>tracki ng spi r i tual tr ends i n the 21st centur y
VOL UME 19: 16 ( 1,199) / MAY 21, 2014
In this issue: CULTURE - Hollywoods revision of death and resurrection + A host of recent movies and television shows are now fnding theres more to love than romance FREEDOM OF SPEECH - liberal feminists suspiciously quiet over the censorship of Islam critic Ayaan Hirsi Ali WRIGHT, N.T. - a profle that balances accolades and criticism Publisher: Apologia www.apologia.org Contact: ar.feedback(at)apologia.org Post Offce Box 9646 Pueblo, CO 81008 Phone: (719) 225-3467 Editor: Rich Poll Contributing Editor: Paul Carden Copyright 2014 by Apologia. All rights reserved. Apologia (the biblical Greek word for defense) is a nonproft organization dedi- cated to the proclamation and defense of the gospel of Jesus Christ. Apologias mission is to equip the body of Christ for spiritual discern- ment by providing timely, accurate religious research information within the feld of Christian apologetics and to advance apolo- getics in Christian missions. Apologia Report surveys widely to identify the most valuable resources for its readers as they encounter competing worldviews. Since 1997, AR has been published roughly 44 times each year via e-mail. The archiving of Apologia Report (in whole or in part) is permitted for the private use of its subscribers alone. This data fle is the sole prop- erty of Apologia. It may not be used without the permission of Apologia for resale or the enhancement of any other product. In cita- tions, please give the following source credit: Copyright 2014, Apologia (apologia.org) CULTURE How Hollywood Killed Death by Alexan- der Huls reports that death at the movies has died. Te movie industry has corrupted one of cinemas if not all of fctions most emotionally taxing moments into hol- low formula.... Filmmakers dont seem to realize that plot mechanics are no shortcut to pathos. ... Death has become a mere transition device. ... Formula may have atrophied death at the movies, but resurrection has killed it. And an unholy coalition between comic- book publishers and an economically weak- ened Hollywood is to blame. Perhaps youve noticed that your local multiplex might as well be Comic Con. Amid rapid shifs in the media-buying pub- lics preferences, comic-book adaptations have proved incredibly lucrative for movie studios, practically becoming Hollywoods main business model. ... Te timing of the rise of resurrection in blockbusters is no accident its an inheritance. Along with the rise of super- hero movies came comic books notorious revolving-door attitude toward death. Given the mediums sprawling, practically intermi- nable story lines, publishers like Marvel and DC Comics ofen need ways to bring major upheaval to their worlds. So they kill of major characters. ... But Marvel and DC are fnancially dependent on characters that are too popular to leave dead. As a result, death to comic readers has become something of a joke: a tolerated pretense that means noth- ing more than a cash grab.... Death is no longer just a transparent formula; it has been hybridized with some- thing worse: Business strategy. Huls adds that killing death threatens to undermine the movie businesss reason for being. ... No matter how much movies or com- ics depart into realities with superpowered beings, technologically advanced futures or fantastical worlds full of impossible crea- tures, they still need to do what all good sto- ries should: Tell us something about being human. But most of todays movies are tell- ing us death doesnt matter. And its hard to imagine a more inhuman observation than that. New York Times Magazine, Apr 20 14, pp44-45. <www.ow.ly/wW7CV> And in another media role reversal in contrast with the secular press criticizing Hollywood for the change described above Christianity Today praises the American flm industry in Long Live True Love (Apr 14, pp72-73) by Alissa Wilkinson, assistant professor of English and humanities at Te Kings College, editor of QIdeas.org, and chief flm critic for CT. Wilkinson reports that A host of recent movies and televi- sion shows from About Time to Frozen to Parks and Recreation tell a new story: Romance is not the only kind of love that makes life worth living. ... Against all odds, Hollywood seems to be discovering that when we make romance the highest form of love, were missing what love is all about. Wilkinson adds that Real love occupies our whole lives. Tis is something we learn in friend- ship, a relationship that, unlike romance, has no natural peak. Teres no fnal goal for friendship. Rather, friendship is an ongoing process of pursuing intimacy. <www.ow.ly/ wWbpw> FREEDOM OF SPEECH Ayaan Hirsi Ali: Silencing a critic of Islam (no byline) Is there a woman alive who has more courage than Ayaan Hirsi Ali? Born into a Muslim family in Somalia, she was subjected to genital mutilation as a child, fed to the Netherlands to avoid a forced marriage, and became an outspoken critic of Islam and its treatment of women. Death threats followed, and she had to go into hiding afer a Muslim fanatic murdered a flmmaker with whom she had worked and warned her that she was next. Now liv- ing in the U.S. under 24-hour police protec- tion, Hirsi Ali remains a heroic example to women around the world but not to Brandeis University. Last week, under pressure from Muslim groups, Brandeis canceled plans to award Hirsi Ali an hon- orary doctorate, claiming that her attacks on Islam went against the universitys core values. It was another depressing example (continued on next page) APOLOGIAreport FREEDOM OF SPEECH (continued) who taught my family members. Soon stu- dents in Bible courses may sneer less and worship more. Byassee asks: So what does Wright actu- ally teach about Paul? ... Teology does the work for Paul that circumcision, food laws, and Sabbath did for the old Paul, the zealous Jew Saul of Tar- sus. It marked out a community as distinct from the world. ... Paul was not worried about where believers souls would go afer death. ... Paul is centrally teaching about Gods faithfulness to Israel. He is showing that Yahweh is a God who keeps his promises, and so can be trusted to fulfll his promises in history. ... Wright argues that Christians believed Jesus was Lord very early in church history not centuries later, afer councils had decided that he was so. ... Righteousness in Scripture does not refer to the righteous Judge passing his righ- teousness to the defendant. According to Wright, passages like [Romans 4, Galatians 2, and 2 Corinthians 5:21] are about God fulflling his promises to Israel in Christ to remake the world through one Jew-plus- Gentile family. For Wright, the doctrine of justifcation is not everything in Paul. It appears in only a few places in his letters. It is the wheel of the car, Wright says not the whole vehicle. So if Pauls courtroom metaphors are not about imputed righteousness, what are they about? Tey have a much narrower frame of reference, says Wright. ... So Pauls court- room references mean only that the judge rules the defendant is in the right, vin- dicated over against any accusation, and assured of resurrection on the last day. Tis is where fellow Christians have objected most strenuously. Here Byassee gives examples from Albert Mohler, D.A. Carson, and John Piper. Byassee adds that of the thought police on college campuses squelching free speech. ... But Brandeis has honored controversial fgures before, said William Kristol in Te Weekly Standard. Previous recipients include playwright Tony Kushner, who once labeled the creation of Israel a mistake, and Arch- bishop Desmond Tutu, who has compared Israel to Hitler. Is there one rule for critics of Judaism, and another for critics of Islam? One group has remained shamefully quiet over the muzzling of Hirsi Ali, said Jef Jacoby in Te Boston Globe: liberal feminists. Tey call opposition to employer- provided contraceptives a war on women. But the savagery of honor killings or child marriages? It does not stir their outrage. ... Robin Abcarian in the Los Angeles Times [said it best]: Te best response to ofensive speech isnt censorship its more speech. A photo-caption under Hirsi Alis image indicates that she refers to Islam as a cult of death. Te Week, Apr 25 14, p17. 1 WRIGHT, N.T. Surprised by NT Wright (Te Bible scholars goal is to massively revise the way we talk about the Christian faith. By many accounts, hes already succeeded.), by Jason Byassee the best, most concise Wright profle weve seen. Some say he is the most important apologist for the Christian faith since C. S. Lewis. In a nutshell, Wrights revision says: Te church has misread Paul so severely, it seems, that no one fully understood the gos- pel from the time of the apostle to the time a certain British scholar started reading Paul in Greek in graduate school. And thats why Wright is earning a lot of criticism and its not just coming from conservatives. In ref- erence to Wright, Bart Ehrman, Barnes & Nobles favorite Bible disdainer, told [Byas- see], Hes a very bright and learned scholar deeply read, widely knowledgeable, and rigorous. And I disagree with about every- thing he says. ... Wrights newest accolade is that he has written the most extensive work on Paul in the history of Christianity, one portion of which is the recent two-volume Paul and the Faithfulness of God (PFG). 2 Richard Hays, the New Testament scholar to whom PFG is dedicated and dean of Duke Divinity School, believes his friend has surpassed Bultmann. Wright has published more, in more areas, with more infuence, than the one who had so impressed the professors critics are right in one way: Many portions of Scripture sound much closer to the tra- ditional understanding of Paul than Wright ever lets on. ... If we deem Wright correct, we as Western Christians will indeed have to redo much of our accepted thinking on atonement, justifcation, salvation, and church. However, Wright is unique in another important way. Most scholars talk about other scholars. Only a blessed few talk about the Bible. Fewer still talk about God. Byas- see shows how Wright is defnitely a mem- ber of the last group. Te passage which reads If you con- fess with your mouth that Jesus is Lord and believe in your heart that God raised him from the dead, you will be saved, (Romans 10:9, ESV) is central to Wrights reading of Paul and of his gospel. Law court and sub- stitution, yes. And especially lordship and obedience, with resurrection showing that God is faithful to his promises to Israel, and so to the whole world. ... Our being saved is bound up with our pointing to, and embodying in advance, the forthcoming kingdom, says Wright, who, notes Byassee, holds ten honorary doctor- ates in addition to those he has earned the conventional way. Cover story. Christianity Today, Apr 14, pp36-43. <www.ow.ly/wRl96> For a detailed critique of Wright and his stance on the controversial New Perspec- tive on Paul, see <www.ow.ly/x4Ys3>. SOURCES: Monographs 1 - Paul and the Faithfulness of God, by N.T. Wright (Fortress, 2013, paperback, 1700 pages) <www.ow.ly/wXKBU> SOURCES: Periodicals 2 - Te Week, <www.theweek.com> VOL UME 19: 16 ( 1,199) / MAY 21, 2014 APOLOGIAreport Multiculturalism. Diversity. Pluralism. How can a Christian navigate the complex maze of spirituality in the 21st century? How can a Christian stay equipped to communicate the gospel efectively and with empathy understanding the viewpoint of the person theyre talking to? Its not easy. But Apologia Report can help. Apologia Report is designed to provide you with weekly summaries of articles available (both in print and online) so that you can stay on top of breaking news and developing spiritual trends. It is an invaluable time- saving resource especially for those in leadership positions, missions, and education. Topics covered in Apologia Report include these and many more: Islam New Atheism Science vs. Religion Buddhism Religious Pluralism Wicca Personalities in Religion Mormonism Secularism Apologia Report is available free of charge and sent to you once a week via email in a two-page pdf format. Subscribe now to this valuable resource! To subscribe: 1. Go to: www.apologia.org/htm/subscribe.htm 2. Fill out the Subscription Form and click Submit. Apologia Report has an archive of past issues available in an online database. Its a gold mine of research drawn from nearly 700 print and online sources, as well as the interaction of Christian apologists from around the world. Search the Apologia Archive at: www.tinyurl.com/archive-apologia. AR-talk is a community of Christian apologists. When you join you will be able to ask questions about an apologetic topic and the members of AR-talk will point you to helpful resources. To join go to: www.apologia.org/htm/joinARtalk.htm. Spiritual Abuse Scientology Post-modernism Jehovahs Witnesses Intelligent Design New Age Movement Shamanism Interfaith Dialog Archaeology Apologia Report is a fantastic service to the world missions community. I read every issue, and constantly fnd information that is valuable. Tis is one of those rare ministries that raises the level of knowledge and understanding across a wide community of Christian leaders. Apologia Report has a tremendous impact that cannot be measured. Michael Jafarian Missions Researcher, CBInternational Many of us at Dallas Teological Seminary receive Apologia Report. It is immensely strategic and helpful. Apologia Report creatively sifs through reams of information and makes available only briefs of newsworthy current issues and events, but also gives me the websites and bibliographic data I need to research further. Its like having a research assistant. I thank the Lord for this service to His church. Scott Horrell Professor of Systematic Teology Dallas Seminary Chec k out our Web s i t e f or mor e i nf or mat i onwww. apol ogi a. or g Apol ogi a P. O. Box 9646 Puebl o, CO 81008 Phone 719 225 3467