Ecués Atlantic An Essay

Journal of Religion in Africa 37 (2007) 275-315
www.brill.nl/jra
Ecu s Atlantic: An Essay in Methodology

Stephan Palmi
University of Chicago, Department of Anthropology, 1126 E 59th Street, Chicago, IL 60637, USA palmie@uchicago.edu
Abstract Arguing from an exposition of the principal epistemological and methodological problems that have plagued African-Americanist research since its inception as a properly disciplined anthropological pursuit, this essay focuses on an ostensibly clear case of transatlantic continuities to question linear construction of historical relations between African and African-American cultural forms. Detailing the social history of an African male initiatory sodality and its supposed Cuban equivalent within their wider political economic contexts, I argue that the apparent dispersion of Cross-River-type secret societies ought not to be seen as a pattern of diusion from a (temporally prior) point of inception to (temporally later) sites of recreation, but as a total pattern of simultaneous Atlantic eventuation and cultural production. Keywords Cuba, Cross River Region, male secret societies, Atlantic world, non-linear history
Introduction My contribution to this special issue derives from a larger project concerned with issues of continuity and disjunction in Atlantic cultural history. I aim to explore here a number of questions to do with whether, and under what conditions, Africanist and African-Americanist forms of knowledge might become subject to epistemologically sound forms of integration. Originally conceived almost ten years ago,1 this essay perhaps ought to be read as a companion piece to my exploration of the growth of both Afro-Cuban traditions and western forms of modernity out of a single structural and discursive formation of Atlantic scope (Palmi 2002). But it also forms an historiographical counterpart to Kenneth Routons (2005) and my own (Palmi 2006a) more recent ethnographically focused attempts to delineate the contours of forms of historical consciousness characteristic of a male secret society known as abaku in western Cuba. In the latter contributions, both Routon and I mainly concern ourselves with how contemporary members of this association reproduce their
Koninklijke Brill NV, Leiden, 2007 DOI: 10.1163/157006607X184825
JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 275
4/19/07 2:40:52 PM
276
S. Palmi / Journal of Religion in Africa 37 (2007) 275-315
particular form of consociation by ritually recalling, into Cuban time and space, a complex series of actions thatin their understandingonce unfolded at a conceptually distant site of origin called Usagar, Bekura Mendo or Enllenisn. Indexing notions of graded spatial inclusivity in contemporary abaku parlance and ritual practice (such that Usagar is considered part of Bekura Mend which, in turn, is part of Enllenisn), these terms have long been taken to encode memories of potentially identiable African place names that slaves from the Cross River region of southeastern Nigeria and southwestern Cameroon carried to Cuba, and there passed on to their descendants. The most recent, as well as most literal-minded, version of this argument has been presented by Miller (2005) who argues that etymological research, combined with ethnographically elicited approval of word-by-word translations by exiled Cuban members of abaku and native Ek-speakers (whom he has brought together on several occasions in New York and Nigeria), and additional glosses authorized by trained linguists can unambiguously disclose and authenticate the objectively true history of a transatlantic historical relationship. The result, or so Miller believes, is not only that, thanks to his assistance, contemporary members of a Nigerian secret society known as ekpe and Cuban abaku can now perceive themselves in the others language and ritual practice (Miller 2005: 26). It is also that ritual signiers such as Usagar, Bekura Mend and Enllenisn, according to him, acquire secular transparency as geographic and/or ethnic indicatorsso that the rst term really refers to a place in southwestern Cameroon known as Usak Edet or Usaghade, the second to a Balondo village to its east named Bekura, and the third to ethnically Ek sons of the soil (i.e., free-born inhabitant of Old Calabar in present-day Nigeria). Millers work falls squarely into a longstanding tradition in African-Americanist research, established in the United States since the time of Melville Herskovitss rst eorts, in the 1930s, to demolish the reigning consensus that slavery had stripped black Americans of any vestiges of their ancestral African cultures (cf. Jackson 1986, Apter 1991, Yelvington 2001, 2006). It belongs to a genre of anthropological inquiry aiming to identify and authenticate historical continuities between African and New World cultural forms that has always been driven not just by explicitly announced theoretical concerns, but by political ones as well (Scott 1991, 1999). In that regard, neither Routon nor I question Millers commitment to a good causesuch as helping Nigerian Ek and Cuban members of abaku establish a common history [that] is an international connection that gives both groups new status as representatives of valuable and ancient cultural traditions (Miller 2005:36). However, not only are such historical rescue missions politically far from unambiguous (given that, as Routon [2005: 37] puts it, they inevitably, if unwittingly lend
JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 276
4/19/07 2:40:53 PM
277
legitimacy to the authority claims of some [local] groups while denying it to others and, perhaps even more troubling, allocate the authority to arbitrate such claims to us); rather, once regarded as an end in itself, the search for the African origins of New World practices and identities also forecloses an important analytical dimension: what if, for example, the terminology on which Miller2 tends to focus indexes localities that exist on a plane that simply has no xed, or even only concretizable geographic equivalent in the world as non-members of abaku know it? What if (irrespective of the origin of these words) Usagar, Bekura Mend or Enllenisn designated assumable positions or states of being, established by chronotopic illocutionary devices that localize specic forms of agency and subjectivity in an epochal (Wagner 1986) ritual frame of interpretation?3 If so, what would be gained by calling such locations or positionalities Africa in any other than a gurative way? Like Routon and Wirtz (this issue), I have previously argued that terms such as, for example, Enllenisn (generally taken to mean Africa) do not so much index (principally veriable) topographic data as impose sacred value on specic situations or utterances. If this is valid, even only in principle, we may be ill served by rashly literalizing the deictical referents of abaku speech and ritual in order to assimilate them to an Africa delineated in geographic and ethnological categories of our making. What is at issue here is not just that the latter categories do not, at least at this point in time, have much salience for members of contemporary Cuban members of abaku (though they may well come to do so in the future).4 Rather, it is that, in naively engineering alignments between topography and tropology, we are, in a methodological sense, attempting to commensurate incommensurables. Why this is so is a question I would like to dwell on in what followsnot, however, by going further down the analytical road of ethnographic criticism of etymological pathways to history. What I intend to do here instead is return to a set of basic, but nowadays seemingly all but forgotten, questions concerning the analytical viability of the transatlantic comparisons on which endeavors such as Millers must necessarily rest. While I will not suggest any easily operationalizable solution to conceptualizing the historical relations between African and African-American cultural formations, I hope to shed light on some of the metatheoretical questions with which any attempt to transcend the current terms of debate would necessarily have to engage. Galton rides again As in my previous contributions to this debate, I take my departure from David Scotts (1991, 1999) observations about what he calls the vericationist
JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 277
4/19/07 2:40:53 PM
278
epistemology, which, to this day, has tended to dominate historical and anthropological studies of African-American cultures. Scott is concerned with a tradition of inquiry that denes the central task of African-Americanist research as providing answers to question such as whether or not or to what extent Caribbean culture [or other African-American cultures, for that matter] is authentically African; and whether or not or to what extent Caribbean peoples have retained an authentic memory of their past, in particular a memory of slavery (Scott 1999: 108). In Scotts view, the primary reason for why we should critically revisit this agenda is that it ultimately arises from an ideological desire to supply a foundational past. Yet this is not the only problem. For vericationist approaches also obscure a whole range of epistemological issues. They do so by suggesting that such a past is, in principle, transparent, and that its recovery is, therefore, merely a question of empirically engineering, to use Scotts (1991) earlier formulation, a plausible match between that event and this memorythe former (properly evidenced historical facts) presumably enjoying a veriable prediscursive objectivity that adds critical corroborative weight to what might otherwise remain the contestable product of the undisciplined collective imagination. Leaving aside the numerous problems connected with operationalizing the concept of memory on a supra-individual level (cf., e.g., Klein 2000, Lambek and Antze 1996), it is the idea of the feasibility of engineering methodologically defensible and theoretically sound transcontinental analytical correlationsor juxtapositions, depending upon perspectivesbetween documentary records on past forms of sociality and eventuation (history) and ethnographic data concerning contemporary local constructions of the past (memory)5 that I intend to call into question in the following. My point of departure lies in a simple issue to do with time, space and units of analysis in African-American anthropology. If traditional narratives of universal history have fractured under the destabilizing impact of non-western histories (Feierman 1993), the opposite eect seems to be observable in anthropology, where the notion of the local is in rapidly increasing disarray (cf. Fardon 1990, Appadurai 1995, Gupta and Ferguson 1997). Today we know that many, perhaps most, classical ethnographies presented us with articial constructions of spatially overdetermined, while temporally underdetermined, units of analysis. This is no longer so. Gone are the discrete and seemingly pelagic villages and tribes of yore, moored as they were in a kind of analytical Sargasso Sea known as the ethnographic present. In their stead, we have become increasingly aware of an expanding heuristic frontier dened by a dazzling multitude of supra-local linkages extending across considerably vast stretches of time. The price we paid for this historicization and globalization of anthropology was that the clean and empirically manageable unit of analysis went out with the murky bathwa-
JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 278
4/19/07 2:40:53 PM
279
ter. We cannot simply go somewhere, stay there for a time, and come home with a monograph based merely on a circumstantial moment of observation. If this is true for anthropologists working in classical ethnographic localities today, African-Americanists have faced such problems all along. From its inception at the turn of the twentieth century in the work of pioneers like the Brazilian medical examiner Raimundo Nina Rodrigues or the Cuban lawyer Fernando Ortiz, the central problematic of this eld of inquiry was dened in terms that transcended, and thereby bound, vast geographical and temporal expanses. What they initially set out to explain was the existence, within their own societies, of modes of thought and behavior that appeared too alien, too obviously tied into a history of forced transatlantic mass migration to be written o as locally bred forms of deviance from the cultural norms of the respective postcolonial elites.6 It eventually was the North American anthropologist Melville Herskovits who would systematize such early glances across the Atlantic into a coherent, though theoretically and methodologically nave, research agenda. He did so by fusing a concept of culture areas (which Herskovits himself had helped to pioneer) with the historicism of its philological precursor theories that had long depended on the notion of clearly separable units of analysis, thereby imparting to African-American anthropology a set of assumptions the problematic nature of which has still to be fully acknowledged (cf. Apter 1991, Scott 1999, Bennett 2000, Yelvington 2001, 2006).7 This cannot be the place for a sustained examination of theory-building in this eld of inquiry. Still, it needs to be noted that most anthropologists in the rst half of the twentieth century who eschewed popular racist interpretations of African-American cultures as biologically determined phenomena ran headlong into a peculiarly inverted version of what is known as Galtons problem. This term refers to a methodological conundrum particularly pertinent to a nowadays (perhaps fortunately) defunct form of cross-cultural statistical comparison (cf. Narroll 1970, Jorgenson 1979).8 The substantive issue, however, was clearly involved in the famous debate between Herskovits and E. Franklin Frazier about how to weigh transatlantic continuities against the impact of independent local factors (i.e., the crushing impact of New World slavery) in the development of African-American cultures. Stated in most simplistic terms, the question was (and, in many ways, still is): given that both similarities and dierences between African and African-American cultural forms cannot well be fortuitous, do we primarily look to Africa or the Americas for an explanation? Each option gives us a dierent choice of which factors to regard as more signicant for the cultural history of African-American societies: those relating to transatlantic diusion of African forms, or to those productive of New World functional adhesions (as Tylor would have put it). Is it, in other words, movement or structure that we need to focus on?
JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 279
4/19/07 2:40:53 PM
280
By the mid-1970s, a rather elegant solution to this African-Americanist version of Galtons problem was oered by Mintz and Price (1992). For several cogently argued reasons, these authors advocated an analytic shift from comparing seemingly free-oating units of cultural form to units of historically contextualized social enactment. Problematizing the historical conditions of social re-aggregation among enslaved Africans in the New World, they directed attention not only to processually induced discontinuities in cultural transmission, but to the theoretical importance of assuming cultural creativity and large-scale ad hoc syntheses to have precipitated the institutional crystallization of such cultural forms as were observable in the Americas. Though careful not to deny the importance of Old World resources in African-American societalization and culture building, their re-statement of the problem nevertheless placed the explanatory onus squarely on the shoulders of those arguing for immediate and ethnically specic African continuities. If Herskovitss approach had implied an imagery of erosion and fragmentation of transplanted African units, theirs emphasized the fusion of fragments into essentially new cultural entities. What came into view, thus, were processes of creolization, informed both by Old World cultural resources and the exigencies of the particular New World social arenas in which they were put to use. Despite its theoretical sophistication and methodological soundness, however, the rapid early synthesis model suggested by Mintz and Price fell short of stimulating a thorough historicization of African-American anthropology. Shifting, as it did, the explanatory premium onto the American side (and, therefore, into the realm of history rather than the search for origins), Mintz and Prices book rather seems to have encouraged, quite contrary to these authors intentions, hypostatizing the concept of creolization to a degree where it allows glossing over history in a manner much reminiscent of an earlier inationary use of the (historically quite vacuous) concept of acculturation.9 This tendency might be viewed as fairly inconsequential in cases where the documentary record is simply too thin to allow more than educated guesses about the particulars of process. Yet it not only trivializes the question of how exactly creole syntheses were achieved, but also obscures the formidable problems presented by cases where covariational adhesions might plausibly be attributed to Atlantic transfernot necessarily of concrete forms, but of organizational models (Palmi 1993). More importantly for my present concerns, it evades the issue of systemic articulations that mayat least in some casesreveal single observational units (on whichever side of the Atlantic) to be part and parcel of larger, encompassing historical constellations shaped by processes operating on a scale that cannot adequately be described (let alone analyzed) within a cis- or transatlantic frame of reference.
JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 280
4/19/07 2:40:53 PM
281
On the leopards trail In order to illustrate this point, let me begin by reiterating a story that has become a kind of myth of origin, not only among the people directly involved, but among scholars concerned with championing what one might call an Africanistic view. It pertains to the Afro-Cuban secret society of abaku, also known as the igos,10 an all-male sodality that probably emerged in Cuba in the rst third of the nineteenth century and continues to exist to this very day. Here is how the probable codier of this narrative, the Cuban scholar Fernando Ortiz (1986: 14), put it some 80 years ago:
Due to a quirk of fate, one day there were brought to Havana a group of black slaves of Ek origin, who had been caught there [in Africa] by the slave traders and transported jointly to the Cuban coast in order to be sold in the barracoons of the slave market of [the town of ] Regla. And those of that group who pertained to the secret and defensive society which was and still is called ekpe or ekpon there [in Africa], reorganized it here to augment their collective power, just as it had functioned there in the estuaries of Calabar.
So far Ortizs opinion on the subject which has, more recently, been restated with but minor alterations by, for example, Enrique Sosa (Sosa Rodrigues 1982: 118 f.), Robert F. Thompson (1983: 228), Jorge and Isabel Castellanos (1992: 211-213), Ivor Miller (2000: 164, 2005), and David Brown (2003). On face value, it is a pretty good story, since it is not based on an unduly large amount of guesswork. Thanks to the attention the Cuban police paid to this secret society, we have some fairly straightforward information on the events surrounding the inception of what came to be known as abaku. Summarizing the evidence, we can piece the events together as follows. In 1836, a group of creole slaves from Havanas well-to-do barrio of Beln traveled across the bay to Regla. Their destination was a house owned by an ocially accredited association of rst-generation Africans known as the cabildo de la nacin carabal bricamo apapa ef . There they acquired, by payment of a considerable amount of money, a body of secret knowledge that enabled them to form an independent sodality named Ek Butn. We do not know how the transaction proceeded, but the institution it engenderedpresumably an association comparable to modern abaku chapters (known as potencias, juegos or tierras)proved an instantaneous and lasting success.11 By 1839 a police raid on the house of the free morena Dominga Crdenas in Havanas barrio Jesus Mara yielded information that led to the subsequent arrest of the 25-year-old creole cook and dockworker Margarito Blanco. In his home the Cuban authorities found written invitations addressed to the
JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 281
4/19/07 2:40:53 PM
282
ocongos of Obane, Ososo and Ef, thus indicating the likelihood that at least three other such associations were already in existence. For Blanco had not only signed these letters with his name but had included his title of ocongo de Ultn and a peculiar graphic sign of which we know that it represented the equivalent of the signature (rma) of the mocongo-title holder of modern abaku.12 Blancos abortive attempt to organize a chapter of abaku in Jesus Mara terminated with his deportation to Spain. Yet other such ventures followed in rapid succession. Despite the massive wave of repression in the aftermath of the so-called La Escalera conspiracy of 1844, the growth of abaku continued virtually unchecked. By 1850, some 40 independent chapters were in operation in Havana and Regla, concentrating mostly in harbor-near barrios, but increasingly branching out into other neighborhoods (and towns such as Guanabacoa) where they repeatedly engaged the Cuban police force in pitched battles over the control of single barrios.13 A mere ten years later abaku had reached the important port city of Matanzas (1862), and nally penetrated the city of Crdenas in 1927the last Cuban urban environment to become a lasting stronghold of abaku.14 Time and again, violence ared up throughout the late nineteenth and early twentieth century, and, despite repeated mass arrests, the growth of abaku seemed beyond control. That this mysterious, aggressive brotherhood somehow came from Africa appears to have been a commonplace among nineteenth-century observers, and speculations about the origin and nature of this ostensibly African secret organization repeatedly occupied the popular press. What added to the mixture of revulsion and curiosity that abaku inspired in the public imagination were the colorful ritual processions that its members periodically performed: guided by drummers and bearers of sacred stas and ensigns, the so-called diablitos or remesdancers entirely covered by a tight-tting checkered costume with a conical headpiecewould emerge from the meeting-houses of single potencias to perform in the streets what contemporaries described as an outlandish pantomime.15 Yet it was not until the 1920s that Fernando Ortiz nally pinned down the fons et origo of abaku.16 Judging from the names of some potencias and the fact that a group of Africans who chose to refer to themselves as carabal had been implicated in the founding of the rst such sodality, Ortiz concluded that abaku was nothing but a transplanted version of a localizable African institution: the so-called leopard societies of Old Calabar known indigenously as ekpe or ngbe. By the time of Ortizs writing, ekpe had acquired enough notoriety among missionaries and colonial administrators in southeastern Nigeria and the British part of the Cameroons to have left a prominent imprint in the early Africanist literature. Since at least the 1850s, the Ek of Old Calabar were known to the Victorian world as the
JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 282
4/19/07 2:40:54 PM
283
leading African experts in secret-society building.17 Following the Brazilian Nina Rodriguess example of ransacking such literature for ethnographic analogies, Ortiz had begun to systematically assemble a library of precisely such writings. Hence his once upon a time a group of enslaved Ek story. And, indeed, scores of formal characteristics of this association appear far too specic to be written o into a narrative of New World creation. An origin myth replete with references to African toponymy and ethnic designations, linguistic features of abakus ritual idiom, the use of an ideographic script clearly related to the nsibidi signs of the Ek,18 a ceremonial complex pertaining to the sounding of an esoteric friction drum (ecu ),19 dancers in multicolored body masks, and several other features ostensibly conspire to render abaku/ekpe/ngbe a prime example for direct Atlantic transfer, coast to coast, unit to unit so to speak.20 The timing of diusion is late, but it occurred under slavery, and precisely at the moment when Cuban slavery was entering its most brutalizing phase. Have we then, nally, found an instance of Africa transplanted intact that we could hold up to what some historians nowadays claim is a league of creolizers sailing in the wake of Mintz and Price?21 I do not think so, and, as I will argue in the following, if this case might teach us a lesson, it is that we will have to recalibrate our units of analysis towards conceptions that enable us to accommodate data pertaining to both Africa and the New World within explanatory frameworks capable of articulating them in a historically meaningful way. An onomastic conundrum Interpreting Cuban abaku in light of the so-called new revisionism (to use Lovejoys [1997] phrase) as an essentially African institution merely transplanted to another continent is, therefore, not so much wrong as ultimately misleading. For such a conception generates a spurious sense of clarity in a situation where some of our most basic conceptual tools are far from adequately operationalized. One of the rst red herrings one encounters when probing into the standard narrative, thus, concerns what M.G. Smith (1957, 1965) called the problem of specic ascription. Can we pin downin time and spacea concrete African antecedent? In logical terms, this question boils down to:
is carabal : Ek :: abaku : ekpe?
Already the rst part of this statement presents thorny problems. Surely, the people congregating in the cabildo de la nacin carabal bricam apapa ef may well have thought of themselves as carabal . But what does that mean
JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 283
4/19/07 2:40:54 PM
284
in terms that relate to Africaninstead of Cubancategories of (ethnic) space and (historical) time? Baldly stated, the answer is: not very muchor, at least, not necessarily so (cf. Northrup 2000). For neither Calabar nor carabal are terms whose referents are diachronically stable or even only synchronically unambiguous. In fact, as I shall argue, the Cuban term carabal simply has no spatio-temporally localizable African referent. This may sound trite to anyone familiar with the extreme volatility of the trade names employed in the international marketing of human chattel, but, in view of the heightened emphasis given in recent years to questions of whether African forms of ethnic identication were maintained or reasserted themselves in New World settings, it nevertheless merits brief attention.22 In the course of the seventeenth century the (European) toponym Calabar traveled from the Rio Real area to the Cross River estuary and, therefore, across what even then must have been a dividing line between the Kwa and Benue-Congo language groups (Simmons 1956: 4, Jones 1963: 33-48, Hair 1967: 262 f.).23 As a result, the terminology used on the American end of the slave trade eventually came to include what must have been speakers not only of Igbo, but Ibibio and even Bantu languages. Thus, although slaves known by the trade name carabal may very well have been present in Cuba since at least the end of the sixteenth century,24 in terms of their African ethnic origins they probably had little in common with the nineteenth-century founders of abaku: for, dierent from the record on the former area (known to Europeans as New Calabar), that for the latter (Old Calabar) does not oer evidence for a commencement of the slave trade on more than a modest scale prior to 1672,25 and for mass exportations not before the 1730s (Latham 1973: 17 f., Curtin 1969: 150, Northrup 1978: 50-54, Lovejoy and Richardson 1999). This situation is likely to have changed during the rst half of the eighteenth century, which saw the rise to prominence of Old Calabar as one of the most important suppliers for the British slave trade.26 Because of the lack of a suciently developed plantation sector, Cuban slave imports during that time still remained at a low level,27 yet we have some indications for assuming a marked increase of the inow of human merchandise marketed under the label carabal.28 In Moreno Fraginalss analysis of Cuban plantation records between 1760 and 1769, slaves designated as carabal made up 25 percent of his total sample of slaves working in sugar mills, rendering them the second largest contingent. While remaining stable percentually in relation to other provenance groups (to employ Carvalho Soaress [2001] useful term), by the decade between 1800 and 1810 they had risen to the position of the numerically largest aggregate in Morenos sample (Moreno Fraginals 1977). Such records obviously tell us little about how slaves so designated might have construed their own identity. Still, the records on the so-called cabildos
JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 284
4/19/07 2:40:54 PM
285
de nacin provide us with crucial data on the formation and collective management of Afro-Cuban identities: representing colonial transformations of the Sevillan institution of legally recognized councils (cabildos) of resident aliens to urban New World environments (Ortiz 1921), these ocially condoned voluntary organizations of Africans were not just social aggregates arbitrarily created by the colonial state. Instead, and very obviously so, the cabildos represented intentional communities based not on ascriptions of origin, but on autonomous constructions of collective identity and allegiance (Palmi 1993). Viewed in this light, the existence of cabildos of any one named AfroCuban nacin becomes an indicator less of the mere numerical strength of particular African population segments in the Cuban diaspora, than of the capacity of groupings of Africans (however constituted) to forge common patterns of identication under certain New World conditionswhether the resulting collective identities were based on factual Old World ethnic commonalities, or on New World allegiances translated into an ethnic idiom. An inventory of Havanas black cabildos de nacin, compiled in 1755 by Bishop Morell de Santa Cruz, thus provides us with what may be taken as an inside view of Afro-Cuban carabal ethnicity and its internal dierentiation: Morell listed ve dierent carabal cabildosmore than any other AfroCuban nacin could boast of at that time (Marrero 1972-78, VIII: 160).29 Whatever the African origins of the members of these associations might have been, they had chosen to identify with a terminology thattaxonomically speakingno longer referred to African, but essentially Cuban social units.30 Quite obviously, the Cuban carabal naciones were not transplanted fragments torn from preexisting African tribes. However their members may have dened their collective identitieson various levels of particularity or inclusivenessthere simply was no concrete African antecedent to these nascent New World African ethnic units. Yet even though this provides us with insights on which to base speculations about the emergence of that one crucial unit under studythe cabildo de los carabal bricamo apapa ef31it is of little help in explaining why this particular grouping should have provided the context for the re-creation of ekpe/ngbe on Cuban soil. For such considerations still leave us with several vexing questions related to the sociology of knowledge about ekpe/ngbe in the Cuban diaspora. If Afro-Cubans who called themselves carabal after about 1750 could have possessed the necessary knowledge, why did they wait until 1836 to put it to use? There could still have been a majority of Ijaw from New Calabar among the Cuban carabalwhich would explain the fact that an ekpelike institution did not emerge in Cuba for another three generations, for secret societies of this type are unknown in that region of the Niger delta. But this is not very likely. The more compelling hypothesiscorroborated as I
JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 285
4/19/07 2:40:54 PM
286
think it is by Africanist ndingsis that ekpe, the African antecedent to Cuban abaku, had simply not yet assumed the shape and functions, or had not yet risen to the kind of prominence, that mid-nineteenth-century British observers committed to the pages that Ortiz, eventually, was to read, and which allowed him to identify Cuban abaku as a Cross-River-type secret sodality. Whence ekpe? Limitations of space will not allow me to fully rehearse the available evidence, but, from what we know today, ekpe/ngbe was by no means a time-hallowed institution in Old Calabar. It was an innovation on both cultural and socialeconomic levels, betting the ideological and political needs of shing villages turned multi-ethnic city statespart and parcel of an Atlantic world built around the exchange of trade goods for commodied people. This esoteric cult association recruited its members not on the basis of lineage aliation and descent. It rather revolved around the economic power to buy the sacred knowledge and initiatory grades necessary to be privy to the sounding of a mystical leopards voice and partake of its juridical powers. In a very crucial sense, the body of secret knowledge, as well as the titles, cult agencies and powers that comprised ekpe, were objects of commercial exchange circulating in increasingly wider networks of mercantile transactions.32 Modern Ek traditions maintain that ekpe was originally sold to one of the rst Ek settlers at Creek Town (Ikot Itunko) by an Ejagham/Ekoi from Usak Edet (Bakasi) on the Cameroon side of the Cross River estuary (Waddell 1863: 313, Nair 1972: 14 f., Latham 1973: 36, Nicklin 1991: 13). There is little doubt that on a functional level this tradition represents a charter dening an exchange-sphere for what became a ourishing commerce in ekpe-related esoteric knowledge. Yet both Ejagham/Ekoi and Afro-Cuban traditions seem to corroborate an Ejagham/Ekoi to Ek diusion (Talbot 1969, III: 779 f., Jones 1956: 16, Ruel 1969: 250, Sosa Rodriguez 1982: 282 f., Rschenthaler 2000, 2006).33 The Ek, indeed, claim to have possessed an indigenous secret society prior to the introduction of ekpe (Latham 1973: 35). Dierent from this indigenous precursor sodality, however, ekpe seems to have provided the Ek with a unique medium of ideological and political arbitrage facilitating the conversion of sacred knowledge into wealth and social power and vice versa.34 And it was the secret of this mode of transvaluation that allowed them to engineer their society into a pivotal nexus within a commercial exchange system of Atlantic proportions. Ekpe may well have had other functions in the past, about which we have very little knowledge. By the turn of the nineteenth century, however, it clearly
JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 286
4/19/07 2:40:54 PM
287
served the goal of organizingand articulating the interests ofa rising commercial elite of ethnically highly heterogeneous origin. More so: ekpe itself had, in a way, become a commodity circulating within an expanding commercial orbit.35 It was the sale and resale of ekpes secretsin fact, their very integration within an exchange sphere including the sale of human merchandisethat facilitated the building of a growing network of supra-local and trans-ethnic trading connections which, by the early twentieth century, extended as far inland as the Cameroon Grasselds.36 By the same token, ekpes mystical voice rang out to the Atlantic as well. Indeed, one might say that ekpe reached Liverpool before it even reached Cuba. By 1828 the British traveler Holman (1840: 392) observed that Captain Burrell of the ship Heywood, of Liverpool, held the rank of Yampai, which is of considerable importance [in fact, it was the highest grade in Old Calabar at the time], and he found it exceedingly to his advantage, as it enabled him to recover all debts due to him by the natives. Burrell may have been among the rst Europeans to become privy to ekpes secret of how to moralize contractual ties. But he certainly was not the last: just as the African hinterland suppliers of human cargo succumbed to the lure of this spiritual broker of economic power, about a score of European buyers documentably fell under its charm as well.37 The mystical leopard, it seems, beckoned to whoever could pay for its serviceswhich consisted in facilitating the transformation of economic assets into sacred authority, and vice versa. Lathams (1973: 29 f.) characterization of ekpe as an elementary capitalist institution of entirely African origin may overstate the case. Yet the numinous entity these associations worshiped may well have been an African avatar of the spirit of capitalism: what ekpe oered to a rising African elite on the Cross River was an ideology capable of domesticating the savage forces unleashed by seaborne European merchant capitalby harnessing them to distinctly local goals. But to return to the American side: even by the rst quarter of the nineteenth century, the Cuban version of ekpeif it really was thatcould quite obviously have had a large number of points of origin.38 Ekpe/ngbe-related knowledge might have diused to Cuba at any time between, say, the 1750s and 1836, and probably did so several times and from a wide variety of locations within the sphere of operation of what Malcolm Ruel (1969) calls the ngbe-polity,39 before it nally congealed in the process of recreating the institution on Cuban soil. Likewise, the original ethnic and even social identity of its carriers seems indeterminate, to say the least: not just scores of unredeemed pawns, but the sons of the headmen of Old Town abducted in the course of the 1767 massacre (Lovejoy and Richardson 1999: 346), or the semi-Bantu Bakassey genllmen [sic] Antera Duke recounts having lured on board a ship in August 1786 (Forde
JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 287
4/19/07 2:40:54 PM
288
1956: 98) may have possessed such knowledge. So may the upwards of twenty Igbo victims of the Arochukwu oracle who, according to Baikies informants (1966: 313) had been shipped to Cuba via Old Calabar. Or take the slaves loaded onto the Cuban schooner which Holman (1840: 389) observed at the Duke Town landing in 1828, and whom Duke Ephraim may have procured from as far as the Cameroons, or from as close as Old Calabar and its immediate vicinity.40 All could have carried their ekpe-titles and the respective bodies of sacred knowledge aboard the ships and into the plantation barracoons, or urban black barrios that became their destination. Ekpe, in other words, was a body of local knowledge impossible to localize in space and time; a structure that moves and is moved onward by the eects of the changes it wreaks upon the social and economic relations within the eld through which it passes. Why, then, did such an (ethnically entirely ambiguous) version of ekpe/ngbe emerge in Cuba at the time it did? The answer I would like to give in the following is ostensibly simple: it did so because both the barrios of urban Cuba and the Cross River city statessmall republics, the missionary Waddell (1863: 314) called themby then formed part of a single historical conjuncture. Though of encompassing, Atlantic nature, it brought forth in both places conditions allowing for certain patterns of what Sidney Mintz (1977) called local initiative and local response. That ekpe/abaku entered this transcontinental political-economic constellation may have been accidental. That it came to mediate these patternsproducing as it did, pronounced similarities on a surface level of formwas due not so much to the agency of a small group of Cuban carabal (whoever they may have been) who enacted the rst sale of the secret on Cuban soil.41 It was due to the fact that the institution to which they introduced another batch of creole Afro-Cubans was already integral to that evolving historical space which we may call the Atlantic world.
Watery solutions So the question to which we should direct ourselves is: why did it catch on? And why did it become endemic to merely a few port towns in western Cuba? The British sold slaves from Old Calabar to virtually all the Antillean colonies and even the North American mainland at just about the same time. Why not there? Let us pursue an old line of inquiry rst, one laid out, again, by Fernando Ortiz. Abaku, Ortiz reasoned, emerged not just in port towns, but in harbornear barrios, and this for quite specic reasons: casting a glance across the Atlantic tells us that these sodalities originated in an riverine environment, and that aquatic symbolism also features prominently in their ritual life. So it doesand,
JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 288
4/19/07 2:40:55 PM
289
in fact, apparently even more soin their New World version where important parts of abakus elaborate founding myth center on the aquatic origins of the mystery, and its initial transaction across a body of water. In keeping with the fact that abaku seemed to condense African toponymy into what Ortizs sisterin-law Lydia Cabrera (1969) would later call a geography by way of remembrance, and Ernesto Sosa (Sosa Rodriguez 1982: 17) a geography of sacred memory, Ortiz thus anticipated contemporary theories of lieux de mmoire (to use Pierre Noras [1989] well-known phrase) in postulating a sort of mystical grid which abaku had, for ritual reasons, superimposed upon the actual topography of Cuba.42 In the beginning, he writes (Ortiz 1986: 15),
various potencias settled near the piers of Regla and its shores; then they scattered in the maritime barrios of the city, such as Jess Mara, Carraguao, Luz, Atars, etc. Even when they diused to the barrios of San Lzaro, Coln and others, they always maintained the tradition that the juego was supposed to be at the anchorage of a marina, i.e. a barrio close to the sea or a river like the Almendares . . . This territorialization which resulted in the division of Havana into independent and rivalling areas, perpetuated, here in the Americas, the legendary insular and localist spirit which, in Africa, was characteristic of the dierent chapters of the fearsome Ekpe.
Ortiz was rightthough, perhaps, for the wrong reasons. To this day, abaku lodgesknown as juegos, potencias or tierrasindeed map out their territories of operation in line with coordinates, both sacred and secular, of their own making. The term juego, thus, refers not just to the notion of a set of obones or plazas (i.e., titleholders), but to their ritual agency in arming and extending power (potencia) over a specic territory (tierra)whether this be a mythical homeland in Enllenisn (a term only insuciently glossed as Africa) or a barrio of Itia Nuncue (Havana), Ita Oror Cande (Regla), Ita Moror (Guanabacoa), Ita Fondoga (Matanzas), or Ita Canimansene (Crdenas), as the four principal strongholds of abaku in Cuba are known today in ritual language. Such assimilation of diasporic space into the categories of an imagined Africa, perhaps, need not surprise us. If, in the early nineteenth-century European mercantile imagination, the Niger Delta had become an inland extension of the Atlantic ocean, a highway into the heart of Central Africa and toward its commercial possibilities (Dike 1956: 18), so had the Ek river gentlemenwho routinely apprenticed their sons on British vessels, amassed vast collections of Victorian bric-a-brac, and even mail-ordered cast-iron palaces from Liverpoolbuilt a Europe of the African merchant imagination into what Edwin Ardener (1989) might have called their essentially Atlantic world structure.43 Surely, given what we know about the repeated enslavement of members of the Old Calabar merchant elite, there is little a priori reason not
JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 289
4/19/07 2:40:55 PM
290
to entertain the hypothesis that these same waters which united actors in Bristol and Old Calabar in the Atlantic pursuit of (however culturally divergent) fantasies of wealth and power might have acquired an analogous transcontinental signicance in the Cuban diaspora: a linkagethough of symbolic naturebetween the piers and dockyards of urban Cuba and the landings and beaches of far away Old Calabar. Central parts of abaku ritual, thus, reenact the initial discovery of the mystical voice of ecu and the founding of the association in Enllenisna term for a landscape distant in space and time that we might be inclined to backtranslate into a chronotopic rendering of abakus African past. During a plante or baroko (ceremony), the title-holders of a potencia are considered to act as, and speak with the voices of, the original founders of the association transacting the secret of ecu.44 In fact, once the power of a potencia is activated and displayed in ritual drama, there is no distinction between Enllenisn (conceived as an African past) and the Cuban present: both space and time collapse as the voice of the holder of the Ecuen-title rings out from the doorstep of a meeting-house to announce the exoteric sequence of a ceremony in the early hours of the morning, and the roaring voice of ecu s sacred friction drum emerges from the cuarto famb (initiatory chamber) of an abaku meeting-house. At that moment any street or alleyway in contemporary Havana can transform into the stage for primordial transactions on the banks of the mythical river Oldn where a woman named Sikan once discovered the secret and was put to death, where the sorcerer Nasak rst fashioned the sacred drum transmitting ecus voice, and where the obones of the tierra ef came across the water to purchase the secret from the tierra ef. In sum, there is little doubt that water was a key to the spread of ekpe/abaku. Its importance, however, lies both in its symbolic functions, and in its economic ones as well. It thus is in the maritime exchanges that historically articulated the landings of Old Calabar with the bay of Havana that we ought to look for an answer to the question of how ekpe not only managed to reassert itself in the New World, but became lastingly ensconced in a few port towns of western Cuba. For, regardless of the continuing capacity of the cultural forms deployed by contemporary adherents of abaku to ritually merge American space and twenty-rst-century time with the event-structure of an African mythical charter, the history of such forms lies elsewhereviz. in the conditions which rendered the harnessing of ekpe-related knowledge to concrete social goals a contextually successful pattern of local initiative and local response. What is at issue, then, is not only how the changing structure of opportunity and constraint given in nineteenth-century Havana allowed the leopards voice to rst ring out on Cuban soil in 1836. The analytical challenge rather lies in bridging the distance between this (New World) event, and those con-
JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 290
4/19/07 2:40:55 PM
291
temporary practices by which ecu s Cuban adepts nowadays commemorate the mysterys African origins, real or imagined. How, to phrase the matter in less abstract terms, did ekpe-related knowledge and practiceincluding the entire structure of African sacred memory it appears to revolve around become subject to continuous social reproduction in Cuba? The rst part of this question is relatively easy to answer. Havanas urban growth had always been related to its strategic position on the eastern rim of the Spanish seaborne empire. With Spains turn to free trade and the onset of Cubas sugar boom in the 1790s, however, the bay of Havana turned into a hub for legal as well as illegal Atlantic exchanges. The volume of merchandise, capital and slaves channeled through Havanas harbor virtually exploded.45 So did its urban population which more than doubled from c. 50,000 in 1791 (Scott 1986: 28) to 112,023 in 1828 (Deschamps Chapeaux 1971: 17), spilling over from the city itself into sprawling barrios extramuros that grew from shanty towns into teeming black neighborhoods. By then, Afro-Cubans made up over 60 percent of the citys population of 112,000, and only a minority of them were slaves.46 Concurrently, a wide variety of licit as well as illicit economic venues opened within the bustling world of docks, warehouses and foundries centered around the bay. Both on account of the scarcity of white labor and the inability or unwillingness of the government to control the ow of merchandise into the channels of an informal and partly illegal market system, enterprising Afro-Cubans came to monopolize strategic positions within an increasingly complex and truly Atlantic structure of economic opportunity.47 One such nodal position was that of the capataz del muelle or dockside labor contractor. And it was around this particular node that abaku appears to have initially begun to crystallize.48 These organizers of the appropriation of Afro-Cuban labor by increasingly international trading companies, in a sense, rode the current of transatlantic economic conjunctures. For they secured the supply of manpower at the point where the streams of Cuban sugar and other export articles intersected the incoming ow of trade goods, slaves and capital. By the same token, however, their position rose and fell with their ability to draw on, and manipulate to their prot, the local labor resources of the harbor-near barrios. It was this intermediate position between international merchant capital and the commoditized black labor it sought after that may have drawn such rising entrepreneurssome of whose careers are well documented49towards the secrets of abaku. And just as ekpe galvanized a slave-trading elite in the Niger delta, its organizational model once more allowed these Afro-Cuban labor-brokers to convert economic assets into sacred power and social control. Partly this was because Havanas Afro-Cuban barrios represented residential and, to a certain extent, economic units whose members evidenced strongly
JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 291
4/19/07 2:40:55 PM
292
dierentiated patterns of local identication and solidarity. The structural analogysuggested by Enrique Sosa (1982: 143)with the towns, wards and quarters of Old Calabar may not be overdrawn, but is certainly beyond empirical corroboration, given what little we know about both places before the second half of the nineteenth century. Nevertheless, it is suciently clear that, once a potencia of abaku moved into one such neighborhood, it began to build up a centralized political structure hinging upon the economic assets accruing from membership, and the sanctioning power single chapters held over their constituency.50 By maneuvering religious title-holders into gatekeeping positions on the local labor market or, alternatively, attracting holders of such positions into their fold (cf. Martnez Bordn 1971: 38), abaku potencias eectively controlled access to employment within their barrios of operation. By the time the Spanish government nally moved to outlaw the association in 1876, some 80 potencias51 had superimposed upon the economic geography of Havana and the industrial zone and warehousing districts of Regla and Guanabacoa the conceptual grid of a geography of sacred memory, thus transforming sites of capitalist production and exchange into what one might call sites for the reproduction of an African past. More crucially, however, they had simultaneously established a tight network of religiously structured relations between members occupying crucial positions in terms of access to labor, the circulation of petty merchandize and contraband goods, and the ow of cash, credit and services throughout the social elds comprised by single barrios or sections thereof. At the same time, they had begun to monopolize access to employment at those outlying industrial or commercial complexestabaqueras, slaughterhouses, markets, warehouses and dockyardswhich they increasingly inltrated, and whose vast demand in physical labor they satised by channeling workers from their own neighborhoods onto the payroll of these large scale enterprises. Already prior to the War of 1895, writes the labor historian Jos Rivero Muz,
The tabaqueros had been accused of pertaining to the said potencias, and if not all of them, so especially those living in the neigborhoods of El Pilar, Los Sitios, Jess Mara and El Horcn, for it was known that there were tabaqueras in which those who were not igos did not receive employment, given that the foremen themselves were sworn in and, therefore, obliged to give preferential treatment to their fellow members. It has also been saidand according to our judgment, on good groundsthat among the meat-packers and workers on the public markets there also abounded the igos, whose associationsabout which so many falsehoods have been written were in reality nothing but societies for mutual assistance . . . (Rivero Muiz 1961: 167).52
JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 292
4/19/07 2:40:55 PM
293
The same held true for the harborside labor market where, as the popular saying went, abaku determined who would eat and who would not (Martnez Bordon 1971: 38). Indeed, as Rivero Muz (ibid.) surmises, part of the repeated violent skirmishes dierent potencias fought out on Havanas streets in the last quarter of the nineteenth century may well have been struggles over access to sources of employment and economic power. Such rivalries obviously were the product of a highly dierentiated structure of economic opportunity, which, for Havanas working population, translated into not just spatial, but also social proximity to sources of employment. But the resulting conicts were nevertheless structured by cultural precepts laid out by ecu itself. There did exist venues of securing amicable relations with or tolerance of an alien potencia on ones native turf.53 Yet although each potencia was in possession of the secret that facilitated the crucial transmutation of economic assets into political as well as sacred power, ecu apparently would not accept tampering with its very sources of strength. Just as the rank and le membership rose and fell with the ability of a potencia to provide steady labor in an economic environment subject to extreme uctuations, so the plazas or obones were loath to relinquish their monopoly over employment options at those key points where Havanas internal distributive system intersected with the world market. By the turn of the twentieth century, abaku-mediated economic linkages between single barrios and the dockside nexuses of transatlantic commercial exchange had solidied to a degree where it had become a commonplace to refer to a maritime terminal or shipping line as belonging to this or that neighborhood (Lpez Valds 1966: 14), and, by extension, to such and such a potencia. According to Lpez Valdss data (based on research in the early 1960s), the holders of the Illamba-title of the Beln-based potencias Bakok and Kanor had risen to the rank of exclusive labor contractors (contratistas) at the docks of the American-owned Ward line, uneasily sharing the labor market of the former with Enlleguell Ef, a powerful and highly prolic potencia from Regla which, under its formidable Illamba Manuel de Jess Chuchu Capaz (1881-1962), would, by the early twentieth century, maneuver itself into the position of dueo del embarcadero (lord of the embankment) of the Regla warehousing district and maritime terminal across the bay.54 Urianabn of the barrio of Coln and Betngo of Pueblo Nuevo dominated the Havana Dock terminal. Reglas Otn Ef ruled at the docks of the United Fruit Companys Flota Blanca line through the oces of its Illambacum-contratista Blas Blasito Prez Rojas. Equeregu Mom and Uriapap of Jess Mara together held sway at the embankments of the Harry Brother line and monopolized two other docks in the southwestern harbor sections of Vaccaro, Atars and Tallapiedra (Lpez Valds 1966: 14 .).
JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 293
4/19/07 2:40:56 PM
294
What emerged, then, was a triply coded system of spatial relations between barrios, abaku potencias and those economic complexes thatwhether by producing trade goods for the world market, or distributing the inowing merchandisegenerated large-scale employment and a few privileged venues for social mobility; venues open to those who managed to combine organizational skill with social capital and hard cash: the former prerequisite to open the doors of the cuarto famb (secret initiatory chamber) of a potencia, and the second necessary to buy a title of strategic import.55 As for the merchant princes of the Niger Delta, ecu to them became a transforming power, one that transforms both those who harness its mysteries to their own goals, and the very world their agency impinges upon. Ecu unbound By then, however, abaku had long crossed the most deeply entrenched social barrier existing in Cuba: in 1857 Andrs Facundo de los Dolores Petit, the famous Isue of the potencia Bakok Ef, and himself a light skinned mulatto of Haitian origin (Ortiz 1952-55, IV: 68),56 sold the secrets of ecu to a group of young white Cubans. On Christmas Eve of 1863, thirteen whites were sworn in as the obones (titleholders) of the rst white potencia of abaku (Roche Monteagudo 1925: 137), appropriately named Okobio Macarar (Ortiz 1952-55, IV: 69) or Ecobio Ef Mucarar (Sosa Rodriguez 1982: 142)translatable as either white brothers or white brothers of Ef.57 Large as it looms in the annals of Cuban abaku, this event has variously been recounted as involving the payment of 1,000 gold ounces (17,000 pesos) with which Bakok Ef bought the freedom of numerous slaves; 500 centenes (2,650 pesos) plus the promise to free certain important members elicited from the whites who were the progeny of elite families; and nally the symbolical sum of 30 ounces, strongly resonating with biblical connotations of treason and deceit (Ortiz 1952-55, VI: 69). Yet whatever the concrete amount was, whatever use Petit and his fellow ocobios put the money to,58 and whatever violent conicts the transaction engendered,59 as Ortiz succinctly put it, the exchange of knowledge around which it revolved nally and irrevocably transformed abaku from a cosa de negros into a cosa de Cuba (Ortiz 1952-55, IV: 71).60 Not only would the memory of the foundational events on the banks of the river Oldn now be carried onward in time by socially white Cubans, but the spirits of the primordial transactants of ecus secret would incarnate in their bodies as well. The paradox, however, is more apparent than real: far from severing what might be perceived as the last ties uniting an African-derived institution with its transatlantic origins, Petits had acted in accordance with the mechanisms of
JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 294
4/19/07 2:40:56 PM
295
reproduction by which ekpe had generated a vast network of commercial and political relations in the Bight of Biafra and its hinterland. It is not only that European slavers had been documentably integrated into ekpes network of sacred allegiance and commercial reciprocity on the African side long before Petit availed himself of an opportunitygenerated, in the last instance, by a larger Atlantic systemwhich may have brought the interests of the rst white indsime (candidates for initiation) in alignment with those of their black ocobios (i.e., brothers in ecu).61 Rather, from its very origin athwart the African riverine highways along which knowledge about the law-giving voice of the leopard was sold from one slave-trading local unit to the other, ekpes success had been pegged to its nature as a sacred commodity circulating against other carriers of values. More than anything else, it was this characteristic that imbued it with a unique capacity to break through, and reproduce itself across, deeply entrenched ethnic barriers. And just as ekpe managed to build up proliferating networks of trade and cooperation among diverse African populationseventually incorporating an array of hinterland societies reaching as far as the Cameroon grasslands into what Ruel (1969) has, perhaps not inappropriately, called an ngbe-polityso did Cuban ocobios reproduce the secret and its politicaleconomic functions by strategically widening its sphere of circulation. For even though the inception of the rst white potencia initially seems to have incited violent reactions, abaku eventually became the rst Cuban institution integrating individuals of African and European descent into a common pattern of identication and solidarity. Paradoxical as it may seem, by the 1860s, we might say, ecu had achieved what Jos Marts visionary anti-racist program of Cuban nation-building would (rather less than successfully) posit some three decades later (Helg 1995, Ferrer 1999). The dierence was that in this case white Cubans did not grudgingly consent to Afro-Cuban participation in an American national project, but eagerly paid for their own inclusion in a black secret society of African origin. Hence whether or not Petits agency was salient within the symbolic universe of African ekpe/ngbe may not be the most appropriate question. For its historical signicance rather lies in transforming Cuban abaku into an enduring part of a transcontinentally dispersed, indeed virtually rhizomatic, system of knowledge and ritual practice capable of rendering the forces of global capitalism locally coextensive with an awesome African power. Like the mythical founders of the association in a Niger Delta of the Cuban imagination, the Africans who founded in 1836 the secret society of Abakuas one can read today on a plaque erected under Cuban government auspices near the embankment of Reglacapitalized on local structures of opportunity generated, ultimately, by the heaving and swelling of larger political-economic tides. And no
JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 295
4/19/07 2:40:56 PM
296
less than their historical contemporaries in Africa, the members of the cabildo carabal bricam apapa ef in Regla, the mysterious creole Belenistas to whom they sold the secret, and Andrs Petit who engineered yet another expansion of its New World sphere of exchange, built a lasting system of commercial transactions in esoteric knowledge into the local conjunctural structure of such Atlantic circulations. In the end, it seems that in the Bay of Havana, local and global politicaleconomic constellations meshed to a degree where international capitalism and an African-derived secret society lastingly became mutually constitutive. If so, however, what do we make of all this? Was it, after all, nothing but the result of the accidental opening up of a diusionary path from here to there? A bunch of initiates, originating who knows where, being shuttled from Calabar to Cuba by the energy generated through the operation of what Philip Curtin (1955) called the South Atlantic system? An obscure miracle of connection as David Scott (1999) puts it in harnessing Edward Kamau Brathwaites poetic phrase to the characterization of a history both too evident and too elusive to be captured by simple empiricist procedures? To be sure, the movement of ekpe to Cuba occurred along a trajectory dened by the historical conjunction of two disparate localities. Call it an accident, if you will. Still, once removed from African soil, ekpe turned into a body of knowledge that had yet to be re-transformed into a system of practice capable of reproduction on Cuban soil. What made for the striking success of ekpe in Cuba was that the ideology it provided seems to have matched the social situation it encountered there to an astonishing degree. As a result, Cubans of various socio-racial identities today ritually enact ecu s initial discovery and sale across African ethnic boundaries. They map sacred memories of an Africa of their collective imagination upon the New World social spaces in which they live and act. And they compete with each other in accumulating ritualistic knowledge about a myth of African origins and the meaning of its New World re-enactment, thereby building up social and cultural capital within their communities whichto this daynot only is transactable into masculine reputation, but economic options as well. Yet whether such African origins ever existed or not (and the question really should be moot by now), a valid explanation for why this is so cannot be found on one single side of those waters which, for a time, brought the bay of Havana into intimate alignment with the landings and beaches of the Cross River and its slave-supplying hinterland. In the nal analysis then, ekpe itself, in a sense, was an Atlanticcreole, if you willinstitution before it even arrived in Cuba. More paradoxically even, in a surprising reversal of received notions about directionality in the
JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 296
4/19/07 2:40:56 PM
297
Afro-Atlantic space-time continuum, abaku eventually became an African phenomenon. In 1912 the British colonial agent and prolic amateur ethnographer B. Amaury Talbot published the rst photograph of an ekpe body mask taken in southeastern Nigeria (Talbot 1912, plate facing page 42). What Talbot did not know was that the long-time resident Spanish genre painter Victor Patricio Landaluze had documented such masks nearly two generations earlier in Cuba (e.g., Landaluze 1881). More astonishing, the rst photographic images of Cross-River-style body masks taken on the African continent had been published a little over a decade before Talbots, and Talbot could not have known about them either because these photographs had been taken in no less unlikely a place than the prison of Monte Ach in the NorthAfrican Spanish penal colony of Ceuta (Salillas 1901). For in yet another series of Atlantic movements, of which we know only the barest outlines, Cuban ocobios deported to the Spanish presidios of Santa Isabel de Fernando Poo and Ceuta since the late 1850s recreated the sodality there. Here we could begin to ask how Spanish counterinsurgent policymore than 600 supposed igos were exiled during the last Cuban war of independence alone62might be linked to wider economic and ideological conjunctures and concerns, and what factors made for the transformation of abaku into a British Caribbean-style Christmas mummery on Fernando Poo (Moreno Moreno 1948), whereas it retained or even augmented its political functions in Cuba wheredespite massive persecutionby the 1920s it played an increasing role in electoral politics.63 But this must be the subject of another publication. In lieu of a conclusion The more important question for now may be the following one: do we even want to continue to speak about ekpe and abaku as institutionspatterned arrangements of social relations and practices that can be, as it were, monitored in their trajectories, like an object hurled from one side of the Atlantic to the other, and, by analogy recalled into New World history from African remembrance? The question is far from trivial, for such a view is what any attempt at the comparative elucidation of a historical relation between ekpe and abaku must realistically be based on. But how can we establish such a relation if we cannot be sure of the separate existence of the entities we aim to relate? Might we not rather think of both ekpe and abaku as part of a single processual constellationsomething akin to a meteorological formation, perhaps; a weather system that moves across time and space, circulating against other airmasses within larger formations, and producing, as it articulates with
JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 297
4/19/07 2:40:56 PM
298
regional micro-climates, the specic historical eects which enter the local record. The analogy may not be as whimsical as it would appear.64 To suggest two examples: Fernand Braudels conception of hierarchically layered, but interacting strata of historical time each with their proper set of spatial parameters of historical eventuation represents one such model, though Braudels own profound lack of interest in historical subjectivity seems to have preempted a good deal of its impact. So diddespite its pitiful neglect of human agency, monstrous jargon and eventual dissipation into the utterly sterile modes of production controversy (cf. Foster Carter 1978)the Marxist theory of structural articulation with its inherent tendency to problematize conceptions of the local and the conditions of its emergence and reproduction. I am not arguing for a return to or emulation of such endeavors, strictu sensu.65 Nor would I want this entire essay to be understood as anything but a methodological note of caution thator so I would hopemight come to inform further ethnographic and archival scholarship. But I do think that the case of abaku presents sucient evidence for the need to recalibrate our intellectual tool kit if we want to keep concepts like that of an Atlantic World from degenerating into fashionable metaphors for what everybody has been doing all along anyway. Clearly, in the case at hand, both space and time are deceptive, for they exist on ontological as well as discursive levels, neither of which easily or even only unproblematically reduces to the other. Given this fact, we might be well advised to treat concepts such as Africa, Cuba, history and memory as heuristic metaphors, lest we feel prepared to once more wrestle with the ghosts of Tylor and Galton, Frazier and Herskovits. In the end, perhaps the question worth asking is not whether there is an Africa in the Americas and how we can nd it, but rather what is the conceptual frame within which we might phrase useful questions about both places at one and the same time.
References
Abascal Lopez, Jess. 1985. La sociedad secreta abaku. Cuba Internacional 17.8, 58-61. Adams, John. 1966 [1823]. Remarks on the Country Extending from Cape Palmas to the River Congo. London: Frank Cass. Agbo, A.E. 1965. Ek Origins and Migrations Reconsidered. Nigeria Magazine 87, 267-280. Appadurai, Arjun. 1995. The Production of Locality. In Richard Fardon (ed.), Counterworks: Managing the Diversity of Knowledge. London: Routledge, 204-225. Apter, Andrew. 1991. Herskovits Heritage: Rethinking Syncretism in the African Diaspora. Diaspora 1, 235-259.
JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 298
4/19/07 2:40:57 PM
299
Ardener, Edwin. 1970. Documentary and Linguistic Evidence for the Rise of the Trading Polities between Rio del Rey and Cameroons, 1500-1650. In Ioan M. Lewis, (ed.), History and Social Anthropology. London: Tavistock, 81-126. . 1989. The Voice of Prophecy. Oxford: Blackwell. Argenti, Nicolas. 2006. Remembering the Future: Slavery, Youth, and Masking in the Cameroon Grasselds. Social Anthropology 14.1, 49-69. Baikie, William Balfour. 1966 [1856]. Narrative of an Exploring Voyage up the Rivers Kwra and Bnue. London: Frank Cass. Barras y Prado, Antonio de la. 1925. La Habana a mediados del siglo XIX: Memrias. Madrid: Imprenta de la Ciudad Lineal. Bastian, Adolf. 1859. Ein Besuch in San Salvador, der Hauptstadt des Knigreichs Congo. Bremen: Heinrich Strack. Bastide, Roger. 1978. The African Religions of Brazil. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press. Bennett, Herman. 2000. The Subject in the Plot: National Boundaries and the History of the Black Atlantic. African Studies Review 43,101-24. Bergson, Henri. 1912. Time and Free Will. London: George Allen. Boas, Franz. 1938. Introduction. In Franz Boas (ed.), General Anthropology. Boston: D.C. Heath, 1-6. Borroto Mora, Alejandrino. 1966. Trabajos tpicos del mercado nico de la Habana. Etnologa y Folklore 2, 61-73. . 1967. Desentralizacin del mercado nico de la Habana. Etnologa y Folklore 4, 79-98. Breen, Timothy H. 1984. Creative Adaptations: Peoples and Cultures. In Jack P. Greene and J.R. Pole (eds.), Colonial British America. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 195-232. Bremer, Frederika. 1968 [1863]. Homes of the New World: Impressions of America. New York: Negro Universities Press. Brown, David H. 1989. Garden in the Machine: Afro-Cuban Sacred Art and Performance in Urban New Jersey and New York. Unpublished Ph.D. thesis, Yale University. . 2003. The Light Inside: Abaku Society Arts and Cuban Cultural History. Washington, DC: Smithsonian Institution Press. Cabrera, Lydia. 1969 [1958]. La sociedad secreta abaku. Miami: Editorial C.R. . 1983 [1954]. El Monte. Miami: Coleccin del Chicherek. Capone, Stefania. Forthcoming, 2007. Transatlantic Dialogue: Roger Bastide and the African American Religions. Journal of Religion in Africa 37.3. Caron, Peter. 1997. Of a Nation Which the Others Do Not Understand: Bambara Slaves and African Ethnicity in Colonial Louisiana. Slavery and Abolition 18, 98-121. Carvalho Soares, Mariza. 2001. Mina, Angola and Guin: Where Are the African Ethnic Groups in Colonial Brazil. Unpublished conference paper. Castellanos, Israel. 1916. La brujera y el iguismo en Cuba desde el punto de vista mdicolegal. Havana: Lloredo y Ca. . 1928. El diablito igo. Archivos del Folklore Cubano 3, 27-37. Castellanos, Jorge, and Isabel Castellanos. 1992. Cultura afrocubana III: Las religiones y lenguas. Miami: Ediciones Universal. Chambers, Douglas. 1997. My Own Nation: Igbo Exiles in the Diaspora. Slavery and Abolition 18, 72-97.
JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 299
4/19/07 2:40:57 PM
300
. 2000. Tracing Igbo into the African Diaspora. In Paul E. Lovejoy (ed.), Identity in the Shadow of Slavery. London: Continuum, 55-71. Coronil, Fernando. 1995. Introduction to the Duke University Press Edition. Transculturation and the Politics of Theory: Countering the Center, Cuban Counterpoint. In Fernando Ortiz, Cuban Counterpoint. Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 1995, ix-lvi. Courlander, Harold. 1944. Abakwa Meeting in Guanabacoa. Journal of Negro History 29, 461-470. Curtin, Philip D. 1955. Two Jamaicas: The Role of Ideas in a Tropical Colony, 1830-1865. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. Danto, Arthur. 1965. Analytical Philosophy of History. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Davila, Nodarse, 1981. Vigencia y aspectos socioreligiosos de la sociedad secreta abacua en la provncia de Matanzas. Typescript. Deschamps Chapeaux, Pedro. 1964. Margarito Blanco Ocongo de Ultn. Boletn del Instituto de Histria y del Archivo Nacional 65: 97-109. . 1969. Cimarrones urbanos. Revista de la Biblioteca Nacional Jos Mart 11, 145-164. . 1971. El negro en la economa habanera del siglo XIX. Havana: Unin de Escritores y Artistas. Daz, Alberto Pedro. 1961. Para iniciarse en la sociedad abaku. Actas de Folklore 1: 17-20. Daz, Mara del Rosario. 2005. The Tragedy of the igos: Genesis of an Unpublished Book. New West Indian Guide 79, 229-237. Dike, K. Onwuka. 1956. Trade and Politics in the Niger Delta, 1830-1885. Oxford: Clarendon Press. Dike, K. Onwuka and Felicia I. Ekejiuba. 1978. The Aro State: A Case Study of State Formation in Southeastern Nigeria. Journal of African Studies 5, 268-300. Eltis, David, and David Richardson. 1997. The Numbers Game and Routes to Slavery. Slavery and Abolition 18, 3-5. Fabian, Johannes. 1983. Time and The Other. New York: Columbia University Press. Fardon, Richard (ed.). 1990. Localizing Strategies. Washington, DC: Smithsonian Press. Feierman, Steven. 1993. African Histories and the Dissolution of World History. In Robert H. Bates, V.Y. Mudimbe and Jean OBarr (eds.), Africa and the Disciplines. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 167-212. Ferrer, Ada. 1999. Insurgent Cuba: Race, Nation, and Revolution, 1868-1898. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press. Forde, Darryll. 1956. Ek Traders of Old Calabar. London: Oxford University Press. Foster-Carter, Aidan. 1978. The Modes of Production Controversy. New Left Review 107, 47-77. Goldie, Hugh. 1964 [1874]. Dictionary of the Ek Language. Farnborough: Gregg Press. Gupta, Akhil, and James Ferguson (eds.). 1997. Anthropological Locations. Berkeley: University of California Press. Hair, P.E.H. 1967. Ethnolinguistic Continuity on the Guinea Coast. Journal of African History 8, 247-268. Halbwachs, Maurice. 1942. La Topographie lgendaire des Evangiles en Terre Sante. Paris: Presses Universitaires de France. Helg, Aline. 1995. Our Rightful Share: The Afro-Cuban Struggle for Equality, 1886-1912. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press.
JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 300
4/19/07 2:40:57 PM
301
Herskovits, Melville J. 1969. On Some Modes of Ethnographic Comparison. In Frances S. Herskovits (ed.), The New World Negro. New York: Minerva Press, 71-82. Holman, James. 1840. Travels in Madeira, Sierra Leone, Tenerie, St. Jago, Cape Coast, Fernando Po, Princes Island, Etc., Etc.. London: George Routledge. Horton, Robin. 1969. From Fishing Village to City State: A Social History of New Calabar. In Mary Douglas and Phyllis M. Kaberry (eds.), Man in Africa. London: Tavistock, 37-58. Hutchinson, Thomas J. 1856. Impressions of Western Africa. London: Longman, Brown, Green, Longmans and Roberts. Jackson, Walter A. 1986. Melville Herskovits and the Search for African Origins. In George W. Stocking (ed.), Malinowski, Benedict, Rivers and Others (History of Anthropology 4), Madison: University of Wisconsin Press, 95-126. Jereys, M.D.W. 1954. Alt-Kalabar und der Sklavenhandel. Paideuma 6, 14-24. . 1966. Ek Origin. Nigeria Magazine 91, 297-299. Jones, G.I. 1956. The Political Organization of Old Calabar. In Darryll C. Forde (ed.), Ek Traders of Old Calabar. London: Oxford University Press, 116-160. . 1988. The Background of Eastern Nigerian History. New Haven: HRAF. Jorgenson, Joseph G. 1979. Cross-Cultural Comparisons. Annual Reviews of Anthropology 8, 309-331. Kingsley, Mary H. 1897. Travels in West Africa. London: Macmillan. Klein, Kerwin Lee. 2000. On the Emergence of Memory in Historical Discourse. Representations 69, 127-150. Knight, Franklin W. 1970. Slave Society in Cuba During the Nineteenth Century. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press. . 1977. Origins of Wealth and the Sugar Revolution in Cuba, 1750-1850. Hispanic American Historical Review 57: 231-253. Lambek, Michael, and Paul Antze. 1996. Introduction: Forecasting Memory. In Michael Lambek and Paul Antze (eds.), Tense Past: Cultural Essays in Trauma and Memory. New York: Routledge, xi-xxxviii. Landaluze, Victor Patricio. 1881. Tpos y costumbres de la isla de Cuba. Havana: Miguel de la Villa. Latham, A.J.H. 1972. Witchcraft Accusations and Economic Tensions in Pre-Colonial Old Calabar. Journal of African History 13, 249-260. . 1973. Old Calabar, 1600-1891. Oxford: Clarendon Press. Leib, Elliot, and Rene Romano. 1985. Reign of the Leopard. African Arts 18, 48-57, 94-96. Le Riverend, Julio. 1974. Historia economica de Cuba. Havana: Instituto Cubano del Libro. Lpez Valds, Rafael. 1966. La sociedad secreta abaku en un grupo de obreros portuarios. Etnologa y Folklore 2, 5-26. Lovejoy, Paul E. 1994. Background to Rebellion: The Origins of Muslim Slaves in Bahia. In Paul Lovejoy and Nicholas Rogers (eds.), Unfree Labor in the Development of the Atlantic World. London: Frank Cass, 151-80. . 1997. The African Diaspora: Revisionist Interpretations of Ethnicity, Culture and Religion under Slavery. Studies in the World History of Slavery, Abolition, and Emancipation 2, 1-24. . 2000. Identifying Enslaved Africans in the African Diaspora. In Paul E. Lovejoy (ed.), Identity in the Shadow of Slavery. London: Continuum, 1-29. Lovejoy, Paul E., and David Richardson. 1999. Trust, Pawnship, and Atlantic History: The Institutional Foundations of the Old Calabar Slave Trade. American Historical Review 104, 333-355.
JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 301
4/19/07 2:40:57 PM
302
McFarlan, Donald M. 1957. Calabar: The Church of Scotland Mission. London: Thomas Nelson and Sons. Mansfeld, Alfred. 1908. Urwald-Dokumente. Berlin: Dietrich Reimer. Marrero, Levi. 1971-78. Cuba, economa y sociedad. Madrid: Playor. Martnez Bordon, Osvaldo. 1971. Histria del puerto de la Habana. Havana: Comisin de histria del regional puerto PCC. Midlo Hall, Gwendolyn. 1992. Africans in Colonial Louisiana. Baton Rouge: Louisiana State University Press. Miller, Ivor. 2000. A Secret Society Goes Public: The Relationship Between Abaku and Cuban Popular Culture. African Studies Review 43, 161-188. . 2005. Cuban Abaku Chants: Examining New Linguistic and Historical Evidence for the African Diaspora. African Studies Review 48, 23-58. Mintz, Sidney W. 1977. The So-Called World System: Local Initiative and Local Response. Dialectical Anthropology 2, 253-270. . 1996. Enduring Substances, Trying Theories: The Caribbean Region as oikoumene. Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute 2, 289-311. Mintz, Sidney W., and Richard Price. 1992. The Birth of African American Culture. Boston: Beacon Press. Moliner Castaeda, Israel. 1988. Los igos. Del Caribe 5, 13-18. Moreno Fraginals, Manuel. 1976. The Sugarmill. New York: Monthly Review Press. . 1977. Africa in Cuba: A Quantitative Analysis of the African Population in the Island of Cuba. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 292, 187-201. . 1983. La histria como arma. Barcelona: Editorial Crtica. Moreno Moreno, Jos A. 1948. El yange fernandino. frica 83-84, 411-412. Morgan, Philip D. 1997. The Cultural Implications of the Atlantic Slave Trade: African Regional Origins, American Destinations and New World Developments. Slavery and Abolition 18, 122-145. Nair, Kannan K. 1972. Politics and Society in South Eastern Nigeria, 1841-1906. London: Frank Cass. . 1977. King and Missionary in Ek Politics, 1846-1858. Journal of African Studies 4, 243-280. Narroll, Raoul. 1970. Galtons Problem. In Raoul Narroll and Ronald Cohen (eds.), Handbook of Method in Cultural Anthropology. Garden City: Natural History Press, 974-989. Nicklin, Keith. 1991. Un emblme Ejagham de la socit Ekpe/An Ejagham Emblem of the Ekpe Society. Art Tribal (Bulletin annuel publi par lAssociation des Amis du Muse Barbier-Muller) 1991, 3-18. Noah, Monday Eong. 1980. Old Calabar: The City States and the Europeans. Uyo: Scholars Press. Nora, Pierre. 1989. Between Memory and History. Representations 26, 7-25. Northrup, David. 1978. Trade Without Rulers: Pre-Colonial Economic Development in South-Eastern Nigeria. Oxford: Clarendon Press. . 2000. Igbo and Myth Igbo: Culture and Ethnicity in the Atlantic World, 16001850. Slavery and Abolition 21, 1-20. Ortiz, Fernando. 1950. La trageda de los igos. Cuadernos Americanos 52, 79-101. . 1952-55. Los instrumentos de la msica afrocubana. Havana: Cardenas y Cia. . 1981. Los bailes y el teatro de los negros. Havana: Editorial Letras Cubanas. . 1986. Los negros curros. Havana: Editorial de Ciencias Sociales.
JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 302
4/19/07 2:40:57 PM
303
Ottenberg, Simon. 1958. Ibo Oracles and Intergroup Relations. Southwestern Journal of Anthropology 14, 295-317. Ottenberg, Simon, and Linda Knudsen. 1985. Leopard Society Masquerades: Symbolism and Diusion. African Arts 18, 37-44, 93-104. Palmer, Colin A. 1981. Human Cargoes: The British Slave Trade to Spanish America, 17001739. Urbana: University of Illinois Press. Palmi, Stephan. 1993. Ethnogenetic Processes and Cultural Transfer in Caribbean Slave Populations. In Wolfgang Binder (ed.), Slavery in the Americas. Wrzburg: Knigshauser und Neumann, 337-364. . 1994. Review of Gwendolyn Midlo Hall Africans in Colonial Louisiana. Africa 64, 168-71. . 1998. Fernando Ortiz and the Cooking of History. Iberoamerikanisches Archiv 24, 353-373. . 2002. Wizards and Scientists: Explorations in Afro-Cuban Modernity and Tradition. Durham, NC: Duke University Press. . 2005. Ackee and Saltsh vs. Amal con Quimbomb? Sidney Mintz Contribution to the Historical Anthropology of African American Cultures. Journal de la Socit des Americanistes 91-2, 89-122. . 2006a. A View From Ita Oror Kande. Social Anthropology 14, 99-118. . 2006b. Creolization and Its Discontents. Annual Review of Anthropology 35, 433-456. and Elizabeth Prez. 2005. An All Too Present Absence: Fernando Ortiz Work on Abaku in Sociocultural Context. New West Indian Guide 79, 219-227. Prez, Louis A. Jr. 1988. Cuba: Between Reform and Revolution. New York: Oxford University Press. Prez, Nancy, Clara Dominguez, Rosa Rodrguez, Orlando Silva and Danubia Terry. 1982. El cabildo carabal isuama. Santiago de Cuba: Editorial Oriente. Price, Richard. 2001. The Miracle of Creolization: A Retrospective. New West Indian Guide 75, 25-64. Rivero Muz, Jos. 1961. El movimiento obrero durante la primera intervencin. Las Villas: Universidad Central de las Villas. Roche Monteagudo, Rafael. 1925. La policia y sus mistrios. Havana: La Moderna Poesa. Rschenthaler, Ute. 2000. Lokalitt und Siedlungsgeschichte im Cross-River Gebiet. Zeitschrift fr Ethnologie 125, 189-214. . 2006. Translocal Cultures: The Slave Trade and Cultural Transfer in the Cross River Region. Social Anthropology 14, 71-91. Routon, Kenneth. 2005. Unimaginable Homelands? Africa and the Abaku Historical Imagination. Journal of Latin American Anthropology 10, 370-400. Ruel, Malcolm. 1969. Leopards and Leaders: Constitutional Politics Among a Cross River People. London: Tavistock. Salillas, Rafael. 1901. Los igos en Ceuta. Revista general de legislacin y jurisprudncia 98, 337-360. Sandoval, Alsonso de, SJ 1956 [1627]. De Instauranda Aethiopum Salute. Bogota: Empresa Nacional de Publicaciones. Scott, David. 1991. That Event, This Memory: Notes on an Anthropology of African Diasporas in the New World. Diaspora 1, 261-84. . 1999. Refashioning Futures: Criticism After Postcoloniality. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 303
4/19/07 2:40:58 PM
304
Scott, Julius S. 1986. The Common Wind: Currents of Afro-American Communication During the Haitian Revolution. Ph.D. thesis, Duke University. Ann Arbor: UMI Serrano, Carlos. 1985. La Colonie pnitentiaire (rebelles, anarchistes, igos dans les pnitenciers espagnols). In Mlanges Amricanistes en Hommage a Paul Verdevoye. Paris: ditions Hispaniques, 79-92. Shaw, Rosalind. 2002. Memories of the Slave Trade. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Simmonds, Donald. 1956. An Ethnographic Sketch of the Ek People. In Darryll C. Forde (ed.), Ek Traders of Old Calabar. London: Oxford University Press, 1- 26. Smith, M.G. 1965. A Framework for Caribbean Studies. In M.G. Smith (ed.), The Plural Society in the British West Indies. Berkeley: University of California Press, 18-74. . 1971. The African Heritage in the Caribbean. In Vera Rubin (ed.), Caribbean Studies: A Symposium. Seattle: University of Washington Press, 34-46. Sosa Rodrguez, Enrique. 1982. Los igos. Havana: Casa de las Amricas. Talbot, P. Amaury. 1912. In the Shadow of the Bush. London: Heinemann. Thomas, Hugh. 1971. Cuba: The Pursuit of Freedom. New York: Harper and Row. Thompson, Robert Farris. 1983. Flash of the Spirit: African and Afro-American Art and Philosophy. New York: Random House. Thornton, John K. 1992. Africa and Africans in the Making of the Atlantic World, 14001680. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Tomich, Dale V. 2004. Through the Prism of Slavery: Labor, Capital and World Economy. Lanham: Rowman and Littleeld. Trouillot, Michel-Rolph. 1982. Motion in the System: Coee, Color, and Slavery in Eighteenth-Century Saint-Domingue. Review 3, 331-388. Trujillo y Monagas, Jos. 1882. Los igos: Su historia, sus prcticas, su lenguage. In Carlos Urrutia y Blanco (ed.), Los criminales de Cuba y Don Jos Trujillo. Barcelona: Establecimiento Tipogrco de Fidel Gir, 363-374. Waddell, Hope Masterton. 1863. Twenty-Nine Years in the West Indies and Central Africa. London: T. Nelson and Sons. Wagner, Roy. 1986. Symbols That Stand for Themselves. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Yelvington, Kevin. 2001. The Anthropology of Afro-Latin America and the Caribbean: Diasporic Dimensions. Annual Review of Anthropology 30, 227-60. . 2006. The Invention of Africa in Latin America and the Caribbean: Political Discourse and Anthropological Praxis, 1920-1940. In Kevin Yelvington (ed.), AfroAtlantic Dialogues. Santa Fe: School of American Research Press, 35-82.
Notes
1. Its earliest version was presented at a conference on The Atlantic Slave Trade in African and African American Memory, held at the University of Chicago, 24-25 May 1997. It has gone through its own set of historical changes since then. 2. As well as self-consciously New Revisionist historians aiming to refocus scholarly debate on the question of African origins. On such tendencies see below, as well as my more specic critique in Palmi (2005). 3. What Wagner has in mind here are not the extended, internally discontinuous events (like The French Revolution) that Danto (1965) calls temporal structures, nor a Bergsonian notion of phenomenological duration (Bergson 1912). For Wagner, epoch desig-
JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 304
4/19/07 2:40:58 PM
305
nates a unit of experienced gurative time that belongs to a ow of analogya now that remembers or imagines itself into (or out of ) other nows (Wagner 1986: 90), and so creates a unitary presence beyond chronological measurement, and scalar resolution. As I tried to show earlier (Palmi 2006a), Usagar, Bekura Mend or Enllenisn might be considered as designations of such nows. 4. In the long run, Millers eorts might well result in the creation of what Johnson (this issue) might call a novel diasporic horizon for Cuban abaku. If so, it would be fascinating to document this ethnographically. 5. Or simply read as such out of behaviors whose pastfulness is not discursively available to the actors themselves (cf. Shaw 2002, Argenti 2006). 6. Ironically, the fact that both initially cast their endeavors in the mold of Lombrosian criminal anthropology (with its emphasis on biologistically conceivedi.e., contextindependentdeterminants of behavior) may have steered them towards a transcontinental view, albeit for the wrong reasons. At least Ortiz, however, had clearly transcended these earlier racialist views by 1930 and embarked on an ethnographic and historical quest which produced some of the nest African-Americanist research to this date (cf. Coronil 1995, Palmi 1998, 2002, Palmi and Prez 2005, Daz 2005). 7. Herskovitss program for African-American studies remained crucially indebted to the maxim his teacher Franz Boas had laid out in terms of linguistic reconstruction: Comparison of related forms throws light upon the history of their dierentiation (Boas 1938: 2). What may have made African-America such an attractive eld for a student of Boas was the fact that in this particular case historical relationships did not have to be inferred (e.g., in the form of hypothetical migrations) from modern evidence, but seemed to be on record. 8. It takes its origin from a famous debate between Sir Edward Burnett Tylor and the eminent statistician Sir Francis Galton, mostly remembered today as the founder of Eugenicsan infamous outgrowth of nineteenth-century scientism. In the case at hand Galton authored an important intervention in the complacent social evolutionism of contemporary armchair anthropologists. At a meeting of the Royal Anthropological Institute in 1889, Tylor presented the results of an ambitious inquiry aiming to derive universal laws of the evolution of human systems of marriage and descent from the comparison of a sample of 350 cultures culled from the ethnographic record. To Tylors dismay, Galton asked him about the independence of his sampling units: how could Tylor guarantee that what he called adhesions (i.e., correlations) between variables (such as, e.g., modes of reckoning descent, incest-barriers, residence rules or forms of kin-avoidance) reected universal patterns of social evolution if he could not rule out the mutual contamination of his sample units through historically contingent processes of cultural diusion? Tylor could not answer the question, and neither has anybody after him ever solved the problem of how to infer presumably universally valid laws of human social development from historical, and therefore necessarily contingent, data. 9. There are additional theoretical problems bound up with the creolization concept which is recently enjoying a remarkable renaissance. Scholars from various walks of theory have seized upon its potential for signifying states of hybridity as an antidote against diverse forms of foundational thought. Since most of them seem to derive the concept from linguistics, the historical usage of the term criollo as a designation of an Old World species grown indigenous in the New World has virtually been obliterated. This is ironical, for all fanciful talk about hybridity notwithstanding, the roots of the creolization-metaphor lie in a discourse on breedinghardly the genre in which postmodern critics like to express
JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 305
4/19/07 2:40:58 PM
306
themselves. An ingenuous use of the term close to its historical origins is evident in Breen (1984). Both Mintz (1996) and Price (2001) have recently independently claried their points of view in respect to some of the unintended consequences of their intervention. For other issues involved in operationalizing the creolizaton metaphor see Palmi (2006b). 10. Particularly in nineteenth-century sources the association is typically referred to as los igos. Today, members of abaku regard the term as derogatory and oensive, and prefer to call themselves and each other ocobios (brothers) or ecoria ene abaku (men born over the drum skini.e., into abaku). 11. See Archivo Nacional de Cuba (hencewith ANC) Asuntos Poltcos, leg. 76 #56, Trujillo y Monagas (1882: 364), Roche Monteagudo (1925: 4), Deschamps Chapeaux (1964: 97). 12. See ANC Comisin Militar leg 23 #1, Deschamps Chapeaux (1964: 98, 101). Abaku has a complex system of titles. Each chapter or potencia consists of 13 holders of major ranked titles, up to 12 titled minor functionaries and an unspecied number of untitled members. The four highest ranking functionaries bear the titles of Illamba, Mocongo, Isu and Isunecu. 13. In 1853 one such clash in the barrio of Jess Mara resulted in the death of police inspector Jos Esquivel, and a series of shoot-outs between igos and the police during the carnival season of 1865 sparked a period of urban warfare that lasted until September 1866 (Roche Monteagudo 1925: 52). 14. See ANC Asuntos Polticos leg 76 #56, Trujillo y Monagas (1882: 365), Moliner Castaeda (1988: 14), Sosa Rodriguez (1982: 131), Abascal Lopez (1985: 60) and Dvila Nodarse (1981: 2 f.). 15. See, e.g., Barras y Prado (1925: 123 f.) for an account dating to 1852. The paintings of the visiting Basque artist Landaluze (1881), reprinted, e.g., in Ortiz (1981), Thompson (1983) or Brown (2003) provide intriguing pictorial evidence for costume and comportment of these masked dancers at mid-nineteenth century. Castellanos (1928) describes the reme body masks (saco, aforeme) in detail, though his interpretation is wildly o the mark. 16. The pertinent publications include Ortiz (1950), (1951), (1952-55), (1975), and especially the series of articles on the negros curros published between 1926 and 1928 in Archivos del Folklore Cubano, and edited by Diana Iznaga (Ortiz 1986). Ortiz seems to have reached the conclusion that the negros ef y carabal son los mismos upon reading Samuel Crowthers Journal of an Expedition on the Niger and Tshadde Rivers (1856) in 1916 (see Ortiz 1975: 46). 17. The most uncivilized part of Africa ever I was in was Old Calabar, the explorer MacGregor Laird stated in 1833, adding that [t]he Calabar River has been so long frequented by British vessels that a description of it would now be superuous (McFarlan 1957: 2 f.). The operation of ekpe received rather extensive coverage in the writings of the Scottish Presbyterian missionaries stationed there since the 1850s (e.g., Waddell 1863). Towards the end of the century, Mary Kingsley subtitled chapter four of her Travels in West Africa with the ironic suggestion that the general reader may omit [it] as the voyager gives herein no details of Old Calabar or of other things of general interest (Kingsley 1897: 73). 18. Often described (e.g., by Thompson 1983) as a prime example (along with the socalled Vai script) for the existence of indigenously African writing systems. 19. Obviously an adaptation of the Ek term ekpe to Hispanic phonology. 20. See e.g. Ortiz (1952-55, IV: 1-85, V: 203-261), 1981), Cabrera (1969), Sosa Rodriguez (1982), Thompson (1983), Ottenberg and Knudsen (1985) and Nicklin (1991). The one aspect that has most consistently worried investigators interpreting abaku along such
JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 306
4/19/07 2:40:58 PM
307
lines are some strangely inconsistent permutations in the central mythological charter of abaku and its ritual reenactment. African versions of ekpe ritual seem to center around the idea of accessing outside forces associated with the leopards voice produced by sounding an esoteric friction drum (see, e.g., Talbot 1912, chapter 4, Simmons 1956: 16 ., Ruel 1969: 246 ., Thompson 1974: 182 ., Leib and Romano 1984, Ottenberg and Knudsen 1985, Nicklin 1991). In Cuba, however, we nd an elaborate mythology centering on the capture by a woman named Sikn of a sacred sh which produces the mysterious voice. Having heard the voice of the mystery, Sikn is subsequently put to death and a friction drum (ecu ) is constructed from her (and/or a goats) skin and that of the sh. This drum is held to objectify the secret power, and its sound is instrumental to attracting and coercing the forces or beings personied by the reme dancers (see Ortiz 1950, Cabrera 1969 and Sosa Rodriguez 1982, chapters 6 and 9). The conspicuous absence of leopard imagery in abaku, and the apparent substitution of the prime African royal animal by a sh has given rise to considerable, and usually quite strained, speculation. See Thompson (1983: 241 .) and Sosa Rodriguez (1982: 289 .) for hypotheses about how the leopard turned into a sh, or whether there may be a (male) symbolic leopard hidden in the (female) sh. The problem is compounded by the fact that (excepting an even more incongruous myth recorded by Talbot (1912: 46 .) we do not know the mythological background to the African institution (if a single such mythology exists at all). 21. Since the early 1990s, Mintz and Prices formulation has come under harsh criticism, mainly by Africanist historians who argue (incorrectly) that Mintz and Price simply ruled out the signicance of Africa for New World history and culture. The most prominent exponents of this Neo-Herskovitsian new revisionism in African-American cultural history, John Thornton (1992) and Paul Lovejoy, not only insist on writing African history forward into the Diaspora (e.g., Lovejoy 1997), but on what Lovejoy (2000) has recently, and quite confusingly, called an Afro-centric approach to African-American history. For a powerfully argued theoretical critique see Scott (1999), for an ethnographically focused one see Palmi (2006a). 22. See, e.g., Thornton (1992), Midlo Hall (1992), Lovejoy (1994, 1997, 2000), Chambers (1997, 2000) and the criticism by Palmi (1993, 1994), Morgan (1997), Eltis and Richardson (1997), Caron (1997) and Northrup (2000). 23. While an Ijaw-group in the Rio Real area today identies with the ethnonym Kalabari, its use in the Cross River region was and still is restricted to topography. 24. Ortiz (1975: 44) notes the documented presence in Havana since 1568 of slaves designated as bras (Brass) whom he (given the then current terminology probably correctly) identied as carabales. 25. The evidence most usually cited is a piece of Royal African Company correspondence published by Elizabeth Donnan (1930-35, I: 93). There it was said that many ships are sent to New and Old Calabar for slaves and teeth, which are there to be had in plenty. In other words: dierent from the overall pattern in the eighteenth century, it seems as if the regions export economy was still mixed instead of wholly slave-based. On the other hand, in 1678 Barbot recorded the presence in Old Calabar of an English vessel with 300 slaves and gave a detailled account of the trade modalities in 1698 (Ardener 1970: 109). Nevertheless, the most recent treatment of the issue concurs that the trade at Old Calabar remained relatively small until Bristol ships became active in the slave trade early in the [eighteenth] century (Lovejoy and Richardson 1999: 338). 26. Conceding the limited value of data from which to compute possible numbers of slaves exported from this region, Latham (1973: 22 f.) estimates the total exports for
JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 307
4/19/07 2:40:58 PM
308
the period between 1710 and 1810 as lying somewhere between 133,600 and 250,000. Drawing upon the Harvard Slave Trade Database, Lovejoy and Richardson (1999: 337) present vastly higher gures (over one million) for the slave exports from the Bight of Biafra in the period between 1701 and 1810, but fail to disaggregate Old Calabar exports from the overall regional picture. 27. Palmer (1981: 106) cites the (ocial) gure of 6,387 slave imports into Havana (the port ocially privileged for international trade) in the period between 1715 and 1738. Given the chronic lack of capital in Cuba prior to the Bourbonic reforms (cf. Le Riverend 1974: 73 .), the contraband trade is not likely to have hiked the total gure up to more than double this number. 28. By mid-century we nd an ocial of the Real Compaa de Comercio of Havana complaining that the English kept the best slaves for their own islands while only selling those pertaining to such unwanted, useless or dangerous nations as congo and carabal (Marrero 1972-78, VI: 36). Assuming this complaint to be based on some measure of fact, one might surmise that the massive slave imports the English undertook during their short, but economically crucial, occupation of Havana in 1763 might have derived from similar sources. 29. This list seems especially valuable, since bishop Morell claimed to have recorded only those cabildos he had personally visited in order to inquire about their conformity to Christian standards. Judging from the (for him devastating) results of his inquiry, we may presume that he, indeed, had rst-hand knowledge of these associations. 30. In other words, one might say that such New World African identities as those marked by the autonomous use of terms like carabal had undergone (and necessarily so) a process of creolization (in the historical sense of becoming peculiar to the New World despite Old World origins) even before they could be passed on to people who were creoles by birth. At the same time, these New World carabal represented not one, but several intentional communities whichalthough dierentiating among themselvescollectively set themselves apart from such generic collectivities as congos, arars, mandingas, etc., whose dierent cabildos also appear on Morells list. 31. One could argue that the name itself already indicates the origin of this association from a deliberate fusion of ethnically heterogeneous African personnel into a new, and essentially Cuban, social entity. Considerable caution is warranted in the use of onomastics for historical reconstruction. Yet the following conclusions do not seem entirely implausible: ef may be taken as a reference to Ek, and apapa as either a corruption of the indigenous name of Duke Town (Atakpa) or of the Qua group (Ejagham-Ekoi) settled in its vicinity whom the Ek called Abakpa (Goldie 1964: 353, Baikie 1966: 351). Bricamo might conceivably be interpreted as relating to Mbarakom, a name pointing to a part of the Cameroon grasslands close to a trade route from Old Calabar to Mamfe (Jones 1984, III: 503). Baikie (1966: 351) thus writes that [p]eople from a tribe named Mbrkim come to Ek occasionally to trade. They pass through the Kw country, and the journey from their own land . . . occupies from two to three months. Hutchinson (1856: 138) states that the Mbrikum or Mbudikum race . . . are [sic] located between Kalabar and Cameroons, and comprises many tribes. Listing some of these, he mentions a people or country, or both, far on the other side of Qua (i.e., S.E. of Duketown) called Mbafum, some of whom are brought occasionally as slaves to Old Kalabar. . . . They are by some persons styled Mbafong, or Ekoi (ibid.). But Mbarakom also seems to have been used in reference to the Ambo lineage of Creek Town (Ikot Itunko) in the nineteenth century (Ardener 1970: 110, Nair 1972: 79). Ardener (ibid.) surmisesnot at all improbablythat the Ambo, though obviously thoroughly Ecized by the nineteenth century, might have originiated in the Cam-
JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 308
4/19/07 2:40:59 PM
309
eroons. Reglas nineteenth-century community of carabal bricam apapa ef thus, might have consisted of a) Ek or Ecized Ejagham from Duke town and its vicinity, and/or b) members of the Ambo ward/lineage of Creek town, and/or c) originally Bantu-speaking, but perhaps bilingual people from the Cameroons who accepted the Ek designation mbarakom and/or d) entirely dierent people who took over such an identity because of perceived advantages in a New World environment. But does that really tell us anything about the provenience of the actual cultural forms that might have integrated such a community? And why would the founders of abaku choose to use yet another African toponymObutong (i.e., the name of the Ek settlement known to Europeans as Old Town)in naming the rst Cuban potencia Ek Butn? Could this have been the place/ port of origin of the mysterious Belenistas? (cf. Sosa Rodrigues 1982: 50-54 for a similar problem concerning a carabal cabildo named isuama isieque de oro which Sosa qualies as a multi-tribal association). 32. African accounts of the origin of ekpe/ngbe among specic regional populations are usually phrased in an idiom of economic transaction: the coming of the leopards voice and the secret of its temporal domestication revolved around payment. While Cuban traditions center around the theme of encountering and tapping mystical forces that reveal themselves to man, with the exception of a myth published by Talbot (1912: 46 .) no traditions of sacred origin seem to have been recorded in Africa. 33. Members of abaku locate the rst revelation of the secret to mankind in a place called Usagar (cf. Ortiz [1952-55, V: 242]). Ortiz surmisesquite plausiblythat it relates to the locality Goldie (1964: 361) called Usahadet, Bakasy (i.e., Usak Edet) and described as a tribe and district on the east side of the estuary of the Calabar river. It is divided into two districts, Bakasy and Qu Bakasy. The country has connected itself with Calabar as a dependence, and dn, v., rn, Amotung and Efut-Iwa are towns where the Calabar people procure canoes, oil, and sh (ibid.). Nicklin (1991, and personal communication) thinks he discovered the location referred to in Afro-Cuban mythology as Usagar among Oroko-speaking people in the vicinity of Isangale (on the Cameroon side of the present international border). Nicklins informants in Isangale refer to themselves as Balondo, and claim to have sold the secret to a group of Ek from Duke Town (Atakpa). Upon less than clear evidence, Lovejoy and Richardson (1999) assert that ekpe initially was controlled by the Old Town (Obutong) ward, became increasingly contested with the founding of Duke Town after about 1748, and eventually passed there after the massacre of 1767 when Duke Town merchants attacked Old Town with the help of British ship captains, killing hundreds of its residents, and selling many of them (including members of the ruling elite) into slavery. An interesting suggestion for reconciling divergences in Cuban and African traditions about the source from which the Ek may have derived ekpe is ventured by Leib and Romano (1984: 94 n. 8). 34. Contemporary members of abaku with whom I worked in Regla are aware that there existed deities who were worshipped in tierra de ef y ef (the land of ef and efthe two main groups guring in the origin myth) before the sacred sh tanze reveled the secret of ecues voice to mankind. 35. Thus, far from being a mere reaction to the inclusion of a few villages of immigrants on the banks of the Cross River in the emergent capitalist world system, ekpe itself must be credited with creating the conditions crucial to the transformation of Old Calabar into a machine for the production of human commodities for transatlantic consumption. By about 1760 the so-called trust-system had become established as the principal modality of commercial interaction between the supercargoes of slave ships and their Ek suppliers.
JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 309
4/19/07 2:40:59 PM
310
Credit in the form of trade goods would be advanced to the African merchants, who then organized up-river slaving expeditions, orwith the increasing growth of a hinterland trade networkdispatched agents to collect the human merchandise in the respective supplying areas (Holman 1840: 393, 396, Jones 1956: 142 ., Northup 1978: 36-38, 114145, Lovejoy and Richardson 1999). This systemnoteworthy for both the extent of its operations and the enormous commercial value of the goods advancedhinged upon the universally recognized authority of ekpe to invoke its sanctions against those who defaulted on their debts. It was this power to insist on the repayment of credit, Latham (1973: 38 f.) notes, which lay behind the spread of Ekpe societies among the other peoples further inland up the Cross river, for by adopting Ekpe they made themselves credit-worthy in the eyes of the Ek, and therefore could avail themselves of Ek credit. In addition, as Ruel (1969: 250) maintains, the adoption of ekpe by hinterland trading societies not only added the prestige of association with the powerful merchant houses of Old Calabar, but served to insure the safety and commercial interests of their own traders, moving as they were through areas controlled by small autonomus groups who might waylay a stranger unless bound by mutual ties to the jurisdiction of ekpe. 36. In the early nineteenth century ekpe had reached Arochukwu. From there it spread not only to the proliferating Aro colonies and their Igbo host populations, but also to the Annang and northern Ibibio areas as far as the Ohaa/Abam region in the east and Isuama in the west. At about the same time, it returned to the Ejagham, Ekoi and other southeastern semi-Bantu in considerably modied form and replaced its indigenous precursor, ngbe (Ruel 1969: 250, Noah 1980, Ottenberg and Knudson 1985, Nicklin 1991). Farther northward on the east side of the middle Cross river, ekpe ourished among the Ekuri, Ododop, Akunakuna, Yak and Mbembe, and towards the end of the nineteenth century it reached the Lower Banyang (Ruel 1969: 217 f.), continuing along the trade route from Old Calabar to Mamfe and the escarpment. There it was acquired by the Bangwa in the 1930s or 1940s. They, in turn, carried it into the Grasselds where the Bamileke and Mambila eventually purchased what, by then, were considerably modied versions clearly deriving from more than a single source. For a sophisticated ethnographically based account of the diusionary dynamics of ekpe/ngbe see Rschenthaler (2006). 37. By 1859, the German traveller Adolf Bastian (1859: 294) similarly observed that captains of slave ships found it advantageous to join ekpe in order to pursue theirby then illegalbusiness. Latham (1973: 80) lists the names of ve commanders of British commercial vessels who underwent initiation into this truly cosmopolitan association between 1874 and 1880. And the German colonial administrator Mansfeld (1908: 160) likewise recounts that his joining a Banyang chapter of ekpe proved mutually benecial. Mansfeld thought the possibility of having colonial decrees promulgated and enacted through ekpe would eliminate native resistance. But it seems clear that the Banyang elders who initiated him had their own thoughts upon the matter: when they announced their decision to admit Mansfeld, they demanded that the association be extended to the seven other social units within the district Mansfeld administered, thereby pressing the German colonial state in the service of the extension of ekpes sphere of operation (ibid.). 38. Cabreras (1969: 63-76) Cuban informants were obviously aware of this fact, for they distinguished between carabal groups who came to Cuba with and without prior possession of a version of ecu. 39. What complicates matters is that, since the growth of an ekpe/ngbe polity must be presumed to have largely paralleled the transatlantic diusion of ekpe-related knowledge,
JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 310
4/19/07 2:40:59 PM
311
the later such exports occurred, the higher not only the number of potential exporting local units became, but also the possibility of fusion of exports from dierent locales. 40. Holman (1840: 396) describes the Dukes method of obtaining slaves on trust from European slavers as follows: He . . . sends his agents into the country with the goods to purchase slaves, promising the Captains their cargoes, amounting to any given number, within a stated time; in the meanwhile he employs other persons to collect in his own town and neighborhood, and if he is very hard pressed, (for the Captains of slavers are always very impatient), he obliges his great men to furnish him with a certain number each. This is done by sending him every individual from the neighboring villages, who have committed any crime or misdemeanor; and should he still continue unable to make up the specied demand, they sell their own servants to him. See Jereys (1954) and Northrup (1978: 65-80) for an overview of modes of slave procuring. 41. Here it is apposite to call attention to a detail that has gone largely unnoticed in the scholarly accounts of the rise of abaku. Abaku seems to have occupied the Cuban authorities ever since that day in July 1839 when Blanco and several of his associatesa group composed of young free creole working menhad been arrested. One of the reasons for their heightened concern was the realization that the grouping, whose head and treasurer Blanco claimed to have been, represented an essentially novel form of association. This is remarkable, for as in other parts of Spanish America, voluntary association of Africans the cabildos de nacinwere a part of institutional social life in urban Cuba. Since at least the seventeenth century such cabildos had been condoned as a means to solve the administrative problems created by the urban masses of free blacks and intractable slaves by allowing them to organize into ethnically dierentiated corporations chartered by, and answerable to, the local government. Blancos group, however, was a dierent matter. As the governmental functionaries involved in their case put it, what set them apart from such traditional associations was these young creoles apparently tried to imitate the manners and customs of the Africans (Deschamps Chapeaux 1964: 101). Despite the Cuban authorities consistent eorts to drive a wedge between the African and creole segments of the black population, what they seemed to be facing was a creole group that had chosen to integrate itself by adopting an ostensibly African organizational model. 42. Ortiz never seems to have seen t to theoretically elaborate this important insight, choosing to analogize abaku-ritual to ancient Greek mystery religions instead (e.g., Ortiz 1981: 486-523). Nevertheless, it may be quite indicative of a lack of institutional memory in the social sciences that the current History and Memory vogue has largely bypassed Roger Bastides (1978 [1960]) highly original, though by no means unproblematic attempt to harness Maurice Halbwachss (1942) theories about sites of sacred memory to an African-American case (cf. Capone, forthcoming). 43. Thriving on European credit of truly fantastic proportions, these native merchant princes regularly entertained the captains of trading vessels in their English housestwostory wooden, or even cast iron constructions mail-ordered from Liverpoolwhere they served meals accompanied by a choice of native palm wine and reportedly excellent champagne (Holman 1840: 362, 364, Waddell 1863: 243 f.). Crows description of the interior of Duke Ephraims iron palace gives a vivid impression of the setting in which such Atlantic encounters would take place: This house or palace is stocked with numerous clocks, watches,
JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 311
4/19/07 2:40:59 PM
312
and other articles of mechanism, sofas, tables, pictures, beds, porcelain cabinets &c. of European manufacture; most of which are huddled together, in confusion, amongst numerous fetiches, and in a state of decay, from disuse, carelessness, and want of cleaning (Crow 1830 in Simmons 1956a: 9). Several of the notables Hope Waddell encountered in the 1850s including King Eyo Honesty IIhad not only been to sea, but had travelled to England and the Caribbean as well (Nair 1977: 246 f.). Just as Bonnys Bill Peppel was fond of inquiring about his brother George (meaning the king of England) when in the company of Europeans (Adams 1966: 135), we nd Duke Ephraim of Old Calabar expressing great regret at not being able to read the newspapers [since they were not handwritten], of the contents of which, although he had seen many, he still remained ignorant. (Holman 1840: 399). A few decades later, one of his successors who signed his letters as Eyamba V., King of all black men would express to consul Hutchinson his desire to see Wellington and Napoleon, that he might show his pre-eminence over them (Hutchinson 1856: 118). Yet at the same time, and in good keeping with the European stereotype of the savagery of African rulers, these sophisticated river gentlemen casually engaged in outdoing each other in massacring scores of slaves in the course of funeral ceremonies, and periodically decimated their own ranks by a poison ordeal in order to stem the tide of witchcraft felt to be rising in their midst. 44. Cf. Cabrera (1969, 1983: 209, 286), Ortiz (1950), Sosa Rodrguez (1982: 189250). In fact, given that the Cuban government has lifted its restriction of party membership for religious practitioners in 1991, today individuals socially classied as militante comunistas canand doritually embody ancestral African presences. 45. Economic growth did not occur in an even, linear fashion, but was punctuated by the crises in international trade caused by, e.g., the Napoleonic wars, the British-American war of 1812-1815, or the Latin American wars of independence, as well as by periodic price depressions on the sugar market. Yet although aggregate data must, accordingly, be viewed as problematic, they do evidence a truly phenomenal pattern of absolute growth. In the period between 1800 and 1827 the amount of sugar exported through Havanas harbor doubled (Le Riverend 1974: 196). Between 1830 and 1864 Cuban sugar production evidenced an increase of 400%. In the same period the average value of total Cuban imports rose from 16.3 to 44.3 million pesos, while that of Cuban exports increased from 13.2 to 57 million pesos (Knight 1970: 44). In 1852 the value of imports unloaded in Havana alone had reached the startling gure of 22.1 million pesos (Knight 1977: 247). That year Havanas harbor registered 1,594 incoming and 1,140 outgoing commercial vessels, accounting for 44% and 34.8% of all Cuban seaborne trade (Knight 1977: 245 f.). Knight (1977) and Thomas (1971: 136-167) give a vivid impression of the careers of a new entrepreneurial class and the ostentatious consumption patterns developed by the rising planter and merchant segment. 46. Out of those 112,023 inhabitants cited by Deschamps Chapeaux (ibid.) merely 46,621 were counted as white. 47. Up until 1829, when the new Codigo Comercial went into eect, the outlets for both imported and locally produced consumer goods (pulperas) had been subject to highly restrictive legal reglementation (Le Riverend 1974: 222 .). Given the notorious corruption of the Cuban colonial authorities (cf. Knight 1970: 102 .), however, smuggling and other sorts of illicit trade ourished. It is quite probable that the black market the very restrictions imposed by Spain had helped to create provided an important distributive economic niche for small-scale traders fencing contraband goods, and the ubiquitous itinerant vendors whose supply undoubtedly derived from both legitimate and illegal sources. Although I am, in the following, mainly concerned with this economy of subversion, it
JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 312
4/19/07 2:40:59 PM
313
should not be forgotten that free Afro-Cubans also monopolized a wide variety of licit trades and, in fact, formed what Deschamps Chapeaux aptly called a pequea burguesa de color (cf. Deschamps Chapeaux 1971 and Klein 1967: 202-227). 48. By 1763 a set of orders issued by the Conde de Ricla had given rise to a peculiar form of organizing dockside labor. By assigning control over longshore labor gangs (cuadrillas) to former members of the batalliones de pardos y morenos leales (black militia), these orders opened up a new career path for enterprising Afro-Cubans; and with the advent of free trade, the black capataces del muellesome of whom occupied their prestigious positions for several decades (Deschamps Chapeaux 1971: 90 .)began to reap the prots their position as brokers between Atlantic buyers and local sellers of manpower promised. Like other Afro-Cubans who, in the rst half of the nineteenth century, monopolized numerous lucrative trades shunned by those white creoles who could aord to dissociate themselves from the stigma of manual labor, these dockyard captains sometimes amassed considerable fortunes: Jos Ooro, e.g., a born African who continued to identify himself as a carabal, was able to sign over four houses and eight coartados (i.e., slaves towards whose freedom he had willed parts of his estate) to his heirs (Deschamps Chapeaux 1971: 94). Yet men like Ooro not only stand as vivid exceptions to the general assumption about the marginal position of free blacks in the slave societies of the Americas. Their careers also give us a clue as to why this expanding maritime world of seamen, dockyard workers, porters, hucksters, tavern keepers, entertainers, prostitutes, petty criminals, entrepreneurs and self-styled organizers of the appropriation of Afro-Cuban labor by increasingly international trading companies might have given rise to abaku. 49. Deschamps Chapeaux (1971: 93 .) lists several cases of fortunes acquired by capataces del muelle. At least one of them, Jos Agustn Ceballos, surpassed all that Jos Ooro could have dreamed of: by 1833, Ceballos employed 160 dockworkers whose collective wages ran up to 1,000 pesos per week. Calculating the income Ceballos received from renting out several houses, his dockyard business and the prots he received from hiring out his slaves, Deschamps Chapeaux (1971: 100) estimates that, at the height of his career, Ceballos may have earned as much as 10,000 pesos a year. 50. Comparing the modern Banyang situation with the historical record on Old Calabar at the middle of the nineteenth century, Ruel (1969: 256) writes: Each lodge [of ekpe/ngbe] has separate access to its own formal Ngbe sanctions; in accord with the basic political principle of autonomous rule, these sanctions can be applied only within the residential group associated with the lodge, or with the agreement of that groups representatives; if the representatives of a number of residential groups (usually hamlets of a village, but it may be villages of village group, and it can be a wide series of ad hoc groupings) agree to common political action (usually the enactment of a law), such action can still be promulgated through Ngbe, despite the fact that dierent lodges are involved. Some of this clearly holds true for Cuba as well. The written reglements of Akanarn Ef published by Prez Beato (El Curioso Americano vol. 1.3, 35-38, vol. 1.4, 56-58; partly reprinted in Sosa Rodrguez [1982: 381-390]) give a vivid impression of the complex forensic apparatus that existed within this potencia in 1882, and the sanctioning power it arrogated for itself. Upon receipt of complaints about a members behavior, ritual hearings would be held in front of the highest ranking title holders in order to establish the truth of the accusation and determine the gravity of the oense. According to the verdict of the
JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 313
4/19/07 2:41:00 PM
314
jefatura, the accused could be ned, or subjected to corporal punishment meted out by an reme personifying a force of retributive justice. In cases of grave oences, he could be temporarily or permanently suspended from membership, or even sentenced to muerte en vida, in which case the potencia performed funeral rites signaling the oenders social death. In the latter cases, the potencia involved would send messagesoften in the form of written notices (known today as ocios)to other chapters of abaku obliging them to respect the sanctions it had passed, in a manner much reminiscent of nineteenth-century descriptions of how the pronouncement of ekpe sanctions by one local chapter in the lower Cross River region bound other chapters to mutual enforcement. Whether or not abaku really killed capital oenders (as has been alleged), it could eectively wreck a persons life by ordering the culprit to be economically ostracized and socially isolated not only from the rest of his neighborhood, but from other barrios as well. 51. Six years after the ocial prohibition, Rodriguez Aras cited the names of 83 potencias still in existence in 1881 (ANC Asuntos Polticos leg. 76 # 56). 52. If the (highly clientelistic) organization of labor at Havanas centralized market (in existence since 1921see Borroto Mora [1966]) is any guide to the situations obtaining prior to that, abaku would have found a fertile eld among the hundreds, perhaps thousands, of cartmen, porters, tarimeros (stall-holders), macheteros (vendors of rotting goods), and watchmen trying to earn a living there, often on a day-to-day basis. 53. An elaborate code of foreign relations is evident in the reglamentos of Akanarn Ef published by Prez Beato (reprinted in Sosa Rodrguez [1982: 381-392]). Cabrera (1975) explicitly mentions rituals of crossing itones (i.e., the sacred batons of the four principal titleholders) by which rival potencias concluded peaceful agreements. But there were other mechanisms: in cases where potencias branched out through sale of secrets and sponsorship of daughter cellswhose relation were sometimes expressed by adding quantiers like taiba (or segundo), eroba (or tercero) etc. to the name of the junior potenciasuch lines of kinship frequently seem to have crossed the established territorial (and, perhaps also, economic) boundaries of single barrios. This, indeed (rather than merely the mythological charter of an initial sale of the secret across a body of water) may have been one reason why the Belenistas journeyed to Regla in 1836. 54. As Ortiz estimated in 1927 (FO uncatalogued folder entited Negros-Cabildos), Enlleguell (with some 400 members) was clearly the largest potencia in the eastern bay, surpassed only by Marianaos potencias Usagar and Focondo Ndibo (about 500 members each), and the powerful Betongo, based in Pueblo Nuevo (and therefore probably targetting Havanas inner-city tobacco industry as well as the harborside) which, by then, had become Havanas largest potencia, boasting around a thousand members. 55. This is speculation, but it seems reasonable to assume that rank and le members rose to positions of prominence not only because of their good standing within a chapter of the association, or their command of ritual particulars, but not the least on account of their economic position (whether in terms of personal liquidity or occupation of key positions within certain enterprises). 56. Cabrera (1969: plate facing page 26) reproduces a photograph of Petit which is nowadays found in the cult houses of several ef potencias in Havana and Regla. 57. Makra is the Ek designation for Europeans (cf. Waddell 1863: 253, 256). It is this potencia which served as the proximate source for all potencias of the rama ef existing in Regla today (cf. Palmi 2006a). 58. The practice of emancipation through gradual compensation of the owner for a slaves commercial value (coartacin) had been institutionalized in Cuba since early on
JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 314
4/19/07 2:41:00 PM
315
(Aimes 1906). In that way, many gainfully employed urban slaves bought their freedom, but the cabildos are also known to have collected money for buying the freedom of their members. To this end they often engaged in the widespread informal lottery systems (see Bremer 1968: 339 for a contemporary report on such practices). That abaku potencias may have used the revenues from the sale of esoteric knowledge and cult agencies in a similar manner is very likely. Since free blacks were legally entitled to own slaves themselves (cf. Deschamps Chapeaux 1971: 47-57 and passim), we might, however, speculate about whether the slaves bought by a given potencia were free in any other than a mere legal sense. Could it be that although they were coartados in the eyes of the law, the respective potencia or some of its individual members had rights to their person and/or services that simply went unrecognized by the Cuban authorities? Access to the papersdeeds, wills etc. of known title holders of abaku might help to solve this question. 59. Ortiz reports that two members of Bakok Ef were killed by rival black potencias in revenge for Petits treason. Some versions of oral tradition maintain that the demise of Bakok Efo, after a police raid in the course of which their sacred drums were conscated, was the result of divine vengeance (Ortiz 1952-55, IV: 69). 60. As an octogenarian informant of Ortiz (1952-55, VI: 70) put it: thanks to Petit, the igos continue to persist in Cuba (Gracias a Petit, siguen en Cuba los igos). Ortiz qualies this statement as follows: This belief is exaggerated, for the endurance of these religions is due to complex causes and not the talents of a single personage; yet the reforms Petit introduced into igoismo and mayombera [Petit also was a priest of a BantuCuban religion] denitively linked the Africans with the creoles, and the blacks with the mulattoes and the whites (ibid.). 61. Oral history has it that the rst white ocobios (members of abaku) subsequently participated in the struggle against Spanish domination which would, in 1868, lead to the rst Cuban war of independence. Though adequate documentation about this event has still to be uncovered, it is likely that members of abaku were involved in attempting to rescue the famous habanero medical students from the fusillade following their protest against Spanish domination in 1871 (cf. Dvila Nodarse 1981: 23 who cites documents corroborating this event, but provides only incomplete archival references). 62. See the lists of deportees in Archivo Histrico Nacional de Espaa, Ministerio de Gobernacin leg. 597 # 2-4, and Ultramr leg. 5007 # 832. On Ceuta as a destination for Cuban deportees during the wars of independence compare Serrano (1985). Other destinations for supposed members of abaku included presidios in Cadiz, Santander and Chafarinas (which tends to be remembered most by contemporary ocobios in Regla). 63. By the 1920s, the populist Liberal government of Regla headed by Dr Antonio Bosch not only erected the rst monument to labor in the Americas, and dedicated a public park to the memory of Lenin, but also printed election placards in the ritual language of abaku. Chuchu Capaz eventually came to serve on Reglas city council until the fall of the Machado dictatorship forced him out of oce in 1933. 64. David Scotts phrase an obscure miracle of connection derives precisely from the context of Edward Kamau Brathwaites poetic distillation of a history of tragic displacement from the winter winds that envelop West Africa in clouds of Saharan dust, and once heralded not just the advent of dry weather, but the impending arrival of slave ships in the Caribbean. 65. But see Tomich (2004) for a cogently argued attempt to salvage some of their insights.
JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 315
4/19/07 2:41:00 PM
JRA 37,2_f7_316-323.indd 316
4/19/07 2:41:19 PM

Ecués Atlantic An Essay

Enviado por

Dados do documento

Descrição original:

Título original

Direitos autorais

Formatos disponíveis

Compartilhar este documento

Compartilhar ou incorporar documento

Opções de compartilhamento

Você considera este documento útil?

Este conteúdo é inapropriado?

Direitos autorais:

Formatos disponíveis

Ecués Atlantic An Essay

Enviado por

Direitos autorais:

Formatos disponíveis

Journal of Religion in Africa 37 (2007) 275-315

Ecu s Atlantic: An Essay in Methodology

JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 275

S. Palmi / Journal of Religion in Africa 37 (2007) 275-315

JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 276

S. Palmi / Journal of Religion in Africa 37 (2007) 275-315

JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 277

S. Palmi / Journal of Religion in Africa 37 (2007) 275-315

JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 278

S. Palmi / Journal of Religion in Africa 37 (2007) 275-315

JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 279

S. Palmi / Journal of Religion in Africa 37 (2007) 275-315

JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 280

S. Palmi / Journal of Religion in Africa 37 (2007) 275-315

JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 281

S. Palmi / Journal of Religion in Africa 37 (2007) 275-315

JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 282

S. Palmi / Journal of Religion in Africa 37 (2007) 275-315

JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 283

S. Palmi / Journal of Religion in Africa 37 (2007) 275-315

JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 284

S. Palmi / Journal of Religion in Africa 37 (2007) 275-315

JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 285

S. Palmi / Journal of Religion in Africa 37 (2007) 275-315

JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 286

S. Palmi / Journal of Religion in Africa 37 (2007) 275-315

JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 287

S. Palmi / Journal of Religion in Africa 37 (2007) 275-315

JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 288

S. Palmi / Journal of Religion in Africa 37 (2007) 275-315

JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 289

S. Palmi / Journal of Religion in Africa 37 (2007) 275-315

JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 290

S. Palmi / Journal of Religion in Africa 37 (2007) 275-315

JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 291

S. Palmi / Journal of Religion in Africa 37 (2007) 275-315

JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 292

S. Palmi / Journal of Religion in Africa 37 (2007) 275-315

JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 293

S. Palmi / Journal of Religion in Africa 37 (2007) 275-315

JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 294

S. Palmi / Journal of Religion in Africa 37 (2007) 275-315

JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 295

S. Palmi / Journal of Religion in Africa 37 (2007) 275-315

JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 296

S. Palmi / Journal of Religion in Africa 37 (2007) 275-315

JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 297

S. Palmi / Journal of Religion in Africa 37 (2007) 275-315

JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 298

S. Palmi / Journal of Religion in Africa 37 (2007) 275-315

JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 299

S. Palmi / Journal of Religion in Africa 37 (2007) 275-315

JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 300

S. Palmi / Journal of Religion in Africa 37 (2007) 275-315

JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 301

S. Palmi / Journal of Religion in Africa 37 (2007) 275-315

JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 302

S. Palmi / Journal of Religion in Africa 37 (2007) 275-315

JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 303

S. Palmi / Journal of Religion in Africa 37 (2007) 275-315

JRA 37,2_f6_275-315.indd 304

S. Palmi / Journal of Religion in Africa 37 (2007) 275-315