PROPERTY

2 Exam Case Outline 2nd Year SR

Atty. Melissa Romana P. Suarez
nd

Title V. Possession
Art.
523

Case Title
Equatorial Realty v. Mayfair

GR
133879

Date
Nov 21, 2001

How
Possession
Exercised
Concept of
Holder
Owner

524

Jose De Luna v. CA

94490

Aug 6, 1992

525

Jose Garcia v. CA
Mangahas v. CA

113140
95815

Aug 10, 1999

Mar 10, 1999

Good/Bad
Faith

526
527

Embrado v. CA
Editha Alviola v. CA
DBP vs. CA

51457
117642
111737

Jun 27, 1994

Apr 24, 1998
Oct 13, 1999

How
Possession
Acquired

531

Somodio v. CA
Equatorial Realty v. Mayfair
Dela Rosa v. Carlos
Pajuyo v. CA and Guevarra

82680
133879
147549
146364

Aug 13, 1994

Nov 21, 2001
Oct 23, 2003
Jun 3, 2004

Possession in
Fact

538

Wong v. Carpio
Cequena v. Bolante

L-50264
137944

Oct 21, 1991

Apr 6, 2000

Possession
that ripens to
ownership

540

Marcelo v. CA
Mangahas v. CA
Cequena v. Bolante
Spouses Recto v. RP
Heirs of Gamos v. Heirs of Frando
Heirs of Crislogo v. Ranon

131803
95815
137944
160421
149117
171068

Apr 14, 1999

Mar 10, 1999
Apr 6, 2000
Oct 4, 2004
Dec 16, 2004
Sep 5, 2007

Presumption
of Just Title

541

Cequena v. Bolante
Mario Titong v. CA

137944
111141

Apr 6, 2000
Mar 6, 1998

Expenses

544546

Pada-Kilario v. CA
Chua v. CA
Florentino v. Supervalue
Daclig v. Macahilig
Heirs of Limense v. Ramos
Briones v. Macabagdal
Torbela v. Spouses Rosario

134329
109840
172384
159578
152319
150666
140528

Jan 19, 2000

Jan 21, 1999
Sep 12, 2007
Feb 18, 2009
Oct 28, 2009
Aug 3, 2010
Dec 7, 2011

555

US v. Rey
John Yu v. de Lara
Catholic Vicar Apostolic v. CA

L-3326
L-16084
80294-95

Sep 7, 1907
Nov 30, 1962
Mar 23, 1990

Definition

How
Possession is
Lost

Citation

301 S 357

8 P 500

Rule on
Irreivindicabi
lity

559

Del Rosario v. Lucena

Varela v. Finnick
Arenas v. Raymundo
Aznar v. Yapdiangco
EDCA Publishing v. Santos
Ledesma v. CA
BPI Family Bank v. Franco

9 P 482
19 P 46

L-3546
L-3890
L-5741
L-18536
80298
86051
123498

Sep 13, 1907

Jan 2, 1908
Mar 13, 1911
Mar 31, 1965
Apr 26, 1990
Sep 1, 1992
Nov 23, 2007

Title VI. Usufruct

Usufruct in
General

Art
562565

Case Title
Eleizegui v. Manila Lawn Tennis Club
Moralidad v. Pernes

GR #
967
152809

Date
May 19, 1903
Aug 3, 2006

Rights of the
Usufructuary

566582

Bachrach v. Seifert [566]

Orozco and Alcantara v. Araneta [566]
Perez v. CA [572]
Alunan v. Veloso [574]
Moralidad v. Pernes

L-2659
L-3691
107737
29158
52809

Oct 12, 1950

Nov 21, 1951
Oct. 1, 1999
Dec 29, 1928
Aug 3, 2006

Obligations
of the
Usufructuary

583602

Bislig Bay v. Government of Surigao [597]

Board of Assessments v. Samar Mining [597]
Mercado v. Real [597]
Hemedes v. CA [600]

L-9023
L-28034
45534
107132

Nov 13, 1956

Feb 27, 1971
Apr 27, 1939
Oct 8, 1999

Extinguishme
nt of
Usufruct

603612

Chingen v. Arguelles [603]

Vda. de Aranas v. Aranas
City of Manila v. Monte de Piedad [603]
Locsin v. Valenzuela [609]
Moralidad v. Pernes

L-3314
L-56249
1975
51333
52809

Jan 3, 1907
May 29, 1987
Nov 10, 1905
Feb 19, 1991
Aug 3, 2006

Lease
General
Provisions

Art.
16421653

Case Title
Wee v. De Castro
Cuenco v. TTSC
Lopez v. Umale-Cosme

Rights and
Obligations

16541688

Florentino v. Supervalue
LBP v. AMS
TRB v. Cuison Lumber
Cheng v. Spouses Vittorio
Yuki v. Co

Citation

GR #
176405
174154
171891

Date
Aug 20, 2008
Oct 17, 2008
Feb 24, 2009

172384
174971
174286
167017
178527

Sep 12, 2007

Oct 15, 2008
Jun 5, 2009
Jun 22, 2009
Nov 27, 2009

Title VII. Easements or Servitudes

Art.
613619

Case Title
Borbajo v. Hidden View [613]
Solid Manila v. Bio Hong [617]
Dela Cruz v. Ramiscal [619]
Unisource v. Chung [618]
Liwag v. Happy Glen Loop [614]

GR #
152440
90596
137882
173252
189755

Date
Jan 31, 2005
Apr 8, 1991
Feb 4, 2005
Jul 17, 2009
Jul 4, 2012

Modes of
Acquiring
Easements

620626

Ronquillo v. Roco [620]

Laureana Cid v. Irene Javier [621]
Bogo-Medellin Milling v. CA [622]
Fe Velasco v. Cusi [622]
Bicol Agro v. Tobias
Taedo v. Bernad [624]
Juan Gargantos v. Tan Yanon [624]
NPC v. Spouses Campos
Aneco Realty v. Landex
Goldcrest v. Cypress Gardens [625]
Privatization v. Legaspi Towers [624]
Bicol Agro v. Obias [622]

L-10619
L-14116
124699
L-33507
172077
L-66520
L-14652
143643
165952
171072
147957
172077

Feb 28, 1958

Jun 30, 1960
Jul 31, 2003
Jul 20, 1981
Oct 9, 2009
Aug 30, 1988
Jun 30, 1960
Jun 27, 2003
Jul 28, 2008
Apr 7, 2009
Jul 22, 2009
Oct 9, 2009

Rights and
Obligations

627
630

Valderrama v. North Negros

Aneco Realty v. Landex

23810
165952

Dec 18, 1926

Jul 28, 2008

Modes of
Extinguish
ment

631
633

Cabacungan v. Corrales [631]

Benedicto v. CA [631]
Taedo v. Bernad [631]
Salimbangon v. Tan

L-6629
L-22733
L-66520
185240

Sep 30, 1954

Sep 25, 1968
Aug 30, 1988
Jan 20, 2010

Easement
Relating to
Waters

637
648

Banzon v. Banzon [642]

Gonzales v. Purificacion de Dios [643]
Valisno v. Adriano [648]

27296
L-3099
L-37409

Oct 8, 1927
May 21, 1951
May 23, 1988

Easement
of Right of
Way

649
657

Costabella v. CA [649]
Francisco v. IAC [649]
Floro v. Llenado [649]
Quimen v. CA [649]
Sta. Maria vs. CA [649]
Villanueva v. Velasco [649]
Dela Cruz v. Ramiscal [649]
Napocor v. Manubay [649]
Woodridge v. ARB Construction [649]
Obra v. Badua [649]

80511

Jan 25, 1991

75723
112331
127549
130845
137882
150936
157825
149125

Jun 2, 1995
May 29, 1996
Jan 28, 1998
Nov 27, 2000
Feb 4, 2005
Aug 18, 2004
Feb 16, 2007
Aug 9, 2007

Different
Kinds of
Easments

Citation

177 S 527

St. Michael v. Masaito [649]

NPC v. Suarez
NPC v. Benjamin Ong Co [649]
Dichoso v. Marcos [649]
NPC v. Heirs of Sangkay
Juana Complex v. Fil Estate [649]

166301
175725
166973
180282
165828
152272

Feb 29, 2008

Oct 8, 2008
Feb 10, 2009
Apr 11, 2011
Aug 24, 2011
Mar 5, 2012

Encarnacion v. CA [651]

77628

Mar 11, 1991

Party Wall

658
666

Case v. Heirs of Tuazon [658]

Lao v. Heirs of Alburo [658]
Valenzuela v. Unson [658]

5044
10372
10266

Dec 1, 1909
Dec 24, 1915
Oct 20, 1915

Easement
of Light
and View

667
673

Cortez v. Yu Tibo [668]

Severina Choco v. Santamaria [669]
Soriano v. Sterberg [670]
Masongsong v. Flores [672]

911
6076
15628
36048

Mar 12, 1903

Dec 29, 1911
Nov 18, 1920
Sep 24, 1932

Drainage of
Buildings

674
676

Cabacungan v. Corrales [674]

Purugganan v. Paredes [674]

L-6629
L-23818

Sep 30, 1954

Jan 21, 1976

Lateral & 684

Subjacent
Support

Ngo Sin Sing v. Li Seng Giap

Castro v. Monsod

172596
183719

Nov 28, 2008

Feb 2, 2011

Voluntary
Easements

North Negros Sugar v. Hidalgo [688]

Trias v. Araneta [688]
La Vista v. CA [691]
Rivera v. IAC [688]
Unisource v. Chung

42334
L-20786
95252
74249
173252

Oct 31, 1936

Oct 30, 1965
Sep 5, 1997
Jan 20, 1989
Jul 17, 2009

688
693