Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Mouriel Roubini 67 March 20327( NGreeceKs <ri"ate 4reditors 're the Cucky 2nesN( The '-
Cist( FT(com( Retrie"ed 2 May 203-(
IMF and the Greek economy - Routos 30
&as recently confirmed by the +uro!ean 4ommissionKs official autumn economic
forecast 2032% finding that if no ne& e,tra Ndebt restructureN is offered% then the debt-
to-G;< ratio &ould rise into ne& heights of 377 !ercent in 2032 and 3 !ercent in
203-(
9
The e,act reasons for the failure of the t&o Greek !rograms% lie on the sim!le
com!arison of IMF*s estimations and the reality that follo&ed 6figure 7(
Figure 2
The IMF*s !ro.ections about the effects of austerity are based on certain
assum!tions( ;es!ite the Fund*s su!!ort for !rotecting s!ending on !o"erty
alle"iation% o"erall e,!enditures cuts including !ublic in"estment and !ublic sector
em!loyment could ha"e detrimental conse1uences for long-term gro&th and
de"elo!ment !ros!ects( 's IMF*s main focus is the re!ayment of !ublic debt through
go"ernment budget*s sur!luses% and the lo&ering of !ublic debt to G;< ratio at
sustainable le"els% one should ha"e in mind the fraction &here the numerator is
!ublic debt and the denominator is G;<( Ae ha"e to decrease the numerator and
increase the denominator( Ahich in turn means increase in !ublic re"enues% and
decrease in !ublic s!ending for the numerator% and gro&th of the economy 6increase
in"estments% boost internal consum!tion% increase e,!orts7 for the denominator( The
im!osed austerity measures and the subse1uent cuts in !ublic s!ending mainly
through &age cuts% !ension cuts% health and education cuts% s1ueeBed li1uidity in the
internal market% &hich in turn increased unem!loyment% businesses defaults% non-
!erforming loans in the banking system( The do&nturn s!iral of the economy &as
una"oidable( <aul @rugman% in his article /?o& the 4ase of 'usterity ?as 4rumbled0%
notes>
9
N+uro!ean economic forecast - autumn 2032N 6<;F7( +uro!ean 4ommission( 7 Mo"ember
2032( Retrie"ed 7 May 203-(
IMF and the Greek economy - Routos 33
/The turn to austerity after '%#%, however, was so drastic, particularly in 3uropean debtor nations, that
the usual cautions lose most of their force. Greece imposed spending cuts and ta! increases amounting
to #5 percent of G)*:.and unli1e the half7hearted efforts at stimulus, these cuts were sustained and
indeed intensified year after year. 4o how did austerity actually wor1, The answer is that the results
were disastrous75ust about as one would have predicted from te!tboo1 macroeconomics(
30
%'&%L(SI'&S
The &ell-kno&n long lasting &eaknesses of the Greek economy are fueled by &idely
s!read ta, e"asion% corru!tion% bureaucracy% im!artiality% and an e,tensi"e
underground economy 6bet&een 22H and 29H as a !ercentage of G;< for the years
399 to 20307
33
( 's a conse1uence Greece is suffering from lo& !roducti"ity% lack of
inno"ation% absence of Foreign ;irect In"estments( In addition to that% one of the
basic "ulnerabilities of the Greek state is the lo& 1uality of go"ernance% and the
subse1uent result of inca!ability to create go"erning institutions that &ill !romote
social trust( 's Rothstein notes>
;A high level of generali6ed trust is caused by what has been called high <uality government
institutions, especially the institutions that implement public policies. The central basic norm
for these institutions is impartiality. This implies that things li1e discrimination =whether based
on ethnicity, gender, class, etc.>, corruption =in its many forms>, clientelism, nepotism and
political favoritism are very rare or non?e!istent when public officials or professionals
implement public policies:.Thus, designing institutions that implement public policy is to
create =or destroy> social trust.0
#'
Greek !olitical elites !ro"ed to be inca!able in im!osing the needed reforms that
&ould enable Greece to e,!erience sustainable gro&th along &ith fiscal disci!line
and social !ros!erity( The inability of the Greek !olitical elites to im!ose these
necessary reforms of the Greek economy and society% in order to !ro"ide a decent
!resence of Greece in the euro area% has long-li"ing roots in the "arious mechanisms
&hich !re"ail in Greece( Rent-seeking interest grou!s dominate the Greek economy
and society% earning a comfortable income &ithout !ro"iding any &ork at all( These
rent seeking grou!s interact in numerous formations and alliances% su!!orting each
other% e"ery time a reform !olitician or an +# directi"e threatens their rents( These
grou!s are re!resented by key actors in the Greek !olitical arena% and the Greek
economy( They strongly o!!ose any reform &hich may alter the status 1uo% and !ut
in danger the ability to continue earning their immoral and unethical rents( 2n the
other hand the rationally ignorant "oters% suitably mani!ulated by the media 6&hich
are o&ned in a large !ro!ortion by re!resentati"es of the aforementioned rent
seeking grou!s% or members of these grou!s7% also o!!ose any reform% because they
are con"inced that the reforms &ill hurt either their economic or their social &ell-
being( Thus they become a large !ressure grou! against reforms 6and actually
30
htt!>LL&&&(nybooks(comLarticlesLarchi"esL203-L.unL0:Lho&-case-austerity-has-crumbledLQ
!aginationGfalse
33
$chneider Friedrich 620307% The @nfluence of the economic crisis on the shadow economy in
Germany, Greece and the other A3B) countries in '%#%& +hat can be doneQ !a!er a"ailable at>
htt!>LL&&&(econ(.ku(atLmembersL$chneiderLfilesL!ublicationsLCatestResearch2030L$had+cGreec
eP$e!t2030(!df
32
Rothstein 5o 620337% 4reating a $ustainable $olidaristic $ociety> ' Manual% My Tid Ra!!ort
9% 'renagru!!en% $tockholm% $&eden% !( 37(
IMF and the Greek economy - Routos 32
against their o&n interests7% acting in fa"or of the rent seeking interest grou!s( The
una"oidable result is the entra!ment of any reform !oliticians% the failure of any
reform efforts% and ultimately the general go"ernance failure(
3-
Greek !olitical elites
ha"e lost their legitimacy and so ha"e the !olicies that are im!lemented since the
first Mo# had been signed% bet&een the Greek go"ernment and the Troika( <eo!le
are e,tremely frustrated because the mandate holders delegated to Troika the
res!onsibility to design the domestic !olicies( 5uilding social trust% through the radical
reform of institutions% is one of the ma.or !rere1uisites for the ad.ustment of the
Greek society( The economic crisis and the im!osed austerity measures intensified
all these !roblems and had disastrous effects in both the economy and the society(
Greece is e,!eriencing for the first time since AAII% such high le"els of
unem!loyment% e,treme !o"erty for large !arts of the !o!ulation% marginaliBation of
the &eak !arts of the society( There is an urgent need for an e,!ansionary economic
!olicy% in order to o"ercome the crisis and to re"erse these de"astating results(
2ther&ise the sliding &ill continue and country*s default &ould be the only solution(
'nd in this case% social unrest cannot be e,cluded from the !robable outcomes(
3-
Mitso!oulos Michael and <elagidis Theodore 620337% Cnderstanding the Brisis in Greece From Doom
to Dust% <algra"e Macmillan% #@(
IMF and the Greek economy - Routos 3-
REFERE&%ES
'nderson Oeffrey 6203-7% Ireland and Greece> ' Tale of T&o Fiscal 'd.ustments% The Institute of
International Finance Research Mote% March 3-% 203-(
'ntoniadis 'ntonis%620307% ;ebt 4risis as a Global +mergency> The +uro!ean +conomic 4onstitution
and 2ther Greek Fables% The +uro!ean #nion and Global +mergencies> ' Ca& and <olicy
'nalysis% 'ntonis 'ntoniadis% Robert $chRtBe% +leanor $!a"enta% eds(% ?art <ublishing% 2033 (
'"ailable at $$RM> htt!>LLssrn(comLabstractG3:9902(
'rdagna $il"ia% 4aselli Francesco 620327% The <olitical +conomy of the Greek ;ebt 4risis> ' Tale of
T&o 5ailouts% C$+ 4entre for +conomic <erformance $!ecial <a!er Mo( 2D% C$+% March 2032(
'rghyrou Michael and Tsoukalas Oohn 620307% The Greek ;ebt 4risis> Cikely 4auses% Mechanics and
2utcomes% B34ifo +or1ing *aper Mo( -2::% Mo"ember 2030(
5enes Oaromir% @umhof Michael% The 4hicago <lan Re"isited% IMF Aorking <a!er A<L32L202% 'ugust
2032(
5retton Aoods <ro.ect 6203-7% The Troika $etting a ;efault Tra!Q% 5retton Aoods <ro.ect #!date =%
3- February 203-% htt!>LL&&&(bretton&oods!ro.ect(orgLtroika=(
5roome 'ndre 620307% The International Monetary Fund% crisis management and the credit crunch%
'ustralian Oournal of International 'ffairs Jol( :=% Mo( 3% !!( -7-D=% February 2030(
5uira 'riel 6200-7% 'n 'nalysis of IMF 4onditionality% <a!er !re!ared for the SJI Technical Grou!
Meeting of the Intergo"ernmental Grou! of 2=% <ort of $!ain% Trinidad and Tobago% February 3--
3=% 200-(
5uiter Aillem% Rahbari +brahim and Michels Ouergen 620337% The im!lications of intra-euro area
imbalances in credit flo&s% 4+<R <olicy Insight Mo( D7% 'ugust 2033(
4ara&ay Teri% Rickard $te!hanie and 'nner Mark 620327% International Megotiations and ;omestic
<olitics> The case of IMF labor market conditionality% International 2rganiBation% 4ambridge
#ni"ersity <ress% "ol( ::6037% !ages 27-:3(
;adush #ri 620307% *aradigm 2ost& The 3uro @n Brisis% 4arnegie +ndo&ment for International <eace%
Aashington% ;(4(% #$'(
;ar"as Tsolt 620327% The Greek ;ebt Tra!> 'n +sca!e <lan% 5ruegel <olicy 4ontribution Issue 2032L39%
Mo"ember 2032(
;ellas ?arris% Ta"las George 620327% The road to Ithaca> the Gold $tandard% the +uro and the origins of
the Greek so"ereign debt crisis% 5ank of Greece Aorking <a!er Mo( 3=9( Mo"ember 2032(
;e $antis Roberto 620327% The +uro 'rea $o"ereign ;ebt 4risis> $afe ?a"en% 4redit Rating 'gencies
and the $!read of the Fe"er from Greece% Ireland 'nd <ortugal% 3uropean Bentral Dan1 +or1ing
*aper 4eries Mo 3=39% February 2032(
;okos Thanos 620327% Aho Cost GreeceQ The Geo!olitical 4onse1uences of the Greek 4risis%
+CI'M+< <olicy <a!er Mo( 3% February 2032(
;Rbel ?ans-Ooachim 620327% 'fter the )Ahate"er-It takes* 5ail-2ut of +uro - Tone 5ank 5ondholders>
The +uroBone*s &asted 2!!ortunity for a 5anking #nion that <rotects $o"ereign Finance%
4+$ifo Forum =L2032(
+4 ;irectorate-General for +conomic and Financial 'ffair 620307% The +conomic 'd.ustment
<rogramme for Greece% 2ccasional <a!ers :3% May 2030(
+4 ;irectorate-General for +conomic and Financial 'ffair 620337% The +conomic 'd.ustment
<rogramme for Ireland% 2ccasional <a!ers 7:% February 2033(
IMF and the Greek economy - Routos 3=
+4 ;irectorate-General for +conomic and Financial 'ffair 620337% The +conomic 'd.ustment
<rogramme for <ortugal% 2ccasional <a!ers 79% Oune 2033(
+4 ;irectorate-General for +conomic and Financial 'ffair 620327% The $econd +conomic 'd.ustment
<rogramme for Greece% 2ccasional <a!ers 9=% March 2032(
+4 ;irectorate-General for +conomic and Financial 'ffair 620327% The $econd +conomic 'd.ustment
<rogramme for Greece First Re"ie& - ;ecember 2032% 2ccasional <a!ers 32-% ;ecember 2032(
+uro!ean Met&ork on ;ebt and ;e"elo!ment 6200:7% Aorld 5ank and IMF conditionality> a
de"elo!ment in.ustice% +urodad Re!ort% Oune 200:(
+yraud Cuc% 5adia MarialuB Moreno 6203-7% Too $mall to FailQ $ubnational $!ending <ressures in
+uro!e% IMF Aorking <a!er A<L3-L=:% February 203-(
Featherstone @e"in 6200-7% Greece and +M#> 5et&een +,ternal +m!o&erment and ;omestic
Julnerability% Eournal of Bommon Far1et 4tudies, Jol( =3% Mo D% !!( 92-9=0(
Featherstone @e"in 6200D7% Introduction> )Modernisation* and the $tructural 4onstraints of Greek
<olitics% +est 3uropean *olitics% Jol( 2% Mo( 2% !!( 22- 2=3(
Featherstone @e"in 620337% The Greek $o"ereign ;ebt 4risis and +M#> ' Failing $tate in a $ke&ed
Regime% Eournal of Bommon Far1et 4tudies, Jol( =9% Mo( 2( !!( 39-237(
Foundation for +conomic and Industrial Research 6I25+7 620307% The Greek +conomy% Uuarterly
5ulletin Mo :0% Ouly 2030(
Frankel Oeffrey 620337% 2"er-o!timism in forecasts by official budget agencies and its im!lications%
A!ford Geview of 3conomic *olicy% Jol( 27% Mo( =% !!( D-:D:2(
Gros ;aniel 620307% Greece and the IMF% 4+<$ 4ommentary% 2= March 2030(
GuraBiu Rudi and Te1o +!idamn 620327% $o"ereign ;ebt 4risis and its Im!act on Aorld Markets% @D)3
Geport% Oune 2032(
?acker% Oacob 620327% The politics of redistribution% 2,ford !resentation% <olicy Met&orkL F+<$% 2--
Ouly 2032(
?an Sue 620327% The Oourney of 'usterity in +uro!e The !ast% !resent and future of +#*s debt crisis and
austerity !aths% Global Infrastructure 'sset Management% 4hicago Il( #$'% Oune 2032(
?ayo 5ernd 620077% Is +uro!ean Monetary <olicy '!!ro!riate for the +M# Q in The Travails of the
3uro6one% 4obham ;a"id 6ed(7% <algra"e Macmillan% #@(
?iggins Matthe& and @litgaard Thomas 620337% $a"ing Imbalances and the +uro 'rea $o"ereign ;ebt
4risis% Burrent @ssues in 3conomics and Finance Jol( 37% Mo( D% !!( 3-33(
IMF 6200:7% Greece> $elected Issues% IMF 4ountry Re!ort Mo( 0:LD% Oanuary 200:(
IMF 620307% Greece> Cetter of Intent% Memorandum of +conomic and Financial <olicies% and Technical
Memorandum of #nderstanding% March 9% 2032(
IMF 620307% Greece> Re1uest for $tand-5y 'rrangement% IMF 4ountry Re!ort Mo( 30L333% May 2030(
IMF 620307% Greece> $taff Re!ort on Re1uest for $tand-5y 'rrangement% IMF 4ountry Re!ort Mo(
30L330% May 2030(
IMF 6203-7% Greece> First and $econd Re"ie&s #nder the +,tended 'rrangement #nder the +,tended
Fund Facility% Re1uest for Aai"er of '!!licability% Modification of <erformance 4riteria% and
Re!hasing of 'ccess% IMF 4ountry Re!ort Mo( 3-L20% Oanuary 203-(
IMF Inde!endent +"aluation 2ffice 620077% $tructural 4onditionality in IMF-$u!!orted <rograms
+"aluation Re!ort% 2007(
IMF and the Greek economy - Routos 3D
IMF 620307% Ireland Memorandum of #nderstanding on $!ecific +conomic <olicy 4onditionality%
Mo"ember 2 2030(
IMF 620337% <ortugal Memorandum of #nderstanding on $!ecific +conomic <olicy 4onditionality% May
37 2033(
IMF $trategy% <olicy% and Re"ie& ;e!artment 620337% 2033 Re"ie& of 4onditionality 2"er"ie& <a!er%
Oune 39% 2032(
International Monetary Fund 620327% Global Financial 4tability Geport7 Restoring 4onfidence and
<rogressing on Reforms% IMF <ublications $er"ices% Aashington ;4(% #$'(
Oeanne 2li"ier% 2stry Oonathan% and Tettelmeyer Oeromin 62007% ' Theory of International 4risis
Cending and IMF 4onditionality% IMF Aorking <a!er A<L0L2-:% 2ctober 200(
Oost Thomas% $eitB FranB 620327% The Role of the IMF in the +uro!ean ;ebt 4risis% ?'A im ;ialog
Aeidener ;iskussions!a!iere Mr( -2% Oanuary 2032(
@olb Robert 620337 , 4overeign )ebt From 4afety to )efault% OohnAiley E $ons% Inc(% ?oboken% Me&
Oersey(
Ciddle Roger 6ed(7 620097% After the crisis& A Hew 4ocio7economic settlement for the 3C% <olicy
Met&ork( Condon% #@(
CRtB $usanne and @ranke Matthias 620307% The +uro!ean Rescue of the Aashington 4onsensusQ +#
and IMF Cending to 4entral and +astern +uro!ean 4ountries% C$+ )+uro!e in Uuestion*
;iscussion <a!er $eries Mo( 22L2030% May 2030(
CyrintBis 4hristos 620337% Greek <olitics in the +ra of +conomic 4risis> Reassessing 4auses and
+ffects, Iellenic Abservatory or the 243, Gree43 *aper Mo( =D% March 2033(
Manolo!oulos Oason 620337% Greece0s ;Adious )ebt0 The 2ooting of the Iellenic Gepublic by the 3uro,
the *olitical 3lite and the @nvestment Bommunity% 'nthem <ress% MV(
Mates Me"en 620327% IMF-+# 4onditionality in Greece> Cearning from mistakesQ% $outh +ast +uro!ean
$tudies at 2,ford% 2!inion <iece% Oune 2032(
Mc Ternan Michael 62032>, )istributional conflicts in the C4 and 3urope% <olicy Met&ork <a!er%
Mo"ember 2032(
Micossi $tefano 620327% #nholy com!romise in the euroBone and ho& to right it% B3*4 *olicy Drief Mo(
277% Ouly 2032(
Mitso!oulos Michael and <elagidis Theodore 620337% Cnderstanding the Brisis in Greece From Doom to
Dust% <algra"e Macmillan% #@(
Muchhala 5humika 620337% The IMF*s Financial 4risis Coans> Mo 4hange in 4onditionalities% Third
Aorld Met&ork% 2033(
Melson Rebecca et( al( 620307% Fre1uently 'sked Uuestions about IMF In"ol"ement in the +uroBone
;ebt 4risis% 4ongressional Research $er"ice Re!ort Mo( 7-D700 R=32-9(
Melson Rebecca et( al( 620337% Greece*s ;ebt 4risis> 2"er"ie&% <olicy Res!onses% and Im!lications%
BG4 Geport for Bongress Mo( 7-D700% 'ugust 2033(
<araske"o!oulos 4hristos 620327% 4orru!tion% Ine1uality 'nd Trust> the Greek "icious circle from
incremental ad.ustment to /critical .uncture0Q% Benter for 3uropean 4tudies at Iarvard Cniversity,
Apen Forum B34 *aper 4eries Mo( 3-% 2032(
<etrakis <anagiotis 620327% The Gree1 3conomy and the Brisis& challenges and responses% $!ringer-
Jerlag% 5erlin% ?eidelberg(
<etmesidou Maria 620337% Is the +#-IMF /rescue !lan0 dealing a blo& to the Greek &elfare stateQ%
4R2< <o"erty 5rief % Oanuary 2033(
IMF and the Greek economy - Routos 3:
Rossi Janessa and 'guilera Rodrigo ;elgado 620307% Mo <ainless $olution to Greece*s ;ebt 4risis%
Bhatham Iouse *rogramme *aper @3 << 2030L0-% February 2030(
Rothstein 5o 620337% Breating a 4ustainable 4olidaristic 4ociety& A Fanual% My Tid Ra!!ort 9%
'renagru!!en% $tockholm% $&eden(
$amitas 'risteidis% Tsakalos Ioannis 6203-7% ?o& can a small country affect the +uro!ean economyQ
The Greek contagion !henomenon% Oournal of International Financial Markets% Institutions E
Money2D 6203-7 !!( 3 -2(
$auernheimer @arlhans 620337% Greece> 5ail-2ut <ackages% 4urrent 'ccount and Foreign ;ebt% 4+$ifo
Forum =L2033(
$chneider Friedrich 620307% The @nfluence of the economic crisis on the shadow economy in Germany,
Greece and the other A3B) countries in '%#%& +hat can be doneQ !a!er a"ailable at>
htt!>LL&&&(econ(.ku(atLmembersL$chneiderLfilesL!ublicationsLCatestResearch2030L$had+cGreec
eP$e!t2030(!df
$chneider Friedrich 620307% The @nfluence of the economic crisis on the underground economy in
Germany and the other A3B)7countries in '%#%& a =further> increase% !a!er a"ailable at>
htt!>LL&&&(econ(.ku(atLmembersL$chneiderLfilesL!ublicationsLCatestResearch2030L$had+c2+4;
2030(!df
$ch&arcB $te"en 620327% $o"ereign ;ebt Restructuring 2!tions> 'n 'nalytical 4om!arison% ?ar"ard
5usiness Ca& Re"ie&% Jol( 2L2032% !!( 9D-323(
$heel 'lok 620327% IMF and the +uroBone - ' ;e"elo!ing 4ountry <ers!ecti"e% ;e!artment of
+conomic 'ffairs% Ministry of Finance% Go"ernment of India +conomic E <olitical Aeekly% "ol(
SCJII Mo( D2% !!( 20-22(
$inn ?ans-Aerner 620307% Rescuing +uro!e% B34ifo Forum% Jol( 33% 'ugust 2030(
TorbiWrn @.ell 6200-7% ;estination +uro!e% The !olitical and economic gro&th of a continent% Manchester
#ni"ersity <ress% Manchester% #@% 200-(
Tsoukalis Coukas 620327% $teering +uro!e out of the 4risis, *olicy Hetwor1 *aper% 2ctober 2032(
Aeisbrot Mark% Montecino Ouan 'ntonio 620327% More <ain% Mo Gain for Greece> Is the +uro Aorth the
4osts of <roX4yclical Fiscal <olicy and Internal ;e"aluationQ% 4enter for +conomic and <olicy
Research% Aashington% ;(4(% #$'% February 2032(
Voung 5rigitte and $emmler Ailli 620337% The +uro!ean $o"ereign ;ebt 4risis> Is Germany to 5lameQ%
German *olitics and 4ociety% Issue 97 Jol( 29% Mo( 3 $!ring 2033(
+YZ[\]^_` a\bcZd\` 6203-7% efgh] iZgjkl mb] ckn aoogh] 6eia7% pZbfknb]q] r_stjk% u\Zqobdl
203-(
vbwd\dxodY yczoo] 620327% un]\cY{b]_zl _]b _dbn[nb_zl t\b\c|jtbl c[n \dobcb_|n jc]stZ}ckc]l cdY
i~p% njcbcdxcd aZm]jq]l yaa% ]Z]ckZkc`Zbd eb_dndfb_|n _]b dbn[nb_|n a{toq{t[n%
v]Zcbdl 2032(