19/3/2014 Heidegger' s black notebooks aren' t that surprising | Domenico Losurdo | Comment is free | theguardian.

com
http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/mar/19/heidegger-german-philosopher-black-books-not-surprising-nazi 1/4
Search
Martin Heidegger: 'The black notebooks are a testament to the almost messianic expectations that inspired
the philosopher to join Hitler?s party .' Photograph: Bettmann/CORBIS
The scandal provoked by the publication of Martin Heidegger's notes and reflections
between 1931 and 1941, currently underway in Germany, is truly stupefying. The
philosopher's "black notebooks" (schwarze hefte) were so-named after the colour of
their covers; and now we find out that they are black above all in their content. But is
this so surprising?
Yes, we do have the confirmation that immediately after Hitler's coming to power
Heidegger signed up to the Nazi party, and that he did so nourishing excited hopes. His
outlook in the first place concerned Germany: "the German people is now on the brink of
rediscovering its own essence and making itself worthy of a great destiny." After the
country's defeat in the first world war, the German people were, he thought, going to
Heidegger's black notebooks aren't that
surprising
Scholars already knew the German philosopher signed up to the
Nazi party. But that doesn't mean nothing can be learned from his
thinking
Domenico Losurdo
theguardian.com, Wednesday 1 9 March 201 4 1 3.01 GMT
19/3/2014 Heidegger' s black notebooks aren' t that surprising | Domenico Losurdo | Comment is free | theguardian.com
http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/mar/19/heidegger-german-philosopher-black-books-not-surprising-nazi 2/4
experience a triumphal renaissance, saving the world from catastrophe and, above all,
from Bolshevism. For Heidegger, indeed, the promises of regeneration implicit within
Nazism went well beyond German borders: it had been called upon to realise his longed-
for "destruction of modernity", putting an end to the egalitarian massification which had,
of course, seen its most ruinous expression in the October Revolution, but had begun
long beforehand with the advent of liberalism and democracy. And, if Heidegger's hatred
for Soviet Russia was boundless, what reigned supreme was his low opinion for the
Anglo-Saxon world.
Nazism constituted, or could constitute, a "new beginning" with respect to all this, a new
beginning for culture and politics. The black notebooks are a testament to the almost
messianic expectations that inspired the philosopher to join Hitler's party. All this much
is true. But it was already known to Heidegger scholars from a section of his 1935
Introduction to Metaphysics and its celebration of the "inner truth and greatness" of
nazism.
Modernity is synonymous with subversion, since with its universalist ideologies
(liberalism, democracy, communism) it destroys the communitarian and traditional
bonds that unite the members of a given people and separates this same people from its
territory and history. Inevitably, the critique of modernity ends up also concerning
Jews. The black notebooks confirm this: present in many countries and attached to
urban rather than rural life, Jews are the incarnation of "rootlessness", "distance from
the soil" and thus subversion. And again, this attitude is far from surprising to the
Heidegger scholar: the 2 October 1929 letter in which the philosopher emphasises the
need to oppose "growing Judaisation within German spiritual life", reinforcing this by
rooting it in authentically German forces, is already well-known.
The black notebooks theorise in explicit fashion the importance of the "racial principle"
and, even if in a contorted manner, justify the Third Reich's race laws. Here, we do find
undoubtedly new material (indeed, material of great interest) adding to what we knew
already. But one already famous, perhaps infamous letter, should not be forgotten. It
was Heidegger's wife who sent it on 29 April 1933, albeit with the agreement of her
husband, who was at the time also the rector of the University of Freiburg. The recipient
was the wife of Edmund Husserl, Heidegger's teacher. This letter expressed his consent
to the "hard new law, rational from Germans' point of view", which excluded Jews from
university teaching, including Gerhart Husserl, son of the illustrious philosopher of the
same name, who as a Jew was stripped of his civil law chair at the university, despite
being a wounded veteran of the first world war. In this context, we must add also the
testimony of Karl Jaspers, according to whom Heidegger drew attention to the
"dangerous international association of Jewry" soon after the Nazi conquest of power.
The outcry over the black notebooks is thus unjustified, but it would be all the more
19/3/2014 Heidegger' s black notebooks aren' t that surprising | Domenico Losurdo | Comment is free | theguardian.com
http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/mar/19/heidegger-german-philosopher-black-books-not-surprising-nazi 3/4
More from the guardian
Sackcloth and Ashes rev iew Ann Widdecombe on
hedonism and self-denial 1 3 Mar 201 4
The 'simple' way to stop burglars that set alarm
bells ringing 1 5 Mar 201 4
Trav el picture quiz - name these famous train
stations 1 4 Mar 201 4
Don't let the cy nics and puritans ruin y our St
Patrick's Day 1 6 Mar 201 4
Unthinkable? A tax on dinosaur rock 1 4 Mar 201 4
More from around the web
Are You an Empath?: Discov er the Truth About
Emotional Sensitiv ity (Empath Connection)
Photos: 1 6 Celebs Who Refuse to Age Gracefully
(Shape)
Billionaires business empires a key to growth for
transaction banks (Euromoney )
You Won't Believ e This Hilarious Drunk Text (Runt
of the Web)
Rules for Proper Flag Etiquette (Colorfastflags.com -
Color Fast Flags Blog)
unjustified to imagine a mythical, eternally irredeemable Germany, ignoring the
historical context in which Heidegger's life and work were situated. His Judeophobia
came at a moment when across the west as a whole, on both sides of the Atlantic, there
was a widespread view that the true culprits for the October Revolution were Jews.
Indeed, in 1920 car tycoon Henry Ford wrote that this event had a racial and not
political origin, and, though making use of humanitarian and socialist language, it in fact
expressed the Jewish race's aspiration for world domination. It is worth noting that it
was Ford's picture that had pride of place in Hitler's study and not Heidegger's: the
origins of nazism and the ideological motives inspiring it were not exclusively German.
Secondly, as the black notebooks confirm, although Heidegger was a Nazi to the end this
does not mean that nothing can be learned from him. Germany is the country that
perhaps more than any other has had to struggle with imperial universalism, often the
synonym of universal interventionism: leaving aside the ancient Romans and the
expeditions of the Emperor Augustus, we ought to bear in mind that first Napoleon III in
1870-1 and then the entente powers in 1914-18 waged war in the name of the expansion
of "civilisation" or "democracy", in each case in the name of "universal" values. This
explains the aggressive, reactionary anti-universalism in Germany that found its first
expression in Nietzsche and then, above all, in Heidegger and Schmitt, both of whom
supported the Third Reich. This is a tragedy and an infamy that certainly leaves
aggressive, reactionary anti-universalism with much to answer; but it does not in any
way absolve western imperial universalism of its own responsibility and crimes.
This piece was translated by David Broder
Get the best of Comment is free
The most shared comment, analysis and editorial
articles delivered every weekday lunchtime.
Sign up for the Comment is free email
19/3/2014 Heidegger' s black notebooks aren' t that surprising | Domenico Losurdo | Comment is free | theguardian.com
http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/mar/19/heidegger-german-philosopher-black-books-not-surprising-nazi 4/4
Ads by Google
Do You Have a UK Pension?
Get Your Pension Out of the UK & Avoid Losing 55%. Free Expat Guide.
www.forthcapital.com/QROPS
Riviera de Santa Cristina
Lotes de 450m Apenas R$440 Mensal. Empreendimento com Lazer Completo!
rivieradesantacristina.com.br/Lotes
Servidor Cloud SSD
50 Mbps Link. Disco SSD Exclusivo no Brasil. Maior Velocidade R$ 125
under.com.br/Cloud
2 01 4 Guar dian News and Media Limit ed or it s affiliat ed companies. All r ight s r eser v ed.