Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
information/complaint + Asking him whether o Not a strict right, but a discretion justified by
he pleads guilty or not guilty. compelling reasons (error, fraud, illegality or
o No arraignment in absentia. Presence of accused manifest injustice).
is not only a personal right but also a public duty.
o No trial in absentia without first arraigning the SUSPENSION OF ARRAIGNMENT
accused; otherwise, judgment is null and void. o Grounds:
1) Accused appears to be suffering from an
TC’s DUTY BEFORE ARRAIGNMENT unsound mental condition which effectively
1) Inform accused that he has right to have his own renders him unable to fully understand the
counsel before being arraigned; charge against him and to plead intelligently
2) Ask WON he desires aid of counsel; thereto.
3) If yes, must grant him reasonable time to do so; o Court shall order his mental examination
4) Must assign counsel de officio. and (if necessary) confinement.
o X: Accused allowed to defend himself in 2) Prejudicial question.
person or has employed a counsel of his 3) Pending petition for review of resolution of
choice. the prosecutor either at the DOJ or the Office
o X: Accused expressly and formally of the President.
renounced the right. o Provided: Suspension not > 60 days
counted from filing of the petition.
TYPES OF PLEA
1) Admission – “Guilty”.
a) Plea of guilty to non-capital offense: PRE-TRIAL
o Court may receive evidence to determine
the penalty to be imposed. PRE-TRIAL CONFERENCE
o Sufficient to sustain a conviction if • In all criminal cases cognizable by the
formally + knowingly + voluntarily Sandiganbayan, RTC and MTC/MTCC/MCTC/MeTC.
entered into. • After arraignment and within 30 days from time
o A judicial confession of guilt, so no need court acquires jurisdiction over person of the
for additional evidence. accused.
o X: • X: Shorter periods under special laws or SC
(1) If information did not allege all circulars.
the crime’s elements.
(2) If information charges a capital PRE-TRIAL AGREEMENTS AND SUBMISSIONS
offense.
(3) If plea of guilt was conditional. Pre-trial stipulations Judicial admissions
b) Plea of guilty to capital offense: Entered into by parties Made by either party
o Mandatory duties of the trial judge: During pre-trial In the course of the trial
(1) Conduct searching inquiry into the conference
voluntariness and full comprehension Facts agreed on prior to
of the consequences of the plea. the actual presentation of
(2) Require prosecution to prove guilt evidence or during trial
and precise degree of culpability. proper
(3) Inquire WON accused wishes to Need not be specially set
present evidence on his behalf and out in a judicial order to
allow him to do so if he desires. bind the parties - admitted
o If improvident plea of guilty to a capital fact thus deemed
offense: Remand case to lower court for established
further proceedings. More expedient - relieves
o X: If accused appears guilty beyond court of burden of issuing
a judicial order
reasonable doubt from evidence
adduced by prosecution and defense.
2) Denial – “Not guilty”. PRE-TRIAL ORDER
3) Qualified admission – “Guilty, but” o Contents:
a) Plea of guilty to a lesser offense necessarily 1) Actions taken;
included in the offense charged. 2) Facts stipulated; &
o Plea bargaining = Pleading guilty to 3) Evidence marked.
lesser offense or to only one/some of the o Effect:
counts of a multi-count indictment in 1) Binds parties.
return for a lighter sentence. 2) Limits the trial to matters not disposed of.
o May also include amending of information 3) Generally, controls the course of action during
to allege more mitigating circumstances. trial.
b) Plea of guilt, but accused presents o X: If modified to prevent manifest
exculpatory evidence. injustice.
o Plea deemed withdrawn and a plea of not
guilty entered for him.
GENERAL PROCEDURE FOR TRIAL
IMPROVIDENT PLEA
= Plea without proper information as to all the TIME TO PREPARE FOR TRIAL
circumstances affecting it; based upon a mistaken o The accused has at least 15 days, after a plea of
assumption or misleading information/advice. not guilty is entered.
o Should not be accepted. If accepted, not sufficient o Notice to the parties required. COC notifies
to sustain a conviction. parties of date of arraignment, which should
be 30 days from the date court acquires
WITHDRAWAL OF PLEA jurisdiction over person of the accused. Within
o Allowed anytime before judgment of conviction the same period, court shall set pre-trial
becomes final. conference.
o If accused pleads not guilty on arraignment, o To meet/refute those new matters taken up
he has 15 days to prepare for trial (including during rebuttal, or to clarify matters that were
pre-trial). made ambiguous.
o Trial to commence within 30 days from receipt of 6) Submission of case.
pre-trial order. o Case deemed submitted for decision upon
o Effect of delay: Accused may move to dismiss for admission of parties’ evidence.
denial of his right to speedy trial. o X: If court directs them to argue orally or
o Subject to double jeopardy rules. submit written memoranda.
o If with prejudice, case cannot be revived
anymore. Otherwise, revival is proper.
o Failure to move for dismissal prior to trial is a DISCHARGE OF AN ACCUSED TO BE A
waiver of the right to dismiss under this
section.
STATE WITNESS
Dismissal without Dismissal with o Prosecutor must to include all the accused in the
prejudice prejudice complaint/information.
Allows new suit for same Adjudication on the o X: Prosecutor may ask the court to discharge
cause of action merits, and final one of them.
disposition, barring right o Applies only if information is already filed in court.
to bring or maintain an o Requisites:
action on the same claim 1) 2 or more persons jointly charged.
or cause 2) Petition for discharge filed before defense
Imports contemplation of Is RJ as to every matter offers evidence.
further proceedings, and litigated 3) Hearing on the petition.
when they appear in an 4) Court is satisfied of the ff:
order or decree, it shows a) Absolute necessity for the testimony;
that the judicial act is not o He alone has knowledge of the crime.
intended to be RJ of the
b) No other direct evidence available for
merits
proper prosecution of the offense, except
Terminates case reserving
the testimony;
to plaintiff the right to file
new complaint which, if
c) Testimony can be substantially
filed, is entirely new and corroborated in its material points;
different from the case d) Accused does not appear to be the most
which was dismissed guilty;
e) Accused never convicted of any offense
ORDER OF TRIAL involving moral turpitude.
1) Prosecution evidence. o Effect of discharge:
o To prove charge (and civil liability). 1) Amounts to an acquittal;
2) Demurrer to evidence = Objection that the 2) Bars future prosecutions for same offense.
evidence prosecution produced is insufficient in o X: If accused fails/refuses to testify
point of law (WON true) to make out a case or against his co-accused in accordance with
sustain the issue. his sworn statement constituting the basis
o Right of accused to present evidence after for his discharge.
demurrer is denied: o Error in asking for and in granting the discharge
cannot deprive the discharged of the acquittal and
If filed with leave of If filed without the guaranty against double jeopardy.
court leave of court o Subsequent amendment of the information does
May adduce evidence in Waives the right to not affect discharge.
his defense present evidence
Purpose of obtaining Submits case for CO-ACCUSED WHO CANNOT BE DISCHARGED
leave of court: To judgment on basis of UNDER RULE 119, SEC. 17
determine WON demurrer evidence for prosecution o If tried separately and has already testified as
was filed merely to stall witness without having been previously
the proceedings discharged.
Implied leave of court no If there are 2 or more
longer sufficient and accused and only one RA 6981 (Witness Rule 119, Sec. 17
prevents accused from presents demurrer Protection Program)
presenting evidence without leave of court: Limited only to grave Applies to all felonies
o Court may defer felony under RPC or its
resolution until equivalent under special
decision is rendered on law
the other accused Absolute necessity for Suffice that there is no
o X: If it can be testimony other direct evidence for
shown from the proper prosecution of
decision that offense committed except
resolution on testimony of accused
demurrer was Witness automatically Witness must still apply
rendered not only entitled to certain rights for the employment of
on the basis of and benefits said rights
prosecution’s Any member of the The same is not required
evidence but also family of the person
on the evidence applying for admission
adduced by his co- within the 2nd civil
accused degree of consanguinity
or affinity is subjected to
3) Defense evidence. threat to his life or injury,
4) Rebuttal evidence. as to prevent him from
o To explain/repeal/counter/disprove the testifying falsely or
defense evidence. evasively
5) Surrebuttal evidence. Witness applying not a No limitation
REFERRAL TO LUPON