Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Fetwa
on
the
Appointment By Richard
of Gottheil.
Dhimmis
to
office.
the
Rcvtic has
des discussed
Etudes the
p.
75
and text
in
faiths, During
of in the on the
found
Ms. ('yJ'
contains Uaj
Ab
ibn bears
al-Ishbili.
4X4^^ by to
JU*Xwl al-Husain
"The
or to
histories fix
conse oc
quently, curred
time decision.
event authority
forth
i)
jfournal
Asiatique
1851,
p. 431.
204
R.
Gottheil
is not
died I
in should
AH to
(1126 infer
AD). from
')
mention The
the
mentioned the unwillingness over the the; strict as the earlier state, Caliphs, strong. (295320 appointed of the secretary, one (ca. 256 when
such a
see
position to have
authority down
"Neither 3) But, as
cadi is This
theologians of when office, placed Billh According Mutamid Sa'id, also 1) The 1310), I, 479; the Caliph charged by
al-Furat, defends
vizier himself, to
non-Mohammedans al-Nsir army, *) of AH) li-din and Malik the was of ibn viziers 'Abdn Allh al-Mu
citing
who tadid
over as
al-Walid. of alibn
authorities,
author Ibn
al-Multik, al-Sillah
Ibn
(Blk
2) NLDEKE, 3) (J^Xj
uLJ L*^^
i^^-k+i-ktk+JI
t5*'^'''
Cited otlier
fiom
the
Kit."ib will be
by
al-KalkashandT,
Subh
al-/{sh
]). 40,
where
o])inions 4) H. F.
Amedroz,
Historical
Remains
of
Hill
al-Sbi
(Leyden
1904),
p. 95. 5) Ykt, Irshd Vizier al-Arib may be (Ed. Sa'id Margoliouth) (ihn Makhlad), II, who 259; but the to have text is
not
plam,
the
is said
been
Fetwa
on
the
A))pointnient
of Dhimmis
to office.
205
was rule
in
Egypt in the
and
under
the
Fatimides
expressly: secretaries
their charge
Mohammedans stian one but death.") rm Vizier dismiss later, head a of the as of he governor his was Under Armenian al-Afdal him, Jew the his
Dhimmis." of one in
Nestor;
Menasseh; of Vizier, factor of forced A was that at he little the had them Bahthe to to
AH);
al-Afdal by a ibn
was
taken
Abul-Munajjah of named was on Agriculture, after necessary the cent. theorj^ AH) this (ibn al-AthIr latter a "Bureau certain him.
5) for of these contraventions. institu distinction between ed. 293, 'Alxln Blrdj 294) as ibn say his I, 505). anything brother. theory Neither of his in
Mohammedan a fine
makes difference
KlialUkn, (VII,
mentions
Ykt a Chri
al-Muhadhdhab
Abil-MalTh,
as tlie
of Fiefs".
i)
k_jUX3t
J..0UI
iicL+i.
[V^
j>L-ijbil
(j'^Ji^
lij^
Cited of
from
the
/)a7i Knn
'All
Bahgat
al-Sairafi's
under Ishk
TiUunid Nasr
Khumrawaih ,al-'riiadi
Ahmad
(270280
is mentioned;
59.
2) Abul-Mahasin, Maured Allatafet 3) Khital hear of a scribe 4) JQR 5) Jewish IX p. 4; (Cairo "Ibn 29;
II 2, p. 4; Cari.yi.e,
al-Hfiz laud.
(524544) p. 13.
we
al-Sairafi, 444.
loc.
ZDMG 62.
Encyclopedia
2o6
R.
Gottheil
and also, first cond, ever, Omar own Jew bribes, works mentary
practice. carry case, tlie have ibn more or a and of the to The with none holder
Not
only them
the full
but special
other powers.
high
but may
Moslem be a
in
the
the explain to to
they
unlawful
Islam."") offer
historical com
Mohammedans this statement. put Christians and think of or duties imprison in one be a who allowed lordly a to
themselves
question Can
ibn
Husain be
covers as in
pretty official
field:
appointed officers
general? a Dhimmi
Moslem to take
poll-tax, His to
occupies to
position comport
is infidel of either
in in one
no
as
regards
a Moslem heart". or to be ig
who a godless He
had
sound
Moslem
practice.
prove
pp. 33, by
17 et seq., loc.
43,
12,
passages the
Goi.d/.iher,
laud.
wildyah,
ibid.
^j
Liyi
(j^Aj
^^y^ Ii8;
^ al-
scribe
of
Aim
Msa
al-Ash'ail,
al-MulTik
B'ctwa
on
Uic Ap])ointmcnt
of
Dhimmis
to offico.
207
is butcher
not
even etc.;
to citing from
be
as
emanating well verses From the in light "Do of how idolaters their not that an of the idolatr}^ to employ prophet this be aid the the of new from not as
''companions" men the a story Koran is until further of them told he Hadith in are
"followers", generations. 140; hammed fessed "Do usual ting of not his V
from cited
preceding IV how had is with point", 143, Mo con cited the ci is to but of in told have had Omar view nor as a simi :
from
unbeliever A
III, his
11 4.
story not
non-Moslem neither be to made Abu and Moslem".') prophet, al-Malik the minted survey Dhimmis of a the do
allowed lar the any was Caliphs. was carded, ibn of pact; unbelievers oppress the office "betrays if the old put
appointment the same their affair time of of dirhams his AH). is service in any is be the a
"Remove help non-Moslem that of were Ahmad to the by remove if he in do time their all they cites any this, Lastl}^ and it is to is has be un of the 'Irak dis from
Christians in Arabic. down are Moslem bound to especially, a general the best does Moslems". his trust way,
it to his
man not
betrayed
owner
Snblf
208
R.
Gottheil
ijJ i^LxAjill
tX+a.!^ xS^^
(jtjJwJI ^/o
ISfUrj |V^aAx
^'L^j I^J^J Uj
LjIIs' x.s\Aa.jj
t>^.^l|j xXXjc
^5^LaJI ^J
j>y!l '^f^}
j^A+A^uA+JI
jv^J
^il
*-g.j^
^1
v_kM/o
|V-Lawo
ijj
ll [J*^^
vLjli' (Xft^
XJLa.
(^1
i^fi^ Juolj
(^^tXJI
LetXXAulj tXiil yol XJu^ L.^ Jkjol^yi ^^La^ L>a.^>sM stXj |vi.Ij'
t5<X!l
jV-LA*4JI V/-*^^
i*^:' ^^1
0^cX**JI Jl ^j-;^^^
i^A4J.A**+J.J ij^ tXs! !^ bl xJ xJ J J-^i jvXi J^Ai Jjjui (ji^ao bL*j| jl X4-ij Laj v_^JJo xJ |J Lo^i (jL^^
L.^^
iv^jJsL^ JLi
jJ^.
La^^Juo J-ji
Si>L=i'l
^ oi.->t> J^
Ids' 3
(Jt*il iLLJIi'
XilXi+xi (jaj
t>-g- Xt>^^
^So (^^)
Uj sJtJue ^^^5
I^J
LUj u*,LjJ.j
dUi> X*m.aAj
jj-x+Xw^l
(j>A4.1***JI
LLoii
Fetwa
on
the
A]>pointnient
of
Dlihnmis
to offiee.
209
15+^:!
is^tX'"
tj^
'Xs-U^
^j^l
v_J^j-CCO ^L^J^
^6^7^.5
Jiksi^Lj ii'
ycLjj
stLu^l^ (V^b'
i_}^JLj Laj
iv^aIc iL.x!
Le >iJU
J^s.
'it>lj\ Ljy;il
^'y^' dJj>
. Jjl. iJL^ ^_^Jij |,K.Lj ^ L Jj.i iJ |j>J JjLs. *iAi. cy.JjLa.!il|j ^LJ.JI^ v'-?;' iv^aI^'j ')3 u^^^ ^^iKil |4i:>oLlj j^j^-A*-L**4JI LJ^I bUlLtu ^jjjx^JI ^j^iKJI jvXlJ^ ^yol l.cX:^iJjl ^1, J^^ ^y
Ld
^5^X!Ai,JI ^tXoj
ooL=-.
j^4.-L*4Jl ^jjJ-JLj jj.Ax^+Jt >;yLL.JI jj^jLJI^ 7"^* ^ltXe!I 5' jXXmjc gU^Lj <^\S3\ xjL^'I ^ (^iLxx
^LaXDI jj^x! ^J^^ tXii ^ ij'"'^"*^' cj!S)l^ '^)^~>^ 1^1 t^T ^' |gXjyi ^jtxJI ^^tXj^j'l xJUI (Joi^ ^^^f LUf Ll y^'^ ^j-^^-JI ^b^^Jl ^^'j
ptXe^ L^b
|^^4-L^I =')iL*i-
I^Jl^
^_^j.iKJJ
i^^
(^1
|V^XI ')iLtJ
iV^J^J xJ^^
r-bJjl iJjl
^J>AJJaJI
l) 5)
Ms. ib.
^jjO. V, 62.
2)
ATira
IV,
143.
3)
ib. IV,
140.
4) ib. V,
56.
Zeitschrift
f. Assyrioloj^in,
XXVI.
I4
2 IO r ,jj(\Jf J luJI jJL^ X'iy^ JLi JU ii^^JI J^^^ tX *-L)l jj.AS^*iJI aJJU Jii ^ JJt Ljl!^ ly-l^ bf s^-v*^ Xll ^/o jj-^^' ffJ lye .LxJ^I
R.
GotUicil w IjtX^'l ^lijl^ li i^jA ^<Xs iljw ^_aa^U i^-Li ^j.jjJI ^XL i>^ipi ^ lijljbfl^ Lo *j0Lbl| Jl iilAji *i?-^U ijl JU LH) tVjjl bi l^jkij y >-,L;jai .^Ax^x) 1^1 (^il
|^^^-wi**/l
S^s i^Auj^
''^V^ 'iLi/o
''-L'l ^A^dlj
i^-<
15^1 iLtAjbi
^^L^l ^a j
^7*i tX-La.^
xi JU ^^^^laJI ^)d'j.cL4,j jJL*u^ JLLC^ oJ^JI |S^LjLj dUi> ^ f-vLt iJ^^^ cXJyi (jUlamj Jjl
|VJ ^JJU
tiJj-*J
j^'T'^U
JU JLi
b)
JU
j>(<>.aaJ(
JU IcXj
').io *iJI <^.J iU)t> ''jl^J^Jj ''L'l J*"<a s^*i ^5! vi '"^^
bi
')xjl (^*-'l
i 15*^
(V^gJUjtiUul JU xj|
OJ>'-*j'
1) Cfr.
Siiaj
nl-ihilk
p. Iig;
Bei.in,
Ioc.
Iniul.
p, 425.
2) 5) IIO AH. 6)
&'/-/'
^jl.
3) .il-Has.in
4) al-Hasan VI,
references
7) Koran
Kolwa
on
llic
A]ipoinlnienl
of
Dliinimis
to office.
2 I 1
i*'^,;'^
[juOyjC
v_Jai |*ys
(^.gJ^i^ iifiUs^ l^.ji.i'Liii JL.x*uLj i_jLkiil ^xS'j-.^JI x.^L^ bjxLs ^jbXJi L^jl Uh/i^ b(j Xj|
|vg-!b:j ^^1^
vii/^xj
|vg.JUjix*ul 3 Jl iUi ^'^ ^b bl^ XJ Ul bl j^X) yol ^^-e X-Ul ^U.i xUI (J-XI; bl^ Jy-^) Jl ^ i JtJUl Sj-^Lij jJU****J jv^UjuUwb ^xit Uj ^xiI bL.i bl^ ii)jf.ci.x!
^^.l*.**.'! xjLi JLIx S'^'^I^J JLJI bl^ J.^ dy^j^ Xxi xJLJl i*-*^ O^jJI 'iyij yyO^ |j-v^;-*^JI ''^y^
^xi V^
ScXxj jv-Lauj f)}'-.^ yij,\y x-Lc (j^-* d^xI .'i}yMI.4.J tUx ^^I xi!l ^jjO^
^CCAij XJ ^5->fl;l
(V^Uiil ly^Xi i ^y
i^^^^AXA^J
JUc-bH ^Xj
ij^^
bl^
^X!^
b>j
1) Abu p. 153;
Sa'Jd
Sa'd
ibn
Mlik
ibn
.Sinn
al-KliudiT;
see
Dahslia,
Tnhfah
p. 115. here. After Lxi^ there are the letters H" |fbl|jS*i!
212
R.
Ciottheil
jjo
dLLJI
tVA
ij-^
j,
tL**JI
(j-o
iUtXJt
Jjcl
ojujo
JJ(^
Jj^l ').Juo^ i
Jl
'J'^^ ^xjbjJI
'^'^ Xl/ ^^LaJI^ (jiJj i^^-j^l ^iXiiXfy JiyJI >1).J^' viJUi J^cUi ^bll 17^1^ i5*J ^.^ (^^-'^ ^LiXJI i5jbaxJI ^i^ jJJI l^l StXjl ij^^ Jj i tX~l ^). ... tXsj 1^7-^'"*^ J^. ^ u*5 7^7*^'
JjL*JI ^^LJIj i j^. Lc JbJI JuJjli ')<Xtt (J ^ ^j^LJIj JLc Juys" Uwj v_as| ySt La aXc Lo ib Jo K> ^\ ^LwJ'bll ,^jJI (jssy ^LiXll
^)>:^UI.X) i (jajl JL' aJUI i^jl;^ br i |^^^-^*Xs***JI bl xlVJI JJ(j> stXjl J^I
i^lyobll
aiAA*,c>
b^^u
^A^J-ku^JI jJ.jJJI
^A4-b*MJ(
bf|
JUcbll ^JiLi^y
bl
^^1 *lp)yij
iUi
^ Jl.xibll
J-S?j ^^^
jj-^J.**JJ (J-o
Jl^bil
(J,XI
iU (jl
al-lslmiyyah unrcad.-ible by !
(Const.
1298)
p. 6.
Goldziher, of Oni.ir".
loc.
land.
|i. 93,
note
0.
Fetwa
on
the
Ap|iciintnient
of
f)hiniinis
to office.
-1.1
^ajj-JIj (jlji-j
lil
l^JI
Uj^j
o'r-^'j j^l^l
^l-^T^J J.^ ^i
;L*.^JI; jjjOjJI
;LXIt
yUjtJI j^cXJI
lj.A4Xi-JI
^.j-
Jw^
stXj
o*.^
U^i
J.**a*j
^(
|fj.A
jl
ltX;c
iU.^
Jj
^Ij
.JoJ.fi ''^
^<Xftj
iulj^
ij xjLajiJI
loUaii-l
xJ^^u^j
Lg.jUj ijjo
1) Ms. 2) Cfr.
i_>ljcXj
Jjl
Jjl
jvJjij
jJCj
of Ibn
Abu
allh
Muhammad (Ed.
al-IJakim
Khallikn, Muham
Wafayat medanische
KhjT
Khallfah
Goldziher, I, 166.
Studien
BROCKELMANN,
Geschichte
Kanz
al-Umml tXi
III,
196 jJJ
(No.
2877): (^-^ ^
^je j^
bL*-^
Jl^JiXauI l*'^^^
jJ,X> jul-afi
Xx>
tJ^^^J'^ 5) Cfr. Kanz al-Ummal 111, 163 (No. 2594): ^^jo JLs ^jjO
2 14
K. fidtllicil,
l'clwa
on
ihi-
AjiiMiinttnoiU
of
Dliinnnis
to office.
joL^I c:JL(;>
J>.s. JLo
-^7^' ^
').... . tXi-'
'
jt > ^1
^A^JLwJI 5I
|JUJI ^LJI
^LiJI
^AXiJI ^JtX.JI
sjo l_)Lg_W
J=?
xaaTj
ivifil
xL'l^ Jk.Xw.JI
,_aX.W*JI j^XJU-'l
,_kAAil
|_g**ki.l
jj>A.*=.
(jLi^
lX
viJLJj.J
b"
iJL4jiAM.j
i'jI^iJ
^'
isO^J
ils.^ *^.r*;5
Jk*^(
215
Ibrhim By Reynold
b. A.
Adham. Nicholson.
Ibrhim Jbir in man, him him who pray of al-Tamimi Khursn. made was up were for these the prayers and we in born his
b.
b.
b.
Yazid of and and said, Balkh pious Ibra took ascetics them "some
b.
the
with father,
his
followed the
and
circumambulating child. were may seems east (Ibn poet {Aghnf Ibrhim from composed thou art not was the in to much awe Nafalyl the al-Uns, 160 doubt more of Irn, "Evidently", granted".
to
legendary Ibrahim's saw Balkh, was the the the who 272, 20). dates
whether probable in VI
Mecca
the 38, b.
province 1 6). Kunsa lb" is His verses what less as of al-Athir uncertain: nephew, on exceeds than little, God
content content of
Adham
world
held
concerning
it
Sul.iynin
1). Mansr".
l.eidcn
MS.,
1 183.