Aquinas University of Legazpi

Research, Planning and Development Pagtais 2013: Facing the Future in Education

EVALUATION OF PAGTAIS
Below are the results of the evaluation of the recently conducted Aquinas University of Legazpi PAGTAIS 2013: Facing the Future in Education conducted on June 3-6, 2013. This report reflects the sentiments of the participants of the activity who are faculty members of the universitys Basic Education and Tertiary Education Level.

1. Rating by the Respondents

Table A: Rating of Seminar Content
Seminar Content 1 2 Appropriateness of Contents to Participants' Intelligence Resource person's effectiveness in eliciting participation Marla C. Papango A 3 Expertise of resource persons on their respective topics Dr. Susana Cabredo Patrick Gerard Paulino Jesus Barizo Maja Francisco Rating Poor 0 0 0 0 Fair 0 0 0 0 Satisfactory 2 1 0 4 Very Satisfactory 18 20 5 17 Excellent 33 32 39 34 Total 53 53 44 55 4.5454545 0 0 0 0 0 0 Average for A 7 3 3 19 21 20 29 31 32 55 4.4 55 55 4.5090909 4.5272727 4.3896104 Average 4.4181818 4.4181818 3.9090909

The top three items/categories with the highest average are all on the expertise of resource persons on their topics. Dr. Susana Cabredo received the highest average equivalent to 4.55, next is Ms. Maja Francisco with the average of 4.53 while Mr. Jesus Barizo got the third highest average equivalent to 4.5.The overall rating for Seminar Content is Very Satisfactory.
4.6 4.4 4.2 4 3.8 3.6 3.4 Marla C. Papango Appropriateness Resource of Contents to person's Participants' effectiveness in Intelligence eliciting participation Dr. Susana Cabredo Patrick Gerard Paulino Jesus Barizo Maja Francisco

Expertise of resource persons on their respective topics

Graph A: Rating of Seminar Content

Aquinas University of Legazpi

Research, Planning and Development Pagtais 2013: Facing the Future in Education
Table 2: Rating of Conduct
Rating Very Satisfactory 17 16 26 24 14 19 22 30 24 26 20 16

Conduct 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 Open Forum Learning Understanding gained Punctuality of those involved Readiness Venue Program Sequence Duration of Activities Participation of attendees Social atmosphere Emcee Audio/Sound Ventilation Average for B

Poor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

Fair 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 0

Satisfactory 2 2 8 0 1 4 5 1 3 5 3 1

Excellent 34 33 20 30 39 32 26 23 26 23 31 37

Total 53 51 55 54 54 55 54 54 53 54 55 54

Average 4.4363636 4.2727273 4.1818182 4.4727273 4.6181818 4.5090909 4.2727273 4.3272727 4.2727273 4.2545455 4.4727273 4.5818182 4.389394

The top three items with the highest rating are: a.) Venue, with an average of 4.61; b.) Ventilation, with 4.58 and; c.) Program Sequence, with the 4.5 of average. It should be noted that there is a very small difference among the ratings of each category. The overall average is 4.4 which is equivalent to Very Satisfactory.

4.7 4.6 4.5 4.4 4.3 4.2 4.1 4 3.9

Graph B: Rating of Conduct

Aquinas University of Legazpi

Research, Planning and Development Pagtais 2013: Facing the Future in Education
Table C: Rating of Value of Activity
Rating Value of the Activity Poor 0 0 0 0 Fair 0 0 0 0 Satisfactory 0 2 1 1 Very Satisfactory 20 23 22 17 Excellent 33 28 30 25 Total 53 53 53 43 Average 4.4545455 4.3272727 4.3818182 3.5636364 4.1818

16 C 17 18 19

Values Acquired Enhancement of Aquinian Identity Attainment of Objectives Over-all Impression Average for C

The table shows that the item which received the highest rating is Values Acquired with an average of 4.45. On the other hand, Over-all Impression has the lowest average (3.56). The over-all average of Value of Activity is 4.18 which is equivalent to Very Satisfactory.
5 4.5 4 3.5 3 2.5 2 1.5 1 0.5 0 Values Acquired Enhancement of Aquinian Identity Attainment of Objectives Over-all Impression

Graph C. Rating of Value of Activity Table D: Grand Average

Indicators Seminar Content Conduct Value of Activity Grand Average Rating Poor 0 0 0 Fair 0 3 0 Satisfactory 20 35 4 Very Satisfactory 120 254 82 Excellent 230 354 116 Average 4.39 4.39 4.18 4.353359684

The graph shows that the Grand Average of all the items/categories listed above is 4.35 which is equivalent to Very Satisfactoty.

Aquinas University of Legazpi

Research, Planning and Development Pagtais 2013: Facing the Future in Education

4.45 4.40 4.35 4.30 4.25 4.20 4.15 4.10 4.05 Seminar Content Conduct Value of Activity

Graph D: Grand Average

2. Comments
What did you like most? talk of Dr. Penetrante Ms. Penetrante's discussion Guidance talk Guidance talk All topics are interesting All topics are interesting All topics are interesting the lecture of Mr. Jess Bariso on student discipline The discussion by Ms. Papango Basic Counseling Techniques talk of Ms. Penetrante and Mr. Paulino the talk of Ms. Penetrante on Guidance Counseling the talk of Ms. Penetrante on Guidance Counseling counseling OBE Resource Persons counseling session with Ms. Neth all talk of Madam Penetrante and Marla Ms. Penetrante's discussion talk of Mrs. Penetrante lecture on the roel of teachers as counselors all the topics all

Aquinas University of Legazpi

Research, Planning and Development Pagtais 2013: Facing the Future in Education
Ms. Penetrante's discussion Ms. Penetrante's discussion speakers like Ms. Marla, Maja & Neth Ms. Penetrante and Ms. Papango's talk Papango's and Penetrante's talk Ms. Penetrante's discussion lectures of Ms. Papango and Ms. Penetrante. lecture of Ms. Panpango and Ms. Penetrante talk of Ms. Penetrante

What did you like least? food food food food food the lecture of Madam Cabredo falling in line to get food food food food serving and menu food food and its servers food food food

What topics need further clarification? Catholic identity of the school the teacher in Catholic school The lecture of Marla Papango on syllabus Topic presented by Madam Cabredo Ms. Francisco's talk on student services talk of Sir Barizo

What in-service training do you think will be of help to you in the future? Moral and Spiritual Enhancement topics counseling counseling cooking enhancement/exposure & presentation employee motivation syllabi making topic of Madam Cabredo the topic of Ms. Papango Technology of Education The role of teachers as counselors

Aquinas University of Legazpi

Research, Planning and Development Pagtais 2013: Facing the Future in Education
professional growth Madam Penefrante all the topics lecture on the roel of teachers as counselors all the topics Guidance counseling rights of teachers Art of Counceling

What are your recommendations for further improvement of this activity? Better food food servings good food, reduce the duration days of seminar and avoid overwhelming activities and presentation lessen the no. of days and improve the meals the lecture should be limited in terms of time. Too long lectures tend to be boring already. limit the seminar for 2-5 days Please conduct more seminars like this, especially on counseling/guidance add more days to counseling techniques more inspiring and enriching sessions food should be improved kindly improve the food service please choose a better caterer. The meals and the service are disappointing to have separate sessions for Basic Education improve the food; get the best resource speakers improve the food