Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
By Richard L. Dixon
It was with great interest and expectation that I had the opportunity to both read and
review Amy Chua’s Book entitled World Fire: How Exporting Free Market Democracy
Breeds Ethnic Hatred and Global Instability. Usually a book of this magnitude is bogged
down with endless statistics without really getting to the relevant point that they are
trying to get across to the reader. However, Ms. Chua leads no stones unturned in her
analysis that the introduction of neo-liberalization free market policies into developing
countries can cause ethnic unrest, backlash, and violence against minorities in countries
that dominated the market-based economy and often were oppressive to the entrenched
the problems that the country of Malaysia experienced with both the ethnic Minority
Chinese and Indians who had assumed all economic power in terms of ownership in
businesses, land, homes, and money at the expense of the impoverished Malay majority
The resentment by the Malay majority towards the Chinese resulted in the race riots of
May 1969 which scores were killed. “The term Bumiputra or Sons of the Soil is a
Malaysian identity that connects the original population to their land, culture, and ruler
(Sultanate). However, the Sons of the Soil became a different meaning for Malaysia as it
evolved into a pluralistic and multicultural society with the introduction of Cheap
Chinese & Indian Labor. This manifested itself in the May races of 1969 which the Malay
majority protested the inequality economically that they endured at the expense of the
It was fortunate that both the Chinese and Indian Minority saw the wisdom (with some
Political Arm-twisting by former Malaysian Prime Minister Dr. Tun Mahathir bin
Mohamad) in standing behind affirmative action efforts to bridge the economic and
inequality gap between them and the Malay Majority with the introduction of the NEP
(National Economic Policy), the Second Malaysian Plan, and Vision 2020 which
launched the country as a regional economical power. Yet even Ms. Chua contends that
the Chinese still hold the reins of power economically in that country. “In Malaysia, too,
privatization and other market policies have starkly magnified the economic dominance
of the country’s Chinese minority. This is true despite extensive affirmative action
policies for the indigenous Malay majority, which has been in place ever since bloody
anti-Chinese riots in 1969 left nearly a thousand dead in Kuala Lumpur. Today, the
(Amy Chua, 2004). Unfortunately the Chinese minorities in the country of Indonesia
weren’t as fortunate as their Malaysian counterparts and were massacred in the thousands
Ms. Chua in her book has been especially critical of the Chinese even though she is of the
same racial lineage. After the murder of her Aunt in the Philippines by one of her staff, is
one of the factors that prompted Ms. Chua write this book. “My family is part of the
percent of the population, Chinese Filipinos control as much as 60 percent of the private
economy, including the country’s four major airlines and almost all of the country’s
It should be interesting to note, that 95% of the 250 full and part-time employees on the
Island of Diego Garcia who work in the MWR (Morale Welfare & Recreation) Clubs
Division that I oversee, are Filipinos. They are hardworking, loyal, loving, and generous
employees. This has given me a unique perspective that Ms. Chua so elaborately writes
about in the first part of her book. I remember one of my Club Managers telling me about
General Manager in one of the Restaurants. He stated that the Casino was Chinese
owned, and in a concerted efforts with female Chinese pawn shop owners, would often
book rooms in the Casino itself. Nightly the Chinese pawn shop owners would wait
patiently downstairs for the Filipino patrons of the Casino who would have gambled
away all of their money. The Filipino gamblers finding them selves desperate to get cash
to continue to feed into their addiction, would then seek out the Chinese pawn shop
owners who would have readily available cash. The one catch though was that the
Filipino gamblers would have to sign over their prized possessions such as cars, houses,
and businesses. Often the exchange rate was unfair, because the Filipinos would get
pittance for the true value of their property. Yet the Chinese Pawnshop owners would
have amasses a huge profit and then turns around and sell the property at substantially
marked up rates to other gullible and unsuspecting Filipinos. In essence, Ms. Chua’s
contention about the cruelty and underhanded business practices that the Chinese use
enterprise and neo-liberal democracy that is exported by the United States to other
emerging nations have not been practiced since the end of the 19th and beginning of the
20th century.
“Contrary to what its proponents assume, free markets outside the West do not spread
wealth evenly and enrich entire developing societies. Instead, they tend to concentrate
glaring wealth in the hands of an outside minority, generating ethnic envy and hatred
What happens when democracy is added to this volatile mixture? In countries with a
(Amy Chua). The rising anti-Semitism in the Russian Republic is a textbook example to
The one thing that Ms. Chua clearly points out in her book is that the forces of
economical and political uncontrolled Globalization is at the center of all of this madness.
In fact, my studies have shown that her book is but one piece of the puzzle in
and emerging nations. Naomi Klein in her book entitled “Shock Doctrine: The Rise of
“This book a challenge to the central and most cherished clam in the official story-that
the triumph of deregulated capitalism has been born of freedom that unfettered free
markets go hand in hand with democracy. Instead, I will show that this fundamentalist
form of capitalism has consistently been midwifed by the most brutal form of coercion,
inflicted on the collective body politic as well as on countless individual bodies. The
The third piece of this puzzle in the exporting and forced implementation of unregulated
market capitalism that both Ms. Klein and Ms. Chua allude can be found in the book by
Pepe Escobar entitled “How the Globalized World is Dissolving into Liquid War.” It is
Mr. Escobar’s observation that the forces of Globalization have torn the world apart into
spheres that threatens to escalate into uncontrolled conflicts and sieges. In fact, he views
combustible raging fires consume whole forest by sucking the oxygen the out of the air
and destroying anything living in its past, so too is the liquidity of uncontrolled
“Beyond strategic and political conflict, Liquid War tends towards the destruction of
anthropological genocide. If the future is being configured by Liquid War all actors are
positioning themselves for the decisive movement, the catharsis in Greek Drama, when
Liquid War boils to the point of Hot War. Dear Leader Kim Jong-il is a weak link; his acts
are very revealing, denouncing real fears. So are Hugo Chavez’s.” (Pepe Escobar, 2006).
In the end though, all three authors readily acknowledge that the very same forces of
Globalization that destroys cultures, nations, and economies are also the ones best suited
to set the path to lead emerging nations to development and the uplifting of their
populations out of the depths of misery and poverty. Yet these force must by harnessed
(just as we do with the capture of the sun’s rays in a solar control panel) and controlled by
prudent legislation with a social safety net to burden the fall of those who fall through the
cracks. “I am not arguing that all forms of market systems are inherently violent. It is
eminently possible to have a market-based economy that requires no such brutality and
demands no such ideological purity. A free market in consumer products can co-exist
with free public health care, with public schools, with a large segment of the economy-
like national oil company-held in state hands. It’s equally possible to require corporations
to pay decent wages, to respect the right of workers to form unions, and for governments
to tax and redistribute wealth so that the sharp inequalities that mark the corporatist state
Ms Chua concludes in her book that there are lessons to be learned by the industrialized
world, in that the best way to gain respectability is to promote a path of human rights and
pro-development for all people in an emerging nations and not just the entrenched few
who will reap the benefits. Promoting a form of market-based capitalism intertwined with
Darwin Lassie Faire principles is the wrong direction to take which is why the Global
South is in such a volatile state of ethnic conflict, war, civil strife, and economic
meltdown.
ENDNOTES
1. Richard L. Dixon, “Sons of the Soil (Bumiputra),” Abstract, Comparative
Political Systems, IRLS501 B001 Win 09, Dr. Thomas Kirkwood, Instructor,
(February, 2009), 1.
2. Amy Chua, World on Fire: How Exporting Free Market Democracy Breeds
Ethnic Hatred and Global Instability, (New York, Anchor Books, 2004), 15-16.
3. Ibid, 3.
4. Ibid, 4.
5. Naomi Klein, “The Shock Doctrine: The Rise of Disaster Capitalism, (New York:
6. (Pepe Escobar, Globalistan: How the Globalized World is Dissolving into Liquid