Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
FA L L 2 0 0 8 V O L U M E 2 0 , N U M B E R 3
Features
In this Issue
Editorial
Bronchiectasis
David Hall, MD. Ph.D., Critical Care and Respiratory Medicine, St. Michael’s Hospital, Toronto;
Assistant Professor, Department of Medicine, University of Toronto
Bronchiectasis, an orphan
ronchiectasis (BXIS) has recently Classification
disease or a disease
orphaned by science . . .2
B been termed an orphan disease.1
However advances in chest imaging,
Bronchiectais is sometimes classified
based on its radiological appearance.
particularly the use of high resolution The clinical significance of this
Better Breathing 2009 computed tomography, have resulted in classification is not clear and there
Update from the Chair increasing recognition of this condition. may be considerable overlap.
It is estimated that 110,000 individuals Cylindrical BXIS is typified by a
of the OTS Better in the United States suffer from BXIS.2 failure of the airways to taper distally.
Breathing Committee . . .3 The decline in BXIS has been In cylindrical BXIS the airways are
attributed to the dawning of the DAVID HALL
smooth, which is in contrast to varicoid
Breathe New Life Award, antiobiotic era and effective childhood BXIS where the airways are irregularly dilated
immunizations for measles and pertussis. None with outpouchings. Saccular BXIS has focal
2009-2010 . . . . . . . . . . .6 the less, in certain communities with poor access dilation of the distal airways and can have a
to health care such as isolated aboriginal honeycombed appearance. Unfortunately these
Career Scientist settlements in Australia or in some native descriptors are not very helpful clinically nor do
Award . . . . . . . . . . . . . .7 Alaskans, the prevalence remains high.3 they clarify the etiology of the BXIS.
The hallmark of BXIS is bronchial dilatation.
Plain chest radiography can suggest such Etiology
How Physicians Can dilatation but lacks sensitivity. In the past the BXIS is associated with many different
Give a Voice to the presence of BXIS was confirmed by contrast conditions and presumably may occur for
Backseat . . . . . . . . . . . .7 bronchography, which has now been replaced by different reasons (see table 1). However, a
high resolution CT scanning. BXIS can be unifying theme seems to be inflammation, often
defined clinically as chronic cough with purulent as a result of infections. The inciting event that
Mission Statement sputum, physiologically with airflow obstruction, sets off the vicious circle of infections and
To Promote Respiratory and anatomically with dilated airways. inflammation may not always be clear but the
Health through Medical As a broad division BXIS can be considered impaired mucous clearance and stagnation of
Research and Education. as cystic fibrosis (CF) related or non-CF related. secretions that occurs as a result of the airway
This article will focus on non-CF related BXIS. changes predisposes the individual to recurrent
The OTR can also be viewed BXIS is a heterogeneous condition and, unlike infections (see figure 1.). Simply having a severe
on-line at on.lung.ca/ CF, there are very few centres of excellence. pulmonary infection or recurrent infections in
Health-Care-Professionals/ Consequently there are few high quality studies childhood may set the stage for bronchiectatic
Ontario-Thoracic-Society/ of non-CF BXIS with mostly case series or changes.
Ontario-Thoracic-Reviews.php retrospective analyses. Although they are Immunodeficiency states such as HIV or
different disease entities it is tempting to apply immunoglobulin deficiency predispose patients
www.on.lung.ca the lessons learned in CF to non-CF BXIS. Continued on page 4
ONTARIO THORACIC EDITORIAL
REVIEWS
Bronchiectasis, an orphan disease
or a disease orphaned by science
An official publication of the Ontario
Thoracic Society, Medical Section of
the Ontario Lung Association,
573 King Street East, Elizabeth Tullis, MD, FRCPC, FCCP, Division Head, Respirology St Michael’s Hospital,
Toronto, Ontario M5A 4L3 Respirology Division Director, University of Toronto, Medical Director, Adult Cystic Fibrosis
(416) 864-9911 • Fax (416) 864-9916 Centre, Associate Professor, Member and Chair, Education Committee (past)
E-mail: ots@on.lung.ca
t is difficult to determine the true Although trials of therapy are
Web Site: www.on.lung.ca
We gratefully acknowledge the OTS Grant in Aid Competition Deadline for 2009-2010
sponsorship of our sponsor The deadline for registration is November 14, 2008 and the application deadline is December 9, 2008
Nycomed for this issue.
at 4:30 pm. The grant guidelines and forms can be viewed at the OTS website, http://www.on.lung.ca/
Health-Care-Professionals/Ontario-Thoracic-Society/Grant-Application-and-Guidelines.php
www.on.lung.ca
2 O NTARIO T HORACIC R EVIEWS FALL 2008
Better Breathing 2009
Lung Health: Global Inspirations – Local Impact
JANUARY 30-31, 2009 – MARRIOTT TORONTO DOWNTOWN EATON CENTRE
UPDATE FROM THE CHAIR OF THE OTS BETTER BREATHING COMMITTEE
am pleased to give you a preview of Better Breathing 2009, Medicine”, will feature presentations on Pulmonary
I the annual conference of the Ontario Lung Association
and the Annual General Meeting of the Ontario Thoracic
Hypertension (Dr. Duncan Stewart, Ottawa Health Research
Institute; The Ottawa Hospital) and Cardiopulmonary
Society. The Planning Committee is very excited about Interactions between Sleep Apnea and the Failing Heart
the topics and speakers chosen for Better Breathing (Dr. Douglas Bradley, Toronto Rehabilitation Institute ).
2009. Plan now to attend the OTS Program, which offers The popular and entertaining Resident Case
an exciting series of lectures, lunch sessions and debates. Presentations, facilitated by Dr. Nha Voduc (Ottawa), will
The focus of the Friday morning Plenary Session is follow the Friday afternoon talks. The afternoon session
“Global Respiratory Medicine”. The objective is to concludes with the OTS Annual General Meeting.
explore the future of respirology in Canada (the West), and DR. MICHAEL FITZPATRICK On Saturday morning, return to the OTS Sessions for
in developing countries. We are very fortunate to have two highly the ever-popular and provocative debates: “Controversies in
regarded plenary speakers. Dr. Nicholas Anthonisen, Winnipeg will Pulmonary Medicine”, chaired by Dr. Charles George, London.
discuss “The future of Respirology in Canada”. Dr. Gonzalo Alvarez, This year's speakers will debate controversial statements including:
Ottawa will talk about Trends in Lung Health in the Developing World. A High PEEP Strategy is Beneficial in ARDS (Dr. Niall Ferguson
The mid-morning OTS/ORCS Joint Session, “What’s New in and Dr. Brian Kavanaugh); Pharmaceutical Industry funded
Lung Health” will feature two members of the Ontario Thoracic research cannot be trusted (Dr. Shawn Aaron, Ottawa and Dr.
Society and one member of the Ontario Respiratory Care Society. Matthew Stanbrook, Toronto) and The Treatment of Non-
Dr. Parameswaran Nair, Respirologist, Firestone Institute of Tuberculosis Mycobacteria is more than marginally effective (Dr.
Respiratory Health, St. Joseph’s Healthcare, will discuss Obesity Onofre Morán, Kingston and Dr. Theodore Marras, Toronto). You
and Asthma. Dr. Patricia Hill Bailey, a member of the Ontario should not miss hearing these entertaining (if polarized !!) debates.
Respiratory Care Society, will give an update on the End-of-Life At the request of OTS members, a respiratory researcher will be
Care in COPD. Dr. Kayvan Amjadi, an interventional respirologist highlighted during the Saturday morning session. We are delighted
in Ottawa, will complete the session with a discussion on to announce that Dr. Jim Lewis (University of Western Ontario,
Interventional Pulmonology - what’s missing? London), a renowned researcher and speaker, and an expert on surface
During lunch-time on Friday, attend the General Lunch with the tension forces in the lung, will give the research presentation.
exhibitors or select one of three “Lunch with a Professor Series”. I want to thank all the members of the OTS BBC 2009 Planning
One lunch session is Cardio-Pulmonary Exercise Testing Workshop Committee (Dr. John Bertley, Dr. Steven Bencze, Dr. Hedy Ginzberg,
(Dr. Christopher Parker, Kingston). A second lunch session will Dr. Sheri Katz, Dr. Christopher Licskai, Dr. Peter Macleod, Dr. Parameswaran
discuss assessment of patients with difficult airway disease; the Nair, Dr. Mitra Niroumand, Dr. Chris Parker, Dr. Mark Soth, Dr. Hans
Difficult Airways Workshop will be given by Dr. Peter Slinger, Stelzer, Dr. John Granton and Michael Keim) for their hard work in
Toronto General Hospital. The third session is the André Péloquin organizing this exciting roster of speakers and interesting topics.
Case Presentations from Community Respirologists and is dedicated Exhibitors will display their products and services and draw
to the memory of Dr. André Péloquin. The case presentations are prizes will be awarded throughout the conference. Watch for the
facilitated by Dr. Steven Bencze (Ottawa) and this year’s case presenters program brochure. Mark January 30-31st, 2009, on your calendar
are Dr. Marcus Newton (Owen Sound), Dr. David Schneidermann and register early!
(Ottawa) and Dr. Jacqueline Nemni (Guelph). Please book early for
the lunch-time clinical sessions as seating is limited. Michael Fitzpatrick, MD, FRCPI, FRCPC, D.ABSM
The Friday afternoon program, “State of the Art in Respiratory Chair, OTS Better Breathing Planning Committee, 2009
Mark your
calendars!
to pulmonary infection and there is an problems with cellular chloride handling. copious. Patients may also complain of
association between these disease states As a result pulmonary secretions become hemoptysis, shortness of breath, chest pain,
and BXIS. thick and tenacious and patients have or fatigue.
Another theme is one of poor clearance difficulty clearing them. In contrast, There may be changes on chest radio-
of secretions as is the case in cystic fibrosis, patients with primary ciliary dyskinesia graph but this modality lacks sensitivity.
primary ciliary dyskinesia, Young’s have abnormalities in the structure and/or The classic changes include “tram-tracking,
syndrome, Mounier-Kuhn syndrome, and function of their cilia. There are a variety of which results from the failure of bronchi to
Williams-Campbell syndrome. Although recognized ciliary abnormalities that are narrow as they progress distally and
impaired clearance of secretions is the evident on electron microscopy; most are manifests as the bronchial walls appearing
underlying problem in these diseases it structural but some “structurally” normal as parallel lines. The signet ring sign refers
occurs for different reasons. In cystic cilia may not be aligned properly. This to an enlarged airway and its adjacent
fibrosis a defect in the CFTR gene results in organelle not only requires that its internal vessel. Normally the airway and vessel
“machinery” be normal but also that the should be of the same caliber. In BXIS the
TABLE 1 Causes of Bronchiectasis13 cilia are aligned such that they can beat in a enlarged airway has the appearance of the
coordinated fashion in order to propel the “ring” and the vessel, the “gem”.
Postinfectious Conditions “mucociliary escalator”. An inability to The sensitivity of high resolution
Childhood lower respiratory tract infections cough effectively also results in impaired computed tomography (HRCT) has allowed
Granulomatous infections clearance of pulmonary secretions, which for the diagnosis of less severe forms of the
Necrotizing pneumonias in adults
occurs in Mounier-Kuhn and Williams disease. The typical findings on HRCT
Other respiratory infections
Campbell syndromes. include: internal bronchial diameter greater
Primary Immune Disorders Infection with atypical mycobacteria than the adjacent pulmonary artery, lack of
Humoral defects may result in BXIS or conversely bronchial tapering, visualization of bronchi
Cellular and/or mixed disorders bronchiectatic airways may predispose an within 1 cm of costal pleura, visualization
Neutrophil dysfunction individual to infection by these pathogens. of bronchi abutting the mediastinal pleura
Other Right middle lobe or lingular BXIS in and bronchial wall thickening.4
Cystic Fibrosis elderly women with atypical mycobacterial Spirometry typically shows airflow
infection well described and referred to as limitation with or with out a reduced forced
Alpha1-Antitrypsin Disease “Lady Windermere” syndrome. It is named vital capacity. Reactive airways can be
after the title character in the Oscar Wilde demonstrated in as many as 40-70% of
Heritable Structural Abnormalities
Ciliated epithelium
play “Lady Windermere’s Fan”. Lady BXIS patients based on response to inhaled
Cartilage Windermere was portrayed as a fastidious bronchodilators or methacholine challenge.
Connective tissue woman of the Victorian era, thus likely to
Sequestration, agenesis, hypoplasia suppress cough and avoid expectoration Treatment
Dwarfism Non-infectious inflammation may The literature on the treatment of BXIS is
also be the inciting event. This may be scant and the quality of the studies poor.
Idiopathic Inflammatory Disorders the cause of BXIS associated with Treatment can be broadly divided into three
Sarcoidosis
inflammatory bowel disease (IBD). The categories, prevention of exacerbations,
Rheumatoid arthritis
Ankylosing spondylitis
association with rheumatoid arthritis (RA) treatment of exacerbations, and treatment of
Systemic lupus erythematosus is less clear and a number of postulates have complications. Treatment options are aimed
Sjögren's syndrome been put forth including a predisposition to at decreasing the bacterial load, enhancing
Inflammatory bowel disease infection as a result of treatments for the clearance of secretions, decreasing
Relapsing polychondritis RA or the BXIS itself is the inciting factor inflammation, or removal of diseased lung.
for the RA. With the exception of a few circumstances
Inhalation Accidents Direct airway injury from inhalation of (i.e. allergic broncopulmonary aspergillosis,
Gastroesophageal reflux/aspiration pneumonia
noxious substances such as toxic metal non-tuberculous mycobacteria) the treatment
Toxic inhalation/thermal injury
Postobstruction
fumes or other toxic gases is also known to of BXIS is not influenced by its etiology.
Foreign body occur. This may result in BXIS due to If sputum cultures are available,
Tumors, benign and malignant infectious complications following the antibiotic therapy should be directed at the
Extrinsic airway compression exposure or due to direct damage of the isolated pathogen or pathogens. In the
ciliated epithelium. absence of cultures studies have shown the
Allergic Bronchopulmonary Aspergillosis/Mycosis most commonly isolated pathogens are H.
Miscellaneous Diagnosis influenzae, P. aeruginosa, and Strep.
HIV infection/AIDS Although clinical manifestations vary, pneumoniae. The duration of treatment for
Yellow-nail syndrome most patients with BXIS suffer from acute exacerbations is not well established
Radiation injury repeated respiratory infections, chronic but common practice is to treat for a
Adapted from Mason RJ, Murray JF, Broaddus VC, Nadel JA eds
cough and purulent sputum. The degree of prolonged course (i.e >10 days).
sputum production is variable but may be Continued on page 5
FIGURE 1 Infection and inflammation, the vicious circle. showed decreased sputum volume in the
fluticasone treated group.9 In the subgroup
of patients with sputum cultures positive for
pseudomonas there was also a significant
reduction in the frequency of exacerbations.
To date there is insufficient evidence to
support the use of systemic corticosteroids
in stable BXIS or exacerbations of BXIS.
Bronchial Hygeine
Patients with BXIS may benefit from chest
physiotherapy or postural drainage. Many
of the techniques for enhanced secretion
clearance have been better studied in CF.
Percussion, postural drainage, flutter
devices or positive end expiratory pressure
(PEP) masks have all been used extensively
with success in CF. Despite this a Cochrane
Even less well established is antibiotic Nebulized antibiotic therapy aimed at database review found no evidence to
treatment of a patient who is not in an chronic pseudomonas infection has been support these interventions in non-CF
exacerbation. A recent Cochrane database successful in CF patients. Unfortunately bronchiectasis.10
review of 9 trials looking at prolonged evidence for a similar approach in BXIS is
courses of antibiotics (ranging from 4 lacking. Results have been inconsistent and Mucoactive Agents
months to one year) in BXIS showed a it is difficult to determine a priori which Inhaled agents to enhance clearance of
positive response rate.5 Exacerbation rates patients will tolerate treatment with inhaled sputum such as Recombinant DNase,
however were not decreased. Included in antibiotics. There are nonetheless reports of hypertonic saline, and powdered mannitol
this meta-analysis were studies of improved quality of life and symptom have also been studied. Mannitol, and
prolonged courses of macrolides and also scores with inhaled tobramycin.7 It is hypertonic saline are hyperosmolar agents
studies of nebulized antibiotics. Although possible to nebulize tobramycin as either that act by both stimulating cough and
beyond the scope of this paper, it would be TOBI® (a preservative free formulation causing a liquid flux into the airways.
interesting to see if the positive effect was designed specifically for nebulization) or to Mannitol is probably the best studied of the
maintained if these latter trials were nebulize the intravenous formulation (off hyperosmolar agents in BXIS. It has been
excluded from the meta-analysis. label indication). However, the intravenous shown to be effective in enhancing
The role of macrolide treatment of CF formulation may theoretically result in a clearance of pulmonary secretions.11
BXIS patients infected with pseudomonas higher incidence of bronchospasm which Recombinant DNase has been
is well established with multiple studies may be alleviated by nebulizing a mixture demonstrated to be beneficial in CF BXIS
showing effects including improved FEV1 of tobramycin and salbutamol. The practice but not in non-CF BXIS. In a well
and decreased exacerbation rates. The in our institution is to administer the first conducted double blind, placebo controlled
mechanism for this benefit is likely a dose of nebulized tobramycin in a multi-center trial of 349 adult patients with
combination of anti-inflammatory and anti- controlled setting with pre and post idiopathic BXIS, DNase was found to result
biofilm properties. The anti-inflammatory inhalation spirometry. in a statistically significant more rapid
properties of macrolides are well decline in FEV1 compared to placebo and
established and they have been used Steroids an increased rate of pulmonary
successfully in the treatment of diffuse It makes physiological sense that exacerbations, although this did not reach
panbronchiolitis. A recent pilot study of interruption of the “vicious circle” of significance. Chest physiotherapy was not
conventional treatment plus azithromycin infection and inflammation in BXIS may controlled for in this study.12 It was
500mg twice weekly in 11 BXIS patients stabilize the disease or improve lung postulated that the predominance of lower
showed a decreased incidence of function. The use of anti-inflammatory lobe BXIS in the idiopathic patients
exacerbations as well as decreased sputum medications has been poorly studied. A compared to upper lobe predominance in
volume compared to usual treatment.6 Cochrane database review of inhaled CF patients may have accounted for the
Subjects also reported increased energy and steroids in BXIS found only 2 suitable differences in these two groups. In upper
improved quality of life while receiving studies for review.8 Although there was a lobe disease gravity may enhance sputum
azithromycin. Although insufficient evidence trend towards improved lung function there clearance. This points out some of the
is available to date to justify an approach was no demonstrated effect on sputum potential downfalls in directly applying
where all BXIS patients are treated with production, cough, wheeze or dyspnea. evidence from CF to non-CF BXIS.
long term macrolide therapy, further More recently a randomized controlled trial
investigations are certainly warranted. of inhaled fluticasone versus placebo Continued on page 6