APPROVED A

Approved without exception

APPROVED WITH COMMENTS AC
Approved Subject to Incorporation of comments
RETURNED FOR CORRECTION RT
Insufficient Information/ Detail
Resubmit for Approval
REJECTED RJ
Complete redesign required
RECEIVED FOR INFORMATION I
Returned without comments
RECEIVED FOR INFORMATION IC
Returned with comments
any obligations covered under contract
Engineer:
Discipline:
Date:
Note: Approval or comments does not relieve the Contractor of
Pyry Energy
TWO(2) X 500MW
MONG DUONG 1 THERMAL POWER PLANT
David Langhorne
Senior Mec Engineer
5-Mar-13
Pyry Comment
Two(2) x 500MW Mong Duong 1 Thermal Power Plant Project

Dwg. / Doc. Title
Outline Drawing for LP-3
Low Pressure FWH
Dwg. / Doc. No. MD1-0-V-114-01-00001
HDEC DT No. MD1-HDH-EVN-X-1036 Submitted Date 2012.11.02 Rev. B
Pyry TR No. 9A000323-002559 Received Date 2012.11.28
New HDEC DT No. MD1-HDH-EVN-X-2233 Re-Submitted Date 2013.02.05 Rev. C
Status Received for Information Returned with Comments

Page1 / 4
No. Pyrys Comments Contractors Reply / Action
G General comments
G1 <Pyrys Comments on Rev.A>
HDEC is requested to check carefully all relative
latest P&I drawings, piping arrangement drawing
to make sure that nozzle number, nozzle size
and nozzle orientation on the outline drawing are
matched.
<Contractors Reply / Action on Rev.A>
Noted.




<Contractors Reply / Action on Rev.B>
Closed.

G2 <Pyrys Comments on Rev.A>
Please confirm the heaters shall be provided
with the ASME U stamp.






<Pyrys Comments on Rev.B>
Closed.
<Contractors Reply / Action on Rev.A>
Refer to Contract GTR 4.13 All pressure
vessels and heat exchangers shall be
manufactured by an approved ASME U-stamp
holder.
SEC is an ASME U-stamp holder. Heaters are
manufactured by an ASME U-stamp holder, but
are not provided with U-stamp.

G3 <Pyrys Comments on Rev.A>
Condensate water levels (low alarm, normal
level control, high alarm, emergency control) in
the shell side shall be shown.
.
<Pyrys Comments on Rev.B>
Closed.
<Contractors Reply / Action on Rev.A>
Reflected.
G4 <Pyrys Comments on Rev.A>
Shell side and tube side operating condition
(inlet/outlet temperature and pressure of steam
and water) at VWO condition to be included in
the design data table.

<Pyrys Comments on Rev.B>
Noted, please include a cross reference to this
document on each Heater Outline Drawing.

<Pyrys Comments on Rev.C>
Reference document should include the
technical data sheet in additional to the
mentioned drawings.
It is noted that the list of reference drawings is
on hold at present so please add the technical
data sheet to the reference list.
<Contractors Reply / Action on Rev.A>
For VWO operating condition, please refer to the
Technical Data Sheet. MD1-0-V-114-09-00002



<Contractors Reply / Action on Rev.B>
Reflected.
Page2 / 4

No. Pyrys Comments Contractors Reply / Action
G5 <Pyrys Comments on Rev.A>
Water velocity in the tube side shall be indicated
in the design data table.


<Pyrys Comments on Rev.B>
Noted, see G4 above.

<Pyrys Comments on Rev.C>
Reference document should include the
technical data sheet in additional to the
mentioned drawings.
<Contractors Reply / Action on Rev.A>
For water velocity in the tube side, please refer
to the Technical Data Sheet. MD1-0-V-114-09-
00002

<Contractors Reply / Action on Rev.B>
Reflected.
G6 <Pyrys Comments on Rev.A>
Include the Heater KKS identifier in the
document title.

<Pyrys Comments on Rev.B>
Closed.
<Contractors Reply / Action on Rev.A>
Reflected.
G7 <Pyrys Comments on Rev.A>
Confirm how the tubes are expanded into the
tube sheet. Indicate whether there is a seal
weld.

<Pyrys Comments on Rev.B>
The question is how are the tubes expanded?
The fact that they are expanded was already
noted on the Rev A document.

<Pyrys Comments on Rev.C>
Closed.
<Contractors Reply / Action on Rev.A>
Refer to the design table on outline drawings.
LP Heater : Expand only
HP Heater : Expand +Seal weld

<Contractors Reply / Action on Rev.B>
Please refer to the ATT#1
(Tube Expanding Procedure Sample)
Drawing/documents to also be provided for
all Heaters.


D1 <Pyrys Comments on Rev.A>
Design Calculation Sheets for heat transfer
calculations and to support the data provided in
the tables on the outline drawing.
The calculation document should also identify
the number or percentage of surplus tubes.

<Pyrys Comments on Rev.B>
Noted. The margin of spare tubes over the
calculated tube requirements should be 3%.

Closed as a comment on these documents
however the percentage of spare tubes shall be
identified in the calculations.

<Contractors Reply / Action on Rev.A>
SEC will submit Design Calculation Sheets for
heat transfer calculations later. SEC has
considered margin for heat transfer surface. And
also, SEC has shop margins for tube plugging of
four(4) to five(5) ea.

<Contractors Reply / Action on Rev.B>
Closed.
D2 <Pyrys Comments on Rev.A>
Design Detail Drawings which indicate:
- arrangement of instrument equipments
and tube bundle.
- Name plate, stamping plate location shall
be indicated
<Contractors Reply / Action on Rev.A>
Noted.
SEC will submit drawings the following;
1. Outline drawing
2. Embedded detail drawing
3. Name plate drawing
Page3 / 4

No. Pyrys Comments Contractors Reply / Action
- Heater shell diameter and thickness
- Earth lugs
- Access to the heater waterbox and tube
sheet
- Inspection manholes to allow visual
inspection of the internal condition of the
heat exchanger tubes.
- Measures implemented to prevent
erosion and corrosion on other details
requested in Clause 6.4.3 of the ERQ.

<Pyrys Comments on Rev.B>
Noted.

And also, you can refer to the outline drawing
you want information such as heater shell
diameter, thickness, Earth lug, Access to the
channel barrel and tube sheet.
In case of prevent erosion and corrosion, you
can refer to the impingement plate from
stainless steel for tube erosion and corrosion.




<Contractors Reply / Action on Rev.B>
Closed.
Detail comments on MD1-0-V-114-01-00001
1 <Pyrys Comments on Rev.A>
There are two (2) steam inlet line having pipe
size of DN650mm (refer to P&ID No. MD1-0-M-
110-21-00033 Rev. C). Therefore, there should
be two (2) nozzles DN650 instead of one nozzle
DN550 as shown in the nozzle data table.
Please check and correct.

<Pyrys Comments on Rev.B>
Closed.
<Contractors Reply / Action on Rev.A>
There are two(2) steam inlet nozzle (C1, C2) in
the nozzle data table. And nozzle size was
calculated as per HEI code and standard.
Two(2) DN550 steam inlet were reflected to
P&ID.
2 <Pyrys Comments on Rev.A>
Complete the nozzle bevel detail table.

<Pyrys Comments on Rev.B>
Closed.
<Contractors Reply / Action on Rev.A>
Noted.
3 <Pyrys Comments on Rev.A>
Emergency drain outlet (F) and Drain outlet (E)
having nozzle size of DN250mm while it is
DN200 in P&ID No. MD1-0-M-110-21-00042.
Please clarify.

<Pyrys Comments on Rev.B>
Closed.

<Contractors Reply / Action on Rev.A>
The nozzle sizes are calculated as per HEI
standard. HDEC will use 250 x 200 reducer for
drain outlet.
4 <Pyrys Comments on Rev.A>
Correct nozzle size for channel relief valve from
DN80(3/4) to DN80(3).

<Pyrys Comments on Rev.B>
Closed.

<Contractors Reply / Action on Rev.A>
Correct nozzle size for channel relief valve from
DN80(3/4) to DN80(3).

5 <Pyrys Comments on Rev.A>
Correct typing error word in the nozzle data
table from Sehll level to Shell level.

<Pyrys Comments on Rev.B>
Closed.

Reflected.
Page4 / 4

No. Pyrys Comments Contractors Reply / Action
6 <Pyrys Comments on Rev.B>
Any change from the previous version shall be
cloud marked.

<Pyrys Comments on Rev.C>
Closed.
<Contractors Reply / Action on Rev.B>
Reflected.