Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
TUESDAY
May 12, 2009
The Stanford Daily An Independent Publication
www.stanforddaily.com Volume 235
Issue 56
LAW SCHOOL
FEATURES
PC OF MIND
By MELANIE SCHEIBLE
Students tread fine line
P
olitical correctness (PC) has a degree
of jurisdiction over a wide range of
contentious issues, on campus and
off. But the actual term “political
between political correctness
correctness” is ill-defined, at best.
This contributes to a variety of opinions about
when and where it’s appropriate to be PC.
and over-sensitivity
Members of Students for an Open Society
(SOS) confront issues like these. the potential benefits for both the speaker and encounters an African American
“Politically incorrect? Is that supposed to the listener in exchanges that are kept at a PC student’s idea of race,” Turner said.
have a positive or negative connotation?” level. Theoretically, being politically correct “We have a culture where we can
questioned SOS member Boris Hanin ‘09. should make us, as speakers, tolerant and talk about that kind of stuff.”
Considering political correctness itself has open-minded; as listeners, it should make us But what about political incorrect-
become something akin to censorship, SOS respected and comfortable. ness? Humor can take the form of
believes it’s better to be accountable than Experts, though, do not always support this racial slurs, mimicking stereotypes or
politically correct. goal to be “politically correct.” exploiting the disabilities of others.
“It’s good [that we aren’t offensive] insofar “I’m rejecting the term [“political correct- MSAN, however, utilized
as when things are less offensive, people are ness”] outright,” said Fred Turner, assistant humor to bring a better
generally being held more accountable,” professor of communication and, by courtesy, understanding to the non-
Hanin said. “When something is offensive, it is of American Studies. “The practice is to be Muslim community about Islam by
often closely associated to the fact that it is sensitive to difference. ‘PC’ can be a snarky putting on a comedy show earlier
fabricated or exaggerated.” term for that important process.” this year.
At Stanford, it seems common to be cau- SOS aims to promote open dialogue across “We had a lot of debate about
tious in choosing language when referring to campus, which can reach the core of complex what the comedians should and
groups of certain races, ethnicities, religions, and controversial issues. Group members real- shouldn’t be able to say,”
genders or sexual orientations. ize this can provoke offensive or insulting Ramadam said. “Comedy is a
Students in the “Freedom, Equality and remarks, but find it important that people are really touchy subject. We don’t
Difference” Introduction to the Humanities able to appreciate opposing views and opin- want to monitor the comedy itself,
(IHUM) course said they asked their Teaching ions. The discourse is to remain reasonable because if it’s not touchy, it’s not going to
Fellows (TFs) what terminology to use when and respectful to elicit legitimate considera- be funny.”
referring to members of racial groups. tion. Prior success with Ahmed Ahmed, an
Program in Writing and Rhetoric (PWR) “Being PC is important because you need internationally popular Muslim come-
instructor Susan Schuyler identified a few to coexist, but it comes to an extreme when dian, may have helped.
guidelines for students, such as to avoid put- you can’t ask the really tough questions,” said “Two years ago, Ahmed Ahmed
ting the word “the” in front of any racial or Nada Ramadam ‘10, president of the Muslim came and a lot of people came and
religious group. Student Awareness Network (MSAN). “If loved the act,” Ramadam said. “But he
However, Schuyler doesn’t believe there they know someone in their class or in their did make some Muslims uncomfort-
are very comprehensive resources available to dorm, I don’t think there’s anything wrong able with jokes about Moses getting
determine what is and is not PC. Rather, it is with having a heated discussion.” high and seeing the Burning Bush. He
an individual’s responsibility and decision to Ramadam added that she feels the pressure can get away with that because he’s a
determine what kind of language is appropri- in American culture to be PC, which she never professional comedian.”
ate in any particular setting. experienced in her native home of Saudi Still, it’s not always so easy for
Schuyler prefers to err on the safe side. Arabia. Yet, the dialogue keeps going. Stanford students.
“[I would] rather see people being over- “One of the things I love about Stanford
sensitive,” she said. students is they’ll raise sensitive issues in class Contact Melanie Scheible at scheible@stanford.
The rationale for being “over-sensitive” is — for example, when an African student edu.
CRIS BAUTISTA/The Stanford Daily
The Stanford Daily Tuesday, May 12, 2009 N 3
OPINIONS
EDITORIAL The Stanford Daily
Established 1892 AN INDEPENDENT NEWSPAPER Incorporated 1973
Christian Torres
President, Editor in Chief
Managing Editors
Devin Banerjee
Deputy Editor
Joanna Xu
Managing Editor of Intermission
Tonight’s Desk Editors
Eric Messinger
News Editor
T HE D UDE A BIDES
SPORTS
Manny being Wyndam
Makowsky
Manny,sort of Between the lines
Manny Ramirez, suspended last along with the apology jig because at
week for 50 games for steroid use, re- some point, I have to preserve my
cently addressed his teammates on the livelihood, and given how high and
issue.The remarks, prepared at the re- mighty everyone is on the steroid
quest of Los Angeles owner Frank issue, I’d essentially be talking myself
McCourt, were given last night at out of the League. I may be edgy, but
Dodger Stadium. The Daily has been I haven’t lost my mind.
fortunate enough to obtain his That said, these thoughts will re-
speech, and will reprint it here for main with me, as I’m sure they will
public viewing. remain with you. I’m fine being be-
rated in public by pundits who make
T
hanks for coming, every- their paychecks by tearing down leg-
one. I’ll be brief. I won’t ends, or by a general manager who
even continue to deny the saved his career by trading for me.
obvious. I admitted this to But here, in this room, let’s just be
Mr. McCourt, and I’ll real with ourselves. Let’s acknowl-
admit it to you.Yes, I did steroids. But edge the 800-pound gorilla: we are all
what I didn’t tell Mr. McCourt is this: complicit, and we all know the un-
I don’t regret it. written law of land. Don’t ask, don’t
Let’s be honest, I am not the only tell and definitely do not get caught.
one in this clubhouse who has juiced. But I was caught, so now I will say
I’d only be mildly surprised if the this, to you, my teammates: The only
number of people who has reached thing I’m truly sorry for is that I was-
into double figures. I’m not trying to n’t smart enough to shield my usage
out anyone, but let’s not blind our- better. And not even because of the
selves to the facts. Steroid users are public shame it brought my family
CHRIS SEEWALD/The Stanford Daily no longer pariahs, but instead the and me — no, because my positive
Freshman Pallavi Menon and the Cardinal fought No. 6 UCLA down to the wire in the national semifinal game, but fell victim to a UCLA goal in the final rule. It’s nothing foreign — doping in test meant that I would have to sit
this sport goes back to the days of out nearly a third of the season, and,
seconds, losing 11-10. The Stanford women’s water polo team rebounded from its disappointment to defeat No. 4 Hawaii in the third-place game. Eisenhower. It’s just in this past let’s be frank, there are few players in
decade that we’ve become funda- the League more valuable to their
mentally against it. franchise than I am to the Dodgers.
Card loses to UCLA in final seconds of semifinal, takes third place in championships the game? This isn’t merely a trou-
bled few looking for a way to get
ahead — this is an institutional issue.
But, we do play in the NL West —
it is so weak that merely breaking
.500 is probably enough to win the di-
Baseball could have acted; it did not. vision title. If we can’t maintain our
By MICHAEL LAZARUS freshman Pallavi Menon scored the tying goal on though, as UCLA scored the game-winning goal So, a cycle was born. Some use lead without me, then we have far
CONTRIBUTING WRITER the ensuing possession. After the second straight with five seconds remaining.The Bruins went on and get ahead, and others feel left be- greater issues than my steroid usage.
UCLA turnover, junior Jessica Steffens put the to defeat USC 5-4 to claim the national champi- hind, so they dope up as well. But, Still, I look forward to rejoining
As the preseason No. 2 seed and the No. 1 seed Cardinal on top,converting on a 6-on-5 power play. onship. I’m not telling you anything that you you in July for the dog days of the
for most of the regular season, a third-place finish The lead did not last for long, however, as the “We came back and played [the] best we had all don’t already know. We’re cut from summer and eventually the postsea-
at the National Collegiate Women’s Water Polo Bruins scored the final two goals of the period to season in those the last three quarters, which made the same cloth — you all know the son. Until that time, I simply ask that
Championship was a disappointing end to the year enter the fourth with an 8-7 lead. the loss that much worse,” Silver said. game — which is why I’ll confide you understand my perspective.And
for Stanford. The fourth period would take Stanford on an The loss sent Stanford to the third-place game these thoughts in you. But in public, given the pervasiveness of this so-
In College Park, Maryland this past weekend, emotional roller coaster. against Hawaii on Sunday. Manny can no longer be Manny, at called problem and its likely pres-
the Cardinal lost to No. 6 UCLA in the semifinals, After tying the game at 8-8, junior Kelly Eaton While surely disappointed about missing out on least for now. It’s best for me to lay ence in this very clubhouse, I know
sending Stanford to the third-place game, where it scored with just over six minutes to play to give the the national championship game, the Cardinal low for now and not voice these opin- you will.
defeated No. 4 Hawaii, 14-11. Cardinal the late lead. A minute later, senior Kira made the best out of its situation. Stanford never ions. I’m sure you look to me and say,
Before squaring off against UCLA on Saturday, Hillman stretched the lead to two with a goal of her trailed in the game en route to the 14-11 victory. “If there’s one superstar juicer who Wyndam Makowsky is apparently a
Stanford dismantled Marist 21-5 on Friday. Even own. “As difficult as it was playing in the third-place will say what we’re all thinking, it will 36-year-old home run hitter. Contact
after the convincing victory over Marist, the Cardi- UCLA reclaimed the lead, however, on a three- game, our team got one more chance to play to- be Manny.” No, it won’t be. I’ll play him at makowsky@stanford.edu.
nal knew it would have its hands full with UCLA. goal streak starting just 15 seconds after Hillman’s gether, and our seniors finished their stellar four
Stanford found out just how hard its time would goal. years here with a win,”Tanner said.
be after UCLA took a 3-1 lead in the first period. With less than a minute until Stanford’s champi- Silver echoed her coach’s sentiments.
The Cardinal could not inch any further in the sec- onship dreams would come to a heartbreaking end, “We’ve been practicing all season to win on that
ond period, entering halftime 5-3. the Cardinal had one final chance to tie the game. Sunday — it was just the wrong game,” the senior
“We had a poor start against UCLA, falling be- As the shot clock ran down,Stanford tried to get off said.“We finished the season right, at least.”
hind because we rushed things on offense,” said a desperation shot.While the Cardinal was prepar- Playing in her final collegiate game, Silver had
Stanford head coach John Tanner.“They scored on ing to take its potential final shot of the season, it arguably her best game, scoring eight goals.
too many after-goal plays, answering our scores heard an unexpected, but welcomed sound: the “I was a little upset not being in the finals, so I
with ones of their own, which kept us from taking UCLA bench blowing its air-horn to call a timeout. wanted to go out swinging and I did that,” Silver
command.” In water polo, the penalty for the defensive team said. “I would give up all my goals in the world in
In the third period, Stanford made its move. signaling for a timeout is a five-meter penalty shot. order to play for the championship, though.”
Down by two with three minutes, 30 seconds left in As it has all season,Stanford turned to its leader, Stanford finishes the season with a 26-4 overall
the period, the Cardinal scored three consecutive Lauren Silver.The senior, as she has all season, de- record, a second-place MPSF trophy and a No. 3
goals under just two minutes to grab its first lead of livered, and tied the game at 10-10 for a potential national ranking.
the game,7-6.Sophomore Kim Kreuger ignited the overtime.
Stanford scoring streak on an outside shot and The Cardinal would not get the opportunity, Contact Michael Lazarus at mlazarus@stanford.edu.
Bloodthirsty in
duction has coincided with Stanford’s
increased success, as the Cardinal has
gone 20-11 over those last 31 games.
The Pac-10 award was Milleville’s
first, and the CBN/LS award was
shared with San Diego State pitcher
Stephen Strasburg, Missouri outfielder
Greg Folgia and San Jose State short-
stop Kyle Bellows.
championships
Women’s rowers sweep Cal Stanford men’s ultimate defense and ended the half with a
4-1 run. Stanford eventually
buckled down on defense while
AGUSTIN RAMIREZ/The Stanford Daily
The Stanford women’s open-weight
rowers, fresh off an impressive sweep team reaches nationals making some great passes and
catches to win the game.
of California at this year’s Big Row,
Senior first baseman Brent Milleville was head to the Pacific-10 Conference “We knew that [the Cal] game
named one of four National Players of Championships on May 16 in hopes of By KENAN JIANG was going to be close and a real
the Week after he compiled 16 RBI and securing a conference title. The No. 1 STAFF WRITER battle, but we thought that our
Cardinal is poised to capture the con- depth would help us pull away in
hit four home runs, two of which were the second half,” said junior team
ference championship after avenging The Stanford Ultimate Fris-
grand slams, during a five-game stretch. bee team advanced to the nation- captain Ryan Thompson.
an early loss to the Golden Bears earli-
er this year.The event lasts through the al championship tournament Both teams played very tight
after a fine showing at regionals. rotations — Stanford relied on its
Milleville wins weekly honors weekend. Pac-10s are expected to pro-
Bloodthirsty, the Cardinal’s Callahan (national Ultimate
vide solid preparation for the women
Stanford senior first baseman Brent as they get ready for the NCAA Cham- “A” team, advanced to next MVP) candidate, coterminal stu-
Milleville was named last week’s Pacif- pionships, which begin on May 29. week’s Ultimate Players Associa- dent Tom James, along with sen-
ic-10 Conference Player of the Week, as Both events will be held in Gold River, tion (UPA) Nationals tourna- ior Chris McCarty, fifth-year
well as one of four National Players of Calif. ment by winning the Bay Area transfer student David Abram,
the Week by the Collegiate Baseball The Stanford women’s lightweight Sectionals in April, and then the coterm captain Nick Schlag,
Newspaper and Louisville Slugger. team was also victorious at Big Row, Northwest Regionals last week in Thompson and fifth-year senior
Milleville destroyed opponents’ defeating Cal’s third varsity eight. The Corvallis, Oregon.At the section- Jacob Speidel.
pitching in his five games last week, hit- team is currently tied with Radcliffe als, Bloodthirsty defeated its On the final play, with the
ting a torrid .474 and scoring six runs. (Harvard) for the second spot in the perennial rival California on its game tied, Abram threw a 60-
His largest impact, though, was in his national rankings. The lightweights way to winning the tournament, yard pass to James, who outran
display of power, as he hit four home head to the Pacific Coast Champi- despite several shaky showings. his defender to win the game.
runs, including two grand slams, and onships on May 16. This event is also No. 6 Bloodthirsty started off Fresh off of its victory, Blood-
drove in 16 runs. In particular, expected to be a stepping stone for the the Northwest Regionals against thirsty will head to the UPA Na-
Milleville excelled in the final two team as it gears up for the Intercolle- Pacific Lutheran College and tionals tournament, where it will
games of the Cardinal’s series with giate Rowing Association (IRA) Na- dominated 15-3 to start off with face off against the 20 best Ulti-
New Mexico, driving in a career-high tional Championships. Both regattas an easy win. The Cardinal then mate teams in the nation, includ-
seven runs on Saturday and hitting one will be held in Sacramento. won against Gonzaga 15-3 after a ing No. 1 Carleton and No. 2 Col-
of his grand slams on Sunday. “The open-water win against their strong early offensive run.Blood- orado.
The recent success is not an anomaly open-weights was a good sign of our thirsty then pulled away in the Stanford hopes to improve on
for the Cardinal first baseman, though, progress and strength this season, but game against UC-Davis 15-7 its third-place showings in 2005
as he has hit .381 with 14 home runs and we have room for improvement in the midway through the match. Stan- and 2006 to achieve its first na-
47 RBI in his last 31 games, raising his next month before taking on our rivals ford won 15-6 against UC-Santa tional championship since 2002.
average for the season to .331. His at nationals,” sophomore lightweight Cruz with strong zone defense Bloodthirsty’s quest for a title be-
power surge has pushed him up to third Katherine Heflin said. before facing Cal for the last gins May 21 in Columbus, Ohio.
in the Pac-10 in RBI and fourth in game, where Bloodthirsty won
home runs. Most importantly, though, — By Jacob Jaffe and 12-11. While Cal got off to an Contact Kenan Jiang at kenanj@
Milleville’s increased offensive pro- Zach Zimmerman early lead, Stanford tightened its stanford.edu.
The Stanford Daily Tuesday, May 12, 2009 N 5
COURT
tion of current Justice Thurgood Emma Goldman Society, agreed on including the military’s “don’t ask,
Marshall, the first African American
to serve on the Court, for whom she
the particular significance of having
a member of the homosexual com-
don’t tell” policy and the choice of
Pastor Rick Warren to participate in DAILY POLL
Continued from front page clerked. munity on the Court. Obama’s inauguration.
“I think it certainly adds a level of “I would say it’s different to have “The probability that either of How likely do you think it is that President Obama will
vulnerability to the nominee,” someone advocate on your behalf them is selected is very low,” Segura nominate an openly homosexual justice for the Supreme
appointment of either woman would Rhode said. “But it also is an oppor- than it is to have someone who is said. “President Obama has not
be a landmark event. tunity to do something that is a land- one of you,” Wadden said. made gay priorities a priority of his Court at some point during his administration?
“I think it would be an enormous mark.” Wadden said her respect for administration.”
step forward for the gay rights “[The level of controversy] Karlan also predates her knowledge Still, students agreed that even a) Very likely. There’s enough political momentum and it
movement to have an out lesbian on wouldn’t be unprecedented,” she of her personal life. the discussion has symbolic value. would help gain support from the Left.
the Court,” Rhode said. “I think it added. “I’ve seen Pamela Karlan lecture Rhode said that while she wished b) Not sure. It will depend on how the gay rights
would help break stereotypes and Students within Stanford’s LGBT a bunch of times, and I actually did- Karlan and Sullivan’s sexuality was
legitimate their qualifications and community are enthusiastic about n’t know she was out until this news not significant to their consideration, movement does over the next few years.
legitimate their normality.” the possibility of the first homosexu- broke,” Wadden said. “I’ve always “that’s not the world in which we c) Unlikely. It’s a big political battle to take on.
“Certainly having a role model al Court nominee. Jamie Tam ‘10, an been really impressed with her.” live,” and the struggle for societal d) Not a chance.
on the caliber of Kathleen Sullivan organizer with the Queer-Straight Sam King ‘10, an active member acceptance often requires steps of
or Pamela Karlan for the nation to Alliance and the Emma Goldman in the LGBT community, said there this nature. e) I don’t care.
see can only be for the best,” she Society for Queer Liberation, feels was the potential for a significant “The only way we can get there is vote today at stanforddaily.com!
added. the move would have great signifi- step to be made. to let people with the courage and
Rhode acknowledged that an cance. “This is definitely a unique histor- lifestyles be out there to represent,”
actual nomination for either, or for “The advancement of LGBT life ical opportunity,” King said. “It Rhode said.
any openly homosexual person, would be tremendous if there were might not happen, but I’m optimistic Tam said that having representa-
intermission
would put the nominee under a an openly queer person on the about it.” tion from Stanford would also be an
great deal of scrutiny. Court,” Tam said. Segura also expressed doubt exciting prospect.
“It would take a personal toll,” Tam also noted that Sullivan or about the likelihood that President “I think it’s cool,” she said. “It
Rhode said. “It sets them up on the Karlan’s “would do a lot for the Obama would choose a homosexual would just be really, really cool.”
receiving end for a lot of hate mail.”
Rhode cited her own memories
queer women’s movement, which is
often marginalized.”
nominee, citing the administration’s
unwillingness to engage on hot-but- Contact Eric Messinger at messinger@
FRIDAY
of harsh resistance to the nomina- Laura Wadden ‘09, a leader of the ton gay rights issues in other areas, stanford.edu.
SHULTZ
CLASSIFIEDS
Secretary of State to explain how to be,” Oliver Ennis ‘11 said of
individuals can work to transform Shultz’s speech. “He always had the HOW TO PLACE AN AD
“what is” into “what ought to be.” ‘ought’ insight guiding his actions.” Call (650) 723-2555 Ext. 1
Continued from front page Shultz used the Reagan-Gorbachev Although the audience left with for display and contract rates
vision of a nonnuclear world as an a clear understanding of Shultz’s *Please allow for 3 business days from the
example of an ideal that has been message, many spectators had when you purchased your ad to when it
the world is and where it should be achieved. entered unsure of what to expect appears in the paper
is the difficulty, Shultz argued. For Shultz, the Cold War repre- from the lecture.
According to Shultz, the power sented a time in which many “I came in with no expectations,” ANNOUNCEMENTS WANTED BY FAX
of ought is “the idea that you have a thought that mutually assured said Neth Walker, a graduate stu- Call 650-725-1329
Please include Credit Card # and Exp. Date
vision out there — a place you destruction protected nations from dent in geological and environmen- Humanist Community in Palo Alto WEB SAVVY GRAD STUDENT E-MAIL
should go — and how complicated nuclear destruction. Having served tal sciences. “I think I’ve been here Diff. speaker each Sun. 11A-noon wanted to refurbish outdated classies@daily.stanford.edu
it is in getting there.” behind the lines, he stated that long enough to know that a lot of Lunch noon-1P www.humanists.org book selling web site of small, ON THE WEB
Click on “Buy Classified Ads” at
Throughout his speech, Shultz there were “too many close calls” times it’s hard to tell what some- local publisher. http://www.stanforddaily.com
DONORS WANTED www.PeninsulaPublishng.com.
rooted this assertion in his own life for this tense state to feasibly con- body is going to speak about.” Charles Wiseman. 948-2511
experiences. Among his many tinue. “That being said, I was $$ SPERM DONOR NEEDED $$
achievements, Shultz served as Shultz strongly argued, “People impressed by the message that he Earn up to $100/donation. Healthy
Secretary of the Treasury and don’t have disputes because they offered and the hope that he MEN, wanted for California
Secretary of State under Richard have weapons — they have weapons offered for the future,” Walker Cryobank’s sperm donor
program. APPLY ONLINE:
Nixon and Ronald Reagan, respec- because they have disputes.” added. www.spermbank.com
tively. For him, the peaceful resolution Ennis also commended Shultz’s
Outside of the political arena, between the Soviet Union and the insight as a leader. HOUSING
Shultz has also worked as an aca- United States, made possible “Because he had a clear idea of
demic and businessman. He is cur- through diplomacy and coopera- where he wanted to go, it really EXCHANGE HOMES? Coming to
Princeton-NYC area this fall?
rently professor emeritus of inter- tion, highlighted the “interactive helped him develop a clear objec- Professor with home in Princeton
national economics at the Graduate process between the vision and the tive along the way on how to get seeks exchange while at Stanford
School of Business and a distin- things you need to do to achieve the there,” Ennis said. “I’m just very Sept-Dec 2009. 3 BR, etc, car,
guished fellow at the Hoover vision.” grateful to have been able to hear gardener, near Lake Carnegie. Walk
Institution. “Obviously, his big message was: from such a distinguished person.” to campus or bus to New York.
In his speech, Shultz frequently we always have to be looking at Call 609-216-0072
referred to his experience as how things are and how they ought Contact An Le Nguyen at lenguyen
Cozy escape place for female commuter.
$685/mo. 650-704-3994.
JOBS
CREATE $$ W/O JOB! RECORDED INFO:
877-937-6286, x9022 THEN CALL
Judy Kay, RN @ 650-738-9445 NOW!
Classies
Work!
BUNNIES!
Yeah, they tend to
go for the sprint,
Sports finished really while news goes the
quickly tonight. full mile.