Você está na página 1de 3

So you found some quotes from the MRM and took to the fainting couch huh? No context, no analysis?

If we look at each of those quotes in context, it may take 15-20 minutes to clear it up. You know that two can play this game right? Perhaps we look at quotes from FAMOUS feminists? Lets give this typical MRA from AVFM a teaching lesson. Courtesy of SaelPalani. Ready? First, I find it quite odd you would accuse the author of missing the context of the published quotes directly from the Manosphere and MRAs. Whats even more strange is that you dont even attempt to correct it. Instead, whats your focus? Not helping your own supposed movement (which is more like bowel movement) but once again bashing on women and feminists. First quote about nuclear family. The nuclear family was the seat of patriarchy. Pater: father. It meant that families were constructed with a man at their head who made all the decisions and had the final voice. Thats oppression of women. Clearly, feminists attacked this basic form of patriarchy: the nuclear family. Second quote about man hating. If you knew anything about class analysis in feminism you wouldve understood this quote. Its not about hating men because of their gender. Its about taking on the privileged class that oppresses the underclass. This goes for the civil rights struggle which was about taking on the ruling white class who was oppressing blacks.

Third quote. Again this is about class consciousness. White het men ARE the privileged CLASS who have a vested interest in maintaining their power. What you also probably dont know is that Robyn Morgan, the authoress, wrote a book over 20 years ago which predicted your reactionary backlash movement. It also talks about men doing housework.

Fourth Quote. The institution of marriage set in motion the nuclear family which, as I already stated, is the basic form of Patriarchy. Getting rid of traditional marriage is in no way saying get rid of men. Fifth quote about rape. This is a political and social commentary about the definition of consent. It was previously assumed that consent was passive meaning it was already in place so that if sex was initiated and nothing was stated by the other party, that they had consented. This quote challenges the passivity of consent and states it should be made active, by the initiation of sex (consent) of the woman. I think its also important to point out that while youre trying to smear Robin Morgan I will also give you this quote of hers since you arent versed at all in feminism.

And let's put one lie to rest for all time: the lie that men are oppressed, too, by sexism -- the lie that there can be such a thing as "men's liberation groups." Oppression is something that one group of people commits against another group specifically because of a "threatening" characteristic shared by the latter group -- skin color or sex or age, etc. Ah yes, the SCUM Manifesto. It seems to me you havent read nor understood the entire piece. It was a futuristic tale about men and women and how only certain men and certain woman would thrive in her new world. I suggest reading that one again. Quote by Katherine MacKinnon. Another political quote. Has nothing to do with hating men and everything to do with the consent issue I already explained. Passive v Active consent in the law. You mention another MacKinnon quote that MacKinnon NEVER made. MacKinnon is a law professor, after all. I bet you didnt know that!

Quoting Sharon Stone is not indicative of a feminist quote. Fail on that one. I could point out several male actors and their not so nice quotes about women. In fact you guys like Tom Leykis an awful lot and he says the most outrageous misogynistic things. Another familiar quote by Mary Daly. Shes not saying she ADVOCATES for reduction of males. Do you have ANY reading comprehension skills at all? She says it will naturally happen, It was an interview question that prompted this quote and the FULL quote is: I think it's not a bad idea at all. If life is to survive on this planet, there must be a decontamination of the
Earth. I think this will be accompanied by an evolutionary process that will result in a drastic reduction of the population of males. People are afraid to say that kind of stuff anymore.

The myth of rampant false rape claims is popular with you MRAs that dont seem to live in reality. The facts are this: The FBI doesnt know but its LESS THAN 8%. It could very well be .5%. In fact when MRAs put up that horrible misogynist poster about this false rape claim hysteria the Edmonton Police told you the stats were NIL for false rape claims. The quote youre using is another political quote that deals with your myth. The fact is, rape is a double victimization. The officials in charge of prosecuting these cases barely get a conviction and they also intimidate the victim. What hes saying is ALMOST ALL rapes are true and hes right. Catherine Comins quote. What shes saying is that men hardly ever know what its like to be DOUBLY victimized as a rape victim when they go to law enforcement. Shes asking men to have empathy for female rape victims since its mostly women who are terrorized in this way. I mean, look at how you Manosphere types go after women online. Barbara Jordan quote. Thats accurate. Think about how youre behaving online and how Paul Elam and the rest of the Manosphere behaves. I think youre showing that quote to have relevancy. Germaine Greer quote. Gee, it has me puzzled why you would even think that quote has anything to do with man hating.

The NOW quote. Another one that has no bearing on your supposed feminist bashing. Suggesting political lesbianism isnt a big deal. No more so than suggesting men go their own way. I find it pretty sad that you are using a quote from a Suffragette as proof of some feminist conspiracy against men while your original claim was that the Author of this piece didnt accurate portray the context. Elizabeth Cady Stantons full quote was this: We are, as a sex, infinitely superior to men, and if we were free and developed, healthy in body and mind, as we should be under natural conditions, our motherhood would be our glory. That function gives women such wisdom and power as no male can possess.

Shes talking about Motherhood, not some plan to end men. Your comment is the perfect example of how Mens Rights Activists arent at all thinking about the issues relating to the sexes but are more interested in womanhating, as the many quotes in this article suggest. The main point is that your movement is not about equality or human rights. Its about tearing down women. Now would you like to stick to the original point and correct the author on his supposed mistakes?

Você também pode gostar