Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011
ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 1 on 68
HAUTE ECOLE DE LA PROVINCE DE LIEGE Economic studies
Higher education degree Foreign Trade 2 nd year
EXPORT
Keys for setting up an export structure
F. CARPENTIER
Heaven is where the cooks are French, the mechanics are German, the policemen are English, the lovers are Italian, and it is all organized by the Swiss. Hell is where the policemen are German, the mechanics are French, the cooks are English, the lovers are Swiss, and it is all organized by the Italians. British newspaper - 1980's - Unidentified
Academic year 2010-2011 Economic studies Avenue MONTESQUIEU, 6 B-4101 Jemeppe
Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 2 on 68 Table of content NUMBERS ABOUT EXPORT ............................................................................................................................ 3 GENERAL TREND OF BELGIAN EXPORT .................................................................................................................. 3 CONTEXT FOR EXPORT ...................................................................................................................................... 7 EXPORT ORIENTED STRUCTURE ........................................................................................................................... 7 SET UP OF AN EXPORT STRUCTURE ....................................................................................................................... 8 PRODUCTS FOR EXPORT ................................................................................................................................ 9 PRODUCT SELECTION ........................................................................................................................................ 9 APPROACH BY ATTRIBUTES ............................................................................................................................... 10 APPROACH BY MATRIX ANALYSIS ...................................................................................................................... 10 STANDARDISE VS ADAPT.................................................................................................................................. 17 PRODUCT, SERVICE OR BRAND REPRESENTATION, DISTRIBUTION CHANNELS ............................................. 17 11 C ........................................................................................................................................................... 18 DISTRIBUTION NETWORK ................................................................................................................................. 20 Internal/external sales representatives ................................................................................................ 20 Agents ................................................................................................................................................... 21 Distributors ........................................................................................................................................... 26 Joint venture, local company ................................................................................................................ 29 OEM/Integrators .................................................................................................................................. 32 Global analysis ...................................................................................................................................... 33 SEGMENTATION .......................................................................................................................................... 35 CROSS-SECTION NORMALIZATION ...................................................................................................................... 36 TERRITORIAL NORMALIZATION .......................................................................................................................... 40 Players and principle of normalization ................................................................................................. 42 Normalizing document ......................................................................................................................... 43 EXPORT MODEL FOR COMPANIES....................................................................................................................... 44 PRACTICAL STEPS ........................................................................................................................................... 44 6 TERRITORIAL PROFILES .................................................................................................................................. 46 LOGISTICS .................................................................................................................................................... 48 TRANSPORT MODE EVALUATION ....................................................................................................................... 49 PACKING ...................................................................................................................................................... 50 VOLUMETRIC WEIGHTING ................................................................................................................................ 51 WARSAW CONVENTION .................................................................................................................................. 52 SDR value is determined by a set of currencies .................................................................................... 53 COMMON TERMS USED IN SHIPMENT ................................................................................................................. 53 Freight consolidation ............................................................................................................................ 53 Dangerous goods declaration............................................................................................................... 53 Door to door ......................................................................................................................................... 54 EUR1 ..................................................................................................................................................... 55 Commercial invoices or pro forma ........................................................................................................ 57 Incoterms .............................................................................................................................................. 57 Trans-shipment ..................................................................................................................................... 57 RULES AND BARRIERS FOR EXPORT ............................................................................................................. 58 EXPORT LICENSE ............................................................................................................................................ 61 TEMPORARY IMPORTS, TRANSIT ........................................................................................................................ 61 USE OF NATIONAL AGREEMENTS ....................................................................................................................... 62 CUSTOM CODES CHANGES, SUB-ASSEMBLIES ....................................................................................................... 62 EXPORT PRICING .......................................................................................................................................... 63 FOREIGN CURRENCIES ..................................................................................................................................... 63 Internal techniques ............................................................................................................................... 63 External techniques .............................................................................................................................. 64 LOCAL LIST PRICES .......................................................................................................................................... 65 FINANCIAL RISK COVERAGE .............................................................................................................................. 66 CONCLUSIONS ............................................................................................................................................. 67 Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 3 on 68
Numbers about Export With less than 0.2% of the worldwide population and a market share of 3.4% of export and 3% of Import, Belgium is ranking 10 th on the hit parade of Foreign trade for goods. Regarding Foreign trade for Services, it reaches 3.6% of market shares and gets to the 8 th place of the classification. Belgian exports are about: 20% of consumer goods, 58% of intermediate goods (equipment and material 28%) 22% of chemical and related goods
Type Worldwide ranking Diamonds and carpets 1 Vegetal fibers, Chocolate and fat (margarine) 2 Glass 3 Eggs, non alcoholic beverages 3 Cars 3 General trend of Belgian export Between 1993 and 2004, the overall value of our export has increased by 129% (3% in 2003-2004) 1 . During the same period, our imports increased by 134%, our GDP (Gross Domestic Product) by 53% with a value of 284 GEURfor exports amounting 246 G EUR. IN 1993, Belgian export were amounting 58% of GDP, this increased up to 87% in 2004. Belgium is highly dependent on its Foreign trade. Our country occupies rank number 10 for export volume with 3.4% of market shares. Import are ranking us on rank number 9. All proportions being equal, Belgium is exporting twice more than Germany and ten times than Japan does. The importance of this trade position can partially be explained by the central geographic position in Eutope, a globally well qualified labour, multilingual and productive. The Belgian Industrial sector can be compared to a complex machinery: it imports raw material and semi)finished goods, which are exported when processed. Regarding exports, we are just behind Canada, before Hong Kong, South Korea, Mexico, Russia, Singapore and Spain.
1 Taking into account inflation of 21%, this increase is in fact 101%. Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 4 on 68 If Belgium is exporting goods about everywhere, almost half of it is going to 3 of our main Trade partners: Germany (20%) o Cars, Cycles, Pharmaceutical & Chemical products, France (17%) o Machines, Mechanical equipment, Mineral fuel, Cast Iron and Steel However, export in direction of these countries has fewer increased than the total of our export 2 . Just after those 3, are: England (9%) o Cars, Cycles, Machines, Mechanical equipment, Pharmaceutical & Chemical products, USA (6.5%) o Pharmaceutical products, Chemical organic products; diamonds and gems, bullion, plated or layered metal
Exportation totale 100% EURO Zone 65% Other than EU 11% Europe non EU 7% Asia 9% USA 5% Table 1 - Shares by region, source diplomatic.be The largest expansion of export in our Foreign trades are: Poland o Chemical products of our industry, household appliances, Cars, Cycles, Machines, Mechanical equipment, Pharmaceutical & Chemical products, Plastics Ireland o Consumer appliances, transport material, Chemical and Pharmaceutical products, Food processing, Energy, other goods (29%) Turkey o Raw material and chemical products, Crude oil and Natural gas, machines and industrial equipment next to these to a minor extent, Canada, India, China, Sweden, Russia Finland
2 Probably partially explained by a growth limitation of these countries in respect to OECD average (2.7%) Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 5 on 68 Belgium has gained more market than the number it lost. Our export have seriously decreased in: Cuba, Indonesia Lybia Burundi It is interesting to see, that 3 countries out of this list have known issues on the International politics scene. One can question whether this is or not linked with the strengthening of Political relationship and interference of Foreign countries in Belgium which is, THE centre of Europe and therefore should lead the way to ethic but also could be seen by the said 3 countries as too close of adverse Foreign policies 3 . Rank in 2004 25 most Importing countries Abs value in 2004 (MdsEUR) % total in 2004 volution +% related to 2003 volution % related to 1993 Rank in 1993 1 Germany 48,67 19,75% 10,60% 122,00% 1 2 France 42,22 17,13% 8,30% 102,70% 2 3 The Netherlands 28,93 11,74% 9,30% 102,80% 3 4 United Kingdom 21,35 8,67% 3,90% 139,70% 4 5 United States of A. 16,06 6,52% 5,80% 242,50% 6 6 Italy 12,91 5,24% 6,90% 120,10% 5 7 Spain 9,6 3,90% 7,40% 216,30% 7 8 Luxemburg 4,84 1,97% 14,80% 90,20% 8 9 India 4,26 1,73% 10,70% 171,10% 11 10 Sweden 3,36 1,36% 6,50% 166,40% 12 11 Isral 2,9 1,18% 23,80% 45,20% 10 12 Japan 2,7 1,10% 22,60% 137,00% 14 13 Austria 2,69 1,09% 13,10% 135,30% 13 14 Switzerland 2,65 1,07% 0,40% 26,60% 9 15 Poland 2,49 1,01% 24,90% 431,50% 25 16 Turkey 2,47 1,00% 27,80% 338,10% 21 17 China 2,35 0,96% 3,60% 302,30% 20 18 Denmark 1,97 0,80% 9,00% 102,10% 15 19 Ireland 1,85 0,75% 22,70% 374,90% 28 20 Hong-kong 1,65 0,67% 5,00% 96,50% 17 21 Russia 1,65 0,67% 26,20% 239,70% 23 22 Geece 1,64 0,67% 13,90% 164,80% 19 23 Portugal 1,57 0,64% 9,50% 63,30% 16 24 Canada 1,48 0,60% 1,00% 299,30% 30 25 Finland 1,42 0,57% 13,70% 226,50% 27 Belgian Export total 246,41 100,00% 9,10% 128,60% Table 2 - Export evolution 1993-2004 source "Institut des Comptes nationaux 2005"
3 However the Political risk is high and exacerbated by recent Nuclear moves, Iran is not a place where our export have particularly decreased because we are not very present there. By contrast Iran is highly exporting to us (Benelux) Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 6 on 68
(a) GDP evolution fixed price in EUROS linked to 2006. (b) Domestic household expenses growth in EUROS linked to 2006: expenses of household and non profit institutions (c) Growth of Public administration expenses in EUROS linked to 2006 (d) Contrinution to GDP evolution. (e) Uncorrected data with calendar incidences. (f) Annual mean value. (g) Estimations (but inflation).
Table 1 - Evolution of Indicators source "Institut des Comptes nationaux 2008"
Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 7 on 68 Context for Export A country is becoming an exporting country when one of the following condition is met at least: Internal resources are in excess compared to the domestic use and necessity Unique internal resources that is used/necessary to foreign countries Services or goods which value is recognized and highly valued outside of the territory Has a transformation industry which can convert raw material into more complex products Limited internal resources in some fields which starts an exchange of products by import, Needs for foreign currencies to compensate the import needs.
Export will in return be negatively affected by: Import barriers set up for political, economical or demographic reasons, Downturn of the evolution of foreign currencies and the local economy of the importing country, Foreign competition, Political and economical context of the exporting country, Financing of Exportation
Necessary tools to help or allow export are: Restriction of customs barriers, Restriction of political and military conflicts, Geographical position and transport infrastructure, National politics, Bank system and funds transfer.
Export oriented structure An export company, must not only control its own market but also has to know all elements here above described (see Context for Export) PRIOR to starting to export. In a way, all products can be exported but the ratio of spent energy on potential revenue, must be lower than 1 on pain of eating all revenues and margins raked in by the domestic business.
Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 8 on 68 When working out the energy value, one has to take: Distribution costs in a foreign country, Transportation costs, Modification and adaptation costs: o Customization in order to adapt to the territory, o Specific Certification and agreements to conform to the territory, o Costs of a modified range of products compared to the volume, Financial costs, o exchanges rate costs, foreign currencies management costs, o assurances and cover, o bank and customs guarantees, Tangible assets costs and management,
Without human and material resources, it is illusory to believe export can be a success. Set up of an export structure The structure of an export company requires specific setting. Indeed, export not only requires a rigorous administration but also external relays whose capacity will very soon turn the steps into success or disaster. The ideal export company will at least embed: a sound and strong administrative department including finance and banking consultancy, a specific Sales (Commercial) department, a logistics/shipping department
While smaller structure will need to outsource them because of costs, larger structures will also require: a legal and contract writing/survey department, a technology watch and patent activity,
Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 9 on 68 Products for export The main difference between products sold on a domestic market and those how are in destination of foreign markets, is that the latter will have to cover needs of consumers/clients of various origins, which identification, approach, and preliminary qualification are to be achieved for succeeding the export operations. In most of the cases, the product will have to conform to local image in order to be adopted which will be supported by marketing actions which will model aspects (color change of packing for instance), naming (numbers instead of model name for cars in China for instance), etc . All these modifications will induce extra costs which will have to be weighted and if possible supported either by: the domestic market in all or partly when export is essentially a strategic move, or the product itself when margins are sufficient.
We will speak in the following chapter about resources and potential of the company: the product being in final the reason of the export decision.
Besides practical and technical details, export potential of a product, essentially depends upon the image (has to be understood as usefulness, visibility, existing appropriateness or to be created) on the territory. The image is then a digest of: product or trademark representation, uses and necessity of the product, availability of the product on the territory; competitive economical criteria, social or cultural values, legal and tax data. Regarding product export, two main case have to be considered: the product is already existing on the market of export, or the product is created to be exported as it has no existence on the market. Not depending on that, purchase of a product is always linked with envy or usage, whichever is the territory. Product selection For existing products, it is necessary to fit the product to be exported with one or several criteria, on pain of not meeting consumer needs or not getting the revenue from the market to the level of expectation.
Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 10 on 68 Approach by attributes When fitting a product to an export market, the attribute approach is a good synthesis approach. Three main product attributes can be defined: Physical Outside appearance and presentation of the product including but not limited to packaging, design, o Service Usage, ergonomics, support and customer service, guarantee, o Symbolic All elements linked with the culture, custom or religion. Some of the physical attributes will exclusively be chosen because of the particular symbol that they represent in the export region. It is also important to note that not all product of a series, can be exported. It is necessary to chose taking into account ration of energy to return of profit, all resource and external constraints, the potential carrying out and other factors.
Approach by Matrix analysis Another interesting approach for SMEs is the matrix analysis. Among these, defining segments, strategy and portfolio: BCG ADL Mc Kinsey Last but not least, Ansoff matrix which is the most appropriate to deal with growth. BCG (Boston Consulting Group) is based on the theory of the life cycle of the product. It aims to positioning in strategic segments in relationship to competition. This two dimension matrix, puts in relation market shares of a company and growth rate potential. The basic objectives of the BCG approach is to assign naturally limited resources on an optimum way to the company, segments, products and activities in order to acquire then confirm a competitive position.
Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 11 on 68
Celebrity or Stars: bring a strong growth and a large market share. The strategy to use is to massively fund in order to keep current position. With progressive market saturation, stars will one day become milk cows, Milk cows: in a slowing down market, they have a relatively strong market share. On a strategic point of view, their position need to be held, cash needs to be generated to find other product of a same brand, and in particular dilemma products, Dilemma: in a fast growing market, are holding a small market share. Veru strong competition on the business, it has to analyze why the product is not capturing more shares. It might also decide to allocate more finance to convert dilemma into stars, Dead weight: products holding small market shares in a declining market. The business has lots of difficulties to keep dead weight products alive. The question is then whether it wouldn't be preferable to remove them from the market
Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 12 on 68
Pitfalls to avoid about this method are:
on a non domestic market, the set up of this matrix will call for a very accurate market study in order to avoid subjective or fanciful values which might lead to a wrong choice, collecting this type of information on a new market is particularly difficult moreover for a new product, a dead weight product on a domestic market may have a second life on a new market, but this can only be determined by an objective approach. A BCG matrix doesn't have to be started on domestic data, When determining interesting products for foreign market using the BCG matrix,, the weak point of this method lies in the fact that it states that a product having small market shares will not be interested to market while it is always the case when introducing a new product (non existing, invention)
Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 13 on 68 The ADL Matrix is analyzing the product portfolio taking into account assets and attractions represented in the sector in which it evolves taking into account life cycle.
This model leads to general decisions for a defined portfolio but this is easily transferable to one product.
For instance, it can be deducted that instead of reorienting the business or the portfolio, it might be decided to redefine the product or to select another (abandon).
Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 14 on 68
Regarding larger structures which can appoint consultants resources, Mc Kinsey matrix allows to focus not on the share of the product (business), but adds other values, economical, distribution channels, etc. . It's a BCG matrix with more options and fine tuning possibilities but it is less easy to put in place by SMEs.
Image, source Eur-Export
1 Strategic products bringing the business a dominating position 2 Tactical products in order to keep a position, a flag branding 2' Tactical product but business is not strong enough to sustain it 3 Loosing products but when multiple market can together produce revenue
Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 15 on 68 The last matrix we'll speak about is ANSOFF's matrix. This matrix proposes strategic choices to reach growth expectations when the product is selected.
Figure 1 - Ansoff Matrix Ansoff's matrix is proposing four growth strategies: By Product development o New characteristics o Different versions with different qualities o New models By Market development o Increase of purchase level of actual clients o Capture of competition's clients o Find New Customers By Market opening o Geographical development of Markets o Adaptation of products to new segments o Development of new distribution routes By Diversification o New products on new markets o Add products or services by Own developments Alliances and distributions Strategic acquisitions Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 16 on 68
Figure 2 - Matrix roles
Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 17 on 68 Standardise vs Adapt When the product we want to export is already in a series active in a given market, it might be beneficial to export it as it is as long as it fulfils detected needs and local regulations. When choosing to standardise, the economical criteria is the dominant factor as it helps avoiding: management of different versions and variant of a product, stock and inventory management of a multiplicity of products, information and documentary management of new products
Adaptation may in return be the only answer mostly when local regulations (tax, import, technical, rules,) are in force in the territory of export. There are two different type of adaptations, adaptation by technical conformation, and commercial adaptation. When performing the marketing/commercial survey/study , these two aspects have to be entered soon enough to allow the business understanding and preparing the necessary resources to succeed.
The most important adaptation to define in time is the technical conformation adaptation because it will be the main and only possibility to start selling a product or service in the country while the commercial adaptation will "only" be something helping or restricting the success of the sales in the said market. Product, Service or Brand representation, Distribution channels It is impossible to succeed to export without being visible. Either the product has to be visible or the Company. When a product to introduce is already existing under another shape or brand in the export market, the visibility of the product is essentially depending upon its status in the market. Businesses or trademarks present in a market will have built a typical local image and the newcomers will benefit/inherit of the same image at least on the early days of export. It is however obvious that the success of a product in a market will depend on the speed to reach the final customer. This in itself says that distribution channels will have to be selected in function of the demanding structure (supplier, manufacturer), the type of product/service (capital equipment, retail product, ..), territory/country specificities and the energy available or agreed to spend When speaking about export, Distribution is what make a product available: outside of its usual space (Spatial transformation), within a defined timeframe to be commercialised (Time transformation) in defined quantities and availabilities (Availability functions) under the necessary shape (Appropriation function) with the smallest loss as possible (Financial function)
Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 18 on 68 11 C An interesting approach for the selection of Ditribution channels has been brought by MM. M.E Czinkota & I.A Ronkainen 4 . When selecting a channel to operate the distribution of its products, a business will have to take care of 11 C points: Customer characteristics, Culture, Competition, Company objectives, Character of the market, Coverage needed/expected, Control issues, Continuity provided, Communication effectiveness
Customer is the target to hit and the one who will do the sales target. His characteristics have to be well defined in order to confirm the product to his needs and expectations. The distribution channel needs to know the target, be accessible to it (for instance on a geographic basis), and has to be identified by the target as able to provide the product/service
Local culture is what will shape the characteristics or even the look of the product to export. It is essential when speaking about 1 st necessity or "heart" (feeling) product
When the product has already entered the market with another player, competition is already in place and has defined its own tracks. The customer is used to a product, a supplier and has set all rules that are applicable. By knowing the Competition in the place, the newcomer will save energy and costs. A lot of errors can be avoided this way and by knowing in deep the distribution channel.
Setting the Company objectives will bring the basis for the right selection of Distribution Channels. Depending on ambitions, means, products and objectives, distribution will follow different routes. When Consolidation is foreseen, the distribution channel will be selected accordingly.
As well as the local culture, character of the market will be shaping the product or service and obviously the Distribution channel. Supply chains and purchase channels will determine which distribution channel will be the most appropriate. This is highly dependent on the infrastructure and equipment of the country. A country with a dense net of roads and a good level of equipment/revenue, will not be considered with the same methods as with another less well equipped country.
With the definition of business objectives, is also the definition of expected revenues that are related to the market coverage. Distribution channels may have a strong impact on this aspect as it may induce big costs on the product and therefore may impact profit or sales price. Most expensive solutions are not always the best and they must be adapted to available margins, type of products, and other elements as described in this chapter. The finance influence ratio between Supplier and Distribution channel have to be properly set in order to stay in line with objectives.
4 Michael R. Czinkota and Ikka A. Ronkainen (2003), 'An International Marketing Manifesto'
Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 19 on 68
Assets to fix to build the sales channel on a foreign territory will certainly depend on the territory but also on the chosen solution. Sometimes, it is necessary to accept losses in the first fiscal years if it helps building a better long term solution.
Control on operations or better not losing it, is a key factor for improving the lifecycle of the product that is exported. If own forces are not sent on the territory to survey operations, the distribution channel needs to be correctly selected in order to guarantee that there will be limited drifts in the policy in place. A Survey system will require to be in line with the resources available to the company and that the expenses related are affordable and proportional to the product value/revenue. This will impact the return value of the export
If we look for a seasonal or timely defined sales only 5 , duration is the main criteria when selecting a network. Indeed the channel will have to show a stable contact point in order not to frighten the target and give him the assurance he will be able to find a regular and long lasting supply point for getting the product or service. Continuity is the goal when selecting the distribution channel in this very case. Because this is a long term work, securing the channel is essential because not only the fact that a diverted channel will create a very strong competition but also that all energy spent will be lost in vain.
To assure that energy will be efficiently spent, communication (quality, quantity) must be privileged at all time. When due to local reasons, communication is difficult (language barriers, contact infrastructure slow or weak, ) problems will always be shown as related to that while in general problems are more important and need to be tracked as soon as possible. Ignoring this will generate survey and translation costs that might create a real barrier to product and service distribution. It is an essential condition that when starting with a distribution structure, people in contact are to be understood and need to understand each other. If for any reason, they are removed or leave, they need to be replaced as soon as possible by an equivalent solution available inside the structure and not outside by preference.
5 Opposing to a one shot/seasonal sales, is the regular sales which looks for a sales that covers a recurring need or which sales is not covering an isolated or time defined need. Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 20 on 68 Distribution network When the product/service has been created or defined, the most important will be to bring it to the target in an optimum condition for the target or the business taking into account the product.
Following are the main distribution channels that we will discuss: Internal sales representative, Agents, Distributors Joint ventures
Internal/ external sales representatives The company has its own sales forces specialised in the territory of exercise. Sales representatives are located in the registered office which will generate large travel expenses when operating abroad. When the company is operating on different platforms 6 , it is necessary to recruit personnel able to deal with the corresponding platforms. The territorial segmentation is then the only answer for saving on personnel costs and in order to group forces.
6 Platforms are a group of territories which have the same geographic, ethnic, social, economic, or commercial characteristics, see the corresponding Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 21 on 68 Strength Sales representatives are training by the company and therefore are the best force able to represent the product Information channel is straight and direct, return is interested because the Sales representative is paid by the company, Complete control over costs, and contact to customers
Strength Travel expenses Sales representative is a foreigner on the territory, it only has a temporary presence, Truncated or limited vision on the territory
Agents
Agents are the local representatives designated by the company. They are recruited or found regarding their capacity to represent the Company and hit the targets assigned in one or several sectors. They are given one product or an entire series with the responsibly of the contact with the end user. There are two main options. Invoicing is made to the agent:
Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 22 on 68 The second part of the alternative is a healthier one in terms of managing final pricing, that is invoicing to the end user: Quotation Gross Price Purchase order Gross Price Company Quotation Gross Price $ $ Payment Gross Price $ $ Commission Customer Area n Agent Sales representatives Sales Rep Area n Sales Rep Area n+1 Sales Rep Area n+x Invoice Gross Price
Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 23 on 68 This second option is preferable because: final customer is identified and maybe followed afterward, financial instruments and conditions, exact control over final pricing because stated as raw market price or raw price increased by a margin coverage, the commission payment to the agent can be against payment of the main invoice by the customer, the agent is responsible of the payment of the customer to get his commission. Inconvenient of this option are: financial load is on the company and not on the agent, agent will not be inclined to collect funds to the customer if the commission level is lower that its own interests 7
The Agent must have a representative contract and a representing letter to prove the legitimacy of the agent to the customers without having to show the contract which embeds private contractual data. The second advantage of the representation letter is that it may renew on a periodic basis the declaration of the said representation to customers and it is also a good way to force parties to consider the extent and situation of their relationship. This is a genuine and enlisting sign which is highly appreciated mostly in Arabic and African countries. Not considering a Business's strategy, whether the agent has or not to be given one or multiple sector is a question where the potential business level has an influence but also the available resources of the agent. When the agent is not getting enough revenue to feed his resources, he will not be able to address resources, will slowly divert from the product to go for more rewarding or funding products or will simply cease his activity. However, for products which may be sold to different sectors in a same country, it will not be common to find a unique agent covering already all sectors if they are many and varied. When a new sector needs to be developed, it is necessary to measure which impact on the base turnover will have the energy needed by the agent to diversify and operate in a new sector. If the existing agent is having sufficient resources to drive more than his nominal sector, this has to be the preferred route because it reinforces the links and financial interests between parties. This may increase the turnover and the importance of having the representation of the company. If the resources are already fully addressed by the product or by other cards of representation, the agent might be spending his energy to the new sector while another existing player in the new sector will naturally be ready to develop the market and add revenue to the company instead of replacing a portion of the existing one. If the sector-based approach hasn't been defined from start, it will be very difficult to set it without breaking the initial contract signed with the agent which is in general generating compensation expenses or call for a mutual agreement at least
7 Depending on the size of business that is given in the hands of the agent, he will carry other brands or products meaning that if the same customer is served also in these other products interests in "chasing" customer's payment can be conflictual for his own interests Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 24 on 68 For durability, it is also important to remember that the relative outside financial value of the agent will depend on the number of representation he holds, he will fight hard to keep products and sectors. It is then a question of establishing a very strong and well defined contract in which fair exit doors are possible. For specific products and sectors (military, nuclear, food, ..) it might be mandatory to nominate an agent in a country because he will act as the legal representative for any concerns or liability with the product. Card blockers
Card blockers are something very frequent in the export business and it has to be observed very carefully. Two profiles are existing: Because Assets of an agent are essentially the cards he holds, some agents are collecting cards and this way to generate a fake value to their business. This may be in view of selling their business or to proceed to other operations where they need to prove a certain business size. They will then not do any sales or promotion efforts because the main reason is not it. Some agents have several business with different registered offices which they use to separate competing products they ask to hold and that are not agreed by individual contracts. This second profile deserves a closer look. An agent playing on different companies, have 100% chances to answer demands and requests on a market even if the required products are made by the compatition. Another very frequent reason of doing that is that the agent has then a price and lead time lever to satisfy his needs and interests (always saying that it is his customer's interest). The agent who holds companies Agent.A and Agent.B is asking supplier.A who gives a price of 100 with a delivery time of 2 weeks. He then goes to Supplier.B and negotiate prices while speaking about volume or market shares until he gets what he wants. Sometimes Agent.A sells by preference products from Supplier.A while customers have been sent by Supplier.B to Agent.B who in fact transferred the request to Agent.A
There is rarely a sufficient septation in business to prevent from financial, (price, reductions, arguments..) to be shared amongst different product lines. This is the main reason for avoiding competition in same hands and moreover having two businesses held by the same agent with competing products. This situation is frequent when commission fees are higher from one supplier to another or when links (shareholders, relationship, personal, ) are existing between the Agent and the Supplier. If this fact is illegal according to signed contracts, it is becoming legal when legal entities are different and the relationship informal and private.
Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 25 on 68 Visible criteria which are announcing this kind of situation are : - A dominant position in a market where it is known that several products are in competitions for years - Volatile market where the loyalty to the trade name is not the use - Introduction of a new product with a selling price which is not competitive, this will require much more efforts than for an existing renown product - A highly spread and diffused structure (which is frequent in Russia) with companies outside of the country - Sales results not in line with projections and expectations while competition is already showing good results with the agents.B who has(unsuspected) links with agents.A - Financial links (or even a common structure) between competing suppliers and the agent In order to see whether we are in this case, only frequent visits are efficient. It's also possible provided commercial efforts to reward customers to get evidences of bad practices by collecting quotations, communications or other sales that the agent would have done in prejudice of your product violating his contract. Despite these potential risks, agent's representation remains the best way to get a permanent local representation as this provides the best source of knowledge of local uses and trends without being forced to set up its own company. Strengths: - Agents are independent from the company, therefore are not a source of permanent financial load. Their load depends on their sales (commission on sales) - Invoicing is done by the company to the final client in general and very often the commission is due only after payment of these invoices. - Local representation with a permanent contact point. Representation expenses are covered by the commission on a temporary basis. One can accept a starting package which would be independent from the sales but this must be well framed and via precise objectives. Weaknesses : - Territory is seen only through the eyes of the agency - Success is only depending on agent's interest, meaning that the less easy to sell product are the less followed and proposed when the agent embeds multiple lines of products - The agent doesn't know at all the company, it is then essential to provide him with frequent information as he cannot sell products he doesn't know - Financial load is on the manufacturer whose only lever is the commission but the level must be sufficient to stimulate the agent to collect the money in case of bad debt. - Frequent visits to motivate troops and support the agent, therefore there will be a load to plan Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 26 on 68 Distributors Distributors are similar to agents but are also importing the products that they can store for distributing to the local target. They are the legal shield between the end user and the producer. They are assuring the supply and they do the invoicing to the target. Distributors invest into a minimum stock that he is financing in part (consignment or fully depending on the contract). In general he gets his goods to a preferred price and does not get a commission on sales. Depending on the terms of his contract, he is then able to state the market price and gets his own revenue from the difference. For that reason, distributor must have a very particular profile, not only in his structure but also in his assets. He must have a clean and sufficient supporting financial structure to get the load related to the stock and inventory. (in this are also import duties). 8 He must have a building able to store the inventory, tools for stock management, packing and shipment if necessary, as well as the personnel able to take care of the product. Purchase order Nett Price Company Invoice Nett Price Shop Area n Shop Area n+x Distributor Customer Area n Purchase order Nett Price Customer Area n Order Nett Price Invoice Gross Price $ $ Payment Gross Price Order Gross Price Order Gross Price Invoice Gross Price Invoice Nett Price Invoice Nett Price
8 Some products will be covered under a temporary import, it will then be necessary to have specific relationship with the local government/tax office in order to get this temporary status. Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 27 on 68 This distribution channel is preferred when operating volume sales or when the import of a product requires a local headquarter. The distributor must have a contract defining his rights and duties and is also the legal representative for all implications related to the product. His inventory might be suggested or imposed in own acquisition or on consignment. The major risk that exist with independent distributors is the creation of a parallel market for instance for spare parts. The distributor must buy his product from a unique supplier with a fixed price. In the list of spares and spare parts, there are dedicated and undedicated parts. The dedicated parts are those made and produced by the manufacturer, these parts are specific to the product and their price cannot be compared to another component existing outside of the supply chain. The dedicated parts or own parts are those produced by the manufacturer and for which none alternative are in existence. This gives the manufacturer two advantages and one inconvenient. Advantages : Spares are a guaranteed revenue Economic value doesn't exist because there is no point of references 9
Inconvenient : The manufacturer has the obligation to keep going the manufacturing and the stocking of the production tool in order to keep the components on stock. This includes the human resources. The undedicated parts are those generally not produced by the manufacturer and used as such to be incorporated in the final product. These components can be supplied by the local market. It must be noted that the manufacturer states the selling price of these components including several factors : minimum stock, cost of supplies, delays and deliveries, wearing and necessity. On the other side, the final customer only sees the components and in his quality/price ratio analysis, he will ignore the external factors. Therefore the sales potential of these components, if they are known to the public, will be lower or potential margins will be reduced. Distributors are then tempted to get their spare parts outside of the official manufacturer in order to get a better purchase price to match the local selling price or get a sufficient margin from the product. For sure, contracts must state that this is forbidden but we must be realistic that this exists in the distribution circuit. The last point to mention on the economic value of the product is that it depends on a market. For a market known for the quality of the local production, for instance computers, it is unrealistic to think that you can sell a computer to the price you have in a country where they are imported.
9 For incorporated or bought components, the manufacturer will modify them in order that they won't too clearly be looking as existing ones. Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 28 on 68 The market price strategy has to be taken into consideration because it may bring two direct potential consequences. If local prices is too high, this will kill the sales potential, if the market price is too low, it will not generate margins where and when it is possible 10 In order to limit this problem, the supplier/manufacturer will have to decide different actions : State that there is only one source of supply (the manufacturer) Specify that price information from the market is necessary and this for the two categories of components Be protective to the information about the origin of his components by removing any identification tags that wouldn't be his. Survey the order level, mostly in all the spares in respect with the wearing known in the local market or in foreign market 11
In the undedicated components, fix reasonable sales price, moreover when the component can be easily compared to another supplier When the purchase level is sufficient, get better discount from his own supplier in order that the final price would be very close to a regular customer price. Strengths : Distributors are independent therefore without permanent financial load to the company They are ( in principle) supposed to have a buffer stock to supply the targets which transfers the financial load. > Bear in mind tax considerations Local representation with a permanent contact point : this way they are showing a larger image than real For the auto promoted products (those which are named and asked by the customer by their trade names), the identity of the distributor is not the key point, it is the availability. Weaknesses : No straight access to the target. The product must be known in the territory before its distributor, it must be called by the target. It's the marketing of the product which will give the success of it. This marketing is a load to the manufacturer. The distributor doesn't provide an after sale service or a guarantee of exchange. This structure has to be set and managed by an independent structure which is fed in components by the distributor. Because of the legal status of the distributor, the breaking of a contract is in general more complex. He doesn't know the compoany at all, his information must be frequent and essential, he cannot propose or set up an inventory of products he wouldn't know.
10 The price is based on the trinomial relationship cost/demand/competition. It is necessary to build a margin reserve when it's possible because there are possibilities of market saturation, uses but also competition. 11 There is no reason that the wear of some components would be higher in some territories than in other but if there are, social, technical or environmental specificities Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 29 on 68 Joint venture, local company We will only speak about reasons for choices and usual problems, but it's very difficult to envisage all cases on a practical side because it really depends on country and places where it is set. The joint venture is an association made with the local partner for the representation of a company or product in a country or a territory. A joint venture, when it's not the only legal accepted solution, is a way to involve a local player with the manufacturer, the supplier who wants to sell on a given country or territory. The principle is simple, a foreign company X is joining another company or people to develop a local activity. The association is made ether through the creation of a new legal entity which associates several existing entities or by the venue of a new entity into an existing structure. The given shares are ether determined by transfer of competences/business/portfolio or by a classic shares' purchase.
Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 30 on 68 It must be said that joint ventures are essentially promoted by newly industrialized countries who want to bring in technologies and international investments. It is very important not to forget that in most of the cases, the ownership of the distribution tool is common and in case of an economical or political instability, you are placed in a foreign territory with all that it involves in terms of rights. It is very seldom that the foreign company holds the majority of shares. It has to go through a local whose loyalty has to be proven because he will be able at all time to pay on it's own as he owns the majority of shares. It is essential to do the right choice of a partner and it is very frequent that this partner has opposing interests without declaring them and this in order to get more control over the market. It is necessary for this type of network that engaged interests are limited in all times and be ready to bad return if financial controls and relationship controls are not in place and used. On a view points of finance and taxes, it is an extension of the existing structure of a supplier and this will have an impact on the accounts because there is an asset added to the structure. Still on the finance side, it is not very seldom that the funds collected by Joint Ventures in their operations and profit generated cannot be brought out of the country but only under certain conditions. This may oblige companies to continue their investment in the country with these funds which is not sometimes something that they want. In case of chaos, funds and assets are generally frozen and locked in the country. Therefore it is impossible to get them back to the mother company. Finally, a very important impact on the international distribution of a product Is the origin of the national branding or the origin of the product. This is highly sensible in deluxe products Some researchers 12 are showing that "end users can integrate the origin information to perform their evaluation, using characteristics or images associated to the country of origin 13 . Mostly when they are no other informative attribute. This concerns the general evaluation of products or specific categories of products. (It's the "Match" concept put forward by "Roth and Romeo, 1992). For example, it may be seen that the label "Made in Germany" is increasing the evaluation of a car but negatively the fact the evaluation of a robe compared with the label "Made in Italy". Some countries can then have a very good reputation for some products : Japan and Germany for cars, US for jeans, cigarettes, France for wines, perfumes and deluxe products."
12 Maxime KOROMYSLOV - Univ de Nancy - Cahier de recherche 2007-01 13 Limage du pays peut elle-mme tre cre par des produits reprsentatifs, les caractristiques nationales, lhistoire avec le pass conomique ou politique du pays et ses traditions culturelles (Nagashima, 1970) Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 31 on 68 The creation of a joint venture on top of allowing the removal of national barriers, logistics or supply chains, will play on two other levels : National integration for the promotion of the service attribute of the product which is necessary for a product with a long life The national reputation of the product in distribution or production which will particularly in the developing countries be seen as essential as a local product do not have the sufficient reputation. Strength : Owned tool meaning a better implication If local production : better conformity and acceptance for the product as well as costs Local representation with a permanent local point which shows an important visible surface Additional asset Weaknesses : Direct financial load with profit and loss risks When the manufacturer is not in majority, when the country stability is not good, big risks regarding structure and funds distribution. Decentralized management New structure meaning advertisement to the target
Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 32 on 68 OEM/ Integrators This last distribution channel is more like a particular category of targets but it is necessary and preferable to define it like a channel but like a customer. The risk is that the potential margin of this type of channels is too low to go through an agent. This channel may only exists for products which may be integrated to larger assemblies or for products which naming or initial identity are changed in order to satisfy a specific commercial strategy of an existing market to the other product. It is very often the case that a market is getting two or more versions of a same product. This allows to attack different segments or sectors by creating a fake competition. In order to succeed that, it is necessary to distribute over two distingue channel which are then in competition. One of the two products will be modified mostly in its aspect or in some of its characteristics. The target has then the choice between two identical versions but under a different trade name or between two versions with different characteristics but also different trade names. This principle is very often used to sell a product on a same market for two different segments. The OEM/Integrator channel is particularly well dedicated to this strategy. The OEM/Integrator channel uses an existing business with one or multiple products in general in the same sector as the received product. This structure produces more less often only distribute products coming from a distribution card to build his own market without spending money in technology or research and development. It imports in his range a product that he has detected the needs in his market. If the product is seasonal or opportunist, this allows them to free their cash and to stay in a niche. If the product is complex, this allows to free resources for development to focus on distribution or objectives. The OEM is a specific kind of distributor because he is stocking a product during its transformation even if this stocking can be of a short duration. The creation of an OEM channel presupposes that an NDA 14 agreement is in existence between parties because the level of information exchange is such that it must allow the OEM to have a sufficient technical knowledge to operate alone in its own product and in the support of the integrated components. Without an NDA, it would be very easy for the OEM to decide shortly after, to let down the manufacturer and start producing his own products based on the information he has received. On the producer side, the integrated OEM product must flow through a specific production and management channel because this product will be on the market under the responsibility of the one who has produced them. But with specific agreement, the load must not be on the shoulder of the official network who distributes the product under the original shape or name but it must be clearly addressed to the local producer. If a product delivered under a different form or name comes back to the original manufacturer and not the OEM, that means that the information about the true origin of the elements has passed to the target. It is absolutely necessary to take measures to avoid it as it can completely destroy the strategy in place as well as the relationship with the OEM.
14 Non Disclosure Agreement Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 33 on 68 It is necessary to understand that this leak of information might be organized by either the target or the OEM, to generate a reason for a contract exit with a breach of agreement. They might invoke disloyalty or unfair actions because the product, sometimes sold to a higher price than the original product, cannot be proposed anymore to the sales under the OEM form and price. The appointment of an OEM will then be the consequence of a clear strategy and displayed to the other channels in order to protect all interests and not only the one who organized it. Strength : Production under another name than the original one Creation of a new image which might also be valued Additional volume production with stocking to the OEM and integrator Weaknesses : No direct promotion of the brand, echo representation No direct access to target If the resulting product has a bad reputation, the integrated product might suffer Absolutely no influence on a voluntary shut of the market. Risks on intellectual property. Global analysis If agents and distributors are depending the cards they hold for their value, they are also, when you choose them, the unique filter. They have full power over the card and its success in a territory. It is highly advisable to have set control doors and exit doors which have to be used when the balance is not true anymore because the more the situation will last, the more difficult it will be to reset it. Foot in the door policy 15
JV and OEM channels will be more related to the strategy and resources of the company. They will need a supporting structure which will be much more important. It is obvious that those two last ones are knowledge export on top of product export. In this case, it is essential that the contractual conditions are well set and can be enforced in case of problems which is not always the case in countries where democratic liberties and freedom of markets are not existing.
15 FREEDMAN,J.L. 1 FRASER, S.C. (1966) Compliance without pressure : The foot in the door technique Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 34 on 68 11C Power Matrix vs Distribution Channels Int/Ext Rep Agent Distributor Joint Venture OEM/Integrator Customer characteristics 3 8 8 6 16 8 Culture 4 8 8 8 7 Competition 5 6 5 5 7 Company objectives 8 6 6 8 3 Character of the Market 3 7 7 7 7 Costs 4 17 7 8 3 7 Capital required 4 18 7 7 3 7 Coverage needed 3 19 5 20 5 5 5 Control issues 9 4 4 7 3 21
Continuity provided 9 5 5 8 22 3 23
Communication effectiveness 9 6 24 5 7 3 25
Where 1 Poor 5 Average 10 Best solution
16 Depends on the initial existence of the product on the market and not of the origin of the company 17 The ratio cost/operation is less good than for an operation that you only pay based on the result like to the agent for instance 18 No investment but fixed social costs and infrastructure support 19 Here again, the ration efficiency is the target but by multiplying the numbers you can get a larger coverage 20 Depends on the agent's structure which is here considered as operating from a single place in a large country 21 Only control over the quality of products and not on results 22 Control only over the life time because owner but this in return does not guarantee the continuity 23 Always subject to a one side change of strategy 24 To be compared with a communication with internal sales rep 25 Not useful if there is a distinction between the original product and the OEM product Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 35 on 68 By analyzing potential given by each channel but this time but this times by advantages and inconvenient, this gives the following table
Type Advantage Inconvenient Internal sales rep Fixed costs and directs Has to learn the market, always a foreigner in transit Agent Fixed market price, knows the identity of the target Sales is on the back of the supplier Distributor Stock and payments Final end user unknown OEM/Integrators Volume and new markets Limited export problems No advertisement for the brand Low prices Joint Ventures Own structure for limited costs (depending on territories) Local involvement Shared ownership Foreigner
Segmentation Whether it is on a domestic market or an export market, it is necessary to know the segmentation of its market and to normalized to the best differences in order to use the energy to the best to get the targets where they are located with the appropriate approach. In order to do so, one must normalized two important aspects of the distribution. Two aspects will be seen hereafter : - Cross-section normalization - Territorial normalization The cross-section normalization tries for a given product to gather different industrial service or activities, and to name them as sectors. The territorial normalization tries to link different territories together and to define common characteristics which are allowing a more rational and economical approach.
Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 36 on 68 Cross-section normalization It's the Scottish economist Colin Clark who has the ide to define three main economical sectors depending on the nature of the industry - Primary sector which involves collection and exploitation of natural resources (material, energy, and some food); - Secondary sector which concerns manufacturing and transformation industries - Third sector which groups service industries (essentially non material : consulting, insurances, training, research, administration,) This classification is not rigid. For example : agriculture was classified as a secondary sector (the cultivator transforms seeds into food, for example) by opposition to hunting and picking. Cross-section normalization that we want to speak about has nothing to see with that classification because to be useful to us, it cannot be a classification which uses all products in a bulk. The information that a company is belonging to a secondary sector, for instance a casting industry, is not giving us a distribution of the target it serves which can be for instance the automotive industry, shipyards or even furniture. When exporting, we have insisted on the benefits of a serious market study but to be efficient it needs to take into account the sectors applicable to the product. The definition of these sectors and their existence is therefore essential not only in generic terms but in very precise terms oriented towards the product, his sector application without forgetting the sectors to be developed. Market study devoted to export will concentrate essentially on the precise identification of sectors then on the definition of market shares expected in regards of these sectors. When selecting distribution channels this segmentation will define whether it is necessary to recruit one or several actors to cover all the sectors discovered. For the company needs, sectors will be defined in function of the application targets for the use of a specific product. A sector will then be characterized by the criteria which are specific to it and which allows a similar treatment when speaking about the minimum regulatory or commercial approach. Categorizing will indeed bring a certain level of normalizing which will be used to delimit and define the field of activity of the distribution channels. To succeed this, one must fix a similarity of latitude which once passed will generate a new category. This work will also allow to focus resources on a more efficient way and to decide what deserves or what can be exported in the defined territories.
Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 37 on 68 Taking into example a simple product like leather : you can find different sector based categories : - Furniture - Clothing - Automotive and aeronautics' equipment - Leisure - Industry, transmission These different sectors can be supplied at an end user level or intermediate distribution channels will however be different as well as potential in regards with the export destination. When potential activities have been determined for the product, it is necessary to evaluate the relative potential on the territory. This evaluation can be done by a specialized independent company but these have their own sector based analysis. It is therefore necessary to adapt his own vision to the closest to the segments otherwise results will not be close to the expectations. The other option is to use local companies already holding the card related to a product but it is necessary to check that they are representing all sectors. The local economic representative can be used as he is operating through all sectors and has a global vision. The last potential can be seen in the electronic information that are on line and visible through a connection but it is highly recommended that these information must be crossed checked mostly when they concern developing countries because these are mostly wishes than realities. Statistics than can be viewed throughout these websites are unoften expressed as an application and are generally to general to be exploited without additional sources. Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 38 on 68
NB : This questionnaire has been filled by structures (agents, distributors, main customers) in place in order to measure their local vision about the sectors that are in existence in their territory. This view is always subjective and has to be put together with other objective facts.
Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 39 on 68 The real work of analysis takes into account independent market analysis, the vision brought back by visits, economical surveys and measures the potential drift. If the distortion is real, this proves that the solution that has been used for the evaluation : - Focused on other sectors - Linked to a funding custom based in a sector that it holds as opposed to others - See as marginal or non existant some sectors - Do not hold human resources or ambition that are necessary to develop sector based approaches. - Disconnected from economical reality of the product it represents. But the sector based analysis is not only used for defining the export potential, it can also be a very good way to develop an existing market and increase the potential revenue in the territory. The strong but also the weak points of local players (agents or distributors) is the fact that is very often active in a precise sector where is focus when ignoring the parallel sector. This is often linked to the available resources. The discovery of a new sector becomes then a potential, some opportunities that it might be better to propose to existing channel before stepping into new recruitment. This gives to the local solution already in place the possibility to increase his revenue if it can be done (resources and accesses). The exploitation of crossed based analysis is afterwards converted into development potential of market shares which is stating precise objectives that can be measured. Country A market volume for all sectors : 1000 Own shares : 75 % Competition 1 : 35 % Competition 2 : 20 % Unknown : 30 % Available shares : 0.15 x 300 = 45 Total shares Competition Own shares Accessible outside of competition Sector 1 10 20 40 40 Sector 2 30 0 30 210 Sector 3 50 45 30 100 Sector 4 10 30 0 70 With a simplified vision, but this course is not aiming to focus on market share calculation, it is visible that if based on unknown shares without getting competition shares, the real potential of a market can be more important but moreover better defined if one take into account the market shares by sector. One this exercise is completed it is also possible to know what resources to recruit and their type to succeed.
Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 40 on 68 Performance and analysis of the competition by sector based approach can produce interesting information. For example, products where competition is weak can be considered as : - Unknown o There is a potential niche - Non rewording, o It is necessary to evaluate the efforts/profit potential - Non accessible o It is necessary to check whether the competition distribution channel and the global strategy might be the reason for this lack of access/interest Territorial normalization Territorial normalization is targeting the similarities between different countries to gather than into a more restrictive list of territories which afterward possible to approach on a more economical and rational approach. Including the non sovereign countries and non UN countries, there was in 2003, 223 countries among which 192 were recognized by the international community. The number of states and countries has always fluctuated in centuries because of colonies, independence declarations, etc. (68 new states in 20 years from 1956 to 1975 26 ). With the access to the global economy, thank to a globalization, countries are created and gets access to independence. The first criteria that create a needs for independence is economical and cultural auto-determination. The geographical distribution is indeed a function of continents 1955 1975 2000 Africa 5 48 53 America 22 29 35 Asia 27 39 47 Europe 32 33 44 Oceana 2 7 14 Total 88 156 193
Most of the countries are named after two names :the short form and the long form. For instance Belgium is the short form of the long form which is Kingdom of Belgium. This also indicates the structure of its political system 27 . For standardization reasons only one name will be used on the international base but this is not sufficient to rationalize data in a way that they can be understood from all and be manipulated by countries without modification. There is in general a consensus adopted when economical data are discussed in order to put local information at hands on a cross-national basis.
26 Source Wikipedia 27 China and People's Republic of China Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 41 on 68
Figure 3 - The world in 2005
Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 42 on 68 In order to handle economic data, it is not necessary to take into account political values like membership of UN or EC. At the most these data will be informative regarding the general policy to use and a careful rule to use in the economic exchanges but this will not be the first criteria for general classification of processing or approach. With the venue of computers in all sectors, it has been necessary to use precise and fixed country naming. Players and principle of normalization International normalizations are dealt by ISO international standard organization founded just after the second world war in 1946. ISO 28 is the resulting organization coming from the fusion of ISA (International Standard Association) in 1926 and UNSCC (United Nation Coordination Committee in 1944). There were 65 delegates coming from 25 countries and the headquarters was located in Geneva, Switzerland because of the origins of the association and his secretary Mr. KUERT coming from SNV. ISO is nowadays an association of 163 countries that are affiliated through their national institute for standardization. Works that are related to European standards are given to the ECN (European Committee of Normalization) which signed in 1991 the Vienna agreement which is a cooperation agreement with ISO. The ECN is now number one member state also represented through their national institute for normalization. The first goal of normalization is to facilitate trade, exchanges and business. The aim is to decrease or remove all export barriers to increase the well being of population and to develop economies of concerned countries. The guideline is that when they exist, national standard are the basis of a discussion brought to the normalization committee who write a resulting document which will then be adopted by all member states as a replacement of existing national documents. For subjects which were not previously supported by a document, member states are deciding whether yes or not there is a need for creating committees for dealing with the writing of the said documents. A very important point to mention is that normalization is not at reach of companies but through the filter of their national institute. The absence of contribution of industries will not prevent committees from progressing. This means that these standardization committees will not be able to defend regional or national positions when they are not informed about the realities of the field and that companies are not interested to participate into the writing of said documents.
28 In Greek, this means equal/balanced which is indeed perfect for an association aiming to define rules of free circulation of goods and people. Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 43 on 68 Normalizing document
The standard which deals with definition of country names is ISO 3166-1 Alpha 2 or Alpha 3 29 . It's the most appropriate document to start with for a territorial definition because it is simple, complete and sufficient. It can be downloaded as a database access, text file or html to be integrated in any kind of specialized applications. I soPays_ Fr IsoCode2 isoCode3 Numrique AFGHANISTAN AF AFG 4 AFRIQUE DU SUD ZA ZAF 710 LAND. LES AX ALA 248 ALBANIE AL ALB 8 ALGRIE DZ DZA 12 ALLEMAGNE DE DEU 276 ANDORRE AD AND 20 ANGOLA AO AGO 24 ANGUILLA AI AIA 660 ANTARCTIQUE AQ ATA 10 ANTIGUA-ET-BARBUDA AG ATG 28 ANTILLES NERLANDAISES AN ANT 530 ARABIE SAOUDITE SA SAU 682 ARGENTINE AR ARG 32 ARMNIE AM ARM 51 ARUBA AW ABW 533 AUSTRALIE AU AUS 36 AUTRICHE AT AUT 40 AZERBADJAN AZ AZE 31 BAHAMAS BS BHS 44 BAHREN BH BHR 48 BANGLADESH BD BGD 50 BARBADE BB BRB 52 BLARUS BY BLR 112 BELGIQUE BE BEL 56 BELIZE BZ BLZ 84 BNIN BJ BEN 204 BERMUDES BM BMU 60 BHOUTAN BT BTN 64 BOLIVIE BO BOL 68 BOSNIE-HERZGOVINE BA BIH 70 BOTSWANA BW BWA 72 BRSIL BR BRA 76
There is also a system called UN/LOCODE developed by UN but it deals with geographic position of ports, airports, train stations, roads, post office, borders and other places used in trade and transport which is not something we deal with. ISO 3166 has a section 2, ISO 3166-2:2007, some codes for country representations with their subdivisions.
29 2 or 3 characters respectively Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 44 on 68 Export model for companies or According the economical and strategic model decided by the company, the territorial segmentation can be referred to a certain model 30 . - Ethnic based o The culture of the country of origin is the central reference of the system and everything is compared in regards to the domestic market. The domestic market has the priority on the export market who will only get what's left in the production that has not been sold to the domestic market. - Poly-centered o All markets are considered as equivalent. Each country is considered individually with a very high level of adaptation or confirmation. - Region or geo-based o Markets are pooled in regions, continents or economic pools to be attacked on a global basis in order to optimize a competitive position. Regarding adaptation of products opposed to the poly-centered model, this orientation will ask for an optimum standardization of product. On a marketing point of view, different strategies can be used 31 : - A global marketing when the company is active on a worldwide market - An export marketing when operations are done through a border - Or a multi domestic marketing for export done only to few countries. Practical steps When the list of countries has been identified and their abbreviation standardized, it is possible to start with a territorial classification which will be specific to the company and to the resources that it uses. Normalization or territorial classification must take into account criteria that can be evaluated from the outside with objective values. Potential criteria are : - Economical standards o Bank standards o Currencies - Social, cultural, historical parameters o Religions o Origins and progression o Social system in place o Languages - Political system o Origin and potential evolution - Geography o Continent o Socio-economic pooling - Own resources
30 According to Perlmutter, 1966 31 According to Keegan & Leersnyder Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 45 on 68 Economical standards are interesting to take into account for the money and currency transactions but are ignoring the aspect related to the product and the target. Whether it is in Euros or Dollars, the product will be sold. To the most, the revenue and the price fixing will need more or less attention. Political system is not very important criteria but when interfering with cross borders transactions. Geographical classification is corresponding to an economical reality in terms of shipment and export but is ignoring cultural aspects but are sometimes very important for some products. Own resources are sometimes defining the type of market that is targeted. For example, a country where the essential of the industry is mining will be in need of crushers and all type of detectors but this data is very specific and almost sectorial meaning it has very few value or generic classification which is aiming to ease the export to different countries using the same work mode and approach. Social, historical and cultural parameters are those directly influencing product definition and the way to sell it to the target. They are essential and must with the geographical classification be the base of the territorial definition. When gathering countries based on those two major criteria, it is possible to do a global communication and a standard approach which will be common to majority of the countries included. Geographical proximity seen alone is only an economical criteria even if, on the cultural side, there is a link between belonging to a continent and a social and a cultural element.
Criteria Effect Economical model Funds movements Geographical model Development and occupation market strategy Social and cultural model Product and relationship modification and adaptation to the local reality
Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 46 on 68 6 territorial profiles Depending on the aspect we will favor, geographical or socio-cultural (which includes political aspects), classification will be different. As mentioned above, the main subdivisions are also closed to a geographical segmentation, for instance : - Europe - America - Asia - Middle and far east - Africa However, these subdivisions are not showing differences in culture that are presents in each country that are included in each category. South Africa cannot be considered on the same foot as North Africa when speaking about culture. The first one will be closer to a Nordic mentality (origin of the population) while the second one will be closer to the mentality of south Europe. It is clear that there is a contamination which generally depends on : - Geographic proximity - Ethnic proximity as well as migration - Importance of trade exchanges The first classification will then have to be completed by additional subdivision which will take into account this contamination particularities in order to re-classify countries independently from their geographic positions. - Europe o North, East o Central and South - America o North o Central and South - Asia o Central o South/East - Middle and far east - Africa o North o Central
Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 47 on 68 Taking a well defined example like Europe, the territorial classification might look like the following one : - Europe o North DK, FI, NL, SK, UK o South SP, PO, IT, GR o East PL, SL, LT, DE o Central BE, FR, (CH), TR Speaking about America when taking into account the cultural and historical reality of these countries, it could be possible to bring north America/Canada to the profile north Europe and Central and south America to the profile Europe South. - America o North US, CA o Central and South BR, UY, PA, Here again, profiles America center and south could be gathered in the same group, more than the profiles north and center who are using different exchange and communication standards. If we use as a principle criteria, cultural and social data, the territorial classification of countries will give a consistent group for a rational approach of countries through a minimum number of different entries. - Latin and Central Europe : ex : Italy, France, Spain o Common history o Proximity relationship o Parallel economical development o Existing free trade - North Europe : ex : Norway, Russia, Germany, Poland o Common history but conflicting o Convention relationship o Import of essential technical products o Introverted countries looking for opening by necessity - Asia o Totally different culture than Europe, very traditional rooting o Interested relationship o Political influence to all levels o Economical factors behing technical advantages o Currency and language barriers
Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 48 on 68 - Middle and Far East o Block requests and middle man always present o Commercial relationship with a very high intimacy tendency o Political and regime influence always present o In search of training and access to information - USA, Canada o Free trade principle o Commercial relationship o Functionality behind technical characteristics o Immediate satisfaction of desire - Latin America and Hispanic countries o Close to Latin and Central Europe o Intimacy relationship o Sectors are limited to the local development o Political influence to all levels The continent terminology after this example is now looking like less consistent when countries are pooled by social and cultural approach instead of proximity or geographical circles. Each of the above territorial profiles will have their own negotiation scale, timing and relationship uses that have to be taken into account to succeed on the said territories. When a territorial classification of countries is not adapted to a product that will be exported, this will always provoked energy losses and more than that, consequences when analyzing global trends to the light of a policy in place. In companies belonging to a group, the territorial classification must be harmonized when there are sales consolidation otherwise, extracted data will have no sense. Logistics We have insisted on the fact that the basis of the export business is to give a product (new) to a target located outside the domestic territory. This in itself says that the logistic section must be in place. This logistic section will be more difficult when dealing with distant structure on which it is very difficult to get a good monitoring like shipment. On this very aspect, the life of a product can be decided, it is then necessary to put this aspect as number one priority. This is the very reason for having at least a performing shipment logistic department in the companies who are exporting much. The selection of logistics systems will depend on geographical particularities of the source and the destination as well as the nature of the exported goods. It is also possible that if some specific transportation media are not existing, this would prevent a product to be exported or will tremendously multiply the local supply price.
Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 49 on 68 Costs and consequences of a bad shipment are very often exceeding the value of transported goods. They can have an impact on the image of the product, can occur direct but also indirect costs by for example reducing the lifetime of a product and be very negative to the export policy of a company. Transportation methods are then selected when taking into account : - Matching to transported goods - Availability - Monitoring, control and security - Costs The cost is the last criteria if monitoring, control and security aspects cannot be guaranteed and that the value of the potential damage might exceed the investment by the selection of a transport solution. A new customer who is evaluating a new product to integrate it in his own production will be delivered using the "Gold" solution which will guarantee that these steps will be fail free. No matter the losses on this transport as long as the delivery is perfect.
Transport mode evaluation Without surprise, classical mode of transport are : - Road - Train - Aircraft - Ships - Piping Each mode will have advantages and drawbacks. When determining the mode of transport, it is useful to use a decision matrix which will have to make the decision more objective and to use the most appropriate network to reach the final destination.
+ - Roads Flexibility, door to door delivery, price efficient because of competition, speed Transshipment, limited monitoring environment Train Reduced handling, soft transport, security Slow, point to point, transshipment Aircraft Reduced handling, speed, security Point to point, costs Ships Cost, volumes and loads Slow, point to point, transshipment, environment Piping Cost, volumes, door to door Point to point, fixed infrastructure Every time that a product has to be handled while travelling, this product will be at risk of being damaged or stolen/lost. When possible, the transport mode will have to select the most direct way with the least handling as possible. Which in case of problems will limit the number of players on which to complain and will increase the efficiency of a claim. Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 50 on 68
Packing As opposed to what is generally believed, the heaviest, the more robust looking or the most expensive packing is not always the best one. The right packing is the one which is really adapted to the type of goods it is protecting and which is essentially capable of supporting normal stress of the travel foreseen for this good. It has to offer a sufficient empty volume that will protect the goods while travelling and being handled adequately. Depending on the cases, it is also necessary to think that the packing will be used on the way back and that the robustness will be sufficient with a non destructive opening to guarantee that it can be re-used. It is the same uses for packing of goods who are travelling by roads, air or water which are submitted to specific risks and damages : packing have to be adapted to these different mode of transport. Depending on the import countries, packing are not allowing certain material and will ask for specific certificates like fumigation for example. Sea packing are particularly concerned by these directives. For example, sea packing must not only sustain pressure, heat, moisture in the hold of ships and in warehouses but also when being handled by cranes in sea ports. This sea packing must also take into account the fact that the good because of its value can be much more exposed to being stolen during the shipment or in the warehouses or because of the nature, load or volume, it can be stored outside in a very bad weather conditions. When goods are in destination of an enclosed country, with a difficult access, these packing must be specifically designed. The most frequent sources of losses and damages are bad conditioning and sufficient packing or a defective marking, a bad conditioning or an insufficient packing will increase the risk of damages, dispersion, breaking or even stealing of the content. An confused or inadequate marking, insufficient or non permanent will creates shipments errors, package identification confusions and as a consequence, losses.
Province de Lige Higher degree ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Volumetric weighting Volumetric weight is weight/volume ration which allows to calculate the density of a parcel. In other words, determine which volume t considering its format. When transporting goods, for instance in aircraft, this volume notion is essential because the space is very expensive. The cause is simple because a parcel must have empty spaces and sufficient number and sufficient sizes to be used as energy absorbers. Very often, containers are full in volume before the maximum load is reached. This results in a money loss for transport companies who have then introduced this volumetric weight notion. The second reason for that resistance which imposes an equal distribution of loads. The volumetric weight is calculated and compared with the real weight of the parcel. The one that will be the most important will be used in the calculation of the cost of the shipment. Express carriers will multiply the volume of the parcel by this weight/volume ratio to get the volumetric weight, if this one is higher than the real weight, then they will use the volumetric weight value as the invoicing value, otherwise, they will use the weight of the parcel.
Volumetric weight = LxlxhxRatio m Aircraft 167 to 250 EUR/m Transportation costs are based on the real weight or volumetric weight, whichever the biggest according to IATA Volumetric weight is calculated as following : L x I x H (in cm) / 6000 (basis on 166 kg/m)
IATA volumetric weight factor - International : - Domestic : Example : A 25 kg parcel which dimensions are 60 x 40 x 80 will have a corresponding invoiced weight of Regarding insurance, by default, Warsaw convention which applies and will compensate by 20 USD/kg.
32 The Air Transport Association ( industry. Its members comprise all major passenger and cargo airlines 33 according to current IATA er degree School - Economic studies Academic year Carpentier F. 2010 Page
Volumetric weight is weight/volume ration which allows to calculate the density of a parcel. In other words, determine which volume the parcel will use considering its format. When transporting goods, for instance in aircraft, this volume notion is essential because the space is very expensive. The cause is simple because a parcel must have empty spaces and sufficient ent sizes to be used as energy absorbers. Very often, containers are full in volume before the maximum load is reached. This results in a money loss for transport companies who have then introduced this volumetric weight notion. The second reason for that is also a notion related to material resistance which imposes an equal distribution of loads. The volumetric weight is calculated and compared with the real weight of the parcel. The one that will be the most important will be used in the calculation he cost of the shipment. Express carriers will multiply the volume of the parcel by this weight/volume ratio to get the volumetric weight, if this one is higher than the real weight, then they will use the volumetric weight value as the invoicing herwise, they will use the weight of the parcel. Volumetric weight = LxlxhxRatio m Aircraft 167 to 250 EUR/m Transportation costs are based on the real weight or volumetric weight, whichever the biggest according to IATA 32 rules. culated as following : L x I x H (in cm) / 6000 (basis on 166 kg/m) 33
IATA volumetric weight factor are : 6000 cm/kg 7000 cm/kg Example : A 25 kg parcel which dimensions are 60 x 40 x 80 will have a ight of 60x40x80/6000 = 32 kg
Regarding insurance, by default, Warsaw convention which applies and will
The Air Transport Association (IATA) represents, leads and serves the airline industry. Its members comprise all major passenger and cargo airlines IATA tariffs Academic year - 2010-2011 Page 51 on 68 Volumetric weight is weight/volume ration which allows to calculate the he parcel will use considering its format. When transporting goods, for instance in aircraft, this The cause is simple because a parcel must have empty spaces and sufficient ent sizes to be used as energy absorbers. Very often, containers are full in volume before the maximum load is reached. This results in a money loss for transport companies who have then introduced this volumetric is also a notion related to material The volumetric weight is calculated and compared with the real weight of the parcel. The one that will be the most important will be used in the calculation he cost of the shipment. Express carriers will multiply the volume of the parcel by this weight/volume ratio to get the volumetric weight, if this one is higher than the real weight, then they will use the volumetric weight value as the invoicing Transportation costs are based on the real weight or volumetric weight, Example : A 25 kg parcel which dimensions are 60 x 40 x 80 will have a Regarding insurance, by default, Warsaw convention which applies and will ) represents, leads and serves the airline Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 52 on 68 Warsaw convention Warsaw convention states modalities of air transport including the air transport letter and the liability limits of the carrier. Excluding a specific insurance that has to be taken to the carrier or to a specialized broker, any luggage, parcels lost or destroyed are compensated by 17 SDR/kg. The SDR for Special Drawing rights is the currency used by the IMF (International Monetary Funds) and 17 SDR are corresponding to 20 USD. The SDR is a specific international tool crated by IMF in 1969 to add to the official existing reserves of member states. Its value is based on a set of four major currencies. SDR may be exchanged against freely usable currencies. With the definition of a general allocation of SDR the 20 th August and a specific allocation on the 9 th September 2009, the SDR value will be brought to 204.1 billions (an increase of 21 billion, which is today 317 billion dollars). This system created in 1969 was created to support fixed parities of Bretton Woods. Any country who would like to enter the system had to hold official reserves, gold or well accepted currencies which could be used to bought back the national currency on the international exchange market in order to support its own exchange rate. But international offer of the two main holdings in gold or dollars was insufficient to support the trading expansion and their financial evolution that was engaged. The international community has then decided to create a new holdings under the surveillance of the IFM. Only few years after the creation of the SDR system, the Bretton Woods system collapsed and the major currencies have started to be quoted following a floating exchange rate. On the other hand, the expansion of the international currencies market allowed reliable governments to get easier credit lines. This double evolution has reduced the need of SDR. SDR is not a currency, it is also not a credit on IFM. It is however a virtual credit on freely usable currencies of state members of IFM. Holders of SDR may get these currencies in exchange of SDR on two ways : base on free exchange rates between state members or when IFM is designating state member whose external position is strong to acquire SDR of state member whose external position is weak. In addition of representing additional holdings, SDR is used as counting units of IFM and many other international organization.
Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 53 on 68 SDR value is determined by a set of currencies SDR value has been initially fixed to 0.888671 grams of fine gold which was the correspondence to 1 USD. After the collapsing of the Bretton Woods system in 1973, the SDR value has been determined according to a set of currencies made of USD, EURO, GPP and Yen. The counter value of SDR in USD is daily displayed on the website of SDR and IFM. The value is representing the proportional sum of each of the four currencies making the SDR expressed in USD and calculated on the basis of the mid-day exchange rate in London. The composition of the set is reviewed every five years by the board of Directors to check that the corresponding ration of each currency is in line with the relative importance of this currency in the international financial system. During the last review of the SDR value in November 2005, the individual weighting of the currencies have been revised based on the export values of goods and services and based on the reserves in each currencies that were held by the other state members of the IFM. These modifications have been put in force on the 1 st January 2006. The next revision has been done in the end of 2010. Common terms used in shipment The terms referred hereafter are only mentioned as a reminder because there are to be seen in a more specialized course which is transportation. This wordbook is not supposed to be exhaustive neither to be very detailed but it explains the major terms used in the export business. Freight consolidation Pooling of parcels going to the same destination into the same carrier in order to optimize transportation costs. Dangerous goods declaration Dangerous goods are spread into 9 different classes with 3 dangerousness. Perfumes are considered as dangerous. The goods considered as dangerous by IATA are listed in the dangerous goods regulations and have to be declared through the annexed form. This form has to be filled by the sender and has to include as a minimum the following information : address of the sender and the addressee, airport of origin and destination, nature and quantities of the concerned goods, class of danger, united nation number and type of packing used. If the declaration is missing or is not correctly filled, this can generates very heavy penalties. It is also highly recommended to check if your usual carrier is accepting the category of goods that you intend to ship.
Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 54 on 68 UN Class Dangerous Goods Division(s) Classification 1 Explosives 1.1 - 1_6 Explosive 2 Gases 21 Fiammable gas 2.2 Non-flammable, non-toxic gas 2.3 Toxic gas 3 Fiammable liquid
Door to door Door to door is used for a shipment taken to the sender address and delivered to the final destination address. As opposed to "Door to Airport" which is mentioning a shipment where the addressee has to collect his goods in the airport of arrival.
Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 55 on 68 EUR1 This document is used to get exemption of custom duties for shipment of goods coming and manufactured in the European Union in direction of certain countries. It very often replaces the declaration of origin which is reserved to goods not exceeding 6000 Euros. EUR1 is used for shipment to the following countries (non exhaustive list) : Iceland, Norway, Switzerland, South Africa, Maghreb countries, Egypt, Mexico and the majority of Eastern Europe countries which are not member of EU. The EUR1 form is used as the evidence of origin to get preferential duty rate to the goods in transit. When the order doesn't exceed 6000 Euro, a declaration of origin on the invoice is sufficient. In order to write down a EUR1 form, two conditions at least have to be respected : - There must me an agreement between EC and the second country which allows the use of this document - Products covered by the document must be originating of EC or from second country as stated in the agreement. EUR1 has to be stamped by the exporting custom office, this Visa is given when doing the custom formalities. This control can also be done by the importing custom authorities who can ask the exporting custom office to check the product in case of doubt.
Province de Lige Higher degree ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0
er degree School - Economic studies Academic year Carpentier F. 2010 Page Academic year - 2010-2011 Page 56 on 68
Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 57 on 68 Commercial invoices or pro forma This document has to be attached in 5 samples when shipping outside of EU or to DOMTOMs. An invoice is called pro-forma when it is with a shipment which does not correspond to a sale. Incoterms Incoterms will define the different logistic steps that will have to be managed and supported by the exporter. International Commercial Terms are defining obligations (expenses and liability) of the buyer and the seller when having a sales-purchase international contract. There are 13 incoterms. However only 3 are usually used in express transport. EXW (Exworks) : The seller has no more responsibility of the goods when it has left his premises. It is the addressee who take care of the transportation. DDU (Delivery Duty Unpaid) : The seller has the responsibility of the goods until the final point of destination. The buyer has to do the import custom steps as well as handling for unloading to the destination. It is the usual incoterm in the express transport. DDP (Delivery Duty Paid) : The seller has the responsibility of the goods until the final destination of the goods. He also takes care of the customs steps only handling for unloading is taken in charge by the addressee. This is the ideal solution for the addressee who has nothing to do neither to pay. Only few carriers are accepting to have the load of the custom duty. When no incoterms are mentioned or negotiated for a delivery in express transportation, it's DDU that is used by default. Trans-shipment Action of a good which is transferred from one transport mode or storing, to another one. The more trans-shipment will happen to a good, the more risk this good has.
Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 58 on 68 Rules and barriers for export In principle association like WTO (World Trade Organization) are writing documents ruling and organizing trade between countries. According to its website definition "The WTO is the only international association which is taking care about rules on trade between countries. His main function is to favor as much as possible the well going forecasting and freedom of exchanges." The WTO has been created in 1994 on the basis of GATT (1947 General agreement of Tariffs and Trade : which was the agreement ruling all customs tariff. Customs tariff has been set to organize the in trade on a given territory. They have been and are still a direct tax system on import goods to satisfy the needs of the country of import. They have also been used to limit the import of some goods and the drift of a system. They are favoring domestic production towards import. On top of the direct funding from local companies, this trick is also influencing the commercial balance by favoring the internal market to the export market. Depending on their type, exported goods are given a known international code called the custom tariff or the custom code. This code is given a specific tariff. In the EC, this tariff is now set at a European scale and not a national scale. It is described in a European publication :"Rule CEE N 2658/87 of the board, of the 23 rd July 1987, related to the tariff and statistic designation and a common custom tariff (Official Journal L 256 from the 07.09.1987). There is another document called Taric which is the integrated custom tariff of the EC. Taric is gathering custom right rates and a state regulation applicable to external commerce of the EC. Taric allows the automatic custom payment of goods by the member states, it also allows to collect, exchange and publish on an optimal way statistic data about foreign trade exchange in the EC. The second goal of the tariff designation is to pool codes in order to make statistics about goods movements with their value. In Europe, its guiding principle is then to organize free circulation of goods and people and all the EC ruling is pushing into that direction by trying to limit as much as possible trade barriers and barriers to circulation of goods and persons.
Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 59 on 68 Taric custom code is made out of a fixed four digit number describing the general category and a supplemental 6 digit number describing the very product.
Figure 4 - Taric code examples, designation
Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 60 on 68 Online website from the EC are able to simulate not only tariff but also specific export restriction regarding the nature of the product and country of origin and destination.
Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 61 on 68 Export license Some product will need to obtain an export license and will require a specific procedure. In general, these products are those having a military or nuclear use, a very important of danger or a dual use possibility. The export license is written by the government of the country of origin and consists in an export license given for the specific goods, the quantities and the declared destination. Getting such a license is quiet long : one or two months and may call for a government assembly. Very often, getting this license is submitted to prior submission of end user certificate which describes the details of the end user and that the declared use will be the one announced. The existence of an end user license doesnt guarantee getting the export license but it's absence on sensible territories or in conflicts is a sign which should be bringing mistrust.
Figure 6 - Taric restrictions Temporary imports, transit In certain cases, when a good has to be deeply modified in a territory before being exported to another territory, it can be subjected to temporary import status. During that period, this good will not be taxed. These temporary import are to be administratively monitored and have a limited period for exemption. The exemption will automatically finish when the good will be exported again or when the maximum duration of temporary import has been elapsed.
Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 62 on 68
Use of national agreements If the direct export on the territory is sometimes looking as the best solution, it is not always the case, when the exporting country deosn't have agreement with the country of import. In certain cases, historical relationship are existing between countries and they have been creating exception rules to ease trade and they are only applicable between two distinct states while they are sometimes in the same economical entities. This is for instance the case for overseas territories in France or for certain British islands when they are trading from England. It is totally possible to use these particularities and to profit about substantial reductions to the condition that the exported goods are covered by interesting customs rates. In order that system can be applied, either the final production has to be identified as coming from the country which has specific agreements (joint venture cases) or that transformation when passing to the country where these agreements are existing is sufficient to justify the label "local origin". In most of the cases that are in the EC, what is measuring a sufficient degree of transformation on top of what is calling a change in the custom code two main criteria are used to replace ( or complete) : 1) Added value criteria : essentially used to determine the origin of the industrial product. The incorporated imported product cannot exceed a certain percentage of the value of the final product 2) The specific laboring conditions. Some goods are submitted to particular rules describing the labor done. This is, for instance the case for a lot of textile products. The criteria allowing the change of original custom tariff will be applied everytime that a transformation will be considered as sufficient. Custom codes changes, sub-assemblies Classification of a product in a specific custom class and therefore the application of a given tariff is function of the use, composition or nature. According to the description given, one product can be placed in one category instead of another. The tax on some product being higher than on others, it is very important to be sure about these factors. The splitting in sub-assemblies (OEM cases) is certainly changing the nature of the goods regarding customs. This sometimes helps getting a more interesting custom code and is a very efficient way for exporting goods without getting a too important tax. When goods are heavily reworked, meaning those who have a very important labor charge, the tax will be put mostly on the labor value which is not very interesting. For our well developed countries, this will add costs on an already very high labor expenses. It may then be very efficient to have a local transformation of the goods.
Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 63 on 68 Export pricing If finances are an essential fact to a company, it is much more sensitive on export market because revenue is loaded by a very big number of variables which very few are under control of the export company. Export pricing must take into account several factors : - Local currency and the position regarding their currency of reference - Costs o Distribution channel o Transformation o Conformity of the product for the local market o Logistics o Transportation o Distant support - The reference price of similar product when existing as well as local economic pressure - Commission level and expected level - Inevitable middle men on some markets It is not in the scope of this lecture to describe all financial mechanisms in detail but some are really classics in the frame of the export and will be hereafter described. Foreign currencies If it's still possible to operate in a foreign country with its own currency, it is not the local economic truth and it will always bring problems or will generate negotiations when exchange rates will not be in favor of the local currency. When accepting local currency transaction, the company is giving a very professional image and maybe reinforced to negotiate other points. The bad side of this is that the company must cover exchange losses risks. In some cases, the company will not be able to select the working currency because the importing country is imposing the currency or because the currency is not available locally. Sometimes this currency is set by uses like GBP or USD. The techniques for managing currencies maybe internal or external. Internal techniques Following an exchange rate on a reference period will help understanding what is the potential fluctuation level and therefore the potential fluctuation of the sales revenue. If the revenue is directly converted into the original currency and doesn't transit to a local bank account, gains or losses can totally eat the margin if there are no coverage systems for the currencies. One must also know that for an annual tax accounting, foreign currencies are valued to the exchange rate of the date of closing which is called principle of precaution. On that date there will be a gain or a loss. It is then highly recommended to have covering operations (external techniques) before this deadline and at least before getting the currencies in the accounts.
Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 64 on 68 When the company is correctly managing forecasts and analysis of exchange rates, it is possible to play on reception date of invoices or payment dates of commissions. - Leading has to be used when payments are coming a strong currency or when receiving funds in a weak currency. - Legging has to be used when receiving funds in a strong currency or when paying in a weak currency. This leads to the following table Importer Exporter Strong currency (forecast of a strength increase) Leading Legging Weak currency (forecast of a currency slow down) Legging Leading
The netting technique consists in using received currencies for one's own use in the same currency. The exchange rate is then determined to the balance. This however imposes : - To limit the number of different currencies in order to proceed to a maximum of application cases, - To rule payments and receivable dates in order that the values entering are compensating the values exiting There are seldom occasions, when two companies are deciding to apply netting between themselves, this is bilateral compensation and means that they are customers to each other. Finally, it is highly recommended to have specific clauses in contract regarding the exchange rate variation. It is then necessary to define for example : - A range of exchange rate changes (mini and maxi) - A ruling about sharing exchange rate variations - A selling price evolution in regards with exchange rates - A payment date in regard with contract signatures - Etc. External techniques Unless there is a use for the collected devices, it may be very advantageous when the value and the reception date of the currencies are known, to have a bank contract called exchange rate coverage. The bank states and locks an exchange rate to the condition of receiving determined amount in currencies at the latest on the date of completion. The reference rate is locked and no matter the fluctuation of the currencies, it will be guaranteed. The side effect of this mechanism is that if the exchange rates are becoming better, there will be no positive impact on the fixed exchange rate. In order to get a revision of the rates to a better value, it is necessary to pay a premium. This then will only be usable for very high volumes.
Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 65 on 68 Local list prices In a given market is corresponding a local economic context which will generate a specific price. This environment is as unique as the contacts with external market are limited. This however never last long. It is commonly admitted that prices and use in a said economical zone which would have a very good geographic connection will always tend to harmonize due to exchanges. Prices are first going down by the low prices market (opportunism effect or treasure hunting by clients) and then are going progressively up when all prices are aligned. On very well connected markets, it may be very dangerous to use two different prices without measurable and visible reasons. For distribution companies or those who have different operating headquarters in different countries, the supply price will have to stay in the same range because it will be easy to compare it. In this very case, it is the distribution channel who will benefit from its knowledge of the market to collect any additional margin. Setting of specific price lists is greatly depending on the knowledge of the value of the good in the country of export. Distribution channels must be the first information source regarding this but it is important to note that if the effective sales price is higher than the one set, unless the contract states the maximum sales retail price (MSRP), it is the channel who will get the difference in his pocket. If the distribution channel declares higher selling price as being the MSRP to the supplier, he will not be able to get a commission on a higher price. It is then recommended to monitor this factor in order to get the best revenue and set consistent prices. The distribution channels appetite is a very frequent cause of failure, mostly for products which volume are low because they try to get in very few operations a very high revenue by highly increasing prices. The opposite is also true. Some are doubling the price to the customer who is still considering this price as acceptable while the supplier has been asked to set its sale price to the channel down. It is always better to set a price list a little bit above the market price and to give a more important commission to the distribution channel who will then apply the price to the customer and will get a good margin or even increasing it a little bit. If the price is really too high, he will still have the possibility of discounting because his commission level will allow it. When using different pricelist, it is very important that all these price lists can be managed and identified at all time otherwise there is a risk that questions may arise to explaining differences. A system can be set with price lists applicable on a set of territories instead of isolated countries and this system can be completed by a commission level which will be calculated on volumes, efforts to produce, type of products, relative value.
Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 66 on 68 Financial risk coverage When selling abroad, it is very difficult to get back the product. If you had on top the fact that you are operating in local conditions which are not very often in our favor as foreigners and that exchange rate risks are in addition, financial risks are real. It is also very frequent because being a foreign company that the customer will ask for bank or performances guarantees. These have to be provisioned and sometimes let down when things are not running the way we expected. There is no protection against these two elements but delivering and performing as required and stated in the contract. Regarding the credit payment, there are credit insurances which are only dealing with this. In Belgium, the local institute is Ducroire on which you can address your request for having a global coverage for the majority of export territories. This coverage is paid by a commission on the global sales value. Attention, this system is not allowing everything and some countries are classified as too dangerous to be covered. The affiliation to a risk credit institute is however giving a very cold vision of the territories of export which can be used when there is no experience or experienced financial department. The risk taking is very minimal when their advices are followed and the payment risk is covered by a coverage which will refund in cases of losses but the time to get them may be important.
Figure 7 -DUCROIRE tool
Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 67 on 68 Conclusions Export is calling for an adapted structure, the setting of monitoring and strategic tools which are not usual in domestic sales. If the majority of techniques is finally related to marketing techniques, it is highly advisable to take into account other factors like environment, tax and social, to increase the chances of succeeding in the export steps. As on a domestic market, the exported goods have to meet the expectations of the target but it is very difficult to measure it because of the distance to the market and the cultural differences that may exist. Because the access to the target depends on the channels put in place, the company has to put sufficient resources for evaluation, development, animation, support and monitoring of the channel it uses. The financial risk is very present on export market and it is important to remain highly critical and reactive to get out of it if needed instead of trying by all means to stay in a place where results are not good. This being said, timescales are different and therefore sufficient resources must be addressed for enough time to have the time to validate a concept which starting might be slower than on a domestic well known market. This lecture is too short for seeing all export aspects in details and some aspects have been seen deeper than others either because they were more important or because the writer has met them more often. This syllabus is completed by references, articles and books where there are a lot of elements that can help completing someone self-training. However, this will have an absolute need of being completed by experience obtained when working on export market.
Province de Lige Higher degree School - Economic studies Academic year - 2010-2011 ModuleExportation_ETR_EN_r0 Carpentier F. 2010 Page 68 on 68 Bibliography and useful sources Internet http://statbel.fgov.be/press/f1065 Statistics in the Belgian economy http://www.tarif-colis.com/1-14- Dico-du- colis.php Transport and pricing http://www.eur- Wordbook about Export export.com/francais/apptheo/logis tique/ douane/regdouane.htm http://ec.europa.eu/taxation Customs Codes and Taric ds/tarhome fr.htm http://www.imf.orq/external/np/exr /facts IFM Rules /fre/sdrf.htm http://www.intracen.org/tfs/docs/g lossar y/If.htm Wordbook about finance and commerce http://www.mondissimo.com/f url General data oneconomies of countries http://europa.eu/leqislation Customs rules in Europe customs/I11003 fr.htm http://www.cambiste.info Exchange rates data and coverage systems
Bibliography See notes in the text
Revision and editions
Nom Date dition Objet ModuleExportation_ETR_r0 10.2009 Version initiale ModuleExportation_ETR_r1 02.2010 Correction ditoriale ModuleExportation_ETR_r2 01.2011 Refonte ditoriale et 1 re rvision, ajouts , actualisation ModuleExportation_ETR_EN-r0 02.2011 First English edition based on R2 FR