PILDAT Nationwide Poll On 100 Days - Report - September2013 PDF

WWW.PILDAT.
ORG
ON PERFORMANCE OF GOVERNANCE & DEMOCRACY in First 100 Days of Pakistans National & Provincial Governments
September 2013
PUBLIC VERDICT
PILDAT Report Public Verdict on Performance of Governance and Democracy in First 100 Days of National and Provincial Governments September 2013
PILDAT is an independent, non-partisan and not-for-profit indigenous research and training institution with the mission to strengthen democracy and democratic institutions in Pakistan. PILDAT is a registered non-profit entity under the Societies Registration Act XXI of 1860, Pakistan. Copyright Pakistan Institute of Legislative Development And Transparency PILDAT All Rights Reserved Printed in Pakistan Published: September 2013 ISBN: 978-696-558-373-9 Any part of this publication can be used or cited with a clear reference to PILDAT.
Pakistan Institute of Legislative Development And Transparency - PILDAT Islamabad Office: No. 7, 9th Avenue, F-8/1, Islamabad, Pakistan Tel: (+92-51) 111 123 345 | Fax: (+92-51) 226 3078 Lahore Office: 45-A, 2nd Floor, Sector XX, Phase III, Khayaban-e-Iqbal, DHA, Lahore, Pakistan Tel: (+92-42) 111 123 345 | Fax: (+92-42) 3569 3896 Web: http://www.pildat.org Follow Us on
Page 2 of 218
Contents
Preface Executive Summary Factors Underlying High or Low Performance Ratings Part 1: Public Verdict on Performance of Federal Government in First 100 Days Part 2: Public Verdict on Quality of Democracy in First 100 Days
Part 3: Public Verdict on Performance of Provincial Governments in First 100 Days

Appendices Appendix A: Research Methodology Appendix B: Survey Instrument (Questionnaire in Urdu & English) Figures & Tables Table 1: Table 2: Table 3: Table 4: Table 5: Table 6: Table 7: Table 8 Table 9: Table 10: Table 11: Table 12: Table 13: Table 14: Table 15: Table 15: Table 16: Table 17: Table 18: Table 19: Table 20: Table 21: Table 22: Table 23: Table 24: Table 25: Table 26: Table 27: Table 28: Table 29: Table 30: Table 31: Table 32: Table 33: Issue Specific Performance Rating of the Federal Government Popular Verdict on the Performance of Provincial Governments Issue Specific Performance Ratings in the Provinces NPR (Net Performance Rating) Index Views on Best Performing Chief Minister in Own and Other Provinces NPR Index of Federal Government Across Provinces NPR-Index of Federal Government Across Gender NPR-Index of Federal Government Across Age Groups NPR-Index of Federal Government Across Education Groups NPR-Index of Federal Government Across Income Groups Overall Performance Rating Performance on Load-Shedding Performance on Eliminating Terrorism Performance on Foreign Affairs Performance on Inter-Provincial Harmony Performance on Inter-Provincial Harmony Performance on Government-Opposition Harmony Performance on Institutional Harmony with Armed Forces Performance on Choice of Cabinet Performance on Addressing Corruption Performance on Addressing Nepotism Public Verdict on Quality of Democracy Public Verdict on Hope Public Verdict on Effectiveness of the Parliament Public Verdict on Effectiveness of the Federal Cabinet Public Verdict on Effectiveness of the Executive Public Verdict on Democratic Checks on Military Public Verdict on Fairness of General Election 2013 Public Trust in Political Parties Public Verdict on Effectiveness of the Supreme Court Public Verdict on Respect for Human Rights Public Verdict on Independence of Media Public Verdict on Sovereignty NPR Index of Punjab Government Across Punjab
Page 3 of 218
Table 34: Table 35: Table 36: Table 37: Table 38: Table 39: Table 40: Table 41: Table 42: Table 43: Table 44: Table 45: Table 46: Table 47: Table 48: Table 49: Table 50: Table 51: Table 52: Table 53: Table 54: Table 55: Table 56: Table 57: Table 58: Table 59: Table 60: Table 61: Table 62: Table 63: Table 64: Table 65: Table 66: Table 67: Table 68: Table 69: Table 70: Table 71: Table 72: Table 73: Table 74: Table 75: Table 76: Table 77: Table 78: Table 79: Table 80: Table 81: Table 82: Table 83: Table 84: Table 85: Table 86: Table 87: Table 88:
NPR Index of Punjab Government Across Age Groups NPR Index of Punjab Government Across Education NPR Index of Punjab Government Across Income NPR Index of Punjab Government Across Gender NPR Index of Sindh Government Across Sindh NPR Index of Sindh Government Across Age Groups NPR Index of Sindh Government Across Education NPR Index of Sindh Government Across Income NPR Index of Sindh Government Across Gender NPR Index of KP Government Across KP NPR Index of KP Government Across Age NPR Index of KP Government Across Education NPR Index of KP Government Across Income NPR Index of KP Government Across Gender NPR Index of Balochistan Government Across Balochistan NPR Index of Balochistan Government Across Age NPR Index of Balochistan Government Across Education NPR Index of Balochistan Government Across Income NPR Index of Balochistan Government Across Gender Performance of Chief Minister Punjab Best Performing Chief Minister (Punjab) Performance on Education Performance on Healthcare Performance on Street Cleaning Performance on Safe Drinking Water Performance on Reducing Crime Performance on Eliminating Corruption Performance on Eliminating Nepotism Hope in the Punjab Government Provincial Autonomy Performance of Chief Minister Sindh Best Performing Chief Minister (Sindh) Performance on Education Performance on Healthcare Performance on Street Cleaning Performance on Safe Drinking Water Performance on Reducing Crime Performance on Eliminating Corruption Performance on Eliminating Nepotism Hope in the Sindh Government Provincial Autonomy Performance of Chief Minister KP Best Performing Chief Minister (KP) Performance on Education Performance on Healthcare Performance on Street Cleaning Performance on Safe Drinking Water Performance on Reducing Crime Performance on Eliminating Corruption Performance on Eliminating Nepotism Hope in the KP Government Provincial Autonomy Performance of Chief Minister Balochistan Best Performing Chief Minister (Balochistan) Performance on Education
Page 4 of 218
Table 89: Table 90: Table 91: Table 92: Table 93: Table 94: Table 95: Table 96:
Performance on Healthcare Performance on Street Cleaning Performance on Safe Drinking Water Performance on Reducing Crime Performance on Eliminating Corruption Performance on Eliminating Nepotism Hope in the Balochistan Government Provincial Autonomy
Page 5 of 218
Preface
This PILDAT Report Public Verdict on Performance of Governance and Democracy in First 100 Days of Pakistans National and Provincial Governments is a performance tracker regarding governance by the Federal Government and 4 Provincial Governments and the performance of Democracy in its various forms and expressions. The Report comes nearly at the end of 100 days of the inauguration of Pakistans newly -elected Federal Government that began with the Prime Ministers oath of office on June 05, 2013. 1This report also sets benchmarks for tracking at later stages during the Federal and Provincial Governments five year term in terms of their contribution to both the form and function of democracy in Pakistan. This report is based on a Public Opinion Poll commissioned by PILDAT and conducted by Gallup Pakistan.2 We gratefully acknowledge the support provided by Dr. Ijaz Shafi Gilani, Chairman Gallup Pakistan, in his contribution to writing of this report. The respondents for this survey are over 3568 men and women chosen through a statistical process from Rural and Urban areas from all 4 provinces of Pakistan. They represent a cross section of young and old, middle and high income; people with no education, modest education and high education. As a result composition of this group is quite similar to the notion of a Public Jury. This is the reason that the findings of this tracker survey are also metaphorically described as the Public Verdict of a National Jury. The field work for the report was done face to face in respondents homes during August 26 September 02, 2013. The sample comprises a cross section of various age, income, education and language groups of the population. Error margin is estimated to be approximately 2-3 per cent at 95% confidence level. The 100-day period in itself is not a yardstick to measure performance; the 100 day period of elected Governments only reflects the direction of their policies. The 100 day period, therefore, has been chosen to measure how the public opinion views the directions of policy set by the Federal and Provincial Governments that came into being after the May 2013 General Election. This report is a part of PILDAT Series on Assessments of the Quality of Democracy & Governance in Pakistan. Disclaimer The results in this Report do not represent views held by PILDAT, the authors or Gallup Pakistan. The results only represent public opinion, computed on the basis of views expressed
The 100 days period has been calculated from June 5, 2013 - the date on which newly-elected Prime Minister of Pakistan, Mr. Muhammad Nawaz Sharif, MNA (NA-120, Lahore-III, Punjab, PML-N) took oath of office - to September 13, 2013. 2 Gallup Pakistan is not related to Gallup Inc. headquartered in Washington D.C. USA. Gallup Pakistan requires that their surveys be credited fully as Gallup Pakistan (not Gallup or Gallup Poll). Gallup Pakistan disclaims any responsibility for surveys pertaining to Pakistani public opinion except those carried out by Gallup Pakistan, the Pakistani affiliate of Gallup International Association. For details on Gallup International Association see website: www.gallup-international.com. Gallup Pakistan has conducted this poll, commissioned by PILDAT, according to the ESOMAR Code of Ethics and internationally recognized principles of scientific polling. The results in this Report do not represent views held by the authors or Gallup Pakistan. The results only represent public opinion, computed on the basis of views expressed by anonymous respondents selected through the procedure outlined in the Methodology section of this Report. Gallup Pakistan cannot be held liable, contractually or otherwise, to the users of this data.
1
Page 6 of 218
by anonymous respondents selected through the procedure outlined in the Methodology section of this Report. PILDAT and Gallup Pakistan cannot be held liable to the users of this data. Islamabad September 2013
Page 7 of 218
Executive Summary According to the country-wide public opinion poll commissioned by PILDAT, popular verdict on performance of the Federal Government led by Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif during its first 100 days is on the whole positive, as 62% of a national sample of men and women across the nations 4 provinces give it a Good Rating, as opposed to 32% that give it a Poor Rating. The balance of the two or the NET PERFORMANCE RATING (NPR) 3 is thus 30. This poll is a performance tracker regarding governance by the Federal Government led by Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif, 4 Provincial Governments and the Performance of Democracy in its various forms and expressions. The Poll was commissioned by PILDAT 4 and comes nearly at the end of 100 days of the inauguration of Pakistans newly-elected Federal Government that began with the Prime Ministers oath of office on June 05, 2013. The respondents for this survey are 3568 men and women chosen through a statistical process from Rural and Urban areas from all 4 provinces of Pakistan. They represent a cross section of young and old, middle and high income; people with no education, modest education and high education. As a result composition of this group is quite similar to the notion of a Public Jury. This is the reason that the findings of this survey are also metaphorically described as the Public Verdict of a National Jury. Cautious approval is the Public Verdict on the performance of Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif s government during First 100 Days Nawaz Sharifs policy of seeking harmony with the armed forces, provincial governments led by the parties which are in opposition at the federal level and opposition parties has received the highest rate of approval. His reaching out on key foreign policy issues is also approved. However, there is a greater caution in the approval of performance on managing electricity shortage and addressing the problem of terrorism. Public verdict about his performance about the choice of cabinet and resolving the malaise of corruption and nepotism is also rather reserved. The NPR ranges from -5 on dealing with the issue of terrorism to over 20 on success in achieving harmonious relationship with the armed forces (26), political opposition (24) and provincial solidarity (24). The NPR Index on dealing with Foreign Affairs is also pretty high (19), but more modest on success in reducing the problem of electricity shortages (6); fighting corruption (13); fighting nepotism (-3). A relatively poor score on fighting nepotism indicates a rather strong perception among the public that the government is not following the policy of merit and rule of law and is rather patronising its favourites. Provincial Pluralism Punjab (56) gives very high NPR to Nawaz Sharif Government, followed by Balochistan (22), KP (-4) and Sindh (-12) in that order. This reflects the provincial competition and vote banks in the respective provinces. Verdict is Partisan in the Direction of Hope
NPR is computed by deducting Negative Ratings from the Positive Ratings, thus giving Net Performance Ratings 4 The public opinion poll was conducted by Gallup Pakistan for PILDAT.
3
Page 8 of 218
The NPR is higher on Overall approval (30) than issue-specific NPR on load shedding (6), fighting terrorism (-5), foreign policy (19). When overall NPR approval exceeds issue-specific NPRs, it indicates that the citizens are more hopeful about the direction of change rather than the achievements in particular issues. Cautious Optimism With the change of Government after Election 2013, in general, Pakistani public opinion is 'cautiously optimistic' about the new Governments ability and capacity to address the issues facing the country. More people are optimistic (44%) about the Governments ability to address Pakistan's current issues than people who are pessimistic (30 %). However, a significant number are also ambivalent (22 %) about it. In addition to the Federal Government, the poll also sought public verdict on each of the 4 Provincial Governments. Punjab Government gets the best rating out of the 4 Provincial Governments. Its NPR Index is 73, while the Sindh Government gets the poorest NPR, which is -2. The NPR for the KP Government stands at 26, and for Balochistan Government, it is 17. We have chosen the following parameters to determine public views about performance of Federal Government during its first 100 days in office: 12345678910Overall Performance Rating Addressing Electricity Shortage or Load-shedding Fighting Terrorism Addressing Key Foreign Policy Issues Creating Inter-provincial Harmony Creating Harmony with Political Opposition Creating Harmony with Armed Forces Competence of Cabinet Members Fighting Corruption Fighting Nepotism
Here are the results of the survey on each one of these parameters: 1- Overall Verdict on Governance at the Federal Level According to the survey 62% gave Positive Rating to Governance by the Federal Government during the first approximately 100 days in Government; 32% gave it a Poor Rating. The Net Rating (difference of Positive and Negative) is thus 30. We will call it the NET PERFORMANCE RATING or NPR in the rest of this Report. The NPR of Performance by the Federal Government is high in some and low in other Provinces. As one would expect, it is the highest in Punjab at 55, followed by Balochistan at 22. It is quite low in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (KP) and stands at -5. This means that those who gave Poor Performance Ratings (~51%) were 5% more than those who gave it a Good Ratings (~46%). In Sindh the NPR was even lower at -12.
Page 9 of 218
Bad, 22%
Very bad, 10%
Good, 44% DK/NR, 6% Very good, 18%
Positive Rating = 62% Negative Rating = 32% Net Performance Rating = 30 %
Performance in dealing with the Issue of Electricity Shortage or Load-Shedding According to the survey, 52% gave positive Rating, while 46% gave Negative Ratings. The NPR is thus only 6. The NPR on this issue varies from province to province. It is the highest in the KP at 32 followed by Punjab at 17, Sindh at -26 and Balochistan at -47. It is interesting that the highest or most favourable NPR on this subject is in the KP where PML-N is not in the Government.
DK/NR, 2%
Very Bad, 15%
Very Good, 19%
Bad, 31%
Good, 33%
Positive Rating = 52% Negative Rating = 46% Net Performance Rating = 6% 3- Performance on the Issue of dealing with Terrorism According to the survey, 46% gave Good Performance Rating to the Government in dealing with the issue of Terrorism, 51% gave Poor Rating. The NPR is thus -5.
Page 10 of 218
The NPR on the issue of Terrorism is the highest in Punjab at 8, followed by KP at 4. It is considerably lower in Sindh at -32, and even lower in Balochistan at -47.
Positive Rating = 46% Negative Rating = 51% Net Performance Rating = -5% 4- Performance on addressing Key Foreign Policy Issues: Relations with USA, China and India According to the survey, the Positive Ratings are 57%, while Negative Ratings are 38%. Thus the NPR is 19. The NPR is the highest in Punjab at 32, followed by Balochistan at 28, Sindh at 02 and KP at -9.
Positive Rating = 57% Negative Rating = 38% Net Performance Rating = 19% 5- Performance on Creating Inter-Provincial Harmony According to the survey, the Positive Performance Ratings achieved by the Federal Government on the subject are 59% while Negative Ratings are 35%. Thus the NPR is 24.
Page 11 of 218
The NPR on provincial harmony is the highest in Punjab at 43, followed by Balochistan at 35, KP at -3 and Sindh at -17.
Positive Rating = 59% Negative Rating = 35% Net Performance Rating = 24% 6- Performance on Creating Harmony with Political Opposition According to the survey, the Positive Ratings by the Federal Government in achieving Harmonious relations with political opposition in the Parliament is 59%, while the Negative Ratings are 35%. Thus the NPR is 24. The NPR is the highest in Punjab at 46 followed by Balochistan at 20, KP at -1 and Sindh at 16.
Positive Rating = 59% Negative Rating = 35% Net Performance Rating = 24% 7- Creating Harmony with the Armed Forces (Bringing State Institutions subservient to Rule of Law) According to the survey, the Positive Ratings achieved by the Federal Government on this issue are 58%, while the Negative Ratings are 32%. Thus the NPR is 26. The NPR is the highest in Punjab at 45, followed by Balochistan at 11, Sindh at -2 and KP at 3.
Page 12 of 218
Positive Rating = 58% Negative Rating = 33% Net Performance Rating = 26% 8- Performance on Choosing Competent Cabinet According to the survey, 31% give Positive Rating on the subject. In other words they are satisfied with the quality or competence of the Federal Cabinet chosen by the Prime Minister. As opposed to this 18% give it a Poor Rating. The remaining (12 %) are either un-informed or unable to give a specific view on the subject. Thus the NPR is 13. The NPR is the highest in Punjab at 22, followed by Balochistan at 20, KP at 5 and Sindh at 5.
Positive Rating = 31% Negative Rating = 18% Net Performance Rating = 13% 9- Performance on Fighting Corruption According to the survey, 54% give Positive Performance Rating to the Federal Government in dealing with the problem of corruption, while 41% gave Negative Rating. Thus the NPR is 13.
Page 13 of 218
The NPR is the highest in Punjab at 30 followed by KP at 18, Balochistan where it is Nil meaning that Positive and Negative Ratings are exactly equal. The NPR is the lowest in Sindh at -25.
DK/NR, 5%
Very Good, 19%
Very Bad, 12% Bad, 29%
Good, 35%
Positive Rating = 54% Negative Rating = 41% Net Performance Rating = 13% 10- Performance of Federal Government on the issue of eliminating Nepotism in Public Affairs The Federal Governments poorest rating was received on elimination of nepotism. According to the survey 45% give Positive Performance Ratings to the Federal Government on the subject, while 48% give Negative Ratings. Thus the NPR is -3.
Positive Rating = 45% Negative Rating = 48% Net Performance Rating = -3% Performance Ratings of Provincial Governments
Page 14 of 218
The survey tried to elicit views from each province about performance of their respective Provincial Government on the issue of checking nepotism in public affairs. Punjab Government gets the highest NPR at 9, followed by KP and Balochistan both of which score -4 each. The performance of Sindh Government is much poorer, since its NPR is -55. Views on Performance of the Provincial Governments were elicited on matters of governance which mostly fall under provincial authority. These include subjects such as Education, Health, Street Cleaning, Providing Safe Drinking Water and Reducing Street Crime, etc. Here are the findings. The responses, it must be noted, were elicited from residents of the respective province only. Performance of Provincial Government on Education According to the survey the highest Performance Ratings were achieved by Punjab whose NPRIndex was 64, compared with KP whose score was only slightly behind at 62. In contract the NPR-Index of Sindh at -8 and Balochistan at -12 were much lower.
Sindh
Very Bad, 4% Very Bad 3%
KPK
DK/NR 1%
Punjab
DK/NR, 4% Very Good, 25%
DK/NR, 2%
Very Good, 4%
Balochistan
DK/N R 2% Very Bad 18% Good 34% Bad 37% Very Good 9%
Bad, 12%
Very Bad, 19% Good, 41% Bad, 34%
Bad 15%
Very Good 38%
Good, 55%
Good 43%
63
-7
62
-13
Performance of Provincial Governments on Healthcare According to the survey, Punjab Government scores the highest NPR at 49, followed closely by KP at 45. The NPR for Sindh at -24 and Balochistan at -33 are much lower.
Punjab
Very Bad 5% DK/NR 5% Very Good 16%
Sindh
DK/NR 2%
Very Good 1%
Balochistan
Very Bad 4%
KPK
DK/NR 1% Very Good 12% DK/NR 5% Very Good 6%
Bad 18%
Very Bad 25%
Good 36%
Bad 23%
Very Bad 21%
Good 25%
Good 56%
Bad 36%
Good 60%
Bad 43%
49
-24
45
-33
Page 15 of 218
Performance of Provincial Governments on the Issue of Street Cleaning According to the survey, Punjab scores the highest NPR at 32. On this issue, KP is considerably behind Punjab and stands at 5 only. Both Sindh and Balochsitan do much poorer as the score of Balochistan is -4 and that of Sindh is -47.
Punjab
Very Bad, 8% DK/NR, 7% Very Good, 13%
Sindh
DK/NR , 2%
Very Good, 1%
Very Bad, 7%
KPK
Balochistan
Bad, 23%
Very Bad, 31% Good, 50%
Good, 24% Bad, 40% Good, 39%
Very Bad, 23%
Bad, 41%
Bad, 27%
Good, 32%
32
-47
-4
Performance of Provincial Governments on Safe Drinking Water According to the survey, the NPR of KP is the highest at 25. On this issue Punjab is the runner up falling closely behind KP at 23. The score for Balochistan is 8, while the NPR for Sindh is extremely low at -46.
KPK Punjab
Very Bad, 7% DK/NR, 9% Very Good, 9% Very Bad, 34%
Balochistan
DK/N Very R, 2% Good, 10% DK/NR, 4% Very Bad, 16% Very Good, 13%
Sindh
DK/NR, 3%
Very Good, 1%
Very Bad, 7%
Bad, 27%
Good, 25% Bad, 38%
Bad, 29% Good, 51% Bad, 28% Good, 39%
Good, 48%
23
-46
23
Performance of Provincial Governments on Reducing Street Crime According to the survey, the NPR of Punjab is the highest at 19 followed by KP at 8, Balochsitan at -12 and Sindh at -46.
Punjab
Very Bad, 7% DK/NR, 10% Very Good, 6%
KPK Sindh
DK/NR, 2% Very Good, 2% Very Bad, 9% DK/N R, 2% Very Good, 17%
Balochistan
DK/NR, 4% Very Bad, 24% Bad, 30% Very Good, 6%
Very Bad, 36% Bad, 29% Good, 49%
Good, 24% Bad, 36% Bad, 36%
Good, 36%
Good, 36%
19
-46
-12
Page 16 of 218
Popularity Contest of 4 Chief Ministers among All Pakistanis According to the survey, Chief Minister Punjab is the clear winner in a popularity contest in which All Pakistanis voted irrespective of their province of residence. Survey findings show that 59% voted in favour of Mr. Shahbaz Sharif as the best performing Chief Minister, followed by Syed Qaim Ali Shah at 18%, Mr. Pervez Khattak at 9% and Dr. Abdul Malik at 4%. These ratings may have been partly influenced by the size of the sample size which is obviously the largest in Punjab followed by Sindh, KP and Balochistan corresponding with the population of each province.
100% 80% 59% 60% 40% 20% 0% Shahbaz Sharif Qaim Ali Shah Parveiz Khatak Dr Abdul Malik 18% 9% 4%
In each province, their respective Chief Ministers enjoy most popularity, with the exception of Balochistan in which Chief Minister Punjab is the most popular. Other than Balochistan and Punjab, where Chief Minister of Punjab, Mr. Muhammad Shahbaz Sharif is the most popular, in other two provinces, namely Sindh and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, Chief Minister Punjab is a close second choice of public. In Punjab, Chief Minister Punjab has 76% approval ratings, followed by Syed Qaim Ali Shah, CM Sindh who is a distant number 2 in Punjab at 8%, followed by Chief Minister KP, Mr. Pervez Khattak, at 4% and Dr. Abdul Malik, Chief Minister Balochistan, with popularity rating of 1% in Punjab. Popularity Ratings of 4 Chief Ministers in Punjab Question: In your opinion, out of the countrys four Chief Ministers, which one has been the most successful? And it can be from your own province or from any other.
100% 90% 80% 70% 60% 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0%
76%
8%
4%
11% 1%
Page 17 of 218
In Sindh Chief Minister Syed Qaim Ali Shahs approval ratings are at 39%, followed very closely by CM Punjab, whose popularity ratings among Sindhs population is 38%, followed by Chief Minister KP at 7% and Chief Minister Balochistan at 6%. Popularity Ratings of Chief Ministers in Sindh Question: In your opinion, out of the countrys four Chief Ministers, which one has been the most successful? And it can be from your own province or from any other.
100% 90% 80% 70% 60% 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0%
38%
39% 7% 6% 11%
In Khyber Pakhtunkwa, Mr. Pervez Khattak, CM KP, has approval ratings of 34%, followed by CM Punjab at 29%, followed by CM Sindh at 26% and CM Balochistan at 1%. Popularity Ratings of 4 Chief Ministers in KP Question: In your opinion, out of the countrys four Chief Ministers, which one has been the most successful? And it can be from your own province or from any other.
100% 90% 80% 70% 60% 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0%
29%
26%
34% 10%
1%
In Balochistan, Dr. Abdul Malik, Chief Minister Balochistan, is approved by 31% - as number 2 choice of people of Balochistan, while Chief Minister Punjab, Mr. Muhammad Shahbaz Sharif enjoys highest popularity ratings of 40%. Syed Qaim Ali Shah, CM Sindh, gets 17% approval ratings in Balochistan followed by CM KP, Mr. Pervez Khattak, at 8%.
Page 18 of 218
Popularity Ratings of 4 Chief Ministers in Balochistan Question: In your opinion, out of the countrys four Chief Ministers, which one has been the most successful? And it can be from your own province or from any other.
100% 80% 60% 40% 40% 20% 0% Shahbaz Sharif Qaim Ali Shah Parveiz Khatak Dr Abdul Malik All others\DK/NR 17% 8% 5% 31%
Factors Underlying High or Low Performance Ratings The following 4 factors seem to be the key in determining the level of Performance Ratings. 1. Political Partisanship It is quite understandable that those who voted for the party currently in power, in the Federation or in the Provinces, are more likely to give better Performance Rating to it compared to those who did not. This is why the NPR of Punjab Government is higher than the Federal Government, 73 as opposed to 48. After all, the PML-N won 46% of the votes in Punjab. But only 33% at the Federal level. But political partisanship is not the only explanation. 2. Outreach beyond Political Partisanship The second most important factor in obtaining high performance ratings is the ability and success to win high ratings from political opponents or those who do not intend to vote for the ruling party. This second factor explains the high NPR achieved by Chief Minister Punjab. His NPR is 90 among the PML-N voters but also as high as 48 among all other who do not intend to vote for the PML-N. This latter figure is considerably lower for the Federal (30) as well as the other 3 Provincial Governments (Sindh -21, KP 26 and Balochistan 17). The findings suggest that the Prime Minister and the respective Chief Ministers can raise their Performance Ratings if they are seen in their position of PM and CM to represent all voters rather than heads of their respective political parties. Apparently, the performance of Chief Minister of Punjab enjoys a great deal of appreciation across political partisanship and provincial boundaries. When asked to name the best of the four Chief Ministers he scores quite high not only in his own but also other provinces. 3. National Mood to Seek Harmony
Page 19 of 218
A third factor underlying high ratings seems to be whether government leaders are successful in seeking harmony. Apparently, the popular mood is weary of a long period of conflict and contentious politics across political groups and institutions. Thus, any policy or action which appears to enlist harmony is appreciated. 4. Issue Specific Differentiation and Pragmatism A fourth factor underlying Performance Ratings seems to be the ability and inclination among Pakistanis to be quite pragmatic and issue specific in giving their positive or negative verdict. It is not a matter of all out love or hate based on emotional support or hostility. Thus, the Federal Government gets as high an NPR as 26 for its harmonious relationship with the armed forced and as low as -5 for its success in dealing with the problem of terrorism.5 Similarly the Punjab Government gets as high an NPR as 64 on education but as low as 19 on reducing crime and only 9 on dealing with the problem of nepotism. This trend to give issue-specific pragmatic evaluation or verdict is visible in the case of all Provinces and the Federal Government. Benchmark for Performance of Democratic Processes and Institutions in First 100 Days Fairness of General Election 2013 got an NPR of -1 as 31% nationwide respondents caused aspersions on the fairness of General Election 2013 while 30% said 2013 General Election was more transparent and freer than the previous General Election (2008). 31% respondents believed there was no difference in the fairness of the 9th (2008) and 10th (2013) General Elections. Trust in Political parties got NPR of 44 as nearly 69% respondents said they trust their political parties (A lot of trust: 32%; Trust to an Extent: 37%) while 16% showed little trust and 9% at very little trust. According to the survey, the Net performance Score of 13 Democratic Institutions or processes is provided below. These scores can not be attributed to the successes or failures achieved by the new Governments during its first 100 days. However these Benchmark figures will be a useful guideline to gauge the performance of new Governments as they make progress during their 5 year term. Net Performance Rating (NPR) on Perceived Improvement Over Previous Government 12345678910115
Overall Quality of Democratic Functioning Hope that Democracy will deliver Effectiveness of Parliament Effectiveness of Cabinet Law-Observing Behaviour of the Executive Effectiveness of Democratic oversight on Military Fairness in Elections Trust in Political Parties Effectiveness of Supreme Court Respect for Human Rights Independence of Media
26 22 19 10 -2 12 -1 44 3 17 20
Note: The survey was conducted from August 26-September 02, 2013 and prior to the All Parties Conference on the Issue held on September 9, 2013.
Page 20 of 218
12-
Safeguarding National Sovereignty
Provincial Governments Role on the subject 13Assertion of Provincial Autonomy: Punjab Sindh KP Balochsitan 5 2 -6 27
Page 21 of 218
Table 1: Issue Specific Performance Rating of the Federal Government INDICA TORS IN RANK ORDER OF NET PERFORMANCE RATING (NPR) INDEX (TOP TO BOTTOM) OVERALL PERFORMANCE RATING PERFORMANCE ON INSTITUTIONAL HARMONY WITH ARMED FORCES PERFORMANCE ON INTERPROVINCIAL HARMONY PERFORMANCE ON GOVERNMENTOPPOSITION HARMONY PERFORMANCE ON FOREIGN AFFAIRS PERFORMANCE ON CHOICE OF CABINET PERFORMANCE ON ADDRESSING CORRUPTION PERFROMANCE ON LOADSHEDDING PERFORMANCE ON ADDRESSING NEPOSTISM PERFORMANCE ON TERRORISM Positive Performance (1) 62 Negative Performance (2) 32 D K / N R 6 1 0 6 NPR-Index Net Performance (3)=(1)-(2) 30
26
7 5
58 59
32 35
24
6 59 57 31 54 52 45 6 35 38 18 41 46 48 51 5 5 1 5 2 7 3
24 19 13 13 6 -3 -5
6 4 8 9 2 1 0 3
Notes: Age: Young: Under 30 years of age; Middle: Between 30 and 50 years of age; Old: Above 51 years of age Income codes: Low: Up to Rs. 15000 (In 2013 this represented the lowest quintile). Medium: Rs. 15,001 to 30,000 (In 2013 this represented the 2nd and 3rd Quintile). High: More than 30,000 (In 2013 this represented the 4th and 5th Quintiles) Location: Urban is defined as location defined as town or city in the census, the total in Pakistan being 470 constituting 35% of the population; Rural is defined as a population living in villages as in the latest census, approximating ~45,000, consisting 65% of the population. Rounding off error: In some cases the totals may not add up to 100 or mismatch with earlier tables to the extent of 1%. Please ignore this, as it is due to round off error. Methodology: Sample Size: 3568; Coverage: National/Rural and Urban/All four provinces; Mode: Face to face; Survey dates: Aug 26 - Sep 02 2013. Estimated error margin: +3-5% at 95% confidence level
Page 22 of 218
Table 2: Popular Verdict on the Performance of Provincial Governments
NPR-Index Positive Performance (1) Federal Government Punjab Sindh KPK Baloshistan 62% Negative Performance (2) 32% Dont Know/No Response 6% 4% 2% 2% 2% Net Performance (4)=1-2 30 73 -2 26 17
Provincial Government 84% 11% 48% 50% 62% 36% 58% 41%
Page 23 of 218
Table 3: Issue Specific Performance Ratings in the Provinces Table 3 shows that performance ratings in the provinces are also issue specific. Perceptions about quality of governance in the 4 provinces and a comparative picture for the 4 Chief Ministers in their respective provinces is also given. (Rank Ordered High To Low On Performance Index) Rated By Residents of Respective Provinces IN RANK ORDER OF NET CM PERFORMANCE RATING (NPR) CM Punjab CM KP CM Sindh Balochistan INDEX (Read in (Read in (Read in (Read in Column) Column) Column) Column) (HIGH TO LOW) OVERALL PERFORMANCE OF CM 1 73 26 17 -2 OF THE PROVINCE 3 64 62 -12 -8 PERFORMANCE ON EDUCATION 4 49 45 -33 -24 PERFORMANCE ON HEALTHCARE PERFORMANCE ON STREET 5 32 5 -4 -47 CLEANING PERFORMANCE ON SAFE 6 23 25 8 -46 DRINKING WATER PERFORMANCE ON REDUCING 7 19 8 -12 -46 CRIME PERFROMANCE ON ADDRESSING 8 15 11 -19 -36 CORRUPTION PERFROMANCE ON ADDRESSING 9 9 -4 -4 -55 NEPOTISM Table 1.1: INDICATORS OF PERFORMANCE ON DEMOCRACY PERFORMANCE ON 1 GOVERNANCE OVERALL 23 -11 33 -18 QUALITY OF GOVERNANCE 2 5 -6 27 2 PROVINCIAL AUTONOMY
Notes: Age: Young: Under 30 years of age; Middle: Between 30 and 50 years of age; Old: Above 51 years of age Income codes: Low: Up to Rs. 15000 (In 2013 this represented the lowest quintile). Medium: Rs. 15,001 to 30,000 (In 2013 this represented the 2nd and 3rd Quintile). High: More than 30,000 (In 2013 this represented the 4th and 5th Quintiles) Location: Urban is defined as location defined as town or city in the census, the total in Pakistan being 470 constituting 35% of the population; Rural is defined as a population living in villages as in the latest census, approximating ~45,000, consisting 65% of the population. Rounding off error: In some cases the totals may not add up to 100 or mismatch with earlier tables to the extent of 1%. Please ignore this, as it is due to round off error.
INDICA TORS
Page 24 of 218
Methodology: Sample Size: 3568; Coverage: National/Rural and Urban/All four provinces; Mode: Face to face; Survey dates: Aug 26 - Sep 02 2013. Estimated error margin: +3-5% at 95% confidence level
Page 25 of 218
Four Factors Underlying High and Low Performance Ratings Factors Underlying High or Low Performance Ratings The following 4 factors seem to be key in determining the level of Performance Ratings. 1. Political Partisanship It is quite understandable that those voted for the party currently in power, in the Federation or in the Provinces, are more likely to give better Performance Rating to it compared to those who did not. This is why the NPR-index of Punjab Government is higher than the Federal Government, 73 as opposed to 48. After all the PML-N won 46% of the votes in Punjab, but only 33% at the Federal level. But political partisanship is not the only explanation. 2. Outreach beyond Political Partisanship The second most important factor in obtaining high performance ratings is the ability and success to win high ratings from political opponents or those who do not intend to vote for the ruling party. This second factor explains the high NPR-Index achieved by Chief Minister Punjab. His NPR-Index is 90 among the PML-N voters but also as high as 48 among all other who do not intend to vote for the PML-N. This latter figure is considerably lower for the Federal as well as the other 3 Provincial governments. Table 4: NPR (Net Performance Rating) Index
Among (Respective) Party Loyals Federal 74 Government Provincial Governments Punjab 90 Sindh 52 KP 65 Baloshistan 44
All Others
Among All (Party Loyals and Others) 30 -73 -2 26 17
-1 48 -46 3 14
The findings suggest that the PM and the respective CMs can raise their Performance Ratings if they are seen in their position of PM and CM to represent all voters rather than heads of their respective political parties. Apparently, the performance of CM of Punjab enjoys a great deal of appreciation across political partisanship and provincial boundaries. When asked to name the best of the four Chief Ministers he scores quite high not only in his own but also other provinces.
Page 26 of 218
Table 5: Views on Best Performing Chief Minister in Own and Other Provinces
All Pakistan CM Punjab CM Sindh CM KP CM Balochistan 59% 18% 9% 4% Punjab 76% 8% 4% 1% Province Wise Sindh 38% 39% 7% 6% KP 29% 26% 34% 1% Balochistan 40% 17% 8% 31%
3. National Mood to Seek Harmony A third factor underlying high ratings seems to be whether government leaders are successful in seeking harmony. Apparently, the popular mood is weary of a long period of conflict and contentious politics across political groups and institutions. Thus, any policy or action which appears to enlist harmony is appreciated. 4. Issue Specific Differentiation and Pragmatism A fourth factor underlying Performance Ratings seems to be the ability and inclination among Pakistanis to be quite pragmatic and issue specific in giving their positive or negative verdict. It is not a matter of all out love or hate bas ed on emotional support or hostility. Thus, the Federal Government gets as high an NPR-Index as 26 for its harmonious relationship with the armed forced and as low as -5 for its success to deal with the problem of terrorism.6 Similarly the Punjab Government gets as high an NPR-Index as 64 on education but as low as 19 on reducing crime and only 9 on dealing with the problem of nepotism. This trend to give issue-specific pragmatic evaluation or verdict is visible in the case of all Provinces and the Federal Government.
Note: The survey was done prior to the All Parties Conference on the Issue held on September 9 Page 27 of 218
Table 6: NPR Index of Federal Government Across Provinces All Pakistan OVERALL PERFORMANCE RATING PERFORMANCE ON INSTITUTIONAL HARMONY WITH ARMED FORCES PERFORMANCE ON INTERPROVINCIAL HARMONY PERFORMANCE ON GOVERNMENTOPPOSITION HARMONY PERFORMANCE ON FOREIGN AFFAIRS PERFORMANCE ON CHOICE OF CABINET PERFORMANCE ON ADDRESSING CORRUPTION PERFROMANCE ON LOADSHEDDING PERFORMANCE ON ADDRESSING NEPOSTISM PERFORMANCE ON TERRORISM 30 Punjab 56 Sindh -12 KP -4 Balochistan 22
26
45
-1
-2
12
7 5
24
43
-17
-3
35
24 19 13 13 6 -3 -5
46 32 22 30 17 13 8 73
-16 -1 -5 -25 -25 -43 -32 -2
-1 -9 4 18 32 2 5 26
20 28 20 Nil -48 -23 -47 17

Page 28 of 218
6 4 8 9 2 10 3
11 Your CM
Page 29 of 218
Table 7: NPR-Index of Federal Government Across Gender All 30 26 24 24 19 13 13 6 -3 -5 Male 29 24 22 20 15 13 17 8 -1 -3 Female 30 28 22 28 23 14 10 3 -6 -6
1 OVERALL PERFORMANCE RATING PERFORMANCE ON INSTITUTIONAL 7 HARMONY WITH ARMED FORCES PERFORMANCE ON 5 INTERPROVINCIAL HARMONY PERFORMANCE ON GOVERNMENT6 OPPOSITION HARMONY PERFORMANCE ON FOREIGN 4 AFFAIRS PERFORMANCE ON CHOICE OF 8 CABINET PERFORMANCE ON ADDRESSING 9 CORRUPTION 2 PERFROMANCE ON LOADSHEDDING PERFORMANCE ON ADDRESSING 10 NEPOSTISM 3 PERFORMANCE ON TERRORISM
Page 30 of 218
Table 8 NPR-Index of Federal Government Across Age Groups Young 26 20 17 19 16 17 8 10 -9 -1 Middle 31 29 26 27 18 11 18 2 1 -7 Old 30 34 17 21 35 3 12 -4 -15 -13
All OVERALL PERFORMANCE 1 RATING PERFORMANCE ON INSTITUTIONAL HARMONY WITH 7 ARMED FORCES PERFORMANCE ON 5 INTERPROVINCIAL HARMONY PERFORMANCE ON GOVERNMENT6 OPPOSITION HARMONY PERFORMANCE ON FOREIGN 4 AFFAIRS PERFORMANCE ON CHOICE OF 8 CABINET PERFORMANCE ON ADDRESSING 9 CORRUPTION PERFROMANCE ON 2 LOADSHEDDING PERFORMANCE ON ADDRESSING 10 NEPOSTISM 3 PERFORMANCE ON TERRORISM 30 26 24 24 19 13 13 6 -3 -5
Page 31 of 218
Table 9: NPR-Index of Federal Government Across Education Groups
All OVERALL PERFORMANCE RATING PERFORMANCE ON INSTITUTIONAL HARMONY WITH 7 ARMED FORCES PERFORMANCE ON INTERPROVINCIAL 5 HARMONY PERFORMANCE ON GOVERNMENT6 OPPOSITION HARMONY PERFORMANCE ON 4 FOREIGN AFFAIRS PERFORMANCE ON 8 CHOICE OF CABINET PERFORMANCE ON ADDRESSING 9 CORRUPTION PERFROMANCE ON 2 LOADSHEDDING PERFORMANCE ON ADDRESSING 10 NEPOSTISM PERFORMANCE ON 3 TERRORISM OVERALL 11 PERFORMANCE RATING 1
Notes: Age: Young: Under 30 years of age; Middle: Between 30 and 50 years of age; Old: Above 51 years of age
Low 44
Medium 30
High 8
30 26
32 24 24 19 13 13 6 -3 -5 29 32 23 18 28 14 Nil 9
28 25 25 22 13 14 5 1 -7
13 8 9 7 8 -7 -5 -15 -20
Page 32 of 218
Income codes: Low: Up to Rs. 15000 (In 2013 this represented the lowest quintile). Medium: Rs. 15,001 to 30,000 (In 2013 this represented the 2nd and 3rd Quintile). High: More than 30,000 (In 2013 this represented the 4th and 5th Quintiles) Location: Urban is defined as location defined as town or city in the census, the total in Pakistan being 470 constituting 35% of the population; Rural is defined as a population living in villages as in the latest census, approximating ~45,000, consisting 65% of the population. Rounding off error: In some cases the totals may not add up to 100 or mismatch with earlier tables to the extent of 1%. Please ignore this, as it is due to round off error. Methodology: Sample Size: 3568; Coverage: National/Rural and Urban/All four provinces; Mode: Face to face; Survey dates: Aug 26 - Sep 02 2013. Estimated error margin: +3-5% at 95% confidence level
Page 33 of 218
Table 10: NPR-Index of Federal Government Across Income Groups All OVERALL PERFORMANCE 1 RATING PERFORMANCE ON INSTITUTIONAL HARMONY 7 WITH ARMED FORCES PERFORMANCE ON INTERPROVINCIAL 5 HARMONY PERFORMANCE ON GOVERNMENT-OPPOSITION 6 HARMONY PERFORMANCE ON FOREIGN 4 AFFAIRS PERFORMANCE ON CHOICE OF 8 CABINET PERFORMANCE ON 9 ADDRESSING CORRUPTION PERFROMANCE ON 2 LOADSHEDDING PERFORMANCE ON 10 ADDRESSING NEPOSTISM PERFORMANCE ON 3 TERRORISM OVERALL PERFORMANCE 11 RATING 30 26 24 24 19 13 13 6 -3 -5 Low 31 23 23 23 19 12 17 12 -2 5 Medium 26 28 17 19 21 15 13 8 -1 -11 High 23 33 32 29 25 21 11 -24 1 -37
Page 34 of 218
PART 1
Public Verdict on Performance of the Federal Government in First 100 Days
Page 35 of 218
Overall Performance Rating

Question: What is your opinion on the overall performance of Prime Minister Muhammad Nawaz Sharif?
Bad, 22%
Very bad, 10%
Good, 44% DK/NR, 6% Very good, 18%
Net Performance Rating = 30

Source: Gallup and Gilani Surveys
Page 36 of 218
Table 11: Overall Performance Rating Question: What is your opinion on the overall performance of Prime Minister Muhammad Nawaz Sharif?
Figures are row percentages
Very Good (1)

All Pakistan Average Gender Male Female Respondent Age Young (Under 30) Middle (30 - 50) Old (50+) Household Income Low Medium High Province Punjab Sindh KP Balochistan Location Rural Urban Voting Intention PML-N PTI PPP All others
Good (2) 44 43 46 46 42 59 46 37 40 51 39 26 46 46 41 50 35 42 42
Bad (3) 22 20 24 23 20 27 20 24 29 12 34 39 25 19 28 7 37 26 32
Very Bad (4) 10 13 8 10 11 7 11 10 6 6 21 12 12 11 10 3 16 21 13
Dont Know (5) 6 5 7 6 6 2 6 5 7 9 2 2 4 6 7 6 3 2 9
18 19 16 14 20 5 16 23 18 23 4 21 13 19 14 34 8 9 5
Net Performanc e Index (6) = (1+2) (3+4) 30 29 30 26 31 30 31 26 23 55 -12 -5 22 36 17 74 -10 4 1
Notes: Age: Young: Under 30 years of age; Middle: Between 30 and 50 years of age; Old: Above 51 years of age Income codes: Low: Up to Rs. 15000 (In 2013 this represented the lowest quintile). Medium: Rs. 15,001 to 30,000 (In 2013 this represented the 2nd and 3rd Quintile). High: More than 30,000 (In 2013 this represented the 4th and 5th Quintiles) Location: Urban is defined as location defined as town or city in the census, the total in Pakistan being 470 constituting 35% of the population; Rural is defined as a population living in villages as in the latest census, approximating ~45,000, consisting 65% of the population. Methodology: Sample Size: 3568; Coverage: National/Rural and Urban/All four provinces; Mode: Face to face; Survey dates: Aug 26 September 02, 2013. Estimated error margin: +3-5% at 95% confidence level
Page 37 of 218
Performance on Load-Shedding
Question: While considering the elimination of load shedding, what do you think about the efforts made by Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif?
DK/NR, 2%
Very Bad, 15%
Very Good, 19%
Bad, 31%
Good, 33%

Page 38 of 218
Table 12: Performance on Load-Shedding Question: While considering the elimination of load shedding, what do you think about the efforts made by Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif?
Very Good (1)

All Pakistan Average Gender Male Female Respondent Age Young (Under 30) Middle (30 - 50) Old (50+) Household Income Low Medium High DK/NR Province Punjab Sindh KP Balochistan Location Rural Urban Voting Intention PML-N PTI PPP All others
Good (2) 33 34 32 35 31 35 35 35 20 2 35 32 32 18 34 31 43 21 36 24
Bad (3) 31 32 30 31 31 35 30 28 39 81 30 34 28 37 32 30 23 35 32 39
Very Bad (4) 15 13 18 13 17 16 13 17 22 14 10 28 5 37 11 23 5 12 22 26
Dont Know (5) 2 2 2 1 2 2 2 1 2 0 3 0 2 1 2 2 0 1 1 5
19 19 19 19 19 12 20 18 17 3 22 5 33 8 21 14 28 32 9 6
Net Performanc e Index (6) = (1+2) (3+4) 6 8 3 10 2 -4 12 8 -24 -90 17 -26 32 -47 12 -8 43 6 -9 -35
Age: Young: Under 30 years of age; Middle: Between 30 and 50 years of age; Old: Above 51 years of age Income codes: Low: Up to Rs. 15000 (In 2013 this represented the lowest quintile). Medium: Rs. 15,001 to 30,000 (In 2013 this represented the 2nd and 3rd Quintile). High: More than 30,000 (In 2013 this represented the 4th and 5th Quintiles) Location: Urban is defined as location defined as town or city in the census, the total in Pakistan being 470 constituting 35% of the population; Rural is defined as a population living in villages as in the latest census, approximating ~45,000, consisting 65% of the population. Methodology: Sample Size: 3568; Coverage: National/Rural and Urban/All four provinces; Mode: Face to face; Survey dates: Aug 26 September 02, 2013. Estimated error margin: +3-5% at 95% confidence level
Page 39 of 218
Performance on Eliminating Terrorism

Question: While considering the elimination of terrorism, what do you think about the efforts made by Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif?
Net Performance Rating = -5

Page 40 of 218
Table 13: Performance on Eliminating Terrorism Question: While considering the elimination of terrorism, what do you think about the efforts made by Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif?
Very Good (1)

Good (2) 34 35 33 34 35 30 37 32 25 36 31 38 18 37 28 46 29 39 19
Bad (3) 36 36 36 35 36 40 33 34 47 37 31 37 43 36 35 29 38 34 44
Very Bad (4) 15 14 16 14 16 15 13 20 21 7 35 9 29 9 28 5 17 20 25
Dont Know (5) 3 3 2 4 2 2 3 3 3 4 0 2 2 2 3 1 1 1 6
12 12 12 14 11 13 14 11 5 16 3 13 7 15 7 19 14 6 5
Net Performanc e Index (6) = (1+2) (3+4) -5 -3 -6 -1 -7 -13 5 -11 -37 8 -32 4 -47 7 -28 31 -12 -8 -45
Page 41 of 218
Performance on Foreign Affairs

Question: When considering improving international ties with countries like America, China and India, what do you think about the efforts made by Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif?

Page 42 of 218
Table 14: Performance on Foreign Affairs Question: When considering improving international ties with countries like America, China and India, what do you think about the efforts made by Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif?
Very Good (1)

Good (2) 44 43 44 44 43 47 44 45 43 47 43 33 37 45 41 57 32 37 34
Bad (3) 29 30 27 29 29 20 28 27 26 24 32 44 22 31 25 19 37 39 33
Very Bad (4) 9 10 9 10 9 9 10 10 7 6 17 9 13 6 15 4 11 15 13
Dont Know (5) 5 5 6 5 5 8 5 5 8 8 2 2 3 4 8 3 3 2 11
13 12 14 12 13 16 13 12 16 15 5 11 26 14 11 17 16 8 8
Net Performanc e Index (6) = (1+2) (3+4) 19 15 23 16 18 35 19 21 25 32 -2 -9 28 22 12 51 0 -9 -4
Page 43 of 218
Performance on Inter-Provincial Harmony

Question: While considering improving internal issues such as unity and cordial relations between provinces, what do you think about the efforts made by Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif?

Page 44 of 218
Table 15: Performance on Inter-Provincial Harmony Question: While considering improving internal issues such as unity and cordial relations between provinces, what do you think about the efforts made by Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif?
Very Good (1)

Good (2) 45 44 45 44 45 49 45 41 49 50 35 39 44 46 41 56 36 35 38
Bad (3) 26 26 27 28 25 24 27 27 23 18 42 39 21 27 26 17 36 40 29
Very Bad (4) 9 10 9 10 9 13 9 12 6 7 15 11 8 7 14 4 13 15 12
Dont Know (5) 6 6 6 7 5 9 6 6 9 8 2 3 7 5 9 3 4 2 13
14 14 13 11 16 5 14 15 13 18 5 8 20 15 10 21 11 8 8
Net Performanc e Index 6) = (1+2) (3+4) 24 22 22 17 26 17 23 17 32 43 -17 -3 35 28 11 56 -2 -11 5
Page 45 of 218
Performance on Government-Opposition Harmony

Question: While considering improving ties with opposition leaders and parties, what do you think about the efforts made by Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif?

Page 46 of 218
Table 16: Performance on Government-Opposition Harmony Question: While considering improving ties with opposition leaders and parties, what do you think about the efforts made by Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif?
Very Good (1)

Good (2) 44 42 45 42 45 44 43 41 46 49 36 34 40 45 41 52 35 32 41
Bad (3) 26 27 25 27 26 25 27 28 24 18 39 39 27 27 26 17 37 39 27
Very Bad (4) 9 10 8 10 8 9 9 9 7 5 18 10 10 7 12 3 13 18 11
Dont Know (5) 6 6 6 7 5 10 6 6 7 8 3 4 5 5 9 3 4 3 12
15 15 15 14 16 11 15 16 15 20 5 13 17 16 13 24 11 8 9
Net Performanc e Index (6) = (1+2) (3+4) 24 20 28 19 27 21 23 19 29 46 -16 -1 20 27 16 57 -4 -18 11
Page 47 of 218
Performance on Institutional Harmony with Armed Forces

Question: What do you think about the efforts made so far by Prime Minister Nawaz Sharifs Government on improving relations with various State Institutions such as the army?

Page 48 of 218
Table 17: Performance on Institutional Harmony with Armed Forces Question: What do you think about the efforts made so far by Prime Minister Nawaz Sharifs Government on improving relations with various State Institutions such as the army?
Very Good (1)

Good (2) 45 46 43 43 45 50 44 45 44 51 39 33 34 45 44 58 34 37 35
Bad (3) 23 24 23 27 22 19 25 22 19 16 32 40 25 25 21 15 36 36 24
Very Bad (4) 9 10 7 9 9 5 9 8 8 5 16 9 14 7 11 3 12 13 12
Dont Know (5) 10 9 11 10 9 18 8 12 14 13 5 5 9 9 12 5 6 4 20
13 12 15 12 15 8 13 13 16 15 8 13 17 14 13 18 13 9 10
Net Performanc e Index (6) = (1+2) (3+4) 26 24 28 20 29 34 23 28 33 45 -2 -3 11 26 25 58 -1 -3 9
Page 49 of 218
Performance on Choice of Cabinet

Question: Some people are of the opinion that the Ministers appointed by the Prime Minister in the Federal Cabinet are a good selection, while others think of these as a bad choice. What is your opinion?

Page 50 of 218
Table 18: Performance on Choice of Cabinet Question: Some people are of the opinion that the Ministers appointed by the Prime Minister in the Federal Cabinet are a good selection, while others think of these as a bad choice. What is your opinion?
Good Choice (1) 31 31 32 33 30 22 31 32 37 36 18 31 33 34 25 50 24 20 16
Bad Choice (2) 18 18 17 16 19 19 19 17 16 14 23 27 13 15 22 11 35 22 17
Between Good and Bad choice (3) 39 37 40 40 38 45 39 38 32 34 53 32 49 39 37 26 32 51 51
Dont Know (4) 12 14 11 11 14 14 12 13 14 16 6 10 4 11 16 12 8 7 16
Net Performance Index (5)=(1)-(2) 13 13 14 17 11 3 12 15 21 22 -5 5 20 19 2 39 -12 -3 -1
Page 51 of 218
Performance on Addressing Corruption

Question: Please tell us of your opinion regarding the elimination of corruption from government departments by Prime Minister Nawaz Sharifs government.
DK/NR, 5%
Very Good, 19%
Bad, 29%

Page 52 of 218
Table 19: Performance on Addressing Corruption Question: Please tell us of your opinion regarding the elimination of corruption from government departments by Prime Minister Nawaz Sharifs government.
Very Good (1)

Good (2) 35 35 35 33 37 41 37 32 34 40 32 24 29 39 29 48 19 38 25
Bad (3) 29 29 29 32 26 34 27 29 30 22 41 34 33 27 32 13 43 32 41
Very Bad (4) 12 10 14 12 13 8 13 11 10 9 21 6 17 9 18 6 10 15 19
Dont Know (5) 5 4 5 4 5 5 4 6 10 7 1 2 1 2 10 3 3 1 9
19 21 17 19 19 12 19 21 16 21 5 34 21 23 12 29 26 14 6
Net Performanc e Index (6) = (1+2) (3+4) 13 17 10 8 18 12 17 13 11 30 -25 18 0 25 -8 58 -7 3 -29
Page 53 of 218
Performance on Addressing Nepotism

Question: Please tell us of your opinion regarding the elimination of nepotism (nepotism meaning that relatives and friends are given unwarranted monetary and social benefits) from government departments by Prime Minister Nawaz Sharifs Government.

Page 54 of 218
Table 20: Performance on Addressing Nepotism Question: Please tell us of your opinion regarding the elimination of nepotism (nepotism meaning that relatives and friends are given unwarranted monetary and social benefits) from government departments by Prime Minister Nawaz Sharifs Government.
Very Good (1)
Good (2) 35 36 35 33 37 32 35 36 39 41 21 42 25 38 29 49 31 25 24
Bad (3) 34 34 33 38 30 36 34 34 31 29 44 40 30 34 33 26 42 44 36
Very Bad (4) 14 13 16 13 15 18 15 13 12 11 24 8 28 12 19 5 15 14 26
Dont Know (5) 7 7 7 6 8 8 6 9 12 8 8 3 7 4 12 4 3 10 11
10 10 9 10 10 6 11 9 5 12 4 8 10 11 7 16 9 7 3
Net Performanc e Index (6) = (1+2) (3+4) -3 -1 -6 -9 1 -15 -2 -1 1 13 -42 3 -23 3 -15 35 -17 -26 -35
Page 55 of 218
PART 2
Public Verdict on Quality of Democracy in First 100 Days
Page 56 of 218
Public Verdict on the Quality of Democracy

Question: In your opinion, since the arrival of the new Government, have people got better opportunities to democratically govern themselves; have these opportunities deteriorated or has there been no change?

Page 57 of 218
Table 21: Public Verdict on the Quality of Democracy Question: In your opinion, since the arrival of the new Government, have people got better opportunities to democratically govern themselves; have these opportunities deteriorated or has there been no change?
Improved (1) 45 47 43 44 45 45 44 45 47 54 26 38 53 47 41 63 39 27 33
Deteriorated (2) 19 19 20 19 20 13 19 21 19 14 22 41 16 19 21 13 30 29 19
No Difference (3) 32 31 33 32 31 39 32 32 30 27 51 19 30 31 34 21 28 43 43
Dont Know (4) 4 3 5 4 3 2 4 2 4 5 1 2 1 3 5 3 3 1 6
All Pakistan Average Gender Male Female Respondent Age Young Middle Old Household Income Low Medium High Province Punjab Sindh KP Balochistan Location Rural Urban Voting Intention PML-N PTI PPP All others
Net Performance Index (5) = (1) -(2) 26 28 23 25 25 32 25 24 29 40 5 -2 37 28 20 50 9 -2 14
Page 58 of 218
Public Verdict on Hope

Question: After the formation of Prime Minister Nawaz Sharifs Government, some people believe that there is greater hope that Pakistan will now be able to overcome its problems and hardships; others think that Nawaz Sharifs Government has not brought any change in Pakistans prospects while yet others think that the situation will become worse. What is your opinion?

Page 59 of 218
Table 22: Public Verdict on Hope Question: After the formation of Prime Minister Nawaz Sharifs Government, some people believe that there is a greater hope that Pakistan will now be able to overcome its problems and hardships; others think that Nawaz Sharifs Government has not brought any change in Pakistans prospects while yet others think that the situation will become worse. What is your opinion?
Increase in your Hope (1) 44 45 42 42 45 46 40 48 58 47 28 51 63 46 40 64 23 28 34
Decrease (2) 22 23 22 24 22 19 23 25 17 17 29 35 16 19 29 11 52 33 20
No Difference (3) 30 29 32 30 31 30 33 25 22 30 43 12 19 31 28 22 23 37 41
Dont Know (4) 4 3 4 4 3 5 4 2 3 5 0 2 2 4 3 3 3 2 6
Net Performance Index (5) = (1) -(2) 22 23 20 18 23 27 18 24 40 29 0 16 46 26 11 53 -29 -5 13
Page 60 of 218
Public Verdict on Effective of Parliament

Question: In your opinion has the National Assembly become more powerful after the new Government came to power, has it become less powerful or has there been no change?

Page 61 of 218
Table 23: Public Verdict on Effectiveness of the Parliament Question: In your opinion has the National Assembly become more powerful after the new government came to power, has it become less powerful or has there been no change?
More Powerful
Less Powerful (2) 19 21 17 21 17 27 21 17 16 14 26 28 23 19 20 10 38 31 17
No Difference (3) 37 35 38 34 39 34 38 34 28 37 45 16 40 37 35 31 26 40 46
Dont Know (4) 6 4 8 6 6 7 5 7 8 9 2 5 4 5 8 5 5 2 10
(1) 38 40 36 39 37 32 36 42 48 40 28 51 33 39 38 54 31 27 27
Net Performance Index (5) = (1) -(2) 19 19 19 18 20 5 16 25 32 26 2 22 10 20 18 43 -8 -4 10
Page 62 of 218
Public Verdict on Effectiveness of the Federal Cabinet

Question: In your opinion, do the new Prime Minister and his ministers, in comparison to the previous Governments, have more authority in matters relating to the country, less authority, or has there been no change?

Page 63 of 218
Table 24: Public Verdict on Effectiveness of the Federal Cabinet Question: In your opinion, do the new Prime Minister and his ministers, in comparison to the previous Governments, have more authority in matters relating to the country, less authority or has there been no change?
Had More Authority (1) 32 33 31 32 32 29 31 32 41 36 27 26 30 32 32 46 17 20 25
Has less Authority Now (2) 22 23 20 23 21 25 24 21 14 21 19 35 17 24 18 20 35 30 15
No Difference (3) 39 38 41 40 39 38 38 40 37 36 50 33 49 39 39 27 43 43 51
Dont Know (4) 7 6 8 5 9 9 7 8 8 8 5 6 4 5 11 6 5 7 9
Net Performance Index (5) = (1) -(2) 10 10 10 9 11 4 7 11 27 15 8 -9 13 8 13 26 -18 -10 10
Page 64 of 218
Public Verdict on Effectiveness of the Executive

Question: In your opinion, did the countrys administration, meaning Civil Officers and bureaucracy, etc. follow the rules and regulations more before, do they do it more now or has there been no difference?

Page 65 of 218
Table 25: Public Verdict on Effectiveness of the Executive Question: In your opinion, did the countrys administration, meaning Civil Officers and bureaucracy etc., follow the rules and regulations more before, do they do it more now, or has there been no difference?
Used to abide by the law more during previous administrations

(1) 27 28 27 26 27 27 28 27 24 25 23 47 23 30 23 28 40 38 16
Are more law abiding now (2) 25 27 23 25 26 24 25 25 33 26 19 24 48 24 28 34 19 18 20
No Difference (3) 41 39 42 43 40 39 41 39 33 41 55 22 24 41 40 32 33 37 56
Dont Know (4) 7 6 8 6 7 10 6 9 11 9 3 7 6 6 9 6 7 7 7
Net Performance Index (5) = (2) -(1) -2 0 -4 0 -2 -3 -4 -2 9 1 -3 -22 25 -6 6 6 -21 -20 4
Page 66 of 218
Public Verdict on Democratic Checks on the Military

Question: In your opinion, did the military and military commanders consider themselves more subordinate to the Parliament before the new Government took charge or after, or has there been no difference?
Used to think as subordinate more before the new government, 18%
DK/NR, 8%
No difference, 44% Think of themselves as subordinates today, 30%

Page 67 of 218
Table 26: Public Verdict on Democratic Checks on the Military Question: In your opinion, did the military and military commanders consider themselves more subordinate to the Parliament before the new Government took charge or after, or has there been no difference?
Used to think as subordinate more before the new government (1) 18 20 15 15 19 20 18 22 11 18 16 24 11 18 18 18 19 29 12
Think of themselves as subordinates today (2) 30 31 29 33 27 30 30 28 35 27 22 44 53 31 27 34 37 23 24
No Difference
Dont Know
Net Performance Index (5) = (2) -(1) 12 11 13 18 8 10 12 6 24 10 6 20 42 13 10 16 17 -6 12
(3) 44 43 47 45 45 42 46 40 38 46 57 24 27 45 43 41 34 43 54
(4) 8 7 9 6 9 8 6 9 16 9 5 9 9 6 12 7 10 4 10
Page 68 of 218
Public Verdict on Fairness of General Election 2013

Question: In your opinion, was this years election, when compared with the election from five years ago, more honest and transparent, or worse?
DK/NR, 7%
No difference, 31%
Election was more honest, free and fair, 30%
Election was less honest, free and fair, 31%

Page 69 of 218
Table 27: Public Verdict on Fairness of General Election 2013 Question: In your opinion, was this years election, when compared with the election from five years ago, more honest and transparent, or worse?
Election was more honest, free and fair

(1) 30 30 31 29 31 23 28 35 39 32 22 31 50 30 32 40 16 28 25
Election was less honest, free and fair (2) 31 33 28 30 31 33 33 30 25 24 39 51 16 30 31 22 58 48 23
No Difference (3) 31 31 32 33 30 34 32 28 24 35 36 10 28 33 28 29 21 22 42
Dont Know (4) 7 6 10 7 8 10 7 7 11 10 3 7 5 7 9 8 5 2 10
Net Performance Index (5) = (1) -(2) -1 -3 3 -1 0 -10 -4 6 14 8 -17 -20 34 -1 1 18 -41 -19 2
Page 70 of 218
Public Trust in Political Parties

Question: How much do you trust your political party? (That is in its ability to be honest and its ability to run the Government).

Page 71 of 218
Table 28: Public Trust in Political Parties Question: How much do you trust your political party? (That is in its ability to be honest and its ability to run the Government).
A lot of Trust (1)

All Pakistan Average Gender Male Female Respondent Age Young Middle Old Household Income Low Medium High Province Punjab Sindh KP Balochistan Location Rural Urban Party Orientation (Voter of the party in election 2013) PML-N PTI PPP All others
Trust to an Extent (2) 37 34 42 37 38 41 36 38 44 32 46 33 64 37 39
Little Trust (3) 16 15 16 16 17 5 16 15 13 17 14 17 7 15 17
Very Little Trust (4) 9 11 7 9 8 18 9 8 8 10 9 7 7 8 11
A lot of Trust (5) 6 6 7 6 7 3 6 7 6 10 1 2 2 6 6
32 35 28 31 31 33 32 32 30 31 30 42 19 34 27
Net Performance Index (6) = (1+2) (3+4) 44 43 46 43 44 51 43 47 54 37 53 51 69 47 38
45 26 29 18
30 32 45 45
12 30 16 15
5 10 8 14
7 2 2 8
59 19 50 34
Page 72 of 218
Public Verdict on Effectiveness of the Supreme Court

Question: In your opinion, was the Supreme Court more powerful before the new Government took charge; is it more powerful now or has there been no change?
DK/NR, 6% More powerful before the new government,
30%
No difference ,
37%
More powerful now, 27%
Net Performance Rating -3

Page 73 of 218
Table 29: Public Verdict on Effectiveness of the Supreme Court Question: In your opinion, was the Supreme Court more powerful before the new Government took charge, is it more powerful now or has there been no change?
More Powerful before the new Government (1) 30 29 30 28 30 33 32 29 21 27 29 45 20 33 23 28 33 54 19
More Powerful now (2) 27 29 25 29 27 27 26 29 38 27 23 27 50 24 33 36 23 14 24
No Difference (3) 37 39 36 37 39 32 37 37 33 38 46 23 29 37 38 30 38 31 50
Dont Know (4) 6 3 9 7 5 8 6 5 8 8 2 5 1 6 6 7 6 1 7
Net Performance Index (5) = (1) -(2) 3 0 5 -1 3 5 6 -1 -17 0 6 19 -30 8 -10 -8 10 40 -5
Page 74 of 218
Public Verdict on Respect for Human Rights

Question: In your opinion, was the respect for human rights greater before the arrival of the new Government, is it greater now or has there been no difference?

Page 75 of 218
Table 30: Public Verdict on Respect for Human Rights Question: In your opinion, was the respect for human rights greater before the arrival of the new Government, is it greater now or has there been no difference?
People were more mindful before

(1) 19 19 17 16 20 14 20 17 14 15 22 29 12 20 15 18 23 35 10
People were more mindful now (2) 36 38 33 33 37 38 36 36 38 39 18 47 54 37 33 44 39 21 30
No Difference (3) 41 40 43 46 39 40 40 41 43 41 57 19 31 39 46 33 35 42 54
Dont Know (4) 4 3 6 4 4 8 4 6 5 5 3 4 3 3 7 5 3 3 5
Net Performance Index (5) = (2) -(1) 17 19 16 17 17 23 16 18 24 23 -3 18 42 17 18 26 16 -14 20
Notes: Age: Young: Under 30 years of age; Middle: Between 30 and 50 years of age; Old: Above 51 years of age Income codes: Low: Up to Rs. 15000 (In 2013 this represented the lowest quintile). Medium: Rs. 15,001 to 30,000 (In 2013 this represented the 2nd and 3rd Quintile). High: More than 30,000 (In 2013 this represented the 4th and 5th Quintiles) Location: Urban is defined as location defined as town or city in the census, the total in Pakistan being 470 constituting 35% of the population; Rural is defined as a population living in villages as in the latest census, approximating ~45,000, consisting 65% of the population. Methodology: Sample Size: 3568; Coverage: National/Rural and Urban/All four provinces; Mode: Face to face; Survey dates: Aug 26 - September 02, 2013. Estimated error margin: +3-5% at 95% confidence level
Page 76 of 218
Public Verdict on Independence of Media

Question: In your opinion, was the Pakistani media, that is television, radio and newspapers, more free before the arrival of the new Government, is it more free now, or has there been no difference?
No difference ,
49%
DK/NR, 5%
More free now,
33%
More free before, 13%

Page 77 of 218
Table 31: Public Verdict on Independence of Media Question: In your opinion, was the Pakistani media, that is television, radio and newspapers, more free before the arrival of the new Government, is it more free now, or has there been no difference?
More Free Before

More Free Now (2) 33 32 34 33 32 38 34 29 37 34 23 43 46 33 33 38 39 25 28
No Difference (3) 49 50 47 50 48 49 49 47 47 49 58 35 43 49 48 45 41 44 58
Dont Know (4) 5 4 7 6 5 8 4 9 7 7 2 6 3 6 6 6 5 2 7
(1) 13 14 11 11 14 5 13 15 9 10 18 15 8 13 13 10 15 30 8
Net Performance Index (5) = (2) -(1) 20 18 23 22 18 33 21 14 27 23 5 28 37 20 20 28 24 -5 20
Page 78 of 218
Public Verdict on Sovereignty

Question: In your opinion, was the pressure of foreign powers such as America and the World Bank etc. more before the new Government came to power, or now, or has there been no difference?
DK/NR, 7%
No Difference , 40%
More pressure before, 30%
More pressure now, 23%

Page 79 of 218
Table 32: Public Verdict on Sovereignty Question: In your opinion, was the pressure of foreign powers such as America and the World Bank, etc. more before the new Government came to power, or now, or has there been no difference?
More Pressure Before

(1) 30 32 27 30 29 26 30 30 34 28 23 45 35 31 28 37 40 29 16
More Pressure Now (2) 23 24 21 24 22 24 24 23 18 16 28 37 33 21 26 17 36 25 23
No Difference (3) 40 38 41 38 41 39 40 37 38 43 46 15 29 41 37 36 21 38 51
Dont Know (4) 7 6 10 8 8 11 7 10 10 12 3 3 3 8 9 9 3 7 10
Net Performance Index (5) = (1) -(2) 7 8 5 6 7 1 6 7 16 12 -5 8 2 9 2 20 4 4 -7
Page 80 of 218
PART 3
Public Verdict on Performance of the Provincial Governments in First 100 Days
Page 81 of 218
SUMMARY CHARTS
NPR-INDEX IN PUNJAB
Page 82 of 218
Table 33: NPR Index of Punjab Government Across Punjab

INDICAT ORS IN RANK ORDER OF NET PERFORMANCE RATING (NPR) INDEX Positive Performance (1) Negative Performance (2) DK /N R NPR-Index Net Performance (3)=(1)-(2)
(TOP TO BOTTOM) OVERALL PERFORMANCE OF 1 PUNJAB CM

PERFORMANCE ON PERFORMANCE ON PERFORMANCE ON
84 80 72 63 57 55 54 50
11 16 23 31 34 36 39 41
4 4 5 7 9 10 7
73 64 49 32 23 19 15 9
3 EDUCATION
4 HALTHCARE
5 STREET CLEANING 6 DRINKING WATER 7 REDUCING CRIME

PERFROMANCE ON PERFORMANCE ON PERFORMANCE ON CLEAN
8 CORRUPTION
PERFORMANCE ON
ADDRESSING ADDRESSING
9 NEPOSTISM
Notes: Age: Young: Under 30 years of age; Middle: Between 30 and 50 years of age; Old: Above 51 years of age Income codes: Low: Up to Rs.15,000 (in 2013 this represented the lowest quintile). Medium: Rs. 15,000 to 30,000 (In 2013 this represented the 2nd and 3rd Quintile). High: More than 30,000 (In 2013 this represented the 4th and 5th Quintiles) Location: Urban is defined as location defined as town or city in the census, the total in Punjab being constituting 32% of the population; Rural is defined as a population living in villages as in the latest census, 68% of the population. Rounding off error: In some cases the totals may not add up to 100 or mismatch with earlier tables to the extent of 1%. Please ignore this, as it is due to round off error. Methodology: Sample Size: 1370; Coverage: National/Rural and Urban/All four provinces; Mode: Face to face; Survey dates: Aug 26 - Sep 02 2013. Estimated error margin: +3-5% at 95% confidence level
Page 83 of 218
Table 34: NPR Index of Punjab Government Across Age Groups

INDICATO RS
IN RANK ORDER OF NET PERFORMANCE RATING (NPR) INDEX

(TOP TO BOTTOM)
All Punjab
Young Middle
Old
1 PUNJAB CM 3 PERFORMANCE ON EDUCATION 4 PERFORMANCE ON HALTHCARE 5 CLEANING

PERFORMANCE ON STREET PERFORMANCE ON CLEAN PERFORMANCE ON REDUCING
OVERALL PERFORMANCE OF
73 64 49 32 23 19 15 9
75 65 51 20 22 27 11 -6
73 63 47 41 25 15 18 18
56 51 38 26 3 -3 42 26
6 DRINKING WATER 7 CRIME
8 CORRUPTION 9 NEPOSTISM
PERFROMANCE ON ADDRESSING PERFORMANCE ON ADDRESSING
Page 84 of 218
Table 35: NPR Index of Punjab Government Across Education

INDICAT ORS

(TOP TO BOTTOM)
All Punjab
73 64 49 32 23 19 15 9
Low
Medium
High
1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
OVERALL PERFORMANCE OF PUNJAB CM PERFORMANCE ON EDUCATION PERFORMANCE ON HALTHCARE PERFORMANCE ON STREET CLEANING PERFORMANCE ON CLEAN DRINKING WATER PERFORMANCE ON REDUCING CRIME PERFROMANCE ON ADDRESSING CORRUPTION PERFORMANCE ON ADDRESSING NEPOSTISM
85 78 55 38 34 34 6 -2
74 60 50 41 20 10 27 19
47 41 32 4 9 8 13 10
Page 85 of 218
Table 36: NPR Index of Punjab Government Across Income IN RANK ORDER OF NET PERFORMANCE RATING (NPR) INDEX
(TOP TO BOTTOM)
INDICAT ORS
All Punjab
73 64 49 32 23 19 15 9
Low
Medium
High
1 3 4 5 6 7
OVERALL PERFORMANCE OF PUNJAB CM PERFORMANCE ON EDUCATION PERFORMANCE ON HALTHCARE PERFORMANCE ON STREET CLEANING PERFORMANCE ON CLEAN DRINKING WATER PERFORMANCE ON REDUCING CRIME
PERFROMANCE ON PERFORMANCE ON
72 61 45 35 22 18 18 6
70 63 47 11 18 31 17 18
80 70 61 33 14 -34 28 39
8 ADDRESSING CORRUPTION 9 ADDRESSING NEPOSTISM
Page 86 of 218
Table 37: NPR Index of Punjab Government Across Gender

INDICATO RS

(TOP TO BOTTOM)
All Punjab
Male
Female
1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
OVERALL PERFORMANCE OF PUNJAB CM PERFORMANCE ON EDUCATION PERFORMANCE ON HALTHCARE PERFORMANCE ON STREET CLEANING PERFORMANCE ON CLEAN DRINKING WATER PERFORMANCE ON REDUCING CRIME PERFROMANCE ON ADDRESSING CORRUPTION PERFORMANCE ON ADDRESSING NEPOSTISM
73 64 49 32 23 19 15 9
70 58 44 33 24 25 18 15
77 71 54 31 22 12 14 2
Page 87 of 218
SUMMARY CHARTS
NPR-INDEX IN SINDH
Page 88 of 218
Table 38: NPR Index of Sindh Government Across Sindh
INDICAT ORS
IN RANK ORDER OF NET PERFORMANCE RATING (NPR) INDEX (TOP TO BOTTOM) OVERALL PERFORMANCE OF SINDH CM
PERFORMANCE ON
Positive Performance (1)
Negative Performance (2)
D K/ N R
2 2 2 3 3 2 3 10
NPR-Index Net Performance (3)=(1)-(2)
1 3 4 8 6 7 5 9
48 45 37 30 26 26 25 18
50 53 61 66 72 72 72 73
-2 -8 -24 -36 -46 -46 -47 -55
EDUCATION
PERFORMANCE ON
HEALTH ISSUES
PERFORMANCE ON
ADDRESSING CORRUPTION
PERFORMANCE ON CLEAN
DRINKING WATER
PERFORMANCE ON
REDUCING CRIME
PERFORMANCE ON
STREET CLEANING
PERFORMANCE ON
ADDRESSING NEPOSTISM
Notes: Age: Young: Under 30 years of age; Middle: Between 30 and 50 years of age; Old: Above 51 years of age Income codes: Low: Up to Rs.15,000 (in 2013 this represented the lowest quintile). Medium: Rs. 15,000 to 30,000 (In 2013 this represented the 2nd and 3rd Quintile). High: More than 30,000 (In 2013 this represented the 4th and 5th Quintiles) Location: Urban is defined as location defined as town or city in the census, the total in SINDH being constituting 49% of the population; Rural is defined as a population living in villages as in the latest census, 51% of the population. Rounding off error: In some cases the totals may not add up to 100 or mismatch with earlier tables to the extent of 1%. Please ignore this, as it is due to round off error. Methodology: Sample Size: 855; Coverage: National/Rural and Urban/All four provinces; Mode: Face to face; Survey dates: Aug 26 - Sep 02, 2013. Estimated error margin: +3-5% at 95% confidence level
Page 89 of 218
Table 39: NPR Index of Sindh Government Across Age Groups

INDICATO RS

(TOP TO BOTTOM)
All SINDH
Young Middle
Old
1 3 4 8 6 7 5 9
OVERALL PERFORMANCE OF SINDH CM PERFORMANCE ON EDUCATION PERFORMANCE ON HEALTH ISSUES PERFORMANCE ON ADDRESSING CORRUPTION PERFORMANCE ON CLEAN DRINKING WATER PERFORMANCE ON REDUCING CRIME PERFORMANCE ON STREET CLEANING PERFORMANCE ON ADDRESSING NEPOSTISM
-2 -8 -24 -36 -46 -46 -47 -55
-22 -6 -31 -46 -55 -54 -58 -68
-45 -14 -24 -34 -45 -49 -47 -47
4 35 26 17 6 1 17 -27
Page 90 of 218
Table 40: NPR Index of Sindh Government Across Education

INDICAT ORS

(TOP TO BOTTOM)
All SINDH
-2 -8 -24 -36 -46 -46 -47 -55
Low
Medium
High
1 3 4 8 6 7 5 9
OVERALL PERFORMANCE OF SINDH CM PERFORMANCE ON EDUCATION PERFORMANCE ON HEALTH ISSUES PERFORMANCE ON ADDRESSING CORRUPTION PERFORMANCE ON CLEAN DRINKING WATER PERFORMANCE ON REDUCING CRIME PERFORMANCE ON STREET CLEANING PERFORMANCE ON ADDRESSING NEPOSTISM
-13 19 -9 -7 -36 -35 -36 -48
-40 -27 -40 -50 -58 -55 -61 -63
-40 -10 -19 -45 -42 -50 -43 -51
Page 91 of 218
Table 41: NPR Index of Sindh Government Across Income

INDICAT ORS

(TOP TO BOTTOM)
All SINDH
-2 -8 -24 -36 -46 -46 -47 -55
Low
Medium
High
1 3 4 8 6 7 5 9
OVERALL PERFORMANCE OF SINDH CM PERFORMANCE ON EDUCATION PERFORMANCE ON HEALTH ISSUES

PERFORMANCE ON
-25 -7 -21 -26 -45 -45 -41 -52
-45 -7 -33 -53 -48 -58 -60 -63
-59 -9 -21 -66 -42 -42 -64 -54
ADDRESSING CORRUPTION PERFORMANCE ON CLEAN DRINKING WATER PERFORMANCE ON REDUCING CRIME PERFORMANCE ON STREET CLEANING
PERFORMANCE ON
ADDRESSING NEPOSTISM
Page 92 of 218
Table 42: NPR Index of Sindh Government Across Gender

INDICATO RS

(TOP TO BOTTOM)
All SINDH
2 -2 -8 -18 -24 -36 -46 -46 -47 -55
Male
4 -1 14 -19 -4 -1 -34 -32 -21 -42
Female
1 -65 -29 -18 -44 -71 -58 -64 -75 -67
PROVINCIAL AUTONOMY OVERALL PERFORMANCE OF 1 SINDH CM 3 PERFORMANCE ON EDUCATION PERFORMANCE ON QUALITY OF 10 GOVERNANCE 4 PERFORMANCE ON HEALTH ISSUES PERFORMANCE ON ADDRESSING 8 CORRUPTION PERFORMANCE ON CLEAN DRINKING 6 WATER 7 PERFORMANCE ON REDUCING CRIME 5 PERFORMANCE ON STREET CLEANING PERFORMANCE ON ADDRESSING 9 NEPOSTISM
11
Page 93 of 218
SUMMARY CHARTS
NPR-INDEX IN KHYBER PAKHTUNKHWA
Page 94 of 218
Table 43: NPR Index of KP Government Across KP

INDICAT ORS IN RANK ORDER OF NET PERFORMANCE RATING (NPR) INDEX (TOP TO BOTTOM)
PERFORMANCE ON PERFORMANCE ON
Positive Performance (1)
Negative Performance (2)
D K/ N R
1 1 2 2 3 2 1 8
NPR-Index Net Performance (3)=(1)-(2)
3 EDUCATION
80 72 62 61 54 53 52 46
18 27 36 36 43 45 47 50
62 45 26 25 11 8 5 -4
4 HEALTHCARE
OVERALL PERFORMANCE OF KP 3 CM PERFORMANCE ON CLEAN 6 DRINKING WATER

PERFROMANCE ON
8 CORRUPTION 7 REDUCING CRIME 5 STREET CLEANING

PERFORMANCE ON PERFORMANCE ON PERFORMANCE ON
ADDRESSING
9 NEPOSTISM
ADDRESSING
Notes: Age: Young: Under 30 years of age; Middle: Between 30 and 50 years of age; Old: Above 51 years of age Income codes: Low: Up to Rs.15,000 (in 2013 this represented the lowest quintile). Medium: Rs. 15,000 to 30,000 (In 2013 this represented the 2nd and 3rd Quintile). High: More than 30,000 (In 2013 this represented the 4th and 5th Quintiles) Location: Urban is defined as location defined as town or city in the census, the total in KP being constituting 17% of the population; Rural is defined as a population living in villages as in the latest census, 83% of the population. Rounding off error: In some cases the totals may not add up to 100 or mismatch with earlier tables to the extent of 1%. Please ignore this, as it is due to round off error. Methodology: Sample Size: 656; Coverage: National/Rural and Urban/All four provinces; Mode: Face to face; Survey dates: Aug 26 - Sep 02, 2013. Estimated error margin: +3-5% at 95% confidence level
Page 95 of 218
Table 44: NPR Index of KP Government Across Age

INDICATO RS

(TOP TO BOTTOM)
All KP
62 45 26 25 11 8 5 -4
Young Middle
62 47 26 26 -8 12 9 -21 61 44 21 20 15 -1 0 -1
Old
28 46 3 22 19 -20 -38 -6
3 PERFORMANCE ON EDUCATION 4 PERFORMANCE ON HEALTHCARE 3 CM

OVERALL PERFORMANCE OF KP
PERFORMANCE ON CLEAN PERFROMANCE ON ADDRESSING PERFORMANCE ON REDUCING PERFORMANCE ON STREET PERFORMANCE ON ADDRESSING
6 DRINKING WATER 8 CORRUPTION 7 CRIME
5 CLEANING
9 NEPOSTISM
Notes: Age: Young: Under 30 years of age; Middle: Between 30 and 50 years of age; Old: Above 51 years of age Income codes: Low: Up to Rs.15,000 (in 2013 this represented the lowest quintile). Medium: Rs. 15,000 to 30,000 (In 2013 this represented the 2nd and 3rd Quintile). High: More than 30,000 (In 2013 this represented the 4th and 5th Quintiles) Location: Urban is defined as location defined as town or city in the census, the total in KP constituting 17% of the population; Rural is defined as a population living in villages as in the latest census, 83% of the population. Rounding off error: In some cases the totals may not add up to 100 or mismatch with earlier tables to the extent of 1%. Please ignore this, as it is due to round off error. Methodology: Sample Size: 656; Coverage: National/Rural and Urban/All four provinces; Mode: Face to face; Survey dates: Aug 26 - Sep 02, 2013. Estimated error margin: +3-5% at 95% confidence level
Page 96 of 218
Table 45: NPR Index of KP Government Across Education

INDICAT ORS

(TOP TO BOTTOM)
All KP
62 45 26 25 11 8 5 -4
Low
60 49 35 24 4 5 5 -10
Medium
59 41 25 25 18 2 13 -5
High
70 48 15 28 9 19 -8 8

PERFORMANCE ON CLEAN PERFROMANCE ON ADDRESSING PERFORMANCE ON REDUCING PERFORMANCE ON STREET PERFORMANCE ON ADDRESSING
6 DRINKING WATER 8 CORRUPTION 7 CRIME
5 CLEANING
9 NEPOSTISM
Page 97 of 218
Table 46: NPR Index of KP Government Across Income

INDICAT ORS

(TOP TO BOTTOM)
All KP
62 45 26 25 11 8 5 -4
Low 63 49 19 25 15 6 2 -6
Medium 58 40 43 21 4 -5 15 -7
High 71 48 3 44 21 59 -9 23
3 PERFORMANCE ON EDUCATION 4 HEALTHCARE 3 KP CM

PERFORMANCE ON
PERFORMANCE ON CLEAN PERFROMANCE ON
6 DRINKING WATER
8 ADDRESSING CORRUPTION 7 CRIME

PERFORMANCE ON REDUCING PERFORMANCE ON STREET PERFORMANCE ON
5 CLEANING
9 ADDRESSING NEPOSTISM
Notes: Age: Young: Under 30 years of age; Middle: Between 30 and 50 years of age; Old: Above 51 years of age Income codes: Low: Up to Rs.15,000 (in 2013 this represented the lowest quintile). Medium: Rs. 15,000 to 30,000 (In 2013 this represented the 2nd and 3rd Quintile). High: More than 30,000 (In 2013 this represented the 4th and 5th Quintiles) Location: Urban is defined as location defined as town or city in the census, the total in KP being constituting 17% of the population; Rural is defined as a population living in villages as in the latest census, 83% of the population. Rounding off error: In some cases the totals may not add up to 100 or mismatch with earlier tables to the extent of 1%. Please ignore this, as it is due to round off error. Methodology: Sample Size: 656; Coverage: National/Rural and Urban/All four provinces; Mode: Face to face; Survey dates: Aug 26 - Sep 02, 2013. Estimated error margin: +3-5% at 95% confidence level
Page 98 of 218
Table 47: NPR Index of KP Government Across Gender

INDICATO RS

(TOP TO BOTTOM)
All KP
62 45 26 25 11 8 5 -4
Male
62 46 26 30 9 13 0 -2
Female
63 45 25 18 14 -2 14 -7

PERFORMANCE ON CLEAN DRINKING PERFROMANCE ON ADDRESSING
6 WATER
8 CORRUPTION 7 PERFORMANCE ON REDUCING CRIME 5 PERFORMANCE ON STREET CLEANING 9 NEPOSTISM

PERFORMANCE ON ADDRESSING
Page 99 of 218
SUMMARY CHARTS
NPR-INDEX IN BALOCHISTAN
Page 100 of 218
Table 48: NPR Index of Balochistan Government Across Balochistan

INDICA TORS IN RANK ORDER OF NET PERFORMANCE RATING (NPR) INDEX Positive Performance (1) Negative Performance (2) DK /N R NPR-Index Net Performance (3)=(1)-(2)
(TOP TO BOTTOM) OVERALL PERFORMANCE OF 1 BALOCHISTAN CM PERFORMANCE ON CLEAN 6 DRINKING WATER
58 52 46 43 43 42 39 31
41 44 50 47 55 54 58 64
17
2 4 4 10 2 4 3 5
8 -4 -4 -12 -12 -19 -33
5 STREET CLEANING
PERFORMANCE ON
PERFORMANCE ON
9 NEPOSTISM
ADDRESSING
PERFORMANCE ON PERFORMANCE ON PERFROMANCE ON
3 EDUCATION
7 REDUCING CRIME 8 CORRUPTION 4 HEALTHCARE

PERFORMANCE ON
ADDRESSING
Notes: Age: Young: Under 30 years of age; Middle: Between 30 and 50 years of age; Old: Above 51 years of age Income codes: Low: Up to Rs.15,000 (in 2013 this represented the lowest quintile). Medium: Rs. 15,000 to 30,000 (In 2013 this represented the 2nd and 3rd Quintile). High: More than 30,000 (In 2013 this represented the 4th and 5th Quintiles) Location: Urban is defined as location defined as town or city in the census, the total in BALOCHISTAN being constituting 24% of the population; Rural is defined as a population living in villages as in the latest census, 76% of the population. Rounding off error: In some cases the totals may not add up to 100 or mismatch with earlier tables to the extent of 1%. Please ignore this, as it is due to round off error. Methodology: Sample Size: 687; Coverage: National/Rural and Urban/All four provinces; Mode: Face to face; Survey dates: Aug 26 - Sep 02 2013. Estimated error margin: +3-5% at 95% confidence level
Page 101 of 218
Table 49: NPR Index of Balochistan Government Across Age

INDICATO RS

(TOP TO BOTTOM)
All Balochistan
Young Middle
Old
1 BALOCHISTAN CM
PERFORMANCE ON CLEAN PERFORMANCE ON STREET PERFORMANCE ON ADDRESSING
17 8 -4 -4 -12 -12 -19 -33
11 9 -2 -12 -23 2 -31 -39
21 3 -9 1 -4 -25 -8 -26
29 13 14 15 -3 -21 -8 -28
6 DRINKING WATER 5 CLEANING
9 NEPOSTISM 3 PERFORMANCE ON EDUCATION 7 CRIME

PERFORMANCE ON REDUCING
8 CORRUPTION 4 PERFORMANCE ON HEALTHCARE
PERFROMANCE ON ADDRESSING
Page 102 of 218
Table 50: NPR Index of Balochistan Government Across Education

INDICAT ORS

(TOP TO BOTTOM)
All Balochistan
17 8 -4 -4 -12 -12 -19 -33
Low
Medium
High
1 BALOCHISTAN CM
PERFORMANCE ON CLEAN PERFORMANCE ON STREET PERFORMANCE ON ADDRESSING
23 16 6 20 -10 -33 -15 -25
10 14 7 -6 -20 -15 -18 -36
20 -11 -29 -26 -7 16 -27 -34
6 DRINKING WATER 5 CLEANING
9 NEPOSTISM 3 PERFORMANCE ON EDUCATION 7 CRIME

PERFORMANCE ON REDUCING
8 CORRUPTION 4 PERFORMANCE ON HEALTHCARE
PERFROMANCE ON ADDRESSING
Page 103 of 218
Table 51: NPR Index of Balochistan Government Across Income

INDICAT ORS

(TOP TO BOTTOM)
All Balochistan
17 8 -4 -4 -12 -12 -19 -33
Low
Medium
High
OVERALL PERFORMANCE OF 1 BALOCHISTAN CM PERFORMANCE ON CLEAN 6 DRINKING WATER PERFORMANCE ON STREET 5 CLEANING
33 -20 -42 -8 7 -35 2 -29
-5 45 48 2 -42 21 -48 -36
0 32 14 -21 -34 11 -31 -40
9 ADDRESSING NEPOSTISM 3 PERFORMANCE ON EDUCATION 7 CRIME

PERFORMANCE ON REDUCING PERFROMANCE ON PERFORMANCE ON
PERFORMANCE ON
8 ADDRESSING CORRUPTION 4 HEALTHCARE
Page 104 of 218
Table 52: NPR Index of Balochistan Government Across Gender

INDICATO RS

(TOP TO BOTTOM)
All Balochistan
17 8 -4 -4 -12 -12 -19 -33
Male
Female
1 BALOCHISTAN CM
PERFORMANCE ON CLEAN DRINKING
33 -20 -42 -8 7 -35 2 -29
-5 45 48 2 -42 21 -48 -36
6 WATER 5 PERFORMANCE ON STREET CLEANING 9 NEPOSTISM 3 PERFORMANCE ON EDUCATION 7 PERFORMANCE ON REDUCING CRIME 8 CORRUPTION 4 PERFORMANCE ON HEALTHCARE
PERFROMANCE ON ADDRESSING PERFORMANCE ON ADDRESSING
Page 105 of 218
Public Verdict on Performance of the Provincial Government of the Punjab
Page 106 of 218
Performance of Chief Minister Punjab

Question: What is your opinion on the overall performance of the Chief Minister of Punjab so far?
DK/NR, 4%
Very Good, 39%
Good, 45%

Note: In some cases the totals may not add up to 100 or mismatch with earlier tables to the extent of 1%. Please ignore this, as it is due to round off error.
Page 107 of 218
Table 53: Performance of Chief Minister Punjab

Question: What is your opinion on the overall performance of the Chief Minister of Punjab so far?
Base: All Punjab Very Good (1) All Punjab Average Gender Male Female Respondent Age Young Middle Old Household Income Low Medium High Location Rural Urban 39 40 38 43 38 18 39 43 34 44 27 Good (2) 45 43 48 42 47 58 45 40 54 43 52 Bad (3) 7 9 5 6 8 19 7 9 7 6 11 Very Bad (4) 4 4 4 5 4 2 5 4 1 4 4 Fig are Row Percentage Net DK/NR Performance Index (6) = (5) {(1)+(2)} {(3)+(4)} 4 73 4 4 4 4 3 4 4 4 3 7 70 77 75 73 56 72 70 80 77 64
Notes: Age: Young: Under 30 years of age; Middle: Between 30 and 50 years of age; Old: Above 51 years of age Income codes: Low: Up to Rs.15,000 (in 2013 this represented the lowest quintile). Medium: Rs. 15,000 to 30,000 (In 2013 this represented the 2nd and 3rd Quintile). High: More than 30,000 (In 2013 this represented the 4th and 5th Quintiles) Location: Urban is defined as location defined as town or city in the census, the total in Punjab being constituting 32% of the population; Rural is defined as a population living in villages as in the latest census, 68% of the population. Note: In some cases the totals may not add up to 100 or mismatch with earlier tables to the extent of 1%. Please ignore this, as it is due to round off error. Methodology: Sample Size: 1370; Coverage: National/Rural and Urban/All four provinces; Mode: Face to face; Survey dates: Aug 26 - Sep 02 2013. Estimated error margin: +3-5% at 95% confidence level
Page 108 of 218
Best Performing Chief Minister

Question: In your opinion, out of the countrys four Chief Ministers, which one has been the most successful? And it can be from your own province or from any other.
100% 90% 80% 70% 60% 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0% Shahbaz Sharif Qaim Ali Shah Parveiz Khatak Dr Abdul Malik All others/DK/NR 8% 4% 1% 11% 76%
Page 109 of 218
Table 54: Best Performing Chief Minister (Punjab)

Base: All Punjab Fig are Row Percentage
Shahbaz Sharif
All Punjab Average Gender Male Female Respondent Age Young Middle Old Household Income Low Medium High Location Rural Urban
Qaim Ali Shah 8 8 8 8 7 7 9 6 1 8 8
Pervez Khattak 4 3 4 5 3 2 3 4 9 2 7
Dr. Abdul Malik 1 0 1 1 1 2 1 1 1 0 2
All others\DK/NR 11 12 10 9 12 22 12 12 8 9 16
76 76 77 77 77 66 75 77 81 81 67
Page 110 of 218
Performance on Education
Question: What is your opinion regarding the performance, in availability of education, of the Chief Minister and his government that has been established in Punjab after the latest election?
Very Bad, 4%
DK/NR, 4%
Bad, 12%
Very Good, 25%
Good, 55%

Page 111 of 218
Table 55: Performance on Education

Question: What is your opinion regarding the performance, in availability of education, of the Chief Minister and his government that has been established in Punjab after the latest election?
Page 112 of 218
Performance on Healthcare
Question: What is your opinion regarding the performance, in availability of healthcare facilities, of the Chief Minister and his government that has been established in Punjab after the latest election?
Very Bad, 5%
DK/NR, 5%
Very Good, 16% Bad, 18%
Good, 56%

Page 113 of 218
Table 56: Performance on Healthcare

Question: What is your opinion regarding the performance, in availability of healthcare facilities, of the Chief Minister and his government that has been established in Punjab after the last election?
Page 114 of 218
Performance on Street Cleaning

Question: What is your opinion regarding the performance, regarding garbage and its disposal, of the Chief Minister and his government that has been established in Punjab after the latest election?
Very Bad, DK/NR, 7% 8% Very Good, 13%
Bad, 23% Good, 50%

Page 115 of 218
Table 57: Performance on Street Cleaning

Question: What is your opinion regarding the performance, regarding garbage and its disposal, of the Chief Minister and his government that has been established in Punjab after the latest election?
Page 116 of 218
Performance on Safe Drinking Water

Question: What is your opinion regarding the performance, in availability of clean drinking water, of the Chief Minister and his government that has been established in Punjab after the latest election?
Very Bad, 7%
DK/NR, Very Good, 9% 9%
Bad, 27%
Good, 48%

Page 117 of 218
Table 58: Performance on Safe Drinking Water

Question: What is your opinion regarding the performance, in availability of clean drinking water, of the Chief Minister and his government that has been established in Punjab after the latest election?
Page 118 of 218
Performance on Reducing Crime

Question: What is your opinion regarding the performance, relating to peace and crime, of the Chief Minister and his government that has been established in Punjab after the last election?
Very Bad, 7%
Very Good, 6% DK/NR, 10%
Bad, 29%
Good, 49%

Page 119 of 218
Table 59: Performance on Reducing Crime

Question: What is your opinion regarding the performance, relating to peace and crime, of the Chief Minister and his government that has been established in Punjab after the latest election?
Base: All Punjab Very Good (1) All Punjab Average Gender Male Female Respondent Age Young Middle Old Household Income Low Medium High Location Rural Urban 6 7 5 5 7 4 6 7 4 5 9 Good (2) 49 50 47 53 47 34 48 52 23 54 37 Bad (3) 29 26 33 25 32 19 29 23 57 26 35 Very Bad (4) 7 7 6 6 6 21 8 5 4 5 11 Fig are Row Percentage Net DK/NR Performance Index (6) = (5) {(1)+(2)} {(3)+(4)} 10 19 10 9 10 8 21 9 12 12 10 9 25 12 27 15 -3 18 31 -34 28 0
Page 120 of 218
Performance on Eliminating Corruption

Question: Please tell us of your opinion regarding the elimination of corruption from governmental departments by your Provincial Government.
DK/NR, 7% Very Good, 11% Very Bad, 13%
Bad, 26%
Good, 43%

Page 121 of 218
Table 60: Performance on Eliminating Corruption

Page 122 of 218
Performance on Eliminating Nepotism

Question: Please tell us of your opinion regarding the elimination of nepotism (nepotism meaning that relatives and friends are given unwarranted monetary and social benefits) from governmental departments by your Provincial Government.
DK/NR, 7% Very Good, 11% Very Bad, 13%
Bad, 26%
Good, 43%

Page 123 of 218
Table 61: Performance on Eliminating Nepotism

Question: Please tell us of your opinion regarding the elimination of nepotism (nepotism meaning that relatives and friends are given unwarranted monetary and social benefits) from governmental departments by your Provincial Government.
Base: All Punjab Very Good (1) All Punjab Average Gender Male Female Respondent Age Young Middle Old Household Income Low Medium High Location Rural Urban 12 15 8 11 12 12 12 10 20 14 8 Good (2) 38 37 39 32 42 43 37 42 41 40 34 Bad (3) 23 24 21 28 20 21 24 22 16 21 27 Very Bad (4) 18 13 24 21 17 8 19 11 5 20 14 Fig are Row Percentage Net DK/NR Performance Index (6) = (5) {(1)+(2)} {(3)+(4)} 9 9 10 8 8 10 16 7 14 18 5 18 15 2 -6 18 26 6 18 39 13 1
Page 124 of 218
Hope in the Punjab Government

Question: After the formation of your Provincial Government through the
recent election, some people believe that there is a greater hope that your province will now be able to overcome its problems and hardships; others think that your Provincial Government has not brought any change in your provinces prospects while yet others think that the situation will become worse. What is your opinion?
DK/NR, 5%
No difference , 26%
Increase in your hope, 46%
Decrease, 23%

Page 125 of 218
Table 62: Hope in the Punjab Government

Base: All Punjab Increase in your hope All Punjab Average Gender Male Female Respondent Age Young Middle Old Household Income Low Medium High Location Rural Urban (1) 46 49 42 46 45 54 44 52 55 46 46 Decrease (2) 23 26 20 25 23 22 26 22 11 23 24 No Difference (3) 26 19 33 24 27 19 27 20 26 26 25 DK/NR (4) 5 5 5 5 5 4 4 7 8 5 5 Fig are Row Percentage Net Performance Index (5) = (1) -(2) 23 23 22 21 23 32 18 30 44 22 22
Age: Young: Under 30 years of age; Middle: Between 30 and 50 years of age; Old: Above 51 years of age Income codes: Low: Up to Rs.15,000 (in 2013 this represented the lowest quintile). Medium: Rs. 15,000 to 30,000 (In 2013 this represented the 2nd and 3rd Quintile). High: More than 30,000 (In 2013 this represented the 4th and 5th Quintiles) Location: Urban is defined as location defined as town or city in the census, the total in Punjab being constituting 32% of the population; Rural is defined as a population living in villages as in the latest census, 68% of the population. Note: In some cases the totals may not add up to 100 or mismatch with earlier tables to the extent of 1%. Please ignore this, as it is due to round off error. Methodology: Sample Size: 1370; Coverage: National/Rural and Urban/All four provinces; Mode: Face to face; Survey dates: Aug 26 - Sep 02 2013. Estimated error margin: +3-5% at 95% confidence level
Page 126 of 218
Provincial Autonomy
Question: In your opinion, did your provincial government have more powers and privileges before the new government came in; does it have more powers now, or has there been no change?
DK/NR, 10%
Had more power and authority before, 22% Has more power and authority now, 27%
No difference , 42%

Page 127 of 218
Table 63: Provincial Autonomy

Question: In your opinion, did your provincial government have more power and privileges before the new government came in; does it have more powers now, or has there been no change?
Base: All Punjab Had more power and authority before (1) All Punjab Average Gender Male Female Respondent Age Young Middle Old Household Income Low Medium High Location Rural Urban 22 23 20 22 22 16 23 25 8 21 23 Has more power and authority now (2) 27 30 23 27 26 34 26 32 31 22 38 No difference (3) 42 40 44 40 44 30 41 35 53 47 31 DK/NR Fig are Row Percentage Net Performance Index (5) = (2) -(1) 5 6 3 6 4 18 3 7 23 0 15
(4) 10 7 14 11 9 20 10 8 8 10 9
Page 128 of 218
Public Verdict on Performance of the Provincial Government of Sindh
Page 129 of 218
Performance of Chief Minister Sindh

Question: What is your opinion on the performance of the Chief Minister of Sindh?
DK/NR, 1%
Very Good, 6%
Very Bad, 18%
Good, 42% Bad, 32%

Page 130 of 218
Table 64: Performance of Chief Minister Sindh

Question: What is your opinion on the performance of the Chief Minister of Sindh?
Base: All Sindh Very good Good Bad Very bad
Figure are row percentages
Dont Know
Net Performance Index
All Sindh Average Gender Male Female Respondent Age Young (Under 30) Middle (30 - 50) Old (50+) Household Income Low Medium High Location Rural Urban
(1) 6 11 2 7 4 17 7 5 6 7 5
(2) 42 45 40 45 39 45 48 30 25 64 19
(3) 32 29 36 30 36 24 29 40 46 23 42
(4) 18 14 22 18 19 13 16 23 23 5 32
(5) 1 1 1 1 1 0 1 3 1 0 2
(6) = {(1)+(2)} {(3)+(4)} -2 12 -16 4 -11 25 10 -28 -37 43 -50
Notes: Age: Young: Under 30 years of age; Middle: Between 30 and 50 years of age; Old: Above 51 years of age Income codes: Low: Up to Rs. 15000 (in 2013 this represented the lowest quintile). Medium: Rs. 15,001 to 30,000 (In 2013 this represented the 2nd and 3rd Quintile). High: More than 30,000 (In 2013 this represented the 4th and 5th Quintiles)) Location: Urban is defined as location defined as town or city in the census, constituting 49% of the population; Rural is defined as a population living in villages as in the latest census, consisting 51% of the population. Note: In some cases the totals may not add up to 100 or mismatch with earlier tables to the extent of 1%. Please ignore this, as it is due to round off error. Methodology: Sample Size: 855; Coverage: National/Rural and Urban/All four provinces; Mode: Face to face; Survey dates: Aug 26-Sept 02, 2013. Estimated error margin: +3-5% at 95% confidence level
Page 131 of 218
Best Performing Chief Minister (Sindh)

100% 90% 80% 70% 60% 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0% Shahbaz Sharif Qaim Ali Shah Parveiz Khatak Dr Abdul Malik All others\DK/NR 7% 6% 11% 38% 39%
Page 132 of 218
Table 65: Best Performing Chief Minister (Sindh)

Base: All Sindh
Shahbaz Sharif
Qaim Ali Shah 39 42 35 39 37 48 47 19 21 61 15
Pervez Khattak 7 6 7 5 8 8 6 8 9 6 7
Dr. Abdul Malik 6 8 4 6 6 9 5 11 4 7 5
38 37 39 43 35 31 34 46 50 21 56
All others\DK /NR 11 7 14 7 14 5 8 16 17 4 18
Page 133 of 218
Question: What is your opinion regarding the performance, in availability of education, of the Chief Minister and his government that has been established in Sindh after the latest election?
Bad, 34%

Page 134 of 218

Question: What is your opinion regarding the performance, in availability of education, of the Chief Minister and his government that has been established in Sindh after the latest election?
Dont Know
(1) 4 3 5 5 4 1 1 11 10 1 7
(2) 41 42 41 41 38 65 45 34 33 56 26
(3) 34 37 32 33 36 24 34 34 35 31 38
(4) 19 16 21 19 20 6 19 18 17 13 25
(5) 2 1 2 1 2 3 1 4 5 0 4
(6) = {(1)+(2)} {(3)+(4)} -8 -8 -7 -6 -14 35 -7 -7 -9 14 -29
Page 135 of 218
Question: What is your opinion regarding the performance, in availability of healthcare facilities, of the Chief Minister and his government that has been established in Sindh after the latest election?
DK/NR, 2%
Very Good, 1%
Very Bad, 25%
Good, 36%
Bad, 36%

Page 136 of 218

Question: What is your opinion regarding the performance, in availability of healthcare facilities, of the Chief Minister and his government that has been established in Sindh after the latest election?
Dont Know
(1) 1 1 1 1 1 1 0 3 5 0 3
(2) 36 39 33 32 36 57 39 29 32 47 24
(3) 36 33 39 40 35 23 35 42 36 32 41
(4) 25 24 25 25 26 9 25 23 22 20 29
(5) 2 2 1 1 1 11 1 3 5 1 3
(6) = {(1)+(2)} {(3)+(4)} -24 -18 -29 -31 -24 26 -21 -33 -21 -4 -44
Page 137 of 218

Question: What is your opinion regarding the performance, regarding garbage and its disposal, of the Chief Minister and his government that has been established in Sindh after the latest election?
DK/NR, 2%
Very Good, 1%
Very Bad, 31%
Good, 24%
Bad, 41%

Page 138 of 218

Question: What is your opinion regarding the performance, regarding garbage and its disposal, of the Chief Minister and his government that has been established in Sindh after the latest election?
Dont Know
(1) 1 1 0 1 1 1 0 3 2 0 2
(2) 24 28 21 19 25 52 29 16 14 39 9
(3) 41 36 46 49 38 24 40 45 44 41 41
(4) 31 32 31 30 35 13 30 33 36 19 44
(5) 2 3 2 1 2 11 1 3 4 1 3
(6) = {(1)+(2)} {(3)+(4)} -47 -38 -56 -58 -47 17 -41 -60 -64 -21 -75
Page 139 of 218

Question: What is your opinion regarding the performance, in availability of clean drinking water, of the Chief Minister and his government that has been established in Sindh after the latest election?
Very Bad, 34%
Good, 25%
Bad, 38%

Page 140 of 218

Question: What is your opinion regarding the performance, in availability of clean drinking water, of the Chief Minister and his government that has been established in Sindh after the latest election?
Dont Know
(1) 1 2 1 1 1 1 0 3 2 0 2
(2) 25 28 22 20 25 51 26 21 23 33 16
(3) 38 33 43 43 35 33 38 39 30 41 35
(4) 34 35 32 34 36 13 33 33 36 25 42
(5) 3 2 3 1 4 2 2 3 9 1 4
(6) = {(1)+(2)} {(3)+(4)} -46 -39 -52 -55 -45 6 -45 -48 -42 -34 -58
Page 141 of 218

Question: What is your opinion regarding the performance, relating to peace and crime, of the Chief Minister and his government that has been established in Sindh after the latest election?
Good, 24% Very Bad, 36%
Bad, 36%

Page 142 of 218

Question: What is your opinion regarding the performance, relating to peace and crime, of the Chief Minister and his government that has been established in Sindh after the latest election?
Dont Know
(1) 2 2 1 2 2 1 1 3 5 0 4
(2) 24 28 20 21 22 49 26 16 21 34 13
(3) 36 31 42 44 31 31 36 37 34 39 34
(4) 36 37 36 33 42 18 35 41 34 26 47
(5) 2 2 1 1 3 1 1 2 6 1 3
(6) = {(1)+(2)} {(3)+(4)} -46 -38 -56 -54 -49 1 -45 -58 -42 -32 -64
Page 143 of 218

Very Bad, 28%
Good, 26%
Bad, 38%

Page 144 of 218

Dont Know
(1) 4 2 7 5 4 0 5 3 1 6 2
(2) 26 33 20 21 27 56 31 17 13 43 9
(3) 38 35 40 45 34 27 37 40 40 35 41
(4) 28 26 30 27 31 12 25 34 40 16 41
(5) 3 3 3 1 4 5 2 6 5 0 6
(6) = {(1)+(2)} {(3)+(4)} -36 -27 -43 -46 -34 17 -26 -53 -66 -1 -71
Page 145 of 218

Question: Please tell us of your opinion regarding the elimination of nepotism (nepotism meaning that relatives and friends are given unwarranted monetary and social benefits) from government departments by your Provincial Government.
Good, 15%

Page 146 of 218

Question: Please tell us of your opinion regarding the elimination of nepotism (nepotism meaning that relatives and friends are given unwarranted monetary and social benefits) from government departments by your Provincial Government.
Dont Know
(1) 3 1 5 4 2 0 3 2 3 4 1
(2) 15 22 9 9 18 31 17 9 14 20 10
(3) 42 38 45 51 34 44 43 38 35 45 38
(4) 31 30 31 31 33 14 28 36 35 21 41
(5) 10 9 11 5 13 11 8 15 13 9 11
(6) = {(1)+(2)} {(3)+(4)} -55 -45 -63 -68 -47 -27 -52 -63 -54 -42 -67
Page 147 of 218
Hope in the Sindh Government

DK/NR, 1%
No difference , 43%
Decrease, 37%

Page 148 of 218
Table 73: Hope in the Sindh Government

recent election, some people believe that there is a greater hope that your province will now be able to overcome its problems and hardships; others think that your Provincial Government has not brought any change in your province s prospects while yet others think that the situation will become worse. What is your opinion?
Base: All Sindh Increase in your hope All Sindh Average Gender Male Female Respondent Age Young (Under 30) Middle (30 - 50) Old (50+) Household Income Low Medium High Location Rural Urban Decrease No Differenc e Dont Know
(1) 19 17 20 24 16 7 18 17 25 17 21
(2) 37 33 41 33 42 28 37 39 34 36 39
(3) 43 48 39 41 42 64 44 43 40 46 40
(4) 1 1 0 2 0 0 1 1 1 1 1
(5) = (1) -(2) -18 -16 -21 -9 -26 -21 -19 -21 -9 -19 -18
Page 149 of 218
Provincial Autonomy
Question: In your opinion, did your Provincial Government have more power and privileges before the new government came in; does it have more powers now, or has there been no change?
DK/NR, 1%
No difference , 44%
Had more power and authority before, 26%
Has more power and authority now, 28%

Page 150 of 218

Question: In your opinion, did your Provincial Government have more power and privileges before the new government came in; does it have more powers now, or has there been no change?
Base: All Sindh Had more power and authority before All Sindh Average Gender Male Female Respondent Age Young (Under 30) Middle (30 - 50) Old (50+) Household Income Low Medium High Location Rural Urban Has more power and authority now No differenc e
Dont Know
(1) 26 25 27 25 25 35 28 21 23 28 23
(2) 28 26 30 30 28 24 29 26 28 33 24
(3) 44 48 42 45 45 41 43 50 45 39 50
(4) 1 1 2 1 2 0 0 3 4 0 2
(5) = (2) -(1) 2 1 4 5 3 -11 2 4 5 4 1
Page 151 of 218
Public Verdict on Performance of the Provincial Government of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa
Page 152 of 218
Performance of Chief Minister KP

Question: What is your opinion on the performance of the Chief Minister of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa?
Very Bad, 6%
DK/NR, 2%
Good, 36%

Page 153 of 218
Table 75: Performance of Chief Minister KP

Question: What is your opinion on the performance of the Chief Minister of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa?
Base: All KP Very Good Good Bad Very Bad
Dont Know
(1)
All KP Average Gender Male Female Respondent Age Young (Under 30) Middle (30 - 50) Old (50+) Household Income Low Medium High Location Rural Urban
(2) 36 36 36 32 38 32 34 42 28 36 37
(3) 30 33 27 30 33 38 32 24 45 32 25
(4) 6 4 9 7 5 10 7 4 2 4 14
(5) 2 1 2 0 3 1 2 1 2 1 4
26 27 25 31 22 19 25 29 23 28 19
(6) = {(1)+(2)} {(3)+(4)} 26 26 25 26 21 3 19 43 3 28 17
Notes: Age: Young: Under 30 years of age; Middle: Between 30 and 50 years of age; Old: Above 51 years of age Income codes: Low: Up to Rs. 15000 (in 2013 this represented the lowest quintile). Medium: Rs. 15,001 to 30,000 (In 2013 this represented the 2nd and 3rd Quintile). High: More than 30,000 (In 2013 this represented the 4th and 5th Quintiles)) Location: Urban is defined as location defined as town or city in the census, constituting 17% of the population; Rural is defined as a population living in villages as in the latest census, consisting 83% of the population. Note: In some cases the totals may not add up to 100 or mismatch with earlier tables to the extent of 1%. Please ignore this, as it is due to round off error. Methodology: Sample Size: 656; Coverage: National/Rural and Urban/All four provinces; Mode: Face to face; Survey dates: Aug 26 - Sep 02, 2013. Estimated error margin: +3-5% at 95% confidence level
Page 154 of 218
Best Performing Chief Minister (KP)

100% 90% 80% 70% 60% 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 10% 0% Shahbaz Sharif Qaim Ali Shah Parveiz Khatak
29%
34% 26%
1% Dr Abdul Malik All others/DK/NR
Page 155 of 218
Table 76: Best Performing Chief Minister (KP)

Question: In your opinion, out of the countrys four Chief Ministers, wh ich one has been the most successful? And it can be from your own province or from any other.
Base: All KP Shahbaz Sharif All KP Average Gender Male Female Respondent Age Young (Under 30) Middle (30 - 50) Old (50+) Household Income Low Medium High Location Rural Urban Qaim Ali Shah Pervez Khattak
Dr. Abdul Malik
All others\DK/ NR
29 24 38 25 32 13 30 30 27 27 42
26 25 26 26 30 14 28 20 33 27 22
34 40 22 39 28 36 30 39 32 36 22
1 1 2 0 2 5 2 1 0 1 1
10 9 12 10 9 31 10 10 8 9 14
Notes: Age: Young: Under 30 years of age; Middle: Between 30 and 50 years of age; Old: Above 51 years of age Income codes: Low: Up to Rs. 15000 (in 2013 this represented the lowest quintile). Medium: Rs. 15,001 to 30,000 (In 2013 this represented the 2nd and 3rd Quintile). High: More than 30,000 (In 2013 this represented the 4th and 5th Quintiles)) Location: Urban is defined as location defined as town or city in the census, constituting 17% of the population; Rural is defined as a population living in villages as in the latest census, consisting 83% of the population. Note: In some cases the totals may not add up to 100 or mismatch with earlier tables to the extent of 1%. Please ignore this, as it is due to round off error. Methodology: Sample Size: 656; Coverage: National/Rural and Urban/All four provinces; Mode: Face to face; Survey dates: Aug 26 - Sep 02, 2013. Estimated error margin: +3-5% at 95% confidence level l
Page 156 of 218
Question: What is your opinion regarding the performance, in availability of education, of the Chief Minister and his government that has been established in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa after the latest election?
DK/NR, 1%
Very Good, 38%
Good, 42%

Page 157 of 218

Question: What is your opinion regarding the performance, in availability of education, of the Chief Minister and his government that has been established in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa after the latest election?
Dont Know
(1)
(2) 42 41 43 46 41 43 47 39 26 43 35
(3) 15 15 17 16 15 33 16 15 12 14 23
(4) 3 4 2 3 4 1 2 5 1 3 3
(5) 1 1 0 1 0 4 1 1 2 0 2
38 39 38 35 39 19 34 39 59 39 36
(6) = {(1)+(2)} {(3)+(4)} 62 62 63 62 61 28 63 58 71 65 45
Page 158 of 218

Question: What is your opinion regarding the performance, in availability of healthcare facilities, of the Chief Minister and his government that has been established in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa after the latest election?
Very Bad, 4%
DK/NR, 1%
Good, 60%

Page 159 of 218

Question: What is your opinion regarding the performance, in availability of healthcare facilities, of the Chief Minister and his government that has been established in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa after the latest election?
Dont Know
(1)
(2) 60 61 58 60 59 62 61 57 68 62 52
(3) 23 22 23 21 23 26 22 23 24 21 28
(4) 4 4 5 5 5 1 3 7 1 4 6
(5) 1 1 1 1 1 0 1 0 1 0 2
12 11 14 13 13 11 14 13 5 12 13
(6) = {(1)+(2)} {(3)+(4)} 45 46 45 47 44 46 49 40 48 49 31
Page 160 of 218

Question: What is your opinion regarding the performance, regarding garbage and its disposal, of the Chief Minister and his government that has been established in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa after the last election?
Very Bad, 7%
DK/NR, 1%
Very Good, 13%
Bad, 40% Good, 39%

Source: Gallup and Gilani Surveys the Pakistani affiliate of Gallup International Association (www.gallup-international.com; www.gallup.com.pk, www.gilanifoundation.com)
Page 161 of 218

Question: What is your opinion regarding the performance, regarding garbage and its disposal, of the Chief Minister and his government that has been established in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa after the last election?
Dont Know
(1)
(2) 39 37 42 41 38 25 39 42 29 41 31
(3) 40 45 32 40 41 58 42 34 49 41 36
(4) 7 5 10 5 9 9 7 7 5 6 12
(5) 1 1 2 1 1 4 1 2 1 1 3
13 12 14 13 11 4 12 14 16 12 18
(6) = {(1)+(2)} {(3)+(4)} 5 0 14 9 0 -38 2 15 -9 6 0
Page 162 of 218

Question: What is your opinion regarding the performance, in availability of clean drinking water, of the Chief Minister and his government that has been established in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa after the last election?
Very Bad, 7%
Bad, 29% Good, 51%

Page 163 of 218

Question: What is your opinion regarding the performance, in availability of clean drinking water, of the Chief Minister and his government that has been established in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa after the last election?
Dont Know
(1)
(2) 51 53 49 55 51 46 52 49 53 54 36
(3) 29 26 32 30 31 21 31 28 20 28 32
(4) 7 8 7 6 8 14 5 10 7 5 19
(5) 2 2 4 2 2 9 3 3 1 2 3
10 12 8 7 8 10 9 10 18 10 11
(6) = {(1)+(2)} {(3)+(4)} 25 30 18 26 20 22 25 21 44 32 -4
Page 164 of 218

Question: What is your opinion regarding the performance, relating to peace and crime, of the Chief Minister and his government that has been established in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa after the last election?
DK/NR, 2% Very Bad, 9%
Very Good, 17%
Bad, 36% Good, 36%

Page 165 of 218

Question: What is your opinion regarding the performance, relating to peace and crime, of the Chief Minister and his government that has been established in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa after the last election?
Dont Know
(1)
(2) 36 36 35 39 31 30 37 32 44 38 25
(3) 36 33 41 33 41 39 39 38 13 33 48
(4) 9 10 8 10 9 18 7 14 6 8 16
(5) 2 1 3 2 2 5 2 1 3 2 3
17 19 12 16 17 7 15 14 34 18 9
(6) = {(1)+(2)} {(3)+(4)} 8 13 -2 12 -1 -20 6 -5 59 15 -30
Page 166 of 218

Question: Please tell us of your opinion regarding the elimination of corruption from governmental departments by Khyber Pakhtunkhwas government.
Very Bad, 7%
DK/NR, 3%
Very Good, 18%
Bad, 36% Good, 36%

Page 167 of 218

Question: Please tell us of your opinion regarding the elimination of corruption from governmental departments by your Khyber Pakhtunkhwas government.
Dont Know
(1)
(2) 36 35 38 33 38 38 39 32 39 37 33
(3) 36 38 34 45 33 32 34 39 33 37 34
(4) 7 6 9 7 8 6 7 8 5 5 19
(5) 3 3 2 3 3 5 3 2 4 2 6
18 18 18 12 18 19 17 19 20 20 8
(6) = {(1)+(2)} {(3)+(4)} 11 9 14 -8 15 19 15 4 21 15 -12
Page 168 of 218

Question: Please tell us of your opinion regarding the elimination of nepotism (nepotism meaning that relatives and friends are given unwarranted monetary and social benefits) from governmental departments by Khyber Pakhtunkhwas government.
DK/NR, 4% Very Bad, 10% Very Good, 12%
Good, 34% Bad, 40%

Page 169 of 218

Question: Please tell us of your opinion regarding the elimination of nepotism (nepotism meaning that relatives and friends are given unwarranted monetary and social benefits) from governmental departments by Khyber Pakhtunkhwas government.
Dont Know
(1)
(2) 34 34 34 28 37 44 37 31 28 35 29
(3) 40 40 40 47 39 31 40 42 33 42 30
(4) 10 9 11 11 9 18 11 9 3 6 27
(5) 4 5 4 4 5 6 5 4 5 4 8
12 13 11 9 11 0 7 14 31 13 6
(6) = {(1)+(2)} {(3)+(4)} -4 -2 -7 -21 -1 -6 -6 -7 23 0 -21
Page 170 of 218
Hope in the KP Government

Question: After the election of officials in the previous elections, some people are confident that their province will now be able to overcome its problems and hardships, whereas others think that the change in government has not changed their opinion and still others think that the situation will become worse. What is your opinion?
DK/NR, 3% No difference , 15%
Decrease, 47%

Page 171 of 218
Table 84: Hope in the KP Government

Question: After the election of the nominated officials in the previous elections, some people are of the opinion that they were confident that their province will now be able to overcome its problems and hardships, whereas others thought that the change in government has not changed their opinion and still others thought that the situation will become worse. What is your opinion?
Base: All KP Increase in your hope All KP Average Gender Male Female Respondent Age Young (Under 30) Middle (30 - 50) Old (50+) Household Income Low Medium High Location Rural Urban Decrease No differenc e Dont Know
(1) 36 36 36 29 40 35 35 37 36 37 32
(2) 47 46 47 57 41 34 48 41 54 46 50
(3) 15 17 12 12 17 15 14 19 9 15 15
(4) 3 1 5 2 2 15 3 3 1 3 3
(5) = (1) -(2) -11 -11 -10 -28 -1 1 -13 -3 -19 -9 -17
Page 172 of 218
Provincial Autonomy
Question: In your opinion, did your provincial government have more power and privileges before the new government came, now, or has there been no change?
DK/NR, 4%
No difference , 20%
Has more power and authority now, 35%

Page 173 of 218

Question: In your opinion, did your provincial government have more power and privileges before the new government came, now, or has there been no change?
Base: All KP Had more power and authority before All KP Average Gender Male Female Respondent Age Young (Under 30) Middle (30 - 50) Old (50+) Household Income Low Medium High Location Rural Urban Has more power and authority now No differenc e Dont know
(1) 41 42 39 36 42 38 45 35 44 40 46
(2) 35 34 37 37 34 34 35 35 30 36 28
(3) 20 21 19 21 21 28 15 27 23 20 23
(4) 4 4 5 7 4 0 5 3 2 5 4
(5) = (2) -(1) -6 -8 -2 1 -8 -4 -9 1 -14 -4 -17
Page 174 of 218
Public Verdict on Performance of the Provincial Government of Balochistan
Page 175 of 218
Performance of Chief Minister Balochistan

Question: What is your opinion on the performance of the Chief Minister of Balochistan?
DK/NR, 2%
Very Bad, 15%
Very Good, 17%
Bad, 26% Good, 41%

Page 176 of 218
Table 86: Performance of Chief Minister Balochistan

Question: What is your opinion on the performance of the Chief Minister of Balochistan?
Base: All Balochistan Very Good Good Bad Very Bad Fig are Row Percentage Net Performance DK/NR Index (6) = {(1)+(2)} (5) {(3)+(4)}
(1)
All Balochistan Average Gender Male Female Respondent Age Young Middle Old Household Income Low Medium High Location Rural Urban
(2) 41 42 39 36 43 54 65 34 33 42 37
(3) 26 18 35 27 24 24 18 23 33 24 29
(4) 15 14 17 17 15 10 12 16 17 12 24
17 23 8 18 17 9 5 24 16 19 9
2 3 1 2 2 4 1 3 1 2 1
17 33 -5 11 21 29 39 19 0 24 -8
Notes: Age: Young: Under 30 years of age; Middle: Between 30 and 50 years of age; Old: Above 51 years of age Income codes: Low: Up to Rs.15,000 (in 2013 this represented the lowest quintile). Medium: Rs. 15,000 to 30,000 (In 2013 this represented the 2nd and 3rd Quintile). High: More than 30,000 (In 2013 this represented the 4th and 5th Quintiles) Location: Urban is defined as location defined as town or city in the census, the total in Balochistan constituting 24% of the population; Rural is defined as a population living in villages as in the latest census, consisting 76% of the population. Note: In some cases the totals may not add up to 100 or mismatch with earlier tables to the extent of 1%. Please ignore this, as it is due to round off error. Methodology: Sample Size: 687; Coverage: National/Rural and Urban/All four provinces; Mode: Face to face; Survey dates: Aug 26 - Sep 02 2013. Estimated error margin: +3-5% at 95% confidence level
Page 177 of 218
Best Performing Chief Minister (Balochistan)

100% 90% 80% 70% 60% 50% 40% 40% 31% 30% 20% 10% 0% Shahbaz Sharif Qaim Ali Shah Parveiz Khatak Dr Abdul Malik All others\DK/NR 17% 8% 5%
Page 178 of 218
Table 87: Best Performing Chief Minister (Balochistan)

Base: All Balochistan Shahbaz Sharif All Balochistan Average Gender Male Female Respondent Age Young Middle Old Household Income Low Medium High Location Rural Urban Qaim Ali Shah Pervez Khattak Fig are Row Percentage Dr Abdul Malik All others\DK/NR
40 43 36 39 41 40 20 43 50 39 44
17 8 28 18 16 9 7 14 26 15 22
8 8 8 7 9 6 5 10 7 7 11
31 35 25 30 28 45 62 27 14 33 21
5 6 2 5 5 0 6 6 3 5 2
Page 179 of 218
Question: What is your opinion regarding the performance, in availability of education, of the Chief Minister and his government that has been established in Balochistan after the last election?
Very Bad, 18%
Good, 34%
Bad, 37%

Page 180 of 218

Question: What is your opinion regarding the performance, in availability of education, of the Chief Minister and his government that has been established in Balochistan after the last election?
Base: All Balochistan Very Good Good Bad Very Bad Fig are Row Percentage Net Performance DK/NR Index
(1)
(2) 34 46 18 30 38 36 37 40 25 36 26
(3) 37 38 37 39 35 36 37 37 38 35 44
(4) 18 7 34 21 16 16 10 14 29 18 19
(5) 2 3 0 3 1 0 2 3 1 2 0
9 6 11 7 10 13 14 6 8 8 10
(6) = {(1)+(2)} {(3)+(4)} -12 7 -42 -23 -4 -3 2 -5 -34 -9 -27
Page 181 of 218
Question: What is your opinion regarding the performance, in availability of healthcare facilities, of the Chief Minister and his government that has been established in Balochistan after the last election?
DK/NR, 5%
Very Good, 6%
Very Bad, 21%
Good, 25%
Bad, 43%

Page 182 of 218

Question: What is your opinion regarding the performance, in availability of healthcare facilities, of the Chief Minister and his government that has been established in Balochistan after the last election?
(1)
(2) 25 24 25 20 30 27 28 26 21 23 32
(3) 43 41 44 43 45 30 34 47 44 42 43
(4) 21 19 24 23 16 34 25 17 22 21 22
(5) 5 9 0 8 3 0 2 5 7 6 1
6 7 6 7 5 9 11 5 5 8 2
(6) = {(1)+(2)} {(3)+(4)} -33 -29 -36 -39 -26 -28 -20 -33 -40 -33 -31
Page 183 of 218

Question: What is your opinion regarding the performance, regarding garbage and its disposal, of the Chief Minister and his government that has been established in Balochistan after the last election?
DK/NR, 4%
Very Good, 14% Very Bad, 23% Good, 32% Bad, 27%

Page 184 of 218

Question: What is your opinion regarding the performance, regarding garbage and its disposal, of the Chief Minister and his government that has been established in Balochistan after the last election?
(1)
(2) 32 20 47 30 32 42 37 27 34 32 30
(3) 27 36 14 25 29 25 32 28 22 26 31
(4) 23 31 12 22 24 16 17 29 19 24 19
(5) 4 7 1 7 2 4 6 5 3 5 2
14 5 27 16 13 14 8 11 22 13 18
(6) = {(1)+(2)} {(3)+(4)} -4 -42 48 -2 -9 14 -4 -19 14 -4 -1
Page 185 of 218

Question: What is your opinion regarding the performance, in availability of clean drinking water, of the Chief Minister and his government that has been established in Balochistan after the last election?
Very Bad, 16%
Bad, 28%
Good, 39%

Page 186 of 218

Question: What is your opinion regarding the performance, in availability of clean drinking water, of the Chief Minister and his government that has been established in Balochistan after the last election?
(1)
(2) 39 32 48 38 39 40 33 37 44 40 33
(3) 28 38 15 26 32 21 33 34 18 27 31
(4) 16 19 13 18 14 21 27 12 14 14 24
(5) 4 6 1 4 4 2 1 6 3 5 1
13 5 24 15 10 15 5 11 20 14 11
(6) = {(1)+(2)} {(3)+(4)} 8 -20 45 9 3 13 -21 2 32 13 -11
Page 187 of 218

Question: What is your opinion regarding the performance, relating to peace and crime, of the Chief Minister and his government that has been established in Balochistan after the last election?
DK/NR, 4%
Very Good, 6%
Bad, 30%

Page 188 of 218

Question: What is your opinion regarding the performance, relating to peace and crime, of the Chief Minister and his government that has been established in Balochistan after the last election?
(1)
(2) 36 25 51 41 29 36 34 30 43 38 28
(3) 30 33 25 25 34 32 30 33 26 26 44
(4) 24 32 13 21 26 28 28 28 17 25 20
(5) 4 5 3 5 4 2 4 5 3 4 6
6 5 8 7 6 2 4 4 10 8 2
(6) = {(1)+(2)} {(3)+(4)} -12 -35 21 2 -25 -21 -21 -27 11 -5 -34
Page 189 of 218

Question: Please tell us of your opinion regarding the elimination of corruption from governmental departments by your provincial government?
DK/NR, 3%
Very Good, 8%
Bad, 43%

Page 190 of 218

Question: Please tell us of your opinion regarding the elimination of corruption from governmental departments by your provincial government?
(1)
(2) 31 36 23 26 34 39 33 34 26 32 28
(3) 43 34 56 48 40 35 27 42 55 43 44
(4) 15 13 17 17 12 17 34 9 9 13 22
(5) 3 4 1 3 3 4 4 4 2 4 2
8 13 2 7 10 5 3 11 8 9 5
(6) = {(1)+(2)} {(3)+(4)} -19 2 -48 -31 -8 -8 -26 -5 -31 -15 -33
Page 191 of 218

Question: Please tell us of your opinion regarding the elimination of nepotism (nepotism meaning that relatives and friends are given unwarranted monetary and social benefits) from governmental departments by your provincial government.
Very Bad, 20%
Good, 39%
Bad, 27%

Page 192 of 218

Question: Please tell us of your opinion regarding the elimination of nepotism (nepotism meaning that relatives and friends are given unwarranted monetary and social benefits) from governmental departments by your provincial government.
(1)
(2) 39 34 47 35 40 54 58 37 30 40 35
(3) 27 25 28 29 25 20 18 30 29 24 36
(4) 20 21 19 20 20 20 14 18 26 20 19
(5) 10 16 3 12 10 5 8 11 11 12 6
4 4 3 3 5 1 2 4 4 4 4
(6) = {(1)+(2)} {(3)+(4)} -4 -8 2 -12 1 15 27 -7 -21 0 -16
Page 193 of 218
Hope in the Balochistan Government

Question: After the formation of your Provincial Government through the recent election,
some people believe that there is a greater hope that your province will now be able to overcome its problems and hardships; others think that your Provincial Government has not brought any change in your provinces prospects while yet others think that the situat ion will become worse. What is your opinion?
DK/NR, 3%
No difference , 18%
Decrease, 23%

Page 194 of 218
Table 95: Hope in the Balochistan Government

Base: All Balochistan Increase in your hope Decrease No Difference Fig are Row Percentage Net Performance DK/NR Index
(1)
(2) 23 21 27 26 20 23 34 23 17 19 36
(3) 18 18 17 16 19 21 24 14 17 18 14
(4) 3 4 1 2 4 5 4 4 1 4 1
(5) = (1) -(2) 33 36 27 29 38 28 3 36 48 39 12
56 57 54 56 57 51 37 59 65 58 48
Page 195 of 218
Provincial Autonomy
Question: In your opinion, did your provincial government have more power and privileges before the new government came in, it has more powers now, or has there been no change?
DK/NR, 2%
No difference , 35% Has more power and authority now, 45%

Page 196 of 218

Question: In your opinion, did your provincial government have more power and privileges before the new government came; it has more powers now, or has there been no change?
Base: All Balochistan Had More Power Before Has More Power Now No Difference Fig are Row Percentage Net Performance DK/NR Index
(1)
(2) 45 40 52 42 48 46 35 44 53 45 44
(3) 35 40 27 38 30 40 46 34 27 37 25
(4) 2 3 1 3 1 2 3 2 1 2 1
(5) = (2) -(1) 27 23 31 25 26 34 20 24 34 30 14
18 17 21 17 21 12 16 20 19 15 30
Page 197 of 218
Appendix A Research Methodology
Page 198 of 218
Research Methodology A- Sample Size And Distribution

Table 1 Un-weighted Sample Size All Pakistan Provincial Distribution 3568 UN-WEIGHTED COUNTS SHOW SIZE OF SAMPLE FOR EACH PROVINCIAL REPORT 1370 855 656 687 Table 2 Weighted Sample (% share in total) WEIGHTED SHARES ARE APPLICABLE FOR COMPUTING ALL PAKISTAN PERCENTAGES 58% 24% 14% 5% Percent share of VARIOUS DEMOGRAPHIC GROUPS In the weighted sample
Punjab Sindh KPK Baluchistan
Provincial Distribution Punjab Sindh KPK Baluchistan
Page 199 of 218
Table 3 Weighted Sample (% share in total) Age Distribution Young Middle Old HH-income Distribution Low Middle High Education Distribution Low Middle High Location Distribution Rural Urban Notes: Age: Young: Under 30 years of age; Middle: Between 30 and 50 years of age; Old: Above 51 years of age Income codes: Low: Up to Rs.15,000 (in 2013 this represented the lowest two quintiles). Medium: Rs. 15,000 to 30,000 (In 2013 this represented the 3rd Quintile). High: More than 30,000 (In 2013 this represented the 4th and 5th Quintiles) Location: Urban is defined as location defined as town or city in the census, the total in Pakistan constituting 33% of the population; Rural is defined as a population living in villages as in the latest census, 67% of the population. Note: In some cases the totals may not add up to 100 or mismatch with earlier tables to the extent of 1%. Please ignore this, as it is due to round off error. Methodology: Sample Size: 1370; Coverage: National/Rural and Urban/All four provinces; Mode: Face to face; Survey dates: Aug 26 - Sep 02 2013. Estimated error margin: +3-5% at 95% confidence level 40% 55% 5% 66% 23% 10% 36% 40% 25% 67% 33%
B- Sample Selection Procedure

This survey uses stratified random sampling. Following steps have been used to achieve this: Stage 1: Stratification: Stratification is principally at two levels: a. The First stratification is by PROVINCE, of which there are 4 in Pakistan.
Page 200 of 218
b.
The Second stratification is by size of location. We stratify by 4 types of locations: Large/Metropolitan Cities (there are 3); Medium size (those whom population is over 100,000 persons); Towns (those whom population is less than 100,000) and Villages (those declared as such in the Census).
Stage 2: Selection of Communities: Within each stratum communities are selected through a random process. In some cases we make replacements by communities of similar profile with a view to logistical and other considerations.
C- Fieldwork Procedure
Briefing/Training of interviewers: The Questionnaire Designed for the survey is briefed to the interviewers at Regional Centres across the Centre. The interviewers are instructed on measures such as: 1. Following Sampling/Quota Instructions Properly 2. Ethical Code of Conduct towards interviewers 3. Following skipping Instructions and other interview instructions on the Questionnaire 4. Maintaining Neutrality in asking Question Mock Calls: After the briefing is completed all the field workers do the mock calls under the direct supervision of an executive or a fieldwork supervisor. This ensures that the field workers properly understand the instructions and they can handle various interviewing problems during the interview (in the field). After completion of mock calls, a debriefing session is arranged in which the problems faced by the interviewers during the mock interviews are discussed and solutions are suggested. Initial Checking: After the training, the interviewers go into the field for actual interviewing. The first ten filled in questionnaires of every interviewer are thoroughly checked by their supervisor to ensure that the interviewer is performing well. In case the work of an interviewer is not acceptable he/she is disengaged from the survey. Field Editor or Intake Edit: In normal routine at least 30-40 interviews of each interviewer are visually checked by the supervisor before passing them to Data Coding/Entry department. The problems or missing information identified during field edit are explained to the relevant interviewer and he/she is instructed to rectify them either through telephone and/or revisit the respondent for clarification and re-asking the missing questions. Supervision & Back Checking:
Page 201 of 218
It is essential that the interviewers are properly supervised on the job and the work done by them is back checked. At least 20% back checking is done on work completed by each interviewer to ensure authenticity of data. Data Coding/Editing: About 20% work of each coder is rechecked and verified by the concerned DC Supervisor/In-charge.
Page 202 of 218
D- Data Entry and Verification

GPs Quality Manual contains a detailed check-list on the handling control, entry and other steps involved in the management of data. Once the questionnaires are received from the field, they are checked and the responses of open-ended questions are coded with the help of a code list. A coding scheme/book/guide is prepared on the basis of these questionnaires. After the coding of open-ended responses, data is entered into computers. GP uses the SPSS data entry program that has flexibility to implement validity checks and skipping rules etc. The SPSS data entry software also has flexibility to verify the entered data by using the double punch options. Gallup normally double punches for 20% of its entered data. After completion of data entries and double punch, all data is cleaned by using a datacleaning program written in SPSS which is customized for every project according to the survey/questionnaire needs. Data is thoroughly checked for an omission, displacements and other error resulting in inconsistencies with the coding scheme.
Page 203 of 218
Appendix B Questionnaire
Page 204 of 218
erio noUtsdu udrU

.Q1a ( ) 1 2 3 4
.Q1b 1 2 3 4
.Q1c 1 2 3 4
.Q2 ( ) 1 2 3 4 .Q3 1 2
3 4
Q4 1 2 3 4 .Q5 1 2 3 4 .Q6 ) (2013 1 2 3 4
.Q7 ( ) 1 2 3 4 5
.Q8 1 2 3 4
.Q9 ) ) 1 2 3 4 .Q10 1 2 3 4 .Q11 1 2 3 4 Q12 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 5 -Q13
-Q14 1 2
3 4 5
-Q15 1 2 3 4 5 -Q16 1 2 3 4 5
-Q17 1 2 3 4 5
-Q18
1 2 3 4 5
-Q19
1 2 3 4 5
-Q20
1 2 3 5 1 2 3 4 5 -Q21
1 2 3 4 5
-Q22
1 2 3 4 5
-Q23
1 2 3 4 5
-Q24
( )
-Q25
( ) 1 2 3 4 5 -Q26
5 5 5 5 5 4 4 4 4 4 3 3 3 3 3 2 2 2 2 2 ( ) 1 A 1 B 1 C 1 D 1 E
.Q27a ( / )
5 5
4 4
3 3
2 2
1 1
a b
.Q27b ( / ) 1 1 3 3 2 2
5 5
4 4
a b
English Questionnaire
Q1a. In your opinion, since the arrival of the new Government, have people got better opportunities to democratically govern themselves; have these opportunities deteriorated or has there been no change? 1. 2. 3. 4. Improved Deteriorated No Difference Dont know
Q1b. After the formation of Prime Minister Nawaz Sharifs Government, some people believe that there is a greater hope that Pakistan will now be able to overcome its problems and hardships; others think that Nawaz Sharifs Government has not brought any change in Pakistans prospects while yet others think that the situation will become worse. What is your opinion? 1. 2. 3. 4. Increase in your hope Decrease No difference Dont know
Q1c. After the formation of your Provincial Government through the recent election, some people believe that there is a greater hope that your province will now be able to overcome its problems and hardships; others think that your Provincial Government has not brought any change in your provinces prospects while yet others think that the situation will become worse. What is your opinion? 1. 2. 3. 4. Increase in your hope Decrease No difference Dont know
Q2. In your opinion has the National Assembly become more powerful after the new Government came to power; has it become less powerful or has there been no change? 1. 2. 3. 4. More powerful Less powerful No Difference Dont know
Q3. In your opinion, do the new Prime Minister and his ministers, in comparison with the previous Governments, have more authority in matters relating to the country, less authority or has there been no change? 1. 2. 3. 4. Have more authority Have less authority now No difference Dont know
Q4. In your opinion, did the countrys administration meaning Civil Officers and bureaucracy, etc., follow the rules and regulations more before, do they do it more now or has there been no difference? 1. 2. 3. 4. Used to abide by the rules more during previous administrations Are more law-abiding now No difference Dont know
Q5. In your opinion, did the military and military commanders consider themselves more subordinate to the Parliament before the new Government took charge or after, or has there been no difference? 1. Used to consider themselves more subordinate than before the new Government 2. Think of themselves as more subordinates today 3. No difference 4. Dont know Q6. Compared with the previous election held 5 year ago, in your opinion was 2013 election, held in a more transparent and fair manner or in a less transparent and fair manner? 1. 2. 3. 4. 2013 Election was held in a fairer manner than 5 year ago Was held in a less transparent and fair manner than previous election No difference Dont know / No Response
Q7. How much do you trust your political party? (That is in its ability to be honest and its ability to run the Government). 1. 2. 3. 4. Very much Somewhat Little Very Little
5. Dont know Q8. In your opinion, was the Supreme Court more powerful before the new Government took charge; is it more powerful now or has there been no change? 1. 2. 3. 4. More powerful before the new government More powerful now No difference Dont know
Q9. In your opinion, did your Provincial Government have more power and privileges before the new Government came to power, is it more powerful now, or has there been no change? 1. 2. 3. 4. Had more power before Has more power now No difference Dont know
Q10. In your opinion, was there greater respect for human rights in public before the arrival of the new Government; is it greater now or has there been no difference? 1. 2. 3. 4. More respect before More respect now No difference Dont know
Q11. In your opinion, was the Pakistani media, that is television, radio and newspapers, freer from the Governmental influence before the arrival of the new Government; is it freer now, or has there been no difference? 1. 2. 3. 4. More free before More free now No difference Dont know
Q12. In your opinion, was there a greater pressure of foreign powers on such as the USA and the World Bank, etc., before the new Government came to power; is it greater now, or has there been no difference? 1. 2. 3. 4. More pressure before More pressure now No difference Dont know
Q13. What is your opinion on the overall performance of Prime Minister Muhammad Nawaz Sharif as of now? 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Very good Good Bad Very bad Dont know
Q14. While considering the various aspects of running the government, what do you think about the efforts made by Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif so far? Very Good A B C D E F In eliminating load-shedding In eliminating terrorism In improving international ties with countries like America, China and India In improving the internal issues such as unity and cordial relations between provinces In improving ties with opposition leaders and parties Improving relations with other institutions like the army Good Bad Very Bad Dont Know
Q15. Some people are of the opinion that the Ministers appointed by the Prime Minister in the Federal Cabinet are a good selection, while others think of these as a bad choice. What is your opinion? 1. 2. 3. 4. Good selection Bad selection Merely Fine Dont know
Q16. What is your opinion on the performance of the Chief Ministers of Punjab, Sindh, Balochistan and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa? (Rotate the sequence) Rotate A B C D Chief Minister Punjab Chief Minister Sindh Chief Minister Baluchistan Chief Minister Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Very Good Good Bad Very Bad Dont Know
Q17. (Look at the Circular Card) In your opinion, out of the countrys four Ch ief Ministers, which one has been the most successful? (Give one answer) And it can be from your own province or from any other. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Shahbaz Sharif Qaim Ali Shah Pervez Khattak Dr. Abdul Malik Dont know
Q18. Please tell us your considered opinion regarding the performance of your Provincial Chief Minister and Government, formed through the latest Election, in various aspects of life? Very Good A B C D E Availability of education Availability of healthcare facilities Regarding garbage and its disposal Availability of clean drinking water Relating to peace and crime Good Bad
Very Bad
Dont Know
Q19a. Please tell us your opinion regarding the elimination of corruption and nepotism (nepotism meaning that relatives and friends are given unwarranted monetary and social benefits) from government departments by Prime Minister Nawaz Sharifs government. Very Good 19a1 19a2 In the elimination of corruption In the elimination of nepotism Good Bad Very Bad Dont Know
Q19b. Please tell us of your opinion regarding the elimination of corruption and nepotism (nepotism meaning that relatives and friends are given unwarranted monetary and social benefits) from government departments by your Provincial Government. Very Good 19b1 19b2 In the elimination of corruption In the elimination of nepotism Good Bad Very Bad Dont Know
Pakistan Institute of Legislative Development And Transparency - PILDAT Islamabad Office: No. 7, 9th Avenue, F-8/1, Islamabad, Pakistan Tel: (+92-51) 111 123 345 | Fax: (+92-51) 226 3078 Lahore Office: 45-A, 2nd Floor, Sector XX, Phase III, Khayaban-e-Iqbal, DHA, Lahore, Pakistan Tel: (+92-42) 111 123 345 | Fax: (+92-42) 3569 3896 Web: http://www.pildat.org Follow Us on

PILDAT Nationwide Poll On 100 Days - Report - September2013 PDF

Enviado por

Dados do documento

Título original

Direitos autorais

Formatos disponíveis

Compartilhar este documento

Compartilhar ou incorporar documento

Opções de compartilhamento

Você considera este documento útil?

Este conteúdo é inapropriado?

Direitos autorais:

Formatos disponíveis

PILDAT Nationwide Poll On 100 Days - Report - September2013 PDF

Enviado por

Direitos autorais:

Formatos disponíveis

WWW.PILDAT.

Part 3: Public Verdict on Performance of Provincial Governments in First 100 Days

Very bad, 10%

Good, 44% DK/NR, 6% Very good, 18%

Positive Rating = 62% Negative Rating = 32% Net Performance Rating = 30 %

Very Bad, 15%

Very Good, 19%

Very Good, 19%

Very Bad, 12% Bad, 29%

Very Bad, 19% Good, 41% Bad, 34%

Very Good 38%

Very Bad 25%

Very Bad 21%

Very Bad, 31% Good, 50%

Good, 24% Bad, 40% Good, 39%

Very Bad, 23%

Good, 25% Bad, 38%

Bad, 29% Good, 51% Bad, 28% Good, 39%

Very Bad, 36% Bad, 29% Good, 49%

Good, 24% Bad, 36% Bad, 36%

Safeguarding National Sovereignty

Table 2: Popular Verdict on the Performance of Provincial Governments

Among All (Party Loyals and Others) 30 -73 -2 26 17

-16 -1 -5 -25 -25 -43 -32 -2

20 28 20 Nil -48 -23 -47 17

Table 7: NPR-Index of Federal Government Across Gender All 30 26 24 24 19 13 13 6 -3 -5 Male 29 24 22 20 15 13 17 8 -1 -3 Female 30 28 22 28 23 14 10 3 -6 -6

Table 9: NPR-Index of Federal Government Across Education Groups

Overall Performance Rating

Very bad, 10%

Good, 44% DK/NR, 6% Very good, 18%

Net Performance Rating = 30

Very Good (1)

Very Bad (4) 10 13 8 10 11 7 11 10 6 6 21 12 12 11 10 3 16 21 13

Dont Know (5) 6 5 7 6 6 2 6 5 7 9 2 2 4 6 7 6 3 2 9

Net Performanc e Index (6) = (1+2) (3+4) 30 29 30 26 31 30 31 26 23 55 -12 -5 22 36 17 74 -10 4 1

Very Bad, 15%

Very Good, 19%

Net Performance Rating = 6

Very Good (1)

Very Bad (4) 15 13 18 13 17 16 13 17 22 14 10 28 5 37 11 23 5 12 22 26

Dont Know (5) 2 2 2 1 2 2 2 1 2 0 3 0 2 1 2 2 0 1 1 5

Performance on Eliminating Terrorism

Net Performance Rating = -5

Very Good (1)

Very Bad (4) 15 14 16 14 16 15 13 20 21 7 35 9 29 9 28 5 17 20 25

Dont Know (5) 3 3 2 4 2 2 3 3 3 4 0 2 2 2 3 1 1 1 6

Performance on Foreign Affairs

Net Performance Rating = 19

Very Good (1)

Very Bad (4) 9 10 9 10 9 9 10 10 7 6 17 9 13 6 15 4 11 15 13

Dont Know (5) 5 5 6 5 5 8 5 5 8 8 2 2 3 4 8 3 3 2 11

Net Performanc e Index (6) = (1+2) (3+4) 19 15 23 16 18 35 19 21 25 32 -2 -9 28 22 12 51 0 -9 -4

Performance on Inter-Provincial Harmony

Net Performance Rating = 24

Very Good (1)

Very Bad (4) 9 10 9 10 9 13 9 12 6 7 15 11 8 7 14 4 13 15 12

Dont Know (5) 6 6 6 7 5 9 6 6 9 8 2 3 7 5 9 3 4 2 13

Net Performanc e Index 6) = (1+2) (3+4) 24 22 22 17 26 17 23 17 32 43 -17 -3 35 28 11 56 -2 -11 5

Performance on Government-Opposition Harmony

Net Performance Rating = 24

Very Good (1)

Very Bad (4) 9 10 8 10 8 9 9 9 7 5 18 10 10 7 12 3 13 18 11

Dont Know (5) 6 6 6 7 5 10 6 6 7 8 3 4 5 5 9 3 4 3 12