Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Shadow
RL of Shakespeare
— Do You Think There
is Evil in Everyone? –
LITERATURE
The Presence of
Evil in Humankind
Little Bad
Seed in Us
Index
• Devil vs. Angel? / İpek Şapçı..……………………………………….…………………….. 1
• Evil in Us / Egenur Bakıner ……………………………………………...………………… 3
• Little Bad Seed in Us / Dilara Şahin ……………………………………………..………... 4
• Evil does not Live in the Cave Borneo/ Ceren Burçak Dağ …………………………….. 6
• The Nature of Human Beings / Gözde Kavak …………………………………………… 9
• The Presence of Evil in Humankind / Romina Azoz ………………………………….. 11
REFORM LITERATURE
Special Supplement of Reform
Designer
Erkut Deral
Periodicalists
İpek Şapçı, Egenur Bakıner, Dilara Şahin,
Gözde Kavak, Romina Azoz, Ceren Burçak Dağ
Communication
reform.isiklisesi@hotmail.com
DEVIL VS ANGEL?
OR IS IT JUST THE DEVIL HIDING
BEHIND THE ANGEL?
İpek ŞAPÇI
Everyone should be careful about their choices because the evil hiding
behind the angel can easily overcome the angel and one day you can
look in the mirror and see a tail and horns but not two beautiful wings.
In every culture and society there is a clear represents Macbeth’s situation pretty well. I totally
distinction of evil and good. People, their habits, disagree with those opinions, because I don’t think
behaviors and also people themselves are always Macbeth could be evil when he was totally pure
evaluated under these two main adjectives: Evil and before. There was evil present in him; he only didn’t
good. It is one of the most popular problems human notice that because a person can’t murder someone
nature dealt with and is still dealing with. A lot of because of fulfilling words of a woman or
books were written, a lot of movies were made on manipulation. If someone commits such a big crime
the eternal battle of good and evil. Despite the then there’s definitely evil present in them. Just like
distinction, it has always been a question whether in Macbeth’s situation; he was very happy to catch a
everyone is only good or evil. Mostly people think tyrant in the very beginning of the play. Then the
that evil is present in everyone because it is not prophecy awakened his ambitions and also the evil
possible for someone to be as innocent, pure and part of him. As a result of having a weak character
good as an angel. Everyone has some dark, evil and weak moral values, Macbeth was easily
side and the main issue is controlling it, so there is manipulated by his evil side. For example, when he
not such a thing that good people never do bad realizes how far he went, he thinks for a moment
stuff; good people have the potential to be evil but about giving up all the things he did, but then he
they can control themselves and this makes them decides that he has already stepped in so far and
good. In the famous play “Macbeth”, this is one of his evil side prevented him from being good again.
the main themes. Shakespeare mainly discusses if In addition to the main character Macbeth,
evil is present in everyone or not. I believe that it is. Banquo also shows us that evil is present in
In the play, the main character Macbeth is the everyone. Despite my opinion, some say that
main symbol of evil. People believe that the difficult Banquo doesn’t show any evil intentions. They
situation, the manipulation of the witches and Lady advocate that he was always a good man and he
Macbeth made Macbeth evil, he was good at the didn’t want to do anything even after hearing the
beginning and he didn’t have any bad intentions. prophecy. For instance, he knows that the words the
For example, when he first heard the prophecy he witches said may affect him in a way that he doesn’t
decided not to do anything to make it happen, if it want, so he is cautious and he doesn’t pay attention
happens, then it will. But after Lady Macbeth talked to those words. He knew what might happen and he
with him and convinced him to commit the murders, wanted to stay as an honorable man. I don’t look at
his opinion changed. The quote: “Look like the the events the same way that the people who
innocent flower but be the serpent under it” believe he is good do. I think even in Banquo there
1
is evil present. He is just hiding the devil behind his Finally, it is subject to argument whether
angelic appearance. Also he, the best character in everyone is actually evil or not. I believe everyone
the book has some evil deeds. He thinks about has an evil part but it depends on the choice, the
doing something to make the prophecy happen, but character of the people to be evil or not. If a person
then he realizes it is just the manipulation of the chooses to be good then, no force can make that
witches and that they can not be trusted. So he fires person bad. But, if someone is slightly near to the
the evil thoughts from his head and is an optimistic bad side, then they can easily become a bad
honorable man again. For example in some part of person, because evil is there but it is not an option.
the play, he says “But hush! No more!” It is clearly It depends on the personality. In addition to that, I
shown here that he has an evil part deep inside his think everyone should be careful about their choices
soul but because of the strong character and the because the evil hiding behind the angel can easily
distinct separation of rights and wrongs he has, he overcome the angel and one day you can look in the
doesn’t let that evil part defeat the good one. I think mirror and see a tail and horns, not two beautiful
this is exactly the behaviour that a decent person wings.
should have.
2
EVIL IN US
Egenur BAKINER
In the play “Macbeth”, the reader can easily o’er.” This quote shows us how he accepts the
focus on the theme of evil. Somebody can think that situation. He thinks he’s got so much blood on his
an evil spirit is present in everyone in the play and in hand that it doesn’t make a difference if he goes on
real life, somebody can support the opposite idea. or stops committing crimes. It’s not ambition, it’s
Therefore the theme “evil” is really an interesting greed, and greed has evil. So I think after seeing
theme to talk about. I’m one of the readers who this evidence, there is no way we can agree with
think evil is present in everyone in the play and in what they say.
real life. I think every human being has bad and The ones who think that evil isn’t present in
good sides and the bad side includes the evil spirit everyone put forward this idea because they have
too. the “Banquo” example. They think evil isn’t present
in Banquo, he’s loyal, honest and not greedy at all. I
Present fears, are less than have to admit they’re right about it. Banquo has a
horrible imaginings. My great personality. However, in Act 3 scene 1,
thought, whose murder yet Banquo talks to himself about Macbeth and the
is but fantastical, shakes so murder. He doesn’t want to be influenced by his
my single state of man that own thoughts and he says: “Hush, no more.” It
shows the reader that Banquo has an evil side too,
function smother’d in
but he can control it. He’s not 100% pure and
surmise, and nothing is but
innocent, it’s just about controll. On the other hand, I
what is not. can give the example as “Lady Macbeth”. Nobody
There may be so many readers who think that would expect evil behaviour from a woman,
evil isn’t present in everyone. They claim that idea however Lady Macbeth is the worst person in the
since they have examples to give. They can say play. In Act 1, scene 5 she says: “That tend on
Macbeth is innocent, evil isn’t present in him, mortal thoughts, unsex me here and fill me from the
however he wants to prove himself to his wife and crown to the toetopfull...”. If a woman, the person
he murders people just for this reason. They have a who milks the baby, who is supposed to have a soft
point in thinking like that. However I think a quote in nature says that, then evil is really present in
Act 1, scene 3 can easily persuade them: “Present everyone. So we can easily understand that their
fears, are less than horrible imaginings. My thought, argument is irrelevant.
whose murder yet is but fantastical, shakes so my In the play, the theme of evil is a focus point.
single state of man that function smother’d in Banquo’s good personality, Macbeth’s will to prove
surmise, and nothing is but what is not.” In this himself to his wife can lead the reader think evil isn’t
scene the readers haven’t met Lady Macbeth and present in everyone. I’m one of the readers who think
Macbeth thinks about a murder. On the other hand, evil is present in everyone since even a great person
opponents of this idea can claim that evil isn’t like Banquo has an evil side, and as a woman, Lady
present in Macbeth, he’s just an ambitious man and Macbeth, has an evil side. Opponents of this idea
he tries to be successful. I can’t agree with this idea. have some points, but in the end as William Golding
In Act 3, scene 5 Macbeth says: “All causes shall says: “Everyone, who is not understanding that man
give way, I am in blood, steep’d in so far that should produces evil as a bee produces honey must be blind
I wade no more, returning werw as tedious as go or wrong in his head.”
3
LITTLE BAD SEEN IN US
Dilara ŞAHİN
William Shakespeare’s play, “Macbeth”, is Opponents of this idea may say that there is
about a man who is tempted by evil forces. This not any badness in human nature. The social
made him do horrible things and finally ruined his surrounding is the cause of evil actions of men.
life. But was that evil force interior or exterior. Are Problems in their life are what make people do
all human beings born with pure goodness or is bad things. These problems could be about
there an evil seed planted in all of us? This economical situation, life standards, family, etc.
question has been the subject of many other For example, in big cities crime rates are higher
novels, too. K. M. Ballantyne’s novel “The Coral in than ghettos. People who live in places like
Island” is a novel which was written to show that that are more likely to commit crimes, like in
all people are good inside. After that William Harlem in New York or Esenyurt in İstanbul.
Golding wrote a novel, “Lord of the Flies”, to However problems in society are not the cause of
prove the claim that there is evil in everyone. I evil actions, they only awaken the evil part of
agree with William Golding about human nature. I humans. Evil takes action with an impulsive
think that human beings have both good and bad movement. There are some triggers which will
sides. make someone show his or her bad side. These
could be money, power, love,
sexual desires, etc. For
example, in Macbeth what
affected Lady Macbeth and
Macbeth was their desires to
be the king and the queen.
After they heard the prophecies
they couldn’t enjoy Macbeth’s
new title which was a great
success. They only thought
about coming to a higher
position. Macbeth says, “Stars,
hide your fires; Let not light see
my black and deep desires.” As
we can understand from this
quote it was their desires for
power which triggered the evil
part in them. Also when
Macbeth changed his mind
about killing Duncan, Lady
4
Macbeth influenced him by questioning his love leader. But this camp was very different then the
for her, his bravery and his manliness. The old one. There was no democracy. The only rule
second trigger was saving his dignity and proving was to obey the chief without questioning.
that he is a real man. So when people’s desires “Roger: He is going to beat Wilfred.
overtake moral values and rules that can cause Bill: What for?
them to do horrible things like committing crimes. R: I don’t know. He didn’t say. He got angry
People who believe that human beings are and made us tie Wilfred up.
completely good may use Tao philosophy to B: But did the chief said why?
prove their claim. According to Tao philosophy R: I never heard him.”
people are good when they come to life but the This is a dialog between two members of this
society and the government are the cause of all camp. It explains the tyranny in that camp clearly.
evil. If you try to control or limit people, you’ll Also day by day Jack’s camp became stronger
cause them turn from good to bad. If you leave and finally he decided to kill Ralph and he almost
people on their own they will build a civilized succeeded. So if there are no rules or social
society on their own. Also Banquo’s actions could conditioning to limit human beings, even children
be an example for that. In the play after hearing can do evil things.
the prophecies Banquo could have killed Duncan All in all, humankind has both goodness and
too. In this way he could be sure that his children badness inside. It will be wrong to say that
would be kings. But he didn’t take action like someone is totally good or evil. It depends on a
Macbeth and left it to fate. Did he do that person’s character and social surrounding to
because of his pure nature or was something determine which one will be more dominant,
else affecting him? I think there is an evil part in because some people can be affected easily,
Banquo, too, like every human being. He didn’t they choose the simple way, to be cruel.
take action against Duncan because of his
loyalty. Also, according to their beliefs, the king
was assigned by God. So he was representing
God on earth and murdering him was the biggest
crime and sin. In general, we can say that people
don’t show their evil part because in society evil
is not considered normal. Laws, ethics rules and
religion limit us. If we put some people on a
deserted island, where there are no rules, they
will all show their evil sides one by one. For
example, “The Lord of the Flies” is about a group
of kids who crashed on an island. They first
choose Ralph, the oldest boy, as leader. He tried
to keep acting in a civilized way. He arranged
meetings and made rules. But then another boy,
Jack, organized another camp where he was the
5
EVIL DOES NOT LIVE IN THE CAVE BORNEO1
Ceren Burçak DAĞ
“I’m here on the ground with my nose in it since These plots do not include intermediate tones as it
all the thing began!” says Al Pacino in the role of is seen. For example, in Turkish Literature Ahmet
Satan in Devil’s Advocate. So, could we ask Mithat’s novels such as “Mr.Felatun and Sir.Rakım”
ourselves where this evil is hiding since the shows these kinds of specialties. Ahmet Mithat
beginning? In the caves? Maybe the Cave Borneo, ornaments Sir Rakım with all the good signs and Sir
in the deepest hollow of all the Earth? Is it so far Rakım does not do anything degenerated morally in
away from us? Or let us think about the total the plot. But on contrast of him Mr. Felatun has the
contrast of it: What if evil is closer than we suppose? worst human sides and consequently a dirty life.
What if it sits in the house of your neighbor? Or This scheme points out the theme of “the excess
what do you say if you find it one day inside you? difference between goodness and evil” and
Now it is the time to be transmitted to the essential supporters of this theme naturally put forward an
case: To be honest Macbeth was a very loyal and idea that the evil is a concept which could not live in
noble subject of his king; however he killed him with a place where goodness exists. However,
opponents of the thought of “evil is in every one”
miss a point in the comprehension of movements. It
“I’m here on the ground is obvious that the world literature creates the
with my nose in it since opposite pole of an idea. Thus, we see the
all the thing began!” says succession of Realism after Romanticism in the
Al Pacino in the role of history. In the contrast of romantics, here realism
7
shows us the inner conflict of Lady Macbeth which In conclusion of all discussion on evil in humans,
is a case between her evil and goodness. She is evil it is apparent that there is evil in every mother-born
enough to prepare to commit a murder but also is person. This is not an obligation but a natural result
good enough to compare Duncan to her father and of nature, because nature itself has its own dialectic
decide not to kill him by herself. After seeing this and in this kind of natural logic, a pole cannot live
evidence, there is no way we can agree with what without its opposite pole. In these limits, to be just
they say. As a result of this, it is quite possible to good and pure is not in the borders of “human
find a piece of goodness in the most evil person as definition.” Thus, every single person has evil inside
well as to find evil in a good person, as in the him and to dominate it is the specialty that
philosophy of yin-yang. differentiates people.
1
Cave Borneo is the biggest hollow of the Earth
8
THE NATURE OF HUMAN BEINGS
Gözde KAVAK
10
THE PRESENCE OF EVIL IN HUMANKIND
Romina AZOZ
“What an evil person!” we say to ourselves after in their minds but the important thing is to act wisely
we see somebody doing something wicked or any by not putting those thoughts into action. In that way
person who is offering a seat to an old one becomes you wriggle yourself away from the evil ones and at
the symbol of kindness in our eyes. After seeing that time you become virtuous. For example, if
people’s behaviors in society, it has became a quick someone is more successful at painting than you, if
response to classify them into good or bad. But you choose to tear his or her canvas into pieces
what is evil? Where does it come from? How did it then you couldn’t chip the evil in you, on the other
develop in us? Has anybody asked or got curious hand if you realize that by doing that you won’t get
about, I wonder. Evil is one of the personal anything and that person will keep continuing being
specialties which has a huge role in forming our successful eventually, you don’t have the signs of
characters. Is it present in all of us? It’s a evil in your actions. Another example from
complicated question whether we have it or not. The Shakespeare’s famous play “Macbeth” can be the
things that shouldn’t be forgotten are that evil is one character Banquo himself. The most important
of the elements of human nature and with the reason for creating such a character like him by
effects of environment it’s not possible to say we Shakespeare is to show the difference between the
don’t have it. good and evil. From this quotation; “Why by the
As being the most complex creations in the verities on thee made good, may they not be my
universe, human beings have a psychological oracles as well and set me up in hope? But hush, no
backcloth besides physical ground. Think of that like more.” it’s obvious that Banquo has evil thoughts in
a soup, all the qualities have been donated to his mind like Macbeth but he chooses to believe in
humans from God, a little bit of honesty, some God, obey the nature and leave those prophecies to
jealousy, a little kindness and some of that fate. Unlike Macbeth he used his intelligence and
meanness etc. In some of them the most harmful wisdom with his bravery and managed to prevent
and dangerous one “evil” can be passed out and himself from doing evil actions. As a conclusion,
those people won’t have the quality of evil in any being evil is one of the basic properties of mankind;
part of their lives. These are known to be the the separation between good and evil ones is to
prophets, the holy men who are the symbol of have an autocontrol mechanism.
goodness and its derivatives. Another example for Everyone is an individual and has their own
pure goodness can be the ones who believed in thoughts. People who are not evil are born pure
mysticism. According to their belief people like innocent and continue to live like that, they don’t get
Yunus Emre, Mevlana or Yusuf Has Hacib didn’t impressed or affected by their environment, they are
contain any feeling of evil in their hearts and only in one hundred percent good. For example you can’t
this way they could reach God, which was their make a good person betray anyone, he or she
biggest will, ideas may say. However, when looking would immediately stand against for that and fight
at the situation with a more realistic way it’s seen for their thoughts, some may think. On the other
that evil is one of the elements of human nature, it hand, the huge effect of environment can not be
has been put in that soup like every other ignored. People who are weak can get influenced
characteristic. It comes from the birth and develops very quickly. A person’s character development
in our structure throughout the time we grow. It’s up depends on the place where he or she lives and
to us whether to arouse those feelings of evil or to who he or she lives with. For example, if a person
control ourselves. Everybody can carry evil thoughts lives with someone who is always saying evil things,
11
there is a huge possibility that this person would environmental effects have an importance on the
think about those evil things. Another example from people’s characteristics, especially weak people can
the play called “Macbeth” is Lady Macbeth’s evil be influenced from the others very quickly and
effects on her husband. She literally wakes up follow the path of evil in their lives.
Macbeth’s evil thoughts after he has already been When you look deeply at the psychology of
12