Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
ProjectRiskManagement
(PMBOKGuide)
MohammadA.Rajabi D t of Dept. fGeomatics G ti Eng., E University U i it of fTehran T h Tel:+982188334341,Cell:+989121325823 Email:marajabi@ut.ac.ir marajabi@ut ac ir Homepage:http://www.marajabi.com
TableofContent
GuidetoPMBOK
MohammadA.Rajabi
Introduction
Theprocessofconductingriskmanagement planning,identification,analysis,response planning andmonitoringandcontrolonaproject planning, Objective:increasetheprobabilityandimpactof positiveevents,anddecreasetheprobabilityand impactofnegativeevents Planriskmanagement Identify Id tif risks ik Performqualitativeriskanalysis Performquantitativeriskanalysis Planriskresponses Monitorandcontrolrisks
GuidetoPMBOK MohammadA.Rajabi 3
Introduction
Risk
Occursinfuture Anuncertaineventorcondition Mayeffect:scope,schedule,cost,performance,and quality Mayhaveoneormorecauses,oneormoreimpacts Arequirement, i t assumption, ti constraint, t i t orcondition diti createsthepossibilityofnegativeorpositive outcomes Limitedpersonnel,permitissue,limitedresources Contingencyplansshouldalwaysbethereasnotalof risks i k arek known! !
GuidetoPMBOK MohammadA.Rajabi 4
Introduction
Risk s to tolerance e a ce Riskattitudesadoptedbypeoplearedrivenby perception, p p tolerances,andotherbiases Consistentapproachtoriskshouldbedeveloped, andcommunicationaboutriskanditshandling shouldbeopenandhonest Riskresponseshouldbeabalancebetweenrisk t ki and taking drisk i ktolerance t l Riskmanagementshouldbeproactiveand consistentthroughoutproject
GuidetoPMBOK MohammadA.Rajabi 5
GuidetoPMBOK
MohammadA.Rajabi
11.1PlanRiskManagement
Thep processofhowtoconductriskmanagement g activities Successoftheotherfiveriskmanagement processeswillbeenhancedbycarefulandexplicit planning Thedegree,typeandvisibilityofrisk managementshouldbecommensuratewithboth therisksandimportanceoftheproject Important I toprovide id sufficient ffi i resourcesand d timeforriskmanagementactivities,andrisk evaluation
GuidetoPMBOK MohammadA.Rajabi 7
Inputs,Tools&Techniques, Outputs
GuidetoPMBOK
MohammadA.Rajabi
DataFlow
GuidetoPMBOK
MohammadA.Rajabi
Inputs
Projectscopestatement
Whattherisksareandhowsignificant g they yare
Costmanagementplan
Howriskbudgets,contingencies,andmanagement reserveswillbereportedandassessed
Schedulemanagementplan
Howschedulecontingencieswillbereportedassessed
Communicationsmanagementplan
Whotoshareinformationonvariousrisksandresponses atdifferenttimes
Enterpriseenvironmentalfactors
Riskattitudesandtolerances(thedegreeofriskthatan organizationwithstand)
GuidetoPMBOK MohammadA.Rajabi 10
Input
Organizationalprocessassets
Riskcategories Commondefinitionsofconcepts p Riskstatementformats Standardtemplates p Rolesandresponsibilities Authoritylevelsfordecisionmaking Lessonslearned,and Stakeholderregisters
GuidetoPMBOK MohammadA.Rajabi 11
ToolsandTechniques
Planningmeetingsandanalysis
Attendees
Projectmanager Selectedteammembersandstakeholders Anyonewithinorganizationinchargeofmanagingriskplanningan executingactivities
Highlevelplansaredefinedincludingriskmanagement costandschedule Risk kcontingencyreserveapplication l approaches h are establishedandreviewed Responsibilitiesareassigned Templatesforriskcategories,definitionoftermslikelevel ofrisk,probabilitybytypeofrisk,impactbytypeof objectives,andprobabilityandimpactmatrixwillbe t il dt tailored toth thespecific ifi project j t
GuidetoPMBOK MohammadA.Rajabi 12
Outputs
Riskmanagementplan
Methodology(approaches,tools,anddatasourcestoperform riskmanagement) Rolesandresponsibilities(lead,support,andriskmanagement t team members, b and dtheir th i responsibilities) ibiliti ) Budgeting(assignresources,estimatesfunds,andestablishes protocolsofcontingencyreserve) Timing(whenandhowoftenshouldtheriskmanagement processshouldbeperformed,establishesprotocolsfor applicationofschedulecontingencyreserves,andestablishes riskmanagementactivitiestobeincludedintheproject schedule) Riskcategories(processofsystematicallyidentifyingrisks. Simplelist/structuresintoRiskBreakdownStructure(RBS))
GuidetoPMBOK
MohammadA.Rajabi
13
ExampleofRiskBreakdown Structure(RBS)
GuidetoPMBOK
MohammadA.Rajabi
14
Outputs
Definitionofriskprobabilityandimpact
Negativeperspective Positiveperspective
GuidetoPMBOK
MohammadA.Rajabi
15
DefinitionofImpactScalesforFour ProjectObjectives
GuidetoPMBOK
MohammadA.Rajabi
16
Outputs
Probabilityandimpactmatrix(risksareprioritized basedontheirpotentialimplications Revisedstakeholderstolerances Reportingformat(howtodocument,analyze,and communicatetheoutcomesoftherisk management tprocesses) ) Tracking(documentshowriskactivitiesare recordedforthebenefitofthecurrentproject, project as wellasforfutureneedsandlessonslearned,and howriskmanagementprocesseswillbeaudited
GuidetoPMBOK MohammadA.Rajabi 17
11.2IdentifyRisks
Theprocessofdeterminingwhichrisksmayaffect theprojectanddocumentingtheircharacteristics Projectmanager manager, teammembers, members risk managementteam,customers,subjectmatter experts,endusers,otherprojectmanagers, stakeholders,andriskmanagementexperts shouldp participate p Iterativeprocess, frequencydependsonsituation
GuidetoPMBOK
MohammadA.Rajabi
18
Inputs,Tools&Techniques, Outputs
GuidetoPMBOK
MohammadA.Rajabi
19
Data Flow
GuidetoPMBOK
MohammadA.Rajabi
20
Inputs
Riskmanagementplan(rolesandresponsibilities,riskmanagement activitiesinbudgetandschedule, schedule riskcategories) Activitycostestimation(providesquantitativeassessmentofthe likelycosttocompletescheduledactivities) Activitydurationestimation(providesquantitativeassessmentof thelikelytimetocompletescheduledactivities) Scopebaseline(assumptionsmadeandtheiruncertainty,atboth microandmacrolevels) Stakeholderregister(forsolicitinginputsforidentifyingrisks) Costmanagementplan(maygenerateoralleviateriskbyitsnature orstructure) Schedule h d l managementplan l (may ( generateoralleviate ll risk kby b its natureorstructure) Qualitymanagementplan(maygenerateoralleviateriskbyits natureorstructure)
GuidetoPMBOK MohammadA.Rajabi 21
Inputs
Projectdocuments
Assumptionslog Workperformancereports Earnedvaluereports Networkdiagrams Baselines,and O h project Other j i information f i proved dtobe b valuable l bl Publishedinformationincludingcommercialdatabases Academicchecklists Benchmarking Industrystudies,and Riskattitudes Projectfilesincludingactualdata Organizationalandprojectprocesscontrols Riskstatementtemplatesand Lessonslearned
MohammadA.Rajabi 22
Enterpriseenvironmentalfactors
O Organizational i i lprocessassets
GuidetoPMBOK
ToolsandTechniques
Documentationreviews(plans,assumptions,previous projectfiles,contracts,andotherinformation Informationgatheringtechniques
Brainstorming g( (tog getcomprehensive p listofproject p j risksusing g multidisciplinaryexperts,andthecategorizingtheideas) Delphitechniques(questionnaire,anonymous,unbiased) Interviewing(experiencedprojectparticipants,stakeholders, andsubjectmatterexperts) Rootcauseanalysis(toidentifyproblem,discoverthe underlyingcause,developpreventionaction)
Ch Checklist kli analysis l i (b (based donhi historical i li information f i and d knowledge.ThelowestlevelofRBSisagoodpointtostart, shouldalwaysbereviewedtoincorporatenewlessons learned)
GuidetoPMBOK MohammadA.Rajabi 23
ToolsandTechniques
Assumptionsanalysis(tocheckthevalidityofthe assumptions,theiraccuracy,instability,inconsistencyor incompletenessofthem) Diagrammingtechniques
Causeandeffectdiagrams(orIshikawa/fishbonediagrams) System/processflowcharts(showinghowvariouselementsofa systeminterrelate,andthemechanismofcausation) Influencediagrams(graphicalrepresentationsofsituation showingcasualinfluences,timeorderingofevents,andother relationshipsamongvariablesandoutcomes SWOTanalysis(Strength (Strength,Weakness Weakness,Opportunities, Opportunities Threats. Threats Strengthsshouldoffsetthreats,opportunitiesovercome weakness) Expertjudgment
GuidetoPMBOK MohammadA.Rajabi 24
Outputs
Riskregister
Listofidentifiedrisks
Shouldbedescribedinasmuchdetailasisresaonable Structure:
EVENTmayoccur,causingIMPACTor IfCAUSE,EVENTmayoccur,leadingtoEFFECT
Therootcausesofrisksmaybecomeeveident
GuidetoPMBOK
MohammadA.Rajabi
25
11.3PerformQualitativeRisk Analysis
Theprocessofprioritizingrisksforfurther analysisoractionbyassessingandcombining theirprobabilityofoccurrenceandimpact Alsoassessingthetimeframeforresponse andtheorganization organizations srisktolerance associatedwiththeprojectconstraintsofcost, schedule scope schedule, scope,andquality
GuidetoPMBOK
MohammadA.Rajabi
26
Inputs,Tools&Techniques, Outputs
GuidetoPMBOK
MohammadA.Rajabi
27
DataFlow
GuidetoPMBOK
MohammadA.Rajabi
28
Inputs
Riskregister Riskmanagementplan
Roles R l and dresponsibilities ibiliti f forconducting d ti risk i kmanagement t Budgets Scheduleactivitiesforriskmanagement Riskcategories Definitionsofprobabilityandimpact,theprobabilityandimpact matrix,and Revisedstakeholders risktolerance
Projectscopestatement
Riskassociatedwithcommontypeprojectsversusprojectsusingfirst ofitskindtechnology,complex,stateofthearttools
Organizational O i i lprocessassets
Informationonprior,similarcompletedprojects Studiesofsimilarprojectsbyriskspecialities,and Riskdatabasesthatmaybeavailablefromindustryorpropreitry sources
GuidetoPMBOK MohammadA.Rajabi 29
ToolsandTechniques
Riskprobabilityandimpactassessment
Impactonprojectsschedule,cost,quality,orperformance, includingbothnegativeeffectsforthreatsandpositiveeffects foropportunities
GuidetoPMBOK
MohammadA.Rajabi
30
ProbabilityandImpactMatrix
GuidetoPMBOK
MohammadA.Rajabi
Dark gray: high risk Medium gray: low risk Light gray: moderate risk
31
ToolsandTechniques
Riskdataqualityassessment
Accurateandunbiaseddataisrequired. required Accuracy, Accuracy quality quality, reliability,andintegrityofdataregardingriskshouldbe checked
Risk Ri kcategorization t i ti
UsingRBS,theareofprojectisaffected,projectphases
Riskurgencyassessment
Risksrequiringneartermresponses Timetoaffectariskassessment Symptomsandwarningsigns Riskrating
Expertjudgment
GuidetoPMBOK MohammadA.Rajabi 32
Outputs
Riskregisterupdate
Riskrankingorprioritylistofprojectrisks
High,moderate,andlow Forschedule,cost,andperformance
Causesofriskorprojectarearequiringparticularattention
Mayimprovetheeffectivenessofriskresponses
GuidetoPMBOK
MohammadA.Rajabi
33
11.4PerformQualitativeRisk Analysis
The ep process ocesso ofnumerically u e ca ya analyzing a y gt the ee effect ecto of identifiedrisksonoverallprojectobjectives performedonrisksthathavebeenp prioritized Isp bythePerformQualitativeRiskAnalysisprocess Presentsqualitativeapproachtomaking decisionsinthepresenceofuncertainty ShouldberepeatedafterPlanRiskResponsesas well llaspart tof fMonitor M it and dControl C t lto t determine d t i iftheoverallprojectriskhasbeensatisfactorily decreased
GuidetoPMBOK MohammadA.Rajabi 34
Inputs,Tools&Techniques, Outputs
GuidetoPMBOK
MohammadA.Rajabi
35
DataFlow
GuidetoPMBOK
MohammadA.Rajabi
36
Inputs
Riskregister Riskmanagement g p plan Costmanagementplan
Setstheformatandestablishescriteriaforplanning,structuring, estimating,budgeting,andcontrollingprojectcosts Ithelpsdeterminethestructureand/or / applicationapproachfor quantitativeanalysisofthebudgetorcostplan
Schedulemanagementplan
Setstheformatandestablishescriteriafordeveloping, developing andcontrolling projectschedule Ithelpsdeterminethestructureand/orapplicationapproachfor quantitativeanalysisoftheschedule
Organizationalprocessassets
Informationonprior,similarcompletedprojects Studiesofsimilarprojectsbyriskspecialists,and Risk kdatabases d b that h maybe b available l bl from f industry d orproprietary sources
GuidetoPMBOK MohammadA.Rajabi 37
Datagatheringandrepresentationtechniques
Interviewing Probabilitydistributions
ToolsandTechniques
Quantitativeriskanalysisandmodelingtechniques
Sensitivityanalysis ExpectedMonetaryValue(EMV)analysis
Analysisunderuncertainty Statisticalconceptthatcalculatestheaverageoutcomewhenthefutureincludes scenariosthatmayormaynothappen Opportunities> positivevalues,threats>negativevalues EMV:multiplyingthevalueofeachpossibleoutcomebyitspossibilityofoccurrenceand addingproductstogether Commonuse: decisiontreeanalysis
Modelingandsimulation
ExpertJudgment
Toidentifypotentialcostandscheduleimpacts,toevaluateprobability,andto defineinputsintothetools Interpretationofthedata Identifytheweaknessofthetools,theirrelativestrengths Whenandwhichtoolismoreappropriategiventheorganizationscapabilities andculture
GuidetoPMBOK
MohammadA.Rajabi
38
RangeofProjectCostEstimates CollectedDuringtheRiskInterview
GuidetoPMBOK
MohammadA.Rajabi
39
ExamplesofCommonlyUsed ProbabilityDistributions
GuidetoPMBOK
MohammadA.Rajabi
40
DecisionTreeDiagram
GuidetoPMBOK
MohammadA.Rajabi
41
CostRiskSimulationResults
GuidetoPMBOK
MohammadA.Rajabi
42
Outputs
Riskregisterupdates Probabilisticanalysisoftheproject Probability b bili of fachieving hi i costand dtime i objectives Prioritizedlistofquantifiedrisks Trendsinq quantitativeriskanalysis y results
GuidetoPMBOK
MohammadA.Rajabi
43
11.5PlanRiskResponses
Theprocessesofdevelopingoptionsandactionsto enhanceopportunitiesandtoreducethreatstoproject objectives FollowsQualitativeRiskAnalysisandPerform Qualitative li i Risk i kAnalysis l i processes,identifies id ifi and d assignspeopletotakeresponsibilityforriskresponses. priorities insertingresources Addressesrisksbasedonpriorities, andactivitiesintobudget,schedule,andproject managementplan Shouldbeappropriatetothesignificanceoftherisk, costeffective,realistic,agreedbyallparties,timely, andownedbyaresponsibleperson
GuidetoPMBOK MohammadA.Rajabi 44
Inputs,Tools&Techniques, Outputs
GuidetoPMBOK
MohammadA.Rajabi
45
DataFlow
GuidetoPMBOK
MohammadA.Rajabi
46
Inputs
Riskregister
Identified Id tifi drisks, i k Root R tcausesof frisks, i k Lists Li t of f potentialresponses,Riskowners,Symptoms, Warningsigns signs,Relativerating/prioritylist, list Listof riskswithneartermresponse,Trendsin qualitativeanalysis q y results,Watchlist oflow priorityrisks
Riskmanagement g p plan
Rolesandresponsibilities,riskanalysisdefinitions, timingforreviews,riskthresholdsforlow, moderate,andhighrisks
GuidetoPMBOK MohammadA.Rajabi 47
ToolsandTechniques q
Riskanalysistoolssuchastreeanalysiscanbeusedtochoosethemost appropriateresponses Mixedresponsesaremostlikelytobeeffective Strategiesfornegativerisksorthreats
Avoid(extendingschedule,reducingscope,shuttingdowntheproject) Transfer(financialriskexposure,insurance,warranties,guarantees) Mitigate(takingearlyactions, actions adoptinglesscomplexprocesses, processes conduction moretests,choosingmorestablesuppliers,prototyping,redundancy) Accept(Passiveacceptance:noactionexcepttodocumentthestrategyand leaveittotheprojectteamtodealwithit.Activeacceptance:establishing contingencyreserveformoney money,time, time andresources)
Strategiesforpositiverisksoropportunities
Exploit(seekingtoeliminatetheuncertaintyassociatedwithaparticular upsideriskbyensuringtheopportunitydefinitelyhappens.Suchasrewardsto shortertimetocomplete, complete lowerthecost) Share(allocatingsomeoralloftheownershipoftheopportunitytoathird partywhoisabletocapturetheopportunityforthebenefitoftheproject. Suchasjointventures,specialpurposecompanies) Enhance(suchasaddingmoreresourcestofinishearly) Accept(notactivelypursuingit)
GuidetoPMBOK
MohammadA.Rajabi
48
Tools&Techniques
ContingentResponseStrategies(tobe executedundercertainpredefinedconditions suchasmissingintermediatemilestones milestones, gaininghighprioritywithasupplier) ExpertJudgment(forspecificanddefinedrisk)
GuidetoPMBOK
MohammadA.Rajabi
49
Outputs
Riskregisterupdates
Appropriateresponsesarechosen,agreedupon,andincludedintheriskregister Levelofdetailcorrespondswiththepriorityrankingandtheplannedresponses(highand moderaterisksusuallyindetail) Indentifiedrisks,theirdescriptions,areasoftheproject(WBS)affected,theircauses(RBS), andhowtheymayaffectprojectobjectives Riskownersandassignedresponsibilities OutputsfromthePerformqualitativeAnalysisprocess,includingprioritizedlistsofproject risks Agreeduponresponsestrategies Specificactionstoimplementthechosenresponsestrategy Triggers, Triggers symptoms symptoms,andwarningsignsofrisks risks occurrence Budgetandscheduleactivitiesrequiredtoimplementthechosenresponses Budgetandscheduleactivitiesrequiredtoimplementthechosenresponses Contingencyplansandtriggersthatcalltheirexecution Fallbackplansforuseasareactiontoariskthathasoccurredandtheprimaryresponsetobe inadequate Residualrisksthatareexpectedtoremainafterplannedresponseshavebeentakenaswellas thosethathavebeendeliberatelyaccepted Secondaryrisksariseasadirectoutcomeofimplementingariskresponse,and Contingencyreservesthatarecalculatedbasedonthequantitativeriskanalysisoftheproject andtheorganizationsriskthresholds
GuidetoPMBOK MohammadA.Rajabi 50
Outputs
Riskrelatedcontractdecisions
Insurance,servicesformitigatingortransferringpartorallofthethreator enhancingorsharingpartoralloftheopportunity UsuallyareinputstothePlanProcurements
Projectmanagementplanupdates
Schedulemanagementplan
Changestotoleranceorbehaviourrelatedtoresourcesloadingandlevelling,and schedule
Costmanagementplan
Changesintoleranceorbehaviourrelatedtocostaccounting,tracking,andreports,as wellasupdatestothebudgetandtheconsumptionofcontingencyreserves
Qualitymanagementplan
Ch Changesin i tolerance t l orbehaviour b h i related l t dto t requirements, i t quality lit assurance,quality lit control,aswellasupdatestotherequirementsdocumentation
Procurementmanagementplan
Changesintoleranceorbehaviourrelatedtostrategyofmakebuydecisionsorcontract types
Humanresourcemanagementplan
Changesintoleranceorbehaviourrelatedtoorganizationalstructure,resource applications,toleranceorbehaviourrelatedtostaffallocation,aswellasupdatestothe resourceloading
MohammadA.Rajabi
51
Outputs
Projectdocumentupdates
Assumptionlogupdates
Maybeincorporatedinthescopestatementorina separateassumptionslog
Technicaldocumentationupdates p
Technicalapproachesand/orphysicaldeliverablesmay change
GuidetoPMBOK
MohammadA.Rajabi
52
11.6MonitorandControlRisks
Theprocessofimplementingriskresponseplans,trackingidentifiedrisks, monitoringresidualrisks,identifyingnewrisks,andevaluatingriskprocess effectivenessthroughouttheproject Projectworkshouldbecontinuouslymonitoredfornew new,changing changing,and outdatedrisks Techniquessuchasvarianceandtrendanalysis Purposes:
Projectassumptionsstillvalid Ifassessedriskhaschangedorcanberetired Riskmanagementpolicies/proceduresarefollowed Contingencyreservesofcost/scheduleshouldbemodifiedinalignmentwith thecurrentriskassessment
GuidetoPMBOK
Inputs,Tools&Techniques, Outputs
GuidetoPMBOK
MohammadA.Rajabi
54
DataFlow
GuidetoPMBOK
MohammadA.Rajabi
55
RiskRegister
Inputs
Workp performanceinformation
Deliverablestatus Scheduleprogress,and Costsincurred
Performancereport
Varianceanalysis Earnedvaluedata, data and Forecastingdata
GuidetoPMBOK MohammadA.Rajabi 56
ToolsandTechniques
RiskAssessment Shouldbedoneregularly
Identificationofnewrisks Reassessmentofcurrentrisks Closingoutdatedrisks
Riskaudits
Examininganddocumentingtheeffectivenessofrisk responsesindealingwithidentifiedrisks.Theirroot causes,and dthe th risk i kmanagement tprocess PMshouldmakesureitisdoneregularly Shouldhaveclearformatandobjectives j
GuidetoPMBOK MohammadA.Rajabi 57
Tools&Techniques q
Varianceandtrendanalysis
Checkingplannedresultstotheactualresults Earnedvalueanalysisandothermethodsofprojectvarianceandtrend analysiscanbeused Outcome:forecastpotentialdeviationoftheprojectatcompletionfrom cost/scheduletargets
Technicalp performancemeasurement
Checkingplannedresultstotheactualresults Metricsshouldbedefined.Suchasweight,transactiontimes,numbersof delivereddefects,storagecapacity
Reserveanalysis
Comparestheamountofremainedcontingencyreservestotheamountof remainingrisks
Statusmeetings
Agendainperiodicmeetings Dependingontheamountofidentifiedrisks,theirpriority,anddifficultyof responsetherequiredtimeformeetingvaries Riskmanagement g becomeseasierthemoreoftenitisp practiced Themorewetalkaboutit,themorelikelypeopleidentifyrisksand opportunities
GuidetoPMBOK
MohammadA.Rajabi
58
Outputs
Outcomeofriskassessments,riskaudits,andperiodicriskreviews whichcanbe:
Newidentifiedrisks,updatestoprobability,impact,priority,responseplans, ownership,andotherelementsoftheriskregister Closedrisksandreleasedassociatedreserves
Actualoutcomesoftheprojectsrisksandriskresponses
Changerequests
Recommendedcorrectiveactions
Contingencyplansandworkarounds(notplannedresponsestounidentifiedor acceptedpassiverisks)
Recommendedpreventionactions
Projectmanagementplanupdates Projectdocumentupdates
GuidetoPMBOK MohammadA.Rajabi 59