Case 1:12-cr-00973-PGG Document 287-2 Filed 05/28/14 Page 1 of 29
Case 1:12-cr-00973-PGG Document 287-2 Filed 05/28/14 Page 2 of 29 Case 1:12-cr-00973-PGG Document 287-2 Filed 05/28/14 Page 3 of 29
EXHIBIT 12
Case 1:12-cr-00973-PGG Document 287-2 Filed 05/28/14 Page 4 of 29 Case 1:12-cr-00973-PGG Document 287-2 Filed 05/28/14 Page 5 of 29 Case 1:12-cr-00973-PGG Document 287-2 Filed 05/28/14 Page 6 of 29
EXHIBIT 13
Case 1:12-cr-00973-PGG Document 287-2 Filed 05/28/14 Page 7 of 29 Case 1:12-cr-00973-PGG Document 287-2 Filed 05/28/14 Page 8 of 29 Case 1:12-cr-00973-PGG Document 287-2 Filed 05/28/14 Page 9 of 29
EXHIBIT 14
Case 1:12-cr-00973-PGG Document 287-2 Filed 05/28/14 Page 10 of 29 Case 1:12-cr-00973-PGG Document 287-2 Filed 05/28/14 Page 11 of 29 Case 1:12-cr-00973-PGG Document 287-2 Filed 05/28/14 Page 12 of 29
EXHIBIT 15
Case 1:12-cr-00973-PGG Document 287-2 Filed 05/28/14 Page 13 of 29 April9, 2014
Delray Beach, FL. 33483 Honorable Paul G. Gardephe United States District Court for the Southern District ofNew York United States Courthouse 40 Foley Square New York, NY I 0007 Dear Judge Gardephe, My name i;; Russell "Rusty'' Bacigalupi, I've resided in Delray Beach, Florida since February of 2000. I am a former touring Golf Professional and currently, I am a Teaching Professional and run the Junior Golf Program for the city of Boca Raton, FL. My company "Baci Golf" formed a junior golf team approximately 3 years ago which was undefeatable in 2012 and 2013 earning the title of the "Number One Team" in the state of Florida. I am writing this letter on behalf of Mathew Martoma whom I understand has been charged with insider trading and will be sentenced by you in June of2014. I met Mathew Martoma and his family approximately 4 years ago and I began teaching his son "J " and his daughter "A " a few weeks after our meeting. J attended 4 hours of weekly lessons and A 2 hours weekly allowing me the privilege to become well aquatinted with the entire Martoma family. Mathew, J and myself set a timeline of 2 years to prepare J for tournament golf and to tryout for my junior golf team. Over the years I've watched J make great stride in becoming an accomplished tournament player both physically and mentally. He also, qualified for my golf team making him the youngest member of the tea.m. Unfortunately, in the past 6 months he's unable to devote the time to practice and/or play tournament golf
. Mathew is such a huge part of J 's life
Until Mathew's legal situation he and I would take J to his tournaments while I would caddy and coach him, Mathew was there for support. On the ride home J would display a huge smile while we'd discuss the positive aspects of his game (his swing, finish, putting, attitude or mental game.) Typically, we would stop somewhere and grab a bite to eat while making a plan on what we were going to work on for the next tournament. He was so full of energy and happiness and loved the competitive aspect of the game. Now he's hardly practicing and hasn't played in any tournament golf since October of last year. Ultimately what concerns me (isn't J 's seemingly lack of interest in golf) its what is fueling his disinterest. I'm deeply concerned about the negative impact of Mathews absence will have on J , A and D Mathew exemplifies a strong, positive, loving father figure in his 3 children's lives and Case 1:12-cr-00973-PGG Document 287-2 Filed 05/28/14 Page 14 of 29 I've already witnessed the negative impact it has brought upon the children, especially J Your Honor, thank you for taking the time to read my letter and I hope you will take it into consideration. Sincerely, Russell Bacigalupi Teaching Golf Professional Head Teaching Professional for Boca Raton, FL. Junior Golf Case 1:12-cr-00973-PGG Document 287-2 Filed 05/28/14 Page 15 of 29
EXHIBIT 16
Case 1:12-cr-00973-PGG Document 287-2 Filed 05/28/14 Page 16 of 29 April21, 2014 Honorable Paul G. Gardephe United States District Court for the Southern District ofNew York United States Courthouse 40 Foley Square New York, NY 10007 Dear Judge Gardephe, It has been brought to my attention that you will be responsible for sentencing Mathew Martoma, or Mat as I know him, in the coming months. I am aware of Mat's conviction on charges of insider trading, and while I can't begin to diminish the seriousness of this offense, I would like to share information with you that I hope you consider in his sentencing. The Mat that I have known since 2003 does not match the person who has been characterized in the press over the past year and his conviction is the furthest thing I would have expected during Mat's career. This revelation also makes writing to you difficult, as I struggle with this reality. Mat and I first met during pre-orientation at Stanford - Mat, an incoming student in the Business School, and I, in the School of Engineering. We met online with other Stanford grad students looking for roommates to live in off-campus housing. At the time I had found a local ranch-style home in Menlo Park with another business school admit, and the two of us were scouring the incoming class for two more classmates to join us. Mat and one other classmate were the first to answer our call. As an engineering student living with three MBA candidates, I had insecurities about mingling with the MBAs, and more importantly, was concerned about being welcomed by his class since I could have been perceived as an outsider. Mat could not have been more welcoming, and embraced me quickly as one of the group. Stanford academics set aside; Mat and my other roommates had a profound impact on my experience at Stanford. Whether it was volunteering for local charities or enjoying a ski house in Tahoe, Mat was a constant companion throughout my grad school experience. Further, I have no doubt that other students welcomed me without hesitation because of the support from Mat and my roommates. During the course of these two years, I played an active role in Challenge 4 Charity, Stanford's non-profit supporting the Special Olympics, and became engaged in several real estate groups within the business school. Without Mat's influence, I would have never explored these opportunities. Two years later, Mat's friendship impacted my life even more. I had just completed a Masters Degree in Civil Engineering and was working in San Francisco on a large construction project for Lucas Films. I'm can't say whether my drive was due to a yearning to learn more in the classroom or a fondness for those MBA's I had grown close to, but I decided to apply for an MBA myself. .. letting my employer know that I would only apply to two schools (Harvard and Stanford) and if not admitted, would commit myself to working on the Lucas project through completion. As I worked through the application process, Mat encouraged me to approach one of his professors to write a case study about the golf club development industry, which I happen to work in to this day. Much to my surprise, this professor engaged me to execute a case to Case 1:12-cr-00973-PGG Document 287-2 Filed 05/28/14 Page 17 of 29 accompany his coursework, and I have little doubt that this introduction led the way to my own acceptance as a Stanford MBA. Without this introduction and Mat's encouragement, my academic and professional career path may not have what it is today. As our paths crossed at Stanford, Mat exhibited a strong work ethic, and maintained a desire to contribute to not only to the Business School, but also to students throughout the University, and I appreciate his depth of character as he embraced students from all backgrounds. While Mat has exhibited a sincere dedication to helping others through my own experience, I also found later in life that he exhibited a sincere desire to stay connected to past friends. Following business school, I took what many would consider a detour in life ... choosing to develop a private island in the Carribean. Guana Cay consisted of a government clinic, one hardware and grocery story, no stoplights and predominantly golf cart traffic. My wife and I welcomed the adventure, but as two native Southern Californians, moving to the Bahamas was outside our comfort zone. During our two-year stint, no more than six friends from our prior lives took time to visit. .. strange considering we lived in paradise. But with kids, career and other obligations, I can't hold a grudge as my own travel schedule was limited during this period. Mat and Rose, along with their first newborn child, were one of the few couples who took time out of their schedule -touring the Bahamas, island hopping, lobster diving .. .learning about life in a 3rd world country. To this day, Mat's desire to stay connected remains dear to my heart, and I am grateful that we were special enough to warrant his time. You can only imagine how monotonous life deep in the Atlantic Ocean can be, and how much my wife and I appreciated seeing familiar faces in a place so far from our own family. Judge Gardephe, I am aware of the conviction Mat is facing, and I can't belittle the gravity of this charge or the validity of the evidence presented in the case. I can only speak to the fact that while Mat's professional character has been challenged, his personal character in our relationship has been unwavering ... committed to academics, friends and charity. This commitment to giving back has been so strong that he established a foundation to fund various charitable organizations. I know he has the strength of character to contribute to society in a positive way, and have little doubt that he will do so if given the opportunity. In addition, he is the father of three wonderful children, and I find it disheartening to envision the possibility that these kids will grow up without a father through the majority of their adolescence, especially one as thoughtful and caring as Mat. I have spent countless hours thinking about his potential sentence, as I am sure you are as well. I humbly ask that you consider the good that Mat could do in his life-time - well educated, engaged, loved and charitably-minded. Please take a moment to determine how best to serve both Mat and his community, as these two are not mutually exclusive. I have personally benefitted from having him in my life, and I don't think I am along in thinking he has great things to offer for years to come. Please give him this opportunity. Thank you in advance for taking these thoughts into consideration. Sincerely, Scott Birdwell Case 1:12-cr-00973-PGG Document 287-2 Filed 05/28/14 Page 18 of 29
EXHIBIT 17
Case 1:12-cr-00973-PGG Document 287-2 Filed 05/28/14 Page 19 of 29 lII ZO, ZJ | lVEDUE VIEIIOWD, hl Z7Z |ODOIDE |U L. LICEDE UDIIEC oIIE5 I5IIICI LOUII OI IDE oOUIDEID I5IIICI O NEW 1OIK UDIIEC oIIE5 LOUIIDOU5E |OEy UIE NEW 1OIK, N1 J7 EI JUCgE LICEDE, | UDCEI5IDC IDI hIIDEW hIIOH W5 CODVICIEC O ID5ICEI IICIDg DC WI DE 5EDIEDCEC Dy 1OUI |ODOI OD JUDE J !h , ZJ. hy DHE I5 JODIDD OU5CODI, DC | H CO5E IIEDC O hIIDEW, KO5E, DC IDEII IDIEE IIIE CDICIED, JO5DU, lV DC VIC. | WOIK I LICE 5 oOIWIE LDgIDEEI. | CIOVE IOH OO5IOD IO IIEDC IDE III OD IWO 5EIIE OCC5IOD5 DC HEI DEIIDg IDE IE5IIHODy DC IDE CI5 O IDE C5E, | W5 DOIDg DC IyIDg OI D CUIII 5IDCE | DVE 5O HUCD OVE OI hIIDEW DC DI5 EIIIIE HIy. DE DEW5 O IDE gUIIy VEICICI HOVEC HE IO IEI5. | DVE IVEC ID h55CDU5EII5 Hy WDOE IE, EXCEI OI IDE IIHE IDI | WEDI IO UKE OI COEgE, WDICD I5 WDED | II5I HEI hIIDEW. VE DVE DEED IIEDC5 OI OVEI Z yEI5 DC CUIIDg IDI IIHE, WE DVE CEEDIIEC IE5 HO5I IECIOU5 CDIEVEHEDI5EDggEHEDI5, WECUIDg5, DIIID5, DII5H5, DIIIDCy5, DC DODCEC OVEI 5OHE O IE5 IOUgDE5I HOHEDI55ICKDE55, O55 O OVEC ODE5 DU \DI5 III. VDED hIIDEW HOVEC DCK IO OO5IOD HEI DU5IDE55 5CDOO, DE DIOUgDI WIID DIH WODCEIU 5UIII5E, KO5E. | IEHEHDEI IDE DIDE55 DC EXCIIEHEDI WDED DEIIDg DOUI hIIDEW5 IOO5 IO KO5E CUIDg IDE 5UHHEI O ZZ, DC CEEDIIIDg IDEII WECCIDg IDE OOWIDg yEI ID |OIIC. V!ID hIIDEW DU KO5E ID OO5IOD, WE HCE HDy DEW HEHOIIE5. LUI WEEKEDC5 WEIE IEC O HIDI IEUDIOH5 WIID COEgE IIEDC5, WICDIDg DC yIDg 5OII5, III5 IO IDE DECD, DVIDg DIDEUE5 DEI IDE LDIE5 KIVEI, IIIDg IDE DE5I I77 DC ICE CIEH 5DO5 ID IOWD, WICDIDg HOVIE5, DC jU5I WIDCIDg COWD IEI ODg WOIK WEEK. |D CI, hIIDEW DC KO5E5 II5I DDy, JO5DU, W5 DOID IEI KO5E5 WIEI DIOKE I IDE EDC O KEC oOX1DKEE5 gHE IDI IDEy WEIE IIEDCIDg. | gUE55 JO5DU W5 5O EXCIIEC DOUI IDE KEC oOX WIDDIDg IDI DE 5IIIEC CDEEIIDg IOH ID5ICE O KO5E5 DEy! | H IOUC IO 5y IDI | W5 JO5DU5 II5I VI5IIOI I IDE DO5II, DC JO5DU5 II5I OUIIDg IOH IDE DO5II W5 IO jOID HE DC Hy IDEI OI UDCD ID IDE CIIy. UIIDg IDE yEI5 IDI hIIDEW DC KO5E IVEC ID OO5IOD, Hy HOIDEI, LI7DEID, W5 CIgDO5EC WIID DOD5HOKEI5 UDg CDCEI. hy HOIDEI W5 DEUIIU WOHD WIID 5EDCEI IgUIE DC CODIgIOU5 5HIE. l IgUIE 5KIEI ID DEI yOUID, DC 5CDOO IECDEI CUIIDg HIDE, 5DE W5 OVEC Dy DC Case 1:12-cr-00973-PGG Document 287-2 Filed 05/28/14 Page 20 of 29 DC gIEI 5ED5E O DUHOI. oDE U5EC IO jOKE WIID DEI 5IUCEDI5 IDI DEI OOC yIHIC W5 CIUy IDVEIIEC, WIID D ICE CIEH CODE OD IO. oDE WOUC IE DEI 5IUCEDI5 WIID 5IIIgDI CE IDI IgE 5EIVIDg O ICE CIEH W5 D5OUIEy DECE55Iy OI gOOC DEID! Oy IDE IIHE hOH W5 CIgDO5EC WIID UDg CDCEI, WE WEIE IOC IDI DEI IOgDO5I5 W5 OOI. VDED hIIDEW DEIC IDE DEW5 O Hy HOIDEI5 IDE55, DE 5EDI Hy HOIDEI gII ID IDE HI. |I W5 DIDIOOH Dg ID DIIgDI OWEIy IIEID WIID DEI IDIII5 5EWD OUI5ICE, DC IDE gII HCE Hy HOIDEI 5O Dy. hy HOIDEI CIEC ID Z7. | IEHEHDEI hIIDEW, KO5E, JO5DU DC IIIE lV IIEDCIDg DEI WKE. UIIDg IDEII VI5II, hIIDEW DC DI5 HIy jOIDEC HE IO HKE III IO OIIgDH5, Hy HOIDEI5 VOIIIE ICE CIEH 5IOIE. hy IDEI, KODC, W IIDEI I hCLIIEI DC LDgI5D LL| ID OO5IOD, W5 CIgDO5EC DC COUIgEOU5y OUgDI DIID CDCEI IOH ZJZJJ. lHEI Hy HOIDEI 55EC Wy, | HOVEC DCK DOHE WIID Hy IDEI WDO W5 5UHEIIDg IOH III Iy5I5 OD DI5 EI 5ICE IOH IDE DIID CDCEI. UIIDg IDI5 IIHE, hIIDEW W5 COD5IDI 5OUICE O 5UOII DC CVICE. LUy IHOIIDI, Hy IDEI EDjOyEC 5EDCIDg IIHE WIID hIIDEW. hy IEDI5 COD5ICEIEC hIIDEW DC KO5E 5 CO5E IIEDC5, EVICEDCEC Dy IDE CI IDI hIIDEW I5 IDE ODy ODE O Hy IIEDC5 IOH UKE OD IDEII LDII5IH5 CIC I5I. hIIDEW5 HOVE IO LODDECIICUI DEDEC 5UCCEDy, DC ID IDE yEI5 IDI OOWEC, hIIDEW5 HIy gIEW IgEI. VE 5IyEC ID IOUCD, DC HDy O OUI IECEDI HEHOIIE5 IOgEIDEI IDVOVE hIIDEW5 CDICIED. hIIDEW5 OCE5I, JO5DU, ODCE CEC HE I Hy CE5K ID h55CDU5EII5 IEC WIID EXCIIEHEDI IEI DE HCE DI5 II5I DIICIE ID gO, KDOWIDg DOW HUCD | IKE IO gO, DC IDVIIIDg HE IO 5DIE ID DI5 jOyU HOHEDI. LD III IO IDE hU5EUH O |IDE lII5 ID OO5IOD WIID hIIDEW5 HIy, | IEHEHDEI lV, hIIDEW5 HICCE CDIC 5KIDg IO DE ID ICIUIE WIID HE DEXI IO DEI VOIIIE IIWOIK, hODEI5 LIIE5. LVEIy IIHE | OOK I IDI ICIUIE, | 5HIE. lDOIDEI IIHE, WDED | W3 VI5IIIDg hIIDEW, EIy ID IDE EVEDIDg hIIDEW5 yOUDgE5I, VIC, DEIC HE 5y IDI | EDjOy CHIDg, 5O IEI IDI EVEDIDg DE WDIEC IO 5EE OD IDE OOI DEXI IO Hy DEC IO HKE II IKE WE WEIE CHIDg. hIIDEW5 CDICIED IE VEIy IDOUgDIU, IKE hIIDEW. 1OUI |ODOI, WDED yOU COD5ICEI hIIDEW5 5EDIEDCE, E5E 5O COD5ICEI DI5 IDDOCEDI DC IEDCEI OVIDg yOUDg HIy. |E5E COD5ICEI DOW HUCD hIIDEW D5 5UEIEC CUE IO IDE UDICIIy IDI IDI5 C5E D5 IECy IECEIVEC. hIIDEW I5 IE5ECIU DC OVIDg DU5DDC DC IDEI, DC VEIy gOOC IIEDC. hIIDEW I5 HD WIID IDE COUIgE DC CEIEIHIDIIOD IO EID DC gIOW IOH DI5 HI5IKE5. hIIDEW I5 IDIEIgEDI, CECICIEC DC COH55IODIE. |E I5 CDIIIDE HD WDO D5 Wy5 gIVED DC DEVEI DO5IEC. | DOE yOU WI 5EE IDE HD IDI | H IOUC IO C DE5I IIEDC. oIDCEIEy,
JODIDD OU5CODI Case 1:12-cr-00973-PGG Document 287-2 Filed 05/28/14 Page 21 of 29
EXHIBIT 18
Case 1:12-cr-00973-PGG Document 287-2 Filed 05/28/14 Page 22 of 29 Case 1:12-cr-00973-PGG Document 287-2 Filed 05/28/14 Page 23 of 29
EXHIBIT 19
Case 1:12-cr-00973-PGG Document 287-2 Filed 05/28/14 Page 24 of 29 Case 1:12-cr-00973-PGG Document 287-2 Filed 05/28/14 Page 25 of 29 Case 1:12-cr-00973-PGG Document 287-2 Filed 05/28/14 Page 26 of 29
EXHIBIT 20
Case 1:12-cr-00973-PGG Document 287-2 Filed 05/28/14 Page 27 of 29 March 2014 Honorable Paul G. Southern District of New York United States Courthouse 40 Foley Square New York, NY 10007 Dear the Permit me to introduce name is Reverend Carmine J. DiBiase. I have been a close and mentor of Mathew Martoma for many years. Mathevvs frorn High school and the Martoma Mathew church where I served as an associate in Florida. I arn aware of the conviction handed the jury in the case against Mathew. I offer this letter in of Mathew's character as you consider his the years that I was closest to Mathew and his I came to know him as a young rnan of the career I have been asked to write letters finest character and of recommendation for a number of young etc Of the many endorsements I have made for young over the years, none confidence and enthusiasm as I had for Mathew. His of character and for life and the many causes he involved himself with was not involved with. of nwre seif centered generation that I IN2S the numerous centered activities that was involved in Local in which he amassed well over 500 700 hours of service. He was also selected as a student ambassador to the former Soviet Union where he raised his own funds for with with him hundreds of donations that would be distributed to children in Russian I am aware that Mathew served his School in about every that is for a young person to do. that I had with Mathew has to do with our mutual involvement in In my vears of countless hours even when it was tile of skill and Scout the Order of the Arrow or merit-based prograrns and Commander. Even then, initiation at the national level is not guaranteed. must pass several and skills based exams, as well as the Mathew was eager to see and , Mathew and I both reached this on our which was no easy Case 1:12-cr-00973-PGG Document 287-2 Filed 05/28/14 Page 28 of 29 In Mathew's determination to a me and that his character. the outdoor skills with one match stick. If a cannot start a fire with one their Frontiersman is over for that year. Ahead of this trial Mathew learned how to start a fire with flint and steel so when the tester gave Mathew the match he didn't need it all. It took many hours of but off in the end. When Mathew used the flint and he amazed everyone at the I'm sure it must have unfair) to others around but knew it was the and his like Mathew think outside the box and that's what makes Scouting is one activity that benefited others. After Mathew his Frontiersman's as a Senior Guide to lead the other with he can<e back to our and other younger for their Frontiersrnan Later in Mathew tried to find a curriculum from difficult horne situations. When he couldn't he convinced a to the needs of children from a local for kids who weren't as versed in their education. That is the Mathew I of into the benefits he received in life and share those with others. Your I am aware that you must have many factors to consider as you formulate an sentence in this case. I do not presume to know much about the law and its However, l ask that vou would consider this letter in your deliberation to Mathew as a voung ambition and vision. Thank you for your consideration. Case 1:12-cr-00973-PGG Document 287-2 Filed 05/28/14 Page 29 of 29