Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
By Michael Zimesnick on Wednesday, April 27, 2011 Solar energy obtained from solar panels is actually one of the cleanest energy sources even when you factor in the manufacturing process and end of life disposal. Most of the environmental impact actually occurs during production due to the electricity coming from coal and other unclean energies. Replacing these power sources with clean energies would greatly reduce the impact of solar panels on the environment.
Pure monocrystalline silicon wafer ready for production. Image by Stahlkocher. License: GNU FDL Silicon is the second most common element found on Earth behind Oxygen making it extremely environmentally friendly to mine when compared to things like coal and uranium. It is also relatively inert and only poses a danger if silicon dust is inhaled making it safe to work with as long as you take precautions. Even though silicon is a
benign material and clearly quite abundant, other chemicals used and created during the solar cell manufacturing process pose more serious environment and health risks. Cadmium, tellurium, gallium, arsenide, germanium, and indium are just a few of the chemicals used in the manufacturing of some solar cells. Although the currently popular crystalline silicon photovoltaic cells dont use these chemicals they do use lead and produce various waste products such as sulfur hexafluoride and nitrogen trifluoride which is 17,000 times more powerful as a greenhouse gas than carbon dioxide. [9] The environmental impact of these high efficiency solar cells depends on extended producer responsibility and the proper disposal of toxic components. The solar industry at large is not currently subject to extended producer responsibility but many believe it should be. Emerging technologies like organic solar cells or polymer photovoltaics make use of organic semiconductors greatly reducing any concerns about disposal. Another major concern is photovoltaic panels being produced in other countries with lax environmental protection laws. Western countries dont typically pose a problem as environmental protection regulations already exist but a large number of photovoltaics come from countries like China who are known for their poor track record with electronic waste. Recently reports came out that Luoyang Zhonggui High-Technology Co. was dumping toxic byproducts like silicon tetrachloride on nearby farms created from polysilicon production intended for solar cell manufacturing around the world.[10] It was surprising because this was a green energy company who might be expected to hold themselves to higher environmental standards.
The 14MW Nellis Solar Power Plant in Nevada, USA uses 140 acres of land. Image by US DOE. Solar power company BrightSource Energy ran into similar problems at a proposed 4,000 acre solar energy generation station that would impact the desert tortoise and an area of rare desert plants. [6] They came back with a new proposal that reduced the acreage by 12% and tried to avoid the area of rare plants but the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service said that the compromise did not fully resolve their concerns. In spite of these land use concerns, the solar energy footprint necessary to provide all electricity from photovoltaic sources is less than 2% of the crop and grazing land in the United States in addition to being less land than is currently used to produce corn for ethanol.[4] It is also less land than is used for coal power when land for the coal mining operations is included.
PV Cycle logo. PV Cycle does not endorse and is not affiliated with this site. Image owned by PV Cycle. Recently an association known as PV CYCLE was created to handle end of life issues relating to solar energy. This organization is composed of members of the photovoltaic energy industry who take on a voluntary commitment to assume the producers responsibility for the complete life cycle of our products. [5] Since photovoltaics have only recently been industrially produced there has yet to be any real demand for solar cell recycling. Though at this point it is promising that the industry appears to be self regulating, for the time being, and is preparing several years in advance of the first wave of end of life PVs. Many people would like to see extended producer responsibility (ERP) implemented in the solar industry and some companies like FirstSolar have voluntarily taken this on. ERP would force solar panel manufacturers to take back their products at end of life and be responsible for proper recycling and disposal. Some of the chemicals involved in certain photovoltaics like CdTe (Cadmium-Telluride) or CIGS (Copper Indium Gallium Selenide) solar cells are actually quite valuable and should provide an incentive for manufacturers to recycle their products. For example Tellurium is a somewhat rare element because it isnt primarily being mined for and as a result only a small amount (industrially speaking) is produced every year. Indium is quite rare as well and thus extremely expensive so solar panel manufacturers would essentially be wasting money by not recycling it. Also as mentioned previously some new technological advances in organic and polymer solar cells could allow for very disposal friendly panels to be created. Currently efficiency for these cells is at around 8% making them unattractive but they are a very promising future technology.
Sources:
1. NREL; Energy Payback: Clean Energy from PV 2. U.S. Energy Information Administration 3. LA Times; Native Americans sue U.S. over solar power plant 4. ScienceDirect; Land-use requirements and the per-capita solar footprint for photovoltaic generation in the
United States
5. PV CYCLE; Our voluntary commitment 6. NY Times; BrightSource Alters Solar Plant Plan 7. NY Times; Western Water War Slows Some Solar Projects 8. U.S. DOE; Energy Demands on Water Resources 9. Scripps Institution of Oceanography; Potent Greenhouse Gas More Prevalent in Atmosphere than Previously
Assumed
10. Washington Post; Solar Energy Firms Leave Waste Behind in China
http://renewableenergyindex.com/solar/environmental-impact-of-solar-panels