16/2/2014 The irresistible appeal of the romantic ideal - FT.

com
http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/bf810484-9255-11e3-8018-00144feab7de.html?ftcamp=published_links%2Frss%2Fcomment%2Ffeed%2F%2Fproduct&siteedition 1/2
By continuing to use this site you consent to the use of cookies on your device as described in our cookie policy unless you have disabled them. You
can change your cookie settings at any time but parts of our site will not function correctly without them.
T
February 13, 2014 3:53 pm
The irresistible appeal of the romantic ideal
By Simon May
Pursue love with less hubris, impatience and intolerance to risk, says Simon May
oday millions of people celebrate one form of love and one only: romantic love, the love that
speaks the language of erotic desire.
As we settle down to our candlelit dinners or, as singletons or conscientious objectors to
Valentines day, wander past packed restaurants envying or pitying the serried rows of couples
we might ask: why do we so privilege romance?
Why, for example, do we not have a St Francis day for love of nature? Or a world friendship day
named after Aristotle (who considered friendship the supreme form of love)? Or an anniversary when love between parents and children
is celebrated with more than the card and flowers given, one-sidedly, on Fathers or Mothers day?
Indeed, why do such alternative love festivals sound faintly absurd to our contemporary ear?
The answer lies in the unique promise of romantic love, as it has been conceived of since the late 18th century, to satisfy five modern and,
taken together, western ambitions.
The first and most important is to find salvation from everyday suffering and banality through a great ideal and to do so outside
traditional religion. The tremendous popularity of the romantic ideal, of two people finding ultimate joy and meaning in a cocoon of
oneness, has in effect privatised salvation.
Second, there is the ambition to subvert traditional relations of class, power and more recently gender and what better than the
heedlessness of romantic love to do so?
Third, romantic love accords with the great prestige attached to passion in modern times. Passion has become a test of a life fully lived a
life in which we are more than calculable and calculating strivers for carefully defined goals. It dignifies our highest goals in a way that, for
ancients such as Aristotle, only reason could.
Fourth, there is the libertarian urge to assert ourselves through our romantic choices as radically autonomous individuals. We see our
romances as central to forging, charting and, crucially, endorsing our evolving identity.
And, finally, romantic love plays the starring role in reclaiming sex and the body and their immense pleasures from the denigration to
which they were subject for centuries.
No other form of love and certainly no other contemporary ideal, whether equality or freedom or ecology or world peace could credibly
promise to address so many fundamental goals in one go.
Of course, such extravagant expectations are easily disappointed. Many couples, finding just one of them unmet such as the crazily close
linkage that exists between sex and love will give up on their romance, either moving on to the next one or else settling for practical
companionship.
But do not believe those who say that romance is on the wane because it is too arduous; or because people cannot deal with the shame of
repeated failure; or because internet dating, with its limitless opportunities, is turning love into a cold commodity.
Ideals and ideologies do not collapse merely by failing. Rather, they decay when the ambitions that nurture them disappear. And the
ambitions that have nurtured romantic love for two centuries are too deeply rooted in the western mind to disappear soon.
Above all the desire for salvation, which romantic love is charged with satisfying, is alive and well. This is the desire to find within the
romantic cocoon the security, identity, meaning, respect for our individuality and redemption from lifes messy imperfection that were
once sought primarily in God.
To say this is to say more than that romantic love has become our new deity. In addition and this is the real danger human love has
Home UK World Companies Markets Global Economy Lex Comment Management Personal Finance Life & Arts
Columnists Analysis Opinion The A-List Editorial Blogs Letters Corrections Obituaries Tools
16/2/2014 The irresistible appeal of the romantic ideal - FT.com
http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/bf810484-9255-11e3-8018-00144feab7de.html?ftcamp=published_links%2Frss%2Fcomment%2Ffeed%2F%2Fproduct&siteedition 2/2
Printed from: http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/bf810484-9255-11e3-8018-00144feab7de.html
Print a single copy of this article for personal use. Contact us if you wish to print more to distribute to others.
THE FINANCIAL TIMES LTD 2014 FT and Financial Times are trademarks of The Financial Times Ltd.
You may be interested in
Titans challenge the claim Scots cannot use the pound
Argentina revises 'bogus' inflation figures
Robots learn from termites how to build without a plan
Father of GPS warns on cybersecurity
Letta to stand down as Italy's PM after party backs Renzi
Hair of the dog risks a bigger hangover for Britain
How to find the needle in Edward Snowden's haystack
China: Funds on the edge
The real titans of finance are no longer in the banks
Kerry takes the long winding road as he pivots to Asia
A piracy tool rehabilitated by the NSA spying scandal
Homework and homesickness
US drugstores go back to the future
Romance is in the air when you find love with an app
Tech groups wrestle with hardware offload
China's Jade Rabbit springs back to life
There is no such thing as the banking profession
Why opposites shouldn't attract
When love is off the rails
become modelled on the specific characteristics of the Judaeo-Christian God. In particular, it is expected to be unconditional, enduring and
purely selfless in its devotion to the wellbeing of loved ones. But to claim that humans can love in this way is hubris.
Moreover, love is widely regarded not as a rare skill, as the Greeks saw it; nor the supreme virtue in need of endless cultivation, as St
Augustine saw it. It is seen rather as a blessing that we all expect to find. And find quickly.
Here is a Valentines day resolution for romantic love: pursue it with less hubris, less impatience and less intolerance to risk.
And free it from the stranglehold of sex. An erotic relationship can flourish without constant consummation as it did, gloriously, in the era
of medieval courtly love.
Above all, we must understand that love is conditional. It is a desire for one whom we experience as indestructibly grounding our life as
offering us a promise of rootedness in the world and to whom we therefore yearn to devote ourselves. To assume it is unconditional is to
play God. And that always ends badly.
The writer is visiting professor of philosophy at Kings College London and author of Love: A History
7
9
8