le_t rook)

nVo3F za
m

e r itt

Ar p

_eo/o3 D Ka

te-

g,9flbtJSSBl"JJBYl,s

tour of the authentic Selective Service registration forms. All of the forms have a Post office stamp Stunnino of -iiiJ"ve"ir "'''. Pictures with four digits. :'.-"' :'I Pflncess Kate Middleton and the Ro/al F:amily. ast, the year designation in Obama's Selective Service registration has two digits, specifying only "80" Kate=d of "1980."
Miclclleton qtvbRistro

9p{Fbil C shows the standard Post Office date-stamp equipment that was used to stamp Selective Service registration (http ://www. goog lead s e rvrc i;.ia;ti;"#;a;7"crr<6nows the three slots on the bottom of the stamp in which the month, day and year plugs were
sa=lEai=CbR6!jZLQUf-

dCijnrv"a2r.t tne

D6quJvUfAibcBEA

a6 81s ...+.1 ;..3 .;i:_ i:=.tx U QtiCl nBBlGovaUr

ATqybGjiBDmpUzlulru

994vV4U!klusl
vYelQS3caseai F7d H

05-vwrii;redv_i^r
RDVDNTZ3JtAqsHeFd erkQwQ3BtnKTCJ39oL DEFNBJm sgvCghqZRa_d
1F
1

Orw0E!_ymYnDkaOliAYB
d_

tlEet r{r'l :?&c! hP2sNqBLQEaTeC

s4.Qry

4&sig=n6964t 1gt
It/l6NUL54ivBcliFxQl
99. ji-e,r-',f c.?.-Pg8.-.^1,,r, 4 3 6 2 6 2 4 0 I 29 6 5 87 2

&ad

I
u

rj

=irttp,.l,tr*w.s'tytuOisti /lookbook/Kate%2 BMddlet ono/o3Fzam c%3DKateMiddleton-Display)

registration.
(/?0 1 2/03/Sheriff-jne-w:nts-ohamaq-original-draft -carrVSca/)

While some of the letters stamped in

Exhibit A: Barack Obama's Selective Service registration form

the outer ring on

some of the

authentic docunents are

indistinct or even missing, all of the

authentic date stamps include four

digits for the year at

the center of the

stamp.

lnvestigators duplicate Obama's

date stamp
Arpaio's
investigators located and

intervieued several 1980s-era Post

Office employees who attested that it was standard

(/20 1 2/03/sheriff-joe-waqts-obamas-origin:l-draft-card/est'/) khibit

B: Authentic Selective Service registralion

forns, w ith Post Office starnps containing four-digit year designalion

procedure to utilize a four-digit date

stamp. lnvestigators next

turned their attention loward figuring out how

Obama's Selective

Service registration
form could possibly have obtained a two-digit year stamp,
(/2o 1 ^in3ls heriff-joe-ulants-nhamrs-original-draft-na

rrlleec/)

Exhibit E shons investigators rivere able to obtain an authentic 1980 pica date stamp. The photograph also shovts the knife set

Rhibit

C: Standard

fost Office date stanp, Selective Servbe registratbn

used in the
investigation. Since investigators could find no 1980 pica Post Office

date stamps
available, they had no choice but to cut a 2008 pica Post Office date stamp and invert the "08" half, so that when it was placed in the

(/^O 1 ?/O3/sheriff-joe-wa nts-obarnac-original-Ck:ft-nar.t/Sq.l/)

fthibit

D: Anthentic Selective Service registration dale

staflls,

1980

date compartnrent, the stamp printed out "80."

Surprisingly, the result ended up looking identical to

the date stamp on

Obama's Selective

Service registration card, as demonstrated in

Exhibit F. Exhibit G makes clear that the off-to-

the-right date stamp seen in the registration, the

sarp

as is seen in

the demonstration by Arpaio's

(/20 1 Zn3lsheriff-joe-wanre-nhamas-original-draft-ce rClsse/)

Exhibit E: Knife used to cut "2008" date, Fca Fost Office date stamp

investigators, is not observed in the authentic four-digit pica date stamp used in the sane office indicated on Obama's Selective Service regislration, which has the same month, July 1980. The numbers "80" are out of line to the right in Obama's card because when they u/ere cut away from the "2008" date plug, they ure not cut squarely. Arpaio's investigators concluded that Obama's Selective Service registration form fit into what was becoming a comrnon narrative for his life: The document was not only forged, it was poorly forged.
ln a March 19 letter addressed to Romo, Arpaio explained that MCSO investigators rivere able to replicate the alleged forgery.

(/2n1 ^/n3/shpriff-joe-wanrs-ohamas-n.iginaLrlraft-nard/ssf/)
Exhibit F:

"80'twcdbit

FICA Fost Cffice date stamp in Barack Obalfa's Selective Service registration (black stanp) and in

the date slanp produced by Sheriff Arpab's investigators (red staflp)

.l

ti
t- _,',

,'

(2n 1 2/03/sherifr-joe-want<-obamas-original-draft-card/ssg4
Exhibit G, Oba.na Selective Service registration on left, authentic Seleciive Service registration on right rnonth. safiE Fost Office

- san

19

I nrJ-2trnnn4aaF/-2ha

(htFr'//rrru wnd c{rm/Z01 o/O5/chcriffjoe=

dema.dsobama-

d'aft-

It begins: Major demand to impeach Obama (http //www.wnd . comI 20

:

ffi
Claim: Obama hid'gay

regietration/prinl/)

The only hope for our

o*l Lr*l

F"1
Police buried Trayvon's criminal history (http: //wwrl.wnd. com/20 13/O4lpolice{uried-

life'to become
president

nation's ftrture
(http: //wunar.wnd. com/20
1

(http://wvvw.wtd. com/20

3/06/demand-obamas-

l?,Ogtclaim{]bama-hid-

3/06/theonly-hope-lor-

Exh

ibit

Excerpt of a repoft of a March 25.20A9 meeting by Dr. Orlv Taitz, ESQ and William Austin Chatfield. director of Selective service regarding fbrgery of Selective Service Certificate of Barack }{ussein Obama. II

Dr. Orly Taitz, Esq. rnet with William Austin Chatfield, Director of Selective Senice at I0:15am ES'f , March 25"2009 . The meeting took place at: Selective Service System, National Headquarters 151 5 Wilson Blvd. Arlington" Virginia 22209. Dr. Taitz introduced herself as the attorney for 140 Military Plaintiff's. active and retired, subject to recall. who are concerned about the Clonstitutional authority of Barack Obama to be Comtnander in Chief. Major General Carroll D. Childers is among these Plaintiflfs. tn addition to being attorney for the Military Plaintiffs. Dr. Taitz also represents 10 State Representatives in this nratter. Based on this. Dr. Taitz addressed Mr. Chatfield on some inconsistencies found with Barack Obama's Selective Service Registration records. Dr.Taitz presented sorne of the tindings (Attachment A) that were delivered to US Departrnent of .Iustice Eric Holder. Jr.. Attomey General. 'the findings indicate that Barack Obama's Selective Service Registration document was created in 2008, and backdated to 1980. Dr. Taitz shor,ved Mr. Chatfield that the Document Location Number. 0897080632, appears to be a 2008 creation. However on the printout. an extra eight (8) rvas added in front of the number to make it look like it is from the year 1980. Dr.Taitz also showed Mr. Chatfield that the postal stamp on the Selective Service Registration Form was incorrect. The stamp used was an obsolete postmark round dater-stamp (retired almost ten (10) years before 1980) to validate a legal document. Mr. Chatfield didn't have any comment on these inconsistencies nor did he offer any explanation. Dr. Taitz provided Mr. Chatfield with a full copy of the dossier sent to the Attorney General. Eric Holder. A cop1, can be downloaded here: link removed She highlighted sections of the dossier to show Mr. Chatfield that Barack Obama has hundreds of Social Security Numbers and properties associated with his name. One Social Security Number in particular was issued in Connecticut " and lists him as being 118 years old. (Attachrnent B) While addressing the issue of hurrdreds of Social Security Numbers and properties being associated with Barack Obama's name. Dr. T'aitz drew attention to two addresses of interest: one located in lllinois and another in New Jersey . The address located in Illinois . 1525 S. Sangamon St. tJnit 707. Chicago IL was sold to an Osama Barakat. T'he Osama Barakat listed (Attachment F) has connections tcl a fbundation that is listed in the "Golden Chain" as sponsors of al Qaeda. (Attachment C) shows an address in Neu. Jersey for Kelly J. McCrum, wife of Craig M. Robinson. Clraig Robinson is Michelle Obama's brother, and is listed at 45 Willow Street in South Amboy, NJ. Not only can this address not be found by mapping the street" but this address had a credit lien on it by a company. Burlow Plumbing. Burlow.Plumbing has a commercial affiliate named Magic Plumbing.

(Attachment D) shows that Magic Plumbing had worked on the sprinkler system at the World Trade Center just days before 9/11. One of the men that performed this work lived in Brooklyn . He left Brooklyn on 9/11 and went to Tennessee . A woman that had a court date involving identity theft with the motor vehicle department in Tennessee met a mysterious death. Mr. Chatfield had no comment or thought in reference to this material being shown to him. Dr. Taitz then provided Mr. Chatfield with information on Barack Obama's former client, Ahmad Bavarati. (Attachment E). Mr. Bavarati ran a non-profit called the Iran Earthquake Relief Fund, which subsequently changed its name to American Care Society, but still supported scientific work in lran . Mr. Chatfield promised he would look into these matters.

Exh ib

it 4

.:.rt.r . :i.i -1./\.i.' \,,.'l.r l'.1.rrj.tl::J . i.r,.., .*rrlL: l, rrr

i !: t::li

i{.ii'.i:,: \:: "lr l.l;lt:'.riit,r. r, i ..li,il

.' " Ir,-ti\

1r-

lr

1,,11..1,..".1 1..1i.i

I i\'l r,rr''. i \lt\ lil:f;;lrli i.t-nLl:1. I \l,t : 'llt.; r,l Ilr:.'_J:r,t . ,-.:._.1,-. ll:j t Ir,ri:\irrt'l . .',-: I : it.-:r .tt 'r .. _-'_ ]i l{, .'l r_'
i
i;1', s.1
,

..Lirrt
'!,11,.

ll. -t,ltr'l''+ilrl: i,..'rlr'r'.1 l;;r'.t.l'..' i\tll:.tttri i'ir.irr::tl.'lr'l;rt lflilt(l,:llri:-iJ,\i.t

:;:11l.id;li,'.1

"l'\ I :l':\ r iltrlr

r'll1;i, i

I'i..rl 'rli i,\ril;.rtrl' i,lli.:i l,tt,-l.rrl,,i:.,..1.''.r,.lr:rrr'..',,1-:;llrrtL'.tltrit l' l:.t.,; -dJ .tll;:ii iL,1

,,1-::i ' !it\,r,*rrirl,

li.r:i.t

,rt: 1l;- . '.1:qlr;ir

rt:,r,,:

iii'-1. r:-:'l l'.iltrl :! :!l | \1", i-.t.,,-i \r.t. r'r,ililt: :tr!l !\li(j |l iit'-' ; \l'5

.l,t

,;

ti-rr.. l,l'rr'rL:::!r.l rr:i.:il..r'iri,:1r1'11.-ttirrtr lrr: \-.'riii;Scfr:i.

ttt llil'lrti.ij,r-rlrrltl[rii;'i11.
t:. !,r:!L.rl lttti

ll Ii;r..,i
rr!'

rru t',1,r\lr:jitiilt"
lltt-.,1t t,,'..rl.l,.t.ll :1:r,,,.{ ttl:t,:'rr:

lrr .rirr:t'il .l,rrgpL \l

.1ril.ll.i..lLr.rr.;.!i.|',tr.t!:rr:i
:, ,rr, ilriirrii

;.'li:r: lu;:iirl

:.!Lll :', i ;,-i].lu:ii.tll.lt:

i ri. l ",,. ,tr:rirl.r'r tr:1rii ir.1t'\( ]t;rl:i" I :lilrl

,;.111i'' ;:"r.i l'f:l'itLi, l'.','-q,11 i tl'';gr':;. il

-t:t:'ilL:. t. i\,1!--l

ttt:;tl,i;(',t!trr',':

t:t.- l \i'\

',rs r r.'-l.tij,''

t iir:,-.:

ttl"'rlr'.i'.a!t.tL!

itl:;'lJ::lrrtti

t":..h.i l.ri'il.'i.lt'r:

, .r-:\ r;.1llt'',rtt tr

',t';. i:.:li

[lt :]:li Lr.i.. l

'.r.r

Exhibit

State of

Texas

)
)
ss.

County of Montgomery

AIT'IDAYIT
Jeffery Stephen Coffinan, being duly sworn" on oath deposes and says: The information contained in this affidavit is based on my personal knowledge. 2. I am a licensed Private Investigator (licensed A620963) in tle State of Texas. 3. I am a retired Resident Agent in Charge/Special Agent from the Deparbnent of Homeland Secwity having retired after 20 years during June 2007. 4. I am a retired Chief lnvestigator with the United States Coast Guard Investigative Service S.esewe) having retired after 22 years drring March 2010. 5. I was formerly an lnvestigator with the Office ofthe Attorney General with the State of Texas serving from August 2008 until I quit during September 2009. 6. On my own and not as an Investigator or Special Agent with any state or federal agency I looked into circumstances surrounding then U.S. Senator Barack Obama's Selective Service registration. 7. I have utilized the Selective Service's "Check A Registation" online firnction fuIUUgSSSoV) numerous times to verify whether a required registration was properly completed. 8. On or about February 13, 2008, I sent an email to information@ssq.ggv asking why Senator Obama's registration didn't show up when queried on the Selective Service website (raluw. sss. eqv). 9. On the sarne day (February 13, 2008) I received an email from igformation@sss.gov stating "Sir: There may be an error in his file ormany other reasons why his registration cannotbe confirmed on-line. However, I did conIirrn with oru Data Management Center that he is, inded registered with the Selective Service System, in compliance with Federal law. Sincerely, Janice L. Hughes/SSS". 10. On September 7, 2008 I viewed a televised interview in which then Senator Obama stated that he registered for the Selective Service when he graduated from high school. I recalled that Senator Obama graduated from high school n 1979 and the Selective Service registration requirements were not reinstituted until
1980. 11. I submitted a Freedom Of Information Act (FOIA) to the Selective Service System for Senator Obama's Selective Service registration. I received a copy of a Selective Service regishation in the name of Barack Hussein Obama and a copy of a computer screen print out with a date of 09/09/08. 12. Reviewing these copies I noted several areas of concem. For example, I noted that on the regisfation copy the signature of the registrant was dated July 30, 1980, but the United States Postal cancellation stamp indicating date received was dated the previous day of July 29, 80. I also noted that the 't{o ID" block was checked indicating that the registrant did not present an ID when the registration

1. I arn a resident of Texas.

was said to have been presented to the postal clerk. The most outstanding aspect of the registration card was that the aforementioned U.S. Postal Cancellation Stamp had onJy a two digit year instead of the usual four digit year. 13. During my active military service with the us Army from 19?3 to 1977,I served as a collateral duty as one of my unit's mail clerk. During that service I was farniliar with US Postal regulations and procedures. It was my understanding that the US Postal Cancellation stamp was a four digit year and not a two digit year. I also knew that the day, montlq and year of that model postat cancellation stamp are removable inserts that the postal clerk changes as appropriate. I have nevei seen a two digit insert for that model postal cancellation stamp. 14. Over several weeks, I researched the issue on the internet attempting to find any other incident where that model cancellation stamp had a two digit year instead of the usual four digit year. I was unable to find any other instance where that model postal cancellation stamp had a two digit year instead of the usual four digit year. 15. Using my training and experiences, I analyzedthe image of the postal cancellation stamp on tlre copy of the registration. It is my conclusion that a four digit year insert ending in "08" was modified by cutting off the first two digits and reinserting the "08" upside down into the postal cancellation stamp to indicate a year of "80". The only four digit year ending in *08" I felt that would be reasonably available would be a'?008" year insert. 16. On the copy of the computer screen printout received under the FOIA I noticed that there was a iine marked DLN and the number of *8089 708 0632". I also noted that on the copy of the Selective Service registration card there was a similar nurnber in the upper right hand comer. This number was "0892080632". The number on the registration card appeared to be a'oBates" type print that

automatically changes with each impression. 17. The difflerences between the DLN number on the computer soreen printout and the registration card printout appears to be the addition ofthe digit *8". I know
no reason for the addition of the "8" in the DLN.
18. Based on

of

my observations, research, experience and training, it is my belief that the Selective Service registration caxd I received under the Freedom Of Information Act request underthe name ofBarack Obama has been altered.

Sworn to me and subscribed before me this

0A
T.{,d.

day ofJanuary 2013.

adilh?"
G.t^}tLS
Nc*tp^t ?vblc

!i4.. trz i*= rl=

JS
t?....s

..

,ni fr ITAET
FIRST

RTUS SXSTOR? IFQIIIRT

SCREEIS

l4ffiEgt$i",E"F,$..s;ilr^
OBAIilA

NAIdB: BARACE mSSBIil ADDRE9S: 161? S BERgnAfrtA er?Y/sTllE/zrJt B0litorJirlru

CURREI{! DATB OF

NAME:

mA[tt-C1lDgr/rrp3: 110 ,/

DATEr 09/09/oa

PAGE OO1 OF

SG2

Apif 1s0s

$slll:

eTTY/STA?S/ZrP: EONOI.ilT&U BTRTBT 0a/0d/fr.

PERMA$BNT

ADDRE$S: 15L? S

BERETAffiA ApT 10gg

HI

95825 96825

TEIrEPIIOIIE; DIJ$:

F 808 000

rru[NSACTIoI{

DATS:

so89 708 09/04/30

0000

0632

REtSff:

IjAST ecTlON DAIE: REISTED $SN:

09/04/a0 00 0000000

PRESS: CT.EAR ==>

END

PIF?

*=> PecF BAgn[eRD PFB ==> PAIIB

FORI|ARD

-a

ffi

SIIECTwE st[VtCF SYSTEM

Rogirlralion Form
RtAD PRtVACj ACT $tAt:ErnEXr O$

osS?0soa32

rlflsF

8vrarr

PFTTJT

Cl-tAlLy

A}44

BA.e.a{fo*.,ooo

lLrJ .i'Tf Rerrr+tt+. tbilb.r md Su{l

t^-r46

9ly

toto*t =

.,

.,

SHD q Falior Conb

Il*nr+r

,/f2t

*t *#

_g .o0 Ct*r trF ? F

a
tsr nFt. #6t

g.:t
td htattr@

Fen.l O& Ssr6I & Ch't t^;d.lt

3
sms.

dat gtr

r9frDr to A6dd GKs

iiit.F6'dt6ol'rc,

rAtro*^tn*u. "

St?tltu! d Rrttrlnt
(i'++qf

a'ldlltnrhal

le!

Fxhibit

v0Tt0

f'ltl{s

S0URCI

orl0l2!

rl Enumcraw

WND EXCLUSIVE

SHEFIFF -,CE DEIMANTS CBFI\IA DFPFI FECIS-TFP]ICN

Selective Service regulation changed days after probe announced
Published: 0511012012 at B:27 PM

13. I -'

-&5
4l

FFCMF R CCRSI (HTIF:/ / \AIA\A \ANr CCITTV At ITHCF/. CCFST/ Ahor rt I Fmair (mailln jcorsi@wnrlclnetdaily nom) |Archive (htlfr'//wunvwnd cnmi:rrlhnriicnrsi/?archir,e=trrre)
.

suhs.ribe to tert (http

//'m Mrt

cnm/arrihor/jnorsi/teprt)

Ads by Gooqle (http://www.qooqle.com/url? ct=abq&q=https:/ /vww.qooqle.com/adsense/supporUbin/request.pflo3Fcontacto/o3Dabq

aic%26url%3Dhttp://www.$rnd.com/2012l05lsheri

ilB7;f,i33l3S;?H##l?$i?ti3*t'lnf6tf,ffi,i?ljfrU,T#Kr$;il,iff;d;"ta;rr-ap,o'

OnoPOlitiC a lPlaza. c O.n(htlp://wu/w.googleadservices.com/pagead/aclk? sa=L&ai=CtgWjJLQUZv3lrH_wQHz3YGQBJ_JjLoD\iOiNm l nAjbcBEAEgSZPsFl DAtlo2Ylvtne5obloSAZoAGS6oX9ASgBAagDAaoEmAFP0JT 5jShkr6aBhxMSV'-HvC63h_7JKk-uxtb0lYqd04e0pmtQqE6QUaheD2LPTHF2s_8A\6K_cH5J62lCeK{Rm EZxm Nw1 NEFwCZTh6bVe8NqyqTUTqxYDQnt\lgS>evP5UfyZdJiVs4uOM _HlGHXr_MkaaH 1 UHcVL_xCM43wSRiAcTvtNou lxX6tUpGAZHq4G0kbj0yaJ4gGAYAHrSXGAg&num=1&cid=5Gg_-N5SH87CH8tgJFYCq iQ&s g=AOD64_2h rs Ob20TZGa BlBx_lQA5O4tig5w&client=ca-pub4362624082965872&adurl=http:/Arvww.onepoliticalplaza.comiin.js p%3Furl%3Dnews letter.jsp%26s rc%3Daw)
i

t9
Providing proof that Sheriff Joe Arpaio intends to continue his

investigation of President Obama's eligiblity, his Cold Case Posse has pressed the director of the Selective Service System not to destroy any
microfilm records that may yet exist of Obama's 1980 draft registration form. ln an emergency letter Wednesday to Selective Service System Director Lawrence Romo, Mlke Zullo, the lead investigator in the Cold Case Posse, asked for reassurance that the microfilm records still exist.
Ads bv Gooqle
(http:/iwww.qoo g e.con /u rl ? ct=ab g &q =hft ps JArvww.qooq I e.com /ads ense/s upporUbin/r
I

(hth //wuru wnd com/n01 ?/OS/qheriffr tdg;:g ,

Clcm: rlclc-

ohama-

draftregistratinn/pIint/)

"We would like to be assured of the disposition of the microfilm reel or reels containing President Obama's Selective Service regisiration form," Zullo wrote. "Please indicate whether or not you have possession of the microfilm reel or reels containing President Obama's records or access to them."

walk-rn Tg.}f-F,pt.io
Disa bled,
s
co
(h ttp e

://www. $ro gl ead

;;= i'aii:ittL'r2lrdiii'
7

zlosls heritl-ioes ervi c nlloaoia??aii k?9 tl 9% 3 rrca

YDpa6lvQHwgyGYAGGqsd

QD vZaX9z2 d i7'l 1.G BA B I P GT

The concerns were raised after Arpaio's office received official confirmation from the Selective Service System that Obama's paper draft registration records have been destroyed after being microfilmed.
ln addition, an article Frublishcd MOnday lry lhc WashingtOn Tisps "(:ornmtrniliec" snnial rrnalisln qection (http //cnmrnr rnities washingtontinFs. enmheighbnrhnod/frecclom-pressnOt-frec/20f irnayl7/qrtcstinn-qr rrrOunding-presidenr-nharnas-Clraft-n+rdl) repOrted new

Bco AID xlVT FBZDJn uaGvK!

wGq BJqBTeq2AFjla ngY2o I g FiO\,r/GJr oas PchZODToo J Jr qiKWOoBla LobsxRiN- tvuodr azpl-4tvtkTwoHWieKTGH ngyl 6 BxloO\ArtwwECGl i Exe JCUI 9y3ofr'9-s'3oxa

ggeeiFlp P.Liisi'ngsiei

jnr

nT(ltMyl tynser4-te 99laz id"t

u zJ Na m c

Selective Service privacy rules might allow existing microfilm records to be destroyed as

!!ll.
Zullo expressed concern the microfilm records of Obama's draft registration form might

99W9F.W-9'1
ivRQYBl
W. n.f.+.'t y d

P.'.f.-. r r r

ror'.t

kB uTX?WAs'lrrk53UUQk-'<d

I iz

iu

already have been destroYed.

FESTbe FlzSRqv/o

vsd2tagtrmJRt{diAYBoAehN

gBI rOEaTeCV_0jaN4&s

l'l:,1 .*9i { :..s,91'1,?s 6

i

22408296 5 872 &adurl jnnp:lrvruw. s'aGs ieoiu u io tA

4 36

"ln the unfortunate event the microfilm reel or reels containing president Obama's Selective Service registration form has been destroyed, can you ptease advise of the date lsr-o;,p5t*U'tttt***, Puo-:lrisPSivcaKGvYefQS3ca the records rir,ere destroyed and the location at which they \,ere destroyed,,' he asked. Zullo's letter save Romo 10 business days within receipt of the tetter to respond. Romo, who was appointed director to the U.S. Selective Service System in 2009 by President obama, reports directly to the president.

g=AODd4 zuty-lsiikBmqA agioxooT*o-1,6_tqSbAU

ae

"ry!4i3,:ljlF[li;r:5;3t,r:
Expert Installation &)9Jh
,_fE

Available.

We.rr'*i:ili",l,?,"^j,^ rrrcruo"Jritrii;tilJ i:ii

qafeStepTub-cor"/pre Selective Service admitsdestruction

e- trqtifFatec
(fttp/Ayw]ryg9og.lea'rrcervicote es.com./oaoead/aclk? YDoa6wQHvr9YGYA6GSsd
7.Bco AID

Romo a letter directly asking if the Selective Service System still retained the original paper draft resistration form. ;;:L#lJicii;jtl.d'ri?'na's o}z:.xszzdiTxl'GBABlPcTiginal, authentic Selective Service registration form for Barack Obama from July 29, 19g6, x17.7 F B2DJn u a GvK ".laOiitlrha$l) or not you have possession of this document," Arpaio wrote. "lf the docurnent is in your

wcqBJsBTgc2iFjtangy2.sie it available for inspection by my Sheritf's Office investigators. We will travel to your facility to
Fj OwQJI_g a s Pg hZODTgqJ qiK\AOoSlaLobsxRvN-

cfre;

RTIMJWT$&qslv.4-tq Qo!, iiiir-.iviirwoFiri;gi'n*;tahavan, associate director of public and intergovernrnental affairs for the Selective Service

dB;loowtwwEccliEreJctll paio with a letter indicating the agency had destroyed Obama's original paper and ink draft
cy4Op0sxQX4r6ofxUzJ Nam iia voi'd eWiiia i;ir-'' kBuTX2WAslrrkS3U U0kxdl

_.;-vitoveroie$rbenzSRqv! no; it was destroyed in 1980," Flahavan wrote. "Per agency policy and practice, when a V.^S?qlss,ltnUlFl,9.!4J?9e!n record is created from the registration card, the card is microfilmed and the paper card is then v6sh&num = 1.&cid:5GhP2s .,r'i...:.i,;;:ir i.-.;i. r:.;i.'..-.;:n NgBLQEaTeCV_ojaN4&si'' our policy for more than 30 years."
g=AOD64_2utY-

a3l pXQDTsednb-;afe?
S5uDXBbBg&client=ca4

chttpl//www.saf6!i!p1tli66intheFederalRegisterSept.20,

9l!;f 4rWashington ^qlf,l'lf.,g!tl 3626 2 4 0 829 6 5 87 2 &ad u rl

Tinres article, Alan Jones noted that the Selective Service System f,rrhlichc.t new

nvlree-99!im4te/)- s11s1 WNn reported Scpt r 6, ?n11, (httn'//u r r.wnri norn/2011/0q/345685/) that Arpaio had commissioned the Cold Case Posse to open an inquiry with full subpoena po\ er into the alleged forgery of several kate Middleton lrnents, including his long-form birth certificate and his Selective Service draft registration form. (http#www.gbogleadservicrs the first update to Selective Service privacy regulations in 11 years.
es.com/pagead/aclk?

Photos

new regulations reclassify the status of draft registration forms from "record copies" to "non.S.i=Ll?i-^911'6JY.zi9!lr;lt the '
YDoaGwQHwgYGYMrlzNo
gCUlvlyogZT-

@ujvur4ucaentgszesFyProviso that "non-record copies" are subject to disposal.

- -----YFsE7'nlhs.ijkqr.n-sAtions further allow the Selective Service System to destroy microfilm copies of Selective Service a6 SlsDvAEBoAMBooSbA ii3icil;Eaied;;ifaar certain circumstances
A7q yb Gj i BD m
p U4 u lxun OX Oczgwzeh Nklyj SP$yca KG vYeiQS3caseaj FTdH 7b9wu

&kOwOjeinrzbJdgbLBich certificate and his Selective Service registration form are forgeries.
DEFN BJmsgvCghqZRa_d

in Phoenix, Arpaio announced the Cold Case Posse had found probable cause that !.1Hfl.:.I?lY-Ii.llgtiYnrerence R DVD N 7Z34tAos HeFdlLPi

1:FLBNQ.{cw7'bBPs-.P4n4s
:l;qI:{Q.E^V_ym Yn D ka oliAYB $Reow t+ E&n u m =2 &ci d =5G

Selective Service registration form, with the Post Office date stamp, July 29, 1980, in the lo!\,er

hP2sNgBLQEaTeCM_0jaN 4'&sid=AoD64,_l llPoQJR$viewed

l!.16.

a number of authentic Selective Service registration forms obtained from the federal
Inf o

&client=ca-pub4362624 O 8296 5 87 2&ad uil lir ttp:.1)uin*,w.styri bistro.co /lookboo k/KateTo ?Flia{llgt
o

l{tlf

51',P91

F.

19L'{i49eedom of

rmation Act req uests.

nVo3F za

_co/o3 D Kate -

nag

tou, of the authentic Selective Service registration forms. All of the forms have a Post office stamp with four digits ::::i'T,ll::Y19"9i' Pflncess Kate Middleton and the -st, ine year designation in Obama's Selective Service registration has two digits, specifying only "80" no/uf n.mifl.
Eig$ll""Sg BIYJBYI,,

Kate=d of"1980." Middleton,StyleBistrogClbit C shows the standard Post Office date-stamp equipment that was used to stamp Selective Service registration (http://www.googleadservic :;l:;h/r;-J"i;;iik6ib-ws tne three slots on the bottom of the stamp in which the month, day and year plugs trcre
sa=h&ai:CbR6!jZLQUt

YDoa6wOHwg'
DOquJvUlPibcBEAlqSZPs

ddtiffio;2;i
..E

tne "

wFovZZnuhsiikBm
p,f 9.PJ4 Fgt{_B.q s.s t -6_ U_QtiC 1_nBBlGgyaUcAi ATqybGjiBDm pU4ul

\rYeiQS3caseaiFTdH

99.9ry4!!!kLrjsl9

C'S_ywlllsTBSV We RDvDNTZ3gAqsHeF
erkQwQ3BtnKTC DEFNBJmsgvCghqZRa_d 1 FLBNQJcWTbBD9J

4&sig=AOD64_1 NPOQJR
lV16NUL54lvBclFxQ1

/lookb ooUKate %2

Mid d

let

ono/o3Fzam c%3DKate-

Maa;i;;d;di;;t
registration.

(/20 1 2/03/sheriff-joe-wants-nha rnaq-origin

l-draft-cerrdisca/)

While some of the letters stamped in

Exhibit A: Barack Obama's Selmtive Service registration form

the outer ring on some of the authentic

documents are indistinct or even missing, all of the

r trllra

-f

authentic date
stamps include four digits for the year at the center of the stamp.

-I:l

E
-I

lnvestigators duplicate Obama's

date stamp
Arpaio's investigators located and
interviewed several
'198Os-era Post

r --

rr

IIIEI

I-

IrI

- rI

(f20'l 2/0?/shoriff-joe-wa nt"-ohamas-originai-d raft-ca

rcl

/sst'/)

Exhibit B: Authentic Slective Srvice registration forns, w ith Fost Off ice starps containing fourdigit year designalion

Office employees

,rhi: :ril*::ici:' initt ii

irgi:irng cu: now

,jl:r:r.t
_-

:i"it,f. liY.j

t"il E=
ifu

,r

",*

:f

Service iegistration
ha','e obiained a

ffi_
En::

,-.,F ai.=!

-q

il?0 : 2/o3.lSheriff-joe-rtanic-+iramas-eriginei-clr#1-car'lls=n/i

Exhibit E shows investigators were

&hibit

C: Standard Fost Office date stanp, Selective Service regislration

able to obtain an authentic 1980 pica date stamp. The photograph also
shows the knife set

used in the investigation.

Since investigators could find no 1980 pica Post Office date stamps available, they had no choice but to cut a 2008 pica Post Office date stamp and invert the "08" half, so that when it was placed in the

(l^O

'/Oi/ehefiff-jOc-wa niS-nharnas_nrig

ina l_rt raft_n: rcllqecU)

Exhibit D: Authentic Selective Service registration dale stanps, 1980

date compartrnent, the stamp printed

out "80." Surprisingly, the

result ended up
looking identical to the date stamp on Obama's Seleciive

Service registration card, as demonstrated in

Exhibit F. Exhibit G makes clear that the off-to-

the-right date stamp seen in the registration, the

sarne as is seen in the demonstration by Arpaio's
(

i20 1 Znsishcriff-joe-wa nts-obams-origina t-draft-card /cse/)

Exhibit E: Knife used to cut "2008" date, Fica Fost Offrce date stamp

investigators, is not observed in the authenticfour-digit pica date stamp used in the sane office indicated on Obama,s Selective Service registration, which has the san month, July 1980. The numbers "80" are out of line to the right in Obama's card because when they were cut away from the "2008" date
plug, they were not cut squarely.

Arpaio's investigators concluded that Obama's Selective Service registration form fit into what was becoming a comrnon narrative for his life: The document was not only forged, it was poorly forged.
ln a March

l9letier addressed to Romo, Arpaio explained that

MCSO investigators were able to replicate the alleged

forgery.

vzL, , ,,'

rL1,/brlts'

"rJne-waLrts-rJr)atrras-.rrtgrn2t-qJart-crro/ssJ/l

(/2n'1 ^/03/sheriff-joe-wants-obarnas-orig
rronth. san Fost Office

inal-rlraft-ca rdlssg/)

Exhibit G, Obarra Seleclive Service regislration on left, authentic Slective Service registration on righl

- sar

19
Ads by Gooqle (http:l Mww.qooqle.com/url? nl=f h^.P-d=ht^c /Au0{lrtq4,!dlA"{:nmlad$en*AlSr.rOrrOrt/hin

/.a^,,6c I ^rpl^2traa ntaa/-

oa

(httF'/iww wnd
joe= demr^ClSobarna-

nnml2O

a/OS/Sheriff-

draft-

MOST POPULAR

rogistration/prirlU)

;3*

6* i

6
It begins:Major

Ii

r;

Claim: Obama hid'gay

The only hope for our

demand to impeach Obama

life'to become
president (http://www.wnd. com/20 1 21 09 I cl aim-obam a-hid-

nation's future
(http://wwrv.wnd. com/20
1

(http:/lwww.wnd.comi20 1 3/06/demand-obamas-

Police buried Trayvon's criminal history (http://www.wnd. com/20

3/06/the-onlv-hopeJor-

13/04/police{uried-

Exh ib

it

Excerpt of a report of a March 25.2A09 meeting by Dr. Orly Taitz, ESQ and William Austin Chatfield, director of Selective service regarding forgery of Selective Service Certificate of Barack Hussein Obama, II

Dr- Orly Taitz, Esq. met with William Austin Chatfield, Director of Selective Service at 10:l5am EST, March 25.2009 . The meeting took place at: Selective Service System, National Headquarters 1515 Wilson Blvd. Arlington, Virginia 22209. Dr. Taitz introduced herself as the attorney for 140 Military Plaintiffs, active and retired, subject to recall. who are concerned about the Constitutional authority of Barack Obama to be Commander in Chief. Major General Carroll D. Childers is among these Plaintiffs. In addition to being attorney for the Military Plaintiffs. Dr. Taitz also represents 10 State Representatives in this matter. Based on this. Dr. Taitz addressed Mr. Chatfield on some inconsistencies found with Barack Obama's Selective Service Registration records. Dr. Taitz presented some of the findings (Attachment A) that were delivered to US Department of Justice Eric Holder, Jr., Attomey General. The findings indicate that Barack Obama's Selective Service Registration document was created in 2008, and backdated to 1980. Dr.Taitz showed Mr. Chatfield that the Document Location Number, 0897080632, appearc to be a 2008 creation. However on the printout, an extra eight (8) was added in front of the number to make it look like it is from the year 1980. Dr.Taitz also showed Mr. Chatfield that the postal stamp on the Selective Service Registration Form was incorrect. The stamp used was an obsolete postmark round dater-stamp (retired almost ten (10) years before 1980) to validate a legal document. Mr. Chatfield didn't have any comment on these inconsistencies nor did he offer any explanation. Dr.Taitz provided Mr. Chatfield with a fulI copy of the dossier sent to the Attorney General, Eric Holder. A copy can be downloaded here: link removed She higirlighted sections of the dossier to show Mr. Chatfield that Barack Obama has hundreds of Social Security Numbers and properties associated with his name. One Social Security Number in particular w'as issued in Connecticut " and lists him as being 118 years old. (Attachment B) While addressing the issue of hundreds of Social Security Numbers and properties being associated with Barack Obama's name. Dr. Taitz drew attention to two addresses of interest: one located in Illinois and another in New.Iersey . The address located in Illinois .1525 S. Sangamon St. Unit 707, Chicago IL was sold to an Osama Baraliat. The Osarna Barakat listed (Attachment F) has connections to a foundation that is listed in the'oGolden Chain'as sponsors of al Qaeda. (Attachment C) shows an address in New Jersey for Kelly J. McCrr;m, wife of Craig M. Robinson. Craig Robinson is Michelle Obama's brother, and is listed at 45 Willow Street in South Amboy, NJ. Not only can this address not be found by mapping the street, but this address had a credit lien on it by a company, Burlow Plumbing. Burlow Plumbing has a commercial affiliate named Magic Plumbing.

(Attachment D) shows that Magic Plumbing had worked on the sprinkler system at the World Trade Center just days before 9/1 l. One of the men that performed this work lived in Brooklyn . He left Brooklyn on9/I1 and went to Tennessee . A woman that had a court date involving identity theft with the motor vehicle department in Tennessee met a mysterious death. Mr. Chatfield had no comment or thought in reference to this material being shown to him. Dr.Taitz then provided Mr. Chatfield with information on Barack Obama's former client, Ahmad Bavarati. (Attachment E). Mr. Bavarati ran a non-profit called the Iran Earthquake Relief Fund, which subsequently changed its name to American Care Society, but still supported scientific work in lran . Mr. Chatfield promised he would look into these matters.

Exhibir 4

r r r

Complete items 1, 2, and 3^ Also cornplete hem 4 if Restricted Delivery is desired. Print your name and address on the reverse so that we can return the card to you. Attach this card to the back of the maitpiece, or on the front if space permits.

E Agent Q-lsq$ee1
B. Beceived by i Pnnted fiame)
D. ls delivory address different from item i
lf YES, enter delivery address

1. Arlicle Addressed to:

7 Cl Yes below: [f No

3.

Ltl ,yt3,,
(fran sfs r frc m se N i ce I abel)

lf

ServiceType
Certmso

E RegtstercC [f E lnsurod Matt tl

Uait u

F:rpress Mait

Retum Reoeipi for Merchandlse

C.o.D.

aaq d Tiln'n"Tnas
PS Form 381 1, February zO04
Domestrc Feturn Feceipt

s''t

Yes

02595-02-M- I 540

U5F5
Track & Confirm
YOUR LABEL NUMBER SERVIC
E

STATUS
OF YOUR

DATE

ITEM

&
TIME

LOCATION

FEATURE

Delivered June ARLINGTON, VA 222A Certified

7, I
2013
'12:3

Mail-

5pm

Notice June ARLINGTON, VA 2220 Left (No Authorize 2013

7, I

d,

Recipient 11:1 Available)3 am Arrival at June ARLINGTON, VA 2220

Unit

7, I
2013

Depart

2A13 Facility Processe June MERRIFIELD, VA 2208 d through 1 USPS 2013

Sort

USPS 7,

b:5s am June MERRIFIELD, VA 2208

1

7,
,

Sort

Facility 2:OA
am June ANAHEIM, CA 92899
6,

Depart

Sort

USPS

2013

Facility Processe June ANAHEIM, CA 92899 d through 5, USPS 2013

YOUR LABEL NUMBER

sERVrc

#1rttt_ &
rrEM

DATE LOCATION

FEATURE
S

TIME

Sort Facility

4:31 pm