Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
VOICES
of Women Entrepreneurs in Bosnia and Herzegovina
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Acronyms..........................................................................................................................................2
Acknowledgments...........................................................................................................................3
IFC Foreword....................................................................................................................................4
MI-BOSPO Foreword........................................................................................................................5
IFC supports the participation of women MI-BOSPO is a leading micro-credit Chapter 1: The Legal and Economic Context Facing Women’s Businesses .
in Bosnia and Herzegovina..............................................................................................................8
as well as men, as an important part of its organization in Bosnia and Herzegovina
mission to foster sustainable private sector targeting women. The organization’s mission Chapter 2: Dealing with Bureaucracy...........................................................................................15
growth in developing countries. Recognizing is to economically empower women, led by
Chapter 3: Bosnian Women: Building Partnerships for Success..................................................24
that aspiring businesswomen are often the belief that the economically empowered
prevented from realizing their economic woman can better influence social change Recommendations..........................................................................................................................28
potential because of gender inequality, IFC and contribute to better quality of life within
Useful Links and Resources............................................................................................................29
is committed to creating opportunities for the family.
women in business. Endnotes.........................................................................................................................................30
References......................................................................................................................................31
Voices of Women Entrepreneurs in Bosnia and Herzegovina |
ACRONYMS ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
This report was prepared by Jozefina Cutura, Many of the women interviewed are MI-
BIH Bosnia and Herzegovina
IFC consultant, and is part of a collaborative BOSPO clients, and the author is grateful to
BEEPS Business Environment and Enterprise Performance Survey effort between IFC’s Gender Program and MI-BOSPO for facilitating the interviews.
MI-BOSPO, a micro-credit provider targeting
CEDAW Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women The author thanks the many individuals who
women in Bosnia and Herzegovina.
gave valuable feedback on earlier drafts of this
CIDA Canadian International Development Agency
The report is based on desk research and report, including Natalie Africa, Alma Bijedić,
DFID Department for International Development in-depth interviews with ten Bosnian women Mark Blackden, Michael Edberg, Leora Klap-
entrepreneurs in September 2007 whose per, Shahbaz Mavaddat, Nejira Nalić, Carmen
EBRD European Bank for Reconstruction and Development
profiles are featured in this report. Interviews Niethammer, and Zouera Youssoufou. Report
EU European Union were also conducted with relevant donors, layout and formatting were prepared by Kate
government agencies, and non-governmental Tallent Design & Communications.
FBIH Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina
organizations. The women interviewed
We finally thank the wonderful women
FIAS Foreign Investment Advisory Service run businesses that range from micro-
entrepreneurs who gave up their valuable
enterprises with fewer than 5 employees,
IFC International Finance Corporation time to share the stories of their successes and
to large businesses employing up to 50
challenges, and who serve as the inspiration to
IMF International Monetary Fund workers. While many are in the traditionally
many other Bosnian women and girls as they
women-dominated service sectors, others are
KM Convertible mark chart their economic futures.
branching out to areas such as engineering.
NGO Non-governmental organization
RS Republika Srpska
UN United Nations
US United States
Alma Bijedić
MI-BOSPO Marketing Manager
| Voices of Women Entrepreneurs in Bosnia and Herzegovina Voices of Women Entrepreneurs in Bosnia and Herzegovina |
on the topic and showcasing positive role models retail shops or beauty parlors. time on their businesses than men do. A female 10
of women in business, in the context of the business owner spends, on average, 29.2 hours 0
Women entrepreneurs cite dealing with
country’s post-conflict background. per week on her business, compared to 46.9 Family Employer Banks Credit unions,
ROSCAs, others
licenses, taxation, finance, and labor issues
hours that a male business owner spends on his women men
In the immediate aftermath of the war, mo- as the biggest obstacles to their business
enterprise (figure 2). Many women turn to self-
mentum on women’s empowerment helped success. In 2008 Bosnia and Herzegovina Source: World Bank (2001).
employment out of necessity, and for some Bos-
enshrine equality for women in legisla- was ranked 105th in the World Bank Group’s
nian businesswomen self-employment seems to
tion. Positive changes include the ratification Doing Business in 2008 report, which rates
help accommodate family responsibilities.
of the Convention on the Elimination of All countries annually on the ease of doing busi-
Forms of Discrimination against Women, and ness. The country’s pace of reform has slowed The lack of strong networks and pervasive Figure 2: Hours Worked per Week by Type of Employment
the adaptation of key new laws on women’s from a few years ago, and its rank slipped cultural barriers also discourage women 50
rights, including the Gender Equality Law, the from 95 in 2007 to 105 in 2008.3 This is a from entrepreneurship. Many women lack
40
Gender Family Law and the Law on Protection worrisome trend for all businesses, but it is the self-confidence in their ability to run a
against Domestic Violence. A requirement that likely to affect disproportionately women- business. Thirty-four percent of the women 30
one third of candidates on party lists during owned businesses due to their small size and interviewed in a 2002 survey of 428 women
20
elections must be female helped strengthen lower capacity to deal with a difficult busi- across the country noted that they are unsure
women’s participation in politics. ness environment. if they have the right skills and knowledge to 10
Unpaid
cording to the 2007 invest less in their businesses.4 Both women en can use to show their success stories important it is to implement policies that will
family workers Labor Force Survey, and men who take out bank loans complain and make their views heard with policy encourage and strengthen their performance.
only 22.6 percent of of overly long and complicated procedures, makers and the international community.
employed Bosnians as well as the high cost of borrowing. In the The report highlights the many positive role
Source: Agency for Statistics of Bosnia-Herzegovina (2007).
are self-employed and meanwhile, microfinance providers, such as models of Bosnian businesswomen, whose
Voices of Women Entrepreneurs in Bosnia and Herzegovina |
Chapter 1
The post-war transition has not encouraged Turkey, are close to, or higher than the global
women’s participation in the private sector average of 52.5 percent (figure 1.1).8
Since the signing of the Dayton Peace
Accords in late 1995, Bosnia and Herze- Women also suffer higher unemployment
govina has been rebuilding its institutions levels. In 2007 the unemployment rate for
The Legal and Economic Context . and strengthening its economy. The country women was 32.9 percent, versus 26.7 percent
Facing Women’s Businesses . is now divided into two largely autonomous for men.9 Unemployment rates are alarmingly
entities, Republika Srpska and the Federation high among young women in the age category
in Bosnia and Herzegovina
of Bosnia Herzegovina, with some of the data of 15 to 24, where their unemployment levels
presented in this report being separate for have reached a staggering 63.1 percent, com-
these two entities. pared to 55.6 percent for men in the same
age category.10
Bosnia’s women were generally perceived to
enjoy equal rights and strong social protection
in many spheres of life during the social- ˇ ć , B H crafts ,
L e j la R adon ci
ist times, but the conflict was marked by an S ara j e v o
erosion of their status. The influx of foreign
aid since the end of Bosnia’s war and donors’ s hopping with Purpose is the motto of BHcrafts, a network of
Bosnian women producing beautifully hand-crafted pieces with tra-
support for gender issues brought new energy ditional patterns that range from knitwear and accessories to home
to the women’s movement. Yet, many women’s décor. The products have been sold at Neiman Marcus, Agnes B, and
National Geographic and Sundance catalogues. The company has an
non-governmental organizations (NGOs)
T
international reach, selling products in Europe, Japan, and the United
his section provides an introduction to the legal and political changes to help ensure equality and services that sprung up in the mid to late States. Several outlets in Sarajevo offer gift options to local tourists.
and regulatory framework facing women in Bosnia for women in the post-war period, indicating 1990s tended to focus exclusively on women’s BHcrafts is one of few Bosnian businesses that have embraced
and Herzegovina. The chapter also discusses how how reform momentum in the immediate political participation or human rights issues. the social entrepreneurship agenda and used it to generate profit
through a message that their items not only represent a beautiful
education, traditions, and cultural norms affect women’s aftermath of a war can be a good opportunity Few focused on women in the private sec- purchase but also benefit impoverished women. Knitting for BHcrafts
towards ensuring women’s empowerment. tor and their potential to contribute to the is the main source of income for many of the women the company
economic status and influence their employment and employs, and allows them to support their families and send their
country’s economic development. children to school. The network usually includes about 350 women
business choices. Bosnia and Herzegovina’s 2003 Law on Gen- per year, but can engage up to 700 women when orders are in high
der Equality is meant to further strengthen Women’s participation in the economy is low, demand. However, according to Lejla, “the local laws do not distin-
Bosnia and Herzegovina’s Legislative Frame- but increasing guish our social entrepreneurship model from a regular business.”
women’s status in areas such as employment, The company has two sets of registrations, and is registered as a firm
works Seek to Ensure Gender Equality Female labor force participation rates in Bos-
media, education, and the private sector. The and as an NGO. “We do two separate sets of accounting for the firm
The constitution prevents discrimination nia and Herzegovina are strikingly low. Com- and the NGO. This separation is a big problem.”
law prohibits discrimination based on gender
based on sex and guarantees equal opportuni- parison data on pre-war trends are unavailable,
and sexual harassment in the workplace, and it Started as a psycho-social project in 1995 by Lejla during her stint
ties for its citizens. Bosnia and Herzegovina but research indicates that women made up a working for the Norwegian People’s Aid organization, BHcrafts has
mandates equal pay for equal work. This law been supported with funding and technical assistance by various
ratified the Convention on the Elimination significant share of the labor force, particularly
also seeks to harmonize the country’s legisla- donors, including the European Union, the Canadian International
of All Forms of Discrimination against in the industrialized sectors.7 Even though Development Agency (CIDA), UNIFEM, and the World Bank. As such,
tion with the acquis communautaire, as part
Women (CEDAW) in 1994, and it adapted the company is one of few donor-supported projects in the country
of the European Union accession process. Yet, women today make up 51.9 percent of the that has focused on women’s private sector participation and eco-
in 2005 key new laws on women’s rights, working age population, their labor force par- nomic empowerment.
women’s organizations in the country note
including the Gender Family Law and the ticipation rate is only about 43 percent, which
that the implementation of the law has been BHcrafts has done an excellent job with marketing its products, and
Law on Protection against Domestic Vio- is much lower than in developed countries. it encourages buying through its website (http://www.bhcrafts.org/).
limited and that appropriate by-laws are still
lence. A requirement that one third of Each BHcrafts product includes a small card with the handwrit-
missing.6 According to Bosnia’s 2005 CEDAW However, their participation rate has been ten name of the woman who made it. Sales are also encouraged
candidates on party lists during elections steadily increasing over the last decade. In through various fashion and charity shows, and auctions at
statement to the UN, the country’s courts are
must be female has helped strengthen embassies. In the future, Lejla is looking to further strengthen
overloaded, and have therefore had limited contrast to Bosnia and Herzegovina, women’s
her brand, increase production, and focus more on the
women’s participation in politics. Other post labor force participation rates in much of the European market.
capacity to handle cases dealing with discrimi-
conflict-countries, such as Afghanistan or rest of Central and East Europe, except for
nation against women.
Rwanda, secured similar positive legislative
10 | Voices of Women Entrepreneurs in Bosnia and Herzegovina Voices of Women Entrepreneurs in Bosnia and Herzegovina | 11
Most new jobs in Bosnia and Herzegovina are may be due partly to women working less, but
Table 1.1: Structure of the Working Age Population, .
being created in the informal sector, which also to the fact that women are concentrated in by Education and Sex
accounted for 42 percent of employment in less well paid occupations.
2004. Also, women make up 69.3 percent of Labor Force
While older women tend to lag behind . Employed Persons Unemployed Persons Inactive Persons
unpaid family workers. Yet, the participation
men in educational attainment, educational
Female
of women in informal employment is almost backgrounds of younger women are compa-
Primary School 25.4 26.8 72.2
the same as in formal employment, demon- rable to men’s and Less
strating once again their lower participation in Education statistics in Bosnia and Herze- Secondary School 56.1 68.3 26.3
the productive economy.11 In general, unem- govina indicate slightly lower secondary College, University, 18.4 4.9 1.5
Masters, Doctoral
ployment rates are higher for women than for school completion rates for women. Yet, Degrees
men across the former Yugoslav countries, with lower completion rates are more pronounced Male
the largest gender gaps in Bosnia and Kosovo.12 among the older generation of women who Primary School
and Less
22.5 25.5 55
All income
in the 15-24 age category has not translated
200 and Herzegovina indicate a much higher gulf women (chart 1.1). This figure is comparable
into employment indicates that they may be
between women and men. Data from 2005 to the rest of East Europe and Central Asia
150 particularly affected by the small formal
indicate that women in Republika Srpska had where the average percentage of female entre-
100
employment sector and gender bias. More-
a mean monthly income from employment preneurs is 26.8 percent (figure 1.3).17
over, as the country’s education system is not
of KM60 (US$48) per month, compared to
50 well adapted to market needs and is under- Part of the reason for such low entrepreneur-
KM145 (US$116) for men. In the Federation going reforms, both women and men could ship levels might be that many Bosnian citizens
0
women’s mean monthly income was higher,
RS Male FBIH Male All BIH Male RS Female FBIH Female All BIH Female benefit from more practical skills needed tend to prefer formal employment with a firm
at KM129 (US$104), compared to KM196
Source: DFID (2005). in business. over becoming an entrepreneur, reminiscent of
(US$157) for men.14 The earnings disparity
12 | Voices of Women Entrepreneurs in Bosnia and Herzegovina Voices of Women Entrepreneurs in Bosnia and Herzegovina | 13
Male firms are bigger, so of course they The significant amount of remittances in the
are more successful. Women have small
country may also affect levels of entrepreneur-
ship. Bosnia and Herzegovina is among the top Box 1.1: Engaging in Business as a Way to Heal: .
businesses, but they help us survive.
20 countries in the world receiving remittances, N ada S t j epano v i ć , D ance .
—Mejrema Alimanović
which amount to over 11 percent of GDP.19 Re- S tudio S ebasti j an , B r cko ˇ
Data from the World Values survey indicate Nada is involved in all aspects of the studio’s work, from managing administrative duties to conducting
the dance classes and giving catwalk lessons to aspiring models. Today the studio has about 300 stu-
that Bosnian women are also more likely Chart 1.1: Persons in Employment by . dents who span a variety of ages. About 8,000 people have taken courses from the studio in the past
than men to favour increased government Status of Employment 11 years in the town of Brčko. A master at multitasking, Nada has accomplished all of this in addition to
her full-time job as a financial director at a local firm. She was even recognized with a “Woman of the
ownership of business rather than private
Year” award by her municipality a few years ago.
ownership, suggesting that women have a
Nada has never had to do much advertising for her business. Local TV stations have been eager to cover
less positive attitude towards business than Employees
her competitions and events, and Nada notes that her students’ distinctive look while out and about
men.18 One reason for this cautious attitude Self-employed in town speak for itself. Her most pressing task now is to secure her own space for classes, as they are
Unpaid currently held in the town’s youth center.
to business may be due to the loss of support family workers
services, such as childcare, social security, and
maternity leave that women were accustomed
to during communism, which has increased Source: Agency for Statistics of Bosnia-Herzegovina (2007).
women’s vulnerability. Despite their low business ownership, wom- from exile and finding few other employment
en do express a growing interest in starting options. For some, starting a business was
Figure 1.3: Share of Female Entrepreneurs .
a business
by Country, Eastern Europe and . a positive, therapeutic activity and a coping
Central Asia Region A survey conducted in 2002 found a marked mechanism (box 1.1).
increase in the numbers of women who ex-
Latvia pressed an interest in starting their own busi- Women’s businesses are smaller than men’s,
Hungary and tend to be clustered in the traditional
Georgia ness, from 18 percent in 1998 to 60 percent
Bulgaria trade, handicrafts, and service sectors
Kazakhstan in 2002.21 Faced with poor employment op-
Ukraine Country-wide data on women’s business activ-
Slovenia portunities, Bosnian women increasingly view
Estonia ity are scarce, but the graph below from the
Poland entrepreneurship as a viable source of income.
Russia Banja Luka municipality shows that women’s
Romania
Moldova
For female-headed households poverty may
businesses are focused on handicrafts, trade,
Kyrgystan
Total
be a particular motivating factor. About 25
Lithuania and services, perhaps due to the lower initial
Bosnia percent of households in the country are fe-
Yugoslavia capital investment and skills requirements for
Belarus male-headed (15 percent of these are widows),
Tajikistan these sectors (figure 1.4).23 This is in line with
Czech Republic and 61.4 percent are likely to be below the
Croatia other countries in the region, where women’s
Slovakia poverty threshold, compared to 33.5 percent
Macedonia businesses are predominantly clustered in
Uzbekistan of households headed by men.22
Azerbaijan wholesale trade, retail, and textiles. The choice
Albania
Armenia
Women interviewed for this study note a of the industries women focus on partly ex-
0 10 20 30 40 50
variety of reasons for starting their businesses, plains why their firms are smaller in terms of
% of entrepreneurs female but most did so out of necessity. A number of sales revenues and profits.24
Source: Sabarwal and Terrell (2008). women started their business upon returning
14 | Voices of Women Entrepreneurs in Bosnia and Herzegovina
Ranking
1500 due to their limited mobility and “their high level landscape that has not sufficiently focused 80
women men of responsibility within the family. We still need to on reforms. This is a worrisome trend for all 60
1200 keep taking care of all the household chores.” A
well-respected woman in her community, Ružica businesses, but it is likely to affect dispro- 40
900 is active in local politics, and was portionately women-owned businesses due 20
the first woman to be 0
600
elected to the post of to their small size and lower capacity to deal Singapore Macedonia, Montenegro Serbia Croatia Greece Bosnia and Albania
300
the representative of with a difficult business environment.
FYR Herzegovina
N
Figure 2.2: Barriers to the Operation and Growth of Businesses (percentage of firms)
erma and Narcisa have come a long way from sewing pillows and bedcovers in their garage Economic policy uncertainty
and selling them at the marketplace. They now own a spacious production space in Ilidja with a Corruption
colourful new showroom. The company employs 25 people and sells 130 different articles across Cost of financing
Tax rates
the former Yugoslavia, with occasional exports to Sweden, Germany and Russia. Macroeconomic instability
Anti-competitive practices of other producers
Their success masks difficult beginnings. The sisters started their business after returning to Bosnia Tax administration
Organized crime/mafia
from Spain, faced with the need to ensure survival and provide for their families. They used an old
Functioning of judiciary
sewing machine and their personal bedding to make their first pillows, which Access to financing
they stuffed with the leftover materials of military uniforms. Street crime/theft/disorder
Contract violations by
customers and suppliers
Their biggest problem has been various government regulations that have negatively affected their business.
Customs and trade regulations
According to Nerma, “laws here don’t stimulate business, they only stifle it.” The sisters formally registered their firm in 1996 Business licensing
and note that the process was difficult. “Even now the government makes problems. That’s how they make money,” Nerma and permits
Labor regulations
says. “The requirements and taxes are horrible. If it were not for these people we employ, we would sell all of this.” Even open- Skills and education
ing their new showroom has not been easy. According to Narcisa, “There were many requirements before we opened it. They of available workers
Lengthy, Complicated Procedures and . We get loans from commercial banks. But
Table 2.1: Dealing with Licenses in . the Cost of Bank Finance are Issues for Figure 2.3: Percentage of Persons who Took Loans in the Preceding 12
Bosnia and Herzegovina the interest rates are too high, and the
Women’s Businesses Months, According to Source of Loan by Sex
Procedures (number) 16 terms are too short. .
Duration (days) 467 Bosnia and Herzegovina is ranked at number —Lejla Radonči ć
60
Cost (% of income per capita) 790.3 13 in the Doing Business report in terms 50
of the ease of obtaining credit, reflecting an larger percentage of bank borrowers and 40
Source: World Bank (2007a).
excellent performance in this area. Banking are also more likely to borrow from credit
30
reform in 2001 has led to the liberalization unions, rotating savings and credit associa-
to ongoing efforts on the inspections reform of the banking sector, and the country has a tions (ROSCAs) and other sources, while men 20
and the “regulatory guillotine” process.27 competitive banking market with regulatory are slightly more likely to borrow from family 10
However, it is still a poor ranking, and several and supervisory functions that are being en- (figure 2.3). 0
women complained of delays and a frustrat- forced. Moreover, credit to the private sector is Family Employer Banks Credit unions,
ROSCAs, others
ing bureaucracy in obtaining needed licenses growing rapidly, with real private sector credit The numbers indicate that women in Bosnia
women men
(box 2.2). The process requires, on average, 16 averaging 22.8 percent between 2001 and and Herzegovina may be better off in terms of
Source: World Bank (2001).
procedures and 467 days (table 2.1). The time 2006.28 The country has an inclusive credit securing credit than women in the rest of the
and effort needed to navigate these procedures registry that covers both commercial and region. A study using data from Europe’s Busi-
can significantly delay business start-up and micro lenders. ness Environment and Enterprise Performance (US$2,725) for men, and women are more
discourage formalization. Given that women Survey found that female-managed firms have likely to take out loans for immediate con-
also bear prime responsibility for household Few of the women interviewed for this report a 5.4 percent lower probability of securing a sumption rather than investment, indicating
tasks, they may experience these procedures noted access to finance as an issue; rather both bank loan than male-managed firms. More- that they invest less in their businesses (figure
more acutely than do men. women and men complained of the cost of over, female-managed firms pay, on average, 2.4).30 Also, Bosnian entrepreneurs are more
finance. In fact, women make up a slightly 0.6 percent higher interest rates than their likely to finance their business start-up with
male counterparts.29 In contrast to the rest of personal funds rather than bank loans. While
Europe, the same study found that women- bank finance is rarely used for business start-
Box 2.2: Dealing with Licenses: . owned firms in South-Eastern Europe report ups in the country, research has found it to
M irsada M ehmedino v i ć , . fewer constraints in access and cost of financ- be significant in ensuring business survival.31
K onfekci j a S D M , L uka v ac ing than male-owned businesses. Therefore, the fact that women are less likely
M irsada was working in a garment factory in Italy after her escape from the Bosnian war when
she met her future husband, an Italian with a long family history of working in the garment industry.
However, the average size of a loan that a
to take out bank loans for business purposes is
likely to have a negative impact on their busi-
After the war ended Mirsada and her husband returned to her home town of Lukavac and built SDM
woman takes out is smaller than a man’s, at
ness survival.
Lukavac, a garment factory that produces slick Italian shirts for export to the Italian market. 2,702.50KM (US$2,169) versus 3,395.82KM
Living in an area of the country known for the high level of pollution from the surrounding heavy While access to bank finance is less of a
industry and large chimneys at the city’s entrance, Mirsada was looking to start a business that would problem for women, businesswomen inter-
offer alternative employment opportunities to the local population and would not harm the environ- Figure 2.4: Average Loan Size (in KM), by Sex
ment. Konfekcija SDM now employs 50 workers, of whom two are male. As is common in the garment viewed for this report note that the length of
industry, women have taken on all levels of responsibility in her factory, from working in production to 5000 time it takes to get bank financing, the lack
being directors. With unemployment in the region high, Mirsada feels positive about her contribution. women men
of long-term financing options, as well as the
4000
While her intentions were good, Mirsada realized that opening up the factory complicated paperwork and requirements are
would not be very easy. Even though Mirsada started to set up her business
in 2003, she did not commence operations until 2006. It took two and a
3000 problematic and lead them to turn instead to
half years to obtain all the necessary paperwork and permits from the
2000
microfinance institutions. Men tend to turn to
government. She notes having to go to various different ministries,
with no clear explanations of who was responsible for what. Her microfinance for the same reasons.
business site was finished only in 2005. Despite her challenges, 1000
Mirsada is optimistic about her future prospects. Her business is
still in the expansion phase and she plans to more than double 0
her workforce in the coming years. Average loan size
As in many other parts of the world, the lack and in late 2007 a new Law on Leasing was A number of the women interviewed are
of registered property under their own name enacted in Republika Srpska. Leasing can receiving both micro-credit and bank loans.
can become a problem for women when
help women’s businesses with limited start-up Women preferred microfinance loans due to
seeking bank financing, particularly for
capital and cash flow to start operating imme- the convenience and speed associated with
larger loan amounts
diately. Yet few of the women interviewed for obtaining them (box 2.4). Yet they note that Box 2.3: MI-BOSPO — Increasing Women’s Access to Finance through
The law provides for joint property registra- Micro Loans
this report seemed aware of the potential that interest rates are too high. Depending on the
tion, but traditional practices of registering
I
leasing offers, indicating the need for educa- type of loan, microfinance institutions charge
land in a man’s name tend to prevail. Only 6.5
tion on this product. from 15 to over 20 percent interest, com- nitiated in 1996 as a World Bank pilot project, MI-BOSPO has evolved into a
percent of women interviewed for the STAR leading micro-credit organization in Bosnia targeting women. The organization’s
pared to 8 or 9 percent interest charged on a mission is to economically empower women, led by the belief that “the economi-
Network survey reported owning land in Microfinance institutions have stepped in to
consumption or housing loan by commercial cally empowered woman can better influence social change and contribute to
their own name (figure 2.5). Moreover, forty fill the funding gap better quality of life within the family.”
banks.35 With competition in the micro-
percent of women noted that lack of property There is a large presence of microfinance
enterprise market in the country increasing, the As of March 2008, MI-BOSPO had 26,580 active clients and a loan portfolio
makes accessing finance difficult. organizations in Bosnia and Herzegovina. In of KM64,000,000 (US$51,375,307). Based in Tuzla, the organization focuses
interest rates have been on a downward trend.
2004, there were 46 registered microfinance mainly on northeast Bosnia. The loans range from US$180 to US$18,200, with
The numbers are similar across the former providers in the country.34 Many of these were
an average tenor of 13.5 months. On any given day, one can see the MI-BOSPO
Taxation Imposes Further Burdens on staff in the colorfully branded company vans visiting clients in the cities that the
Yugoslav countries. In neighbouring Monte- established with donor assistance following Women’s Businesses organization serves.
negro only 3 percent of property is registered the end of the war, but are now self-sufficient Bosnia and Herzegovina is undertaking tax MI-BOSPO is involved in various community initiatives, such as a local recycling
in women’s names, while the corresponding (box 2.3). The country passed similar micro- reform, including lowering property taxes and program, and is starting a foundation that will focus on research and programs
figure in rural parts of Kosovo is 10 percent.32 finance laws in Republika Srpska in 2001 and simplifying corporate income taxes.36 How- to the benefit of women. MI-BOSPO is a member of Women’s World Banking, a
global network of microfinance organizations based in New York.
The growth in the leasing market in the the Federation in 2000. A new law on micro- ever, tax rates are still rated by entrepreneurs
For more information, visit: http://www.mi-bospo.org.
country could have positive effects for women. credit organizations stipulates that micro- among the highest obstacles to doing business
Outstanding leasing contracts in Bosnia and credit organizations have to transform from in the country. For instance, taxes that an
Herzegovina grew by 74 percent between non-profit organizations to either foundations employer has to pay for each employee to the
2004 and 2005.33 The IFC has been work- or commercial entities. social insurance fund average about 70 percent
ing to update the leasing legal framework, of an employee’s net pay, making it very costly Box 2.4: Benefiting from Microfinance: .
MI-BOSPO is simple because we know and
to create new jobs.37 N izama I msiragi ć , M ilk C ow .
. B reeding F actor y N ear T uzla
trust each other. .
ˇ ć , .
I
M irsada M a j dan ci We had problems with taxation at first. “
—Mejrema Alimanović
H erbal P harmac y M editera started work with MI-BOSPO as soon as they began operating here seven years
We had nine inspection visits within .
S
ago,” says Nizama Imsiragić, sitting in the shade of a tree in front of her milk
six months. . cow breeding factory at a large farm near Tuzla. Running a family business to-
teeped in a family tradition of herbalists and with a degree in pharmacy, gether with her husband, Nizama started out by selling the milk of her one cow
it seemed only natural for Mirsada to turn to herbal medicine when she was Figure 2.5: Women’s Property Ownership . in the neighborhood. Soon enough she saw the potential for more. She now has
—Fahira Habibović
looking to start her own business. Mirsada is today the director and sole in Bosnia nd Herzegovina (percentage) eighty cattle and various machines for processing milk. Their milk is sold to the
owner of a pharmacy that focuses on herbal medicine and natural drugs. Tuzla Milk Factory and distributed to the region.
50
She started her business in 1997 after returning from exile in Germany,
now employs five people, and is increasingly focusing on herb growing and Loans from MI-BOSPO have played a key role in this development. “I
production on her family-owned land. “I have focused on plants because of 40 The Doing Business in 2008 report found that
had one cow and wanted one more,” says Nizama. “I got a loan
my family tradition and history. Nature is our salvation,” she says. Her clients the number of payments in the taxes category from MI-BOSPO and bought a second cow.” Her experience
are the locals from her town of Živinice, including athletes and people who 30
has been reduced from 73 to 51 annually with MI-BOSPO has been positive and she values the long-
believe in alternative medicine. standing relationship with the organization. “They are very
20 from the previous year, but the total estimated fast. Now that I have secured their trust, I can get credit at
Mirsada used her own funds to start the business, yet notes that financing has
required time for processing these payments any time,” she says.
been an issue. “Banks are not an attractive option for financing, as they have 10
too many requirements. While microfinance organizations have higher interest increased from 100 hours to 368, increasing Going forward, Nizama would like to focus on breeding
rates, they are faster. Yet they do not offer large enough loans.” 0 complexity. The complexity and cost of the the Holstein breed of cows, which are distinctive black-
Land House and-white-colored cows known for their large milk
Mirsada has a resilient spirit, and notes: “I do not intend to give up. I will con- process may be one of the reasons why wom- production capacity. Nizama is optimistic about her
in own name don’t own
tinue to fight on.” In the future, she hopes to acquire more land and expand en, who tend to be more time constrained firm’s future: “We have this large space for the cows, in
the herbal production side of her business. joint no answer/ which we invested a lot of funds. We have capacity for 50
don’t know than men, do not formally register their small more cattle.”
Source: Baksic-Muftic, Jasna et al. (2003).
informal businesses or hire workers.
22 | Voices of Women Entrepreneurs in Bosnia and Herzegovina Voices of Women Entrepreneurs in Bosnia and Herzegovina | 23
There is no flexibility with employees. . number of women entrepreneurs noted issues numerous labor inspections by government to pay the maternity leave through the social
The state does not offer good training .
with poor quality of workers and the difficulty that often amount to harassment. A study by insurance system instead of leaving it effec-
in finding good employees. the World Bank Group’s Foreign Investment tively to the employer.41 Moreover, research
for workers. We are coming out of a .
Advisory Service (FIAS) noted that the system indicates that employers often disregard the
communist system, and the state is . Vocational education opportunities are also for labor inspections lacks reasonable rules and norms of the labor law, prevent women from
insuring people who do not have good limited for those who wish to improve their remedies and gives individual inspectors large using maternity leave, and sometimes even fire
work habits. We have gone through 150 skills, and companies tend to invest little amounts of power but little accountability. women during pregnancy.42
in training their workers. Moreover, a 2006
workers to get 50 good ones. This situation can easily lead to requests for
labor study found that vocational training is Discrimination against older women is also
—Mirsada Mehmedinović bribes that are difficult for women entrepre-
associated with a negative effect on earnings of prevalent, with older women being rejected
neurs to refuse.40
about 20-25 percent, probably due to the fact from consideration for employment due
Poor Worker Skills Can Impact Women’s. that poor people with lower job prospects tra- Women employees, in particular, are often to their age and looks. Job advertisements,
Business Performance
ditionally enrol in vocational programs instead seen as a burden by employers. The World particularly in the services industry, often
The education system in Bosnia and Herze- of completing a full secondary school degree.39 Bank has argued that the one year maternity have specific requirements for applicants to be
govina has not adapted to a market economy. A 2005 World Bank Education Restructuring leave policy, mandated in the labor laws, hin- below 35 years of age and to look attractive.43
The system focuses on training for defined Project has been designed to address some of ders female employment. Maternity benefits Increased awareness by women’s NGOs and
jobs in a command economy rather than these issues. in Republika Srpska are financed through Gender Centers on this problem and gender
adaptability and flexibility, and has yet to general payroll contributions and are therefore sensitivity training for the private sector may
equip young people with the skills that are Rigid protection has meant that private em-
not a disincentive to hiring women. In the help change such perceptions.
ployers have had a difficult time firing and
needed in the private sector. According to the Federation the benefits are supposed to be
hiring workers
World Bank, more than 40 percent of second- financed by the Cantonal social protection
While there have been some initial reforms
ary students in the country continue to study system, but in practice are often left to the
of the labor code and employment institutes,
programs in hundreds of occupational spe- employers to finance, creating a disincentive
more is needed. Women entrepreneurs tell of
cializations for which there are few jobs.38 A to hiring women. One potential solution is
.
M e j rema A limano v i ć , .
K iosk S hop M eri , L uka v ac
W hen her husband was injured during the war and had to stop working, Mejrema borrowed funds
from relatives and started a small kiosk to ensure the family’s survival. “Those were the post-war years,
and life was difficult. My husband was a war invalid and we were having a hard time getting by.”
But the hard times are long over for Mejrema. From her first small kiosk, Mejrema has developed a
variety of business ventures in her town of Lukavac that include agriculture and coffee roasting. Four
years ago she also opened a greenhouse where she grows strawberries and vegetables that she sells in
her own shops. The market for her products is local, and Mejrema says she would have to improve the
labeling to be able to sell the products elsewhere.
Her biggest problem has been finding well qualified and reliable employees. “Today’s
youth do not like to work hard and are not careful. They don’t have good work
habits. It is very hard to find good workers.” With a business that depends
on customer loyalty, she has had a hard time finding workers who have a
pleasant and friendly attitude towards the customers.
impetus and ideas for the women in Bosnia schemes, have received donor support in heard. The report highlights the many positive
and Herzegovina (box 3.1). Bosnia and Herzegovina. Yet these represent role models of Bosnian businesswomen, whose
ad-hoc activities in an environment that lacks success stories can provide inspiration to young
Government and donors should work with
a coordinated, strategic focus on women in women who are just starting out in their profes-
women’s businesses to ensure change
the private sector. sional life. By listening to the voices of Bosnia’s
Donor assistance in Bosnia and Herzegovina
women and documenting their inspirational
to date has focused overwhelmingly on issues The government has enacted supportive stories, the report demonstrates the vast but
such as women’s political participation, peace legislation and put in place a machinery to underutilized potential of women and sends the
building, or trafficking. In other post-conflict address gender concerns, including Gender message of how important it is to implement
countries donors have traditionally supported Centers at the state level and at the level of policies that will encourage and strengthen
similar gender activities, typically failing to entities, and Gender Equality Commissions. their performance.
capitalize upon women’s economic potential. These organizations might be well placed to
Encouragingly, in recent years donors have strengthen support for women in the private
started to support initiatives geared towards sector, including engaging in advocacy on is-
women’s business potential, such as in Kosovo sues facing women entrepreneurs.
(box 3.2). Some economic empowerment
initiatives, such as the BHcrafts initiative This report is one advocacy tool that women
L e j la S paho , P erspe - H a v a F azli ć , C leaning .
described earlier in this report or micro-credit can take to policy makers to make their views kti v a E ngineering , S er v ice S E I F , H air and .
Visoko T anning S alon , F lower S hop.
K alesi j a
Box 3.1: Networking for Success: Examples Box 3.2: Donors Promoting Women
L ejla Spaho has an impressive resume
—she is a teacher at a secondary school A fter living in Germany for several years, Hava returned to her
of Women’s Business Associations Entrepreneurs in Kosovo in Visoko, the national head of the BH small Bosnian town of Kalesija in 1997 filled with optimism about
National Association of Women Faced with poor employment prospects and Women’s Economic Network, a cantonal the future, but also with various business ideas. Yet she first focused
Business Owners a patriarchal system, women in Kosovo are representative, and also the owner of Pers- on family and spent some time raising her three children.
facing particular challenges as Kosovo strives pektiva Engineering, a firm providing services
With 9,000 women-owned businesses in to rebuild its institutions and economy. in consultancy, engineering, and architec- Hava soon got to work. She had always loved flowers, and started by
America as its members and 80 chapters tural design. After being a director of a selling flowers on the street in her town. Soon enough, there were
throughout the country, this association cre- To address the issue, the Swiss Agency for De- state-owned construction firm, she used her plenty of clients, and Hava opened a flower shop in 2004. Today she
ates networking opportunities for its members, velopment and Cooperation initiated a project business connections to open her company also owns a hair salon, a tanning salon, a greenhouse for growing
organizes nation-wide conferences and public in 2001 to foster small and medium enter- ten years ago. flowers, and a newly opened cleaning service SEIF. “I get the ideas
policy days, and provides tools for growing prises, with a particular focus on building skills for my businesses from listening to the needs of the customers. I
a business. For more information, visit their among young women. The program offers As a leader of the BH Women’s Economic brought back a lot of positive impressions from Germany,” she says.
website: http://www.nawbo.org/ courses for women entrepreneurs on business Network, Lejla is an advocate for issues She and her husband are now focusing increasingly on their cleaning
management, accounting, and marketing, as facing women in the economy and in busi- service. “People are not aware about cleaning services in this market.
Jordan Forum for Business and well as vocational training. A media campaign ness. According to Lejla, the network has We will need at least a year of advertising to acquaint
Professional Women and exhibitions showcasing women’s products about 1,800 members in each region of the people with the notion,” Hava says.
are designed to counter societal prejudices country, though a small number of these are
Established in 1976, the Forum provides a and encourage young women to enter the active. The network facilitates information A dynamic and hard-working woman, Hava
platform to develop, empower and advocate business arena. sharing, conducts research, advocacy, and manages to juggle her personal life with
for women in business in Jordan. For more training activities. the demands of her various businesses.
information, visit their website: http://www. For more information, visit: http://www. Despite the multiple demands on her
bpwa.org.jo/ swisscontact.org/english/pages/PR_Dn/PR_ According to Lejla, “part of the problem day, she finds time for family and
Dn_005_Img.php with the network has been that the women usually leaves work by 4 or 5pm. “I
Global Directory of Women’s members expected financial support from love to work but I am also attached
Business Associations the network. Also, businesswomen have to my family. I usually cook myself.
no time to be part of an association given But I am having a harder time
IFC’s Gender Program houses a Global all their other obligations.” Yet she remains making time for friends these days.”
Directory of Women’s Business Associations, a passionate advocate for women in busi- As if managing a growing family and
searchable by country: http://rru.worldbank. ness, taking a leadership role and an active various businesses were not enough
org/External/psd-gender/ part in the network’s training activities and work, Hava is also studying on a part-time
learning exchanges. basis for a university degree in economics.
28 | Voices of Women Entrepreneurs in Bosnia and Herzegovina Voices of Women Entrepreneurs in Bosnia and Herzegovina | 29
b Conduct further research into concerns facing women in business, and ensure
business surveys are sex-disaggregated and analyzed by gender.
Many Bosnian women Highlight Women’s Success Stories to Raise the Profile of Women . Businesswomen, media,
are held back by poor in Business government and donors
self-confidence and lack
of a belief in their ability b Increase awareness of women’s potential in business and highlight the success
to succeed in business. stories of women in the private sector, such as through this publication, by work-
ing with the media and sponsoring events that celebrate women’s achievements
in business.
30 | Voices of Women Entrepreneurs in Bosnia and Herzegovina Voices of Women Entrepreneurs in Bosnia and Herzegovina | 31
ENDNOTES REFERENCES
1
ILO (2008). 23
UNECE (2004). Agency for Statistics of Bosnia-Herzegovina. Investment and Growth in Bosnia & Herze-
2
Agency for Statistics of Bosnia-Herzegovina 24
Sabarwal and Terrell (2008). 2007. “Labor Force Survey 2007: Preliminary govina.” Foreign Investors Council, Sarajevo
(2007). 25
Bosnia and Herzegovina shares its rank in Data.” Agency for Statistics of Bosnia-Herze- and Banja Luka.
3
(World Bank 2007a). the Transparency International index with govina, Sarajevo.
Global Rights. 2004. “Shadow Report on the Im-
4
World Bank (2001). The currency conversion Montenegro, Macedonia, Gabon, Jamaica,
Baksic-Muftic, Jasna et al. 2003. “Socio-Eco- plementation of CEDAW and Women’s Human
into US$ is as of April 2008. Kiribati, Lesotho, Maldives, Swaziland, and
nomic Status of Women in BiH: Analysis of Rights in Bosnia and Herzegovina.” Sarajevo.
5
Baksic-Muftic, Jasna et al. (2002). Thailand.
Results of a Star Pilot Survey.” World Learning
6
Interview with Global Rights, Sarajevo, 26
Foreign Investors Council (2007). Helsinki Committee for Human Rights in
September 2007. 27
World Bank (2007b). STAR Network. Jez, Sarajevo.
Bosnia and Herzegovina. 2008. “Report on
7
Wash, Martha (1997). 28
International Monetary Fund (2007). Centre for Enterprise and Economic Develop- the Status of Human Rights in Bosnia and
8
World Bank (2005a). 29
Muravyev et al (2007). ment Research. 2000. “Young Entrepreneurs, Herzegovina.” Sarajevo.
9
Agency for Statistics of Bosnia-Herzegovina 30
World Bank (2001). Women Entrepreneurs, Ethnic Minority
(2007). A person is defined as unemployed 31
Demirguc-Kunt, Asli, Leora Klapper, and ILO. 2008. “Global Employment Trends for
Entrepreneurs and Co-Entrepreneurs in the
if during the last week prior to the survey Georgios Panos (2007). Women.” ILO, Geneva.
European Union and Central and Eastern Eu-
interview they: a) did not work, in paid or 32
Zuckerman, Elaine and Ann Graham rope.” Middlesex University Business School, International Helsinki Federation for Human
self-employment; b) were actively seeking (2002); International Helsinki Federation for United Kingdom. Rights. 2000. Women 2000: An Investigation into
work; c) were currently available for work. Human Rights (2000).
the Status of Women’s Rights in Central and South-
10
Agency for Statistics of Bosnia-Herzegovina 33
International Monetary Fund (2006). Demirguc-Kunt, Asli, Leora Klapper and
Eastern Europe and the Newly Independent States.
(2007). 34
International Monetary Fund (2006). Georgios Panos. 2007. “The Origins of Self-
New York and Vienna: International Helsinki
11
Yemtsov, Ruslan and Erwin Tiongson. 35
MI-BOSPO Market Analysis and Com- Employment.” World Bank, Washington, DC.
Federation for Human Rights. Available at:
(2008). parison with Competitors. Internal Report.
DFID. 2005. “Labor and Social Policy in Bos- http://www.ihf-hr.org/publicat.htm.
12
UNECE (2004). March 2008.
nia-Herzegovina: the Development of Policies
13
US Census: http://www.census.gov/Press- 36
World Bank (2007a). International Monetary Fund. 2007. “Bosnia
and Measures for Social Mitigation. Living in
Release/www/releases/archives/income_ 37
Foreign Investors Council (2007). and Herzegovina: Selected Issues.” IMF Coun-
BIH: Panel Study Wave 4 Report.” Bosnia and
wealth/005647.html 38
World Bank (2005c). try Report No 7/269. IMF, Washington, DC.
Herzegovina Council of Ministers, Sarajevo.
14
DFID (2005). 39
World Bank (2005b).
15
Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina Fed- 40
FIAS (2001). International Monetary Fund. 2006. “Bosnia and
EBRD and World Bank. 2002. “Bosnia and
eral Office of Statistics (2006). 41
World Bank (2005b). Herzegovina Business Environment and Herzegovina Financial System Stability Assess-
16
World Bank (2005a). 42
Helsinki Committee for Human Rights in ment.” World Bank and IMF, Washington, DC.
Enterprise Performance Survey (BEEPS2).”
17
Sabarwal, Shwetlena and Katherine Terrell Bosnia and Herzegovina (2008). Washington, DC. Muravyev, Alexander et al. 2007. “Entrepre-
(2008). 43
Global Rights (2004).
neurs’ Gender and Financial Constraints: Evi-
18
World Values Survey. Bosnia data accessible 44
Global Rights (2004). Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina Federal
dence from International Data.” Discussion
online: http://www.worldvaluessurvey.org/ 45
UNESCO (2006). Data on kindergarten fees Office of Statistics. 2006. “Women and Men
Paper 706. German Institute for Economic
19
World Bank (2005a). reflects approximate fees in 2008. in Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina.”
Research, Berlin.
20
Demirguc-Kunt, Asli, Leora Klapper and 46
Sandor, Maria (1997). Federal Office of Statistics, Sarajevo.
Georgios Panos (2007). 47
Centre for Enterprise and Economic Republika Srpska Institute of Statistics. 2007.
FIAS. 2001. “Bosnia and Herzegovina Com-
21
Baksic-Muftic, Jasna et al. (2003). Development Research (2000). “Women and Men in Republika Srpska No.
mercial Legal Framework and Administrative
22
State Agency for Statistics, Republika Srpska 4.” Banja Luka.
Barriers to Investment.” FIAS, Washington, DC.
Institute of Statistics, Federation of BiH In-
stitute of Statistics and World Bank (2002); Sandor, Maria. 1997. “Women Entrepre-
Foreign Investors Council. 2007. “White
DFID (2005). neurship in Central and Eastern Europe.”
Paper 2007: Priority Solutions for Obstacles to
32 | Voices of Women Entrepreneurs in Bosnia and Herzegovina
REFERENCES
Economic Reform Today, Number II, CIPE, World Bank. 2005a. “Bosnia and Herzegovina
Washington, DC. Country Economic Memorandum.” Report
No. 29500-BA. Poverty Reduction and Eco-
Sabarwal, Shwetlena and Katherine Terrell. nomic Management Unit, Europe and Central
2008. “Does Gender Matter for Firm Perofor- Asia Region. Washington, DC.
mance: Evidence from the East European and
Central Asian Region.” PREM Gender, World World Bank. 2005b. “Bosnia and Herzegovina
Bank, Washington, DC. Labor Market Update: the Role of Industrial
Relations.” Human Development Sector Unit,
State Agency for Statistics, Republika Srp- Europe and Central Asia Region. World Bank,
ska Institute of Statistics, Federation of BiH Washington, DC.
Institute of Statistics, and World Bank. 2002.
“Welfare in Bosnia and Herzegovina 2001: World Bank. 2005c. “Project Appraisal Docu-
Measurement and Findings.” Sarajevo. ment: Bosnia and Herzegovina Education
Restructuring Project.” Report No. 31840-BA.
UNECE. 2004. “Access to Financing and ITC Human Development Sector Unit, South East
in the UNECE Region.” Geneva and New York. Europe Country Unit, Europe and Central
UNESCO. 2006. “Bosnia and Herzegovina; Asia Region. Washington, DC.
Early Childhood Care and Education Pro- World Bank. 2001. “Bosnia Herzegovina
grammes.” Report UNESCO, Geneva. Living Standards Measurement Study Survey
US Census Bureau. 2005. “Income Stable, 2001.” World Bank, Washington, DC.
Poverty Rate Increases, Percentage of Ameri- World Economic Forum. “The Global
cans without Health Insurance Unchanged.” Gender Gap Report 2007.” World Economic
Press Release, August 30. Available online: Forum, Geneva.
http://www.census.gov/Press-Release/www/re-
leases/archives/income_wealth/005647.html World Values Survey. Available online: http://
www.worldvaluessurvey.org/
Wash, Martha. 1997. “Post-Conflict Bosnia
and Herzegovina: Integrating Women’s Special Yemtsov, Ruslan and Erwin Tiongson. 2008.
Situation and Gender Perspectives in Skills “Bosnia and Herzegovina 2001-2004: Enter-
Training and Employment Promotion Pro- prise Restructuring, Labor Market Transitions,
grammes.” ILO, Geveva. and Poverty.” World Bank. Policy Research
Working Paper 4479.
World Bank. 2007a. Doing Business in 2008.
World Bank, Washington, DC. Zuckerman, Elaine and Ann Graham. 2002.
“USAID/Federal Republic of Yugoslavia: Gen-
World Bank. 2007b. “New Doing Business der Assessment of Serbia and Montenegro.”
Global Report Shows BiH Falling Further Development Alternatives, Washington, DC.
Behind the Region.” Press Release, September
26, Washington, DC.
MKF ‘MI-BOSPO’
Bosne srebrene bb
75 000 Tuzla
Bosnia and Herzegovina
Tel: ++ 387 35 270 283
Fax: ++ 387 35 252 448
www.mi-bospo.org