id 1 2 3 4 6 8 9 10 11 13 14 15 17 18 19 20 22 24 25 27 28 29 30 31 32 33

Completed Last page 2014-02-26 19:27:225 2014-02-27 15:20:235 2014-02-26 21:13:505 2014-02-26 21:42:125 2014-02-26 21:35:145 2014-02-26 22:11:075 2014-02-26 22:45:565 3 1 1 2014-02-27 01:35:155 2014-02-27 02:55:435 2014-02-27 10:22:025 3 2014-02-27 13:03:155 2014-02-27 15:01:335 3 2014-02-27 18:52:545 1 2014-02-27 23:54:005 2014-02-28 11:49:265 1 2014-02-28 14:26:105 3 1 1

Start language Date started Date last action How old are How you-often do When you listen do you tolisten musicto music the m en 2014-02-262014-02-26 19:08:26 19:27:22 20 Everyday Alone en 2014-02-262014-02-27 20:27:33 15:20:23 22 Everyday on my ipod when walking en 2014-02-262014-02-26 20:27:53 21:13:50 21 Everyday Alone in room or walking somewhe en 2014-02-262014-02-26 20:54:35 21:42:12 53 Everyday whilst running and driving en 2014-02-262014-02-26 21:22:46 21:35:14 21 Everyday While travelling en 2014-02-262014-02-26 22:03:09 22:11:07 55 Everyday gym en 2014-02-262014-02-26 22:13:03 22:45:56 19 Everyday At home on my laptop en 2014-02-262014-02-26 22:15:53 23:06:22 52 Everyday car/running en 2014-02-262014-02-26 22:41:15 22:45:27 42 One day of Cooking a week en 2014-02-262014-02-27 23:51:32 00:04:32 40 Everyday in the gym, with friends, live music, en 2014-02-272014-02-27 00:03:42 01:35:15 21 Everyday Alone at home, with friends, walkin en 2014-02-272014-02-27 02:28:45 02:55:43 22 Everyday alone (and next in line, with friends en 2014-02-272014-02-27 09:36:07 10:22:02 45 Everyday While working or in the car en 2014-02-272014-02-27 10:11:43 11:56:07 52 4-6 days a week alone in your room, en 2014-02-272014-02-27 10:48:26 13:03:15 20 Everyday jazz, funk, instrumental fusion en 2014-02-272014-02-27 14:40:41 15:01:33 39 2-3 days a week Social situations - pub, home en 2014-02-272014-02-27 17:16:17 19:26:31 60 Everyday alone at home and in car en 2014-02-272014-02-27 18:32:15 18:52:54 18 Everyday alone in my room en 2014-02-272014-02-27 19:35:35 19:40:17 20 Everyday alone and when at the gym en 2014-02-272014-02-27 22:10:51 23:54:00 22 Everyday All of the above! Mostly on my own en 2014-02-282014-02-28 11:03:13 11:49:26 22 Everyday Alone in my room, showering, also en 2014-02-282014-02-28 13:38:29 13:47:34 50 2-3 days a week Car journeys, in kitchen rather than en 2014-02-282014-02-28 13:51:19 14:26:10 50 2-3 days a week In car, on train, in kitchen rather tha en 2014-02-282014-02-28 14:59:14 15:13:16 49 Everyday In the Car en 2014-02-282014-02-28 18:38:50 18:41:17 31 Everyday when relaxing en 2014-02-282014-02-28 23:55:57 23:58:26 23 Everyday In the car

How do youHow listen often to music every Who, (ipod, 6 in months your radio, What, opinion, do youtube, in you your is go Who the opinion, to spotify, most see is/are atechnically is cd-player Do live your the you musical favourite best download etc.)talented musical Do performancemusical think music musician performance it is "artist(s)"Do immoral from think you peer it you've have for (Just is Is to immoral people the peer heardone witnessed man networksmusician to for (just playing download people live one or trumpet and please) to group music download who in of was from this musc it m c t spotify, cd, iPod More than 20 John times Coltrane every Pearl sixJam, months Hyde The Wytches park, No 2010 Undecided On one hand Yes, as he/she/they a musician you is/are spend performing. all your ipod 2-5 times every Eric Clapton six months Red Hot Chili Jeff Peppers Buckley Yes Undecided It is theft. However Yes, he/she/they I think artists is/are have performing. to move Ipod, youtube 5-10 times every Johnny six Greenwood months Radiohead Radiohead Live in Paris Yes 2003 Undecided Yes, he/she/they is/are performing. iphone and 5-10 radiotimes every Antonio sixForcione months Australian Pink Rolling Floyd Stone No Undecided Can you really Yes, own he/she/they music? is/are performing. iPod Once everyBig six Walter monthsHorton Black Keys Grandaddy Yes No If you own the Yes, CDs he/she/they but don't is/are have access performing. to th ipod Once everytony six months banks Genesis Live Genesis at Hammersmith Yes 1973 No The amount Yes, of music he/she/they available is/are now performing. increases mainly radio 15-20 and youtube timesstevie everyray six vaughan months Hoochie Coochie Vocalists Man, No by Buddy Guy, Undecided at Montreal Music should Yes, be he/she/they available to is/are everybody, performing. but m radio/iphone 5-10 times every antonio six forcione months willy and the rolling bandits stones No Undecided How can you Yes, own he/she/they a tune! is/are performing. iPod Less than once Morten every Harket six Madonna months (concert A-ha in Amsterdam) No Yes It is theft all artists deserve their royalties. ipod, Youtube, 2-5 cds, times vinyl every Dave and six Grohl radio. months Orbital (tohgh 2009 to stick The live to Smiths at one) Brixton No for musical Academy Yes instrument, (also tough Difficult. Orbital to stick for Music to electronic one) is expensive, :-/ over inflated, esp ipod/itunes 15-20 timesArt every Tatum six months Ravi Shankar Tom - Monterey Waits Yes Pop Festival No 1967 Only if the music Yes, he/she/they would not otherwise is/are performing. be purch ipod, radio and 2-5 times youtube every evelyn sixglennie months patti smith really don't have Yes a favourite, No depends I choose on situation which Yes,music etc. he/she/they I'm tolistening pay is/are for to performing. hurray for t radio, ipod, Less spotify than once Elton every Johnsix Eric months Clapton Etta JamesYes Undecided Yes, he/she/they is/are performing. radio, cd Less than once peter every gabriel six peter months gabriel Sting No Undecided Yes, he/she/they is/are performing. ipod, youtube, More soundcloud than 20 Beyonce times every Beyonce, six months ALL at the OFmoment.. THEM!! No ifJefferson I haveNo to mentiona Airplanebecause few of the it is I MANY:https://www.youtube.com/w don't the same knowas if this giving is a someone performance mus radio Less than once Paulevery SimonQueen six months at Live Pulp Aid No Undecided Yes, he/she/they is/are performing. radio/cd More than 20 yehudi times menuhin every Queen six months in concert bruce springstein No Undecided Yes, he/she/they is/are performing. phone, spotify Once and every youtube eminem six monthsBastille bon iver No Yes Because it means Yes, he/she/they there is less is/are money performing. in the m iphone and Once spotify everyIsix don't months really The notice xx, playing Mo KenneyNo live at the BrightonYes centre Means that the artists aren't getting paid for th iPod, Hi-Fi from 10-15 laptop times(although (iTunes every six mostly), technical months blimey.. soundcloud skill clich errrrrr.... is very but& maybe low other maybe Yes on streaming, Radiohead my Tom priorities Waits No occasionally at list) Reading maybe This Festival vinyl is Preston obviously in Yes, Reed? 2009 he/she/they a debate bigger is/are than performing. this box iPod, Radio15-20 (mainly times through Bjork every repeat six months Portishead podcasts of performing Currently, shows online), I at Yes might Glastonbury youtube, choose NoLittle soundcloud, festival Dragon in I don't summer record think2013 player. Yes, it is inherently he/she/they immoral is/are performing. to downloa ipod and radio I don't see live Ericmusic Clapton Rolling Stones Beatles at Wembley No 1992? Yes Need to support the music industry, they are a i-pod, radioI don't see live Ericmusic Clapton Rolling stones Beatles 1992 Wembley No Yes Music industry Yes, needs he/she/they to be supported is/are performing. Radio I don't see live I couldn't music say Sade if one is more Queen tech talented No than Undecided another Yes, he/she/they is/are performing. spotify 2-5 times every stevie six wonder months Tower of Power Tower of Power No Yes artists deserve to get paid for their work! Radio, cd, ipod 2-5 times every Jimmy sixhendrix months Lana del ray Lana del ray No Undecided

Are the DJ's In in this this clip clip is Is performingthis theDJ singer performingIs (http://www.youtube.com/watch-v=KOntC_oMh3c) in the this DJ clip in (http://www.youtube.com/watch-v=D7k1CSpg5tc) Are this performingthe clipsingers performingIn (http://www.youtube.com/watch-v=X4f_hG-AiiI) this in clip this (http://www.youtube.com/watch-v=vM1VRZRfH_8) is clip Which this performingDJ of performingthe Which following (http://www.youtube.com/watch-v=SjxSNo of the (http://www.youtube.com/watch-v=7f do Which following you of is important the dofollowing you is inimportant ado good youmusic is inim a Yes, he/she/they Yes, he/she/they is/are Yes, performing. he/she/they is/are Yes, performing. he/she/they is/are Yes, performing. he/she/they is/are Yes, performing. he/she/they is/areVery performing. Important is/are Very performing. Important Not Important Yes, he/she/they Yes, he/she/they is/are Yes, performing. he/she/they is/are Yes, performing. he/she/they is/are Yes, performing. he/she/they is/are Yes, performing. he/she/they is/areQuite performing. is/are Important Quite performing. Important Not Important Yes, he/she/they Yes, he/she/they is/are Yes, performing. he/she/they is/are Yes, performing. he/she/they is/are Yes, performing. he/she/they is/are Yes, performing. he/she/they is/areVery performing. Important is/are Very performing. Important Not Important Yes, he/she/they No, he/she/they is/are Yes, performing. is/are he/she/they not No,performing. he/she/they is/are Yes, performing. is/are he/she/they not Yes, performing. he/she/they is/areQuite performing. is/are Important Very performing. Important Quite Important I don't know Yes, if this he/she/they is a performance. Yes, he/she/they is/are Yes, performing. he/she/they is/are Yes, performing. he/she/they is/are Yes, performing. he/she/they is/areVery performing. Important is/are Quite performing. Important Quite Important No, he/she/they Yes, is/are he/she/they not Yes, performing. he/she/they is/are No, performing. he/she/they is/are Iperforming. don't is/are know not I if don't this performing. know is a performance. Very if this Important is a performance. Very Important Very Important Yes, he/she/they No, he/she/they is/are Yes, performing. is/are he/she/they not Yes, performing. he/she/they is/are Yes, performing. he/she/they is/are No, performing. he/she/they is/areQuite performing. is/are Important not Very performing. Important Not Important Yes, he/she/they No, he/she/they is/are Yes, performing. is/are he/she/they not No,performing. he/she/they is/are Yes, performing. is/are he/she/they not Yes, performing. he/she/they is/areQuite performing. is/are Important Very performing. Important Quite Important all artists deserve their royalties. Music is expensive, over inflated, especially for a virtual product, as opposed to a Cd. People can't afford it and it is sad that the artist get so li No, he/she/they Yes, is/are he/she/they not Yes, performing. he/she/they is/are No, performing. he/she/they is/are No, performing. he/she/they is/are not No,performing. he/she/they is/are not Quite performing. is/are Important not Very performing. Important Not Important Yes, he/she/they Yes, he/she/they is/are Yes, performing. he/she/they is/are Yes, performing. he/she/they is/are Yes, performing. he/she/they is/are Yes, performing. he/she/they is/areVery performing. Important is/are Very performing. Important Not Important Yes, he/she/they Yes, he/she/they is/are Yes, performing. he/she/they is/are Iperforming. don'tis/are know Iperforming. if don't this know is a performance. Yes, if this he/she/they is a performance. Very Important is/are Very performing. Important Quite Important Yes, he/she/they No, he/she/they is/are Yes, performing. is/are he/she/they not Yes, performing. he/she/they is/are Yes, performing. he/she/they is/are Yes, performing. he/she/they is/areVery performing. Important is/are Quite performing. Important Not Important Yes, he/she/they No, he/she/they is/are Yes, performing. is/are he/she/they not No,performing. he/she/they is/are Yes, performing. is/are he/she/they not Yes, performing. he/she/they is/areVery performing. Important is/are Very performing. Important Not Important Yes, he/she/they Yes, he/she/they is/are Partly performing. is/are performing, No, performing. he/she/they partly Yes, not is/are he/she/they performing. not No,performing. he/she/they is/areVery performing. is/are Important not Quite performing. Important Quite Important Yes, he/she/they No, he/she/they is/are Yes, performing. is/are he/she/they not Yes, performing. he/she/they is/are Iperforming. don'tis/are know Yes, performing. if this he/she/they is a performance. Very Important is/are Very performing. Important Quite Important Yes, he/she/they Yes, he/she/they is/are Yes, performing. he/she/they is/are Yes, performing. he/she/they is/are Yes, performing. he/she/they is/are Yes, performing. he/she/they is/areQuite performing. is/are Important Very performing. Important Not Important at the artists aren't getting paid for the work they do, and then that's annoying as gig tickets etc start going through the roof and music gets m Yes, he/she/they Yes, he/she/they is/are Yes, performing. he/she/they is/are Yes, performing. he/she/they is/are Yes, performing. he/she/they is/are Yes, performing. he/she/they is/areQuite performing. is/are Important Very performing. Important Not Important Yes, he/she/they Yes, he/she/they is/are Yes, performing. he/she/they is/are Yes, performing. he/she/they is/are Yes, performing. he/she/they is/are Yes, performing. he/she/they is/areQuite performing. is/are Important Quite performing. Important Quite Important upport the music industry, they are artits and professionals Yes, he/she/they No, he/she/they is/are Yes, performing. is/are he/she/they not No,performing. he/she/they is/are No, performing. he/she/they is/are not Yes, performing. is/are he/she/they not Quite performing. is/are Important Very performing. Important Quite Important No, he/she/they No, he/she/they is/are not Yes, performing. is/are he/she/they not No,performing. he/she/they is/are Yes, performing. is/are he/she/they not No,performing. he/she/they is/areVery performing. is/are Important not Quite performing. Important Very Important serve to get paid for their work!

Which of the Which following of the do Which following you of is important the do Which following you of is inimportant the ado Which good following youmusical of is inimportant the ado Which good following you performancemusical of is inimportant the ado How good following you performancefamiliar [Group musical is inimportant ado How good are participation] you performancefamiliar you [Audience musical is inimportant with aHow good are these performanceengagement] familiar you [Stage musical in musicians/bandswith a good presence] are these performanceyou [Playing musical musicians/ban with these accurate performa [The [Chan mu Be Very Important Very Important Quite Important Quite Important Quite Important Quite Important Highly familiar Highly with familiar their Know allwith ofthem their theirmusic quite all ofwell their but music not all of Not Important Very Important Not Important Quite Important Not Important Quite Important Fairly familiar Know withthem theirHave quite most heard well of their but them music not all butof don't their know music th Not Important Very Important Quite Important Quite Important Quite Important Quite Important Fairly familiar Know withthem theirHave quite most heard well of their but them music not all butof don't their know music th Very Important Very Important Very Important Quite Important Very Important Very Important Highly familiar Highly with familiar their Have allwith ofheard their theirmusic them all of but their don't music know th Quite Important Quite Important Very Important Quite Important Quite Important Quite Important Know them Know quite well them but Have quite notheard well all of but their them not music all butof don't their know music th Quite Important Quite Important Very Important Quite Important Quite Important Very Important Highly familiar Highly with familiar their Know allwith ofthem their theirmusic quite all ofwell their but music not all of Quite Important Not Important Quite Important Very Important Not Important Very Important Fairly familiar Fairly with familiar theirHave most with heard of their their most them music of but their don't music know th Quite Important Quite Important Very Important Quite Important Very Important Very Important

it and it is sad that the artist get so little from the money made. I understand why people do it but the artist gets nothing, so they suffer more Not Important Not Important Quite Important Quite Important Not Important Quite Important Fairly familiar Highly with familiar theirHave most with heard oftheir their them all music of but their don't music know th Not Important Very Important Quite Important Quite Important Quite Important Quite Important Fairly familiar Know withthem theirHave quite most heard well of their but them music not all butof don't their know music th Quite Important Very Important Quite Important Very Important Not Important Not Important Highly familiar Fairly with familiar their Know all with ofthem their their music quite most well of their but music not all of Not Important Quite Important Quite Important Not Important Quite Important Quite Important Quite Important Very Important Very Important Quite Important Quite Important Quite Important Fairly familiar Never with heard theirHave most of them heard of their them music but don't know th Not Important Quite Important Very Important Very Important Quite Important Quite Important Fairly familiar Know withthem theirKnow quite most well them of their but quite music not well all of but their notmusic all of Quite Important Very Important Very Important Quite Important Quite Important Very Important Quite Important Quite Important Quite Important Quite Important Quite Important Very Important Fairly familiar Have with heard theirHave most themheard of but their don't them music know but them don't know very we th ng through the roof and music gets more expensive. Quite Important Quite Important Quite Important Quite Important Not Important Very Important Know them Fairly quite well familiar but Fairly with not familiar all their of their most with music of their their most music of the Not Important Not Important Not Important Quite Important Not Important Not Important Fairly familiar Know withthem theirFairly quite most well familiar of their but music with not all their of their mostmusic of the Quite Important Very Important Very Important Quite Important Not Important Quite Important Highly familiar Fairly with familiar their Know all with ofthem their their music quite most well of their but music not all of Quite Important Quite Important Very Important Very Important Not Important Quite Important

How familiar How are familiar you with How are these familiar youmusicians/bandswith Please are these you listen musicians/bandswith Please to these [Dragonforce] thelisten following musicians/bandsPlease to [Radiohead] the clips listen following by Please to clicking [Jonathan the clips listen following on by Please to the clicking Wilson] the clips appropriate listen following on by Please to the clicking the clips appropriate letters listen following on byto carefully the clicking the clips appropriate letters following on and bycarefully the clicking decide clips appro letter o a w b Know them Highly quite well familiar but Never not with all heard their of A their all of was them of music a their live B music performance. was a live Aperformance. was a live Bperformance. was a live Aperformance. was a live Bperformance. was a live performance. Never heard Fairly of them familiar Never with heard theirA most of was them of a live their Bperformance. was music a live Bperformance. was a live Aperformance. was a live Bperformance. was a live Aperformance. was a live performance. Have heardHighly them but familiar don't Never with know heard their them Ball of was them of very a their live well A music performance. was a live Bperformance. was a live Aperformance. was a live Bperformance. was a live Aperformance. was a live performance. Never heard Have of them heardNever them but heard don't A of was them know a live them Bperformance. was very a live well Bperformance. was a live Bperformance. was a live Bperformance. was a live Aperformance. was a live performance. Have heardHave themheard but don't Have them know heard but them don't B them was know very but a live well them don't Aperformance. was know very a live well them Bperformance. was very a live well Aperformance. was a live Bperformance. was a live Aperformance. was a live performance. Have heardKnow them them but don't Never quite know well heard them but A of was not them very all a live well of B their performance. was music a live Aperformance. was a live Bperformance. was a live Aperformance. was a live Aperformance. was a live performance. Never heard Know of them them Have quite heard well but B them was not all but a live of don't B their performance. was know music a live them Bperformance. was very a live well Aperformance. was a live Bperformance. was a live Aperformance. was a live performance.

tist gets nothing, so they suffer more. More affordable music, with more going to the artists is the ideal. The record companies will Continue, Know them Fairly quite well familiar but Never with not all heard their of A their most of was them music of a live their Bperformance. was music a live Bperformance. was a live Aperformance. was a live Bperformance. was a live Aperformance. was a live performance. Never heard Have of them heardHave themheard but don't A them was know but a live them don't Bperformance. was know very a live well them Bperformance. was very a live well Bperformance. was a live Bperformance. was a live Aperformance. was a live performance. Never heard Know of them them Never quite well heard but B of was not them all a live of B their performance. was music a live Bperformance. was a live Aperformance. was a live Aperformance. was a live Bperformance. was a live performance. Never heard Know of them them Have quite heard well but B them was not all but a live of don't A their performance. was know music a live them Bperformance. was very a live well Aperformance. was a live Bperformance. was a live Aperformance. was a live performance. Never heard Know of them them Never quite well heard but A of was not them all a live of B their performance. was music a live Aperformance. was a live Aperformance. was a live Bperformance. was a live Aperformance. was a live performance. Have heardHave themheard but don't Have them know heard but them don't A them was know very but a live well them don't Aperformance. was know very a live well them Bperformance. was very a live well Aperformance. was a live Bperformance. was a live Bperformance. was a live performance. Have heardHighly them but familiar don't Know with know them their them A quite all was of very well a their live well but B music performance. was not all a live of B their performance. was music a live Aperformance. was a live Bperformance. was a live Aperformance. was a live performance. Never heard Highly of them familiar Never with heard their Aall of was them of a their live A music performance. was a live Bperformance. was a live Aperformance. was a live Bperformance. was a live Aperformance. was a live performance. Never heard Have of them heardNever them but heard don't B of was them know a live them Bperformance. was very a live well Bperformance. was a live Aperformance. was a live Aperformance. was a live Aperformance. was a live performance.

How familliar How were familliar you How with were these familliar yousongsHow with were these familliar [The yousongsHow with Beatles] were these familliar [Led yousongsHow with Zeppelin] were these familliar [Talking yousongsWhat with were Heads] these band [Dragonforce] yousongsDo or with musician you these [Radiohead] enjoy songsIffirst you digital comes said [Jonathan musicyes to to mind Why Question Wilson] when or why you 2, notthen thin B was a live performance. I don't thinkIf of you digital mean music The electronic same as a genre, as music, in non rather I love digital ait, way Imusic believe of rec Quite familliar Very familiar Hadn't heard Hadn't it before heard Quite it before familliar Hadn't heard Nero it before Yes. Its a very The broad samearea things of I'd music. look Like for in any any o Very familiar Quite familliar Hadn't heard Quite it before familliar Very familiar Hadn't heard Fourtet it before Yes. It has the Production potential valueOriginality to make any kind of soun of so Very familiar Very familiar Might of heard Hadn't it before heard Hadn't it before heard Hadn't it before heard bastille it before yes, but it isDance very repetitive music...makes and reminds me want meto ofg Quite familliar Hadn't heard Very it before familiar Hadn't heard Hadn't it before heard SKRILLEX it before Yes. It's valid Sound artistic quality, expression progession and can and get a re re Very familiar Very familiar Very familiar Might of heard Might it before of heard Hadn't it before heard none it before dont know Very familiar Very familiar Might of heard Hadn't it before heard Quite it before familliar Very familiar metronomyYes, its musically a great valid, rhythm, andand its really melodic atmosphe eleme

The record companies will Continue, so people will download illegally. I don't...Yet!!! :D Quite familliar Very familiar Might of heard Very it familiar beforeQuite familliar Hadn't heard Skrillex it before Yes, but only Artistic if it is intent used as that a goes tool for beyond a greater the Very familiar Might of heard Might it before of heard Might it before of heard Might it before of heard Might it before of heard blawan it beforeYes, I think Ummm, of danceinterest. (house etc) I think music bad which digital Very familiar Very familiar Quite familliar Might of heard Quite it before familliar Hadn't heard Fat it before Boy Slim...! Not as much I like as real real music instruments being played

Very familiar Hadn't heard Might it before of heard Hadn't it before heard Might it before of heard Might it before of heard Postal it before Service Yes, when it well is carefully thought out thought structure out. Iand enjoy textu ap Quite familliar Might of heard Hadn't it before heard Might it before of heard it beforeHadn't heard Not it before sure Not sure

Quite familliar Might of heard Hadn't it before heard Hadn't it before heard Hadn't it before heard Might it before of heard netsky it beforeyes, although A good I'm thinking drop of digital music as a

A was a live performance. I'm not sureIfwhat you mean the term I'm music still refers not in a to... sure digital as what in, format, mp3s? you mean. then Maybe yes Might of heard Quite it before familliar Very familiar Hadn't heard Very it before familiar Hadn't heard Daft it before Punk I think 'digital' Innovation, music is a interesting vague term, manipulation since all

Very familiar Might of heard Might it before of heard Hadn't it before heard Hadn't it before heard Hadn't it before heard David it before Guetta?? Its Ok, I prefer I guess to think like of anything musicians it will income the old do

Do you think Indigital general, music do In general, you should think be do Do musicians judged you youthink approve on Do who musicians the you same of use 'sampling' approve synthesizers terms Do who you of use as other 'sampling' think other synthesizers in Do people DJ's their musicyouother who music think tracksWhy in sample Watch people DJ's their are Why or less, who music a why other trackslittle ormore, sample Watch notwhy are bit peoples Why of notless, or a this other equally little or music more, clip why bit peoples of talented, of notare or a this robot equally more, - music comment clip when program of less talente are a rob com or m Of course, for Equally the same talented Synthesizers reasons to musicians outlined Yes can be who above. incredibly It's play People another instruments rewarding into Not creative classical sure and outlet, creative Depends music the sneered Beastie to how use, Nomuch to Boy's atthink guitar ingenuity Paul's otherwise music Boutique they when is use astonishingly it iscame sampled out, analogu closed we shom Yes. Because Notits sure just a Idifferent have no form idea Yes of how music. they're If You it sounds used. still judge I couldn't Equally good, it with why talented comment your not? It can ears. to be on musicians harder how The Yes skilful instruments towho remix/sample they Maybe play are used instruments not is someone at irrelevant this stage else's but work in time tha No in the same Equally waytalented that I personally youto wouldn't musicians Yes prefer judge who non a piece If digital play you instruments of get music rock their Equally but music permission in principle talented by There exactly which to they is musicians the an Iare assume same No art doing to criteria taking who you theA play have same samples that robot instruments you to thing doesn't if and would you in putting want learning make a piece tochoices them sell to of use your classica togethe depe the mu t yes Less talented than musicians Not sure who The play sample instruments Less tends talented to be Just what than different makes musicians Nothe track who no play good, emotion instruments not the rest of it! No, different Equally vibe intalented performance. Still needs to musicians a Yes solid background who Because play instruments ofitmusical has Equally theknowledge potential talented Obviously to toand musicians work there's practise. No really a who well limit Artistry play and to sampling instruments sound require SICK. someone agency. and just rip yes Not sure Not sure Less talented it doesnt than musicians require No talent who Artistic play instruments performance is not about pr No, because Equally all types talented of you music could to musicians are be Not different a very sure who talented and sometimes play judging instruments dj, orany a Less it traditional can of talented them be respectful on In musician terms than the same musicians and ofwho creative No very terms lacked well who can talent, chosen, talent Robots play be they problematic instruments - the but aren't have nature in other developed less of -instances maybe talent enough doesnt not it alw can to c

Yes. Everything Less artistic talented 'Music' and than creative has musicians No its should purist who be form This play judged (such instruments is the on as death similar Less the human talented of terms. 'creativity', It voice). is than Music easier, musicians using The is just No less further someone a personally part who away of Art play else's the from is expressive, instruments overarching something creativeness this pureand that form, artistic to an transcends and build irresponsib expressio the on mor for w I'm not sureEqually which terms talented you to mean? musicians Yes Quality, wholistener Love play instruments a enjoyment bit of Equally intertextuality and talented technical Quoting (seriously). to musicians other skill? Yes people Then who yes. does playnot instruments make your essay worse or It is cleaverEqually and has talented itsIn place some toand musicians ways is Yes aI form would who ofsay creativity It play can equally instruments give which a talented Less new should talented lease as they They be of than life judged, both are to musicians a merely have song praised No tobut taking master who and it is Even play what acknowledge a their bit instruments though has naff... means already make a like of robot making been any upor something other an done music. electron form and Ine w o r

No. I think that Equally the same talented many applies to who musicians to use Yes different synthesizers who genres It play is merely instruments have within vision Equally appreciation the 'other' and talented know music. The for exactly orginal another toThey musicians No artist what are persons all is effect who seperate talented work They play they and instruments enough want lack angles recognising feeling. to at produce. to looking produce One potential. They important atsomething music ofetn The an au Not sure Not sure Depends on Yes the individual Sometimes Not it adds sure to the Depends originalon and No the improves individual it. As long as they are clear it's sa

Yes, it's all music Not sure there shouldn't be Yes discrimination against Equally a genre talented just It is because ato different musicians No it istype created who of talent Because play digitally, instruments but it's it a takes robot still a can't still talent. skill feel and emotion pass

I think I might Equally have talented missed see Sterne's the to musicians point. Yes article Did who you "Media mean Yes, play or instruments though electronic Instruments? Equally there music? are talented Yes." obviously Entirely In which The to musicians depends theoretical, musicological case No ofon course who and the Even play and context. often I think ethical instruments in even compositions itAlso merits implications technical, samples as much based differences are foranalysis some largely entire in Yes for the Equally above reasons, talented It's just Ito think musicians another today Yes type there who of Just play is instrument, noas instruments solid blowing boundary Equally there air isthrough talented no between Above significant a to tube reasons, 'digital' musicians qualitative with Noand holes no who 'other' qualitative difference in I play think itmusicmanipulates instruments art difference -or is it's something if a I were way the to sounds other of to creatively human, compare kinds made an of sa m b

Yes - I thinkEqually you can talented judge I suspect something to musicians that Yes there simply who is a on Yes play high whether -instruments sometimes degree you Equally oflike talent OK it talented or ifin Ithe not think using context without topeople musicians digital No feels the like synthesizers need right Fat who to Bot and I play think differentiate Slim, it to instruments has the make David been human loops into Guetta going live brain and on or are rifts and recorded, a talented long and its cap tim ne

Watch a little bit of this clip of a robot programmed to improvise (http://www.youtube.com/watch-feature=player_detailpage&v=qy02lwvGv3

Maybe not at this stage but in time computers will be able to do anything we can A robot doesn't make choices depending on what it likes and dislikes. It might seem like it is making choices if it programmed to play with a no emotion Artistry require agency. Artistic performance is not about programmed performance Robots aren't developed enough to be truly creative, but can only reflect their programming by humans

Art is something that transcends what we would define as music, and being a musician doesn't automatically make one an artist. Art is, as

Even though a robot or an electronic gadget can make 'sound' which is classed as music nowadays, it does not have the human element t

They lack feeling. One important aspect of music is accuracy and logic. However this is all dead without emotion. The human touch to mus

Because a robot can't feel emotion and therefore won't have the same impact as a person to create emotive and passionate music.

Even in compositions based entirely around algorithms or randomisation, there is human intent. See Brian Eno and many others. I think art is something human, an expression of human agency. If something is being produced purely from mathematical programming, th I think the human brain and its capacity for emotion is light years away from allowing robots and computers from capturing the essence of

re=player_detailpage&v=qy02lwvGv3U#t=169). As musical scales are based on mathematics, do you think robots or other machines have cr

hoices if it programmed to play with a degree of randomness but that is still just part of the program. I think someone that makes a robot or p

atically make one an artist. Art is, as Oxford dictionary defines it, "the expression or application of human creative skill and imagination". The

does not have the human element that gives it the edge. It is like digital art...if I master my 'technology' ie my computer program that can pro

ut emotion. The human touch to music is what touched human viewers the most. Without a humna involved in the production of music there

motive and passionate music.

Brian Eno and many others. y from mathematical programming, then I do not think it contains a human/expressive element to make it 'art'.

uters from capturing the essence of an emotional musical performance

ink robots or other machines have creative power enough to be 'artists'- Why or why not- - comment

nk someone that makes a robot or programs some computer software to make sound in a random way is an artist but the robot itself isn't.

n creative skill and imagination". The robot can play, but it is not showing creative skill or imagination (as those are programmed aspects tha

ie my computer program that can produce the artwork, I can make a 'good' picture BUT it is totally different to me mastering my paint brush

ved in the production of music there is little deep interaction between the music and the listener/audience. I think it is important to improve b

is an artist but the robot itself isn't.

s those are programmed aspects that are encoded into the machine), and it is not human.

ent to me mastering my paint brush in order to make a technically accurate picture with carefully mixed colours, texture, subtle nuances and

ce. I think it is important to improve by ear in order to come out with something that truly compliments other instruments playing in the best wa

colours, texture, subtle nuances and my own personality and passion, all of which comes through my picture where a robot could never repro

her instruments playing in the best way and come up with a fusion that trully touches the emotions. There is also a beauty in notes occasiona

cture where a robot could never reproduce...in my opinion. The same applies to music. It is a spiritual experience creating great music/art an

e is also a beauty in notes occasionally being off key or rythmes falling off beat. It adds more depth to an improvised piece. There is also mor

perience creating great music/art and you give off a certain energy that people respond to... electronics can never reproduce this human ele

n improvised piece. There is also more instinctive understanding for dymanics/not combinations when the human ear is used for judgement

can never reproduce this human element! :-)

e human ear is used for judgement